<?xml version='1.0' encoding='UTF-8'?><?xml-stylesheet href="http://www.blogger.com/styles/atom.css" type="text/css"?><feed xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom' xmlns:openSearch='http://a9.com/-/spec/opensearchrss/1.0/' xmlns:blogger='http://schemas.google.com/blogger/2008' xmlns:georss='http://www.georss.org/georss' xmlns:gd="http://schemas.google.com/g/2005" xmlns:thr='http://purl.org/syndication/thread/1.0'><id>tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8173728209140337514</id><updated>2026-03-27T06:33:40.242-04:00</updated><category term="no excuses charter schools"/><category term="accountability"/><category term="multicultural education"/><category term="Michel Foucault"/><category term="curriculum theory"/><category term="race"/><category term="KIPP"/><category term="UW-Madison"/><category term="history"/><category term="poverty"/><category term="Mike Goldstein"/><category term="Tom Popkewitz"/><category term="achievement gap"/><category term="higher education"/><category term="market-based ed reform"/><category term="standardized testing"/><category term="Herbert Kleibard"/><category term="Michael Apple"/><category term="curriculum history"/><category term="deficit model"/><category term="difference"/><category term="discipline"/><category term="income inequality"/><category term="social justice"/><category term="teacher education"/><category term="Adolescence"/><category term="Africa"/><category term="Discipline and Punish"/><category term="Ed Schools"/><category term="Gloria Ladson-Billings"/><category term="MATCH"/><category term="Starting an Ed School blog"/><category term="choice"/><category term="educational history"/><category term="gender"/><category term="historiography"/><category term="teacher evaluation"/><category term="teacher quality"/><category term="teacher retention"/><category term="teachers unions"/><category term="Boston Public Schools"/><category term="NCLB"/><category term="Peace Corps"/><category term="Ravitch"/><category term="Relay School of Education"/><category term="Teach for America"/><category term="U.S.-affiliated education reform in Kenya"/><category term="assimilationist teaching"/><category term="common core standards"/><category term="culturally relevant teaching"/><category term="education"/><category term="education economics"/><category term="education reform"/><category term="equity"/><category term="eugenics"/><category term="instruction"/><category term="international development"/><category term="international education"/><category term="objectivity"/><category term="paul tough"/><category term="politics of inclusion/exclusion"/><category term="poststructuralism"/><category term="power-knowledge"/><category term="sociology"/><category term="the urban child"/><category term="Cosmopolitanism and the Age of School Reform"/><category term="Doug Lemov"/><category term="Eric Hanushek"/><category term="Frederick Hess"/><category term="Howard Zinn"/><category term="Ian Hacking"/><category term="Jason Morgan"/><category term="Kenya"/><category term="Kristoff"/><category term="Mary Louise Pratt"/><category term="Mary Poovey"/><category term="Memory"/><category term="Nancy Lesko"/><category term="Official Knowledge"/><category term="PISA"/><category term="The Death and Life"/><category term="The New Teacher Project"/><category term="Thomas Jesse Jones"/><category term="Tilson"/><category term="Whitney Tilson"/><category term="academic autopoesis"/><category term="conferences"/><category term="curriculum design"/><category term="dangerous individual"/><category term="diversity training"/><category term="education funding"/><category term="extended time"/><category term="fact"/><category term="funds of knowledge"/><category term="goldstein"/><category term="juvenile delinquency"/><category term="mind"/><category term="paradigms"/><category term="philanthropy"/><category term="psychology"/><category term="research"/><category term="science education"/><category term="science studies"/><category term="sex harassment"/><category term="social change"/><category term="social efficiency"/><category term="social studies"/><category term="universal human rights"/><category term="vouchers"/><category term="60 Minutes"/><category term="A Few Good Men"/><category term="Alice Goffman"/><category term="Allington"/><category term="American Educational Research Association"/><category term="Angela Valenzuela"/><category term="Antonio Gramsci"/><category term="Arne Duncan"/><category term="Audre Lorde"/><category term="Beau Lotto"/><category term="Bill Nye"/><category term="Campbell&#39;s Law"/><category term="Chicago teachers strike"/><category term="Citizens Schools"/><category term="Common Ground"/><category term="Contact Zone"/><category term="David Berliner"/><category term="Democratic Schools"/><category term="Diane Ravitch"/><category term="E.D. Hirsch"/><category term="ELLs"/><category term="Edge of Ed"/><category term="Education Nation"/><category term="Ellen Brantlinger"/><category term="Encoding White Resentment"/><category term="Eric Gutstein"/><category term="Fordham Institute"/><category term="Foucault and a Politics of Confession in Education"/><category term="G. Stanley Hall"/><category term="Gee Officer Krupke"/><category term="Geoffrey Canada"/><category term="George W. Bush"/><category term="Giorgio Agamben"/><category term="Harold Rugg"/><category term="Hayden White"/><category term="Hazel Carby"/><category term="Hoxby"/><category term="Ian Bogost"/><category term="Imperial Eyes"/><category term="Jacques Derrida"/><category term="James Beane"/><category term="Jay Matthews"/><category term="Jim Horn"/><category term="John Carson"/><category term="Joy in the Congo"/><category term="Ken Ham"/><category term="Kibera"/><category term="Kinshasa Symphony"/><category term="Kurt Danziger"/><category term="Lake Naivasha"/><category term="Lewis Terman"/><category term="Linda Darling-Hammond"/><category term="Lisa Delpit"/><category term="Little War on the Prairie"/><category term="Looper"/><category term="Loïc Wacquant"/><category term="Lynn Thomas"/><category term="MCAS"/><category term="Maasai"/><category term="Madison"/><category term="Mama Hope"/><category term="Mark Zuckerberg"/><category term="Marking the Mind"/><category term="Martin Haberman"/><category term="Martin Luther King"/><category term="Match Education"/><category term="Matthew Weinstein"/><category term="Michael Parenti"/><category term="Michael Petrilli"/><category term="Mindy Blaise"/><category term="Nairobi"/><category term="National Public Radio"/><category term="Noble Street Charter Schools"/><category term="Norbert Elias"/><category term="On Point"/><category term="Parker J. Palmer"/><category term="Paulo Friere"/><category term="Pedagogy of Poverty"/><category term="Pedagogy of the Oppressed"/><category term="Pierre Bourdieu"/><category term="Potawatomi Death March"/><category term="Rabbit-Proof Fence"/><category term="Race to the Top"/><category term="Reading and Writing the World with Mathematics"/><category term="Rod Washington"/><category term="Sam Wineburg"/><category term="Secretary of Education"/><category term="Sposato Graduate School of Education"/><category term="Stephen Garton"/><category term="Steven Brill"/><category term="Stolen Generation"/><category term="Struggling for the Soul"/><category term="Students for Ed Reform"/><category term="Sylvia Wynter"/><category term="Teach Like a Champion"/><category term="Teaching as Leadership"/><category term="Teju Cole"/><category term="Texas"/><category term="The Cannibal Warlords of Liberia analysis"/><category term="The Gates Foundation"/><category term="The Guardian"/><category term="The Homeowner&#39;s Society"/><category term="The Isthmus"/><category term="The Measure of Merit"/><category term="The Politics of the Womb"/><category term="The Simpson Street Free Press"/><category term="The Souls of Black Folks"/><category term="The Walton Family"/><category term="The White Savior Industrial Complex"/><category term="This American Life"/><category term="Thomas Broman"/><category term="Thomas Kuhn"/><category term="Tippecanoe"/><category term="Uncommon Schools"/><category term="Unlocking Potential"/><category term="Vice"/><category term="W.E.B. Du Bois"/><category term="WEB Du Bois"/><category term="West Side Story"/><category term="Wisconsin Public Radio"/><category term="academia"/><category term="advertising"/><category term="anthropology"/><category term="astroturf organizations"/><category term="best practices"/><category term="brain"/><category term="career"/><category term="charter schools"/><category term="chimera"/><category term="college completion"/><category term="confessional"/><category term="criminal justice"/><category term="critique of experience"/><category term="debate"/><category term="deciphering knowledge"/><category term="democracy"/><category term="democratic education"/><category term="disciplinary individualism"/><category term="discrimination"/><category term="disenchanting discourse"/><category term="double consciousness"/><category term="economic sociology"/><category term="economics"/><category term="education orthodoxy"/><category term="education policy"/><category term="environment"/><category term="esquith"/><category term="ethnography"/><category term="female genital mutilation"/><category term="film criticism"/><category term="flower industry international development"/><category term="gated communities"/><category term="governmentality"/><category term="guilt"/><category term="homeless"/><category term="humanitarianism"/><category term="hybridity"/><category term="income mobility"/><category term="intellectual isolation"/><category term="intelligence"/><category term="ivory tower"/><category term="knowledge"/><category term="looping effect"/><category term="massive online open course"/><category term="media literacy"/><category term="mental trauma"/><category term="merit pay"/><category term="middle school"/><category term="music"/><category term="neuroscience"/><category term="parenting"/><category term="performativity"/><category term="philanthropolicymaking"/><category term="post-traumatic stress disorder"/><category term="postcolonialism"/><category term="progress"/><category term="psychoanalysis"/><category term="religious education"/><category term="rubric"/><category term="schooling"/><category term="science"/><category term="sex education"/><category term="social science"/><category term="soda ban"/><category term="special education"/><category term="stereotypes"/><category term="stop and frisk"/><category term="styles of reasoning"/><category term="taste"/><category term="teacher life"/><category term="teacher morale"/><category term="the camp"/><category term="theory"/><category term="time on task"/><category term="tracking"/><category term="truancy"/><category term="turnaround schools"/><category term="underclass"/><category term="video games"/><title type='text'>Ed Reform Anonymous</title><subtitle type='html'>Exploring the reasoning that fabricates the problems and solutions of education reform.</subtitle><link rel='http://schemas.google.com/g/2005#feed' type='application/atom+xml' href='http://edreformanon.blogspot.com/feeds/posts/default'/><link rel='self' type='application/atom+xml' href='http://www.blogger.com/feeds/8173728209140337514/posts/default?max-results=1&amp;redirect=false'/><link rel='alternate' type='text/html' href='http://edreformanon.blogspot.com/'/><link rel='hub' href='http://pubsubhubbub.appspot.com/'/><link rel='next' type='application/atom+xml' href='http://www.blogger.com/feeds/8173728209140337514/posts/default?start-index=2&amp;max-results=1&amp;redirect=false'/><author><name>Unknown</name><email>noreply@blogger.com</email><gd:image rel='http://schemas.google.com/g/2005#thumbnail' width='16' height='16' src='https://img1.blogblog.com/img/b16-rounded.gif'/></author><generator version='7.00' uri='http://www.blogger.com'>Blogger</generator><openSearch:totalResults>92</openSearch:totalResults><openSearch:startIndex>1</openSearch:startIndex><openSearch:itemsPerPage>1</openSearch:itemsPerPage><entry><id>tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8173728209140337514.post-5926310397719262324</id><published>2014-12-29T16:08:00.002-05:00</published><updated>2014-12-30T19:50:22.504-05:00</updated><category scheme="http://www.blogger.com/atom/ns#" term="achievement gap"/><category scheme="http://www.blogger.com/atom/ns#" term="education reform"/><category scheme="http://www.blogger.com/atom/ns#" term="humanitarianism"/><category scheme="http://www.blogger.com/atom/ns#" term="international development"/><category scheme="http://www.blogger.com/atom/ns#" term="international education"/><category scheme="http://www.blogger.com/atom/ns#" term="no excuses charter schools"/><category scheme="http://www.blogger.com/atom/ns#" term="Peace Corps"/><category scheme="http://www.blogger.com/atom/ns#" term="politics of inclusion/exclusion"/><category scheme="http://www.blogger.com/atom/ns#" term="universal human rights"/><title type='text'>My Humanitarian Crisis</title><content type='html'>&lt;table align=&quot;center&quot; cellpadding=&quot;0&quot; cellspacing=&quot;0&quot; class=&quot;tr-caption-container&quot; style=&quot;margin-left: auto; margin-right: auto; text-align: center;&quot;&gt;&lt;tbody&gt;
&lt;tr&gt;&lt;td style=&quot;text-align: center;&quot;&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjvNUhplZnUrmcc2zOLNpHonbBnnP3jB5PtOF7h5Uak5NRXnUnoJoqDfk6b68vE9NMsrw06x3lfVFaZA4G9_eBiHeMG6kswMOpgT5aeA9mInBHmof6NueYx93aGEOsPQlL07EPmkInaHmab/s1600/Humanitarianism+collage.jpg&quot; imageanchor=&quot;1&quot; style=&quot;margin-left: auto; margin-right: auto;&quot;&gt;&lt;img border=&quot;0&quot; src=&quot;https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjvNUhplZnUrmcc2zOLNpHonbBnnP3jB5PtOF7h5Uak5NRXnUnoJoqDfk6b68vE9NMsrw06x3lfVFaZA4G9_eBiHeMG6kswMOpgT5aeA9mInBHmof6NueYx93aGEOsPQlL07EPmkInaHmab/s1600/Humanitarianism+collage.jpg&quot; height=&quot;456&quot; width=&quot;640&quot; /&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;
&lt;tr&gt;&lt;td class=&quot;tr-caption&quot; style=&quot;text-align: center;&quot;&gt;The oxymoronic statement in the lower right is made possible by the essential humanism of Western thought (and politics).&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;
&lt;/tbody&gt;&lt;/table&gt;
&lt;div class=&quot;separator&quot; style=&quot;clear: both; text-align: center;&quot;&gt;
&lt;/div&gt;
For a better part of my 20s, I participated in a variety of social organizations with missions dedicated to “doing good.” This meant working to alleviate poverty and to “close gaps” in academic achievement. In both cases, these organizations were kinds of rescue missions that began from a premise that assumed a clear separation of “us” and “them.” Part of what made this distinction possible, I have realized, has been theoretical techniques employed by the social sciences to produce cultural distantiations between “kinds” of peoples. It is in the production of difference that it becomes possible to represent “us” (those who make the data that provides the truth of the problem and the need for intervention) as saviors, and others (those the data represents) as the objects of our rescue.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;div&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/div&gt;
&lt;div&gt;
Though I did not use this language at the time, I found the relationships these data engendered as problematic in that it assumed I, merely by virtue of growing up as an English-speaking American from a middle-class home with a college degree had something critical to offer others and not vice versa. What that “something” was had various formulations, but whatever it was—and here I’ll call it “cachet” (both for its common meaning of prestige and its older denotation as a distinguishing mark)—it authorized my existence in cultural spaces that were not “my own.” As a Peace Corps volunteer, cachet justified the cost of the U.S. government flying me halfway around the world to live in a Guinean village for two years. As an East Boston schoolteacher, cachet justified my position as a teacher to children whose community I did not live in and whose native languages I did not speak. Cachet offered a liquidity to my life to move into spaces and experiences to which I did not belong. It authorized me to interact with others in a mode that preserved a hierarchical relation. My cachet derived from a notion that I performed a “service” to marginalized others and that my work was an antidote to their conditions.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
I am no longer so clear as to relationship between one’s personal commitments to social change and their outcomes. Instead, I find a great deal troubling in the discursively produced relations that presume my relationship to others begins from a privileged position of having something of inherent value that assumes a deficit in those who do not. The relationship, it seems, too closely resembles those of missionaries traveling to benighted lands in order to ministering to the poor. Whether as a volunteer or a schoolteacher, these positions required me to transform others to resemble more closely the ideals I also hoped to embody. It seems to me that this understanding of the world and of social wrongs and who was to blame for them allow hierarchical power relations to pass as eternal truths that are themselves effects of power. That moral imperatives of poverty reduction and closing gaps naturalize rather than challenge hierarchical relations. This has a curious effect. Moral imperatives make the cause of social justice an unproblematic continuation of what once was called “God’s work” and yet render the promise of that justice like a mirage forever clinging to the horizon—a messianic promise of something that will one day, but not yet, come to pass. While differences that count may circulate and the data purported to reveal the “truth” of social inequalities may change, the social sciences stabilize a certain integral relation: forever are “we” (those on the side of normalcy) the helpers and “they” (the aberrant) the helped.&lt;/div&gt;
&lt;div&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
To this point, what I have said may be read as itself a kind of testimonial. What seems natural now is to discuss how I have come to “see the light” and how now I have a greater appreciation for what is “really” going on in the world. While acknowledging that I do now think differently about the problems of social inequities and the means of addressing them, I cannot say that I have arrived at any greater truth or understanding that would permit me to give up my commitments to right social wrongs. (Besides, as Thomas Popkewitz has said, an optimism for the future is perhaps a necessary element of modernity.) In maintaining this optimism, though, I find it necessary to critique what I have now come to see as constitutive of how we understand what are, in fact, the social wrongs to be rectified.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/div&gt;
&lt;div&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/div&gt;
&lt;div&gt;
The problem, to be brief, is this. In the effort to address social wrongs, the social sciences produce knowledge of populations that assume a giveness to particular identities that hide unspoken normativities for being, seeing, and acting in the world. Rather than transforming the social situation, the social sciences perform conserving actions—they begin by justifying a particular cultural worldview as scientific and denying the possibility for worldviews that would challenge a particular theory of truth. In this novel form of ministering to the poor, the social sciences use the language of emancipatory politics as a kind of social gospel—the sciences provide &quot;the truth&quot; to correctly map the social situation and shed light on &quot;the real&quot; social situation. The goal is to provide for the marginalized due representation, voice, and empowerment in the conduct of their affairs. Unspoken in this emancipatory politics is that the social sciences embody a culturally and historically particular humanism that prescribes valid modes of political expression and denies others. This expression of a vision of what politics “should” look like simultaneously rejects alternative politics as dangerous and other modes of life as abnormal and deviant. It also authorizes, ironically, the social sciences to &quot;speak for&quot; the disempowered in the name of giving &quot;them&quot; voice. At this level, I am reminded of the U.S. effort to &quot;liberate&quot; Iraq and install &quot;democracy&quot;—an imperialist worldview only possible when democracy is taken as the natural developmental outcomes of all peoples, irrespective of history. Such is the cunning of imperialist reason and it is found not only in military invasions but often (and usually first) in humanitarian interventions as well.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Does this mean you could characterize my stance as that of a &quot;burnt-out humanitarian?&quot; No! I reject accusations of such cynicism. While my concerns with humanitarian reason arise from dispiriting engagements in efforts aimed to address social inequalities, my critique is not directed at the well intentioned people engaged in this work, or at the more general commitments to right social wrongs. I, too, think of myself as well intentioned and similarly committed. Where paths diverge is at the level of the essential humanism embedded in our current humanitarian projects. This humanism begins by policing the sensible—by already having already decided upon the terms of who the &quot;human&quot; really is, and how that vision of the human prescribes the conduct of others in ways that limits the possibilities for other political modalities, forms of reasoning, and modes of life—instead, it offers a dogma in the guise of emancipation—a straightjacketed vision of who “we” are and &lt;i&gt;should be&lt;/i&gt;. The effect of this humanism is abjection—to make problematic the social inclusion of others as they are and instead require as a condition of inclusion one’s inner transformation.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/div&gt;
&lt;div&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/div&gt;
&lt;div&gt;
While a paradox of inclusion and abjection seems to be condition of our humanitarian present, my optimism for a future comes from the understanding that the conditions that define our present need not have already determined the possibilities of the future. Instead, I am hopeful, if I can use this word, that by recognizing the limits in our current ways of thinking about social inequalities we can begin to rethink not merely the methods and data of our interventions but of the principles of our methodologies and theories that make “interventions” logical in the first place.&lt;/div&gt;
</content><link rel='replies' type='application/atom+xml' href='http://edreformanon.blogspot.com/feeds/5926310397719262324/comments/default' title='Post Comments'/><link rel='replies' type='text/html' href='http://edreformanon.blogspot.com/2014/12/my-humanitarian-crisis.html#comment-form' title='0 Comments'/><link rel='edit' type='application/atom+xml' href='http://www.blogger.com/feeds/8173728209140337514/posts/default/5926310397719262324'/><link rel='self' type='application/atom+xml' href='http://www.blogger.com/feeds/8173728209140337514/posts/default/5926310397719262324'/><link rel='alternate' type='text/html' href='http://edreformanon.blogspot.com/2014/12/my-humanitarian-crisis.html' title='My Humanitarian Crisis'/><author><name>Unknown</name><email>noreply@blogger.com</email><gd:image rel='http://schemas.google.com/g/2005#thumbnail' width='16' height='16' src='https://img1.blogblog.com/img/b16-rounded.gif'/></author><media:thumbnail xmlns:media="http://search.yahoo.com/mrss/" url="https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjvNUhplZnUrmcc2zOLNpHonbBnnP3jB5PtOF7h5Uak5NRXnUnoJoqDfk6b68vE9NMsrw06x3lfVFaZA4G9_eBiHeMG6kswMOpgT5aeA9mInBHmof6NueYx93aGEOsPQlL07EPmkInaHmab/s72-c/Humanitarianism+collage.jpg" height="72" width="72"/><thr:total>0</thr:total></entry></feed>