September 16th, 2026, updated with a new winner for best lightweight, best ultralight, and best waterproof with a year's worth of testing notes to confirm rankings, updated pricing and commentary on value
Home > Gear Reviews > Hiking

Love 'em or loathe 'em, fanny packs are one of the most practical ways to carry essentials on the trail. They keep your phone, snacks, sunscreen, and other small items within reach without the heat and bulk of a full daypack. Smaller models work well for short hikes and everyday use, while larger waist and lumbar packs can carry water, layers, and enough gear for longer outings.

I'm a Denver-based writer who hikes weekly, and I researched the most talked-about fanny packs, waist packs, and lumbar packs before testing the most promising models. Our testers used them on mountain hikes, bike rides, road trips, fly-fishing outings, festivals, international travel, and a 60-mile urban thru-hike through Ventura, California.

Together, we evaluated capacity, waist-belt fit, bounce, comfort, pocket organization, access while moving, durability, and how well each pack handled sweat, dirt, and repeated use. We also considered whether each model was best suited to short hikes, long-distance trails, carrying water, running, or everyday use.

Top Pick: The Patagonia Terravia Mini Hip Pack earns our Best Overall award. It stood out for its low weight, secure and comfortable fit, useful organization, and versatility as a waist pack, sling, or compact travel bag. Its 1-liter capacity holds a phone, sunscreen, headlamp, snacks, and keys without feeling bulky, making it a practical choice for short hikes and everyday outings.

Read more: Best Running Belts

Related: Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs

We create reader-supported, objective gear reviews independently selected by our editors. This story may contain affiliate links, which help fund our website. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission, without costing you an extra cent. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body! Learn more.

Comparison Table

The Best Hiking Fanny Packs

Best Overall Fanny Pack: Patagonia Terravia Mini Hip Pack

Price: $39
Volume: 1 L, 5L available
Weight: 3.9 oz
Dimensions: 8 x 4.5 x 2
What we liked: versatile, bluesign certified, recycled material, perfect size, stylish
What we didn't like: not bottle compatible, waist strap could be longer

If you’re looking for a hands-free way to carry the bare necessities (excluding hydration), the Patagonia Terravia Mini Hip Pack is the best fanny pack for you—and the best fanny pack for most hikers, dog walkers, casual cyclists, and everyday use. 

What makes it great for hiking is that it's lightweight and stores in its own pocket when not in use, yet is durable and has great pockets to organize hiking essentials. It can also be worn multiple ways: as a fanny pack, sling pack, or by its carabiner hooked to a belt loop.

Whether walking the dog or carrying basic hiking gear for easy access, this Terravia sits comfortably on your waist and looks great in many fun colors.

In the 1L volume, we were able to fit a phone, sunscreen and lip balm, sunglasses, a headlamp, a snack, electrolytes, a thin liner glove, a wallet, and keys (it has a handy key ring so you won't accidentally lose your keys when pulling something out mid-hike). 

It's become our go-to bag for dog walking and can fit doggie bags, a ball, treats along with human gear like a phone, wallet, and keys. It's got a touch of style and you have your choice of 8 color combinations, including solid blue or black.

A hiker wears the Patagonia Terravia Mini Hip Pack across his chest for easy access to essentials while hiking.

Two hikers test the Patagonia Terravia Mini Hip Pack on the trail, where its lightweight 1-liter size carries essentials without adding much bulk.

The Patagonia Terravia Mini Hip Pack has an exterior zippered pocket for keeping small hiking essentials organized and easy to reach.

The 1-liter Patagonia Terravia Mini Hip Pack holds hiking essentials like sunscreen, a headlamp, snacks, electrolytes, a wallet, and keys.

We tested the Patagonia Terravia Mini Hip Pack on hikes and found its small, lightweight design well suited to carrying the essentials on shorter outings.

The Patagonia Terravia Mini Hip Pack can be worn around the waist or across the chest, making it a versatile option for hiking and everyday use.

• Fabric

  This pack was made with sustainability in mind—it's made of 100% recycled ripstop nylon and polyester. The body fabric is also bluesign approved, indicating the supply chain is safe for the environment, workers, and customers. It is also made in a Fair Trade Certified factory. 

  The Patagonia Terra Via Mini fanny pack is part of Patagonia's commitment to make gear without PFCs/PFAS, forever chemicals. You can read more about PFAS in our article on PFAS in outdoor gear.

• Comfort and adjustability

  The waist belt is comfortable, lightweight, and flexible, meant for wearing both around your waist or across your chest. This makes it versatile for shorter hikes and also in urban settings.

• Volume

  The Patagonia Terravia Mini hip pack has a volume of 1L, which is on the lower end for a hiking fanny pack.

  However, we found that small size to be an advantage in many situations.

  For example, it stows away into its own pocket when not in use, such as when it's really raining or if you're traveling and a day hike is just one of many activities that you're packing for. 

  Yet it's the perfect sizing for shorter hikes where you just want to get up and go.

• Flaws but not dealbreakers

  We were hard-pressed to dislike anything about this waist pack, but did find some hikers wanted water bottle pockets. This pack does not come with its own water bottles and doesn't have water bottle pockets, so if you have a tall bottle you want to carry in a waist pack, this could be an issue. 

  If you want a waist pack with water bottles, see our winner for best hydration pack for carrying bottles or look at our guide for Best Mountain Bike Hip Packs. They tend to be very similar to hiking fanny packs but always have hydration compatibility.

• Sizing

  Lastly, we wanted the waistband to be longer to be more inclusive of hikers of all sizes. Additionally, some testers who wanted to use it as a sling pack found that it wasn't long enough to fit over shoulders (admittedly, it wasn't designed exactly for that use).

• Warranty and repairs

  Like all Patagonia gear, this waist pack comes with Patagonia’s Ironclad Guarantee. This feature covers Patagonia gear for life.

  Patagonia’s environmental mission strives to repair gear instead of manufacture new items. For a minimal price, they’ll even repair items with normal wear and tear.

Best High Volume Lumbar Pack: Mountainsmith Tour Lumbar Pack

Price: $110 
Waist size: 28 to 48 inches
Volume: 7 L
Weight: 1 lb 6 oz
Dimensions: 9.5” x 9” x 3.75”
Pockets: 6
What we liked: multi-use, versatile, functional pockets
What we didn't like: extra space can lead to a heavy pack

I found the Mountainsmith Tour Lumbar Pack to be a fantastic alternative to a regular backpack—and especially great as a multi-use product. For those hikers who prefer a hands-free hiking experience, hate to have a heavy pack creating a sweaty back, or prefer a lumbar pack that sits behind instead of in front, the Mountainsmith Tour is the best lumbar pack and best high volume waist pack out there.

• Versatility

  What’s attractive about the Mountainsmith Tour Lumbar pack is its versatility: you can use it for biking, longer hikes, or in lieu of a briefcase in casual business environments, or even as a diaper bag (it’s the same size as many bags marketed as “diaper bags” and Mountainsmith’s website touts that the Tour makes a good diaper bag). 

  Many customer reviewers said they appreciated the many needs this pack could meet. One of our writers is a hiker with an injured shoulder who uses this pack for overnight backpacking trips.

• Volume

  I was prepared to dislike this pack because of its larger capacity. When I typically think of fanny packs,  I think of a compact bag ideal for carrying smaller items. 

  Instead, I discovered that I really liked having the larger capacity of the Tour. It is 9.5” x 9” x 3.75” which means the roomy main compartment is large enough to fit an e-reader or a mini laptop, which made it a convenient everyday bag for me, too.

  However, since one of the most attractive aspects of this pack is all of the pocket space, one issue that could come up with the Tour is the urge to fill it. 

  If you are the type of person who has to fight the urge to fill every pocket and pouch up with stuff, consider how extra items will change the weight of the pack during a longer excursion. 

  The urge to fill the Tour is a minor issue that you just have to be aware of as you mindfully pack for your next adventure. You can fit a full-size hiking water bottle in each water bottle pocket.

• Sizing Available

  The size is great if you’re needing to carry items besides your wallet. The adjustable waist strap is easy to adjust, fitting waists from 28-48 inches.

• Front Zippered Pocket

  The small zippered pocket on the front of the pack is especially nice because it gives you easy access to important items—like your ID, keys, or cards—without needing to access the main compartment in the pack. It’s also big enough for snacks like energy bars.

• Front Waist Belt Pocket

  This pocket is located directly on the right-hand side of the waist belt. This pocket is ideal for storing keys and is also ideal for storing a cell phone or snack bar. Behind the pocket, there is also an additional pocket that you could also stick your wallet into or some other slightly larger item.

• Side Reinforced Water Bottle Holders

  There are two water-bottle pockets, one on each side of the pack, with adjustable bungee cords to help secure the bottles. I really liked that there were two pockets because you can carry two water bottles and even a hydration reservoir if needed for longer treks in the wilderness.

• Strappettes

  The strappettes (Mountainsmith’s term for an adjustable strap that turns the lumbar pack into a backpack) are sold separately. At $30, I think it’s worth the money to purchase one. Best yet: that price hasn't gone up in a couple years, unlike so many other pieces of gear. 

  While the Tour works well as a hiking fanny pack, the strapette shoulder strap creates more usage options for the pack, turning it into a backpack with a racerback. The Tour is the only hip pack we considered that has this capability.

• Front Compression Attachment System

  Another unique aspect of this fanny pack is the compression straps, located on the front of the pack. Having a compression strap is ideal for storing lighter jackets or other pieces of gear for easy secure and easy access.

  Bottom line: This larger volume lumbar pack is ideal for replacing your day hiking backpack or using around town. It's a lumbar pack that can carry everything you need with all the thoughtful designs of a traditional backpack.

Best EveryDay Fanny Pack: Cotopaxi Bataan Del Día 

Price: $33
Volume: 3 L
Pockets: 3
Weight: 3 oz
Dimensions: 10” x 5” x 4”
What we liked: style, made from lightweight remnant fabric, can be used a cross body bag
What we didn't like: less durable, depending on where you purchase it, you may have no control of the colors you get

Fun, whimsical, and stylish in that 80s throwback kind of way, the Cotopaxi Bataan Del Día Fanny Pack is great for around town or that next beach party. 

This 3L pack is big enough for a few sundries but small enough so you can’t lose anything inside. Two small mesh pockets also keep your smaller items—keys, cash, and credit cards—from moving around your pack as you move. 

For use in town, it has a long waist strap that can convert into a cross body bag. It's made of upcycled fabric by sewers who get to decide their own color combinations and Cotopaxi is a Certified B-Corp. The Bataan is a bestseller at REI and favorite of many hikers due to its everyday look and fun design.

• Fabric

  The Bataan del Dia is made out of lightweight nylon from remnant fabric. It’s the only fanny pack where you have the option to choose your own colors and get a unique colorway suited to your style (if you order directly from Cotopaxi's website). Otherwise, there are lots of fun options of colors as artisans are empowered to make their own decisions on color combos.

  Cotopaxi has a great description of how their remnant fabric program works on their website. 

  Factories notify Cotopaxi when they have extra material and Cotopaxi makes limited-run color editions of the Del Dia to reduce waste by repurposing material. It’s made from fabric leftover from other companies’ large-scale production runs, keeping fabric out of landfills.

• Style and versatility

  For everyday use, we liked turning it into a sling bag.

  It had one of the longest waist belts of any of the packs we considered—making it one of the most size inclusive fanny packs out there.

• Customization

  One of the most unique things about the Bataan is when you order direct from Cotopaxi, you can either choose the colors on your Bataan to get a unique and one-of-a-kind colorway of your own style. 

  Or you select “Surprise Me” for something unexpected. Whatever you choose, the color options on the website are hand-selected by the sewers constructing the product in the Philippines. 

  Cotopaxi gives the sewers complete creative control over the look of packs sold on the website. Note that the color options are standardized if purchasing your Cotopaxi del Dia from other retailers, though.

• Volume and pockets

  In the 3 L, we can fit a large phone, small water bottle, rain jacket, sunscreen and lip balm, sunglasses, snacks, electrolytes, wallet, keys, headlamp, and wind shirt, lighter, small knife, map, and a few first aid items. This covers all the Ten Essentials.

• Durability

  Some reviewers noted a lack of durability of the Bataan, mostly when it came to the decal design peeling off or colors fading. We haven't had issues in several years of wearing the same fanny pack, but given that the fabric is upcycled, it's possible that every pack has different durability.

Best Budget Fanny Pack: JanSport Fifth Avenue

Price: $25
Dimensions: 6” x 10” x 3.5” 
Carrying Capacity: 2.5 L
Weight: 4.5 oz
Number of Pockets: 2
What we liked: great price, stylish, lots of color choices, surprisingly durable
What we didn't like: not waterproof

If you need a classic fanny pack for around $20, the JanSport Fifth Avenue is the way to go. The beauty of this pack is its simplicity and lots of color options. There's something for everyone and nearly everyone we asked said they like how it looks. 

The JanSport Fifth Avenue is 2.5 L—more than double the size of similarly priced smaller packs—and made of polyester rather than canvas, which means a lower price point to boot.

• Style

  The JanSport Fifth Avenue comes in lots of options in solid colors. Note: not all retailers sell all the designs, so check a few of them to find the colors you like.

  We’d also warn that the JanSport's lighter colors (we have a pale pink one) get dirty faster than other packs. So if you’re planning to go hiking or biking with this pack, expect the dirt to show pretty quickly.

• Durability

  For several years, we were concerned that the polyester fabric (vs. canvas) would impact the long-term durability of this fanny pack. However, after more than 3 years of testing, we have found the JanSport Fifth Avenue fanny pack passes our durability test and is worthy of its new award as best budget fanny pack.

Best Lightweight Fanny Pack: Gossamer Gear Bumster

Price: $29
Fits Waists: Up to 45 in
Dimensions: 5.5 x 10.5 x 2.5 in
Carrying Capacity: 1.5 L
Weight: 3.1 oz
What we liked: lightweight, good storage
What we didn't like: narrow waist belt, only adjusts up to 45 in.

Though it is a minimalist pack, the Gossamer Gear Bumster has just what you need. The 1.5L Gossamer Gear Bumster is one of the lightest-weight pack we reviewed and has waterproof zippers and water-resistant fabric. This makes it a clear winner for best minimalist fanny pack. 

We liked the inside key clasp and mesh divider big enough to secure a phone. We also liked the hidden pocket on the back, making it an ideal travel fanny pack for storing cash, cards, ID, or other valuables.

A hiker wears the Gossamer Gear Bumster on the trail, showing the lightweight fanny pack’s compact 1.5-liter design.

We tested the lightweight Gossamer Gear Bumster on hikes, where its 1.5-liter capacity provides storage for essentials without adding much weight.

The Gossamer Gear Bumster keeps hiking essentials close at hand in a lightweight, water-resistant fanny pack with waterproof zippers.

The 3.1-ounce Gossamer Gear Bumster is a minimalist fanny pack with enough storage for essentials on day hikes and other outdoor adventures.

• Versatility

  For those of you looking for a lighter pack that can hold chalk, sunblock, or carabiners while rock climbing, this pack deserves a look. You can also use the exterior looped attachments on the Gossamer Gear Bumster to attach additional lighter pieces of equipment that you might bring with you.

• Waistbelt

  The only thing we didn't like is that the waist belt is narrower than I’d like, and can only adjust up to 45 inches—one of the shorter ranges of our reviewed packs.

Best Fanny Pack For Thru-Hiking: Thrupack Summit Bum Classic

Price: $65
Dimensions: 9” x 5” x 3”
Waist Size: Fits up to 50 inches
Carrying Capacity: 2.5 L
Weight: 3.5 oz (standard strap), 4.7 oz (comfy strap)
Number of Pockets: 3
What we liked: water resistance, lightweight, durability, fun colors, versatility with waistbelt
What we didn't like: limited stock

Last year, readers reached out to us about testing the Thrupack Summit Bum Classic. It was one of the original fanny packs and is popular on the Pacific Crest Trail, Appalachian Trail, and Colorado Trail. After a year of testing on the trails, it is our new winner for best fanny pack for thru-hiking.

The Thrupack Summit Bum has two options for fabric: essentially waterproof ECOPAK or essentially waterproof Ultra. The second is a highly durable, abrasion-resistant, and lightweight material commonly found in ultralight backpacking backpacks popular with thru-hikers. It is also lighter than nylon and significantly more durable and UV-resistant, meaning it can survive the rigors of a thru-hike.

With fun colors and great style, the Summit Bum is made in the USA by thru-hikers. This cottage brand’s fanny packs are a favorite on the trail for their style, light weight, comfort, and convenience.

• Water resistant and durable fabric

  The Thrupack Summit Bum has two options for fabric: essentially waterproof ECOPAK or essentially waterproof Ultra. The second is a highly-durable, abrasion-resistant, and lightweight material commonly found in ultralight backpacking backpacks popular with thru-hikers. It also is lighter than nylon and significantly more durable and UV-resistant, meaning it can survive the rigors of a thru-hike, while also offering a lot of water resistance.  

  We've also use this pack extensively to store our fly fishing accessories in situations where we are in the water and don't want things to get wet. It’s a hands-free way to keep our flies and indicators organized without investing in dedicated fly fishing bags, which tend to be expensive.

• Comfy strap remains comfortable over thousands of miles

  The Summit Bum has the option of using a comfy strap instead of the standard strap. We love the comfy strap. In fact, when comparing the Thru Pack to fanny packs by other ultralight brands, the comfy strap is a huge factor in why we keep coming back to the Summit Bum for thru-hiking. 

  The Comfy Strap is available in many fun colors and designs and replaces the standard 1" webbing strap that comes with the Summit Bum. It is 2" wide and expands 24" beyond the list size so can be used as a sling pack over the shoulder. It weighs 0.7 oz more than the regular strap but it makes a difference.

• Style

  It comes in more color options than some other ultralight fanny pack brands, like Hyperlite Mountain Gear Versa. Some are made of Ultra (more on that below). Some are made of eco-friendly material, like the Eco Summit we tested made of ECOPAK-EPX200, made of 100% recycled material. 

  You even have the option of building your own custom pack.

• Versatility

  The Thru-pack is a good fanny pack to protect camera gear, phones, maps, or layers that you want easy access to. The light weight, durability, generous capacity without feeling unstable, and water-resistance is why we recommend this pack as the best fanny pack for thru-hiking.

Best Hiking Fanny Pack with Water Bottle Holder: Osprey Savu 5 Lumbar Bottle Pack

Price: $70
Capacity: 5L
Dimensions: 7” x 9” x 4”
Waist size: 25-50 inches
Hydration: 2 water bottles
Pockets: 5 + main compartment
Material: Recycled 600-denier PET polyester/recycled 400-denier high-tenacity nylon
Weight: 13.4 oz
What we liked: pockets and organization, quality fabric
What we didn't like: more suited for mountain biking, may not be best for hikers or casual wear 

The Osprey Savu 5 is the winner of Best MTB Hip Pack for Carrying Bottles in our Best Mountain Bike Hip Pack guide. 

But we think this waist pack is worth your attention, even if you aren't a mountain biker.  

It features two sturdy bottle slots, two zippered hip pockets, one main rear compartment, and a small, zippered, and moisture-resistant phone/valuables pocket. 

It was among the most stable and comfortable of the waist packs we tested. It's versatile - large enough for several hours of adventures but isn’t overly bulky for shorter trips.

For $65, the Savu 5 offers great value, especially compared to the Osprey Talon we also tested. Its useful features, excellent durability, functionality, and comfort make it a top choice for people who want to carry water bottles.

• Pockets

  We like that there are two mesh pockets within the main compartment for organization. Dual-zippered side pockets are easy to access and fit most average-sized phones (though the water-resistant middle pocket is intended for phone storage). Unlike all but the more advanced packs we considered, it has four compression straps to keep the waist pack tight when it’s not fully stuffed. 

• Comfort and bounce

  The Savu was designed with mountain bikers in mind, so was designed to be bounce-proof. For hikers, that means it will feel extremely stable. The waist belt on the Savu 5 is wide and comfortable, distributing the weight well with minimal bounce. We wore it for hot laps while mountain biking with little bounce. On hikes, it can handle uneven terrain and scrambling while staying put.

• Durability

  The quality of the recycled nylon is one reason why Osprey Packs are the Overall winner in our Best Day Packs for Hiking guide and our Best Baby and Toddler Carriers for Hiking guide. We've been impressed with how well it has held up in rough conditions.

Best Waterproof Hiking Fanny Pack: Hyperlite Mountain Gear Versa

Price: $85
Capacity: 2.5 L
Dimensions: 2.25 x 6 x 9
Waist size: Up to 52"
Hydration: None
Pockets: 3
Material: Dyneema Cuben Fiber
Weight: 4.27 oz
What we liked: lightweight, sleek, extremely water resistant
What we didn't like: limited colors and sizes

The Hyperlite Mountain Gear Versa is the only waist pack we considered made of Dyneema Cuben Fiber, a water-resistant material commonly found in ultralight backpacking backpacks and tents popular with thru-hikers. 

If you’re going to get wet (and at some point, the thru-hikers on the Treeline Review team say this is inevitable), the DCF fabric is almost completely waterproof and this pack also has waterproof seamed seals. The Versa is a good fanny pack to protect camera gear, phones, maps, or layers that you want easy access to. 

The light weight, durability, generous capacity without feeling unstable, and water-resistance made this a strong contender for the best fanny pack for any hiking you may be doing in wetter weather. While the brand doesn't explicitly call it waterproof, in our testing, this is as close as we've seen to a lightweight waterproof fanny pack.

HMG won’t go as far as to say the Versa is 100% waterproof, but it’s pretty close. The zippers are taped to be waterproof and lay flat when zipped, so they don’t catch on passing shrubs or branches. 

Our non-thru-hiker tester found the DCF was loud and crinkly when in use. But for all but the most lightweight devotees, we think the price and noise are dings against this pack.

Best Ultralight Fanny Pack: Ultralight Fanny Pack by High Tail Designs

Price: $66
Capacity: 1 L
Dimensions: 8 x 4 x 2
Waist size: 39.5"
Hydration: None
Pockets: 1
Material:
Weight: 1.8 oz
What we liked: extremely lightweight, good capacity, lots of colors and sizes, Made in the USA
What we didn't like: not as comfortable as fanny packs with more padding (that weigh more)

If you want the most ultralight fanny pack out there, the High Tail Designs Ultralight Fanny Pack is the clear winner. At 1.8 oz, this is the most ultralight full-size, fully-functional fanny pack out there. What it lacks in weight it more than makes up for in character. With fun and colorful designs by real artists, the High Tail Designs Ultralight fanny packs are made by thru-hikers in the USA.

Ultralight Fanny Pack by High Tail Designs

Made of a sublimated 2.92 oz/sqyd abrasion-resistant Dyneema Hybrid fabric that is durable and water-resistant, this fanny pack has everything you want in a fanny pack and nothing you don't. It has fully-taped seams and a non-zip internal pocket. You'll find burlier Dyneema on the Hyperlite fanny pack, but not at a lighter weight or at a more affordable price. 

As expected for an ultralight fanny pack, you aren't going to get as much padding (and the comfort associated with it) with this waist pack as you would with burlier options like the Summit Bum. But if you want a cool-looking pack that is as light as you can get, the High Tail Designs Ultralight fanny pack is the clear winner.

Other fanny packs, lumbar packs, and waist packs we tested

Thrupack Summit Bum Pocket

Price: $70
Weight: 3.7 oz
Waist Size: Up to 50"
Pockets: 3

We loved the Thrupack Summit Bum Pocket, which is similar to the Thrupack Summit Bum Classic that was our winner for best for thru-hiking. The difference is in the mesh pocket, which is on the outside of the pack and can hold a phone. Ultimately, for thru-hikers, we think a shoulder strap is a more secure pocket system. Still, if you prefer to have waist-side access to your phone, this could be a good alternative to the Summit Bum Classic.

Osprey Seral 7 Lumbar Pack

Capacity: 7L
Hydration: 1.5 L (Reservoir Included)
Waist Size: 27-50 inches
Weight: 18.9 oz
Pockets: 3
Material: Recycled 600-denier PET polyester/recycled 400-denier high-tenacity nylon

The Osprey Seral 7 is a winner in our Best Mountain Bike Hip Pack guide and we think it crosses over to hiking, too. Many outdoor media reviews have given it accolades, including Outdoor Gear Lab awarding the Seral 7 a Top Pick award. 

A 1.5-liter reservoir carries water and leaves plenty of room in this waist pack for other essentials. Aside from the Mountainsmith Tour, it has the most capacity of any packs in this review, making it ideal for long hauls on the trail.

The Seral 7 has a breathable back panel, easily adjustable waistband, and durable outer fabric. The main difference between the Osprey Seral 7 and Osprey Savu is the water system and the storage capacity. We think the Savu will meet most hikers' needs better because it has a smaller capacity. Between the two waist packs, the Savu's smaller capacity makes it more stable and comfortable.

REI Co-Op Trail 5 Waist Pack

Capacity: 5 L
Dimensions: 19 x 7 x 4 inches
Weight: 9 oz
Pockets: 4
Material: Shell: recycled nylon; lining: recycled polyester

We loved the REI Co-op 5 L waist pack. We carried it on a 3-day, 60 mile hike near Ventura, California and were surprised by how it fit everything we need for an entire day of hiking. 

There are pockets galore and everything is very organized. Ultimately, it's very similar to the Osprey Savu, our winner for best for carrying bottles. The newest version even has fun color options and contains recycled material that meet bluesign criteria. 

We chose the Savu because it has better padding and stays a little more rigid—which we think is a good thing for a hiking waist pack. Still, we recommend the REI Co op 5 L, especially if you want to save compared to the Osprey Savu.

Waterfly Slim Fanny Pack

Price: $20
Weight: 5 oz
Waist Size: Fits up to 50 in
Pockets: 4

The Waterfly Slim Fanny pack—a bestselling pack on Amazon—is the least expensive pack we looked at. 

It does a great job of what it is supposed to do: is made of water-resistant polyester material, and can be worn across your chest as a sling bag, around your waist, or on your back, and has multiple compartments to store smaller items.

There are many people out there who aren’t looking for their fanny packs to be fashionable. Instead, they’re looking for a solid pack that does what it sets out to do for a reasonable price. 

Ultimately, we decided the JanSport Fifth Avenue–which is within a couple dollars of the Waterfly Slim Fanny pack–was more stylish, had more color options, and had better volume and versatility.

Why you need a hiking fanny pack

Love 'em or still warming up to the idea, a hiking fanny pack solves a problem you probably didn't realize you had until you tried one: where do you put your phone, snacks, and sunscreen when you don't want a full pack on your back?

During testing, we found ourselves reaching for a fanny pack even on hikes where we'd normally grab a backpack out of habit. A pack like the Patagonia Terravia Mini held a phone, sunscreen, lip balm, sunglasses, a headlamp, a snack, electrolytes, a liner glove, a wallet, and keys, everything most of us actually need for a shorter hike, without the sweaty back or shoulder strain of a full pack. For longer days, the Cotopaxi Bataan Del Día covered the entire Ten Essentials list in just 3 liters.

A fanny pack also keeps things accessible in a way a backpack doesn't. Digging through a main compartment to find lip balm or a snack gets old fast, especially mid-stride. Most of the packs we tested put your most-used items within reach without breaking your pace.

They're also more versatile than they get credit for. We used ours for day hikes, sure, but also for dog walks, farmers’ market runs, fly fishing, bike rides, and a three-day, 60-mile urban thru-hike through Ventura, California. Several packs in this guide, like the Cotopaxi Bataan and Thrupack Summit Bum, convert to sling bags or cross-body bags, so the same pack that works on trail works just as well in town.

And if you're worried about looking like it's 1993, the options have come a long way. Between Patagonia's sleeker designs and Cotopaxi's colorful, one-of-a-kind Del Día colorways, there's a fanny pack out there that doesn't feel like a costume.

If you've ever hiked with your phone in one pocket, sunscreen in another, and snacks somewhere you can't remember, a hiking fanny pack is the fix.

What to look for in a hiking fanny pack 

Whether you're replacing your backpack for a quick day hike or just want your essentials within reach while biking around town, a good hiking fanny pack needs to be more than just trendy. Here’s what we look for—and what you should consider—before you buy.

Capacity: how much do you really need to carry?

Fanny packs range from minimalist 0.5-liter models to high-volume 9-liter lumbar packs. If you just want to stash your phone, keys, and a snack, a 1–2 L pack is plenty. But if you’re aiming to replace a daypack, look for something in the 5–9 L range with space for water, layers, and the Ten Essentials. For thru-hikers and ultralight fans, we’ve found 2–3 L to be the sweet spot for weight, volume, and access.

Fit and sizing: make sure it stays put

A fanny pack is only as comfortable as its fit. Look for a waist belt that’s adjustable enough to wear around your hips or across your chest, with enough length to accommodate a wide range of body types. Packs with padded belts or wider straps distribute weight better and reduce bounce on the move—key for running, biking, or scrambling.

Organization: pockets make the difference

We prefer fanny packs that make it easy to find what you need without digging around. Look for multiple compartments, mesh dividers, or internal key clips to keep essentials sorted. External pockets or stretchy mesh sleeves are great for items you grab often—like lip balm, snacks, or sunscreen.

Water bottle storage: optional, but useful

Not every pack includes a water bottle holder—and not everyone needs one. But if you do want hydration on the go, make sure your fanny pack fits your bottle snugly. Look for angled or elasticized sleeves that hold bottles securely without making them a hassle to reholster. If you plan to carry a reservoir, check for compatibility or internal routing for the hose.

Material and weather resistance

For most hikers, water-resistant fabric is enough to shed light rain and sweat. But if you’re hiking in consistently wet conditions or want to protect electronics, look for seam-sealed construction and waterproof fabrics like ECOPAK or DCF. Upcycled or recycled materials are a bonus for sustainability.

Comfort: think padding and breathability

Even small fanny packs can cause discomfort if they dig into your hips or trap sweat. Mesh back panels, light padding, and moisture-wicking fabrics make a big difference on hot days or long hikes. Heavier packs especially benefit from wider waist belts and breathable padding.

Durability: choose materials that match your use

If you're tough on gear or plan to use your fanny pack for years, durability matters. Ultralight fabrics are great for cutting weight but may not hold up to constant abrasion. Nylon, ripstop, and reinforced stitching all increase lifespan. Pay attention to customer reviews about how packs perform over time—especially around zippers and straps.

Style: it’s okay to choose a pack you love to wear

Function matters, but let’s be honest—you’re more likely to bring your fanny pack if you like how it looks. Whether you prefer minimalist neutrals, bold colors, or fun patterns, don’t underestimate the power of personal style. Many of the packs we reviewed come in multiple colors, so you can find something that fits both your needs and your vibe.

How To Choose The Right Fanny Pack 

If you’re focused on finding a hands-free and shoulder-free option to carry must-have items while on the go, the following questions can help simplify your decision-making process:

• What will I be doing? 

• How long will I be gone?

• Will I need to bring snacks?

• How light does the pack need to be?

• What’s my budget?

The type of activities that you enjoy will also affect your choice of pack. If you’re running, biking, or moving quickly, a pack that is easily secured and doesn’t move up and down is ideal—which usually means a thicker waist belt. A pack with internal dividers or pockets will also help keep you organized during high-impact activities.

You may also find that different activities need different packs—one good for running might not be best as a backpack replacement.

We include fanny packs, waist packs, and lumbar packs in this guide because we realize different conditions require different packs.

Care and maintenance tips

Your fanny pack sees just as much action as your hiking shoes: crammed with snacks, bounced around on bike rides, and tossed on the ground mid-hike. A little care goes a long way toward keeping it functional for years.

Most packs don't need frequent washing, but once yours starts smelling like sunscreen and trail mix, it's time for a spot clean. A sponge, mild soap, and warm water handle most grime. Skip the washing machine unless the manufacturer specifically says it's safe, and avoid harsh detergents that can break down water-resistant coatings, especially on packs made with technical fabrics like the Ultra or ECOPAK material used in the Thrupack Summit Bum. Air dry in the shade rather than direct sun to prevent fading and keep the shape intact.

Empty your pack out after every trip rather than leaving it packed and ready to go. Crumbs and forgotten snacks degrade fabric over time and are the fastest way to end up with a pack that smells worse than it should.

Zippers are usually the first thing to fail on a well-used fanny pack. If one snags, don't force it; back it out gently and clear whatever fabric got caught. A swipe of zipper lubricant every few months keeps things moving smoothly.

Check high-friction spots regularly, especially the waist belt and corners, which take the most abuse if you wear your pack on one hip or use it while biking. Upcycled and ultralight materials, like the remnant fabric used in the Cotopaxi Bataan, are more prone to wear than heavier nylon, so give those packs extra attention and reinforce weak spots with seam grip or repair tape before small fraying turns into a hole.

Store your pack somewhere cool and dry between trips. Leaving it in direct sun, like on a car seat, breaks down fabric coatings and causes fading. If your pack stuffs into its own pocket, let it breathe occasionally rather than keeping it compressed all the time, which can cause creasing over the long run.

If something does break, a torn seam or a busted buckle doesn't necessarily mean your pack is done. Many brands, including Patagonia with its Ironclad Guarantee, offer repairs or replacement parts, and a basic gear repair kit handles most fixes without needing to replace the whole pack.

FAQ

• Can you wear a hiking fanny pack with a backpack?

  Yes, and many thru-hikers do exactly this, wearing a small fanny pack in front for quick-access items while their main backpack carries everything else. The main friction point is the hip belt: a bulky lumbar pack worn behind you can interfere with a backpack's hip belt padding, while a slim front-worn pack like the Patagonia Terravia typically clears it without issue. If you plan to wear both together regularly, a minimalist front pack is more compatible than a high-volume lumbar pack.

• Should a hiking fanny pack sit in front or behind?

  It depends on the pack's size and purpose. Small, minimalist packs like the Patagonia Terravia or Gossamer Gear Bumster work well worn in front, since their low profile keeps items within easy reach without shifting much. Larger lumbar packs, like the Mountainsmith Tour, are generally worn behind, resting the weight on your hips and glutes rather than your stomach, which is more comfortable for carrying heavier loads over long distances or on uneven terrain.

• How much can you comfortably carry in a hiking fanny pack?

  Comfort depends more on how the weight is distributed and how well the pack fits than on raw capacity. A 1 to 2 liter pack loaded with just a phone, snack, and sunscreen stays close to the body and rarely causes discomfort. Once you push toward the 5 to 9 liter range, like the Mountainsmith Tour, a wide, padded waist belt becomes essential for spreading that weight evenly across your hips rather than letting it dig in at one point. Overfilling any fanny pack, even a high-capacity one, tends to create bounce and pressure points regardless of the stated volume.

• Are hiking fanny packs waterproof?

  Waterproofing exists on a spectrum. Some packs use only water-resistant fabric that beads off light rain but eventually soaks through. Others add coated or taped zippers, which stop water from seeping in through the closure point specifically. A smaller number, like the Thrupack Summit Bum and Hyperlite Mountain Gear Versa, use fully seam-sealed waterproof fabrics such as ECOPAK or Dyneema Composite Fabric, keeping contents dry even in sustained rain or river crossings. If you need guaranteed dry storage for electronics or fishing gear, look specifically for sealed seams rather than just a water-resistant fabric claim.

• Can a fanny pack replace a daypack?

  For short, mild-weather outings, yes. A 5 to 9 liter fanny pack can comfortably carry water, snacks, a light layer, and the Ten Essentials for a few hours on trail. Where a fanny pack falls short is on longer or more demanding trips: it cannot carry the water volume of a hydration reservoir at scale, has limited room for insulating layers in changing weather, and lacks the structure to carry bulkier safety equipment like a first aid kit or emergency shelter. For half-day hikes in stable conditions, a fanny pack works well; for full-day trips or unpredictable weather, a daypack remains the safer choice.

• Do hiking fanny packs bounce?

  Bounce comes down to fit, load, and pack design working together. A wide, well-padded waist belt secures the pack against your body and reduces movement significantly compared to a narrow strap. Packs specifically designed for high-motion activities, like the Osprey Savu 5, use structured backing and compression straps to stay stable even during running or mountain biking. Heavier loads bounce more than light ones regardless of pack quality, and the effect is most noticeable in running-specific packs like the Ultimate Direction Ultra Belt when fully loaded with water. Compression straps that cinch down excess space also meaningfully reduce bounce on partially filled packs.

How We Researched And Tested

After a dozen hours of research, we found 59 fanny packs that were popular in media and among everyday users. Then we tested nearly two dozen of them side-by-side for three years on everything from casual walks in town to thru-hikes. We took them to festivals, bike rides, road tripping, to mountain peaks, fly fishing, and international adventure travel trips.

We tested by roading, walking, and roaming around town to get a feel for each pack. After around hundreds of miles of exploring—short walks, long rides across town, quick visits to the farmers market, and hikes in Colorado’s Front Range—we sorted out which packs are good for which activity.

From there, we had the Treeline Review team take them on further activities, from climbing 14ers to traveling around the world, mountain biking, thru-hiking, and fly fishing. 

About The Author / Why You Should Trust Us

Michelle Jackson is a Denver-based writer who has covered stories in Vice, AARP, Debt.com, Chime, and more.

She grew up in Boulder, Colorado, and runs the podcast and blog Square State, all about Colorado.

She hikes weekly, loves camping, and snowboards imperfectly.

September 17th, 2026, updated with a years' worth of testing notes, updated prices and commentary on changes
Home > Gear Reviews > Climbing

One of the most important pieces of climbing gear is your helmet. It’s one of those items that you hope to never need, but when you do, it’s really important that it protects your noggin. Fortunately, climbing helmets have come a long way from the heavy, ill-fitting designs of the past. Today’s helmets use different materials and constructions to balance protection with comfort, ventilation, weight, and durability.

Our lead tester, Mary Beth Skylis, has been climbing across the globe for more than a decade and has extensive experience on limestone, granite, alpine terrain, and long multi-pitch climbs. Over several years, we tested climbing helmets in Yosemite, the Rocky Mountains, and climbing areas in North and South Carolina, using them for everything from sport and cragging days to multi-pitch routes, alpine objectives, and year-round climbing.

We compared fit, sizing, and adjustability, along with interior padding and comfort for all-day wear. We also considered ventilation on hot approaches and climbs, weight on long multi-pitch and alpine days, coverage and construction, and practical features such as headlamp clips. For safety performance itself, we relied on the helmets’ stated climbing certifications rather than attempting to replicate standardized impact testing.

Top Pick: The Mammut Wall Rider MIPS earns our Best Overall award. We found its internal padding comfortable enough for all-day use, while the relatively low weight and large ventilation openings kept it from feeling overly bulky on long climbing days. We also appreciated that it combines that comfort with broad coverage and MIPS technology, though the size adjustment system takes a little more effort to dial in than some of the other helmets we tested.

Related: Best Climbing Ropes

*Climbing is dangerous, and you —and not this gear review website— are responsible for your safety. No matter what gear you have, you need to make safe decisions, take classes from certified guides, and read the instructions before you go! No matter what climbing helmet you buy, always make sure the helmet meets the safety certifications you need. Always purchase climbing equipment from reputable sources.

We create reader-supported, objective, independently-selected gear reviews. This story may contain affiliate links, which help fund our website. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission without costing you an extra cent. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body! Learn more.

Comparison table

The Winners

Best Overall Climbing Helmet: Mammut Wall Rider MIPS Helmet 

Weight: 225-250 grams / 7.94-8.82 ounces
Sizes: 52-57 cm, 56-61 cm
Construction: EPP Foam, Polycarbonate shell
Safety ratings: EN 12492
What we liked: Advanced safety features, comfortable fit, bill, all-around protection
What we didn’t like: Price, size adjuster could be more intuitive

We chose the Mammut Wall Rider with MIPS technology as our top pick because it does what a climbing helmet should do: it protects your head from not only standard climbing obstacles but also the rotational force that’s commonly responsible for concussions. What’s more, it does so at a relatively accessible price, and it manages to retain comfort—taking away any excuse a climber might devise to ditch their helmet. There’s no reason not to wear the Mammut Wall Rider.

The Mammut Wall Rider was the first climbing helmet to adopt MIPS technology in 2018—just two years after the first MIPS helmet was released for equestrian use. While the technology has been around for almost 20 years, this helmet’s hefty price point creates a deterrent for some athletes, forcing them to shell out an extra $50 in an already expensive sport. In our opinion, it’s worth the strain on your pocketbook, because your head deserves  protection. 

In addition to its MIPS technology, the Mammut Wall Rider utilizes expanded polypropylene (EPP) as its foam base, and a partial hard shell to help protect climbers from both falling rock or ice and from the impact of a fall. The internal padding components enhance comfort, which is ideal for all-day use. 

And it even comes with bonus features, like two clips on the front of the helmet and a rubber loop on the back to keep your headlamp in place, and large ventilation ports for improved air circulation. With features like these, you might assume that the helmet is heavy, but it weighs just 225–250 grams, making it a relatively lightweight helmet option.

Best Affordable Climbing Helmet: Metolius Hardtop Climbing Helmet 

Weight: 250-270 grams / 8.8-9.5 ounces
Size: 52-58 cm, 58-61 cm
Construction: EPP Foam, ABS Shell
Safety ratings: EN 12492
What we liked: Accessible price, reasonable weight, durability, washable fit pads
What we didn’t like: Helmet style, no brim

Metolius is constantly challenging climbing gear prices, and the Metolius Hardtop Climbing Helmet is a great example of that trend. For the same cost as three pairs of wool socks, climbers can grab a high-quality helmet with an EPP and ABS construction with an ultralight webbing retention system that protects and cradles your head no matter if you’re at the local sport crag or on a big wall somewhere in the world.

Weighing 8.8 to 9.5 ounces, this helmet is one of the bulkier options on this list. But its weight adds to a burlier construction that can handle heavy use. While EPS alternatives to this helmet are a little bit lighter, they also likely won’t be able to handle living in the same backpack as your quickdraws or rack. So, this is a great pick if you’re hard on your gear and you want your helmet to be a bit burlier.

In addition to providing a durable, entry-level construction, this helmet comes with large ventilation holes, headlamp clips with an elastic strap in the back, and removable fit pads for cushioned comfort.

Best Beginner Climbing Helmet: Black Diamond Capitan E Helmet

Weight: 320–350 g / 11.3–12.3 oz
Size: 53-59 cm, 58-63 cm
Construction: EPP foam, EPS foam puck and a two-piece recycled ABS/DuraPET shell
Safety ratings: EN 12492 (mountaineering), UIAA
What we liked: Additional safety certification/coverage, available in a MIPS version, side and back protection
What we didn’t like: Heavier than competitive helmets

The standard Black Diamond Capitan E Helmet comes close to matching the price of our Best Affordable pick, the Metolius Hardtop Climbing Helmet, but it differs in a few ways. This helmet is a few ounces heavier, and it integrates both EPP and EPS foam into the design to create added durability while reducing the likelihood of experiencing a helmet fracture.

We found it to be comfortable and reliable in design, but noticeably heavier than the Mammut Wall Rider. But we love the helmet’s dual EN and UIAA safety certifications and extended coverage. 

Our main caveat is that this helmet runs small, so it’s not the best option for climbers who require a spacious fit. What’s more, it can be difficult to adjust this helmet while you’re wearing it since the plastic piece that keeps the webbing in place requires adjustments on both sides. But overall, this is a great helmet for beginners due to its accessible price, hefty design, and added protection.

Best Alpine Climbing Helmet/ Best Lightweight Climbing Helmet: Petzl SIROCCO Helmet

Weight: 160-170 grams / 5.6-6 ounces
Size: 48-58 cm, 53-61 cm
Construction: EPP Foam shell, PC Crown, EPS liner, Polyester webbing
Safety ratings: CE EN 12492, UIAA
What we liked: Easily the lightest helmet on this list
What we didn’t like: Higher price point, no longer meets EN 18100 (2024 ski mountaineering requirements)

Described by Petzl as an “ultra-lightweight” helmet, this helmet really lives up to its intended design. Weighing 5.6 to 6 ounces depending on size, the SIROCCO has the equivalent weight of a bar of soap or 12 playing cards. The Petzl SIROCCO is easily the lightest helmet on this list by about 3 ounces. While some climbers might not give a hoot about a 3-ounce difference, alpinists and big-wall climbers probably do.

In order to create that lightweight design, Petzl combined EPP foam, a polycarbonate crown, an EPS liner, and polyester webbing while adhering to both EN 12492 and UIAA standards. Made for alpinism and mountaineering, this helmet is a must-have for backcountry lovers. It provides all of the protection you could want without adding bulk to your pack. This helmet also has 24 vents to help your head shed heat amidst challenging adventures—another ideal quality for multi-day adventures. 

Admittedly, this helmet has a less accessible price (it’s the most expensive helmet on our list, and it doesn’t come with MIPS technology). We also don’t love the magnetic clasp system on this helmet since the magnet can attract sediment, making it difficult to close.

Still, it’s tough to beat a helmet that offers this much coverage while weighing practically nothing. This is a must-have helmet for serious adventurers and ounce counters that want protection without bulk.

Best Multi-Pitch Climbing Helmet: Mammut Crag Sender Helmet

Weight: 210-220 grams / 7.4-7.8 ounces
Size: 52-57 cm, 56-61 cm
Construction: EPS foam, PC shell
Safety ratings: CE EN 12492 
What we liked: Added front, back, and side protection, cushioning, headlamp attachment, rear adjustment wheel
What we didn’t like: Runs large

The Mammut Crag Sender was our go-to helmet while multi-pitch climbing in Yosemite, and it worked like a dream. This helmet weighs 7.4-7.8 ounces, making it barely noticeable while you’re on the wall all day. Its EPS foam and PC shell construction give it great coverage and protection benefits without the added weight of EPP alternatives. It also comes with large ventilation openings and integrated air channeling to keep you cool on full-day adventures.

Multi-pitch climbers typically gravitate towards helmets that can be adjusted with one hand, and the Mammut Crag Sender accomplishes this with its wheel adjustment system. Instead of forcing you to use two hands to shift the fit of the attachment system, you can easily shift the sizing back and forth with just one hand. We also found that this helmet’s fit makes it a good choice for people with small heads.

Best Climbing Helmet FOR COMFORT: Black Diamond Vision Helmet

Weight: 215-225 grams / 7.5-7.9 ounces
Size: 53-59 cm, 58-63 cm
Construction: EPP Foam, EPS Foam Puck, ABS Shell
Safety ratings: UIAA, EN 12492
What we liked: One of the most durable helmets in the Black Diamond collection, low-profile suspension, removable padding, good for big heads
What we didn’t like: Slightly generous fit

The Black Diamond Vision is one of the most comfortable helmets we tested due to its extra padding and design. While some helmets come with tight spots, the Vision manages to provide full coverage without overdoing it. We never felt like we needed to readjust the helmet once we customized the suspension system, which felt like a testament to its comfortable design.

This helmet comes with an EPP foam construction, an EPS foam puck, and an ABS shell to provide protection without the bulk. It’s also known for being the most durable helmet in the Black Diamond collection, which is ideal for those of us who are hard on our gear. 

This helmet also comes with integrated headlamp clips, and six color options. The overall design and adjustable features of this helmet are intuitive and easy to use. 

MOST Versatile Climbing Helmet: Petzl Meteor/Meteora Helmet

Weight: METEOR: 235-245 g | 8.3-8.6 oz; METEORA: 225 g | 7.9 oz;
Size: METEOR: 52-59 cm (S/M); 57-61 cm (M/L); METEORA: 48-58 cm
Construction: PC Crown, EPS liner, Polyester webbing
Safety ratings: CE EN 12492, UIAA
What we liked: Protection versatility, vents, designed for ponytails, slider adjustment
What we didn’t like: Limited sizing

We tested both the Petzl METEOR and the Petzl METEORA, a women’s-specific climbing version. Both models exceeded our expectations in a variety of ways, including their simple designs, venting system, and overall versatility. The main difference between the women’s and men’s versions of the helmet is ponytail compatibility, which can be a nice addition for those of us who rock long hair. But, truthfully, we loved these helmets for an entirely different reason: their multi-sport versatility.

While this helmet previously held a certification for ski touring (PCSR-001) and notably comes with goggle attachment points, it no longer holds that certification.

These helmets provide protection for a variety of impact types, yet they manage to retain a lightweight design. The women’s version of this helmet comes in one size, and weighs 7.9 ounces, which is a middle-of-the-road weight for a quality climbing helmet. But this helmet is anything but a middle-of-the-road helmet. 

In addition to its multiple safety certifications, this helmet is made with a polycarbonate crown, an EPS liner, and polyester webbing. The women’s version contains 21 vents for added breathability, as well as an OMEGA headband to keep your ponytail off of your neck. 

The Petzl METEOR was the first-ever helmet certified for ski touring, and it remains one of the best options today. Features like its breathability and goggle attachment points make it reliable and consistent no matter the mountain conditions. Our only complaint is that the women’s version of this helmet only comes in one size.

What to look for in a climbing helmet

A quality climbing helmet should meet recognized climbing safety standards while providing a proper fit, adjustable components, and enough comfort to wear for a full day. Weight, ventilation, construction, coverage, and features can also make one helmet better suited to your climbing style than another.

Fit

Climbing helmets should fit snugly without sliding around while you climb. The helmet should sit evenly around your head without feeling wobbly or creating pressure points. The chin strap should feel secure while still allowing you to comfortably slip a finger between your face and the strap.

Fit is one of the most important factors when choosing a helmet. A helmet with impressive features is not a good choice if its shape simply does not work for your head.

Sizing

Most climbing helmets come in multiple sizes based on head circumference, so start by measuring your head and comparing it with the manufacturer’s sizing chart. Some models also offer different fits or designs that accommodate ponytails or smaller head circumferences.

Rather than choosing a men’s, women’s, or unisex label by default, focus on which model fits your head securely and comfortably.

Adjustability

Climbing helmets use different adjustment systems, including plastic rear adjustment systems and webbing-based designs. Most allow you to adjust both the circumference around your head and the chin strap.

Good adjustability is especially useful if you sometimes wear a thin hat or beanie underneath your helmet. Whatever you wear, readjust the helmet so it remains snug and secure rather than simply loosening it to make extra layers fit.

Comfort

While protection is the priority when choosing a climbing helmet, comfort should not be overlooked. You should be able to wear your helmet for a full climbing day without persistent pressure points, pinching, hair pulling, or excessive heat buildup.

Interior padding, helmet shape, the retention system, and overall weight all contribute to how comfortable a helmet feels over several hours.

Weight

Climbing helmets vary considerably in weight. Lightweight helmets can be particularly appealing for long approaches, alpine climbing, and multi-pitch routes where you may wear the helmet for much of the day.

Heavier models may use more substantial constructions, but weight alone does not tell you how durable or protective a helmet will be. Consider weight alongside construction, fit, certification, and intended use.

Ventilation

Climbers often spend long days in warm and exposed environments, so ventilation can make a noticeable difference in comfort. Large or numerous ventilation openings help maintain airflow on hot approaches and climbs.

If you primarily climb in warm climates or spend long days on the wall, ventilation deserves more consideration than it might for someone who mostly climbs in cool conditions.

Climbing helmet safety ratings

Climbing helmets are commonly certified under standards such as EN 12492 and UIAA 106. These standards evaluate factors including impact absorption, penetration resistance, and retention-system strength. Check the certifications listed for a helmet rather than assuming that any helmet designed for another sport provides the same type of protection required for climbing.

This is also why we separate our field testing from safety certification. We can evaluate fit, comfort, ventilation, coverage, adjustment, and usability, but standardized impact performance is determined through certification testing.

Helmet construction

Climbing helmets generally use hard-shell, foam, or hybrid construction. The three main elements are the outer shell, inner liner, and retention system. The shell and foam work together to manage impact, while the retention system, including the chin strap and adjustment components, keeps the helmet positioned on your head.

Different constructions balance weight, durability, and bulk differently, so there is no single material combination that is automatically best for every climber.

EPS and EPP foam

Many climbing helmets use expanded polystyrene (EPS), expanded polypropylene (EPP), or a combination of the two.

EPS is lightweight and commonly used to absorb impact, but it can be more susceptible to damage from rough handling or being crushed in a pack. EPP is also designed to absorb impact and tends to be more resilient to everyday compression and handling. Some helmets combine multiple foams to balance weight, coverage, and durability.

ABS and polycarbonate shells

Climbing helmets also commonly use ABS or polycarbonate (PC) in their outer construction. ABS is often used in more substantial hard-shell designs, while polycarbonate is frequently paired with lightweight foam constructions.

As with foam type, shell material is only one part of the design. Fit, certification, coverage, weight, and how you plan to use the helmet should matter more than choosing a helmet based on one material alone.

Coverage

Climbing helmets vary in how far they extend around the sides and back of the head. When comparing helmets, look at how much coverage a model provides and whether that shape works comfortably with your head and hair.

More coverage can also influence weight, ventilation, and fit, so consider it as part of the helmet’s overall design rather than as an isolated feature.

MIPS and rotational-impact systems

Some climbing helmets incorporate MIPS, or Multi-directional Impact Protection System, which is designed to address rotational motion during certain impacts. MIPS has been used for years in other helmet categories and is now available in some climbing helmets, including our Best Overall Mammut Wall Rider MIPS.

A MIPS-equipped helmet may cost more, and it should still fit correctly and carry appropriate climbing certification. Think of it as an additional design feature rather than a substitute for proper fit or certification.

Care and Maintenance Tips for Climbing Helmets

Caring for your climbing helmet goes a long way toward maintaining its integrity and reliability for years at a time. 

Regular Inspections

One of the best ways to keep tabs on your helmet is by inspecting it regularly with the rest of your gear. Look for damage to essential components like the shell, foam, and attachment system. If it’s showing any signs of cracks, dents, signs of impact, or discoloration (since discoloration could hint at UV damage), it’s probably time to retire your helmet. 

Keeping it Clean

Every climbing helmet can benefit from a periodic scrub. First, detach the removable padding from the helmet. Then, use a mild soap, warm water, and a cloth to wash the helmet. Once you’ve gently cleaned the helmet, make sure to let all components of the helmet air dry fully before reassembling the pieces.

FAQ

• How should a climbing helmet fit?

  A climbing helmet should fit snugly and sit level on your head without sliding around when you move. It should feel secure without creating painful pressure points, and the chin strap should hold the helmet in position while remaining comfortable. Use the helmet’s adjustment system to fine-tune the fit, especially if you add or remove a thin hat or beanie.

• When should I replace a climbing helmet?

  Replace a climbing helmet according to the manufacturer’s retirement guidance and after damage or a significant impact that may have compromised its construction. Regularly inspect the shell, foam, straps, buckles, and adjustment system for cracks, dents, deformation, or other signs of damage. Age limits vary by manufacturer, so check the instructions for your specific helmet rather than relying on one universal lifespan.

• Can I use a bike or ski helmet for rock climbing?

  Not as a direct substitute unless the helmet is also specifically certified for climbing. Different helmet standards are designed around different impact and retention requirements. Some helmets are certified for more than one activity, but check the actual certifications listed by the manufacturer rather than relying on appearance or similar construction.

• Can I wear a beanie under a climbing helmet?

  Yes, if the helmet still fits properly. A thin beanie can work in cold conditions, but you may need to readjust the helmet so it remains snug and does not shift around. Avoid adding so much bulk underneath that the helmet sits too high or cannot be secured correctly.

• What is the difference between EN 12492 and UIAA 106?

  Both are standards used for climbing and mountaineering helmets and include testing related to impact absorption, penetration resistance, and the retention system. Some climbing helmets carry only EN 12492 certification, while others also carry UIAA certification. Check each model’s current certifications when comparing helmets rather than assuming every climbing helmet carries exactly the same ratings.

• Is MIPS worth it in a climbing helmet?

  It can be a worthwhile additional feature if you want a helmet designed to address rotational motion as well as the protection provided by the helmet’s standard construction. However, MIPS should not take priority over proper fit, comfort, and appropriate climbing certification. A helmet you can wear securely and comfortably every time you climb is still the more important starting point.

How we researched and tested

We evaluated climbing helmets across different constructions, weights, fits, and intended uses, looking at their manufacturer specifications and climbing safety certifications before putting them through long-term field use. Rather than treating one helmet style as best for everyone, we compared how different designs worked for sport climbing, cragging, multi-pitch routes, alpine objectives, and year-round use.

Our testing took place over multiple seasons in Yosemite, the Rocky Mountains, and climbing areas in North and South Carolina. We wore the helmets on single- and multi-pitch routes, sport and cragging days, big-wall and alpine objectives, and long approaches. The Mammut Crag Sender, for example, became our go-to helmet for multi-pitch climbing in Yosemite, where its low weight, ventilation, and one-handed adjustment were particularly useful during full days on the wall.

During testing, we focused on fit, sizing, and adjustability, including how securely each suspension system held the helmet in place. We compared interior padding and comfort during all-day wear, ventilation and heat management in warm conditions, and how noticeable each helmet’s weight felt during long multi-pitch and alpine days. We also evaluated practical features such as headlamp clips and how intuitive each helmet was to adjust and use while climbing.

For protection, we looked at each helmet’s construction, coverage, and stated safety certifications rather than attempting to reproduce standardized impact tests ourselves. Our recommendations combine those certified specifications with our field observations of comfort, fit, ventilation, weight, adjustment, and usability.

About the Author / Why You Should Trust Us

 Mary Beth Skylis is a freelance writer who specializes in adventure content and travel. She’s been climbing across the globe for more than a decade, and is a total sucker for limestone, granite and long multi-pitch climbs. She currently works as a columnist for Backpacker Magazine. She also has bylines in Climbing, REI, Alaska Magazine, Women’s Health, Outside Magazines, Trail Runner, SELF, 5280, and Yellow Scene. When she isn’t writing, she can typically be found frolicking in the Rocky Mountains. Follow her on Instagram: @h1kertrash.

September 17th, 2026
Home → Gear Reviews → Travel Gear

Our verdict

The Hydro Flask 32 oz Wide Mouth with Flex Straw Cap travel water bottle is a rigid, stainless-steel, insulated bottle built for travel scenarios where you want to keep drinks hot or cold for an extended period of time. 

We tested it on several trips over the summer on flights, trains, rental cars, and on day hikes where the water remained cool for the entire duration of the trip. During the workday we filled it with cold drinks and it retained its temperature for almost 24 hours. We also filled it with ice that lasted more than 8 hours.

The Hydro Flask water bottle with Flex Strap Cap worked really well in hot climates where we carried cold water for a refreshing drink throughout the day. It has a mixed profile where the top part of the bottle is broad, but the base is narrow, so it still fits in all standard vehicle cup holders and expandable side pockets on travel backpacks. The virtually indestructible double-walled stainless steel body makes it very durable both while exploring new cities, navigating airports and transit, during daily commutes and the workday, and while hiking in the wilderness. With a large carrying capacity of 32 oz, it is perfect for a whole day of exploring.

Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap

The only major tradeoff is that at 11.10” tall, it doesn’t fit completely inside pockets of smaller daypacks and some backpacks. 

Despite its large size, the Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Water Bottle is a good choice for travelers who want a durable, high-capacity bottle for long days of sightseeing, road trips, flights, and outdoor adventures.

We create reader-supported, objective gear reviews independently selected by our editors. This story may contain affiliate links, which help fund our website. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission, without costing you an extra cent. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body! Learn more.

Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap specifications

• Price: $45

• Capacity: 32 oz

• Empty weight: 16.5 oz

• Dimensions (full): 11.10" H x 3.30" diameter 

• Collapsible: No

• Filter: No

• Insulated: Yes with TempShield double-wall vacuum insulation that keeps drinks cold for 24 hours

• Material: Double-walled stainless steel

• Mouth width: Wide and compatible with all Hydro Flask Wide Mouth Lids

• Lid/valve type: Flex Straw Cap

• Leakproof: Yes

• Fits standard cup holder: Yes, as the base is narrower than the top part of the bottle

• Dishwasher safe? Yes

• BPA-free: Yes

Comparison table

Best for

• Daily use, especially in hot climates

• Long trips where you’ll want a large-capacity water bottle

• Frequent travelers who want a durable bottle that will last for multiple trips

• Easy outdoor adventures and adventure travel where you have access to clean water as this bottle does not have a filter

• Travelers who prefer an insulated water bottle, as this was our top insulated pick in our Best Travel Water Bottles guide

What we liked

• Easy fill-up with the wide opening on the bottle 

• Insulation keeps cold drinks cold for 24 hours

• Snap-close mouthpiece with a fast-flowing straw

• The straw flips shut to prevent accidental spills

• The bottle is leakproof even if you place it upside down in a bag

• It holds ice for more than 8 hours

• It is dishwasher safe

• It has lots of options for colors, sizes, and caps that work with the same base

What could be better

• It is a tall bottle at 11” height, so it might not fit in pockets of small backpacks or daypacks

• It has a plastic straw so it might not be suited for hot drinks

• It can dent if it is dropped on rock, stone, or granite

How we tested

We tested the Hydro Flask travel water bottle on multiple flights with cold water that stayed cool for the duration of the trip. We also tested the bottle on all-day hikes in Rocky Mountain National Park and while walking around Boulder, Colorado, including in hot, 90-degree summer days.

After each trip, we tested how easy it was to take apart, clean thoroughly in the dishwasher, and pack away for the next adventure. We also did drop tests to test durability, and tested the water bottle’s packability and leakproofness in adventure travel backpacks, packable backpacks, vehicle cupholders, and on planes. 

We also tested it alongside other travel water bottles and  hiking water bottles to compare features, like how easily it travels, how intuitive it is to use, the insulation, capacity, and its portability.

Performance in the field

Packability

The Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap does not have a consistent slim profile, so it is best packed inside a bag rather than in the side pocket. However, it has a narrow base so it fits into standard cupholders in cars like a Toyota Highlander as well as a Chevy Malibu. You can even clip it to a purse or sling using a carabiner on the soft, flexible bottle handle. We used it both inside a backpack as well as hand-held while exploring a city and hiking trails in Rocky Mountain National Park. 

Leakproofness

The bottle is leakproof when placed horizontally in a bag and upside down in the side pocket of a backpack. We even placed it upside down in a backpack to test the leakproofness and found no leaks or spills.

Ease of filling and drinking

Due to its wide mouth opening, the Hydro Flask travel bottle is easy to fill up in a hotel sink, as well as at water fountains, which we tested multiple times on a trip. The flip-top straw is soft and has a fast flow rate. The lid that comes with this bottle does not have a chug option because of the straw, but you can switch the top with any standard Hydro Flask screw tops for easy access. All Hydro Flask bottles are compatible with both screw top and straw top covers so it is easy to mix and match for more versatility if you want to switch between the straw and chug covers. 

Portability and carry

When completely filled with water, the Hydro Flask travel water bottle weighs 32 oz (or 16.5 oz empty) and can be carried comfortably thanks to the soft, flexible carry loop. We also tested how it fit into the side pocket of multiple backpacks like the Fjallraven Kajka X-Latt 45 L as well as cup holders in rental cars. 

Durability

The Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap didn't show signs of denting, scratching, or leaking thanks to its stainless steel construction. We found this true when packed in suitcases and carry-on luggage. The lid and mouthpiece did not leak, chip, or melt in the dishwasher even after months of use across various landscapes and temperature variations. We tested the bottle’s construction durability by dropping on a gravel path and did not find any dents. However when dropped on a concrete sidewalk, the bottle had a minor dent on the outside but not on the inside so it did not impact bottle performance.

Taste and material performance

We found the bottle has no plastic or silicone taste even when outdoors in extremely high heat (90 degrees F), as we encountered during a hike in Colorado in the summer, and there was no odor retention. We washed it with regular dish washing detergents in a dishwasher after every use. We did not test it with hot beverages because of the plastic straw. 

Insulation

The Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle is an insulated bottle made of double-walled stainless steel which retains the temperature of cold drinks for up to 24 hours. We tested it on a particularly hot day with upwards of 90 degrees F and found it to be true. It performed better in terms of insulation compared to the Ocean Bottle Peak Go (15 hours) and Yeti Rambler (16 hours). Because the straw is plastic, it is not suitable for hot drinks but you can replace the straw cap with a standard Hydro Flask Wide Mouth Lids for use with hot liquids.

Features

• A leakproof locking flip straw cap gives a secure seal even when placed horizontally or upside down. 

• The bottle is made from TempShield double-walled vacuum insulation and stainless steel for a durable construction. 

• A wide screw-top opening makes it easy to fill from sinks, fountains, and natural water sources. 

• It is dishwasher safe.

• Compatible with all wide-mouth lids and caps.

• Color and size options: comes in over 19 different colors and can also be customized by choosing different color lids or adding personal engravings to the bottle. It also comes in a 24 oz size.

• Limited lifetime warranty

Brand and product sustainability, corporate ethics, and warranty

Hydro Flask uses recycled materials in their products, and eliminated single-use plastic packaging from more than 90% of their products. They’re a founding member of the Outdoor Industry Association’s Climate Action Corp. You can learn more on Hydro Flask’s Corporate Responsibility webpage.

Hydro Flask also has a trade-in program where you can send in your old products for a $5 credit towards your next purchase. 

All Hydro Flask bottles carry a limited lifetime warranty against manufacturer’s defects for the life of the product. Hydro Flask will replace any product found to be defective within the scope of normal and appropriate use. 

Should you buy the Hydro Flask 32 oz Wide Mouth with Flex Straw Cap travel water bottle?

Buy if:

• You travel for 6 to 8 hours where 24 ounces is sufficient without the need for extra bottles in your bag

• You prioritize insulation 

• You want a reliable bottle for daily carry when you travel

• You like the color options

Skip if:

• You want a water bottle that is collapsible due to space restrictions

• You need filtration or purification

Where to buy the Hydro Flask 32 oz Wide Mouth with Flex Straw Cap travel water bottle

The Hydro Flask 32 oz Wide Mouth with Flex Straw Cap is a popular item, so you have options when it comes to retailers. Here are some of the pros of the retailers.

Amazon

Pros: Free 2-day shipping with Amazon Prime membership (can be same-day delivery in major metropolitan cities)

Backcountry

Pros: Frequent sales for Expedition Perks members (free to join), fast shipping, Gearhead chat customer service is excellent

Advice on where to buy

In general for gear, we recommend purchasing from a place with easy or free returns, like REI. 

Similar travel water bottles

Grayl UltraPress Purifier

Price: $90
Capacity: 16.9 oz
Empty weight: 12.5 oz
Dimensions (full): 9.75" H x 2.95” diameter 
Collapsible: No
Filter: Yes; cartridge

The Grayl UltraPress is the best overall winner in our Best Travel Water Bottles guide. It has an integrated purifier technology to protect against viruses, bacteria, protozoa, microplastics, and many chemicals. The Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap does not have a filter. 

The UltraPress holds 16.9 ounces and is lighter and more compact, while the Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap is heavier due to the stainless steel construction and holds 32 oz, making it better for longer outings, especially in hot climates. 

If you prioritize insulation and portability for travel, day hikes, international trips, and everyday carry, choose the Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap. Opt for the UltraPress if you're heading on trips where water quality is questionable.

Grayl UltraPress Purifier

LifeStraw Go Series Filter Water Bottle

Price: $45
Capacity: 22 oz
Empty weight: 8.7 oz
Dimensions (full): 9.4" H x 2.8" diameter 
Collapsible: No
Filter: Yes, 2-stage membrane, microfiber, and activated carbon

The LifeStraw Go Series is a filtered water bottle, while the Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap does not have a filter. The Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap is designed for adventures where capacity and insulation are more important than filtration. 

The LifeStraw Go Series won best filtered travel water bottle in our Best Travel Water Bottles guide.

Choose the LifeStraw Go Series if you want a purifier that fits seamlessly into your travel routine, and choose the Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap if you need a rugged, insulated system for travel, city trips, or short hikes where you won't need to filter water.

LifeStraw Go Series Filter Water Bottle

Grayl GeoPress Purifier

Price: $100
Capacity: 24 oz
Empty weight: 15.9 oz
Dimensions (full): 10.4" H x 3.4” diameter
Collapsible: No
Filter: Yes; cartridge

The Grayl GeoPress is a travel water bottle with integrated purifier technology to protect against viruses, bacteria, protozoa, microplastics, and many chemicals. The Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap does not have a filter. 

The GeoPress holds 24 oz ounces and is lighter and more compact, while the Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap is heavier due to the stainless steel construction and holds 32 oz, making it better for longer outings, especially in hot climates. 

If you prioritize insulation and portability for travel, day hikes, international trips, and everyday carry, choose the Hydro Flask 32 oz Travel Bottle with Flex Straw Cap. Opt for the GeoPress if you're heading on trips where water quality is questionable.

Grayl GeoPress Purifier

Why you should trust us / About the author

The author, Karthika Gupta, is an adventure travel writer with over 25 years of adventure travel experience. She has hiked on all seven continents and loved every minute of it. She has even completed Highlander UAE and Fjallraven Chile, along with hundreds of miles in the Indian Himalayas.  She covers outdoor gear, small-group adventure travel, and hiking/camping trends for national and international publications, blending real experience with practical advice. Her work is grounded in miles hiked, boots tested, and a belief that everyone belongs in the outdoors regardless of gear and experience—you don’t need to overpack or overcomplicate to have a meaningful adventure. 

Her previous piece focused on an Adventure travel checklist guide.

You can find more of her adventures on her Instagram @karthikagupta or her website.

September 17th, 2026, updated with a year's worth of testing notes to confirm ranking, updated prices, and to remove discontinued products
Home → Gear Reviews → Climbing

If you’ve ever experienced rope burn on a long day of climbing, you know how precious a quality pair of belay gloves can be. The extra fabric provides a layer of protection in high-friction areas like the pocket between the thumb and index finger, reducing the odds of ending up with abrasions or cuts. They also provide extra padding and warmth, which can make them invaluable during cool-weather alpine adventures.

While they’re technically soft goods, climbing gloves can enhance technical ability by adding friction, along with a bit of emotional support on challenging climbing days. For this guide, we tested climbing gloves across splitters, big walls, alpine climbs, and multi-sport endeavors.

We evaluated comfort, durability, friction, grip, dexterity, and fit, along with how well each glove worked for its intended use. We also paid attention to padding, finger coverage, breathability, and how easy each pair was to get on and off during a climbing day.

Top Pick: The Metolius Half Finger Climbing Gloves are our favorite overall because they balance protection, friction, comfort, and dexterity. We used the full-finger version through 14 pitches of hauling and climbing in Yosemite and were impressed by how well the construction held up. The half-finger design keeps that same durable build while leaving the fingertips free for more dexterity.

Gearing up for your climbing season? Check out our Best Climbing Helmets.

We create reader-supported, objective, independently-selected gear reviews. This story may contain affiliate links, which help fund our website. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission, without costing you an extra cent. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body! Learn more.

Comparison table

The winners

Best overall climbing gloves: Metolius Half Finger Climbing Gloves

Type: Climbing, belay, big wall
Material: Leather
Length: Half-finger
MSRP: $45
What we liked: Durability, comfort, versatility
What we didn’t like: The break-in period, heavier than competitive options

We love the Metolius Climbing Gloves for many reasons. They’re super tough, reinforced in all the right places, and built to withstand weeks on the wall. They have a hook-and-loop wrist closure, a clip-in loop for attaching them to a harness, and sizes XS–XL.

I used the these gloves while ascending 14 pitches in Yosemite, hauling gear, and hanging over the valley for hours at a time. At the time, we were slow to slip a pair of gloves on since they inevitably get in the way and make it difficult to snap photos while climbing. But truthfully, the Metolius Climbing Gloves were an essential piece of gear during this foray into big walling. 

The ½-finger version is even better than the full-finger gloves, since it helps you to maintain dexterity and use all of your tools without fumbling around (a big no-no on big walls). It slightly cuts down on weight, while offering the same features of the full-finger glove. 

Where reliability is needed, these are my go-to climbing gloves. They provide maximum coverage while maintaining dexterity, making them an ideal pick for aid climbing, jugging, and hauling. They’re also unmatched when it comes to belaying and rappelling amidst less-strenuous adventures. Admittedly, with a 4.3 to 4.8 ounce weight, they’re heavier than many alternative options, but in our opinion, the weight is worth the performance.

Best affordable climbing gloves: Black Diamond Crag Half Finger Gloves

Type: Belay, via ferrata
Material: Synthetic (60% nylon, 40% PU shell, 96% polyester, 4% elastane back hand, foam padding 100% terry cloth thumb)
Length: Half-finger
MSRP: $25
What we liked: Fit, comfort, affordability
What we didn’t like: Not designed for heavy rope use

Oftentimes an affordable price tag results in an inferior piece of gear, causing premature wear and aging. Yet the Black Diamond Crag Half Finger Glove manages to defy this expectation by providing one of the most affordable climbing glove options on the market while maintaining durability.

Climbers can grab a pair of these gloves for about the same cost of a pizza and expect them to last for the whole season. These gloves easily stood up to jagged limestone walls and chossy gneiss over the course of the summer. What’s more, we found the seams and stitching on these gloves to be ideally positioned to minimize damage to high-use areas like the space between the thumb and the index finger, which is ideal for hardcore usage. 

Made with a variety of synthetic materials, these gloves provide climbers with a close fit and a half-finger closure that makes belaying and climbing still attainable. Ranging in sizes from extra small to extra large, it’s fairly easy to find a pair that fits your hand. While some half-finger gloves have a tendency to bunch around the crease of the knuckles, the Black Diamond Crag Half Finger Gloves provide protection without substantially limiting the fingers’ range of motion. Finally, these gloves weigh 2.49 ounces, making them one of the lighter options on this list, which is ideal for weight-conscious climbers and alpinists.

Best crack climbing gloves: Outdoor Research Splitter II Gloves

Type: Crack 
Material: 80% polyester, 20% PU outer material, 55% PU, 45% nylon outer overlay
Length: Open-palm crack glove
MSRP: $45
What we liked: Comfort, grip, color
What we didn’t like: Lack of padding, sizing options

Crack climbing is a discipline that forgoes comfort for the sake of achievement, but the Outdoor Research Splitter II Gloves provide added protection and comfort amidst even the hardest crack climbs.

These gloves are made with a mixture of polyester, polyurethane (PU), suede, and silicone materials to create a balanced, grippy glove that acts like a second skin for the back of the hand. Designed for hand jamming, climbers can expect these gloves to help maintain friction while preventing bunching and allowing the hand to maintain control. But it’s important to find the right fit since they can cause slipping if they’re too big. 

The Outdoor Research Splitter II Glove is a great first crack glove. They’re pretty affordable in the realm of crack gloves, which makes them accessible for those who are just dipping their toes into the discipline. Their thin design allows the climber to maintain control and comfort while suspended mid-air, and they weigh just over an ounce. They also come with decent wrist coverage, which is great for deeper jams. Plus, the patterned index fingers help to eliminate a common failure point on the gloves. 

Due to the gloves' minimalist design, they’re not the best choice for offwidth climbs, fist cracks, or stacks. Instead, we’d recommend a glove with added padding to tackle such routes unless you prefer to live in a world of pain and suffering. And unlike some alternative crack gloves, they’re not built to last forever. Additionally, they come in limited sizes (small, medium, and large), which can make it challenging to find the right fit. But if you do, they’re a great entry-level glove for climbers who are ready to ditch the tape and go steady with crack climbing.

Best alpine climbing gloves: Petzl CORDEX Lightweight Belay Gloves

Type: Belay
Material: Leather, nylon
Length: Full-finger
MSRP: $55
What we liked: Dexterity, durability, surprisingly breathable, lightweight design
What we didn’t like: Fingertips can feel bulky

Alpine climbers generally prioritize a fast and lightweight pack, which means that every single piece of gear has to be refined. The Petzl CORDEX Lightweight Belay Gloves maintain this exact balance with their 4-ounce weight and durable design. In fact, these gloves use goatskin leather in places that need extra reinforcement, like on the palm of the hand and between the thumb and index finger.

The glove switches to a stretchy nylon material to cut down the weight and add breathability for long days in the alpine. The result is a lightweight glove that can go the extra yard due to its refined design. 

We used these gloves on a few different alpine climbs across Rocky Mountain National Park and found that they also added a layer of warmth without causing saturation in wind-whipped areas. While we wouldn’t take these gloves out on full-blown winter expeditions, they performed beautifully in late spring in the Rockies.

Our main complaint with these gloves is that the fingertips can feel bulky, which can be problematic while tying knots in precarious situations. While it’s not an impossible task, we wondered if a slightly different fingertip design could perfect these gloves, making them reliable under any circumstances.

Best belay gloves: Metolius Talon Belay Gloves

Type: Belay
Material: Synthetic
Length: Full-finger
MSRP: $25
What we liked: Fit, comfort, reinforcement points, versatility, cost
What we didn’t like: Interior seam can cause chafing

The Metolius Talon Belay Gloves are the second most affordable option on this list, just barely losing to the Black Diamond Crag Half Finger Gloves. They’re also the lightest option (aside from our favorite crack climbing gloves), weighing 1.7 to 2.5 ounces per pair.

These gloves really shine when it comes to providing a minimalist belay glove with added protection that maintains dexterity. These gloves come with basic reinforcements on high-wear points for a touch of durability. The fingertips are less bulky than competitive options, which is great in situations where you need to tie knots and manage a belay device. And their fit is one of our favorites since it’s close to the skin and leaves little room for bulk. 

While some climbers complain that the synthetic fabric of this glove feels similar to a climbing rope, thereby adding unnecessary friction, we found that they still perform better than a cheap pair of knock-off climbing gloves at our home crag. Their lightweight, synthetic design will make them an ideal companion in environments that have a tendency to get wet.

Best Climbing Gloves for Dexterity: Outdoor Research Granite Glove

Type: Belay, rappel
Material: Goat leather, split suede, neoprene
Length: Full-finger
MSRP: $65
What we liked: Extra back-of-hand padding, minimal fingertip seams, stitching, dexterity
What we didn’t like: Can be tough to take off quickly

Upon slipping a pair of the Outdoor Research Granite Glove over our hands, it was immediately evident that their fit and ergonomic design are unmatched. These gloves…well…fit like a glove, making us question where our skin ends and where the leather begins.

With their extra back-of-hand padding and minimal fingertip seams, they made us feel protected without impingement, making it easy to manage ropes, tie knots, and handle belay devices. 

What’s more is that these gloves are designed with dexterity at the forefront of their structure. They move in all of the places they need to move, providing a touch of extra space around high-mobility areas like the knuckles and clever design components like a split palm and minimal fingertip seams. And they come with Kevlar stitching to ensure that they’ll continue to rock ‘n’ roll in even the sharpest environments. 

Weighing 3.4 ounces, these gloves are right in the middle of their weight class. But unlike some competitors, they don’t skimp on reinforcements. 

Our only caveat is that, like most leather gloves, there is a brief break-in period for these gloves. We had to take them out a few times before the fabric began to soften. And their close fit means that they can be tough to take off in a pinch. But their overall comfort, design, and reliability made them an easy winner. 

Best half-finger climbing gloves: Hestra Duratan Short 5 Finger Gloves

Type: Climbing, alpinism
Material: Duratan synthetic-suede palm, weather-resistant polyamide backhand, and neoprene cuff
Length: Half-finger
MSRP: $70
What we liked: Feels custom, machine washable, slightly stretchy
What we didn’t like: One of the pricier options, questionable long-term use

With a reputation for making high-quality, durable, cold-weather gloves for ski and outdoor use, it shouldn't come as a surprise to know that Hestra manages to make a quality climbing glove, too. The Hestra Duratan Short 5 Finger is a great indication of this reality with its extremely lightweight, form-fitting glove.

The slightly stretchy fabrics make this glove feel like it was made for you. Also different from most climbing companies, Hestra offers numerical sizing options based on palm length in its gloves, which is likely another reason why these feel customized. The neoprene cuff also gives the glove a natural-feeling design. 

The Hestra Duratan Short 5 Finger Gloves also comes with shock-absorbing foam and Duratan over the knuckles to tackle any climb. They’re weather-resistant and breathable, which makes them a great companion in high alpine environments and at home. And, amazingly, these gloves are also machine washable, which is great for those of us who are hard on their climbing gear. 

Admittedly, these gloves come with a significant price, too. And since this glove isn’t as reinforced as gloves like the Metolius Belay Glove, we have some concerns about this glove from a long-term usage standpoint. However, it’s a great option for climbers who are looking for extra weatherproof capabilities and a custom-feeling glove that easily adapts to alpine environments.

Best Cold Weather Climbing Gloves: Outdoor Research Extravert Gloves

Type: Multi-sport
Material: Nylon, spandex, leather, fleece, wool, acrylic, polyester
Length: Full-length
MSRP: $85
What we liked: Great weather resistance, a touch of stretch, super warm
What we didn’t like: Hefty cost

The Outdoor Research Extravert Gloves are water- and wind-resistant, which makes them a great pick for cold-weather adventuring. We found that these gloves performed well in a variety of situations due to their rugged design, darted fingers, and warm materials. In fact, we think you could just as easily take these ice climbing as you could take them snowshoeing or backcountry skiing.

Their fit is true to size, with a touch of stretch. The lining of the glove comes with a 40% wool, 35% acrylic, and 25% polyester construction to support a warm environment while the outer material is made of an 88% nylon and 12% spandex blend. And the palm is made with goat leather for added durability. 

The biggest problem with these gloves is that they’re easily the most expensive option on this list. With the exception of the Hestra Duratan, they’re nearly double the cost of any other option (if not triple). The way we rationalize the added cost is by highlighting their versatility. The overall ability of this glove to switch from sport to sport makes it a good pick for mountain athletes who love tackling multi-sport endeavors.

Other climbing gloves we tested

Outdoor Research Fossil Rock II Glove

Type: Climbing, belay, rappel
Material: 95% polyester/5% spandex outer; goat-leather palm; cow split-suede palm overlay; neoprene cuff
Length: fingerless
MSRP: $45

The Outdoor Research Fossil Rock II Glove have a few strengths, like a durable construction, reinforcements in high-use areas, and a comfortable neoprene cuff. But we found that the finger entryways were bulkier than we’d like, which significantly impacted dexterity. While these might be a good choice for basic rope management at the crag, their inflexibility makes them a tough sell in environments that require versatility. 

Metolius Belay Glove

Type: Belay
Material: Cowhide
Length: Full-finger
MSRP: $45

We love the Metolius Belay Gloves. They’re one of our favorite picks in existence. The only reason they didn’t make it to our list of winners is because the Metolius Climbing Glove slightly edged them out due to their added dexterity and versatility. But we’d still be quick to pack these for big wall climbing, aid climbing, and any endeavor that requires ascending.

What to look for in climbing gloves

A good pair of climbing gloves should protect your hands while allowing you to maintain precision amidst every climb. But determining how to find the gloves that’ll balance your needs can be tricky. Make sure to look at these factors before making your final pick.

Intended use

Are you expecting to spend your life navigating torturous offwidths? Do you aspire to big-wall climb in Yosemite? Climbers finagle their way to all kinds of different features, requiring varying amounts of hand protection. Crack climbing is particularly hard on the skin, which makes a quality pair of crack gloves essential to long days on the wall. Similarly, alpine climbs are often lengthy, all-day endeavors that expose the climber to sharp rock and ice, making gloves an appreciated addition. 

But not everyone likes or needs to use climbing gloves. Some belayers might opt for a pair of gloves if they have sensitive skin or want to avoid rope burn. Those who partake in via ferratas might also find climbing gloves to enhance comfort since most routes expose you to steel cables, rungs, and other types of equipment that can be hard on the hands. Those with existing calluses and a penchant for shorter adventures might be able to get by without them. 

Material

Climbing gloves utilize a range of different materials including leather, synthetic, and rubber-backed options. Synthetic gloves usually offer a lightweight, breathable option while leather is extremely durable but prone to trapping moisture. Rubber-backed gloves are most commonly used on crack climbs because of the extra padding they provide. 

Fit and dexterity

The key to finding the perfect climbing glove comes down to finding the right balance between fit and dexterity. Most climbers find that a snug (but not tight) glove provides the best fit. Your hands should maintain a full range of motion, without feeling restricted. At the same time, gloves that are too loose can cause bunching and get trapped in the belay device. But that fit shouldn’t drastically reduce dexterity. Instead, it should allow your hands to zip and unzip your jacket, clip carabiners, and manipulate belay devices. 

Padding and protection

The whole point of wearing a climbing glove is to enhance protection and comfort during long adventures. So, padding and protection should be priorities while looking for the right glove. The amount of padding and protection that’s needed varies by climbing type and climber preference, but for the most part, a quality glove should add a layer of protection and some padding without feeling bulky or cumbersome. 

Breathability

Climbing gloves that lack breathability can cause excessive sweating and a loss of grip power in warm conditions. Synthetic and lightweight climbing gloves tend to be more breathable than bulky leather gloves. But they’re also less durable. 

Grip and palm design

Factors like material choice and construction can determine how much grip a pair of climbing gloves maintains. Typically, they’re made to optimize friction while maximizing protection. 

Climbing gloves also come with a few different types of palms. Some palms come with reinforced spots, while others have a minimalistic design with a single sheet of fabric. Most climbers find that they appreciate a palm design that’s reinforced in high-use areas but also allows a full range of motion (which is often determined by the stitching). 

Durability and stitching

We love strong materials and beefy stitching because they feel more reliable and trustworthy than delicate alternatives. But strong materials can also yield a hefty glove. The key to the perfect climbing glove is finding a pair that blends finesse with reliability to ensure that you’re covered even while suspended hundreds of feet off of the ground.

Types of climbing gloves

Climbing gloves come in a few shapes and sizes to accommodate different activity types. Some environments are more likely to require the extra protection of a climbing glove since they can be tough on the hands.

Belay gloves

Belay gloves are primarily used to control the rope, while reducing direct friction to the hands. This type of glove is designed to eliminate hot spots and the general discomfort of tough ropes rubbing against sensitive skin.

Crack gloves (tape vs. glove style)

Many crack climbers use tape or dedicated crack gloves because of the brutal nature of this style of climbing. Not only do crack climbers use their fingertips and palms to scale rocks, but they also often have to hand jam, which exposes more of the hand’s surface area to sharp rock. As a result, most people find that having an added layer of tape or a glove is essential to long days at the crag. While it is possible to make a crack climbing glove out of tape, fashioning an effective glove requires a lot of tape, and the resulting gloves are usually only good for a few days of climbing.

Alpine and cold-weather gloves

Alpinists might use a variety of different climbing gloves depending on the length and conditions of the endeavor. High mountain environments are cooler than lower elevation endeavors, which may require the use of insulated gloves. Some alpinists opt for waterproof options to keep their hands safe and warm even in rain and snowy conditions. Or they might utilize a layering system in extreme situations. 

Fingerless vs. full-finger

Full-coverage climbing gloves maximize warmth and protection but they can limit dexterity. Conversely, half-finger gloves offer much of the same protection while allowing the hand to maintain its dexterity, but they generally provide less warmth than full-finger alternatives. 

Multi-sport vs. climbing-specific gloves

Some companies make climbing gloves that are designed to accommodate multi-sport athletes as they shift from sports like alpine climbing and mountaineering to ski-touring and resort skiing. In most cases, a climbing-specific glove provides better precision than a multi-sport glove. They also tend to be lighter than a multi-sport option. But those with many outdoor interests can also find a glove that accommodates a few different sports.

How should climbing gloves fit?

When you try a climbing glove for the first time, you should be able to make a fist without feeling like your hand is constricted by the materials. At the same time, there shouldn’t be excess material across the glove. You need the “Goldilocks” of gloves. 

When buying gloves online, most outfitters will offer a sizing chart. It’s a really good idea to measure your hand to ensure that you’ll have enough space to maintain hand dexterity once you’ve chosen your gloves. Keep in mind that leather tends to soften over time, which can lend itself to a gentler fit after extended use.

Care and maintenance tips

One of the most important climbing glove maintenance tips is to allow them to fully dry before storing them. Moisture can cause buildup and mold growth in gloves, which can contribute to premature breakdown. 

Leather gloves can be conditioned to encourage a soft, pliable shape. And it doesn’t hurt to periodically wipe them down with a damp cloth. 

When you’re ready to store your climbing gloves, keep them in a cool, dry place to avoid sun damage. 

The lifespan of climbing gloves varies based on the frequency of use, the type of climbing, and the quality of climbing gloves. Crack climbing gloves, for example, may only last a single season while leather gloves can last for years. Actual lifespan depends heavily on use, construction, rock type, care, and frequency. If a pair of gloves is starting to show signs of worn seams or tears, it might be time to retire them.

FAQ

• Do I really need climbing gloves?

  Determining whether or not you need climbing gloves depends on factors like the environment in which you’ll be climbing, personal preference, and the type of climbing you’ll be doing. Those who expect to crack climb, aid climb, haul gear, and tackle multi-pitch routes are more inclined to need a pair of climbing gloves than someone who mainly boulders or climbs indoors. 

• Are belay gloves worth it?

  Depending on the endeavor, a quality pair of climbing gloves can add significant comfort as well as protection against sharp rock, ice, and the elements. But they’re not an essential gear item for everyone. You might need a pair of belay or climbing gloves if you expect to spend a lot of time in the alpine, in mixed environments, and hauling or belaying. If you predominantly boulder or climb in the gym, skip the climbing gloves.

• Can I use my cycling gloves for climbing?

  You have free will, so we’re not going to say you can’t use your cycling gloves for climbing. However, cycling gloves are designed with very different priorities in mind. Chances are that the materials and build will not stand up to the demands of climbing—or at least, not for long. What’s more, cycling gloves could actually be detrimental to your climbing success by creating bulk in the wrong areas.

• What’s the difference between crack gloves and tape?

  Using tape to make a pair of crack gloves is a good way to cut down on climbing gear expenses, but it’s not very long-lasting. And it limits movement more than the standard pair of crack gloves. True crack gloves manage to prioritize hand and finger dexterity while providing a slightly more durable climbing glove option.

• Do gloves affect grip on the rope or rock?

  Yes! Most climbing gloves are designed with grip enhancement in mind. The main challenge is that they prevent tactile feedback, which makes it harder for climbers to feel what’s happening on the rock surface.

  For more on grip enhancement, you may also be interested in our Best Climbing Chalk.

How we researched and tested

This article involved testing six climbers, with experience levels ranging from guides with 25+ years of climbing experience and people who have been climbing for 5 years. Climbers ranged in preferred type of climbing from deser crack climbers to those who prefer cool-weather, high-altitude climbs. But our testing also involved crack climbing, cold-weather climbing, and long belays.

Rock

We spent most of our time outside in the Rocky Mountains where we tackled gneiss and granite routes on sport, trad, and alpine routes. But throughout the past few years, we’ve also put gloves to the test on Yosemite granite, on North Carolina’s plutons, and South Carolina’s grainy gneiss. 

Alpine environments

Some of our testers spent a few days navigating alpine routes on Longs Peak in Colorado and across Rocky Mountain National Park over the course of the past two years. They predominantly opted for leather gloves in this environment due to the added warmth and durability.

Multiple testers with different-sized hands and experience levels

Climbing gloves can be a great pick for both new climbers and seasoned athletes, depending on their needs and preferences. Seasoned athletes might opt for highly technical gloves with a lightweight build to tackle specific endeavors while new athletes may benefit from an added layer of protection of any kind. Our most advanced tester has decades of climbing experience across the country, while our newest climber had only experienced a few outdoor outings prior to testing these gloves. 

Multiple use cases (belaying, cracks, cold-weather climbing)

Over the years, we’ve used climbing gloves for belaying, hauling, crack climbing, and cold-weather alpine climbing. We found that crack gloves are a must-have item. Cold-weather climbing also greatly benefits from a solid pair of climbing gloves. While not essential for belaying, ascending, or hauling, climbing gloves make the experience way more comfortable.

Why you should trust us / About the author

Mary Beth Skylis is a freelance writer who specializes in adventure and travel journalism. She’s been climbing across the globe for more than a decade and loves any opportunity to tackle limestone, granite, and long multi-pitch climbs. Skylis currently works as a columnist for Backpacker Magazine. She also has bylines in Climbing, REI, Alaska Magazine, Women’s Health, Outside Magazine, Trail Runner, SELF, 5280, Westword, Boulder Magazine, Business Insider, and Travel + Leisure,. When she isn’t writing, she can typically be found in the Rocky Mountains. 

Skylis also worked with half a dozen additional climbers for this piece in an attempt to make calculated, complete evaluations of these gloves. The other climbers involved had varying levels of experience, ranging from entirely new climbers to professional guides in the Rockies with more than 25 years of climbing experience. Follow Skylis on Instagram: @h1kertrash.

To see all of Mary Beth's stories, check her author page.

September 16th, 2026
Home → Gear Reviews → Cycling

Our verdict

The Yakima StepUp Swing 2” hitch bike rack is a solid rack that is especially useful for folks who want complete rear-vehicle access without a rack or bikes in the way at all. 

We spent a summer testing the StepUp Swing 2” on road trips, camping trips, and for everyday use to nearby trailheads, and we were impressed. Even with the swing-out mechanism, this rack remains stable on rough dirt roads. The swing-out is easy to engage and especially useful for vehicles like trucks and camper vans. 

It isn’t the lightest or easiest to load of all the racks we’ve tested, but it is a solid and effective rack that’s ideal for folks who prioritize vehicle access while bikes are still loaded on the rack.

We create reader-supported, objective gear reviews independently selected by our editors. This story may contain affiliate links, which help fund our website. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission, without costing you an extra cent. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body! Learn more.

Yakima StepUp Swing 2”  Hitch Bike Rack Specifications

• Rack type: Hitch tray

• Bike capacity: 2

• Hitch receiver size: 2”

• Max weight per bike: 65 lb (off-road and RV, 43.5 lb)

• Total weight capacity: 130 lb (off-road and RV, 87 lb)

• Mounting style: Ratcheting cane arm for front wheel, ratcheting strap for rear wheel

• Bike fit range: Wheel sizes from 16”-29”, wheelbases from 32”-52”, tire width up to 4.5”

• Rear access: Yes, full swing-away access

• Anti-wobble system: No

• Security: Yes, hitch and bike lock included

• Foldable when empty: Yes

• Rack weight: 70 lb

• Folded / stowed dimensions: 62”W x 28”H x 16”D

• Materials: Steel, steel tubing, plastic, rubber

• Warranty: Limited lifetime warranty

• Price: $999

Comparison table

Best for

• Riders who want unencumbered rear-vehicle access without having to remove bikes or rack

• Folks who often camp with bikes in tow and need easy vehicle access

• Folks wanting a rack that can both tilt away and swing away for vehicle access

• Cyclists and mountain bikers who want a frameless contact system for transporting bikes, including E-bikes

What we liked

• Swing-away mechanism allows for complete rear-vehicle access

• Tilt mechanism allows access with tailgate fully down

• Great for camping and road trips, thanks to easy rear vehicle access

• Rack is stable on dirt roads even with more moving parts than non-swinging racks

• Included locks are easy to use

What could be better

• Not as easy to load as racks with dual cradle arms for tires (ratcheting cane arm and strap take more time to secure)

• Rack is heavy and a little complex to set up

• Cannot increase bike capacity beyond two bikes

• No anti-wobble mechanism in hitch attachment limits stability on rough roads, and lowers maximum weight limit

How we tested

We tested the Yakima StepUp Swing 2” rack primarily on a full-sized truck with a 2-inch hitch (which is the only hitch size this rack fits). We loaded full-suspension mountain bikes and gravel bikes onto the rack, and did the majority of our testing and travel with two full-suspension mountain bikes weighing around 30 pounds each, both loaded onto the rack. 

We took the rack on a road trip from Colorado to Southern Utah to ride mountain bikes, along with several other shorter trips including weekend camping trips down rough dirt roads and many drives to various trailheads around Colorado. We spent time driving at high speeds on highways for long distances, too. 

We often had only one tester loading the rack, which was easy to do. Occasionally, two testers would load bikes together, and with this rack a second hand can be helpful (though not at all necessary, as long as the person loading is strong enough to lift the bikes onto the rack). 

With the primary testing vehicle being a truck used for family outings with a toddler and a large dog, often camping or road tripping, the options for rear vehicle access, including the swing mechanism, were used frequently and greatly appreciated. 

After multiple months of consistent use, we have encountered no durability issues, rattles, or notable stability issues with this rack. 

We also tested the Yakima StepUp Swing Rack alongside other bike racks for cars in our Best Bike Racks for Cars, Trucks, and SUVs guide.

Will it fit your setup?

The following checklist will help you avoid frustration and unnecessary returns by ensuring the StepUp Swing 2 will work with your current vehicle and bike setup.

Your vehicle has / is:

• 2” hitch receiver 

• Standard passenger car, truck, van, or SUV

• RV compatible (with max weight per bike of 43.5 lb)

Your bikes are:

• Frameless-contact mounting works with carbon bikes

• Full-suspension, gravel, road 

• Step-through

• Wheel size between 16”-29”

• Wheelbase between 32”-52”

• Fat tires up to 4.5” in width

• Road/gravel skinny tires

E-bikes

• Max weight of 65lb per bike

• Max rating is 43.5lb per bike for off-road use

• Loading ramp available separately

Capacity growth

• 2 bike maximum

Performance in the field

Loading ease

We primarily tested this rack with two full-suspension mountain bikes weighing around 30 pounds each. Bikes were easy to load onto the rack—similar to other racks with the same cane arm/back wheel strap loading system. The rack sits high enough for good ground clearance (with all of the rack sitting above the hitch itself), but not so high that it makes it challenging to load bikes. 

Our 5’3” tester did not have an issue loading bikes onto the rack. Systems that use cradle arms can be quicker and easier to load, but we did not have any notable challenges loading this rack.

Bike security and stability

Overall, we did not find any notable issues with stability and bike security when testing the Yakima StepUp Swing rack. At high speeds on highways, the bikes remained stable, even when winds picked up. We also tested on dirt roads, and the rack and bikes remained stable and secure. 

This rack is solid, but it is not the most stable we’ve tested, and that is largely for two reasons. The first is that it does not have an anti-wobble mechanism (like a threaded bolt that stabilizes the rack in the hitch) in the hitch attachment. This means the rack is a little less stable on rough roads compared to racks we’ve tested that do have this feature (like the Kuat Piston Pro, which is incredibly stable). The second is that the swing-away mechanism inherently limits stability to some extent, simply because there are more moving parts in the rack overall. 

However, it’s worth noting that while this is not the most stable rack we’ve tested, it should be more than sufficient for most folks. But if you often off-road on particularly rough 4X4 roads, you may want to consider something more stable—but that more stable option likely won’t have the swing-away feature. 

Rear-vehicle access

Rear-vehicle access is the highlight feature of the Yakima StepUp Swing 2” rack. Like many other racks on the market that we’ve tested, it tilts away from the vehicle to allow for quick access to the back of a vehicle. And it tilts far enough, with bikes fully loaded, to allow the tailgate of a truck bed to open completely and sit flat. 

But then comes the swing-away feature. A threaded screw at the base of the rack allows the rack to unfold and open laterally, swinging away completely to the side of the vehicle. This allows complete rear access, which is particularly useful for trucks or vans, or any vehicle where you have a large storage space in the back.

We primarily tested this rack on a full-size truck with a cap over the bed and found this feature to be excellent for accessing the truck bed, especially while camping and on road trips. 

Bike-fit versatility

This rack can accommodate a wide range of bike sizes, similar to many other racks out there. It can fit kids’ bikes with as small as 16” wheels up to larger bikes with 29” wheels. It can fit bikes with wheelbases between 32” and up to 52”, which covers most common bikes, from kids’ bikes and cruisers to mountain bikes and fat bikes (with tires up to 4.5” wide). We tested this rack primarily with full-suspension mountain bikes, but were also easily able to fit gravel and commuter bikes onto the rack without issue.

E-bike capability

This rack is capable of carrying e-bikes weighing up to 65 pounds a piece. It is worth noting that off-roading or putting this rack on an RV reduces the weight capacity for each bike to 43.5 pounds, so this rack is not suitable for RVing or off-roading with heavy e-bikes on board. We did not specifically test with e-bikes, though based on our testing experience, we do trust that rating. There is a ramp available for purchase separately for easy e-bike loading, which costs an additional $119 at the time of publication. 

Build quality

The overall build quality of this rack is solid, and we appreciate that replacement parts are available if they are needed. In our multiple months of testing with constant use on a vehicle, we have not noticed any rattling or instabilities, or any other durability issues with the rack. 

Installation and hitch fit

This rack is partially assembled out of the box, and it does take some time to install—about double the time of some other racks we’ve tested. Our testers found it a bit frustrating at times, but ultimately after about an hour or so the rack was set up and ready to roll. It is worth noting that this rack is quite heavy–70 pounds! Our tester was able to install it on his own, but some folks may find setup for this rack easier with two people.

Stowed footprint

The Yakima StepUp Swing 2” rack folds upright against the back of the vehicle when not in use. It is fairly low profile, though not the smallest, lightest, or most minimal when stowed—it sticks out 16 inches from the vehicle when stowed. This is largely because of the additional metal and parts needed to allow for the swinging mechanism. 

Features

Loading and bike hold

• Frame-free tire/wheel clamping avoids contact with the frame—safe for carbon and unusual frame shapes

• Adjustable ratcheting arm accommodates a wide tire-width and wheel-size range, up to 4.5”-wide tires and 16”-29” wheel sizes

• Loading ramp is available separately for e-bikes ($119)

• Generous bike-to-bike spacing minimizes handlebar and pedal interference

• Individual tray adjustment slides bikes fore/aft to clear each other

Rear-vehicle access

• Lever tilt drops the rack to reach the hatch / tailgate—works when loaded

• Tailgate sits flat and fully opened with rack tilted back—works when loaded

• Optional swing-away pivot for full rear access on vans and SUVs

• Tilt returns and locks positively so the rack doesn't flop in transit

Stability and hitch attachment

• Rigid platform keeps bikes from swaying on rough roads

Security

• Integrated locking hitch pin secures the rack to the vehicle

• Cable lock secures each bike to the rack

• Keyed-alike system across locks for convenience

Build and stowability

• Steel construction balances weight, strength, and corrosion resistance

• Folds upright/flat against the vehicle to reduce footprint when empty — sticks out 16 inches from vehicle when folded

Setup and maintenance

• Partially assembled out of the box; 60-plus-minute setup to road-ready

• Serviceable moving parts and available replacement hardware

• Finish resists chipping and road grime; simple to clean

Sustainability

Yakima’s Climate Action Roadmap includes plans to reduce emissions, waste, and corporate travel/commuting; increase use of renewable energy (e.g., their headquarters in Lake Oswego, Oregon, is now 100% powered by wind), use of sustainable materials, recycling in headquarters and manufacturing facilities; and develop products that last a lifetime.

FAQ

• Does the Yakima StepUp Swing fit other sized hitches?

  No. This rack only comes in a 2” hitch option. Yakima does sell a hitch adapter, but only for 2.5” hitches, turning them into a 2” hitch to fit their racks. If you have a 1.25” or 3” hitch, Yakima doesn’t currently have any adapters for those.

• Can the Yakima StepUp Swing carry e-bikes / what's the weight limit?

  Yes, this rack is capable of carrying e-bikes up to 65 pounds each. That weight limit is decreased to 43.5 pounds off-road or when the rack is mounted to an RV.

• Will the Yakima StepUp Swing damage a carbon frame?

  No, this rack uses frameless contact for mounting and will not damage a carbon frame. The ratcheting hook arm secures the front wheel at the fork, while a ratcheting strap secures the rear wheel at the base of the wheel.

• Can I access my trunk/hatch with bikes loaded on the Yakima StepUp Swing?

  Yes, this rack provides full rear vehicle access. You can access the back of the vehicle by tilting the rack, or by swinging the rack away and to the side, which allows for complete rear access.

• Does the Yakima StepUp Swing fit fat tires / kids' bikes / step-through frames?

  Yes, this rack fits a wide variety of bike types and sizes. The frameless contact attachment system means that step-through bikes and other odd frame shapes work, as long as the wheels fit. Kids’ bikes fit with wheels as small as 16”.

• No. The max capacity on this rack is two bikes.

  Can I expand the Yakima StepUp Swing to carry more bikes?

Should you buy the Yakima StepUp Swing?

Buy if you want easy, unencumbered, rear-vehicle access, if you often car camp with your bikes in tow, or if you drive a truck or van and want full access to the back. 

Skip if you need maximum stability on rough roads, are on a tight budget or you want to be able to expand your rack to carry more than two bikes.

Where to buy the Yakima StepUp Swing?

The Yakima StepUp Swing hitch bike rack is a popular gear item, so you have options when it comes to retailers. Here are some of the pros of the retailers.

REI

Pros: 100% satisfaction policy for 1 year; 10% dividend for members.

Amazon

Pros: Free 2-day shipping with Amazon Prime membership (can be same-day delivery in major metropolitan cities)

evo

Pros: 365 day returns, store locations in ski towns for easy last-minute pick-up, may offer rentals if you want to try before you buy, earn 10% back in Rewards, free membership gets discounts on services and rentals

Advice on where to buy

In general for gear, we recommend purchasing from a place with easy or free returns, like REI. 

Similar bike racks

Yakima StepUp Swing vs. Yakima EXO DoubleUp

Rack type: Hitch tray
Bike capacity: 2
Hitch receiver size: N/a (this rack requires EXO base, sold separately, which fits 2” hitch receivers)
Max weight per bike: 50 lb per bike on EXO Swing Base; 40 lb per bike on EXO Top Shelf
Total weight capacity: 100 lb on EXO Swing Base; 80 lb on EXO Top Shelf

When paired with the Yakima EXO Swing Base, the EXO DoubleUp rack is another option for folks who want a swing-away rack. Rather than being an all-in-one system, the EXO DoubleUp rack is sold as one piece, with a Yakima EXO base needed to mount the rack. Purchasing the EXO Swing Base with the EXO DoubleUp rack makes for a setup that is significantly more expensive than the StepUp Swing rack. This system is ideal for folks who want to carry both bikes and gear on one rack system and that’s the main benefit. If you simply want a swing-away bike rack, the StepUp Swing 2” is more affordable and will likely offer better value overall.

Learn more in our in-depth review of the Yakima EXO DoubleUp bike hitch rack.

Yakima StepUp Swing vs. Kuat Sherpa 2.0

Rack type: Hitch tray
Bike capacity: 2
Hitch receiver size: 2” or 1.25”
Max weight per bike: 40 lb
Total weight capacity: 80 lb

The Kuat Sherpa 2.0 is one of Kuat’s most popular bike racks, and for good reason. It’s a solid, user-friendly option that is more affordable than other Kuat racks. While the Sherpa 2.0 does have a similar mounting system to the StepUp Swing—it also uses ratcheting cane arms and ratchet straps—the Sherpa does not swing out like the StepUp Swing. So, your rear-vehicle access will be more limited with the Sherpa than it is with the StepUp Swing, though the Sherpa does still tilt to allow hatch access. But we think the Kuat Sherpa 2.0 is a bit more stable on rough roads overall. So, if that’s a higher priority for you than rear vehicle access, this is a solid and reliable rack worth considering.

Yakima StepUp Swing vs. Hollywood Racks CrossTrack 2

Rack type: Hitch tray
Bike capacity: 1 or 2 (tested)
Hitch receiver size: 2” (tested) or 1.25”
Max weight per bike: 66 lb
Total weight capacity: 132 lb

The Hollywood Racks CrossTrack 2 is an affordable rack that’s easy to load. It uses two ratcheting cradle arms on either wheel to mount and secure the bike, which makes this rack a little easier to load than the Yakima StepUp Swing. The CrossTrack is also easier to set up out of the box than the StepUp Swing and weighs less, too. But, like the Kuat Sherpa, it does not swing away to allow for full rear-vehicle access, so if that’s your top priority, the Yakima StepUp Swing is a better bet.

Learn more in our in-depth review of the Hollywood Racks CrossTrack bike hitch rack.

Why you should trust us / About the author

A true mountain dweller, Stasia feels far more at home on a high alpine ridge than on a busy city street. She’s worked as a backpacking guide in Southeast Alaska, has held a WFR, AIARE 1, AIARE 2, and Avalanche Rescue Certifications, and is working to become an avalanche education instructor. She’s now a full-time writer and editor in the outdoor space and has been testing and writing about gear for over a decade.

Stasia learned to mountain bike as a kid in Utah, and rekindled her love for the sport after moving to Summit County, Colorado, and getting a new (and very much improved from her very old hand-me-down) full-suspension bike several years ago. She spends most of her summer days out on the singletrack, and while she often has the privilege of biking right from her house, she and her family love a good road trip or romp down a rough dirt road with bikes in tow. So, she spends a lot of time loading bikes on and off of racks to travel for vacations and bike races around the Mountain West—often keeping an eye on the side view mirror to make sure the bikes are secure when 4-wheel-drive really kicks in. 

Find more of Stasia’s work on her Treeline Review author page.

September 16th, 2026
Home > Gear Reviews > Cycling

Our verdict

The Yakima EXO SwingBase is the foundation swing-out hitch rack you use to attach the EXO DoubleUp bike rack, OpenRange camp kitchen, GearLocker cargo box, or RoadShower portable shower to your vehicle’s tow hitch. You can’t carry anything with the EXO SwingBase alone, but you need it to carry any one of these EXO accessories. 

I tested the EXO SwingBase for three months during the summer in Colorado. I installed the SwingBase and every accessory myself, and have driven over 1,000 miles with it so far. A decent chunk of that driving has been on rough dirt roads, too. I tested the SwingBase with the DoubleUp, OpenRange Deluxe, and RoadShower. 

The SwingBase is the only hitch-mounted rack that swings out and allows you to carry two separate accessories. It gives you maximum flexibility in how you carry outdoor gear while you drive. It’s an ideal choice for people with a rooftop tent or otherwise don’t have enough roof rack space for everything they need to carry on the outside of their vehicle. And it’s durable and easy to install yourself, unlike some roof rack setups.

Yakima EXO SwingBase

The biggest downside of the EXO SwingBase is that it’s expensive. The base itself is about what you would expect to pay for a rear swing-out rack, but the base itself will only carry the DoubleUp, OpenRange, RoadShower, GearLocker, or other EXO accessories, which each cost what you’d expect to pay. And if you want to carry two of those items, you’ll also need to buy the TopShelf, which costs a lot. 

Also, the EXO SwingBase won’t work on every vehicle. You’ll need to check the vehicle tongue weight capacity, the maximum weight that a tow hitch can support, to use the EXO system with your vehicle. In short, if you have a smaller crossover SUV, such as a Subaru Outback, you might be close to the tongue weight limit, but you can use this system if you don’t overload it. 

The price is high to use the EXO SwingBase to its full capabilities, but vehicle-mounted cargo gear is always expensive. It needs to be strong enough to handle highway speeds while standing up to the elements. And you’ll need to make sure everything you want to haul with the EXO system won’t be too heavy for your vehicle. 

If you’re looking for a swing-away cargo platform to carry multiple gear items on your vehicle’s hitch, you should start with the Yakima EXO SwingBase and build your cargo hauling kit from there. 

We create reader-supported, objective gear reviews independently selected by our editors. This story may contain affiliate links, which help fund our website. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission, without costing you an extra cent. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body! Learn more.

Yakima EXO SwingBase Hitch Bike Rack Specifications

• Price: $699

• Weight: 68 lbs

• Hitch receiver size: 2-inch only

• Hitch class required: Class III and IV only

• Swing-away: Yes

• Locking mechanism: HitchLock (secures base to vehicle); additional SKS locks included for accessories

• Accessory attachment: Tool-free EXO Cleat system with locking SpeedKnobs

• Fits trailers, campers, or RVs: No

• Built-in bottle opener: Yes

• Warranty: Manufacturer's limited lifetime warranty

• Compatible accessories: EXO DoubleUp (bike rack), EXO OpenRange (cargo box), EXO GearLocker, EXO GearWarrior, EXO TopShelf riser, EXO SnowBank

Comparison table

Best for

• Mid-to-large sized SUV, truck, or van owners with a vehicle tongue weight limit over 300 pounds 

• Crossover vehicle owners with a tongue weight capacity over 300 pounds who want to carry bikes plus more on a hitch rack

• Anyone looking for a swing-away cargo carrying hitch rack

• Vanlifers, overlanders, or extended road-trippers who want to carry gear outside of their vehicle

What we liked

• Easy to install

• Securely hauls gear and bikes

• Swing-away feature makes the back of the vehicle actually usable

• Comes with security bolts and locking hitchpin

What could be better

• Expensive initial investment

• Requires a lot of pieces to get the full potential out of this system, which is expensive

• Too heavy for smaller vehicles

How we tested

I tested the Yakima EXO SwingBase with multiple EXO accessories on my 1999 GMC Savana 2500 with a 500-pound tongue weight Class 3 trailer hitch. I mounted the EXO DoubleUp, RoadShower 7G, and OpenRange accessories to the SwingBase, along with the EXO TopShelf, which allowed me to carry any two of those accessories. I tested the system all summer, driving over 1,000 miles in Colorado and New Mexico. I drove most of that distance on highways, but I also drove rough, dirt washboard roads daily to get to campsites. 

Initially, I tested the DoubleUp bike rack alone on the EXO Swingbase. Then, I added the EXO TopShelf, moved the DoubleUp onto that top shelf, and installed the 7-gallon RoadShower (with the EXO mounting kit) on the lower level. After driving around with that setup for over a month, I swapped the RoadShower for the OpenRange Deluxe. The heaviest weight I carried on the EXO system was when I had the RoadShower on the lower shelf and DoubleUp bike rack with two bikes, one of which was an e-bike, on the top shelf. The total weight of that setup was approximately 290 pounds. I have had the DoubleUp and OpenRange on the SwingBase for over a month now, and I've had no issues with it. 

We also tested the Yakima EXO SwingBase with the DoubleUp alongside other bike racks in our Best Bike Racks for Cars, Trucks, and SUVs guide, directly comparing installation processes, ease of use, carry capacity, stability, security, durability, and more.

Vehicle compatibility

A typical Class 2 hitch (which can have either a 1 ¼ inch or 2-inch receiver) that you’ll find on crossovers, sedans, or small SUVS can support up to 350 pounds, usually less than this, though. Class 3 or 4 hitches (which always have a 2-inch receiver) can support more weight. If you have a larger vehicle with a higher tongue weight capacity, such as a truck or full-size SUV, you shouldn’t have to worry about tongue weight and vehicle compatibility. But if you have a smaller vehicle, you might. 

For example, the standard 2021 Subaru Outback has a tongue weight limit of 270 pounds. The EXO SwingBase itself weighs 68 pounds, the DoubleUp bike rack is 37 pounds, and two bikes weigh roughly 50 pounds. So with the SwingBase, DoubleUp, and two bikes weighing 155 pounds, you only have 115 pounds of tongue weight capacity left. You would quickly reach that capacity by adding TopShelf (33 pounds) and the OpenRange Deluxe (72 pounds). You would be just over capacity with the 7-gallon RoadShower, which weighs 84 pounds when full. 

Performance in the field

Receiver stability

This rack feels very stable at the hitch receiver. I never notice it wobbling while driving on rough roads or at high speeds on the highway. Even when I attempt to wiggle it by hand, it barely moves at all. Most other bike racks I’ve used wobble a lot more than the EXO SwingBase.  

Swing mechanism

The swing mechanism swings out smoothly when loaded full. It has a thread-in locking mechanism, which prevents the rack from swinging out when you don’t want it to. To swing out the rack, simply unscrew the locking mechanism with the attached handle (no tools required), pull out the locking pin, and swing it away from your vehicle. If the rack is heavily loaded with bikes and gear, you’ll have to use some force to swing it out, but it still swings smoothly. 

Installation and setup

I installed the entire EXO system by myself, using only the tools Yakima provided. Installing the EXO SwingBase alone took about two minutes, then installing each additional accessory took another five minutes. It’s all intuitive and straightforward. 

As long as you have a 2-inch hitch receiver, you should be able to install this yourself with ease. The 68-pound EXO SwingBase wasn’t very difficult to lift and slide into place on my own.  

Accessory attachment

Every EXO accessory I added to the SwingBase was also easy to install. I think it consistently took longer to remove the packaging from each accessory than to attach it to the EXO base. 

Every accessory I tested, except the RoadShower, comes with cleats that fit the EXO system already installed. This means that installing the accessories is as simple as dropping the cleats into the EXO system tracks and tightening the knobs. The SpeedKnobs lock when you have tightened them fully against the cleats. The lock cores come pre-installed, too.

Security

The SpeedKnobs and HitchLock on the hitch pin come with locks preinstalled. These are easy to use and would make it difficult for a thief to steal your rack or the accessories attached to it. 

Some online customer reviewers express concern that some accessories use standard bolts to attach to the cleats. In my experience, you can’t get to most of these bolts when the accessory is attached to the EXO base or TopShelf. 

You can undo the bolts that attach the Double Up bike rack from the cleats, however. This means that in theory, a thief could undo the two nuts and bolts holding the bike rack tray to the EXO system cleat, then walk away with the bike and tray. I haven’t had any issues with this, but if you regularly park your vehicle in high-traffic, high-crime areas, you shouldn’t leave your bike on a bike rack either way, because a determined thief can always find a way to steal it. I’d recommend gluing a ball bearing in the hex head of the bolt that holds the rack to the EXO cleats in this instance, but I think best practice is to avoid places where your bike is likely to be stolen off your rack. 

Durability

After a three-month testing period, the EXO SwingBase, pivot, and locking hardware look dirtier, but otherwise they’re in great shape. There is no corrosion, obvious wear marks, or rattling. I would expect this system to last for years without issue. 

Features

Swing Mechanism

The EXO SwingBase has a swing mechanism that pivots the gear attached to the rack away from your car with the gear loaded so that you can access the back of your vehicle. It has a threaded locking mechanism and pins that hold the swing arm closed while you’re driving. 

HitchLock

It comes with a locking hitch pin that uses the same key as the locking SpeedKnobs, which lock the EXO accessories. 

EXO Cleat System

The EXO Cleat System allows you to easily slide an accessory into the arms on the EXO SwingBase. Once you’ve fitted the cleats on the bottom of the accessory into the tracks on the SwingBase arms, you tighten the SpeedKnobs to hold the cleats in place on the SwingBase arms. 

SpeedKnobs

The EXO SwingBase arms have tracks that the EXO Cleat System fits into, and each end has a SpeedKnob. These SpeedKnobs tighten the EXO Cleat System to hold the accessory securely on the SwingBase. You can also lock the SpeedKnobs so they can’t be unscrewed without the key. 

Bottle Opener

Of course, like every other piece of outdoor gear, the EXO SwingBase has a bottle opener at the end of each SwingBase arm, just below the SpeedKnobs. 

Sustainability

Yakima has committed to reducing company emissions by 50% by 2030. 

Their plan to reduce emissions is to reduce reliance on air freight; increase use of renewable energy; their headquarters in Lake Oswego, Oregon is now 100% powered by wind; increase use of sustainable materials; reduce waste and increase recycling in headquarters and manufacturing facilities; develop products that last a lifetime; and reduce corporate travel/commuting.

You can read more about Yakima’s sustainability on their website. 

FAQ

• Does the Yakima EXO SwingBase work on a 1.25-inch hitch receiver?

  No, the EXO SwingBase works only with a 2-inch hitch receiver. 

• What accessories are compatible with the Yakima EXO SwingBase?

  The EXO SwingBase is compatible with the Yakima EXO TopShelf, DoubleUp, GearLocker, OpenRange, OpenRange Deluxe, BackDeck, GearWarrior, and RoadShower (in the 4- and 7-gallon version with the RoadShower EXO Kit).

• How much of my vehicle's tongue weight capacity does the SwingBase use on its own?

  The EXO SwingBase weighs 68 pounds on its own. So, depending on your vehicle’s tongue weight capacity, this could be a substantial amount of your vehicle’s total tongue weight capacity. 

• Can I install the Yakima EXO SwingBase by myself?

  If you’re even moderately mechanically inclined, you can install the EXO SwingBase by yourself. The base itself weighs 68 pounds, so as long as you can lift that much on your own, you should be able to slide it into your vehicle’s hitch receiver and install the locking pin on your own.

Should you buy the Yakima EXO SwingBase?

Buy if:

• You want to use the Yakima EXO system to carry any number of Yakima EXO accessories such as the DoubleUp, GearLocker, OpenRange, BackDeck, GearWarrior, or RoadShower.

• You have a tongue weight capacity of over 300 pounds and a 2-inch Class 3 or 4 hitch receiver

• You want to carry a lot of gear on the back of your vehicle without it blocking access to your trunk

• You want a swing-away rack system with a lot of accessory options

Skip if:

• You just want a swing-out bike rack

• You have a smaller vehicle with a 1 ¼ inch tow hitch receiver

Where to buy the Yakima EXO SwingBase

The Yakima EXO SwingBase hitch bike rack is a popular gear item, so you have options when it comes to retailers. Here are some of the pros of the retailers.

REI

Pros: 100% satisfaction policy for 1 year; 10% dividend for members.

Amazon

Pros: Free 2-day shipping with Amazon Prime membership (can be same-day delivery in major metropolitan cities)

evo

Pros: 365 day returns, store locations in ski towns for easy last-minute pick-up, may offer rentals if you want to try before you buy, earn 10% back in Rewards, free membership gets discounts on services and rentals

Advice on where to buy

In general for gear, we recommend purchasing from a place with easy or free returns, like REI. 

Similar bike hitch racks

Yakima EXO SwingBase vs Kuat Pivot v3

Price: $549
Weight: 250 lb total
Hitch receiver size: 2"
Swing-away: Yes
Locking mechanism: Yes

The Kuat Pivot v3 is a swing-away attachment that lets you use any 2-inch hitch-mounted rack and swing it away from the back of your vehicle. I’ve used the Pivot v2 with a Thule bike rack and a hitch-mounted spare tire rack. The Pivot costs $150 less than the EXO SwingBase, and you can use it with the bike rack or hitch-mounted accessory you already have. You can also choose a version of the Pivot that swings to either the driver side or the passenger side, unlike the EXO SwingBase, which only swings to the passenger side. The Pivot v3 has a 250 lb weight capacity.

In contrast, the EXO SwingBase technically only has a weight capacity based on the accessories it’s carrying (the EXO GearLocker’s weight capacity is 100 lb, for example), but has a similar weight capacity. The Pivot v3 is a great option if you only want to carry one rack on the rear of your car, and especially if you already have that hitch-mounted rack and simply want it to swing out. The EXO SwingBase is a better option if you want to stack multiple rack items and if you’re willing to buy into Yakima’s EXO system.

Kuat Pivot v3

Yakima EXO SwingBase vs Thule Arcos Tilt Platform and Arcos Box

Price: $600
Weight: 110 lb total
Hitch receiver size:  2" (comes in 1.25 as well)
Swing-away: Tilt
Locking mechanism: Yes

The Thule Arcos Tilt Platform and Arcos Box (sold separately but used together) is another rear-mounted cargo-carrying system. This system doesn’t swing away from the vehicle; rather, it tilts down to (sort of) get out of the way. The Arcos system is also more expensive than the Yakima EXO system. And the Arcos system only fits a cargo box. No other accessories (or a second level) work with the Arcos base. The Arcos does, however, come in a 1.25-inch hitch receiver version so that it can be used with smaller vehicles with lower tongue weights.

Thule Arcos Tilt Platform and Arcos Box

Yakima EXO SwingBase vs PAKMULE Scout

Price: $795-$1120
Weight: 500 lb total
Hitch receiver size: 2, 2.5"
Swing-away: No
Locking mechanism: Yes

The PAKMULE Scout is another hitch-mounted cargo carrying option. The PAKMULE is a simple cargo tray, but it has a solid floor with holes to secure bike rack trays or strap anything else onto the platform. The PAKMULE doesn’t swing away, but it is rated for off-road use and has a 500-pound weight capacity. The PAKMULE costs about $100 more than the EXO SwingBase alone, but it costs less than the SwingBase plus any one accessory.

PAKMULE Scout

Yakima EXO SwingBase vs Yakima StepUp Swing 2"

Price: $999
Weight: 135 lb total
Hitch receiver size: 2"
Swing-away: Yes
Locking mechanism: Yes

The Yakima StepUp Swing 2" is a two-bike hitch-mounted rack that swings away. This Bike rack works like the EXO SwingBase plus the EXO DoubleUp, but it comes as one unit, so you don’t have to buy separate items. The EXO SwingBase plus the DoubleUp ($699+$549=$1248) costs about $250 more than the StepUp Swing 2" on its own. If you’re just looking for a swing-away bike rack, the StepUp Swing is a great option. But if you want to carry a bike rack plus other gear on your tow hitch, the EXO SwingBase plus necessary accessories is a better choice.

Yakima StepUp Swing 2"

Why you should trust us / About the author

Sam Schild lives full-time in a DIY converted 1999 GMC Savana campervan, which he uses as a mobile basecamp across the American West. He has reviewed car camping accessories such as mattresses, portable showers, backpacking bidets, and portable toilets for Treeline Review, along with loads of running, biking, and backpacking gear. 

Over three years of full-time van-life and 3 more years of living in a Honda Element, he has experimented with many ways to haul gear on the outside of vehicles, from rooftop cargo boxes to swing-away racks. For this review, he used the Yakima EXO SwingBase and accessories to carry bikes, the RoadShower solar shower, and the EXO OpenRange for an entire summer in Colorado. He never once had any mishaps while hauling his precious outdoor cargo. 

You can find more of Sam’s work on his Treeline Review author page, website, or Instagram.

September 16th, 2026, updated with another year's worth of testing notes, new prices and commentary on value
Home > Gear Reviews > Climbing

We’ve spent the past three years hauling climbing rope bags across sandstone in Utah, granite in California, and crags and gym floors throughout Colorado. A good rope bag should keep your rope clean and organized without adding unnecessary bulk or frustration, whether you’re carrying it a few minutes from the car or hiking a longer approach with the rest of your climbing gear.

For this guide, we relied on more than a decade of experience using rope bags and tarps, including years of climbing throughout Colorado’s Front Range (and writing a guidebook about it). We carried them on dusty approaches, through tight spaces, and over long days at the crag, using them for sport, trad, ice, and multi-pitch climbing. Several of the bags and tarps in this guide have also been in our regular rotation for many years, giving us a good sense of how they hold up over time.

We evaluated each rope bag for carrying comfort, tarp design, capacity, durability, and how well it kept ropes clean in real-world use. We also paid attention to how easily each bag packed up, how well its closures and buckles worked, whether the tarp made it easy to organize the rope ends, and how much room there was for a harness, shoes, rack, or other gear.

Top Pick: The Black Diamond Stone 42 Duffel earns our Best Overall award. The first time we opened it at East Colfax in Clear Creek Canyon, the removable tarp and internal organization immediately made setting up easier. Its tarp had plenty of room for an 80 m rope, the color-coded tie-in loops helped keep the rope ends organized, and the stashable shoulder and waist straps made it easier to move through tight spaces or haul the bag when needed.

We create reader-supported, objective gear reviews independently selected by our editors. This story may contain affiliate links, which help fund our website. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission — without costing you an extra cent. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body! Learn more.

Climbing rope bags comparison table

The winners

Best overall climbing rope bag: Black Diamond Stone 42 Duffel

Weight: 2 lbs. 8 oz.
Size: 42 L
Tarp size: 47” X 59”
Bag type: Backpack
Pockets: 2 internal zip pockets
What we liked: Removable tarp, giant zippered pockets, internal loops make it easy to organize gear
What we didn’t like: Inside is black making it harder to see some things

The Black Diamond Stone 42 Duffel has everything we want in a crag bag and it’s the rope bag we keep reaching for every time we head out. When we splayed the pack open for the first time at East Colfax in Clear Creek Canyon, we were impressed by how easy it was to access the tarp and organizing features inside. 

The removable tarp is big enough to handle rolling up an 80-meter rope. It also has red and green tie-in loops for securing the ends of the rope, which is great for rope organization. 

We also love that the shoulder and waist straps easily tuck away into the pack in case you need to haul it up or move through narrow spaces where it might get caught on tree branches, rocks, or other things. We also love the burly handles on the outside, which make it easy to hold from the top or front, to tie into a rope or clip a carabiner to.

The Stone Duffel tarp fully splayed out at East Colfax.

The Black Diamond Stone Duffel showing its winning features: tarp and tieiin points, gear loops, and zippered pockets.

Inside the pack there are two top loops you can easily attach all your quickdraws and/or trad gear to. With 42 L of space inside there’s also plenty of space to hold your climbing shoes, harness, and more. The two giant, zippered internal pockets are great for storing necessities, like keys, a headlamp, and snacks. 

Made of stocky, recycled 840-denier nylon and 1,260-denier ballistic nylon, the duffel should last for a decade or more of tough use. This streamlined pack is well-designed, comfortable to carry long distances, and has all the features we want in a crag pack.

Best climbing rope bag for carrying extra gear: Metolius Ropemaster HC

Weight: 1 lb. 4 oz.
Size: 29 L
Tarp size: 52" x 58"
Bag type: Burrito
Pockets: None
What we liked: Can carry an 80 m rope and extra gear, rope viewing window, easy to cinch and wrap up
What we didn’t like: Only one shoulder strap, could be a little larger, no pocket or other organization features

You may ask yourself—or us—why we feature the Metolius Ropemaster HC (high-capacity) as a high-capacity bag when we’ve got larger backpacks listed here. That’s because some of those are more climbing backpack than rope bag. The extra liters of capacity that the Ropemaster has over the backpack-style rope bags does make it easier to carry more gear or accommodate bigger shoes and harnesses as well as a longer, 80 m rope.

We appreciate the rope viewing window, which makes it really easy to know what rope is in there before you head out. We also found it’s very easy to cinch the rim of the bag and then use the straps to really ratchet everything down tight, making it ideal for navigating narrow nooks and crannies, hauling gear up to the next pitch, and not taking up too much space at the crag.

The Ropemaster HC is the second version of the first rope-specific bag, Metolius’ Ropemaster. Despite the added capacity, little has changed since its introduction over three decades ago—you know the saying: “if it ain’t broke…”.

Best Climbing Rope for Travel: Sterling Vertac Black Gear Bag 40L

Weight: 3 lbs.
Size: 40 L
Tarp size: N/A
Bag type: backpack
Pockets: 6 internal and external
What we liked: Burly, great organization options, comfortable shoulder straps
What we didn’t like: Bulkier than other bags, no included rope tarp, can’t stow away the shoulder straps

If you’re heading out on your next dream climbing trip to somewhere in Thailand, Kalymnos, the Dolomites or Tonsai…we’re jealous! If we were making that trip we’d want a pack that can handle not just the rigors of the rock but also the airport, boat, yak, and whatever else travel will throw at it. 

That’s where the Sterling VERTAC Black Gear Bag 40L comes in. It’s a rope bag that doubles as a travel backpack—so you can go from the gate to rock before even stopping at your hostel or houseboat.

The Sterling Vertac Black Gear Bag shown with two 70m ropes, harness and other gear.

You can easily clip gear to the daisy loops to keep it from becoming a knotty mess in the Vertac.

Sterling claims it’s a 40-liter pack but it felt like it was bigger than the 42-liter Stone Duffel from Black Diamond. That's because its shape gives us a lot of usable space. It easily gobbled up two 70 m ropes with enough room for a harness, shoes and a rack of trad gear. We could also see using it as our only backpack on an extended cragging weekend, since it can carry a rope, rack, harness, helmet, shoes and some extra clothes inside.

Still, if we needed to haul it up a multipitch route, the handle, rated at 50 pounds, would be up to hauling up almost any gear we left in there, as well as the gear of most of our climbing party.

Best climbing Rope tarp: Trango Cord Trapper Rope Tarp

Weight: 9.5 oz. 
Size: N/A
Tarp size: 48" x 60"
Bag type: Tarp
Pockets: None
What we liked: Multiple color options, lightweight
What we didn’t like: No carry straps, cinching tarp down takes a little getting used to

If you’re looking for a compact, lightweight climbing tarp to protect your rope at the crag and make it easier to slip into a backpack without coiling it, this is our go-to. We’ve had the same Cord Trapper Tarp for about a decade and have used it rock climbing throughout Colorado, cragging Clear Creek, trad climbing at Eldorado Canyon, ice climbing in Ouray, and at countless other spots around the state. Somehow we still haven’t put any holes in it.

The Cord Trapper is easy to tuck and roll your rope up into it like a burrito, cinch down with the strap, and stow it in larger packs for long hikes into remote areas, like climbing in the Buffalo Creek Wilderness. It also has red and green tie-in points to make sure you pull from the top of the rope pile rather than the bottom. Otherwise it’s a no-frills rope tarp that retails for $25. But you can find it for about $20 at some stores—just a little more than a cheap truck tarp. 

It doesn’t have any carrying straps, making it awkward to carry on its own. But it allows you to cinch a rope down tightly without coiling it, then stow it neatly in a backpack, like the Sterling VERTAC. We also love that the tarp is available in multiple colors. It is another way that makes it easier to find your rope when packing up at the crag, or if you have two or more ropes you could keep each type of rope in a different colored tarp, so it’s easy to grab and go.

Best affordable climbing rope bag: Ikea Frakta Shopping Bag

Weight: 4 oz.
Size: 22” x 15” x 14” (72 liters)
Tarp size: N/A
Bag type: Bucket-style
Pockets: None
What we liked: Can’t beat $1 in terms of price, multiple carry loops make it easy to tie off rope and carry the bag, lots of space for extra gear
What we didn’t like: Not as durable as other options, no way to really cinch the top closed, no organization abilities, no tarp

If you’ve never seen the big blue bag at a crag you probably haven’t looked. This simple, lightweight bag from IKEA is a favorite of dirtbags everywhere—indeed when an ice climbing buddy saw a potentially abandoned IKEA bag at Lincoln Falls, her eyes lit up with crag booty dreams. She was a little crestfallen when someone else claimed it. 

It’s hard to debate the value. IKEA sells this bag for less than a dollar or you can buy a 10-pack on Amazon delivered to your door. Essentially it’s a truck tarp with handles sewn into a shopping bag, which is probably why it’s so cheap—IKEA’s using it to encourage more shopping! At 4 ounces it’s the lightest bag here and, at 72 liters of capacity, it has the largest capacity of any bag we considered. Plus, it folds down to nothing when not in use.

However, it’s lacking a lot of other things we’re looking for in a climbing bag. It doesn’t have any padded backpack straps, organization, or a tarp. It’s just a bucket. Also, while IKEA rates it for carrying up to 55 pounds, it’s not abrasion-resistant like tarps designed for the rigors of climbing. It just won’t last as long as other rope bags and tarps. And, as it breaks down, you may end up leaving some plastic debris at the crag that will eventually work its way into a wild animal or nearby body of water.

Other climbing rope bags we tested

Black Diamond Super Chute

Weight: 1 lb. 1 oz
Size: 25 liters
Tarp size: 48" x 57"
Bag type: burrito/funnel
Pockets: Small rope ID pocket
What we liked: Ability to roll up like a burrito or slide rope into the bag like a funnel, big enough to carry 80 m rope
What we didn’t like: Not a lot of space to carry extra gear, no external loops, no carry handle

This rope bag has the bare basics we’d want in a crag bag—it’s cinchable, has a shoulder strap, and a tarp. It’s similar to the Metolius Ropemaster HC. The ability to use the tarp to funnel the rope pile into the bag is nice, but we find that rolling the rope in a tarp before rolling it into the bag helps keep the rope pile in order more. And while the Ropemaster has a transparent window so you can see the rope inside, the Super Chute has a business card-sized pocket with a mesh cover so you can see the name of the rope you wrote on the card. But that’s it’s only pocket. It also lacks a carrying handle or any other opportunity to carry it other than the sparsely padded shoulder strap.

Metolius Speedster Rope Bag

Weight: 1 lb. 4 oz.
Size: 29 L
Tarp size: 52" x 58"
Bag type: Backpack/funnel
Pockets: Small zippered pocket
What we liked: Big enough for an 80 m rope and some extra gear, small pocket for gear like keys and belay glasses, zipper down the front of the pack makes it super easy to access everything
What we didn’t like: Funnel style pack makes it easier to mess up the rope pile, not a lot of ability to strap extra gear on the outside, no back panel padding

This is another good rope bag from Metolius but it just wasn’t our favorite. We’d choose the Black Diamond Stone 42 over it. The Stone is more versatile, with straps that can be used as a backpack or duffel bag. This pack doesn’t have a rope ID window and the gear pocket is smaller than on other options. As described with the Super Chute above, we’re also not entirely sold on the funnel method of stuffing a rope in a pack. 

Black Diamond Rope Bucket 

Weight: 13.3 oz.
Size: N/A
Tarp size: N/A
Bag type: Bucket
Pockets: none
What we liked: Zipper makes easy work of compressing the rope, loops at top make it easy to haul bag up
What we didn’t like: No tarp, no place for extra gear, loops at top aren’t color-coordinated 

This was a unique rope bag among the pieces tested. It’s not a traditional rope bag or even a tarp. In fact, it has no tarp. It’s a bucket for quickly stowing rope on multi-pitch or mountaineering routes using gravity to keep the rope pile in order, so theoretically, you don’t really need to tie-in the bottom end of the rope. But in practice, if you don’t tie off the top end of the rope it would be easy to lose it when carrying the rope.

The zipper allows the bucket to open wide, while the top loops make it easy to connect the bucket to an anchor. Connecting the bucket to an anchor keeps the bucket open, making it easy to toss rope into it from a hanging belay station. It’s great for that, but not really as a practical crag bag or rope bag. You’d need to roll the rope up in a tarp, put the tarp in the bucket and then zip it up.

Metolius Rope Tarp

Weight: 9.4 oz.
Size: N/A
Tarp size: 58" x 53"
Bag type: Tarp
Pockets: One giant rope pocket
What we liked: Giant rope pocket makes it easy to funnel rope into bottom of the tarp before folding and rolling, color-coded rope tie-ins
What we didn’t like: Doesn’t come with the carabiner needed to secure the tarp

Treeline testers liked all the features on the Metolius Rope Tarp. It's a good size and shape for flaking out a 70 m rope. As with the other rope tarps, you drop the rope into it and wrap it up burrito-style.  

One thing we didn’t like is that though it secures with daisy chains, it doesn’t come with the carabiner that is required to keep it secure. You'll have to provide your own carabiner.

Why do you need a climbing rope bag

A climbing rope bag isn’t just a great way to carry hundreds of feet of rope. Along with a tarp (usually integrated) it’s actually an important piece of gear that will help you prolong the life of your climbing rope by protecting it from the elements, including sand, grit, dirt, and anything else at the climbing crag. By keeping these particles off the rope, a rope bag helps keep it cleaner and prevents the particles from embedding themselves in the rope fiber causing premature wear and tear.

For a complete climbing setup, be sure to also choose the right chalk and chalk bag. Check out our guides on the Best Climbing Chalk and Best Climbing Chalk Bags.

Types of climbing rope bags

Climbing rope bags come in several styles, from simple tarps to full backpacks and specialized bags for multi-pitch, big-wall, or canyoneering use. The right style depends mostly on how far you carry your rope, how much additional gear you need to bring, and where you climb.

What to look for in a climbing rope bag

Material

You’ll generally want a rope bag with a relatively heavy denier nylon or polyester that may have a durable water repellent (DWR). You don’t want a fully waterproof bag because you’ll want the rope to dry out if it gets wet and it might not dry out if it’s in a waterproof bag between uses. A wet rope should not be stored sealed in any bag. Waterproofness during transport is a different issue.

Durability

Rope bags are usually made of heavier denier nylon and polyester that can withstand years of rough use and being tossed about at the crag, bumping against jagged rocks, getting snagged on tree and branch stumps, the sandy dirt at the base of the crag as well as the errant glass shards you might run into at the base of an old crag. A rope bag will likely outlast at least two ropes’ life with a little care—if not four or five.

Size and capacity

Most rope bags aren’t rated in terms of liters like most backpacks are. We tested rope bags and tarps outside, usually with a 70 m climbing rope between 9.9 mm and 9.3 mm. Every one we tested was able to fit a 70 m rope with relative ease. Almost every rope bag was manufacturer rated to accommodate an 80 m rope as well. Some rope bags are much smaller, for a gym-length, 30 m rope, however we didn’t test any of those in this round of testing.

Tarps

Almost all the rope bags we tested had tarps attached. Most the tarps we tested were rectangular (the Metolius Rope Tarp is oval). The size varied from 48” x 52” to 48" x 60”. A bigger tarp is often nicer for flaking your rope and putting gear like your climbing shoes and climbing rack on, but other factors are as important, if not more.

The best tarps we tested not only had rope tie-ins, but different colored rope tie-ins so you know which end to use if you don’t flake the rope every time you pull it out of the bag.

The other nice feature is removability. We don’t always take the tarp off the bag, but it’s a great feature to have at a small crag where space is at a premium or on a multi-pitch day when you want to protect the rope between pitches but don’t want to carry the whole bag. The only bag we tested with a removable tarp was the Black Diamond Stone Duffel. 

Compartments and pockets

Unless you’re looking for a basic tarp, having a zippered pocket or two is ideal in a good rope bag. At the least it’ll allow you to stash your keys, sunglasses, and a snack safely. After all there’s nothing worse than forgetting your keys at the crag and having to hike back to it and search for your keys—not that that’s ever happened to us—we swear!

Zipper and closure systems 

The rope bags we tested had a variety of different closure systems and methods. While the majority secured with compression straps and adjustable buckles. Some others, like the Black Diamond Stone Duffel close with a zipper. Though we love the Stone Duffel, in most cases we preferred a rope bag with more compression so we can cinch the rope into the smallest package possible.

Carrying and Comfort

With the exception of tarps, rope bags have carrying handles and/or shoulder straps. A lot of rope bags tested have a sling-style shoulder strap. With these, it’s important to have a long enough strap so that the bag can hang low enough that it won’t interfere with a small backpack that you’re also carrying to the crag. 

Some others are designed with two long shoulder straps to allow for carrying on the side or tightened down to wear like a pack. Yet others are designed to wear as a backpack, like the Sterling VERTAC.

Consider how long your approach typically is (the right Approach Shoes are your friends!), and whether or not you want a pack that works best for multi-pitch climbing and longer routes.

Padded shoulder straps 

Most rope bags had some light padding on the shoulder straps, giving some comfort while carrying them to the crag. Black Diamond’s Rope Bucket had the least amount of padding and we wouldn’t want to carry it on our shoulders for very long.

Only the Sterling VERTAC and the Black Diamond Stone Duffel had straps that we’d be happy to carry for many miles. They’re also the only bags tested with hip belts.

Handles and portability

Having a strong handle on one end of the bag is ideal. If you’re cramming through narrow cracks in the rock where the bag might snag, you can drop the bag off your shoulder and shimmy through holding it by the handle. It’s also great for multiple-pitch climbing and walking off the top, because you can tie the end of the rope to the handle after you’ve secured the tarp.

Ventilation and moisture management 

None of these rope bags or backpacks feature the ventilation you’d find in backpacks for hiking and backpacking. Rope bags are primarily designed for shorter trips.

Gear loops and attachment points 

Other than handles and shoulder straps, most basic rope bags don’t have gear loops and attachment points. The backpack-style bags had some internal loops and attachment points. They make it easier to manage gear like quickdraw and trad protection inside the bag, and to keep everything where you want it.

Rope ID

We know a lot of people only have one or maybe two climbing ropes (like a dry-treated rope and a non-dry-treated rope). And it’s pretty easy to tell the difference between two different ropes in two different types of rope bags.

However, a means of quick rope identification, like looking through the clear plastic viewing window on the Metolius Ropemaster, makes it super easy to make sure you grab the right rope for the right adventure. It also makes it easier to find your rope when you’re at a busy crag and all the bags look alike. The Black Diamond Super Chute has a rope ID slot as well.

How to choose a climbing rope bag

What type of climbing are you doing?

Whether you’re sport, top-rope, trad, ice, or alpine climbing, a rope bag is a great piece of gear to have to protect your rope. In most cases, any of these rope bags or tarps will more than meet your needs. However, if you’re multi-pitch climbing or alpine climbing, weight will be at a premium and you’ll want as light a bag as possible or a bag with a removable tarp. 

How long is your rope?

All of the rope bags and tarps tested easily handled 70 m ropes up to 9.9 mm in diameter. That’s enough rope for the majority of sport and trad routes in the US. The bags should also be large enough for 80m ropes, which is usually the longest rope most people climb with.

How much other gear will you need to carry in this bag?

If you’re just carrying a rope, a bag like the Metolius Ropemaster is ideal. If you want to carry everything to the crag or ice wall, a pack like the Black Diamond Stone Duffel has room for everything—climbing shoes, pro, rope (of course), harness, etc. But you may want to carry your helmet on the outside. 

How wet is your destination?

Hopefully not too wet. Hopefully you’re climbing on dry rock or ice that’s cold enough that it’s not melting. None of the rope bags tested are waterproof and that’s so the ropes can breathe in case they get wet during use or inside the bag.

Climbing rope bag care and maintenance

Rope bags spend a lot of time in dirt, sand, and dust, so they benefit from occasional cleaning. Shake or brush out loose debris regularly, and rinse the bag and tarp when dirt starts to build up. If cleaning it by hand, rinse from the outside first to help push dirt and grit out of the fabric, then rinse the inside and tarp.

Follow the manufacturer’s care instructions before putting a rope bag in a washing machine or using detergents. After cleaning, let the bag and tarp dry completely before packing your climbing rope back inside.

If your rope gets wet while climbing, take it out of the bag after the trip rather than leaving it packed away damp. Once everything is dry, check straps, buckles, zippers, handles, and tarp tie-in points for wear so small problems do not turn into failures at the crag.

FAQ

• Can I use a regular backpack instead of a climbing rope bag?

  Yes. A regular backpack can work, especially if you already carry your rope inside a larger crag pack. The main advantage of a dedicated rope bag is the integrated tarp and organization that make it easier to keep the rope clean, flake it out, and pack it again quickly. If you use a regular backpack, carrying a separate rope tarp can provide many of the same benefits.

• Can I carry climbing gear in the same bag as my rope?

  Yes, as long as the bag has enough capacity. Larger backpack-style rope bags can often carry a harness, shoes, quickdraws, water, and other gear along with the rope, while smaller burrito-style bags may have room for little more than the rope itself. Avoid packing sharp or dirty gear where it can damage or heavily contaminate the rope.

• Do I need to coil my rope before putting it in a rope bag?

  Usually not. One of the advantages of a rope bag and tarp is that you can flake the rope directly onto the tarp, secure the ends, and then fold or roll the bag around it. At the next crag, you can open the tarp and start with an organized rope pile rather than recoiling and reflaking the entire rope.

• How do I keep track of the ends of my climbing rope in a rope bag?

  Many rope tarps have two tie-in points, and some use different colors for each end. Secure the rope ends to those loops before packing up so you can identify the top and bottom when you open the bag again. This also helps prevent an end from disappearing into the rope pile.

• Can I store my climbing rope in its rope bag between trips?

  Yes, if the rope and bag are clean and completely dry. Do not leave a damp rope sealed or tightly packed away, since it needs airflow to dry properly. After a wet climbing day, remove the rope from the bag and let both dry fully before storing them again.

• How big should a rope bag be for a 70 m or 80 m rope?

  Capacity depends on rope length and diameter as well as how much additional gear you want to carry. A thicker 80 m rope takes considerably more space than a thinner 60 or 70 m rope, so manufacturer rope-length recommendations are more useful than liter capacity alone. If you also want to carry shoes, a harness, or a rack, leave additional room rather than choosing a bag that only barely fits your rope.

How we researched and tested

We’ve been using climbing rope bags and tarps for more than a decade after discovering how much easier they make it to keep ropes clean, organized, and ready to use. Much of our long-term testing has taken place throughout Colorado, particularly along the Front Range while author Chris Meehan was doing fieldwork for his guidebook Colorado Front Range: Best Outdoor Adventures. That has included climbing areas from Shelf Road to Rocky Mountain National Park, along with Boulder Canyon, Clear Creek Canyon, Eldorado Canyon, Ouray, and other crags around the state. We’ve also used rope bags while climbing on sandstone in Utah and granite in California.

We used the bags with ropes of different lengths and diameters for sport, trad, ice, gym, and multi-pitch climbing. At the crag, we compared how comfortably each bag carried, how easily the rope could be flaked onto or packed into the tarp, how much additional climbing gear fit inside, and how quickly everything could be packed again at the end of the day. We also looked at tarp size and visibility, rope-end tie-ins, closures and buckles, pockets and organization, carrying straps and handles, and how well each design kept the rope away from dirt and grit.

Long-term durability was also part of the evaluation. Some of the bags and tarps in this guide have been used regularly for many years, including the Cord Trapper, which allowed us to see how their fabrics, straps, windows, closures, and tarps held up well beyond the initial test period. We did not test dedicated haul bags or canyoneering rope bags in this round, so we do not make recommendations in those categories.

• Sport, trad, ice, gym, and multi-pitch climbing
• Sandstone, granite, and Colorado crags
• Ropes of different lengths and diameters
• Repeated packing and unpacking at the crag
• Years of regular use for durability checks

• Carrying comfort
• Rope and tarp organization
• Capacity for extra climbing gear
• Closures, straps, handles, and pockets
• Protection from dirt and grit

About the author / Why you should trust us

As someone who’s been climbing on and off for the last decade, I’ve found that rope bags are a great way to help keep my ropes organized among a flood of other gear. While a great rope coil looks great, it requires a climber to flake it every time at the crag. With a rope bag and tarp you just pile the rope into the bag and you’re ready to go.

I’m an outdoors writer covering adventure and gear, and I enjoy outdoor activities all year round, including skiing on the slopes and backcountry, snowshoeing, and ice climbing. I’ve authored numerous gear guides for Treeline Review, write for Popular Mechanics, Bicycling Magazine, Popular Science, Backpacker, and other outdoor publications/organizations. 

I have authored multiple outdoor guidebooks, including Colorado’s Best Front Range Adventures: The Greatest Hiking, Climbing, Paddling and More From Denver to Colorado Springs and Fort Collins. In it, I cover the best hiking, mountain biking, climbing, and rafting in the region. 

I’m also the author of Falcon Guide’s Climbing Colorado's Fourteeners: From the Easiest Hikes to the Most Challenging Climbs and edited Justin Lichter’s excellent guide to thru-hiking titled Trail Tested: A Thru-Hiker's Guide To Ultralight Hiking And Backpacking. All of this experience has helped me become a first-rate gearhead and product tester.

At Treeline Review, we strive to offer unbiased reviews to help you find the best product for the price. Treeline Review doesn’t accept sponsored content, native advertising, or paid reviews. I am not sponsored by any companies, nor are any of my family members sponsored by, employees of, or ambassadors of any of the companies in this review.

You can read all of Chris' articles on his author page.

September 15, 2026, updated with a year's worth of testing notes on durability and weatherproofness, to reflect price changes and value, and to remove discontinued products
Home > Gear Reviews > Electronics

Running after dark can be a great way to fit in miles when the days are short or the weather is cooler, but you need enough light to see where you’re going and, especially on roads, to help others see you. We tested running lights for everything from early-morning road runs to dark trail runs to find options that stay comfortable and secure while giving runners the visibility they need.

We tested more than 25 headlamps, handheld lights, wearable lights, and rear visibility lights on roads and trails in nighttime and early-morning conditions. We also tested how securely wearable lights stayed in place, including doing jumping jacks to check for bounce, and used the lights in different weather conditions.

During testing, we compared brightness, visibility to others, battery life, durability, fit, and ease of use. We also paid close attention to comfort while running, how much each light bounced, how well it handled sweat and rain, and whether its beam and battery life made sense for the type of running it was designed for.

Top Pick: The Black Diamond Distance LT 1100 was our favorite overall. Its elastic headband stayed comfortable with minimal bounce in our testing, and the PowerTap setting made a noticeable difference when we wanted to quickly light up more of the trail. We also liked its balance of brightness, battery life, weather resistance, and weight for road runs, trail runs, technical terrain, and longer nighttime outings.

We deem running lights an essential running accessory for running in the dark. If you are getting up early before the sun rises and need an extra light to get started, or running in the evening after work or to avoid the lingering heat, we have you covered so you can see the road or trail in front of you and be seen by others.

We create reader-supported, objective, mission-driven gear reviews independently selected by our editors. This story may contain affiliate links, which help fund our website. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission – without costing you an extra cent. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body! Learn more.

Running lights comparison table

The winners

Best Overall running light: Black Diamond Distance LT 1100

Lumens: 600 max, 1100 Power Tap
Weight: 108 Grams
Battery source: Rechargeable Li-ion battery 
Waterproof: IP67
Rechargeable: USB-C
What we liked: Power Tap 1100 Lumens, longer battery life, multiple color modes, highest waterproof rating of the lamps we tested, great balance of weight vs. lumens
What we didn’t like: Price, battery cannot be charged separately from lamp 

The Black Diamond Distance LT 1100 is our best overall running light since there isn’t a dark running situation where we would leave this one behind. 

This headlamp has four color options: warm white, red, green and blue light. The Black Diamond Distance LT 1100 excels for running on road, trail, highly technical terrain and overnight racing. Of the multiple light colors, red is great for preserving night vision, the green for reading topo maps and the blue for foggy situations. It is also dimmable, and has strobe lighting. 

The battery life is about 4.5 hours on high (600 lumens), which is long enough for most regular night training runs, but not long enough for ultras or marathons. The battery meter lets you know when you are getting low so you won’t be stuck running in the dark.

The PowerTap with 1100 lumens is convenient and easy-to-use, especially for those scary “what is that up ahead” moments only to find out it is a tree stump and not a bear. We found ourselves using the PowerTap feature for fun quite a bit just to test it out, and found it makes a huge difference — you can see the whole trail light up with a decent peripheral. PowerTap is useful for unfamiliar areas of trail to get acquainted quickly and to find our car at the trailhead much faster.  

The elastic headband is comfortable and holds the headlamp in place with minimal bounce. It does hold sweat and needs to be dried out after a hard run. If it gets really wet it needs to be tightened during the run. 

This headlamp has lots of features and it is worth reading the directions to get the most out of this light. For example, the headlamp separates from the battery, but the charging port is on the headlamp, not the battery. So you can’t charge a spare battery on its own without the light attached. This makes it more difficult to get spare batteries charged before a big event. 

The Black Diamond Distance LT 1100 headlamp also won best running headlamp in our Best (and Brightest) Headlamps guide.

Best Brightest Running Light: Black Diamond Distance 1500 Headlamp

Lumens: 800 max, 1500 PowerTap
Weight: 213 grams
Battery source: removable battery 
Waterproof: IP67
Rechargeable: Battery comes off for charging and extras can be purchased
What we liked: Power Tap to 1500 lumens lights up the whole trail in a second
What we didn’t like: Price, most complicated of all the headlamps we tested

This headlamp is a beast; it has the most features and brightest lumens of all the lights we tested. At 213 grams, it is the heaviest of all the headlamps we tested, but it was shockingly comfortable to wear. One reason we find it comfortable is that it comes with a removable top strap for extra support. We found that we didn’t need the extra top strap for most occasions. During testing it was comfortable to wear with the added top strap and allowed us to feel more secure about not losing our headlamp on a technical trail. We were surprised that the top strap didn’t interfere with our long-haired testers' ponytail.

To reach the brightest function of this lamp you literally just tap the side of the light and it gives you full power. It is really fun to play with. We enjoyed it as a way to make the run more fun, power tapping to see what was ahead, and waiting until we ran to the area where the light reached, like a mini fartlek but with light. 

We love the different colored light options in this headlamp: red, blue, and green in addition to the white light. Similar to the Black Diamond Distance 1100, the colored lights help with activities beyond running on the trail like group settings and reading maps.

The battery pack on the back of the lamp helps distribute the weight evenly so it feels well balanced when running. Additional batteries are available for purchase and can be charged separately from the headlamp. The pack at the back curves to hold comfortably against our testers’ heads. This was also comfortable for both long hair and short-haired testers. The optional top strap worked nicely with a ponytail or braid. The red rear blinker is off to the side so a ponytail above it is not obstructing the safety lights. We love that it has the rear blinkers built in for extra safety and visibility. 

You have to read the instructions that come with this light. It has a lot of features and lighting options that are hard to figure out on their own. Some of the other lights we tested were much simpler to use out of the box. We also love that this headlamp came with its own padded zippered case, convenient for storage and travel. This headlamp is on the heavier side so it can be overkill for shorter runs so it likely won’t be the only headlamp you need in your stash.

Best Running Light for Ultrarunning: Petzl NAO RL

Lumens: 900 standard, 1500 reactive
Weight: 145 grams
Battery source: Removable rechargeable battery
Waterproof: IPX4
Rechargeable: USB-C 
What we liked: Reactive Lighting saves battery life, lighter weight than others of similar brightness, rear red light with separate on/off button
What we didn’t like: Harder to wear with ponytail and long hair, no front red light option

Reactive lighting works to conserve battery life and gets brighter when you need it. We had fun testing this by looking at our feet and then the trail far into the distance and watching the light get brighter almost instantly. The reactive lighting is super fast and responsive. And it has a removable battery with extras available for purchase. 

The Petzl NAO RL is lighter weight than the other 1500 headlamps we tested, which is great for overnight racing where grams count. Rear light has a red light bar across the battery that has its own switch for on/off/strobe controls. Single button operation in front of light is simple to use. This headlamp has an optional top strap for added support. We found this headlamp to be well supported without the top strap, but it did add some support when we tested it.

As you cycle through the brightness levels, the headlamp goes into an off mode before coming back on. Some testers did not like that it turned off completely when they wanted to change the brightness, they found it harder to change without stopping or slowing down. 

There is not a red light option on the front of the headlamp, making this a less desirable option for some.

As noted above, the rear battery clip is rather tall and may affect long-haired users with ponytails or braids. The lightweight elastic also got stuck in long hair on occasion.

Best running light for visibility to drivers: BioLite Dash 450

Type: Headlamp
Weight: 2.75 ounces
Max Lumens: 450
Visibility: 90 meters
Battery life: 3 hours on high, 60 hours on low
IP Rating: IPX4
Rechargeable? Internal USB-C battery charges in two hours
What we liked: Visibility in front and behind with backlight, well balanced design, lightweight
What we didn't like: Not as waterproof as other models

The BioLite Dash 450 is the best running light for visibility to drivers because it has a rear light and rear battery. We like this model for road running because the rear light helps you remain visible to traffic behind you. The battery pack is well balanced with the light in the front for little to no bounce while running. 

We also like that the BioLite Dash 450 is easy to charge with a portable battery pack while you run. Since the charging port is in the back, you can easily tuck a portable battery into a running pack and keep your headlamp and your legs running into the night. 

You can read more in our in-depth, long-term review of the BioLite Dash 450 headlamp.

The bright back light on the BioLite Dash 450 headlamp means cars can see you from behind.

The balanced weight between front and back light on the BioLite Dash 450 means you won’t get a headache from the robust back light.

The bright front light on the BioLite Dash 450 running headlamp.

Side view of the BioLite Dash 450 headlamp showing the sweat-wicking headband.

Although both headlamps have back lights, we liked the BioLite Dash 450 more than the BioLite 800 Pro we’ve also tested because it is 2.75 ounces compared to the 5.3 ounces of the 800 Pro, making it significantly lighter and less bulky. 

The BioLite Dash light has five angles and lightly clicks into each one. We like that once you choose an angle it stays put until you change it. 

Both long-haired testers and testers without hair found this to be comfortable to wear against the skin. The elastic band gets a little more grippy the more you sweat, helping it stay in place on long hot runs. We also appreciate the IPX4 water resistance rating so it can stand up to a bit of rain and sweat. 

Overall, with rear light visibility and pass-thru charging, we like this light for running on the road because it is light and comfortable.

Best Lightweight running light: Black Diamond Deploy

Lumens: 325, 180
Weight: 39 grams
Battery source: rechargeable by USB-C 
Waterproof: IPX4
Rechargeable: yes
What we liked: Tiny and packable, wearable under a brimmed hat
What we didn’t like: Fewer lumens, shorter battery life

The Black Diamond Deploy is small and mighty. We loved so many things about it we had a hard time running without it. We loved this light for those late afternoon runs where you aren’t sure if you will make it home before dark, or those morning runs where you start out a few minutes before the sun fully rises. It is great for that in-between season where you aren’t always running in the dark.

This light is designed to be worn under a baseball-style hat and nestle right under the brim, perfect for an incognito light once the sun comes up. No one can tell you have it on.

There is no reason not to stash this light in your running gear, and it is also great as a backup headlamp since it is so light and small. It is very comfortable to wear and does not bounce around. There is a little padding where the light meets your forehead for comfort. 

We really liked this light for road runs where you have some streetlights available to help light your way. However, 325 lumens isn’t quite bright enough on its own to be a standalone light on long trails. 

The battery life is also shorter than others, but the trade-off is that this is super lightweight.

Best Affordable Running Light: Nitecore NU25 MCT 400

Lumens: 400/200
Weight: 50 grams/1.76 ounces
Battery source: Rechargeable
Waterproof: IP66
Rechargeable: USB-C port
What we liked: Lightweight, white/red lights, can switch out the headband
What we didn’t like: No replacement headbands available from Nitecore

The Nitecore NU25 MCT 400 (multi-color temperature) running headlamp is the best affordable running light. Not only is it a fraction of the cost of other running lights, but it has running-specific features that work and make it useful in different kinds of terrain.

The Nitecore NU25 MCT 400 has multiple color temperatures (MCT), improving on the classic Nitecore NU25. The multiple color temperature LED lights allow you to switch between warm, neutral, and cool lights. We like that feature for group runs. Some people find it disorienting and dizzying to run with a group that has a mix of white and yellow lights, so this allows more coordination between runners.

The ability to switch between warm, neutral, and cool lights also gives you more control over visibility in different conditions. For example, the warm light works better in fog and rain. Cool white is better for visibility. Warm, neutral, and cool all come in three different brightness levels and there is also a red light mode.

The white lights can be focused as a spotlight on the right, or a floodlight on the left or both at the same time for maximum output. There is also a solid red light and red strobe mode which is really nice to have in such an affordable model. 

You can read our in-depth review of the Nitecore NU25 MCT 400 headlamp here.

This light is very comfortable to wear and lightweight, making it easy to carry for those runs early or late in the day where you get a little bit of sun and darkness. The headlamp is easy to stash in a pocket or wear over your hat, and is easy to forget it’s even there. 

This headlamp is also super easy to charge with a USB-C port located on the left side. There is a four-dot battery meter as well so you will know when you need to start conserving power. With an IP66 water resistance we felt confident that this light could withstand any sweaty or rainy run. 

There are a few options for headband on the Nitecore NU25 MCT 400 and we tested them all and like the full headband version the best for running. The headband glows in the dark, making this simple to find at night. 

The actual light can be unclipped from the included headband so you can wear the reflective headband by itself or clip it to one you already own and like better. Oftentimes the headband with our headlamps can wear out before the light itself and this makes it simple to switch things up.

For a budget option though, the light, modes, and general comfort on the Nitecore NU 25 MCT 400 is great.

Best Chest Running Light: COAST Hi-Vis Lighted Vest LH150 V2

Category: Be Seen
Type: Wearable Rope Light
Weight: 2.4 ounces
Max Lumens: Not stated
Visibility: Not stated
Battery life: 18 hours
IP Rating: IP54 Splash Resistant
Rechargeable? Rechargeable internal USB-C battery
What we liked: 360 degrees of visibility with the wearable rope light, multiple color options
What we didn't like: Not as bright as other lights, may cause chafing if worn without a barrier under it.

The COAST LH 150 V2 vest is wearable lights for running in the dark or low light conditions. We liked this for populated areas where people and cars might be a concern. There are six different colored light settings, including a multi-colored light. The lights follow the length of the rope all around your torso, making them visible from any angle for better safety. The battery life varies for each color. 

We like that this vest is a lightweight way to help you be seen by others, and they work well when paired with a headlamp or hand-held light. Some runners may find the lights to cause chafing when worn close to the skin–we found that we were unable to wear them with a tank top or short sleeves for that reason. This vest pairs best with a long-sleeve shirt or jacket. The vest is adjustable and can fit over a running pack or vest for longer outings.

If you’re interested in COAST’s voice-activated headlamp, check out our in-depth review on the COAST FL97R Rechargeable Headlamp.

We liked the minimalist design on the COAST Hi-Vis Lighted Vest LH150 V2. It stays out of the way while making arm movements during runs.

The COAST Hi-Vis Lighted Vest LH150 V2 pairs well with a headlamp for front and back visibility.

The COAST Hi-Vis Lighted Vest LH150 V2 lights up in multiple colors. Here, it is shown in red.

We like the flexibility to be able to be seen in a variety of running situations. The lights are brightest closest to the battery, which is located on the center of the back when you are wearing them and slowly taper off in brightness towards the front. We didn’t find this to be a deal breaker since we have secondary illumination on the front most of the time anyway in order to see where we are going. 

These lights also can work to illuminate a dog, or be worn around the neck like a glow necklace–the adjustability of them allows for some creative applications beyond the intended vest style. The clip lets you clip them onto just about anything–we have even used this vest to light up a tent like a set of string lights. 

Overall, with the choice of colors and flexibility of ways to wear, the Coast LH150 V2 vest is our choice for best chest light.

Best Tail running light: Nathan HyperBrite RX

Lumens: 16
Weight: 17 grams
Waterproof: IPX4
Rechargeable: Micro-USB
What we liked: Size and price 
What we didn’t like: So small and light it is easy to lose

Not only is the Nathan HyperBrite RX a cute tiny light, it’s also affordable. We love the simple single button operation and it clips pretty much anywhere you need it to go. We even clipped it to one of our headlamps that did not have a rear light. 

This light has four modes, and a simple click of the button takes you to the next mode. The three blinking modes help increase visibility to drivers on the roads at night and save battery. 

This is a light you wear not for your benefit to see, but to make sure that you are seen from behind. This light does the job. It is bright and lightweight and it is easy to forget that you are wearing it. We have also used these on dog leashes and collars for added visibility for our running buddies.

Other running lights we tested

Nathan Luna Fire 400 RX

Lumens: 400, 300
Weight: 62 grams with the strap
Battery source: Internal rechargeable by USB-C
Waterproof: IPX4
Rechargeable: Yes

The Nathan Luna Fire 400 RX was our former winner for best chest light. We loved the versatility of the Nathan Luna Fire 400 RX. There are multiple ways to wear this light — it comes with an elastic strap that can be adjusted to fit around your chest, waist, or hips. You can also remove the strap and clip it to your shirt or running vest. One Treeline Review tester even tried it on their hat and it worked there as well. 

After another year of testing other options, we decided we liked other chest lights for running better. The Nathan Luna Fire bounced more and has a shorter battery life than most lights. The included chest strap was looser than we liked, but the light can clip on to any strap you already own or a running vest. When we used this on our running vest it was much more stable.

BioLite Range 400

Category: See
Type: Headlamp
Weight: 2.6 ounces
Max Lumens: 400 lumens 
Visibility: 90 meters
Battery life: 6 hours on high, 200 hours on low
IP Rating: IP67
Rechargeable?  Internal USB-C Battery 

The BioLite Range 400 has a single light in the front with a quick-charge battery for those times when you forget to charge after your last outing. We love how comfortable this headlamp is to wear–the band is super soft and has no points of irritation, and we were able to wear it against our skin without any issues. You can read more in our In-Depth Review of the BioLite Range 400 headlamp.

Our testers with long hair didn’t report any issues with hair getting caught in the headlamp, it was also comfortable for our tester without hair to wear against the skin and not have any points of irritation.

This headlamp has a well-balanced build for running without any movement from the headlamp. It stays where you need it. The Range has a more adjustable tilt compared to previous BioLite models, like the 800 Pro and the Dash 450. There are five positions that click into place with a little more range between each click. 

We also like the quick charge USB-C option. Charging 8 minutes gives you one hour of use on high. This is perfect for those times when the battery is drained and you still want to get a quick run in. By the time you drive to the trailhead, you should be able to get a decent amount of charge on your headlamp for a one-hour run. 

This model is also IP67 waterproof submersible, so it is great for those stormy running situations. 

The reason the BioLite Range 400 didn’t win any categories is it isn't as bright as other running lights we tested and isn't as affordable or lightweight as other 400 lumen options. We think it is a great hiking and everyday headlamp, but for runners, we think it is worth getting something more specialized. However, this was the most comfortable headlamp to wear long term while running–so comfortable we have even fallen asleep while wearing it–and a worthwhile option to consider.

BioLite 800 Pro

Lumens: 800, 500
Weight: 150 grams
Battery source: 3,000 mAh Li-ion Rechargeable Battery
Waterproof: IPX4
Rechargeable: yes, and pass-through charging works with included cable 
What we liked: Pass-through charging and comfortable band
What we didn’t like: Heavier than others with similar lumens

The BioLite 800 Pro is highlighted in our Best Reflective Gear for Running in the Dark guide.  This is a great running headlamp, the band is the softest and most comfortable of all the headlamps we’ve tested. We love how it feels next to our skin — there was no need to add a layer underneath it. The band also reacts well with sweat, increasing in stickiness a bit so we didn’t have to make as many adjustments to it while running and sweating. 

See our in-depth review of the BioLite 800 Pro headlamp for more information.

We appreciate the large area of rear lights for visibility on the road and trails. The rear light is controlled with a separate button so you can turn it on and off as needed to save battery. Having both front and rear lights is a plus, since that is less gear to remember out the door.

Additionally, we love the pass-through charging on this headlamp, allowing us the ability to run all night with it by connecting it to an external battery pack. We also appreciate how bright this light is and how well it lights up the trails.

This was a contender for best overall, but we found the rear pack a little bulky, especially when you compare it to the Black Diamond Distance 1100 which has more lumens with no rear battery pack. It also isn’t as water resistant as the Black Diamond 1100, which for sweat and rain is an important factor for us. 

This light is a solid choice for any runner, it is bright enough for most users and has multiple light modes for types of trail and road.

Nitecore UT27 800 Pro

Lumens: 800, 500
Weight: 74 grams
Battery Source: Removable Battery
Waterproof: IP66
Rechargeable: Yes and AAA batteries can be used in a pinch
What we Liked: Has both warm and cool-toned white light, lightweight for 800 lumens
What we didn’t like: Durability concerns

The Nitecore UT27 800 Pro is bright and lightweight for its 800 lumens. Although it is an Amazon's Choice pick and bestseller, we didn't find it to be as good as other running lights we tested. 

It has three color choices for light, a white and a yellow (warm) light in addition to a red light. The two buttons at the top are labeled W for the white light and Y for the yellow light, making it very simple to use out of the box. This was the only running light we tested with two button options for light like this. The yellow (warm) light is designed for rain, snow or foggy conditions. We also liked using the yellow light on open trails. One tester commented that yellow light may be better for those who get migraines or nausea when running with a headlamp. 

We found the battery compartment difficult to open and not intuitive to use, it feels very flimsy — so much so that we are worried about breaking it and long-term durability. Our testers with larger hands also had a really hard time getting it open.  

Also, we needed to wear a barrier between this headlamp and our skin to make it comfortable. The band has a single line of silicone that dug into our forehead and left an indentation after running. Other bands had different patterns of silicone and used different materials, so we didn’t have this issue with others.

Petzl IKO CORE

Lumens: 500, 100
Weight: 79 grams
Battery Source: Removable Petzl Core Battery
Waterproof: IPX4
Rechargeable: Yes and AAA batteries can be used in a pinch
What we liked: Very lightweight and bright
What we didn’t like: Uncomfortable

The Petzl IKO CORE is extremely popular with trail runners for its ultralight build. It can be worn around the neck or as a headlamp. It has a unique design with a silicone band that holds it in place. One of our testers wore this headlamp on a 100-mile overnight ultramarathon. They really liked the lightweight band and that it did not hold onto sweat as they were running. This headlamp allows for micro adjustments of the angle instead of a few preset clicks. Overall this was not a winner for us but it is still an excellent running light, and very bright at 500 lumens. 

However, our glasses-wearing tester found this really uncomfortable to wear with their glasses. The rear battery pack was also harder for our long-haired tester to wear comfortably without getting hair stuck in the cord.

Another tester noted that after extended wear the band rubbed a raw spot on their ear. Comfort could be a tradeoff for high lumens in this ultralight design.

Nathan Polaris Hand Torch 400 RX

Lumens: 400, 300
Weight: 134 grams
Battery Source: internal rechargeable battery Micro-USB
Waterproof: IPX4
Rechargeable: Yes
What we liked: Bright, good in snow and rain, red rear blinker
What we didn’t like: Hard to use hands while holding it

One of our testers has an older version of the Nathan Polaris Hand Torch 400 RX running flashlight that they have used for over ten years (and it still charges!). This flashlight has a rear red blinking light and an angled front light. It has a comfortable hand strap so you don’t have to worry about dropping it or gripping too hard while you are running.

We love this light during snow or rain storms; the lower angle allows us to see the ground better than headlamps. This new version is brighter with a nice focused beam and was comfortable to run with for testers with  large and smaller hands. 

For road running we carry this in our street-adjacent hand for extra visibility to cars. The rear blinker light helps increase visibility to drivers on the road. This is a great entry-level light for those who are used to running with a traditional flashlight with the added benefit of a comfortable strap so you can relax your grip.

As much as we love this light, it wasn’t our winner because you are still holding a flashlight in your hand and using this prevents you from being able to easily check maps on your phone or GPS watch like we could with the Knuckle Lights Advanced.

Nathan Lightbender RX

Lumens: 6
Weight: 43 grams
Battery Source: Internal battery Micro-USB
Waterproof: IPX4
Rechargeable: Yes

We liked that the Nathan LightBender RX safety light features three colors of steady or blinking light so we could be visible while running. It also features a larger visible area so when worn around the arm you are visible from more angles. 

However, we found this uncomfortable to wear with short sleeves or tank tops and needed to layer a sleeve or jacket underneath it.

Nathan HyperBrite Orb Strobe

Lumens: 16
Weight: 23 grams
Battery Source: Coin Battery CR2032
Waterproof: IPX4
Rechargeable: No

The Nathan HyperBrite Orb Strobe is easy to clip on and affordable. Four light modes allow you to be seen. It can clip onto the back of a waistband, running vest, hip pack, or even a hat.   

However, we prefer the newer version with a rechargeable battery.

Knuckle Lights Tail Light Safety Blinker

Lumens: Unknown
Weight: 19 grams
Battery Source: Coin Battery CR2032
Waterproof: Not stated

The Knuckle Lights Tail Light Safety Blinker is the smallest light we’ve tested. It has a red and white light. This light attaches with a magnet and has a loop which works really nicely on the back of a running vest.

While a great size, we would prefer a rechargeable version of this light. We also felt that it could be a little brighter.

What to look for in a running light

Brightness (Lumens)

The lumens will dictate the brightness of the light. Runners will want between 300 and more than 500, depending on what time of day they are running, where they are running, and how technical the terrain is.

I like to consider the color of the light. A seemingly white light can be either yellow, white or blue in tone. The color of the light can make a difference especially if you are prone to headaches or nausea. I find that when I am using multiple lights it is best if they are all a similar color, mixing a blue headlamp with a yellow handheld light can make me nauseous. 

Some of the lights we tested, like the Nitecore UT27, have an option to switch between white and yellow light. You can then mix the headlight with a handheld or waist light that matches those colors.

Beam pattern

Many of the headlamps we tested have the option for a focused beam or for a floodlight or a mix of both. The focused beam is great for spotting obstacles on the trail directly in front of you but you lose peripheral vision. Using the floodlight allows for excellent peripheral vision and spotting turns on technical trails but you get less intense light right in front. Using both allows for the best of both lights, letting you see your surroundings and see the trail in front of you nice and clear. 

The handheld and wearable lights are mostly a focused beam, making them a great addition to a headlamp with floodlighting. 

Battery life

One of the most important factors after brightness is the battery life. Some of the ultralight models that we tested lacked long battery life and would not last a full overnight run. This may not matter to a runner whose runs are never longer than the shortest battery life expected on a lamp. Unlike backpacking lights where charging can be a hindrance at night, if you are running and going back to civilization every night it is easy to plug in your lamp and keep it charged for the next run. 

Many of the lights we tested have a reserve battery, to prevent you from running out of light during your run. The lights will only go to full power when the battery is above a certain percentage of charge. This is another reason to always keep them fully charged before each run.

Rechargeability

Most of the lights we tested are rechargeable or feature rechargeable batteries. This is an important factor that we consider as disposable batteries have a long-term impact on the environment. There were a few exceptions but those were mostly the tail lights and the nickel batteries last a very long time before they need replacing. 

Weight

After considering brightness and battery life, weight is probably the next on the list in terms of  importance. The brighter the headlamp and the longer the battery life, the heavier it will typically be, though there are a few exceptions in the mix. You just have to find a balance  of these three factors that works for your needs. For example, the Black Diamond Deploy is one of the lightest lights that we tested, but the battery life is also one of the shortest as well as the lumens are some of the lowest. 

Comfort and fit

The lights we tested vary in style and considerations need to be looked at as far as how you plan to wear a headlamp, with or without a hat or if you have long or short hair. We tested the headlamps on both long and short-haired individuals and with and without hats to see how they performed. 

Weather resistance (Waterproof/Weatherproof)

Most of the lights we tested came with an IP rating of water resistance. If you are someone who perspires a lot or if you plan to run in a lot of rain and snow this is a very important factor to consider. Having the right rain gear for running can help protect you and your electronics. See our tips for running in the rain for more ways you can keep you and your gear safe in wet weather.

Durability

There may be a trade-off between durability and weight in some of the lights, lightweight lights may have more plastic instead of metal components and require more care to prevent breakage. 

Ease of use

One button, two buttons, three buttons, multiple modes… If you don’t plan on using all of the fancy modes that some of the higher-end models come with, a simpler one-button model might be the right choice. For shorter runs we preferred lights that were easy to charge with easy to use basic features.

Visibility features (Reflectivity/Additional Lighting)

The rear lights come with a few different options. You can have a steady light or a blinking light. The blinking light preserves the battery life and also has the benefit of being more noticeable to cars driving by. 

We like using the steady light when we are running with a group on a trail and our running mates find the steady light nicer to follow than the blinking lights. On the road, we want to be seen and noticed by fast-moving cars and the blinker is helpful. Most testers were unable to see their own blinky light since it was in the back and were able to run unbothered by any blinking.

To learn more about how to stay visible in the dark, check out our Best Reflective Gear for Running in the Dark guide.

Adjustability (Beam angle/Brightness levels)

Most of the lights we tested have some way to change the angle and direction of the light. Where you place the light will depend on your personal preference, speed, and terrain. We usually like to be able to see a few seconds ahead of us and depending on how fast we are going that may be a shorter or longer distance ahead. 

Size and portability

These lights are generally sized bigger the brighter they are and the longer the battery lasts. Get the light that makes sense for the type of running you plan to be doing. 

One of our testers runs in the morning and only needs a headlamp for about 30 minutes before the sun rises, something less robust like the Black Diamond Deploy is perfect in this situation. Those of us who end up running later in the evening and even starting in the dark need a brighter light, and smaller lights aren’t going to cut it for hours in the dark.

Price and value

Our affordable winner is a great option for any runner, if you aren’t sure that night running is for you, you can start with the affordable winner and then add a waist light or handheld as you get more into it. The ability to add lights to your setup can help keep the financial investment lower. 

How to choose a running light

The best running light for you depends first on where and when you run. A road runner who mainly needs to be visible to drivers has different needs from someone running technical trails in complete darkness. Think about whether you need a light primarily to see, to be seen, or both.

Match the brightness to where you run

You do not necessarily need the brightest light available. For well-lit roads, a lower-output light may be enough, especially if visibility to drivers is your main concern. Dark trails and uneven terrain generally call for more light and a beam that lets you see farther ahead as well as around you.

Adjustable brightness is useful because conditions can change during a run. You may want more light on a technical trail or unfamiliar section, then less once you reach a road, neighborhood, or the first light of dawn.

Think about battery life

Battery life matters most in relation to how long you actually run. A light for short weekday runs does not need the same runtime as one you plan to use for long trail runs or overnight events.

Also pay attention to how easy it is to recharge the light and whether you can carry a backup. I like small backup lights such as the Knuckle Lights One because they are easy to stash in a pocket or pack if I am going to be out for a long time.

Check comfort and bounce

A running light can have great specs and still be annoying if it moves around once you start running. Fit matters especially with headlamps and chest lights.

When possible, try moving around in the light before buying it. I have even done jumping jacks to see whether a headlamp stays put. If you run in winter, check the fit over a beanie or hat as well.

Consider sweat and weather

If you run in hot weather, sweat resistance matters. If you regularly run in rain or snow, look at the light’s water-resistance rating and make sure the controls are still easy to use when your hands are cold or wet.

The position of the light can also matter in bad weather. A lower light, such as a handheld, waist, or chest light, may create less glare from rain or snow than a beam positioned at eye level.

Choose a style that fits how you run

Headlamps are convenient because they keep your hands free and point where you look. Handheld lights put the beam lower to the ground and can make changes in terrain easier to see. Chest and waist lights offer another hands-free option, while clip-on and rear lights are mainly useful for helping other people see you.

You may also find that one light does not cover every situation. I use different lights depending on the run, and smaller lights can be useful as backups or for things like late-night dog walks.

Tips for running with a light

• Position the light properly: It may take a few minutes of your run to figure out the proper positioning for your lights. Depending on your speed, you may want the beam  of the light to be farther in front of you rather than focusing on your feet. Think of where you normally look when you run, and start with aiming the light there. 

• Use multiple lights: There are many advantages to having multiple lights at once. With two lights you don’t have to stress about burning out the battery since you have a backup. Using two front lights like a headlamp and waist light or handheld can increase the depth of field especially for technical trails. I always recommend wearing a tail light so you are visible from behind. They are affordable and lightweight.

• Check battery life: Most of the lights we tested only work on full power when they are fully charged and then they go into a reserve mode with lower power as they get closer to running out of battery. This reserve mode is super helpful so you are less likely to get stuck someplace in the dark. To avoid having to use reserve mode at the beginning of your run make sure the light is at full power, if they are locked you can usually tap a button to trigger the battery meter to blink the current charge. 

• Adjust brightness: This is a fun one. You are either going to be running in the dark and hopefully watching the sun come up, which means you can start with the brightest light and slowly taper it off as the sun rises. This method is also recommended for any runs that start in the full dark sky, start with a bright light as your eyes adjust, it becomes easier to taper off to the lower light levels. Some evening runners will start with a lower light setting as the sun sets and increase brightness as it gets dark on an evening run.  

• Secure the light for comfort: To preserve the straps on your lights, try to use them on a looser setting and tighten them up as needed. Some of the lights were more comfortable under a headband or clothing. 

• Test in different conditions: I tested all the lights in a dark bedroom with no mirrors before trying them on a run. I wanted to make sure I was going to have enough light to see the trails once it got really dark. I also tested them in my backyard at night running in place and making sure I was able to see the light and that my hat/hands/knees weren’t blocking the beam.

• Carry a backup: If you have two lights you already have a backup. Some of the lights we tested have extra batteries and they are lightweight to carry for long runs.

• Mind your pace: Don’t expect to run your usual pace at night, especially at first. It is slower for most people,  even accomplished ultrarunners slow their pace at night. It is harder to see, so don’t be discouraged.  

• Use red light mode: Red light mode is wonderful for preserving night vision, and for pre- or post-run hangouts with your running crew. Red light is also helpful for sneaky off-trail bathroom breaks.

• Stay visible to others: The tail light and rear lights on some headlamps are essential for any nighttime road running so you can be seen. On the trail, the blinky lights can help runners behind you keep track of you and make you visible to SAR if needed in an emergency. 

• Snow and rain: Handheld and waist lights are generally better than headlamps for snow and rain. The lower angle to the ground helps cut the “Star Wars” effect of the snow or rain falling. Again, clip-on lights can be great for this. Use the focused spot beam instead of the floodlight. Sometimes lower lumens can make it easier to see. Running in snow and rain are usually going to be slower runs, but it can be a really fun experience. 

FAQ

• How many lumens do I need for night running?

  Most runners need at least 500 lumens for safe trail running in complete darkness, while road runners can get by with 300-400 lumens. Trail runners tackling technical terrain should aim for 600-800+ lumens for adequate visibility of obstacles and trail features. Road runners benefit from lower lumen lights since they have more predictable surfaces and often some ambient lighting. Consider your typical running environment - urban areas with streetlights require less brightness than remote forest trails.

• Should I use a headlamp or handheld light for running?

  Both can work well, and some runners use more than one type of light. Headlamps keep your hands free and can provide both focused and peripheral light. Handheld, waist, and chest lights put the beam lower to the ground, which can improve depth perception and can also be useful when running in rain or snow.

• How long should my running light battery last?

  Choose lights with battery life that exceeds your longest typical run by at least 25% for safety margin. Most recreational night runs last 1-3 hours, making lights with 4+ hour battery life ideal. Ultra-runners need 8+ hours or swappable batteries for overnight events. Battery life decreases significantly on maximum brightness, so factor in your typical usage patterns. Many lights have reserve modes that provide dim emergency lighting when the main battery depletes.

• What's the difference between flood and spot beam?

  A spot beam concentrates light farther ahead, while a flood beam spreads light across a wider area. We found both useful for running. A wider flood can help you see more of the trail around you, while a focused beam can help you see farther ahead. Some of the lights we tested let you use both.

• Do I need a rear light for running at night?

  A rear light can help drivers and other runners see you from behind, which is especially useful for road running. We also like rear lights when running with a group on trails. Some headlamps have a rear light built in, while small clip-on tail lights can be added to clothing or a running pack.

• How do I prevent my running light from bouncing?

  Ensure proper fit with snug but comfortable straps and consider your light's weight distribution. Headlamps with rear battery packs typically bounce less than front-heavy designs. Tighten straps gradually during your run as you warm up and sweat increases grip. For chest or waist lights, position them close to your center of gravity. Very lightweight options under 2 ounces rarely cause bouncing issues regardless of fit.

• Can I run with a running light in rain or snow?

  Many of the lights we tested have water-resistance ratings and can handle sweat or wet weather, but the level of protection varies by model. Check the light’s IP rating if you regularly run in rain or snow. We also found that handheld, waist, and chest lights can work well in precipitation because their lower beam angle can reduce glare from rain or snow directly in front of your face.

• Should I use red light mode while running?

  Red light preserves night vision and shows courtesy to other runners, but provides less trail visibility than white light. Use red light when approaching other runners, in group settings, or when you need to preserve night vision for stargazing. Switch back to white light for technical terrain where you need maximum visibility. Red strobes work well for rear visibility lights while being less distracting than white strobes.

Running lights care and maintenance tips

Most of the lights we tested have rechargeable batteries. It is important to not “overcharge” the batteries and unplug them once they are fully charged. We like to throw ours on the charger post-run and check back after an hour or two so it is ready to go for the next run. 

Your headlamp will probably be pretty sweaty after a good run, so you will want to make sure it is dry before putting it away for storage. Many of the lights we tested came with storage bags. We use the bags to keep everything together and to protect the light from getting scratched or scuffed. 

If your light has a lock setting, use it so you don’t accidentally drain the battery before your next run. There is nothing worse than getting ready for an evening run and realizing your lamp is dead. Likewise, if you decide to get extra batteries for your headlamp keep the extras fully charged and check the battery life on your extras before you head out. 

Most of these lights have rechargeable batteries that can drain in cold weather. I left a headlamp in my car in winter and found the battery dead, even though I had fully charged it last time after using it. I try to store my lights inside away from extreme temperature swings. For tips on winter running, check out our guide on How to Run in Winter — 13 Tips for Running in the Cold.

The elastic straps can wear out with excess salt from sweat. Depending on your waterproof rating you may need to spot clean your headband to keep it in top shape. A damp washcloth can do wonders removing sweat and salt. Make sure it is fully dry after cleaning.

How we researched and tested

We spent hours researching lights for running and narrowed down our list to search for the best running lights. We read reviews on other sites, and talked to other runners, sometimes for hours, about their favorite lights and why they love them. We also considered lights for different types of running, weather, heat and cold, and terrain. 

We narrowed down our list to our top running lights, and tested more than 25 running lights over three years. We took lights out running on the trail and road in a variety of conditions and weather. We did jumping jacks with wearable lights to see if they would fall off or bounce around. 

We ran mostly in the evening hours into nighttime, getting  to enjoy the stars outside, along with getting to see all the nocturnal animals on the trails. We also drained the batteries and charged them back up to see how easy they were to charge.

• Night and early-morning runs
• Road and trail running
• Jumping-jack bounce tests
• Battery drain and recharge cycles
• Different weather and temperatures

• Brightness and beam visibility
• Visibility to other people
• Battery life and charging
• Comfort, fit, and bounce
• Durability and weather resistance

About the author / Why you should trust us 

Sara discovered running in high school and never really stopped. What started as a way to spend time with her dad before school in the mornings morphed into a lifelong love for the sport. She loves running marathons and half marathons both on road and trail and has a wall full of finisher medals. A self-proclaimed night owl, she won’t be found running before sunrise unless she has paid for a race entry. Sara has spent many hours running at night. She loves the solitude on the trails and the cooler weather in the summer. In addition to running, she can be found skiing, snowboarding in winter and backpacking or thru-hiking with her dog in summer. As a former member of SAR, she believes that safety should always be a priority in any outdoor adventure and having lights for running, especially in winter when the days are so short, is essential.

To see all of Sara Kruglinski’s stories, check her author page.

September 15th, 2026, updated with another year's worth of testing to verify rankings and 3 new pairs tested
Home > Gear Reviews > Climbing

A good beginner climbing shoe should feel secure enough for precise footwork without being so tight or aggressive that it makes learning uncomfortable. For this guide, we focused on shoes that balance comfort, grip, support, and durability for new climbers learning technique in the gym and outdoors.

Our lead tester is a certified climbing instructor and former climbing gym manager who has taught hundreds of beginners. For this guide, she and other testers wore the shoes on gym routes, bouldering problems, and moderate outdoor climbs, with testers representing different foot widths and climbing experience levels.

We evaluated each shoe for fit and comfort, grip, edging performance, support, sensitivity, break-in, and durability. We also considered how easy each shoe is to put on and adjust, how forgiving the fit is for newer climbers, and whether it provides enough performance for a beginner to keep progressing without immediately needing an upgrade.

Top Pick: The La Sportiva Finale (men's and women's) earns our Best Overall award. It stood out for its comfortable, supportive fit, dependable grip and edging, durable construction, and versatile performance for beginners climbing both indoors and outside.

Related: Best Climbing Harnesses

We write mission-driven gear reviews. To find the best gear, we combine expert reviews, everyday user opinions, and rigorous independent trail testing—never native ads or sponsored posts. We are 100% reader-supported and may make a small commission from some qualifying affiliate links. Learn more.

Comparison Tables

Men's

Women's

We note any discounts we see on our Deals page, which is updated daily.

Climbing Curious? See our other Climbing articles:

• How to Build a Home Climbing Wall

• Best Climbing Belay Devices

• Best Climbing Chalk

• Best Climbing Chalk Bags

• Best Climbing Rope Bag

• Best Climbing Ropes

The Best Beginner Climbing Shoes

Best Overall Beginner Climbing Shoe: La Sportiva Finale

Women's and Men's

Rubber Type: 5 mm Vibram XS Edge 
Lining: Unlined 
Upper Material: Leather/Microfiber 
Closure: Lace-up
Can be Resoled: Yes
Type: Neutral
Sizing: Runs slightly small
What we liked: comfortable enough for beginners but aggressive enough for intermediate climbers, a shoe that sticks with you as you become a more skilled climber, dialed in fit, grippy sole, value for the price
What we didn't like: may rub some people's Achilles

The La Sportiva Finale is the winner for best overall beginner climbing shoe for its 5 mm stiff and grippy sole and a snug and secure fit for beginners that doesn't feel painfully compressed, but still feels precise.

The Finale's foot-conforming leather upper and traditional lace closure allow for dialed fit that is comfortable for beginners while also offering a lot of performance. Plus, unlike many climbing shoes in this price range, its construction is durable. With a hint of downturn, the Finale also makes a great “bridge shoe” to more technical climbing, so you can stick with this shoe as you gain more skills and strength. At $139.00, the Finale is well worth the price for beginners and intermediate climbers. It’s also the winner for Best for Beginners in our Best Indoor Climbing Shoes and Best Bouldering Shoes guide.

You can read more in our in-depth review of the La Sportiva Finale climbing shoes.

The La Sportiva Finale has a sharp and stiff rubber sole that is great for durability but has less sensitivity than a thinner soled shoe.

• Sole and durability

  We found the Vibram XS Edge rubber sole on the Finale to be sharp and stiff, adding to the longevity of the shoe. One of the ways rock climbing shoes fail over time is that the rubber loses this stiffness, but we don’t see that happening with the Finale for a long time. A stiffer shoe is well-suited for those getting into the sport as it provides support for foot muscles and ligaments. And as eco-minded climbers, we appreciate that this shoe can be resoled. 

  On the other side of the coin, the thick 5 mm rubber offers less sensitivity than a shoe with thinner rubber on holds. Most climbers getting into the sport will value the support of a stiffer shoe, but if sensitivity is important to you, the Black Diamond Momentum (review below) might be a better choice.

• Comfort and closures

  The La Sportiva Finale has a lace closure, which we think is the way to go for a beginner and intermediate climbing shoe. For beginners, we recommend prioritizing comfort. That means not sizing down like you're in ballet shoes (as some beginners are tempted to do). We recommend going with something closer to your true size.  

  Some climbers may be drawn to velcro straps for the ease of getting in and out of them. We respect that. 

  But for beginners, we think you'll want to opt for shoes that you need to take off less often. If your feet hurt when you wear climbing shoes, you'll start associating climbing with pain instead of with fun. Each time you take off your climbing shoes, that's an opportunity for you to stop climbing and go home. To stick with the sport, you'll want to choose shoes you can wear comfortably. 

  That's why we don't think of the Finale's laces as a dealbreaker. Velcro is the quickest loosening and tightening closure. But you can often get a more dialed fit by using laces. 

  As you grow into climbing, if you get into climbing some cracks, the laces can keep the profile of the shoe down and more maneuverable in tight places.

• Sizing and fit

  As far as sizing goes, the Finale is more of a “performance fit”—that is, they fit tightly. With its leather uppers, however, the tightness eases up after being broken in. 

  Based on our experience, we recommend beginners stay close to your true size or size up half a size for comfort.

  We’re impressed by the overall design of the Finale, though the small V-shaped slit on the Achilles tended to rub my foot personally. Should you encounter rubbing, climbing or athletic tape can help with rubbing. To help choose how to size your shoe, see our section below on how to fit and size a climbing shoe.

• Our verdict

  The Finale is truly a great option for beginners and will likely be a shoe you own and use for a long time.

  The specs, fit, performance in our testing, and supporting reviews from other media and customers alike make the Finale the clear winner for overall best beginner climbing shoe. 

  It's a shoe that will last and allow you to grow into it over time so that you’re not purchasing a more aggressive shoe a few months later.

Best Affordable Climbing Shoe: La Sportiva Tarantulace

Women's and Men's

Rubber Type: 5 mm FriXion RS 
Lining: Unlined
Upper Material: Leather
Closure: Lace-up
Can be Resoled: Yes
Fit: Runs slightly large (half size big)
Type: Neutral
What we liked: Shape, comfort
What we didn’t like: Thick rubber can affect foot placement

The Best Affordable Beginner Climbing Shoe is the La Sportiva Tarantulace. Priced at a delightful $99—it’s not only one of the most affordable options out there, but delivers on performance. 

The shape is great for comfort, making this a great introductory shoe, or a shoe for long days of climbing. 

The Tarantulace is a classic beginner-to-intermediate shoe often mentioned by outdoor media as a good option for someone looking to stop using gym rental shoes and invest in their first pair of rock climbing shoes. 

It won our Best Affordable climbing shoe award because it is a great value. While it does not have the same performance as our higher-priced winning recommendations, it holds its own when up against other models twice the price.

The lace-up closure system allows you to adjust the entire shoe, which is a helpful way to learn how fit impacts performance.

• Fit, closure, and comfort

  The Tarantulace has a neutral last—a small arch in the underfoot—which works great for a beginner climber transitioning into intermediate levels. 

  The lace-up closure is great for adjusting the whole shoe, especially as folks get into climbing and familiarize themselves with the parts of a rock climbing shoe and how they impact performance. 

  The leather upper stretches, so it remains comfortable no matter what type of climb you’re doing. That comfort will benefit you on gym climbs or bouldering as well when you start gearing up for longer multi-pitch climbs.

• Sizing

  In terms of sizing as a whole, I ordered a half-size down from my street size and found them a touch snug at first. After breaking them in, they fit exactly like I want them to fit, though. My only sizing complaint was that the heel cup seemed to fit loose on this model. To help choose how to size your shoe, see our section below on how to fit and size a climbing shoe. 

  One thing to note about these shoes is the rubber is also quite thick, which many beginners find a benefit for durability as they learn footwork. However, it can make it challenging when attempting precise foot placement. Still, the thick rubber may be beneficial for durability, which may help save you money as you climb more and more.

Best Velcro Beginner Climbing Shoes: Black Diamond Momentum

Women's and Men's

Rubber Type: 3.75 mm (men’s) and 3.5 mm (women’s) Black Label rubber
Lining: Polyester suede
Upper Material: Microsuede polyester
Closure: Velcro strap/hook-and-loop
Can be Resoled: Yes
Type: Neutral
Sizing: Runs small
What we liked: Breathability, stretchiness
What we didn’t like: Outsole rubber inferior on edging

Black Diamond’s classic beginner shoe, the Momentum, shows up on a lot of lists for a reason: it has some awesome features for climbers looking to transition out of a rental shoe. The Momentums also have a solid beginner price, too: they’re competitive with our Budget Pick, the La Sportiva Tarantulace. At $130, it's hard to beat the Momentums. That is another reason why it’s often cited as a good choice for a beginner shoe.

The Momentums have been around for years and were previously our vegan winner. In the latest iteration, however, they contain suede in the upper and liner. 

A well-used older model Black Diamond Momentum—the strap version wins our Best Velcro beginner climbing shoe award

The knit on the Black Diamond Momentum is breathable and comfortable.

The Black Diamond Momentum is a great value for a beginner climbing shoe.

• Material and comfort

  The microsuede polyester upper and knit tongue offer breathability and all-day comfort. In testing, we found the Black Diamond Momentum to be a comfortable, neutral shoe. The knit stretches to your feet but the liner makes it so it doesn’t feel too stretchy. In fact, customer reviews report it runs small. 

• Sizing

  The biggest complaint we saw across the board in reviews was the inconsistency with sizing. We also had this issue. I usually wear a size 38, and decided to test a 39 (US W 7.5)—and they were still quite small. If I were to order again, I would even consider going to a EUR 40. To help choose how to size your shoe, see our section below on how to fit and size a climbing shoe.

• Climbing gear packages available

  It’s available in both men’s and women’s versions and even a kids’ version. You can also get the Momentum Harness Package, which has a climbing harness, ATC belay device, locking carabiner, chalk bag, and climbing chalk (but no shoes).

• Outsole

  In testing, we noticed the fabric can feel sticky if your feet are prone to getting sweaty. The Black Label rubber on the outsole also didn’t work as well as other shoes on edging performance (meaning placing the shoe on a pronounced edge of rock). While any part of the shoe can be used for edging, it’s most commonly done with the inside of the shoe, under the ball of your big toe. See thephoto below for what edging looks like.

  That being said, the Black Diamond Momentum is not designed for the high precision footwork you would find in a high-performance shoe. It’s a beginner shoe designed to make you feel comfortable getting into climbing and we think it does that job well. 

  If the Momentums don’t work for you or you’re looking for something with more precision, check out Evolvs. Much of their line is vegan and the Defy and Elektra Velcro versions are our vegan climbing shoe winners (see reviews below). They're just a little more expensive. 

• Our verdict

  There's a reason that the Momentum is one of the highest-rated beginner climbing shoes at REI and Backcountry: a balance of comfort, accessibility, and price. As you'd expect for being a budget shoe, it didn't perform as well as shoes we tested that cost more. But we think that is fine and you still get a lot of value for the price.

  There's a lot to love about this shoe. At $130, even increased pricing in other outdoor gear in the last couple of years, it's hard to beat the Momentums. 

Best Beginner Climbing Shoe For Bouldering: Five Ten Niad Moccasym

Rubber Type:  4.2 mm Stealth® C4
Lining: Unlined
Upper Material: Suede leather
Closure: Elastic slipper
Can be Resoled: Yes
Type: Moderate
Sizing: Runs small 0.5 to 1 size
What we liked: Toe rubber, good on edges
What we didn’t like: Toe rubber wears out quickly, break-in period.

The Five Ten NIAD Moccasym is the best beginner climbing shoe for bouldering. Although it is marketed for intermediate climbers, we find that many beginner boulderers advance quickly and these are among the best affordable slipper-style climbing shoes we tested. 

The NIAD Moccasym is an easy on-and-off slipper that is convenient for bouldering or short climbs. Since bouldering relies on shorter power moves and rest periods in between, having a shoe that comes on and off quickly is ideal. 

This is one of those pairs of shoes that climbers keep buying again and again. There are a lot of benefits to starting off your climbing career with “the one” you’ll keep for years.

Although this model is popular among intermediate and advanced boulderers, we think the NIAD is absolutely worth it for all levels of climbing. We especially recommend them for the type of beginner climbers who already know they are dedicated to the sport, come into climbing already fit, and want to excel fast.

And in the case of the Five Ten NIAD Moccasym, if you're a boulderer, there is a good chance this climbing shoe will be "the one."

• Sole and rubber

  The patented Stealth C4 rubber from Five Ten is a real crowd pleaser on all of their shoes. It’s sticky, not too thick, and really well engineered. Unlike the previous model, the latest edition has toe rubber running up the top of the foot—which is great for toe hooks. Compared to older models, it's gone from a softer to stiffer midsole, which has less sensitivity. 

  It's worth noting that some people who have been buying these shoes for a long time find that sizing is trickier with the rubber on the upper. No matter whether this is your first pair or 10th pair, be sure to size accordingly (more on that below).

  Most customer reviews also found the toe rubber wore out or delaminated quicker than the rest of the shoe’s rubber. However, like most of the shoes in this review, they can be resoled, so you can keep using them for a while.

• Sizing

  As far as sizing goes, prepare to potentially go a full size up from your street shoe, as these are going to stretch quite a bit given the leather upper. 

  It's worth noting that the Niad doesn't get as high of customer reviews as other shoes because of the sizing. The Niad is one of those models that is loved so much, people buy it again and again. So when the sizing changes, it can be upsetting.

• Upper

  There are a few downsides to the Niad. Forewarning: the leather upper will likely dye your feet red for the first couple of uses, which can be mildly alarming—but it does rinse off.

• New name

  If you've been around the climbing world for awhile, you may know the Five Ten Mocassym by its former name, which was a long-standing bestseller for the brand. 

  The Five Ten Niad Moccasym shoe is a new twist on an old classic, the Five Ten Anasazi Moccasym (which referred to an outdated term for the Ancestral Pueblo and was renamed–you can read more about this in our Mesa Verde article). The very similar Niad Moccasym is a great all-around slip-on shoe that doesn’t sacrifice any comfort.

• Design changes

  As mentioned above, the Niad doesn't get as high of customer reviews as you would expect given this has been a beloved shoe for almost a decade. Upon looking into it, adding rubber over the big toe was divisive among long-time Niad fans. The Niad now is more of a high-performance version than earlier versions, which can impact fit (and time to put the shoe on) as well.

  While older models of the Niad were designed for crack climbing, we recommend the new Niads for bouldering and gym climbing. If that's what you buy them for and get the right size, you should be happy. 

• Value

  Our biggest hesitation with this shoe is that they’re pricey for a beginner shoe. But as mentioned above, there are many types of beginner climbers.

  If you know you’re the type of boulderer who is going to go to the gym 5 times a week and be heading outdoors in a few months and buying your own crash pad with your next paycheck, you may enjoy investing in the quality and performance of the Niad. 

  This is a fail-safe shoe for all disciplines of climbing, especially with the new strip of rubber added. It’s a great shoe all around — a new model of something tried and true!

• Comparison with other beginner-friendly bouldering shoes

  In our Best Bouldering Shoes guide, we recommend the La Sportiva Finale as the best for beginners (same as with this article). But if you made it this far in the article and weren't swayed by the Finale, we think the Five Ten NIAD Moccasym is the best choice for you.

  In our Best Bouldering Shoes guide, we recommend the La Sportiva Mantra as best for indoor bouldering and it could be a good choice for newer climbers who only climb at the gym, but it isn't great for outdoor bouldering. If you are climbing outdoors, the Scarpa Instinct VSR gets great reviews from our testers, but costs nearly $100 more than the NIAD Moccasym.

  We recommend the NIAD Moccasym for beginner climbers in this guide because of its affordable price, slip-on design, and reliability.

Best Vegan Beginner Climbing Shoe: Evolv Elektra (Women’s) Evolv Defy (Men’s)

Rubber Type: 3.5 mm (Defy) and 4.2 mm (Elektra) TRAX® SAS
Lining:  Unlined
Upper Material: Synthetic microsuede
Closure: Velcro straps/hook-and-loop
Can be Resoled: Yes
Type: Neutral
Sizing: Runs small
What we liked: Great for learning toe and heel hooks
What we didn’t like: Synthetic material retains odors

Evolv has a great reputation in the climbing world for its high-performance, vegan footwear. The Evolv Elektra and Defy are no exception.

The Elektra has a padded split tongue that is comfortable and convenient for airing your feet out when not climbing. 

The TRAX® SAS rubber is great if you're learning to heel hook or toe hook. (Photo example of heel hooking below.) While these are more advanced moves, they are always fun to learn as a new climber. And one of the most beginner-friendly aspects of the Elektra is that it is reasonably priced: $109 for the velcro closure and $129 for the lace-up closure.

• Upper and sizing

  In testing, we found that these shoes will not stretch as they get broken in-which makes sense, as they have a synthetic upper. (This isn’t necessarily a negative, just something to be aware of.) I ordered a half-size smaller than my street shoe, and it felt pretty good. However, if the Elektra is your first climbing shoe, I recommend you go up a half-size from your street shoe for maximum comfort, as opposed to the tighter “performance fit” that I got out of them.

• Evolv Elektra vs. Defy

  Although the Elektra is marketed at REI and Backcountry as a women’s shoe, Evolv’s website says all shoes are unisex. For men’s sizing, just go up in size or opt for the Evolv Defy.

• Odor

  One downside to the synthetic shoe material is that the Elektra will get quite stinky after a few sessions. We recommend using baking soda to dry and pull out some of the sweat after a session. Silica packets are great for drying the shoes out, but won’t deodorize. Two to three tea bags in each shoe for 24 hours can help mitigate the moisture and some of the smell. You can also get an antiseptic spray, like Lysol, to help kill and/or slow the growth of bacteria.

• Our Verdict

  Overall, the Elektra is a super straightforward beginner shoe, nothing too fancy or technical which is sometimes what makes an awesome beginner shoe.

Best for Wide Feet: Butora Endeavor

Women's and Men's

Rubber Type: 4.0 mm Butora NEO Fuse
Lining: Microfiber
Upper Material: Suede/leather
Closure: Strap
Can be Resoled: Yes
Fit: Runs small
Type: Neutral
What we liked: Extremely comfortable, narrow and wide widths, good price point
What we didn’t like: Not the best on overhangs

If you have a narrow or wide foot, we'd encourage you to check out the Butora Endeavor. It comes in both narrow and wide widths – somewhat of a rarity in the rock climbing shoe world. Because of this sizing, we found them to be supremely comfortable (and again, we think that comfort is the top priority for beginner climbers).

• Design

  In addition to being designed for wide feet, the Butora Endeavors have other design features that accommodate climbers whose feet have a hard time fitting comfortably in other shoes.

  The Butora Endeavors have two Velcro straps that are opposing, which further fine-tunes the fit. We also like the asymmetrical toe shape, which is great for those of us with Morton's Toe.

• Value

  While we think it's a great all-around shoe, that means it's not great at any one thing. So you may find yourself outgrowing it fairly quickly as your climbing progresses.

Other beginner climbing shoes we tested

These were all the climbing shoes we thought were good enough to test. They got good reviews not just in other media, but from customers at multiple sites. 

While ultimately, we think based on our criteria, most climbers will be better served by our winners, each of these models has its own pros and cons. One might work better for you, depending on your circumstances and budget.

Scarpa Origin

Men's and Women's

Rubber Type: Vision Rubber
Lining: Unlined
Upper Material: Suede leather
Closure: Strap
Can be Resoled: Yes
Type: Flat-last, neutral
Fit: Higher-volume fit

The Tarantulace and Scapa Origin are often compared. The SCARPA Origin rock climbing shoe often comes up in other media's lists of The Best Beginner Climbing Shoes for a reason: it's an affordable and neutral shoe. It's available as both a men's climbing shoe and a women's climbing shoe. It's often on sale.

Still, when we considered the features and how it performed in testing, we liked the Tarantulace better than the Origin as a budget beginner climbing shoe. 

Durability is an issue on the SCARPA Origin climbing shoe with reviewers reporting rubber peeling and sewing issues. Several climbers report the Origin runs small, especially in the toe box. 

Reviewers also found it lacks the grip of comparable shoes. 

So while you may have good luck with the Origin (and we did), we think if you're looking for a budget shoe that will last as you go from a beginner climber to an intermediate climber, you may as well save yourself a little money and get the Tarantulace.

Scarpa Helix V

Women's and Men's

Rubber Type: Vibram XS Edge
Lining: Unlined
Upper Material: Suede leather
Closure: Strap (also comes in lace version)
Can be Resoled: Yes
Type: Flat with slight asymetry
Fit: Neutral, slightly wide
What we liked: value for the price, better performance than most budget climbing shoes
What we didn’t like: rubber is less sensitive, stiffer fit

The SCARPA Helix V are a close competitor to the La Sportiva Finales, and provide a bit more performance than many other budget and beginner climbing shoes. 

They have sticky Vibram XS Edge rubber, but we preferred the softer, more sensitive design of the La Sportiva Finales. They have a pretty similar—though stiffer—fit compared to the Finales, so if you’re interested in a decently low-cost pair with Vibram rubber but mostly rope climb, these are worth your consideration.

We also noticed the SCARPA Helix’s shape made them not ideal for overhanging climbs (where the rockface is at a degree in which you are climbing greater than vertical). While this may not be something you jump into right away as a beginner (or maybe you will!), it’s something to keep in mind if you were hoping to use it as a beginner to intermediate shoe.

After reading customer reviews on sizing, I ordered a half-size up from my street shoe and they fit perfectly! If you are looking for something a little less tight in the toe box, consider sizing up one full size. (Remember, because they have a leather upper, they will stretch!) To help choose how to size your shoe, see our section below on how to fit and size a climbing shoe.

La Sportiva Mythos Eco

Women's and Men's

Rubber Type: 4 mm La Sportiva ECO rubber (recycled)
Lining: Unlined
Upper Material: ECO Idro-Perwanger biodegradable leather that uses a metal-free eco-tanning process
Closure: Lace-up
Can be Resoled: Yes
Type: Neutral
Fit: Runs large (we sized down 1/2 size)
What we liked: Patented lace system
What we didn’t like: Rubber not as sticky as it should be

The Mythos Eco from La Sportiva is a classic shoe—they’ve been around for over 25 years and continue to top the charts. La Sportiva re-released the Mythos with their own blend of recycled rubber and all the same comfort and technology as the original—which we love!

The Mythos uses a noticeably soft leather upper which makes them comfortable for swelling feet on long or hot days. The Mythos also provides extreme comfort with sturdy arch support not found in all rock climbing shoes. The patented lace-up closure system makes for the best fit possible, and also makes these extra comfortable for crack climbing. These are all features that many beginners appreciate–and more advanced climbers do, too.

The Mythos rubber felt soft and less sticky than other shoes we tested when trying to get a precise toe placement.

We think the good outweighs the bad, but at $179, the Mythos Eco was too pricey to make our winners list–at least for beginners. It might be a great buy as you advance in climbing, but for beginners, we recommend one of our other more affordable winners instead.

While we love the soft leather, it comes with two challenges. First, once the shoes are well-loved, they don’t hold up as well as other shoes. Another challenge with the Mythos is the sizing, which can be a bit finicky. We recommend going down at least one size from your street shoe. I went down to a 37.5 from a 38, since I knew the eco-leather upper would stretch; it still ended up being too big by about one size. 

Similarly, our senior editor Brandon Lampley wears a 46 size street shoe and owns Mythos in 42, 42.5, and 43.5. Many climbers find that owning multiple pairs helps them customize their ideal fit for different climbs. 

But for your first pair of climbing shoes, you’re likely still figuring out what type of fit you like, making it more difficult to size the Mythos for your ideal comfort and use.

Scarpa Reflex VS

Men's and Women's

Rubber Type: Vision rubber
Lining: Unlined
Upper Material: Suede/ synthetic
Closure: Straps
Can be Resoled: Yes
Type: Flat, neutral
Fit: Comfort-focused
What we liked: Incredible value for the price
What we didn’t like: rubber isn’t as sticky or responsive as other beginner climbing shoes

The Scarpa Reflex VS are an incredibly affordable climbing shoe with a price that rivals the La Sportiva Tarantulace and La Sportiva Finale. They have a flat design that is comfortable. While the rubber doesn't feel as good as the Vibram XS Edge on the Finales, these are are another option under $100.

La Sportiva Skwama Lite

Men's and Women's

Rubber Type: 4 mm FriXion Black half-sole rubber with Delta-Cut design
Lining: Unlined
Upper Material: Microfiber
Closure: Strap
Can be Resoled: Yes
Type: Moderate; medium asymmetry and slight downturn
Fit: Feels wide
What we liked: Value for an intermediate shoe may appeal to strong and fit beginners
What we didn’t like: rubber isn’t as sticky as other intermediate shoes, lack of comfort

The La Sportiva Skwama Lites are marketed as a shoe for climbers looking to "level up their technical game." We considered it as a climbing shoe that would appeal to beginner climbers who already know they are dedicated to the sport and want to advance quickly. It has a slight asymmetry and downturn that true beginners will want to avoid, but we were drawn to them because they are more reasonably priced than many intermediate climbing shoes. 

In testing, we found the Skwama Lites are not as comfortable as even other intermediate shoes we tested and the rubber isn't quite as sticky, either. If you are getting into climbing and aim to be intermediate or advanced in a short period, we'd steer you towards the La Sportiva Skwama Vegan, which is similarly aggressive but more comfortable.

What to look for in a Beginner climbing shoe

Whether you're bouldering, top roping, or starting multi-pitch climbs outdoors, there are a few qualities to consider in a climbing shoe: material, outsole sensitivity and flexibility, closures, and shape of the shoe. (We’ll get more into fit and sizing later.)

Upper Material

An “upper” consists of everything above the sole on a shoe. On rock climbing shoes, you’ll find uppers made of either leather (sometimes suede, a softer type of leather) or synthetic materials.

Leather Uppers

Stinky feet? No problem! Just lean more towards a leather shoe. Leather and suede are natural materials that breathe much better than synthetic materials, so the sweat inside your shoe evaporates more easily. With all-leather shoes, such as the Five Ten Moccasym, the color of the shoe will likely bleed onto your skin, particularly as you first start to use them. While sometimes a source of momentary panic—I’d know—I promise it’s harmless.

Leather shoes are available with lined and unlined uppers. Lined leather uppers have an extra piece of fabric between your feet and the shoe. This means that the leather isn’t directly touching your skin. Unlined uppers only have one layer—the leather on the outside is the same fabric touching your skin on the inside. As a climber, it’s important to know whether your shoe is lined or unlined because it impacts sizing. Lined shoes tend to stretch less than unlined. Unlined uppers tend to be more popular with companies and customers across the board for comfort. Most climbers find unlined shoes are easier to break in, too.

Synthetic Uppers

Synthetic uppers end up wicking moisture away from your feet and ultimately absorbing it—which can be a real plus when your feet are sweaty. Companies like Evolv (which makes the Elektra, reviewed above) treat their synthetic uppers with an antimicrobial finish, which helps to kill the bacteria that cause smelly shoes. Note that it only helps—eventually all rock climbing shoes will end up stinky. Baking soda or an antibacterial spray can also help with the smell. 

Synthetic uppers are more straightforward when it comes to stretch. They tend to stretch less than leather uppers do—and depending on the fabric used, they may not stretch at all—so sizing is a lot easier. 

Another bonus? Synthetic uppers often mean a vegan shoe, so if that’s important to you, a synthetic upper will be your best bet.

Outsole Sensitivity and Flexibility

At its simplest, the outsole on a climbing shoe is made of rubber—and that rubber sits not only on the underside of your foot, but wraps up the sides of your feet and over your heels and toes as well. While the rubber used on all rock climbing shoe soles is “sticky” — meaning it’s designed to create more friction, so it’s easier to stay connected to the rock or climbing hold — the precise kind of rubber on a particular shoe is often proprietary, or connected to a specific brand.

The sensitivity and flexibility of an outsole are not only dependent on the rubber used but also the rubber sole’s thickness (or thinness). A thick sole is great for durability and longevity, making this a great option for a beginner or intermediate climber. That thickness provides support, so your feet don’t tire as easily. Thick midsoles and sole rubber may feel more supportive or comfortable and may reduce foot fatigue for some beginners. You’ll see similar designs in climbing shoes that are truly designed for intermediate climbers like the La Sportiva Mantra or the La Sportiva Solution Comp bouldering shoes.

The durability of an outsole is important because as a beginner, you’ll be learning climbing footwork, which can be a process best done with a pair of shoes that can hold up to your practice. 

However, thicker outsoles reduce your feel and sensitivity of the wall or the rock. They also make the shoe less flexible, which can be good for more rigid terrain. 

Thinner soles are great for harder projects because of the high sensitivity but don’t last as long. Most beginners find that a hard sole is best because it offers more support while their feet and ligaments build strength. Like with hiking boots, more support means your feet won’t tire as much.

Type of Closure

Velcro

Velcro and slip-on are the quickest styles of closure. However, with Velcro, the hook and loop will eventually lose their effectiveness. Climbers who prefer bouldering or shorter climbs sometimes prefer shoes with Velcro straps because it is easy to take on and off.

Lace

Laces are great for being able to adjust the exact tightness of the shoe, especially with the La Sportiva Mythos we reviewed. This is especially helpful for beginner climbers, as you can adjust the fit and tightness depending on the performance you’re looking for (comfort vs performance). A downside is that laces wear out, especially if you’re rock climbing outside a lot, but they are relatively inexpensive and easy to replace. Lace systems can also be a pain if you’re frequently putting your shoes on and off.

Most of the shoes we reviewed are offered in either lace-up or Velcro straps, though some models give you a choice between the two. Experiment to try what works best for you!

Shape of the Shoe

There are three different footbed (or “last”) shapes to climbing shoes that correspond to the amount of bend built into the shape of the shoe—neutral, moderate, and aggressive. Neutral shoe lasts have little to no camber (bend) in them. Moderate and aggressive shoe lasts have a distinctive curve in the arch and toe. A moderate shoe has a noticeable curve, but an aggressive shoe will look like a downturned shoe. The best last for you depends on what kind of rock climbing you’ll be doing and your level of climbing ability.

We believe neutral lasts make the best rock climbing shoes for beginners looking to get used to the feeling of being in climbing shoes. (That said, they’re also great for experienced climbers looking for all-day comfort on longer climbs or a more relaxed fit.) Typically, this style not only features a relatively flat profile, but also thick, supportive rubber outsoles. Just like with hiking boots, a supportive shoe means your feet won’t tire as easily. Most of the shoes we tested fall into this category, as this is a feature many people appreciate as a beginner or intermediate climber. However, most advanced climbers will have a pair of shoes like this, too. A neutral shoe will remain a part of most climbers’ quiver, even as they go on to buy and use more aggressive or tighter-fitting shoes. 

Moderate lasts have a slight camber in the arch and toe and are great for all-around climbing. Stickier rubber and a thinner sole on moderate shoes help the climber feel more of what’s under their feet. Many intermediate climbers choose this kind of rock shoe. 

Aggressive lasts typically have an asymmetric shape, curving towards the big toe, and are very downturned. For the most part, this type of rock shoe is much less comfortable than the other two and is used more for powerful moves on shorter climbs or when bouldering. Since these are not recommended for beginners, we did not test any climbing shoes with aggressive lasts.

Men’s vs Women’s Climbing Shoes

In general, women’s climbing shoes are designed to be narrower and softer than the same men’s version. This is because men, in general, have wider feet and are heavier, thus requiring a stiffer shoe. Some women’s shoes are even built on a women’s-specific last (thank you, La Sportiva!). A better way to think about men's vs. women's climbing shoes is higher-volume and lower-volume fits, regardless of gender label.

We encourage you to find the right shoe for you, regardless of labeling. We know plenty of women who wear men’s rock climbing shoes, and vice versa. With climbing, performance fit is what matters.

Types of climbing shoes

Climbing shoes generally fall into three shapes: neutral, moderate, and aggressive.

Neutral shoes have a flatter profile and are usually the best choice for beginners because they prioritize comfort and versatility. They work well for gym climbing, top-roping, and many outdoor routes.

Moderate shoes have a slight downturn that can provide more precision on steeper or more technical climbs while remaining relatively comfortable. Some beginners may prefer a moderate shoe if they want a little more performance as their skills progress.

Aggressive shoes have a pronounced downturn designed for steep climbing and difficult bouldering. They usually prioritize precision and power over all-day comfort, so most beginners do not need them for their first pair.

How To Fit And Size A Climbing Shoe

Climbing shoes should fit snugly and securely without causing significant pain. If they are too loose, your foot can move inside the shoe and reduce precision. If they are painfully tight, you are less likely to keep them on long enough to learn and climb comfortably.

Sizing varies considerably between brands and models, so your street-shoe size should only be a starting point. Upper materials matter too: unlined leather typically stretches more with use than synthetic materials, while lined shoes tend to retain their original fit better. Whenever possible, try several sizes and models rather than assuming you need to size down.

A good beginner fit should have little empty space around the heel or sides of the foot, with your toes reaching the front of the shoe without being painfully compressed. Your toes may be slightly bent depending on the shoe's shape, but numbness, sharp pressure, or persistent pain are signs that the fit is too tight.

Feet can swell during the day and while climbing, so trying shoes on later in the day can give you a better idea of how they will feel during a session. Most climbing shoes are designed to be worn next to the skin, but wearing socks is also fine if that is more comfortable for you. The important thing is to size the shoe based on how you actually plan to wear it.

For beginners, we recommend prioritizing a secure, comfortable fit over an extremely tight performance fit. You can always choose a more specialized or aggressive fit later if your climbing style and goals call for it.

Climbing shoe Care and maintenance tips

Taking proper care of your climbing shoes is essential not only for their longevity but also for your climbing performance and safety. Here are some maintenance and care tips to ensure your beginner rock climbing shoes stay in top shape:

Cleaning your climbing shoes

Regular cleaning: After each climbing session, take a moment to clean your shoes. Brush off dirt, chalk, and grime using a soft brush or a toothbrush. This prevents the buildup of dirt and sweat, which can lead to odors and deterioration of the shoe materials.

Deep cleaning: Periodically, perform a more thorough cleaning. Use a mild detergent and water to clean the shoe's exterior. Be sure to rinse them thoroughly and allow them to dry naturally. Avoid using a washing machine, as it can damage the shoes.

Drying your climbing shoes

Air dry: Never leave your climbing shoes in direct sunlight or near a heat source, such as a radiator or heater. Instead, let them air dry at room temperature. Excessive heat can cause the shoe materials to warp, delaminate, or lose their adhesive properties.

Use shoe deodorizers: To prevent odor buildup, consider using shoe deodorizers or inserts made of cedar or activated charcoal. These help absorb moisture and keep your shoes smelling fresh.

Storage

Store in a cool, dry place: When you're not climbing, store your climbing shoes in a cool, dry place. Avoid leaving them in your climbing bag or car for extended periods, as extreme temperatures and humidity can degrade the materials.

Keep them uncompressed: Store your shoes with a shoe tree or stuff them with newspaper to help maintain their shape and prevent the toe box from collapsing.

Resoling

Know when to resole: As your climbing shoes wear down, you may need to consider resoling. Signs that it's time for a resole include a thinning outsole, thinning rubber, or reduced performance on the wall.

Professional resoling: It's recommended to have your shoes professionally resoled by a trusted cobbler or climbing shoe resoling service. They can restore the shoe's original performance and extend its lifespan.

Inspect for damage

Regular inspection: Regularly inspect your climbing shoes for any visible damage, such as delamination, loose stitching, or deformed rubber. Damaged shoes can compromise your safety and performance.

Replace damaged shoes: If you notice significant damage, it's safer to retire those shoes and invest in a new pair. Worn shoes can reduce grip, edging, or fit.

How to break in your new climbing shoes

New climbing shoes may feel stiff or unusually snug at first, particularly if they use leather or thicker rubber. They should not, however, require you to tolerate sharp or persistent pain in order to “break them in.”

Start with shorter climbing sessions and easier routes or boulder problems while you get used to the fit. Pay attention to pressure points and hot spots, and adjust the laces or straps if possible. Leather uppers typically stretch and conform to the foot more than synthetic materials, so expect the amount of break-in to vary by shoe.

Give the shoes several climbing sessions to settle in, but do not expect break-in to correct a fundamentally poor fit. If you continue to experience significant pain, numbness, or concentrated pressure, try a different size or model rather than forcing the shoe to work.

FAQ

• Do beginner climbing shoes need to hurt?

  No. Beginner climbing shoes should feel snug and secure, but they should not cause sharp or persistent pain. An extremely tight fit can make it harder to spend enough time climbing to develop good footwork and technique. For a first pair, comfort and a secure fit are usually more useful than an aggressively tight performance fit.

• Should beginners size down in climbing shoes?

  Not necessarily. Climbing-shoe sizing varies substantially between brands and models, so there is no universal rule that beginners should size down from their street-shoe size. Start with the manufacturer's sizing guidance and focus on how the shoe actually fits your foot. Leather shoes may stretch with use, while synthetic models generally change less.

• Can I use the same climbing shoes indoors and outdoors?

  Yes. Most beginner climbing shoes are versatile enough for both gym and outdoor climbing, including top-roping, sport climbing, and bouldering. As your skills develop, you may eventually want a more specialized shoe for a particular style of climbing, but beginners usually do not need multiple pairs.

• Can I resole my climbing shoes myself?

  While it's technically possible to resole climbing shoes yourself, it's recommended to have it done by a professional cobbler or a climbing shoe resoling service. They have the expertise and equipment to ensure a proper and safe resoling job.

• Can I resole my climbing shoes multiple times?

  The number of times climbing shoes can be resoled depends on the shoe's construction and how well they've been cared for. Quality climbing shoes can typically undergo several resoles if maintained properly.

• Do I need to buy a specific shoe for each climbing style?

  No, most beginners should start with a versatile all-around climbing shoe for various styles. As you learn more about what type of climbing you like, you can get specialized shoes. Specialized shoes are designed for specific techniques like crack climbing or slab climbing, so as a beginner, it's more practical to invest in one versatile pair initially and then buy more pairs later.

• What should I do if my climbing shoes stretch too much?

  If your climbing shoes stretch more than anticipated, you can try using insoles or inserts to reduce the interior volume slightly. However, keep in mind that significant stretching may indicate a misfit, so consult a climbing shoe expert if the problem persists. You may need to get a different size.

• Is it normal for climbing shoes to hurt my big toe or toenails?

  Climbing shoes may put some pressure on the big toe or toenails, but they shouldn't cause intense pain or damage. If you experience pain or notice toenail issues, consult with a climbing shoe expert to ensure your shoes fit correctly.

• How long do climbing shoes last?

  It depends on how often you climb, your footwork, the type of rock or climbing surface, and the shoe's construction. The outsole rubber is usually one of the first areas to show significant wear. Rather than following a fixed timeline, watch for thinning rubber, holes, loss of grip, or damage around the toe and rand.

• Do I need socks with climbing shoes?

  No, but you can wear them if you prefer. Climbing shoes are generally designed to be worn directly against the foot, which gives the shoe a close fit and can improve sensitivity. Some climbers prefer thin socks for comfort, warmth, or hygiene. If you plan to climb in socks, wear them when trying shoes on so you choose the right size.

• When should climbing shoes be resoled?

  Consider resoling when the outsole becomes noticeably thin, especially around the toe, but before you wear through the rand underneath it. Resoling early can extend the life of a well-fitting pair of climbing shoes. Whether a shoe can be resoled, and how many times, depends on its construction and condition.

What Makes The Best Beginner Climbing Shoes

It is important to look at the website of each shoe before purchasing, as they will be able to give you the tech specs on each shoe and what they are designed for. 

Still, we think for beginner climbers, the best shoe is actually the shoe that feels good on your foot.

There are so many different types of beginner climbers:

People who will be getting after it daily and rock climbing outdoor multi-pitch in a month and those who will climb moderate auto-belay routes at the gym as exercise for many years.

Until you are a rock climber who knows what you want to be doing and are comfortable doing it, the shoe that is best for you is a shoe that is comfortable.

Starting your rock climbing journey with the right shoes is key, but don’t overlook other important gear that will make your climbs safer and more enjoyable. If you’re looking to complete your gear set, be sure to check out our guide on the Best Climbing Rope Bags to find the perfect bag for your needs. Additionally, having the right chalk is essential for maintaining a good grip, so explore our top picks in the Best Climbing Chalk guide. To keep that chalk handy, take a look at our recommendations for the Best Climbing Chalk Bags. And, of course, safety should always come first—make sure to choose a reliable belay device from our Best Belay Devices guide.

How We Tested

Over the past five years, we've tested more than 20 pairs of beginner rock climbing shoes. Our main writer is a climbing instructor and former manager of a climbing gym in a major city. Over the course of running the gym, she's worked with hundreds of beginner climbers to understand their needs and common questions.

For this article, we've run these beginner climbing shoes past everyone from true beginner climbers to seasoned climbing guides.

Each pair of shoes we tested for this article was tested on multiple different roped routes over several years of climbing. We also tested the shoes bouldering indoors on problems of varying difficulty. Then, we tested the shoes outdoors on moderate climbs and outside bouldering.

However, to reflect the experience of the majority of beginner rock climbers, we spent most of our testing time in a rock climbing gym. Most beginner climbers will start their journey indoors rather than outdoors. We also recognize that the rubber on each shoe holds up differently on real rock.

• Multiple roped gym routes
• Indoor bouldering at varied difficulty
• Moderate outdoor climbs
• Outdoor bouldering
• Mostly gym-based testing for beginner relevance

• Fit and comfort
• Grip and edging performance
• Support and sensitivity
• Break-in and adjustability
• Durability and room to progress

About The Author / Why You Should Trust Us

Kate Butler is a rock climbing enthusiast who managed a climbing gym for years in St. Paul, MN. She taught rock climbing classes in top rope, lead climbing, and technique climbing, introducing hundreds of beginners to the sport.

She’s achieved Climbing Wall Instructor (CWI) and Single Pitch Instructor (SPI) certifications. Kate managed an international guiding company conglomerate out of Alaska and worked with Montana Alpine Guides and Montana Whitewater seasonally.

Kate is also the author of Treeline Review’s How to Get Into Ice Climbing guide. She enjoys skiing and ice climbing when the weather turns brisk, or canoeing in the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness and rock climbing throughout the West in the warmer weather.

September 11th, 2026, updated with more models tested, an additional year and thousands of miles more testing
Home > Gear Reviews > Backpacking

Your backpack should feel like a natural part of your pack system, not a burden, especially at the end of a long day on trail. A backpacking backpack is the piece of gear everything else depends on. If it doesn't fit well, the weight you're carrying multiplies mile by mile. If it's too heavy before you load it, you're already behind on your base weight goals. The good news is that the last decade of lightweight pack design has made it possible to carry a fully featured, comfortable framed pack for two pounds or less, which wasn't true when most of the classic packs were designed.

We've backpacked thousands of miles in dozens of packs, testing everything from ultralight frameless options to full suspension systems on routes including the Oregon Desert Trail, Blue Mountains Trail, and long food and water carries in the Arizona desert. We also interviewed backpackers ranging from weekend hikers to world-class long-distance thru-hikers to understand what actually matters across different trip lengths and styles.

What separates a genuinely good lightweight backpack from one that disappoints comes down to how well the suspension system transfers load to your hips rather than your shoulders, whether the fit is adjustable enough to dial in for your specific torso and hip measurements, how the pocket layout works while moving rather than just at camp, and how the materials balance weight against durability for the terrain you're actually hiking.

Top Pick: The Gossamer Gear Mariposa earns our Best Overall award. After 1,000 miles and years of testing, it stood out for a new suspension system that comfortably carries heavy loads at half the weight of traditional packs, a full set of functional and accessible pockets on the pack and hip belt, and versatility that works equally well for someone transitioning from a five-pound pack and a seasoned ultralight hiker on a long desert route.

Want something lighter and faster? See our Best Fastpacks

We create reader-supported, objective gear reviews independently selected by our editors. This story may contain affiliate links, which help fund our website. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission — without costing you an extra cent. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body! Learn more.

Backpack Comparison Table

Looking for a day hiking backpack? Check out our Best Day Packs for Hiking Guide

Curious about pack volume? See How Accurate are Stated Volumes of Backpacking Backpacks?

Interested in backpacking gear? See our Backpacking section for our most popular stories.

• PCT Gear List & Strategy

• Best Sleeping Bags for Backpacking

• Best Sleeping Pads for Backpacking

• Best Backpacking Tents

• Best Lightweight Hiking Boots

The winners

Best Lightweight Backpacking Backpack: Gossamer Gear Mariposa 60

Capacity: 60L
Weight: 2.09–2.26 lb fully configured, depending on size and belt
Materials: 100 & 200 denier Robic high-tensile strength nylon
Cost: $315
Max load: 35 lbs
What we liked: lightweight, durable, comfortable
What we didn't like: suspension capabilities not as strong as Swift X

The Mariposa is our winner for the best lightweight backpacking backpack. If I had to count the backpack I saw on PCT thru-hikers the most this year, it'd be the Gossamer Gear Mariposa. 

Although the bestselling Mariposa qualifies as an ultralight pack, it offers backpackers all the utility, comfort, volume, and durability of a heavier, traditional pack at a fraction of the weight. 

That's why we think it's the best lightweight backpack for everyone from first-time backpackers to thru-hikers making the transition from traditional backpacking to ultralight backpacking. 

Its intuitive, easy-to-use design and extra padding tipped it ahead of other backpacks in its weight class. This is especially useful for thru-hikers who don't have time to fiddle with getting their pack right.

The Mariposa is a multi-year bestseller for a reason, with years of data and thousands of happy ultralight backpackers and thru-hikers. 

Read our full review of the Mariposa here.

Hikers wear the Gossamer Gear Mariposa 60 on the trail, showing the pack’s comfortable fit and streamlined profile in use.

The Gossamer Gear Mariposa 60 carries a full load on a rocky mountain trail, with its padded shoulder harness and hip belt helping distribute the weight.

The Gossamer Gear Mariposa 60 stands packed against a tree, showing its large main compartment, spacious exterior pockets, and integrated hip belt pockets.

A backpacker accesses gear beside the Gossamer Gear Mariposa 60, with the pack’s large side pockets providing convenient storage for frequently used items.

A close-up of the Gossamer Gear Mariposa 60 shows its padded S-curve shoulder harness and integrated hip belt pockets for carrying small essentials within easy reach.

The Gossamer Gear Mariposa 60 sits beside a backpacker at camp, showing how its spacious design accommodates a full backpacking load while remaining lightweight.

• Updates on the newest model

  The newest version of the Mariposa has a PVT system that transfers weight to your body better than the previous version. When we compare the older Mariposa with the new model, the old version has a U-shaped frame while the new model has a closed-shape aluminum frame attached to the pivoting hip belt. The result is a noticeably more comfortable pack that moves with you. 

  The new Mariposa has an S-curve shoulder harness as the standard, which fits both men and women better. You also have the option of straight or curved hipbelts (approximately men's and women's models), though the process to swap out for the women's hipbelt is annoying.

  Notably, the placement of the load lifters has also changed on the new version. The new load lifters are higher up and attached to the frame to transfer weight like load lifters are supposed to.

  The new version uses a more durable recycled 100D and 210D Robic. From an aesthetic standpoint, the new Robic looks sleeker and more refined.

  The internal hydration pocket has been removed.

• Pockets and organization

  Larger than on other lightweight packs we considered, the pockets are integrated right into the hip belt. Integrated sewn-in pockets are beneficial because they won't slide or fall off should a plastic attachment come loose, as can happen with optional pocket attachments. 

  Large pockets are also a huge bonus when backpacking, as you can access your phone, GPS, camera, snacks, or maps without having to stop and remove your pack or use a fanny pack. 

  Unlike any other pack we considered, the Mariposa has three side pockets. On the right side is a water bottle pocket, big enough for two 1-liter bottles. 

  Above the water bottle pocket is an 8” wide x 10” tall pocket, where some people keep their cookware or other items that are voluminous but lightweight. On the left side is an 8” wide x 16” tall pocket that would be great for a small tent (we were able to fit a Zpacks Duplex tent without its stuff sack into this pocket).

• Adaptability

  The hip belt, frame, and sit pad (back support) can be easily removed, converting the pack into a frameless pack weighing close to one pound.

• Flaws but not dealbreakers

  One minor issue is that there is not a great place to hold a full-size umbrella (popular with many hikers for sun and rain protection). The umbrella will fit in the large side pocket, but there is no side compression strap or cord to secure items that stick out above the pocket.

• The bottom line

  For its comfort, features, easy organization, and spaciousness, the Gossamer Gear Mariposa is a great choice for backpackers headed on their first thru-hike.

Best Dyneema Backpacking Backpack: Hyperlite Mountain Gear Junction

Capacity: 40L, 55L
Weight: 1.88 lbs
Materials: White: DCH50 (Main Body) & DCH150 (Bottom)
Black: DCH150 (Main Body & Bottom)
Max load: 40 lbs
Cost: $349
What we liked: overall durability, water resistance
What we didn't like: issues with durability of the mesh

The Hyperlite Mountain Gear Junction is the best Dyneema backpacking pack available because of its balance of quality, durability, and water resistance. Hyperlite Mountain Gear is a small, outdoor gear manufacturer in Maine. We found that HMG backpacks are made with an attention to detail that makes it worth paying a premium for their gear. The ultralight Junction backpacks — available in 40L and 55L sizes — became our Dyneema winner because of their ease of use and well-designed pockets.

Read our full review of the HMG Junction.

The HMG Junction backpack at Kearsarge Lakes in the Sierra. Photo by Naomi Hudetz.

The HMG Junction has DCH fabric lined side pockets and generous hipbelt pockets for storage. Photo by Liz Thomas.

The HMG Junction on the PCT near Mt. Ashland. Photo by Liz Thomas.

• Material

  While not everyone will want a backpack made of Dyneema Composite Hybrid (DCH, formerly known as Cuben Fiber Fabric), many backpackers find it to be a top priority. DCH is a rugged sailcloth that is abrasion-resistant and waterproof enough to be the fly on a three-season tent. Despite being waterproof, we strongly recommend you use additional methods to protect your gear. See our section on how to keep your gear dry.

  While HMG is not the first backpack manufacturer to use the DCH fabric, they do more volume in DCF and DCH backpacks than any other company. That volume has allowed HMG to refine the process to an art.

• Design

  The similar HMG Windrider and Southwest have been ultralight thru-hiker standards for several years. After testing different models on a thru-hike of the Ouachita Trail, we compared and think the Junction is the best. Here's why: The Junction’s design is a combo of the best of the Southwest and Windrider — and before it existed as its own model, a design similar to the Junction was one of the most popular custom design requests.

• Comfort

  HMG packs are designed to carry comfortably without load lifters, which is a point of contention among hikers. Some hikers — even lightweight or ultralight hikers — find a benefit to load lifters, saying they prevent shoulder knots and bruising. Others think they’re a relic of traditional backpacking backpacks. If you know you like load lifters, try the HMG pack fully loaded in your house before committing to it (don't worry — they have a great return policy).

• Our verdict

  We think the HMG Junction is the best Dyneema pack for most backpackers. While not everyone wants or needs a Dyneema pack, HMG has perfected the art of working in this fabric to create a pack that will serve you well on the long haul.

Best Ultralight Backpacking Backpacks: Pa'lante V2 with Joey Straps

Capacity: 37 L
Weight: 21 oz
Cost: $240
Materials: 210D UHMWPE Gridstop
Max load: 25 lbs
What we liked: Comfortable shoulder straps, durable pack body materials, has running vest-style pockets as well as backpacking pack pockets, has a bottom pocket
What we didn't like: Fastpacks aren't for everyone

For ultralight backpackers who have thru-hiked before, we think the Pa'lante Packs V2 with Joey Straps (aka: running vest straps) is the best ultralight backpacking backpack we've tested in years of testing fastpacks. 

We have an entire story dedicated to fastpacks (backpacking backpacks that are designed for people moving light and fast). This style of backpack is not for everyone and we don't recommend it for most backpackers. But if you are considering this style of pack, the Pa'lante V2 is the very best.

The V2 with Joey straps has lots of functional pocket space and comfortably carries a fastpacking set-up. It even fits a BV500 bear canister, which makes it an excellent option for backpackers who want a fastpack that is functional for most trips.

In almost a year of use, we've found you can roll down to the point where the higher capacity doesn't get in the way of running on the downhills on every backpacking trip.

If you want a stellar ultralight backpacking pack that’s versatile enough to use on shorter trips and longer outings, check this one out. Learn more in our in-depth review of the Pa’lante Packs V2 Backpack with Joey Straps.

The Pa’lante V2 with Joey Straps features running vest-style shoulder straps with multiple accessible pockets for carrying water and small essentials.

A backpacker packs the Pa’lante V2 with Joey Straps in the field, showing the pack’s roll-top design and flexible capacity.

The Pa’lante V2 with Joey Straps carries a lightweight load on the trail, with the pack’s streamlined design suited to fast-and-light travel.

A backpacker hikes with the Pa’lante V2 with Joey Straps through open terrain, showing its compact profile and lightweight fastpacking design.

The Pa’lante V2 with Joey Straps moves comfortably with a backpacker on rocky terrain, with its vest-style shoulder straps keeping the load close to the body.

• Durable ultralight materials

  The V2 with Joey Straps uses 70D UHMWPE stretch mesh for the shoulder strap, bottom, and rear external pocket. The pack body and side water bottle pockets are 210D UHMWPE gridstop material. Both of these materials are extremely durable. These are the same materials used on the standard V2, which we’ve put over 2,000 miles on. There are no tears or obvious signs of wear anywhere on that pack, or the V2 with Joey Straps. 

  The vest straps are made of two layers of 3D mesh with subtly stretchy, edge-binding tape. These straps aren’t nearly as stretchy as some running vests, but they stretch more than standard backpack straps.

• Functional capacity

  The V2 with Joey Straps is great because it has a higher volume capacity than many of the other fastpacks we tested, so you can carry more food and water. We love the original V2 for the same reason and think the padded backpack-style straps are slightly better for carrying heavier loads. But we also love the V2 with Joey Straps because it has extra pockets on the shoulder straps.

• Our verdict

  The V2 with Joey Straps is a great pack for everything from fast-and-light thru-hiking to weekend backpacking trips that cover a lot of miles, and shorter adventures where you need to carry a lot of layers, a climbing helmet, or more.

Best Backpack Under 2 Lbs: ZPACKS Arc Haul UltrA 60L

Capacity: 60 L
Weight:  1.31 to 1.39 lbs (depending on size)
Materials: Ultra 100, Ultra 200, mesh, 3D spacer mesh
Cost: $400
Max load: 40 lbs
What we liked: light weight, frame carries weight well, waterproof material
What we didn't like: price, limited colors, pockets are extra

The Zpacks Arc Haul Ultra 60L backpack is made from Ultra 100 and 200, and at 1.34 lbs is perhaps the lightest mid-size volume pack on the market with a frame. It's our top choice for best water-resistant backpack with an extremely water-resistant material and full-seam taping. We've used some version of this pack on thru-hikes in the wettest conditions without a packliner (but we don't advise this). It's an excellent pack on its own merit, and its waterproofing abilities make it the best lightweight pack choice for wet conditions.

We love the Arc Haul for its light weight and Curved Carbon Fiber frame system which allows airflow to the back. The roll top closure adds additional security from wet conditions, and the pack has efficient pocket and strap features that let you customize exactly what you need. For more, read our review of the Zpacks Arc Haul.

• Water resistance

  The Zpacks Arc Haul Ultra is an update from the previous version, the Zpacks Arc Blast. Our testers used the Arc Blast for thru-hikes of the Pacific Crest Trail and two thru-hikes of the Great Divide Trail in the Canadian Rockies. On our first thru-hike of the Great Divide Trail, it rained or snowed for 37 of 40 days on trail with the carwash effect (wet bushes) leaving us sopping wet for almost the entire trip. The Arc Haul kept everything dry, even without a liner. 

  We did further "lab" testing of dunking this fully loaded pack into a Sierra alpine lake with our sleeping bag (unprotected) inside. We also sprayed the Arc Blast with a hose for a minute straight. In both cases, the Arc Haul delivered. 

  Note: We always recommend using a packliner, even on waterproof backpacks. But with the Arc Haul, you can go for the most minimalist packliner possible, the Nylofume. 

• Comfort

  We tested the newer Arc Haul Ultra on a fall thru-hike of the Arizona Trail. It's comfortable and well balanced, holding the weight of the long water carries through the desert. Admittedly, the Arizona Trail wasn't the wettest hike for testing waterproofing, but when it rains and snows in Arizona, it really does let loose.

• Our verdict

  If you're willing to spend extra for the security and extreme light weight, the Zpacks Arc Haul is a time-tested pack and thru-hiker favorite. 

Best Backpacking Pack for Tall People: LiteAF Curve Full Suspension

Capacity: 40L or 46L
Weight: 25 to 36+ ounces, depending on fabric, size, and add-ons
Materials: Ultra 200, Ultra X, ECOPAK, or Dyneema
Cost: $418
Max load: 35 lbs
What we liked: comfort, durable, secure fit, bottom pocket, side pockets, upper pockets,
What we didn't like: expensive, no hydration system

The LiteAF Curve is a great lightweight backpacking pack for tall people. Our main tester, who is 6-feet tall, found it to fit incredibly well. It is lightweight and durable, and its volume and suspension system can handle the heavy food and water carries sometimes required on thru-hikes. The Curve Full Suspension backpack is available in 40L or 46L sizes. 

The Curve is one of the most customizable backpacks available. You can add a hip belt, shoulder, upper side or bottom pockets, choose from over 40 colors or designs, and select between different top closure options.  

The LiteAF comes in four torso sizes and four hip belt sizes, so you can get a near-custom fit. This is especially appreciated for tall people and backpackers with long torsos and smaller waists, who often struggle to find a good fit.

You can read more in our full review of the LiteAF Curve backpack.

• How we tested

  We tested the LiteAF over 600 miles of rugged hiking in Arizona and New Mexico on the Mogollon Rim Trail. We were extremely impressed with its durability – especially considering we did some bushwhacking through sharp desert vegetation. The pack still looks as good as new.

• Excellent pockets

  The large, rugged mesh front pocket is large enough for a wet tent, rain gear, and other items needed throughout the day. The water bottle pockets can fit two bottles and are easily accessed while on the move.

• Water-resistant materials

  The LiteAF Curve is available in UltraWeave, ECOPAK, or Dyneema. All are lightweight, waterproof, and extremely durable. The packs are seam-taped and very water resistant; however, we always recommend a waterproof bag liner. 

• Ability to customize

  You can customize the LiteAF Curve to meet your specific needs and hiking style. However, customization comes at a cost. Few folks will stick with the base model. If you include every option, the price rises over $600, the most expensive of any pack we tested.

Best Large Capacity Backpack: ULA Catalyst

Capacity: 75L
Weight: 2.8 lbs
Materials: ULA 400 Robic nylon
Cost: $320
Max load: 40 lbs
What we liked: high weight and volume capacity, great for backpackers with kids
What we didn't like: heavier than other packs tested

Sometimes you need to carry a large volume—even if it isn’t that heavy. Guides, troop leaders, or folks with children may have to carry extra food, first aid kits, or other people’s gear. The ULA Catalyst has a 75-liters capacity and a 40-pound load rating — but only weighs 3 pounds.

The Catalyst was the most popular and highest rated pack among Pacific Crest Trail (PCT) hiking class according to the annual survey of PCT hikers.

You can read more in our in-depth, long-term review of the ULA Catalyst backpacking pack.

• Volume and capacity

  We liked the Catalyst because it’s a lightweight backpacking pack that is specifically designed to take bigger volumes and somewhat heavier loads. The ULA Catalyst is a full-featured pack designed for folks who want to haul bulkier items such as fishing gear, extra camera equipment, or large food carries.

• Best uses

  We also have found the Catalyst to be a good choice for lightweight backpackers with kids who may want to carry some of their children’s gear. Several of our writers use the Catalyst while backpacking with kids. 

  We've even had readers write in to tell us they use it when they've had to backpack with extra medical equipment. The capacity and carry of this pack are great, especially for an ultralight backpack.

• Bear can

  The Catalyst can fit a full-size bear canister both vertically and horizontally (another reason it’s popular with PCT thru-hikers). In contrast, our top backpack pick, the Six Moon Designs Swift X, can only fit a bear can vertically (although it can be strapped to the top horizontally). The ability to carry a bear can is essential for traveling through national parks, like Yosemite, and through the Sierra and Adirondacks.

• Max load

  Despite the Catalyst’s ability to take larger volumes, it’s only rated to 40 pounds. This means it is well-suited for you if you’re carrying your own gear plus large volume items that tend to not weigh much.

• Our verdict

  We like the Catalyst for winter hiking or shoulder season hiking, where we find ourselves bringing a lot of lightweight but bulky down items. A 10-degree sleeping bag takes up a lot more volume than a 30-degree bag, even if it only weighs a few ounces more. Similarly, warmer down jackets or synthetic jackets can be bulky. These are the situations where the Catalyst excels.