<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!--Generated by Site-Server v@build.version@ (http://www.squarespace.com) on Sat, 21 Nov 2026 19:20:22 GMT
--><rss xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/" xmlns:itunes="http://www.itunes.com/dtds/podcast-1.0.dtd" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:media="http://www.rssboard.org/media-rss" version="2.0"><channel><title>Posts - Jamhoor</title><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/</link><lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 19:10:43 +0000</lastBuildDate><language>en-US</language><generator>Site-Server v@build.version@ (http://www.squarespace.com)</generator><description><![CDATA[]]></description><item><title>Typesetting Dissent: The Progressive Papers Ltd. and Pakistan’s Cold War</title><category>Pakistan</category><category>Interview</category><dc:creator>Asmer Asrar Safi &amp; Mishael Hyat Ayub</dc:creator><pubDate>Fri, 13 Nov 2026 15:59:17 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/typesettingdissentppl</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:6aedfb7c6f407c5ddf1e451e</guid><description><![CDATA[Tariq Ali on Pakistan’s most influential left-wing press, the intellectuals 
behind it, the new country they envisioned, and its 1959 seizure by the 
military regime.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Tariq Ali on Pakistan’s most influential left-wing press, the intellectuals behind it, the new country they envisioned, and its 1959 seizure by the military regime.&nbsp;</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/334ffd1f-4875-4543-8b92-c5fe5cf69df5/Tarik+Ali+Interview.png" data-image-dimensions="2560x1440" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/334ffd1f-4875-4543-8b92-c5fe5cf69df5/Tarik+Ali+Interview.png?format=1000w" width="2560" height="1440" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/334ffd1f-4875-4543-8b92-c5fe5cf69df5/Tarik+Ali+Interview.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/334ffd1f-4875-4543-8b92-c5fe5cf69df5/Tarik+Ali+Interview.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/334ffd1f-4875-4543-8b92-c5fe5cf69df5/Tarik+Ali+Interview.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/334ffd1f-4875-4543-8b92-c5fe5cf69df5/Tarik+Ali+Interview.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/334ffd1f-4875-4543-8b92-c5fe5cf69df5/Tarik+Ali+Interview.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/334ffd1f-4875-4543-8b92-c5fe5cf69df5/Tarik+Ali+Interview.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/334ffd1f-4875-4543-8b92-c5fe5cf69df5/Tarik+Ali+Interview.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration: Jamhoor</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration: Jamhoor</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>The Progressive Papers Ltd. (PPL) was founded in 1946 by Mian Iftikharuddin, a left-wing politician associated with the Muslim League and erstwhile member of the Indian National Congress, under the patronage of Muhammad Ali Jinnah. Responsible for publishing the daily Pakistan Times and Imroz alongside the weekly Lail-o-Nihaar, the PPL became a home for socialist intellectuals and independent journalists in Pakistan’s early years. Its papers were notable for offering critical coverage of oft-underreported issues concerning labor, land reforms, and preventative detention policies while also situating Pakistan’s domestic preoccupations within the larger context of Cold War conflicts. The papers remained staunch in their opposition to Pakistan’s alignment with the US, maintaining a consistently anti-imperialist line in open defiance of state policy. <br><br>The PPL’s journalistic ranks, however, were not ideologically homogeneous. Its largely male cast of journalists included many who were not avowedly on the Left, and who had been employed as much for their prowess as prolific writers and thinkers as for any political commitment. Faiz Ahmad Faiz, Mazhar Ali Khan, Chiragh Hasan Hasrat, Ahmad Nadeem Qasmi, I. A. Rahman, F. E. Chaudhary, Anwar Ali, and Alys Faiz were among the individuals associated with the project who went on to cement their names in Pakistan's journalistic and literary worlds.</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>The Pakistan Times was first printed out of the Civil &amp; Military Gazette’s building on Lahore’s Mall Road in January 1947, before the PPL settled into its main office on Rattan Chand Road. Imroz, launched in March 1948, began at the Attar Chand Kapoor Press on Abbot Road, next to Nishat Cinema. That was reputedly the second-largest press in undivided India, and Imroz joined its sister paper on Rattan Chand Road in 1950. It was the first Urdu daily printed on a rotary press, and it soon ran editions from Multan and Karachi, with the Multan edition reaching readers as far south as Sukkur. By the Pakistan Times’ tenth anniversary in March 1957, its print order stood at 50,000, the highest in the country. As the papers grew in influence and popularity, the PPL offered a challenge to more centrist and regime-aligned sections of the press. In 1959, however, the Ayub Raj nationalized the organization. Mazhar Ali Khan, who had succeeded Faiz Ahmad Faiz as chief editor of the Pakistan Times, resigned in protest. The papers subsequently became part of the regime’s National Press Trust. What had been a central node for critical journalism and left-wing intellectual production had been reduced to an instrument of military rule.</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>We sat down with veteran intellectual, author, and organizer Tariq Ali, whose father Mazhar Ali Khan was central to the PPL’s editorial history. Having grown up around the papers during their heyday, Ali offers us a personal account of the people, political commitments, and the intellectual currents that animated the PPL’s offices. In this conversation, he traces the ideological origins of the project, the political influence of its journalism, and the relationships between its editors, writers, and the political movements that characterized Pakistan’s formative years.&nbsp;</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Sixty-six years after the takeover, Pakistan’s press again operates under a hybrid order in which the line between civilian government and military command has all but dissolved. The 2025 amendments to the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act have also criminalized the dissemination on social media and elsewhere of “anti-state” sentiment, an ever-expanding and nebulously defined category, making it punishable by imprisonment. As in 1959, the state’s intensified crackdown on dissent at home has gone hand in hand with a courtship of Washington abroad. The PPL may be history, but the dynamics of media dissent and its suppression certainly are not.&nbsp;&nbsp;</em></p>


  









&nbsp;

  <hr />
  

  




&nbsp;
  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Asmer Asrar Safi (AAS): </strong>The Progressive Papers Ltd. (PPL) was founded in 1946, at a moment when the political and intellectual contours of Pakistan were still being contested. Its emergence brought together a range of Muslim League politicians and progressive intellectuals from the Left, making it a particularly interesting site through which to examine the relationship between socialism, anti-imperialism, and the Pakistan Movement.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Could you take us back to the political and intellectual currents that gave rise to this project?&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Tariq Ali (TA): </strong>Well, obviously, these papers wouldn’t have existed without Pakistan. I think a starting point should be the debate on Pakistan within the Left.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">There was a debate inside the Communist Party of India (CPI), and they eventually published a little pamphlet called <em>Pakistan and National Unity</em>, explaining their position. This largely followed Jinnah’s definition of Pakistan, but it went even further in some ways, arguing that Muslims constituted a nationality, if I remember correctly.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Once the CPI had come out in favour of Pakistan, it became impossible for the Muslim League to ignore them. Jinnah was personally very pleased that this had happened because he knew that many people around him were duds: former Unionists and plodders from the Unionist Party. He wanted some real people. There were intellectuals, Muslim intellectuals from the United Provinces—Uttar Pradesh, Lucknow, and elsewhere—who joined the Muslim League, as did people from other parts of India. But the League was looking for intellectuals who could rise above even what it demanded, and it found them in the Communist Party.</p>


  









&nbsp;

























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/48f232c8-0a33-4cb5-a38e-01c4264a10a1/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.58.08%E2%80%AFPM.png" data-image-dimensions="1152x978" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/48f232c8-0a33-4cb5-a38e-01c4264a10a1/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.58.08%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=1000w" width="1152" height="978" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 66.67vw, 66.67vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/48f232c8-0a33-4cb5-a38e-01c4264a10a1/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.58.08%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/48f232c8-0a33-4cb5-a38e-01c4264a10a1/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.58.08%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/48f232c8-0a33-4cb5-a38e-01c4264a10a1/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.58.08%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/48f232c8-0a33-4cb5-a38e-01c4264a10a1/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.58.08%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/48f232c8-0a33-4cb5-a38e-01c4264a10a1/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.58.08%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/48f232c8-0a33-4cb5-a38e-01c4264a10a1/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.58.08%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/48f232c8-0a33-4cb5-a38e-01c4264a10a1/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.58.08%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>From “Pakistan and National Unity” (1942) by Gangadhar Adhikari. Source: Marxists.org.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>From “Pakistan and National Unity” (1942) by Gangadhar Adhikari. Source: Marxists.org.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  

&nbsp;
  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794257573460_20401">Their starting point was the Progressive Writers’ Association, which provided the necessary bridge between the Communist Party and the non-communist, but progressive world. It was a front organization, certainly, but it was a bit more than that. Some people who disliked its close affiliation with the CPI didn’t join it, although they should have. Saadat Hasan Manto, our greatest short-story writer, didn’t join the Progressive Writers’ Association for quite principled reasons.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The other thing worth remembering is that the Muslim League and the Communist Party were the two principal organizations that decided to back the British during the Second World War. The British were therefore well disposed towards them. The League and the CPI were both able to operate relatively openly during the war, while Congress and other nationalists were being imprisoned. This helped the CPI grow and gave its intellectuals access to political circles they had previously been excluded from.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>There was a debate inside the Communist Party of India (CPI), and they eventually published a little pamphlet called Pakistan and National Unity, explaining their position.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This was the atmosphere in which it became clear that Pakistan was going to be formed, come hell or high water. At the last stage, Jinnah was desperate to have something. Afterwards, he complained that Pakistan had been given a “truncated and moth-eaten” territory. In my opinion, the whole process was badly mishandled by the British and the Muslim League, not to mention Congress, which was extremely ungenerous and refused to make serious concessions.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In this atmosphere, the Communist Party leadership in India decided that all its Muslim communists in the areas that were to become Pakistan should, for this particular period, work inside or very close to the Muslim League. My father refused. He said, “No, we’ve been fighting these people all our lives. There’s no way we’re going in there!” But they had to. The party’s decision was that they had to collaborate.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86c61403-78d6-4bd3-a4bb-47b558a46420/Danial_Alma_Latifi_1.width-900.png" data-image-dimensions="346x374" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86c61403-78d6-4bd3-a4bb-47b558a46420/Danial_Alma_Latifi_1.width-900.png?format=1000w" width="346" height="374" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86c61403-78d6-4bd3-a4bb-47b558a46420/Danial_Alma_Latifi_1.width-900.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86c61403-78d6-4bd3-a4bb-47b558a46420/Danial_Alma_Latifi_1.width-900.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86c61403-78d6-4bd3-a4bb-47b558a46420/Danial_Alma_Latifi_1.width-900.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86c61403-78d6-4bd3-a4bb-47b558a46420/Danial_Alma_Latifi_1.width-900.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86c61403-78d6-4bd3-a4bb-47b558a46420/Danial_Alma_Latifi_1.width-900.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86c61403-78d6-4bd3-a4bb-47b558a46420/Danial_Alma_Latifi_1.width-900.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86c61403-78d6-4bd3-a4bb-47b558a46420/Danial_Alma_Latifi_1.width-900.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Danial Alma Latifi (1917-2000). Image: St. John’s College, University of Oxford. </em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Danial Alma Latifi (1917-2000). Image: St. John’s College, University of Oxford. </em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794252315996_45500">That is how Danial Latifi came to be asked to write the Muslim League’s manifesto for the 1946 elections, the most radical manifesto the party ever produced. Latifi was a very witty communist lawyer. The manifesto was approved by Jinnah, who said, “I like this.” And so it became the Muslim League manifesto. Of course, most of the Leaguers in what became Pakistan were landlords. This created a contradiction because the manifesto called, I think, for massive land reforms. From the beginning, there was a major contradiction within the Muslim League. For the landlord Leaguers, the question was how far they could make concessions. They were willing to make a few, but not too many, and ultimately they didn’t make many.</p>
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794252315996_22028">Nevertheless, the communists were not regarded as traitors in what became Pakistan. They were accepted, and this paved the way for the founding of Progressive Papers Limited, which concretized the alliance, however temporary—and it was temporary—between Muslim League leaders and the Left.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The Left was represented by Mian Iftikharuddin, a very talented and gifted politician who had become radicalized while studying at Balliol College, Oxford. He had certainly read the <em>Communist Manifesto</em>, as well as bits and pieces of Marx more generally. The Soviet Union was also winning the war, and its prestige was extremely high at the time. All of this helped shape Mian Iftikharuddin’s politics. He was never formally a member of the CPI, but he was, in some ways, one of its better-known fellow travelers.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>That is how Danial Latifi came to be asked to write the Muslim League’s manifesto for the 1946 elections, the most radical manifesto the party ever produced. Latifi was a very witty communist lawyer. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The first informal meeting included Mian [Iftikharuddin] Sahib and Faiz Ahmad Faiz. I have a feeling that Sibte Hasan and Sajjad Zaheer, from the Progressive Writers’ Association, were also consulted, although Sajjad Zaheer had not yet moved to Pakistan. This was the first meeting at which they decided, or at least discussed, setting up a newspaper chain. It was Mian Sahib’s idea. A new country would need newspapers. The only newspaper of any significance apart from the pre-independence papers was <em>Dawn</em>, which, if my memory serves me correctly, had been a Muslim League weekly in Delhi. It was brought to Karachi, and the Haroon family helped turn it into a daily newspaper. But there was very little else. Its circulation was largely concentrated in Karachi. Although it circulated more widely later, it wasn’t a popular paper in the broader sense. It was too closely identified with one political formation: the Muslim League.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The idea of creating Progressive Papers Limited was therefore a brilliant one.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9eb3b87a-0f13-44fb-a6c3-55d3bbed9019/Mian-Iftikhar-1024x784.png" data-image-dimensions="1024x784" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9eb3b87a-0f13-44fb-a6c3-55d3bbed9019/Mian-Iftikhar-1024x784.png?format=1000w" width="1024" height="784" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9eb3b87a-0f13-44fb-a6c3-55d3bbed9019/Mian-Iftikhar-1024x784.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9eb3b87a-0f13-44fb-a6c3-55d3bbed9019/Mian-Iftikhar-1024x784.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9eb3b87a-0f13-44fb-a6c3-55d3bbed9019/Mian-Iftikhar-1024x784.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9eb3b87a-0f13-44fb-a6c3-55d3bbed9019/Mian-Iftikhar-1024x784.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9eb3b87a-0f13-44fb-a6c3-55d3bbed9019/Mian-Iftikhar-1024x784.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9eb3b87a-0f13-44fb-a6c3-55d3bbed9019/Mian-Iftikhar-1024x784.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9eb3b87a-0f13-44fb-a6c3-55d3bbed9019/Mian-Iftikhar-1024x784.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Mian Iftikharuddin. Image: Revolutionary Papers.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Mian Iftikharuddin. Image: Revolutionary Papers.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">My father, Mazhar Ali Khan, and Mian Iftikharuddin were very close friends. They had worked together as left-wing members of Congress at one stage. Mian Sahib was keen to involve my father in the papers from the beginning. At the time, my father had decided that his main task in life was to establish peasant organizations near our family estates, educate the peasants, and build militant peasant organizations. He had gone to Wah, in Rawalpindi district, and begun his work, much to the annoyance of other members of the family. The CPI Central Committee discussed the matter because my father said he would follow the party’s instructions. Although he could have entered Parliament through his family, the party advised him against taking a seat on that basis.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1d2d778e-1b37-405f-9610-175a53a4aec2/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.18.46.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="2364x5120" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1d2d778e-1b37-405f-9610-175a53a4aec2/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.18.46.jpeg?format=1000w" width="2364" height="5120" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1d2d778e-1b37-405f-9610-175a53a4aec2/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.18.46.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1d2d778e-1b37-405f-9610-175a53a4aec2/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.18.46.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1d2d778e-1b37-405f-9610-175a53a4aec2/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.18.46.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1d2d778e-1b37-405f-9610-175a53a4aec2/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.18.46.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1d2d778e-1b37-405f-9610-175a53a4aec2/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.18.46.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1d2d778e-1b37-405f-9610-175a53a4aec2/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.18.46.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1d2d778e-1b37-405f-9610-175a53a4aec2/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.18.46.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Pakistan Times report on a speech delivered by Mian Iftikharuddin at Islamia College, Lahore, in December 1947. Source: Government College University Library, Lahore.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Pakistan Times report on a speech delivered by Mian Iftikharuddin at Islamia College, Lahore, in December 1947. Source: Government College University Library, Lahore.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794275023330_29199">At this point, Mian Iftikharuddin sent him a telegram saying that he was coming to Wah and that my father should put everything aside for a week because they needed to talk. He came and stayed with us, speaking with my father every day. My father said, “Look, Mian Sahib, political organization is essential. It has been very weak in this part of the country. Now, with Hindu and Sikh communists leaving in droves, the party is going to be very weak in any case. I think I should concentrate on this.” Mian Sahib replied, “Look, this is really your forte: writing and investigating. Do it for the newspaper.” He eventually persuaded my father to become deputy editor under Faiz.&nbsp;</p>
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794275023330_23676">My father subsequently became a central part of the whole operation. In fact, it was he who came up with the name “Progressive Papers Limited.” He felt that they had to signal, even if not through the pages themselves, who they were.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The point I’m making is that this group of progressives had already decided to establish the papers before they went to see Jinnah. There’s a notion that the idea came from Jinnah, but that’s nonsense. They went to see Jinnah, who thought it was a good idea. He was quite open-minded in that respect. But he said that they should also work with some of his people. So the leading landlords were brought in as shareholders, like Mumtaz Daultana and Shaukat Hayat—my maternal uncle. But Mian Sahib insisted that, since he had set the whole thing up, he should have a controlling stake. I think he held 50 per cent. With those shares, there was no doubt about who would control and dominate the paper.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">One of the Muslim League leaders, possibly Jinnah himself although I’m not sure, also told the people setting up the papers that they were very clever but had never run a newspaper before. To help them, they had arranged for Brigadier Desmond Young, a British officer, to work with Progressive Papers Limited for a time. This is something that isn’t usually mentioned or publicized very much, but it should be. My father, Mian Iftikharuddin, and Faiz said, in effect, “So what? Let him sit in the office. If he gives us useful technical advice, we’ll accept it. Otherwise, we’ll keep him happy, make sure he gets his drinks on time, and so on.” Young eventually gave up, saying that the editors were set in their ways and producing a good newspaper, so there wasn’t much he could do.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">That is how the whole thing came into being.</p>


  









&nbsp;


  

  



  
    
      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794256123311-MU7LXTOVECL99OMPKIW9/The+Pakistan+Times+main+office.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1280x911" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="Pakistan Times and Imroz Offices at Rattan Chand Road, Lahore. " data-load="false" data-image-id="6af22cfbdb2d6a67e7a60553" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794256123311-MU7LXTOVECL99OMPKIW9/The+Pakistan+Times+main+office.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794256123390-1SF8IFPFG5TSPXFDK0LI/WhatsApp+Image+2026-10-30+at+5.51.14+PM.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1600x1048" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="Pakistan Times and Imroz Offices at Rattan Chand Road, Lahore. " data-load="false" data-image-id="6af22cfbb17fd97d1ff6349d" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794256123390-1SF8IFPFG5TSPXFDK0LI/WhatsApp+Image+2026-10-30+at+5.51.14+PM.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      
    
  

  
    
    
    
      
      
        
          <a tabindex="0" role="button" class="previous" aria-label="Previous Slide"
          ></a>
          <a tabindex="0" role="button" class="next" aria-label="Next Slide"
          ></a>
        
      
    
    
     
  




  

    
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
    

  






  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>Offices of the Pakistan Times and Imroz at Rattan Chand Road, Lahore. Images: Mazhar Ali Khan family archive.</em></p>


  









&nbsp;
  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Mishael Hyat Ayub (MHA): </strong>You’ve spoken about the need for a newspaper in Pakistan’s early years. In your book, <em>Pakistan: Military Rule or People’s Power</em>, you draw extensively on the <em>Pakistan Times</em> to reconstruct the political conflicts unfolding during this period. What does reading the <em>Pakistan Times</em> allow us to see that we might not be able to recover from other sources? More broadly, whose voices was the paper trying to represent? What kind of Pakistan did it imagine the new state could become, particularly amid the conflicts shaping it, from Kashmir and refugee rehabilitation to the instability of early governments?&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>TA</strong>: I think that if you study the <em>Pakistan Times</em> closely, some things become very obvious. Politically, the newspaper wasn’t explicitly socialist, but it was definitely in favour of massive reforms to the country’s structures, especially in the countryside. It reported peasant evictions in a way that no other newspaper did. Its sister paper, <em>Imroz</em>, which was established a year later, in 1948, covered these issues particularly well too. For many readers, it was the first time they had gained an idea of how peasants lived and what their lives involved. The papers also reported working-class struggles and actions in factories.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">They also covered political debates taking place both within and outside the Muslim League. Overall, I would describe their perspective as one of social-democratic rationalism. They weren’t religious papers, but they were strongly committed to ensuring that democracy and the democratic institutions established after 1947 functioned properly. They reported on parliamentary debates, for instance. Other newspapers did this too, but the <em>Pakistan Times</em> gave these debates meaning by explaining the context in which they took place.&nbsp;</p>


  









&nbsp;


  

  



  
    
      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263102959-ZKRMFMJF2NA4I6JUXU19/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%282%29.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="2811x2816" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="WhatsApp Image 2026-11-09 at 22.19.04 (2).jpeg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af2483be0a43a116875ad26" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263102959-ZKRMFMJF2NA4I6JUXU19/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%282%29.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263105645-X4H66DRH6OV7UJRDHP8T/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%283%29.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="3271x5120" data-image-focal-point="0.5368184840425532,0.14965986394557823" alt="WhatsApp Image 2026-11-09 at 22.19.04 (3).jpeg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af2483b6d86c43c4b7c9e4b" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263105645-X4H66DRH6OV7UJRDHP8T/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%283%29.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263107309-VJFN060MZHG0GMLQR1IV/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%284%29.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="2606x4993" data-image-focal-point="0.47879464285714285,0.1360544217687075" alt="WhatsApp Image 2026-11-09 at 22.19.04 (4).jpeg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af2484130b3e9207657e70f" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263107309-VJFN060MZHG0GMLQR1IV/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%284%29.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263110477-5F0PUU5LZ4USJOITPCBQ/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="2626x5120" data-image-focal-point="0.49604166666666666,0.10884353741496598" alt="WhatsApp Image 2026-11-09 at 22.19.04.jpeg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af248437492842c3d47e647" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263110477-5F0PUU5LZ4USJOITPCBQ/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263110815-8AUY108R9CV8ZODBKWO7/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.22.31.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1045x1600" data-image-focal-point="0.4844563802083333,0.10884353741496598" alt="WhatsApp Image 2026-11-09 at 22.22.31.jpeg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af2484669c715197cefdbef" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263110815-8AUY108R9CV8ZODBKWO7/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.22.31.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263113652-Z3FU5RSZ0XA3UY15T90U/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%281%29.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="2736x4395" data-image-focal-point="0.4919327445652174,0.08163265306122448" alt="WhatsApp Image 2026-11-09 at 22.19.04 (1).jpeg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af2484798bdf1569a31d90b" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263113652-Z3FU5RSZ0XA3UY15T90U/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%281%29.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263115984-P262APYQB0V1O262UXK9/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.03.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="2843x4164" data-image-focal-point="0.416875,0.10884353741496598" alt="WhatsApp Image 2026-11-09 at 22.19.03.jpeg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af24849fbd03b396f4ec0b2" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794263115984-P262APYQB0V1O262UXK9/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.03.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      
    
  

  
    
    
    
      
      
        
          <a tabindex="0" role="button" class="previous" aria-label="Previous Slide"
          ></a>
          <a tabindex="0" role="button" class="next" aria-label="Next Slide"
          ></a>
        
      
    
    
     
  




  

    
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
    

  






  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>Clippings from the Pakistan Times (1946-1948). Source: Government College University Library, Lahore.</em></p>


  









&nbsp;
  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>I would describe their perspective as one of social-democratic rationalism. They weren’t religious papers, but they were strongly committed to ensuring that democracy and the democratic institutions established after 1947 functioned properly. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">From the beginning, the papers strongly opposed fake news, which some other newspapers published to encourage their own side. That was their importance, and it’s why I used them extensively in my book. I was surprised by how useful the paper’s archives proved to be. While I was writing the book, the late Nizamuddin, the librarian at the <em>Pakistan Times</em> who had established its library, sent me every clipping I requested. I would tell him which subject I was working on, and the clippings would arrive in parcels in London, where I was writing. It was incredibly useful. Nobody else was [reporting and analyzing events] on the same scale and detail.&nbsp;</p>
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">On Kashmir, the paper’s position was clear from the beginning. Faiz was a close personal friend of Sheikh Abdullah, the Kashmiri Muslim leader, and obtained information that wasn’t being supplied to other newspapers. Nehru had pledged a referendum and the right of Kashmiris to national self-determination, but he kept delaying it. The <em>Pakistan Times</em>’ editorials argued more or less that the way Indians had taken Kashmir was blatantly unfair and that the people should be allowed to choose their future.</p>


  









&nbsp;


  

  



  
    
      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794264815834-H82IPNHEDP37Q3XODWL9/PHOTO-2026-11-09-22-52-49.jpg" data-image-dimensions="3668x5120" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="PHOTO-2026-11-09-22-52-49.jpg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af24ee94501f92dd56b50dd" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794264815834-H82IPNHEDP37Q3XODWL9/PHOTO-2026-11-09-22-52-49.jpg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794264820537-ETQD47WRRD4E667P5ISA/PHOTO-2026-11-09-22-52-50.jpg" data-image-dimensions="3142x5120" data-image-focal-point="0.41788194444444443,0.09523809523809523" alt="PHOTO-2026-11-09-22-52-50.jpg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af24ef0b6be630892b020e1" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794264820537-ETQD47WRRD4E667P5ISA/PHOTO-2026-11-09-22-52-50.jpg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      
    
  

  
    
    
    
      
      
        
          <a tabindex="0" role="button" class="previous" aria-label="Previous Slide"
          ></a>
          <a tabindex="0" role="button" class="next" aria-label="Next Slide"
          ></a>
        
      
    
    
     
  




  

    
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
    

  






  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>Clippings from the Pakistan Times (1947). Source: Government College University Library, Lahore.</em></p>


  









&nbsp;
  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Pakistan’s early foreign policy was another area where the Papers were at loggerheads with every<strong> </strong>[Pakistani]<strong> </strong>government. The <em>Pakistan Times</em> was opposed to Pakistan joining the security pacts. They were opposed to Pakistan's membership of the Baghdad Pact, which was set up by the United States during the Cold War as part of their war strategy.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Initially, there was little debate about foreign policy in the government. The Muslim League leaders largely accepted British advice. In one of my books, I provide evidence of a Muslim League leader travelling around and meeting Americans and British officials to ask which direction Pakistan should take. There was very little independent-mindedness within the Muslim League. An overwhelming majority of its leaders had become so accustomed to working with the British that, to be frank, they didn’t know how to think independently.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The thought that Pakistan could have pursued an independent foreign policy or adopted non-alignment, as India was moving to do, was rejected by some for rather foolish reasons. They didn’t want to copy India. It was childish things like that. By and large, Pakistan’s leaders decided to join the post-war pro-American bloc of countries.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">On the other hand, the papers were hostile to the security pacts because they correctly understood them as a crude attempt to gobble up Pakistan and control its foreign policy, which was certainly the case. One big incident on this front is when the British, French, and Israelis invaded Egypt in 1956 in an attempt to topple Nasser because he nationalized the Suez Canal. Pakistan’s government of the day, led by the Bengali politician Huseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy, supported Britain and Israel. It didn’t support Nasser.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>In some ways, this was the Progressive Papers’ finest hour. Through their newspapers, they helped mobilize opposition to the government’s policy, and people took to the streets in defiance of it.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In some ways, this was the Progressive Papers’ finest hour. Through their newspapers, they helped mobilize opposition to the government’s policy, and people took to the streets in defiance of it. I remember the demonstration very vividly because I was there, at a very young age. There were hundreds of thousands of people on the streets of Lahore. All the universities closed down, and students came out on strike. The pressure forced the government to move back a bit from the position it had taken. The Progressive Papers’ role was incredibly popular, although other newspapers attacked it for supporting Nasser.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This was a high point: the papers were at loggerheads with the government over foreign policy, and their position intensified American anger. The US wanted Pakistan to remain in its camp, not to have a newspaper permanently criticizing its influence.</p>


  









&nbsp;


  

  



  
    
      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794315105210-MNH9PF7FC3J65WCGIORZ/Zhou+Enali+visit+2.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1600x1028" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="Zhou Enali visit 2.jpeg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af3135f3f0ad70963ce1790" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794315105210-MNH9PF7FC3J65WCGIORZ/Zhou+Enali+visit+2.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794315105019-WANJW68M2YAY9V1F0CLE/Zhou+Enlai+visit.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1600x1042" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="Zhou Enlai visit.jpeg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af3135f434a5f2651c09937" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794315105019-WANJW68M2YAY9V1F0CLE/Zhou+Enlai+visit.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794315106561-DFD8783WW4JDQ3KRWG0N/Zhou+Enlai_s+visit+to+Pakistan.+Lunch+at+Mian+Iftikharuddins.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1280x886" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="Zhou Enlai_s visit to Pakistan. Lunch at Mian Iftikharuddins.jpeg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af31362cc7e460e4fab824b" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794315106561-DFD8783WW4JDQ3KRWG0N/Zhou+Enlai_s+visit+to+Pakistan.+Lunch+at+Mian+Iftikharuddins.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      
    
  

  
    
    
    
      
      
        
          <a tabindex="0" role="button" class="previous" aria-label="Previous Slide"
          ></a>
          <a tabindex="0" role="button" class="next" aria-label="Next Slide"
          ></a>
        
      
    
    
     
  




  

    
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
    

  






  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>Reception for Zhou Enlai at Mian Iftikharuddin’s residence at 21 Aikman Road, Lahore, during his 1956 visit to Pakistan. The Chinese delegation included He Long, Qiao Guanhua and Gong Peng. Source: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives. </em></p>


  









&nbsp;
  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>MHA: </strong>All this internationalism and anti-imperialism existed within an increasingly repressive domestic political environment, from the 1951 Rawalpindi Conspiracy Case to the imprisonment of people involved in Progressive Papers Limited—Faiz, among others—and the subsequent banning of the Communist Party of Pakistan in 1954, which profoundly altered the terrain in which the Left could operate.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">How do you think the papers navigated all this? What was the relationship between their anti-imperialist editorial positions and the repression of the organized Left within Pakistan?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>TA:</strong> The anti-imperialist position was popular because it also appealed to a certain nationalism. It wasn’t particularly strong, but it did exist in the country on some levels. And the conspiracy cannot be understood outside that context.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The decision of the Muslim League government to collaborate permanently with the British and later the Americans is what created the crisis inside the army.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Major General Akbar Khan, [a ringleader of the conspiracy] who was second-in-command in the army, wasn’t a nobody. He had been angered by the failure to do anything on Kashmir, because the British had vetoed any direct involvement by the Pakistan army—whereas the Indians were allowed to fly in and take Srinagar airport with support from the British. Gandhi, despite his pacifism, was very strongly in favour of that move. In Pakistan, the army wasn’t allowed to do the same.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This created a great deal of anger inside the army towards the British. What General Akbar was planning was a radical coup that would break relations with the British—not literally, perhaps, but would move Pakistan into a completely different position. It would have been a pre-Nasser coup, because Nasser hadn’t yet emerged in that way. These developments were taking place inside the Pakistan army from late 1947 onwards.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>The anti-imperialist position was popular because it also appealed to a certain nationalism.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Of course, there was also the involvement of the Communist Party. You must understand that what was left of the Communist Party in Pakistan after Partition was tiny. In the Frontier, the main political force was Abdul Ghaffar Khan’s Khudai Khidmatgar movement. The communists worked with it rather than fighting it, but were unable to build a strong independent organization there. The Communist Party of India (CPI) had been strong in Punjab, but with the departure of the Sikhs after Partition, there were very few Muslims involved as such and the communists were unable to sustain a party. That was why the CPI decided to send Sajjad Zaheer, Sibte Hasan, Imtiaz Ali Khan, and others from India to try to build the party in Pakistan.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The problem was that they were very good intellectuals, but they had no real independent base in Punjab. They had a tiny base in Karachi, where large numbers of Muslim refugees had arrived from India after 1947. In some ways, Karachi became the strongest base of the communist movement in Pakistan. But it wasn’t a large party, and it never developed into one. Some party members used to complain that all their best cadres had been taken by Progressive Papers Limited and given salaries at <em>Imroz</em> and the <em>Pakistan Times</em>. They would mock the journalists, saying, “We have to work from the ground up, while you people have already got jobs,” and so on. There was an element of truth in that.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">But the reason these people had been recruited was that some of them were very good journalists and functioned as such. <em>Imroz</em>, in particular, had a very fine stable of Urdu writers and journalists, including progressives and some communists. That was one reason the paper had a knack for winning popular support. Before the takeover, it was published, I think, in Lahore, Karachi, and Multan.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">When I met Sajjad Zaheer in London for the first time after the Rawalpindi Conspiracy Case in the 1960s, we sat and chatted for several hours. I asked him to explain his involvement in the conspiracy case, and his first sentence had me in fits of laughter. He said, “Well, Tariq, this is how it happened, we were at a cocktail party in Lahore.” [<em>Laughs</em>]</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">He continued: “Akbar came. I was there, and Faiz was there too—or perhaps it was Sibte, not Faiz. But I was there. General Akbar Khan suddenly came up to me and said, ‘Listen, we need you communists because we are making arrangements to overthrow this government. We need your help drafting the manifesto and so on. Write it, and work with us.’”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I asked him, “Did you have no hesitations at all?”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">He said, “Bhai, we weren’t that strong anyway. We thought, if something comes of it, so be it.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I said, “The Left, whatever was left of it in Pakistan, you helped destroy, and then you went back to India.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">He said, “Yes, it was a big mistake.” He said they had become a bit overexcited.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The communists also helped prepare a list of people to be executed if they seized power. It included senior state and government figures; Qurban Ali Khan, the Inspector General of Police, was certainly on it.</p>


  









&nbsp;

























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9f3906c6-b2d7-401d-8e5d-b306be3264b1/1.+Faiz+arrest+1951.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1061x1600" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9f3906c6-b2d7-401d-8e5d-b306be3264b1/1.+Faiz+arrest+1951.jpeg?format=1000w" width="1061" height="1600" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 50.00vw, 50.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9f3906c6-b2d7-401d-8e5d-b306be3264b1/1.+Faiz+arrest+1951.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9f3906c6-b2d7-401d-8e5d-b306be3264b1/1.+Faiz+arrest+1951.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9f3906c6-b2d7-401d-8e5d-b306be3264b1/1.+Faiz+arrest+1951.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9f3906c6-b2d7-401d-8e5d-b306be3264b1/1.+Faiz+arrest+1951.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9f3906c6-b2d7-401d-8e5d-b306be3264b1/1.+Faiz+arrest+1951.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9f3906c6-b2d7-401d-8e5d-b306be3264b1/1.+Faiz+arrest+1951.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9f3906c6-b2d7-401d-8e5d-b306be3264b1/1.+Faiz+arrest+1951.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Letter from Mazhar Ali Khan to the editors of various Lahore newspapers following Faiz Ahmad Faiz’s arrest on 9 March 1951. Source: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives. </em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Letter from Mazhar Ali Khan to the editors of various Lahore newspapers following Faiz Ahmad Faiz’s arrest on 9 March 1951. Source: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives. </em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  

&nbsp;
  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794252315996_169365">But it was never a serious conspiracy. They were infiltrated from the very beginning by senior army officers, brigadiers and others, who pretended to go along with the conspiracy while reporting everything back to military intelligence. The advice from military intelligence was to hang on and let it continue. There was also no way the conspirators were on the verge of seizing power. They had very few contacts in East Pakistan, which is something few people discuss. If the Communist Party had been seriously involved, you would expect to see some participation from East Pakistan, where the communists were a real political force, even if not an especially large one.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Now, Mishael asked how the Progressive Papers navigated their way through this. Mercifully, my father wasn’t told about the conspiracy. He wasn’t involved at all. Ahmed Nadeem Qasmi and others at <em>Imroz</em> weren’t involved either, and neither was Mian Iftikharuddin. The line they adopted was that if Faiz had been involved—<em>if</em>, they didn’t say that he was—he certainly hadn’t passed the information on to them.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>There was also no way the conspirators were on the verge of seizing power. They had very few contacts in East Pakistan, which is something few people discuss.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">My parents were very grateful that they hadn’t been taken into the conspirators’ confidence. In fact, this was the only time my mother, because all of its leaders had been arrested, was appointed general secretary of the underground Communist Party. She worked in that capacity, but the party was soon banned, and the whole thing came to an end.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">That is precisely why I say that what remained in Pakistan [after the conspiracy and the banning of the Communist Party of Pakistan in 1954] was Progressive Papers Limited. It became the voice of the progressive left, whether communist or non-communist. Anyone who was progressive appreciated the papers. In later years, I would meet people who told me, “We were in the army,” or “We were in the civil service, but we were educated by those newspapers. That’s why our caliber was slightly better,” they would joke.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The papers survived the conspiracy. Faiz, I think, was kept on the payroll while he was in prison.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AAS: </strong>I want to briefly return to Mian Iftikharuddin, especially given his break from the Muslim League in 1948, and how his own political trajectory evolved from that point onwards. There was the Azad Pakistan Party and the National Awami Party–both of which he helped establish. Could you speak to his political evolution and how it intersected with the history of the papers, particularly as the Left itself was, in many ways, forced to evolve during the 1950s?&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>TA:</strong> After Faiz’s arrest, my father was appointed principal editor in charge of both the <em>Pakistan Times</em> and <em>Imroz</em>. He was the person responsible for what they did.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a7f8610e-96e1-4cca-99cf-9c2c64bbe14d/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%285%29.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="2817x4709" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a7f8610e-96e1-4cca-99cf-9c2c64bbe14d/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%285%29.jpeg?format=1000w" width="2817" height="4709" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a7f8610e-96e1-4cca-99cf-9c2c64bbe14d/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%285%29.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a7f8610e-96e1-4cca-99cf-9c2c64bbe14d/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%285%29.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a7f8610e-96e1-4cca-99cf-9c2c64bbe14d/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%285%29.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a7f8610e-96e1-4cca-99cf-9c2c64bbe14d/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%285%29.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a7f8610e-96e1-4cca-99cf-9c2c64bbe14d/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%285%29.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a7f8610e-96e1-4cca-99cf-9c2c64bbe14d/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%285%29.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a7f8610e-96e1-4cca-99cf-9c2c64bbe14d/WhatsApp+Image+2026-11-09+at+22.19.04+%285%29.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Pakistan Times report on Mian Iftikharuddin’s resignation as Minister for Rehabilitation of Refugees in November 1947. Source: Government College University Library, Lahore.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Pakistan Times report on Mian Iftikharuddin’s resignation as Minister for Rehabilitation of Refugees in November 1947. Source: Government College University Library, Lahore.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794263179724_49414">Mian Sahib himself left the Muslim League in 1948, which was, of course, an event tied to the instructions given by Moscow to all its parties to try to seize power. This was the period of the Ranadive thesis within the Indian Communist Party, which was a sudden shift away from working with Congress towards armed rebellions, one or two of which weren’t entirely unsuccessful. In Pakistan, however, there was nothing of the sort. All it meant was a break with the Muslim League and the setting up of a front party, the Azad Pakistan Party.</p>
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794263179724_40521">All the banned communists, and people who would be banned in the future, joined the Azad Pakistan Party. Originally, it also had a few Muslim Leaguers who came over on the basis that the Azad Pakistan people said, “Well, we support the 1946 manifesto of the Muslim League. We’re not going beyond that.” But then they realized that this was actually a nest of communists and more committed people.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Mian Sahib kept the party going, but the Progressive Papers didn’t give it too much publicity. He was always grumbling and complaining. He once even said to me, “Your father never gave us more publicity than we deserved. And he said the papers couldn’t be used for that purpose.” Which they weren’t. They were careful not to be linked to the organization.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/082bc66d-a6ad-4fab-a5f7-e91c3b7bac32/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Abdul+Ghaffar+Khan.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1600x1124" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/082bc66d-a6ad-4fab-a5f7-e91c3b7bac32/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Abdul+Ghaffar+Khan.jpeg?format=1000w" width="1600" height="1124" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/082bc66d-a6ad-4fab-a5f7-e91c3b7bac32/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Abdul+Ghaffar+Khan.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/082bc66d-a6ad-4fab-a5f7-e91c3b7bac32/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Abdul+Ghaffar+Khan.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/082bc66d-a6ad-4fab-a5f7-e91c3b7bac32/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Abdul+Ghaffar+Khan.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/082bc66d-a6ad-4fab-a5f7-e91c3b7bac32/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Abdul+Ghaffar+Khan.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/082bc66d-a6ad-4fab-a5f7-e91c3b7bac32/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Abdul+Ghaffar+Khan.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/082bc66d-a6ad-4fab-a5f7-e91c3b7bac32/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Abdul+Ghaffar+Khan.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/082bc66d-a6ad-4fab-a5f7-e91c3b7bac32/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Abdul+Ghaffar+Khan.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Mazhar Ali Khan with Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan. Image: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Mazhar Ali Khan with Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan. Image: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Later on, when people began creating an opposition movement in Pakistan, those in the Azad Pakistan Party, who were mainly centered in Lahore and Karachi, decided to link up with Ghaffar Khan’s movement in Pakhtunkhwa. The Muslim League governments never got over the fact that, in one of the largest Muslim-majority provinces, they had systematically lost elections to Ghaffar Khan, who believed in a composite nationalism rather than just a Muslim nationalism. That irritated them, and they punished him. They locked him up for periods of time; he would go to Jalalabad in Afghanistan and not return to Pakistan, and so on. But his Khudai Khidmatgars moved leftwards as they saw what they were confronted with. The National Awami Party was born out of the amalgamation of the Khudai Khidmatgars, the Azad Pakistan Party, and other smaller groups and individuals from the Left.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">However, the generation that brought down the dictatorship in 1969 was a generation that had been educated by the Progressive Papers Limited. There’s no doubt about that.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>MHA: The<em> Pakistan Times</em> and <em>Imroz</em> brought together writers, journalists and intellectuals, including people who did not share the Left’s politics. They also developed a distinctive visual culture, with F. E. Choudhury’s photographs and Anwar Ali’s cartoons. What made their editorial culture distinctive, and how did PPL balance progressive commitments with journalistic independence and professional standards?</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>TA:</strong> The PPL emerged partly because of the weaknesses of the Left in Pakistan. They were very tiny after 1947. And Iftikharuddin’s brilliant initiative was to make sure that the Left didn’t totally disappear.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a830cd6c-2c01-4f40-82b5-597886de8a08/792694940-1687408638-1741238085.jpg" data-image-dimensions="562x562" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a830cd6c-2c01-4f40-82b5-597886de8a08/792694940-1687408638-1741238085.jpg?format=1000w" width="562" height="562" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a830cd6c-2c01-4f40-82b5-597886de8a08/792694940-1687408638-1741238085.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a830cd6c-2c01-4f40-82b5-597886de8a08/792694940-1687408638-1741238085.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a830cd6c-2c01-4f40-82b5-597886de8a08/792694940-1687408638-1741238085.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a830cd6c-2c01-4f40-82b5-597886de8a08/792694940-1687408638-1741238085.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a830cd6c-2c01-4f40-82b5-597886de8a08/792694940-1687408638-1741238085.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a830cd6c-2c01-4f40-82b5-597886de8a08/792694940-1687408638-1741238085.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a830cd6c-2c01-4f40-82b5-597886de8a08/792694940-1687408638-1741238085.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Chiragh Hasan Hasrat. Image: The Friday Times.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Chiragh Hasan Hasrat. Image: The Friday Times.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794317043123_33759">Faiz and my father were very particular about the quality of the research and writing. This is why the first editor of <em>Imroz</em> was not on the Left at all. Chiragh Hasan Hasrat was one of the great Urdu journalists of his time, very witty and an incredible Urdu writer. And Faiz actually suggested that the Urdu paper’s quality had to be particularly high because there was competition in the field. <em>Nawa-i-Waqt</em> in particular also had good columnists, but from the right-wing. Hasrat was given a free hand over <em>Imroz</em>. He finally left because he quarreled with everyone, but without any animus. But he left behind a very strong team of writers and journalists whom he had helped to train. Hameed Akhtar was one of them, and he was a leftist.&nbsp;</p>
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794317043123_29182">I’m stressing this to emphasize that the aim was, in a strange way, to make sure that the newspapers were journalistically of a very high quality. It was a curious hybrid. People like my father argued that, otherwise, it would be very difficult to defend even progressive views. The newspapers had to become indispensable, so that people knew that if you wanted to read real news and get real coverage in the English press, it was <em>Pakistan Times</em>, and in the Urdu language, well, <em>Imroz</em>, alongside its competitors. Later on, when the newspapers were taken over in 1959, I think <em>Time</em> magazine or <em>Newsweek</em> said that <em>Pakistan Times</em> was the best-edited paper in Asia. Everyone who led PPL—Chiragh Hasan Hasrat, Iftikharuddin, Faiz, my father and, later, Ahmed Nadeem Qasmi—made sure the standards of journalism did not fall.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>I’m stressing this to emphasize that the aim was, in a strange way, to make sure that the newspapers were journalistically of a very high quality. It was a curious hybrid. People like my father argued that, otherwise, it would be very difficult to defend even progressive views.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794272000883_225169">And there was the fact-checking. There were people at <em>Pakistan Times</em>—Nizamuddin, the librarian, was one of them, but there were others—who would cast an eye over a story. If anything didn’t look right, they checked the facts. They rang the reporter up in Lyallpur, saying, “Where did you get this news from? Who told you?” Things like that, which were very unusual for the press in Pakistan at that time and created new standards for reporting altogether.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794272000883_225168">Choudhury Sahib, the photographer, was a genius in his own way. He photographed people who were normally ignored in this totally bourgeois, elite-dominated world. Workers would see their photographs after a May Day demonstration. Women forming women’s organizations would see their meetings covered.&nbsp;</p>


  









&nbsp;


  

  



  
    
      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794256570728-AYB842X6C3Z2ZNZUYZLC/Faiz+and+Mazhar+with+Soviet_Eastern+European+journalists.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1600x1107" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="Faiz and Mazhar with Soviet_Eastern European journalists.jpg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af22ebaa9f9b13cdf15149c" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794256570728-AYB842X6C3Z2ZNZUYZLC/Faiz+and+Mazhar+with+Soviet_Eastern+European+journalists.jpg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794256570540-LQY6N8YV1KQ6PGLSHQTC/Possibly+press+conferece.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1600x1348" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="Possibly press conferece.jpeg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af22ebaa9f9b13cdf15149a" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794256570540-LQY6N8YV1KQ6PGLSHQTC/Possibly+press+conferece.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794256569377-6TZ2H7KPOVOZGD6X9ED6/PT+newsroom.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1600x1092" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="PT newsroom.jpeg" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af22eb955cea35e8d908eba" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794256569377-6TZ2H7KPOVOZGD6X9ED6/PT+newsroom.jpeg?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      
    
  

  
    
    
    
      
      
        
          <a tabindex="0" role="button" class="previous" aria-label="Previous Slide"
          ></a>
          <a tabindex="0" role="button" class="next" aria-label="Next Slide"
          ></a>
        
      
    
    
     
  




  

    
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
    

  






  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>From the offices of the Progressive Papers Ltd. Images: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives. </em></p>


  









&nbsp;
  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This visual side extended to cartoons. Anwar developed this character called Nanna in 1953, who served as the daily voice of the readers. He was the one people would look to and say, “What does Nanna say today?” And, as with these things, not every one of them was brilliant. They were uneven. But they were an interesting innovation.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[In terms of working relations], it was a very friendly, comradely atmosphere–not at all “I am the boss and you are working for me.” People used to go and talk to Iftikharuddin when they saw him, and he encouraged that. And Iftikharuddin, in particular, laughed a lot when people made jokes about him, if they were funny. He never minded that. One famous example was that he would cast a quick eye over <em>Imroz</em> every day, though he never read it. One day, he walked into Chiragh Hasan Hasrat’s office and said, “Today you’ve really outdone yourself—there’s a beautiful editorial in <em>Imroz.</em>” Hasrat thanked him, then joked to the other journalists that Iftikharuddin’s chauffeur, Khizer, must have read the paper.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Faiz was, of course, a guy in his own right, with his own identity, but he never used that in any way. None of this “I’m a great poet” business. People respected him for what he was, and he behaved like any other person. And that also had a way of educating people.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The papers also brought together journalists who did not necessarily share the Left’s politics. The chief reporter, Iftikhar Ahmed, was not on the Left, but was an excellent journalist who respected the papers because they allowed him to tell the truth. He left when the papers were taken over and later became a lawyer, working with Mahmud Ali Kasuri and others.</p>


  









&nbsp;

























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5f8bd99-80e6-4716-ac66-a1923a3d3dc7/Staff+payroll+journalists.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1600x1109" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5f8bd99-80e6-4716-ac66-a1923a3d3dc7/Staff+payroll+journalists.jpeg?format=1000w" width="1600" height="1109" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 66.67vw, 66.67vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5f8bd99-80e6-4716-ac66-a1923a3d3dc7/Staff+payroll+journalists.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5f8bd99-80e6-4716-ac66-a1923a3d3dc7/Staff+payroll+journalists.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5f8bd99-80e6-4716-ac66-a1923a3d3dc7/Staff+payroll+journalists.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5f8bd99-80e6-4716-ac66-a1923a3d3dc7/Staff+payroll+journalists.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5f8bd99-80e6-4716-ac66-a1923a3d3dc7/Staff+payroll+journalists.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5f8bd99-80e6-4716-ac66-a1923a3d3dc7/Staff+payroll+journalists.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5f8bd99-80e6-4716-ac66-a1923a3d3dc7/Staff+payroll+journalists.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>Staff salary and increment register for the Progressive Papers Ltd. Image: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>Staff salary and increment register for the Progressive Papers Ltd. Image: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  

&nbsp;&nbsp;

























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c57c9b0e-9118-4efe-86af-05f3acdff015/Pakistan+Times+anniversary+celebrations+at+Mazhar+Ali+Khan_s+residence.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1600x1098" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c57c9b0e-9118-4efe-86af-05f3acdff015/Pakistan+Times+anniversary+celebrations+at+Mazhar+Ali+Khan_s+residence.jpg?format=1000w" width="1600" height="1098" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 66.67vw, 66.67vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c57c9b0e-9118-4efe-86af-05f3acdff015/Pakistan+Times+anniversary+celebrations+at+Mazhar+Ali+Khan_s+residence.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c57c9b0e-9118-4efe-86af-05f3acdff015/Pakistan+Times+anniversary+celebrations+at+Mazhar+Ali+Khan_s+residence.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c57c9b0e-9118-4efe-86af-05f3acdff015/Pakistan+Times+anniversary+celebrations+at+Mazhar+Ali+Khan_s+residence.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c57c9b0e-9118-4efe-86af-05f3acdff015/Pakistan+Times+anniversary+celebrations+at+Mazhar+Ali+Khan_s+residence.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c57c9b0e-9118-4efe-86af-05f3acdff015/Pakistan+Times+anniversary+celebrations+at+Mazhar+Ali+Khan_s+residence.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c57c9b0e-9118-4efe-86af-05f3acdff015/Pakistan+Times+anniversary+celebrations+at+Mazhar+Ali+Khan_s+residence.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c57c9b0e-9118-4efe-86af-05f3acdff015/Pakistan+Times+anniversary+celebrations+at+Mazhar+Ali+Khan_s+residence.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Pakistan Times anniversary celebrations at Mazhar Ali Khan’s residence. Image: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Pakistan Times anniversary celebrations at Mazhar Ali Khan’s residence. Image: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  

&nbsp;
  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I. A. Rehman, the film correspondent, kept the culture pages going, while K. M. Asif, the chief sports editor, was highly respected for his sports writing and could not be bought, despite attempts to do so. Syed Amjad Hussain was another leading reporter, and Kamal Haider, the news editor, was far removed from the Left but generally sympathetic to the papers’ aims.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">And that’s how they made it into the outfit that it was and became: by not simply recruiting people from the Left, because… I remember my father joking that, apart from all their other problems, they tend to be very lazy!</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AAS: </strong>You’ve already alluded to the nationalization of the papers. Could you give us a brief account of how that played out and what it reflected about the regime’s priorities at that moment?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>TA:</strong> What happened was this: the newspapers had undoubtedly become very powerful. So, when martial law was declared in October 1958, there was a sense of crisis among the high command. I was at dinner at Mian Iftikharuddin’s house because his younger son, Suhail, and I were friends. Over dinner, my father and Mian Sahib discussed what martial law could mean for the papers, and they were both quite sanguine. They said, “If they impose censorship, just send all our stuff to the censors. If they censor it, we’ll just leave the paper blank, and the blankness will make it clear to our readers that we couldn’t publish what we wanted to. Let’s keep cool heads and not do anything foolish. The papers should be preserved at all costs.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">That was the general mood. At first, while all the other newspapers published editorials praising the military takeover, <em>Pakistan Times</em> ran an editorial written by my father on soil erosion. It dealt with the actual problem of soil erosion in Pakistan, but the message was very clear: our political soil was being eroded as well, without saying a single word about it.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Someone from the paper would then ring up whoever was in charge of censorship and say, “The paper is ready.” They would reply, “We don’t want to censor you. You write.” Out of caution, the editorials and opinion pieces were sent to the censor, and sometimes they raised objections, but by and large they let things through because the papers had become very careful.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">At the same time, two things were happening. At the first cabinet meeting of the martial law government, where Bhutto was a junior minister, Bhutto later told me, “Tariq, it’s quite astonishing. The first thing Ayub Khan said to the whole cabinet was, ‘I want you to understand one thing. There is only one embassy in Pakistan, and that’s the American embassy.’” The message was very clear.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">My aunt Bilquis, my father’s sister, was married to the interior minister, General Sheikh. A few weeks later, she came and told my father that it was a staunchly pro-American government and that he should have absolutely no illusions about that. That was all she said. He replied, “We don’t. Thanks for confirming it.” American pressure over Progressive Papers Limited intensified. The Americans hated the papers; they had never liked them.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">One day in late March 1959, my father received a phone call. It was Bhutto, who was then Minister for Commerce. He said, “Mazhar, are you free this evening? Let’s meet up at Faletti’s Hotel for a <em>gup shup</em>.” It was a very casual invitation, probably because the phones were tapped.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">My father turned up at Faletti’s, and Bhutto said, “Look, this is serious business. There’s a horrible plan being concocted to take over Progressive Papers Limited.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">My father said, “What? Are you sure?”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">“Yeah. I’ve sat in cabinet meetings. Manzur Qadir is the one really pushing for it.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">One of the country’s greatest criminal lawyers was pressing for a crime to be committed.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">They talked, and my father asked what Bhutto suggested. Bhutto said that the only way out, though even that might not work, was for Mian Iftikharuddin to ask for an interview with Ayub Khan and say what needed to be said. He should ask why the government was thinking of banning their papers and explain that they were doing nothing illegal. Everything they published was sent to the censors.</p>


  









&nbsp;

























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594b575e-4bc7-43a4-8585-b549416903f7/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Ayub+Khan+3.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1348x1600" data-image-focal-point="0.5189770200148258,0.24801550096881053" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594b575e-4bc7-43a4-8585-b549416903f7/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Ayub+Khan+3.jpeg?format=1000w" width="1348" height="1600" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 66.67vw, 66.67vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594b575e-4bc7-43a4-8585-b549416903f7/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Ayub+Khan+3.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594b575e-4bc7-43a4-8585-b549416903f7/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Ayub+Khan+3.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594b575e-4bc7-43a4-8585-b549416903f7/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Ayub+Khan+3.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594b575e-4bc7-43a4-8585-b549416903f7/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Ayub+Khan+3.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594b575e-4bc7-43a4-8585-b549416903f7/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Ayub+Khan+3.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594b575e-4bc7-43a4-8585-b549416903f7/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Ayub+Khan+3.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594b575e-4bc7-43a4-8585-b549416903f7/Mazhar+Ali+Khan+and+Ayub+Khan+3.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Mazhar Ali Khan meeting Ayub Khan in his capacity as President of the countrywide Council of Pakistan Newspaper Editors (CPNE), prior to the nationalization of Progressive Papers Ltd. Source: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Mazhar Ali Khan meeting Ayub Khan in his capacity as President of the countrywide Council of Pakistan Newspaper Editors (CPNE), prior to the nationalization of Progressive Papers Ltd. Source: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  

&nbsp;
  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794256998632_51509">Bhutto told my father, “Mazhar, this might work, but it might not. I’m just warning you to be careful.”</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>My father turned up at Faletti’s, and Bhutto said, “Look, this is serious business. There’s a horrible plan being concocted to take over Progressive Papers Limited.”<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">My father went straight from Faletti’s to 21 Aikman Road, where Mian Sahib lived, and took him aside. He told him what they were planning.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Mian Iftikharuddin, who could often be very clear-eyed, particularly because he knew this elite and what they were capable of, said that Bhutto was exaggerating. My father asked, “Why would he exaggerate? He’s taken his political career into his own hands by telling us. They could sack him; he could be finished. Why would he do that?”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Mian Sahib said there was always talk of doing these things. My father replied, “Iftikhar, he was very serious.” Bhutto had recommended that Mian Sahib go and see Ayub to find out whether a deal could be done to save the papers.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">But Mian Sahib said, “No, who can touch us? We’re so powerful and strong.” Well, they were. But that was precisely why the government felt they had to be taken over. They couldn’t trust them.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In a way, it was quite creditable that he said, “Why should I go? We’ve done nothing wrong. What am I supposed to say?”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">My father said, “You should say exactly that. We’ve heard that you’re planning to take over the newspapers, and we’ve come to appeal to you not to do it.” He wanted him to be upfront about it. But Mian Sahib didn’t go. Ayub might not have agreed to see him anyway, but no attempt was made.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Ironically, two cabinet ministers arrived at our front door on the eve of the takeover. One was Bhutto, whom my father knew well as a family friend. The other was my uncle, General Sheikh. They told my father that this was not an action against him as editor of the paper, but against Mian Iftikharuddin. The government had information that Mian Sahib was involved in the coal trade with China, which supposedly constituted a threat. Can you imagine? China, with which they have traded endlessly ever since! They used trade with China as one of the excuses for taking over the papers. It was an allegation that was later brought against him. They had come to ask my father to stay on as editor-in-chief and publisher-in-chief of Progressive Papers Limited, but the papers would be owned by the state.&nbsp;</p>


  









&nbsp;

























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86ddb0bc-77a4-40e8-97be-62b2cd1248d8/b80a6184-c2d1-49e9-b71a-376b01cd6769.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1024x445" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86ddb0bc-77a4-40e8-97be-62b2cd1248d8/b80a6184-c2d1-49e9-b71a-376b01cd6769.jpg?format=1000w" width="1024" height="445" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 66.67vw, 66.67vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86ddb0bc-77a4-40e8-97be-62b2cd1248d8/b80a6184-c2d1-49e9-b71a-376b01cd6769.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86ddb0bc-77a4-40e8-97be-62b2cd1248d8/b80a6184-c2d1-49e9-b71a-376b01cd6769.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86ddb0bc-77a4-40e8-97be-62b2cd1248d8/b80a6184-c2d1-49e9-b71a-376b01cd6769.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86ddb0bc-77a4-40e8-97be-62b2cd1248d8/b80a6184-c2d1-49e9-b71a-376b01cd6769.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86ddb0bc-77a4-40e8-97be-62b2cd1248d8/b80a6184-c2d1-49e9-b71a-376b01cd6769.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86ddb0bc-77a4-40e8-97be-62b2cd1248d8/b80a6184-c2d1-49e9-b71a-376b01cd6769.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/86ddb0bc-77a4-40e8-97be-62b2cd1248d8/b80a6184-c2d1-49e9-b71a-376b01cd6769.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Excerpt from a press note issued by the government regarding the takeover of the Progressive Papers Ltd. Source: Pakistan: Military Rule or People’s Power (1970) by Tariq Ali.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Excerpt from a press note issued by the government regarding the takeover of the Progressive Papers Ltd. Source: Pakistan: Military Rule or People’s Power (1970) by Tariq Ali.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  

&nbsp;
  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794325203673_21019">My father just laughed in their faces. Bhutto replied that once the papers were owned by the government, they could invoke the Essential Services Act, which would forbid my father from disobeying orders, leaving his post, and so on.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">My father replied, “Well, if you do that, we’ll be having conversations in prison, no doubt.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">They pleaded with him, quite seriously. But my father said there was no question of his staying on. “We built these papers to promote freedom and democracy in the country, and freedom of the press. And you want me to be in charge of government-owned newspapers? It’s unheard of.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So they left.</p>


  









&nbsp;


  

  



  
    
      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794257358657-7A6OGZ2CG3BE3BSL17J6/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.46.19%E2%80%AFPM.png" data-image-dimensions="1110x1518" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="Screenshot 2026-11-09 at 8.46.19 PM.png" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af231c6dd636f7095b38398" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794257358657-7A6OGZ2CG3BE3BSL17J6/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.46.19%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794257358005-9MZ0UWOO5ECBH84AMM3I/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.46.29%E2%80%AFPM.png" data-image-dimensions="950x1314" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="Screenshot 2026-11-09 at 8.46.29 PM.png" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af231c6b730387330c26ab3" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794257358005-9MZ0UWOO5ECBH84AMM3I/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.46.29%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      

        
          
            
              
                <img class="thumb-image" elementtiming="system-gallery-block-slideshow" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794257361970-4E6GBJ06DPB9I0AT7QAR/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.46.38%E2%80%AFPM.png" data-image-dimensions="948x1304" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" alt="Screenshot 2026-11-09 at 8.46.38 PM.png" data-load="false" data-image-id="6af231cf593f124d123c8464" data-type="image" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1794257361970-4E6GBJ06DPB9I0AT7QAR/Screenshot+2026-11-09+at+8.46.38%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=1000w" /><br>
              

              
                
              
              
            
          
          
        

        

        

      
    
  

  
    
    
    
      
      
        
          <a tabindex="0" role="button" class="previous" aria-label="Previous Slide"
          ></a>
          <a tabindex="0" role="button" class="next" aria-label="Next Slide"
          ></a>
        
      
    
    
     
  




  

    
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
          

        

        
      
    

  






  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>Excerpts from Mazhar Ali Khan’s testimony in defence of Progressive Papers Ltd. (PPL), sent to the then Minister for Commerce and later Prime Minister of Pakistan, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. Source: Mazhar Ali Khan family archives. </em></p>


  









&nbsp;
  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">My father went to the office and called a big staff meeting. They had already seen police jeeps surrounding Progressive Papers Limited, so everyone knew something was happening. He explained what had happened and told them about the offer he had turned down. He wanted his name removed from the imprint of the following day’s paper and his resignation announced. That was all.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>And that was it. The whole experiment collapsed. People missed these papers. They said so at the time and afterwards.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794260682047_60465">He said to them, “I know the circumstances many of you are in, and I don’t want any heroic actions. Those of you who have families and children, especially, should feel free to stay in your jobs if you want to. We’re not advising you to do anything on that front. It’s entirely your own personal choice.” It was a very sad day.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794260682047_60466">And that was it. The whole experiment collapsed. People missed these papers. They said so at the time and afterwards.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794260682047_60467">The first editorial in the government-owned <em>Pakistan Times</em> was written by Qudratullah Shahab. It was called “The New Leaf.” It was a disgusting piece of writing. Altaf Gauhar, later Ayub’s information chief, was the one who commissioned Qudratullah Shahab to write it. Later, he said, “I am ashamed. It’s one of the things I’ve done that I’m most ashamed of.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1794260682047_60468">This should be noted: every major paper in the country supported the takeover of Progressive Papers Limited. <em>Dawn</em> and <em>Nawa-i-Waqt</em> were particularly prominent, but all the others joined in. So much for solidarity. It was also a signal to people that the government wasn’t going to tolerate any meaningful dissent. The country was stifled, and that fed the uprisings that were soon to emerge.&nbsp;</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>This interview has been edited for length and clarity</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Asmer Asrar Safi</em></strong> is a writer and organizer from Lahore, Pakistan. He is currently pursuing a PhD in History at the University of Oxford as a Rhodes Scholar. His research focuses on the intellectual history of the Pakistani Left in the 1960s.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Mishael Hyat Ayub</em></strong> is a researcher and writer from Lahore, Pakistan, currently based in Singapore. Her work focuses on inequality, state power, and struggles over visibility and voice in South Asia. She studied anthropology at Yale-NUS College.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/334ffd1f-4875-4543-8b92-c5fe5cf69df5/Tarik+Ali+Interview.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">Typesetting Dissent: The Progressive Papers Ltd. and Pakistan’s Cold War</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>Double Consciousness and the Power of Solidarity</title><category>Interview</category><category>Bangladesh</category><category>Diaspora</category><dc:creator>Nafis H</dc:creator><pubDate>Thu, 05 Nov 2026 15:52:49 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/double-consciousness-and-the-power-of-solidarity</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:6a95d959d34efe369c19a409</guid><description><![CDATA[An interview with Ashik Siddique, co-chair of the Democratic Socialists of 
America.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>An interview with Ashik Siddique, co-chair of the Democratic Socialists of America</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  
























  













  
    
      
    
    
      
        
          
            <img data-load="false" data-mode="cover" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1793763864081-3UY0ZE2LUIYUQOE59S76/Header_Interview+with+Ashik+Siddique+%28DSA%29.png?format=1000w"
            />
            
            
          
        
      
    
    
  
    <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Watch the full video interview here.</em></p>
  


    



  






  
  
  




  
  
  
  
    
  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Editorial Note: Since the interview, the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) secured major victories in the 2026 Midterm Elections in the U.S. on November 3, 2026. DSA contested 222 races (including ballot measures) across federal, state and municipal levels, and at the time of publication, won 135 of those races (38 are still to be called). Significantly, DSA is now sending 8 Democratic Socialists to Congress in 2027 - an electoral power not seen since the prominent American socialist Eugene V. Debs garnered a million votes in the 1920 Presidential Election. </em></p>


  










  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Nafis Hasan (N):</strong> Hi, everyone. Welcome to Jamhoor's podcast series. My name is Nafis Hasan. I'm one of the editors for Jamhoor. And today, we are joined by Ashik Siddique, a Bangladeshi American, who is also the co-chair of the Democratic Socialists of America, the largest socialist organization in the United States. Welcome, Ashik, to <em>Jamhoor</em>.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Ashik Siddique (A):</strong> Thanks so much for having me, Nafis.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> So actually, we wanted to invite you to our podcast, you know, to talk a little bit about all of the media attention that DSA is currently getting, also as the largest socialist organization in the belly of the beast, you know, the dying empire that is the United States, and to sort of talk a little bit about what we are seeing with Zohran Mamdani's win, the rise of the South Asian electorate, the diaspora being very active in the leftist spaces, and all that other good stuff, but I wanted to start off asking you about, tell me how did you get involved with the DSA? What was your political evolution? Because, you know, as a fellow Bangladeshi, we are always taught that politics is not something you should touch with a 10-foot pole, especially if you're coming from the middle class, right? So how did you get involved in all of this?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yeah, well, I'm used to telling the story of my political development mostly, you know, to American audiences, so there's a way in which like a lot of the things that brought me into politics tracks what the American millennial experience. Like I grew up in the 90s. I went to public schools and then grew up after 9/11. Like I came of age, I was 13 years old when it happened. I grew up in New York City, in a Bangladeshi Muslim family, so that was kind of baseline, very politicizing. But then I went to college during the time that Obama got elected after the decade of the war on terror, being against George Bush and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and everything. But I wasn't really politically active. It was kind of like on a personal level, I started to get more interested in political organizing. After finishing university, I graduated after the 2008 economic crisis. So coming into a job market where it was just really a bad situation for anybody my age and younger. And just realizing that the expectations of, you know, if you work hard and go to school and get a good job, you might… you'll probably do better than your parents or like, that's the expectation. That just really wasn't the case. Like very quickly that perception changed. And then a year after I graduated college, Occupy Wall Street happened. I was in New York City at the time working at a job with bosses who were very challenging to deal with. So that just kind of woke me up to how much was not changing politically with Obama in office.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">When Obama got elected, I was very excited. I went to some events during his campaign, but then when he got elected, it was like, all right, he'll take it from here. Like that's what the campaign itself said. So I just checked out of paying attention to political news for a few years.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Even until that time, there was not a sense that politics was something you could do as a normal person. But then after the Occupy year, just like showing up, being at Zuccotti Park, with all these people on the streets, and just really feeling how much was not changing, was even getting worse, like economically, the wars were continuing, just all these things that really weren't changing structurally at all in the Obama administration just kind of activated me more. So I met a bunch of people through that who got me more interested in climate organizing. I did that for a few years, and then when Bernie Sanders ran for president in 2016, 2015 to 16, I became super activated. As a volunteer, I was running phone banks out of my living room. Meeting all these people from all walks of life who were connecting with different parts of this platform, like very diverse. So that made me feel a lot of agency, kind of for the first time, like with just normal people coming together for some kind of political change. I found a Facebook group during that campaign called Bangladeshi Americans for Bernie Sanders. I was just like, who are these people? What are you talking about? Bangladeshi Americans for anything? Like, I've never seen Bangladeshis activated politically in the U.S, you know? So it was just a Facebook group of, like, a handful of people. I DM'd them, just like, who are you people? Can I join? Like, I'm a Bangladeshi American for Bernie Sanders. And they were from all over the country and figuring out how to organize for Bernie to talk to Bangladeshis in their communities in New York and Los Angeles and Texas. And yeah, I just refreshed my very basic Bangla skills, which are not very good, but there was like a Bernie Sanders campaign template for graphics and stuff that they would let volunteers translate. So I did the Bangla translation for “Not me, us” like “<em>Ami na, Amra</em>.” And I was very proud of that. Like, I'm not a graphic designer, but I was able to do that. So yeah, that was really exciting. I met a bunch of cool people from across the country through that. Then he didn't win, and I joined DSA in January 2017.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/57a0faa0-0792-4ba4-9de4-a2958c17f95b/2016-04-18-1460964133-7465764-BernieArticle7.jpg" data-image-dimensions="960x720" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/57a0faa0-0792-4ba4-9de4-a2958c17f95b/2016-04-18-1460964133-7465764-BernieArticle7.jpg?format=1000w" width="960" height="720" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/57a0faa0-0792-4ba4-9de4-a2958c17f95b/2016-04-18-1460964133-7465764-BernieArticle7.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/57a0faa0-0792-4ba4-9de4-a2958c17f95b/2016-04-18-1460964133-7465764-BernieArticle7.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/57a0faa0-0792-4ba4-9de4-a2958c17f95b/2016-04-18-1460964133-7465764-BernieArticle7.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/57a0faa0-0792-4ba4-9de4-a2958c17f95b/2016-04-18-1460964133-7465764-BernieArticle7.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/57a0faa0-0792-4ba4-9de4-a2958c17f95b/2016-04-18-1460964133-7465764-BernieArticle7.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/57a0faa0-0792-4ba4-9de4-a2958c17f95b/2016-04-18-1460964133-7465764-BernieArticle7.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/57a0faa0-0792-4ba4-9de4-a2958c17f95b/2016-04-18-1460964133-7465764-BernieArticle7.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>An image from a 2016 article documenting Bangladeshi Americans’ mobilization efforts in support of Bernie Sanders’ 2016 presidential campaign. Image: Bangladeshi Americans for Bernie </em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>An image from a 2016 article documenting Bangladeshi Americans’ mobilization efforts in support of Bernie Sanders’ 2016 presidential campaign. Image: Bangladeshi Americans for Bernie </em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I was in DC, Trump got inaugurated, and I was just — I had already been depressed after Bernie lost, but then just felt like I had to do something. I figured, okay, I guess I'm a democratic socialist. I supported Bernie. What does that mean? And DSA was there. Also, having done climate organizing, I got more interested in, or I found more kind of socialist analyses of why the climate crisis is so bad, like, why isn't anything really happening politically on the scale that it would need to, to deal with the scale of it? And so, eco-socialism is something that I started to find more and more, and then I met a lot of people through DSA, including you, in those early years, and then that really helped us develop a democratic socialist program against the climate crisis and figuring out how we organize in our communities for things like public power, expanding public transit, all these things.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So I think I started with my standard story, but then I could say more about what really politicized me from my family's background which I think is more interesting to the audience we're talking about.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> No, yeah, please. I do want to comment on the fact that… on the Bangladeshi Americans doing anything political, because in my… I've been… I didn't grow up here, right? But since I've been here since 2007, my experience has also been that Bangladeshi Americans are more interested in holding up the cultural aspect of their identities, rather than recalling or hearkening back to the political roots that they come from, so I’d be very curious to hear about your family's history and how that inspired you.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yeah, I guess just since I already started talking about Bangladeshi Americans for Bernie, I was really struck in that period, during the few months that I was active, just, they were, I would say, mostly probably millennials, some were a bit older, some were a bit younger, but it was just very much about our context as Americans that politicized us. Some of us were interested in things like the climate crisis, which definitely impacts Bangladesh a lot, and that was part of our consciousness. Being anti-war and anti-imperialism, I think some people were more motivated by that, but mostly it was just… we came of age in the United States, and the economy increasingly sucks. We're really unhappy with what's happening here. But then the Bangladeshi politics… I had been definitely raised and conditioned from a young age to not pay attention to it. I would ask, you know, as a curious young person who paid attention to news and stuff, I would ask what's happening in Bangladesh? It's in… you know, I'm seeing a headline about an election. My parents would just be like, don't worry about it, it's too messy. And I remember there were times growing up, like, there's a big Bangladeshi American community in the tri-state area that my family was part of, so I remember being at <em>dawats</em>, like, events and things where sometimes political things would come up, but they would be speaking in Bangla at a level that…my Bangla is not good enough to understand big words, especially political stuff. Just looking back, I realized, there was actually a lot of political content to what they were saying, and people would get in arguments about BNP, Awami League, all this stuff, and it would get really heated, and I remember times where people would almost get into fist fights over political arguments.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> I mean, they did, right? Even recently, there was an almost fistfight between Awami League and BNP supporters in New York City, which is, you know, totally tangential, but over the years, there has been fistfights in New York City between those two parties. But that's something that's so ingrained in Bangladeshi culture. Even if we are told like don't look at politics, we're constantly talking about it. People have so many political opinions, from the <em>rickshaw walas</em> to the people running the tea stalls, to any <em>dawats</em> you go to, even in upper-middle-class society, everybody has an opinion about the political situation, but just commenting on it, not participating in it.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> The more I learned about it as I grew older, the more I realized, like, oh, because there are real serious stakes and there's political violence, and the whole history of Bangladesh through independence and since then was really violent, and there was just realizing…learning more about the US role in all of that is something that I became conscious of much later. But I guess just zooming out and starting from a very early age, I grew up hearing stories about my parents' experience of the Liberation War. They were teenagers in 1971, so they immigrated to the United States. My dad came in the 70s, my mom came in the early 80s after they got married. And they were some of the earliest relatives, like, over the next decade or two, a lot of their siblings came. So I grew up with a very large extended family, mostly in the New York area. My cousins were all, kind of a decade older or younger than me. All of our parents were very proud of their Bangladeshi heritage. The stories about the war, like, that was just, 1971 was just, like, deeply something that we grew up hearing stories about. We went to Bangla schools for a few years, on weekends, in Queens. There was a lot of pride in Bangladeshi culture that was very political about the experience of becoming independent through this bloody struggle. So I grew up with this very intense national pride that comes from the experience of a national liberation revolution, and then a lot of my peers, like in school, who were American, just didn't even know what Bangladesh was. So there was this kind of extreme diversion between this pretty intense Bangladeshi national pride, and my friends at school or teachers barely knowing what Bangladesh is. So I feel like that really shaped me at a basic level, just…there's so much pride in the language, right? All Bangladeshis are so proud of the Bangla language, and just the experience of having a revolution be based so much on the language and cultural identity, but then, there's no Duolingo for Bangla. This is something that comes to mind every so often, especially when I'm around other Bangladeshis, how is there not a Duolingo for Bangla? And it kind of is, like, I think…I mean, this is a whole tangent, but just Bangladesh never became, or Bengal never became an economically important region, and that was because of colonialism and imperialism. It used to be one of the wealthiest regions in the world, so I think Bengalis have this sense of historical heritage and pride in the culture and language and the former economic status, but there's such a huge divergence between that and where it is now. So I think for people in the diaspora, it's kind of even more intense. Like, just reflecting on how I grew up, there's this really intense pride in the language. I have uncles and aunts who would always be like “<em>Bangla bolo,</em>” you have to speak Bangla, at our family things. You're not at school, here, you speak Bangla. Because you have to learn, people died for this. In American culture, whatever, it's just like, if anybody knows anything, it's (Bangladesh’s) very poor and they're screwed over by rising sea levels. That's kind of it.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">There was this kind of…I learned the term double consciousness later in life, W.E.B. Du Bois, just wrote really well about the experience of Black Americans, having their experience with people of their shared identity, but then just feeling totally on the other side, or also being forced to see themselves through the view of the dominant identity, or like people who have power. So it was just that sense of like, okay, I have this very intense understanding of myself in this heritage where there is a lot of pride from becoming free in this way, but then that's totally ignored or discounted.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So I think that discrepancy made me over time think more deeply about what is my role in America? With cousins or other friends who are Bangladeshi Americans, I feel like that kind of did, there's a sense of where do you really belong, right? This is very common for any immigrant background person. But it just weirdly felt even more kind of…you have to find other means to define yourself, I guess.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Maybe it's different now for Bangladeshi kids growing up today, because there are way more Bangladeshi Americans now, in New York or LA, and in a bunch of cities, there's a huge diaspora now that's getting politically organized, which is amazing to see, which we could get into with Zohran, because Bangladeshis in particular were a big part of that, but yeah, I feel that kind of gap between just the different communities I was part of just helped me develop my identity and sense of the world in a way that wasn't too attached in either direction, I guess, and helped me kind of see things more systematically, maybe? Because I think Bangladeshi nationalism has its own problems, which we've had a lot of conversations about.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I think the diaspora attachment to 1971 and the Liberation War, I learned the history more like, well, then it got really complicated, didn't it? So I think my parents' generation, just were really focused on a particular review of everything that happened, leading up to and through that year. But then the reality of political development in Bangladesh, it's… very messy and complicated, and now, the past 2 years, right? Everything that's happening, that's causing a re-evaluation of the history, which I know is very thorny territory. It's so complicated. So I guess just to go back to the experience of meeting Bangladeshi Americans for Bernie Sanders and figuring out what do we do in the United States? That's where we are now. We're understanding all these things about global capitalism and imperialism and all these things, like the climate crisis, all these things that make it very challenging for people in Bangladesh or in that part of the world. What can we do in the United States to change the political conditions to change everything?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">What would it take to change the power structure of the world, so that people in a country like Bangladesh aren't just forced to make pretty horrible choices. I could ramble in a lot of directions here, but I think just that was a big part of what got me interested.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I haven't even talked much about climate stuff, but I think that was really a lot of things that led me to be much more concerned about the climate crisis, earlier than a lot of people on the left in the US, or feeling like there is this kind of moral imperative to organize in the United States somehow to change it so that people in Bangladesh have a chance. Especially the experience of seeing the climate crisis through the lens of colonialism, understanding what happened in 1971, and Bangladesh's liberation coming out of this global colonial system, and the genocide that happened in 1971 was an outcome of that. That’s in Bangladesh's past that my parents raised me to understand. But then just the knowledge of the climate crisis as this future or ongoing catastrophe that could get way worse. I think that was another kind of double consciousness of just being like, oh, this is extra fucked. So, sorry, can I curse?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Yeah, yeah. That's allowed.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Just checking. Do we have impressionable young South Asian children?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> They already know what that means.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> We have worse words in our languages.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Yeah! Yeah, exactly.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br><strong>A:</strong> So, yeah, I think understanding the legacy of genocide in Bangladesh was something that also was a deeper part of that double consciousness, where I grew up understanding there was this catastrophe, this really traumatic world historical atrocity that happened, and then, in the United States, growing up with, education about the Holocaust, for example, and, there's a whole other thread here about… I mean, in the past few years, I think with Palestine organizing, a lot more people are evaluating that in terms of the Holocaust exceptionalism. For people on the left, the point should be that all genocides are bad, and this should not happen anywhere.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I identify with what Jews and so many other people went through during the Holocaust that were being taught about as, like, the worst thing that can ever happen, and that gave me a really basic sense of empathy, and my family lived through something like that, too, and that should never happen, but then also the kind of discounting of that experience. I remember bringing it up at some point in school, maybe in fourth grade, when we were reading a book, an account of somebody who survived a concentration camp during World War 2, and just saying something like, oh, genocide happened in Bangladesh too, and the teacher kind of said something, I don't remember exactly what it was, but I remember it made me feel bad. It was just like, well, that's different, or like, this was the worst one, like, that kind of thing. And I remember feeling like&nbsp; that's not fair, in a very basic way.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So many other genocides and mass atrocities have happened through the 20th century, or for longer. Mike Davis had the book, right? Late Victorian Holocausts, which I still haven't read, but I feel like I get the gist, like I want to read it…<br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> It's definitely interesting you bring that up, because, as you're talking about the climate organizing space as a big influence in your thinking and development as a socialist, I was also thinking how there's natural disasters or climate events that precede revolutionary changes.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">To give the example of Bangladesh, the Bhola cyclone in 1970 that precipitated, and the response by the Pakistani government at that time to the the devastation in East Pakistan at that time was one of the big motivating factors for people to feel like they were an internal colony who were neglected by the West Pakistani administration.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">We both organize in climate spaces and it's a bit of a weird feeling when you understand that time works differently in that space, especially in organizing. We have only indicators or approximations of how bad it can get, and the timeline of it, but then things can get much worse, much faster, which we're seeing now. Even 10 years ago, when we joined DSA almost at similar times, the idea was like, oh, we have more time than we thought we had. But like now with the prediction of the El Nino for this year, the outlook is much worse than what we had predicted.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">That was a very interesting thread. I have so many more questions, but I do want to focus a little bit on the part about where you said, you see a lot more radicalization among the South Asian diaspora, after Zohran's win. I want to kind of talk a little bit about that. Because Zohran Mamdani's win as the New York City mayor is arguably one of the biggest electoral victories by DSA…and also maybe in the US for the left in the last decade or so, just in case that I don't know something that happened, I'm just going to predicate that, so top three, top three wins ever in the left, in the current century, just, like, hedge all my bets.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">But what was interesting about Zohran's win was this analysis of the rise of the Muslim electorate, or the South Asian electorate. And not just the electorate, but also the mobilization around him by not just the standard bearers, like for Bernie it was pretty expected that millennials who are college-educated, they are going to bat for Bernie, but for Zohran people who voted for him, who canvassed for him, it was regular, everyday people. I don't know how many times he has called out Pakistani aunties or Bangladeshi aunties.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">That's just such a very niche constituency who (you) would never expect to see on the streets to go canvassing or even vote for Zohran because of the political stuff that we've been discussing, the attitude towards politics.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">How was Zohran's campaign different from other South Asian progressives, like Pramila Jayapal, when she ran, or continues to run in California, or even Ro Khanna, or even in New York City, Shahana Hanif's, like, previous elections. As somebody who grew up in New York City, how do you see the change in the political attitudes of the South Asian diaspora?<br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yeah, I think it's a really big set of changes that are happening. I think, at the core, it’s that there is a working-class constituency that's really developing. Working-class formation is happening in a way that I haven't really seen in my lifetime with the communities of more recent immigrants. When I say community, it feels even kind of flattening in a way, because for so many decades, like when I was becoming more politically conscious, there's a sense of just different immigrant groups or ethnic groups being distinct communities.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I think the Democratic Party does a lot of identifying different constituencies as communities based on identity, and then kind of treating them in isolated ways that way. Like, oh, there's the black community, there's various Latino communities, there's LGBT community. Like, whatever else it is, and then just kind of treating them as distinct, and defining people that way, based on identities, while moving more and more away from an understanding of [the] working class or especially labour. Just like the backbone of all the major social and economic gains of the past century was a strong labour movement.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Like, organized workers across different sectors having organized power to challenge capitalists who have a lot of power politically, and that was a core part of what made the New Deal possible, or environmental gains, or civil rights, or loosening restrictions on immigration in the 1960s – which allowed my parents to come the next decade. So all these things happened with a much stronger labour movement and workers being more organized. And a lot of that was, in the past 20th century, it was like a lot of immigrant workers. Then it was mostly what we would now call “white ethnics”, like, Eastern Europeans or Italians or Irish or whatever. Today, the working class in the United States broadly is immigrants from South Asia, the Middle East, Latin America. So there's a lot of Muslim immigrants. There are obviously many others. Like I think in a lot of cities, Mexican immigrants are a big population. In New York City, there are a lot of different kinds of Muslim immigrants. Like that's just a huge population. And that's just my vantage point is knowing a lot of Bangladeshi Americans in New York City, but that's grown a lot, just in the past two decades. Like when I was a kid, I grew up in Bay Ridge in South Brooklyn and we were among very few. Like, I remember being in a class where I was one of three kids who were not specifically Irish or Italian Catholic. It was, like, me, a Sri Lankan kid, like, one who was Korean, maybe one or two who were Jewish, but, like everyone else, was, like, Catholic from Ireland or Italy, second or third generation, or however many generations. So, but Bay Ridge now has become very Arab, and particularly Palestinian. Like, it's the highest concentration of Palestinians, I don't know about in the US, maybe in Michigan or something, there are more, but that's just changed a lot over the past two decades. There are whole neighborhoods of New York now that are lots of Bangladeshis. There's, like, three different little Bangladeshis at this point. There's, like, the one in Kensington and Brooklyn, there's Queens, there's one in the Bronx. So that developed, I think, like, I haven't lived in New York in over a decade myself, but when I was a kid, there was, like, Church Avenue in Brooklyn. Like, my parents would go grocery shopping there. That's a district that Shahana Hanif represents. So she got elected a few years ago with a lot of support from that community getting more politically organized.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So with Zohran, I think when he decided to run for mayor, there was already, like he already had done a lot of meaningful work as an assembly member for four years with different sectors of workers. Like taxi workers, like kind of famously now, like he went on hunger strike for two weeks. With taxi workers who are on strike for a new contract for higher wages, like all these things. And that was a very intense struggle that this whole set of workers in a community had been going through for many years. So he was part of that fight to win gains as workers, and then he helped advance tenant rights in a lot of ways. So, there's an organization that's really important to his success, called DRUM, Desis Rising Up and Moving, which is an organization of, mostly, South Asian, like, workers and tenants, throughout New York City. So it's not just…<br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2bb82da7-785e-4921-9b50-d264312b0074/zohran_NYCDSA.webp" data-image-dimensions="2048x1365" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2bb82da7-785e-4921-9b50-d264312b0074/zohran_NYCDSA.webp?format=1000w" width="2048" height="1365" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2bb82da7-785e-4921-9b50-d264312b0074/zohran_NYCDSA.webp?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2bb82da7-785e-4921-9b50-d264312b0074/zohran_NYCDSA.webp?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2bb82da7-785e-4921-9b50-d264312b0074/zohran_NYCDSA.webp?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2bb82da7-785e-4921-9b50-d264312b0074/zohran_NYCDSA.webp?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2bb82da7-785e-4921-9b50-d264312b0074/zohran_NYCDSA.webp?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2bb82da7-785e-4921-9b50-d264312b0074/zohran_NYCDSA.webp?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2bb82da7-785e-4921-9b50-d264312b0074/zohran_NYCDSA.webp?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Zohran Mamdani at a DSA campaign for his 2025 mayoral election. Image: DSA</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N: </strong>And mostly women, right? Like it’s led by aunties, as a lot of them say.&nbsp;<br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yeah, totally, yeah. And I’ve met a bunch of their core organizers. Like they have some millennials and younger people too, who are bilingual and help do a lot of the translation work. Like, I met a bunch of them while canvassing for Claire Valdez, and like some of the New York candidates a few months ago. So, they had&nbsp; built up this really extensive network that’s now very useful for electoral organizing. Like they’re able to do all these canvasses in Bangla, for mostly people who are mostly monolingual speakers of Bangla, or you know, much more fluent in Bangla than in English but are taxpaying citizens in New York, so they can vote, but weren't really activated to see anything that that would advance their needs as workers, as tenants, as as working class people.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So, I guess the point I'm getting at is, this is not just about identity representation. Zohran, I mean, it's powerful that he's Muslim, that he, you know, people see someone who looks like them, who speaks their languages or, you know, understands their culture well. That's all important and part of his success. Like, that's part of why, you know, when he does a video in Bangla, it goes viral in Bangladesh. Like, I get relatives in Bangladesh, like, sending things to my parents in WhatsApp.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> It’s amazing, yeah.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> It’s incredible. But that comes on the strength of that organizing on the ground that's around shared class interests. It's about making things better for workers in New York City, many of whom <em>are</em> South Asian and Muslim. It's about making housing affordable. So organizing people as tenants, as, you know, helping people afford a home. That's a core part of it. So it's not like a superficial identity thing. Just like, look, well vote for me because I look like you. That's <em>a</em> part of it, but it's really on the strength of this really powerful community organizing around class interests, and labour unions are a core part of it.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">There's a bunch of, like, I think the Taxi Workers Alliance endorsed him pretty early. labour unions like UAW, that's local that increasingly has worked pretty closely with New York City DSA. Public sector workers came out and endorsed him in a way that they hadn't really intervened in a primary before. But DSA members who were part of that helped make that endorsement. So all these things started to come together. And he also, for the better part of a year, he was going to like different Masjids, like around the city, like every weekend, basically. And really just speaking to people directly about the platform. Like that's where, what he campaigned on, was critical to success across the board. Anybody paying attention saw that they were, kept hearing it reinforced. The top three demands were freezing the rent, fast and free buses and universal childcare. He was saying that to all these uncles and aunties at Masjids. He was saying this to like, you know, people at parties in Bushwick and Bed-Stuy, like the hipster neighborhoods. He was saying this to, you know, whoever. So that's how he organized this really powerful coalition of people across identity differences, of race, ethnicity, religion. And that was really something that I, I haven't seen really anywhere in the country, this powerfully. And New York City is the largest city in the United States. It's the wealthiest city in the world, and it has a very large and diverse working class. But it takes a lot to organize working class consciousness, because the working class in the US is very divided by especially identity things. Along racial lines, along different, like different immigrant groups are pitted against each other. And that's also where I think Zohran's success in bringing people together across these differences, especially different immigrant groups, is such a big change from just 4 years ago. Where Eric Adams, the previous mayor, was elected in 2021 as a former police officer who just really played that up. And he got a lot of working-class support, especially from immigrant communities, from Black New Yorkers because he really hammered these very divisive concerns about public safety, like fears of, you know, the wrong kind of people coming in, like very anti-immigrant sentiment. Like I started hearing in my family network, just people who had been voting Democrat for years, like, start to say things about, like, oh, well, these newer immigrants, like, the undocumented immigrants are causing all these problems, like, they're causing crime, they're using all these public services, like, just pretty reactionary framing. So, like. that kind of reactionary framing, pitting different immigrant groups against each other, that's something that the Eric Adams administration did really well, in ways that were very scary. Like, I started to… Yeah, just hearing people in my life, like, start to say these things was very concerning. And I think this is a trend across the country, where in bigger cities that have a history of being Democrat-dominated, these kinds of reactionary framings, like just scapegoating immigrants, cutting public services, raising rents, like allowing real estate developers to drive up prices. Like, this is a trend across the country. So, that makes the Zohran coalition, and what New York City DSA helped make possible, even more powerful. That they were able to say, no, the reason for getting priced out is real estate developers having too much power. We need to organize to do things like freeze the rent, to expand affordable housing, to expand public transit, to help make the cost of living affordable for all of us. And that can bring people together instead of just allowing blame to fall on very vulnerable people in society. So that's been a really powerful shift over the past year, and that comes from this on the ground organizing, especially of workers and tenants who are South Asian.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Yeah, I think that awakening of political consciousness is so fascinating and interesting, because also, in the last round of elections where New York City DSA had some huge wins, one of the big wins was David Orkin, right, in Assembly District 38, which represents… yeah.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> I love this example because he's actually New York City DSA's first white man that they've endorsed in the better part of a decade.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> I know. And he won in an area that has primarily South Asian immigrants, and which area elected the first ever South Asian woman to go to assembly, right? Like Jennifer Rajkumar, right? So that was, like, the encapsulation of, like, it's just not enough to look like us anymore. You have to be able to listen to our demands, like what we really need is somebody who is going to fight for our basic rights and our basic needs, and not just look like us and give lip service right?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> That was so powerful. I spent the last few days of the primary campaigning in that area, in Woodside, Queens, which is mostly Bangladeshi. Like, almost every door I knocked for a whole shift, for a few hours was Bangladeshi families. And a lot of them just, like I had to refresh my not very good Bangla to just like communicate. But we had all this Bangla lit, all this just, you know, just the talking points were all about these cost of living things. And we were able to point to Zohran, just like, oh, do you like what he's doing? We want to elect more people who are going to do it. And they were like, okay. And it was David Orkin, white guy, or he might be mixed, I think he might be part Mexican, but, you know, presents as a white man.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Sure, but it's like such a distance from like, having a brown person represent you.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> The point is it doesn't matter, you know? He can present as a white man and because he's campaigning on these things and is aligned with this broader political project around these demands, that's the basis for winning. And, you know, he was showing up. He was talking just, showing up all over the place for months. He put out videos and things and literature in Bangla, and…</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> And had Bengali uncles who had full beards coloured with <em>mehendi</em>…</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> With the <em>mehendi</em> beards, yeah..</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Yeah. And I got to say, this is kind of an aside, because canvassing for Zohran in Astoria, right, which is a Bangladeshi stronghold. Canvassing in Bangla just hits different. It just is a whole different level of communication that you can do, where they won't turn you away because you're speaking that language. They'll be like, oh, wait, he's saying something in my language, and they're, like, actually curious, and some people ask me, like, why are you doing this, you know? Like, why are you, like, canvassing for this guy? And then you get to talk to them, right? Besides, like the standard pitch, right? So, it's a next level of like, communicating that that is like, so that's so amazing.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a198089a-3b10-4eb9-a29c-ece655c814df/Screenshot%2B2026-06-23%2Bat%2B10.45.21%E2%80%AFPM.webp" data-image-dimensions="1500x1094" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a198089a-3b10-4eb9-a29c-ece655c814df/Screenshot%2B2026-06-23%2Bat%2B10.45.21%E2%80%AFPM.webp?format=1000w" width="1500" height="1094" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a198089a-3b10-4eb9-a29c-ece655c814df/Screenshot%2B2026-06-23%2Bat%2B10.45.21%E2%80%AFPM.webp?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a198089a-3b10-4eb9-a29c-ece655c814df/Screenshot%2B2026-06-23%2Bat%2B10.45.21%E2%80%AFPM.webp?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a198089a-3b10-4eb9-a29c-ece655c814df/Screenshot%2B2026-06-23%2Bat%2B10.45.21%E2%80%AFPM.webp?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a198089a-3b10-4eb9-a29c-ece655c814df/Screenshot%2B2026-06-23%2Bat%2B10.45.21%E2%80%AFPM.webp?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a198089a-3b10-4eb9-a29c-ece655c814df/Screenshot%2B2026-06-23%2Bat%2B10.45.21%E2%80%AFPM.webp?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a198089a-3b10-4eb9-a29c-ece655c814df/Screenshot%2B2026-06-23%2Bat%2B10.45.21%E2%80%AFPM.webp?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a198089a-3b10-4eb9-a29c-ece655c814df/Screenshot%2B2026-06-23%2Bat%2B10.45.21%E2%80%AFPM.webp?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>DSA candidates (L-R) Diana Moreno, David Orkin, Samantha Kattan, Aber Kawas and Claire Valdez celebrate their victories in the June 2026 New York Democratic primaries. Image: Ryan Schwach via  </em><a href="https://queenseagle.com/"><em>Queens Daily Eagle</em></a></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>DSA candidates (L-R) Diana Moreno, David Orkin, Samantha Kattan, Aber Kawas and Claire Valdez celebrate their victories in the June 2026 New York Democratic primaries. Image: Ryan Schwach via  </em><a href="https://queenseagle.com/"><em>Queens Daily Eagle</em></a></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yeah, it's incredible. And it's because like the reason, I mean, yeah, I've heard that question from other canvassers, especially in these areas where people are asking like, who are you? Like, who's paying you? You know, it's just like, no, because we really care about these issues and these policies that we all can benefit from. Like, we have a shared interest here.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">That's why we're volunteering our time, spending our Saturday or Sunday talking to strangers in a language we don't even know. Like, there are DSA members who are white or Asian or whatever, who learned Bangla phrases, you know, like, “kemon achen?”. You just had this basic connection, which is just so, like Americans, especially are very alienated from each other like we don't have, you know, there's like your family sphere, your work sphere, and then maybe you have some other hobby. But that's kind of it. And in most of the country, especially New York, you know, it's not normal to talk to strangers, or it's even, like, people are suspicious or feel even hostile. But we're in a moment now where just so many people, like most people are feeling bad about how our society works. Their day to day lives suck. People are having to work longer hours or multiple jobs just to make ends meet. And that's across all kinds of backgrounds. So I think there is this basic, shared alienation that's happening now, that is even more reason to try to connect through politics. And that's happening in this really powerful way that DSA members are helping make possible. But then orgs like DRUM and other organizations that are really trying to organize working class people around our shared interests. So that's happening in a way that, it would have been hard for me to imagine, you know, just a few years ago. And seeing it, like, the experience of, yeah, just getting all these, Bangladeshi uncles and aunties to see a picture of David Orkin and Claire Valdez, and being like, oh yeah, they've been here, like, I know, and like, the other lady, we don't, we don’t like her.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> That's amazing. I love that so much.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yeah, and then just seeing like those blocks in particular just light up on the map, after the election results and just knowing like, oh, so many people put in the work to organize all these people around our shared interests. That's just powerful, and it comes from the solidarity that is one of…building solidarity across differences, especially of identity, of race, and language, that's one of the most powerful things that I've seen happen over the past few years, and Zohran's campaign is an example of that, and other electoral campaigns like David, like Claire, but seeing the organization around that, around these shared interests, across things that have been very divisive in the past. Racism is really deeply baked in in the United States, and I've seen, like, in parts of Queens where there's a Bangladeshi majority neighborhood next to a Black majority neighborhood. I've heard really ugly things said against Black people from some uncles and aunties sometimes, but you transcend that not by just being like you're a bad person for saying that. It's like, no, we actually have shared interests here and racism is used to keep us divided. But the things that would make this better are things that would benefit all of us. So that's where. Zohran is powerful. One of his mother's movies, Mississippi Masala.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Yeah.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> It's relevant here, right? Like, just the Black-South Asian solidarity is something that I've kind of thought a lot about, because it's a kind of division that I saw coming up in New York, but also, learning about the deeper history of the Bangladesh Revolution, and then just left organizing, I came across this song in Bangla on YouTube at some point. What's it called? It's about Paul Robeson, who is, you know, [an] internationally famous artist and leftist. And it's called Negrobhayamar Paul Robeson, like my black brother, Paul Robeson. In English, it's They Do Not Let Us Sing. It's like this beautiful 4-minute song. I'm gonna find it. I think it's from this hour-long video that I found, that's one hour of Bangladeshi communist music, and it's just all these different leftist songs.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> I love that. I think the song is… it's by Hemanga Biswas. Our black brother, Paul Robeson, <em>Negro bhai amar</em>, Paul Robeson, right?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yeah, yeah. But the substance of the song is all about how, like, they're identifying, on the other side of the world, they're identifying with the struggles of Paul Robeson as a Black man in the United States facing racism and just inequality. And they're saying okay, our master is here, they do not let us sing, they're keeping us silent. But we see him with this powerful voice, calling for all people's liberation, and that's inspiring us to sing. It's just such a beautiful example of solidarity, and how people in Bengal and South Asia identified with the struggles of Black people in the United States. And, that's kind of a deeper history that I've learned more about over the years. Just that kind of international solidarity and consciousness that was so powerfully motivating for so many people around the world in the 20th century, but then, in the era of neoliberalism, globalization, and suppression of the left everywhere, I think that fell away. But now I think that kind of consciousness is kind of reviving. Or I think with the internet, we can access it much more easily and figuring out how it's related to the context we're dealing with in New York City or wherever in the United States.<br><br><br></p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dce0f8a3-1961-4578-834f-dbdedd43fa61/Mississipi-Massala-05.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1920x1034" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dce0f8a3-1961-4578-834f-dbdedd43fa61/Mississipi-Massala-05.jpeg?format=1000w" width="1920" height="1034" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dce0f8a3-1961-4578-834f-dbdedd43fa61/Mississipi-Massala-05.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dce0f8a3-1961-4578-834f-dbdedd43fa61/Mississipi-Massala-05.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dce0f8a3-1961-4578-834f-dbdedd43fa61/Mississipi-Massala-05.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dce0f8a3-1961-4578-834f-dbdedd43fa61/Mississipi-Massala-05.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dce0f8a3-1961-4578-834f-dbdedd43fa61/Mississipi-Massala-05.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dce0f8a3-1961-4578-834f-dbdedd43fa61/Mississipi-Massala-05.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dce0f8a3-1961-4578-834f-dbdedd43fa61/Mississipi-Massala-05.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A scene from Mira Nair’s 1991 film Mississipi Masala, starring Danzel Washington and Sarita Choudhury</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A scene from Mira Nair’s 1991 film Mississipi Masala, starring Danzel Washington and Sarita Choudhury</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N: </strong>Right. Yeah, and again, there's so many fascinating threads to pull from. And I do want to come back to this question of international solidarity, especially since I know our audience is going to be interested in that. But I do want to go back to a little bit of DSA’s internal stuff a little. Both of us are, in DSA as people of colour from, like, I think we're coming up to close to a decade in being involved. And oftentimes – and I think this is still true – that there are concerns and condescension levied at DSA as being a white majority organization, right? And you're one of the co-chairs of this organization, and how have you seen the demographics change in the last few years or since you joined? Has it become more multiracial? Or what would your response be to people saying ‘oh, I don't want to join this organization because it's for white people’, right? Which was also something that was levied against people who were going hard for Bernie. I was like, oh, they're Bernie Bros, or they're all white people, why would we ever support that, right? So, in the context of what you're saying about, it's not just enough to have that identity anymore, it's also having shared class interest, right? How do you see these concerns levied at DSA? And how is DSA as an organization growing past that point?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yeah, I mean, I feel like I've been grappling with these questions for the better part of the decade that I've been in DSA. One, it absolutely is changing a lot. I think the more we organize outward-facing things like these electoral campaigns that are very intentionally engaging and empowering, and working with different kinds of people coming from different immigrant backgrounds or racial backgrounds, that is helping a lot, very demonstrably. And the labour organizing. I would say running electoral campaigns that are really strategically developed to empower and build working-class power in different kinds of communities, and the labour organizing. Those two things have really helped diversify DSA in the places that we're doing it effectively.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So like New York and Los Angeles are our two largest chapters of DSA, and both of them, I think, are really becoming&nbsp; just demonstrably, increasingly diverse in ways that reflect those cities. Los Angeles is a city that I think is majority, or at least plurality, Latino, especially Mexican and a lot of Asian communities, and LADSA reflects that. I remember being at their convention in the past year and looking at and being like “okay, this is remarkably different than the largely white constituencies that I remember seeing over the years in other places”. So yeah, that comes through organizing.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">And when I talked about Bangladeshi Americans for Bernie Sanders being kind of a formative thing for me, before I even joined DSA. So, we really enjoyed, at the time, just countering the arguments about, ‘oh, these are white Bernie bros’, just white men who were whatever, and we were just like, ‘we're right here’, you know? And there were events that were organized in places that showed there was a serious base of people who were Bangladeshi immigrants, were second or third generation at this point, and totally activated around these issues that the campaigners are presenting, and that's the point. People of all different backgrounds are interested in these things, and now we have to organize together to make them possible.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So I kind of came in with that sense. In the first year I was in DSA in the DC chapter, I definitely <em>was</em> in a lot of rooms where I was one of very few people who weren't white and it felt kind of weird at a basic level. But I was there because of the politics. I was like, okay, I think I'm a democratic socialist because of these things, I need to be part of something that makes those things possible. What is going to make that possible? And, there is no other organization that can make that possible in the United States. So I started out with this very basic sense of, okay, there is no organization that can solve the problems of racism in the United States within itself. We're part of this society that is pretty racist. That is structurally very unequal in these basic ways, and you can't fix that within one organization. And, there's this idea of prefigurative politics. That an organization you're a part of, or a community group that you're a part of can prefigure, can create the new kind of structure or society within your organization that represents the future you're organizing toward. And, I think that's a nice goal, and there are ways we can start to get at that, like have practices within an organization like DSA or any other organization where you try to intentionally develop and support more people of marginalized identities to build them up. But you can't entirely, you can't just fully be a not racist organization when the entire rest of society that you're part of is still very racist. So, I think, the types of organizing we do and how we do it can help us transform the rest of society and start to really rev the engine of that kind of organizing change in ways that make us attractive to more people – people of colour, people of different identities who see that, like okay, this organization is serious about changing all of society, and I want to be part of that.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So that happens through the organizing that people see us doing. So they see us representing these policies, and activating so many people to feel how they can be part of making that change. So that's what, Zohran's campaign is such a powerful example of doing in New York, in Los Angeles, or in Washington, D.C. Like the chapter that I just mentioned being in a room of mostly white people when I joined almost 10 years ago now. But now they just helped elect Janeese Lewis George as a Black woman.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Yeah. Also, Aparna Raj, another South Asian leftist, as a city councilor.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Totally. Exactly. Yeah, let's talk about Aparna. Aparna's a good friend, and she was chair of the Metro DC DSA chapter in the years right after 2020, the Black Lives Matter uprising that was totally galvanizing across the country, but especially in DC, which has been historically a majority Black, now, maybe plurality Black. Hypergentrification has pushed a lot of people out. So we really had to grapple with that in the D.C. chapter.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">When I was in leadership, I think it was, 2018 to 2019, and I was very interested in helping diversify our organization, but I just was learning through practice, through talking to other people of colour who <em>were</em> active in the chapter. Just like, okay, we're all activated around these politics. We don't wanna become more diverse in a superficial or tokenizing way. Which was, <em>is</em> a dynamic that I think can come up a lot in organizing spaces where people, with good intentions, want to help the organization become more diverse. But might just… the first person of colour they see, they're like, ‘hey, do you want to be in leadership?’ And then aren't really doing anything to support that person to be in leadership, and then they're not set up to succeed, and bad things can happen. And I kind of felt myself in that position in a very early stage. And maybe the first year I was there, I was in a working group of DSA. We have a structure that's totally volunteer, member-driven. So it's relatively easy to just show up and start doing something and then get into leadership. So I remember being asked to take a leadership position, just like, "Hey, you're showing up. Do you wanna do this?" And I was just like very quickly given all this responsibility that felt kind of overwhelming. And there were other people who had a lot more experience and were probably better at doing the thing, but who were kind of just like, well, you should do it because you're a person of colour. And that was a weird dynamic. And I ended up kind of getting support and just getting help from people, or learned how to ask for help when I needed it. And then ended up being well supported. And then I got into chapter leadership and just developed a lot of experience over two years. That helped develop me as an organizer and as somebody who could do political leadership. And then I just kept doing more stuff. I kept saying yes to things people asked me to do until I became coach over the whole organization.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Look where you are now.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yeah, yeah. But I think all along the way, I was very, I guess part of it is just like I was raised with very immigrant, just like, you have to work hard. You always have to work twice as hard for half the credit, you know?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Right. The drive to succeed. You have to do something that's worth talking about, you can’t just be fucking around.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A: </strong>Yeah. I think there was a very... yeah, I mean, that that was just something I heard constantly as a kid. You know? Like, you're gonna have to work twice as hard for half the credit.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Yeah. Yeah.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> And that's something that, unfortunately, I think that does still play out in ways in organizing sometimes. But we've gotten a lot better at developing structures to support people to develop as organizers, as leaders, and just distribute that work. The point of DSA is to organize democracy at every level of what we're doing and to try to distribute work. The way we do campaigns is to break things down so that somebody can come in pretty fresh without a lot of experience, but then start to learn how to do things.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Like okay, go knock doors, talk to people, learn how to use a spreadsheet to go through a list and make contacts, organize an event. Here's what it takes to organize an event, like rent out a library room or, organize a social or something. And these things can start to add up. You get more experience. Like, organize a reading group, a political education event. All these types of things that teach more and more people how to do that and then decide how to make decisions together about how to do that. And as we distribute those leadership skills –those organizing skills– the more we do that across the board and have good systems, pipelines to do that, then we can especially develop people of marginalized identities to come in and do that. Because we're making it easier for everybody.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">And also the shared responsibility. It's not just… nobody's entitled to anything. Like everyone has to do some work. This is a classic Marxist thing, right? Like from each according to their ability, to each according to their means. So there is a sense of responsibility. And this is another thing that cuts against the tokenizing thing. We shouldn't advance somebody in leadership just because of the fact of their identity. They also need to be prepared to do things, to have responsibility, to be part of a collective. There's a shared responsibility that comes from that. So, I think the sense of everyone should be able to do some basic things, and have some basic sense of responsibility, and that's how we develop collective leadership. And that's a big part of what we're doing. So when we elect people as leaders in our organization, or to run for office or something, we definitely want way more people of colour, more women, queer people, whatever it is, whatever marginalized identities, that is totally a priority.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">And we have to develop the systems, the structures to support people to be in leadership, to be effective leaders, and not just in a tokenizing way. Like, it really sucks if you… especially to be in the position of someone in a marginalized identity, and then be in a position of leadership and not be prepared to do it. Then the backlash can be even harsher sometimes. That's a very common dynamic in the era of neoliberal politics. I think, honestly, this is part of a big reaction against the Democratic Party, where there is this very powerful drive that's kind of tokenizing to get people of marginalized identities and positions of leadership. But then not having a program that they're organizing for to change things economically for everybody else of that identity. So it's not enough to have Black people in leadership or from whatever immigrant background if you're not actually improving conditions for everybody else of that identity who are mostly working class people.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N: </strong>So, we have talked a little bit about your journey through DSA, DSA's electoral program, but can you tell us about DSA's politics? We have been told… I mean, we know it's a big tent organization, it's a larger socialist organization. What is DSA's program? Because you said the Democratic Party does not have a program for its electeds, its representatives, right? So what is DSA's program for its electeds, for its members, for the working class, or for everyday people? And also, because you have brought up international solidarity, how does the program reflect this internationalist lens, and how are you building towards solidarity in this age of, you know, fascism everywhere, things are getting bad everywhere?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A: </strong>Yeah, we just published a national program called Workers Deserve More. You can check it out at <a href="http://program.dsausa.org">program.dsausa.org</a>. So this lays out a pretty expansive vision for how we would like to transform our society in the United States. So it's not at this stage…</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N: </strong>Also famously quoted by the Speaker of the House, Mike Johnson, on the House floor, right?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yes. That was so crazy. Yeah, they're flipping out about it. Fox News has been giving us a lot of free advertising about this program.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Love that.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> So this includes things that are the kinds of things that our electoral candidates are campaigning on right now to address cost of living, things like universal healthcare, universal childcare. Things toward a Green New Deal to expand public transit and transform our grid to renewable electricity that is, ideally free at the point of service. Expanding union power. Those are all the kinds of things that we're campaigning on now, like public power over utilities, making food, education, energy, healthcare publicly funded goods. Those are things that we are advancing locally and nationally.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">But then there are much bigger picture vision things about how do we transform our democracy? We are in a very undemocratic political system. The United States is kind of uniquely among Global North countries [and] is really stacked toward existing powers. Historically, it was really developed to, I mean it started with just suffrage for white males, mostly landowners effectively. So a lot of work happened through a lot of struggle over two and a half centuries to expand the category of who can even vote. But then the Senate is really stacked toward, it's a minoritarian system of democracy versus representative bodies in parliaments in other countries that have proportional representation where you can count on the principle of one person, one vote. It's not mediated by an electoral college for president, or the Senate that just stacks it towards smaller states versus larger states.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So, we want to have a system where everybody has an equal say as one human person. We want to take on the power of corporations. Right now, after Citizens United and all these things that have developed to give corporations way more power to the point where they're legally defined as people, like that's crazy to us. We want to change that. So our vision goes from near term addressing cost of living things with universal public goods, expanding union power and worker power, to changing how our political structure works. And that's a much longer-term vision. It's not something we think can happen just by voting more, or just getting more people to vote. It means we need more power in labour unions, we need to organize people in their workplaces, in their communities to transform how politics even happens.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So, there's this basic idea we have in DSA of transformative reforms or non-reformist reforms, like the kinds of things that we can advocate for as policies to reform things. But then, if we were to win them, they would just raise expectations of people to demand even more. So beyond just reforming, to transform our whole political system. So something like healthcare for all, Medicare for all would be something that if we were to win it, then millions of workers, people across the country, would no longer have to count on their employer for private health insurance. So that frees them up to maybe agitate for <em>more</em> rights at work, or to demand better work conditions without having to worry about their healthcare being taken away if they're fired. So things like that can just…what are the kinds of reforms we can demand, and organize to win that then make way more things possible?&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So that's a basic principle, but ultimately, we want to help people envision what does life look like beyond capitalism? It's not just about having the government do more. We don't just want to have the government do nice things. To us, that's not what socialism is. We want to create a new system. We want to move from capitalism to socialism, going through the democratic structure that we have.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So the program that we have lays out, there's a nice little narrative at the top about, imagine that you take a day off from work in a future beyond capitalism. What would that be like? What would it be like to not have bills really for basic necessities because those are universal public goods? Those are things that… we see are really important to help people imagine, what does a real future look like? As we start to organize to transform things. Because there's a short-termism that's really baked into American politics in particular. I think this is probably the case across the Global North. But in the US especially, it's like every two years there's a new electoral cycle. Everybody in Congress just has to do a lot of fundraising to get elected or reelected. People are only thinking in two year cycles. So it's very hard to do any kind of longer term planning or, just thinking beyond your own re-election as somebody in Congress. And most Americans, most people have no way to engage in getting people to think about what a longer-term vision looks like. So, with something like the climate crisis, that's why there is no progress on climate at the national level in the United States, because that's a long-term systematic problem that's very hard to think about for people who are in these two year cycles. So, we want to activate millions of people to imagine what that better future looks like where we can really change things. Organize enough people to make these things possible, think about what it would be like to organize our lives and democratically be able to have a say in how we spend our day-to-day life, week to week, month to month, year to year. Like those are decisions that should be made by everyone instead of the very wealthiest people like the billionaires who dominate and profit from the way things work right now.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N: </strong>That's such a beautiful way to think about politics, right? It's like you have to be able to imagine a life beyond your current grind in capitalism. Like what else are you striving for, right? But it's so hard because even taking that time, taking the two minutes to imagine the day off is hard, because you're constantly bombarded by, how am I gonna pay my bills? How am I gonna cover childcare? How am I gonna afford to pay my rent, right? So, the program that you laid out is, like, in the near term, if you're able to alleviate these constant battles just to survive, you will have the time to look forward and be like, okay, what else can we do.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So, as somebody working in the labour movement in unions, we also have to think about this because we're constantly –employers and bosses are constantly trying to exploit their workers, even in a union environment. And you have to constantly put out fires and tell the bosses, you can't do this, it's in the contract.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">But also, what about the future? What are we building towards? For example, the Medicaid cuts. Or how do we fight against the bigger things that are happening?&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So can you tell me a little bit more about how, let's say in this imagination, how DSA is thinking about its internationalist politics? Because DSA, again, not to overuse the term, but it is the largest socialist organization in the United States, which is by and large, still the imperial superpower. Obviously there is multipolarization happening. There's the question of China, as we are all supposedly living in the Chinese century. And for you, for me, for a lot of our listeners who are probably listening from South Asia or other countries where the United States may not be the only imperial or superpower looking into building out extractive industries to use the climate lens. For example, there's a lot of concerns about Chinese investments in Bangladesh or in Pakistan or in India resulting in extractivism.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So, how does that play out in your mind and in DSA's entire political landscape. What exactly is your orientation towards these things? When we talk about building solidarity across geographical boundaries or across borders. What does that look like to you and DSA? Obviously you are not DSA, but, how does it figure into DSA's politics, and how do you personally think about those things?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yeah, I think across the board in DSA, we have a pretty strong consensus that our role within the United States is to change American policy. We have the power to – if we expand democracy to actually allow it to be the case that all Americans can vote on what we want American foreign policy to be. We see the interest of people in the United States is to provide for things right here.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So if we had universal public goods just to meet people's needs right here. That goes against the imperative right now to spend a trillion dollars on a military budget that is just meant to militarily dominate the whole rest of the world for the profits of multinational corporations. Of weapons profiteers, companies like whoever is profiting from dropping bombs on other parts of the world, so that other corporations can come in and extract resources from the people who live there. That's not in our shared interest, if we have an international consciousness.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I think there is a wide range of perspectives about a bunch of particulars in international policy, and this has been the case as long as there's been a left around the world. There are always big questions about how do you exist in a country that is doing imperialism, that is engaging in the great powers contests? This was the case in the run up to the First World War, where leftists in Germany, or the UK, or France had very intense heated conflicts and divergences around how they engage with these questions. So those are all live today in the United States, which is still the most powerful country in the world, has the largest military. So there are real contradictions in how we relate to a bunch of particular international situations.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">But I think across the board, we have a consensus across DSA that we need to end the U.S. military-imperial, however we want to define it. The military-industrial complex is a problem. We need to do away with it. We need to shift resources massively from militarism to social needs, especially in the United States. And we really don't see there being military solutions to any range of things that are seen as problems around the world. So just ending US military aid to countries that are doing genocide, like Israel. There's a total consensus on that. With Palestine, especially over the past few years, an arms embargo against Israel is a very clear thing to focus on because the state of Israel is the largest recipient of US military aid. That's just a direct thing that we should have the power to change. So that's a big core commitment.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Ending US overseas military bases is something that is not really talked a lot about politically within the US, but it's kind of taken for granted. The United States right now has over 700 foreign military bases. The next countries are Russia and China. Russia has something like maybe 20, China has 2 or 3. So, there's such a massive discrepancy there that costs tens of billions of dollars per year, maybe hundreds of billions at this point. So it's both a waste of resources, and also it helps make the whole world more unsafe. It makes people trust the United States less in places that have military bases. There are all these problems that come from just having a lot of, mostly men, just concentrated to dominate people locally. We could get into all the problems with that.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">But even if we're coming at it from an angle of self-interest for people in the United States, there's a particular kind of liberal nationalist lens, I think. People have this idea, at least in the Democratic Party, that we're spreading American values, we're spreading democracy. Okay yeah, we're not going to do these wars, those are bad, but we're still going to spread American values somehow with the implicit understanding that that still is military domination. [That] we still need to have the strongest military. That doesn't work in practice. We get what we pay for. The more we invest in militarism, the more it just becomes, well, when you have a hammer, then everything looks like a nail. And that's the basis for somebody like Trump coming into office and doing this much more open imperialism. Talking about the Monroe doctrine, referring to the Monroe doctrine over a century ago, which we were taught to think was in the past. Where America was just openly doing imperialism across the Western Hemisphere. He's fully just bringing that back and expanding it. Like, oh, we should take over Greenland, we should take over… What if we start taking over the Gulf of Mexico, which is now the Gulf of America? A lot of Americans are shocked to hear this, but it's just reviving things that were said pretty openly a century ago. And now there's even more material basis for it <em>because </em>America has an even larger military than it ever did. We've had a military budget approaching a trillion dollars for decades through Democrat and Republican administrations alike. So Trump is now able to work with that to cause all these threats globally. But that's been enabled by both parties in power.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So anyway, we just don't see militarism as a solution to the world's problems. And what if we redirected a trillion dollars from militarism globally to solving the climate crisis, to investing in infrastructure and adaptation, expanding renewable energy everywhere? What if the United States were interested in doing that?&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">You mentioned China, right? There's a lot of concern, [or] threat perception about China and the United States becoming a new global hegemon. So again, if people are even concerned about it on those terms, then perhaps the United States should try to compete a little bit on those grounds. Right now, China has a plan for a future with the climate crisis. They're actually investing a lot of resources in renewable energy and solar energy and exporting it all over the world. So now countries like Pakistan recently just implemented solar panels in a very distributed way very quickly. So now they're able to adapt more to this entry, and they have China to thank for that, not the United States, right?&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So we're just heading into this multipolar world where military domination by one country is not viable or strategic or useful. It's just a massive waste of resources, and it causes a lot of harm. Moreover, I don't want to think about it just in economic dollar terms. I'm used to doing that because we've been asked about policy a lot lately. But it's just caused destruction at a degree that's hard for many Americans to imagine. Like the costs of war in the Middle East since 2001, since 9/11. There's the money cost, which is over 8 trillion dollars, which is crazy. Half of that would have been enough to shift the entire U.S. energy grid to renewable electricity. There was a study that said it would have been $4 trillion, or still would be, to have 100% renewable energy across the country. So if that had started two decades ago, instead of the war on terror, we would just be in a totally different world.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">But then the human cost – 38 million people were displaced across the Middle East over two decades. That's, like, the entire population of California or Canada. That's just, a scale of human destruction. I think a million people or more were killed by the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. So this is being caused by US imperialism. By US militarism. The US war machine. It's a core commitment to end that, and everybody will benefit from that –the people who are no longer being bombed, or under threat of military invasion around the world. But also in the United States. That is a shared interest that we have to organize.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I think there are also different perspectives about well, can we do that in the US? Like can working class people in the United States really change that? Is it even in their interests? Or do they actually benefit from imperial extraction? There's a lot of discourse around this, a lot of, Marxist theory about how global systems work.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Right, the Global North working class can only get benefits if they are relying on this extractive model, or an exploit in the Global South, right? Yeah.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yeah. Or just Marx wrote a lot about thinking about the industrial working class, like industrial workers in the 19th century, who were in countries like the UK and Germany and the United States. It’s not wrong to say that a lot of those industrial workers now, the industries have been shifted to Global South countries, countries like Bangladesh or China or Vietnam or wherever. Bangladesh's economy today is very driven by garment factories. The types of garment factories that existed in New York City or in London over a century ago, but now they're in places like Bangladesh. So I think there are people in the US, or leftists throughout the Global North, who feel like, well, maybe they are the revolutionary subjects of the 21st century, and our role in countries like this is just a question mark. Like, what is our role? Do we even have a role? Maybe it'll just happen there.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Right.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> I mean I feel pretty strongly, from my life experience and everything, like one, I see the potential being enacted to organize workers in the U.S. who are increasingly diverse. It's not just white people. There are these real examples of solidarity across differences based on shared working class interests here. We just have to keep doing that more, more and more across the entire country, like organizing people from all sorts of working class backgrounds.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">And we're seeing results of that. We're seeing that in New York, we're seeing that in Michigan, where somebody like Abdul El-Sayed, who's not a DSA member, but has a lot of aligned goals. Detroit DSA just scored a huge win with Donovan McKinney for Congress, who's black. He's the first black Congressman in a while. I think the largest majority black city in the country is Detroit. So they're the only city that is fully represented by Socialists now in office; Rashida Tlaib and Donovan McKinney.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Which is a powerful example of Black Palestinian solidarity. Just organizing major parts of the working class of Detroit across these differences, around shared interests. So that's really important, especially when we're looking at the Great Lakes region.I've been in the Great Lakes region a lot lately from Michigan to Milwaukee. Wisconsin had a great race recently with Francesca Hong, who came pretty close to winning the primary.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> 0.4%. What a close race.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A: </strong>Yeah, and so Wisconsin revived a lot of interest in sewer socialism, which was a political tendency in the early 20th century where Milwaukee was the basis. The Socialist Party then helped elect a bunch of people to Milwaukee who expanded public services. Just things like sewers, water treatment, and expanding quality of life in very basic ways through public power, and were openly socialist. And they were reelected for decades. They were very popular. And there were a lot of immigrants at the time who were part of that working class base. There are a lot of people who moved to Wisconsin and Minnesota in the 19th and 20th centuries who came from Scandinavia or other parts of Europe, who were a big part of that socialist…</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Also, Rashida Tlaib's father was very involved in the UAW, famously the UAW strike in Detroit, right?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> That's right. He was an auto worker in Detroit. Exactly.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Yeah. And he was an Arab Palestinian autoworker. Who organized his community to support the autoworkers on strike and gather around that. That was one of her key — she describes it as one of her key moments of politicization early on in life.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yeah, exactly. So, often in the United States, there's a perception of, when people say working class, they imagine a white factory worker who's blue-collar and just coded in conservative ways culturally. But it's way more diverse than that, and we just can't essentialize people around identity factors. The point should be organizing actually existing workers for real things people can imagine, and help expand people's imagination through the kinds of campaigns we organize, the fights we pick, and then what we win.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So anyway, I just have been thinking about that, the sewer socialist history, and socialism in the United States over a century ago, which <em>was</em> a major part of American politics. And that was very immigrant coded. It was very shaped by immigrant workers at the time. So a big task of today is refreshing that with the actual existing workers, many of whom are immigrants today. But just organizing people across those differences. And that's a big part of renewing American society, but across the world, like that international consciousness is important to bake in.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">And, it's already happening. It's happening, and we just have to keep organizing more quickly than the fascists are. To scapegoat immigrants and fear mongering in all these ways while stripping all of our public services for parts. So the more we organize this way around people's shared interests here in the United States, that helps build that international consciousness, especially because so many people are immigrants from parts of the world that experienced colonialism, imperialism, all these things.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So, I bring it back to the climate crisis. A big question globally in climate politics is how can we get enough money invested from the countries that benefited from colonialism, that allowed them to become so wealthy and are most responsible for the climate crisis because of all the carbon emissions. How can they be motivated to share resources with all the less developed countries that were on the other end of colonialism? And to me, a big part of it is organizing people in their shared interests. Who are immigrants, especially in the United States, to organize our collective power, again, across differences around shared class interests in the US, and then, that's part of the small democratic political base that will be motivated in the shared interest to eventually help fund a lot of resources to go to other parts of the world, so that we can all survive this over the 21st century.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N: </strong>And how would one, a listener based in the United States, get involved in such organizing?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> You can join the Democratic Socialists of America. Check out our website, <a href="http://dsausa.org">dsausa.org</a>. It's just as easy as signing up, paying dues, whatever you can. Again, from each according to their ability, to each according to their means. So our dues-based structure is pretty flexible. And that's a really core source of our power, where we just passed 120,000 members across the country, which makes us the largest socialist organization in the United States in history. Which is very exciting. You can join by paying dues, and then you can do whatever you want. We're driven by our members. There are a lot of ways to plug in to do more organizing, but at the core, it's about having lots of members who can shape our decisions together democratically, and our funding structure helps us punch way above our weight, just based on what anyone can contribute. And that’s what helps us be meaningfully independent of the existing political system. We can decide what to do with our resources together, what kinds of campaigns we organize, what we do in our communities. So yeah, from wherever you are, you can be a DSA member, and it's a great time to join.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>N:</strong> Well, that's all we have time for today. But thank you so much, Ashik, for this very long-ranging conversation. And thank you for sharing so much about your own personal growth and what DSA is doing and hopes to accomplish. Onwards to organizing!</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A: </strong>All right. Thank you, Nafis. Really good to talk.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Ashik Siddique </em></strong><em>is the</em><strong><em> </em></strong><em>co-chair of the Democratic Socialists of America.</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Nafis Hasan </em></strong><em>is a Bangladeshi writer and organizer based in Philadelphia. He is the author of </em><a target="_blank" href="https://www.commonnotions.org/metastasis?srsltid=AfmBOooLx1Ifhp75bFkvr6tcDo1vyBdanPrrpZP4Q9D_IErMsDeWs42d"><em>Metastasis: The Rise of the Cancer-Industrial Complex and the Horizons of Care</em></a><em> </em>and <em>also sits on Jamhoor’s editorial committee.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1793763864081-3UY0ZE2LUIYUQOE59S76/Header_Interview+with+Ashik+Siddique+%28DSA%29.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">Double Consciousness and the Power of Solidarity</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>Hum Dekhenge: Student Uprisings in the Age of Hindutva</title><category>Essay</category><category>India</category><dc:creator>Chandni Desai</dc:creator><pubDate>Thu, 17 Sep 2026 14:44:20 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/hum-dekhenge-student-uprisings-in-the-age-of-hindutva</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:6aa413c513045e2f705cbba1</guid><description><![CDATA[A story of revolutionary and security internationalisms.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A story of revolutionary and security internationalisms.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d815e8a5-7180-48ac-b347-6492521abee6/photo+1+tear+gas+jantar+mantar+protests+2026-07-22T190145Z_475862421_RC22JMAGPE95_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-POLITICS.JPG" data-image-dimensions="4500x3153" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d815e8a5-7180-48ac-b347-6492521abee6/photo+1+tear+gas+jantar+mantar+protests+2026-07-22T190145Z_475862421_RC22JMAGPE95_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-POLITICS.JPG?format=1000w" width="4500" height="3153" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d815e8a5-7180-48ac-b347-6492521abee6/photo+1+tear+gas+jantar+mantar+protests+2026-07-22T190145Z_475862421_RC22JMAGPE95_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-POLITICS.JPG?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d815e8a5-7180-48ac-b347-6492521abee6/photo+1+tear+gas+jantar+mantar+protests+2026-07-22T190145Z_475862421_RC22JMAGPE95_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-POLITICS.JPG?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d815e8a5-7180-48ac-b347-6492521abee6/photo+1+tear+gas+jantar+mantar+protests+2026-07-22T190145Z_475862421_RC22JMAGPE95_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-POLITICS.JPG?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d815e8a5-7180-48ac-b347-6492521abee6/photo+1+tear+gas+jantar+mantar+protests+2026-07-22T190145Z_475862421_RC22JMAGPE95_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-POLITICS.JPG?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d815e8a5-7180-48ac-b347-6492521abee6/photo+1+tear+gas+jantar+mantar+protests+2026-07-22T190145Z_475862421_RC22JMAGPE95_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-POLITICS.JPG?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d815e8a5-7180-48ac-b347-6492521abee6/photo+1+tear+gas+jantar+mantar+protests+2026-07-22T190145Z_475862421_RC22JMAGPE95_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-POLITICS.JPG?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d815e8a5-7180-48ac-b347-6492521abee6/photo+1+tear+gas+jantar+mantar+protests+2026-07-22T190145Z_475862421_RC22JMAGPE95_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-POLITICS.JPG?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Police use teargas to control the crowd during the student protests at Jantar Mantar in New Delhi, India, July 22, 2026. Image: REUTERS/Adnan Abidi</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Police use teargas to control the crowd during the student protests at Jantar Mantar in New Delhi, India, July 22, 2026. Image: REUTERS/Adnan Abidi</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Thousands of students filled the streets of India in July 2026 in one of the largest student mobilisations since Narendra Modi and Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) came to power in 2014. As students waged their protests, confronting police and the Rapid Action Force (RAF), a paramilitary unit of the Central Reserve Police Force, the youth did not invent a new language of resistance. Leftist students reached for the voices of South Asia’s courageous revolutionaries and poets that had long animated the subcontinent’s struggles against British colonialism, caste and class oppression, and sectarianism. Students chanted: “<em>Inquilab Zindabad </em>(Long Live the Revolution),” “<em>Jai Bhim </em>(Hail Dr. B.R. Ambedkar),” “<em>Sarfaroshi ki tamanna ab hamare dil mein hai </em>(The desire for self-sacrifice now fills our hearts),” and numerous other chants. People also recited the Punjab-born Pakistani communist poet Faiz Ahmed Faiz’s “<em>Bol, ke lab āzād hain tere</em>” (Speak, for your lips are free) and “<em>Hum Dekhenge</em>” (We Shall See). These slogans and poetic verses were acts of historical remembrance, situating the student struggle against a corrupt and right-wing, neo-fascist BJP Hindutva regime within a radical tradition of rebellion. They were carried by left student organisations and taken up by many who had never belonged to one.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The student uprising, or Cockroach protests, sits at the intersection of two transnational circulations. One is the long, revolutionary internationalism of anti-colonial, anti-imperialist emancipatory political memory and praxis: a generation that never lived through these moments powerfully invoked Faiz Ahmed Faiz’s poetry, Hasrat Mohani and Bismil Azimabadi’s Urdu poetics, Bhagat Singh’s revolutionary vocabulary, and B.R. Ambedkar’s anti-caste jurisprudence. The left invoked them to position themselves within a historical continuum to reimagine an India free from religious hatreds, inequality, oppressive caste and class relations and patriarchal beliefs, intensified since 2014. The other is the security internationalism of counter-insurgency doctrines: the way policing techniques, surveillance technologies, counter-insurgency training, weapons, and biometric infrastructure move between states through trade fairs, bilateral agreements, and homeland security consultancy, carrying an ideology of population management, as surely as the chants and poetry carry an ideology of freedom. Students in India inherited the first circulation by remembering and invoking it. The extreme state violence that met them in the street was built, in traceable part, by the second circulation.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Student Protests Under BJP Authoritarianism</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In May 2026, India’s National Testing Agency (NTA) cancelled the NEET medical entrance examination, the gateway through which more than 2.2 million students a year seek a medical career, after a paper leak. Over a dozen students committed suicide, turning the exam scandal into a national crisis. Competitive examinations in India for all professions are built on years of hard work and immense family sacrifice. For poor and middle-class families, preparing for them often means investing heavily, taking on debt, selling scarce assets, relocating to coaching centres, and forgoing essential life necessities, all sustained by the unpaid social reproduction of family members who provide emotional support, and domestic labour that falls disproportionately on women. The leaks devalued all of it, and broke the promise that education was a path to employment and a secure future.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>The protesters came from every background: Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, and Buddhists; upper-caste and Dalit; middle-class and poor; women, men, and gender-nonconforming folks; high schoolers, farmers, workers, and the parents of protesters. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Out of that anger came the Cockroach Janata Party (CJP), launched in May 2026 by Abhijeet Dipke as a satirical response to the Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, who had dismissed India’s unemployed youth as “cockroaches” and “parasites of society.” The cockroach became a powerful symbol because protesters reclaimed an image of disposability and transformed it into one of persistence: the people treated as unwanted would keep returning. By early June a protest encampment was put in place at Jantar Mantar, India’s most prominent protest site near Parliament in Delhi, which was joined within days by the All India Students Association (AISA), the Students’ Federation of India (SFI), and other left student unions and organisations, turning it into a mass movement demanding reform of the examination system and the resignation of BJP Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan. By late June the climate and education activist Sonam Wangchuk had joined the sit-in from Ladakh with an indefinite hunger strike, alongside several AISA students. On July 18, on the 21st day of that hunger strike, Delhi police <a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/7/18/indian-police-forcibly-hospitalise-activist-after-20-day-hunger-strike"><u>forcibly removed him</u></a> and took him to Safdarjung Hospital, which ignited the protests further. Two days later, more than 10,000 people were marching on Parliament under the banner “<em>Chalo Sansad</em>” (Let’s go to Parliament) and were met with extreme state violence and the shutdown of <a href="https://internetfreedom.in/iff-condemns-the-internet-shutdown-in-parts-of-central-delhi-no-suspension-order-has-been-made-public/"><u>mobile internet services</u></a> by the government. This ignited further nationwide protests.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The protesters came from every background: Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, Christians, and Buddhists; upper-caste and Dalit; middle-class and poor; women, men, and gender-nonconforming folks; high schoolers, farmers, workers, and the parents of protesters. Gurdwaras (Sikh temples) opened overnight to shelter and feed the crowds, in keeping with the Sikh tradition of langar (serving free communal food), and mosques did the same. The corporate media, the shouting mouthpieces of the government known as the “godi media,” tried to brand the movement as foreign-funded by Pakistan, China, or George Soros; yet the students’ control of their own narrative broke the attempt. In an interview with <a href="https://www.democracynow.org/2026/7/24/india_cockroach_movement_arundhati_roy?utm"><u>Democracy Now</u></a>, Arundhati Roy described a large first-time cohort of middle-class and upper-caste Hindu students, many from households that vote BJP. Some were the children and grandchildren of Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) sympathisers, the right-wing Hindu nationalist organisation that popularised Hindutva as a political ideology through a project of transforming India into a Hindu nation. This was the most destabilising development for the government. A movement built from the state’s “usual suspects” is easy to dismiss as ideological opposition, a movement that includes the sons and daughters of the BJP’s own voter base is a fracture inside the base itself. The protests also exposed the class contradictions of India’s education system. What began as a revolt against examination corruption became a struggle over neoliberal capitalism in which education had grown privatised, expensive, and insecure with high unemployment and an economic crisis that has captured the nation since the BJP came to office. In naming the gap between the promise of meritocracy and the lives of millions of students, left student organisations turned an educational grievance into a broader struggle over class, caste, labour, inequality, and fascism.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2185c96a-5a92-4d2e-9be6-981cab8cbddb/Inquilab+image+shutterstock_2818039089.jpg" data-image-dimensions="8064x6048" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2185c96a-5a92-4d2e-9be6-981cab8cbddb/Inquilab+image+shutterstock_2818039089.jpg?format=1000w" width="8064" height="6048" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2185c96a-5a92-4d2e-9be6-981cab8cbddb/Inquilab+image+shutterstock_2818039089.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2185c96a-5a92-4d2e-9be6-981cab8cbddb/Inquilab+image+shutterstock_2818039089.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2185c96a-5a92-4d2e-9be6-981cab8cbddb/Inquilab+image+shutterstock_2818039089.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2185c96a-5a92-4d2e-9be6-981cab8cbddb/Inquilab+image+shutterstock_2818039089.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2185c96a-5a92-4d2e-9be6-981cab8cbddb/Inquilab+image+shutterstock_2818039089.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2185c96a-5a92-4d2e-9be6-981cab8cbddb/Inquilab+image+shutterstock_2818039089.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2185c96a-5a92-4d2e-9be6-981cab8cbddb/Inquilab+image+shutterstock_2818039089.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Political graffiti, protest slogans and spray-painted messages cover a boundary wall near the site of the students’ protest at Jantar Mantar in New Delhi, July 2026. Image: Sayyed Abuzar Ali</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Political graffiti, protest slogans and spray-painted messages cover a boundary wall near the site of the students’ protest at Jantar Mantar in New Delhi, July 2026. Image: Sayyed Abuzar Ali</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">For 12 years, the BJP’s governance has run on a specific architecture: Hindus and Muslims cast as the primary antagonists, with Dalits, Sikhs, and other communities in turn pitted against a Hindu centre, so that any demand to hold the government accountable could be deflected into religious grievance instead. That architecture has been enforced through a climate of sectarian polarisation and fear by Hindutva mob violence aimed at intimidating those who challenge the government or assert their rights; police complicity in violence against non-Hindus; a corporate media apparatus and BJP IT cell that together amplify the state’s narrative, producing years of fear and self-censorship. The left student unions refused the deflection, communal hatreds, and Hindutva fascism. Corruption in an exam system is not a Hindu-Muslim question, and the large coalition that formed around it was proof that the divide in Modi’s India could be crossed. One chant in particular illustrated this point: “J<em>ab jab Modi darta hai, Hindu-Muslim karta hai</em>” (Whenever Modi is afraid, he turns to Hindu-Muslim politics). Neha Bora, AISA’s National President, a hunger-striker and a leading organiser of the protests, accused the government of trying to recast the student movement as a communal one.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Humour, memes, masks, ridicule, and profanity punctured the BJP’s carefully crafted image and aura of masculine and religious authority that it has spent years and vast resources cultivating. Street art and protest signs caricatured Modi alongside Gautam Adani and Mukesh Ambani, two corporate oligarchs central to the consolidation of Indian monopoly capital. This imagery drew on an iconography of crony capitalism that has circulated in Indian protest culture since Punjab’s farmers burned effigies of the same two men in 2020. Protesters traced the education crisis to the corporate influence of these billionaires, and to the <em>pracharaks</em> (RSS organisers) installed across the country’s key institutions, particularly educational institutions fully captured by the BJP who are destroying the education system. For the youth, this was evidence that their generation had no future under the present order. The culture of resistance the student protests produced became one of the sharpest challenges the BJP has faced. On July 25, Dharmendra Pradhan, a key party strategist and one of Modi’s most reliable cabinet colleagues resigned. Since 2014 the BJP had conceded no ministerial resignation to protest or opposition demand. The student movement generated the people power that forced the regime to bend.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Revolutionary Internationalism: The Poets and Revolutionaries Students Invoked</h4>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>“Inquilab Zindabad,” first coined by the Urdu poet, anti-colonial leader and freedom fighter Hasrat Mohani, was adopted by the Punjabi revolutionary Bhagat Singh, who popularised the slogan in the Central Legislative Assembly of the British Raj in 1929, before he was hanged at 23 for resisting British colonial rule alongside two of his comrades.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Several chants and poems recited at the student protests carried a longer, border-crossing history. That history had been quietly edited out of this generation’s school curricula. A decade of saffronisation of education and the curriculum through BJP-led textbook <a href="https://time.com/6269349/india-textbook-changes-controversy-hindu-nationalism/?utm">revisions has trimmed or removed chapters</a> on: Mughal history, the 2002 Gujarat massacre, the post-independence ban on the RSS following Mahatma Gandhi’s assassination, the later ban after the Babri Masjid demolition, secularism, democracy, dissent, caste oppression and Dalit movements, and environmental issues, while expanding narratives centred on Hindu civilisational identity and mythology. Combined with privatisation, the expansion of the coaching industry, and repeated examination failures, the curriculum became another site through which the BJP government sought to shape both knowledge and citizenship. In such a context, reaching for B.R. Ambedkar, Bhagat Singh, Hasrat Mohani, Bismil Azimabadi, and Faiz was not only paying homage, it was a revolutionary recovery of praxis.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">“Inquilab Zindabad,” first coined by the Urdu poet, anti-colonial leader and freedom fighter Hasrat Mohani, was adopted by the Punjabi revolutionary Bhagat Singh, who popularised the slogan in the Central Legislative Assembly of the British Raj in 1929, before he was hanged at 23 for resisting British colonial rule alongside two of his comrades. Singh’s own political formation was itself an act of circulation; he was influenced by the Russian Revolution, Marxism, anti-imperialism, socialism, Irish revolutionaries, and corresponded with an international network of anti-colonial radicals, and understood the Indian freedom struggle as one front in a wider world war against empire.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Another revolutionary refrain associated with Singh, “Sarfaroshi Ki Tamanna” (“the desire for self sacrifice”), was written around 1921 by the Muslim poet Bismil Azimabadi and later popularised by the revolutionary Ram Prasad Bismil, a leader of the Hindustan Republican Association, which Singh belonged to. Carried into the revolutionary movement by figures executed by the British including Bismil, Ashfaqullah Khan and Singh, the poem became an anthem of resistance and a shared revolutionary vocabulary that crossed social, political and religious boundaries.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The RSS <a href="https://www.newsclick.in/fact-check-rss-had-no-role-indias-freedom-struggle?page=1&amp;utm">did not participate in the freedom struggle</a> that produced these anti-colonial revolutionaries; its founding texts, on the contrary, drew admiringly on European fascism, particularly Nazism, and its early leadership counselled cadres to stay out of India’s anti-colonial movement because Hindu nationalism’s real enemy was internal, not British. What distinguishes the RSS <a href="https://archive.org/details/hindunationalist00chri">Hindutva fascism</a> and governance from ordinary right-wing authoritarianism is an organised paramilitary movement older than the Indian republic itself that has spent a century building towards state capture rather than merely winning an election.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>Layered with these slogans were also Faiz Ahmed Faiz’s verses, “Bol,” first published in 1941 during British colonial rule, and “Hum Dekhenge” (We Shall See) written under Pakistani martial law in 1979 and later banned by General Zia-ul-Haq’s regime. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Within this context, when students recited slogans coined, written, and chanted by some of the subcontinent’s most beloved revolutionaries, figures whose anti-colonial, anti-imperialist, and anti-caste traditions sit uneasily with the RSS’s own historical and ideological inheritance, they exposed a documented rupture in the ruling party’s claim to represent the nation. As the government denounced protesting students as “anti-national” and “terrorists,” these chants reclaimed the language and memory of India’s anti-colonial struggle. Not everyone welcomed that inheritance fully. The CJP’s leadership appealed to protesters to hold several approved slogans, dropping “Azaadi” (Freedom)—a historic anti-colonial cry against the British, given renewed political force in the Kashmir Valley—to avoid handing the government material for “negative narratives.” The appeal did not hold. Where the CJP’s leadership kept its distance from the question of Hindutva, Neha Bora told a public gathering that Hindutva and the RSS had to be uprooted from Indian soil.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Other frequently recited slogans were “Jai Bhim,” and “Educate, Agitate, Organize.” In doing so, the students invoked B.R. Ambedkar, whose own sense of caste oppression was comparative and global. Ambedkar wrote much of India’s Constitution which affirmed equality before the law for all people, enshrined fundamental rights, freedom of religion, affirmative action reservations, and universal adult suffrage. He also drafted Article 17 which abolished untouchability and made caste discrimination unconstitutional. In 1946, writing from Bombay, <a href="https://www.saada.org/explore/archive/items/20140415-3544">he corresponded with W.E.B. Du Bois</a> about parallels between Dalit and Black American subjugation. Du Bois wrote back to Ambedkar that he had <a href="https://www.saada.org/explore/archive/items/20140415-3545">“every sympathy with the Untouchables of India.”</a> A generation later, a group of Dalit writers and activists named themselves the <a href="https://www.forwardpress.in/2019/12/dalit-panthers-an-authoritative-history/">Dalit Panthers</a>, explicitly modelled on the Black Panther Party, and Martin Luther King Jr.’s own 1959 visit to India left him <a href="https://kinginstitute.stanford.edu/king-papers/documents/my-trip-land-gandhi?utm">remarking</a> on parallels between caste oppression and American racial segregation. Ambedkar was also one of the country’s foremost advocates for women’s legal rights, which is why many women organisers continue to invoke him as an enduring source of political inspiration and a debt owed.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cf09fd0c-5943-4039-9887-efbfe2471a57/pro-pal+protests+students+detained+shutterstock_2382275697.jpg" data-image-dimensions="7360x4912" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cf09fd0c-5943-4039-9887-efbfe2471a57/pro-pal+protests+students+detained+shutterstock_2382275697.jpg?format=1000w" width="7360" height="4912" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cf09fd0c-5943-4039-9887-efbfe2471a57/pro-pal+protests+students+detained+shutterstock_2382275697.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cf09fd0c-5943-4039-9887-efbfe2471a57/pro-pal+protests+students+detained+shutterstock_2382275697.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cf09fd0c-5943-4039-9887-efbfe2471a57/pro-pal+protests+students+detained+shutterstock_2382275697.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cf09fd0c-5943-4039-9887-efbfe2471a57/pro-pal+protests+students+detained+shutterstock_2382275697.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cf09fd0c-5943-4039-9887-efbfe2471a57/pro-pal+protests+students+detained+shutterstock_2382275697.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cf09fd0c-5943-4039-9887-efbfe2471a57/pro-pal+protests+students+detained+shutterstock_2382275697.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cf09fd0c-5943-4039-9887-efbfe2471a57/pro-pal+protests+students+detained+shutterstock_2382275697.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Delhi Police and RAF detaining protesters from India’s leftist parties as they participate in an pro-Palestine solidarity protest at Jantar Mantar, New Delhi, Oct 16 2023. Image: Sipa USA</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Delhi Police and RAF detaining protesters from India’s leftist parties as they participate in an pro-Palestine solidarity protest at Jantar Mantar, New Delhi, Oct 16 2023. Image: Sipa USA</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Layered with these slogans were also Faiz Ahmed Faiz’s verses, “Bol,” first published in 1941 during British colonial rule, and “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RNuU_lBRCDI">Hum Dekhenge</a>” (We Shall See) written under Pakistani martial law in 1979 and later banned by General Zia-ul-Haq’s regime. Calling on people of the subcontinent to speak while they still could, and promising “a coming reckoning” against authoritarianism, these poems have become enduring anthems of protest movements across South Asia, including the 2019–20 anti-CAA (Citizenship Amendment Act) and anti-NRC (National Register of Citizens) protests in India. Yet the afterlife of Faiz’s poetry cannot be separated from the political life that produced it. His resistance to authoritarianism led to years of imprisonment and exile, eventually taking him to Beirut, Lebanon, where he edited the Afro-Asian Writers’ Association’s <em>Lotus</em> magazine and worked alongside Palestinian revolutionaries, including poets Muin Bseiso and Mahmoud Darwish, whom Faiz first met in the Soviet Union in the late 1960s, as well as the writer Ziad Abdel Fattah and PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat. In Beirut, Faiz witnessed frequent Israeli incursions into the city and the 1982 invasion of Lebanon and wrote elegies for Palestinian fighters and children, making Palestine not a metaphor grafted onto the poems, but part of the very soil from which they emerged.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>Situating the current student protests within the longer history of student resistance, including the anti-CAA and NRC protests, the repression of students at JNU, Jamia Millia Islamia University, Occupy University Grants Commission (UGC), and the movement for Rohith Vemula (a Dalit PhD scholar), points to the way the BJP government has progressively refined its repertoire of surveillance, policing and repression against dissenting students. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The student protests did not happen in a vacuum. Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imam, two former Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) scholar-activists who are Muslim and are India’s most prominent political prisoners, have now spent more than six years in Delhi’s Tihar jail <a href="https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2026/01/india-continued-detention-of-umar-khalid-and-sharjeel-imam-raises-grave-concerns/">without trial, denied bail again by the Supreme Court in January</a> even as five of their seven co-accused in the same February 2020 Delhi anti-Muslim pogrom conspiracy case were finally released. They were arrested under the anti-terror Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act for their alleged role in organising protests against the NRC and CAA, the same movement that also sang Faiz’s poetry, popularised the slogan Azaadi and chanted Bhagat Singh and Ambedkar into Delhi’s air. Their continued detention is the material referent behind the word anti-national, or terrorist, labels deployed by the BJP and state authorities against a wide range of dissidents including Muslims, Dalits, Adivasis, Sikhs, Kashmiris, and leftists, and since the summer protest to all youth, including Hindus.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The word anti-national does specific work. It turns a person with a grievance into an enemy-of-the-state, and once that move is made under a legal architecture built for counter-terrorism rather than crowd control, six years in a prison cell without trial stops being a scandal and becomes state policy and a lesson to intimidate others. Situating the current student protests within the longer history of student resistance, including the anti-CAA and NRC protests, the repression of students at JNU, Jamia Millia Islamia University, Occupy University Grants Commission (UGC), and the movement for Rohith Vemula (a Dalit PhD scholar), points to the way the BJP government has progressively refined its repertoire of surveillance, policing and repression against dissenting students.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The continuity extended beyond domestic struggles: the same left student unions and organisations that were confronting the state apparatus in the cockroach protests had also spent the previous two and a half years mobilising thousands in solidarity with Palestine and against India’s deepening alliance with Israel, facing arrests, detention, surveillance and restrictions on assembly. In October 2024, more than <a href="https://theprint.in/india/poems-keffiyehs-a-skit-at-jantar-mantar-as-left-leaders-activists-protest-israels-war-in-gaza/2301392/">40 organisations</a> collectively gathered at Jantar Mantar to protest one year of Israel’s genocide in Gaza which became a site of police surveillance, crackdown and Hindutva mob violence against pro-Palestine protestors.<strong> </strong>This violence re-emerged during the exam protests. It marked the point where the two circulations of resistance and repression collided at Jantar Mantar.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">State Violence against Protesters and Movements&nbsp;</h4>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>This is what a doctrine of population management looks like: a grammar of suspicion, biometric sorting, shooting at unarmed protesters and bystanders, religious targeting, family harassment, and family-as-hostage detention, normalised over a decade of violence against Muslims, Kashmiris, Dalits, Adivasis, Sikhs, leftists, the working class and poor.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Students faced barricades, police and RAF lathi charges (beatings with batons), tear gas, AK-47 and pellet gun bullets, arrests, detention, harassment, sexual assault, and some sustained severe injuries. Delhi Police also deployed an <a href="https://www.outlookindia.com/national/cjp-protest-under-ai-watch-delhi-polices-facial-recognition-vans-spark-privacy-concerns">AI-enabled surveillance van</a> equipped with 360-degree cameras and facial-recognition capacity, called Ikshana. Police officers were seen wearing <a href="https://www.techtimes.com/articles/322033/20260729/delhi-police-scanned-student-protesters-ai-courts-are-now-asking-who-authorized-that.htm">AjnaLens smart glasses</a>. Police used video feeds and database matching to identify people at the demonstration, later used to witch-hunt protesters specifically Muslims, Dalits and leftists. Digital-rights advocates challenged the absence of clear legal authorisation, retention limits, notification procedures and independent oversight. The use of such technologies transformed these protests into biometric checkpoints, allowing police to record faces, identify participants, and create enduring databases of dissent.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">A day after the Delhi crackdown, in Bihar’s Siwan district, a constable was filmed opening fire with an AK-47 during the Bihar Bandh, the statewide shutdown. <a href="https://www.ibtimes.co.in/siwan-ak-47-firing-cop-suspended-after-viral-video-injured-protesters-condition-stable-904222">Three people wounded,</a> among them a 15-year-old shop worker named Md Arif, shot in the neck on his way home from work; he survived. In the Bihar crackdown, police arrested hundreds of protestors, including many leaders of left student unions. And in Delhi, Mohammad Junaid, a Muslim volunteer who spent weeks distributing meals to protesters at the Jantar Mantar encampment, said <a href="https://clarionindia.net/cjp-volunteer-mohammad-junaid-family-released-after-alleged-police-harassment/">plainclothes police officers blindfolded him</a>, detained him overnight, and abandoned him 250 kilometres away in Mussoorie. At the same time, police in Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh and Meerut detained his father, his minor brother and his sister’s in-laws, confiscating the family’s PAN cards, Aadhaar cards and bank passbooks until Junaid turned himself in. Danish Ali, Joint Secretary of the JNU Students’ Union, said police visited her family home and village in an apparent attempt to intimidate her as well. This is what a doctrine of population management looks like: a grammar of suspicion, biometric sorting, shooting at unarmed protesters and bystanders, religious targeting, family harassment, and family-as-hostage detention, normalised over a decade of violence against Muslims, Kashmiris, Dalits, Adivasis, Sikhs, leftists, the working class and poor.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5fd8338f-b98c-4980-b848-c798c6de3b65/photo+RAF+firing+Reuters+image+2026-07-20T153359Z_1540971303_RC2MHMAZH0CC_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-GEN-Z.JPG" data-image-dimensions="5475x3650" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5fd8338f-b98c-4980-b848-c798c6de3b65/photo+RAF+firing+Reuters+image+2026-07-20T153359Z_1540971303_RC2MHMAZH0CC_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-GEN-Z.JPG?format=1000w" width="5475" height="3650" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5fd8338f-b98c-4980-b848-c798c6de3b65/photo+RAF+firing+Reuters+image+2026-07-20T153359Z_1540971303_RC2MHMAZH0CC_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-GEN-Z.JPG?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5fd8338f-b98c-4980-b848-c798c6de3b65/photo+RAF+firing+Reuters+image+2026-07-20T153359Z_1540971303_RC2MHMAZH0CC_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-GEN-Z.JPG?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5fd8338f-b98c-4980-b848-c798c6de3b65/photo+RAF+firing+Reuters+image+2026-07-20T153359Z_1540971303_RC2MHMAZH0CC_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-GEN-Z.JPG?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5fd8338f-b98c-4980-b848-c798c6de3b65/photo+RAF+firing+Reuters+image+2026-07-20T153359Z_1540971303_RC2MHMAZH0CC_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-GEN-Z.JPG?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5fd8338f-b98c-4980-b848-c798c6de3b65/photo+RAF+firing+Reuters+image+2026-07-20T153359Z_1540971303_RC2MHMAZH0CC_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-GEN-Z.JPG?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5fd8338f-b98c-4980-b848-c798c6de3b65/photo+RAF+firing+Reuters+image+2026-07-20T153359Z_1540971303_RC2MHMAZH0CC_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-GEN-Z.JPG?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5fd8338f-b98c-4980-b848-c798c6de3b65/photo+RAF+firing+Reuters+image+2026-07-20T153359Z_1540971303_RC2MHMAZH0CC_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-GEN-Z.JPG?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A member of the Rapid Action Force (RAF) fires tear gas towards protesters in New Delhi, India, 20 July, 2026. Image: REUTERS/Anushree Fadnavis TPX</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A member of the Rapid Action Force (RAF) fires tear gas towards protesters in New Delhi, India, 20 July, 2026. Image: REUTERS/Anushree Fadnavis TPX</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Gender was a central dimension of both the repression and the public response to the student protests. Women reported that police officers or members of far-right Hindutva mobs struck, verbally abused, groped or molested them, while videos and testimonies described torn clothing during the police crackdown. Such violence carries significance beyond crowd control, as the humiliation or displacement of women’s clothing invokes patriarchal ideas of honour and respectability that can discourage future political participation. The government’s response also revealed the gendered policing of dissent. Modi’s criticism of women and girl protesters for using “abusive language,” coupled with his unsolicited paternalistic forgiveness of them in <a href="https://www.pmindia.gov.in/en/news_updates/pm-urges-people-to-guide-the-misguided-says-abuses-never-solve-anything/">an awkward Instagram reel</a>, reflected a gendered expectation that “respectable” women and girls remain polite and deferential, even as male anger, profanity, and violence are more readily accepted. Following the protests, many women have reported facing doxing, rape threats, and online BJP IT cell harassment, as well as police harassment of their families. This is intended to humiliate them nationally and intimidate them into withdrawing from public life. Yet, in openly expressing rage, women and gender non-conforming folks challenged both political authority and patriarchal gender norms, exposing the BJP’s hypocrisy of policing women’s speech while repeatedly defending and protecting men convicted of rape, such as the rapists of <a href="https://www.scobserver.in/cases/early-release-of-bilkis-bano-gangrape-convicts/">Bilkis Bano in the Gujarat massacre</a>. The godi media turned its coverage towards character assassinations of student protesters, especially women and girls, the most notorious was the case of <a href="https://frontline.thehindu.com/politics/ruchika-singh-bulli-bai/article71309148.ece">Ruchika Singh, a 15-year-old girl</a> who mocked Modi in an online video and was coerced to apologise and forced to flee her home. Modi, Hindutva mobs, and the godi media are making an example out of her, to show the country that ridiculing the Prime Minister is closer to sedition than protected political speech.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Built With Israel: The Counter-Insurgency Doctrine Behind Police Crackdowns&nbsp;</h4>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span> Occupied Kashmir has been the laboratory: biometric monitoring, facial recognition, internet shutdowns, arrests, disappearances and extra-judicial killings, heavily armed crowd control, all of it justified in the language of “counter-terrorism” and “national security.” <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The security doctrine that met the student protesters has a face, and this summer it was put on camera again, as it was in <a href="https://www.versobooks.com/en-ca/blogs/news/colonizing-kashmir-interview-with-hafsa-kanjwal?srsltid=AfmBOoqSNYXb6kVp9L9TvmF49DyYFmm33R3J9SeYjQ9OT38-dcPHr61t">Kashmir</a> in 2019 after the <a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/ep-8-a-year-of-siege-in-kashmir-military/id1521349067?i=1000489230048">abrogation of Article 370 and 35A</a>, and during <a href="https://www.routledge.com/A-Peoples-History-of-the-Farmers-Movement-2020-2021/Singh-Siddiqui/p/book/9781032803937">the farmers’ protests of 2020–21</a>. The extreme state violence and crackdown on student protestors across the country this summer was not freelance brutality by officers improvising under pressure. It was produced by a decade of training exchanges, cybersecurity MOUs, and homeland security seminars. A police force has been retrained to read a protest not as people with grievances exercising their democratic right but as a threat to be sorted, tracked, neutralised and criminalised.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The doctrine decides in advance what kind of thing a crowd is, once that decision has been made in Israeli classrooms and Delhi seminar rooms, the baton and the bullet only enforce it. <a href="https://uwapress.uw.edu/book/9780295744988/resisting-disappearance/">Occupied Kashmir</a> has been the laboratory: biometric monitoring, facial recognition, internet shutdowns, arrests, disappearances and extra-judicial killings, heavily armed crowd control, all of it justified in the language of “counter-terrorism” and “national security.” What was developed through the oppression and control of Palestinians and adapted through India’s militarised occupation of Kashmir, has returned to Delhi, Mumbai, Patna and, above all, Manipur as “ordinary policing.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">India’s diplomatic ties with the Israeli settler-colonial apartheid state opened in 1992, with covert defence purchases going back further, but the relationship changed character after 2014 when the BJP came to power. In 2015, 150 Indian Police Service <a href="https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/defence/ips-officers-visit-israel-to-learn-best-policing-practices/articleshow/48541981.cms?utm">(IPS) officers visited the Israel National Police Academy</a> to study counter-insurgency, low-intensity conflict and warfare, counter-terrorism, and policing technologies; IPS trainees have gone every year since. Trainees observed Israel’s Border Police and airport-security operations, while SIBAT, the Israeli Defence Ministry’s international defence-cooperation arm, introduced them to Israeli homeland-security companies and the use of technology in “live situations.”&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>India became the world’s largest buyer of Israeli arms, spending upward of a billion dollars annually. Increasingly, those weapons were also made on Indian soil, as the 2022 India–Israel Vision on Defence Cooperation paired Israeli military technology with Modi’s push for domestic manufacturing under the  “Make in India” initiative.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Modi’s 2017 visit to Israel, the first by a sitting Indian prime minister, marked a decisive deepening of the India–Israel alliance, producing roughly $2 billion in Israeli defence and intelligence purchases, a cybersecurity agreement, and, according to a <em>New York Times</em> <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/28/magazine/nso-group-israel-spyware.html">investigation</a>, India’s acquisition of Israel’s Pegasus spyware, later used against Indian journalists, academics, activists, and opposition leaders. What began as police training soon became institutionalised: by 2018, an <a href="https://www.pib.gov.in/Pressreleaseshare.aspx?PRID=1522060">India–Israel Joint Steering Committee</a> on Homeland and Public Security formally committed the two states to sustained cooperation in police “capacity building and modernization” and border management. Israeli security expertise was thus entering India not simply through weapons purchases, but through the training, technologies and institutional practices of the police themselves.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">India became the world’s largest buyer of Israeli arms, spending upward of a billion dollars annually. Increasingly, those weapons were also made on Indian soil, as the 2022 India–Israel Vision on Defence Cooperation paired Israeli military technology with Modi’s push for domestic manufacturing under the&nbsp; <a href="https://www.pib.gov.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=109953&amp;utm">“Make in India”</a> initiative. Adani Enterprises and Elbit Systems established a joint venture in 2018 to manufacture the <a href="https://www.adaniwatch.org/the_adani_group_weapons_and_israel">Hermes 900 drone</a> for the Israeli military, the only production line outside Israel, while Bengaluru’s Alpha Design Technologies and Elbit produced SkyStriker loitering munitions for the Indian Army. By 2024, Israeli arms companies including ELTA, Rafael, Elbit, and Skylock were using a <a href="https://mod.gov.il/en/press-releases/press-room/innovative-israeli-indian-collaboration-in-counter-drone-seminar?utm">standing forum in Delhi</a> to develop further defence and dual-use partnerships. But as Azad Essa argues in <a href="https://www.plutobooks.com/product/hostile-homelands/"><em>Hostile Homelands</em></a>, this convergence is ideological as well as material. RSS ideologues drawing on Savarkar and Golwalkar had long admired Zionism as a model of ethno-religious nationhood. Under Modi, a lifelong RSS member, that affinity increasingly shaped state policy, from <a href="https://www.deccanherald.com/india/uttar-pradesh/cm-yogi-adityanath-directs-police-to-act-against-pro-palestine-statements-posts-on-social-media-2725964">suppressing</a> domestic criticism of Israel’s genocide in Gaza to attempts at withholding support from UN resolutions calling for its end.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Modi’s most recent 2026 visit to Israel, two days before the illegal US-Israeli war on Iran, crystallised this transformation at a moment of full-scale regional war in West Asia. Addressing the Knesset, the first Indian leader to do so, <a href="https://israeldailynews.org/full-transcript-of-indian-pm-modis-speech-to-knesset/">Modi told the chamber</a> that Indian-origin Jews in Israel hold that “Israel is their fatherland and India their motherland,” that he was born on the day India recognised Israel, and that India stood with Israel with full conviction. He was awarded a medal for strengthening the alliance and embraced Netanyahu, who remains subject to an International Criminal Court arrest warrant. The material consequences of this alliance became still clearer in July 2026, when Amnesty International’s <a href="https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/asa20/1327/2026/en/"><em>Made in India: The Supply of Weapons and Ammunition to Israel</em></a> documented 2,596 shipments of arms, ammunition, and military components from Indian companies to Israel between October 2023 and November 2025, including artillery-shell casings and components for SkyStriker drones. Against the backdrop of the International Court of Justice’s <a href="https://www.icj-cij.org/node/204091?utm">provisional measures</a> in the genocide case, India could hardly claim ignorance of how these supplies might be used.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5c6b0f3a-86ad-4db3-aa50-798c7b085aa3/policing_india-Israel.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1600x1066" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5c6b0f3a-86ad-4db3-aa50-798c7b085aa3/policing_india-Israel.jpeg?format=1000w" width="1600" height="1066" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5c6b0f3a-86ad-4db3-aa50-798c7b085aa3/policing_india-Israel.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5c6b0f3a-86ad-4db3-aa50-798c7b085aa3/policing_india-Israel.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5c6b0f3a-86ad-4db3-aa50-798c7b085aa3/policing_india-Israel.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5c6b0f3a-86ad-4db3-aa50-798c7b085aa3/policing_india-Israel.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5c6b0f3a-86ad-4db3-aa50-798c7b085aa3/policing_india-Israel.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5c6b0f3a-86ad-4db3-aa50-798c7b085aa3/policing_india-Israel.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5c6b0f3a-86ad-4db3-aa50-798c7b085aa3/policing_india-Israel.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Indian police cadets at the National Police Academy in Israel (Beit Shemesh), August 1st, 2018. Image: Israeli Ministry of National Security</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Indian police cadets at the National Police Academy in Israel (Beit Shemesh), August 1st, 2018. Image: Israeli Ministry of National Security</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">For India’s left and people of conscience at home and across the diaspora, this marked the culmination of a reversal decades in the making: from a global leader of non-alignment and supporter of Palestine and the Palestinian Liberation Organization, to a government supplying the Israeli war machine, integrating Israeli surveillance and security practices at home, and aligning itself ever more closely with Israel and Washington in ways an earlier generation would not have imagined. Yet it was against this architecture of repression and alignment that the students won their immediate concessions.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Reformist Victories, Making Revolution Imaginable&nbsp;</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The Cockroach movement’s immediate gains were reformist: the education minister’s resignation, <a href="https://www.reuters.com/world/india/indian-federal-police-file-charges-against-13-over-exam-paper-leaks-2026-07-30/">a signed agreement with the government</a> on compensation for the families of students who died by <a href="https://www.outlookindia.com/national/13-reported-suicides-after-neet-paper-leak">suicide</a>, a parliamentary commitment to reform the examination system, and assurances that protesters would not face police arrests and detention. These were the terms on which students suspended their hunger strike and called off their mass protest. But the movement never declared the struggle finished. If the protest’s achievements were liberal in form, its political significance was far larger. It exposed fractures in the BJP’s claim to unquestioned authority, it disrupted the ideological confidence of Hindutva and exposed its inner fascist workings to the country, ruptured over a decade of fear and censorship, revealed the failure of neoliberal capitalism, and sparked the emergence of a generation willing to confront the state through many forms. The threat to the regime posed by this generation was perhaps evident in Modi’s 2026 Independence Day address, he branded youth <a href="https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/armed-naxals-gone-but-ideological-naxals-seek-opportunities-pm-modi-urges-identify-isolate/videoshow/133258813.cms">protesters “dimagi Naxals”</a> (“intellectual Naxals”), invoking the language of Maoist insurgency to recast political dissent as an “internal security threat” to be dealt with.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The protests radicalised and awakened millions of young people and have instilled a sense of hope for another India, and protests continue across the country in the present. People have called for the resignation of BJP Home Minister Amit Shah (responsible for the police, RAF, and their brutality) and Modi himself, captured powerfully in the chant “Desh bachao, Modi Hatao” (Save the Country, Get Rid of Modi). The protests also ruptured the borders meant to divide them, as Pakistani students sent moving messages of solidarity to India’s students, one blogger specifically identifying them as the “children of divorce,” referring to the subcontinent’s Partition. Student movements in Bangladesh and Sri Lanka have also asked what they can do in solidarity with the left student unions who are committed to advancing the struggle further.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The protests also confirmed what the two circulations traced throughout this essay had always implied: internationalism is never politically neutral. Each gives rise to a distinct political world, one producing a generation capable of creative collective resistance, imagining revolution, and cultivating hope (despite internal contradictions); the other produces institutions capable of administering immense state violence and human rights violations.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Revolutions rarely arrive fully formed, they begin by making the existing order appear vulnerable. In that sense, the student uprisings may be remembered not as the revolution itself, but as the moment one became imaginable. The surveillance cameras on the mast are still running, compiling a database for whom the state will target in the days to come. <em>Hum Dekhenge</em> records something else, written in the future tense, it promises that there is still more to be seen: the world it anticipates has not yet arrived, and students continue to organise and struggle for a different future. They are remaking and ushering in a new world in these fascist times.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">To them: Inquilab Zindabad!</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Chandni Desai </em></strong><em>is an Assistant Professor at the University of Toronto. She&nbsp;is working on a book tentatively titled Revolutionary Circuits: Cadres, Culture, Internationalism and the Palestinian Revolution.&nbsp;</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d815e8a5-7180-48ac-b347-6492521abee6/photo+1+tear+gas+jantar+mantar+protests+2026-07-22T190145Z_475862421_RC22JMAGPE95_RTRMADP_3_INDIA-POLITICS.JPG?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="1051"><media:title type="plain">Hum Dekhenge: Student Uprisings in the Age of Hindutva</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>The Pakistani Left’s Middle Class Crisis</title><category>Essay</category><dc:creator>Aisha Tahir and Khurram Ali</dc:creator><pubDate>Fri, 04 Sep 2026 12:00:07 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/the-pakistani-lefts-middle-class-crisis</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:6a7f68803d3a8d06286a069b</guid><description><![CDATA[A history and class critique of the left’s positions on the India-Pakistan 
war in May 2025.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A history and class critique of the left’s positions on the India-Pakistan war in May 2025.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1788460229622-IJ21TLGAIGBV0OZ574F0/23.png" data-image-dimensions="2560x1440" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1788460229622-IJ21TLGAIGBV0OZ574F0/23.png?format=1000w" width="2560" height="1440" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1788460229622-IJ21TLGAIGBV0OZ574F0/23.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1788460229622-IJ21TLGAIGBV0OZ574F0/23.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1788460229622-IJ21TLGAIGBV0OZ574F0/23.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1788460229622-IJ21TLGAIGBV0OZ574F0/23.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1788460229622-IJ21TLGAIGBV0OZ574F0/23.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1788460229622-IJ21TLGAIGBV0OZ574F0/23.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1788460229622-IJ21TLGAIGBV0OZ574F0/23.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Composite illustration using web-sourced images. Illustration: Jamhoor </em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Composite illustration using web-sourced images. Illustration: Jamhoor </em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In an <a href="https://www.jamhoor.org/read/how-the-recent-indo-pak-conflict-exposed-fault-lines-in-the-pakistani-left">article</a> published by <em>Jamhoor</em>, Muhammad Umar Ali and Dr. Syed Azeem exposed “deep ideological contradictions” in the Pakistani Left’s response to the brief India-Pakistan conflict in May 2025. They analyzed various positions of Leftist parties and criticized the stance of “unprincipled peace,” arguing that the primary contradiction should be Indian fascism and expansionism which presents a danger for the entire subcontinent. Therefore, the people of Pakistan should stand with the people of Nepal, Bangladesh and other countries of South Asia against Indian expansionism. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Here we offer a critique of this position. We also provide brief histories of the trajectories of some of the main left parties, paying special attention to how a middle-class political outlook has dominated left politics in Pakistan.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">On a theoretical level, Ali and Dr. Azeem make two broad generalizations.&nbsp;The first puts Haqooq-e-Khalq Party and Awami Workers Party (Asim Sajjad Akhtar) under a single category of the ‘New Left’ pursuing Gramscian thought. While it is true that both parties share the rejection of Leninist and Maoist models of the past and emerge mostly from academia, in reality, they take opposing positions. The second generalization brackets the current major parties of the Pakistani Left—the Awami Workers Party (Akhter Hussain), Mazdoor Kisan Party (Taimur Rahman), Communist Party of Pakistan, and Tabqati Jeddojehad—into the “traditional Left.” Each of these parties is a combination of different tendencies. Today, their legacies are indecipherable due to recurring splits and mergers amongst various fractions, which will be discussed later in this article. These generalizations assume a continuous historical journey of different tendencies and parties, but the reality is different.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">History and Continuity</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In the late 1960s and early 1970s, radical movements across the globe witnessed a resurgence inspired by Mao Tse Tung thought and the 1980s and 1990s marked its decline. China had changed its position towards supporting revolutionary movements around the world. The Soviet Union also declined under Khrushchev’s revisionist political legacy. The Pakistani left, dependent on these two countries for its ideological and practical framework, witnessed a corresponding decline. With no organizational structure to consolidate and provide leadership (unlike the Left in Peru, India and Philippines), parties began losing their political character. Reduced to drawing room clubs, they started to merge for a chance at survival.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>The lack of practice-driven theory limits Dr. Azeem and Ali’s ambitions to find continuity of Maoism to theoretical juggling. In the absence of any rectification campaigns in these parties, Dr. Azeem and Ali’s approach lacks concrete analysis.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Dr. Azeem and Ali dedicate a section on the evolution of the Maoist tendency fixated on the idea of “continuity and rupture.” There are several approaches to this concept, one used by Foucault and another by Althusser. Foucault's analysis is not dialectical. Althusser uses the concept to develop an “epistemic break” in Marx’s work, differentiating between Marx’s earlier and later works, rejecting the former. Dr. Azeem and Ali draw on J. Moufawad-Paul’s ideas instead. The latter blends different theorists to use continuity and rupture to study the development of Maoism. He understands Maoism as a continuity of Marxism-Leninism but also a rupture from its limitations. That is, when new problems emerge in struggle, the tendency does not completely break from the previous one. Rather, the tendency continues to build on some concepts while diverging from others to develop new concepts necessary for the evolution of struggle and further advancement of analysis.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Dr. Azeem and Ali follow this approach. While Moufawad-Paul draws his analysis from concrete practices of Maoists from China, Peru, India and others around the world, Dr. Azeem and Ali draw from a limited set of concrete practices. In terms of practice, there has been no development of Mao Tse Tung Thought in Pakistan towards Maoism. If anything, the trajectory of Maoist organizations—Mazdoor Kisan Party and National Students Federation—only indicates a shift towards modern revisionism and Dengism, which will be discussed in detail in the next section. The lack of practice-driven theory limits Dr. Azeem and Ali’s ambitions to find continuity of Maoism to theoretical juggling. In the absence of any rectification campaigns in these parties, Dr. Azeem and Ali’s approach lacks concrete analysis.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Pakistan Mazdoor Kisan Party</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The authors are currently members of the Pakistan Mazdoor Kisan Party which is a broken faction of the Mazdoor Kisan Party established just before Bangladesh’s independence from Pakistan. The other faction claiming Mazdoor Kisan Party’s legacy is Taimur Rehman’s party. There is also a significant group in the Awami Workers Party (Akhter Hussain) led by Hamza Virk, which is also influenced by Mazdoor Kisan Party (Major Ishaq), as the Communist Mazdoor Kisan Party merged with National Workers Party in 2009 to form Workers Party Pakistan and then Awami Workers Party.</p>


  









&nbsp;

























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/43c4d5bc-8c3b-40f8-a153-949c3eec2303/Chinese+cultural+poster.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1510x2196" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/43c4d5bc-8c3b-40f8-a153-949c3eec2303/Chinese+cultural+poster.jpg?format=1000w" width="1510" height="2196" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 66.67vw, 66.67vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/43c4d5bc-8c3b-40f8-a153-949c3eec2303/Chinese+cultural+poster.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/43c4d5bc-8c3b-40f8-a153-949c3eec2303/Chinese+cultural+poster.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/43c4d5bc-8c3b-40f8-a153-949c3eec2303/Chinese+cultural+poster.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/43c4d5bc-8c3b-40f8-a153-949c3eec2303/Chinese+cultural+poster.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/43c4d5bc-8c3b-40f8-a153-949c3eec2303/Chinese+cultural+poster.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/43c4d5bc-8c3b-40f8-a153-949c3eec2303/Chinese+cultural+poster.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/43c4d5bc-8c3b-40f8-a153-949c3eec2303/Chinese+cultural+poster.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A Chinese Cultural Revolution poster which says, "In the vast world, forge a red heart.” from 1968. </em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  

&nbsp;
  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>The authors correctly analyze the Hashtnagar Movement led by Mazdoor Kisan Party as one of the most important peasant movements in Pakistan. Yet, they do not closely analyze why the movement failed to become a powerful force like the Naxal movement which challenged the whole system.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The authors argue that the Mazdoor Kisan Party, under the leadership of its founder and central ideologue Major Ishaq, was on the path to reach Maoism. But this is not what the party’s history suggests. Its steady decline and fractures experienced since 1979 are reflective of its revisionist trend and Punjab-centric politics. Despite initiating a merger with another Mao Tse Tung Thought group, the People’s Democratic Front, which was a mass front of National Students Federation, the merger failed to materialize, according to Hasan Alia, former President of National Students Federation (Rasheed Group). Mazdoor Kisan Party insisted that Nawaz Sharif was a national-capitalist, implying that the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz was an ally against imperialism. Mazdoor Kisan Party then merged with the Communist Party of Pakistan, the main pro-Soviet party, to form Communist Mazdoor Kisan Party, compromising their position on the USSR. As a result, Mazdoor Kisan Party submitted to the Communist Party of Pakistan’s political position that the Maoist tendency was incorrect in terming USSR a social imperialist power. Lastly, the Mazdoor Kisan Party has not produced a single document that criticizes Deng Xiaoping's policies.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d8a5b0df-5b14-49c6-bc67-ec7b7b3e3d91/606915fceb2ce.jpg" data-image-dimensions="269x300" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d8a5b0df-5b14-49c6-bc67-ec7b7b3e3d91/606915fceb2ce.jpg?format=1000w" width="269" height="300" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d8a5b0df-5b14-49c6-bc67-ec7b7b3e3d91/606915fceb2ce.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d8a5b0df-5b14-49c6-bc67-ec7b7b3e3d91/606915fceb2ce.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d8a5b0df-5b14-49c6-bc67-ec7b7b3e3d91/606915fceb2ce.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d8a5b0df-5b14-49c6-bc67-ec7b7b3e3d91/606915fceb2ce.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d8a5b0df-5b14-49c6-bc67-ec7b7b3e3d91/606915fceb2ce.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d8a5b0df-5b14-49c6-bc67-ec7b7b3e3d91/606915fceb2ce.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d8a5b0df-5b14-49c6-bc67-ec7b7b3e3d91/606915fceb2ce.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A rare photograph of Major Ishaq, founder of the Mazdoor Kisan Party. Image: Communist Mazdoor Kissan Party Pakistan, X</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1788532614336_14280">The authors correctly analyze the Hashtnagar Movement led by Mazdoor Kisan Party as one of the most important peasant movements in Pakistan. Yet, they do not closely analyze why the movement failed to become a powerful force like the Naxal movement which posed a challenge to the whole system. Furthermore, despite the huge success in Hashtnagar, Mazdoor Kisan Party failed to grow in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa as it did in Punjab to the point that it is now considered a Punjab-centric party within the Left, with no significant units and leaders outside Punjab, except the legacy of Hashtnagar. A more pertinent question is why the founding members of the party who led the Hashtnagar struggle ended up separating from Major Ishaq, eventually pursuing the politics of oppressed nationalities. Afzal Bangash formed Awami National Party with Wali Khan and Sher Ali Bacha formed Pakhtunkhwa Milli Awami Party with Mahmood Khan Achakzai. The lack of self-criticism of their party leads the authors to adopt two premises of Mazdoor Kisan Party (Ishaq) that result in incorrect conclusions.&nbsp;</p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br>Haqooq e Khalq Party</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Haqooq e Khalq party’s leadership was initially primarily associated with the Trotskyist tendency within the Labour Party with the exception of some members who came from other tendencies. The leadership formed Awami Workers Party by merging with various leftist groups of different ideological orientations. Within 6 years, some of the leadership split from Awami Workers Party and abandoned party politics, under the influence of prefigurative thought, to concentrate on non-hierarchical movements while also being actively involved with national movements, particularly the Pashtun Tahaffuz Movement. They formed the Haqooq e Khalq Movement.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d77afcb5-4698-463e-b23a-3fc99f30cf45/Chungi_HKM.jpg" data-image-dimensions="701x686" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d77afcb5-4698-463e-b23a-3fc99f30cf45/Chungi_HKM.jpg?format=1000w" width="701" height="686" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d77afcb5-4698-463e-b23a-3fc99f30cf45/Chungi_HKM.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d77afcb5-4698-463e-b23a-3fc99f30cf45/Chungi_HKM.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d77afcb5-4698-463e-b23a-3fc99f30cf45/Chungi_HKM.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d77afcb5-4698-463e-b23a-3fc99f30cf45/Chungi_HKM.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d77afcb5-4698-463e-b23a-3fc99f30cf45/Chungi_HKM.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d77afcb5-4698-463e-b23a-3fc99f30cf45/Chungi_HKM.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d77afcb5-4698-463e-b23a-3fc99f30cf45/Chungi_HKM.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A large group of women at a Haqooq e Khalq meeting in Chungi, Lahore. Image: Geo.tv</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A large group of women at a Haqooq e Khalq meeting in Chungi, Lahore. Image: Geo.tv</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Their turn to non-hierarchical movements and national movements was short-lived. They shifted towards constituency politics, particularly in the working class neighbourhood of Chungi in Lahore. The Haqooq e Khalq Movement was converted to a structured party, the Haqooq e Khalq Party. After experiencing an electoral defeat in 2024, their leader, Ammar Ali Jan reflected that they failed because the election became a referendum on Imran Khan such that the electorate voted on a national debate (which their party was not a part of) instead of local issues. They turned towards building a mainstream narrative of left within the masses through the media. They also moved towards traditional pro-Soviet politics inspired by Domenico Losurdo. At the 2025 Marxism Political School at the Irtiqa Institute in Karachi, Jan’s lecture defended Stalin and the current Chinese model with a hint of criticism of identity politics and the New Left school.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>The party’s prioritisation of social media can be seen to appeal to this class. In recent times, the same class, especially Gen Z, has reinvigorated anti-colonial and anti-imperial ideas because of the Palestine solidarity movement. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In the span of ten years, the incredible shifts in their political framework reflect an opportunism which emerges from an incoherent understanding of class and national composition. Today, their non-linear journey, from the Labour Party to the effort to create mainstream parties in alliance with Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto Junior or with Moshin Dawar fits within this pattern. Although Farooq Tariq and certain members of their group have remained consistently involved with the power-loom workers’ movement, bonded labour and the Okara peasant movement (using NGO funding), the party’s class composition and following are primarily based in the urban, upper middle class of central Punjab and to a much smaller extent from other urban centers.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><a href="https://philippinerevolution.nu/1998-2005/cpp/docs/rect/recte04a.htm">Historically</a>, the middle class is known for looking for short-cuts and quick successes, changing its ideology and politics and lending itself to political opportunism and careerism.&nbsp;If an organization fails to achieve celebrated wins in five years, they join another emerging movement. Social media activists also usually belong to this class. Another important facet of this class is that many of them are either settled or visiting western countries for economic or educational opportunities. This distance can create a patriotic imagination of the homeland whose national, racial and religious identity is under attack in the imperialist world. The party’s prioritisation of social media can be seen to appeal to this class. In recent times, the same class, especially Gen Z, has reinvigorated anti-colonial and anti-imperial ideas because of the Palestine solidarity movement. The brutality employed by Israel, on the one hand, helped them realize why imperialism is the principal contradiction in today’s world, but on the other hand, it resulted in feelings of powerlessness watching the genocide of the people of Gaza on a daily basis on their cell phones.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Amidst this, academics like Vijay Prashad, revisionist left parties like the Communist Party of India (Marxist) and social media platforms like Breakthrough News portray China as an anti-colonial socialist country, catering to the upper middle class’ new interest in China. Haqooq e Khalq Party’s political analysis of the India-Pakistan conflict through the lens of geopolitical competition between the US and China appeals to this section of the middle class, which is the party’s class base. Haqooq e Khalq Party provides a perfect thesis for them: US imperialism is supporting India to become an Israel-like state in the region, bullying all the neighbouring countries, including Pakistan, so that it can challenge China in the region.</p>


  









&nbsp;

























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/29c70a6d-90a2-4b8c-8af4-5f71a1ed67b2/IMG_9471.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1170x1160" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/29c70a6d-90a2-4b8c-8af4-5f71a1ed67b2/IMG_9471.jpg?format=1000w" width="1170" height="1160" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 66.67vw, 66.67vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/29c70a6d-90a2-4b8c-8af4-5f71a1ed67b2/IMG_9471.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/29c70a6d-90a2-4b8c-8af4-5f71a1ed67b2/IMG_9471.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/29c70a6d-90a2-4b8c-8af4-5f71a1ed67b2/IMG_9471.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/29c70a6d-90a2-4b8c-8af4-5f71a1ed67b2/IMG_9471.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/29c70a6d-90a2-4b8c-8af4-5f71a1ed67b2/IMG_9471.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/29c70a6d-90a2-4b8c-8af4-5f71a1ed67b2/IMG_9471.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/29c70a6d-90a2-4b8c-8af4-5f71a1ed67b2/IMG_9471.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto at a Haqooq e Khalq’s Khalq Youth Front’s protest for Palestine, August, 2025 in Karachi. Image: </em><a href="https://www.instagram.com/haqooq_e_khalqparty/?hl=en"><em>Haqooq e Khalq Party</em></a></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto at a Haqooq e Khalq’s Khalq Youth Front’s protest for Palestine, August, 2025 in Karachi. Image: </em><a href="https://www.instagram.com/haqooq_e_khalqparty/?hl=en"><em>Haqooq e Khalq Party</em></a></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  

&nbsp;
  
  <h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Awami Workers Party (Aasim Sajjad Akhtar)</h4>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>Their predicament is that if the middle-class students of the peripheries force them to take national questions seriously, the urban upper-middle class limits the party from completely negating Pakistani identity. As such, they can neither completely ignore the national question within Pakistan nor take a radical line. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Awami Workers Party (Asim Sajjad Akhtar) includes different sections of the middle class from various regions: students and youth who belong to middle and lower sections of the middle class from Pakistan’s peripheries of Sindh, Balochistan, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, Gilgit Baltistan and Kashmir. It also includes professors, researchers, and development sector professionals from the urban upper middle class. They are not a homogeneous group as there are important leaders from a pro-Soviet tendency like Zahoor Sahab, Farman Sahab and Bakhshal Thallo, who also influence the party line. The Awami Workers Party and in particular Akhtar’s insight that industrial workers and peasants are not the primary classes for a revolution anymore comes from the conditions of the urban cities where the party has gained strength.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Aside from universities, Aasim has remained active in the <em>katchi abaadis</em> (informal settlements) of Islamabad with primarily urban semi-proletariat and lumpen classes. But even their role in the party was often subservient to the upper middle class, as evident by the 2018 elections contested by party, where Ammar Rashid and Ismat Shahjahan got the party tickets while their supporter base was comprised of residents of <em>katchi abadis</em>. Similarly, their second area of interest is Hyderabad and other smaller cities of Sindh, where they primarily concentrate on students, mostly coming from the middle and upper peasantry who are relatively better off than landless peasants and rural workers. Their contradiction with feudalism is not as sharp as that of the latter classes. They are primarily against corporate projects with some incorporation of nationalist and identity politics.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This party has struggled over the question of how to develop a politics which combines these tendencies: the pro-Soviet left, urban upper middle class, middle and lower sections of the rural middle class, the urban semi-proletariat and lumpen classes. Still, the party leadership has a strong urge to develop a middle class party, as evident from their consideration of a merger with Haqooq e Khalq Party despite disagreements on almost every political question.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Their predicament is that if the middle class students of the peripheries force them to take national questions seriously, the urban upper middle class limits the party from completely negating Pakistani identity. As such, they can neither completely ignore the national question within Pakistan nor take a radical line. Interestingly, the middle section of the middle class of the peripheries is usually also stuck between feelings resonating with the national oppression of their regions and job opportunities available in urban centers. This compels them to take a stance of a loose federation with more power to the national units and the concept of a decentralized party.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This political framework and arrangement is similar to the National Awami Party of the pro-Soviet left which disintegrated in the 1970s. The National Awami Party also acted as an umbrella under which both moderate nationalists, middle classes and socialists worked together under the pro-Soviet line, but was unable to provide anything meaningful to national struggles. Similarly, this political framework allows the domination of middle forces — a small national capitalist class, professionals, academics, and other middle class elements — over the formation of alliances, as was the case with the National Awami Party. Hence the Awami Workers Party’s (Aasim Sajjad Akhtar) over-emphasis on identity politics and climate issues. This Gramscian interpretation and framing includes all identities instead of taking class as the central subject, making the model acceptable for the urban upper middle class, particularly professors and researchers concerned with academic theories and research papers.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Although Ayyaz Malick usually has independent positions from the Awami Workers Party (Aasim Sajjad Akhtar) and class takes a central position in his analysis, Dr. Azeem and Ali accurately consider his recent article on the India-Pakistan conflict as Awami Workers Party’s line. Mallick’s criticism of the Haqooq e Khalq Party’s position and his analysis of the conflict and its relation to the national question in Pakistan was precise and informed more by a Maoist position than a Gramscian one. However, Awami Workers Party’s (Aasim Sajjad Akhtar), including Ayyaz, fall short due to their skepticism about the success of any national liberation movement or radical militant leftist struggle in Pakistan. Similarly, they do criticize the role of China in Balochistan but hesitate in declaring it a <a href="https://www.bannedthought.net/India/CPI-Maoist-Docs/Books/China-Social-Imperialism-CPI-Maoist-2021-Eng-view.pdf"><u>social imperialist</u></a> country or even an exploitative power. Both these middle positions are reflective of the different middle classes they interact with, and the groups their politics depend on.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Gramsci’s concept of the historical bloc on which the Latin American countries built the concept of “pluri-national” becomes important for them. Pluri-nationalism means a political and legal framework to pacify the contradictions of various nations in a single country through autonomy and self-determination. Awami Workers Party’s Aasim Sajjad Akhtar and Dr. Ayyaz Mallick use the concept to justify their balance between two positions–– nationalism vs. liberation of oppressed nationalities. Pluri-national is an academic name for the politics of the National Awami Party. Similarly, their emphasis on democratic politics instead of a more radical one and their lack of recognition of the semi-feudal nature of the state reflects the approach of various urban and rural middle-class career-oriented sections within their party. In result, certain interpretations of Gramsci provide convenience to build political unity across differences.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/981371dd-35da-4d62-b24d-897a8ff5a9ee/Alia.jpg" data-image-dimensions="800x480" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/981371dd-35da-4d62-b24d-897a8ff5a9ee/Alia.jpg?format=1000w" width="800" height="480" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/981371dd-35da-4d62-b24d-897a8ff5a9ee/Alia.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/981371dd-35da-4d62-b24d-897a8ff5a9ee/Alia.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/981371dd-35da-4d62-b24d-897a8ff5a9ee/Alia.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/981371dd-35da-4d62-b24d-897a8ff5a9ee/Alia.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/981371dd-35da-4d62-b24d-897a8ff5a9ee/Alia.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/981371dd-35da-4d62-b24d-897a8ff5a9ee/Alia.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/981371dd-35da-4d62-b24d-897a8ff5a9ee/Alia.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Alia Amirali, leader of the Awami Workers Party (AWP), speaking to katchi abaadi residents protesting evictions in Islamabad in 2026. Image: Hum English. </em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Alia Amirali, leader of the Awami Workers Party (AWP), speaking to katchi abaadi residents protesting evictions in Islamabad in 2026. Image: Hum English. </em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Awami Workers Party (Akhter Hussain)</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Awami Workers Party (Akhter Hussain) can neither be framed as Gramscian nor as the Traditional Left. Although it can be argued that many of its members emerged from pro-Soviet parties such as the Pakistan Socialist Party and the Communist League, a deeper analysis shows that those coming from the Socialist Party had long dissociated from their Marxist-Leninist past. Instead, they became more involved in democratic struggles and constitutional rights for peasants and workers. At the same time, they emphasized that the party was not only one of the <em>mehnatkash</em> (working class) but also of the <em>mehnatkaar </em>(professional classes), a position reflected in its leadership remaining in the hands of the upper-middle class.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The dominance of the upper-middle class and upper peasantry has historically remained strong within this group and predates the Awami Workers Party’s formation in 2012 and the formation of the Pakistan Socialist Party, when the group was still part of the pro-Peking Bhashani section of the National Awami Party. During the 1960s, strong Kisan committees existed in both wings of Pakistan and were associated with the National Awami Party. Around the time of the famous Toba Tek Singh conference of Maulana Bhashani, the Punjab Kisan Committee split between the Major Ishaq and Chaudhry Fateh Mohammad groups, a split that eventually led the former to convert their committees into the Mazdoor Kisan Party. The Major Ishaq group raised two key allegations: first, that landed classes were representing the Kisan committees; and second, that this class composition explained the deradicalization of the peasant movement. A close study of this group’s journey toward the Awami Workers Party suggests that both allegations had considerable merit.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f1976cf1-cf8f-4dd0-beee-f3e22366ae7b/craslam-and-fatch-mohammad-1968-1.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1018x774" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f1976cf1-cf8f-4dd0-beee-f3e22366ae7b/craslam-and-fatch-mohammad-1968-1.jpg?format=1000w" width="1018" height="774" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f1976cf1-cf8f-4dd0-beee-f3e22366ae7b/craslam-and-fatch-mohammad-1968-1.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f1976cf1-cf8f-4dd0-beee-f3e22366ae7b/craslam-and-fatch-mohammad-1968-1.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f1976cf1-cf8f-4dd0-beee-f3e22366ae7b/craslam-and-fatch-mohammad-1968-1.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f1976cf1-cf8f-4dd0-beee-f3e22366ae7b/craslam-and-fatch-mohammad-1968-1.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f1976cf1-cf8f-4dd0-beee-f3e22366ae7b/craslam-and-fatch-mohammad-1968-1.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f1976cf1-cf8f-4dd0-beee-f3e22366ae7b/craslam-and-fatch-mohammad-1968-1.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f1976cf1-cf8f-4dd0-beee-f3e22366ae7b/craslam-and-fatch-mohammad-1968-1.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Chaudhry Fateh Mohammad addressing National Awami Party (NAP) meeting in Faisalabad in 1968. Image: </em><a href="https://fatehm.com/"><em>Fatehm.com</em></a></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1788533209129_16605">The politics of this group continued to be deradicalized over time, shifting from affiliation with Bhashani’s pro-Peking “jalao ghirao” (siege and burn) politics to Khrushchev’s line of revolution through democratic means, and after 1989, toward parliamentary democracy, human rights, and social justice, replacing any notion of revolution. Subsequently, the group actively pursued a social-democratic approach by aligning with broad democratic and liberal forces. Even today, while the party’s practice remains social-democratic, it has begun identifying itself as Marxist-Leninist due to strong reactions from the lower strata of the party and the growing importance of remnants of the Mazdoor Kisan Party and National Students Federation within the Awami Workers Party (Akhter Hussain).</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This section, consisting largely of former Mazdoor Kisan Party and National Students Federation members, follows a Dengist line and holds significant expectations from Xi Jinping. The majority of this group comes from middle-class backgrounds in Punjab and Karachi and harbors strong patriotic sentiments along with hostility toward national movements. There is also a populist section within the party comprising the Gujar community from Buner, who joined under Fanoos Gujar after he left mainstream parties due to caste-based discrimination against lower-caste Gujars. While this group had the potential to be radicalized, the party made no such effort. Instead, they were reduced to passive followers, with representation limited to the inclusion of Fanoos Gujar’s nephew, Usman Gujar, in the central committee. Overall, the party’s class and national base primarily consists of retired sections of the middle class from Punjab and Karachi.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Awami Workers Party (Akhter Hussain) is limited in its efforts to understand Pakistani society or develop a concrete political strategy. Following sour experiences with the New Left and nationalist factions within (the larger, pre-split) Awami Workers Party as well as the Women’s Democratic Front, it has turned Marxism-Leninism into a dogma, interpreted through its own revisionist framework. While the dominant section had long degenerated toward social democracy, the rise of China as a global power has prompted a renewed ideological shift in that direction.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c5294ccc-d933-47a5-b0bf-57c2f8549589/bee730e9-ec47-40ed-b49e-518dd4f71e5d.png" data-image-dimensions="960x640" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c5294ccc-d933-47a5-b0bf-57c2f8549589/bee730e9-ec47-40ed-b49e-518dd4f71e5d.png?format=1000w" width="960" height="640" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c5294ccc-d933-47a5-b0bf-57c2f8549589/bee730e9-ec47-40ed-b49e-518dd4f71e5d.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c5294ccc-d933-47a5-b0bf-57c2f8549589/bee730e9-ec47-40ed-b49e-518dd4f71e5d.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c5294ccc-d933-47a5-b0bf-57c2f8549589/bee730e9-ec47-40ed-b49e-518dd4f71e5d.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c5294ccc-d933-47a5-b0bf-57c2f8549589/bee730e9-ec47-40ed-b49e-518dd4f71e5d.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c5294ccc-d933-47a5-b0bf-57c2f8549589/bee730e9-ec47-40ed-b49e-518dd4f71e5d.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c5294ccc-d933-47a5-b0bf-57c2f8549589/bee730e9-ec47-40ed-b49e-518dd4f71e5d.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c5294ccc-d933-47a5-b0bf-57c2f8549589/bee730e9-ec47-40ed-b49e-518dd4f71e5d.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A rally organized by AWP in Islamabad’s katchi abaadi. Image: </em><a class="x1i10hfl xjbqb8w x1ejq31n x18oe1m7 x1sy0etr xstzfhl x972fbf x10w94by x1qhh985 x14e42zd x9f619 x1ypdohk xt0psk2 x3ct3a4 xdj266r x14z9mp xat24cr x1lziwak xexx8yu xyri2b x18d9i69 x1c1uobl x16tdsg8 x1hl2dhg xggy1nq x1a2a7pz xkrqix3 x1sur9pj xzsf02u x1s688f" href="https://www.facebook.com/AllianceforKachiAbadis?__tn__=-UC*F"><em>All Pakistan Alliance for Kachi Abadis</em></a></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A rally organized by AWP in Islamabad’s katchi abaadi. Image: </em><a class="x1i10hfl xjbqb8w x1ejq31n x18oe1m7 x1sy0etr xstzfhl x972fbf x10w94by x1qhh985 x14e42zd x9f619 x1ypdohk xt0psk2 x3ct3a4 xdj266r x14z9mp xat24cr x1lziwak xexx8yu xyri2b x18d9i69 x1c1uobl x16tdsg8 x1hl2dhg xggy1nq x1a2a7pz xkrqix3 x1sur9pj xzsf02u x1s688f" href="https://www.facebook.com/AllianceforKachiAbadis?__tn__=-UC*F"><em>All Pakistan Alliance for Kachi Abadis</em></a></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1788495907402_13427">The recent split between the Awami Workers Party’s Dr. Asim Sajjad Akhtar group and Akhter Hussain group was closely linked to questions of identity politics, particularly the national question. While the Dr. Asim Sajjar Akhtar group argues that environmental and other identity-based issues are equally significant as class contradictions in the party line, the Akhter Hussain group maintains that these questions are not even worthy of analysis, including from a class perspective. The similarity between Akhter Hussain group’s position on the current Pakistan–India conflict and that of Mazdoor Kisan Party (Taimur Rahman) reflects their shared class base. This is evident in the Awami Workers Party and Mazdoor Kisan Party (Taimur Rahman)’s statements on how both states should refrain from acting as proxies for imperialist powers and should cease terrorist activities against each other—blaming Baloch and Kashmiri militant groups—without any acknowledgment of the national oppression faced by the people of Kashmir and Balochistan.<br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Pakistan Mazdoor Kisan Party</h4>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>This thesis further reflects the class and national composition of the Mazdoor Kisan Party: a party attempting to organize lower-caste bonded laborers and landless peasants in Punjab while being led by the rural middle peasantry and urban middle class of the same region. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Dr. Azeem and Ali also attempted to create a rupture from their own tendency and party but as discussed earlier, no concrete analysis was provided regarding why the Hashtnagar movement stalled. Similarly, there was no critique of why the Mazdoor Kisan Party transformed into a left-wing party largely confined to Punjab. Above all, the discussion remained limited to the glorification of Major Ishaq, without offering a critical evaluation of his politics. Even when they acknowledge that the pro-Peking parties of West Pakistan failed to take correct positions on national questions, they do not identify the underlying causes and instead attribute this failure to the closeness between the Chinese and Pakistani states. If this explanation were sufficient, then Siraj Sikdar—the most radical Bengali Maoist leader—would logically have adopted a similar position. All this stems from Dr. Azeem’s idealist pursuit of continuity, evident in their subjective error in using two theses of Major Ishaq and the old Mazdoor Kisan Party, without critically analyzing their merit.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">First, they rely on the thesis presented by Major Ishaq in his well-known <a href="https://vanguardbooks.com/products/mashriqi-pakistan-aur-punjab-ka-almiya">book</a>, <em>Mashriqi Pakistan aur Punjab ka Almia (East Pakistan and the Dilemma of Punjab)</em>, which emphasizes the “differences between the civilizations that developed around the Indus River and those around the Ganges River,” suggesting the existence of two distinct cultural and economic histories. It is therefore unsurprising that many consider Major Ishaq a chauvinist, as this thesis not only justifies the division of the subcontinent into two dominions rather than multiple nation states but also reinforces the state narrative that East Pakistan separated for geographical and cultural reasons, rather than due to uneven development and severe national exploitation and discrimination imposed by the state. This also explains why figures such as Dr. Hamza Virk and Dr. Arfan Choudhry lectured activists of the Baloch liberation movement by arguing that Balochistan and Punjab share historic cultural and economic ties, and therefore there exists no basis for separation.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The second thesis of the earlier Maoist groups, with which Dr. Azeem and Ali <a href="https://www.jamhoor.org/read/how-the-recent-indo-pak-conflict-exposed-fault-lines-in-the-pakistani-left">attempt</a> to establish continuity, is that the “material roots of the partition of India and Pakistan” lie in the “class and caste contradictions faced by the majority of Muslim masses in Punjab, East Bengal, and Sindh.” They further clarify what they mean by “masses” and their “contradictions” by stressing that these groups primarily consisted of small peasants, tenants, landless individuals, and scheduled caste members who were exploited by both British colonialism and landowning and money-lending Hindu upper castes, who were minorities in these regions. This represents an opportunist position and helps explain why the leadership of the pro-Peking left groups—particularly the Mazdoor Kisan Party—became increasingly confined to the middle class and middle peasantry of Punjab and Karachi. It also reinforces the narrative of Pakistan’s ruling classes and state on the national question by creating the impression that the subcontinent was marked by genuine communal contradictions at the lowest levels of society, and that Pakistan emerged not as a product of British colonial interests and allied Hindu and Muslim elites, but as a savior of Muslim masses. This thesis further reflects the class and national composition of the Mazdoor Kisan Party: a party attempting to organize lower-caste bonded laborers and landless peasants in Punjab while being led by the rural middle peasantry and urban middle class of the same region. This is not only an ideologically and politically incorrect line, but also factually inconsistent.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">One can take the case of Sindh to test whether this thesis truly explains the material roots of partition or merely reflects the Punjabi subjectivism of a middle-class and middle-peasant leadership. There is no doubt that religion and caste were closely linked to class composition in Sindh; however, while the urban merchant and money-lending classes were largely Hindu, the landowning and feudal classes were predominantly Muslim. In fact, it was precisely the contradiction between these two classes that created the conditions which enabled British colonial forces to invade Sindh and annex it to the Bombay Presidency.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Similarly, for centuries the Sayeds or Shahs have occupied the highest caste status in Sindh, a reality reflected in the poetry and texts produced during the Talpur era. Although the Talpurs ruled Sindh politically, real prestige and social authority remained with the Sayeds. Moreover, the early development of Sindhi nationality is often attributed to Hindus, due to the emergence of merchant and small industrial capitalist classes among them and their role in urban development. It was these forces that first demanded the separation of Sindh from the Bombay Presidency. The Muslim League, at that time, had no real standing against the Sindh United Party, just as it lacked influence in Punjab against the Unionist Party. At the mass level, the situation was even weaker: despite persuading the Muslim feudal leadership of the Sindh United Party to join the Muslim League, the latter failed to secure popular support. As G. M. Syed acknowledged in <em>Sindh Jo Muqaddamo (The Case for Sindh)</em>, the orchestration of the Manzilgah Masjid riots was essential for the Muslim League to generate even minimal mass backing.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">These historical facts, combined with the religious harmony still exhibited by the masses in Sindh today—despite the continued exploitation and oppression of Hindus and lower castes by feudal and other Muslim ruling classes—and the strong current of Sindhi nationalism accompanied by deep resentment toward Punjab’s ruling classes, suggest that both theses advanced by the old Mazdoor Kisan Party and related Maoist groups reflect a tendency to find&nbsp;empirical evidence in support of the patriotic line instead of thorough and deep analysis. They reflect how even progressive sections of the Punjabi middle class and middle peasantry tail the Punjabi ruling classes and the Pakistani state. This tendency is further illustrated by the recent shift of a former NSF president, Akhter Rohella, toward Mohajir chauvinist politics, where he employs the same thesis to mock Sindhi nationalists by claiming that without Mohajir advocacy for Pakistan, Sindhi Muslims would have remained under Hindu moneylenders</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">These theses inevitably lead Dr. Azeem and Ali toward Dr. Ammar’s position. While they do not openly endorse Pakistan’s ruling classes, their dismissal of left-wing calls opposing the war—calls urging the people of India and Pakistan to struggle against their own fascist and authoritarian states—as “unprincipled peace” effectively masks the same political stance. The primary difference lies in their theoretical affiliation with Maoism, which prevents them from framing the conflict within the context of a new Cold War between an imperialist United States and a “socialist” or “anti-colonial” China.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Their <a href="https://www.jamhoor.org/read/how-the-recent-indo-pak-conflict-exposed-fault-lines-in-the-pakistani-left">position</a> ultimately rests on the assertion that India and Pakistan are not comparable, and that the left must “stand in genuine solidarity with the militant struggles of Adivasis, Dalits, and Kashmiris within India, as well as the regional victims of its expansionism, including the Nepalese, Bengali, and Sri Lankan peoples, against the Brahmanical Hindutva fascist state, its imperialist backers, and the ruling classes throughout the region.” We fully agree with the call to stand with all oppressed sections fighting the fascist and expansionist Indian state. However, the unresolved question is how the authors differentiate these struggles from those of Baloch, Pashtuns, Sindhis, Hazaras, Shias, Ahmadis, Kashmiris, and other oppressed groups within Pakistan, as well as the victims of Pakistan’s regional expansionism in Afghanistan, under an authoritarian Sunni Islamic state backed by imperialist forces.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Conclusion</h4>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>[A]lthough we have discussed middle-class errors of certain parties in Pakistan, almost all the leftwing parties and groups, including Karachi Bachao Tehreek, are grappling with the issue of such errors. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1786736216795_70873">While Dr. Azeem and Ali’s article is helpful in tracing historical debates, their conclusion was reduced to a simplified analysis. They failed to correctly identify the historical contradictions leading to the partition; central for understanding the current conflict. They used selective empiricism to justify the creation of Pakistan. The problem lies in the ultra-academic approach taken by Dr. Azeem and Ali. They emphasize the historical evolution of the trends, portraying their fixation with the under-explored concept of “continuity and rupture” which they followed rather dogmatically instead of analyzing the concrete practices, actions and class forces within the parties and groups. This led the focus of the article towards finding continuities while ignoring the ruptures on a practical level.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">They also ignored the failure of Mazdoor Kisan Party to conduct any thorough rectification campaign within the party to concretely change its direction. Their broad theoretical generalizations, reflective of their dogmatic and over-theoretical approach, led to an incorrect critique, insufficient for understanding the historical failure of their own party, let alone the Left’s various positions.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Here it is worthwhile mentioning that although we have discussed middle-class errors of certain parties in Pakistan, almost all the leftwing parties and groups, including Karachi Bachao Tehreek, are grappling with the issue of such errors. Either they tilt towards the empiricist practice, with a focus only on contemporary and immediate issues, creating a centric politic, deradicalizing themselves–shifting from class politics towards identity politics–– or moving towards dogmatism; which results in rejecting national and other identity questions, generalizing very different trends, avoiding concrete analysis and framing everything in the realm of theory. One more evidence of this middle-class subjectivism is the fact that almost all the leadership of the leftwing parties, whether emphasizing the importance of the rural or not, remains and grounds their politics in urban centers, particularly amongst university students.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Within every organization, there is an ongoing struggle between middle-class and working-class lines and currently the former is dominating the parties. This struggle will persist, and the principles of the mass line and two-line struggle will remain essential tools for all left-wing organizations seeking to combat bourgeois and middle-class influences within their ranks. It is only through criticism and self-criticism, and concrete rectification campaigns the Left can analyze strategic and theoretical frameworks and evolve in our approach to truly organize the masses.&nbsp;</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Aisha Tahir</em></strong><em> is a documentary filmmaker based in New York City.</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Khurram Ali </em></strong><em>is the convener of Karachi Bachao Tehreek and previously served as the Central Organizer of the National Students Federation.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1788460229622-IJ21TLGAIGBV0OZ574F0/23.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">The Pakistani Left’s Middle Class Crisis</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>Beyond Bengali Hegemony in 1971</title><category>Bangladesh</category><category>Photo Essay</category><dc:creator>Ifaz Khan</dc:creator><pubDate>Tue, 11 Aug 2026 23:56:13 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/beyond-bengali-hegemony-in-1971</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:6a73cd9d845c3452e0fc6fb1</guid><description><![CDATA[The forgotten history of Bangladesh’s non-Bengali freedom fighters who 
fought in the 1971 Liberation War.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>The forgotten history of Bangladesh’s non-Bengali freedom fighters who fought in the 1971 Liberation War.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/62871f12-d5d9-44be-b921-7d823f3d44fe/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure.png" data-image-dimensions="2000x1600" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/62871f12-d5d9-44be-b921-7d823f3d44fe/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure.png?format=1000w" width="2000" height="1600" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/62871f12-d5d9-44be-b921-7d823f3d44fe/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/62871f12-d5d9-44be-b921-7d823f3d44fe/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/62871f12-d5d9-44be-b921-7d823f3d44fe/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/62871f12-d5d9-44be-b921-7d823f3d44fe/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/62871f12-d5d9-44be-b921-7d823f3d44fe/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/62871f12-d5d9-44be-b921-7d823f3d44fe/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/62871f12-d5d9-44be-b921-7d823f3d44fe/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Collection of photographs of some Adibashi and non-Bengali freedom fighters of Bangladesh.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Collection of photographs of some Adibashi and non-Bengali freedom fighters of Bangladesh.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Bangladesh emerged from a nine-month liberation war in 1971, fought against decades of political, economic, and cultural discrimination by the West Pakistani state. Although the new nation was founded on ideals of democracy, equality, and inclusion, public memory of the war gradually came to centre overwhelmingly on the experiences of the Bengali majority. Yet scattered across archives, newspapers, and family collections are traces of other lives that fought for the same dream of freedom: Adibashi fighters from the hills and plains, Urdu-speaking supporters of the <em>Mukti Bahini</em>, and members of other marginalized communities whose stories rarely entered official histories.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This collection revisits some of those forgotten presences through photographs, newspaper clippings, and archival fragments that survived the passage of time. In doing so, it also exposes the silences of the archive itself. While Bengali suffering and resistance understandably dominated wartime reporting in documents and local newspapers, the experiences of many Adibashi and non-Bengali participants remained largely undocumented. These gaps are not merely accidental; they reveal how some contributions to liberation were remembered, while others are allowed to fade to the margins of national memory.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This marginalisation did not emerge in a vacuum. Historian Mohiuddin Ahmed and investigative journalist Masudul Haque have documented the rise of influential Bengali ultranationalist currents within sections of the Awami League's student organisations during the 1960s. These ultranationalist factions grew so powerful, that they even reportedly worried Sheikh Mujibur Rahman himself. While the liberation struggle was fought in the name of democracy, equality, and self-determination, competing visions existed regarding the identity of the future state. For some, Bangladesh was to be a homeland for all who lived within it; for others, it was to be defined primarily through a singular Bengali national identity.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">These tensions became apparent during the Liberation War itself. Although many Chakma, Marma, Santal, Garo and other indigenous youths sought to join the Mukti Bahini, several accounts describe suspicion and obstacles placed in their path. S. Mahmud Ali notes that many Adibashi students, who had supported the Bengali nationalist movement during the late 1960s, travelled to India expecting to join the war effort only to encounter distrust and return disillusioned. Former freedom fighter and researcher Ayub Hossain similarly documents cases of indigenous volunteers (especially from Chakma community) who struggled to gain acceptance despite their commitment to the liberation cause.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The end of the war did not resolve these anxieties. In the months following independence, violence, dispossession, and reprisals affected many non-Bengali communities. Biharis were frequently treated as a collective enemy regardless of individual wartime positions, while indigenous communities in the Chittagong Hill Tracts increasingly found themselves at odds with a state that prioritized a singular national identity. When indigenous leader Manabendra Narayan Larma sought constitutional recognition and autonomy in 1972, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman famously responded: “We are all Bengalis.” For many indigenous communities, this statement symbolised the state's unwillingness to accommodate distinct identities within the new republic.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The consequences extended far beyond the immediate post-war years. Numerous indigenous freedom fighters struggled to obtain recognition, compensation, or a place within official narratives of liberation. Ayub Hossain records instances in which Santal veterans remained excluded from benefits granted to other freedom fighters, while discriminatory attitudes persisted long after independence. Communities that had fought, sheltered refugees, guided guerrillas, and endured wartime atrocities remained absent from textbooks, memorials, and public commemorations.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Many of these patterns remain visible today. Adibashis, Biharis, <em>Harijan</em> and <em>Bede</em> communities, tea workers, and other marginalized groups continue to face discrimination, dispossession, and unequal access to opportunities. Their experiences differ, yet they share a common place at the margins of national memory. The photographs and archival fragments in this collection are therefore not merely records of the past. They are reminders that the struggle for recognition did not end in 1971. For many of Bangladesh's forgotten allies, it continues to this day.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/553dda23-8880-4047-a112-527dc39e3afa/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%283%29.png" data-image-dimensions="920x375" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/553dda23-8880-4047-a112-527dc39e3afa/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%283%29.png?format=1000w" width="920" height="375" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/553dda23-8880-4047-a112-527dc39e3afa/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%283%29.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/553dda23-8880-4047-a112-527dc39e3afa/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%283%29.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/553dda23-8880-4047-a112-527dc39e3afa/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%283%29.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/553dda23-8880-4047-a112-527dc39e3afa/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%283%29.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/553dda23-8880-4047-a112-527dc39e3afa/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%283%29.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/553dda23-8880-4047-a112-527dc39e3afa/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%283%29.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/553dda23-8880-4047-a112-527dc39e3afa/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%283%29.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Source for newspaper clipping: Songramer Notebook</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Source for newspaper clipping: Songramer Notebook</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Left] Santal freedom fighter Sagram Majhi, who led Santals into the liberation war. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Right] Newspaper clipping from <em>Jugantor</em> on March 26, 1971, reporting clashes between Pakistan Army and civilians in north Bangladesh, particularly Rangpur. The report indicates the Nishbetganj Chaos of March 23, when Pakistani forces raided and brought repression into nearby Santal villages. On March 28, thousands of indigenous Santals (armed with indigenous weapons like bows-arrows, knives) alongside Bengalis and Orangs, in a bold move, surrounded the Nishbetganj Cantonment of Rangpur. It was the first act of defiance against Pakistani forces, which ended up killing 600 of the crowd.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9d47300f-d4e4-470d-9206-38da3c5daccb/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%288%29.png" data-image-dimensions="831x591" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9d47300f-d4e4-470d-9206-38da3c5daccb/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%288%29.png?format=1000w" width="831" height="591" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9d47300f-d4e4-470d-9206-38da3c5daccb/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%288%29.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9d47300f-d4e4-470d-9206-38da3c5daccb/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%288%29.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9d47300f-d4e4-470d-9206-38da3c5daccb/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%288%29.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9d47300f-d4e4-470d-9206-38da3c5daccb/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%288%29.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9d47300f-d4e4-470d-9206-38da3c5daccb/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%288%29.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9d47300f-d4e4-470d-9206-38da3c5daccb/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%288%29.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9d47300f-d4e4-470d-9206-38da3c5daccb/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%288%29.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Left and Center Top] Marma King Momphru Sain and his historical palace which served as a base for Mukti Bahini. Momphru Sain established a hospital, his own local liberation force, gave away 33 of his advanced semi-automatic rifles, and his personal vehicles to freedom fighters; Sain also himself fought in the liberation war. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Left and Center Bottom] Uk Ching Marma and a rare photograph of him on the battlefield. Uk Ching Marma was a <em>Havildar</em> of the East Pakistan Rifles (EPR), and one of those EPR members&nbsp;who revolted. He is the only Adibashi freedom fighter to win the <em>Bir Bikrom</em>, one of the highest gallantry awards for participants of the liberation war. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Right] Chinghla Mong Chowdhury Mari was one of the finest footballers playing for Pakistan’s national team. In 1971, he joined the liberation war as a captain for Sector-1 zone, and later served as Quartermaster under Major Ziaur Rahman—commander of Sector-1 and the Z-Force (a military brigade of Mukti Bahini).</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4b54d131-f7fc-4a43-ac58-b968d865cf6a/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%289%29.png" data-image-dimensions="897x485" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4b54d131-f7fc-4a43-ac58-b968d865cf6a/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%289%29.png?format=1000w" width="897" height="485" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4b54d131-f7fc-4a43-ac58-b968d865cf6a/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%289%29.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4b54d131-f7fc-4a43-ac58-b968d865cf6a/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%289%29.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4b54d131-f7fc-4a43-ac58-b968d865cf6a/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%289%29.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4b54d131-f7fc-4a43-ac58-b968d865cf6a/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%289%29.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4b54d131-f7fc-4a43-ac58-b968d865cf6a/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%289%29.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4b54d131-f7fc-4a43-ac58-b968d865cf6a/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%289%29.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4b54d131-f7fc-4a43-ac58-b968d865cf6a/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%289%29.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Left] Newspaper clipping from <em>Prothom Alo</em>, November 22, 2015, on an event commemorating ten Harijan martyrs of the Liberation War. Considered untouchables and facing marginalisation, they still took part in the Liberation War—carrying out dangerous tasks like hiding freedom fighters, smuggling weapons for them, spying on Pakistani forces and supplying food to freedom fighters. A group of Harijans from Mirin Jilla Harijan City Colony of Dhaka, also took part in the war as aides to Mukti Bahini. They had to face the brunt of it, as Pakistani forces received intel and raided their colony on November 22, 1971, <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/news/recognition-ever-elusive-martyred-harijans-2235771"><u>and kidnapped ten of them</u>. Mahabir Lal Samund, Nan</a>du Lal, Anowar Lal, Ishwar Lal, Khalbal Das, Ghashita Das, Sankar Das Hela, Nanda Lal, Lalu Das, and Ramcharan—these ten members were taken away and were never seen again. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Right]&nbsp; Compilation of photos belonging to a few of the <em>Cha-Sromik</em> freedom fighters. The <em>Cha-Sromik</em> (tea workers) people are another marginalized working-class community in Bangladesh, comprising of a cluster of ethnic and religious groups like Dalit communities (brought from regions in India, such as Bihar, Odisha, West Bengal, Andhra Pradesh, and Madhya Pradesh, during the British colonial era), including Adibashi groups like the Santal, Oraon, Munda, Kharia, and Mahali. During the liberation war, the tea gardens of northeastern Bangladesh were attacked by Pakistani occupation forces with heavy weaponry. Massacres unfolded as Pakistani forces gutted several houses across tea gardens, killed several tea-workers, their children and families in their sleep, suspecting them of aiding the Mukti Bahini. Several of them fought in the liberation war as spies, rescue operators, weapons smugglers and fighters on field.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6fd3bc4a-03ff-438c-b562-dd959893ce0c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2810%29.png" data-image-dimensions="586x719" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6fd3bc4a-03ff-438c-b562-dd959893ce0c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2810%29.png?format=1000w" width="586" height="719" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6fd3bc4a-03ff-438c-b562-dd959893ce0c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2810%29.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6fd3bc4a-03ff-438c-b562-dd959893ce0c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2810%29.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6fd3bc4a-03ff-438c-b562-dd959893ce0c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2810%29.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6fd3bc4a-03ff-438c-b562-dd959893ce0c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2810%29.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6fd3bc4a-03ff-438c-b562-dd959893ce0c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2810%29.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6fd3bc4a-03ff-438c-b562-dd959893ce0c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2810%29.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6fd3bc4a-03ff-438c-b562-dd959893ce0c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2810%29.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Top Left] An extremely rare photograph of Khogendro Lal Chakma in the early 1970s. He was an officer of East Pakistan Police Service, and the first indigenous freedom fighter from Chittagong Hill Tracts to be martyred . He supplied weapons from his police stations to freedom fighters, and blew up a bridge on the Dhaka-Chittagong Highway to stop Pakistani forces from advancing.&nbsp; </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Top Right] Mongpocha Chakma from Cox’s Bazar, alongside several other Chakmas, fought the liberation war in Bandarban.&nbsp; </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Bottom Left] Rare photograph of Roshomoy Chakma sometime in the 1970s. He was barred from joining the liberation war by Bengali ultranationalists, eventually driving him into burning the house of a Pakistani Punjabi man living in Khagrachhari out of frustration.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Bottom Right] Monish Dewan, a student of Rajshahi Cadet College who joined the liberation war with his friends, photographed sometime around the 1970s.&nbsp; </p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3629b63a-9e12-43b3-ae24-b7eb4c4e3f6d/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2811%29.png" data-image-dimensions="643x677" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3629b63a-9e12-43b3-ae24-b7eb4c4e3f6d/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2811%29.png?format=1000w" width="643" height="677" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3629b63a-9e12-43b3-ae24-b7eb4c4e3f6d/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2811%29.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3629b63a-9e12-43b3-ae24-b7eb4c4e3f6d/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2811%29.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3629b63a-9e12-43b3-ae24-b7eb4c4e3f6d/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2811%29.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3629b63a-9e12-43b3-ae24-b7eb4c4e3f6d/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2811%29.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3629b63a-9e12-43b3-ae24-b7eb4c4e3f6d/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2811%29.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3629b63a-9e12-43b3-ae24-b7eb4c4e3f6d/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2811%29.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3629b63a-9e12-43b3-ae24-b7eb4c4e3f6d/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2811%29.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Top Left] Some remaining relics after the Pakistani Army vandalised temples during the&nbsp; 6th May Buddha Bihar Massacres.&nbsp; </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Top Right] A short newspaper clipping from <em>Jugantor</em> (May 7, 1971) about Pakistan Army’s attack in Cox’s Bazar, but no mention about the heinous massacre of Rakhain Buddhists by Pakistani forces in Rakhain Para, Moheshkhali, Cox’s Bazar, resulting in the deaths of around 20 Rakhain civilians [Source: Songramer Notebook]. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Bottom] A Meitei freedom fighter on the battlefield (some sources suggest he was Rakhain or from other indigenous ethnicity).</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7afe316a-03ac-4d05-bc56-9379249d640c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2812%29.png" data-image-dimensions="622x571" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7afe316a-03ac-4d05-bc56-9379249d640c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2812%29.png?format=1000w" width="622" height="571" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7afe316a-03ac-4d05-bc56-9379249d640c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2812%29.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7afe316a-03ac-4d05-bc56-9379249d640c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2812%29.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7afe316a-03ac-4d05-bc56-9379249d640c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2812%29.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7afe316a-03ac-4d05-bc56-9379249d640c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2812%29.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7afe316a-03ac-4d05-bc56-9379249d640c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2812%29.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7afe316a-03ac-4d05-bc56-9379249d640c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2812%29.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7afe316a-03ac-4d05-bc56-9379249d640c/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2812%29.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Top Left] Two Garo freedom fighters interviewed in Tareque Masud’s documentary <em>Muktir Kotha</em> (1999) . </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Top Right] Promod Mankin, a Garo freedom fighter who led Garos into the liberation war. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Bottom Left] Rono Bikram Tripura and [Bottom Right] Hemda Ronjon Tripura on the battlefield were from the Tripura community, and were some of the leading figures in liberation war in the Chittagong Hill Tracts.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c497560d-7295-454d-8f00-ec7bdac8ac16/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2813%29.png" data-image-dimensions="811x322" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c497560d-7295-454d-8f00-ec7bdac8ac16/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2813%29.png?format=1000w" width="811" height="322" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c497560d-7295-454d-8f00-ec7bdac8ac16/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2813%29.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c497560d-7295-454d-8f00-ec7bdac8ac16/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2813%29.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c497560d-7295-454d-8f00-ec7bdac8ac16/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2813%29.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c497560d-7295-454d-8f00-ec7bdac8ac16/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2813%29.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c497560d-7295-454d-8f00-ec7bdac8ac16/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2813%29.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c497560d-7295-454d-8f00-ec7bdac8ac16/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2813%29.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c497560d-7295-454d-8f00-ec7bdac8ac16/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2813%29.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Left] Newspaper clipping from <em>Prothom Alo</em>, published on November 18, 2015 about the forgotten Mro freedom fighter Labre Mro. Labre Mro was from Bandarban’s Naikyangchhari area who fought alongside Mukti Bahini. His espionage activities for the Mukti Bahini brought about his&nbsp; martyrdom by the Pakistani forces. Yet, even today, he remains forgotten and denied any state recognition. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Right] A group of indigenous freedom fighters with bows-and-arrows, alongside their Bengali counterparts.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/55b93ea4-9d70-42bc-a15c-fc498a21c0a0/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2814%29.png" data-image-dimensions="904x606" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/55b93ea4-9d70-42bc-a15c-fc498a21c0a0/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2814%29.png?format=1000w" width="904" height="606" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/55b93ea4-9d70-42bc-a15c-fc498a21c0a0/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2814%29.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/55b93ea4-9d70-42bc-a15c-fc498a21c0a0/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2814%29.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/55b93ea4-9d70-42bc-a15c-fc498a21c0a0/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2814%29.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/55b93ea4-9d70-42bc-a15c-fc498a21c0a0/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2814%29.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/55b93ea4-9d70-42bc-a15c-fc498a21c0a0/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2814%29.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/55b93ea4-9d70-42bc-a15c-fc498a21c0a0/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2814%29.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/55b93ea4-9d70-42bc-a15c-fc498a21c0a0/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2814%29.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Source for the newspaper clipping: Subrata Shuvo</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Source for the newspaper clipping: Subrata Shuvo</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Top Left] Subedar Syed Khan, an Urdu-speaking Bihari freedom fighter who was an officer in the EPR. Alongside Uk Ching Marma, he was the second non-Bengali freedom fighter recognised by the state for his bravery and was awarded with <em>Bir Protik</em>. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Top Center] Kabul Ahmed from Bogura, a Bihari civilian who took part in the war and was martyred. He never got any recognition. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Bottom Left] Momtaz Khan Pathan, a Pakistani ethnic-Pashtun factory owner in Tangail, who joined the liberation war. He supplied medicines for Mukti Bahini and gathered intel through his cousin in the Pakistani Army.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Bottom Center] Sami Ahmed Khan, another Bihari freedom fighter who worked as a spy and food supplier for Mukti Bahini, but is yet to receive any state recognition. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Right]&nbsp; Newspaper clipping from during Liberation War, belonging to Sarbahara party’s newspaper publication <em>Mukti Juddho</em>, which another Bihari freedom fighter Samiullah Azmi often wrote for.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/69d23a48-86c7-46e1-8105-3029462db7bf/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2815%29.png" data-image-dimensions="536x472" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/69d23a48-86c7-46e1-8105-3029462db7bf/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2815%29.png?format=1000w" width="536" height="472" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/69d23a48-86c7-46e1-8105-3029462db7bf/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2815%29.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/69d23a48-86c7-46e1-8105-3029462db7bf/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2815%29.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/69d23a48-86c7-46e1-8105-3029462db7bf/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2815%29.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/69d23a48-86c7-46e1-8105-3029462db7bf/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2815%29.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/69d23a48-86c7-46e1-8105-3029462db7bf/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2815%29.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/69d23a48-86c7-46e1-8105-3029462db7bf/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2815%29.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/69d23a48-86c7-46e1-8105-3029462db7bf/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2815%29.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Image courtesy: Protidiner Bangladesh</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Image courtesy: Protidiner Bangladesh</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Left] Kakon Bibi, a legendary female freedom fighter from Khasi ethnic community, who received the <em>Bir Protik</em> award and [Right] Tushi Hagidk from Garo ethnic community.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3350fdfb-545f-432e-bd95-e91f22af713e/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2816%29.png" data-image-dimensions="655x748" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3350fdfb-545f-432e-bd95-e91f22af713e/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2816%29.png?format=1000w" width="655" height="748" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3350fdfb-545f-432e-bd95-e91f22af713e/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2816%29.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3350fdfb-545f-432e-bd95-e91f22af713e/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2816%29.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3350fdfb-545f-432e-bd95-e91f22af713e/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2816%29.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3350fdfb-545f-432e-bd95-e91f22af713e/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2816%29.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3350fdfb-545f-432e-bd95-e91f22af713e/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2816%29.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3350fdfb-545f-432e-bd95-e91f22af713e/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2816%29.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3350fdfb-545f-432e-bd95-e91f22af713e/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2816%29.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Image courtesy for newspaper clippings : Songramer Notebook</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Image courtesy for newspaper clippings : Songramer Notebook</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Top Left] A photograph of indigenous refugees during 1971. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Center Left] A photo collage with Sheikh Mujib’s meeting Chhatra League and other Bengali nationalists in a gathering. Inside the photo is a newspaper clipping from February 15, 1972. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Bottom Left]  A photo of a <em>Chhatra League</em> event in late 1960s, and beside it is a photo of Manabendra Narayan Larma. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Top Right] <em>Gonokontho</em> newspaper, dated July 6, 1973, reporting about <em>Rakkhi Bahini</em>’s brutal repression in hill tracts. The Rakkhi Bahini was a paramilitary force formed by Sheikh Mujib as a check against the Bangladeshi Army post-independence. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">[Bottom Right] The same newspaper reported on July 8, 1974, about the post-independence imprisonment of several Bihari civilians and the repression they faced inside prisons, including enforced prostitution on Bihari women.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Ifaz Ali Khan</em></strong><em> is a writer, independent researcher, and human rights’ activist, currently pursuing a bachelors degree in Computer Science &amp; Engineering at East Delta University. He also writes for International Policy Digest.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1786422084681-WBCCB6QI1WVNSK5VQKCU/The+Forgotten+Non-Bengali+Freedom+Fighters+of+1971+and+The+Politics+of+Erasure+%2817%29.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="879" height="675"><media:title type="plain">Beyond Bengali Hegemony in 1971</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>GEN-Z Revolution: The India Chapter</title><category>India</category><category>Photo Essay</category><dc:creator>Mandeep Punia</dc:creator><pubDate>Sat, 01 Aug 2026 01:20:20 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/gen-z-revolution-the-india-chapter</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:6a6a5c10ba56455eff386f1d</guid><description><![CDATA[A chronology of the Cockroach Janata Party protest that rocked Modi’s 
reign.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A chronology of the Cockroach Janata Party protest that rocked Modi’s reign.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/113aebe2-faa9-4be6-a33d-1771a7d3c8e6/AAGCEJC9ttU_1785362187022.jpg" data-image-dimensions="2400x1600" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/113aebe2-faa9-4be6-a33d-1771a7d3c8e6/AAGCEJC9ttU_1785362187022.jpg?format=1000w" width="2400" height="1600" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/113aebe2-faa9-4be6-a33d-1771a7d3c8e6/AAGCEJC9ttU_1785362187022.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/113aebe2-faa9-4be6-a33d-1771a7d3c8e6/AAGCEJC9ttU_1785362187022.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/113aebe2-faa9-4be6-a33d-1771a7d3c8e6/AAGCEJC9ttU_1785362187022.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/113aebe2-faa9-4be6-a33d-1771a7d3c8e6/AAGCEJC9ttU_1785362187022.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/113aebe2-faa9-4be6-a33d-1771a7d3c8e6/AAGCEJC9ttU_1785362187022.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/113aebe2-faa9-4be6-a33d-1771a7d3c8e6/AAGCEJC9ttU_1785362187022.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/113aebe2-faa9-4be6-a33d-1771a7d3c8e6/AAGCEJC9ttU_1785362187022.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>The events that transpired at Jantar Mantar over the last few weeks cannot be summed up by the term ‘demonstration’. The story began with one Instagram page. On 15 May 2026 the Chief Justice of India (CJI), Surya Kant referred to the unemployed youth as ‘cockroaches’ and ‘parasites’ in open court. Satire, in the form of social media accounts and other actions, was a response to the CJI’s remark and slowly but surely it transformed into a protest. Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) Instagram page amassed 20 million followers in a matter of weeks.</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>The online ire entered the streets on June 6, 2026 when thousands of students gathered at Jantar Mantar. On the heels of these crowds followed the people who would eventually sit in hunger strikes, the pots and pans to be distributed in langars, the people who slept on sheets on the footpaths of Jantar Mantar, and eventually the lathis that descended on the crowds. </em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>This photo story takes us along on the journey of the CJP-led protest which demanded the resignation of Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan along with broader reforms of the examination system.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <h3 data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><span class="sqsrte-text-color--black">Pitching the Tent</span></h3>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7417800c-3631-485b-a769-23e7f3b5dd7c/DSC06109+-+Copy.jpg" data-image-dimensions="7008x4672" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7417800c-3631-485b-a769-23e7f3b5dd7c/DSC06109+-+Copy.jpg?format=1000w" width="7008" height="4672" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7417800c-3631-485b-a769-23e7f3b5dd7c/DSC06109+-+Copy.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7417800c-3631-485b-a769-23e7f3b5dd7c/DSC06109+-+Copy.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7417800c-3631-485b-a769-23e7f3b5dd7c/DSC06109+-+Copy.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7417800c-3631-485b-a769-23e7f3b5dd7c/DSC06109+-+Copy.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7417800c-3631-485b-a769-23e7f3b5dd7c/DSC06109+-+Copy.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7417800c-3631-485b-a769-23e7f3b5dd7c/DSC06109+-+Copy.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7417800c-3631-485b-a769-23e7f3b5dd7c/DSC06109+-+Copy.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>The CJP stage at Jantar Mantar</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>The CJP stage at Jantar Mantar</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Any movement can perhaps trace its beginning to a particular moment or incident. For this particular one, it was the setting up of the protest stage at Jantar Mantar - it began with a few protestors, a banner, a mic and a stage. The handful of voices who assembled at Jantar Mantar to set up this stage have already entered the annals of history. Their main demand was the resignation of Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan after the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) paper leak (the NEET is India’s mandatory national admissions exam for students pursuing undergraduate and postgraduate medical and dental degrees).</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/64132b3b-afdf-428c-ab47-0fcd94dc5164/DSC06179+-+Copy.jpg" data-image-dimensions="7008x4672" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/64132b3b-afdf-428c-ab47-0fcd94dc5164/DSC06179+-+Copy.jpg?format=1000w" width="7008" height="4672" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/64132b3b-afdf-428c-ab47-0fcd94dc5164/DSC06179+-+Copy.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/64132b3b-afdf-428c-ab47-0fcd94dc5164/DSC06179+-+Copy.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/64132b3b-afdf-428c-ab47-0fcd94dc5164/DSC06179+-+Copy.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/64132b3b-afdf-428c-ab47-0fcd94dc5164/DSC06179+-+Copy.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/64132b3b-afdf-428c-ab47-0fcd94dc5164/DSC06179+-+Copy.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/64132b3b-afdf-428c-ab47-0fcd94dc5164/DSC06179+-+Copy.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/64132b3b-afdf-428c-ab47-0fcd94dc5164/DSC06179+-+Copy.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Protestors lighting candles for students who committed suicide</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Protestors lighting candles for students who committed suicide</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The galvanising force of this movement, however, was far greater than any slogan or speech from the stage. This image shows candles lit in memory of the students who took their lives, unable to survive the immense pressure caused by the NEET paper leak. The bowed heads and the flickering flames make it clear that this protest was never just about demanding a minister's resignation. It was an attempt to seek accountability for the names and faces that now live only in photographs and memories. In other words, it was a demand for those responsible to be held accountable. The outpouring of grief and anguish eventually converged in the hunger strike, the crowds, and the tussle that followed.</p>
<h3 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Test of Hunger</h3>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/710c6f8b-33d0-402d-b7b7-199e56795b5b/47-2.jpg" data-image-dimensions="5315x2990" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/710c6f8b-33d0-402d-b7b7-199e56795b5b/47-2.jpg?format=1000w" width="5315" height="2990" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/710c6f8b-33d0-402d-b7b7-199e56795b5b/47-2.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/710c6f8b-33d0-402d-b7b7-199e56795b5b/47-2.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/710c6f8b-33d0-402d-b7b7-199e56795b5b/47-2.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/710c6f8b-33d0-402d-b7b7-199e56795b5b/47-2.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/710c6f8b-33d0-402d-b7b7-199e56795b5b/47-2.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/710c6f8b-33d0-402d-b7b7-199e56795b5b/47-2.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/710c6f8b-33d0-402d-b7b7-199e56795b5b/47-2.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Sonam Wangchuk, On Hunger Strike</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Sonam Wangchuk, On Hunger Strike</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Sonam Wangchuk’s arrival on 28 Jun 2026 to Jantar Mantar and his decision to go on hunger strike went largely unnoticed. As his weight started dropping with each passing day, people began to worry. His haggard face, his eyes, and his physical frame showed signs of fatigue. The protestors&nbsp; embraced his wellbeing as one of their demands. These images circulated widely as symbols of the CJP-led protest in international headlines.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">On 17th July, the Delhi police took him under their custody and admitted him to the Safdarjung Hospital. After this incident, while the protests picked up pace, Wangchuk ended his hunger strike on the night of 23rd July after a total of 26 days. At the written assurance of the government regarding fulfilling his three main demands, he ended his hunger strike in Gurugram’s Medanta Hospital, in the presence of Union Ministers J.P. Nadda and Jitendra Singh.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <h3 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In Harmony</h3>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5416e68-2600-4755-98ad-baad3618b770/IMG_3775-3.jpg" data-image-dimensions="2048x2038" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5416e68-2600-4755-98ad-baad3618b770/IMG_3775-3.jpg?format=1000w" width="2048" height="2038" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5416e68-2600-4755-98ad-baad3618b770/IMG_3775-3.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5416e68-2600-4755-98ad-baad3618b770/IMG_3775-3.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5416e68-2600-4755-98ad-baad3618b770/IMG_3775-3.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5416e68-2600-4755-98ad-baad3618b770/IMG_3775-3.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5416e68-2600-4755-98ad-baad3618b770/IMG_3775-3.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5416e68-2600-4755-98ad-baad3618b770/IMG_3775-3.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b5416e68-2600-4755-98ad-baad3618b770/IMG_3775-3.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Neha Bora, Amin Amitoj, and Manish Kumar in frame</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Neha Bora, Amin Amitoj, and Manish Kumar in frame</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Neha Bora, Amin Amitoj, and Manish Kumar portray the same determination on their young faces as Wangchuk. Their hunger strike is a testament to the fact that this protest was not about an individual but is representative of this generation’s struggles and woes.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <h3 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">At Night: When the Roads Became the Resting Place</h3>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d92dec2a-7a1b-4451-9432-1b942f4317d5/IMG_0039-2.jpg" data-image-dimensions="5184x3456" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d92dec2a-7a1b-4451-9432-1b942f4317d5/IMG_0039-2.jpg?format=1000w" width="5184" height="3456" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d92dec2a-7a1b-4451-9432-1b942f4317d5/IMG_0039-2.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d92dec2a-7a1b-4451-9432-1b942f4317d5/IMG_0039-2.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d92dec2a-7a1b-4451-9432-1b942f4317d5/IMG_0039-2.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d92dec2a-7a1b-4451-9432-1b942f4317d5/IMG_0039-2.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d92dec2a-7a1b-4451-9432-1b942f4317d5/IMG_0039-2.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d92dec2a-7a1b-4451-9432-1b942f4317d5/IMG_0039-2.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d92dec2a-7a1b-4451-9432-1b942f4317d5/IMG_0039-2.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>The protestors resting at night</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>The protestors resting at night</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The fist-raising-slogan-shouting youth take respite on the footpath at night. Beneath the tarpaulin they lay down some sheets and are lulled to sleep by the gentle ripples of the posters hanging above. While daytime images of sloganeering showed no glimmer of exhaustion and discomfort, these became glimpses of some neglected, yet equally important, parts of the protest.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b5fd03e-d476-4f7a-80b8-6d0b94d8d000/IMG_0057-2.jpg" data-image-dimensions="5184x3456" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b5fd03e-d476-4f7a-80b8-6d0b94d8d000/IMG_0057-2.jpg?format=1000w" width="5184" height="3456" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b5fd03e-d476-4f7a-80b8-6d0b94d8d000/IMG_0057-2.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b5fd03e-d476-4f7a-80b8-6d0b94d8d000/IMG_0057-2.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b5fd03e-d476-4f7a-80b8-6d0b94d8d000/IMG_0057-2.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b5fd03e-d476-4f7a-80b8-6d0b94d8d000/IMG_0057-2.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b5fd03e-d476-4f7a-80b8-6d0b94d8d000/IMG_0057-2.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b5fd03e-d476-4f7a-80b8-6d0b94d8d000/IMG_0057-2.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b5fd03e-d476-4f7a-80b8-6d0b94d8d000/IMG_0057-2.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Protestors on the footpath at Jantar Mantar</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Protestors on the footpath at Jantar Mantar</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The roads around Jantar Mantar became temporary homes. Some rested on the footpath, while others slept in the middle of the roads.&nbsp;</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <h3 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Doomsday</h3>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dd20bc28-6f86-4c64-831b-9da1bf02c94b/8.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1280x720" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dd20bc28-6f86-4c64-831b-9da1bf02c94b/8.jpg?format=1000w" width="1280" height="720" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dd20bc28-6f86-4c64-831b-9da1bf02c94b/8.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dd20bc28-6f86-4c64-831b-9da1bf02c94b/8.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dd20bc28-6f86-4c64-831b-9da1bf02c94b/8.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dd20bc28-6f86-4c64-831b-9da1bf02c94b/8.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dd20bc28-6f86-4c64-831b-9da1bf02c94b/8.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dd20bc28-6f86-4c64-831b-9da1bf02c94b/8.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/dd20bc28-6f86-4c64-831b-9da1bf02c94b/8.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Crowds gather at Jantar Mantar</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Crowds gather at Jantar Mantar</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">While it started out with only a handful of protestors, the movement led by CJP quickly transformed into a crowd of thousands. This photo was taken on 20th July when lakhs of protestors gathered to march towards the Parliament. An eagle soaring over the scene would have perhaps described it thus: “Lutyen’s Delhi was either covered with trees or brimming with young heads.” The swelling crowd in and around Jantar Mantar were evidence of the protest’s reach and support.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <h3 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Police Violence</h3>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9c790941-381e-4c53-abaa-83b712dd2b31/9_+lathicharge.jpg" data-image-dimensions="785x457" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9c790941-381e-4c53-abaa-83b712dd2b31/9_+lathicharge.jpg?format=1000w" width="785" height="457" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9c790941-381e-4c53-abaa-83b712dd2b31/9_+lathicharge.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9c790941-381e-4c53-abaa-83b712dd2b31/9_+lathicharge.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9c790941-381e-4c53-abaa-83b712dd2b31/9_+lathicharge.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9c790941-381e-4c53-abaa-83b712dd2b31/9_+lathicharge.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9c790941-381e-4c53-abaa-83b712dd2b31/9_+lathicharge.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9c790941-381e-4c53-abaa-83b712dd2b31/9_+lathicharge.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9c790941-381e-4c53-abaa-83b712dd2b31/9_+lathicharge.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The most bitter moment of the protest arrived. The Delhi Police and the Rapid Action Force (RAF) personnel charged on the students and youth who had, until then, adorned the hunger strike as their mode of protest. This picture leaves us with the following question, “When will the colonial mindsets of these <em>khakhi</em>-clad personnel change? In the colonial era we had General Dyer and in this 21st century democracy we have khakhi-uniform clad General <em>kaayar</em> (timid or coward).”</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <h3 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The Eruption of Rage on Both Sides</h3>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a680a91a-5259-46a6-a9fb-9707803ecebb/10.jpg" data-image-dimensions="4643x3095" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a680a91a-5259-46a6-a9fb-9707803ecebb/10.jpg?format=1000w" width="4643" height="3095" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a680a91a-5259-46a6-a9fb-9707803ecebb/10.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a680a91a-5259-46a6-a9fb-9707803ecebb/10.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a680a91a-5259-46a6-a9fb-9707803ecebb/10.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a680a91a-5259-46a6-a9fb-9707803ecebb/10.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a680a91a-5259-46a6-a9fb-9707803ecebb/10.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a680a91a-5259-46a6-a9fb-9707803ecebb/10.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a680a91a-5259-46a6-a9fb-9707803ecebb/10.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Rahul Gandhi with the pellet gun victim</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Rahul Gandhi with the pellet gun victim</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The protestors have claimed that the Delhi police fired pellet guns to disperse the crowd. At least five victims have been identified including a journalist reporting for Outlook. This photograph depicts one victim’s torso and face pierced with pellets and provides proof against Delhi police’s denial of the use of pellet guns.&nbsp;</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <h3 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Slugs and Slurs</h3>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63e46797-7307-4deb-9ad2-7502167fb3f5/10+A.jpg" data-image-dimensions="4864x3648" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63e46797-7307-4deb-9ad2-7502167fb3f5/10+A.jpg?format=1000w" width="4864" height="3648" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63e46797-7307-4deb-9ad2-7502167fb3f5/10+A.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63e46797-7307-4deb-9ad2-7502167fb3f5/10+A.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63e46797-7307-4deb-9ad2-7502167fb3f5/10+A.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63e46797-7307-4deb-9ad2-7502167fb3f5/10+A.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63e46797-7307-4deb-9ad2-7502167fb3f5/10+A.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63e46797-7307-4deb-9ad2-7502167fb3f5/10+A.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63e46797-7307-4deb-9ad2-7502167fb3f5/10+A.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>The youth amidst slurs</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>The youth amidst slurs</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This was not the moment to challenge the gun with the pen. The stage is now occupied by the Gen Z generation of the 21stof 21st century. They faced the batons and bullets with Instagram reels and posters of profanity and curses. After the incidents of 20th July, about 80 percent of the posters directly attacked the regime. All their meanings converged at “The Emperor has no clothes.”</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <h3 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In the End</h3>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d0425281-340e-4c74-accc-fedc8508207d/cjp+wins.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1091x512" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d0425281-340e-4c74-accc-fedc8508207d/cjp+wins.jpg?format=1000w" width="1091" height="512" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d0425281-340e-4c74-accc-fedc8508207d/cjp+wins.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d0425281-340e-4c74-accc-fedc8508207d/cjp+wins.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d0425281-340e-4c74-accc-fedc8508207d/cjp+wins.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d0425281-340e-4c74-accc-fedc8508207d/cjp+wins.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d0425281-340e-4c74-accc-fedc8508207d/cjp+wins.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d0425281-340e-4c74-accc-fedc8508207d/cjp+wins.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d0425281-340e-4c74-accc-fedc8508207d/cjp+wins.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Scenes of celebration after announcement of Pradhan’s resignations</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Scenes of celebration after announcement of Pradhan’s resignations</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">On 25th July, the long anticipated news finally arrived - Dharmendra Pradhan has sent his resignation letter to the Prime Minister. A wave of joy made its way through the crowd when the news of resignation reached Jantar Mantar, which, until then had been heavy with the fatigue of the hunger strike and weariness of the lathi charge. Faces scrunched up in anger were now smiling ear to ear. Tired bodies were rejoicing. The streets of Jantar Mantar, which until the previous day had been the battlefield, had finally transformed into a theatre of victory.&nbsp;</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Mandeep Punia </em></strong><em>is a freelance journalist based in Haryana</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1785546898053-NYWMBY1PXZZYYE6OJXCA/DSC06894.jpg?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="1000"><media:title type="plain">GEN-Z Revolution: The India Chapter</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>From the Other Side of the Line</title><category>Interview</category><category>Pakistan</category><category>Kashmir</category><dc:creator>Hashim Bin Rashid</dc:creator><pubDate>Mon, 20 Jul 2026 12:00:37 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/from-the-other-side-of-the-line</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:6a4f4204cd24967cb46baa20</guid><description><![CDATA[A Kashmiri activist from Pakistan-administered Kashmir on their struggle 
for self-determination.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A Kashmiri activist from Pakistan-administered Kashmir on their struggle for self-determination.&nbsp;</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/27871c1e-2288-49ff-9031-8460be48c585/AJK+Protests.png" data-image-dimensions="2560x1440" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/27871c1e-2288-49ff-9031-8460be48c585/AJK+Protests.png?format=1000w" width="2560" height="1440" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/27871c1e-2288-49ff-9031-8460be48c585/AJK+Protests.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/27871c1e-2288-49ff-9031-8460be48c585/AJK+Protests.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/27871c1e-2288-49ff-9031-8460be48c585/AJK+Protests.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/27871c1e-2288-49ff-9031-8460be48c585/AJK+Protests.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/27871c1e-2288-49ff-9031-8460be48c585/AJK+Protests.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/27871c1e-2288-49ff-9031-8460be48c585/AJK+Protests.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/27871c1e-2288-49ff-9031-8460be48c585/AJK+Protests.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available image</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available image</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>In 2023, Kashmiris in Pakistan-administered Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK) came together to form the Jammu Kashmir Joint Awami Action Committee (JAAC), rallying behind a 38-point Charter of Demands. These ranged from access to subsidized food rations to greater democratic governance and control over the region’s economic development. When the government stalled on implementing these demands, the committee answered with a wave of strikes and demonstrations, first in 2024, then again in 2025 and most recently this June. On June 4, the AJK government declared JAAC a proscribed organization.&nbsp;</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Jamhoor editor Hashim bin Rashid interviewed an activist from JAAC, kept anonymous for security reasons, about the protests and political repression in Kashmir.&nbsp;</em></p>


  









&nbsp;

  <hr />
  

  




&nbsp;
  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Hashim (H): What is the current situation in Pakistan-administered Kashmir?</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>&nbsp;</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Activist (A)</strong>: The public is deliberately not told about the history of the struggle. On September 29 2025, there were major protests in AJK, which culminated in a long march on October 1. On October 4, the government <a href="https://www.dawn.com/news/1946524">accepted</a> the Charter of Demands with a three-month timeline for implementation.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">JAAC announced a long march on June 9 of this year after there was no implementation of the October 4 agreement. On June 4, JAAC was declared a proscribed organization, and a government crackdown started on June 5. Protestors were fired upon.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: What is the history of JAAC? How did it emerge?&nbsp;</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A: </strong>Over the last decade, various Awami (People’s) Action Committees emerged in AJK, spontaneously and simultaneously. Nationalist and progressive organizations kept facing crackdowns. We felt it was necessary to build a mass movement that brought together these different groups and committees, including traders and transporters.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In 2019, when India abolished Article 370 in Kashmir, there were protests and demonstrations in AJK. When the Pakistan government responded with repression, people became disillusioned. The people’s committees began to grow after this.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>When the Pakistan government responded with repression (towards protests against India’s revocation of Article 370), people became disillusioned. The people’s committees began to grow after this.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In 2023, a lot of the problems people were facing came to a head. Different divisions in AJK face different problems. In Mirpur, there was loadshedding. Promises were made when Mangla Dam was built to provide free electricity to Mirpur, which is a hotter region. Yet the price of electricity increased significantly. In the Poonch district, the price and allocation of wheat became a major issue. In August 2023, there were local sit-ins around these issues, which spread across AJK. People began to burn electricity bills.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In September 2023, the people leading the protests at the tehsil (sub-district) level came together to form JAAC, with the action committees working under this structure. We called for a wheat subsidy and the creation of a “national electricity grid.” A 10-point agenda around electricity was created, which included the tariffs and renegotiating royalties.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">On May 11 2024, JAAC had another long march towards Muzaffarabad. On May 13, the government accepted the demand for the price of electricity to be reduced to half. We demanded that this should be ratified constitutionally. After the long march, in October 2024, the government issued a presidential ordinance that imposed restrictions on the right to assembly, allowing only “registered organizations” to protest. This was essentially directed against JAAC and its action committees.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">On December 5 2024, large demonstrations and sit-ins blocked major entry points across AJK to demand implementation of the 10-point charter. When the government refused, JAAC returned to the people and expanded its demands. That process of consultation gave rise to the movement of September 29 2025, whose 38-point charter we are now fighting to see implemented.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: The movement has used the slogan, “Haq-i-Malikiyat, Haq-i-Hukmarani” (Right to Ownership, Right to Governance). What do these mean in the context of AJK?</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong><em> Haq-ie-Malikiyat</em> is the right to our resources. We want the implementation of the 2019 AJK High Court ruling to renegotiate all hydropower projects with the Pakistan government, and greater say in future infrastructure projects.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The demand for <em>Haq-i-Hukmarani</em> is about our right to represent and govern ourselves. The AJK government has long been controlled through reserved seats. Of the 53 seats in the AJK assembly, 12 are reserved for Kashmiri refugees residing across Pakistan. There are also 8 reserved seats for women, technocrats and ulema. These seats are often used to control the AJK government from the Centre.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The Centre has the ability to take down the government. In 2006-2011, there were four prime ministers. Between 2011-2026, there were another four prime ministers. The people feel that the AJK governments are being manipulated from the Center. One of our main demands is to end the 12 reserved seats.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">There is also another issue. Gilgit Baltistan, which is a key part of Kashmir, has no seats in the assembly. For almost 80 years, Gilgit Baltistan has been separated from AJK.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: Does the movement prioritize any of the demands?&nbsp;</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="is-empty"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> The demands fall into different categories. Some are broader, like removing government bureaucratic privileges and abolishing the refugee seats. Others have a more local impact, like calls for health units and CT scan machines. Other demands concern infrastructure and development projects.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">There is a long history behind some of these demands. One example is the demand for the construction of Shountar Tunnel to connect Gilgit-Baltistan to the Neelum Valley and Muzaffarabad. Historically, the princely state of Jammu Kashmir had routes to Gilgit Baltistan. After Gilgit Baltistan went to the Pakistan federation, the routes between GB and AJK were deliberately destroyed to break the connection between the people and their struggles. In 2008, the National Student Federation took out a “wahdat [unity] march” to restore these routes. During this march, the government killed two young protestors.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>The demand for the construction of Shountar Tunnel asks for restoration routes between Gilgit Baltistan and AJK, which were deliberately destroyed to break the connection between the people and their struggles.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Similarly, we demand the construction of the Azadparan Road, because a dam was built without a proper survey, rendering the road unusable and damaging the surrounding land. This demand is about infrastructure, but also about climate and the environment. Since the 2019 earthquakes, in which a focal point was Mirpur, there has been a call for a geological survey to assess if this seismic activity is linked to hydel pressure. A movement in Mirpur has developed around this demand.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/17291d5e-1c4b-49e3-9c6c-2e02404e89bb/Police+fires+on+AJK+protestors.png" data-image-dimensions="2560x1440" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/17291d5e-1c4b-49e3-9c6c-2e02404e89bb/Police+fires+on+AJK+protestors.png?format=1000w" width="2560" height="1440" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/17291d5e-1c4b-49e3-9c6c-2e02404e89bb/Police+fires+on+AJK+protestors.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/17291d5e-1c4b-49e3-9c6c-2e02404e89bb/Police+fires+on+AJK+protestors.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/17291d5e-1c4b-49e3-9c6c-2e02404e89bb/Police+fires+on+AJK+protestors.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/17291d5e-1c4b-49e3-9c6c-2e02404e89bb/Police+fires+on+AJK+protestors.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/17291d5e-1c4b-49e3-9c6c-2e02404e89bb/Police+fires+on+AJK+protestors.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/17291d5e-1c4b-49e3-9c6c-2e02404e89bb/Police+fires+on+AJK+protestors.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/17291d5e-1c4b-49e3-9c6c-2e02404e89bb/Police+fires+on+AJK+protestors.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Police firing tear gas to disperse protestors during the October 2025 protests in Muzaffarabad. Image: Naseer ud Din/Reuters</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Police firing tear gas to disperse protestors during the October 2025 protests in Muzaffarabad. Image: Naseer ud Din/Reuters</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: What is the current state of the crackdown?&nbsp;Are there any negotiations?</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A: </strong>It is a complete crackdown. Those traders who kept their shops shut are being picked up. Traders have been forced to open shops. There are no formal negotiations taking place. Maulana Fazal ur Rehman and Hafiz Naeem have offered to intervene. JAAC has written to them, accepting their mediation. The AJK Bar Council Committee also approached the government and JAAC with an offer to mediate talks.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">We do have a history of negotiating with the government. The October 4 agreement created three committees where government officials met JAAC members. The last committee meeting was the week before JAAC was declared a banned organization.&nbsp;<br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: What has been the role of the AJK Assembly in the movement?&nbsp;</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> The tenure of the current AJK Assembly was completed in June of this year. On June 8, the election schedule was announced with elections on July 27.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">When the assembly is in session, the AJK prime minister holds limited authority. Real power is usually split between the inspector general and the chief secretary of AJK, both of whom are Pakistani appointees who answer to Islamabad. They don’t listen to the AJK prime minister. With the assembly now out of session, that power rests with the election commissioner.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">It was the AJK inspector general who asked for <a href="https://www.dawn.com/news/2005470">more police support against JAAC,</a> which led to 14,000 personnel being deployed. The AJK Interior Ministry issued the notification declaring JAAC a banned organization.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Before the end of its term, the last resolution presented in the AJK Assembly was for talks with JAAC. In previous talks, the AJK prime minister appointed two cabinet members in the committees, but they had no power.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This is where the demand for <em>Haq-i-Hukmarani</em> comes from. We have no autonomy. AJK is governed by the Karachi Agreement of 1949 and the Interim Constitutional Act of 1974, both of which give more power to the Government of Pakistan. The AJK Assembly has limited power to finance infrastructure projects. The development budget is under Rs50 billion. JAAC has also demanded that the role of the bureaucracy be restricted. AJK is a small territory, but there are over 100,000 government officials who get significant perks. Despite JAAC calling for a reduction of these perks, the AJK Assembly approved an increase of perks for bureaucrats.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In this context, JAAC has taken up the role of a true people’s assembly.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6af20255-b5a6-4164-8c47-74ffe0a62569/JAAC+protest+2026.png" data-image-dimensions="2560x1440" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6af20255-b5a6-4164-8c47-74ffe0a62569/JAAC+protest+2026.png?format=1000w" width="2560" height="1440" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6af20255-b5a6-4164-8c47-74ffe0a62569/JAAC+protest+2026.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6af20255-b5a6-4164-8c47-74ffe0a62569/JAAC+protest+2026.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6af20255-b5a6-4164-8c47-74ffe0a62569/JAAC+protest+2026.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6af20255-b5a6-4164-8c47-74ffe0a62569/JAAC+protest+2026.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6af20255-b5a6-4164-8c47-74ffe0a62569/JAAC+protest+2026.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6af20255-b5a6-4164-8c47-74ffe0a62569/JAAC+protest+2026.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6af20255-b5a6-4164-8c47-74ffe0a62569/JAAC+protest+2026.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Protests during the recent JAAC strike in Neelum Valley, AJK. Image: Naseer ud Din/Reuters</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Protests during the recent JAAC strike in Neelum Valley, AJK. Image: Naseer ud Din/Reuters</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: The government of Pakistan has highlighted the demand for removing the 12 refugee seats as the only remaining controversial point. It also claims that conceding to this demand would undermine the case for a united Kashmir. How does JAAC address this criticism?&nbsp;</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> The Pakistan government claims to have accepted 36 of JAAC’s demands, but says it cannot accept the demand to abolish the 12 refugee seats because it is unconstitutional. It has also presented this as the movement’s only demand, declaring it will not accept this demand to protect the Kashmir freedom movement. This is a narrative war, which they have used to argue that the mobilization is “India-funded.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">First, they need to present evidence of accepting the first 36 demands. Second, there is broad consensus in AJK around the refugee seats. If you listen to speeches made at the people’s assemblies, speakers talk about rights and autonomy for AJK. Even the AJK politicians agreed that refugee seats have been used to derail the AJK assembly. They have changed their position under pressure.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The Pakistan People’s Party AJK president Chaudhry Mohammad Yasin agrees that the refugee seats are a problem, but they need to be proportionate. He has argued that elections for such seats should take place inside AJK, and it is the political parties inside AJK who should be allocated the refugee seats.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">If someone does not live in a territory, if they do not pay taxes, if they are not resident there — how can they be their representatives? Seats in the AJK assembly are won by receiving over 50,000 votes. Some refugee seats are won by receiving 500-1000 votes. The refugee members of the assembly are given equal status with those who ran a full campaign. This is without getting into the issue of whether they have a genuine domicile in Kashmir.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: Is there a history of mobilizations against the refugee seats?&nbsp;</strong><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> Yes, Kashmiri nationalists, such as the Jammu Kashmir Liberation Front and National Student Federation, have demanded the abolition of refugee seats since the 1980s. The core leadership of the Pakistan People’s Party has also asked for reform. Usually, the party that loses from these seats brings up the demand.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Within JAAC, the demand arose because of the conduct of refugee assembly members on the implementation committees, where they behaved in threatening ways. JAAC first demanded that no refugee member sit on the negotiating committees. The expanded charter then went further, calling for the removal of the refugee seats altogether. It was considered important for Kashmir’s political autonomy.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: Let’s talk in more detail about the demand for “Haq-i-Malkiyat.” What does it include?&nbsp;</strong><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A: </strong><em>Haq-i-Malkiyat</em> means local control over land, forests, and water. It is the right of indigenous people to improve their lives. Currently, all infrastructure projects planned for AJK require seeking funds from Pakistan, since the AJK assembly has no revenue other than land revenue and other small local taxes.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Through this right, we want control over our resources to shape our development and progress in AJK. This would be a local developmental, rather than an imperialist, model.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">There is a narrative in Pakistan that Kashmiris take our resources. This is wrong. Kashmiris don’t get fair contracts for their resources. Some resources don’t even have contracts. Others are still on the Centre’s old terms. For example, Mangla Dam royalties are still at the old rates. JAAC has asked for the implementation of the 2019 AJK court decision to renegotiate contracts for hydropower resources.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: There is a long history of grievances and negotiations around hydropower projects in AJK.&nbsp;</strong><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> When Mangla Dam was built, it submerged the historic city of Mirpur. There is a narrative that Pakistan settled Mirpuris in the United Kingdom. This is incorrect. Mirpuris began settling in the United Kingdom since World War 2. There are lots of books on this. After Miripuris were displaced because of the dam, many moved to the UK through their own initiative.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">There was even more displacement during the 2011 Mangla Dam Raising Project, where compensation was low. People were given Rs. 1.5-2 million, which neither allowed them to buy land or build a house. The Mangla Dam resettlement agreement used the term, zelli kunba (sub-family), to resettle the parents and children separately.&nbsp; This was not done. This remains a core demand of the Mirpur Action Committee. People settled on government lands have also not been given land ownership. There is also a demand for a survey of whether Mangla Dam is causing earthquakes in Mirpur. This is what happens when there is development from above.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Similarly, the Neelum-Jhelum Project created a major water problem for the people of Muzaffarabad. The Muzaffarabad Action Committee leadership comes from the Darya Bachao Tehreek (Save the River Movement), which was active in 2016-2017, whose demand was: “Save the river to save Muzaffarabad’s water.” There have been people’s mobilizations against infrastructure and development projects led from the Centre.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: How did the abrogation of Article 370 in Indian-occupied Kashmir influence AJK activism?&nbsp;</strong><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> In 2019, when Article 370 was abrogated in India, there were a few marches towards the Line of Control, where the slogan was: “Ye Khooni Lakerain Torni Hain” (Break Down These Bloody Lines).&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>The long marches towards the Line of Control in 2019 created a new form, content and dynamism in AJK politics. People had reservations over Pakistan’s response and began to assert their Kashmiriyat.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The turning point was the formation of the People’s National Alliance. AJK nationalists have demanded freedom for Indian-occupied Kashmir, but without connecting it to local issues. In 2019, the alliance began a march towards Muzaffarabad, demanding downsizing the AJK bureacracy. There was a crackdown against the march.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This became the basis for the idea that if we are to engage in a national struggle then we will need to connect with local struggles. People were already organizing on local issues. This led to the end of the People’s National Alliance and the emergence of the non-party civil society alliance of JAAC.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The long marches towards the Line of Control in 2019 created a new form, content and dynamism in AJK politics. People had reservations over Pakistan’s response and began to assert their Kashmiriyat (Kashmiri identity).</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: How does the class composition of AJK shape the protests?&nbsp;</strong><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong> In AJK, the class structure is that of a periphery. The local population does not control its resources. There is no big industry. It has been kept de-industrialized. In the small cottage industries in Mirpur and Kotri, workers are usually from Punjab. This means there is no Kashmiri industrial working class.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">There is a strong small merchant class. Traders get goods from Pakistan and sell them in Kashmir. Traders have had a very important role in shutter down strikes and building economic pressure. In the last five-ten years, there has been a big influx of brands in Kashmir. This has impacted local trade since they cannot compete. They have been feeling disempowered.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">There is also a large migrant working class in Kashmir. One or two people from each family work in Pakistan, the Gulf, or the United Kingdom. There is a class and ideological differentiation between them. The Mirpur working class became connected to British working class politics and Labor Party activism, which has an influence in AJK. Some of them became elite, but most of them are still working class there. There are connections between the Kashmiri migrant workers and JAAC around nationalist and indigenous politics.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Locally, the heart of the resistance is in the Poonch district, which is a periphery within AJK. Moreover, the movement is stronger in the peripheries of each major city in AJK, where there is no agricultural development. People practice small-scale agriculture with some feudal remnants, and can barely run their household expenses. Someone from each family has to become a migrant worker. Moreover, there remain food shortages in AJK since local agriculture is not sufficient. There is some bigger agriculture downstream from Mangla Dam, which only supplies part of the local diet, but even then, food has to be imported.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/30a1ebd6-0a94-4898-bbea-eb2dacb2b2fb/05232056241da8b.webp" data-image-dimensions="2000x1199" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/30a1ebd6-0a94-4898-bbea-eb2dacb2b2fb/05232056241da8b.webp?format=1000w" width="2000" height="1199" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/30a1ebd6-0a94-4898-bbea-eb2dacb2b2fb/05232056241da8b.webp?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/30a1ebd6-0a94-4898-bbea-eb2dacb2b2fb/05232056241da8b.webp?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/30a1ebd6-0a94-4898-bbea-eb2dacb2b2fb/05232056241da8b.webp?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/30a1ebd6-0a94-4898-bbea-eb2dacb2b2fb/05232056241da8b.webp?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/30a1ebd6-0a94-4898-bbea-eb2dacb2b2fb/05232056241da8b.webp?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/30a1ebd6-0a94-4898-bbea-eb2dacb2b2fb/05232056241da8b.webp?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/30a1ebd6-0a94-4898-bbea-eb2dacb2b2fb/05232056241da8b.webp?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Supporters of the Joint Awami Action Committee (JAAC) continue their protest while mourning a demonstrator who was killed during the October 2025 strike. Image: Reuters</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Supporters of the Joint Awami Action Committee (JAAC) continue their protest while mourning a demonstrator who was killed during the October 2025 strike. Image: Reuters</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: Are there any class contradictions?&nbsp;</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A:</strong>&nbsp; While the AJK middle class is part of the movement, it has a mixed role, since it tends towards reformism and opportunism. Middle class ideologies make the movement spontaneous and non-party based.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The opportunistic elements comes from this non-ideological space. The AJK elite is generally comprador due to its relationship with the Pakistani establishment. For example, early on, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI)’s cadre began to connect to JAAC, but then it separated itself from the movement after the central leadership put pressure on their political workers.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>H: What do you think will be the future of people’s struggles in AJK?&nbsp;</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>The most popular slogan today is, “Shuhada ke Khoon se Inqilab Aae Ga, Masjid ke Minaron se, Inqilab Aae Ga” (The Revolution Will Come).<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A: </strong>The movement has become more progressive over time. The most popular slogan today is, “Shuhada ke Khoon se Inqilab Aae Ga, Masjid ke Minaron se, Inqilab Aae Ga” (The Revolution Will Come). There is deeper penetration of the movement within the broad Kashmiri masses.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Earlier, women would only come out for protests in Mirpur. In Pooch, even in a mobilization of over 10,000 people, there used to be only one or two female lawyers. Now, there is a huge amount of women in both big and local rallies. Even in the so-called “backward” areas, women’s participation is high.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The form of protest has also evolved in AJK. Local action committees are organizing different types of gatherings. This is creating a new culture. In the areas where there is water logging, there are events around this. Areas where there is displacement and lack of ownership rights, there is organizing around these.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Generally, a spontaneous movement creates a more reformist narrative, but the movement in AJK is moving towards a more transformative narrative. Different committees were formed, which included writers, workers, and women. The writers would organize literary events and festivals. Labor committees organized workers. These, of course, have their own histories.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In the future, the AJK movement will need to organize deeper given the governing classes they face. It is currently a mass movement with lacks ideological training and revolutionary organization. However, through its expansion, the consciousness among Kashmiris of being colonized, of being in an occupied region, is growing.&nbsp;</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Hashim bin Rashid </em></strong><em>is a member of the Jamhoor editorial collective, and teaches on the environment and social movements at the University of Pennsylvania.&nbsp;</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/27871c1e-2288-49ff-9031-8460be48c585/AJK+Protests.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">From the Other Side of the Line</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>“Imprisonment Will Only Make Our Movement Stronger:” Mahrang Baloch Speaks from Prison</title><category>Pakistan</category><category>Interview</category><dc:creator>Akbar Notezai</dc:creator><pubDate>Mon, 29 Jun 2026 12:39:50 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/imprisonment-will-only-make-our-movement-stronger-mahrang-baloch-speaks-from-prison</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:6a426796f504d3288e5798d6</guid><description><![CDATA[Mahrang Baloch speaks about her experience in solitary confinement in Hudda 
District Prison, Quetta.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Baloch political activist Mahrang Baloch speaks about her experience in solitary confinement in Hudda District Prison, Quetta. </em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/280f263e-3c61-4e8b-aeeb-aa4d13965164/Mahrang" data-image-dimensions="5120x2880" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/280f263e-3c61-4e8b-aeeb-aa4d13965164/Mahrang?format=1000w" width="5120" height="2880" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/280f263e-3c61-4e8b-aeeb-aa4d13965164/Mahrang?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/280f263e-3c61-4e8b-aeeb-aa4d13965164/Mahrang?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/280f263e-3c61-4e8b-aeeb-aa4d13965164/Mahrang?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/280f263e-3c61-4e8b-aeeb-aa4d13965164/Mahrang?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/280f263e-3c61-4e8b-aeeb-aa4d13965164/Mahrang?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/280f263e-3c61-4e8b-aeeb-aa4d13965164/Mahrang?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/280f263e-3c61-4e8b-aeeb-aa4d13965164/Mahrang?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available images</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available images</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><em>A Pakistani Anti-Terrorism Court sentenced Dr. Mahrang Baloch and Sibghatullah Shah to life imprisonment on 22 June 2026 in what has widely been recognized as political victimization and an attempt to silence Baloch voices demanding accountability from the Pakistani state. </em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><em>We are republishing a recent interview with her that originally appeared in </em><a target="_blank" href="https://www.indexoncensorship.org/2026/06/dr-mahrang-balochs-prison-reads-the-books-that-have-inspired-her/"><em>Index on Censorship</em></a><em>.</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><em>For further background on the Baloch Yakjehti Committee, which Mahrang Baloch leads, see </em><a target="_blank" href="https://www.jamhoor.org/read/voices-of-baloch-nationalism-a-conversation-with-mahrang-baloch"><em>our 2024 interview</em></a><em> with her. For a longer history of the Baloch national struggle, see this </em><a target="_blank" href="https://www.jamhoor.org/read/nothing-less-than-decolonization-the-baloch-national-struggle"><em>piece</em></a><em>. </em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal is-empty"><strong>What conditions do you face inside the jail in Quetta?</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal is-empty">I am being held in solitary confinement in Barrack No. 9 of Hudda Jail alongside my two political colleagues, Beebow Baloch and Gulzadi Baloch. Despite the existence of a separate ward for female prisoners, we have deliberately been kept isolated in a separate barrack. Over the past 14 months, my meetings have been severely restricted, limited only to a few family members and lawyers, even though the jail manual places no such restrictions on prisoners’ visitation rights. This is a clear and continuous violation of my fundamental rights.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>The cases against me and other BYC leaders are political in nature. The jail trial is being used as a tool to increase pressure on us, weaken our movement, and further strengthen the atmosphere of fear and repression in Balochistan.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Families of forcibly disappeared persons and ordinary people from across Balochistan come to meet us, but they are stopped at the prison gate. The primary purpose of this is to isolate us from our people, weaken our resistance, and disconnect us ideologically and politically from the Baloch national movement.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Restrictions were also imposed on our access to books. I was denied permission to bring books from my personal library into the jail. After continuous protests, this restriction was temporarily lifted. However, even today, whenever we require new books, we are once again subjected to the same obstacles and harsh restrictions.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In October 2025, our court trial proceedings were shifted inside the jail, and our jail trial began, a move that constitutes a blatant violation of the fundamental principles of a fair trial. All the cases filed against us are politically motivated, unjust, and based on bad faith. Despite this, we continued to hope for justice through the judiciary. For the past year, the Anti-Terrorism Court (ATC) has conducted our cases in a highly biased manner. In February, we formally requested the replacement of the judge due to concerns regarding his partiality. However, despite no decision being made on that application, the proceedings against us have continued, creating a serious obstacle to the delivery of justice.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63659d27-b0df-4677-9381-323da38f68d4/663cb74c8c4d5.webp" data-image-dimensions="870x613" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63659d27-b0df-4677-9381-323da38f68d4/663cb74c8c4d5.webp?format=1000w" width="870" height="613" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63659d27-b0df-4677-9381-323da38f68d4/663cb74c8c4d5.webp?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63659d27-b0df-4677-9381-323da38f68d4/663cb74c8c4d5.webp?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63659d27-b0df-4677-9381-323da38f68d4/663cb74c8c4d5.webp?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63659d27-b0df-4677-9381-323da38f68d4/663cb74c8c4d5.webp?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63659d27-b0df-4677-9381-323da38f68d4/663cb74c8c4d5.webp?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63659d27-b0df-4677-9381-323da38f68d4/663cb74c8c4d5.webp?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/63659d27-b0df-4677-9381-323da38f68d4/663cb74c8c4d5.webp?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Mahrang Baloch speaks at a BYC rally. Source: Baloch Yakjehti Committee.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Because the trial is being conducted inside the jail, journalists and members of civil society in Balochistan have also been denied access to our hearings, which constitutes another violation of fair trial standards.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The cases against me and other BYC leaders are political in nature. The jail trial is being used as a tool to increase pressure on us, weaken our movement, and further strengthen the atmosphere of fear and repression in Balochistan.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Can solitary confinement break your spirit?</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">For the past year, I have been held in solitary confinement in Hudda Jail. We are being kept in isolation in an attempt to separate us from our organization and movement and to subject us to psychological pressure. The barrack where we are imprisoned was originally built to punish dangerous and high-profile prisoners. Our meetings and communication have been severely restricted, yet solitary confinement cannot weaken me, because for me, prison and torture have become symbols of resistance. Unlike ordinary prisoners, these experiences carry a very different meaning in my life.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">My childhood was shaped under the shadow of state torture cells while witnessing my father’s struggle for freedom. My father, Ghaffar Baloch, was once imprisoned in the same jail where I would come carrying Eid cards to meet him. The towering prison walls and its multiple iron gates felt like terrifying nightmares to me. The state torture cells, where thousands of forcibly disappeared Baloch were detained, always remained alive in my imagination. Every night, I would mentally reconstruct those dark spaces in my mind.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">When my father was released after his third enforced disappearance, the stories of torture he shared became permanently engraved in my memory. I would often imagine the darkness of those torture cells, the condition of a revolutionary from his purpose, the unbearable reality of state violence, and the point where a person begins to pray for death every single day. The sound of every door opening would make one’s body tremble in fear, wondering if the next round of torture was about to begin.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">After my father was extrajudicially killed, I carried a deep desire to one day see the torture cell where he had been held. I constantly wondered how he spent his final moments and what suffering he endured. From that moment onward, I made it the purpose of my life to work for the freedom of every individual trapped in such torture cells.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">When I joined the struggle against enforced disappearances, my pain found meaning. I had finally discovered the purpose of my life, to continue on this path and endure every hardship became my source of strength and fulfillment. Whenever we grew exhausted during sit-ins or long marches, we reminded ourselves of the young people from our nation who were enduring torture inside secret detention cells for the future and dignity of our people.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Whenever someone was released from a torture cell, I felt the same joy I once felt upon my father’s release. I always made sure to meet them. The part of my mind once occupied only by the images of my father’s mutilated body and wounded face gradually became filled with the faces of those newly freed Baloch youth, faces that never allowed me to stop.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e22b8a4-ab02-4868-85a8-f74cb154d183/732116687_1327366942862996_7229214909666173671_n.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1280x960" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e22b8a4-ab02-4868-85a8-f74cb154d183/732116687_1327366942862996_7229214909666173671_n.jpg?format=1000w" width="1280" height="960" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e22b8a4-ab02-4868-85a8-f74cb154d183/732116687_1327366942862996_7229214909666173671_n.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e22b8a4-ab02-4868-85a8-f74cb154d183/732116687_1327366942862996_7229214909666173671_n.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e22b8a4-ab02-4868-85a8-f74cb154d183/732116687_1327366942862996_7229214909666173671_n.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e22b8a4-ab02-4868-85a8-f74cb154d183/732116687_1327366942862996_7229214909666173671_n.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e22b8a4-ab02-4868-85a8-f74cb154d183/732116687_1327366942862996_7229214909666173671_n.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e22b8a4-ab02-4868-85a8-f74cb154d183/732116687_1327366942862996_7229214909666173671_n.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e22b8a4-ab02-4868-85a8-f74cb154d183/732116687_1327366942862996_7229214909666173671_n.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Source: Baloch Yakjehti Committee (BYC)</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Whenever I began a difficult campaign, I would tell myself that if even one forcibly disappeared person was freed because of our efforts, then that alone would be our greatest success. All other hardships would become meaningless.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Becoming part of this struggle allowed me to heal, because this movement gave meaning and purpose to our collective pain and national suffering. That is why solitary confinement and prison cannot break me. Since the earliest days of my struggle, torture cells and isolation have represented symbols of resistance for me. For the Baloch people, they have become symbols of defiance against oppression.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This solitary confinement has become a place where we write, study the struggles of people around the world, and strengthen our political consciousness. Our imprisonment will only make our movement stronger and will continue to inspire and mobilize our people in new ways.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Has it affected you physically and emotionally?</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Over the past 14 months in solitary confinement, combined with restricted movement and delays in receiving medical care, I have been suffering since October from severe back pain and radiculopathy. Due to the lack of timely diagnosis and proper medical treatment, I was forced to rely on self-medication, which further worsened my condition. In February 2026, I was eventually transferred to a hospital, where I was diagnosed with Lumbar Disc Prolapse. Despite this diagnosis, I am still being denied proper medical treatment, including physiotherapy, which is an essential part of my recovery.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Solitary confinement can leave deep physical and psychological impacts on political prisoners. The state’s objective is not merely to punish us, but also to weaken our revolutionary identity, morale, and political resistance. However, I believe that the truth and legitimacy of our cause give us the strength to endure state repression.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Our struggle is aimed at ending every form of state oppression, and it is for this purpose that we continue to endure inhumane conditions such as solitary confinement. By imprisoning us, the state seeks to spread fear among the people. Yet even within these prison walls, through our resilience and determination, we want to show our people that oppressed nations can continue to resist state violence effectively, even in their weakest moments.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Our philosophy of resistance is the result of decades of struggle by our people for justice, peace, and survival on our own land. No prison or torture cell can weaken that conviction.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>Our struggle is aimed at ending every form of state oppression, and it is for this purpose that we continue to endure inhumane conditions such as solitary confinement. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">When states choose repression and force over tolerance for dissent, they cease to become institutions of justice and instead turn into instruments of fear. But fear is always temporary. Genuine people’s movements eventually overcome it, and that same fear ultimately transforms into a source of strength for the people.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">State repression has made people fearless. The killing of innocent individuals and the constant demand for justice have deepened public political consciousness. This is the purpose shared by me and every Baloch political activist: that our people understand the importance of collective strength, resistance, and political awareness.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">If my solitary confinement helps strengthen that purpose, then I will endure this imprisonment with pride and even greater determination.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>What role does the BYC play in Balochistan?</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The BYC is an indigenous movement of Balochistan. Following the implementation of the “kill and dump” policy in Balochistan since 2009, the state launched a severe crackdown on active political parties and movements. Over the past two decades, thousands of innocent Baloch people have been killed as a result of state repression. In such circumstances, there was an urgent need for a strong public movement against what many Baloch view as an ongoing genocide.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This period represents one of the harshest phases of repression in Balochistan, as even women and children were no longer safe from state violence. It was under these conditions that the BYC emerged. Beginning with resistance protests across Balochistan, the movement gradually evolved into a broad public movement that gained widespread support throughout the region.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/46ed9a8f-aea5-4771-aa50-caef2a043a7d/Screenshot+2026-06-29+at+2.11.15%E2%80%AFPM.png" data-image-dimensions="816x526" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/46ed9a8f-aea5-4771-aa50-caef2a043a7d/Screenshot+2026-06-29+at+2.11.15%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=1000w" width="816" height="526" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/46ed9a8f-aea5-4771-aa50-caef2a043a7d/Screenshot+2026-06-29+at+2.11.15%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/46ed9a8f-aea5-4771-aa50-caef2a043a7d/Screenshot+2026-06-29+at+2.11.15%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/46ed9a8f-aea5-4771-aa50-caef2a043a7d/Screenshot+2026-06-29+at+2.11.15%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/46ed9a8f-aea5-4771-aa50-caef2a043a7d/Screenshot+2026-06-29+at+2.11.15%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/46ed9a8f-aea5-4771-aa50-caef2a043a7d/Screenshot+2026-06-29+at+2.11.15%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/46ed9a8f-aea5-4771-aa50-caef2a043a7d/Screenshot+2026-06-29+at+2.11.15%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/46ed9a8f-aea5-4771-aa50-caef2a043a7d/Screenshot+2026-06-29+at+2.11.15%E2%80%AFPM.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Mahrang Baloch addresses a protest in Gwadar, Balochistan. Source: Baloch Yakjehti Committee (BYC). </em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The BYC has played a central role in documenting human rights violations and advocating for national and political rights in Balochistan. Under the pretext of security concerns, international human rights organizations have largely been denied access to the region. Representatives of the Working Group on Enforced or Involuntary Disappearances have not been granted permission to visit Balochistan for the past 15 years, preventing independent observation and reporting on ongoing human rights abuses. Similarly, many international institutions have failed to provide effective reporting on the situation in Balochistan.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In this environment, the BYC has simultaneously functioned as both a human rights organization and a civil rights movement. It organized major public gatherings such as the March Against Baloch Genocide, the Raji Muchi, and the Dalbandin gathering. Each of these mass assemblies served as a public referendum against the state’s repressive policies, bringing together people from every segment of Baloch society, including elders, women, students, and youth.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Alongside organizing sit-ins and public demonstrations, the BYC has also become one of the most active bodies documenting and reporting human rights violations in Balochistan. In 2025 alone, the BYC collected data on 1,250 cases of enforced disappearances. This work was carried out while the organization itself was facing an intense state crackdown, with much of its central leadership imprisoned and many activists subjected to harassment and intimidation.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Through political mobilization within a short period of time, the BYC succeeded in raising national political consciousness among the Baloch people and bringing international attention to the suffering of Balochistan. At the same time, the BYC leadership helped fill the vacuum in mass politics that had existed in Balochistan for nearly a decade.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The strong participation of women within the BYC also reflects the movement’s progressive political vision. Women were mobilized, educated about their fundamental rights, and encouraged to become active participants and leaders within the organization.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>What challenges did you face while promoting nonviolent resistance in Balochistan?</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Promoting nonviolent resistance and democratic political struggle in Balochistan is an extremely difficult task, because students, journalists, and human rights activists are routinely silenced through enforced disappearances, killings, and targeted violence carried out under state repression.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Peaceful political movements are often labeled as “anti-state” or “security threats,” and activists are subjected to profiling, harassment, arrests, and fabricated criminal cases. At present, more than 50 cases have been filed against me and other BYC leaders across Balochistan. Every protest organized by families of missing persons has resulted in cases being registered against us, which reflects the continuation of state policies aimed at suppressing freedom of expression and peaceful political dissent.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>Every protest organized by families of missing persons has resulted in cases being registered against us, which reflects the continuation of state policies aimed at suppressing freedom of expression and peaceful political dissent.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Even FIRs related to the actions of armed groups have been filed against peaceful political activists. This represents an extreme form of state brutality, where nonviolent political workers are deliberately linked to armed organizations in order to justify state violence and repression against them.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Despite all these pressures and hardships, the people of Balochistan have not abandoned peaceful politics. For the BYC, nonviolent resistance is not merely a political struggle; it is a continuous effort to create space for human rights, justice, and dialogue in an environment dominated by fear, silence, and repression.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Is book reading helping you overcome your isolation in solitary confinement?</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In solitary confinement, my greatest source of support has been my books, the memories of the Baloch resistance movement, and the courage of those who have endured repression before us. Books have strengthened my political consciousness, intellectual depth, and belief in resistance during this period of isolation. They have expanded my understanding and helped me remain connected to my inner strength despite physical confinement.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Much of our protest inside prison has centered around gaining access to books. Reading about revolutionary movements and political figures has given me the opportunity to reflect deeply on my own struggle, beliefs, and purpose in life. Through this process, I have been able to understand my mission with greater clarity.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Books have also helped me endure the weakest and most difficult moments of solitary confinement by giving me the capacity to better understand and carry the pain and suffering of my people.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Some of the books I have read during this period include:</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">1. Interview with History by Oriana Fallaci</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">2. The Writings of Mao</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">3. The Power of Habit by Charles Duhigg</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">4. Living My Life by Emma Goldman</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">5. Roots by Alex Haley</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">6. No Friend But the Mountains by Behrouz Boochani</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">7. The Political Thought of Abdullah Öcalan</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">8. The Geopolitics of Shaming: When Human Rights Pressure Works and When It Doesn’t</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">9. The Paradox of Repression and Nonviolent Movements</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">10. Indira Gandhi and the Year That Transformed India</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">11. Long walk to freedom Nelson Mandela</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">12. مہر افلاک (صورت خان مری)</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">13. The Song of youth by yang mo</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">14. World Order by Henry Kissinger</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">15. Prisoners of Geography by Tim Marshal</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">16. Resistance and Decolonisation by Amircarl Cabral</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">17. Men in the Sun by Ghassan Kanafani</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">18. Remotely Colonial by Nina Swidler</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">19. Back to the Future by Martin Axmann</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">20. Manufacturing Consent: the political economy of the mass media by (Noam Chomsky and E.S Herman)</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">21. Battle Ground by Christopher Phillips</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">22. بلوچ اور ان کا وطن (ڈاکٹر فاروق بلوچ)</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Dr. Mahrang Baloch</em></strong><em> is an activist and the leader of the Baloch Yakjehtee Committee.</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Akbar Notezai </em></strong><em>is a journalist from Quetta.</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br><em>Related content:</em></p><ol data-rte-list="default"><li><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><a href="https://www.jamhoor.org/read/voices-of-baloch-nationalism-a-conversation-with-mahrang-baloch"><em>Voices of Baloch Nationalism: A Conversation with Mahrang Baloch</em></a></p></li><li><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><a href="https://www.jamhoor.org/read/nothing-less-than-decolonization-the-baloch-national-struggle"><em>“Nothing Less than Decolonization”: The Baloch National Struggle</em></a></p></li></ol>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1782738851962-7EBZCJRYXQTH63X1CX5B/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">“Imprisonment Will Only Make Our Movement Stronger:” Mahrang Baloch Speaks from Prison</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>Asianism and Its Limits</title><category>India</category><category>Essay</category><dc:creator>Esmat Elhalaby</dc:creator><pubDate>Thu, 25 Jun 2026 13:00:08 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/asianism-and-its-limits</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:69c849b789a4ed3b6db6356b</guid><description><![CDATA[On contested dreams of pan-Asian unity—from Palestine to India and beyond.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>On contested dreams of pan-Asian unity—from Palestine to India and beyond.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/eb12ea50-1680-4ca7-a8e2-76852851f8be/Asianism+and+Its+Limits_header+-+Esmat.png" data-image-dimensions="1920x1080" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/eb12ea50-1680-4ca7-a8e2-76852851f8be/Asianism+and+Its+Limits_header+-+Esmat.png?format=1000w" width="1920" height="1080" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/eb12ea50-1680-4ca7-a8e2-76852851f8be/Asianism+and+Its+Limits_header+-+Esmat.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/eb12ea50-1680-4ca7-a8e2-76852851f8be/Asianism+and+Its+Limits_header+-+Esmat.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/eb12ea50-1680-4ca7-a8e2-76852851f8be/Asianism+and+Its+Limits_header+-+Esmat.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/eb12ea50-1680-4ca7-a8e2-76852851f8be/Asianism+and+Its+Limits_header+-+Esmat.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/eb12ea50-1680-4ca7-a8e2-76852851f8be/Asianism+and+Its+Limits_header+-+Esmat.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/eb12ea50-1680-4ca7-a8e2-76852851f8be/Asianism+and+Its+Limits_header+-+Esmat.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/eb12ea50-1680-4ca7-a8e2-76852851f8be/Asianism+and+Its+Limits_header+-+Esmat.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Book cover of <em>Parting Gifts of Empire</em>, by Esmat Elhalaby</p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Book cover of <em>Parting Gifts of Empire</em>, by Esmat Elhalaby</p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>This is an excerpt from Esmat Elhalaby’s </em><a href="https://www.ucpress.edu/books/parting-gifts-of-empire/paper"><em>Parting Gifts of Empire: Palestine and India at the Dawn of Decolonization</em></a><em> (University of California Press, 2025). An Indian edition was published this year by </em><a target="_blank" href="https://www.sanctumbooks.com/BookInfo/3787/9789395474979"><em>Sanctum Books</em></a><em>. </em><br><br>On the afternoon of February 5, 1947, members of the Egyptian Feminists Union huddled in the bedroom of an ailing Huda Shaarawi, doyen of the Arab women’s movement. A few days earlier the group had received an invitation to the Asian Relations Conference, and they were meeting to decide who would be dispatched to represent them. For the women assembled, the prospect of going to India was daunting. It was an unfamiliar place and would require a long journey by air. This scene is recounted in the memoirs of Hawaʾ Idris, a young cousin and mentee of Shaarawi’s. Idris summons a familiar trope: Arabs and Indians had long had a close relationship, and now was the time to renew it. The conference, she wrote, was a dream come true. “The pioneers of the nahda,” she exclaimed, “could not have imagined such an event would ever be organized.”</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4d9cf8bc-dff7-4aca-9f97-302385002ebf/Arab+Women%E2%80%99s+Conference.png" data-image-dimensions="470x445" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4d9cf8bc-dff7-4aca-9f97-302385002ebf/Arab+Women%E2%80%99s+Conference.png?format=1000w" width="470" height="445" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4d9cf8bc-dff7-4aca-9f97-302385002ebf/Arab+Women%E2%80%99s+Conference.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4d9cf8bc-dff7-4aca-9f97-302385002ebf/Arab+Women%E2%80%99s+Conference.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4d9cf8bc-dff7-4aca-9f97-302385002ebf/Arab+Women%E2%80%99s+Conference.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4d9cf8bc-dff7-4aca-9f97-302385002ebf/Arab+Women%E2%80%99s+Conference.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4d9cf8bc-dff7-4aca-9f97-302385002ebf/Arab+Women%E2%80%99s+Conference.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4d9cf8bc-dff7-4aca-9f97-302385002ebf/Arab+Women%E2%80%99s+Conference.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/4d9cf8bc-dff7-4aca-9f97-302385002ebf/Arab+Women%E2%80%99s+Conference.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Egyptian Feminist Union meeting for the First Arab Women’s Conference bureau election, under the leadership of Huda Sha’rawi. Image: Emily Ibrahim Fares, الحركة النسائية اللبنانية, Beirut: Dar al-Thaqafah, p. 94.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Egyptian Feminist Union meeting for the First Arab Women’s Conference bureau election, under the leadership of Huda Sha’rawi. Image: Emily Ibrahim Fares, الحركة النسائية اللبنانية, Beirut: Dar al-Thaqafah, p. 94.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Although Shaarawi herself was too ill to travel, she had already resolved that the group would send representatives to the conference. A woman by the name of ʿIsmat ʿIssam was the first to volunteer, offering to pay her own way and hoping to inspire another woman to join her. The meeting, however, was quickly derailed. Idris wrote that one participant in the meeting objected to attending the conference altogether. The intentions of the organizers, the unnamed woman said, needed to be interrogated. The women noted that Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the leader of the Muslim League, had just been in Cairo and warned that the conference was being boycotted by Indian Muslims and its organizers were hiding their anti-Muslim prejudices.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">A month and a half earlier, Jinnah had indeed stopped in Cairo on his way back from London. While there he met with prominent political figures, including the mufti of Jerusalem Amin al-Husseini and Muslim Brotherhood head Hassan al-Banna. Not everyone in Egypt was enthusiastic about his presence, however. The Wafd Party, long <a target="_blank" href="https://link.springer.com/book/10.1057/9780230339514">aligned</a> with the Indian National Congress, recounted in its newspaper that Jinnah’s “dependence on the British is not agreeable with Egypt’s great national principles.” Jinnah stoked Pan-Islamic anxieties when he proclaimed that “it is only when Pakistan is established that Indian and Egyptian Muslims will be really free; otherwise, there will be the menace of a Hindu Imperialist Raj spreading its tentacles right across the Middle East." A few days later, <em>Akhbar al-Youm</em> reported that Arab participation in the forthcoming Asian Relation Conference would mean “the virtual declaration of an Arab war on the Muslims of India!” Jinnah’s outrage had been sparked by Nehru’s <a target="_blank" href="https://archive.org/details/commonwealthnati0000mans">comments</a> in the Indian Constituent Assembly days earlier that India “has become—let us recognize it—leaders of the freedom movement of Asia, and whatever we do we should think of ourselves in these larger terms.”</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1209e7c9-c0ab-416f-b781-01bfb92d245a/Jinnah+with+arab+leaders_1946.jpg" data-image-dimensions="480x319" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1209e7c9-c0ab-416f-b781-01bfb92d245a/Jinnah+with+arab+leaders_1946.jpg?format=1000w" width="480" height="319" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1209e7c9-c0ab-416f-b781-01bfb92d245a/Jinnah+with+arab+leaders_1946.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1209e7c9-c0ab-416f-b781-01bfb92d245a/Jinnah+with+arab+leaders_1946.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1209e7c9-c0ab-416f-b781-01bfb92d245a/Jinnah+with+arab+leaders_1946.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1209e7c9-c0ab-416f-b781-01bfb92d245a/Jinnah+with+arab+leaders_1946.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1209e7c9-c0ab-416f-b781-01bfb92d245a/Jinnah+with+arab+leaders_1946.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1209e7c9-c0ab-416f-b781-01bfb92d245a/Jinnah+with+arab+leaders_1946.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1209e7c9-c0ab-416f-b781-01bfb92d245a/Jinnah+with+arab+leaders_1946.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Jinnah with Grand Mufti of Jerusalem Amin al-Husayni and other Palestinian and Egyptian delegates in Cairo, Egypt. Image: The Muslim Archive.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Jinnah with Grand Mufti of Jerusalem Amin al-Husayni and other Palestinian and Egyptian delegates in Cairo, Egypt. Image: The Muslim Archive.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Nevertheless, Idris was not convinced by Jinnah’s declarations. She rebuffed the other woman, claiming that press reports were not evidence enough for such claims and that Jinnah himself was an unreliable source. Her opponent was outraged that Idris would challenge such a “great leader.” Shaarawi broke up the fight and decided that reliable information must be obtained before moving forward. She enlisted Idris to contact the Foreign Ministry and the Egyptian consulate in Bombay to find out if the conference was actually an anti-Muslim affair, as it had been characterized. The fact-finding mission determined that everything was sound. The Egyptian Feminist Union was heading to India.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">· · ·</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2c31ca75-d41d-4c4d-90a0-b5ce236d160f/Screen%2BShot%2B2020-03-12%2Bat%2B12.06.16%2BPM.webp" data-image-dimensions="1007x1104" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2c31ca75-d41d-4c4d-90a0-b5ce236d160f/Screen%2BShot%2B2020-03-12%2Bat%2B12.06.16%2BPM.webp?format=1000w" width="1007" height="1104" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2c31ca75-d41d-4c4d-90a0-b5ce236d160f/Screen%2BShot%2B2020-03-12%2Bat%2B12.06.16%2BPM.webp?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2c31ca75-d41d-4c4d-90a0-b5ce236d160f/Screen%2BShot%2B2020-03-12%2Bat%2B12.06.16%2BPM.webp?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2c31ca75-d41d-4c4d-90a0-b5ce236d160f/Screen%2BShot%2B2020-03-12%2Bat%2B12.06.16%2BPM.webp?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2c31ca75-d41d-4c4d-90a0-b5ce236d160f/Screen%2BShot%2B2020-03-12%2Bat%2B12.06.16%2BPM.webp?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2c31ca75-d41d-4c4d-90a0-b5ce236d160f/Screen%2BShot%2B2020-03-12%2Bat%2B12.06.16%2BPM.webp?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2c31ca75-d41d-4c4d-90a0-b5ce236d160f/Screen%2BShot%2B2020-03-12%2Bat%2B12.06.16%2BPM.webp?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2c31ca75-d41d-4c4d-90a0-b5ce236d160f/Screen%2BShot%2B2020-03-12%2Bat%2B12.06.16%2BPM.webp?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Hawa Idris and Karima El-Said with Jawaharlal Nehru. Image: Sawt al-Sharq.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Hawa Idris and Karima El-Said with Jawaharlal Nehru. Image: Sawt al-Sharq.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1781975257091_16297" class="MsoNormal">ʿAbd al-Wahab al-ʿAzzam had himself long wished to go to India. He had a chance in the summer of 1939, when he was invited to attend a conference of Orientalists in Hyderabad, but the Second World War kept him away. After that lost opportunity, he recounts, his longing for India grew along with his “knowledge of its literature and languages.” Earlier in 1939, he had written a series of articles for the inaugural issues of the new Egyptian cultural weekly <em>al-Thaqafa</em>, titled “Islamic Literature of India,” which introduced the magazine’s readers to Mirza Ghalib and Muhammad Iqbal. Indeed, throughout the 1930s he wrote articles about Indian literature generally and Iqbal in particular for <em>al-Risala</em>. Azzam was Egypt’s premier Persianist and the founder of the Institute for Oriental Studies at Cairo University, where he had earned his doctorate in 1932 after receiving an MA at London’s School of Oriental Studies. As part of his doctoral dissertation, Azzam published the first full-length translation into Arabic of Ferdowsi’s epic <em>Shahnameh</em>. In March 1947, after years of longing and study, Azzam finally had his opportunity to go to India. The roster of Arabs, then, was filling up. With the Egyptian feminists Hawaʾ Idris and Karima al-Said, Azzam joined two more Egyptians at the Asian Relations Conference, including Mustafa Momin and Mustafa Kamal (the Egyptian consul in Bombay). A sixth Arab was also there, Lebanese politician Taqi al-Din al-Sulh, representing the Arab League.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Arab and Indian women activists regularly analogized their plight over the course of the twentieth century, in the face of a reticent international women’s movement headquartered in the West.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Arabs therefore shared the stage with Nehru, Sarojini Naidu, and Mohandas Gandhi in 1947, when thousands gathered on the grounds of the Old Fort in Delhi to witness the forging of new Asian relations. This Asian stage was already being shared by Arab feminists and their Indian counterparts in the years before the Asian relations conference. Arab women activists had participated in Indian Women’s Conferences in the 1940s, to powerful effect. And Shaarawi herself was well known and beloved by Indian nationalist leaders and writers. Anti-colonial feminism was one of a number of overlapping and sometimes competing forms of social and political thinking that inspired the 1947 conference’s participants. Arab and Indian women activists regularly analogized their plight over the course of the twentieth century, in the face of a reticent international women’s movement headquartered in the West.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594d3590-5cb9-43a5-9966-16a74cdda3de/Nehru-and-Gandhi-at-the-Asian-Relations-Conference-1947.png" data-image-dimensions="500x329" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594d3590-5cb9-43a5-9966-16a74cdda3de/Nehru-and-Gandhi-at-the-Asian-Relations-Conference-1947.png?format=1000w" width="500" height="329" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594d3590-5cb9-43a5-9966-16a74cdda3de/Nehru-and-Gandhi-at-the-Asian-Relations-Conference-1947.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594d3590-5cb9-43a5-9966-16a74cdda3de/Nehru-and-Gandhi-at-the-Asian-Relations-Conference-1947.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594d3590-5cb9-43a5-9966-16a74cdda3de/Nehru-and-Gandhi-at-the-Asian-Relations-Conference-1947.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594d3590-5cb9-43a5-9966-16a74cdda3de/Nehru-and-Gandhi-at-the-Asian-Relations-Conference-1947.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594d3590-5cb9-43a5-9966-16a74cdda3de/Nehru-and-Gandhi-at-the-Asian-Relations-Conference-1947.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594d3590-5cb9-43a5-9966-16a74cdda3de/Nehru-and-Gandhi-at-the-Asian-Relations-Conference-1947.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/594d3590-5cb9-43a5-9966-16a74cdda3de/Nehru-and-Gandhi-at-the-Asian-Relations-Conference-1947.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Nehru, Gandhi and Abdul Ghaffar Khan at the Asian Relations Conference in Delhi, 1947. Image: Wikimedia Commons.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Nehru, Gandhi and Abdul Ghaffar Khan at the Asian Relations Conference in Delhi, 1947. Image: Wikimedia Commons.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1781464066707_11568" class="MsoNormal">Meetings of “Eastern Women,” as they were known, took place throughout the first decades of the twentieth century. The days between the two world wars saw London, Paris, Brussels, and Berlin become hosts to many meetings Pan-African, Pan-Asian, and anti-imperialist in sentiment (some of them sponsored by the Comintern). But it was in those years immediately after the Second World War, accompanied as they were by the intensification of anti-colonial demands in the face of weakened, if belligerent, imperial powers in Europe, that postcolonial governments in waiting were finally able to collaborate on their own terms.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>The course of the proceedings themselves revealed the extent of the limits of Asia in world politics. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">In his indispensable, if partisan, history of nonalignment and Afro-Asia, G. H. Jansen, a journalist and onetime press attaché for the Indian embassy in Cairo, recognized the Delhi conference as the beginnings of a new kind of Pan-Asianism. Indeed, he <a href="https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.553420">called</a> it the “apex of Asianism.” “Never again,” he wrote, “would there be such a gushing outflow of the Asian spirit, pure and undefiled.” Despite this enthusiasm, however, the meeting seemed also to announce Asianism’s limits. The conflict between the Congress and the Muslim League revealed the limits of Asia in national affairs. “Thus,” announced London’s <em>Economist</em>, “the first consequence of a gathering theoretically aimed at promoting unity among Asiatics has been to add fuel to the flames of Indian civil strife.” Imperial observers were not the only critics. On the second day of the conference, after the fiery inaugural speeches, the great Indian Marxist and internationalist M. N. Roy released a manifesto casting doubt on the whole enterprise, titled “Asia and the World.” “Representatives of resurgent Asia! May you deserve the distinction! But the demonstration of fictious solidarity will not be enough,” Roy announced at the outset. He was an opponent of the capitalist and undemocratic composition of Nehru’s Indian National Congress. Nehru was, in Roy’s words, “the pale-pink pseudo-socialist idol of which today poses as the would-be liberator of Asia.” Unlike Europe, Roy argued, Asia was not a cultural unit, Japanese imperialism being a case in point. The course of the proceedings themselves revealed the extent of the limits of Asia in world politics. Two controversies in particular soured the mood. First was China’s disapproval of Tibet’s being invited as an independent delegation, an affair with lasting implications. The second controversy was a flare-up over the question of Palestine, an episode that would place the Arab delegates at the very center.</p>


  









&nbsp;

























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2e965b42-efab-41fc-90b0-6f1e816a4953/M.N-Roy-with-V.I-Lenin-1920-Picture-Photo-Credit-Frontline.jpg" data-image-dimensions="435x577" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2e965b42-efab-41fc-90b0-6f1e816a4953/M.N-Roy-with-V.I-Lenin-1920-Picture-Photo-Credit-Frontline.jpg?format=1000w" width="435" height="577" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 66.67vw, 66.67vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2e965b42-efab-41fc-90b0-6f1e816a4953/M.N-Roy-with-V.I-Lenin-1920-Picture-Photo-Credit-Frontline.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2e965b42-efab-41fc-90b0-6f1e816a4953/M.N-Roy-with-V.I-Lenin-1920-Picture-Photo-Credit-Frontline.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2e965b42-efab-41fc-90b0-6f1e816a4953/M.N-Roy-with-V.I-Lenin-1920-Picture-Photo-Credit-Frontline.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2e965b42-efab-41fc-90b0-6f1e816a4953/M.N-Roy-with-V.I-Lenin-1920-Picture-Photo-Credit-Frontline.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2e965b42-efab-41fc-90b0-6f1e816a4953/M.N-Roy-with-V.I-Lenin-1920-Picture-Photo-Credit-Frontline.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2e965b42-efab-41fc-90b0-6f1e816a4953/M.N-Roy-with-V.I-Lenin-1920-Picture-Photo-Credit-Frontline.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2e965b42-efab-41fc-90b0-6f1e816a4953/M.N-Roy-with-V.I-Lenin-1920-Picture-Photo-Credit-Frontline.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>M.N. Roy (center) with Vladimir Lenin and Maxim Gorky at the Second Congress of the Communist International in Moscow, 1920.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>M.N. Roy (center) with Vladimir Lenin and Maxim Gorky at the Second Congress of the Communist International in Moscow, 1920.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  

&nbsp;
  
  <h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Palestine Is Asian</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">What is perhaps most striking about how the Arab participants in the conference have been written off or their presence overshadowed by the real and imagined specter of Pan-Islam is the impact they had on the event’s actual <a href="https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.77470/page/n5/mode/2up">proceedings</a>. In the opening sessions of the conference, each delegation was asked to introduce themselves. Mostafa Momin declared that “liberty has dawned and the world is destined to see another renaissance in Asia.” Karima al-Said highlighted the persistence of the British occupation of Egypt, despite nominal independence. When Taqi al-Din al-Sulh took the microphone, he struck a historical note. He delineated, in the briefest terms, the colonial geography that bound South and West Asia: “[The countries of the Arab League] run between the East and the West and have always been known as the door to India. Most of the troubles we suffered from came to us because of this position, and we now share with you your freedom, as your freedom is necessary for our freedom.” Sulh ended by noting that “in the heart of these countries is Palestine,” which was being taken advantage of by a “special minority under the defence of British bayonets.” “We object to that,” he continued, “and we hope that you will stand by the side of right with us.” His comments took this particular tenor because of who had preceded him at the podium that day: Hugo Bergman, the head of the Jewish Delegation from Palestine.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Some ten participants strong, the Hebrew University contingent outnumbered the Arab presence at the conference. Ironically perhaps, given the events that would follow, the Egyptian delegation and the Jewish delegation from Palestine arrived on the same flight. According to Idris, they both got on board a plane in Lydd, the Egyptians having just arrived there from Cairo. They flew together, to Dhahran and then Karachi, before disembarking finally in Bombay. It was only then that the Egyptians at last realized who they had been traveling with, as the Hebrew University delegation had sat together the entire time and spoke among themselves. The logistics of the whole affair reflected the conference’s political contentiousness. Idris relates that the British in Egypt had made visas and flights difficult to acquire, constantly delaying information and permissions on clearly false pretenses. The British no doubt had their reasons, as Chatham House’s confidential report on the conference stated that “the Egyptian delegates made more venomous attacks on Britain than anyone attending the conference.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">The Jewish delegation’s remarks were provocative. Their main speaker was Hugo Bergman, a philosopher at Hebrew University. “Those are the greetings of the representatives of an old religion and an old Asian people which was driven from its Asian motherland 1800 years ago,” Bergman introduced himself. He went on to elaborate the superiority of Asian values of religious tolerance to European intolerance, while praising Europe’s “logical reasoning [and] methodical thinking.” “It is our hope,” he continued, “that Palestine, notwithstanding present difficulties, will not go the European way of ‘solving’ so to speak, problems by dispossessing populations.” The Arab delegates were incensed at the Jewish delegation’s summoning of Asian feeling. Before Bergman was even finished speaking, Idris dashed off a note and had it sent up to Nehru. She demanded the Arabs have an opportunity to respond.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>The Arab delegates were incensed at the Jewish delegation’s summoning of Asian feeling.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Nehru repeated his wish that the conference steer clear of controversial matters; “nevertheless,” he went on “if this conference enters into these questions, we will get involved in them.” He invited Said to speak. “I would like to place before you the views of the Arab women,” Said began her retort. “We strongly object to any settlement in Palestine except for the Arabs,” she continued: “The gentleman himself said that the Jews have been in Europe for the last eighteen centuries. I tell you that the Arabs have been in Palestine for the last fourteen centuries. . . . We have had no trouble with the Jews at all. They have been welcome; they have been our friends; they have settled very happily among us; but we do not want British rule to be replaced by that of European Zionists. We object to them as foreigners. The Arabs must live in Palestine. Palestine cannot belong any more to its original inhabitants.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Nehru refused Bergman’s request to speak after Said finished, leading Bergman and the rest of the delegation to storm out of the meeting hall. Idris recalls that an Indian delegate followed them out and was able to cajole them back. Upon his return, Bergman shook the hand of Taqi al-Din al-Sulh, the Arab League’s representative. Idris remarks that Bergman’s handshake was clearly a performance, one, however, that had no effect on the Asians assembled. In any case, Chatham House reported that the Jewish Delegation “received a rather cool reception.” Jansen <a href="https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.553420">wrote </a>that the event “must have been one of the last occasions on which Zionist and Arab leaders experienced that minimal degree of physical contact.” Nehru, however, had the last word that day, announcing at the end of the plenary session that “the people of India . . . have always said that Palestine is essentially an Arab country and no decision can be made without the consent of the Arabs.” He was echoing—almost to the word—<a href="https://archive.org/details/HindSwaraj-Nehru-SW-15/page/n13/mode/2up">remarks</a> he had made scarcely a week before in the pages of the Bombay Sentinel. In both cases, he attributed support for Palestine not to himself, but to the Indian people more generally. A typical move, perhaps, of the patriarchal and pedagogical mode of nationalism that Nehru was known for, but significant nevertheless, for the Muslim League actively sought to couch the Palestine question in communal terms.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">The confrontation between the Arab delegates and the Jewish delegation was a rare sour moment in a conference better characterized by carefully choreographed consensus. It was, however, predictable, even by the organizers themselves, who had planned for a celebration of Asian unity. In one of the Indian Council of World Affairs’s booklets for the meeting, “Racial Problems,” the author, one T. K. Venkatram offered a particularly pessimistic assessment of Palestine’s colonization: “Palestine presents a peculiar problem. It presents an ominous resemblance to [the] Indian problem in that the two elements of the population who have got to live in the country show a complete lack of any spirit of accommodation and refuse to agree about the form of the future constitution. It is difficult to say whether the Inter-Asian Conference could offer a just solution harmonising the interest of the Arabs or the Jews, or whether the Mandatory power will accept any proposal emanating from the Conference.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">While the booklet’s characterization of the situation is not wholly accurate—Palestinians had been working for two decades to accommodate the British-backed colonization of their land—the author’s comparative gesture is one that would be raised repeatedly by Indians and Arabs in their meetings together and writing about each other. In his own postscript to the conference, Kalidas Nag, a Pan-Asianist intellectual from Bengal and one of the chief theorists of the “Greater India” idea, made the comparison in surgical terms. He wrote in <a href="https://books.google.ca/books/about/New_Asia.html?id=AgMQAQAAMAAJ&amp;redir_esc=y"><em>New Asia</em></a>: “As in the case of India, some expert political surgeons have prescribed the remedy of cutting-up the country into two! The patients, of course, have no right of appeal or of protest; and so they must submit to lie on the operation table, with or without anesthesia. Thus within a couple of months from the termination of the first Asian Relations Conference, major operation[s] are being performed on the body-politic of the many oriental nations still under Western masters and caretakers.”</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b59c4725-b6b9-44cf-8bcc-8e42a7d76458/b035287d-d408-474c-a25d-d15ca634548d.jpg" data-image-dimensions="750x472" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b59c4725-b6b9-44cf-8bcc-8e42a7d76458/b035287d-d408-474c-a25d-d15ca634548d.jpg?format=1000w" width="750" height="472" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b59c4725-b6b9-44cf-8bcc-8e42a7d76458/b035287d-d408-474c-a25d-d15ca634548d.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b59c4725-b6b9-44cf-8bcc-8e42a7d76458/b035287d-d408-474c-a25d-d15ca634548d.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b59c4725-b6b9-44cf-8bcc-8e42a7d76458/b035287d-d408-474c-a25d-d15ca634548d.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b59c4725-b6b9-44cf-8bcc-8e42a7d76458/b035287d-d408-474c-a25d-d15ca634548d.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b59c4725-b6b9-44cf-8bcc-8e42a7d76458/b035287d-d408-474c-a25d-d15ca634548d.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b59c4725-b6b9-44cf-8bcc-8e42a7d76458/b035287d-d408-474c-a25d-d15ca634548d.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b59c4725-b6b9-44cf-8bcc-8e42a7d76458/b035287d-d408-474c-a25d-d15ca634548d.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Kalidas Nag with Rabindranath Tagore aboard a ship en route to China. Image: The Telegraph Archive.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Kalidas Nag with Rabindranath Tagore aboard a ship en route to China. Image: The Telegraph Archive.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Nag’s assessment is significant, as he knew Hugo Bergman personally, having visited Jerusalem and admired the academic work of the Hebrew University, especially the Indology of Immanual Olsavaanger. “It was, therefore, a matter of real joy to me,” Nag wrote, “when I had the privilege of welcoming in Delhi the Jewish delegation.” Nevertheless, despite his sympathies with Bergman and the “Wandering Jews” in general, Nag’s comments are supportive of the Arab position. He again compares Palestine to India when he calls on the Indian press to pay greater attention to the situation: “The whole country of Palestine is convulsed today, like India, with problems of partition or chaos.” Nag’s book was published on August 15, the very day the partition of South Asia commenced.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Esmat Elhalaby</em></strong><em> is a historian of the transnational Middle East and South Asia. He is Assistant Professor at the University of Toronto.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/eb12ea50-1680-4ca7-a8e2-76852851f8be/Asianism+and+Its+Limits_header+-+Esmat.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">Asianism and Its Limits</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>“Everything Is in Place to Start a Riot”: Joe Sacco</title><category>India</category><category>Interview</category><category>Literature</category><dc:creator>Meghnad Bose</dc:creator><pubDate>Thu, 04 Jun 2026 11:30:14 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/everything-is-in-place-to-start-a-riot-joe-sacco</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:6a139f5a3d57987841e7fffb</guid><description><![CDATA[Talking about his latest comic journalism book, ‘The Once and Future Riot,’ 
Joe Sacco reflects on the Muzaffarnagar riots of 2013 and threats to global 
democracy.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Talking about his latest comic journalism book, The Once and Future Riot, Joe Sacco reflects on the Muzaffarnagar riots of 2013 and threats to global democracy.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/26ea5e1a-d25d-4aef-a7b5-6d6e822a3d51/Joe+Sacco.png" data-image-dimensions="1920x1080" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/26ea5e1a-d25d-4aef-a7b5-6d6e822a3d51/Joe+Sacco.png?format=1000w" width="1920" height="1080" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/26ea5e1a-d25d-4aef-a7b5-6d6e822a3d51/Joe+Sacco.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/26ea5e1a-d25d-4aef-a7b5-6d6e822a3d51/Joe+Sacco.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/26ea5e1a-d25d-4aef-a7b5-6d6e822a3d51/Joe+Sacco.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/26ea5e1a-d25d-4aef-a7b5-6d6e822a3d51/Joe+Sacco.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/26ea5e1a-d25d-4aef-a7b5-6d6e822a3d51/Joe+Sacco.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/26ea5e1a-d25d-4aef-a7b5-6d6e822a3d51/Joe+Sacco.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/26ea5e1a-d25d-4aef-a7b5-6d6e822a3d51/Joe+Sacco.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Book Cover. The Once and Future Riot by Joe Sacco. Publisher: Metropolitan Books</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Book Cover. The Once and Future Riot by Joe Sacco. Publisher: Metropolitan Books</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In 2014, journalist Joe Sacco, travelled to Muzaffarnagar in Uttar Pradesh, after interreligious riots between local Hindu Jats and Muslims devastated the northern Indian state in 2013.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Known for comics journalism on global conflict zones with books such as <em>Palestine</em> (1993), <em>Footnotes in Gaza</em> (2009), and <em>War's End: Profiles From Bosnia</em> (2005), Sacco’s new book, <em>The Once and Future Riot</em>, tells the story of the Muzaffarnagar riots of 2013 to reflect on the fate of democracy and the risk posed by communal tensions globally.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Meghnad Bose interviewed Sacco during his May book tour, with <em>Jewish Currents</em> and Hindus for Human Rights, to discuss why he tells stories of conflict and communal tension, his approach to storytelling, and his reflections on what we can learn from the Muzaffarnagar riots to deal with growing polarization.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The following is an excerpt from the conversation. It has been edited for clarity and brevity.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Meghnad Bose:</strong> How did you end up choosing the Muzaffarnagar riots in Uttar Pradesh, northern India, in 2013 for the book?&nbsp;<br><br><strong>Joe Sacco: </strong>I'm always interested in events that are little flashes in the pan and then people forget. When you tell stories like these, you begin to see deeper meanings. I wanted to go and hear what people say about what happened, because the world and politics are based on narratives. You have to discover what actually happened and what people say happened. Journalism is not just a question of competing narratives. The journalist has to strive to reach what, imperfectly, is called the truth.&nbsp;<br><br><strong>MB: </strong>In the book you presented a lot of competing, contradicting narratives. You present the perspectives but also challenge them along the way. Having reported on riots in India myself, sorting out who is telling the truth and who is lying is a challenge. How did you grapple with this challenge of how to present these competing narratives?</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>I realized I have very Western perspectives. Why not just admit it? We all bring our cultural baggage with us.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>JS: </strong>A lot of my journalism is based on oral testimony. In some cases, there are imperfections in oral testimony. I did a story about Gaza where I was talking about a less well-known incident from 1956. People were recollecting 50-year-old memories.&nbsp; Many stories did not line up, but over a multitude of stories, I got a general arc of what happened. Journalists often are confronted with situations like this. Sometimes I like to throw this problem into the lap of the reader.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In the case of the Muzzafargar riots,&nbsp; many of those attacked, including Muslim laborers and people in tractor trolleys, their stories seemed to capture what happened. In other cases,&nbsp; especially in villages where violence was perpetrated, there are reasons to present a different narrative. It's not because they remember it differently, but more “I need to obscure what we did here. I need to shape the story to our best interest or to my best interest for legal reasons or some other reason.” I like to throw this, the seams of journalism, at the reader.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I went to journalism school. When I got out, I didn't understand how correspondents, especially those writing about a different cultural milieu, acted so authoritative. When I was in the field, I realized I often didn't know what was going on. I was looking at other journalists and realized they didn’t know either, but you never got it from reading their stories.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1babb2a2-fae6-4290-b92a-c5f0f416cb2d/1920px-Joe_Sacco_Iraq-1536x1152.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1536x1152" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1babb2a2-fae6-4290-b92a-c5f0f416cb2d/1920px-Joe_Sacco_Iraq-1536x1152.jpg?format=1000w" width="1536" height="1152" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1babb2a2-fae6-4290-b92a-c5f0f416cb2d/1920px-Joe_Sacco_Iraq-1536x1152.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1babb2a2-fae6-4290-b92a-c5f0f416cb2d/1920px-Joe_Sacco_Iraq-1536x1152.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1babb2a2-fae6-4290-b92a-c5f0f416cb2d/1920px-Joe_Sacco_Iraq-1536x1152.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1babb2a2-fae6-4290-b92a-c5f0f416cb2d/1920px-Joe_Sacco_Iraq-1536x1152.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1babb2a2-fae6-4290-b92a-c5f0f416cb2d/1920px-Joe_Sacco_Iraq-1536x1152.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1babb2a2-fae6-4290-b92a-c5f0f416cb2d/1920px-Joe_Sacco_Iraq-1536x1152.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1babb2a2-fae6-4290-b92a-c5f0f416cb2d/1920px-Joe_Sacco_Iraq-1536x1152.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Sacco in Iraq in 2005  – </em><a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"><em>CC BY-SA 3.0</em></a></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Sacco in Iraq in 2005  – </em><a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"><em>CC BY-SA 3.0</em></a></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1780451231389_8950">I realized I have very Western perspectives. Why not just admit it? We all bring our cultural baggage with us. It's why I have a hard time believing in the objective style of journalism I was taught. When you are a Westerner, going into a context like India or Gaza, you are going to look at things through the prism of your upbringing. This is what I like about the comics form. I am showing myself — [and] by showing myself, I'm admitting to the reader that all they are seeing is being filtered through one person's eyes.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b7bf3fd6-dd92-4c91-a54e-00ee3b6a42b6/Excerpt1_Joe+Sacco+book.png" data-image-dimensions="880x618" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b7bf3fd6-dd92-4c91-a54e-00ee3b6a42b6/Excerpt1_Joe+Sacco+book.png?format=1000w" width="880" height="618" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b7bf3fd6-dd92-4c91-a54e-00ee3b6a42b6/Excerpt1_Joe+Sacco+book.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b7bf3fd6-dd92-4c91-a54e-00ee3b6a42b6/Excerpt1_Joe+Sacco+book.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b7bf3fd6-dd92-4c91-a54e-00ee3b6a42b6/Excerpt1_Joe+Sacco+book.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b7bf3fd6-dd92-4c91-a54e-00ee3b6a42b6/Excerpt1_Joe+Sacco+book.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b7bf3fd6-dd92-4c91-a54e-00ee3b6a42b6/Excerpt1_Joe+Sacco+book.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b7bf3fd6-dd92-4c91-a54e-00ee3b6a42b6/Excerpt1_Joe+Sacco+book.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b7bf3fd6-dd92-4c91-a54e-00ee3b6a42b6/Excerpt1_Joe+Sacco+book.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Excerpt from ‘The Once and Future Riot’ by Joe Sacco. Publisher: Metropolitan Books</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Excerpt from ‘The Once and Future Riot’ by Joe Sacco. Publisher: Metropolitan Books</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>In Muzaffarnagar,  people were getting up on podiums to get people’s emotions to simmer down, but in the end, the crowd did not want that.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>MB: </strong>You traveled to Muzaffarnagar in the mid 2010s and met the right-wing Hindu priest Yati Narsinghanand.Since then, he has become one of the Hindu far right’s most virulent figures in India who has openly called for genocidal violence against Indian Muslims and has multiple police cases against him. What do you remember about meeting Yati and others like him?<br><br><strong>JS: </strong>I met him twice there. I was shocked that he would say something like “There've been 500 cases of gang rape in Uttar Pradesh in the last 10 years and not one time has a Hindu ever raped a Muslim girl in the entire country.” Even if you're a Hindu nationalist, how can you believe it?<br><br><strong>MB: </strong>…a lot of people with those views are increasingly getting closer to power…&nbsp;<br><br><strong>JS: </strong>Narsinghanand creates that space for people to go far to the right. He has stuck to his narrative. He argues that Hindus are victims. He claimed there would be a genocide of Hindus in Uttar Pradesh. It was astonishing.<br><br><strong>MB: </strong>That also brings me to the title of your book. Why “The Once and Future Riot?”<br><br><strong>JS: </strong>Because we need to address some basic things and think about what the word democracy means, beyond electoral politics. Of course, there is going to be tension and interests that go one way or another. At the end, the democratic spirit is about including voices.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This is not being addressed in India or in Western countries that call themselves democracies either. Everything is in place for a spark to start a riot, whether that riot is spontaneous or directed — even spontaneous riots will get directed. There are politicians who are going to see what use can be made out of this. In Muzaffarnagar, people were getting up on the podiums at some of the panchayats to get people’s emotions to simmer down, but in the end, the crowd did not want that. There have to be fundamental changes in the way we think of each other, and other communities. Because everyone takes on the mantle of victimhood so easily.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b47ee0e1-b4ae-4ebe-8565-0adf527804cd/Excerpt2_Joe+Sacco.png" data-image-dimensions="880x618" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b47ee0e1-b4ae-4ebe-8565-0adf527804cd/Excerpt2_Joe+Sacco.png?format=1000w" width="880" height="618" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b47ee0e1-b4ae-4ebe-8565-0adf527804cd/Excerpt2_Joe+Sacco.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b47ee0e1-b4ae-4ebe-8565-0adf527804cd/Excerpt2_Joe+Sacco.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b47ee0e1-b4ae-4ebe-8565-0adf527804cd/Excerpt2_Joe+Sacco.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b47ee0e1-b4ae-4ebe-8565-0adf527804cd/Excerpt2_Joe+Sacco.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b47ee0e1-b4ae-4ebe-8565-0adf527804cd/Excerpt2_Joe+Sacco.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b47ee0e1-b4ae-4ebe-8565-0adf527804cd/Excerpt2_Joe+Sacco.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/b47ee0e1-b4ae-4ebe-8565-0adf527804cd/Excerpt2_Joe+Sacco.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Excerpt from ‘The Once and Future Riot’ by Joe Sacco. Publisher: Metropolitan Books</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Excerpt from ‘The Once and Future Riot’ by Joe Sacco. Publisher: Metropolitan Books</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>The political question was limited to: how are we going to consolidate our base further through this? It led to a huge political upheaval.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Politicians use fear to consolidate their base. It's the easiest route. [Today] you are not going to consolidate a base by saying, we are going to increase the bus service from one place to another and we are going to clean the streets. People want that, but really what's going to agitate them is fear. Who is the other? Why are we the victims? This template has been going on. Not just in India. At a big mass rally before the wars started in the former Yugoslavia, the Serb nationalist leader Milosevic said they will never beat you again.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I think all the elements are in place, to perennially be in this space where there can be a riot and it often happens around elections. It is almost as if society is kept at this low boiling point, just beneath the surface. The same is happening in the United States. It's a very dangerous thing, because it could spiral out of control.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">With the way in Uttar Pradesh that the Samajwadi party tried to play it, I think trying to appease the Muslim voter bloc backfired on them. When they offered compensation of 500,000 rupees, at first it was only given to Muslims who had lost their homes. It took the Indian Supreme Court to say <a href="https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/muzaffarnagar-riots-supreme-court-asks-up-government-to-compensate-all-not-just-one-community-541917"><u>every victim</u></a> needs to be compensated. The political question was limited to: how are we going to consolidate our base further? It led to a huge political upheaval.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Talking about the West now, I think we're at a dangerous point with the way immigrants are talked about, when Trump calls people coming over from south of the border as the ‘worst kind of rapists and murderers.’ You are smearing entire populations. While a lot of people see through it, the problem is a lot of people don't.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Some people are looking at their lives and see that it's not going well. Politicians are finding convenient scapegoats. Is an American worker going to understand the economics at play and what's going on? It's just easier to have someone say, these Mexicans are taking your jobs, they're taking all the social security benefits, schools have to pay for all this, it's your tax money. Hatred is what we all understand quite easily.<br><br><strong>MB: </strong>You visited Muzaffarnagar in 2014. This book got published in 2025. You have had some time for these thoughts to gestate. What were the other parallels that you reflected on over these years?<br><br><strong>JS: </strong>I did the reporting in 2014, and I wrote it soon after that. It took me a while to get back to it because I didn't want to draw another violent book. But as I was drawing it, especially toward the end, Trump was elected and I saw how he was touching the edge of violence or allowing it [by] not condemning it. It is like the Modi model in Gujarat. You don't condemn, you sort of stand aside. When Charlottesville happened, Trump said that there were “very fine people, on both sides.” He did not try to stop it. He muddied&nbsp; the waters. Then the January 6 riots happened. The narrative from Trump's side is that these people were victims, and he, almost, absolved them of guilt? The charges were dropped. People had been killed. Trump is legitimizing a certain amount of violence. This is true around the world, you see this unaccountability.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>It’s just easier to have someone say, oh, actually, these Mexicans are taking your jobs, they’re taking all the social security benefits, ... it’s your tax money. Hatred is what we all understand quite easily.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>MB: </strong>At the conservative conference CPAC in 2025, I spoke to some of the Jan 6th rioters who'd been pardoned. I remember the feeling of impunity they had, and it reminded me of Hindutva vigilantes in Uttar Pradesh and other parts of India who have committed hate crimes against Muslims on camera without facing penalties. This parallel strikes one’s self when reporting on different geographies, from Palestine to Bosnia to India to the United States. What are your key takeaways from authoring this book?<br><br><strong>JS: </strong>The Indian Constitution is interesting in that addressing certain inequalities is embedded into Indian democracy. It is sad to see that seeping away. The secular spirit of the original Constitution allows for different communities to have their place. It's a secular state, but it is a fine line. However, when Modi officiates, in a priestly manner, at the opening of a temple at the site of Babri Masjid, can you really call India a secular state?&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">As I was finishing the book, I realized I wanted to write it in a way that was particular to India, but could be seen as a commentary on democracies in general. I want the reader to come away with some questions and think about democracy and its relationship to electoral politics and why are we intertwining ourselves with violence?&nbsp;<br><br><strong>MB: </strong>You don’t like to use the phrase, ‘graphic novel,’ to describe your work. It is non-fiction journalism. How do you describe it?</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2330a0e1-f076-4e28-bf57-6edf6b591931/joe+sacco+book+excerpt.png" data-image-dimensions="800x1200" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2330a0e1-f076-4e28-bf57-6edf6b591931/joe+sacco+book+excerpt.png?format=1000w" width="800" height="1200" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2330a0e1-f076-4e28-bf57-6edf6b591931/joe+sacco+book+excerpt.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2330a0e1-f076-4e28-bf57-6edf6b591931/joe+sacco+book+excerpt.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2330a0e1-f076-4e28-bf57-6edf6b591931/joe+sacco+book+excerpt.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2330a0e1-f076-4e28-bf57-6edf6b591931/joe+sacco+book+excerpt.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2330a0e1-f076-4e28-bf57-6edf6b591931/joe+sacco+book+excerpt.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2330a0e1-f076-4e28-bf57-6edf6b591931/joe+sacco+book+excerpt.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2330a0e1-f076-4e28-bf57-6edf6b591931/joe+sacco+book+excerpt.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Excerpt from ‘The Once and Future Riot’ by Joe Sacco. Publisher: Metropolitan Books</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Excerpt from ‘The Once and Future Riot’ by Joe Sacco. Publisher: Metropolitan Books</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>JS: </strong>I don't like the phrase graphic novel [since it is non-fiction], but I use it since other people use it. Many cartoonists pushed back against the phrase, ‘graphic novel.’ It feels like a marketing term for adults. On the other hand, I don’t have a problem with the word ‘comics.’ People ask, ‘What's comical about that?’ However, comics is the term for published cartooning. I use the phrase comics journalism. Some people prefer calling it graphic journalism. I like using cartoons since it gives a reader a sense of place. I want the reader coming along for the ride. Drawings help by painting an atmosphere.<br><br><strong>MB: </strong>Yes, the first few pages of traffic transported me to a bustling Indian street. Books like these delve into specific events but have a more universal message. What would you like someone who reads The Once and Future Riot to take away from it?<br><br><strong>JS: </strong>I want people to think about their democracies. To think deeply about what their representatives represent and what their role is as a citizen. What is the responsibility of one citizen to another citizen? To look beyond their community differences, race, skin color, and other differences, and instead think of each other as citizens. I want the reader to interrogate these things.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Meghnad Bose</em></strong><em> is an award-winning investigative journalist based in the U.S. He is a professor of journalism at The University of Memphis, where he heads the MA program in Open-Source Investigative Reporting.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/26ea5e1a-d25d-4aef-a7b5-6d6e822a3d51/Joe+Sacco.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">“Everything Is in Place to Start a Riot”: Joe Sacco</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>A Generational Change in Nepali Politics</title><category>Essay</category><category>Nepal</category><dc:creator>Pranaya Rana</dc:creator><pubDate>Tue, 26 May 2026 20:27:21 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/a-generational-change-in-nepali-politics</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:6a10bc2976b6952ae9d10337</guid><description><![CDATA[On the long road that turned a rapper into Nepal's prime minister.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>On the long road that turned a rapper into Nepal's prime minister.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2d475744-3c44-4a92-943e-0f920a10a0a1/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%282%29.png" data-image-dimensions="5120x2880" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2d475744-3c44-4a92-943e-0f920a10a0a1/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%282%29.png?format=1000w" width="5120" height="2880" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2d475744-3c44-4a92-943e-0f920a10a0a1/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%282%29.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2d475744-3c44-4a92-943e-0f920a10a0a1/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%282%29.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2d475744-3c44-4a92-943e-0f920a10a0a1/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%282%29.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2d475744-3c44-4a92-943e-0f920a10a0a1/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%282%29.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2d475744-3c44-4a92-943e-0f920a10a0a1/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%282%29.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2d475744-3c44-4a92-943e-0f920a10a0a1/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%282%29.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2d475744-3c44-4a92-943e-0f920a10a0a1/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%282%29.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">On March 27, Balendra “Balen” Shah, a 35-year-old rapper, structural engineer, and former mayor of the city of Kathmandu, was formally sworn in as the prime minister of Nepal. Shah’s inauguration was replete with symbolism. Shah, the son of an Ayurvedic doctor, was administered the oath of office and secrecy by President Ram Chandra Poudel at exactly 12.34pm, a time chosen according to Vedic numerology. A 108 Hindu priests and 17 Buddhist monks chanted auspicious hymns while blowing conch shells as if announcing the arrival of a wartime general. A day earlier, on March 26, Shah had released a new rap song, Jay Mahakali, harkening to the battle cry of the Gurkha soldiers—<em>Jay Mahakali, Ayo Gorkhali</em> (Hail the Goddess Mahakali, the Gorkhas are here).</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The very next day, in the early hours of the morning, the Balen Shah government took former Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli and former Home Minister Ramesh Lekhak into custody. Oli, who leads the Communist Party of Nepal (Unified Marxist-Leninist), and Lekhak, who is from the Nepali Congress political party, had both resigned in ignominy after the mass death and destruction of what has been labelled “the Gen Z protests” of September 2025.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c770ee5f-8461-4557-9e5d-b44ddcd2d813/Picture1.jpg" data-image-dimensions="605x806" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c770ee5f-8461-4557-9e5d-b44ddcd2d813/Picture1.jpg?format=1000w" width="605" height="806" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c770ee5f-8461-4557-9e5d-b44ddcd2d813/Picture1.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c770ee5f-8461-4557-9e5d-b44ddcd2d813/Picture1.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c770ee5f-8461-4557-9e5d-b44ddcd2d813/Picture1.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c770ee5f-8461-4557-9e5d-b44ddcd2d813/Picture1.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c770ee5f-8461-4557-9e5d-b44ddcd2d813/Picture1.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c770ee5f-8461-4557-9e5d-b44ddcd2d813/Picture1.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c770ee5f-8461-4557-9e5d-b44ddcd2d813/Picture1.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Students participate in an anti-corruption protest in Kathmandu, sparked by the banning of social media by the government of KP Sharma Oli on September 8, 2025.&nbsp;Photo: Pranaya Rana.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">On September 8, a protest movement against corruption, impunity, and a social media ban led primarily by young Nepalis ended in bloodshed after security forces fired upon unarmed protesters, killing 19. Lekhak, the home minister, resigned the same day, but Oli, the prime minister, refused, claiming no responsibility for the deaths the security forces had wrought.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Nepal exploded in anger the next day, burning down state institutions, political party offices, and attacking politicians. Sher Bahadur Deuba, the chief of the Nepali Congress, and his wife, Arzu Rana Deuba, were brutally assaulted by protesters in their homes before being rescued by the Nepal Army. Oli finally resigned and was airlifted to the security of Army barracks, where he spent the next week in hiding. A new interim government led by former Chief Justice Sushila Karki, chosen by Gen Z leaders and endorsed by thousands in an informal Discord poll, was put in place with the mandate to hold elections in six months. The Kakri government, as demanded by Gen Z, formed a commission to investigate the death and destruction of those two days in September when a total of 76 Nepalis died.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9faa4588-40dd-4844-8048-27070bfd6bc0/Picture1.jpg" data-image-dimensions="562x751" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9faa4588-40dd-4844-8048-27070bfd6bc0/Picture1.jpg?format=1000w" width="562" height="751" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9faa4588-40dd-4844-8048-27070bfd6bc0/Picture1.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9faa4588-40dd-4844-8048-27070bfd6bc0/Picture1.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9faa4588-40dd-4844-8048-27070bfd6bc0/Picture1.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9faa4588-40dd-4844-8048-27070bfd6bc0/Picture1.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9faa4588-40dd-4844-8048-27070bfd6bc0/Picture1.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9faa4588-40dd-4844-8048-27070bfd6bc0/Picture1.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9faa4588-40dd-4844-8048-27070bfd6bc0/Picture1.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Protesters set fire to a police station in Maharajgunj, Kathmandu, on September 9, 2025. Two police officers would be lynched by rampaging mobs. Photo: Pranaya Rana.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>Shah was seen as an avatar of a new way of doing politics in Nepal–brash, decisive, and not afraid to challenge entrenched political interests.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">The Karki government completed its mandate, successfully holding an election for a new House of Representatives on March 5. The Rastriya Swatantra Party (RSP), a party formed just over three years earlier in 2022, dominated the election, winning 182 out of 275 seats, just two seats short of a two-thirds majority. Central to the RSP’s sweeping victory was Balen Shah, the Kathmandu mayor who had emerged as a central figure during the Gen Z movement. Shah was seen as an avatar of a new way of doing politics in Nepal–brash, decisive, and not afraid to challenge entrenched political interests. Tellingly, Shah mounted a direct challenge to Oli in the election, contesting the Jhapa-5 constituency, long considered Oli’s stronghold. Shah defeated Oli with over 70,000 votes, the most any candidate has received in an election.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Shah had long held Oli directly responsible for the carnage of September 8. He believed that Oli, as prime minister, held ultimate moral responsibility for the killings and, by refusing to step down, had directly contributed to the violence and destruction of September 9. During the hustings, Oli offered to debate Shah publicly. The latter refused, saying he would not share the same stage as a “terrorist.” Days after the March 5 election, the investigative commission formally submitted its report to the interim government. Despite widespread calls from Gen Z activists, the Karki government refused to publicly release the report. However, the report was leaked to the press in full, confirming Shah’s conviction.&nbsp;The report&nbsp;<a href="https://kathmandupost.com/national/2026/03/25/karki-commission-s-recommendations-on-the-gen-z-protests-explained-in-10-points">recommended</a>&nbsp;that Oli and Lekhak, among others, be investigated and prosecuted for reckless killing and investigation and prosecution for reckless and negligent killing under the Nepali Penal Code. That Shah would hold Oli accountable was thus foregone.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Since Oli and Lekhak’s arrest, the Shah government has moved swiftly. The very next day, another former minister was arrested on corruption charges and asset investigations have been opened against three former prime ministers, including Oli. A prominent businessman, long believed to be a primary link between politicians and corrupt business interests, has been prohibited from leaving the country. Nepal, long mired in corruption and impunity, has never had a reckoning of this scale. Although there are concerns about executive overreach and a lack of due process—Oli and Lekhak were taken into custody&nbsp;<a href="https://kathmandupost.com/national/2026/03/29/legality-of-oli-lekhak-arrests-comes-into-question">without a formal arrest warrant</a>&nbsp;signed by a judge—Nepalis by and large are firmly in Shah’s corner, celebrating what they see as long overdue.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>A History of Revolution</strong></h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">The RSP’s thumping electoral victory and Shah’s elevation to prime minister are no doubt pivotal moments, but modern Nepali history is replete with such moments of sweeping political change. Every few decades, Nepal witnesses a popular revolt that reshapes the country.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">In 1990, thousands of Nepalis took to the streets across the country, demanding an end to Panchayat, the direct rule of the monarchy, which had been in place since the early 60s. This movement, the first People’s Revolution, stripped the monarchy of absolute power, relegating it to a ceremonial role, and vested authority in the people, as represented by the political parties. A new constitution was written, and Nepalis celebrated the reestablishment of democracy after decades of rule by a dictatorial monarch.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c9540be7-0b43-4f82-aad2-d3f34bf32aca/1990_Nepalese_revolution%2C_Kathmandu.jpg" data-image-dimensions="3240x2272" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c9540be7-0b43-4f82-aad2-d3f34bf32aca/1990_Nepalese_revolution%2C_Kathmandu.jpg?format=1000w" width="3240" height="2272" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c9540be7-0b43-4f82-aad2-d3f34bf32aca/1990_Nepalese_revolution%2C_Kathmandu.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c9540be7-0b43-4f82-aad2-d3f34bf32aca/1990_Nepalese_revolution%2C_Kathmandu.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c9540be7-0b43-4f82-aad2-d3f34bf32aca/1990_Nepalese_revolution%2C_Kathmandu.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c9540be7-0b43-4f82-aad2-d3f34bf32aca/1990_Nepalese_revolution%2C_Kathmandu.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c9540be7-0b43-4f82-aad2-d3f34bf32aca/1990_Nepalese_revolution%2C_Kathmandu.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c9540be7-0b43-4f82-aad2-d3f34bf32aca/1990_Nepalese_revolution%2C_Kathmandu.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c9540be7-0b43-4f82-aad2-d3f34bf32aca/1990_Nepalese_revolution%2C_Kathmandu.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Assembly in Kathmandu during the 1990 People’s Revolution. Image: Min Ratna Bajracharya.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Barely six years had passed when a new revolution emerged, this time in the country’s rural mid-west. The Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist) launched a “People’s War” in February 1996, demanding an end to feudalism, as represented by the monarchy, and the establishment of a secular “people’s republic” that would ensure the rights of the poor and marginalized. Initially dismissed by the state as a minor security issue, the insurgency found broad purchase among Nepal’s rural poor and historically marginalized groups. The Maoist guerrillas would fight the Nepal Police, the newly created paramilitary Armed Police Force, and the professionally trained Nepal Army to a near-standstill over the next 10 years, when over 16,000 Nepalis would die.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fc1bc8e-8d32-415b-9f1b-f6c603a6a7a5/Nepal_maoist_valley.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1920x1280" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fc1bc8e-8d32-415b-9f1b-f6c603a6a7a5/Nepal_maoist_valley.jpg?format=1000w" width="1920" height="1280" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fc1bc8e-8d32-415b-9f1b-f6c603a6a7a5/Nepal_maoist_valley.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fc1bc8e-8d32-415b-9f1b-f6c603a6a7a5/Nepal_maoist_valley.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fc1bc8e-8d32-415b-9f1b-f6c603a6a7a5/Nepal_maoist_valley.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fc1bc8e-8d32-415b-9f1b-f6c603a6a7a5/Nepal_maoist_valley.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fc1bc8e-8d32-415b-9f1b-f6c603a6a7a5/Nepal_maoist_valley.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fc1bc8e-8d32-415b-9f1b-f6c603a6a7a5/Nepal_maoist_valley.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fc1bc8e-8d32-415b-9f1b-f6c603a6a7a5/Nepal_maoist_valley.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A family in a Maoist administered valley in Nepal. Photo: Pavel Novak.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">In 2005, as the Maoist conflict showed no signs of abating, the ceremonial king once again seized power in a coup. Dismissing the political parties and jailing politicians, the king centralized all authority. A year later, Nepalis once again took to the streets. Nepal’s political parties banded together with the rebel Maoists to broker a peace agreement and unseat the king.&nbsp;The second People’s Movement ended with an&nbsp;<a href="https://ciaotest.cc.columbia.edu/wps/carter/0021698/index.html">election for a Constituent Assembly</a>&nbsp;tasked with drafting a new constitution.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Barely a year had passed since the peace deal that ended the civil conflict when protests erupted again in the Terai plains to the south of the country. The ethnic Madhesi population, long discriminated against and socio-politically excluded from power, demanded a semblance of autonomy to throw off Kathmandu’s yoke. A new aspiration was thus added to the Constituent Assembly’s duty roster. The new constitution would now establish Nepal as a federal, secular republic, a new country shorn of its Hindu identity, its monarchy, and its unitary governance structure.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>The Unfulfilled Promise of “New Nepal”</strong></h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">When the civil war formally ended in 2006 with the signing of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement, Nepalis were promised a “new Nepal”—a Nepal born anew from the ashes of civil conflict, enlightened and rejuvenated by revolutionary promise. Indeed, the 10-year Maoist conflict led to a broad-based reckoning with the state as it stood. The war unleashed a new wave of identity politics where historically marginalized groups like women, the Madhesis, and Indigenous Janajatis demanded a fair share of the state that claimed to represent them. Inclusion and proportional representation became key pillars of state and government composition, with quotas assigned to historically marginalized groups—women, Dalits, Madhesis, Tharus, and Muslims—based on their share of the population. The 240-year-old monarchy, a symbol of the dominance of one particular ethnic group over a country as diverse as Nepal, was abolished and Nepal declared a secular republic.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Yet, despite all their revolutionary zeal, it did not take long for the Maoists to be coopted by the very system they had once denounced as bourgeois and feudal. When the Maoists entered parliamentary politics as a political party, they were caught between a rock and a hard place. Political conditions necessitated entry into mainstream politics, which eventually brought forth the contradictions within the communist party's structure, which was largely beholden to&nbsp;the chairman—Pushpa Kamal Dahal “Prachanda.”&nbsp;Dahal quickly discovered that mainstream politics is a different beast compared to a guerrilla insurgency. The Maoists won the first election held after the signing of the peace agreement in a landslide, and Dahal ascended as prime minister. But less than a year into his tenure, Dahal resigned in ignominy. His attempt to establish civilian supremacy over the Nepal Army was protested by other parties and ultimately thwarted by the president.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Corruption allegations emerged against Dahal and the senior Maoist leadership. Hardline Maoists who had never believed in the mainstream democratic process broke away to form smaller parties. Even Dahal’s second-in-command, Baburam Bhattarai, parted ways with his chairman to form a new party with a more socialist ideology. The first Constituent Assembly, tasked with drafting a new constitution after the end of the war, failed in its mandate. The traditional parties, particularly the Nepali Congress and the CPN-UML, quickly reasserted themselves. In the second Constituent Assembly, formed in 2013, the Maoists were relegated to a distant third with the Congress and UML emerging as the top two parties, respectively.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">The second Constituent Assembly also struggled, but ultimately produced a statute amidst the destruction wrought by the 2015 earthquakes that killed over 8,000 Nepalis. The new constitution was flawed and thus protested by many communities, including the Madhesis and the indigenous peoples, but it was promulgated and became the new law of the land.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">The 2015 constitution promised deep structural changes to the manner in which Nepalis would now be governed. Nepalis were no longer subjects of a king but sovereign citizens with the power of the vote. Federalism would devolve power away from centralized Kathmandu to the seven provinces, each with its own Provincial Assembly to draft laws. Secularism meant that Nepal no longer had a state religion and would thus accord equal status to all faiths within the country.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Ultimately, none of these changes materialized as envisioned. Federalism was stymied by the reluctance of the federal government in Kathmandu to cede power to the provinces. Laws intended to allow the provinces to govern themselves better, remained locked in the federal Parliament for over a decade. At the federal level, the top leadership of the three largest political parties—the Nepali Congress, the UML, and the Maoists—took turns as chief executive, as if in a game of musical chairs. The Maoists had now become willing participants in coalition politics, allying in turn with the UML and the Congress as it suited them. In 2018, the UML and Maoists merged to form the Nepal Communist Party, the largest communist bloc in Nepal’s history, with a near two-thirds majority in Parliament. Yet, even this gargantuan force collapsed when the political ambitions of the two top leaders—Dahal and KP Sharma Oli—clashed.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Since the formal end of the civil war in 2006, Nepal has had 14 prime ministers, none of whom completed their five-year terms. Among these, Oli emerged as the defining figure of this era of dysfunction. Oli, formerly a second-rung leader in the UML, quickly rose to the top of the UML hierarchy on a nationalist plank in the wake of the unofficial Indian blockade in 2015. He took on a decidedly anti-Indian posture, often openly antagonizing the Indian establishment with controversial statements, and pursued closer ties to China. Both his provocations, including issuing a new political map of Nepal in 2020 that included territory claimed by India, and his courtship of Beijing, yielded nothing tangible, only serving to distract from domestic political crises and a languid economy. Oli also grew increasingly authoritarian, twice attempting to dissolve the House of Representatives—in December 2020 and again in May 2021. Each effort was deemed unconstitutional by the Supreme Court.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Yet Oli managed to return to the prime minister’s chair each time, supported by a coalition with either the Congress or the Maoists. Nepalis saw coalition politics for what it was—naked attempts to hold on to power even at the cost of allying with ideological rivals. Sher Bahadur Deuba, the president of the Nepali Congress, had been prime minister five times throughout his political career; Oli four times, and Dahal three times. None of them had much to show for it, except a creeping sense among the populace that these political actors and their cronies were benefiting materially and politically at the cost of the rest of the&nbsp;country. </p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e62409c-d4d0-4c3f-a2ed-a24b29ee52d8/891656-gdelqhbsns-1518698046.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1200x630" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e62409c-d4d0-4c3f-a2ed-a24b29ee52d8/891656-gdelqhbsns-1518698046.jpg?format=1000w" width="1200" height="630" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e62409c-d4d0-4c3f-a2ed-a24b29ee52d8/891656-gdelqhbsns-1518698046.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e62409c-d4d0-4c3f-a2ed-a24b29ee52d8/891656-gdelqhbsns-1518698046.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e62409c-d4d0-4c3f-a2ed-a24b29ee52d8/891656-gdelqhbsns-1518698046.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e62409c-d4d0-4c3f-a2ed-a24b29ee52d8/891656-gdelqhbsns-1518698046.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e62409c-d4d0-4c3f-a2ed-a24b29ee52d8/891656-gdelqhbsns-1518698046.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e62409c-d4d0-4c3f-a2ed-a24b29ee52d8/891656-gdelqhbsns-1518698046.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/6e62409c-d4d0-4c3f-a2ed-a24b29ee52d8/891656-gdelqhbsns-1518698046.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>K.P. Sharma Oli has served three terms as the prime minister of Nepal, from 2015 to 2016, 2018 to 2021, and 2024 to 2025. He has been the chairman of the Communist Party of Nepal (Unified Marxist-Leninist) since 2014. Image: AFP.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1779549480538_46070" class="MsoNormal">Jobs were scarce and pay remained low. Nepalis were&nbsp;<a href="https://www.freiheit.org/sites/default/files/2025-09/emigration-from-nepal-and-its-impact-on-economy_0.pdf">deserting the country</a>&nbsp;in droves, seeking little hope of a secure future within the country.&nbsp;Nepali migrants ended up in war zones, even joining the Russian Army in its war of aggression against Ukraine, where dozens would die. Ten Nepali students on a “learn and earn” program in Israel were killed when Hamas launched its October 7 attacks. Thousands of otherwise healthy Nepali workers&nbsp;<a href="https://kathmandupost.com/national/2020/02/29/hundreds-of-young-healthy-nepalis-die-sudden-deaths-in-foreign-lands-no-one-knows-what-s-killing-them">died from unexplained “heart attacks</a>”&nbsp;while working in West Asian countries like Qatar and Saudi&nbsp;Arabia. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">At home, corruption and impunity were rampant. Politicians&nbsp;<a href="https://www.recordnepal.com/here-is-what-you-need-to-know-about-the-baskota-case">caught on tape</a>&nbsp;demanding bribes and business elites implicated in money laundering in the&nbsp;<a href="https://www.icij.org/inside-icij/2019/03/nepaleaks-on-the-trail-of-money-flowing-from-nepal-to-tax-havens-then-back-to-nepal/">NepaLeaks</a>&nbsp;and Pandora Papers leaks were rarely investigated, let alone prosecuted. The prevailing sentiment was that nothing could get done unless you were part of a vast patronage network linked to the political elite.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>Political instability, policy inconsistency, unemployment, and a broad perception of corruption left Nepalis betrayed. The “new Nepal” they had been promised never materialized.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Political instability, policy inconsistency, unemployment, and a broad perception of corruption left Nepalis betrayed. The “new Nepal” they had been promised never materialized. The Maoists betrayed the rural poor and marginalized who had fought their wars; the UML and NC turned democratic politics into an extractive system of patronage; and the structural economy was never diversified beyond remittance and subsistence agriculture. A generation of youth came of age watching their parents leave the country to work in West Asian labour camps. At home they scrambled for a decent education and a well-paying job, while the children of politicians posted selfies from luxurious vacations on Instagram.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>The Rise of the RSP and Balen Shah</strong></h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Enter the Rastriya Swatantra Party and Balen Shah.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">The RSP was formed in 2022, just months ahead of the scheduled legislative election, by Rabi Lamichhane, a charismatic former television host. The RSP, whose name translates to National Independent Party, professed no real ideology, a stark contrast to the primarily left-leaning communist and socialist mainstream parties. Lamichhane parlayed his popularity into a political force that won 21 seats in the federal House of Representatives, making it the fourth-largest party.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">That same year, Nepal also held local-level elections. Balen Shah, then a new entrant to politics, announced his candidacy for the mayorship. Shah made canny use of social media and traditional media, appearing on numerous television interviews and YouTube podcasts. On social media, he was supported by the Facebook page Routine of Nepal Banda, a “news” page with millions of followers that shared information on various socio-political developments across the country. Shah won handily, defeating heavyweights like a former mayor and a member of the politically influential Ganesh Man Singh family.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">While the RSP attempted to play mainstream politics, joining government and running several ministries, it was waylaid by the travails of its founder. Lamichhane had once acquired American citizenship, but had given it up to return home and contest elections. However, he had failed to follow due process while reacquiring Nepali citizenship, a fact that the mainstream media quickly discovered and made public. Lamichhane was stripped of his election win and his position as home minister by the Supreme Court. Undeterred, he rectified his mistake, contested a by-election, and won again.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">But his woes were not over. Lamichhane was the managing director of Gorkha Media, which operated the popular Galaxy 4K television network. Gorkha Media was owned by GB Rai, then Lamichhane’s business partner and close confidant. Rai was&nbsp;<a href="https://en.setopati.com/social/164111">alleged to have embezzled money</a>&nbsp;from several financial institutions he operated and funnelled it into Gorkha&nbsp;Media. Lamichhane, as managing director, had signed off on numerous cheques, implicating him in the scheme. The media once again ran with this story, and Lamichhane was charged with fraud, embezzlement, and organized crime. He was arrested and jailed for nearly a year, denied bail.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">While the RSP was floundering without its chief, Shah was treading a different path. As mayor, Shah was openly hostile to the mainstream political parties, particularly Oli and the UML. In 2023, he briefly halted garbage collection at Singha Durbar, the main government complex, accusing federal ministers of failing to support him on city affairs. In 2024, Shah dumped a truckful of dirt in front of the Road Division Office in protest over delays in road expansion by the federal Ministry of Physical Planning and Infrastructure. On social media, Shah was incendiary. He threatened to burn down Singha Durbar after police stopped a car carrying his wife for a routine security check. Towards the end of his tenure as mayor, he cursed out the mainstream parties and even friendly countries like India, China, and the USA, writing, “You guys all combined can do nothing.”</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">His rejection of the political mainstream only bolstered his outsider image among the public, even if his actions drew much criticism. His violent attempts to forcibly remove squatter settlements and roadside vendors were met with opprobrium from rights groups like Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International. He also burnished his nationalist image by openly opposing India. He placed a map of “Greater Nepal” in his office in response to the unveiling of an “Akhanda Bharat” mural in the Indian parliament. Both are irredentist concepts, making territorial claims over areas belonging to another. He also banned the showing of Indian films in the capital after the film Adipurush claimed that Sita from the epic Ramayana was born in present day India. Whereas, Nepalis consider that Sita was born in the present day city of Janakpur in southern Nepal.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">While some sections of the public criticized Shah, his popularity only grew among the young. They saw him as a bold actor, not afraid to challenge the political parties or even an influential country like India. They extolled his work in cleaning up Kathmandu, expanding roads and pavements, and beautifying the city. Shah also implemented educational reforms and strictly enforced rules requiring private schools to provide a set number of scholarships to disadvantaged students. When the Gen Z movement took root, Shah emerged as the most influential actor. Gen Z activists initially asked Shah to run the interim government, but he was canny. Shah’s ambition was to run government for a full five-year term; not become a&nbsp;lame duck&nbsp;prime minister whose only mandate was to hold elections.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>An Unprecedented Election&nbsp;</strong></h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">In the aftermath of the Gen Z movement, the RSP positioned itself as the heir to its demands. It was a relatively new party, not wholly tainted by corruption. Notwithstanding the accusations against Lamichhane, the rest of the party was well-liked and seen as consisting of capable technocrats. Even then, it struggled to find the niche it needed to capture the voters’ imagination. Balen Shah was just what it needed.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Shah formally joined the RSP in late December and resigned as mayor to contest the election. From then on, the RSP moulded itself around Shah’s image. While Lamichhane appeared alongside Shah in party imagery, his star was almost completely eclipsed by Shah's. Nepal is a Westminster-style multi-party democracy, meaning political parties contest elections and then elect a prime minister from among the winners. But for the first time, Nepal had a presidential-style election. The RSP presented Shah as its prime ministerial candidate before the election, pledging to make him chief executive. This resonated with voters and forced the other parties to present their own prime ministerial candidates—Gagan Thapa for the Congress and Oli for the UML.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2621e810-0d83-46e6-b116-d62649c7eea0/1-nepal-balen-gen-z-GettyImages-2261503870.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1500x1000" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2621e810-0d83-46e6-b116-d62649c7eea0/1-nepal-balen-gen-z-GettyImages-2261503870.jpg?format=1000w" width="1500" height="1000" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2621e810-0d83-46e6-b116-d62649c7eea0/1-nepal-balen-gen-z-GettyImages-2261503870.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2621e810-0d83-46e6-b116-d62649c7eea0/1-nepal-balen-gen-z-GettyImages-2261503870.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2621e810-0d83-46e6-b116-d62649c7eea0/1-nepal-balen-gen-z-GettyImages-2261503870.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2621e810-0d83-46e6-b116-d62649c7eea0/1-nepal-balen-gen-z-GettyImages-2261503870.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2621e810-0d83-46e6-b116-d62649c7eea0/1-nepal-balen-gen-z-GettyImages-2261503870.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2621e810-0d83-46e6-b116-d62649c7eea0/1-nepal-balen-gen-z-GettyImages-2261503870.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2621e810-0d83-46e6-b116-d62649c7eea0/1-nepal-balen-gen-z-GettyImages-2261503870.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Balendra Shah takes a selfie while campaigning in Jhapa, Nepal, on Feb. 16. Image: Prakash Mayhema AFP. </em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Shah’s campaigning was tightly choreographed, with a 660-member team handling social media alone. His speeches were rare and brief, but drew massive crowds of thousands. In the city of Janakpur in the Madhes plains, he spoke for just around nine minutes in colloquial Maithili, galvanizing the crowd. Madhesis, long discriminated against by the hill Khas-Arya castes for their perceived loyalty to India, embraced Shah as one of their own. Although Shah has never made his Madhesi identity a cornerstone of his image, Madhesis felt represented. Shah’s win was a win for all of them—the country’s first Madhesi prime minister.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">On election day, the traditional political parties were trounced. But voters did not just vote for the RSP. Many were not even aware who the RSP candidate was in their constituency; they simply voted for Balen Shah’s party. When counting ended, all the other parties had been reduced to bit players. Nepalis had handed Shah’s party a near-supermajority in Parliament.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>The Road Ahead</strong></h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">The slew of arrests and asset investigations initiated by the Shah government since coming to power are only the first in a series of planned reforms. In its first Cabinet meeting, the government announced a 100-point reform agenda for the near future focused on improving service delivery and eliminating avenues for corruption.&nbsp;Among the first far-reaching decisions has been a&nbsp;<a href="https://www.bwint.org/BwiNews/NewsDetails?newsId=1237">blanket ban</a>&nbsp;on party-affiliated student unions in colleges and universities, as well as on party-affiliated trade unions for civil servants and teachers. This prohibition, which was criticized for infringing on the constitutional right to political association, was temporarily halted by the Supreme Court in mid-May.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Other planned reforms are much more ambitious. The government’s plans to digitize all public services will meet with a lack of access and infrastructure. While nearly all Nepalis use mobile phones, internet penetration is still roughly 56 percent. Digital literacy is even lower, at just around 31 per cent, meaning the majority of Nepalis are unable to adequately access, process, and understand information using digital services. Bridging the stark digital divide between urban centres and rural areas will require sustained literacy campaigns and increased investment in infrastructure, both of which cannot be expected to pay immediate dividends.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>The 100-point agenda, however, does not address what is perhaps the most immediate concern—the escalating crisis in West Asia, where over 1.7 million Nepalis live and work. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1779549480538_10436" class="MsoNormal">The 100-point agenda, however, does not address what is perhaps the most immediate concern—the escalating crisis in West Asia, where over 1.7 million Nepalis live and work. There are worries that any expansion of the war on Iran could drastically affect not just the safety of Nepali migrants but also the economy back home. Remittances from abroad&nbsp;<a href="https://www.nrb.org.np/contents/uploads/2023/01/vol30-2_art1-1.pdf">equal one-fourth</a>&nbsp;of the country’s GDP. Any disruption to the economies of the Gulf states could have dire consequences for the health of Nepal’s own economy, which will also be battered by rising fuel prices and a looming fertilizer shortage. If things get worse, Nepal might even have to mount a gargantuan rescue effort to bring back its citizens, a task the country cannot undertake on its own.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1779549480538_10437" class="MsoNormal">Before the election, the RSP manifesto set an ambitious target of becoming a $100 billion economy in five years. To reach that size from Nepal’s current $42 billion economy will require a seven per cent year-on-year growth rate. At a time when the global economy is reeling from the cascading effects of the conflict in West Asia, the goal does not just seem aspirational but nigh impossible. Even before the conflict, the World Bank had forecast growth of 2.1 to 3 per cent for the upcoming fiscal year.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1779549480538_10438" class="MsoNormal">There are also concerns about the RSP’s rhetoric on meritocracy. Marginalized groups fear that issues of representation and inclusion could be abandoned in the pursuit of technocratic development. Whatever gains there are could thus be limited to a certain stratum of society. To its credit, Shah has ensured that women make up one-third of the new Cabinet of Ministers, even appointing a minister from one of the most discriminated of Dalit communities. The government has also decided to formally apologize to Dalits and marginalized communities and enact a series of reforms to address their systemic historical exclusion. These are comforting signs, but they are largely symbolic and will need to be followed up with concrete action and implementation.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1779549480538_10439" class="MsoNormal">What Nepalis know all too well is that promises made during elections are easily broken. The supermajority handed to the RSP is thus not only an opportunity but also a responsibility. Despite repeated disappointments, Nepalis have placed their faith in a new party promising radical reforms. The Shah government has moved at breakneck speed, but it remains to be seen whether it can maintain that pace for the next five years. It will not be easy for Shah and the RSP to fulfil all their promises, but the answer must be in the attempt.&nbsp;</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Pranaya Rana</em></strong><em> is a writer and journalist based in Kathmandu. He is the author of City of Dreams: Stories and runs the newsletter Kalam Weekly.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2d475744-3c44-4a92-943e-0f920a10a0a1/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%282%29.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">A Generational Change in Nepali Politics</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>On NPA’s Quest to Restore Political Agency in Bangladesh</title><category>Interview</category><category>Bangladesh</category><dc:creator>Nafis Hasan</dc:creator><pubDate>Tue, 05 May 2026 14:15:03 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/on-npas-quest-to-restore-political-agency-in-bangladesh</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:69f41420f841474b74d66e03</guid><description><![CDATA[Readus Jawad and Oliur Sun, central committee members of the newly formed 
left political platform Network for People's Action (NPA), in conversation 
with Jamhoor about the future of left-wing politics in post-July 
Bangladesh.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Readus Jawad and Oliur Sun, central committee members of the newly formed left political platform Network for People's Action (NPA), in conversation with Jamhoor about the future of left-wing politics in post-July Bangladesh.</em></p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/615da14c-d6f4-4b78-af28-279a50f8a7f8/NPA_Jamhoor_LS.png" data-image-dimensions="2560x1440" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/615da14c-d6f4-4b78-af28-279a50f8a7f8/NPA_Jamhoor_LS.png?format=1000w" width="2560" height="1440" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/615da14c-d6f4-4b78-af28-279a50f8a7f8/NPA_Jamhoor_LS.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/615da14c-d6f4-4b78-af28-279a50f8a7f8/NPA_Jamhoor_LS.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/615da14c-d6f4-4b78-af28-279a50f8a7f8/NPA_Jamhoor_LS.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/615da14c-d6f4-4b78-af28-279a50f8a7f8/NPA_Jamhoor_LS.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/615da14c-d6f4-4b78-af28-279a50f8a7f8/NPA_Jamhoor_LS.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/615da14c-d6f4-4b78-af28-279a50f8a7f8/NPA_Jamhoor_LS.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/615da14c-d6f4-4b78-af28-279a50f8a7f8/NPA_Jamhoor_LS.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration: Jamhoor</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration: Jamhoor</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Editorial Note: The interview was conducted on January 30, 2026 prior to the elections in Bangladesh on February 12, 2026. </em></p>


  










  
  
    
    
      
        
        
        
          
          
            
        
        
          <iframe allow="autoplay; fullscreen; encrypted-media; picture-in-picture;" scrolling="no" allowfullscreen="true" src="//cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fembed.acast.com%2F63778e5f5e1176001162cd77%2F69e3d9e8d2febdbec90d5043&amp;display_name=Acast&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fembed.acast.com%2F63778e5f5e1176001162cd77%2F69e3d9e8d2febdbec90d5043&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fthumborcdn.acast.com%2Fw5RM5HbqefpvdF0ElepkImlREXg%3D%2F350x350%2Fhttps%253A%252F%252Fassets.pippa.io%252Fshows%252F63778e5f5e1176001162cd77%252F1777683423731-d6a2c545-afbb-4c60-8afe-c089b9e0877e.jpeg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=acast" width="600" frameborder="0" title="Acast embed" class="embedly-embed" height="180"></iframe>
        
        
            
          
        
        
      
    
  
  









  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>The following transcript has been edited for clarity and brevity. It is not an exact match of the audio interview.</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">___________________________<br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Nafis Hasan</strong>: Thank you, Oliur and Jawad. My name is Nafis Hasan, and I'm a member of the editorial committee at Jamhoor, a left online media platform focusing on South Asia and its diasporas. Today we have Oliur Sun and Readus Jawad, two central committee members from the Network for People's Action, a new left-wing platform from Bangladesh in the post-July Revolution political landscape. Welcome, Oliur and Jawad.<br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Oliur Sun</strong>: Thank you, Nafis, and thanks to <em>Jamhoor</em> for hosting us today.<br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Nafis</strong>: So, I want to dive in to talk about what the Network for People's Action is -&nbsp; what is the NPA, where did the name come from? I saw some post online that said it was the name of a WhatsApp group. Like, how did that happen? Tell us a little bit more about your origin story and what your name signifies, and tell us a little bit more about what exactly is the NPA, and why did you choose to form a platform instead of a political party? And more importantly, why now? What is it about this political moment in Bangladesh that has inspired you and your comrades to form this platform?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Readus Jawad</strong>: Basically, even during Sheikha Hasina's tenure, there was a very palpable sense of political emptiness in Bangladesh, because at the end of the day, we have these two sort of bourgeois liberal parties, like BNP and Awami League. None of them actually represent the people, and Awami League day by day became a very despotic, a very fascist entity. There was always a plan in people's, or there's some sort of dream in people's spirit, that we will one day be able to do a different kind of politics, we will one day be able to do something that will be not only effective in Bangladesh, but the politics will be rooted in Bangladesh, the politics will be developed keeping the historicity and the ethnography of Bangladesh in mind. So that was basically the goal from the very beginning.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">After that many people were trying to build something like that, something of a political organization, something of a coalition, even before the July uprising. So, after the July uprising , there was a breakthrough. People could organize freely, people could organize more openly, and they were not as persecuted as they would be under Hasina’s regime. So basically, that's where the idea first originated. I still remember that two days after Hasina's fall, I was talking to another member of NPA, and I was saying to that person, hey, brother, we have to form something, like there's a very large political vacuum in this country, so we have to do something. So that was basically the goal, and the story about the name is very true. The name was basically made as a WhatsApp group name, as a placeholder. It was called New Political Action. At the end of the day, we voted for the name Network for People's Action, because at the end of the day, what we want to do is connect people. We don't want to be the party where everybody has to join, or we don't want to be a platform that everyone has to subscribe to if they want to have a secular or liberal or leftist politics in Bangladesh. What we want to do is connect people's struggles in Bangladesh, because even after the July uprising, we saw the rise of fundamentalism, a rise of right-wing tendencies, fascistic tendencies in Bangladesh politics, but there was resistance to those politics, their rise. We want to connect those pockets of resistance, we want to connect people's struggle, and deliver at least a narrative, a tangible way, a solution-based way that people can actually hope for a better future; people can actually., feel connected to us even if he or she is not a part of our platform.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The process of forming this platform has been going on for about 10-12 months. The timing for our inauguration ceremony wasn’t some plan that we will emerge before the election, and we will be some kind of political force. That wasn't really our goal. We couldn't manage an auditorium last December, that's why we did it in January. We are a bunch of volunteers, we are funding our own political parties, we are giving our own money. We are collecting funds from our own people. Everybody involved is either in a job or in a business, or they work for themselves. So they are giving their time to build something that is still in its infancy. So, at the end of the day, we don't know yet what this network for political action will bring. But our goal is to connect people who firstly believe in the historicity of Bangladesh, who believe in the spirit of ‘71, ‘90, and 2024, and people who believe in the universal human dignity and civil and and political rights for everyone. And secondly, people who understand that power has been centralized in Bangladesh in the hands of a very small number of wealthy people, and if we want to dismantle the fascistic structure that has been put in place in Bangladesh, we have to dismantle that oligarchy that is now controlling Bangladesh.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Oliur Sun:</strong> I think also one of the other reasons why it was named network is actually because we also do not want to fall into the trap of narrow nationalism, which is gaining ground globally with sort of fascistic movements that are taking place everywhere. For example, usually what would happen is whenever you're trying to form a new political platform, whenever the N-word is used in an abbreviation, you would usually think of nationalism, right, or nation, or something like that. Another reason why I think this platform was formed was also because we wanted to revisit the relationship between the state and the citizens, which have been in a very precarious state over the last 15 years, or even going back to the genesis story of the country. And not just in the country, I think it goes back to the genesis of South Asia, like how South Asia has been formed, and different countries of South Asia have been formed, so that's also a history that we are actually looking at quite closely, and it's also one of our guiding narratives. We are very rooted in history in that sense; I mean, not to do some sort of historical determinism, but having a grounded sense of history, so we don't repeat history in a way that we don't want to.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">And also, to offer an understanding of democracy beyond majoritarianism, which I think is almost the case everywhere. And there's a direct connection between majoritarianism and corporate capitalism, which absolutely go hand in hand. That's also something that we actually want to revisit, because, right after the July uprising, which was an uprising against authoritarian government. People use the word fascism, but I'm not quite sure if that is actually an appropriate wording to describe or denote a regime like that, because what we see, or what we are witnessing right now, is also a different kind of fascism. In fact, the one which is actually more close to, perhaps, the origin story of fascism itself in Italy. And if you really look at that, then you'd find the idea of religion and profit - money making is actually quite embedded in the fascistic kind of logic, or, in the myth-making of fascism, if you read from Mussolini and all of that.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So, that's also another understanding which I think we are quite aware of, and we actually want to offer a new kind of understanding of democracy itself as well, and I think globally liberal democracy is in peril - let's not be delusional about that at all. So I don't think just offering a different version of liberal democracy is going to be enough, but of course, it has to be contextualized as well. A country like Bangladesh and its relationship with the global capital always puts us in a very precarious state in terms of policy-making, in terms of being able to make economic decisions. It's very difficult when you have to take loans from IMF and World Bank, and if you don't take them, then you have domestic oligarchy, and then you have a global system of oligarchy, so you are actually crunched in between, you are crushed all the time from both sides. So, the only way to safeguard some sort of citizens' rights, dignity, or well-being, and not just citizens but other forms of lives as well, such as the environment, other sentient beings, trees, plants, insects, and all of that. How do you really safeguard or create a strategy of safeguarding when you are crushed between the global capital and the local set of oligarchies?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">That's actually one of our offerings - it's very challenging, and we don't really have everything laid out because, of course, it's a struggle that you have to put up with and then you figure out as you struggle at the same time. There's no one solution which has worked anywhere in the world, honestly. Because even if you look at Europe, you have a model of social democracy, something which I think is one way of understanding or maybe one way of negotiating with the capital, right? You have some democratic rights for the citizens, where you try to fight the concentration of wealth, but you don't also want to challenge global capitalism, because then you have situations where Trump could just quite easily pick up a Venezuelan president. I mean, nothing would stop him from taking in a Bangladeshi prime minister, right? So, there were those discussions of regime change and all of that as well, but we obviously don't subscribe to that sort of understanding, especially in light of the July uprising, because it was a people's movement, ultimately.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">We have to sort of articulate what our position is going to be in relation to the world, and also across larger South Asia, because in South Asia you have other versions of fascistic movements, especially what happens in India directly affects us. We are direct sufferers of whatever political establishment or movements spring up in India. So if you have a very unequal and discriminatory relationship with your neighbor, and the fact that we're a landlocked country, that's also another reality that we have to acknowledge. So, taking all of this in mind, we actually thought that it's better to have something which is led by people. And by people, we also have that sort of open orientation - it doesn't have to be limited within South Asia, or within Bangladesh, in fact. We are very much interested in building coalitions with people's movements from all around the world, people who are struggling against fascism, struggling against oligarchy, they're all our comrades, and we are trying to also build relationships with them, trying to find strategies which will not just help us, but also help our comrades all over the world. So I think that's an understanding of where we come from.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/275be797-3f9a-48a5-9712-ba7fffb0b5dd/npa+3.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1280x720" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/275be797-3f9a-48a5-9712-ba7fffb0b5dd/npa+3.jpg?format=1000w" width="1280" height="720" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/275be797-3f9a-48a5-9712-ba7fffb0b5dd/npa+3.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/275be797-3f9a-48a5-9712-ba7fffb0b5dd/npa+3.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/275be797-3f9a-48a5-9712-ba7fffb0b5dd/npa+3.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/275be797-3f9a-48a5-9712-ba7fffb0b5dd/npa+3.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/275be797-3f9a-48a5-9712-ba7fffb0b5dd/npa+3.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/275be797-3f9a-48a5-9712-ba7fffb0b5dd/npa+3.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/275be797-3f9a-48a5-9712-ba7fffb0b5dd/npa+3.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Network for People’s Action (NPA) launch rally in Dhaka on January 16, 2026. Source: NPA Facebook page</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Nafis:</strong> Wow, yeah, I mean, it raises so many questions. This is all very, very interesting, and I want to dig into some of the things both you and Jawad have mentioned, and are very pertinent to&nbsp; current politics in Bangladesh, and one of them is what you mentioned about being grounded in history, or the historicity of Bangladesh, right? Because one thing we have noticed in the post-July landscape is that there's a lot of co-optation of what history is, and what it's not; it's a reaction to how Awami League and Sheikh Hasan's regime had created this singular historical narrative that without Bangabondhu, there would be no Bangladesh, right? Without Awami League, there would be no Bangladesh. The only history that matters is the history of Awami League in the creation of Bangladesh, right? One of the biggest backlash to that was the burning of Bangabondhu’s house in Dhanmondi 32, right? Obviously there is public sentiment that drove it, which ultimately resulted in what we see as mob-ocracy. But there's also something that Naeem Mohammed had written about - even if you really hate Awami League, that house still remained a critical piece of Bangladesh's history, because it was a turning point. in reversing Bangabandhu’s regime to full-on military takeover five years later in 1980. So when we talk about being grounded in history, what does that mean to NPA, or to you two? I mean, obviously there's no official position yet, but, what is the direction that you see yourself in, and how do you understand history? Given your left-wing orientation, we'd like to hear a little bit about where the materialist analysis of history is embedded in your understanding.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Oliur Sun</strong>: Okay, alright. So first of all, I think in response to that, what we have to understand is it was a very organized kind of a reaction. It was not something that's spontaneous because there were a lot of instigators; when you do some kind of activism, there's always instigation, so that's one way of understanding this. But what we have seen globally, that's also a trend. You have some right-wing influencers online, preachers, speakers, and those kinds of people who are actually actively influencing some of the domestic violence which had taken place quite some time after the July uprising.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Nafis:</strong> Yeah, the Pinaki-Elias crowd.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Oliur Sun:</strong> Right? Of course, absolutely. Thank you for naming them. It was actually quite actively orchestrated. It was not something that's spontaneous, like oh, people are mad about Bangabondhu, right? So that could have happened on the 5th of August. Right? And it did not happen on the 5th of August. People did barge into the Prime Minister's house, the Prime Minister's palace, the Prime Minister's office, and several other buildings as well. They even burned down a couple of media institutions as well, television channels, which were always airing propaganda. You have those types of moments in any sort of revolutionary uprising kind of situation.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">But this was not something that we understand as a spontaneous reaction. And again it's part of our critical history, because whoever Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was, he was a leader during the liberation war, and that's something that you cannot erase. It's a historical fact. And, of course, any person can turn dictatorial. Any leader can turn authoritarian. And that is another historical reality that you have to come to terms with. But one does not undo the other. So that's something that we have to understand that a person who was at least the face of the struggle would really deserve a place in history of Bangladesh's emergence. So that's something that I think we are absolutely clear about. And at the same time, that doesn't have to turn into some kind of cultism, so that's also something that I think we are very much against. And I think this is something that most modern nations actually struggle with, because this is an embedded design in the idea of a modern state. You need some kind of a cult that will sustain this state. And I think this is a model that we have inherited quite well from the British Crown. So I think that is actually a design, and it's the problem with the design, and not necessarily with the person itself. Of course, even during Sheikh Mujib's regime, a lot of leftists were killed; there were extrajudicial murders. Siraj Sikder was, or is perceived as one of the first instances of extrajudicial killings during the Sheikh Mujib regime, so let's also take that as a historical fact, so that's there.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">But, interestingly, there were a lot of left-leaning political parties, and even celebrated left figures aligned with Sheikh Mujib at that time. So that's also another historical reality, and there is a historical departure of Sheikh Mujib from left-wing Mujibism, and this is also another interesting idea, because Awami League actually had maintained some sort of a center-left or somewhat left image globally. The sort of global image of Awami league that they are this liberal progressive political force, which has helped shape Bangladesh and Bangladesh’s political narrative and what it stands for, its values and all of that. And then at the same time, the domestic experience of Awami League is something that's very different. And from the birth of Awami League, especially post-independence, I'm talking post-1971 right after Bangladesh was born, Sheikh Mujib was someone who had a different role. And then after he came to power, which I think we are also witnessing right now, people who were faces of a revolution quite often turn reactionary, or give in to the establishment, or are not able to manage the post-uprising situation well. And that is something that we have also experienced; the faces of our uprising - people feel betrayed by them. That's also one of the contexts in which NPA steps in.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The disillusionment and the betrayal of people's trust - although we have also seen a very nationalistic drive in terms of understanding of history, you want to challenge Awami League’s co-option of history, but what do you challenge it with? If you challenge it with another reactionary, narrow, nationalistic imagination, then that's no better and that is exactly what has gone wrong. Because you are trying to portray a different kind of vision, something which I think will compare with the Akhand Bharat kind of narrative. So you have this Akhand Bangla, something like that - I mean, there is a map, a revival of the old maps, like I've seen people sharing maps. This gives you this revivalist imagination, which I think is quite popular amongst right-wingers, especially in South Asia. If we compare that with Hindutva, you'd see that kind of weaponizing of decolonization or post-colonial narratives, and narrative making, and then offering a version like that.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">We have seen this sort of revivalist moments as well - celebrations or festivals in a pre-colonial way, like back during the Sultanate, the way Eid was celebrated, we're gonna celebrate Eid this time like that, so these sort of revivalist tendencies are also very much present, which I think we are very critical and aware of. Because we are not doing some sort of historical revivalism as well, right? We know that we are at a very new political juncture, at a very new time, and it requires a new kind of politics, so we're learning lessons from everywhere, and we're trying to figure out what strategies would actually work best to challenge this sort of fascistic, narrow nationalist sort of tendencies, but at the same time also trying to have an understanding of how to fight the kind of narratives are out there. For example, according to Franz Fanon, nationalism is also understood as a reaction toward anti-colonial struggle. So, we are also revisiting whether that's still the case, or whether that's something that's still going to work, because something that's rooted in left history or left-wing political history is also the idea of internationalism, right? So I think whether we can fight the global capital within our own nation only is also a question that we are quite driven by.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Nafis:</strong> Jawad, do you want to weigh in on the question of history and how you are rooted in it?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Readus Jawad</strong>: Yeah, I just wanted to add, like, two or three things. So, Sheikh Mujib's house got burned down on 5th of August, when Sheikh Hasina was deposed. But it wasn't demolished until 5th February, so after 6 months. They took bulldozers and tried to demolish the house. But the house has not yet been demolished, and it has become a ritual. If anything happens with Awami League, or anything happens against Awami League, people go there, tear off some bricks and some rods, so the problem that we have seen after 5th of August in 2024 is a symbolic collapse of society, or the symbolic collapse of the historical narrative. For 15 years, the historical narrative was that Sheikh Mujib was the undisputed leader of the liberation movement, Awami League was the undisputed party of liberation. No other people did anything. Sheikh Mujib declared independence on 25th March, on 16th December, and Bangladesh became independent, right?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This sort of narrative - what it did was replace people's struggle, people's lived struggle of everyday lives, with a sort of great leader narrative, and this has happened in Bangladesh time after time. This has happened before in 1947, for example, in what we called East Bengal back then. East Bengali peasants were one of the main proponents of the Pakistan movement since the Khilafat movement happened. But at the end of the day, when Pakistan happened, all credit went to Jinnah. So, this sort of capture of people struggle by one person or one influential party happened in our history many, many times, and this happened after July also. NCP tried to frame that only they and their allies were the only stakeholders of July, and not everybody had a say, or not everybody was part of July.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Influential political parties and leaders are trying to take ownership of people’s struggle, and we believe why this keeps happening is that the material basis of history has not changed in Bangladesh. Before 1947, it was a largely agrarian, peasant-based country. It's still a largely agrarian, peasant-based country. In 2020, when COVID-19 happened, a lot of people went back to the agricultural sector because industry was shut down. So, the country is still in the same material position, but there has been a new development, there has been a new class that basically is the actual proletariat, because even in a village community, a person who doesn't have anything, who doesn't have any of his own land, can still get by by borrowing from people or trying to survive in different ways. But when urban migrant workers emerged in Bangladesh as a class, they didn't have any sort of social or economic or any other state protection mechanisms. So these urban workers are very agitated, they are very disillusioned with all the development narratives, all the historical narratives, and at the end of the day, July was able to call on them. July was able to encircle them in a way that they felt something will happen from this that will change their lives, that will make their lives a little easier, but that didn't happen. So what we see is that a people’s struggle that has been going on before 1947 has been getting captured by the bourgeois and elite people over and over. So what our understanding, or what our intention is to make people their own spokesperson. We don't want to replace participation with representation. When people have to tell their own stories they have to form their own history, and that's what we have been trying to do ever since July. I personally have done programs to portray how the liberation war was a people’s struggle, how it wasn't just done by one party or a leader. We are in a process of reclaiming our own history, we have a process of reinterpreting the narratives and understanding who benefits from what narratives and how people can actually find their own place in the history of Bangladesh.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/446414e1-04db-4677-a945-caad4de9ac26/dhanmondi_32-a_1.jpg" data-image-dimensions="857x482" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/446414e1-04db-4677-a945-caad4de9ac26/dhanmondi_32-a_1.jpg?format=1000w" width="857" height="482" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/446414e1-04db-4677-a945-caad4de9ac26/dhanmondi_32-a_1.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/446414e1-04db-4677-a945-caad4de9ac26/dhanmondi_32-a_1.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/446414e1-04db-4677-a945-caad4de9ac26/dhanmondi_32-a_1.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/446414e1-04db-4677-a945-caad4de9ac26/dhanmondi_32-a_1.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/446414e1-04db-4677-a945-caad4de9ac26/dhanmondi_32-a_1.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/446414e1-04db-4677-a945-caad4de9ac26/dhanmondi_32-a_1.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/446414e1-04db-4677-a945-caad4de9ac26/dhanmondi_32-a_1.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Bangabondhu Sheikh Mujib’s residence and museum in Dhanmondi Road 32, Dhaka, set on fire and destroyed using bulldozer after August 5. Source: The Daily Star</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Nafis</strong>: That is very fascinating, and I want to shift gears a little bit and move the question towards what you said, Jawad - how your goal is to have people tell their own stories, and what Oliur you had said about how you want to envision a democracy that's beyond majoritarianism. Do you see these things as interlinked?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">And if so, what do you think your approach is going to be? Like, how do you make it happen, and what does that look like in the coming years? How do we have a democracy that is beyond majoritarianism? There's so much heterogeneity, even in a country that's 97% Muslim and Bengali. There's still all these different voices, and not just identity-based voices, but also, classes. Like what, Jawad, you were saying, the urban migrant workers had no protection, and one of the biggest things we saw was during COVID, garment factory workers - they weren't sure if their factories were going to open. They walked all the way from their villages and then suddenly the factory worker owners are saying, no, we're closing and they have to walk back. And the state did nothing to help them. So tell me a little bit more about how you envision bringing that sort of democracy to people, which is beyond representation, beyond majoritarianism.<br><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Readus Jawad</strong>: Well, I would say that, our organogram would give you a very basic idea of how we want to do this. Basically, we have two councils - one is the Central Council that has been published, and another is an executive council that will be published in the next press conference, probably next week. Both of these councils are democratic; there's no hierarchy, nobody takes the decision, everybody sits down, we have a meeting. We hear everybody's concerns, and then we move on to voting, and even after voting, we talk about the problems that our decisions might generate and how to mitigate them. So we are functioning like that and we intend to do the same in every other scenario. For example, we have already received thousands of applications from all over the country who want to connect with us. We are planning on meeting each and every one individually. We don't want to do it over Zoom, we don't want to do it over any sort of written interview or anything like that. We will go to their localities, we will go to their areas and we will connect with them, connect with their community, and hear their stories from themselves. We don't want to replace their voices with ours. If we have an issue that we have to address, we will bring the direct sufferers or the direct victims of that issue to.the forefront. We don't want to make or take people's narrative for ourselves and do politics with that. So that's one of our concerns. And secondly, what we want to accomplish at the end of the day is to enable people to talk about politics. And create an environment that will make them feel safe. For example, we took decisions in the Central Council even before the NPA was officially formed that I didn't agree with, or that Oliur probably didn't agree with. We made many of those decisions, but at the end of the day, we believe that if we don't respect each other's dignity, each other's understanding and perspectives, we will never be able to grow as a political party or any sort of political entity. So, we have this approach to direct democracy, if I should say, that we want to implement everywhere. We want to have these direct lines of communication with the people, with the masses, and we want to bring their ideas and their voices into the mainstream, where they have been perpetually marginalized.<br><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Nafis</strong>: Oliur, did you want to add anything to that?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Oliur Sun:</strong> This is another challenge that I think people have not yet been able to sort out, that is, how do you NOT do identity politics and still have diversity in the room, or in your decision-making process, how do you make sure it's not just a bunch of men making or getting more ground than others. This can actually happen in many political settings, especially in party-making decisions, because, even in platforms, even in organizations, this is something that I have seen repeatedly happen over and over again, and this is actually a problem with left-wing parties in our country. So that's something that we have to be extremely aware of, and I think we are still in the process of developing a strategy. Jawad was mentioning about the Executive Council and the Central Council, but then we also have a General Assembly, and then at the same time, we are trying to currently reach out to people who are interested. We have already made contacts, we have already filled out forms, but then, you know, there's also a digital divide in the country, so there's actually a huge chunk of people who do not have access to internet, or not as active on social media, or would not be able to fill out a Google form, so you already have a class barrier right there.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">That's also something that we have to take into account and set our strategies in a way so that we can go beyond that kind of digital divide. And this is something that we are actually trying to form, and there are a couple of decisions which are kindly being made in terms of how we reach out to people who are not in our room. For example, do we want to listen to a <em>Hijra</em> person, or do you want them to make part of our decision-making process? Do we have someone who is an informal worker? Let's say, for example, a domestic worker who doesn't really have any sort of protections whatsoever, not even a formal contract with their employer, so do we have someone like that when we are making or planning our economic strategies, when we are planning our programs. So it's very important for us, I think, to look in the room and see who is there and who is not, instead of someone who perhaps already has a social standing. Or, you know, someone people already know, and this is a problem with most of the parties, right? You do go after the celebrity cult - like, who is in your party, who is a well-known, popular kind of face? And then they end up gaining more credibility, or their voices are heard more or taken more seriously than others. This is a very serious challenge that we have to settle and we're still trying to build strategies to resolve that. We haven't figured it out at the moment, but we are trying to reach out to communities which are usually not represented.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">This is a problem with any political party. Even if you look at any political party globally, most of them, in their decision-making bodies, will not have people from historically marginalized groups. And, they might have someone as their face of the party or someone as a member of the parliament, but in the decision-making body, you will not actually find them, and that is actually where the limits of this sort of identity politics come in, because they are always used as faces, never as decision makers. So this is actually something that I think we want to take up as a challenge - how do we have people from different groups which are historically marginalized, and put them in a room while we are trying to make decisions? And they should be in the decision-making body, so whatever they can agree on the commonalities would benefit or offer us a vision of material conditioning which actually is going to apply to everyone. So I think that sort of strategy making might help.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">And this is something that I have not seen practiced anywhere, even in left-wing platforms, networks, even NGOs, you name it. Most of the platforms don't really have them in decision-making bodies. They will go and listen to them, but then you are going to be the voice for them. And you don't know them, and then we are judging that person based on their connection with the communities, right? I mean, I'm just speculating like, for example, you'd find a straight guy working with the trans community being their voice. Or maybe, a middle class privileged person translating what the working class needs are. That sort of issues are inherent especially when you are trying to make decisions for a community who are not there, or, you know, who are presented through someone else. That's a very big challenge. So that's something that we are actually trying to figure out because Bangladesh, although it's a very small land, we're actually dealing with a large number of people from different demographies, from different social class positions, even caste, I mean, we don't really talk about caste in Bangladesh that much, but that's also something that we have to take into account. You have Harijians who work as cleaners, and they are someone who is completely out of the political imagination. And then you obviously have the Rohingyas, which, we have sheltered them, but they are not even part of any consideration whatsoever until recently - there is an ongoing conversation like the Bangladeshi government has offered Rohingyas who are stuck in Saudi Arabia that they would be given Bangladeshi passports. That's also something that's not really part of the political mainstream discourse. What is part of the political mainstream is the idea of repatriation. But then nobody knows how that's going to happen, and Dr. Yunus is making promises that by next year, most Rohingyas will go back to their homeland, and that obviously did not happen because you are dealing with a very different political reality there. So how do you deal with these people when they don't even have an official refugee status?</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>Even the left-wing parties have failed us in terms of delivering those ideals, because there’s always been this tension between cultural versus material welfare, and most of the left-wing parties are more interested in carrying on the banner of secularism rather than carrying on the banner of free healthcare<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  <figcaption class="source">&mdash; Oliur Sun</figcaption>
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308642">And in a country like Bangladesh with its economy, we are told that you cannot afford to offer them some sort of refugee status, because then the question of rights comes in. And then how do you settle that? How do you make sure that they have the right to education, or the right to healthcare, and all those kinds of things. So that's also an ongoing issue that we have to come to terms with, something that we are actually thinking through. We are currently building strategies so that, at least in the decision-making process, decisions should be made in a way by who is not represented in the decision-making body, and they should have a say, even if they don't hold an official position. I think this is how at least certain decisions should be made, where you actually look in the room, and you realize that, you know, most of the people are not actually here. So we need people from historically marginalized communities to be in the room, so that we can agree upon something in common. And those sort of commonalities are exactly something that we are trying to look at, and that again includes material conditions like healthcare, access to public services and maybe even transportation, which is something that is not really part of our mainstream political discourse.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308641">Even the left-wing parties have failed us in terms of delivering those ideals, because there's always been this tension between cultural versus material welfare, and most of the left-wing parties are more interested in carrying on the banner of secularism rather than carrying on the banner of free healthcare. So that is a very big challenge, and you see that most of the left-wing parties are in the primary phases of this secular liberal struggle, rather than some sort of material conditions, conditions which actually are going to benefit the people directly. And that's exactly the biggest challenge we are currently facing. If you can have free healthcare for everyone, then everybody benefits - people who cannot afford healthcare, people who have to go to public healthcare services for critical diseases or injuries which require critical attention. People are actually heavily reliant on the public healthcare services, and that's something that they're not currently getting, and the public health system is not being able to deliver the needs that they have right now.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308640">So that's going to be part of our agendas as well, and we are trying to base ourselves in terms of how we can create strategies for material welfare, and not going back to some sort of Chinese cultural revolution. and again, that's also a part of our conversation, like, whether we subscribe to Chomsky as China being sham communism, or whether we want to take that as a model where people actually have been struggling with this as well. how do you come to terms with industrial capitalism?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308639"><br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308638"><strong>Nafis:</strong> Oliur you brought up some really good points, and I'm really interested in dissecting this material versus cultural fights that we have had, because it seems to be a very big spot in contemporary left politics in Bangladesh. But I do want to go back to the question of identity politics and tokenism that you brought up, especially in the case that we have seen post-July. And it's not just in Bangladesh, right? Like, for example, for the longest time the right wing in the U.S. are xenophobic, they're anti-immigrant, or anti-black people, right? However, they do have representation from those communities, right? In the last election, we saw a rise in the number of votes in almost all immigrant and people of color communities for Trump, right? So, similarly in Bangladesh, what we're seeing is that, for the longest time, the belief was that Awami League was the party for the Hindus, Awami League was the party for the Adibashis, right?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308637">But the case of Sarbamitra Chakma, which presents a very interesting case study in identity politics and how it can be weaponized, and I would love to hear your analysis of that situation. Sarbamitra Chakma ran on right-wing platforms, right, which was very different, because we saw that the same parties or the same groups who supported Sarbamitra Chakma were also connected to the people who beat up Adibashis on the streets of Dhaka, and who championed the full military occupation of CHT forever, right? Because they think, no, this is part of Bangladesh, there's a separatist movement going on, right? So how do we understand identity politics currently in Bangladesh's political landscape? And also, how do you figure out a way where you're not just using tokenism? One thing that has come out in the wake of Sarbamitra Chakma's case is that , there's no way to say Adhibashis are oppressed, because they will say, well, look at this guy, he is part of NCP, or, like, he was part of NCP, and he went pretty far. There's also representation of Adibashis in the members of parliament, etc, so why are you saying they are oppressed?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308636">But we know they are oppressed because there's members of the Bawm community who have been incarcerated without any sort of charges against them for more than 500 days now, and the government is not saying anything about or justifying what exactly are the allegations against those folks. So, tell me a little bit more about, like, in the current political landscape, how do you see identity as a political object?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308635"><br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308634"><strong>Oliur Sun:</strong> I mean, I'm talking about what people look like, their face color, their skin color, their biologies, for example. But this is a check that I have used, and this has worked more or less so far - checking for privilege, because Sarbamitra doesn't really represent the struggle of the Adibashis in any way whatsoever. He comes from a very well-off middle-class family and went to elite schools within Rangamati; has attended Notre Dame College in Dhaka, so he's not someone who is directly a victim of, let's say, a land grab by the military in the Chittagong Hill Tracts. He's not the kind of adhibashi who is struggling or fighting for their own land, not even someone who is struggling to at least make the CHT accord a reality. So that's something that we have to understand - he's not someone who shares the Adibashi struggle. Now, if you want to make him the face of Adibashis, you know, sure, go ahead. But he does not represent the struggle. So he's someone who doesn't really have a stake in the damage,for example, he doesn't feel for the Bawms; like, they have been incarcerated for … actually, it's going to be 700 days really soon.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308633">And they were arrested during the Awami League regime, and the interim government did not even release them, so they're still in jail. Although, a lot of people were released from jail without any sort of formal legal processes, but then you have members of these communities who are just stuck in jail, basically, and nobody can even legally help them, so that's the kind of reality that we're dealing with. And then you have, you know, people like Sarbamiitra Chakma, who people take for face value, because, you know, here you have a face of the indigenous.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308632">People who look different, so you go after the bodily other, right? That's the sort of, I think, identity and politics that we are actually dealing with, and this is something that also goes back to even the US. You have Melania Trump, she's white, she's the first lady, but cannot even speak English properly, and so how do you reckon with that reality? Does Melania really represent the immigrant struggle? She clearly does not. And in the very same way, Sarbamitra also doesn't represent the indigenous struggle. So, who is going to come to the forefront if you really do a privilege check; like, who is privileged in terms of what? Someone can be Indigenous, but then you have indigenous people who own multiple buildings in Dhaka City with extreme wealth.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308631">And then you obviously have different groups as well. He belongs to the dominant majority of the indigenous group - Chakma, and then you have people from other communities, even Marma is also the second dominant group. So, you really have to understand the struggle of the indigenous communities to actually understand that he's not the representative of that community, or doesn't represent their struggle. Or the commoners within that landscape.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308630">It's actually not too difficult, honestly; if you really look or check their privileges, I think then it becomes quite apparent. So, yes, the idea of identity is very much there, and this is something that Jamaat has used a lot, because they are the prime face of Islamist political positioning. They have a Hindu candidate running for election in Khulna and you really have to ask, like, is this person really representing a Hindu community whose house has been burned down by miscreants or Islamists? So if that's not really the case, then you can't take them as the face of, or as the representative of the community.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308629">And I think that's something that's not too difficult to dissect or understand. We also should not take people as stupid, because people actually understand these kinds of things quite well. Because what we are dealing with is actually identities who are co-optable, right? And that's something that people are going to enjoy, right? Especially the right-wingers, especially the nationalists. Who is this ideal other? So the ideal other is the other who is going to work for us. Who is going to serve our political agenda, and not the other one. Not the one who protests, not the one who stands for their struggle, but the one who actually carries on our mantle, carries on our struggle, which is the sort of majoritarian agendas, the kind of negotiatory politics to which they're going to act as a bridge.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308628">So it's basically a sort of sham representation. They don't really represent anybody, they represent privilege. Right there, that's what they represent, and they actually want to have the sort of privileged positions within the society to create a space for their own. And I think this is something that left-wing parties have also struggled with. Like you become a face, then how do you not fall for the celebrity cult? How do you avoid the idea of glamour, right? It's glamorous, and then you attract attention, you attract privilege. How do you really deal with that reality? And it's easier said than done. I’ve even seen seasoned activists falling for that sort of celebrity cult. Once you become a celebrity, you have a position in power, and also you get treated slightly differently in terms of positionality that you have acquired. So how do you really deal with your privilege? And how you do not get blinded by your privilege is also a very serious task that I think we all have to be extremely, extremely aware of.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308627"><br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308626"><strong>Readus Jawad:</strong> Yeah, I'll just very briefly say two things. Firstly, about Sarbamitra, the most interesting aspect of Sarbamitra's activities around the campus and regarding DUCSU, is that he is basically being told to do the dirty work of the panel he was elected in. He was elected in the panel for Islami Chatro Shibir and he's basically being directed to do their dirty work, to beat people up, to evict homeless people from campus, evict small business owners, small vendors from campus, and, this is not something new, like Sarbamitra has been doing this since last September.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308625">The problem is, what happens in liberal democracy is that we inherently understand that someone does tokenism, if, for example, BNP is also a very tokenistic party. We are talking about Jamaat-e-Islami, but BNP is also a very tokenistic party. BNP had a woman as their chairperson for the longest time, but at the end of the day, they couldn't find 5% women candidates for their election. In Bangladesh, what happens is that tokenism is viewed as intention, right? So, when Jamaat nominated two, three people outside of their party, outside of their student organization, or nominated two, three women in the DUCSU election, and in other student council elections, people thought that, okay, they will change, they will have some sort of revolutionary change later, we will see some of this reflection in the election. But there is no reflection of this in the election. Jamaat did not nominate a single female candidate.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308624">And secondly, I would say that we have to understand how class can overcome some sort of identity barriers. For example, a person who has been.evicted from the Dhaka University campus by Sarbamitra will be more - it doesn't really matter how right-wing he is - he will be more empathetic to an Indigenous person who has lost his land because of development projects or because of army building a barrack in his backyard. So, these emotions are very common, but we have to link those emotions together, we have to make people understand, convey the message to the people that all of our struggles are basically bounded, together and against the same entities, at the end of the day. So, this is how I believe that the identity barriers can be resolved according to class lines.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_308623"><br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p>
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354035"><strong>Nafis:</strong> There is that idea of intersectionality which posits some form of similar thing. What you're saying is that class and race are not mutually exclusive, or there is a politics that can combine both of them, right? And I think it has been difficult for the Left, not just in Bangladesh, but worldwide, especially also in the Western Hemisphere, to articulate a politics like that, because often, like what you're saying, we swing one way or the other. There's also strands of Marxism, or Left thought that have strayed one way or the other, right? There's that idea called vulgar Marxism or class reductionism, where everything is boiled down to class, versus, people swaying way too far into the identity politics realm, where the identity becomes the animating factor in your politics, right? But one thing that has really been a sticking point in Bangladesh politics, ever, I would say since partition, is this existential crisis that Bangladeshis have, like, are they a Bengali first, or are they a Muslim first? And it seems like this question has come to the forefront once again in the post-July political landscape because Jamaat, they are very smart. They have spent a lot of time building out their infrastructure, as we have seen in the student union elections countrywide. But they have never been able to get more than 15 to 30 seats in the parliament, right? So their power lies in this grassroots level, but they're never able to articulate that power upwards into the parliamentary level. But this time, it seems to be different, right? Because they are articulating a version of we are Muslims, right? And I think in a reactionary move towards Hasinas' regime, that seems to be taken up by Bangladeshi people. Like, they're more accepting of that fact, because Awami League was always seen as the face of secular liberalism that posited that we are Bengali first, right? So, how do you view this question of Bengali versus Muslim? Is that an animating driving force of how political parties are rearranging their views of what it means to be a Bangladeshi?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354034"><br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354033"><strong>Readus Jawad</strong>: Okay, so we have to understand that there's no binary choice of being a Bengali or a Muslim, right? For example, there is no one singular Islam - if you see the Islam of the Middle East, if you see the Islam of Saudi Arabia, and if you go on into the Levant, and then you go into Turkey, you go into Iran, Persia, and then other Muslim-dominated nations in Middle Asia, you come into India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, and then you come into Bangladesh, and then into Indonesia, Malaysia, all of these countries have their distinct cultures and their distinct versions of Islam, right? So, in Bangladesh, Muslim is not really just an identifier of religion, it has almost become an identifier of class.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354032">Because at the end of the day, what the hegemonic political narrative was that in 1947, we created a nation for Muslim peasants in East Bengal which became Pakistan and everything. So, at the end of the day, what people were saying is that if we make a Muslim nation, just because of our religious identity, that doesn't make us coherent as a nation. So that's when we saw the rise of Bengali nationalism and the lead up towards the liberation war. But now that we have our own country, we don't have to choose between being a Muslim or a Bengali. We can do whatever we want to do. Whoever puts this dual loyalty test to the people of Bangladesh are their enemies. This is very obvious. When someone tells you to choose - become either Muslim or a Bengali - they are actually dividing people, they are actually creating a tension that doesn't and should not even exist.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354031">So that's my point. And secondly, what I believe is that what Jamaat has been trying to do is that they have seen the rise of this religion-driven rise in fascism in India, also in Afghanistan, also in Pakistan at various times. So they're trying to emulate this. They're trying to unify the nation by using Islamic moral framework, Islamic language, and Islamic languages of justice. They are trying to unite the nation by showing them this big other exists, that Hindutva is coming to get us, or Modi is coming to get us, <em>Akhand Bharat</em> is coming to get us.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>When someone tells you to choose - become either Muslim or a Bengali - they are actually dividing people, they are actually creating a tension that doesn’t and should not even exist.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  <figcaption class="source">&mdash; Readus Jawad</figcaption>
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354030">But at the end of the day, it will not endure, because being Bengali and being Muslim, is inherently baked into the existence of many people in our country. Like, even the most hardcore person who doesn't want to have anything to do with Bengali culture, anything to do with Bengali identity, still eats fish with rice. That's the most Bengali thing to do. He still is going to talk in Bengali. If he wants to curse someone, he's going to curse in Bengali. He is not going to curse in Arabic, right? So, these things are very inherent to one's existence, and when we take into account this plurality of understanding - some people may want to be Muslim before they want to be Bengali, and some people may want to become more Bengali than their Muslim- that doesn't really take away from our national strength, from our national identity, and that does not need to be as divisive as political parties make it to be.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354029"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354028"><strong>Nafis:</strong> I have a quick follow-up question to that. I know the referendum, the <em>Gonobhot</em>, that is also on the ballot; they are proposing to change the constitution from saying we are all Bengalis to we are all Bangladeshis. I'd also like to hear your take on that.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354027"><br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p>
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354026"><strong>Oliur Sun:</strong> I think I'm going to go back to the previous point; I think that's also going to address that issue as well. The problem is with the modern state, and why do you always have to have some sort of ethno-nationalist framework for a modern state to be operational and why are citizens being always asked this question, or having to choose an identity in order for the modern state to function, like that is where I think the problem starts. And of course, you do have that historical reality where there is an identity crisis because of 200 years of colonialism, so that's also something that we can't ignore. There's a lot of epidermalization of inferiority that people have. Out of that, a lot of reactions, especially in terms of identity, actually springs up… it's almost like people are constantly in a phase of existential crisis, right? And that is also actually a psychological reaction - to actually dissect that as well, because I think the sort of deep psychological damage of colonialism has not been addressed politically and that is something that needs to be debunked. Fanon also talks about this in his writings, right? The making of a new man who would be able to go beyond this internalized idea of inferiority. Identity crisis inflicted by having to choose between you and the superior being, like, the whites, the colonizers, and then you have yourself, so how do you really sort of deal with that kind of crisis psychologically is something that has an immediate effect. And it's also a narrative, I think, quite a popular narrative in terms of how Islam was introduced to Bengal, and why people developed a certain sort of attachment or affinity towards that sort of Islam or Muslim identity.&nbsp;</p>
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354025">At the same time, you also have to account for the reality that how was Islam, or the Muslim identity, or even, for that matter, <em>Sanatan </em>identity or Hindu identity was constructed, reiterated during the colonial state during the British Raj, and what is done to the idea and ideation of people, their understanding of their existence, their, attachments and sense of being during that time. Which has then, obviously, been replicated in this modern state-making process when you have India and Pakistan completely being divided based on religion. And that is a reality that we have to negotiate. So I think the idea or the split between Bengali and Muslim actually dates back to that sort of problem. And, it's something which I think has repeatedly been debunked by several intellectuals, but the problem here is most of the political parties have not really taken that up. BNP had or did preach some sort of Bangladeshi nationalism, something which you were actually referring to, like the Constitution revising that Bengali identity and putting in Bangladeshi as a more inclusive word, which I think, by the book it works, most definitely, but then we also have to be critical of that sort of history, where you have history of Bangladeshi Nationalist Party (BNP) actually orchestrating demographic engineering in the Chittagong Hill Tracts, displacing millions. Or if not millions, thousands of indigenous people, have had episodes of migration into neighboring countries, so how do you really deal with that? Like, you have Bangladeshi nationalism, which has actually caused that. So, having that in the Constitution does not necessarily translate into better politics, or doesn't really change the ground reality.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354024">&nbsp;And again, it's because of the colonial administrative legacy that we have continued. People are actually quite removed from these institutions, and that's also something that we have to understand. People don't want to visit a government office because it's alienating for them. So what have we done to actually revise or attend to that sort of anxiety. Why do people feel alienated in a government office? It's where they should be going to take services, right? So, that is also one of the important political tasks that most of the political parties have not really taken up, and revising this whole sort of structure, which is a direct legacy of colonialism, and again being modeled after an ethno-nationalist modern state.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354023">And I think globally that is what is actually in crisis. In the US, even in Gaza, the idea of an ethno-nationalist framework would repeatedly come up. So, I think the question of Bengali versus Muslim actually is a very ethno-nationalist sort of question. And there's a very right word for this sort of debate in Bangla, which is called কুতর্ক (<em>ku-torko</em>). I don't know an English equivalent for that, but I think it's something similar to that. Because you're having to sort of, you know, choose between your identities, and here I'm very Zizekian. Like, if you go deep into yourself, you find there's no reason for you to choose anything. You're under an organization, which is a state, which is an almost violent organization to a certain degree. So, the negotiation should be with an organization, without having to choose any sort of identity. I'm a citizen, and that is my primary identity in a country. I have a Bangladeshi passport. I'm a Bangladeshi passport holder. Whether I'm a Bangladeshi or Muslim doesn't change the fact, or doesn't change the reaction of an immigrant officer in the U.S. when they see the Bangladeshi passport. And that is exactly something that we have to deal with. So maybe, having the word Bangladeshi in the Constitution would help in terms of, let's say, having a legal fight, in terms of making more room, especially when we are making policies for everyone in the country. So it does help, you know, legally speaking.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354022">But then I'm also not sure of the sort of material reality or the material translation of that legal framework, and that is something that is actually our work to be done. It's not ready yet. And that is exactly where we step in, I think, as a political platform.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354021"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354020"><strong>Readus Jawad:</strong> These sorts of terms - Bangladeshi or, like, any sort of nationalistic terms - they don't mean anything to people who cannot avail their basic services. For example, a person who sleeps on the streets of Dhaka, he does not have the ability to get a national ID card. It doesn't matter what we call him. It doesn't matter if we call him Bangladeshi, or Bengali, or Muslim, or Bengali Muslim, or anything. He doesn't even have a way to prove that this is his name, right? The name he calls himself, or who are his parents. He doesn't have any sort of identification with the state or the nation. So, like, creating this sort of cosmetic band-aids for the existential and identity problem in the core of this Bangladesh state I don't think will be very fruitful in the long term.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354019"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354018"><strong>Nafis:</strong> Yeah, and I think when you were saying that, that really brings us back to the question of, what the Left has spent years doing, getting into cultural fights versus material fights on the ground, is something that I heard in the last couple of years. There was a video recording, maybe, of a rickshawpuller who had said, or, like, something to that extent, where basically it was an expression of saying that I want the freedom to be able to feed myself, or feed my family, right? And that's where, really, it comes down to, is that.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354017">Regardless of these larger questions of ethno-nationalism or identity and class, it comes down to, like, okay, are people able to even survive in this country? And I think, that's been a vacuum that the left has not been able to fill and I was wondering what you think about, or where do you see NPA filling in that gap, and how to fill in that gap? And I know you referred to some free healthcare programs, that I don't know if that was hypothetical, but is it something that's going to be part of your platform? How do you see reversing that trend of just getting bogged down by cultural fights?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354016"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354015"><strong>Readus Jawad:</strong> First, I have to give a disclaimer - we don't have any sort of resentment or disrespect to any leftist parties in Bangladesh. We view all of us, all of them, as our comrades, and we are very much willing to work in solidarity and in cooperation with them. Just to get it out of the way. But the problem with leftist parties in Bangladesh have been the fact that after 1990, after the fall of the Soviet Union, what happened was that the largest leftist party of Bangladesh, Communist Party Bangladesh (CPB), was basically in a very frozen, a very decision-paralyzed state. Like, they could not take any other strategies, right? So, almost all major leftist parties in Bangladesh do revolutionary politics. They want to overthrow the whole class structure through a violent or non-violent revolution, and after that, they want to create a state or a society that will be beneficial to the proletariat, and then that will crush the oligarchy or the bourgeois class. But at the end of the day, what happens is that in a global neoliberal order, something like this revolution is very distant. People don't really believe that something like this is going to happen, and what happens is that the communist parties or other leftist parties often fail to articulate to people how they can improve people's lives within the existing framework of a liberal bourgeois democracy. So they talk about revolutions, they talk about how they will upend the cost structure, but at the end of the day, people don't really care about that. People care about their day-to-day needs. I have worked in a leftist party way back in my school days, and whenever I talked to people, people would say, okay, you are going to do a revolution, okay, call me when the time of revolution comes. Like you are not offering me any intermediate solution between this time and revolution. What am I supposed to do now?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_354014">So, our goal from NPA is to give people those specific very grounded solutions that we can do, we can tangibly do, and how we can improve people's lives systemically. For example, Oliur talked about healthcare services and, one of our, for example, major parts of our policy platform is the formalization of workers. In Bangladesh, 85% of the workers who are part of the workforce work in the informal sector. They don't have any sort of rights, they don't have any sort of labor protections, they don't have any sort of standardized wage or anything like that, they don't have any workplace safety or regulations or anything like that. So, what happens is that these people, if we go to them, if we talk about revolution, if you talk about upending class structure, these people may be very sympathetic, but he is living a day-to-day struggle. He cannot throw himself into that politics from the very beginning. But what we are going to offer these people, or what one of our policy platforms is, is a formalization of the economy. We are going to offer a minimum wage, for example, or standards for regulations, standards for, for example, street vendors, standards and regulations, for example, day laborers in Dhaka, or in other places. We want to make a very impactful difference in people's lives that leftist parties have often failed to articulate to people.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>From 5th August to 8th August...the people became united, people put up mechanisms for self-defense, people put up mechanisms for self-rule, people put up mechanisms for conflict resolution... But what happened after July was that their political agency was very deliberately stripped away from them.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  <figcaption class="source">&mdash; Readus Jawad</figcaption>
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383774">I'm very sympathetic to their ideas, and I'm very certain that many leftist parties actually have those solutions in mind, but their politics is not geared towards providing this solution. Their politics is geared more towards bringing a revolutionary change in Bangladesh, which is basically a very difficult task thing to do, and this is why I think leftist parties often default to a sort of cultural battle, or sort of culture war, because when you don't have anything substantial to say to the public, what are you going to do? You are going to see that the right-wing is fomenting some sort of social conflict, some sort of cultural conflict, and you have to talk about that, because that's the easiest thing to do, and that gets you some reaction that's, you know, the very basis of reactionary politics. It gets you credibility, it gets you media time, it gets you attention from people, so it becomes a very shallow, but effective outlet for political activities of leftist parties, and I have done that too in during my student activism days, I have done similar sort of culture war activism, but at the end of the day, that is because we didn't have a plan.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383750"><br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383751"><strong>Oliur Sun:</strong> Yeah, and just to add to that, I think what we offer is, first of all is a platform who are not running for this year's election, but are very serious about electoral politics. And this is something that the left-wing parties in Bangladesh have not taken seriously. They're not sure whether to wait for a revolution, or, you know, have a couple of candidates for election, so they're always somewhere in between. They have their feet on both boats, and you can't really do politics like that, right? If you're serious about electoral politics, then do elections seriously. But then they're also not serious about elections, they're also not serious about revolution, so that already puts you in a very confused state, and that is something where I think we step in. We are very serious about electoral politics, like, you are operational under a very problematic, obviously democratic system, and that's okay, but being very serious to engage with that problem is something where our commitment lies, and I think that is very significant, if not a total departure, but I think that is a very serious difference between already established left-wing parties who are, again, somewhere confused between having a revolution and an election.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383752">But we are very clear about that, at least on that front. And also, I think the idea of right to well-being, and I think if you can address the idea of well-being, the word being is already in the word well-being. So, if you can address right well-being, I think people's being are quite settled and satisfied. At least, then you have other things to worry about. And this is something that I think also goes back to the time of partition when a lot of left-wing parties… actually it was a very popular slogan, right? <em>This is a false freedom, and millions of people are hungry and starving</em>. So I think that's also something that we take very seriously. And in addition to that, we cannot ignore the fact that Bangladesh is actually one of the most climate-vulnerable countries, so right to air, clean air, right to clean water, to clean land, most of our land is actually heavily contaminated with lead… how can you not have that as part of your political agenda? You go to any political manifestos or any political policies of any left-wing parties in Bangladesh, they will not have a single article, and I say this because I was also part of left-wing organizations for a very long time. They don't really have that as part of their political agenda. So who is going to bring this up, right? I mean, not someone whose primary funders are some industries who are causing all this pollution, or, you know an organization for pesticide is also your funder, you are not going to have that as part of your political agenda. So, it's the left who already should have had that as part of their political programming, but they don't. And that tells us about something, right?&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383753">There is a lack of update in terms of how you should or how you can do politics. What are some of the relevant and pressing realities of your time that you need to address, and that's where I think most of the established political left parties have fallen behind, and that's where I think we step in as a comrade, of course, not as someone who is going to oppose and all of that, although we have had significant amount of frustrations with a lot of meetings, and we know where they go and a lot of these conversations where some of them are goes back to the idea of Cold War, that, oh, historically, left-wing parties have been vilified, which they have been, yes, true, but then at the same time, for how long can you really sustain as a political entity if you are always playing the victim? Which, I mean, again, I think the right-wingers are better at playing victims rather than the left-wingers are, or able to garner some kind of sympathy, so that's also something that I think we have to address, so we are not here as victims, we are not here as. again, not some harbingers of revolution, necessarily, but we do offer tangible, implementable material policies which will have a direct impact on people's lives, and that's where I think a strong commitment, you know, lies, and especially things which have been historically ignored, right? I mean, air, water, food.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383754">And, you know, contamination and pollution of all kinds, and that actually addresses a lot of realities already. For example, even when you start talking about pollution, you would be able to name the polluters. and they are always 100% some corporate industries. So that already addresses that, you see, and then you already have a sort of quite left-wing positionality already. So it's actually about how you articulate your politics, and that's something that we are quite interested in, aware of, and we want to take this as a challenge head on. And of course, nothing is guaranteed, everything is precarious, but we want to address the precarities that exist in the world, but we want to take that risk.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383755"><br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383756"><strong>Readus Jawad:</strong> Yeah, I just wanted to add one thing. You see that, during Sheikh Hasina's time, during Sheikh Hasina's rule, we were almost very certain that something is going to happen, because Sheikh Hasina is not, never going to allow a peaceful transition of power, right? So something is going to happen. Something like a revolution, or a civil war, or something, something like this, like July, August, is going to happen. And almost all leftist parties knew that. If I know that, if a Master's student of economics knows that, of course leftist theoreticians, of course leftist politicians knew that. But they didn't… they were not able to capture that revolutionary momentum, right? That revolutionary momentum was ultimately captured by Jamaat-e-Islami. And, like, people who are associated with Jamaat-e-Islami often say that they are the biggest Leninist party in Bangladesh, right? They are doing the revolutionary politics that right-wingers, , sorry, left-wingers are failing at. So what we want to do is, at the very end, at the very least, we want to be a rallying point for people who want to have tangible change, and at the same time, people who want to have sort of people-facing front for their revolutionary politics, because at the end of the day, there will always be, and we will always have support and respect for people who do revolutionary politics, people who do armed struggles, and all that. So, we are not discouraging that, we are not vilifying them. We want to work with them and provide them a source of outreach to the great masses.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383757"><br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383758"><strong>Nafis:</strong> Yeah, that's a very interesting point that you made, that Jamaat is ultimately doing the sort of mass politics that left-wing parties have always envisioned in Bangladesh. I wish we had a lot more time. I wish we were doing this in person,but, you know, for the interest of time, we do have to close soon, but I do want to ask one last question. And I know we didn't talk about India or geopolitics at all, and that's such a big thing right now that's animating Bangladeshi politics, right, especially with the killing of Osman Hadi and all of that. But I would say, like let's say, if you could summarize your assessment of the July Revolution and its aftermath so far, and where do you see NPA’s politics moving beyond the February election? So, kind of a two-part question. Like, one, what's your assessment of the July Revolution till now? And then, where do you see NPA’s politics moving forward after February?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383759"><br><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383760"><strong>Readus Jawad:</strong> Well, my assessment of July will obviously be subjective, because I was&nbsp; studying at Dhaka University at the time. I was on the streets almost every day, so it's very subjective, but for me, July is yet another passive revolution in Bangladesh. Basically, it happened through people's blood, sweat, and tears. Ordinary masses rose up, and they sacrificed their lives, but at the end of the day, if you look at the progression, what happened in July, on 5th August, Sheikh Hasina fled. From 5th August to 8th August, the people of Bangladesh, the people became united, people put up mechanisms for self-defense, people put up mechanisms for self-rule, people put up mechanisms for conflict resolution. Hujur people, religious people, or Islamic scholars went to temples to safeguard them, went to mazars to safeguard them, to shrines to safeguard them, so people claimed their political agency after July and during the movement.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383761">But what happened after July was that their political agency was very deliberately stripped away from them. They were given a government, which we still don't know who formed the government, who decided who the advisors are going to be. Nobody knows anything about this. There's no transparency still. So, at the end of the day, what happened was that people's political agency were being taken away from them as the new government was being formed, and the new government, you know that there's been this talk of reforms and everything, but reforms that are very tangible, that can improve people's lives tangibly, those reforms have not been passed. The Women Reform Commission's report has been basically thrown away. And&nbsp; for example, the Mass Media Reform Commission has also been basically suppressed. They didn't really do anything with their recommendations. RAP has not been abolished. People have been talking about the evolution of the Rapid Action Battalion (RAB) for a very long time, RAB is still operational. So, at the end of the day, what was bound to happen after July didn't happen, because people were not allowed to practice their own political agency. I believe NPA's primary goal and primary objective should be to bring people back into politics. We have to make people understand that in July, you did your own politics, you went to the streets, you chanted your own slogans, you made your own demands known, and that's why you got the results that you wanted. If you don't continue this process, if you do not participate democratically, and I'm not talking just about agitation and street protest, that this also comes down to policy discussions, this also comes down to many other very small, procedural things that have to be done with the consent of people within our party and within the state, as a whole.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span> we want to make people do their own politics, we want to bring people into our political fold...and we want people to realize that they have to do their own politics at the end of the day. They have to reclaim their own political agency. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  <figcaption class="source">&mdash; Readus Jawad</figcaption>
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383762">So, we want to make people do their own politics, we want to bring people into our political fold,&nbsp; we want to take them into confidence, and we want people to understand, and we want people to realize that they have to do their own politics at the end of the day. They have to reclaim their own political agency. There's no substitute for that. There's never going to be any organization. who is going to do your politics on behalf of you, because at the end of the day, whenever people relinquish their own political agency in the hands of others in the history of Bangladesh, that has not proven well. That has not been proven to have any results, positive results for the lives of people, so I believe this is the primary goal. And the secondary goal, I would say, is to address the very widespread discrimination that was at the forefront of people's mind before July, because, like, for example, one of the main reasons July almost happened, because educated university graduate youth were disproportionately more likely to be unemployed than people who did not graduate from universities, right? So you go through a 4 or 6-year degree, and you're still not getting any jobs, or the jobs you are getting are not paying you even a living wage, right? So, people are very frustrated, people have very, very deep economic anxieties. And we have to understand that these anxieties have to be relieved, people have to be given economic relief through the state. And we… NPA should be a tool to forwarding this goal, because if we don't do that, this economic anxiety will probably be captured by the right-wing forces, reactionary forces, and that will probably give or that can probably give rise to another.</p>
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383763"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383764"><strong>Oliur Sun:</strong> The sort of aftermath, or even during, well, right after Sheikh Hasina had fled, people were actually still on the streets. When you have representatives from the political parties actually going directly to the cantonment and having this meeting with the Army Chief of Staff deciding what the next course of actions for the country should be, this is a very serious question, whether the political parties actually represent… are being able to represent people's will. It’s something that I don't think we have been able to settle yet. So that's one serious challenge which we are still left with. And these are the political parties which people have actually relied on, because of course, you know, you're always choosing between one or two - I mean, if it's not Awami League, then it's definitely going to be BNP or Jamaat, and then, of course, you know, you have NCP formed by the students, and, you know, they were trying to offer something, or were at least claiming to offer something new, but then we also know that, you know, how they were co-opted by the system, or were interested in getting co-opted by the system. And now they're definitely in alignment with Jamaat. So that's a reality that we have to take into account, and I think people are disillusioned, number one, so that's a very serious challenge, because people were in a position of trust, and their trust was betrayed, so it's gonna be very difficult for people to trust something new again.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383765">But I think people are also quite aware of the fact that, you know, they don't really have representatives, so that's something that we have to address. So that's a challenge for us to actually become the people's representatives. And I think that's where our commitment should be quite clear, because we have been dealing with this choice between either, you know, secular, liberal establishment, whatever that may be, and then, you know, highly capitalistic, exploitative, etc, etc. And then, on the other hand, you have this fear of religious Islamists taking over the country, and then threatening that sort of secular establishment. And this is what historically the left-wing's anxiety has been. I mean, they're more afraid of the Islamists than perhaps the capitalists just to put it bluntly, right? So, how do you really address that? And this is something that has been a very serious intellectual problem within the left-wing political establishments and platforms.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383766">Like, how do you address the question of religion, right? Because, you know, again, like, the right wing in Bangladesh is not the same right wing, like, in the US. It's not the white supremacists. It's the enemies of what the white supremacists at least claim to be their enemies. They are actually our right wing. So it's a very interesting sort of situation, and that requires a different kind of narrative, different kind of intellectual labor that we have to put in, and of course, different kind of political labor that we have to come up with. And I think the July Uprising could not really settle that question, because, again, like I said, people on the 5th of August were still on the streets, were ready to burn, like, literally the old establishment down.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383767">But then they trusted the political representatives, or, you know, the traditional political representatives, like established political parties, who had called for restraint, and were asking people to be patient, and we were effectively without a government for almost 3 days, maybe a bit more than that. And that's exactly when was the time when communities came together, because they knew that there is no state to protect them.They actually came together. So right after the government was formed, and this is an expectation, and this is something that, you know, I think historically our citizens have been deprived of. The protection of an organization like the state. And, you know, arguably, in many ways, that organization doesn't function or doesn't exist in many cases, or has always been co-opted by people who are already privileged. It's either the bureaucrats. Or, our office holders, or maybe even the political representatives of the people who are always capturing the state. And how do you really distribute or redistribute the privileges of an organization amongst the people is actually a challenge that I think NPA is willing to take up. Because historically, people have been deprived of the benefits of a state.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383768">I mean, of course, the modern state is a problematic institution in a lot of ways. But then I think, as a country like Bangladesh, we have integrated the country in a way, right? I mean, we have fought for it, it's not just the Partition, it's also the Liberation War of 1971. So taking that into account, how do we really create a state which is accountable to citizens? And one that cannot be so easily captured by some groups who are always interested in some sort of opportunism is something that I think we have to be extremely, extremely aware of. And I think that something that should be also part of our political focus is the idea of privilege, and also something that I think we should constantly do is a privilege check. And we have a word for this, right? Like, you have the word সুবিধাবাদী (<em>shubidhabadi</em>)… what we mean by shubidhabadi is actually opportunists, but then opportunity in Bangla is সুযোগ (<em>shujog</em>), which doesn't really make sense, right? So it should be something like privilege seekers. So I think we have to go after the privilege seekers. Like, who is here for privilege?And who is here for actually delivering the policies is something where we have to make this distinction.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383769">So whoever is putting up the veneer of a political leader, we have to address and challenge that idea - are they here for privilege? I think that is something that is quite tangible, and you can tell that by looking at, not to body shame anyone, but, you know, the accumulation of the belly right after gaining some sort of political position. And that already shows like you are accumulating privilege bodily, not just materially, which is always something that is a sign of privilege-seeking, and that is something that you can point out. That is something that's tangible, material, and people can perceive that. People notice those things, right? So you have very clear identifiable markers, like, who the privilege seekers are, and who are actually politicians, who are actually public representatives. So that's something that I think we should be putting at the heart of our political narrative. And I think that's something that people are already quite aware of, have been challenging our disillusion with, and therefore cannot rely on the established political parties who have previously been in power.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383770">So I think part of the reason why Jamaat has gained a lot of ground, especially in different communities, is actually because people are disillusioned with even BNP, because they have been in power, they have experienced them, and that's why there is a lack of trust. I mean, of course, you know, there was a government which was a coalition government of BNP and Jamaat-e-Islami and whatnot. And you have the idea of religiosity, and then fueling up the tension of that sort of historical bond, like, Pakistan being a sort of safe haven for deprived Muslims, something which the revivalist narrative has been increasingly been trying to bring up - that Muslims have been historically marginalized, and, how Bengali identity is closer to Hindutva and all of that. So that is also something that has been repeatedly used. So that has also gained a lot of popularity in recent times because the other political narratives actually completely fail to address people's daily realities, material conditions, and all of that. And instead, you have previous political parties who completely have their hands dirty in terms of looting, or, you know, what we call চাঁদাবাজি (extortion) and all of that, and that is something that people are already quite aware of and are already fed up with. So, it's going to be a very difficult election this time. And that's why it takes a lot of organizing as well. So we are willing to sit with the people and see their patience or be part of their patience, right, like the patience of witnessing another election, and whatever that it might deliver, so we are actually willing to take that journey with people, and see where it goes. And then, as we sit with them, interact with them, speak with them, we also tweak and change a lot of our policies and bring them in when we are going to contest in the next election, when we'd have a political party or as a political organization when we'll be formed like that. So that's where our positionality currently stands.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383771">The July Revolution/Uprising - it's something that I think has been completely hijacked by the privileged class without consultation with the people directly, even certain stakeholders who were directly invested in the movement, were even persecuted, were under threats; they were not even consulted with. So there's only a certain segment of people who participated in the revolution who were consulted with. So that already tells you there is an active exclusion of certain groups of people, especially the ones who could perhaps challenge the privileged establishment, right? That is a reality that we have been dealing with. So we don't think that July Revolution could deliver what it potentially could deliver, so that's where we step in. And then at the same time, the historical marginalization of this particular space, or this particular geography in the world, and that positionality is something that we want to articulate as well. But, not in terms of a revivalist kind of politics, but something which people have been the worst sufferers of, and how do we really redistribute privilege? Because, I mean the popular narrative is we are a poor country, we have been historically exploited, absolutely true. But then you also have immense amount of wealth being accumulated by only a handful of people who have their second home in Malaysia, would go vacationing in Europe every month, or maybe a couple of months. So, it doesn't really match up. Like when we tell these narratives of poverty, and then people have this strong standing in the global capitalist marketplace, it doesn't really just match up to anything. We want to challenge that discourse or narrative head-on as well.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383772"><br class="ProseMirror-trailingBreak"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777988014395_383773"><strong>Nafis:</strong> Well, Jawad, Oliur, thank you so much for your time. This has been a very long-ranging conversation, and very, very illuminating. I'm very excited, personally, to see where NPA goes. Thank you once again for speaking to <em>Jamhoor</em>, and we hope to follow what you all are doing in Bangladesh in the coming months and years.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Readus Salehen Jawad</em></strong><em> is a member of the central committee of Network for People’s Action and a graduate student of Economics at Dhaka University. He is also a Feature Writer at The Business Standard. </em><br><br><strong><em>Oliur Sun</em></strong><em> is a sunyatavadin and a creator/organizer of multidisciplinary knowledge in textual and visual forms based in Dhaka. Currently a Lecturer of English and Humanities at the University of Liberal Arts Bangladesh, his teaching portfolio includes Pathshala South Asian Media Institute. He’s also a cofounder of Bodhichitta and a language justice consultant at Foundation for a Just Society. His work explores decolonial trajectories, intersectionalities and queerness. He is also a central committee member at Network for People’s Action.</em><br><br><strong><em>Nafis Hasan </em></strong><em>is a Bangladeshi writer and organizer based in Philadelphia. He is the author of </em><a target="_blank" href="https://www.commonnotions.org/metastasis?srsltid=AfmBOooLx1Ifhp75bFkvr6tcDo1vyBdanPrrpZP4Q9D_IErMsDeWs42d"><em>Metastasis: The Rise of the Cancer-Industrial Complex and the Horizons of Care</em></a><em> </em>and <em>also sits on Jamhoor’s editorial committee.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/615da14c-d6f4-4b78-af28-279a50f8a7f8/NPA_Jamhoor_LS.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">On NPA’s Quest to Restore Political Agency in Bangladesh</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>Dreams of a Better World</title><category>Book Review</category><category>Diaspora</category><category>Pakistan</category><dc:creator>Aditya G</dc:creator><pubDate>Thu, 30 Apr 2026 01:16:50 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/dreams-of-a-better-world</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:69e6d002bebe4e35b3710326</guid><description><![CDATA[Tariq Mehmood’s latest novel follows the radicalization of a Pakistani man 
after his emigration to Britain.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Tariq Mehmood’s latest novel follows the radicalization of a Pakistani man after his emigration to Britain.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0d351fd1-9a9c-48b5-99b5-6605a09314b3/Singofthewesterwind.png" data-image-dimensions="4160x2340" data-image-focal-point="0.4685260643529577,0.344043005375672" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0d351fd1-9a9c-48b5-99b5-6605a09314b3/Singofthewesterwind.png?format=1000w" width="4160" height="2340" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0d351fd1-9a9c-48b5-99b5-6605a09314b3/Singofthewesterwind.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0d351fd1-9a9c-48b5-99b5-6605a09314b3/Singofthewesterwind.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0d351fd1-9a9c-48b5-99b5-6605a09314b3/Singofthewesterwind.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0d351fd1-9a9c-48b5-99b5-6605a09314b3/Singofthewesterwind.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0d351fd1-9a9c-48b5-99b5-6605a09314b3/Singofthewesterwind.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0d351fd1-9a9c-48b5-99b5-6605a09314b3/Singofthewesterwind.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0d351fd1-9a9c-48b5-99b5-6605a09314b3/Singofthewesterwind.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>When this Saleem returns to Pakistan, he realizes that he has become a chimera of nationalities, despised for being Pakistani in Britain, estranged as a Valaiti (foreigner) in Pakistan.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><em>Sing to the Western Wind</em>&nbsp;is not the first novel Tariq Mehmood has written about a man named Saleem moving between Pakistan and Bradford, England. That would be 2003’s&nbsp;<em>While There Is Light</em>, in which the protagonist’s mother sends him in his youth to stay with relatives in Bradford. Growing up in Rivers of Blood-era England, he helps form a group of Asian British activists and is later arrested on speculative terrorist charges (a fictionalized rendering of the&nbsp;<a href="https://www.jamhoor.org/read/self-defence-is-no-offence-a-conversation-with-tariq-mehmood">1981 arrests of United Black Youth League members</a>, which included Mehmood, that led to the Bradford 12 trial).&nbsp;When this Saleem returns to Pakistan, he realizes that he has become a chimera of nationalities, despised for being Pakistani in Britain, estranged as a <em>Valaiti</em> (foreigner) in Pakistan.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/8cb7aa81-7fef-4339-bddb-a88ed8d930d4/Picture1.jpg" data-image-dimensions="614x699" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/8cb7aa81-7fef-4339-bddb-a88ed8d930d4/Picture1.jpg?format=1000w" width="614" height="699" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/8cb7aa81-7fef-4339-bddb-a88ed8d930d4/Picture1.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/8cb7aa81-7fef-4339-bddb-a88ed8d930d4/Picture1.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/8cb7aa81-7fef-4339-bddb-a88ed8d930d4/Picture1.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/8cb7aa81-7fef-4339-bddb-a88ed8d930d4/Picture1.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/8cb7aa81-7fef-4339-bddb-a88ed8d930d4/Picture1.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/8cb7aa81-7fef-4339-bddb-a88ed8d930d4/Picture1.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/8cb7aa81-7fef-4339-bddb-a88ed8d930d4/Picture1.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><em>Bradford, England. Photo by Akbal Singh Kang. Image: </em><a href="https://www.scienceandmediamuseum.org.uk/what-was-on/4000-miles-home"><em>National Science and Media Museum</em></a><em>.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1776735440883_13888" class="MsoNormal">Published by Daraja Press in 2016 and re-issued by Verso this June, <em>Sing to the Western Wind</em>&nbsp;centers on a Saleem who takes a more itinerant route to disaffection and political action. He replants himself in Bradford in 1965, uprooting himself from his life as a teacher in a village near Rawalpindi, as well as from his mother and his lover Yasmin, who is of lower caste than him. Fresh off the plane, he and other Pakistani emigrants follow an agent to a house of others like them, where they enter into grim contracts: “You village donkeys; don’t forget that you can’t even pray before you pay,” the agent, also their landlord, instructs them. In addition to receiving twenty pence per week from a communal fund, “everyone in the house was also signed up to the death committee and should anyone die, the cost of taking their body plus one person home was paid for.”</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>Saleem initially operates in a state of political inertia in Bradford, feeding lines of cotton into spindles, but those around him push him into motion.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1776735440883_13881" class="MsoNormal">Saleem’s spoken English soon helps him land a job on the all-Asian night shift at a nearby textile mill, and his ability to read and write letters for his fellow migrants is a further boon, granting him a better room at the house and the title of Masterji at the mill.&nbsp;Saleem initially operates in a state of political inertia in Bradford, feeding lines of cotton into spindles, but those around him push him into motion—beginning with a formal letter to mill management requesting cleaner latrines, which other workers convince him to write. Then, a chance run-in with a friend—Mangal Singh, whose Sikh family was expelled from Saleem’s village following the creation of Pakistan, and who is also on the night shift—pulls him into the orbit of organized action. Guided by the values of his comradely father, Mangal convinces the night shift labourers to join the mill’s union and make elemental demands: bridging the wage gap between Asian and white workers and keeping the canteen open at night. Saleem and Mangal begin to attend union meetings and pub discussions that erode Saleem’s sense of embarrassment at being a mill worker and instill in him socialist visions for the world.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7dfb089a-c2c0-44b7-9819-5bad0b801a78/Picture1.jpg" data-image-dimensions="565x556" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7dfb089a-c2c0-44b7-9819-5bad0b801a78/Picture1.jpg?format=1000w" width="565" height="556" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7dfb089a-c2c0-44b7-9819-5bad0b801a78/Picture1.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7dfb089a-c2c0-44b7-9819-5bad0b801a78/Picture1.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7dfb089a-c2c0-44b7-9819-5bad0b801a78/Picture1.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7dfb089a-c2c0-44b7-9819-5bad0b801a78/Picture1.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7dfb089a-c2c0-44b7-9819-5bad0b801a78/Picture1.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7dfb089a-c2c0-44b7-9819-5bad0b801a78/Picture1.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7dfb089a-c2c0-44b7-9819-5bad0b801a78/Picture1.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>An English mill. Photo by Akbal Singh Kang. Source: </em><a href="https://www.scienceandmediamuseum.org.uk/what-was-on/4000-miles-home"><em>National Science and Media Museum</em></a><em>.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote" data-animation-override>
    <span>“</span>Saleem’s dynamic with Carol and Yasmin comes to represent the age-old fork in the diasporic road.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777517155044_9934" class="MsoNormal">That utopian glimmer lasts six years. As fractures form among the mill workers over Bangladesh’s liberation war back in South Asia, Saleem receives the news that his mother has passed away. When he returns from a truncated period of mourning, the mill’s closure plunges him into precarious employment. He drifts to East London, takes up work as the driver for a bakery, and starts seeing a new lover, Carol, the rebellious daughter of his boss at the mill.&nbsp;Saleem’s dynamic with Carol and Yasmin comes to represent the age-old fork in the diasporic road: while he all but forgets Yasmin, who accused him of being a white man during his recent sojourn in Pakistan, the typical frictions of miscegenation wear on him and Carol. Though Carol’s father and brother attempt to menace Saleem away, Carol herself presses for a more committed relationship, at which Saleem balks. “So you think your white bit doesn’t understand [that] you lot only do girlfriends, eh?” she asks, frustrated that their relationship has stalled in Britain. “Just fuck us and marry your village virgins. Isn’t that it?”</p>
<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777517155044_9897" class="MsoNormal">Eventually, Saleem capitulates and returns with Carol to his village. Living now in a luxurious toilet-laden house built from his British wages, Saleem has become “a saab, a babu, a sir, with a big Pukka house and servants.” One of those servants is Yasmin, the only person Saleem’s cousin Habib can find to cook at the house on short notice. Saleem feigns to not know her, but even Carol wonders, “Why is there so much pain in Yasmin’s face?” Uncomfortable with this new Saleem, one who discourages her from giving money to the beggars frequenting the house, Carol decides to go back to Britain. Saleem remains to help Habib with his business, the Kamal Goods Forwarding Agency.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777517155044_9898" class="MsoNormal">Here the novel veers into territory beyond the slow-burning identity crisis of the previous one hundred pages. Yasmin comes to Saleem for help locating her uncle, Kala, a truck driver who does business with Habib—though she does not pass up the opportunity, first, to chastise Saleem for his silently traitorous loftiness: “Then who am I? Who is this small dark massalan [low-caste], who is no better than a donkey. Ride her if you will sir.” The search for Kala sends Saleem and Habib to Charsadda, then across the border into the battlegrounds of Afghanistan during the Soviet-Afghan War. The intricate sketches in this portion of the novel bring together a cigar-puffing pir of ambiguous nationality, mujahideen fighters, captured Afghan women, and unaccounted Stingers with devastating consequences, drawing from Mehmood’s time as a journalist at the <em>Frontier Post</em>. Saleem’s life, in the aftermath, becomes vague and unsure of itself:&nbsp;</p><blockquote id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777517155044_9899"><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">And somewhere in the world, I married Yasmin. And sometime after that, when I was sitting in the hollow of the banyan tree, chain-smoking dope-filled cigarettes and listening to a nightingale that had kept me company for I don’t know how long, the postman came and gave me a postcard from Carol.</p></blockquote><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1777517155044_9900" class="MsoNormal">And some decades after that, he is back in Britain, widowed after Yasmin’s death, estranged in an on-and-off way from their daughter&nbsp;Aisha, and hallucinating the past in between inhales of the Blairite era—and yet he is the most resolute he has ever been. He plans a suicide bombing in Manchester.&nbsp;On his final walk, reminders of his motivations flutter past: neighbours who shunned him after September 11, a veteran who lost both hands in Iraq, a newspaper asking readers to turn in terrorists as defined by a bullet-point list.“Handling chemicals is dangerous. Maybe you’ve seen goggles or masks dumped somewhere?” one of the criteria innocently demands. (If Saleem were making his walk in the 2020s, the newspaper would ask whether its readers know anyone who is part of or sympathetic to Palestine Action.)</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c1e6c0cd-6b51-421f-b5d7-be3dd66510bc/Picture1.jpg" data-image-dimensions="427x605" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c1e6c0cd-6b51-421f-b5d7-be3dd66510bc/Picture1.jpg?format=1000w" width="427" height="605" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c1e6c0cd-6b51-421f-b5d7-be3dd66510bc/Picture1.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c1e6c0cd-6b51-421f-b5d7-be3dd66510bc/Picture1.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c1e6c0cd-6b51-421f-b5d7-be3dd66510bc/Picture1.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c1e6c0cd-6b51-421f-b5d7-be3dd66510bc/Picture1.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c1e6c0cd-6b51-421f-b5d7-be3dd66510bc/Picture1.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c1e6c0cd-6b51-421f-b5d7-be3dd66510bc/Picture1.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/c1e6c0cd-6b51-421f-b5d7-be3dd66510bc/Picture1.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A poster depicting the acquittal of the Bradford 12, as featured in the Above the Noise exhibit in Bradford’s National Science and Media Museum</em><a href="https://www.scienceandmediamuseum.org.uk/what-was-on/above-noise"><em>. Source: National Science and Media Museum</em></a><em>.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>A poster depicting the acquittal of the Bradford 12, as featured in the Above the Noise exhibit in Bradford’s National Science and Media Museum</em><a href="https://www.scienceandmediamuseum.org.uk/what-was-on/above-noise"><em>. Source: National Science and Media Museum</em></a><em>.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1776734210764_19815" class="MsoNormal">Mehmood is not one to settle for bare-minimum solutions. When Bradford’s National Science and Media Museum sought to host an exhibition of the local history in 2019, a semantic skirmish between former members of the Asian Youth Movement and the United Black Youth League (both of which Mehmood helped found) caused him to reflect, four years later: “The youth movements of the past were no more. The dreams of a better world had got lost in the nightmares of the present.”&nbsp;<em>Sing to the Western Wind</em>&nbsp;is a novel about, by, and for those attuned to this bleakness, and attempting to make do with&nbsp;hopelessness.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><strong><em>Aditya G. </em></strong><em>is a writer based in New York City.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0d351fd1-9a9c-48b5-99b5-6605a09314b3/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%281%29.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">Dreams of a Better World</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>The Forgotten Massacre of the Left in Bangladesh</title><category>Bangladesh</category><category>Essay</category><dc:creator>Ifaz Khan</dc:creator><pubDate>Fri, 03 Apr 2026 01:13:10 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/the-forgotten-massacre-of-the-left-in-bangladesh</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:69c5d9a6dc6b1923644fa22c</guid><description><![CDATA[The Rakkhi Bahini's campaign of terror against left-wing opposition in the 
1970s marked the beginnings of extrajudicial killings in Bangladesh.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><em>The Rakkhi Bahini's campaign of terror against left-wing opposition in the 1970s marked the beginnings of extrajudicial killings in Bangladesh.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/575467fc-bbd1-43e2-b7fb-e001b95ecea6/42995.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1600x900" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/575467fc-bbd1-43e2-b7fb-e001b95ecea6/42995.jpg?format=1000w" width="1600" height="900" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/575467fc-bbd1-43e2-b7fb-e001b95ecea6/42995.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/575467fc-bbd1-43e2-b7fb-e001b95ecea6/42995.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/575467fc-bbd1-43e2-b7fb-e001b95ecea6/42995.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/575467fc-bbd1-43e2-b7fb-e001b95ecea6/42995.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/575467fc-bbd1-43e2-b7fb-e001b95ecea6/42995.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/575467fc-bbd1-43e2-b7fb-e001b95ecea6/42995.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/575467fc-bbd1-43e2-b7fb-e001b95ecea6/42995.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available images</em></p>


  










  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Today, discussions about historical leftist repression are often globalised: Instagram pages and social media accounts devoted to leftist history increasingly highlight massacres in South America, Southeast Asia, and Europe. Yet the systematic targeting and extrajudicial killings of leftists in Bangladesh remains largely forgotten. Bringing this history to light not only to honours the memory of those who suffered, it helps us understand how these patterns of repression shaped political activism, dissent, and student-led protests in Bangladesh, like the July Uprising, that erupted decades later.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><strong>Hope Turns into Despair</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">After a nine-month liberation war, Bangladesh achieved independence on December 16, 1971. The victory was accompanied by immense popular hope. Many believed that the new state would reject authoritarianism, corruption, and social inequality, and uphold democracy, human rights, and social justice. Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, affectionately known as <em>Bangabandhu (Friend of Bengal)</em>, was widely seen as a leader capable of implementing this vision.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">At the same time, socialists and communists in Bangladesh believed that a truly prosperous and egalitarian state can only be built following the ideals laid down by Karl Marx, Vladimir Lenin, and Mao Zedong.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Soon the hopes and aspirations of the people were shattered, as the newly founded Bangladesh descended into authoritarianism, corruption, food crisis, unemployment and rising crime rates between 1972-75. Armed dacoits used to plunder villages, extort from people, attack police stations, and even often kidnap women.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Investigative journalist Anthony Mascarenhas in <em>Bangladesh: A Legacy of Blood</em> (1986), described the atmosphere of the period as armed gangs, often wearing military caps and carrying rifles, openly plundering markets and neighbourhoods. Moudud Ahmed, a lawyer and politician, in his book, <em>Bangladesh Sheikh Mujibur Rahman’er Shashonkaal (Bangladesh Era of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman), </em>wrote that criminals masqueraded as freedom fighters and took control of different territories due to weapons left behind during the liberation war.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><u>Implemented as part of Mujib’s own interpretation of socialism</u>, the Bangladesh government nationalised 85 percent of industries and 90 percent of foreign trade. Political scientist Talukder Maniruzzaman argued that Awami League (AL) adminstrators appointed to these nationalised factories, had no knowledge about running a capitalist or socialist system. Instead, they focused on enriching themselves through smuggling machinery and raw materials to India. These administrators, comprised of AL members, became a corrupt, high-income elite class formation.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Soon after independence, on April 4, 1972, the <em>New York Times, </em>broke a story on corruption by the AL. Groups within the party were taking over truckloads of food aid in daylight to sell it later to the highest bidder. Others used their influence to get lucrative government contracts. Another report by <em>New York Times, </em>onOctober 4, 1972, documented how food relief meant for war-affected Bangladesh was being smuggled into India. These practices created a combined economic and food crisis in Bangladesh, as food prices soared.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><strong>Was Mujib Socialist or Anti-worker?</strong></p>


  



































  
  
    
  <figure data-test="image-block-v2-outer-wrapper" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-layout="stack" class="
      sqs-block-image-figure
      image-block-outer-wrapper
      image-block-v2
      design-layout-stack
      combination-animation-site-default
      individual-animation-site-default
      individual-text-animation-site-default
      image-position-left
      
    " data-scrolled
  >
    
      
        
        
          
          
            
            
            
            
            
            
            <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/950a9d27-bc4c-427d-97d4-86c26ab6aa63/Image+2+-The+Five+Leaders+of+Bangladeshi+Left.png" data-image-dimensions="512x317" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/950a9d27-bc4c-427d-97d4-86c26ab6aa63/Image+2+-The+Five+Leaders+of+Bangladeshi+Left.png?format=1000w" width="512" height="317" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/950a9d27-bc4c-427d-97d4-86c26ab6aa63/Image+2+-The+Five+Leaders+of+Bangladeshi+Left.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/950a9d27-bc4c-427d-97d4-86c26ab6aa63/Image+2+-The+Five+Leaders+of+Bangladeshi+Left.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/950a9d27-bc4c-427d-97d4-86c26ab6aa63/Image+2+-The+Five+Leaders+of+Bangladeshi+Left.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/950a9d27-bc4c-427d-97d4-86c26ab6aa63/Image+2+-The+Five+Leaders+of+Bangladeshi+Left.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/950a9d27-bc4c-427d-97d4-86c26ab6aa63/Image+2+-The+Five+Leaders+of+Bangladeshi+Left.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/950a9d27-bc4c-427d-97d4-86c26ab6aa63/Image+2+-The+Five+Leaders+of+Bangladeshi+Left.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/950a9d27-bc4c-427d-97d4-86c26ab6aa63/Image+2+-The+Five+Leaders+of+Bangladeshi+Left.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
            
          
        
          
        
      
    
    <figcaption data-width-ratio class="image-card-wrapper">
      

        
          <p class="sqsrte-small"><em>Five Leaders of the Bangladesh Left. Serajul Alam Khan (left), Major M.A Jalil (background), Maulana Abdul Hamid Khan Bhashani (center), Siraj Sikder (background), and Col. Abu Taher (right). Image: @centristbangladesh</em></p>
        

        
          
        

        

      
    </figcaption>

    


  </figure>

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Sheikh Mujib preached <a href="https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/321639/%E2%80%98i-am-not-a-marxist.-i-am-a-socialist-but-a">his own version of socialism</a>—Mujibism. This characterisation of Mujib was rejected by the Bangladeshi left. Badruddin Umar, a Marxist-Leninist theorist and activist, wrote an essay in <em>Shaptahik Shadhika</em> on September 3, 1972, which argued that the AL’s nationalisation programme was not intended to establish socialism, but rather to prevent the working class from achieving genuine political power. The repression and chaos produced by this so-called socialism, he warned, were neither accidental nor surprising.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>The Awami League’s nationalisation programme was not intended to establish socialism, but rather to prevent the working class from achieving genuine political power.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Leftist politician Haydar Akbar Khan alleged that Sheikh Mujib himself was an ally of American imperialism, rather than an opponent of it. Khan’s book <em>Dui Doshoker Bam Rajniti: Shonkot o Shomossha(Two Decades of Left Politics: Crisis and Problems), </em>criticised Mujib for handing over national oil exploration in Bay of Bengal to American corporations. He alleged that American establishment had bailed Mujib out of prison in Pakistan in exchange for his support for American policies in the region.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">With corruption, lawlessness, and a looming food crisis facing newly formed Bangladesh, the Bangladeshi left rejected Mujib’s version of ‘socialism’ and began a campaign for a state based on true socialist ideals.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Forging an alliance between Maoists and Leninists, the three major leftist political parties were led by major figures in the Bangladeshi left. The National Awami Party (NAP) was led by Maulana Bhashani, Sarbohara was led by Siraj Sikder, while Jatiyo Samajtantrik Dal (JSD) was led by Major Abdul Jalil, Serajul Alam Khan, and Colonel Abu Taher. The three parties rapidly gained maximum support in the rural populace and students, who had been disillusioned by the corruption and authoritarianism of Mujib regime.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><strong>The Formation of Rakkhi Bahini</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Fearing the rise of a leftist opposition, the AL regime began a campaign of state-backed terror to silence them. AL politicians began to advise Mujib to strengthen the police and Ansar forces to counter the lawlessness. Instead, Mujib decided to form an elite paramilitiary force, named Jatiya Rakkhi Bahini (JRBorNational Defense Force<strong>)</strong>, officially tasked with combatting armed gangs and establish law and order.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Rakkhi Bahini, comprised mostly of Mujib Bahini members loyal to Mujib during 1971 Liberation War, was officially founded on February 1, 1972. Rakkhi Bahini members swore direct allegiance to Sheikh Mujib and worked with local AL party units. Thus, they were often synonymously called Mujibists. Provided automatic weapons, steel helmets, jeeps, and trucks, the Rakkhi Bahini managed to establish camps all over the country. The Mujib regime continued to increase budget allocations for Rakkhi Bahini, while reducing funds available for the army and police force.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Political scientist Talukder Maniruzzaman notes that leftist parties like JSD took a strong stance against Indian and American influence on Bangladesh, seeing it as imperialism, while simultaneously opposing Mujib regime.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">The Indian government supported the creation of Rakkhi Bahini. Several key figures in Rakkhi Bahini, including Training Director, Lieutenant Anwar-ul Alam, admitted in his book <em>Rakkhi Bahini’r Shotto Mittha (Truth &amp; False of Rakkhi Bahini), </em>that India was eager to assist in forming Rakkhi Bahini, and sent an Indian Army team led by Major Trivedi to Dhaka for training purposes. In another book <em>Rakkhi Bahini’r Ojana Oddhay (The Unknown Chapter of Rakkhi Bahini),</em> Assistant Director, Colonel Sorowar Hossain Molla, admitted that Rakkhi Bahini’s uniforms, weaponry and even boots came from India.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><strong>A Massacre of the Left</strong></p>


  



































  
  
    
  <figure data-test="image-block-v2-outer-wrapper" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-layout="stack" class="
      sqs-block-image-figure
      image-block-outer-wrapper
      image-block-v2
      design-layout-stack
      combination-animation-site-default
      individual-animation-site-default
      individual-text-animation-site-default
      image-position-left
      
    " data-scrolled
  >
    
      
        
        
          
          
            
            
            
            
            
            
            <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d1e28c35-a901-420e-83c6-6a46ea51ab32/Image+3+-+Around+a+million+leftists+are+to+be+killed%2C+Weekly+Haq+Katha.png" data-image-dimensions="943x693" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d1e28c35-a901-420e-83c6-6a46ea51ab32/Image+3+-+Around+a+million+leftists+are+to+be+killed%2C+Weekly+Haq+Katha.png?format=1000w" width="943" height="693" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d1e28c35-a901-420e-83c6-6a46ea51ab32/Image+3+-+Around+a+million+leftists+are+to+be+killed%2C+Weekly+Haq+Katha.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d1e28c35-a901-420e-83c6-6a46ea51ab32/Image+3+-+Around+a+million+leftists+are+to+be+killed%2C+Weekly+Haq+Katha.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d1e28c35-a901-420e-83c6-6a46ea51ab32/Image+3+-+Around+a+million+leftists+are+to+be+killed%2C+Weekly+Haq+Katha.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d1e28c35-a901-420e-83c6-6a46ea51ab32/Image+3+-+Around+a+million+leftists+are+to+be+killed%2C+Weekly+Haq+Katha.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d1e28c35-a901-420e-83c6-6a46ea51ab32/Image+3+-+Around+a+million+leftists+are+to+be+killed%2C+Weekly+Haq+Katha.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d1e28c35-a901-420e-83c6-6a46ea51ab32/Image+3+-+Around+a+million+leftists+are+to+be+killed%2C+Weekly+Haq+Katha.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/d1e28c35-a901-420e-83c6-6a46ea51ab32/Image+3+-+Around+a+million+leftists+are+to+be+killed%2C+Weekly+Haq+Katha.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
            
          
        
          
        
      
    
    <figcaption data-width-ratio class="image-card-wrapper">
      

        
          <p class="sqsrte-small"><em>Maulana Bhashani’s weekly leftist magazine, Shaptahik Haq Katha (Weekly Absolute Truth), published an article on May 26, 1972, titled, ‘Around a million leftists are to be killed,’ on a foreign conspiracy to kill and assassinate leftists in Bangladesh. Image: Songramer Notebook </em></p>
        

        
          
        

        

      
    </figcaption>

    


  </figure>

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Maulana Bhashani’s weekly leftist magazine, <em>Shaptahik Haq Katha (Weekly Absolute Truth), </em>published an article on May 26, 1972, titled, ‘Around a million leftists are to be killed,’ on a foreign conspiracy to kill and assassinate leftists in Bangladesh. Political scientist Talukder Maniruzzaman’s book, <em>The Bangladesh Revolution and its Aftermath, </em>notes that leftist parties like JSD took a strong stance against Indian and American influence on Bangladesh, seeing it as imperialism, while simultaneously opposing Mujib regime.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">These fears came true as Rakkhi Bahini began to target the Bangladeshi left after June 1972. The anti-India, anti-US, anti-AL position of the Bangladeshi left made them targets of the Rakkhi Bahini. This paramilitary force operating as a killing squad, similar to <a href="https://scispace.com/pdf/the-ghost-of-machiavelli-an-approach-to-operation-gladio-and-46pfmk3a5e.pdf">CIA-funded NATO</a> stay-behind army squads who targeted the left in Western Europe, Greece, and Turkey. Rakkhi Bahini had a similar modus operandi as Gladio—enforced disappearances, illegal detentions, tortures, assassinations, and even massacres. Even some of their tactical playbook, such as Cordon-and-Search operations, was similar.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Maulana Bhashani’s weekly leftist magazine, Shaptahik Haq Katha (Weekly Absolute Truth), published an article on May 26, 1972, titled, ‘Around a million leftists are to be killed,’ on a foreign conspiracy to kill and assassinate leftists in Bangladesh.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Indian Major General Sujan Singh Uban, who helped<a href="https://www.trtworld.com/article/12756149"> build Rakkhi Bahini</a>, had &nbsp;commanded a special squad of CIA-trained Tibetan fighters against China in the 1960s. Whether Sujan Singh learnt and taught the Gladio blueprint from CIA to the Rakkhi Bahini remains a subject of debate. But, in practice, Rakkhi Bahini implemented a Gladio-like scorched-earth strategy against the left and other political opponents of Mujib regime.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Investigative journalist Ahmed Musa’s book <em>Itihasher Katghoray Awami League (Awami League In The Witness Box of History) </em>notes that Rakkhi Bahini’s extrajudicial killings and enforced disappearances on left activists were so intense, that sometimes the Bangladesh Army and police would arrest leftists and imprison them to save their lives.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">One of the first major anti-left extermination campaigns started in Kishoreganj, in the sub-district Bajitpur, where 126 people were killed by Rakkhi Bahini for allegedly supporting left politics. This was part of a brutal camapign. A farmer from Kishoreganj, Abdul Ali, was forced to behead his own son, Rashed’s dead body after the Rakkhi Bahini shot him dead. In Pirojpur, Barishal, Amina, suspected of sheltering leftists, was doused with kerosene, leaving severe burns.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">As Bangladesh’s rural population became more sympathetic to the leftist cause, Rakkhi Bahini raids became the norm. In Kishoreganj’s Sararchar area, Rakkhi Bahini set up an illegal detention facility called ‘Tiger Hole’ in their camp, where they used to detain and torture people suspected of being sympathetic to leftist politics. Detention facilities and torture cells like Tiger Hole were established in Rakkhi Bahini camps all over the country. Women and teenagers were not spared from the paramilitary’s brutality. The Rakkhi Bahini also targetted non-leftist opponents of the Mujib’s government.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><strong>Looting and Communalism</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Rakkhi Bahini and local AL cadres got together to loot and rob people, as well as occupied land, especially when it was owned by Hindus. In an interview, Saiful Islam, a leftist activist from Kishoreganj, noted, “The Mujibists do the looting themselves, and then blame it on leftists.” Aruna Sen, wife of leftist leader Shanti Sen, noted that Rakkhi Bahini cadres in rural areas also spread anti-Hindu sentiments and called them ‘<em>Malauns</em>’ (a derogatory slur against Hindus).</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">In 1973, a road-rage incident linked to Rakkhi Bahini created national outrage. When, on June 29, 1973,&nbsp; a passenger bus overtook a Rakkhi Bahini truck, the Rakkhi Bahini followed the bus and opened fire at the Chittagong Eastern Refinery refinery. Four people died and several were injured. Similar incidents of Rakkhi Bahini raiding factories to assault workers were reported.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>The Rakkhi Bahini’s role in the Chittagong Hill Tracts continues to shape the conflict that Bangladesh still grapples with today.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1774798048496_39029" class="MsoNormal">Ethno-nationalist and Bengali-chauvinist, the Rakkhi Bahini’s reign of terror spread to indigenous tribes and ethnic minorities living in the Chittagong Hill Tracts. In 1972, after Mujib denied constitutional recognition to ethnic minorities, Rakkhi Bahini raided in tribal villages <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/4369049?seq=1">under the pretext of rooting out</a> ‘Pakistani Army collaborators of 1971.’ The raids in the Hill Tracts followed a similar pattern: illegal detentions, torture, massacres, and rapes. Indigenous-owned land was also taken over and handed over to Bengalis. The Rakkhi Bahini’s violence and land occupations created fissures between Bengalis and indigenous <em>Pahari</em>s which continue to shape the ongoing conflict.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  <figure data-test="image-block-v2-outer-wrapper" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-layout="stack" class="
      sqs-block-image-figure
      image-block-outer-wrapper
      image-block-v2
      design-layout-stack
      combination-animation-site-default
      individual-animation-site-default
      individual-text-animation-site-default
      image-position-left
      
    " data-scrolled
  >
    
      
        
        
          
          
            
            
            
            
            
            
            <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/631e99a5-9320-4c1b-96fa-0ce1f990ce82/Image+6+-+March+20+JRB+Attack%2C+Daily+Ittefaq+report.png" data-image-dimensions="928x1104" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/631e99a5-9320-4c1b-96fa-0ce1f990ce82/Image+6+-+March+20+JRB+Attack%2C+Daily+Ittefaq+report.png?format=1000w" width="928" height="1104" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/631e99a5-9320-4c1b-96fa-0ce1f990ce82/Image+6+-+March+20+JRB+Attack%2C+Daily+Ittefaq+report.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/631e99a5-9320-4c1b-96fa-0ce1f990ce82/Image+6+-+March+20+JRB+Attack%2C+Daily+Ittefaq+report.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/631e99a5-9320-4c1b-96fa-0ce1f990ce82/Image+6+-+March+20+JRB+Attack%2C+Daily+Ittefaq+report.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/631e99a5-9320-4c1b-96fa-0ce1f990ce82/Image+6+-+March+20+JRB+Attack%2C+Daily+Ittefaq+report.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/631e99a5-9320-4c1b-96fa-0ce1f990ce82/Image+6+-+March+20+JRB+Attack%2C+Daily+Ittefaq+report.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/631e99a5-9320-4c1b-96fa-0ce1f990ce82/Image+6+-+March+20+JRB+Attack%2C+Daily+Ittefaq+report.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/631e99a5-9320-4c1b-96fa-0ce1f990ce82/Image+6+-+March+20+JRB+Attack%2C+Daily+Ittefaq+report.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
            
          
        
          
        
      
    
    <figcaption data-width-ratio class="image-card-wrapper">
      

        
          <p class="sqsrte-small"><em>Newspaper report about Rakkhi Bahini’s attack on January 20’s JSD Protest. Image: Daily Ittefaq/Songramer Notebook</em></p>
        

        
          
        

        

      
    </figcaption>

    


  </figure>

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">The Rakkhi Bahini’s action were protected by Mujib and the AL. The <a href="https://legislativediv.portal.gov.bd/sites/default/files/files/legislativediv.portal.gov.bd/page/bf3cd905_628f_4cb8_8b76_c5adeb487c18/283.pdf">Rakkhi Bahini Amendment Act of 1974</a> stripped courts of the power to hold the force accountable. Moudud Ahmed, lawyer and politician, writes that when 18 year-old Shahjahan disappeared after being detained for allegedly being a JSD activist, the Rakkhi Bahini kept no records of the detention. The absence of systematic record-keeping of its searches, seizures, arrests, or other operations was a pattern which has prevented meaningful judicial investigation into the Rakkhi Bahini’s activities at the time.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><strong>Mass Killings</strong></p>


  



































  
  
    
  <figure data-test="image-block-v2-outer-wrapper" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-layout="stack" class="
      sqs-block-image-figure
      image-block-outer-wrapper
      image-block-v2
      design-layout-stack
      combination-animation-site-default
      individual-animation-site-default
      individual-text-animation-site-default
      image-position-left
      
    " data-scrolled
  >
    
      
        
        
          
          
            
            
            
            
            
            
            <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5bb46d9c-a74a-488d-a7dc-192320c46374/Image+7+-+Rakkhi+Bahini%27s+terror+in+newspapers.png" data-image-dimensions="1414x1865" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5bb46d9c-a74a-488d-a7dc-192320c46374/Image+7+-+Rakkhi+Bahini%27s+terror+in+newspapers.png?format=1000w" width="1414" height="1865" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5bb46d9c-a74a-488d-a7dc-192320c46374/Image+7+-+Rakkhi+Bahini%27s+terror+in+newspapers.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5bb46d9c-a74a-488d-a7dc-192320c46374/Image+7+-+Rakkhi+Bahini%27s+terror+in+newspapers.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5bb46d9c-a74a-488d-a7dc-192320c46374/Image+7+-+Rakkhi+Bahini%27s+terror+in+newspapers.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5bb46d9c-a74a-488d-a7dc-192320c46374/Image+7+-+Rakkhi+Bahini%27s+terror+in+newspapers.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5bb46d9c-a74a-488d-a7dc-192320c46374/Image+7+-+Rakkhi+Bahini%27s+terror+in+newspapers.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5bb46d9c-a74a-488d-a7dc-192320c46374/Image+7+-+Rakkhi+Bahini%27s+terror+in+newspapers.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/5bb46d9c-a74a-488d-a7dc-192320c46374/Image+7+-+Rakkhi+Bahini%27s+terror+in+newspapers.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
            
          
        
          
        
      
    
    <figcaption data-width-ratio class="image-card-wrapper">
      

        
          <p class="sqsrte-small"><em>Reports catalogue Rakkhi Bahini’s criminal activities, including rape, enforced disappearances, and terrorising areas. On September 29, 1973, Gonokontho reported that around 30,000 freedom fighters were languishing in jails for being JSD activists. Image: Songramer Notebook</em></p>
        

        
          
        

        

      
    </figcaption>

    


  </figure>

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">On January 20, 1974, JSD activists broke curfew to hold a protest in Dhaka against the Rakkhi Bahini’s terror, the AL’s corruption, and economic mismanagement of the country. The Rakkhi Bahini brutally broke the protest by beating protestors, including those who took shelter in the Baitul Mukarram Mosque. Political historian Mohiuddin Ahmed, in <em>Jashoder Utthan Poton: Osthir Shomoyer Rajniti (The Rise and Fall of JSD: Politics of The Chaotic Era) </em>writes that at another JSD protest on March 17, in Ramna, Dhaka, Rakkhi Bahini shot dead around 50 people.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Rakkhi Bahini was reported to have opened fire at the public with semi-automatic rifles and machine guns in several parts of the country. In a story published on June 23, 1975, <em>Chicago Daily News </em>reported around 1,500 teenagers were killed by Rakkhi Bahini in Mymensingh district alone in January 1974. Most victims were thought to be part of the Sarbohara party. The publication of the story led to a ban on foreign journalists entering the country, and increased restrictions on local newspapers.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Rakkhi Bahini was also accused of using brutal methods in torture, including boiling water. Investigative journalist Ahmed Musa, wrote, “Some of their medieval-styled brutality even surpassed that of the Pakistan Army.” In his book <em>Dui Doshoker Bam Rajniti: Shonkot o Shomossha (Two Decades of Left Politics: Crisis and Problems</em>, Haydar Akbar Khan’s writes that after a Rakkhi Bahini camp in Kaliganj, Jessore, was dismantled a mass grave was discovered with at least 60 bodies. Estimates of the total number of people massacred by the Rakkhi Bahini between 1972–75 vary: investigative journalists like Masudul Haque and Ahmed Musa suggest roughly 10,000–30,000 were killed, while JSD claims the killings were as high as 60,000.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><strong>Siraj Sikder’s Last Stand and Mujib’s Assassination</strong></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Besieged by the Rakkhi Bahini’s reign of terror and severe economic mismanagement, Sarbohara leader Siraj Sikder decided to take up arms to overthrow the Mujib’s regime. AL narratives paint Sikder as ‘<em>lal-shontrasi</em>’ (red-terrorist). But no one asks: what made him chose guerilla warfare?</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Besieged by the Rakkhi Bahini reign of terror, Sarbohara leader Siraj Sikder decided to take up arms to overthrow the Mujib’s regime. AL narratives paint Sikder as ‘lal-shontrasi’ (red-terrorist). But no one asks: what made him chose guerilla warfare?<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Sikder chose the path of Che Guevera after the 1974 famine caused by corruption and economic mismanagement and the Rakkhi Bahini’s state-backed reign of terror. However, Sikder could not complete his revolution, as he <a href="https://archive.org/details/fearfulstatepowe0000alis/page/188/mode/2up">was killed by Rakkhi Bahini</a> in a staged-encounter on January 2, 1975.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">The notority of the Rakkhi Bahni amongst the Bangladesh army officers and cadre and the impunity with which Sikder was killed was reported to have inspired ideologically centrists in the Bangladesh army, including Sayed Faruq, Bazlul Huda, Abdur Rashid, and Shariful Haque Dalim to stage a coup against Mujib. The reign of terror of the Rakkhi Bahini ended on August 15, 1975, when the 2nd Field Regiment staged a coup, and dismantled the Rakkhi Bahini camps after assassinating Mujib. &nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal">Many in Bangladesh celebrated the fall of unpopular Mujib’s regime, and the Rakkhi Bahini’s reign of terror came to an end. However, Bangladesh’s political leadership learnt little from how the creation of Rakkhi Bahini sealed the fate of Mujib, and revived the practice of using paramilitary forces, namely the Rapid Action Battalion in 2004, which remains accused of extrajudicial killings of over 1,000 members of the political opposition. The dark chapter of Bangladesh’s history in which there was a state-backed massacre of leftists must be remembered, not just to honor the memories of Bangladesh’s fallen revolutionaries in the global left, but to stop the mistakes of the past from being repeated in the present and future of the country.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="MsoNormal"><strong><em>Ifaz Ali Khan</em></strong><em> is a writer, independent researcher, and human rights’ activist, currently pursuing a bachelors degree in Computer Science &amp; Engineering at East Delta University. He also writes for International Policy Digest.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1774979454448-EZK935NJBGBYQUNHW4UL/42995.jpg?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">The Forgotten Massacre of the Left in Bangladesh</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>Iran and Anti-Imperial Feminism</title><category>Interview</category><dc:creator>Ania Loomba</dc:creator><pubDate>Mon, 23 Mar 2026 01:00:58 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/iran-and-anti-imperial-feminism-an-interview-with-faranak-miraftab</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:69bc3caacb74693760bd001e</guid><description><![CDATA[From Iran to India, two feminist scholars—Ania Loomba and Faranak 
Miraftab—reckon with empire.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>From Iran to India, two feminist scholars—Ania Loomba and Faranak Miraftab—reckon with empire.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b57cd14-ad32-4923-a7a9-4460ef6fe592/PHOTO-2026-03-23-15-22-35.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1600x900" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b57cd14-ad32-4923-a7a9-4460ef6fe592/PHOTO-2026-03-23-15-22-35.jpg?format=1000w" width="1600" height="900" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b57cd14-ad32-4923-a7a9-4460ef6fe592/PHOTO-2026-03-23-15-22-35.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b57cd14-ad32-4923-a7a9-4460ef6fe592/PHOTO-2026-03-23-15-22-35.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b57cd14-ad32-4923-a7a9-4460ef6fe592/PHOTO-2026-03-23-15-22-35.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b57cd14-ad32-4923-a7a9-4460ef6fe592/PHOTO-2026-03-23-15-22-35.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b57cd14-ad32-4923-a7a9-4460ef6fe592/PHOTO-2026-03-23-15-22-35.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b57cd14-ad32-4923-a7a9-4460ef6fe592/PHOTO-2026-03-23-15-22-35.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/2b57cd14-ad32-4923-a7a9-4460ef6fe592/PHOTO-2026-03-23-15-22-35.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available images</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available images</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">On Wednesday, 11th March, 2026, along with 135 other nations, India co-sponsored a resolution of the United Nations Security Council which condemned Iran for attacking several Gulf countries, while remaining silent about the US-Israeli unprovoked earlier attack on Iran. India's action came on the heels of Prime Minister Modi's visit to Israel where he hugged Netanyahu, condemned Hamas's actions of October 7, and remained silent on Israel's genocide in Gaza. The cosponsoring of the resolution underscored the Hindu supremacist regime's endorsement of Trump and Netanyahu's global agenda. Condemning the Indian government's stand as "gutless," Arundhati Roy avowed: "I stand with Iran. Unequivocally. Any regimes that need changing, including the US, Israel and ours, need to be changed by the people, not by some bloated, lying, cheating, greedy, resource-grabbing, bomb-dropping imperial power and its allies who are trying to bully the whole world into submission." Of course, India's current position on Palestine and now on Iran ties in with the ruling party's Islamophobia, expressed both in its foreign policy and internally for decades. As far back as 2000, India's home minister, LK Advani, had visited Tel Aviv and announced that India and Israel <a href="https://studies.aljazeera.net/en/reports/2013/04/201347114923799215.html">shared</a> "a common perception of terrorism as a menace, even more so when coupled with religious fundamentalism."</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Netanyahu shamelessly invoked the Iranian women’s movement’s slogan of “Zan Zindagi Azadi” before dropping bombs on civilians. Shortly after the US bombed a girls’ school in Iran.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Today, I want to reflect on what the attack on Iran might mean for feminists in India, and more generally in South Asia, and on what it might mean for transnational feminist solidarities. As we know, the purported emancipation of women has been a key element in justifications of the Islamophobic US assaults on Afghanistan and Iraq, and of Israel's earlier attack on Iran in 2025 where Netanyahu shamelessly invoked the Iranian women's movement's slogan of "Zan Zindagi Azadi" before dropping bombs on civilians. Shortly after the US bombed a girls' school in Iran, left-wing politician Manuela Bergerot lashed out: "This is how the right defends the rights of Iranian women: by celebrating the murder of 160 girls." And it <em>literally </em>does this. The U.S. conservative commentator Matt Schlapp <a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/video/newsfeed/2026/3/12/how-is-feminism-being-used-to-justify-war-in-iran#flips-6390769184112:0">declared</a> that "it is hypocritical to say that these attacks harmed women and children questioned how one could condemn their deaths when ...the young girls you reference would be...live a life [sic] in a barbaric and unequal society behind a burqa..."</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c7ed6d2-ea1c-42ad-a05f-d6cb3668dff8/2560.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="2600x1950" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c7ed6d2-ea1c-42ad-a05f-d6cb3668dff8/2560.jpeg?format=1000w" width="2600" height="1950" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c7ed6d2-ea1c-42ad-a05f-d6cb3668dff8/2560.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c7ed6d2-ea1c-42ad-a05f-d6cb3668dff8/2560.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c7ed6d2-ea1c-42ad-a05f-d6cb3668dff8/2560.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c7ed6d2-ea1c-42ad-a05f-d6cb3668dff8/2560.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c7ed6d2-ea1c-42ad-a05f-d6cb3668dff8/2560.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c7ed6d2-ea1c-42ad-a05f-d6cb3668dff8/2560.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c7ed6d2-ea1c-42ad-a05f-d6cb3668dff8/2560.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Mourners at a funeral held for children killed in the strike. Photograph: Anadolu/Getty Images</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Mourners at a funeral held for children killed in the strike. Photograph: Anadolu/Getty Images</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">We in South Asia have been familiar with this playbook from the days of the British Raj, when colonial rule was justified by pointing to the "disgusting" sexual habits and culture of the natives. However, these colonial histories should not lead us to inhabit a binary between colonizers and colonized because that oversimplifies what is at stake now and renders invisible women's own demands for freedom and equality. We know this from our own history. Feminist historians of India have written extensively on how elite native men, increasingly disenfranchised and excluded from the public sphere, became more tyrannical at home, asserting the demands of native tradition and values to delegitimize women's demands for equality. From at least the early twentieth century, many women, as individuals and as part of organized groups, refused the choice between imperialist and home-grown patriarchies.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>From at least the early twentieth century, many women, as individuals and as part of organized groups, refused the choice between imperialist and home-grown patriarchies.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In postcolonial India, the colonial playbook has been adapted in the service of Hindu majoritarianism, which has whipped up anti-Muslim sentiments by invoking the "plight" of Muslim women as victims of sexist biases within the community, while simultaneously casting Muslim men as rapacious, perpetually engaged in a "love jihad" to prey on Hindu women. The discourse of the Muslim woman as victim goes hand in hand with under-reporting or ignoring the horrific sexual violence that Muslim women were subjected to during the genocide in Gujarat in 2002. The courts have <em>de facto</em> legalized such violence—the men who raped Bilkis Bano were prematurely released in 2022 and welcomed home with sweets and garlands. Islamophobic pronouncements about Muslim polygamy and backwardness are brought up whenever the subject of reform of Muslim personal laws to give women greater equality comes up. This has meant that a Muslim woman was "called upon to make a difficult choice between her claims for gender equality and equal protection of law on the one hand, and her religious beliefs and community affiliations on the other" as feminist lawyer Flavia Agnes once put it. Refusing this choice, Muslim women in India have used even imperfect laws to fight for their rights, while also participating in the wider women's movement in India.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">These earlier histories resonate with the situation that confronts anti-war anti-imperialist feminists, and indeed all anti-imperialists, today. While we condemn the attacks on Iran, we cannot also ignore the real critiques of the Iranian regime mounted by Iranian women. As Shahrzad Mojab, Professor Emerita at the University of Toronto puts it in a powerful recent statement:&nbsp;</p><blockquote><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">A revolutionary feminist position on Iran must refuse the false and damaging binary that demands choosing between defending the Islamic Republic and endorsing US-imperialist and Zionist intervention. This is a constructed choice designed to collapse political judgment into campism. It converts solidarity into a competition of moral allegiances and leaves ordinary people, workers, women, youth, and minorities to a reality shaped simultaneously by internal repression as well as external militarized destruction.</p></blockquote><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">It is in this context that I interviewed Faranak Miraftab, Professor at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, who shared Mojab's statement with me. Faranak herself had to flee Ayatollah Khomeini’s Iran after her sister was <a href="https://www.news-gazette.com/news/iranian-ui-professor-ex-refugee-feels-travel-bans-pain-deeply/article_c4c33da7-067d-58cb-972d-d8b06569b523.html">executed </a>along with 50 other women at the age of 27. Faranak herself was 23 at the time.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Our conversation touched upon issues of feminist anti-imperialism, as well as the need and scope of international feminist solidarities, which I think are useful for us in South Asia as we navigate the complexities of our own political landscapes.</p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Conversation with Faranak Miraftab</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Ania Loomba</strong>: Faranak, on March 8, International Women's Day, the US feminists' coalition "Women's March" used the Iranian women's slogan "Women, Life Freedom" in order to critique the Israeli American war on Iran. Its Instagram <a href="https://www.instagram.com/p/DVl0HatjbjG/">post</a> said: "Iranian Women have spent decades fighting for their freedom. They don't need Trump's bombs. Women's liberation will not be delivered by bombs. The same man whose DOJ buried a 13-year-old's testimony started a war without a vote, without a plan, and without our consent." The responses to this Instagram post defending the war were largely from Iranian women: "As an Iranian woman I need to disagree with you! We tried and every time, the barbaric regime killed many of us! Sorry but the only solution was the bombs! Thanks for your concern!" Another read: "Do Not dare to use this Name for your own benefits, woman life freedon [sic] Revolution," and yet another, "The irony of a woman life freedom placard with this message." There were many messages like this, what is your reaction?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>Faranak Miraftab</strong>: First, my opinion on the Zan Zindagi Azadi movement is that it was one of the most progressive events that I have been part of and witnessed in my life. Woman, Life, Freedom was truly a feminist movement, in its approach, in the way it worked, in its slogan, and it was beautiful, beautiful to watch young men joining women and accepting women's leadership on the streets and following them.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">When it was happening, I felt I was dreaming all of this. It cannot be possible to see men and women of all ethnicities and different classes supporting protesting women and understanding something that we feminists said for so long - that liberation of men wouldn't happen unless women are also liberated. This was theoretical, but I think 40-something years of vicious oppression in Iran, the key element of which was the control of women's bodies, proved to men that their liberation is through the liberation of women. And it was no longer theoretical; it was on the streets of the country.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The slogan Woman, Life, Freedom itself is progressive because it captures almost all those things that we stand for, right? Gender equity, livelihood, freedom. You know the slogan came from the Kurdish women's movement. And Iranian Kurds borrowed it and then spread it to the rest of the country. When it was happening in 2022, we wanted all the feminists around the world to come out in our support. With the exception of a few global south countries, including neighbouring Turkey, we did not see solidarity marches or statements by feminist movements. And it was our greatest dismay and disappointment. I, being based in the U.S., thought, why don't I see American feminists coming out, supporting this slogan, using it for their own cause? Because, at the same time, women in the U.S. were seeing their own social reproductive rights being eroded; we were all fighting for similar issues.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Iranian women don’t have one singular position. We have various ethnic groups, different class interests, right and left on the political spectrum, and I don’t think anybody would be able to say, I am speaking for Iranian women. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I had an Indian friend who came to all our marches for Zan Zindagi Azadi in Champaign-Urbana, and I was so moved; she kept saying that in India, Muslim women were being targeted by the Hindu fundamentalist regime. And so, she was saying, whether it's against Hindu fundamentalism, or it is social reproductive rights in the U.S., or these other rights in Iran, we should all be united.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I do not see it as appropriation when the slogan is used to carry the same message. What I reject is when "Women Life Freedom" is used by parliamentarians in the European Union for their own cause to bash the Islamic Republic state, which is a vicious, suppressive, oppressive regime. But they are using it, you know, to score their own political points. <em>That </em>is when I reject it. So, it depends on who is using it, and towards what. When other feminist movements use the slogan, we celebrate it, we want it, that is how it should be.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a3db1896-450c-404b-9bdd-ea6a3992d5b8/YL4AML52NFK5XMTGKYCGWD44DM.jpg" data-image-dimensions="5184x3456" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a3db1896-450c-404b-9bdd-ea6a3992d5b8/YL4AML52NFK5XMTGKYCGWD44DM.jpg?format=1000w" width="5184" height="3456" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a3db1896-450c-404b-9bdd-ea6a3992d5b8/YL4AML52NFK5XMTGKYCGWD44DM.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a3db1896-450c-404b-9bdd-ea6a3992d5b8/YL4AML52NFK5XMTGKYCGWD44DM.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a3db1896-450c-404b-9bdd-ea6a3992d5b8/YL4AML52NFK5XMTGKYCGWD44DM.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a3db1896-450c-404b-9bdd-ea6a3992d5b8/YL4AML52NFK5XMTGKYCGWD44DM.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a3db1896-450c-404b-9bdd-ea6a3992d5b8/YL4AML52NFK5XMTGKYCGWD44DM.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a3db1896-450c-404b-9bdd-ea6a3992d5b8/YL4AML52NFK5XMTGKYCGWD44DM.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/a3db1896-450c-404b-9bdd-ea6a3992d5b8/YL4AML52NFK5XMTGKYCGWD44DM.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Protestors at a Woman, Life, Freedom March near the Irani consulate in Istanbul. Photo: Reuters.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Protestors at a Woman, Life, Freedom March near the Irani consulate in Istanbul. Photo: Reuters.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AL:</strong> Yes. Radical movements have always borrowed slogans from their comrades in other parts of the world or in other types of movements, for example, the slogan of Indian feminists "Hum Kya Chahte? Azadi!" [What do we want? freedom!"] was inspired by the women's movement in Pakistan. It has been used by dissident movements of different kinds in India, students' movements, in Kashmir, in protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act. Similarly, the Chilean chant, "¡El pueblo unido jamás será vencido!" (The People united shall never be defeated") has been used in radical protests worldwide.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The March 8th women's march was for reproductive rights, but it was also explicitly against the US-Israeli war on Iran and saying that Iranian women don't need to be saved by Trump and Netanyahu. But in these messages, in their social media responses, we heard an endorsement of the Israeli-US attack by many Iranian women, and we have all seen images of Iranian women in London, Los Angeles and other cities celebrating the attack.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM:</strong> So, Iranian women don't have one singular position. We have various ethnic groups, different class interests, right and left on the political spectrum, and I don't think anybody would be able to say, I am speaking for Iranian women. Nor can I say that. I want to be very clear that I speak from the position of a left anti-imperialist and feminist woman. And I do see that our enemies and our fronts of struggle are multiple. On one side, we are anti-imperialist, and we are against the intervention of the U.S and Israel into our affairs, but on the other hand, and simultaneously, we are also against the Islamic Republic state.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AL</strong>: But Faranak, the Iranian women who objected to US women using the slogan also pointed out that many US feminists have not spoken out against the Iranian regime thus far. One woman wrote, "If you remained dead silent after a massacre of 40,000 ppl just two months ago, and if you have remained silent for women being treated less than second rate citizens by IRI for 50 years, you now have ZERO right to use our name to push your agenda. Stop whitewashing regime’s crimes. Listen to Iranians. Stop patronizing us." Another wrote: "It is funny that when in 2022 I reached out to you about Woman Life Freedom movement and asked for support no one cared to reply."</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>What I do not support is the position that says I am the only one who has the right to speak for Iranian women, and you cannot be in solidarity with me, either because you are not Iranian, or because you were silent in the past. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">We also know that many liberal feminists have not come out in support of Gaza. Do you think that this might be a turning point in the United States where a lot of people who haven't previously spoken out might actually be so disgusted with this war that it might push them into taking stances that they were not willing to take earlier?&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="is-empty"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM:</strong> People who are now taking a position against the war in Iran but did not utter a word when Iranian state massacred thousands of its own citizens in 48 hours, or remained silent about the ongoing genocide in Gaza, that is not acceptable. Those lives were as precious as the lives of civilians that are being bombed in Iran today. But it doesn't mean that because they were silent then, they must be silent now. It does mean that if your humanity is moved now, if you don't want to see schoolchildren killed and innocent people in their homes being bombed and killed, then you should continue this not only for Iran but also for Gaza and everywhere we see imperial military bullies at work. I support that position. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">What I do not support is the position that says I am the only one who has the right to speak for Iranian women, and you cannot be in solidarity with me, either because you are not Iranian, or because you were silent in the past. As an anti-imperialist feminist Iranian outside Iran, I very much welcome feminists in India, in the U.S. and everywhere else to lend their voice to us and use this same slogan whose origin is transnational, and further globalize it, but not to prostitute it by selectively choosing moments of solidarity. Because I don't think this struggle will end here.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Yes, so if your consciousness is raised now and you are paying attention, please continue to raise your voice in the future. Rather than silencing them, we should engage with these new voices that are daring to speak in true solidarity, a solidarity which should not exist just in this moment but in the future too.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AL:</strong> That's a really important point, because what you're also saying is that our movements must grow, and we cannot push away people who want to come in.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM:</strong> Exactly, otherwise we stay atomized. We must, as left anti-imperialist feminists, use opportunities to grow. We must understand that my struggle and your struggle are connected. If I am fighting about women's issues in Iran, which are really human rights issues, it doesn't mean that I am necessarily lining up with the U.S. or Israel. I think this is the moment in which we can make that position clear, that I am against the Zionists, and the attack on Iran, and I am, at the same time, against the oppression of Iranians by the state. The sad thing is that what happened in Gaza was a playbook for Israel, and they are going to do the same in Iran, using the same language, justifications and brutality. And a truly transnational feminist left perspective can see these similarities.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><br><strong>AL:</strong> Can you spell out the playbook a bit more?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM:</strong>&nbsp; Well, when they hit the first hospital in Gaza, I remember that there was a scramble about who hit it. They said, oh, Hamas hit it, it wasn't us. And then, it was like nothing happened, and they were going out there outright and hitting hospitals and schools. And saying that people in these places are being used like human shields.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">And now they are doing exactly the same. They hit the school, and yesterday, a number of medical health centres were hit. I’ve lost track of the exact count, but it's incredibly high. You know, we have been under sanctions, so our medications have been produced locally. They have hit two of the most important pharmaceutical factories in Iran.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">That is the playbook: going after schools and hospitals and not even being worried about covering it up. They haven't said that pharmaceutical companies are housing human shields, but they say that about the hospitals. I was reading somewhere that they say that Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) is meeting in the basement of hospitals.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">So that's the playbook. And Israel has a real interest in seeing Iran razed to the ground.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AL:</strong> Yes absolutely. Faranak, I wonder if you would be willing to share a little bit about your own history and how it informs the stances that you take today. What are your thoughts when you look back to that earlier period? Many of the readers of this interview might be much younger people who don't have an intimate knowledge of what happened in Iran 30 to 40 years ago.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>The left has been paying the price all along. We have been persecuted by the Shah and by the Islamic Republic from the very early days. It is not surprising that followers of the Shah’s son also chant slogans against the left today.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM</strong>: I came to political consciousness under the monarchy, prior to the establishment of the Islamic Republic. Maybe the younger generation doesn't have that historical memory, but I remember how scared we were of SAVAK, the Shah's intelligence service, which was trained by Israel's Mossad and CIA. Everybody knew that their techniques of torture, their mechanisms of control, and surveillance were taught by Mossad. That was an incredibly scary time for the left, and those opposed to the Shah.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ca0c07a6-e3e4-47b5-9600-5e76d9551b0e/the_shah_our_man_in_tehran_1050x700.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1050x700" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ca0c07a6-e3e4-47b5-9600-5e76d9551b0e/the_shah_our_man_in_tehran_1050x700.jpeg?format=1000w" width="1050" height="700" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ca0c07a6-e3e4-47b5-9600-5e76d9551b0e/the_shah_our_man_in_tehran_1050x700.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ca0c07a6-e3e4-47b5-9600-5e76d9551b0e/the_shah_our_man_in_tehran_1050x700.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ca0c07a6-e3e4-47b5-9600-5e76d9551b0e/the_shah_our_man_in_tehran_1050x700.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ca0c07a6-e3e4-47b5-9600-5e76d9551b0e/the_shah_our_man_in_tehran_1050x700.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ca0c07a6-e3e4-47b5-9600-5e76d9551b0e/the_shah_our_man_in_tehran_1050x700.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ca0c07a6-e3e4-47b5-9600-5e76d9551b0e/the_shah_our_man_in_tehran_1050x700.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ca0c07a6-e3e4-47b5-9600-5e76d9551b0e/the_shah_our_man_in_tehran_1050x700.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Reza Pahlavi and John F. Kennedy in Washington, D.C. in 1962.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Reza Pahlavi and John F. Kennedy in Washington, D.C. in 1962.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" id="yui_3_17_2_1_1773959071484_18872">While opposition overall was viciously suppressed under the Shah, he thought that Islam was not as serious a threat as was the left. Hence the organizational network of the religious opposition and the mosques were able to lead the revolution. And shortly after the establishment of the Islamic Republic, the surveillance machinery of SAVAK changed its name to SAVAMA and was used to pursue the opposition including the left.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">My own beloved sister was arrested for her activism with a leftist group and in 3 weeks, without a trial or hearing, was executed, together with 50 other young girls. That was in December 1981. And many of my comrades and friends also experienced similar tragedies.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span> The whole phenomenon of Reza Pahlavi is very young, it’s 2 to 3 years old because during the Woman Life Freedom movement his name was not in the streets.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The left has been paying the price all along. We have been persecuted by the Shah and by the Islamic Republic from the very early days. It is not surprising that followers of the Shah’s son also chant slogans against the left today. If you are supporting Iranians against the Islamic Republic, you should also support them against imperialism, against foreign intervention, against control of our affairs by the US or Israel. From a feminist and left perspective, this ability to fight on two fronts at the same time is very important.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AL</strong>: You mentioned, when we last spoke, that the monarchists were against the slogan "Women Life Freedom." And that they were not part of that movement. Despite being very anti-feminist, they claim, like large sections of the Western media, that Iranian women were so "free" under the Shah.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM</strong>: It's very interesting, actually. The whole phenomenon of Reza Pahlavi is very young, it's 2 to 3 years old because during the Woman Life Freedom movement his name was not in the streets. People didn't know that he claims to be an alternative. He rose to fame because of the support of the television stations that are funded by Israel, and because of the social media propping him. Some people will say that the Woman Life Freedom movement didn't succeed because it didn't have a leader, didn't have a recognizable name to rally behind. And they use that very reasoning to argue that we need to follow Reza Pahlavi now.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I see such arguments as indications of extreme hopelessness. In a constant struggle between hope and despair, the tragedy is in the defeat of imagination, in imagining the possibility of an alternative. People don't see how they can get rid of this oppressive regime, which has a monopoly on force. How can we ever confront it on the streets, facing its bullets? So they say, this is not going to work, we need another military intervention to "rescue" us. And again, they don't have the historical and transnational perspective which tells us imperialists have never ever liberated any people.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The other point you were mentioning, how in the rallies of the monarchists, banners of Woman Life Freedom were banned. The monarchists were bringing them down because they saw them as a competition to their own slogan which is Long Live the King.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AL</strong>: Where were these rallies? Outside Iran, yes?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM</strong>: Yeah, outside Iran, and the Shah's son never came out to say, I do not endorse or approve of the behaviour of my followers. I think it is very sad, because what Woman Life Freedom did in Iran was profound. I mean, maybe it did not change the regime, but it had transformative effects. Culturally, it went into every household, every conversation. From rich to poor, from Kurds and Baloch people to the centre of the country. And it sparked a consciousness and a cultural transformation that is worth decades. It's not a change that resulted in a change of power, but the civil disobedience of women was very important. Practically, they were not wearing their hijab anyway. So, they practiced what they were refusing to do. And this was the case even until last month.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">I think what we are seeing, sadly, is the toxic masculinist patriarchal powers of the U.S. and the Zionists, Pahlavi, and the Islamic Republic. All of them are representatives of the patriarchal, sexist order. They have come together, and they are also fighting against each other. And this is just one incident in history in which we see how patriarchal and anti-patriarchal powers, capitalism and anti-capitalism, imperialism and anti-imperialism are ranged in this fight. And we have to be very clear on which side we are on in <em>each</em> of these fronts.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AL</strong>: Would it be fair to say that the Woman Life Freedom movement prepared the ground for the next wave of protests about economic issues? It was a broadening of the protest because Women Life Freedom was also about sustenance. &nbsp; &nbsp; &nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM</strong>: When months ago, with the devaluation of the toman, the bazarees (merchants) closed their shops, many of us were saying that this is the "Life" part of the slogan which is now the focus. The demand was that we cannot live with this kind of economic situation. I was not there, but through social media I was seeing very powerful scenes of civil disobedience. There were scenes of youth sitting in front of the police forces, just sitting, like those scenes from Tiananmen Square. And it was very powerful.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">But the call from outside Iran by the Shah's son was: you have to come out at night and attack and take over the key state institutions and bases. He called for a very different form of confrontation from the feminist strategies which had worked, not in the sense of toppling the regime but in bringing in more people. We still have 20% of Iranian voters supporting the hardliners. We can't kill them all, we can't throw them in the sea. The feminist movement was &nbsp;practicing civil disobedience. I've been seeing how it works. The movement brings in villagers and people from all over the country. But the protest movement last year quickly changed from horizontal feminist practices of resistance to very masculinist type of strategies. At the same time, Mossad proclaimed that its agents were amongst the protestors, and that definitely made things worse, and offered the state a convenient justification to come in with full force and start shooting at people. Not that they would have resisted shooting anyway. They shot people during Woman Life Freedom. But I'm just pointing out that feminist practices of cultural and horizontal organizing were very hard for the regime to control. When this changed to a more masculinist language, it gave a free ticket to the hardliners to be in power.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0fdd13b1-1ca7-410d-882e-1984f9332f4c/f6ac31e_upload-1-u7t0yvjis75u-089-mei-irn-ss-item-20260307-038-1.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1112x741" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0fdd13b1-1ca7-410d-882e-1984f9332f4c/f6ac31e_upload-1-u7t0yvjis75u-089-mei-irn-ss-item-20260307-038-1.jpeg?format=1000w" width="1112" height="741" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0fdd13b1-1ca7-410d-882e-1984f9332f4c/f6ac31e_upload-1-u7t0yvjis75u-089-mei-irn-ss-item-20260307-038-1.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0fdd13b1-1ca7-410d-882e-1984f9332f4c/f6ac31e_upload-1-u7t0yvjis75u-089-mei-irn-ss-item-20260307-038-1.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0fdd13b1-1ca7-410d-882e-1984f9332f4c/f6ac31e_upload-1-u7t0yvjis75u-089-mei-irn-ss-item-20260307-038-1.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0fdd13b1-1ca7-410d-882e-1984f9332f4c/f6ac31e_upload-1-u7t0yvjis75u-089-mei-irn-ss-item-20260307-038-1.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0fdd13b1-1ca7-410d-882e-1984f9332f4c/f6ac31e_upload-1-u7t0yvjis75u-089-mei-irn-ss-item-20260307-038-1.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0fdd13b1-1ca7-410d-882e-1984f9332f4c/f6ac31e_upload-1-u7t0yvjis75u-089-mei-irn-ss-item-20260307-038-1.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0fdd13b1-1ca7-410d-882e-1984f9332f4c/f6ac31e_upload-1-u7t0yvjis75u-089-mei-irn-ss-item-20260307-038-1.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Airstrikes target an oil depot in Tehran, Iran, March 7, 2026. Image: Le Monde.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Airstrikes target an oil depot in Tehran, Iran, March 7, 2026. Image: Le Monde.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AL</strong>: What do you know about Trump saying he hopes the Kurdish movement would also mount an offensive against the Iranian regime?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM</strong>: Yes, well Trump was claiming that the Kurdish movement is now going to be working as the U.S.’s ground troops. It seems like that claim has died down. I haven't heard it in the last two or three days. When it first started being mentioned, Komalah, which is the communist party of the Kurdish people, said they are not going to participate in this, that they understand that imperial forces will use their people and land as sacrifice for their imperial ambitions, that what they did in Rojava, the Kurdistan of Syria, they will also do here. So, they distanced themselves from the other six groups that had formed an alliance to potentially enter the war.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AL</strong>: Faranak, what contact do you have with your own friends and family in Iran today? What other news can you get from inside?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM</strong>: I have heard from two cousins. Not directly, but they managed to contact their children who were abroad, and say, “we are alive.” But I haven't been able to connect with my aunt who is in a nursing home or with my extended family. The Iranian students who are here, and who have their parents and siblings back in Iran are very stressed and distressed.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Anti-war feminists outside Iran are being very much viciously attacked by the monarchists who are aligned with Israel and Trump.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The pounding continues. The lack of internet has meant that very few images come out. Just as in Israel, in Iran they are not allowed to broadcast their own losses. The state wants to have control over what information is broadcast. But in the few images that have come out, you can see the flattening of neighbourhoods, images that resonate with those from Gaza. Some of the voices that come out are saying they don't want this war.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AL</strong>: That would be a very hard position to take today. I remember reading, in an important interview with Neda Naji, a feminist and former political prisoner in Iran. She described the situation after the Israeli attacks on Iran some two years ago, saying that "While the right-wing Iranian opposition, which supported the military attacks, were dancing happily in the safe streets of Europe and America, feminists tried to raise their voices against the war to the best of their ability. This was a very difficult task in a situation where opposition to war among Iranians is not a given and the killing of civilians is considered a natural and inevitable part of war. Even what is happening in Gaza cannot awaken those who have been deluded by the lies of military aggressors and child killers." She rightly pointed out that the result of such imperialist wars is always "the intensification of nationalism and the discourse of defending the homeland." This is what we are seeing today also, yes?&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM</strong>:&nbsp; Yes, anti-war feminists outside Iran are being very much viciously attacked by the monarchists who are aligned with Israel and Trump. And internally, the killing of Khamenei, who deserved to face justice and be tried by families of its victims, is, instead, being mourned as a martyr. Thanks to the Israel-U.S. military attack, the hardline has the perfect excuse for its repression. This military aggression has strengthened the fundamentalist state and further pushed back the gains by the long struggle of workers, teachers, women and students' movements.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Having said that, I wish to stress that the people of Iran should not be seen as victims. They are fierce and in resistance.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">In recent days, the IRGC appears frequently on the Islamic Republic's TV threatening people very clearly, saying that if now we see anyone protesting in the streets, we will treat them not as protesters, but as enemies. And we won't waste time and resources to arrest them; we will just shoot and execute them. So, people in Iran are experiencing both imperialist and state violence.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">One of my friends said that she received a short note from a family member through a VPN, which is very hard to get and expensive, which said that they feel very lonely. They are being bombed from the sky. And from the state. The state is supposed to be your protector. It is shooting anti-ballistic missiles, which is protecting you against bombs but it's also bombarding you with these threats of violence, and I think that is why they feel very lonely.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Having said that, I wish to stress that the people of Iran should not be seen as victims. They are fierce and in resistance. Almost five decades of educational manipulation, imprisonment, punishment and various forms of economic, political and existential violence was not able to silence people. The same people who have been rising repeatedly despite threats of state violence, are resisting the imperial military invasion of Israel-US forces. I am however deeply concerned about the cost of this process.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AL</strong>: That's why it's even more important that everybody who is outside shows their solidarity.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM</strong>: Yes, and one important support should be for the political prisoners among whom are amazing civil society leaders who can create an alternative to this regime and to the Shah’s son, who is presented as the only alternative to the IRI. That Reza Pahlavi, who has no political career, has done nothing in the last decades, can suddenly be projected as an alternative, is an indication of the political vacuum that the Iranian state is to blame for. Even reformists who were rising through the clergy system, were silenced, arrested, imprisoned or killed. The vacuum that the state produced gave rise to this monstrous Israeli project of restoring the monarchy.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>AL</strong>: This is a crucial point that you've made about political prisoners. At the same time, not every opponent of this regime is jailed. So, can you tell us what efforts are being made to lay the ground for such an alternative?</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong>FM</strong>: There are calls from inside and outside the country to create a council of transition which would have people from various ethnic groups and political orientations including leftists and feminists involved in the Women Life Freedom movement. On March 14th, they announced their first gathering in Europe. The&nbsp;inclusive Woman, Life, Freedom Network officially emerged from the&nbsp;Women Life Freedom movement. It is&nbsp;one of the most active networks working both inside Iran and abroad to help&nbsp;establish a coordinating and leadership council&nbsp;for the period following the fall of the Islamic Republic.&nbsp;This network has supported various grassroots movements in Iran, including workers’ movements, students' movement, teachers’ protests, and other forms of grassroots movements. There is another group called&nbsp;Progressive Students, consisting of students from different universities across Iran,&nbsp;who also maintain links with broader social movements, including the workers’ movement, retirees’ protests, the student and school student movements, the women’s movement, and the movement against executions. In this sense, their network of connections extends across multiple sectors of Iranian civil and social activism. Since the war began, they have not been able to be as active due to the internet shutdown but based on a few posts on X and Telegram, we know that they remain active on the ground.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true">As we say in Spanish, la lucha continua. The struggle continues.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Ania Loomba</em></strong><em> is Catherine Bryson Professor Emerita at the University of Pennsylvania and Global Professorial Fellow at Queen Mary University London. She writes on&nbsp;race and colonialism, feminism, contemporary Indian literature and society, as well as Renaissance literatures and cultures.</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><strong><em>Faranak Miraftab</em></strong><em> is Professor of Urban and Regional Planning at University of Illinois, Urbana Champaign with courtesy appointments at the departments of Gender and Women Studies and Geography. A native of Iran, she has conducted research in Latin America, Africa, and North America.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1774294392119-6Q8P9ZD3TAJXBRLYWSKX/PHOTO-2026-03-23-15-22-35.jpg?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">Iran and Anti-Imperial Feminism</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>The Politics of Indigeneity in Post-Hasina Bangladesh&nbsp;</title><category>Bangladesh</category><category>Essay</category><dc:creator>Laleh Bergman Hossain</dc:creator><pubDate>Sun, 15 Mar 2026 17:00:13 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/the-politics-of-indigeneity-in-post-hasina-bangladesh</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:69b6bc1d19ab314a0c8f6c94</guid><description><![CDATA[Adibashi struggles in the Chittagong Hill Tracts continue to expose the 
limits of Bangladeshi nationalism.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""><em>Adibashi struggles in the Chittagong Hill Tracts continue to expose the limits of Bangladeshi nationalism.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af119023-fd18-42f6-9b40-43575b0e640d/signal-2026-03-14-20-46-12-531.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1229x1600" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af119023-fd18-42f6-9b40-43575b0e640d/signal-2026-03-14-20-46-12-531.jpg?format=1000w" width="1229" height="1600" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af119023-fd18-42f6-9b40-43575b0e640d/signal-2026-03-14-20-46-12-531.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af119023-fd18-42f6-9b40-43575b0e640d/signal-2026-03-14-20-46-12-531.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af119023-fd18-42f6-9b40-43575b0e640d/signal-2026-03-14-20-46-12-531.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af119023-fd18-42f6-9b40-43575b0e640d/signal-2026-03-14-20-46-12-531.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af119023-fd18-42f6-9b40-43575b0e640d/signal-2026-03-14-20-46-12-531.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af119023-fd18-42f6-9b40-43575b0e640d/signal-2026-03-14-20-46-12-531.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af119023-fd18-42f6-9b40-43575b0e640d/signal-2026-03-14-20-46-12-531.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available images</em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""><em>‘Everything implemented on the Hills will be implemented on the plain lands,’</em> warned Kalpana Chakma, an Indigenous activist allegedly abducted by plainclothes Bangladeshi military officers in 1996 and still missing nearly 30 years later. Her slogan, a reminder that political transformation in Bangladesh cannot be separated from the struggle of the <em>Adibashis</em> in the Chittagong Hill Tracts (CHT), reappeared across Dhaka’s walls in the weeks surrounding Sheikh Hasina’s overthrow in August 2024.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">The CHT, comprising three hilly districts in southeastern Bangladesh, has been a long-standing victim of the politics of state-making and state-building in South Asia. Largely inhabited by a collection of 12 minority ethnic groups, the region and its populations have been left outside a national imagination centred around building an exclusively Bengali national identity.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Collectively known as <em>Adibashi</em> (Indigenous) or Jumma people, these groups made up <a href="https://academiccommons.columbia.edu/doi/10.7916/D8HQ479C">90% of the population</a> of the Hill Tracts in the 1950s. However, post-partition development drives, alongside decades of militarisation and settler colonisation under<a href="https://academiccommons.columbia.edu/doi/10.7916/D8HQ479C"> successive Bangladeshi governments</a>, led to the forced displacement of Adibashis, resulting in drastic shifts in ethnic and religious composition, and heightened land disputes. In 1956, the Pakistani government constructed the Kaptai Dam on the Karnaphuli River to generate hydroelectric power. The dam permanently displaced nearly 25% of the region’s population, creating what is referred to amongst Adibashis as the <em>Bara Parang </em>or “The Great Exodus”.&nbsp; Demographic change intensified under Ziaur Rahman’s Bangladesh National Party (BNP) regime—between 1979-1983, government sponsored programs resettled hundreds of thousands of landless Bengalis into the region. By 1991, Adibashis only made up 51% of the population of the Hill Tracts.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Nationalism, as it often does, made blind the majority to the violence required to collapse a nation-state into a single ethnicity.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Meanwhile, official rhetoric, believing homogeneity to be the key to nation-building, has denied Adibashi identity outright. Bangladesh’s founding President, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, famously declared that “Everyone in Bangladesh is Bengali.” Having led the struggle for the recognition of Bengali identity and culture, Mujib now refused Adibashi groups a cut of that dream. The struggle for self-determination in Bangladesh became tied specifically to a unified Bengali nation, and schoolbooks made no mention of Adibashi demands for autonomy or self-determination. Nationalism, as it often does, made blind the majority to the violence required to collapse a nation-state into a single ethnicity.<br></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Resistance and Occupation&nbsp;</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Adibashi groups mobilised, and in 1977 Manabendra Narayan Larma, a Chakma politician and Adibashi rights advocate, formed the <em>Parbatya Chattagram Jana Samhati Samiti</em> (PCJSS), a left-wing political party representing various indigenous groups and advocating for regional autonomy for the CHT. Its armed wing, the <em>Shanti Bahini</em>, launched an insurgency against the Bangladeshi government, fighting for regional autonomy and land rights. The state responded with overwhelming force, in a military crackdown marked by widespread human rights violations including extrajudicial killings, torture, sexual violence and forced displacement. What emerged was a protracted armed conflict that lasted nearly three decades, throughout which the Bangladeshi military set up six military garrisons and more than 500 military camps in the CHT. As the landscape of the Hill Tracts became saturated with checkpoints, patrols and surveillance, civilian life unfolded under conditions of constant military control. At the same time, the military settled 400,000 poor, landless Bengalis in the Hill Tracts, granting them land titles and food rations, and positioning them as buffers between the army and Adibashi communities, thereby drawing them into the systematic displacement and dispossession of Adibashi populations.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Following the restoration of parliamentary democracy to Bangladesh in 1991, formal peace negotiations began with the newly elected prime minister Sheikh Hasina of the Awami League. On 2 December 1997, the Shanti Bahini laid down arms and signed the CHT Peace Accord, which promised a route towards self-rule through a system of regional and district councils, and importantly, land redistribution and reparations.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">However, decades on, the 1997 Accord remains largely unimplemented, having done little to restore land to Adibashi communities or dismantle the military’s grip over the region. Critical provisions enabling the genuine devolution of authority have been stalled, and land restitution, the withdrawal of army camps, and control over law enforcement have yet to be fully transferred to the councils. Beyond a handful of publicised actions to dismantle a few temporary military camps, the military’s everyday presence endured, and as <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/329597908_Against_Forgetting_Gendered_Justice_in_Post-conflict_Bangladesh"><u>Dina Siddiqui </u></a>argues, in many ways the Accord in fact invisibilised the militarisation of everyday life.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Indeed, in the post-accord landscape, state power was not withdrawn so much as reconfigured, resurfacing in the form of military-controlled tourism, embedding settler-colonialism into routines of leisure and consumption. The hills and forests of the CHT, marketed for their ‘unique cultural diversity,’ filled up with hotels and luxury resorts for Bengali tourists, largely operated by the business arm of the Bangladesh Army. Adibashi cultures became reduced to tokenised symbols and romanticised representations, while the steady influx of Bengali tourists helped to naturalise both military presence and demographic domination. Further, the persistent failure of the 1997 Accord to deliver tangible benefits, such as land restitution and genuine demilitarisation, critically delegitimised the moderate indigenous political leadership, causing the PCJSS to splinter and leading to several <a href="https://www.eurasiareview.com/21122021-bangladesh-factional-killings-in-chittagong-hill-tracts-analysis/">violent clashes</a> between rival political factions within the regional autonomy movement in the Hill Tracts. </p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fe8a2ffb-3bc9-4430-9e6a-94c4e3d03f48/kolpona+chakma.JPG" data-image-dimensions="1920x1280" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fe8a2ffb-3bc9-4430-9e6a-94c4e3d03f48/kolpona+chakma.JPG?format=1000w" width="1920" height="1280" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fe8a2ffb-3bc9-4430-9e6a-94c4e3d03f48/kolpona+chakma.JPG?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fe8a2ffb-3bc9-4430-9e6a-94c4e3d03f48/kolpona+chakma.JPG?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fe8a2ffb-3bc9-4430-9e6a-94c4e3d03f48/kolpona+chakma.JPG?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fe8a2ffb-3bc9-4430-9e6a-94c4e3d03f48/kolpona+chakma.JPG?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fe8a2ffb-3bc9-4430-9e6a-94c4e3d03f48/kolpona+chakma.JPG?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fe8a2ffb-3bc9-4430-9e6a-94c4e3d03f48/kolpona+chakma.JPG?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fe8a2ffb-3bc9-4430-9e6a-94c4e3d03f48/kolpona+chakma.JPG?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>Graffiti depicting Kalpana Chakma near Dhaka University, January 2025. Image: author</em></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">From “Post-Conflict” Bangladesh to the Fall of Hasina</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Within this context of ongoing settler-colonialism, political disillusionment and institutional paralysis, a second phase of insurgency began to coalesce, culminating in renewed armed activity in October 2022 led by the Kuki-Chin National Front (KNF). The KNF, which emerged in 2017, is a separatist group that seeks an autonomous region spanning parts of Bandarban and Rangamati for Kuki-Chin peoples, an umbrella term encompassing several smaller Adibashi communities, including the Bawms, an indigenous Christian community in the CHT. Rejecting the authority of the CHT Regional Council and District Councils, the KNF has instead called for the creation of an independent Kuki-Chin Territorial Council (KTC), with control over land administration, tourism, and a separate police force.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">The state’s response to the KNF followed a familiar pattern, and between <a href="https://iwgia.org/en/bangladesh/5554-caught-crossifre-bawm-complex-ties-between-bangladesh-military-kuki-chin-national-front.html?ref=netra.news#_edn14">October 2022 and October 2024</a>, more than 4,000 Bawms were displaced from their ancestral lands amid sweeping security operations carried out in the name of counterinsurgency. Framed as raids against the KNF, these operations disproportionately targeted civilian Bawm populations who were turned from civilians to suspected militants. The Hill Tracts continued to be governed through the logic of occupation, treated not as part of the nation, but as a frontier to be militarised and settled. </p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">As Kalpana Chakma had warned decades earlier, this mode of governance did not remain confined to the Hills, and the techniques honed in the CHT—of surveillance, arbitrary detention, and extrajudicial violence—increasingly travelled to the plainlands.&nbsp; Under Sheikh Hasina’s government, enforced disappearances became a routine instrument of political control, with human rights groups estimating that at least <a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/1/5/thousands-of-forced-disappearances-under-hasina-rule-in-bangladesh-inquiry">1,500 people</a> were disappeared during her rule. <a href="https://www.humanrightsresearch.org/post/a-damaged-democracy-sheikh-hasina-s-authoritarian-rule-in-bangladesh#:~:text=Bangladeshis'%20freedom%20of%20press%20and,(Amnesty%20International%2C%202021).">Journalists</a> were harassed, surveilled, detained, and physically assaulted. Dissent was criminalized through sweeping digital security laws, critics were jailed without charge or coerced into silence, and the increasing militarization and politicization of the police entrenched a pervasive culture of impunity.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">By the summer of 2024, these accumulated abuses reached a breaking point. Public university students in Dhaka took to the streets to protest the regime’s manipulation of a government job quota system to reward political loyalists. What began as a student movement quickly spiralled into a mass uprising, culminating in the collapse of the Awami League government after fifteen years of increasingly autocratic rule. In the months that followed,&nbsp; Dhaka’s walls began to be filled with murals calling for pluralism and interfaith solidarity as the nation envisioned a new Bangladesh, rooted in ideas of inclusivity and belonging. For Adibashi communities, this graffiti portrayed an apparent&nbsp;crack in the walls of exclusion, hinting at the possibility of belonging to a country that had long denied them space in its imagination.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Michael’s reappearance symbolised the immediate arrival of political hope and the sudden eruption of post-revolutionary optimism following the fall of a regime that many thought would never end.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">The experience of this sudden political transformation is epitomised by the story of Michael Chakma, a prominent Adibashi activist forcibly disappeared by the state in April 2019. After years of campaigning against military settlement and land seizures in the CHT, Michael had vanished into Bangladesh’s notorious military intelligence prison, <em>Aynaghar</em>, or the “House of Mirrors.” Presumed dead, Michael <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/article/2024/aug/15/bangladesh-sheikh-hasina-michael-chakma-disappeared">reappeared</a> on 5 August 2024, just hours after Sheikh Hasina fled the country. “I returned to a Bangladesh full of hope,” Michael told me over the phone. “A new Bangladesh, a new independence, an environment full of hopes and dreams.” Michael’s reappearance symbolised the immediate arrival of political hope and the sudden eruption of post-revolutionary optimism following the fall of a regime that many thought would never end.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">This optimism initially seemed to indicate a shift towards pluralism. An image incorporated into a national textbook pictured a new “Bangladesh 2.0,” made up of Muslims, Hindus, Christians, Buddhists, and Adibashis, and for the first time, Adibashi communities were formally invited to participate in Bengali New Year’s celebrations. Conversations about settler-colonialism began to enter mainstream conversations and indigenous communities, including the Bawm people, were brought into public rallies and national platforms.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Many of the Adibashi activists who played important roles in Hasina’s ouster decided to enter into the fold of representational politics. Alik Mree, a young leader from the Garo community, joined the National Citizen’s Party (NCP), a student-led political party formed in the aftermath of the uprising, becoming its only indigenous representative. Others participated in counterintuitive ways, with Sarba Mitra Chakma winning a seat in the Dhaka University Student Union elections as a candidate from the alliance led by <em>Chaatra Shibir</em>-led student alliance, the student wing of the <em>Jamaat-e-Islami</em>. Amidst criticisms that Shibir’s Islamist ideology was at odds with his identity, Sarba Mitra maintained that participation offered an important institutional platform from which indigenous concerns could still be articulated.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Yet this move towards inclusion unravelled almost as soon as it appeared. Rather than broadening notions of belonging, mob pressure narrowed it down further. Bengali nationalism reasserted itself with renewed ferocity, now fused with the demand for a singular Muslim Bengali identity. At the same time, <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cjdjj44xxr5o">resentment toward India</a>, shaped by the Awami League’s perceived proximity to New Delhi, as well as long-standing grievances over border killings, trade imbalances, and water-sharing disputes, fed a widening rhetoric of wounded sovereignty that cast Adibashi political claims as security concerns, and Adibashi activists as potential proxies for Indian influence. Following protests by a student group, who argued the word “Adibashi” threatened national unity, it was removed from the aforementioned textbook. When Adibashi groups in Dhaka protested this removal, they were brutally attacked by right-wing nationalist groups, and several young activists were left injured.“The dream of a new Bangladesh is still a dream,” Michael Chakma reflected. </p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0517bbd1-d2a4-40f2-aa7c-19fbbc4360d2/michaelchakma.png" data-image-dimensions="1090x728" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0517bbd1-d2a4-40f2-aa7c-19fbbc4360d2/michaelchakma.png?format=1000w" width="1090" height="728" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0517bbd1-d2a4-40f2-aa7c-19fbbc4360d2/michaelchakma.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0517bbd1-d2a4-40f2-aa7c-19fbbc4360d2/michaelchakma.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0517bbd1-d2a4-40f2-aa7c-19fbbc4360d2/michaelchakma.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0517bbd1-d2a4-40f2-aa7c-19fbbc4360d2/michaelchakma.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0517bbd1-d2a4-40f2-aa7c-19fbbc4360d2/michaelchakma.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0517bbd1-d2a4-40f2-aa7c-19fbbc4360d2/michaelchakma.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/0517bbd1-d2a4-40f2-aa7c-19fbbc4360d2/michaelchakma.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>“Where is Michael Chakma.” Graffiti from 2022, two years before Michael’s re-appearance following Hasina’s overthrow. Source: </em><a href="https://www.instagram.com/radical.graffiti.bangladesh?utm_source=ig_web_button_share_sheet&amp;igsh=MWZoMWJ6dTJhZ2NlbQ=="><em>Radical Graffiti Bangladesh </em></a></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">A Fading Optimism</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">For many Adibashi activists who had participated in the July Uprising, this backlash crystallised a growing sense of disillusionment. I spoke with Paddmini Chakma, an activist and photographer advocating for demilitarisation in the Hill Tracts, who recalls initially feeling hopeful that “long-suppressed voices were finally beginning to emerge.” However, that hope faded quickly as she came to assess the interim government’s approach to Adibashi rights as largely unchanged and exclusionary. “More broadly, the interim government has continued a pattern of symbolic inclusion without substantive representation,” she continued. One of the earliest indications of this was the appointment of an advisor for the CHT without any meaningful consultation with indigenous peoples or representatives from the region. Paddmini argued the selective visibility of indigenous groups reflected continuity with past governments, as indigenous presence is acknowledged symbolically while structural injustices persist.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Indeed, while state-sponsored celebrations of Bengali New Year showcased Adibashi communities as emblems of cultural diversity, the state’s old reflexes of repression, far from fading, remain deeply entrenched. In post-Hasina Bangladesh, military operations against the Bawm community, carried out in the name of raids against the Kuki-Chin National Front, continued unabated. A <a href="https://netra.news/2025/bawms-are-bangladeshi-citizens-treat-them-as-such/">Netra News investigation</a> found that since April 7th 2024, at least 22 civilians have been killed by the military, and nearly 200 Bawm civilians have been caught up in the campaign of state repression as cases filed under Hasina’s government continued seamlessly under the Interim Government. As Paddmini notes, Adibashi peoples were reduced to “cultural showcases rather than political subjects with rights and agency,” even as arbitrary detention, sexual violence, and prolonged imprisonment without trial persisted in the Hill Tracts.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">I also spoke with Adit Dewan, a filmmaker and curator who has worked against the censorship of Adibashi communities. Reflecting on the outbreak of mob violence and vigilante justice in the post-uprising period, Adit describes the moment as one of rapid political reversal. “For a moment, I thought Bangladesh would move toward law and justice,” he said, “but this hope disappeared as bad governance and mob violence took lead.”&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Adit highlights how mob violence quickly took a communal turn, as Adibashi groups were branded as “anti-state” by nationalist and pro-settler groups. In September 2024, only a month after Hasina’s ouster, 19 year old <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/crime-justice/news/he-was-our-hope-now-theres-only-silence-3989836">Anik Chakma</a> was beaten to death in Rangamati, ironically while attending a protest against communal violence. A year later, in September 2025, <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/news/protest-over-rape-3-shot-dead-khagrachhari-3996791">Khagrachari</a>, one of the three districts of the Hill Tracts, exploded in protests, strikes and roadblocks following the alleged gangrape of an Adibashi schoolgirl by a Bengali settler. Reactions to the outbreak of protests once again revealed the disproportionate and brutal nature of both state and settler responses. The state deployed several platoons of the Border Guard Bangladesh, and imposed Section 144, restricting public gatherings.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f4833ed5-9e55-4f29-be57-a30565b9644f/pohela+boishakh.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1440x960" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f4833ed5-9e55-4f29-be57-a30565b9644f/pohela+boishakh.jpg?format=1000w" width="1440" height="960" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f4833ed5-9e55-4f29-be57-a30565b9644f/pohela+boishakh.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f4833ed5-9e55-4f29-be57-a30565b9644f/pohela+boishakh.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f4833ed5-9e55-4f29-be57-a30565b9644f/pohela+boishakh.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f4833ed5-9e55-4f29-be57-a30565b9644f/pohela+boishakh.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f4833ed5-9e55-4f29-be57-a30565b9644f/pohela+boishakh.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f4833ed5-9e55-4f29-be57-a30565b9644f/pohela+boishakh.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/f4833ed5-9e55-4f29-be57-a30565b9644f/pohela+boishakh.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small">Adibashi<em> activists call for constitutional recognition and an end to exploitation at Bengali New Year’s celebrations, January 2025. Image: Sayrat Salekin.&nbsp;<br></em></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Meanwhile, Bengali settlers launched retaliatory attacks and killed two Adibashi men guarding a temple. Soldiers opened fire on protesters in Guimara, killing at least three people and injuring more than forty. Several homes and shops were also torched. The Home Advisor, Lt Gen Jahangir Alam Chowdhury, <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/asia/india/news/khagrachhari-violence-india-dismisses-allegation-involvement-4000896">alleged</a> that the violence in Khagrachari was being fuelled by a “vested quarter,” provoked by India or “fascist” groups. Such deflections only underline the government’s refusal to confront the anger born of militarisation, dispossession, and impunity in the Hill Tracts. Alik Mree resigned from the NCP in protest against the party’s silence over Khagrachari.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Ballot Box Politics</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Nearly a year and a half after Sheikh Hasina’s fall, on February 12 2026, Bangladesh headed to the polls in its first genuinely competitive elections in seventeen years. Yet this long-awaited return to electoral politics unfolded amid a right-wing resurgence, as the centre-right BNP, in the absence of the Awami League, dominated the elections, competing against a coalition led by the Jamaat-e-Islami, a right-wing Islamist party. In a surprising move, the NCP joined this Islamist-led coalition, at the cost of 13 of its central leaders, including some of its most well-known women members who were unable to reconcile this partnership with their professed progressive commitments. With a rise in conservative, misogynist and anti-minority rhetoric, excitement about elections was accompanied by a growing anxiety that many social freedoms and protections could now be rolled back. The BNP, led by Tarique Rahman, heir to one of Bangladesh’s two main political dynasties, won a two-thirds majority, while Jamaat achieved its best performance in the country’s history, emerging as the main opposition party.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Adibashi activists approached the elections with particular caution. Both Adit Dewan and Paddmini Chakma expressed deep scepticism about what electoral change will mean for the Chittagong Hill Tracts. “I am not very hopeful,” Adit said. “Political parties are not talking about implementing the CHT Peace Accord. Instead, they want to ‘reassess’ it, which risks pushing Adibashi peoples out of the governance structure altogether. The parties also said nothing about constitutional recognition for indigenous communities.”</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/538f1a3a-c12e-40c5-a99e-be0c269f9af5/khagrachari.png" data-image-dimensions="1486x838" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/538f1a3a-c12e-40c5-a99e-be0c269f9af5/khagrachari.png?format=1000w" width="1486" height="838" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/538f1a3a-c12e-40c5-a99e-be0c269f9af5/khagrachari.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/538f1a3a-c12e-40c5-a99e-be0c269f9af5/khagrachari.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/538f1a3a-c12e-40c5-a99e-be0c269f9af5/khagrachari.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/538f1a3a-c12e-40c5-a99e-be0c269f9af5/khagrachari.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/538f1a3a-c12e-40c5-a99e-be0c269f9af5/khagrachari.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/538f1a3a-c12e-40c5-a99e-be0c269f9af5/khagrachari.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/538f1a3a-c12e-40c5-a99e-be0c269f9af5/khagrachari.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="sqsrte-small"><em>Protestors block a road in Khagrachari, September 2025. Source: </em><a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/news/protest-over-rape-3-shot-dead-khagrachhari-3996791"><u><em>The Daily Star</em></u></a></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""><br>These concerns were compounded by the constitutional referendum scheduled alongside the parliamentary election. The referendum centred on the implementation of the ‘July Charter,’ drafted after the 2024 uprising, signed by most of the political parties active at the time, and framed as a blueprint for democratic reform and the prevention of future authoritarianism. Critics, however, <a href="https://www.tbsnews.net/thoughts/letting-people-decide-why-interim-government-must-step-back-referendum-campaigning-1345566"><u>warned</u></a> that the referendum collapsed multiple, complex reforms into a single yes-or-no vote, denying citizens the opportunity to assess each of the 47 constitutional reform proposals on their own merit. The interim government further narrowed space for debate by presenting a “yes” vote as the only legitimate option, implying that dissent amounts to a rejection of reform itself, and worse, an endorsement or alignment with the fallen “fascist” forces.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>This feels less like justice and more like a strategic move to preserve existing structures of exclusion. It seems to partially recognise Indigenous demands while stripping away their political and social identity.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  <figcaption class="source">&mdash; Paddmini Chakma</figcaption>
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">For Paddmini, the referendum encapsulated a deeper problem. “The 2026 constitutional referendum feels confusing and deliberately vague,” she explained. “It talks about linguistic diversity, but it avoids explicitly recognising Indigenous peoples as Indigenous. Indigenous languages may be mentioned, but political subjectivity, land rights, and historical struggles are completely ignored.” The result, she argued, is not meaningful inclusion but a familiar pattern of containment.“This feels less like justice and more like a strategic move to preserve existing structures of exclusion. It seems to partially recognise Indigenous demands while stripping away their political and social identity.” Because of this, I have very little hope that the upcoming elections will bring real change for Indigenous peoples,” Paddmini told me in the week running up to the vote.&nbsp;</p><p class="">Ultimately, the July National Charter was approved by 60.26 percent of voters. Yet its endorsement did not translate into immediate constitutional transformation as the newly elected BNP MPs, joined by several independents, refused to take the <a href="https://www.tbsnews.net/bangladesh-election-2026/bnp-abstained-no-provision-administering-oath-constitutional-reform-council"><span>second oath</span></a> stipulated in the President’s Order that would have initiated the charter’s implementation, citing its lack of constitutional legitimacy. With more than two-thirds of MPs declining to take the oath, the implementation process has been paused, and it is unclear what will happen next.&nbsp;</p><p class="">The persistence of violence and exclusion in the CHT reveals the limits of political change in post-July Bangladesh. Regimes may fall, elections may return, and the language of reform may shift, but the deeper architecture of the state remains largely intact. The brief opening created by the July Uprising offered a glimpse of an alternative political imagination, but the rapid contraction of that space, marked by mob violence and right-wing resurgence, shows how fragile that imagination remains. Adibashi visibility has once again been tolerated only insofar as it does not challenge land, power, or sovereignty.</p><p class="">As Bangladesh emerges from a defining electoral moment, the CHT remains a litmus test for the country’s democratic claims. The struggle of Jumma people in the CHT for participation and inclusion is not a peripheral grievance but a mirror held up to the nation itself, reflecting the costs of a nationalism that continues to promote unity through erasure. To stand in solidarity with Adibashi voices is to challenge the homogenising narratives of language, culture, and identity that have defined the Bangladeshi nationalist project for over half a century, and to imagine a different kind of nation: one not built on erasure, but on recognition. </p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p class=""><strong><em>Laleh Bergman Hossain</em></strong><em> is a Bangladeshi-British writer and researcher interested in identity, politics and visual cultures across South Asia and the Middle East.&nbsp;</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1773585141945-UGOKWWBM3UK18FB8OXLX/signal-2026-03-14-20-46-12-531.jpg?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1229" height="1600"><media:title type="plain">The Politics of Indigeneity in Post-Hasina Bangladesh&nbsp;</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>The Limits of the Settler Colonial Analogy in South Asia</title><category>Kashmir</category><category>India</category><category>Essay</category><dc:creator>Anubhav Singh</dc:creator><pubDate>Sun, 08 Mar 2026 16:23:24 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/the-limits-of-the-settler-colonial-analogy-in-south-asia</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:69a9bc0d37c55c7e874c58a2</guid><description><![CDATA[Is India’s role in Kashmir “settler colonial” or part of a shared legacy of 
internal colonialism across South Asia?]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p class=""><em>Is India’s role in Kashmir “settler colonial” or part of a shared legacy of internal colonialism across South Asia?</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7b2c54a0-5672-4c75-9ab5-9cc72cef8cd6/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity.png" data-image-dimensions="2560x1440" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7b2c54a0-5672-4c75-9ab5-9cc72cef8cd6/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity.png?format=1000w" width="2560" height="1440" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7b2c54a0-5672-4c75-9ab5-9cc72cef8cd6/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7b2c54a0-5672-4c75-9ab5-9cc72cef8cd6/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7b2c54a0-5672-4c75-9ab5-9cc72cef8cd6/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7b2c54a0-5672-4c75-9ab5-9cc72cef8cd6/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7b2c54a0-5672-4c75-9ab5-9cc72cef8cd6/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7b2c54a0-5672-4c75-9ab5-9cc72cef8cd6/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7b2c54a0-5672-4c75-9ab5-9cc72cef8cd6/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available images</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available images</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p class="">India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Israel in February 2026 marks a decisive rupture in India’s foreign policy. India, once one of Palestine’s most vocal supporters, has turned its back on them. The symbolism was unmistakable: New Delhi was no longer trying to balance its support for Palestinian statehood with strategic engagement with Israel. It had chosen a side.&nbsp;</p><p class="">In recent years, commentators have asked: is India now South Asia’s “Israel”? Or is Kashmir India’s Palestine? Kashmir remains one of the most militarized regions in the world: marked by grave human rights violations and the erosion of democratic autonomy. However, it is worth asking if the popular invocation of the India-Israel and Kashmir-Palestine equivalence offers more to our progressive analysis than it takes away.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""></p><h4>If India=Israel, Pakistan=?<strong>&nbsp;</strong></h4><p class="">On April 22, 2025, a brutal attack on Indian tourists in Kashmir left 26 dead, with responsibility claimed by The Resistance Front—an organization India alleges is a front for the Lashkar-e-Taiba. In response, the Indian government launched Operation Sindoor, targeting what it described as terror infrastructure in Murdike and Bahawalpur, deep within Pakistani territory. Pakistan retaliated, and the skirmishes ended only in mid-May.&nbsp;</p><p class="">In the days that followed, several commentators, echoing a now-familiar refrain, likened India’s actions to those of Israel in Gaza or the West Bank. India, they argued, was fast becoming a Zionist state in South Asia—an occupying force seeking regional hegemony through violence, demographic change, and militarized control.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>The India–Israel analogy, particularly in relation to Kashmir, is deeply flawed—not because India is innocent, but because its form of domination structurally differs from that of a settler colonial state. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">However, India is not a settler-colonial state by origin, nor is Pakistan a stateless, disenfranchised entity like Palestine. Pakistan is a sovereign state with one of the world’s largest standing armies, a robust intelligence infrastructure, and nuclear weapons. It has initiated wars with India, harbored non-state actors, and shaped insurgencies across the region. The comparison collapses especially when one considers the deterrent structure of nuclear parity. India and Pakistan are not in an occupation-resistance dynamic, but in a mutual deterrence relationship shaped by doctrines of escalation control and war avoidance.&nbsp;</p><p class="">The logic of India's limited strikes, although disproportionate —be it Balakot in 2019 or Operation Sindoor in 2025—is to signal capability without triggering a full-scale war and driven by posturing for consumption of a domestic audience for electoral gains, not permanent occupation of sovereign territory.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/07f67b0c-5694-4535-8a66-343feea79b19/532365-sindoor-1.webp" data-image-dimensions="1500x859" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/07f67b0c-5694-4535-8a66-343feea79b19/532365-sindoor-1.webp?format=1000w" width="1500" height="859" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/07f67b0c-5694-4535-8a66-343feea79b19/532365-sindoor-1.webp?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/07f67b0c-5694-4535-8a66-343feea79b19/532365-sindoor-1.webp?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/07f67b0c-5694-4535-8a66-343feea79b19/532365-sindoor-1.webp?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/07f67b0c-5694-4535-8a66-343feea79b19/532365-sindoor-1.webp?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/07f67b0c-5694-4535-8a66-343feea79b19/532365-sindoor-1.webp?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/07f67b0c-5694-4535-8a66-343feea79b19/532365-sindoor-1.webp?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/07f67b0c-5694-4535-8a66-343feea79b19/532365-sindoor-1.webp?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Government supporters celebrate in Uttar Pradesh, India, marking ‘Operation Sindoor’ on Wednesday, May 7, 2025. Image: Press Trust of India (PTI).</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Government supporters celebrate in Uttar Pradesh, India, marking ‘Operation Sindoor’ on Wednesday, May 7, 2025. Image: Press Trust of India (PTI).</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p class="">Framing India as Israel and Pakistan as Palestine ignores the complex regional balance of South Asia, and instead replaces it with an incorrect moral binary. It positions Pakistan as a victim while absolving its colonial violence in Balochistan and Gilgit-Baltistan. It also erases the agency and suffering of Kashmiris, who are neither extensions of Pakistan nor India, but people with their own political aspirations—repeatedly silenced by both India and Pakistan.&nbsp;</p><p class="">The India-Israel analogy is now commonly invoked in international activist and academic spaces in relation to India’s occupation of Kashmir. Works like Azad Essa’s <em>Hostile Homelands</em> draw on powerful imagery: Kashmir as India’s Palestine, a besieged land stripped of autonomy, flooded with soldiers, and reengineered demographically. While emotionally evocative, this comparison obscures more than it reveals. It collapses two vastly different political histories, legal frameworks, and strategic realities into a moral shorthand that fails both as analysis and critique.&nbsp;</p><p class="">The India–Israel analogy, particularly in relation to Kashmir, is deeply flawed—not because India is innocent, but because its form of domination structurally differs from that of a settler colonial state. Instead, India's repression of Kashmir must be seen in the context of postcolonial centralization, internal colonialism, and an authoritarian shift that extends across other marginalized regions such as the Northeast and Adivasi heartlands. To truly understand and challenge the violence in Kashmir, we must step beyond simplistic analogies and confront the specificity of India’s own colonial legacies and its present trajectory.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""></p><h4>Foundational Disanalogy: Settler Colonialism vs Postcolonial Nationhood</h4><p class="">To liken India to Israel is to misunderstand the historical genesis of the Indian state. Israel was founded as a settler-colonial project—a homeland for Jews established through the displacement of Palestinians, justified through the logic of return and maintained through systems of apartheid and occupation. Its very foundation rests on what Patrick Wolfe termed the “logic of elimination:” the removal or erasure of the indigenous population to make way for a settler nation.</p><p class="">India’s state formation was the result of anti-colonial struggle, not settler conquest or displacement of populations. The Indian state was a successor to the British colonial state. The princely state of Jammu and Kashmir, like Hyderabad and Junagadh, acceded to India through a contested and coercive process—not dissimilar to Pakistan’s annexation of Balochistan in 1948. These were integrationist moves, not settler-colonial ventures. They reflected the logic of coercive nation-state consolidation, not demographic engineering.</p><p class="">Even the demand for “Akhand Bharat,” often cited as India’s Zionist parallel, lacks a settler-colonial infrastructure. Unlike Zionism’s materialization in Israeli settlements, Hindutva remains largely ideological and majoritarian, not territorial in the same settler sense—at least until recent policies bordering on demographic transformation.</p><p class="">India’s postcolonial nationalism has been violent and coercive toward its peripheries. However, coercion in the service of integration is not the same as colonization in the service of population replacement. India’s violence in Kashmir must be understood through its own authoritarian and centralizing tendencies—not through borrowed frameworks that obscure more than they illuminate.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259903-MEEHNO9GCRFCH6C6DNYF/accession.jpg" data-image-dimensions="744x461" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259903-MEEHNO9GCRFCH6C6DNYF/accession.jpg?format=1000w" width="744" height="461" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259903-MEEHNO9GCRFCH6C6DNYF/accession.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259903-MEEHNO9GCRFCH6C6DNYF/accession.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259903-MEEHNO9GCRFCH6C6DNYF/accession.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259903-MEEHNO9GCRFCH6C6DNYF/accession.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259903-MEEHNO9GCRFCH6C6DNYF/accession.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259903-MEEHNO9GCRFCH6C6DNYF/accession.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259903-MEEHNO9GCRFCH6C6DNYF/accession.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Amid rebellions in Poonch and fearing Pakistani-backed tribal militias, Maharaja Hari Singh acceded Kashmir to India on October 27, 1947, in return for military assistance, with a plebiscite promised once order was restored. Image: The Daily Star.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Amid rebellions in Poonch and fearing Pakistani-backed tribal militias, Maharaja Hari Singh acceded Kashmir to India on October 27, 1947, in return for military assistance, with a plebiscite promised once order was restored. Image: The Daily Star.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <h4>How Kashmir Differs from Palestine: The Autonomy Framework Pre-2019—Article 370 &amp; 35A</h4><p class="">Unlike occupied Palestinian territories being governed by Israeli military law, Kashmir—at least until 2019—was formally part of the Indian Union, with constitutional protections, civil courts, and state institutions (however compromised). India did not have unilateral, unchallenged domination vis à vis Kashmir. Instead, India’s sovereignty over Kashmir has been contested by Pakistan consistently, to the detriment of the aspirations of the heavily repressed population caught in between.&nbsp;</p><p class="">Before the revocation of Articles 370 and 35A in August 2019, Jammu and Kashmir occupied a unique constitutional position within the Indian Union.&nbsp;The region enjoyed a special status in&nbsp;India that granted it its own Constitution, a separate flag, and significant autonomy in all matters except foreign affairs, defense, and communications. Article 35A, since 1954, allowed the Kashmiri state to define “permanent residents” and provide them exclusive rights in land ownership, state employment, and welfare.</p><p class="">These provisions functioned, albeit imperfectly, as constitutional safeguards against demographic transformation and cultural assimilation. Far from embodying a settler-colonial logic, Article 35A explicitly protected Kashmir from the influx of non-locals, preventing the kind of demographic reshaping characteristic of settler colonialism.</p><p class="">In contrast, no such legal framework of autonomy exists in the occupied Palestinian territories. Palestinians live under Israeli military law, without citizenship, and with no right to determine the legal conditions of land ownership or political representation. The Indian Constitution, even in its distorted execution, granted Kashmiris a set of legal rights that Palestinians have never possessed under Israeli occupation.</p><p class="">The repeal of Article 370 and 35A in August 2019 marks a dramatic rupture—but until that moment, Kashmir’s relationship with India was at least legally federal, rooted in a constitutional compact. To compare this to Israel’s governance of Gaza or the West Bank is to flatten history and law into metaphor, losing sight of the actual political architecture that existed for seven decades.<br><br></p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259933-P6YKTNIUCG46WMPJ0C8P/im-97694.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="1000x667" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259933-P6YKTNIUCG46WMPJ0C8P/im-97694.jpeg?format=1000w" width="1000" height="667" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259933-P6YKTNIUCG46WMPJ0C8P/im-97694.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259933-P6YKTNIUCG46WMPJ0C8P/im-97694.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259933-P6YKTNIUCG46WMPJ0C8P/im-97694.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259933-P6YKTNIUCG46WMPJ0C8P/im-97694.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259933-P6YKTNIUCG46WMPJ0C8P/im-97694.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259933-P6YKTNIUCG46WMPJ0C8P/im-97694.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1613354259933-P6YKTNIUCG46WMPJ0C8P/im-97694.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Aug 11, 2019: Kashmiri women protest the revocation of Articles 370 and 35a by the Indian government. Image: </em><a target="_blank" href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/protesters-demonstrate-in-kashmir-despite-indian-clampdown-11565551606"><em>Danish Siddiqui via Wall Street Journal</em></a></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Aug 11, 2019: Kashmiri women protest the revocation of Articles 370 and 35a by the Indian government. Image: </em><a target="_blank" href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/protesters-demonstrate-in-kashmir-despite-indian-clampdown-11565551606"><em>Danish Siddiqui via Wall Street Journal</em></a></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <h4>Internal Colonialism: Kashmir, the Northeast and Adivasis</h4><p class="">While rejecting the India–Israel settler-colonial analogy, it is&nbsp;important not to sanitize the Indian state’s conduct in Kashmir. The story of Kashmir within India is one of progressive erosion of autonomy, political repression, and militarized governance. A similar trajectory&nbsp;is visible in other peripheral regions like the Northeast and Adivasi territories, which can be better understood through the lens of internal colonialism.</p><p class="">Since the 1990s, Kashmir has been one of the most heavily militarized zones in the world. The imposition of the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA) has granted Indian security forces near-total legal immunity, with widespread allegations of torture, rape, disappearances, and fake encounters. The Kunan Poshpora mass rape case (1991) and the Pathribal fake encounter killings (2000) remain haunting examples of impunity under military rule. Civil society organizations like the Jammu Kashmir Coalition of Civil Society have documented thousands of enforced disappearances and mass graves, with little to no legal redress.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>In Nagaland, Manipur, and Assam, dissent has been historically met with counterinsurgency, not dialogue. These are not anomalies—they are signs of a centralizing postcolonial state managing its “frontiers” through coercion, much like its colonial predecessor.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">This pattern is not confined to Kashmir. In the Northeast, similar arrangements under Article 371 allowed for conditional accession, yet were also accompanied by AFSPA and political marginalization. In Nagaland, Manipur, and Assam, dissent has been historically met with counterinsurgency, not dialogue. These are not anomalies—they are signs of a centralizing postcolonial state managing its “frontiers” through coercion, much like its colonial predecessor.</p><p class="">Unlike Israel, India does not legally segregate populations through separate citizenship regimes. But it functionally produces second-class citizenship in regions it deems “sensitive” or “exceptional.” The framework here is not of elimination or ethnic cleansing, but of incorporation without equality—a project of national integration enforced at gunpoint.</p><p class="">In this light, Kashmir’s predicament is not an outlier but a symptom of a deeper crisis in Indian federalism and democracy. To compare it with Palestine is not only analytically imprecise—it risks obscuring the specific forms of repression that define India’s own political geography.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""></p><h4>The Post-2019 Shift: Demographic Engineering?</h4><p class="">The abrogation of Article 370 and Article 35A in August 2019 marked a paradigmatic shift in India’s approach to Kashmir. With the dismantling of constitutional safeguards, Kashmir was stripped of its statehood, bifurcated into two Union Territories, and placed under direct rule from New Delhi. The government claimed this would usher in development and integration; in reality, it marked the suspension of democratic rights and the reconfiguration of Kashmir’s legal and demographic fabric.</p><p class="">Since 2019, India has granted domicile status to over 85,000 non-resident individuals, including security personnel, bureaucrats, and migrant workers. This change, previously barred under Article 35A, has raised serious concerns about demographic engineering—the slow, bureaucratic transformation of the region’s Muslim-majority character without the need to create settlements or military colonization.</p><p class="">This move echoes settler-colonial strategies. While there are no formal state-sponsored settlements, the infrastructure is being laid for a structural alteration of Kashmir’s identity through legal manipulation, resource reallocation, and engineered migration. The state has moved from internal colonial control to a form of postcolonial demographic reordering, where the territory is rendered governable by diluting the political weight of its native population.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>To claim India has become Israel is to foreclose critical distinctions that help us understand this dangerous new trajectory—one that must be condemned in its own right, not merely because it resembles Zionist practice.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">Still, it is important to recognize that this shift is recent and emergent, not foundational. India was not built as a settler-colonial state, and Kashmir was not historically managed as one. What we are witnessing post-2019 is a convergence of methods, not of origins. To claim India <em>has become</em> Israel is to foreclose critical distinctions that help us understand this dangerous new trajectory—one that must be condemned in its own right, not merely because it resembles Zionist practice.</p><p class="">The recent push toward demographic change in Kashmir is not entirely without precedent. As early as 1947–48, during the Poonch massacre, thousands of Muslims were killed or displaced from Jammu, with the complicity of the Dogra regime, the RSS and Indian forces. This reengineered the demography of the Jammu region, transforming it into a Hindu-majority space more loyal to the Indian Union. While this violence predates the current era, it reveals that the logic of demographic disciplining—especially through force—has long existed within India’s nation-building project. What distinguishes the post-2019 moment is the transition from episodic violence to bureaucratized, legal mechanisms—from mass expulsion to state-sanctioned domicile laws and land access for outsiders. It denotes a critical rupture from a flawed, alienating democratic process to outright colonization.&nbsp;</p><p class="">Yet this demographic logic is not exclusive to India. In Gilgit-Baltistan, Pakistan abolished the State Subject Rule in the 1970s—akin to India’s removal of Article 35A—and has since facilitated the settlement of Sunni Punjabis and Pashtuns in a historically Shia-majority region. These policies have been accompanied by sectarian violence, including attacks by Lashkar-e-Jhangvi, a state-backed Sunni extremist group, on Shia civilians. Land reform bills now permit non-locals to own property, raising legitimate fears of a sectarian settler project aimed at diluting Shia political power. Pakistan thus mirrors the very settler-colonial logics it accuses India of employing—through military presence, demographic manipulation, and religious homogenization.</p><p class="">Both post-colonial states have deployed population engineering, resource control, and military dominance to redraw the ethnic and political landscape of their borderlands.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""></p><h4>“Pakistan’s Kashmir”: Balochistan’s Missing Analogy</h4><p class="">If Kashmir is to be framed as “India’s Palestine,” then Balochistan must surely be considered “Pakistan’s Kashmir.”</p><p class="">Balochistan was annexed by Pakistan in 1948, despite the Baloch Khanate’s brief declaration of independence and calls for a referendum. Since then, the province has seen multiple insurgencies, each met with military repression. Thousands of Baloch activists, students, and civilians have been forcibly disappeared, often found tortured or killed. Reports by the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan and international watchdogs point to mass graves, extra-judicial killings, and systemic silencing of dissent.</p><p class="">The strategies of control in Balochistan mirror those used by India in Kashmir: militarization, enforced disappearances, denial of autonomy, and resource extraction. Baloch nationalists, like Kashmiri separatists, have demanded self-determination; in both cases, the central state has responded with coercion rather than consent, practicing internal domination over their own peripheries.&nbsp;</p><p class="">To ignore Balochistan while invoking Kashmir is to moralize one state's violence while sanitizing another’s. If the goal is solidarity against oppression, it must be principled and consistent—not contingent on the geopolitical narratives of postcolonial nation-states.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1749305985768-QQ2WD75X0CELCOCGTOJG/sit-in%2Bfor%2BZareef.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1099x824" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1749305985768-QQ2WD75X0CELCOCGTOJG/sit-in%2Bfor%2BZareef.jpg?format=1000w" width="1099" height="824" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1749305985768-QQ2WD75X0CELCOCGTOJG/sit-in%2Bfor%2BZareef.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1749305985768-QQ2WD75X0CELCOCGTOJG/sit-in%2Bfor%2BZareef.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1749305985768-QQ2WD75X0CELCOCGTOJG/sit-in%2Bfor%2BZareef.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1749305985768-QQ2WD75X0CELCOCGTOJG/sit-in%2Bfor%2BZareef.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1749305985768-QQ2WD75X0CELCOCGTOJG/sit-in%2Bfor%2BZareef.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1749305985768-QQ2WD75X0CELCOCGTOJG/sit-in%2Bfor%2BZareef.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1749305985768-QQ2WD75X0CELCOCGTOJG/sit-in%2Bfor%2BZareef.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Sit-ins demanding justice for forcibly disappeared Baloch have become a recurring form of protest in Pakistan. Image: Hazaran Rahim Dad.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Sit-ins demanding justice for forcibly disappeared Baloch have become a recurring form of protest in Pakistan. Image: Hazaran Rahim Dad.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <h4>The Forgotten Front: Adivasis, Land, and the Logic of Elimination</h4><p class="">While Kashmir commands global attention and is increasingly framed through the Israel–Palestine lens, a more direct and longstanding instance of the logic of elimination exists within India itself—its relationship with Adivasi (indigenous tribal) communities. Spread across central and eastern India, these populations face systemic displacement, militarized violence, and cultural erasure at the hands of the Indian state. Yet, this reality is rarely framed in settler-colonial terms.</p><p class="">The displacement of Adivasis is not metaphorical—it is material, extractive, and violent. Across Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Odisha, and Madhya Pradesh, vast tracts of forest land have been seized for mining, dams, industrial corridors, and so-called development projects. The beneficiaries are not settlers but corporate entities like Adani, Vedanta, and POSCO, backed by state power. The victims are tribal communities who are evicted, incarcerated, or killed, often without compensation or rehabilitation.</p><p class="">When resistance emerges—especially through Maoist-aligned movements—it is met with brutal counterinsurgency campaigns, like Operation Green Hunt, involving fake encounters, mass arrests, and violations of international humanitarian norms. The Forest Rights Act, meant to safeguard tribal land, is routinely bypassed. Indigenous cultures are reduced to tourism, their sacred lands to resource frontiers.</p><p class="">This is, in many ways, a textbook case of internal settler logic—the displacement of indigenous peoples to make way for extractive capitalist expansion. And yet, it is not recognized as such, either within India or globally. Compared to Kashmir, there is little international solidarity movement for Adivasis, drawing analogy to apartheid followed by hashtags or global outcry. It is seen as India’s internal matter, despite being an instance of ongoing, violent dispossession.</p><p class="">This selective application of the settler-colonial lens reveals a troubling truth: the framework is often deployed not where the logic is most visible, but where it is most politically expedient. Kashmir is thus foregrounded, while Adivasi suffering is invisibilized—a blind spot that any serious decolonial critique must urgently confront.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""></p><h4>Colonial Continuities and the Settler-Native Binary: A Mamdanian Reconsideration</h4><p class="">What binds the cases of Kashmir, the Northeast, Balochistan, Adivasi lands, and Gilgit-Baltistan is not settler colonialism, but the postcolonial state’s continuation of colonial strategies. Both India and Pakistan inherited the legal, institutional, and ideological architecture of the British Raj—one built around centralization, militarized frontier governance, racialized surveillance, and the management of difference through law.</p><p class="">This is especially visible in the legal and administrative regimes these states deploy: AFSPA in Kashmir and the Northeast, the Frontier Crimes Regulation (FCR) in FATA, and the extensive use of emergency powers and military rule in Balochistan. These are not aberrations. They are mechanisms of a postcolonial state that never decolonized, but instead repurposed colonial technologies of control to govern internal “others.” The Indian and Pakistani states do not seek to eliminate their peripheries, but to discipline, incorporate, and extract from them—whether through resource grabs, land expropriation, or political marginalization.</p><p class="">This argument finds powerful theoretical support in Mahmood Mamdani’s <em>Neither Settler nor Native</em><strong>,</strong> where he critiques the settler-colonial framework not for its inaccuracy in specific cases, but for its analytical rigidity. For Mamdani, the core feature of modern state violence is not physical elimination alone, but the institutionalization of permanent political identities—settler and native—as legal constructs. These identities become the basis of governance, exclusion, and domination.</p><p class="">Mamdani urges us to shift focus from moral binaries toward how states manufacture majority-minority distinctions and reproduce political inequality through law and bureaucracy. In this sense, India’s repression in Kashmir, or Pakistan’s actions in Gilgit-Baltistan, are not about displacing people for settlers, but about governing through the logic of difference—where access to rights, land, and representation is contingent upon loyalty, religious identity, or ethnic subordination.</p><p class="">Applying Mamdani’s lens helps clarify why the India–Israel analogy misleads. India's violence in Kashmir is not the result of a Zionist import, but of a postcolonial state logic that mirrors colonial rule in form and substance. The challenge, then, is not simply to name India a settler-colonial state, but to confront how postcolonial sovereignty produces and governs “permanent minorities” within its own borders, often under the guise of national unity or security.</p><p class="">The task ahead is to transcend these state-produced identities, and imagine political communities where neither “settler” nor “native” are categories of governance. As Mamdani argues, liberation requires dismantling the political distinction itself, not reversing who holds power within it.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""></p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p class="">The analogy between India and Israel, though rhetorically compelling, ultimately falters under critical scrutiny. It obscures the specific historical trajectories and legal architectures that shape the Indian state, reducing Kashmir’s complex and painful realities to a borrowed script. India is not a settler-colonial state by origin, nor is Pakistan a stateless entity like Palestine. Rather, both India and Pakistan are postcolonial nation-states that have inherited—and internalized—the logic of their colonial predecessor.</p><p class="">Their respective strategies in Kashmir, Balochistan, Gilgit-Baltistan, the Northeast, and Adivasi territories reveal a shared repertoire of authoritarian governance: centralization, demographic engineering, military exceptionalism, and the denial of meaningful self-determination. These are not anomalies; they are systemic features of how postcolonial states have managed pluralism and dissent—not by decolonizing their institutions, but by repurposing colonial structures of control.</p><p class="">Rather than relying on externally derived frameworks like settler colonialism, which do not capture the historical and structural specificities of South Asia, we must examine postcolonial nation-states like India and Pakistan as ideological and institutional successors of the colonial state.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Both India and Pakistan have inherited and perpetuated the logic of the colonial state: centralization, militarized frontier governance, legal exceptionalism, and the management of difference through coercion<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">Both India and Pakistan have inherited and perpetuated the logic of the colonial state: centralization, militarized frontier governance, legal exceptionalism (e.g. AFSPA, FCR), and the management of difference through coercion. Their projects of nation-building have involved internal colonization of peripheries like Kashmir, Balochistan, the Northeast, and Adivasi regions—not to replace native populations, but to discipline, assimilate, extract from, or sideline them.</p><p class="">While some recent developments in India—such as domicile laws in Kashmir—increasingly resemble settler-colonial methods, the foundational character of the Indian state remains that of a centralized postcolonial successor to empire, not a settler regime. Similarly, Pakistan’s actions in Gilgit-Baltistan and Balochistan exhibit sectarian demographic engineering, but within a postcolonial frame rooted in majoritarian nationalism and territorial consolidation, not settler expansion.</p><p class="">To understand and challenge these forms of state violence, whether in Kashmir, or Gilgit, or Bastar, South Asia needs a framework that emerges from its own history—one that recognizes how postcolonial sovereignty often reproduces colonial modes of domination in the name of unity, development, or national security.</p><p class="">Only by confronting this shared legacy of violence can we begin to imagine alternative futures for the region—ones rooted not in analogy, but in accountability, history, and decolonial possibility.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p class=""><strong><em>Anubhav Singh</em></strong><em> is a scholar of South Asia and a graduate of The Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University. His work examines caste, nationalism, and the reconfiguration of sovereignty in contemporary India, with particular focus on Hindutva.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/7b2c54a0-5672-4c75-9ab5-9cc72cef8cd6/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">The Limits of the Settler Colonial Analogy in South Asia</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>After a Dictator, Bangladesh Turns Right</title><category>Bangladesh</category><category>Essay</category><dc:creator>Sarah Nafisa Shahid</dc:creator><pubDate>Tue, 24 Feb 2026 01:54:20 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/after-a-dictator-bangladesh-turns-right</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:699bb34cd34a80448cd20860</guid><description><![CDATA[Hardline Islamists gain ground in historic election following the 2024 July 
Uprising that ousted Sheikh Hasina.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""><em>Hardline Islamists gain ground in historic election following the 2024 July Uprising that ousted Sheikh Hasina.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ba92bf11-6c03-4e66-afcf-2758eac3cd27/signal-2026-02-22-11-28-40-662.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1600x900" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ba92bf11-6c03-4e66-afcf-2758eac3cd27/signal-2026-02-22-11-28-40-662.jpg?format=1000w" width="1600" height="900" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ba92bf11-6c03-4e66-afcf-2758eac3cd27/signal-2026-02-22-11-28-40-662.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ba92bf11-6c03-4e66-afcf-2758eac3cd27/signal-2026-02-22-11-28-40-662.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ba92bf11-6c03-4e66-afcf-2758eac3cd27/signal-2026-02-22-11-28-40-662.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ba92bf11-6c03-4e66-afcf-2758eac3cd27/signal-2026-02-22-11-28-40-662.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ba92bf11-6c03-4e66-afcf-2758eac3cd27/signal-2026-02-22-11-28-40-662.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ba92bf11-6c03-4e66-afcf-2758eac3cd27/signal-2026-02-22-11-28-40-662.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/ba92bf11-6c03-4e66-afcf-2758eac3cd27/signal-2026-02-22-11-28-40-662.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available images</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available images</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">On February 12, 2026, Bangladesh held its first general election since overthrowing the authoritarian rule of Sheikh Hasina and the Awami League (AL)—an election widely believed to be a true democratic election in 17 years. Around <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/national-election-2026/news/not-just-wave-4106511">44%</a> of the electorate were young (&lt;37 years old), first-time voters. The centre-right Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) and its leader, Tarique Rahman, returning from his AL-imposed exile, gained a majority of parliamentary seats to form the government. Its main opposition was the far-right <em>Jamaat-e-Islami</em> (JI) who built a 11-party alliance with smaller Islamist parties and the National Citizens’ Party (NCP), a party formed to reflect the aspirations of the youth-led mass uprising that overthrew the previous regime. The disposed AL were banned from participating in the elections, leaving a significant portion of the electorate without representation. The election results mark a clear turn in Bangladesh towards right-wing populism – but this is not shocking. A close reading of the post-uprising moment exposes that this paradigm shift has been brewing for a while, especially in the absence of a strong, progressive alternative.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">The Right-ward Turn in Post-uprising Bangladesh</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">The main contestant against the BNP was the far-right JI, an Islamist party marred by its role as collaborators of the Pakistani state during Bangladesh’s liberation struggle in 1971. JI’s 11-party coalition managed to win 77 out of 300 seats in the election, higher than they have ever achieved in Bangladesh’s history. Of course, one must account for the fact that AL, historically BNP’s primary political opponent, was banned from participating in the elections this time. Yet, winning almost <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/national-election-2026/news/not-just-wave-4106511">40% of the popular vote</a> in an election with around 60% voter turnout is a serious feat.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af23e0dc-8a28-4bed-897a-ac94dae89e94/bangladesh-elections-2026-1277-crore-people-to-vote-check-who-is-eligible-voting-process-timing.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1200x900" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af23e0dc-8a28-4bed-897a-ac94dae89e94/bangladesh-elections-2026-1277-crore-people-to-vote-check-who-is-eligible-voting-process-timing.jpg?format=1000w" width="1200" height="900" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af23e0dc-8a28-4bed-897a-ac94dae89e94/bangladesh-elections-2026-1277-crore-people-to-vote-check-who-is-eligible-voting-process-timing.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af23e0dc-8a28-4bed-897a-ac94dae89e94/bangladesh-elections-2026-1277-crore-people-to-vote-check-who-is-eligible-voting-process-timing.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af23e0dc-8a28-4bed-897a-ac94dae89e94/bangladesh-elections-2026-1277-crore-people-to-vote-check-who-is-eligible-voting-process-timing.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af23e0dc-8a28-4bed-897a-ac94dae89e94/bangladesh-elections-2026-1277-crore-people-to-vote-check-who-is-eligible-voting-process-timing.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af23e0dc-8a28-4bed-897a-ac94dae89e94/bangladesh-elections-2026-1277-crore-people-to-vote-check-who-is-eligible-voting-process-timing.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af23e0dc-8a28-4bed-897a-ac94dae89e94/bangladesh-elections-2026-1277-crore-people-to-vote-check-who-is-eligible-voting-process-timing.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/af23e0dc-8a28-4bed-897a-ac94dae89e94/bangladesh-elections-2026-1277-crore-people-to-vote-check-who-is-eligible-voting-process-timing.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Graffiti announcing Bangladesh’s 2026 elections. Source: The Sunday Guardian/X.</em> </p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Heading into the election, there was widespread speculation that JI would sweep a landslide victory. JI had been steadily <a href="https://counterpointbd.com/Why-Jamaat-Wins">building its organizational strength</a> at the grassroots level, embedding itself in the lives and struggles of working class people. They have developed cadres committed to the party’s ideology who are accountable to a centralized, vertical party structure—much like the traditional Leninist model. Party cadres are rooted in local communities and campuses, and often mobilize to provide mutual aid and support in absence of a welfare state. This has solidified loyalty and support for JI’s vision of a theocratic Bangladesh in previously untapped layers of Bangladeshi society.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">JI also bore the ire of Hasina’s regime; its key members were tried under a special war crimes tribunal in 2013 and given either life sentences or the death penalty. Numerous JI activists have been forcibly disappeared by the state security apparatus under Hasina, with few making it out alive once she was ousted. This systematic targeting generated sympathy towards JI, especially amongst groups that opposed state violence and supported human rights.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Earlier in 2025, JI’s student wing,<em> Chhatra Shibir</em>, won student union elections across university campuses including both Dhaka University and Jahangirnagar University, two of the most progressive public university campuses in the country and institutions that were central to the July Uprising. In December 2025, the assassination of a prominent political figure related to the uprising, Osman Hadi, revived the zeal and anger of the July Uprising which was promptly capitalized by the Islamist right-wing. Hadi had come up as a charismatic leader from the <em>madrassa</em> system and was actively shaping a post-uprising majoritarian politics of Bengali Muslim nationalism that was initially separate from JI. But the JI-led coalition was able to exercise pro-July, anti-India sentimentality when Hadi was given a state funeral with thousands of well wishers flocking to Dhaka for the event.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">Yet, none of this really translated to electoral gains for JI.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>JI’s significant gain in this election, however, is not merely about votes and seats, but about mainstreaming its politics in a country where the party was considered fringe, and at times even banned.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">JI’s significant gain in this election, however, is not merely about votes and seats, but about mainstreaming its politics in a country where the party was considered fringe, and at times even banned. Critically, JI’s win has shifted the overton window enough to the right to normalize and even popularize hardlines like Mamunul Haq, the leader of <em>Khelafat Majlis</em>, who gave a fierce challenge to BNP’s Bobby Hajjaj, a heavyweight candidate, in one of Dhaka’s prominent ridings. Haq infamously called for the dissolution of the Women’s Affair Reform Commission, formed under the Interim Government, and is well known for his misogynist and exclusionary comments, while positioning his own ideology as anti-imperialist and anti-establishment.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cca69030-e1a2-4e88-b19a-25ddd7bb87dd/1747544633-de18290af049e8e5cbf91c786640b11f.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1000x600" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cca69030-e1a2-4e88-b19a-25ddd7bb87dd/1747544633-de18290af049e8e5cbf91c786640b11f.jpg?format=1000w" width="1000" height="600" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cca69030-e1a2-4e88-b19a-25ddd7bb87dd/1747544633-de18290af049e8e5cbf91c786640b11f.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cca69030-e1a2-4e88-b19a-25ddd7bb87dd/1747544633-de18290af049e8e5cbf91c786640b11f.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cca69030-e1a2-4e88-b19a-25ddd7bb87dd/1747544633-de18290af049e8e5cbf91c786640b11f.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cca69030-e1a2-4e88-b19a-25ddd7bb87dd/1747544633-de18290af049e8e5cbf91c786640b11f.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cca69030-e1a2-4e88-b19a-25ddd7bb87dd/1747544633-de18290af049e8e5cbf91c786640b11f.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cca69030-e1a2-4e88-b19a-25ddd7bb87dd/1747544633-de18290af049e8e5cbf91c786640b11f.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/cca69030-e1a2-4e88-b19a-25ddd7bb87dd/1747544633-de18290af049e8e5cbf91c786640b11f.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Mamunul Haque, Islamic cleric and leader of Khelafat Majlis, speaks against Indian and US imperialism at a rally. Source: The Daily Sun</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Mamunul Haque, Islamic cleric and leader of Khelafat Majlis, speaks against Indian and US imperialism at a rally. Source: The Daily Sun</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">JI’s coalition with non-Islamist “centrist” parties such as the NCP, consisting of student leaders from the Uprising, and the Liberal Democratic Party led by former Liberation War veteran Oli Ahmad, provided the cover that was needed to legitimize hardline Islamist ideology in the electoral arena.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">The NCP claimed that their party ideology is “<a href="https://www.jamhoor.org/read/militant-centrism-in-post-revolution-bangladesh">militant centrism</a>” but several of their core leadership, including <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/news/shibir-played-role-allies-july-august-uprising-sarjis-3788651">Sarjis Alam</a> and <a href="https://www.newagebd.net/post/politics/270594/islamist-parties-urge-unity-to-start-islamist-rule">Akhter Hossen</a>, have leaned towards some kind of <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/politics/news/new-political-party-ex-shibir-leaders-nagorik-committee-stay-away-3834826">Islamist politics</a>. The tensions came to a boil on December 28, 2025, when several female leaders of the NCP defected from the party when it announced its coalition with JI, a party that repeatedly refused to nominate women for any of their seats. NCP campaign front runners such as <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/politics/news/tajnuva-jabeen-resigns-ncp-quits-election-race-4067746">Tasnim Jara</a> and <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/politics/news/tajnuva-jabeen-resigns-ncp-quits-election-race-4067746">Tajnuba Jabeen</a> publicly condemned the NCP-JI alliance and noted NCP’s own ideological contradictions inside the party. Despite all of this, NCP’s core leadership continued with the alliance and helped position JI as the pro-July, pro-reform, and anti-India choice.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/198a0633-7b72-463f-b52f-f61cd25abbdf/GettyImages-2260071772-1-1770712829.webp" data-image-dimensions="770x513" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/198a0633-7b72-463f-b52f-f61cd25abbdf/GettyImages-2260071772-1-1770712829.webp?format=1000w" width="770" height="513" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/198a0633-7b72-463f-b52f-f61cd25abbdf/GettyImages-2260071772-1-1770712829.webp?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/198a0633-7b72-463f-b52f-f61cd25abbdf/GettyImages-2260071772-1-1770712829.webp?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/198a0633-7b72-463f-b52f-f61cd25abbdf/GettyImages-2260071772-1-1770712829.webp?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/198a0633-7b72-463f-b52f-f61cd25abbdf/GettyImages-2260071772-1-1770712829.webp?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/198a0633-7b72-463f-b52f-f61cd25abbdf/GettyImages-2260071772-1-1770712829.webp?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/198a0633-7b72-463f-b52f-f61cd25abbdf/GettyImages-2260071772-1-1770712829.webp?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/198a0633-7b72-463f-b52f-f61cd25abbdf/GettyImages-2260071772-1-1770712829.webp?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>NCP leaders Nahid Islam and Asif Mahmud Bhuiyan share the stage with JI leader Shafiqur Rahman at an election rally in Dhaka. Source: Syed Mahamudur Rahman/Al Jazeera</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>NCP leaders Nahid Islam and Asif Mahmud Bhuiyan share the stage with JI leader Shafiqur Rahman at an election rally in Dhaka. Source: Syed Mahamudur Rahman/Al Jazeera</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p class="">Many viewed the interim government, led by Dr. Muhammad Yunus and other NGO and civil society figureheads, as sympathetic to the NCP, Islamists, and right-wing mobs. Former student coordinators Nahid Islam and Asif Mahmud Shojib Bhuiyan were both part of the interim government and then later joined the NCP. Hasnat Abdullah and Sarjis Alam regularly mobilized student groups to impose demands on the interim government and were met with minimal resistance. This was most evident when students and <em>touhidi janata</em> (Islamist mob) were given free reign to demolish Sheikh Mujibur Rahman’s house in Dhanmondi Road no. 32 that had been previously preserved as a museum.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>BNP’s win in this election came as a tactical victory, not a decisive one. Swaths of liberals, seculars, women, religious and ethnic minorities, and even Hefazat voters flocked to the polls to vote against the JI-led Islamic bloc<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">There was no protection given to religious and ethnic minorities, <em>bauls</em> (folk singers), <a href="https://en.prothomalo.com/entertainment/movies/t4lcfzlyzq">artists</a> and groups who came under attack numerous times in the aftermath of the uprising. Reports of local NCP activists engaging in <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/crime-justice/news/mob-storms-gulshan-house-claiming-it-belongs-ht-imams-son-3840171">extortion</a> and <a href="https://www.tbsnews.net/bangladesh/court/bogura-ncp-leader-mizanur-sent-jail-over-extortion-embezzlement-and-assault-1367771">bribery</a> became commonplace. And as frustration grew with the interim government, BNP distanced itself from the reform agenda and skewed ahead as the obvious anti-JI choice in this race.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">BNP, on the other hand, has always maintained its commitment to centre-right politics. The party believes in private enterprise and the free market and during prior rule, engaged in massive corruption that helped embed the party with the industrial ruling class. It is not merely a coincidence that a BNP-majority means that there are more <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/news/new-parliament-businesspeople-far-outnumber-politicians-4107141">business people</a> in parliament than politicians.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">As such, BNP’s win in this election came as a tactical victory, not a decisive one. Swaths of liberals, seculars, women, religious and ethnic minorities, and even Hefazat <a href="https://netra.news/2026/bnp-victory-bangladesh-election/">voters</a> flocked to the polls to vote against the JI-led Islamic bloc. Despite that, JI successfully increased its parliamentary representation, marking a significant shift in Bangladesh's political centre to the right and codifying the far-right Islamist bloc as the main opposition to BNP’s economic conservatism, in the absence of any left or liberal opposition.&nbsp;<br></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Caught in the Middle: India, U.S.A., China</h4><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">India has loomed over Bangladeshi politics often as an interventionist threat and other times as a bogeyman and JI had positioned itself as the only anti-India party. During the Uprising and in its aftermath, the slogan “<em>Delhi na Dhaka? Dhaka Dhaka</em> [Delhi or Dhaka? Dhaka Dhaka]” became popular amongst the youth and Islamists alike. Former coordinators of the student movement and currently members of parliament, Hasnat Abdullah and Nahid Islam, would often lead rallies with this chant.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">AL was also seen as closely linked with India, a legacy Hasina inherited from her father, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. The fact that Delhi gave refuge to Hasina when she fled the country only solidified that association.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">JI winning most of their <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/national-election-2026/news/not-just-wave-4106511">seats across districts</a> lining the West Bengal border only confirms this widespread antagonism against “Indian hegemony.” One can imagine that the local communities in Rangpur and Khulna are most likely to be impacted by India-Bangladesh projects such as Rampal Power Plant and the Teesta water-sharing agreement, as well as bear witness to the regular border killings at the hands of Indian Border Security Forces (BSF). The Modi goverment’s anti-Muslim rehtoric only aggravates majoritarian victimhood in Bangladesh’s majority Muslim proletariat.&nbsp;</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="false" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/843e4f49-fbf1-44e9-a086-ef25d0ca8629/HBJsewgXAAEug60.jfif" data-image-dimensions="1724x1966" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/843e4f49-fbf1-44e9-a086-ef25d0ca8629/HBJsewgXAAEug60.jfif?format=1000w" width="1724" height="1966" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/843e4f49-fbf1-44e9-a086-ef25d0ca8629/HBJsewgXAAEug60.jfif?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/843e4f49-fbf1-44e9-a086-ef25d0ca8629/HBJsewgXAAEug60.jfif?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/843e4f49-fbf1-44e9-a086-ef25d0ca8629/HBJsewgXAAEug60.jfif?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/843e4f49-fbf1-44e9-a086-ef25d0ca8629/HBJsewgXAAEug60.jfif?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/843e4f49-fbf1-44e9-a086-ef25d0ca8629/HBJsewgXAAEug60.jfif?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/843e4f49-fbf1-44e9-a086-ef25d0ca8629/HBJsewgXAAEug60.jfif?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/843e4f49-fbf1-44e9-a086-ef25d0ca8629/HBJsewgXAAEug60.jfif?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Geographical distribution of seats won by the BNP and JI-led coalitions. Source: Election Commission/X. </em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Geographical distribution of seats won by the BNP and JI-led coalitions. Source: Election Commission/X. </em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">And for whatever reason, this anti-India sentiment is often articulated in Bangladeshi politics through violence towards religious minorities, the Left, secular/atheists, and liberal institutions. Just two months before the election, the office buildings of two of the largest newspaper dailies in the country, <em>The Daily Star </em>and <em>Prothom Alo</em>, as well as music/cultural institution <em>Chhayanaut</em>, were torched by angry mobs claiming these outlets to be “Indian mouthpieces.” On the same day, a Hindu garment worker, Dipu Chandra Das, was lynched for allegedly disrespecting the Quran—an allegation later proved to be false.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">The fact is, while Indian expansionism is a legitimate concern, it is only one of many superpowers trying to exert influence over Bangladesh. Both China and the U.S. have keen interests in Bangladesh. For example, in 2022, direct Indian investment in Bangladesh was only <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/business/economy/news/pm-urges-indian-firms-invest-bangladesh-3113961">US$15.7 million</a> whereas Chinese investment was <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/business/news/bangladesh-sees-rising-chinese-investment-amid-trade-shifts-3857736?utm_source=chatgpt.com">US $1.4 billion</a>. China also has invested in the <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/business/news/payra-port-painful-burden-economy-3855726">Payra Port</a> and the <a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2021/6/15/clean-air-group-calls-out-china-backed-coal-plant-in-bangladesh">Banshkhali Coal Power Plant</a> and is the primary weapon supplier for the Bangladesh military. In her final days in power, Sheikh Hasina was struggling to maintain this balancing act between China, India, and the <a href="https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/308718/pm-hasina-us-can-overturn-power-of-any-nation-if">U.S.</a></p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">None of this is surprising considering the increased global hostility in this multipolar world and the crumbling of international rules-based order. In fact, it may be these geopolitical anxieties that informed the interim government’s insistence on leasing administration of Chittagong Port, one of the most strategic ports in the Indian Ocean, to foreign operators. The initiative was met by an <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/news/no-dp-world-deal-during-govts-tenure-4101621">indefinite strike</a> from port workers who were then harassed, intimidated, and arrested. The leasing process was ultimately put to a pause.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">It is important to note here that just two days before the election, the Yunus-led interim government rushed to finalize a <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/business/column/news/unequal-rushed-and-risky-4104086">trade deal with the U.S. that</a> aligns Bangladesh squarely under the American sphere of influence. With this trade deal, Bangladesh committed to purchasing military equipment from the U.S. while limiting its purchase from other countries, removing tariffs on 6,000 American products, purchasing energy directly from the U.S. while allowing them full reign to explore and extract critical minerals and energy resources from Bangladesh. In return, Bangladesh receives a marginal tariff waiver only on ready-made garment products made from American cotton. This deal could not only restructure Bangladesh's economy in the coming days but also weaken the power of industrial labour with threats of job layoffs.&nbsp;<br></p><h4 data-rte-preserve-empty="true">Challenges Ahead</h4>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>The power vacuum left by AL was capitalized mostly by the populist-Islamic right-wing on the ideological terrain and the ruling class-backed “deep state” (military, security forces, intelligence and civil bureaucrats) on the political terrain<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">The cross-class mobilization during the July Uprising signified a desire to reject the status quo. In the absence of any organized progressive formation prior to the spontaneous uprising, this desire has manifested into a reactionary expression. The power vacuum left by AL was capitalized mostly by the populist-Islamic right-wing on the ideological terrain and the ruling class-backed “deep state” (military, security forces, intelligence and civil bureaucrats) on the political terrain.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">With BNP’s win, the managers of the state have changed but the entire state apparatus remains the same. The military, civil bureaucracy, security forces, and the balance of class power remain exactly the same as during the last Awami regime. These actors have been <a href="https://www.nybooks.com/articles/2026/02/12/bangladeshs-stalled-student-revolution-cyrus-naji/">waiting anxiously</a> for the transition to an elected government so that things could return to business as usual.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">The reality of the July Uprising and this election is that ordinary people’s lives have been largely unchanged, if not gotten worse. The Uprising started with a movement for stable government jobs in an increasingly unstable economy—a demand that has been overlooked in the aftermath. Unemployment remains high and affordability is still a major issue in the urban centres. The post-uprising period also saw minimal labour reforms. Mass mobilization for decent wages by tea workers and garment workers remain unaddressed and the appetite for structural reform unmet.&nbsp;</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class="">The July Uprising had brought with it an opening to build a broad working class movement for social change. Left-leaning student groups, teachers, culture workers, and activists were at the forefront of the July movement but in the last 18 months, they have gotten roiled up in the culture wars which pit progressive, humanist values against Islamic, traditional ones, signifying an ideological polarization between the left-secular and the populist-Islamic right wing. This dichotomy is mainly concerned with identity politics and narrows the terrain to engage in class struggle that builds solidarities across these identities. Bangladesh, already functioning under neoliberalism, will now have to navigate the U.S.-imposed economic agenda in a rapidly sharpening imperial order. It is urgent, then, for the left to address these contradictions of the moment we are in. If there is one thing people have now learned from the Uprising, it is that power lies beyond the parliament—on the streets, in workplaces, and in communities.&nbsp;&nbsp;</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p class=""><strong><em>Sarah Nafisa Shahid</em></strong><em> is a Bangladeshi writer and community organizer based in Toronto, Ontario. Her work has been published in The Daily Star, Hyperallergic, Now Magazine and other publications. She is a regular contributor to Spring Magazine and is the co-host of Spring Radio.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1771889065496-S1AMYN591T8ALF7TWWQA/signal-2026-02-22-11-28-40-662.jpg?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">After a Dictator, Bangladesh Turns Right</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>The Enigma of Pinaki’s Populism</title><category>Bangladesh</category><category>Essay</category><dc:creator>Nafisa Tanjeem</dc:creator><pubDate>Sat, 14 Feb 2026 16:19:25 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/the-enigma-of-pinakis-populism</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:698e97d1a634947b053b7d2c</guid><description><![CDATA[On Pinaki Bhattacharya’s strategies to fame as Bangladesh’s most popular 
right-wing influencer.]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""><em>On Pinaki Bhattacharya’s strategies to fame as Bangladesh’s most popular right-wing influencer.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fee60202-2d2c-4ff7-951d-c0ef6a20ea4f/Pinaki+Bhattacharya.png" data-image-dimensions="2560x1440" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fee60202-2d2c-4ff7-951d-c0ef6a20ea4f/Pinaki+Bhattacharya.png?format=1000w" width="2560" height="1440" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fee60202-2d2c-4ff7-951d-c0ef6a20ea4f/Pinaki+Bhattacharya.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fee60202-2d2c-4ff7-951d-c0ef6a20ea4f/Pinaki+Bhattacharya.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fee60202-2d2c-4ff7-951d-c0ef6a20ea4f/Pinaki+Bhattacharya.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fee60202-2d2c-4ff7-951d-c0ef6a20ea4f/Pinaki+Bhattacharya.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fee60202-2d2c-4ff7-951d-c0ef6a20ea4f/Pinaki+Bhattacharya.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fee60202-2d2c-4ff7-951d-c0ef6a20ea4f/Pinaki+Bhattacharya.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fee60202-2d2c-4ff7-951d-c0ef6a20ea4f/Pinaki+Bhattacharya.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available images</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration by Jamhoor, created using publicly available images</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p class="">In the history of Bangladesh’s political commentators and influencers, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/c/pinakibhattacharya">Pinaki Bhattacharya</a> is a phenomenon, ranging from being described as an “online human rights and political activist”&nbsp; to a “self-proclaimed anti-Hindu and anti-India activist,” depending on which media platforms are writing about him and when. Trained as a medical doctor, Pinaki initially became involved in leftist politics; in 2013, he was an organizer of the <a href="https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/southasia/2013/03/21/the-paradoxes-of-bangladeshs-shahbag-protests/">Shahbag movement</a>, which sought justice for war crimes committed in 1971 by members of <a href="https://jamaat-e-islami.org/en/"><em>Jamaat-e-Islami</em></a>, the largest Islamist political party in Bangladesh. In 2018, due to the threat of detention by the military intelligence agency during the Awami League regime, Pinaki had to leave Bangladesh and seek <a href="https://www.voanews.com/a/bangladeshi-online-activist-fears-for-life-remains-in-hiding/4537701.html">political refuge</a> in France. He has continued creating political content from there since then; his YouTube channel currently boasts more than <a href="https://www.youtube.com/c/pinakibhattacharya">four million subscribers</a>. Ironically, Pinaki now serves as a major spokesperson for the <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news/how-ncp-jamaat-coalition-benefits-jamaat-and-bnp-more-4077191">Jamaat–National Citizen Party (NCP) coalition</a> and has actively urged his followers to vote for the coalition in the upcoming 2026 general election in Bangladesh.&nbsp;</p><p class="">Although many critical scholars and activists in Bangladesh see Pinaki’s rhetoric primarily as propaganda, a large portion of his four million subscribers shape their political thinking and positions based on what Pinaki says. From Boomers to Gen Z, Pinaki has an enormous base that considers him a political guru and repeats his talking points in public political debates and discussions. Through his populist rhetoric, Pinaki has captured the power to shape a country’s political narrative and dictate political actions on the ground from afar, the most salient and terrifying one being the creation of mobs to attack institutions he deems as enemies of the state. Internationally, Pinaki has often been featured as an “exiled blogger” and “human rights activist,” and has been<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EMgEMxDXARk"> interviewed</a> by international media platforms that have a narrow understanding of Bangladesh's complex local political dynamics.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Through his populist rhetoric, Pinaki has captured the power to shape a country’s political narrative and dictate political actions on the ground from afar, the most salient and terrifying one being the creation of mobs to attack institutions he deems as enemies of the state.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">Pinaki’s rhetoric is a mish-mash of left-wing and right-wing political thought with a veneer of pro-Bangladesh sovereignty. In a country that had ostensibly adopted center-left to center-right politics since liberation, veering into authoritarianism in the last decade, it’s important to examine exactly which strategies Pinaki has so effectively used to shape political thought among the masses. What lies behind the enigma of Pinaki’s populism? In this piece, I will analyze his populist communication strategies using one of his videos, “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ch8neirAY2c"><em>Voter Agei Khela Shesh: Front Jitbe Kon Plan-e</em></a>” [The Game is Over before the Vote: Which Plan will Win the Front?].</p><p class=""><a href="https://www.idea.int/blog/explainer-populism-left-and-right-progressive-and-regressive">Populism</a> is a political ideology whose core claim is that an elite establishment is working against the interests of the people. Populism claims to represent the people, positions the people against the elite establishment, and calls on them to fight those in power. Populists can be left-wing or right-wing. For example, in the United States, Bernie Sanders, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, and Zohran Mamdani all practice left-wing populist politics. Left-wing populists talk about how billion-dollar corporations control working-class communities, exploit them, and accumulate massive profits.&nbsp;</p><p class="">Right-wing populists, on the other hand, identify as the problem those who are “Others”—immigrants, refugees, and non-white people. Brazil’s Jair Bolsonaro, India’s Narendra Modi, Hungary’s Viktor Orbán, and the United States’ Donald Trump - all practice right-wing populist politics. Narendra Modi repeatedly identifies Muslims <a href="https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/indias-muslims-continue-to-face-discrimination-and-hate-following-modis-election-win">as the problem</a>. Trump has effectively declared <a href="https://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/trump-2-immigration-1st-year">war</a> on immigrants, refugees, and Muslims. In this way, identifying an “Other” and attacking them as a way of protecting the “self” has been a classic right-wing populist strategy. Right-wing populism often takes an intensely nationalist form. Sometimes, right-wing populists oppose globalization as a means to protect national interests. Leftists, too, are usually major critics of globalization. As a result, the line between left-wing and right-wing populism often blurs for those with a surface-level political understanding. At times, right-wing populists borrow and appropriate elements from leftist arguments, making it sound—at first glance—like leftist politics, while in reality the politics is deeply right-wing. Pinaki is a perfect example of this.</p>


  









&nbsp;

























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/56a46353-4be3-4909-b91e-c938aa66a096/capture-65397967067b34130cb7da3.10699026.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1280x1280" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/56a46353-4be3-4909-b91e-c938aa66a096/capture-65397967067b34130cb7da3.10699026.jpg?format=1000w" width="1280" height="1280" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 66.67vw, 66.67vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/56a46353-4be3-4909-b91e-c938aa66a096/capture-65397967067b34130cb7da3.10699026.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/56a46353-4be3-4909-b91e-c938aa66a096/capture-65397967067b34130cb7da3.10699026.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/56a46353-4be3-4909-b91e-c938aa66a096/capture-65397967067b34130cb7da3.10699026.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/56a46353-4be3-4909-b91e-c938aa66a096/capture-65397967067b34130cb7da3.10699026.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/56a46353-4be3-4909-b91e-c938aa66a096/capture-65397967067b34130cb7da3.10699026.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/56a46353-4be3-4909-b91e-c938aa66a096/capture-65397967067b34130cb7da3.10699026.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/56a46353-4be3-4909-b91e-c938aa66a096/capture-65397967067b34130cb7da3.10699026.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Pinaki Bhattacharya gets interviewed by France24 on the July Revolution. Source: France24</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Pinaki Bhattacharya gets interviewed by France24 on the July Revolution. Source: France24</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  

&nbsp;
  
  <h4>Strategy One: Use of colloquial Bangla, comedy, and sexist slang</h4><p class="">In Bangladesh, the tradition of political commentary using regional language and comedy was arguably pioneered by M. R. Akhtar Mukul. The most popular program of the <a href="https://en.banglapedia.org/index.php/Swadhin_Bangla_Betar_Kendra"><em>Swadhin Bangla Betar Kendra</em></a>, the radio channel of the Bangladesh government in exile during the 1971 war of independence, was <a href="https://military-history.fandom.com/wiki/Chorompotro"><em>Chorompotro</em></a>. From May 25 to December 16, 1971, these 8–10-minute recordings were broadcast regularly. Despite the countless uncertainties and sufferings of the war, people made time to listen to <em>Chorompotro</em><strong> </strong>because it made them laugh even in the midst of sorrow, despair, and anxiety, while also informing and motivating them about the liberation war against Pakistan.</p><p class="">The language on Pinaki’s YouTube channel is somewhat similar to non-standard, colloquial Bangla. I would argue that his decision to abandon “standard” Bangla in favor of non-standard Bangla is a highly calculated one. The use of non-standard Bangla signals to followers that Pinaki does not practice elite politics. It builds trust by suggesting that since his language resembles that of ordinary people, his politics must prioritize ordinary people’s interests.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Sexist slang sells. In a society where patriarchal thinking is deeply entrenched, it is hardly surprising that people eagerly consume political discussions infused with patriarchal humor.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">Combined with humor, comedy, and extremely sexist slang, this non-standard language makes Pinaki’s political analysis highly palatable to a massive cis-Bengali-heterosexual-Muslim-male audience. Sexist slang sells. In a society where patriarchal thinking is deeply entrenched, it is hardly surprising that people eagerly consume political discussions infused with patriarchal humor.</p><h4>Strategy Two: An anti-intellectual stance</h4><p class="">Pinaki repeatedly adopts an anti-intellectual position. In the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ch8neirAY2c">video</a> under discussion, while criticizing the women leaders of NCP who protested <a href="https://thediplomat.com/2026/01/bangladesh-jamaat-e-islami-draws-ncp-and-ldp-into-an-islamist-alliance/">NCP’s coalition with <em>Jamaat-e-Islami</em></a>, Pinaki says, “Some women leaders of NCP have created unnecessary trouble.” According to him, by raising “irrelevant side issues” while working on “national issues,” these women leaders are sabotaging the entire process. Pinaki argues that NCP is now “learning the consequences” of placing “clever, calculative people” in important positions, people who did not go to the streets to fight against the anti-fascist regime. Pinaki’s remark appears to target political leaders like <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/drtasnimjara/?originalSubdomain=uk">Tasneem Jara</a>, who studied at Viqarunnisa Noon School and Dhaka Medical College, two prestigious academic institutions in Bangladesh, completed a master’s degree at Oxford University, and left a prestigious job in the UK to enter Bangladeshi politics. Pinaki rejects the claim that national politics will collapse without highly educated people.&nbsp;</p><p class="">Appropriating distinctly leftist vocabulary, Pinaki says politics is not a corporate job, not teaching at a university, not practicing medicine or engineering, and that higher education is not a substitute for political organizing experience. Political legitimacy, according to Pinaki, comes from struggling, sacrificing, and taking risks in solidarity with common people. “You may have ascended to the sky with your knowledge, but your people are on the ground”—this, he argues, is the problem with elite politicians. Politicians must speak the language of the ground. Pinaki criticizes former Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, who held degrees from Oxford and Cambridge Universities, for being part of an “elite consensus.” Pinaki also criticizes the interim government led by Professor Yunus, founder of Grameen Bank and Nobel Peace Prize winner, and formerly a college professor. On the surface, Pinaki consistently opposes “elite” and “technocratic” governance.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/855bd4bc-cce4-49f1-83b3-b30834a5351f/629830819_1500353688115140_4107650195692800437_n.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1600x900" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/855bd4bc-cce4-49f1-83b3-b30834a5351f/629830819_1500353688115140_4107650195692800437_n.jpg?format=1000w" width="1600" height="900" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/855bd4bc-cce4-49f1-83b3-b30834a5351f/629830819_1500353688115140_4107650195692800437_n.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/855bd4bc-cce4-49f1-83b3-b30834a5351f/629830819_1500353688115140_4107650195692800437_n.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/855bd4bc-cce4-49f1-83b3-b30834a5351f/629830819_1500353688115140_4107650195692800437_n.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/855bd4bc-cce4-49f1-83b3-b30834a5351f/629830819_1500353688115140_4107650195692800437_n.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/855bd4bc-cce4-49f1-83b3-b30834a5351f/629830819_1500353688115140_4107650195692800437_n.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/855bd4bc-cce4-49f1-83b3-b30834a5351f/629830819_1500353688115140_4107650195692800437_n.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/855bd4bc-cce4-49f1-83b3-b30834a5351f/629830819_1500353688115140_4107650195692800437_n.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Cover image of Pinaki’s video released February 10, 2026, titled “This is Jamaat’s Kaafir Section’s Ameer Speaking”</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Cover image of Pinaki’s video released February 10, 2026, titled “This is Jamaat’s Kaafir Section’s Ameer Speaking”</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p class="">Pinaki’s critique of elite intellectualism does not necessarily come from a pro-working-class, anti-elite stance. Rather, right-wing populists like Pinaki fear critical thinkers with progressive views who are equipped to dismantle some of his incoherent and inaccurate references and logical fallacies and can oppose his ethno-nationalist, sexist, and xenophobic narratives. For example, Fahmidul Haq, a U.S.-based Bangladeshi researcher, writer, and educator, mentions in his book <em>July Jagoroner Dinlipi </em>(2025) that when he refuted some claims of Pinaki, Pinaki, in response, canceled him publicly in a YouTube video and introduced him to the followers as <em>“Shera Shahbagi”</em> [the best <em>Shahbagi</em>]. The word <em>Shahbagi</em> is a popular Bangla political insult and trolling label widely used in right-wing online and partisan debates to describe overly secular, liberal, and an “urban elite” mindset. Haq further argues that right-wing populist online influencers like Pinaki must pay attention to what increases their followers’ engagement. Therefore, they always try to present what will satisfy and excite their followers, and their analyses usually contain half-truths presented as “evidence.” Haq points out that common followers often lack the knowledge or critical thinking skills to identify the fallacies in the arguments presented. I would argue that tagging highly educated progressives as “elites,” therefore, becomes an effective tactic to cancel them before their critiques of Pinaki gain traction among the public.</p><h4>Strategy Three: KISS — Keep It Simple and Stupid</h4><p class="">Pinaki cites the “KISS – Keep It Simple and Stupid” principle in one of his <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ch8neirAY2c"><span>videos</span></a>.&nbsp; Pinaki himself says that people don’t read or analyze anymore; they scan and take shortcuts. I would argue that Pinaki understands very well how to attract an audience with no training in critical thinking and no time or intellectual ability to comprehend deep, complex analysis. His main talking points appear repeatedly as animated text, making him very easy to follow. Unlike unappealing long-form text, the spicy combo of Pinaki’s non-standard Bangla, sexist slang, images, animations, and flashy videos is well-equipped to compete with other floating content of social media and hold the attention of his followers.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Despite his anti-elite and anti-intellectual stance, Pinaki uses a barrage of “references,” ranging from newspaper screenshots to other sources, to reassure followers of his intellectual authority<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">Despite his anti-elite and anti-intellectual stance, Pinaki uses a barrage of “references,” ranging from newspaper screenshots to other sources, to reassure followers of his intellectual authority. Since his viewers lack the time or ability to examine various sources and find the “truth,” Pinaki does the “research” for them and delivers a “simple and stupid” truth. However, Pinaki’s content is anything but simple. His content involves careful planning, expert input, a full team to research and execute the plan, and substantial funding. It is implausible that one individual could produce such technologically advanced content at such a high volume, day after day, without sustainable sources of funding.</p><h4>Strategy Four: Creating an “Other”</h4><p class="">A key ingredient of right-wing populism is constructing an “Other” to blame for everything. For example, in the United States, current President Donald Trump has successfully created a large base of support among Americans <a href="https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/trump-overwhelmingly-leads-rivals-in-support-from-less-educated-americans"><span>without a college degree</span></a> by other-ing immigrants. Scholars have <a href="https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/trump-overwhelmingly-leads-rivals-in-support-from-less-educated-americans"><span>argued</span></a> that this is not necessarily because of the ignorance of people who haven’t attended college. Rather, people who are not highly educated are statistically more likely to be financially struggling. It is easy to appeal to people who are struggling to make ends meet by saying that they are not getting their fair share, which is being grabbed by an undeserving “Other” (e.g., immigrants or Muslims), and someone will stand up for them.</p><p class="">Currently, Pinaki’s highly effective “Other” is India, and, according to Pinaki, the political party that would stand up for the common people in Bangladesh is the Jamaat-NCP coalition. In a recent <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ch8neirAY2c"><span>video</span></a>, he identifies Bangladesh’s four main problems: poverty, corruption, unemployment, and the hegemony of India. Poverty, corruption, and unemployment— all make logical sense. But why single out Indian hegemony and avoid any discussions of the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JNZcOgPh8eQ"><span>Chinese</span></a> or the <a href="https://oercommons.org/courseware/lesson/87953/student/?section=1"><span>American hegemony</span></a>?</p><p class="">In fact, Pinaki has separate <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XocLIZLTIx0"><span>episodes</span></a> on how to maintain good relations with China and the United States. He even discusses how to maintain diplomatic and economic ties with a belligerent, authoritarian leader like Donald Trump. It seems that he has no problem with U.S. imperialism or China’s neo-imperial expansion in Bangladesh. Bangladesh <a href="https://en.prothomalo.com/business/local/kp4amtijik?utm_source=chatgpt.com"><span>borrowed</span></a> $10 billion from China for 14 infrastructure projects under the Hasina government under strict conditions—but Pinaki shows no concern about Bangladesh’s economic dependence on China.&nbsp;</p>


  





























  













  
    
      
    
    
      
        
      
    
    
  
    <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Pinaki Bhattacharya explains how Bangladesh can win America’s heart</em></p>
  


    



  






  
  
  




  
  
  
  
    
  


  
  <p class="">Much of what Pinaki says about Indian hegemony is true, but he never dissects the complex political economy of that hegemony or addresses the complicity of the Bangladesh government and civil and corporate elites across the political spectrum who sustain the hegemony and reap its benefits. For example, Maha Mirza <a href="https://www.prothomalo.com/opinion/column/6w9w3ptfu0?fbclid=IwY2xjawPamLhleHRuA2FlbQIxMABicmlkETFTZ0I1WUxvREZhdFZGc0oxc3J0YwZhcHBfaWQQMjIyMDM5MTc4ODIwMDg5MgABHhN9R9jaKj7u3bNe-jQcp_-TGc-qfymvev5vv8Maylr5Za3J3rB892k5Hazt_aem_4goqE17ldCH1KeyTxYY2Lg"><span>points out</span></a> that the current interim Bangladesh government, allegedly resisting the Indian hegemony, reduced the subsidy for local yarn production from 5 percent to 1.5 percent. As a result, Bangladeshi yarns became much more expensive than Indian yarns that enjoy up to a 15 percent subsidy from the Indian government, along with state protection, investment, and funds to improve production technologies. During the last fiscal year, imports of Indian yarn into Bangladesh increased by 137 percent, while more than 50 Bangladeshi spinning mills closed, losing out to cheaper Indian yarn. So far, the interim government of Bangladesh has imported USD 2 billion worth of yarn, while local yarn worth USD 120 billion remains unsold in stock. Mirza cites a series of other examples of leaving Bangladeshi industries to the mercy of the free market while importing cheaper Indian products that enjoy high levels of subsidy and protection from the Indian state. Mirza argues that the interim government is destroying the economic backbone of Bangladesh while chanting the “Delhi or Dhaka – Dhaka, Dhaka” slogan only to cater to performative populist politics, one akin to Pinaki’s.</p><p class="">Such nuanced and sophisticated analysis is usually never present in Pinaki’s populist rhetoric. Pinaki’s populism needs an “Other,” and now that “Other” is India. He asks his followers to resist the Indian hegemony by voting for the NCP-Jamaat coalition but never addresses why it is important to build a national capacity and self-reliant foundation to confront the unjust terms, conditions, and arrangements as Bangladesh engages in diplomatic and economic negotiations and exchanges with hegemons like India, China, or the United States.</p><h4>Strategy Five: Co-opting the language of social justice</h4><p class="">Pinaki skillfully appropriates the language of social justice. In the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ch8neirAY2c">video</a> mentioned above, he explains how “big capital” manipulates the state's regulatory mechanisms, how automation enables large corporations to produce at a mass scale and eventually outcompete and crush small- and medium-sized businesses, and how big capital eliminates jobs rather than creating them. He also calls on his followers to dismantle oligarchy.</p><p class="">Yet he remains silent on Jamaat-e-Islami’s massive oligarchic power. <a href="https://en.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/Jamaat-s-fund-provider">Mir Quasem Ali</a>, a founder of Jamaat<em> </em>and<em> Islami Chhatra Shibir</em>, the student wing of Jamaat, raised huge funds from Saudi Arabia and other places. He was the founding vice chairman of Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited and owned a wide range of corporations across healthcare, transport, banking, telecom, media, and education. He also owned big businesses like the Ibn Sina Trust, Diganta Media, and the Keari Limited. Jamaat leaders established numerous madrassas across Bangladesh, as well as universities like the <a href="https://manarat.ac.bd/">Manarat International University</a> and the <a href="https://www.iiuc.ac.bd/">International Islamic University Chittagong</a>. Jamaat is now actively working to restore the economic power that it lost during the Awami regime. Here, Pinaki’s hollow appropriation of leftist social justice rhetoric becomes clear. He talks about breaking up big capital and oligarchy but remains silent about Jamaat’s huge oligarchic power and NCP’s close proximity to the Jamaat-led oligarchy.</p><h4>Strategy Six: Storytelling</h4><p class="">Pinaki is an exceptional storyteller. Using narratives, data, statistics, videos, and so-called “scholarly” sources, he convinces audiences of the credibility of his arguments while skillfully decrying intellectualism as an elite pursuit. He entertains followers by using sexist slurs against his opponents. He uses colloquial Bangla to connect with the masses. Most of his followers are exhausted by day-to-day struggles for survival. They lack the time, energy, or critical-thinking training to verify Pinaki’s “irrefutable” evidence. They hear what Pinaki says—but they lack the bandwidth to identify what he doesn’t say. That is why Pinaki can mobilize outrageous mobs against Indian influence while conveniently ignoring Chinese or U.S. imperialism. His followers learn to hate cultural and economic elites like <em>Prothom Alo</em>, <em>The Daily Star</em>, and <em>Chhayanaut</em>, while remaining indifferent to Jamaat’s oligarchic power.</p><p class="">Pinaki himself talks about narrative resources as a form of state power. What he doesn’t say is that he himself actively constructs a right-wing populist narrative. From abroad, he continues to influence political, economic, and social institutions and processes in Bangladesh. His populism hijacks the language of social justice and inspires people to dream of dismantling the systemic oppression perpetuated by the elites, but he very cleverly conceals from his followers the fact that his populism serves the interests of certain groups, political parties, and big capital.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c2e498c-e56a-47e5-8d1c-8efca1fd1c6a/605885041_1464213028395873_1887303476518594192_n.jpg" data-image-dimensions="2048x1152" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c2e498c-e56a-47e5-8d1c-8efca1fd1c6a/605885041_1464213028395873_1887303476518594192_n.jpg?format=1000w" width="2048" height="1152" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c2e498c-e56a-47e5-8d1c-8efca1fd1c6a/605885041_1464213028395873_1887303476518594192_n.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c2e498c-e56a-47e5-8d1c-8efca1fd1c6a/605885041_1464213028395873_1887303476518594192_n.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c2e498c-e56a-47e5-8d1c-8efca1fd1c6a/605885041_1464213028395873_1887303476518594192_n.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c2e498c-e56a-47e5-8d1c-8efca1fd1c6a/605885041_1464213028395873_1887303476518594192_n.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c2e498c-e56a-47e5-8d1c-8efca1fd1c6a/605885041_1464213028395873_1887303476518594192_n.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c2e498c-e56a-47e5-8d1c-8efca1fd1c6a/605885041_1464213028395873_1887303476518594192_n.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/3c2e498c-e56a-47e5-8d1c-8efca1fd1c6a/605885041_1464213028395873_1887303476518594192_n.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Cover image for Pinaki’s video on the attack on Chhayanaut in December 2025 following the death of Sharif Osman Hadi. Title reads “Vandalism at Chhayanaut, Pinaki is furious”.</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Cover image for Pinaki’s video on the attack on Chhayanaut in December 2025 following the death of Sharif Osman Hadi. Title reads “Vandalism at Chhayanaut, Pinaki is furious”.</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p class="">In Bangladesh, many leftist and progressive populist politicians, academics, and activists have long been engaged in grassroots movements and writing. But the unfortunate truth is that the public does not follow grassroots movements unless the situation becomes extremely dire or directly affects their personal lives and interests. People also lack the patience to read long texts and think them through. The reach of social media among the general population in Bangladesh has now become alarming. Social media has effectively overridden all other sources of information, including the mainstream media, books, newspapers, magazines, and other educational sources. If alternative and genuinely anti-imperialist, anti-capitalist, decolonial, and feminist progressive narratives are not created and circulated on social media, the reach of Pinaki and so-called populist “activists” like him will continue to grow.</p><p class="">The general public will entrust these populists, like Pinaki, with the responsibility of knowledge production and unquestioningly accept them as authoritative figures. Exploiting this opportunity, Pinaki and his ilk will continue to popularize their politics of nationalist hatred and violence while consolidating their own interests. Meanwhile, Bangladesh’s working people, women, religiously minoritized communities, Indigenous communities, people of diverse gender identities, and all those in various marginalized and minoritized positions—who are far removed from being part of the big capital as Pinaki insinuates—will continue to suffer from hardships day after day, with no sign of hope.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p class=""><em>Editor’s Note:</em> <em>An earlier version of this piece was originally published in Bangla on </em><a href="https://bdfeministarchives.org/2026/01/10/pinaki-keno-popular/"><em>Bangladesh Feminist Archive</em></a><em>. The piece has been updated and translated for Jamhoor by the author.</em></p><p class=""><strong><em>Nafisa Nipun Tanjeem</em></strong><em> is an educator, researcher, writer, and organizer. She currently serves as an Associate Professor in the Department of Interdisciplinary Studies at Worcester State University in the United States.</em></p><p class=""><em><br><br></em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/png" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/fee60202-2d2c-4ff7-951d-c0ef6a20ea4f/Pinaki+Bhattacharya.png?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">The Enigma of Pinaki’s Populism</media:title></media:content></item><item><title>Destituting the Party: The Crisis of the Pakistani Left</title><category>Essay</category><category>Pakistan</category><dc:creator>Sher Ali</dc:creator><pubDate>Sat, 10 Jan 2026 02:20:47 +0000</pubDate><link>https://www.jamhoor.org/read/destituting-the-party-the-crisis-of-the-pakistani-left</link><guid isPermaLink="false">6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c:6029d5130b4b332aaec50b06:69612aedb7310d5a13b2dc35</guid><description><![CDATA[A critique of party-centric tendencies within the Pakistani Left’s debate 
on the India-Pakistan conflict]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""><em>A critique of party-centric tendencies within the Pakistani Left’s debate on the India-Pakistan conflict.</em></p>


  











  <hr />
  

  






























  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/e1df4a3e-2b8f-4663-ac4f-4e866f7ac253/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%281%29.png" data-image-dimensions="3840x2160" data-image-focal-point="0.5089919972952933,0.7120770038789923" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/e1df4a3e-2b8f-4663-ac4f-4e866f7ac253/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%281%29.png?format=1000w" width="3840" height="2160" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/e1df4a3e-2b8f-4663-ac4f-4e866f7ac253/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%281%29.png?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/e1df4a3e-2b8f-4663-ac4f-4e866f7ac253/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%281%29.png?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/e1df4a3e-2b8f-4663-ac4f-4e866f7ac253/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%281%29.png?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/e1df4a3e-2b8f-4663-ac4f-4e866f7ac253/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%281%29.png?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/e1df4a3e-2b8f-4663-ac4f-4e866f7ac253/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%281%29.png?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/e1df4a3e-2b8f-4663-ac4f-4e866f7ac253/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%281%29.png?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/e1df4a3e-2b8f-4663-ac4f-4e866f7ac253/Copy+of+Forging+the+Steel+of+Unity+%281%29.png?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration: Jamhoor</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Illustration: Jamhoor</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p class="">The ongoing debate within Pakistan’s Left reveals how thoroughly its dominant frameworks have hardened into habits of thought incapable of grasping contemporary political reality. The recent interventions by <a href="https://www.jamhoor.org/read/forging-the-steel-of-unity-left-politics-in-contemporary-pakistan">Ammar Ali Jan</a>, <a href="https://www.jamhoor.org/read/how-the-recent-indo-pak-conflict-exposed-fault-lines-in-the-pakistani-left">Syed Azeem and Muhammad Umar Ali</a>, and <a href="https://www.jamhoor.org/blog/anti-imperialism-vs-geopolitical">Ayyaz Mallick</a> seek strategic clarity in the aftermath of the latest confrontation between India and Pakistan, but each relies on conceptual reflexes inherited from an earlier moment. These reflexes presume that the state remains a coherent vessel of political possibility, that sovereignty can be retrieved through correct geopolitical alignment, and that the masses exist as a latent unity waiting to be summoned. Against this imaginary, it is necessary to describe how the Pakistani state and global capital actually operate through differentiated extraction, coercion and abandonment, how movements emerge from specific sites of exposure and endurance, and why leadership that continually invokes unity cannot meet the conditions it claims to diagnose.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Treating China as non-imperial because it does not mirror the base infrastructure of the United States misunderstands how present day imperial relations operate through combinations of financialisation, extraction and mediated governance rather than simple conquest.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">Ammar Ali Jan’s intervention is built on the assumption that the Pakistani state, though compromised, can reorganise society if a sovereign project is articulated with sufficient clarity. His argument turns on the claim that postcolonial states retain a legitimate right to self defence against external aggression and that the Left must acknowledge this right. This framing depends on abstracting Pakistan from the material architecture that constitutes it. Pakistan does not confront imperialism as a unified political subject. It is organised through overlapping networks of militarised development, financial dependency and bureaucratic governance that distribute protection and exposure unevenly. Frantz Fanon’s account of how postcolonial states inherit racialised, gendered and classed hierarchies helps to clarify this structure.Identification systems, welfare schemes, development and security projects, policing and land grabs sort people into those whose lives the state protects and those it treats as expendable.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""></p><h4>Uneven Masses</h4><p class="">Seen from this perspective, the social terrain that Jan calls “the people” or “the masses” is not a single formation awaiting ideological coherence. It is an uneven field composed of precarious urban workers pushed through unstable labour markets, rural households trapped in debt and dispossession, women whose labour remains elastic and unrecognised, migrants whose remittances uphold the economy while their own lives remain peripheral to state’s concerns, climate displaced families navigating repeated loss, caste marked communities living under permanent suspicion, and queer and trans collectivities who absorb overlapping forms of policing and social violence. These differentiated conditions do not signal ideological confusion. They express the patterned effects of how power distributes vulnerability and privilege.</p><p class="">Work on contemporary imperialism, including Samir Amin’s analysis of unequal exchange and dependent accumulation, helps to clarify this structure. For Amin, global capital subordinates peripheral economies through debt, extraction and political disciplining. Pakistan’s integration into circuits of accumulation follows this logic. Negotiation does not occur from a position of sovereign choice. It takes place from within relations already organised by dependency. Jan’s claim that Pakistan can reclaim sovereignty by pivoting toward Asia rests on ignoring how Chinese investment, debt restructuring and corridor projects reproduce forms of dependency that are imperial in their effects. Credit arrangements, mineral concessions and logistical integration discipline domestic politics through financial imperatives and security commitments. The fact that these processes do not rely on a dense network of bases does not make them neutral.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>The question becomes whether Pakistan “retains the right to defend itself,” instead of whether it possesses the material capacity to act independently within a global hierarchy structured by debt, security rents, military patronage, IMF supervision and corridor based integration into Chinese and Gulf capital. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">Jan also misreads contemporary imperial relations when he draws a sharp line between the violent architecture of the United States and the supposedly benign rise of China. Peripheral states do not step outside imperial hierarchies by changing patrons. Debt and resource capture fold them back into the same order through different channels. Financial power can operate without overt military domination and reorganise life through economic capture rather than territorial conquest. Extractive power now often functions through dispersed arrangements that rely on corridors, security enclosures, debt relations and flexible appropriation of territories and bodies. These dynamics are embedded in development schemes, remittance economies, labour mobility regimes and the infrastructures of corridor projects that reconfigure space without formal occupation. Treating China as non-imperial because it does not mirror the base infrastructure of the United States misunderstands how present day imperial relations operate through combinations of financialisation, extraction and mediated governance rather than simple conquest.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9010e977-f8cd-4593-93e5-82f7ea5cce7a/GPrnR6ksCwKtzGV6.jpg" data-image-dimensions="1017x734" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9010e977-f8cd-4593-93e5-82f7ea5cce7a/GPrnR6ksCwKtzGV6.jpg?format=1000w" width="1017" height="734" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9010e977-f8cd-4593-93e5-82f7ea5cce7a/GPrnR6ksCwKtzGV6.jpg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9010e977-f8cd-4593-93e5-82f7ea5cce7a/GPrnR6ksCwKtzGV6.jpg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9010e977-f8cd-4593-93e5-82f7ea5cce7a/GPrnR6ksCwKtzGV6.jpg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9010e977-f8cd-4593-93e5-82f7ea5cce7a/GPrnR6ksCwKtzGV6.jpg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9010e977-f8cd-4593-93e5-82f7ea5cce7a/GPrnR6ksCwKtzGV6.jpg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9010e977-f8cd-4593-93e5-82f7ea5cce7a/GPrnR6ksCwKtzGV6.jpg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9010e977-f8cd-4593-93e5-82f7ea5cce7a/GPrnR6ksCwKtzGV6.jpg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Pakistani Prime Minister on official state visit to China in 2024</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Pakistani Prime Minister on official state visit to China in 2024</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p class="">Jan frames disagreement as a failure of others to “decide,” accusing them of retreating into “safe scholarship” and avoiding the tragic choices demanded by history. The decision he advances is not grounded in the material conditions under which the state operates. It is grounded in moral affirmation. The question becomes whether Pakistan “retains the right to defend itself,” instead of whether it possesses the material capacity to act independently within a global hierarchy structured by debt, security rents, military patronage, IMF supervision and corridor based integration into Chinese and Gulf capital. In this configuration, sovereignty is invoked as a moral claim rather than examined as a material condition. Dependency is treated as a matter of attitude rather than architecture. This is exactly the trap that Amin describes when nationalist discourse invokes sovereignty as if it were held in reserve, while the actual position of the state in the world economy has already been organised by collective imperial power.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Jan’s repeated appeals to “the people,” “the nation,” “sovereignty” and a “national popular project” are not grounded in institutional capacity or social formation. They cover the gap between the world he describes and the world he wants to summon. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">Fanon is instructive here for another reason. When postcolonial elites invoke unity or national destiny, they often mobilise universals to suppress antagonisms rooted in class, gender, caste and racialised exposure. Jan follows this trajectory. He insists that the Left must suspend its analysis of internal repression and national oppression in order to affirm the state’s right to self defence. The distinction between external sovereignty and internal justice is presented as a matter of sequence. One must come before the other. Fanon’s warning was that such sequencing allows the postcolonial bourgeoisie to consolidate its position while postponing the transformation of the conditions that shape everyday life. Jan repeats that operation by asking movements confronting dispossession, disappearances and militarised policing to treat their own struggles as secondary to a national project that has consistently organised itself against them. Shortly after this debate, the aftermath of the India-Pakistan exchange made that sequencing concrete. Appeals to national defence moved alongside the establishment of a new federal court, proposals for a twenty seventh amendment and an intensified clampdown on dissent. The language of sovereignty travelled with institutional changes that extend state power and narrow avenues of contestation. In that context, Jan’s framework does more than misdescribe the terrain. It normalises the expectation that those already living with dispossession and militarised control should set aside their own struggles in order to preserve a state that continues to govern them as expendable.</p><p class=""><a href="https://illwill.com/impasses">Maurizio Lazzarato</a> helps to name the language that accompanies this movement. In his account of the impasses of critical thought after the 1970s, he traces how universals such as “the people,” “sovereignty,” “nation,” “unity” and “decision” persist as rhetorical anchors long after the material bases of collective political agency have been eroded by financialisation, debt governance, militarised globalisation and logistical rationalisation. These terms no longer correspond to organised subjects. They operate as stand- &nbsp; &nbsp; ins for strategies that no longer exist. They appear when the Left cannot account for the mechanisms of domination and instead invokes abstract cohesion. Jan’s repeated appeals to “the people,” “the nation,” “sovereignty” and a “national popular project” are not grounded in institutional capacity or social formation. They cover the gap between the world he describes and the world he wants to summon.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>When Jan asserts that Pakistan’s right to self defence must be affirmed, he speaks in the register of universality while leaving these internal divisions intact. <span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">Universal language smooths over differentiation and presents unity as a starting point rather than a problem. The more differentiated the social terrain becomes, the more Jan leans on universal terms. The more diminished the state’s capacity, the more he insists on its necessity. Amin’s account of how nationalist discourse slides from opposition into the management of dependency sits in the background here, marking the point where invocations of sovereignty no longer confront the global order but help to administer it.</p><p class="">Pakistan’s governance architecture, including documentation regimes, counterterror finance, securitised development and colonial policing, organises distinctions along lines of region, sect, ethnicity, class and race. When Jan asserts that Pakistan’s right to self defence must be affirmed, he speaks in the register of universality while leaving these internal divisions intact. The state does not defend an undifferentiated “people.” It defends an order built on hierarchical distributions of security and exposure.&nbsp;</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>Their reliance on older Leninist and Maoist categories assumes a mass subject capable of consolidation through a vanguard party, even though the unified industrial proletariat that underwrote those strategies no longer exists.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">Jan’s reading of Mao reinforces these problems. He presents Mao’s temporary collaboration with the Kuomintang as a precedent for supporting Pakistan’s military under conditions of external threat. The analogy extracts the tactic and leaves behind the strategy. Mao’s alliances were subordinated to mass mobilisation, land reform, armed organisation and the construction of counter power. They presumed a capacity to analyse the coordination of imperial forces and to intervene at points of rupture. Jan keeps the image of alliance and abandons the work that made it meaningful. Mao becomes a justification for trusting a military that remains central to Pakistan’s rentier order, rather than a figure for building antagonistic capacity against it.</p><p class="">Azeem and Umar Ali appear, at first, to stand at the opposite pole. They reject what they see as HKP’s capitulation to national defence and call for “revolutionary militant people’s struggles” against Western, Indian and Chinese imperialism. Their identification of Hindutva fascism, intensified repression in Kashmir and expanding resource grabs is important. Their wider history of Left alignments across South Asia traces real debates. But their diagnosis repeats the same abstraction. Imperialism is condensed into a single axis along which all actors can be placed. Differentiated movements across Pakistan are treated as distractions from a unified people’s war that exists only on paper. Their proposal does not confront the constraints imposed by debt, border regimes, logistical corridors and security infrastructures. It imagines a subject capable of fighting multiple fronts without considering how that subject is fragmented by the very conditions they name.</p><p class="">Their reliance on older Leninist and Maoist categories assumes a mass subject capable of consolidation through a vanguard party, even though the unified industrial proletariat that underwrote those strategies no longer exists. The landscape is fractured by financialisation, caste and gendered violence, ecological precarity, migration and militarised borders. Invoking a people’s war across this terrain does not answer the question of organisation. It relocates it into a horizon that cannot be reached. The party form becomes a shell that claims authority without demonstrating capacity.</p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>While commentators debated principles in Lahore and Karachi, residents of Rawalakot and surrounding areas endured nightly shelling, blackouts and the disruption of daily life.<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <p class="">Ayyaz Mallick seeks to escape these closures through a call for a pluri-national consciousness. He criticises metropolitan sections of the Lahore Left for collapsing into nationalist sentiment and for drawing simplistic analogies between Pakistan and Palestine. He points to the fusion of external dependency with internal regimes of national oppression. His critique of convivial nationalist rhetoric and of the Lahore based convergence around war patriotism is necessary. His proposal still returns to the expectation that unity can be reconstructed at the level of a national popular project. Contradictions that have material origins are redirected into a question of a proper ideological frame. The assumption that consciousness at the scale of the nation can be recalibrated to hold together divergent experiences of dispossession reduces the problem to one of naming rather than organisation.</p><p class="">In this situation, the language used against social movements does a particular job. When Jan sneers at “social movementism,” or Azeem and Ali reduce decades of struggle to MRD/NGO pipelines, they are not really describing movements. They are defending the right of parties to remain central even when they are peripheral. They are protecting their own position as interpreters of a landscape they do not organise. The more a social movement demonstrates the capacity to think, act and endure without party leadership, the more vicious the labels become. Calling movements “messianic,” “sectarian,” “liberal,” “NGO,” “safe” does not further analysis.<strong> </strong>It polices the boundary of who is allowed to speak as the Left.</p><p data-rte-preserve-empty="true" class=""></p>


  










  

<figure class="sqs-quote-block-contents block-animation-site-default">
  <blockquote data-animation-role="quote"
  >
    <span>“</span>A Left committed to transformation would start from this recognition, stop demanding that movements subordinate themselves to national projects that cannot hold them<span>”</span>
  </blockquote>
  
  



</figure>



  




  



  
  <h4>A Left Removed</h4><p class="">Leadership in the Left has withdrawn from the terrains where people confront extraction, abandonment and coercion. <a href="http://www.clrjames.uk/works/facing-reality-the-new-society-where-to-look-for-it-how-to-bring-it-closer-a-statement-for-our-time/">C. L. R. James</a> described how leadership often substitutes proclamation for movement, confusing analysis with organisation and commentary with presence. This distance was exposed during the recent India–Pakistan exchange. While commentators debated principles in Lahore and Karachi, residents of Rawalakot and surrounding areas endured nightly shelling, blackouts and the disruption of daily life. Conversations with activists from Azad Kashmir revealed how artillery fire reorganised everyday routines in ways absent from metropolitan Left discourse. Leadership continues to speak from afar, avoiding the difficult, necessary work of building infrastructures of protection, mutual aid and organisation in the places where people live under fire.</p><p class="">Across Pakistan, people craft forms of coordination where the state withdraws or intensifies coercion. Neighbourhood protection networks, feminist, queer and trans collectivities, women’s groups, student solidarities, anti displacement committees, informal care infrastructures, debt sharing practices and climate relief efforts arise from necessity, not from ideological permission. These formations are prefigurative in the sense that <a href="https://www.pure.ed.ac.uk/ws/files/126552660/Raekstad_2018_Constellations.pdf">Benjamin Raekstad</a> and others describe. They emerge from improvisational practices through which people survive in hostile conditions and experiment with forms of collective life that do not wait for sanction from centralised organisations. They materialise in the ways displaced families share risk, in solidarities forged at sites of extraction, in relationships of care that move across caste and class divisions during crisis, and in refusal practices that interrupt the smooth reproduction of domination. They inhabit contradiction rather than resolve it and show that political invention arises from shared exposure rather than from the command of leadership.</p>


  



































  
  
    
  

    

    

    
      <figure class="sqs-block-image-figure intrinsic"
      >
        
      
        
          
            
            
      
        
          
          
          
          
          
          
          <img data-stretch="true" data-image="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fbccd31-5cee-4f1f-8557-1f47bf773ade/mahrang.jpeg" data-image-dimensions="2600x1682" data-image-focal-point="0.5,0.5" data-sqsp-image-classic-block-image alt="" data-licensed-asset-preview="false" data-load="false" elementtiming="system-image-block" src="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fbccd31-5cee-4f1f-8557-1f47bf773ade/mahrang.jpeg?format=1000w" width="2600" height="1682" sizes="auto, (max-width: 640px) 100vw, (max-width: 767px) 100.00vw, 100.00vw" srcset="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fbccd31-5cee-4f1f-8557-1f47bf773ade/mahrang.jpeg?format=100w 100w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fbccd31-5cee-4f1f-8557-1f47bf773ade/mahrang.jpeg?format=300w 300w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fbccd31-5cee-4f1f-8557-1f47bf773ade/mahrang.jpeg?format=500w 500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fbccd31-5cee-4f1f-8557-1f47bf773ade/mahrang.jpeg?format=750w 750w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fbccd31-5cee-4f1f-8557-1f47bf773ade/mahrang.jpeg?format=1000w 1000w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fbccd31-5cee-4f1f-8557-1f47bf773ade/mahrang.jpeg?format=1500w 1500w, https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/9fbccd31-5cee-4f1f-8557-1f47bf773ade/mahrang.jpeg?format=2500w 2500w" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-loader="sqs" data-image-component="1.0.1">
        
      
    
            <template class="js-cdk-image-lightbox-template">
  
    
      
        
          
        
      
      <a class="sqs-lightbox-close js-cdk-image-lightbox-close-button" role="button" tabindex="0" aria-label="" ></a>
      
        
          
            <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Dr Mahrang Baloch, the leader of the Baloch Yakjehti Committee (BYC), addresses the crowd in Gwadar. Image: The Guardian</em></p>
          
        
      

      
    
  
</template>

          
        
      

      
        <figcaption data-sqsp-image-classic-block-caption-container class="image-caption-wrapper"
        >
          <p data-rte-preserve-empty="true"><em>Dr Mahrang Baloch, the leader of the Baloch Yakjehti Committee (BYC), addresses the crowd in Gwadar. Image: The Guardian</em></p>
        </figcaption>
      
    
      </figure>
    

    


  

  


  
  <p class="">This is the terrain of destituent politics that <a href="https://illwill.com/on-destituent-power">Mario Tronti</a> and others have analysed. Destitution does not mean simple destruction of institutions. It names the process by which people withdraw adherence from forms that no longer hold political possibility and build relations elsewhere. In Pakistan, this appears when movements bypass party structures to organise legal defence, mutual aid, strike funds and protest camps, when they refuse to recognise courts, commissions or negotiations that function only to delay and deflect, and when they create their own protocols for protection and accountability. The party form is not abolished by decree. It is left behind in practice.</p><p class="">The crisis of Pakistan’s Left does not begin with theoretical confusion. It begins with the distance between where people build political capacity and where leadership situates itself. Movements confronting land extraction, debt, disappearances, policing, ecological destruction, queer and trans precarity and gendered violence already produce analyses that exceed metropolitan commentary. They do not need to be folded into pre-existing lines. They need organisations willing to stand inside them. A Left committed to transformation would start from this recognition, stop demanding that movements subordinate themselves to national projects that cannot hold them, and join the plebeian terrain where people are already organising against dispossession and repression, allowing those struggles to reorder what leadership imagines politics to be.</p><p class="">The Pakistani state organises life through extraction, coercion and abandonment. Movements organise life through care, refusal and invention. A Left serious about transformation would begin from this distinction. It would step into the exposures where struggle unfolds, confront its own distance from the terrain and abandon exhausted organisational forms. Pakistan is already undergoing this reconfiguration. The question is whether those who speak in the name of the Left are prepared to catch up.</p>


  











  <hr />
  

  





  
  <p class=""><strong><em>Sher Ali Khan</em></strong><em> is a researcher, journalist, and organizer whose work examines how crisis, capital, and state power shape differentiated life in Pakistan and the broader Global South. He is also the creator and host of the Organic Filaments Network, a platform for rigorous political and theoretical conversations with scholars, organizers, and movements.</em></p>]]></content:encoded><media:content type="image/jpeg" url="https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/6029d50f0b4b332aaec50a8c/1769349657267-24I6CJHFOKR2LUVH2H0K/830463F6-CAE5-4734-B2EE-E150ACE15651.JPG?format=1500w" medium="image" isDefault="true" width="1500" height="844"><media:title type="plain">Destituting the Party: The Crisis of the Pakistani Left</media:title></media:content></item></channel></rss>