After having some time to digest the roster, I wanted to share a few thoughts about the 2010 Steelers.

Overall thoughts:

I go into every season thinking that the Steelers are going to win the Super Bowl.  I’m just that kind of fan.  Everybody is 0-0, so why be pessimistic?  Sure, the Steelers didn’t make the playoffs last year, but they were Super Bowl champs the prior year.  Have they really changed that much?

In some ways, we are actually stronger than the team that won the Super Bowl.  But in other ways, we look awfully similar to the team that missed the playoffs in 2009.  Let’s take a look at the team’s strengths and weaknesses.

Strengths:

Quarterback – The quarterback position is clearly a strength for this team.  We all know what Big Ben can do.  And I was pleasantly surprised to see a very serious debate going on among Steelers fans about who should start in Ben’s absence.  Some felt that Byron Leftwich was the best choice.  Others were advocating Dennis Dixon.  Still others felt that Charlie Batch was the way to go.

The way that I see it is that the Steelers have 4 very capable quarterbacks.  Any one of them can lead their team to a win in the NFL.  Each of them has different strengths and weaknesses.  But they are all capable.  Not many teams have as backup quarterbacks that are as talented as ours.  So that is a very good problem to have.

Linebacker – The Steelers have always been known for having great linebackers.  And this year’s linebackers are as good as any in recent memory.  Not only are they good, but they are deep.

I was concerned that the team was going to be forced to cut one of their talented rookie linebackers in order to get the roster down to 53 players.  But they surprised me and kept 9 linebackers on the roster.  That was a great move.  I challenge you to name another team that is as strong at linebacker as the Steelers currently are.

Running back – Some believe that the Steelers are going to be more of a running team in Ben Roethlisberger’s absence.  Personally, I’m not convinced.  I don’t believe that Bruce Arians will ever allow that.  But if he did (he won’t), we have a great group of running backs to carry the load.

One of the most notable things about this group of running backs is that they are all capable of breaking runs to the outside, or getting tough yards between the tackles.  With Isaac Redman and Jonathan Dwyer added to the mix, I don’t think the Steelers are going to struggle in short yardage situations the way they did last year.

Wide receiver – This group has a good mix of youth and experience.  Hines Ward is the same dependable receiver he’s always been.  Mike Wallace is going to get a lot more opportunities, so that is going to be great for the team.  I think he is ultimately going to be a better receiver than Santonio Holmes was.  And the two rookies, Emmanuel Sanders and Antonio Brown, should both to have long, productive careers with the Steelers.  It wouldn’t surprise me if one or both of the rookies ended the year ahead of Antwaan Randle El and Arnaz Battle on the depth chart.

Defensive line – Aaron Smith is back.  Need I say more?

Weaknesses:

Defensive line – I know that I just said that the defensive line was a strength.  But it’s also a weakness.  Our line is old.  In fact, Ziggy Hood is the only defensive lineman that we have who is under 30.  That’s not good.  We have to address this problem in next year’s draft.

Offensive line – I feel like a broken record each time I say this.  But our offensive line just isn’t that good.  Max Starks tries hard, but he just isn’t quick enough to handle speed rushers.  Trai Essex wouldn’t start on most NFL teams.  And Flozell Adams is past his prime, and is a penalty waiting to happen.  By the 3rd game of the season, when Flozell has accumulated his 20th false start penalty and his 50th holding penalty, Steelers fans are going to start clamoring for a change at right tackle.

Fortunately, the Steelers drafted Maurkice Pouncey in the first round.  Pouncey is already the starter, and I anticipate nothing but good things from him for the next 10 years.

Cornerbacks – Our cornerbacks got torched last year.  They made mediocre wide receivers look like Randy Moss.  The couldn’t stop anybody.  They didn’t record their first interception until the last game of the season.  And unfortunately, they haven’t looked much better in the preseason.

The team did bring back Bryant McFadden, but McFadden didn’t record a single interception last year with the Arizona Cardinals, so he isn’t likely to help in that regard.  Hopefully, Ike Taylor will return to his old ways and will be able to stop the opponents’ best receiver.  Also, I’m hoping that either Keenan Lewis or Crezdon Butler steps up and beats out William Gay for the nickel position.

So those are my initial thoughts as I look at the players who made the Steelers’ final 2010 roster.  Do you agree or disagree.  Please leave a comment and let me know your thoughts.

(If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a comment by clicking on the square at the top right of this article. Also, please subscribe to our blog by pressing the orange button below. You can also follow us on Twitter by clicking the bird doohicky below. Also consider following us on Facebook. Thanks.)

Subscribe in a reader

Quarterbacks: Charlie Batch, Dennis Dixon, and Byron Leftwich.

Ben Roethlisberger will be added to the roster after week 4, and Charlie Batch will probably be released.  They won’t keep 4 quarterbacks.

Running backs: Rashard Mendenhall, Mewelde Moore, Isaac Redman, and Jonathan Dwyer.

I thought Stefan Logan would make the team, but it looks like the Steelers used his position to keep an extra linebacker.

Wide receivers: Hines Ward, Mike Wallace, Anwaan Randle El, Arnaz Battle, Emmanuel Sanders, and Antonio Brown.

This group is young, but very talented.

Tight ends: Heath Miller, Matt Spaeth,  & David Johnson.

Same tight ends as last year.  No surprises here.

Offensive linemen: Max Starks, Chris Kemoeatu, Maurkice Pouncey, Trai Essex, Flozell Adams, Doug Legursky, Jonathan Scott, Ramon Foster, and Tony Hills.

I predicted that the team was going to cut Justin Hartwig, and they did.  However, I thought that Kraig Urbick was going to beat out Tony Hills, but I missed on that one.

Defensive linemen: Aaron Smith, Casey Hampton, Brett Keisel, Ziggy Hood, Nick Eason, and Chris Hoke.

No real surprises here.  I did think Sunny Harris might be on the final roster, but he is not a real loss.

Linebackers: LaMarr Woodley, James Farrior, Lawrence Timmons, James Harrison, Keyaron Fox, Larry Foote, Jason Worilds, and Thaddeus Gibson, and Stevenson Sylvester.

This was probably the toughest decision for the coaches.  They always keep 8 linebackers.  But the rookies all played so well that they made it impossible to cut any of them.  So they cut Sunny Harris instead, and kept an extra linebacker.  Good for them.

Safeties: Troy Polamalu, Ryan Clark, Ryan Mundy, & Will Allen.

No surprises here either.

Cornerbacks: Ike Taylor, Bryant McFadden, William Gay,  Keenan Lewis, Anthony Madison, and Crezdon Butler.

I thought that the team would keep Joe Burnett and try to sneak Crezdon Butler onto their practice squad.  However, I guess they were happier with what they saw from Butler, because Burnett was cut.  Anthony Madison made the team just as I predicted he would.  He’s too valuable on special teams to let him go.

Specialists: Jeff Reed, Dan Sepulveda, and Greg Warren.

No surprises here.

Injured reserve: Willie Colon, Tuff Harris, Limas Sweed

Reserve/Suspended: Ben Roethlisberger

Physically unable to perform (PUP): Chris Scott

So the Steelers stayed old on the defensive line, but got much younger at wide receiver and linebacker.  Overall, this looks like a talented bunch.   I do hope that we’ll see more from the defensive backs than they showed us in the preseason.  The offensive line remains a concern, but that’s nothing new.

Overall, I am happy with the final 53-man roster.  How do you feel about it?  Leave a comment and let me know.

(If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a comment by clicking on the square at the top right of this article. Also, please subscribe to our blog by pressing the orange button below. You can also follow us on Twitter by clicking the bird doohicky below. Also consider following us on Facebook. Thanks.)

Subscribe in a reader

Quarterbacks: Charlie Batch, Dennis Dixon, and Ben Roethlisberger.

Charlie will now enter the season as the starter.  Dennis Dixon will be the back-up.   And Ben will take over after his suspension ends.  Byron will likely be placed on injured reserve.  Once he is healthy, the Steelers will have to decide between Leftwich and Batch.

Running backs: Rashard Mendenhall, Mewelde Moore, Isaac Redman, Jonathan Dwyer, Stefan Logan.

Logan should make the team despite decent performances by Antonio Brown and Emmanuel Sanders in the return game during preseason.  In my opinion, Frank Summer just didn’t do anything to help his cause.  Dwyer, on the other hand, played his way onto the roster with his performances over the past 2 preseason games.

Wide receivers: Hines Ward, Mike Wallace, Anwaan Randle El, Emmanuel Sanders, Antonio Brown.

Lots of youth on the team at wide receiver.  But these kids have played well.  Emmanuel Sanders and Antonio Brown are the real deal.  And we all know what Mike Wallace can do.  So it looks like another year on the practice squad for Tyler Grisham.

Tight ends: Heath Miller, Matt Spaeth, David Johnson.

Same tight ends as last year.  I’ve never been a Matt Spaeth fan, but the Steelers don’t have anyone who can beat him out of his roster spot.

Offensive linemen: Max Starks, Chris Kemoeatu, Maurkice Pouncey, Trai Essex, Flozell Adams, Doug Legursky, Jonathan Scott, Ramon Foster, Kraig Urbick.

This is the first major roster surprise.  I don’t think that Justin Hartwig is going to make the team.  Hartwig is definitely better than Doug Legursky.  However, he makes too much for a back-up center.  Once Pouncey beat him out as the starter, Hartwig was in jeopardy.  The Steelers never really tried him at guard, so that said to me that his time as a Steeler was over.

Kraig Urbick still hasn’t shown much, but he is still a young player.  Tony Hills, on the other hand, has been around for a year longer than Urbick, and he hasn’t shown anything either.  So he loses by default.

Defensive linemen: Aaron Smith, Casey Hampton, Brett Keisel, Ziggy Hood, Nick Eason, Chris Hoke, and Sunny Harris.

Personally, I think that Doug Worthington has more long-term potential than Sunny Harris.  However, Harris has more time in the defense, and he understands it better.  The Steelers lost Harris to free agency last year, so they probably won’t take the risk of losing him again this year.  Nick Eason and Chris Hoke are both veterans in the system, and they both had good preseasons.  So they are probably safe despite their age.  That leaves Worthington on the outside.

Linebackers: LaMarr Woodley, James Farrior, Lawrence Timmons, James Harrison, Keyaron Fox, Larry Foote, Jason Worilds, and Stevenson Sylvester.

In my opinion, linebacker is the toughest position to choose.  We have so many talented linebackers right now.  Frankly, I played with the idea of cutting James Farrior, but I just don’t think the Steelers are going to do that.  Jason Worilds is a lock.  And Stevenson Sylvester played so well during preseason that I believe he forced the Steelers to make a decision that they hadn’t planned on making.  I believe that the team wanted to keep Thaddeus Gibson, but Sylvester outplayed him during preseason.  That leaves Thaddeus Gibson as the odd man out.

Don’t get me wrong, I hate this scenario.  I loved what I saw from Thaddeus Gibson during training camp.  The guy has the potential to be a future star.  But I don’t believe the team will keep more than 8 linebackers.

Remember, I am trying to guess what the Steelers will do.  If it were up to me, Farrior would be cut, Keyaron Fox would start, and Thaddeus Gibson would be on the roster.

One possible option here is to cut Stefan Logan, and to give his roster spot to Thaddeus Gibson.  Then the team would have to rely on Antonio Brown or Emmanuel Sanders for return duty.

Safeties: Troy Polamalu, Ryan Clark, Ryan Mundy,  Will Allen.

Not a lot of competition at safety.  Frankly, I wish there were more.  I’m still not in love with  Mundy, and Clark is getting old and had a poor season last year.   But we have to go with what we have, so these are the safeties.

Cornerbacks: Ike Taylor, Bryant McFadden, William Gay, Joe Burnett, Keenan Lewis, Anthony Madison.

Keenan Lewis almost played his way off of the roster due to his performance against the Denver Broncos.  However, he redeemed himself in the final game against the Panthers.

It pains me to say that William Gay is going to be on the roster, but I don’t see any chance of him getting cut.

I believe that Crezdon Butler has more potential than Gay, and is currently a better cornerback than Anthony Madison.  However, Madison is a valuable special teams player.  The team probably believes that they can slip Butler onto their practice squad.

Specialists: Jeff Reed, Dan Sepulveda, and Greg Warren.

No surprises here.  However, I think the team will abandon the experiment of letting Sepulveda do kickoffs.  I think that we will see Jeff Reed kicking off, just like we have in past years.

So that’s my final 53.  The Steelers will be announcing theirs later today.  Which names do you agree with, and which ones do you disagree with?  Let me hear it.

(If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a comment by clicking on the square at the top right of this article. Also, please subscribe to our blog by pressing the orange button below. You can also follow us on Twitter by clicking the bird doohicky below. Also consider following us on Facebook. Thanks.)

Subscribe in a reader

In the 1st quarter, the Steelers started Ben Roethlisberger.  The team wanted to get him some final snaps prior to his suspension.  The coaches said that they wanted to get him more snaps in the “no huddle” offense as a final tune-up.

After Roethlisberger played two series, he was replaced by Byron Leftwich.  Leftwich was presumed to be the Steelers’ starting quarterback going into the regular season.  However, things can change quickly.

On his second series, Leftwich sustained a knee injury and had to leave the game.  MRI results haven’t been reported yet, but it is believed that the injury may be serious enough to prevent Leftwich from playing for at least two games.  If that’s the case, then the Steelers quarterback plans have suddenly been turned upside down.

Dennis Dixon had been battling Leftwich to see who would be the starting quarterback in Big Ben’s absence.  But once Leftwich got injured, the team immediately started questioning their quarterback situation.  Fourth string quarterback Charlie Batch, who has barely gotten any snaps during training camp or the preseason, suddenly emerged as a potential starter.

Charlie Batch & Dennis Dixon

After Dennis Dixon’s poor showing against the Denver Broncos, the Steelers are probably reluctant to name him as the starter.  So Charlie Batch, who was probably going to be cut from the team, is now the most seasoned quarterback the Steelers have available to them.  More importantly, he may emerge as the starter.

Batch played the majority of the second half, though he mainly handed the ball off to the running backs.  After Leftwich’s injury, the Steelers didn’t want to take any more chances with quarterbacks, so the called almost no passing plays.

The final score of the game was 19-3.  However, after losing Leftwich, winning the game didn’t seem very satisfying.

Despite the bad news from the game, there were a few bright spots worth noting.  Rookie running back Jonathan Dwyer got a lot of playing time at running back, and he capitalized on it.  Dwyer carried the ball 20 times for 86 yards.  He led the team in rushing yards.  He was also the rushing leader in last week’s game against Denver.

Dwyer had been in jeopardy of not making the team, after sitting out most of training camp with injuries.  But his recent performances may have won him a roster spot.

Another player who may have redeemed himself is Keenan Lewis.  Lewis almost played himself out of a job last week when he lost his head and got called for several penalties.  Coach Tomlin chewed Lewis out for his performance and benched him for the rest of the game.

But Lewis played well against the Panthers.  He didn’t allow his man to catch any passes, and he seemed to be in the right place on most plays.

The Steelers have to submit their final 53-man roster to the NFL by Saturday, so they must make some very tough decisions over the next 48 hours.  Prior to Thursday’s game, the quarterback position looked like one of the easiest roster decision.  Now, it is suddenly one of the more difficult decisions for the coaches.

Stay tuned.

(If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a comment by clicking on the square at the top right of this article. Also, please subscribe to our blog by pressing the orange button below. You can also follow us on Twitter by clicking the bird doohicky below. Also consider following us on Facebook. Thanks.)

Subscribe in a reader

The most well known of the players who was cut was veteran linebacker Andre Frazier.  Frazier has been a backup linebacker for the Steelers for many years.  He has primarily played special teams, but he has also played as a backup linebacker as well.

Frazier got hurt this summer and was placed on the injured reserve list.  However, linebacker is going to be one of the hardest positions to make the team at this year.  The Steelers brought back Larry Foote, and then they also drafted 3 rookies who are all challenging the veterans for a roster spots.  So backup linebackers like Andre Frazier and Patrick Bailey were going to have a difficult time remaining with the team unless they had an outstanding training camp and preseason.  Once Frazier got hurt, his chances of remaining with the team went out the window.

The team also cut fullback Dwayne Wright, guard Adrian Jones, linebacker Brandon Renkart, and cornerback David Pittman.

In another move, rookie offensive lineman Chris Scott was placed on the reserve/physically unable to perform list.

This was the easy cut.  None of these players are going to be missed.  The next one is going to be much more difficult.  I am waiting anxiously to see how the linebacker position shakes out.  There are some very difficult decisions that are going to have to be made.

(If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a comment by clicking on the square at the top right of this article. Also, please subscribe to our blog by pressing the orange button below. You can also follow us on Twitter by clicking the bird doohicky below. Also consider following us on Facebook. Thanks.)

Subscribe in a reader

Some of the penalties were understandable.  Those we can forgive.  But others were just inexcusable.  For example, will somebody please tell Flozell Adams that he’s not supposed to move until AFTER the ball is snapped.  He seems to have a fundamental misunderstanding of that concept.  Instead of Flozell “The Hotel” Adams, his nickname should be Flozell “Off-sides” Adams.

Other penalties were just plain stupid.  Like Keenan Lewis getting a personal foul for retaliating on a wide receiver who was talking trash to him.  Immediately after the play, Coach Tomlin called Lewis to the sideline and chewed him out.  I couldn’t tell what Tomlin was saying, but the fact that he grabbed Lewis by the collar and held him the whole time that he was talking to him indicated to me that he wasn’t giving him compliments about his excellent technique.  As if we needed even more proof that Tomlin wasn’t happy, he sent lewis to the bench following their “discussion”.

Lawrence Timmons also got in on the blunders with his silly roughing the quarterback penalty.  Ummmm Lawrence, if you’re going to throw the quarteback to the ground, please try to do it a little sooner.  Doing it 30 seconds after the whistle blows is usually going to draw a penalty.

But even without the rash of penalties, the Steelers just didn’t play well.  The Broncos’ offense seemed to be able to move the ball at will.  And they did it on the ground and through the air.  The Steelers’ defense looked eerily like the 2009 version that couldn’t stop anybody.

The quarterbacks also looked bad.  It’s never a good thing when Charlie Batch looks like the best quarterback on the roster.  But that’s exactly how it looked last night.

Dennis Dixon learned the hard way that it is a lot tougher playing against the opponent’s first string defense than it is going against their 3rd string defense.  He threw two costly interceptions that probably cooled off the throng of fans who had been calling for Coach Tomlin to name Dixon as the starter during Ben Roethlisberger’s suspension.

Unfortunately, Byron Leftwich didn’t look much better.  So it looks like the quarterback race is going to go all the way down to the wire.   Byron Leftwich and Dennis Dixon will have one final preseason game in which to make their case to be the starter.

Despite the many bad things that happened during the game, there were also some very good things that happened.  Probably the most important was that rookie center Maurkice Pouncey made his first start at the position.  Moreover, he did quite well.  Most centers don’t have to make their first start against Jamal Williams.  Williams is a 350 pound monster who is a perennial Pro Bowler, and one of the most feared nose tackles in the NFL.  But Pouncey held his own, and completely neutralized Williams.

Another bright spot was rookie running back Jonathan Dwyer.  Dwyer was injured for most of training camp, so fans and coaches haven’t really gotten to see what he can do.  Because he hasn’t been able to perform, he was in jeopardy of not making the team.  However, he had a great showing last night.  He led the team in rushing with 89 yards on 13 carries.  But even more impressive than the actual yardage was the way that he got them.  He had three long runs of 17, 18, and 40 yards.  He also had several runs where he showed that he can be a very physical runner as well.  On one particular play, he seemed to carry at least 3 or 4 tacklers for almost 10 yards before they finally brought him down.  That is what Steelers fans have been longing to see since Jerome Bettis retired.

The Steelers have one final preseason game in which to evaluate players.  Hopefully, that game will not feature as many penalties and stupid plays as we saw Sunday night.

(If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a comment by clicking on the square at the top right of this article. Also, please subscribe to our blog by pressing the orange button below. You can also follow us on Twitter by clicking the bird doohicky below. Also consider following us on Facebook. Thanks.)

Subscribe in a reader

The age question is simply this; should a team stick with an established veteran who is in the latter stages of his career, or should they give a young player an opportunity to gain experience and prove what he can do?

The age question is as old as sports itself.  And to be honest, there is usually no “right” answer to the question.

The Green Bay Packers faced this question when they had to decide between future Hall-of-Famer Brett Favre and the talented young Aaron Rodgers.

The San Francisco 49ers eventually got to a point where they had to choose between the aging Joe Montana and the heir-apparent, Steve Young.

Through most of the Bill Cowher era, and into the Mike Tomlin era, the Steelers have tended to be a patient bunch.  Young players have not been called upon to perform as rookies.  And the team often stuck with older players when their was a talented younger player waiting in the wings.  A prime example of this was James Harrison.  In my opinion, James Harrison was better than Joey Porter for the final 1.5 years of Porter’s tenure with the Steelers.  If you watched him in training camp, it was obvious that Harrison was unstoppable.  Yet, Cowher proved to be very loyal to the veteran Joey Porter.  Once Harrison was finally given his shot, the rest of the NFL got to see what I was seeing in him at practice.  And a star was born.

As we look at the roster battles that are currently taking place with the Steelers, I see quite a few  “youth versus experience” questions arising for the Steelers coaching staff.

The most obvious of these age questions is at quarterback.  Should the Steelers go with the proven veteran, Byron Leftwich, during Ben Roethlisberger’s absence, or should they give Dennis Dixon some valuable regular season playing experience?  Quarterback is a crucial position, and most coaches tend to be more comfortable with experienced leadership at the position.  But how is a talented young player like Dennis Dixon supposed to get experience if the coaches won’t let him play?

Dixon is making a strong case for himself during the preseason, but despite his best efforts, the coaches may still decided that experience counts  most.

Similar battles are occurring at other positions as well.  Take the defensive line for example.  Aaron Smith and Brett Keisel are both on the wrong side of 30.  The Steelers used a first round draft pick to select Ziggy Hood.  Yet, Ziggy’s playing time has been limited because Smith and Keisel are so solid at their positions.  Aaron Smith’s injury did give Hood more opportunities to play last year, but even when those opportunities arose, Dick LeBeau often chose to play the more experienced Nick Eason and Travis Kirschke over Ziggy Hood.

The Steelers also have Sunny Harris and Doug Worthington fighting for roster spots on the defensive line.  I’ve never been a fan of Sunny Harris, but I really like what I’ve seen from Doug Worthington so far.  Unfortunately, Nick Eason is outplaying Worthington so far in preseason.  Eason is already 30 years old, and it seems unlikely that he’ll ever be a starter for the Steelers.  So should the team hold a roster spot for the older veteran, Eason, who likely won’t be with the team 2 years from now, or should they hold onto one of the younger players who may become just as good, but who will potentially be with the team for the next 10 years?  With what Worthington has already shown in training camp, and with his Ohio State pedigree, he is unlikely to make it through waivers if the Steelers try to sneak him onto the practice squad.  So it’s likely that they will lose him if they don’t keep him on the 53-man roster.  And the team already lost Sunny Harris to the Carolina Panthers last year.  Do they want to take the risk of losing him again?

On the offensive line, the Steelers have struggled for years.  And it looks like rookie Maurkice Pouncey is going to be given an opportunity to start.  However, other tough decisions are going to have to be made.  Is Trai Essex that much better than Kraig Urbick or Ramon Foster?  Is Jusin Hartwig that much better than Doug Legursky?

At wide receiver, the Steelers also have major questions.  With the loss of Santonio Holmes, Hines Ward is the only veteran that is guaranteed a roster spot.  Mike Wallace only has one year under his belt, so despite the fact that he had a great season last year, he is still very young and inexperienced.  Rookie Emmanual Sanders has shown enough in training camp and preseason that he is almost assured of a roster spot.  So that’s even more inexperience at the position.  In my opinion, Antonio Brown has looked better than Antwaan Randle El at training camp and in the preseason.  But can the team afford to have him ahead of Randle El since they already have so much youth at the wide receiver position?  And should they keep the much more seasoned Arnaz Battle at the expense of young Tyler Grisham?

Perhaps the most difficult roster battle will occur at linebacker.  James Harrison, LaMarr Woodley, James Farrior, and Lawrence Timmons are guaranteed roster spots.  The Steelers also have Keyaron Fox, who is a special teams ace,  and who often plays better than Lawrence Timmon when he plays in his place.   They also brought back former Steelers LB Larry Foote.  Foote was allowed to leave as a free agent two years ago because he was getting a little long in the tooth.  And now he is back, but he is even older than he was the first time.

Any other year, this would be a great group of linebackers to enter the season with.  However, the Steelers also have 3 rookie linebackers who are making strong cases for themselves.  Jason Worilds, Thaddeus Gibson, and Stevenson Sylvester have all shown glimpses of potential greatness.  Yet it is unlikely that the team will be able to keep all three of them.  So the coaching staff is going to be forced to make some very difficult decisions.

To make matters even more difficult for the coaches, the Rooney family has asked the coaches to do a better job of finding playing time for the younger players.

Cutting the roster down to the final 53 players is always difficult.  However, this year it will probably be even more difficult than it usually is.  And the burning question on everybody’s mind will be, “should we choose youth or experience?”

(If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a comment by clicking on the square at the top right of this article. Also, please subscribe to our blog by pressing the orange button below. You can also follow us on Twitter by clicking the bird doohicky below. Also consider following us on Facebook. Thanks.)

Subscribe in a reader

Though Eli Manning didn’t play, one quarterback who DID play was Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger.  Big Ben did not play in the Steelers first preseason game, but he was the starter for this game.

Ben looked a bit rusty, and the rust was evident in his statistics.  Roethlisberger completed 6 of 8 passes for 76 yards.  However he was sacked once, and he threw an interception during his short time in the game.  And as he usually does, Big Ben held onto the ball waaaaaaay too long.  Because of this, he was often running for his life.  The Steelers’ porous offensive line didn’t help the situation.  New York Giants players were constantly in the Steelers’ backfield applying pressure.

Big Ben passes under pressure.

Big Ben ended his short stint in the game with a sub-par 64.6 quarterback rating, the lowest among the three Steelers’ quarterbacks who played during the game.

When the second quarter began, Roethlisberger was replaced by Byron Leftwich at quarterback.  Like Roethlisberger, Leftwich was constantly under pressure.  However, unlike Roethlisberger, Leftwich got rid of the ball.

On one play in particular, Leftwich made a play which we seldom see from Roethlisberger.  Leftwich saw speedy wide receiver Mike Wallace racing down the field, and he threw the ball past him so that Wallace could run under the ball and catch it in stride.  Steelers fans have gotten used to seeing Roethlisberger under-throw Wallace on his deep routes so Wallace usually has to come back to the ball rather than catch it in stride.  Because Wallace was able to catch the ball in stride, the play resulted in a 68 yard touchdown.

Leftwich played the entire second quarter, and completed 3 of six passes for 95 yards and a touchdown.  His final quarterback rating was 135.4, the highest among the three Steelers’ quarterbacks.

In the second half, Dennis Dixon started at quarterback, and he played the entire half.  Just like he did against the Detroit Lions, Dixon appeared to be the most effective of the Steelers’ quarterbacks.  He marched the team down the field for touchdowns on both of his first two offensive series.  Dixon also provided a running threat that neither of the other quarterbacks offer.  On one play, Dixon broke a 22 yard run that he probably could have gotten into the end zone.  However he was running along the sideline, and his momentum carried him out of bounds.

Dixon completed 7 of the 8 passes that he attempted.  He ended the game with 82 passing yards and a 109.4 quarterback rating.

So just like in the Steelers’ first preseason game, Dennis Dixon made a strong argument for why he, rather than Byron Leftwich, should be the Steelers starter during Ben Roethlisberger’s 4-6 game suspension.

Steelers’ Head Coach Mike Tomlin may ultimately decide to go with Leftwich as the starter, but Dixon is certainly making his decision much more difficult than he anticipated.

Other points of interest:

• Punter Dan Sepulveda handled all of the kick-offs for the Steelers’ second preseason game.  Sepulveda practiced kick-offs regularly during Steelers Training Camp, but was not called upon to kick-off during the team’s first preseason game against the Detroit Lions.  Several of Sepulveda’s kicks seemed short.  However, he did get 2 of his 6 kick-offs into the end zone, and one was downed for a touchback.  Last week, Jeff Reed only got one of his 5 kicks into the endzone, and none were downed for touchbacks.

• Rookie Antonio Brown handled the majority of the Steelers’ kick and punt return duties last night.  He averaged 10.8 yards on 4 punt returns, the longest of which was for 18 yards.  He also averaged 25 yards on 2 kickoff returns.

• Isaac Redman once again made a strong case for being the backup to starting running back Rashard Mendenhall.  Redman rushed for 34 yards on six carries.  He also scored a touchdown.

Isaac Redman scores TD.

• Justin Vincent was the Steelers’ leading rusher with 37 yards on 6 carries.  However, most of his carries came in the 2nd half against the Giants’ second and third string defenses

• Rashard Mendenhall didn’t look particularly impressive running the ball.  He carried the ball 8 times for a total of 11 yards.  His 1.4 yards per carry was the lowest among the Steelers’ running backs.  He also continues to do that annoying spin move anytime he senses contact coming.  Mendenhall almost seems reluctant to face contact head-on.

• Steelers’ cornerback Ike Taylor was ejected from the game after getting in a fight in the opening minutes of the game.  Dumb, Ike.  Really dumb.

(If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a comment by clicking on the square at the top right of this article. Also, please subscribe to our blog by pressing the orange button below. You can also follow us on Twitter by clicking the bird doohicky below. Also consider following us on Facebook. Thanks.)

Subscribe in a reader

Most Steelers fans thought that the wide receiver position was going to be a glaring weakness for the team after the loss of Santonio Holmes.  But surprisingly, I think that the exact opposite is true.  In my opinion, the wide receiver position is going to be one of the team’s greatest strengths this year.

Don’t get me wrong.  The loss of Santonio Holmes definitely hurts.  Holmes was our best receiver after the catch last year.  Holmes was the receiver who was the most elusive after getting the ball in his hands.  Holmes also seemed to be the receiver who worked best with Ben Roethlisberger when Big Ben was scrambling and playing “sandlot football”.

But the Steelers drafted two receivers in the NFL Draft, and then they brought in several free agents, and suddenly, a weakness is looking like a strength.  In fact, I think that this is the position that is going to give coaches the most difficult time when it comes time to decide who will make the final 53-man roster.

Let’s look at the receivers.

Hines Ward – Everyone knows who Hines Ward is.  He holds just about every Steelers receiving record.  This will be Ward’s 13th season in the NFL.  James Farrior is the only Steelers player who has been in the league longer.  However, Ward’s game has never depended on speed or athleticism, so age seems to affect him less than it would other receivers.  Ward will probably lead the team in receiving this year too.

Mike Wallace – This is the player that I am more excited about than anyone else on the Steelers’ roster.  Wallace was amazing last year.  And Santonio Holmes’ departure will mean even more opportunities for Wallace.  Wallace led the entire NFL in yards/catch.  That’s pretty good for a rookie.  Oh yeah, and he also had more touchdowns than a certain receiver who now plays for the NY Jets.  Santonio who?

Wallace was able to rely strictly on his speed last year, since he was typically facing the opposition’s #3 cornerback.  This year, he will be facing the opponent’s top cornerback, so he is going to have to be much more precise in his route running and in his receiving technique.  Wallace has been focusing on this throughout training camp.

Antwaan Randle El – Like Santonio Holmes, Randle El is best remembered for one heroic play in a Steelers’ Super Bowl victory.  But aside from that one play, Randle El’s career as a wide receiver has been rather ordinary.  He has never come close to having 1,000 receiving yards in a season.  He has never scored more than 4 touchdowns in a season.  Last season, he didn’t score a single touchdown despite playing in all 16 games for the Redskins.

When they signed him, I was pretty certain that Randle El was going to be the #3 receiver for the Steelers this season.  But now, after watching all of the receivers in training camp, I am not 100% certain that Randle El will make the final 53-man roster.

Tyler Grisham – I was probably the biggest advocate of Tyler Grisham last season.  I was the first media outlet to write about him.  Moreover, I predicted that the Steelers would keep him on the practice squad before most people had even heard of him.

Tyler Grisham at training camp.

Grisham is still the same gritty, “give it 110%” player that I saw last year.  However, the Steelers have so much talent at wide receiver this year, that I don’t think Grisham has any chance of making the team.  He may be kept on the practice squad like he was last year.  But the Steelers have some VERY TALENTED young players in training camp.  I just don’t see Grisham being able to beat them out for a roster spot.

Emmanuel Sanders – This kid has been the star of Steelers Training Camp.  Take my word for it.  He’s good.  Very good.  If you didn’t read my review of him following the NFL Draft, please click here.

Emmanuel Sanders lines up.

Sanders is both fast and quick.  He has great hands, and he has a knack for getting open.  The impressive thing is that I have seen him catch quite a few passes from Ben Roethlisberger and Byron Leftwich during training camp.  That means that the coaches have been playing him with the first team at times.  Not many rookies get that opportunity.  If I were picking the Steelers’ final roster right now, I would take Emmanuel Sanders ahead of Antwaan Randle El.

Isaiah Williams – Williams is the only wide receiver on the Steelers roster who did not play in the preseason game against the Detroit Lions.  That probably says a lot.  I have been impressed by Williams during training camp.  However, there is so much talent at the wide receiver position, that he has just not been able to separate himself from the crowd.  Sorry Isaiah, but you chose the wrong year to be in Steelers Training Camp.

Brandon London – This kid has been the Tyler Grisham of this year’s training camp.  He has played with incredible consistency.  He’s not the fastest receiver on the field, but he is clearly the tallest wide receiver in training camp.  At 6’4″, he towers over all of the other receivers.  And we all know that Big Ben prefers tall receivers, so this may work in London’s favor.

I really like what I’ve seen from London.  But I don’t think that he’s done enough to beat out all of the competition at his position.  He’s too good to simply let him go, but he’s not quite ready for prime time.  I’m going to predict that the Steelers will keep him on the practice squad.  However, because this is technically London’s 3rd year in the league (he was on the Miami Dolphin’s roster in 2008, but was out of the league in 2009), I will have to check the rules to see if he is eligible for the practice squad.

Arnaz Battle – Arnaz Battle’s primary value to the Steelers is as a special teams player.  However, fans got to see what Battle can do as a receiver in the preseason game against the Lions.  Battle caught a 51 yard reception that definitely caught the attention of Steelers fans.

Fans tend to get overly excited about individual plays that are made during preseason.  So to bring them back to earth, I have to mention that this is Battle’s 8th season in the NFL.  He spent the last 7 years with the San Francisco 49ers.  He is a seasoned veteran, but his best years are behind him.

Antonio Brown – Like Emmanuel Sanders, this rookie has been lighting it up at Steelers Training Camp.  I don’t think that he is a well-regarded as Sanders is, because I have rarely seen him practicing on the same unit as Ben Roethlisberger.  Instead, Brown almost always practices with Dennis Dixon.  But this may work to his advantage.  Brown has clearly become Dennis Dixon’s favorite target.  And with the impressive showing that Dixon had against the Lions, there is a possibility that Dixon may actually be the starting quarterback for the Steelers’ first 4 games.  If that is the case, then being his favorite receiver should work in Brown’s favor.

Antonio Brown works with Dennis Dixon.

If you didn’t read my review of Antonio Brown following the NFL Draft, please click here.

As I said earlier, the Steelers are going to have a lot of talent at wide receiver this year.  However, they are not going to have a lot of experience at the position.  It should be interesting.  Stay tuned.

(If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a comment by clicking on the square at the top right of this article. Also, please subscribe to our blog by pressing the orange button below. You can also follow us on Twitter by clicking the bird doohicky below. Also consider following us on Facebook. Thanks.)

Subscribe in a reader

The question that most fans were asking going into the game was “who will play quarterback?”  The answer was a bit of a surprise.  Ben Roethlisberger didn’t play at all.  He was dressed for the game, but the coaches decided not to play him.  Byron Leftwich started the game.  And just like he has in training camp, he looked a bit rusty and inaccurate.  Dennis Dixon came in to replace Leftwich, and it is fair to say that it was Dixon who led the Steelers to victory.  And just like in training camp, Charlie Batch was left with a handful of meaningless snaps.

There were high points and low points in the game.  One of the low points was the running game.  This was particularly disturbing because it was obvious that the Steelers were trying to emphasize the run.  There’s nothing more frustrating than making a concerted effort to do something, and failing at it.

The Steelers running backs seemed to be stuffed each time they tried to run the ball.  Rashard Mendenhall rushed 5 times for 2 yards.  Mewelde Moore rushed 1 time for 3 yards.  Justin Vincent rushed 1 time for 5 yards.  Jonathan Dwyer rushed 6 times for 8 yards.  The lone bright spot seemed to be Isaac Redman, who rushed 15 times for 60 yards and a touchdown.

Isaac Redman runs hard

But before you get too excited about Redman’s performance, just remember that Redman was the rushing star of last year’s preseason too.  He earned the nickname “Red Zone” because of his ability to get the ball in the endzone.  Yet, despite his effectiveness in the preseason, Frank Summers made the Steelers’ final 53-man roster, and Redman was placed on the practice squad.  So I’ve learned to temper my excitement about players who perform well in the preseason.  Apparently, the Steelers coaches see things that we don’t.  Or perhaps it’s actually the other way around.  Perhaps they don’t see what we do. 

The game was marred by a 1 hour and 13 minute delay due to rain and lightning.

But when the rain let up, it was Dennis Dixon who shined the brightest.  Dixon completed long passes to Arnaz Battle (51 yards) and Antonio Brown (68 yards).  The pass to Brown resulted in a Brown’s first NFL touchdown.  Perhaps the connection to Brown was to be expected, since anyone who has been at Steelers Training Camp has probably noticed that Brown has emerged as Dennis Dixon’s favorite target.

One disappointment was Flozell Adams.  Flozell has looked very good at training camp.  However, he looked a bit slow during last night’s game.  He gave up an obvious sack on Byron Leftwich.  Adams was looking right at the rushing defender, and he even got his hands on him, but he still ran right past Adams as though he weren’t even there.  Adams is going to have to do a lot better than that.  But overall, the Steelers quarterbacks were only sacked twice, so that’s not so bad for a first outing.

Byron Leftwich gets sacked.

Other bright spots included Rookie linebacker Stevenson Sylvester and Ryan Clark.  Sylvester seemed to be all over the field.  He led the team with 4 tackles and 3 assists.  Clark picked up an interception, something that the Steelers seemed unable to do last season.

Based on this game, I can already hear some Steelers fans calling for Dennis Dixon to be named the starter when the regular season starts.  I would caution them to temper their excitement.  There are still 3 more preseason games remaining.  Just as he played well this game, he could play terribly next game.  It is probably best to judge every player based on their body of work over all 4 preseason games, rather than rushing to judgment after only one game.

It’s obvious that there are still things that the Steelers need to work on.  Despite the interception by Ryan Clark, the secondary got sliced to pieces by Matthew Stafford.  None of the cornerbacks looked like playmakers.  That is exactly what we saw last season.  So fans are going to want to see that change before the regular season starts.

The bottom line is that the Steelers got the win, and that is what really counts.  But the coaches are going to have some things to work on once they look at the film of the game.  But of course, that’s exactly what the preseason is for.  Personally, I’m just ecstatic to see the Steelers on the field again.

Here we go Steelers, here we go!

(If you enjoyed this article, please consider leaving a comment by clicking on the square at the top right of this article. Also, please subscribe to our blog by pressing the orange button below. You can also follow us on Twitter by clicking the bird doohicky below. Also consider following us on Facebook. Thanks.)

Subscribe in a reader