2008 Impact Factors - RSC leads the way for chemistry

25 June 2009
Publication of the 2008 impact factors, calculated by ISI, once again brought good news for authors and readers of RSC journals. 

We apologize in advance for any disruptions. We know that there are a lot of people now using ChemSpider services to feed your own systems so our apologies in advance. We expect improved service for all when this transition is complete.

We’ll see you on the other side of this transition in just over 24 hours. Wish us luck…

The Spectral Game: leveraging Open Data and crowdsourcing for education

Jean-Claude Bradley , Robert J Lancashire , Andrew SID Lang and Antony J Williams

Journal of Cheminformatics 2009, 1:9doi:10.1186/1758-2946-1-9

Abstract (provisional)

We report on the implementation of the Spectral Game, a web-based game where players try to match molecules to various forms of interactive spectra including 1D/2D NMR, Mass Spectrometry and Infrared spectra. Each correct selection earns the player one point and play continues until the player supplies an incorrect answer. The game is usually played using a web browser interface, although a version has been developed in the virtual 3D environment of Second Life. Spectra uploaded as Open Data to ChemSpider in JCAMP-DX format are used for the problem sets together with structures extracted from the website. The spectra are displayed using JSpecView, an Open Source spectrum viewing applet which affords zooming and integration. The application of the game to the teaching of proton NMR spectroscopy in an undergraduate organic chemistry class and a 2D Spectrum Viewer are also presented.

We have already started testing the system on the RSC servers that will go live sometime early next week. At present the intended schedule is that we will be switching over sometime between Monday and Wednesday. Of course, this is an intention at present and, based on testing, this may change. For right now we have stopped depositions onto ChemSpider. If curation activities continue we will sync these over to the live server next week so no issues there. ChemSpider will go offline next week sometime and, as the actual data becmes clearer, the announcements will be updated.

Watch this space…ChemSpider is moving to the RSC servers and their will be disruptions in the next few days.

There are then the “servants for the community”. In this case I mean servants with the most positive connotation. Those who slave away on Wikipedia articles and don’t immediately have their names up in lights. You actually have to dig under an article to find out who wrote/contributed to it. It’s not upfront and center. On Wikipedia chemistry there are a very small number of dedicated individuals who contribute large blocks of time to working on Wikipedia to improve its quality and content. There is a Long Tail of contribution of course but you might be quite surprised by the small number of “primary” contributors. If you check out their Wiki pages however these individuals are recognized and commended within their own community of participation yet may never be known by the readers of the articles.

On ChemSpider we have a similar situation. There are a very small number of primary curators (I will name them: Myself, Heinz Kolshorn and Barrie Walker - these people are enhancing ChemSpider literally daily). We have a smaller number of secondary contributors who add a spectrum once in a while, annotate a record occasionally or curate out bad data. I would say this is about 30 other people. We also have people who provide us data to deposit and they do it willingly but don’t want to have a hands on approach to depositing data onto the database.

When I was in the UK recently during my first week of employment with the RSC I gave a number of presentations. There was a lot of interest in what ChemSpider could bring to the organization and offer the community and a lot of discussions regardng “what if”. Of the audiences I would suggest that only a small portion actually laid their hands on the system to investigate its capability and an even smaller fraction chose to jump in, feet first, and use the system and participate fully. There was one spike in particular. During the evening after one of the presentations I noticed that one individual in particular was adding comments to individual records, questioning names, suggesting that structure layouts be changed and examining links to external resources. The first evening there were a few edits. The next night, even more, and since then this individual has continued, unabated, making edits and now enhancing the articles with new information, in this case YouTube videos.

David Sharpe is fairly new to the RSC and is one of those people who just cares. A silent contibutor in the background (until today!) who is cleaning and enhancing ChemSpider for the sake of the community. To be clear, his work on these activities has been done in the evenings and weekends and this past weekend he was exchanging emails with me about adding “Element Videos” to the elements on ChemSpider. David’s been moving across the elements on ChemSpider and using the YouTube embed functionality to put the Periodic Table videos from the University of Nottingham into the Description section of the appropriate records.

Check out for example the video for Sulphur here. As we move forward we will layer on a recognition system for individuals contributing to ChemSpider so that we can track the spectral depositions, curations and so on. We believe that such efforts warrant recognition and applause. Of course some will choose to be anonymous and remain in the background making their difference in a silent manner. We honor you all.

I am especially looking forward to spening time with Andrew Lang, one of the brains behind the Spectral Game. We’ve spoken on the phone, exchanged many emails and worked on a couple of projects together. But we get to meet at SciFoo!

Last time I was at SciFoo I spent time talking with Cameron Neylon and JC Bradley about Open Notebook Science. At that time I had lots of ideas about what we could do to support Open Notebook Science. We actually have done quite well but at that time we were severely resource constrained. Things are a little different now we have been acquired by the RSC and I am looking forward to talking about what’s necessary and possible now.

Nicko Goncharoff from SureChem will be there. Nicko and I have spent a lot of time together over the past few years, mostly by phone and over email as we worked to integrate SureChem into ChemSpider and use their software development kit under our ChemMantis semantic chemistry markup tool. It’s always good to see him.

Other people I hope to spend some time talking to: Peter Murray Rust from the university of Cambridge, Timo Hannay, Alf Eaton and Terry Sheppard from the Nature Publishing Group and Theodore Gray.

The ChemSpider LinkedIn Group can be accessed here.