<!doctype html>
<html lang="en-us">
  <head>
    <meta charset="utf-8">
    <title data-react-helmet="true">Error: 400</title>
		
<!-- OneCount tracker -->
  <script id="oc-widget-main" src="//validate.onecount.net/js/all.min.js#b25436a6ddd683837f3a8f5386d49a80464e90de"></script>
<!-- End OneCount tracker -->

<!-- check consent -->
  <script>
  function getConsent(name) {
    var dc = document.cookie;
    var prefix = name + "=";
    var begin = dc.indexOf("; " + prefix);
    if (begin == -1) {
        begin = dc.indexOf(prefix);
        if (begin != 0) return null;
    } else {
        begin += 2;
        var end = document.cookie.indexOf(";", begin);
        if (end == -1) {
        end = dc.length;
        }
    }

    return decodeURI(dc.substring(begin + prefix.length, end));
  }
  </script>
<!-- check consent -->

<!-- Google Tag Manager Data Layer -->
<script>
  var consentCookieValueAsBoolean = (getConsent('consent') === 'true');
  dataLayer = [{
    consent: consentCookieValueAsBoolean
  }];
</script>
<!-- /Google Tag Mananger Data Layer -->

<!-- Google Tag Manager -->
<script>(function(w,d,s,l,i){w[l]=w[l]||[];w[l].push({'gtm.start':
new Date().getTime(),event:'gtm.js'});var f=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0],
j=d.createElement(s),dl=l!='dataLayer'?'&l='+l:'';j.async=true;j.src=
'https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id='+i+dl;f.parentNode.insertBefore(j,f);
})(window,document,'script','dataLayer','GTM-NMWSH2N');</script>
<!-- End Google Tag Manager -->
<script type="text/javascript">var _sf_startpt=(new Date()).getTime()</script>
<!-- Newrelic -->
<!-- NREUM: (0) -->
<!-- /Newrelic -->

<!-- start DFP: htlbid  -->
<script src="https://htlbid.com/v3/newrepublic.com/htlbid.js"></script>
<script>
  var htlbid = htlbid || {};
  htlbid.cmd = htlbid.cmd || [];
</script>
<!-- end DFP -->

<!-- Favicons -->
  <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="57x57" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/apple-touch-icon-57x57.png">
  <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="60x60" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/apple-touch-icon-60x60.png">
  <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="72x72" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/apple-touch-icon-72x72.png">
  <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="76x76" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/apple-touch-icon-76x76.png">
  <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="114x114" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/apple-touch-icon-114x114.png">
  <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="120x120" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/apple-touch-icon-120x120.png">
  <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="144x144" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/apple-touch-icon-144x144.png">
  <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="152x152" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/apple-touch-icon-152x152.png">
  <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="180x180" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/apple-touch-icon-180x180.png">
  <link rel="icon" type="image/png" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/favicon-32x32.png" sizes="32x32">
  <link rel="icon" type="image/png" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/favicon-194x194.png" sizes="194x194">
  <link rel="icon" type="image/png" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/favicon-96x96.png" sizes="96x96">
  <link rel="icon" type="image/png" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/android-chrome-192x192.png" sizes="192x192">
  <link rel="icon" type="image/png" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/favicon-16x16.png" sizes="16x16">
  <link rel="manifest" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/manifest.json">
  <link rel="mask-icon" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/safari-pinned-tab.svg" color="#000000">
  <link rel="shortcut icon" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/favicon.ico">
  <meta name="msapplication-TileColor" content="#ffffff">
  <meta name="msapplication-TileImage" content="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/mstile-144x144.png">
  <meta name="msapplication-config" content="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/favicons/browserconfig.xml">
  <meta name="theme-color" content="#ffffff">
<!-- /Favicons -->

<!-- Start: OneCount Automation Widget -->
<script>GCN.onecount.setTargeting();</script>
<!-- End: OneCount Automation Widget -->

		<meta data-react-helmet="true" name="description" content="This link is broken, but the democratic experiment endures."/><meta data-react-helmet="true" property="og:url" content="https://newrepublic.com/"/><meta data-react-helmet="true" property="og:title" content="Error: 400"/><meta data-react-helmet="true" name="twitter:title" content="Error: 400"/><meta data-react-helmet="true" property="og:description" content="This link is broken, but the democratic experiment endures."/><meta data-react-helmet="true" name="twitter:description" content="This link is broken, but the democratic experiment endures."/><meta data-react-helmet="true" property="og:type" content="website"/><meta data-react-helmet="true" property="og:image" content="https://images.newrepublic.com/f5acdc0030e3212e601040dd24d5c2c0c684b15f.png?w=1109&amp;q=65&amp;dpi=1&amp;fit=crop&amp;crop=faces&amp;h=577"/><meta data-react-helmet="true" name="twitter:image" content="https://images.newrepublic.com/f5acdc0030e3212e601040dd24d5c2c0c684b15f.png?w=1024&amp;q=65&amp;dpi=1&amp;fit=crop&amp;crop=faces&amp;h=512"/><meta data-react-helmet="true" property="og:site_name" content="The New Republic"/><meta data-react-helmet="true" name="twitter:site" content="@newrepublic"/><meta data-react-helmet="true" property="og:locale" content="en_US"/>
		<link data-react-helmet="true" rel="canonical" href="https://newrepublic.com/"/>
    <link rel="stylesheet" href="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/newmain-965377ab97ceabbacc6d.css"/>
  </head>
  <body>
    
<style>
div.ie-popup {
  display:none;
}
@media all and (-ms-high-contrast: none), (-ms-high-contrast: active) {
  /* IE10+ only */

  div.ie-popup {
    display:block;
    position: fixed;
    z-index: 10;
    bottom: 0;
    width: 100%;
    height: 100%;
    background: rgba(154, 151, 151, 0.88);
    animation: fadeIn 0.25s ease-out 1s 1 backwards;
  }
  .ie-popup-inner {
    position: absolute;
    top: calc(50% + 2rem);
    left: 50%;
    transform: translate(-50%, -50%);
    max-width: 500px;
    max-height: 500px;
    width: 100%;
    height: 100%;
    background: #302E2E;
    color: white;
    font-family: Lava Std;
    padding: 5.0em 2.5em 4.0em 3.5em;
    line-height: 3.2rem;
    border-radius: 50%;
    font-size: 34px;
  }
  div.ie-popup-inner a {
    color: #FF8200;
    text-decoration: underline;
  }
  div.ie-popup-strike {
    margin: 0.8em -1em 0.8em 0;
    background-image: url("https://images.newrepublic.com/6298424db74112859091c134816474ddcdc13b4f.png");
    background-size: cover;
    padding-top: 4.75%;
    font: inherit;
    vertical-align: baseline;
  }
  div.ie-popup-inner p {
    font-family: "lava", Georgia, serif;
    letter-spacing: -0.005em;
    margin-bottom: 1em;
    line-height: 1.3;
    font-size: 1.8rem;
  }
  @media (max-width: 767px) {

    .ie-popup-inner {
      font-size: 24px;
      padding: 5.5em 1em 0 1.7em;
      border-radius:unset;
    }
    .ie-popup-inner p {
      font-size: 1.8rem;
    }
  }
}
</style>
<div class="ie-popup">
    <div class="ie-popup-inner">
    <p>Looks like you’re using a browser we don’t support.</p>
      <div class="ie-popup-strike"></div>
      <div><p>
      To improve your visit to our site, take a minute and
      <a href="https://browsehappy.com/" target=_blank>upgrade your browser.</a>
     </p> </div>
    </div>
</div>
<!-- Google Tag Manager (noscript) -->
<noscript><iframe src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-NMWSH2N"
height="0" width="0" style="display:none;visibility:hidden"></iframe></noscript>
<!-- End Google Tag Manager (noscript) -->
<div id="pwPopups"></div>
    <div id="app-root"><span class="NotFound" data-reactroot="" data-reactid="1" data-react-checksum="659742471"><!-- react-empty: 2 --><div class="false" data-reactid="3"><a href="#main" class="skipNav" data-reactid="4">Skip Navigation</a><div class="HomePageNav_container homepageVerticalNav    HomePageNavFull_container" data-reactid="5"><nav class="HomePageNav homepageVerticalNav" data-reactid="6"><span class="HomePageNav_siteNav" data-reactid="7"><!-- react-empty: 8 --><span class="HomePageNav_hamburgerContainer" data-reactid="9"><button class="hamburger hamburger--squeeze false" type="button" id="hmb-btn" aria-expanded="false" aria-label="open additional navigation" data-reactid="10"><span aria-hidden="true" class="hamburger-box" data-reactid="11"><span aria-hidden="true" class="hamburger-inner" data-reactid="12"></span></span></button><button aria-label="search" class="HomePageNav_search" id="srch-btn" aria-expanded="false" data-reactid="13"><svg class="searchIcon" width="24" height="24" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" data-reactid="14"><path d="M15.853 16.56c-1.683 1.517-3.911 2.44-6.353 2.44-5.243 0-9.5-4.257-9.5-9.5s4.257-9.5 9.5-9.5 9.5 4.257 9.5 9.5c0 2.442-.923 4.67-2.44 6.353l7.44 7.44-.707.707-7.44-7.44zm-6.353-15.56c4.691 0 8.5 3.809 8.5 8.5s-3.809 8.5-8.5 8.5-8.5-3.809-8.5-8.5 3.809-8.5 8.5-8.5z" data-reactid="15"></path></svg></button></span><a aria-hidden="true" class="HomePageNav_logo" href="/" data-reactid="16"><svg class="verticalNav__monogram" id="Layer_1" data-name="Layer 1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 445.85 160.76" data-reactid="17"><title data-reactid="18">TNR_brand monogram_black</title><path d="M424.4,143.6,381.27,80.38C374.72,84.45,361.85,86,353.72,86c-13.54,0-25.74-3.16-36.8-12v-.23C395.27,80.16,414,60.51,414,35.45,414,7.22,383.53,0,340.18,0h-107V.9c14.29,1.41,42.78,18,54.55,50.48a73.63,73.63,0,0,1,3.12,17.44v35L200.92,0H11.71L0,72.71H.9C17.61,31.16,35.45,1.13,68,1.13V114.7c0,30.48-2.25,41.55-27.09,45.16v.9H224v-.9c-14.63-1.44-44.11-18.8-55.34-52.83a74.9,74.9,0,0,1-2.27-14.41V36.46l106.39,124.3h41.92v-.9c-12.89-2.94-18.25-10.9-19.8-30.24V77.22c0-40.12,5.71-65.32,18.33-73.5a13.69,13.69,0,0,1,7.45-2.14H328c25.52,0,34.78,16,34.78,35.22S353.5,73.16,328,72.7l-13.77-.22,59.84,88.28h71.8v-.9C436.59,157.83,432.07,154.89,424.4,143.6ZM162.31,83.54c0,33.38-4,56.41-12.55,67.92a16.29,16.29,0,0,1-5.6,5.4l-.06,0a12.88,12.88,0,0,1-9.77,1.25,15,15,0,0,1-9.77-6.69q-.48-.72-1-1.41c-5.2-7-5.93-18-5.93-35.35V1.13h.27A40.32,40.32,0,0,1,148.27,15.4l9.55,11.18a18.73,18.73,0,0,1,4.49,12.17Z" data-reactid="19"></path></svg></a><h1 class="--visuallyHidden" data-reactid="20">The New Republic</h1><ul class="HomePageNav_verticals" id="list" data-reactid="21"><li data-reactid="22"><a href="/the-soapbox" data-reactid="23">THE SOAPBOX</a></li><svg class="NavSlash" width="100%" height="100%" data-reactid="24"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="25"></line></svg><li data-reactid="26"><a href="/apocalypse-soon" data-reactid="27">APOCALYPSE SOON</a></li><svg class="NavSlash" width="100%" height="100%" data-reactid="28"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="29"></line></svg><li data-reactid="30"><a href="/sold-short" data-reactid="31">SOLD SHORT</a></li><svg class="NavSlash" width="100%" height="100%" data-reactid="32"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="33"></line></svg><li data-reactid="34"><a href="/critical-mass" data-reactid="35">CRITICAL MASS</a></li><svg class="NavSlash" width="100%" height="100%" data-reactid="36"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="37"></line></svg><li data-reactid="38"><a href="/magazine" data-reactid="39">MAGAZINE</a></li><svg class="NavSlash" width="100%" height="100%" data-reactid="40"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="41"></line></svg><li data-reactid="42"><a href="/podcasts" data-reactid="43">PODCASTS</a></li></ul><span class="HomePageNav_signInOut" data-reactid="44"><button class="HomePageNav_signInButton" data-reactid="45"></button></span></span><a class="HomePageNav_wordmark" href="/" data-reactid="46"><svg class=" verticalNav__wordmark linkedNamePlateFull" id="Layer_1" data-name="Layer 1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 1785.23 127.04" data-reactid="47"><title data-reactid="48">The New Republic </title><path d="M86.6,6.72H8.33L0,58.44H.64C12.53,28.89,25.21,7.53,48.34,7.53V88.31c0,21.68-1.61,29.55-19.27,32.12v.64h73.87v-.64C85.28,117.86,83.67,110,83.67,88.31V7.53c23.13,0,35.82,21.36,47.7,50.91H132L123.69,6.72Z" data-reactid="49"></path><path d="M268.78,7.37V6.72H204.54v.65C215.79,9.94,219,17.8,219,39.49V60.18H175.63V39.49c0-21.69,3.22-29.55,14.46-32.12V6.72H125.85v.65C137.09,9.94,140.3,17.8,140.3,39.49V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64h64.24v-.64c-11.24-2.57-14.46-10.44-14.46-32.12V63H219V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.46,32.12v.64h64.24v-.64c-11.24-2.57-14.45-10.44-14.45-32.12V39.49C254.33,17.8,257.54,9.94,268.78,7.37Z" data-reactid="50"></path><path d="M395.5,69.36c-12.21,29.55-53.32,50.91-74.84,50.91V62.45h0V63h57.65v-.57h0v-1.6h0v-.67H320.66v.67h0V7.53c21.52,0,51.87,21.36,63.75,50.91h.65L377.19,6.72H270.87v.65c11.24,2.57,14.45,10.43,14.45,32.12V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64H377.19L396.3,69.36Z" data-reactid="51"></path><path d="M479.38,6.72v.65c10,1,29.89,12.48,38.46,35a40.47,40.47,0,0,1,2.56,14.37V80.59l-64-73.87H410.16v.65l18.78,22v38c-.13,33.29-5.93,51.82-18.78,53.09v.64h62.63v-.64c-10-1-29.85-12.47-38.43-34.94a40.17,40.17,0,0,1-2.57-14.4V32.63l75.69,88.44h15.74V86.28h0V58.43c.36-32,6.18-49.82,18.77-51.06V6.72Z" data-reactid="52"></path><path d="M652.53,6.72v.65c8.19,1.12,11.88,3.69,15.25,11.24l50,106.48h.8L736,86.94h0l13.58-29.55,29.2,67.7h.64l19.16-42.57,21.51-46.79c9.75-18.1,19.84-27.68,27.75-28.36V6.72ZM708.09,22c-4.65-10.92-4.65-14.29,7.07-14.29,9.8,0,14.62,3.37,17.83,10.92l15.12,35.13L734.54,83.27ZM811,48.57l-15.18,33L773.14,22C769,11.06,767.68,7.69,779.4,7.69c11.16,0,24.15,6.29,30.52,16.83A25.76,25.76,0,0,1,811,48.57Z" data-reactid="53"></path><path d="M668.74,69.36c-12.2,29.55-53.31,50.91-74.84,50.91V63h57.65v-.57h0v-1.6h0v-.67H593.9V7.53c21.53,0,51.88,21.36,63.76,50.91h.65L650.44,6.72H544.12v.65c11.24,2.57,14.45,10.43,14.45,32.12V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64H650.44l19.11-51.71Z" data-reactid="54"></path><path d="M1186.11,120.45v.64h-67.45v-.64c11.24-2.57,14.45-10.44,14.45-32.12V39.51c0-21.68-3.21-29.55-14.45-32.12V6.75h57.65c34.21,0,60.39,3.69,60.39,32.28,0,30.35-36.3,34.69-66.81,32.28v-.65c22-.8,30.51-11.72,30.51-31.47,0-20.24-8.83-31.48-32-31.64V88.33C1168.44,110,1169.41,117.88,1186.11,120.45Z" data-reactid="55"></path><path d="M1533.4,120.29c21.52,0,46.25-20.72,60.22-75h1.13l-3.54,75.8h-107.6v-.64c11.24-2.57,14.46-10.44,14.46-32.12V39.51c0-21.68-3.22-29.55-14.46-32.12V6.75h64.24v.64c-11.24,2.57-14.45,10.44-14.45,32.12Z" data-reactid="56"></path><path d="M1662.37,7.39c-11.24,2.57-14.45,10.44-14.45,32.12V88.33c0,21.68,3.21,29.55,14.45,32.12v.64h-64.24v-.64c11.25-2.57,14.46-10.44,14.46-32.12V39.51c0-21.68-3.21-29.55-14.46-32.12V6.75h64.24Z" data-reactid="57"></path><path d="M1727.74,3.85c17.34,0,29.06,9,35.65,9,7.07,0,8-5.78,8.51-12.85h.8l12.53,60.23h-.8C1775.11,34.69,1757,5,1727.74,5c-17.83,0-28.59,26.18-28.59,58.62s10.76,58.46,28.59,58.46c29.23,0,47.37-29.71,56.69-55.25h.8L1772.7,127h-.8c-.48-7.07-1.44-12.85-8.51-12.85-6.59,0-18.31,9-35.65,9-38.55,0-68.26-23.13-68.26-59.58S1689.19,3.85,1727.74,3.85Z" data-reactid="58"></path><path d="M1124.19,69.38c-12.21,29.55-53.32,50.91-74.84,50.91V63.09H1107v-.62h0v-1.6h0v-.62h-57.64V7.55c21.52,0,51.87,21.36,63.75,50.91h.65l-7.87-51.71H999.56v.64C1010.8,10,1014,17.83,1014,39.51V88.33c0,18.74-2.4,27.16-10.31,30.76a3.82,3.82,0,0,1-3,0c-3.88-1.58-6.7-4.26-10.75-10.22l-30.68-45c-4.66,2.89-13.81,4-19.59,4-9.64,0-18.31-2.24-26.18-8.51v-.16c55.73,4.5,69.06-9.47,69.06-27.3,0-20.08-21.68-25.21-52.52-25.21H859.68v.64c11.24,2.57,14.45,10.44,14.45,32.12V88.33c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64h64.24v-.64c-11.24-2.57-14.46-10.44-14.46-32.12V7.87h11.89c18.15,0,24.73,11.4,24.73,25.05s-6.58,25.86-24.73,25.54l-9.8-.16,42.56,62.79h151.77L1125,69.38Z" data-reactid="59"></path><path d="M1440.45,60.87v-.32c26.34-3,41.91-13.17,41.91-28.59,0-14.13-12.84-25.21-48.34-25.21H1305.11v.64c11,.87,26.69,12.12,35.62,28.15a63.21,63.21,0,0,1,5.44,25.65v6.9c0,15.25-3.24,27.7-9.36,36-5.81,7.88-14.25,12-24.39,12h-2.32a23.62,23.62,0,0,1-16.38-6.56c-7-7.28-10.77-19.51-10.77-35.69V22.81c0-12,4.33-13.82,13.33-15.42V6.75H1232v.64c9.47,1.6,13.17,3.37,14.13,11.08a234.43,234.43,0,0,1,1.45,26.5V75.8c0,24.09,10.43,47.7,51.23,47.7,17.77,0,30-5.61,37.93-14.89C1344.67,99.92,1349,86,1349,68.09v-6.9c0-.79,0-1.58,0-2.36.25-25.72,5.35-47.2,16.38-50.91a7.16,7.16,0,0,1,2.05-.34h.57a7.79,7.79,0,0,1,2.35.36c9.64,3.05,12.47,11.23,12.47,31.58V88.33c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64H1440c30.67,0,49.78-10.6,49.78-31.15C1489.75,65.69,1463.41,61.19,1440.45,60.87Zm-22.33-53H1425c14.46,0,21.36,9,21.36,26.34s-6.9,27-21.36,27h-6.91Zm6.75,112.1h-6.75V62.31h6.75c15.74,0,27.94,7.71,27.94,29.07S1440.61,120,1424.87,120Z" data-reactid="60"></path></svg></a><a class="HomePageNav_wordmark--mobile" href="/" data-reactid="61"><svg class="tnrWordmark--twoLines tnr" id="Layer_1" data-name="Layer 1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 1301.47 347.02" data-reactid="62"><title data-reactid="63">TNR_brand wordmark_black</title><path d="M171.37,0H61.3L49.59,72.72h.91C67.21,31.17,85.05,1.13,117.57,1.13v113.6c0,30.48-2.26,41.55-27.1,45.16v.9H194.35v-.9c-24.84-3.61-27.1-14.68-27.1-45.16V1.13c32.52,0,50.36,30,67.07,71.59h.9L223.51,0Z" data-reactid="64"></path><path d="M459,337.76v.91H364.16v-.91c15.81-3.61,20.33-14.68,20.33-45.16V224c0-30.49-4.52-41.56-20.33-45.17v-.9h81.08c48.1,0,84.91,5.19,84.91,45.39,0,42.68-51,48.78-93.95,45.39v-.9c30.94-1.13,42.91-16.49,42.91-44.27,0-28.45-12.42-44.26-44.94-44.48V292.6C434.17,323.08,435.53,334.15,459,337.76Z" data-reactid="65"></path><path d="M947.36,337.54c30.26,0,65-29.13,84.68-105.46h1.59l-5,106.59H877.35v-.91c15.81-3.61,20.32-14.68,20.32-45.16V224c0-30.49-4.51-41.56-20.32-45.17v-.9h90.33v.9c-15.81,3.61-20.32,14.68-20.32,45.17Z" data-reactid="66"></path><path d="M1128.72,178.78c-15.81,3.61-20.33,14.68-20.33,45.17V292.6c0,30.48,4.52,41.55,20.33,45.16v.91h-90.33v-.91c15.8-3.61,20.32-14.68,20.32-45.16V224c0-30.49-4.52-41.56-20.32-45.17v-.9h90.33Z" data-reactid="67"></path><path d="M1220.63,173.81c24.39,0,40.87,12.65,50.13,12.65,9.94,0,11.29-8.13,12-18.07h1.13l17.61,84.69h-1.12c-13.1-35.91-38.62-77.69-79.72-77.69-25.07,0-40.2,36.81-40.2,82.43s15.13,82.2,40.2,82.2c41.1,0,66.62-41.78,79.72-77.68h1.12L1283.86,347h-1.13c-.68-9.93-2-18.06-12-18.06-9.26,0-25.74,12.64-50.13,12.64-54.2,0-96-32.52-96-83.78S1166.43,173.81,1220.63,173.81Z" data-reactid="68"></path><path d="M427.55.91V0H337.21V.91C353,4.52,357.54,15.59,357.54,46.07v29.1h-61V46.07c0-30.48,4.52-41.55,20.33-45.16V0H226.56V.91c15.8,3.61,20.32,14.68,20.32,45.16v68.66c0,30.48-4.52,41.55-20.32,45.16v.9h90.33v-.9c-15.81-3.61-20.33-14.68-20.33-45.16V79.17h61v35.56c0,30.48-4.52,41.55-20.33,45.16v.9h90.34v-.9c-15.81-3.61-20.33-14.68-20.33-45.16V46.07C407.22,15.59,411.74,4.52,427.55.91Z" data-reactid="69"></path><path d="M605.72,88.08c-17.16,41.55-75,71.59-105.23,71.59V78.37h0v.8h81.07v-.8h0V76.11h0v-.94H500.49v.94h0v-75c30.26,0,72.94,30,89.65,71.59h.91L580,0H430.48V.91c15.81,3.61,20.32,14.68,20.32,45.16v68.66c0,30.48-4.51,41.55-20.32,45.16v.9H580l26.87-72.71Z" data-reactid="70"></path><path d="M723.67,0V.91c14.11,1.39,42,17.55,54.09,49.21a56.81,56.81,0,0,1,3.59,20.21v33.54L691.38,0h-65V.91l26.42,30.93v53.4c-.2,46.81-8.34,72.87-26.42,74.65v.9h88.08v-.9c-14.09-1.39-42-17.53-54-49.12a56.64,56.64,0,0,1-3.61-20.25V36.43L763.2,160.79h22.13V111.88h0V72.72c.51-45,8.69-70.06,26.4-71.81V0Z" data-reactid="71"></path><path d="M967.15,0V.91c11.52,1.58,16.71,5.19,21.45,15.81l70.24,149.72H1060l24.53-53.64h0l19.1-41.55,41.05,95.19h.9l27-59.86,30.24-65.79c13.7-25.44,27.91-38.92,39-39.88V0Zm78.14,21.46c-6.55-15.36-6.55-20.1,9.93-20.1,13.78,0,20.55,4.74,25.07,15.36l21.26,49.4-19.08,41.52ZM1190,58.84l-21.34,46.43-32-83.81c-5.87-15.36-7.68-20.1,8.8-20.1,15.69,0,34,8.84,42.92,23.67A36.23,36.23,0,0,1,1190,58.84Z" data-reactid="72"></path><path d="M371.94,266c-17.16,41.55-75,71.59-105.24,71.59V257.11h81.06v-.87h0V254h0v-.87H266.7V179c30.26,0,72.95,30,89.66,71.58h.9l-11.07-72.71H196.7v.9C212.5,182.39,217,193.46,217,224V292.6c0,26.35-3.38,38.18-14.5,43.24a5.32,5.32,0,0,1-4.25,0c-5.45-2.22-9.42-6-15.12-14.38L140,258.27c-6.55,4.07-19.42,5.65-27.55,5.65-13.55,0-25.74-3.16-36.81-12v-.23c78.37,6.33,97.11-13.32,97.11-38.39,0-28.23-30.49-35.45-73.85-35.45H0v.9c15.81,3.61,20.32,14.68,20.32,45.17V292.6c0,30.49-4.51,41.55-20.32,45.16v.91H90.33v-.91C74.52,334.15,70,323.09,70,292.6V179.46H86.72c25.52,0,34.78,16,34.78,35.23s-9.26,36.35-34.78,35.9l-13.78-.22,59.85,88.3h213.4L373.07,266Z" data-reactid="73"></path><path d="M990,88.08c-17.16,41.55-75,71.59-105.23,71.59V79.17h81.06v-.8h0V76.11h0v-.94H884.72v-74c30.26,0,72.94,30,89.65,71.59h.91L964.21,0H814.71V.91C830.52,4.52,835,15.59,835,46.07v68.66c0,30.48-4.51,41.55-20.32,45.16v.9h149.5l26.87-72.71Z" data-reactid="74"></path><path d="M816.66,254v-.45c37-4.29,58.94-18.52,58.94-40.2,0-19.87-18.07-35.45-68-35.45H626.35v.9c15.49,1.23,37.53,17,50.08,39.58a88.88,88.88,0,0,1,7.65,36.07v9.71c0,21.44-4.55,38.94-13.16,50.62-8.17,11.08-20,16.94-34.3,16.94h-3.26c-9.22-.21-17-3.38-23-9.22-9.84-10.24-15.16-27.44-15.16-50.2V200.46c0-16.94,6.1-19.42,18.75-21.68v-.9H523.6v.9c13.32,2.26,18.51,4.74,19.87,15.58a329.37,329.37,0,0,1,2,37.26V275c0,33.88,14.68,67.07,72,67.07,25,0,42.19-7.89,53.34-20.93,11.09-12.23,17.2-31.74,17.2-57v-9.71c0-1.11,0-2.21-.06-3.31.35-35.58,7.29-65.39,22.29-71.33a11.73,11.73,0,0,1,3.89-.75h.1a12.51,12.51,0,0,1,4.29.67c13.12,4.43,17,16,17,44.24V292.6c0,30.48-4.51,41.55-20.32,45.16v.91H816c43.13,0,70-14.91,70-43.81C886,260.76,849,254.43,816.66,254Zm-31.4-74.52H795c20.32,0,30,12.64,30,37s-9.71,37.94-30,37.94h-9.72Zm9.49,157.63h-9.49V256h9.49c22.13,0,39.29,10.84,39.29,40.88S816.88,337.09,794.75,337.09Z" data-reactid="75"></path></svg></a><h1 class="--visuallyHidden" data-reactid="76">The New Republic</h1></nav></div><div class="HomePageNav_container homepageVerticalNav    HomePageNavTiny_container --fadeOut" data-reactid="77"><nav class="HomePageNavTiny homepageVerticalNav" data-reactid="78"><span class="HomePageNav_siteNav" data-reactid="79"><span class="HomePageNav_hamburgerContainer" data-reactid="80"><button class="hamburger hamburger--squeeze false" type="button" id="hmb-btn" aria-expanded="false" aria-label="open additional navigation" data-reactid="81"><span aria-hidden="true" class="hamburger-box" data-reactid="82"><span aria-hidden="true" class="hamburger-inner" data-reactid="83"></span></span></button><button aria-label="search" class="HomePageNav_search" id="srch-btn" aria-expanded="false" data-reactid="84"><svg class="searchIcon" width="24" height="24" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" data-reactid="85"><path d="M15.853 16.56c-1.683 1.517-3.911 2.44-6.353 2.44-5.243 0-9.5-4.257-9.5-9.5s4.257-9.5 9.5-9.5 9.5 4.257 9.5 9.5c0 2.442-.923 4.67-2.44 6.353l7.44 7.44-.707.707-7.44-7.44zm-6.353-15.56c4.691 0 8.5 3.809 8.5 8.5s-3.809 8.5-8.5 8.5-8.5-3.809-8.5-8.5 3.809-8.5 8.5-8.5z" data-reactid="86"></path></svg></button></span><a aria-hidden="true" class="HomePageNav_logo" href="/" data-reactid="87"><svg class="verticalNav__monogram" id="Layer_1" data-name="Layer 1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 445.85 160.76" data-reactid="88"><title data-reactid="89">TNR_brand monogram_black</title><path d="M424.4,143.6,381.27,80.38C374.72,84.45,361.85,86,353.72,86c-13.54,0-25.74-3.16-36.8-12v-.23C395.27,80.16,414,60.51,414,35.45,414,7.22,383.53,0,340.18,0h-107V.9c14.29,1.41,42.78,18,54.55,50.48a73.63,73.63,0,0,1,3.12,17.44v35L200.92,0H11.71L0,72.71H.9C17.61,31.16,35.45,1.13,68,1.13V114.7c0,30.48-2.25,41.55-27.09,45.16v.9H224v-.9c-14.63-1.44-44.11-18.8-55.34-52.83a74.9,74.9,0,0,1-2.27-14.41V36.46l106.39,124.3h41.92v-.9c-12.89-2.94-18.25-10.9-19.8-30.24V77.22c0-40.12,5.71-65.32,18.33-73.5a13.69,13.69,0,0,1,7.45-2.14H328c25.52,0,34.78,16,34.78,35.22S353.5,73.16,328,72.7l-13.77-.22,59.84,88.28h71.8v-.9C436.59,157.83,432.07,154.89,424.4,143.6ZM162.31,83.54c0,33.38-4,56.41-12.55,67.92a16.29,16.29,0,0,1-5.6,5.4l-.06,0a12.88,12.88,0,0,1-9.77,1.25,15,15,0,0,1-9.77-6.69q-.48-.72-1-1.41c-5.2-7-5.93-18-5.93-35.35V1.13h.27A40.32,40.32,0,0,1,148.27,15.4l9.55,11.18a18.73,18.73,0,0,1,4.49,12.17Z" data-reactid="90"></path></svg></a><h1 class="--visuallyHidden" data-reactid="91">The New Republic</h1><ul class="HomePageNav_verticals" id="list" data-reactid="92"><li data-reactid="93"><a href="/the-soapbox" data-reactid="94">THE SOAPBOX</a></li><svg class="NavSlash" width="100%" height="100%" data-reactid="95"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="96"></line></svg><li data-reactid="97"><a href="/apocalypse-soon" data-reactid="98">APOCALYPSE SOON</a></li><svg class="NavSlash" width="100%" height="100%" data-reactid="99"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="100"></line></svg><li data-reactid="101"><a href="/sold-short" data-reactid="102">SOLD SHORT</a></li><svg class="NavSlash" width="100%" height="100%" data-reactid="103"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="104"></line></svg><li data-reactid="105"><a href="/critical-mass" data-reactid="106">CRITICAL MASS</a></li><svg class="NavSlash" width="100%" height="100%" data-reactid="107"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="108"></line></svg><li data-reactid="109"><a href="/magazine" data-reactid="110">MAGAZINE</a></li><svg class="NavSlash" width="100%" height="100%" data-reactid="111"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="112"></line></svg><li data-reactid="113"><a href="/podcasts" data-reactid="114">PODCASTS</a></li></ul><span class="HomePageNav_signInOut" data-reactid="115"><button class="HomePageNav_signInButton" data-reactid="116"></button></span></span><a class="HomePageNav_wordmark" href="/" data-reactid="117"><svg class=" verticalNav__wordmark linkedNamePlateFull" id="Layer_1" data-name="Layer 1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 1785.23 127.04" data-reactid="118"><title data-reactid="119">The New Republic </title><path d="M86.6,6.72H8.33L0,58.44H.64C12.53,28.89,25.21,7.53,48.34,7.53V88.31c0,21.68-1.61,29.55-19.27,32.12v.64h73.87v-.64C85.28,117.86,83.67,110,83.67,88.31V7.53c23.13,0,35.82,21.36,47.7,50.91H132L123.69,6.72Z" data-reactid="120"></path><path d="M268.78,7.37V6.72H204.54v.65C215.79,9.94,219,17.8,219,39.49V60.18H175.63V39.49c0-21.69,3.22-29.55,14.46-32.12V6.72H125.85v.65C137.09,9.94,140.3,17.8,140.3,39.49V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64h64.24v-.64c-11.24-2.57-14.46-10.44-14.46-32.12V63H219V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.46,32.12v.64h64.24v-.64c-11.24-2.57-14.45-10.44-14.45-32.12V39.49C254.33,17.8,257.54,9.94,268.78,7.37Z" data-reactid="121"></path><path d="M395.5,69.36c-12.21,29.55-53.32,50.91-74.84,50.91V62.45h0V63h57.65v-.57h0v-1.6h0v-.67H320.66v.67h0V7.53c21.52,0,51.87,21.36,63.75,50.91h.65L377.19,6.72H270.87v.65c11.24,2.57,14.45,10.43,14.45,32.12V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64H377.19L396.3,69.36Z" data-reactid="122"></path><path d="M479.38,6.72v.65c10,1,29.89,12.48,38.46,35a40.47,40.47,0,0,1,2.56,14.37V80.59l-64-73.87H410.16v.65l18.78,22v38c-.13,33.29-5.93,51.82-18.78,53.09v.64h62.63v-.64c-10-1-29.85-12.47-38.43-34.94a40.17,40.17,0,0,1-2.57-14.4V32.63l75.69,88.44h15.74V86.28h0V58.43c.36-32,6.18-49.82,18.77-51.06V6.72Z" data-reactid="123"></path><path d="M652.53,6.72v.65c8.19,1.12,11.88,3.69,15.25,11.24l50,106.48h.8L736,86.94h0l13.58-29.55,29.2,67.7h.64l19.16-42.57,21.51-46.79c9.75-18.1,19.84-27.68,27.75-28.36V6.72ZM708.09,22c-4.65-10.92-4.65-14.29,7.07-14.29,9.8,0,14.62,3.37,17.83,10.92l15.12,35.13L734.54,83.27ZM811,48.57l-15.18,33L773.14,22C769,11.06,767.68,7.69,779.4,7.69c11.16,0,24.15,6.29,30.52,16.83A25.76,25.76,0,0,1,811,48.57Z" data-reactid="124"></path><path d="M668.74,69.36c-12.2,29.55-53.31,50.91-74.84,50.91V63h57.65v-.57h0v-1.6h0v-.67H593.9V7.53c21.53,0,51.88,21.36,63.76,50.91h.65L650.44,6.72H544.12v.65c11.24,2.57,14.45,10.43,14.45,32.12V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64H650.44l19.11-51.71Z" data-reactid="125"></path><path d="M1186.11,120.45v.64h-67.45v-.64c11.24-2.57,14.45-10.44,14.45-32.12V39.51c0-21.68-3.21-29.55-14.45-32.12V6.75h57.65c34.21,0,60.39,3.69,60.39,32.28,0,30.35-36.3,34.69-66.81,32.28v-.65c22-.8,30.51-11.72,30.51-31.47,0-20.24-8.83-31.48-32-31.64V88.33C1168.44,110,1169.41,117.88,1186.11,120.45Z" data-reactid="126"></path><path d="M1533.4,120.29c21.52,0,46.25-20.72,60.22-75h1.13l-3.54,75.8h-107.6v-.64c11.24-2.57,14.46-10.44,14.46-32.12V39.51c0-21.68-3.22-29.55-14.46-32.12V6.75h64.24v.64c-11.24,2.57-14.45,10.44-14.45,32.12Z" data-reactid="127"></path><path d="M1662.37,7.39c-11.24,2.57-14.45,10.44-14.45,32.12V88.33c0,21.68,3.21,29.55,14.45,32.12v.64h-64.24v-.64c11.25-2.57,14.46-10.44,14.46-32.12V39.51c0-21.68-3.21-29.55-14.46-32.12V6.75h64.24Z" data-reactid="128"></path><path d="M1727.74,3.85c17.34,0,29.06,9,35.65,9,7.07,0,8-5.78,8.51-12.85h.8l12.53,60.23h-.8C1775.11,34.69,1757,5,1727.74,5c-17.83,0-28.59,26.18-28.59,58.62s10.76,58.46,28.59,58.46c29.23,0,47.37-29.71,56.69-55.25h.8L1772.7,127h-.8c-.48-7.07-1.44-12.85-8.51-12.85-6.59,0-18.31,9-35.65,9-38.55,0-68.26-23.13-68.26-59.58S1689.19,3.85,1727.74,3.85Z" data-reactid="129"></path><path d="M1124.19,69.38c-12.21,29.55-53.32,50.91-74.84,50.91V63.09H1107v-.62h0v-1.6h0v-.62h-57.64V7.55c21.52,0,51.87,21.36,63.75,50.91h.65l-7.87-51.71H999.56v.64C1010.8,10,1014,17.83,1014,39.51V88.33c0,18.74-2.4,27.16-10.31,30.76a3.82,3.82,0,0,1-3,0c-3.88-1.58-6.7-4.26-10.75-10.22l-30.68-45c-4.66,2.89-13.81,4-19.59,4-9.64,0-18.31-2.24-26.18-8.51v-.16c55.73,4.5,69.06-9.47,69.06-27.3,0-20.08-21.68-25.21-52.52-25.21H859.68v.64c11.24,2.57,14.45,10.44,14.45,32.12V88.33c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64h64.24v-.64c-11.24-2.57-14.46-10.44-14.46-32.12V7.87h11.89c18.15,0,24.73,11.4,24.73,25.05s-6.58,25.86-24.73,25.54l-9.8-.16,42.56,62.79h151.77L1125,69.38Z" data-reactid="130"></path><path d="M1440.45,60.87v-.32c26.34-3,41.91-13.17,41.91-28.59,0-14.13-12.84-25.21-48.34-25.21H1305.11v.64c11,.87,26.69,12.12,35.62,28.15a63.21,63.21,0,0,1,5.44,25.65v6.9c0,15.25-3.24,27.7-9.36,36-5.81,7.88-14.25,12-24.39,12h-2.32a23.62,23.62,0,0,1-16.38-6.56c-7-7.28-10.77-19.51-10.77-35.69V22.81c0-12,4.33-13.82,13.33-15.42V6.75H1232v.64c9.47,1.6,13.17,3.37,14.13,11.08a234.43,234.43,0,0,1,1.45,26.5V75.8c0,24.09,10.43,47.7,51.23,47.7,17.77,0,30-5.61,37.93-14.89C1344.67,99.92,1349,86,1349,68.09v-6.9c0-.79,0-1.58,0-2.36.25-25.72,5.35-47.2,16.38-50.91a7.16,7.16,0,0,1,2.05-.34h.57a7.79,7.79,0,0,1,2.35.36c9.64,3.05,12.47,11.23,12.47,31.58V88.33c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64H1440c30.67,0,49.78-10.6,49.78-31.15C1489.75,65.69,1463.41,61.19,1440.45,60.87Zm-22.33-53H1425c14.46,0,21.36,9,21.36,26.34s-6.9,27-21.36,27h-6.91Zm6.75,112.1h-6.75V62.31h6.75c15.74,0,27.94,7.71,27.94,29.07S1440.61,120,1424.87,120Z" data-reactid="131"></path></svg></a><a class="HomePageNav_wordmark" href="/" data-reactid="132"><svg class=" verticalNav__wordmark linkedNamePlateFull" id="Layer_1" data-name="Layer 1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 1785.23 127.04" data-reactid="133"><title data-reactid="134">The New Republic </title><path d="M86.6,6.72H8.33L0,58.44H.64C12.53,28.89,25.21,7.53,48.34,7.53V88.31c0,21.68-1.61,29.55-19.27,32.12v.64h73.87v-.64C85.28,117.86,83.67,110,83.67,88.31V7.53c23.13,0,35.82,21.36,47.7,50.91H132L123.69,6.72Z" data-reactid="135"></path><path d="M268.78,7.37V6.72H204.54v.65C215.79,9.94,219,17.8,219,39.49V60.18H175.63V39.49c0-21.69,3.22-29.55,14.46-32.12V6.72H125.85v.65C137.09,9.94,140.3,17.8,140.3,39.49V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64h64.24v-.64c-11.24-2.57-14.46-10.44-14.46-32.12V63H219V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.46,32.12v.64h64.24v-.64c-11.24-2.57-14.45-10.44-14.45-32.12V39.49C254.33,17.8,257.54,9.94,268.78,7.37Z" data-reactid="136"></path><path d="M395.5,69.36c-12.21,29.55-53.32,50.91-74.84,50.91V62.45h0V63h57.65v-.57h0v-1.6h0v-.67H320.66v.67h0V7.53c21.52,0,51.87,21.36,63.75,50.91h.65L377.19,6.72H270.87v.65c11.24,2.57,14.45,10.43,14.45,32.12V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64H377.19L396.3,69.36Z" data-reactid="137"></path><path d="M479.38,6.72v.65c10,1,29.89,12.48,38.46,35a40.47,40.47,0,0,1,2.56,14.37V80.59l-64-73.87H410.16v.65l18.78,22v38c-.13,33.29-5.93,51.82-18.78,53.09v.64h62.63v-.64c-10-1-29.85-12.47-38.43-34.94a40.17,40.17,0,0,1-2.57-14.4V32.63l75.69,88.44h15.74V86.28h0V58.43c.36-32,6.18-49.82,18.77-51.06V6.72Z" data-reactid="138"></path><path d="M652.53,6.72v.65c8.19,1.12,11.88,3.69,15.25,11.24l50,106.48h.8L736,86.94h0l13.58-29.55,29.2,67.7h.64l19.16-42.57,21.51-46.79c9.75-18.1,19.84-27.68,27.75-28.36V6.72ZM708.09,22c-4.65-10.92-4.65-14.29,7.07-14.29,9.8,0,14.62,3.37,17.83,10.92l15.12,35.13L734.54,83.27ZM811,48.57l-15.18,33L773.14,22C769,11.06,767.68,7.69,779.4,7.69c11.16,0,24.15,6.29,30.52,16.83A25.76,25.76,0,0,1,811,48.57Z" data-reactid="139"></path><path d="M668.74,69.36c-12.2,29.55-53.31,50.91-74.84,50.91V63h57.65v-.57h0v-1.6h0v-.67H593.9V7.53c21.53,0,51.88,21.36,63.76,50.91h.65L650.44,6.72H544.12v.65c11.24,2.57,14.45,10.43,14.45,32.12V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64H650.44l19.11-51.71Z" data-reactid="140"></path><path d="M1186.11,120.45v.64h-67.45v-.64c11.24-2.57,14.45-10.44,14.45-32.12V39.51c0-21.68-3.21-29.55-14.45-32.12V6.75h57.65c34.21,0,60.39,3.69,60.39,32.28,0,30.35-36.3,34.69-66.81,32.28v-.65c22-.8,30.51-11.72,30.51-31.47,0-20.24-8.83-31.48-32-31.64V88.33C1168.44,110,1169.41,117.88,1186.11,120.45Z" data-reactid="141"></path><path d="M1533.4,120.29c21.52,0,46.25-20.72,60.22-75h1.13l-3.54,75.8h-107.6v-.64c11.24-2.57,14.46-10.44,14.46-32.12V39.51c0-21.68-3.22-29.55-14.46-32.12V6.75h64.24v.64c-11.24,2.57-14.45,10.44-14.45,32.12Z" data-reactid="142"></path><path d="M1662.37,7.39c-11.24,2.57-14.45,10.44-14.45,32.12V88.33c0,21.68,3.21,29.55,14.45,32.12v.64h-64.24v-.64c11.25-2.57,14.46-10.44,14.46-32.12V39.51c0-21.68-3.21-29.55-14.46-32.12V6.75h64.24Z" data-reactid="143"></path><path d="M1727.74,3.85c17.34,0,29.06,9,35.65,9,7.07,0,8-5.78,8.51-12.85h.8l12.53,60.23h-.8C1775.11,34.69,1757,5,1727.74,5c-17.83,0-28.59,26.18-28.59,58.62s10.76,58.46,28.59,58.46c29.23,0,47.37-29.71,56.69-55.25h.8L1772.7,127h-.8c-.48-7.07-1.44-12.85-8.51-12.85-6.59,0-18.31,9-35.65,9-38.55,0-68.26-23.13-68.26-59.58S1689.19,3.85,1727.74,3.85Z" data-reactid="144"></path><path d="M1124.19,69.38c-12.21,29.55-53.32,50.91-74.84,50.91V63.09H1107v-.62h0v-1.6h0v-.62h-57.64V7.55c21.52,0,51.87,21.36,63.75,50.91h.65l-7.87-51.71H999.56v.64C1010.8,10,1014,17.83,1014,39.51V88.33c0,18.74-2.4,27.16-10.31,30.76a3.82,3.82,0,0,1-3,0c-3.88-1.58-6.7-4.26-10.75-10.22l-30.68-45c-4.66,2.89-13.81,4-19.59,4-9.64,0-18.31-2.24-26.18-8.51v-.16c55.73,4.5,69.06-9.47,69.06-27.3,0-20.08-21.68-25.21-52.52-25.21H859.68v.64c11.24,2.57,14.45,10.44,14.45,32.12V88.33c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64h64.24v-.64c-11.24-2.57-14.46-10.44-14.46-32.12V7.87h11.89c18.15,0,24.73,11.4,24.73,25.05s-6.58,25.86-24.73,25.54l-9.8-.16,42.56,62.79h151.77L1125,69.38Z" data-reactid="145"></path><path d="M1440.45,60.87v-.32c26.34-3,41.91-13.17,41.91-28.59,0-14.13-12.84-25.21-48.34-25.21H1305.11v.64c11,.87,26.69,12.12,35.62,28.15a63.21,63.21,0,0,1,5.44,25.65v6.9c0,15.25-3.24,27.7-9.36,36-5.81,7.88-14.25,12-24.39,12h-2.32a23.62,23.62,0,0,1-16.38-6.56c-7-7.28-10.77-19.51-10.77-35.69V22.81c0-12,4.33-13.82,13.33-15.42V6.75H1232v.64c9.47,1.6,13.17,3.37,14.13,11.08a234.43,234.43,0,0,1,1.45,26.5V75.8c0,24.09,10.43,47.7,51.23,47.7,17.77,0,30-5.61,37.93-14.89C1344.67,99.92,1349,86,1349,68.09v-6.9c0-.79,0-1.58,0-2.36.25-25.72,5.35-47.2,16.38-50.91a7.16,7.16,0,0,1,2.05-.34h.57a7.79,7.79,0,0,1,2.35.36c9.64,3.05,12.47,11.23,12.47,31.58V88.33c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64H1440c30.67,0,49.78-10.6,49.78-31.15C1489.75,65.69,1463.41,61.19,1440.45,60.87Zm-22.33-53H1425c14.46,0,21.36,9,21.36,26.34s-6.9,27-21.36,27h-6.91Zm6.75,112.1h-6.75V62.31h6.75c15.74,0,27.94,7.71,27.94,29.07S1440.61,120,1424.87,120Z" data-reactid="146"></path></svg></a><a class="HomePageNav_wordmark--mobile" href="/" data-reactid="147"><svg class=" verticalNav__wordmark linkedNamePlateFull" id="Layer_1" data-name="Layer 1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 1785.23 127.04" data-reactid="148"><title data-reactid="149">The New Republic </title><path d="M86.6,6.72H8.33L0,58.44H.64C12.53,28.89,25.21,7.53,48.34,7.53V88.31c0,21.68-1.61,29.55-19.27,32.12v.64h73.87v-.64C85.28,117.86,83.67,110,83.67,88.31V7.53c23.13,0,35.82,21.36,47.7,50.91H132L123.69,6.72Z" data-reactid="150"></path><path d="M268.78,7.37V6.72H204.54v.65C215.79,9.94,219,17.8,219,39.49V60.18H175.63V39.49c0-21.69,3.22-29.55,14.46-32.12V6.72H125.85v.65C137.09,9.94,140.3,17.8,140.3,39.49V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64h64.24v-.64c-11.24-2.57-14.46-10.44-14.46-32.12V63H219V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.46,32.12v.64h64.24v-.64c-11.24-2.57-14.45-10.44-14.45-32.12V39.49C254.33,17.8,257.54,9.94,268.78,7.37Z" data-reactid="151"></path><path d="M395.5,69.36c-12.21,29.55-53.32,50.91-74.84,50.91V62.45h0V63h57.65v-.57h0v-1.6h0v-.67H320.66v.67h0V7.53c21.52,0,51.87,21.36,63.75,50.91h.65L377.19,6.72H270.87v.65c11.24,2.57,14.45,10.43,14.45,32.12V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64H377.19L396.3,69.36Z" data-reactid="152"></path><path d="M479.38,6.72v.65c10,1,29.89,12.48,38.46,35a40.47,40.47,0,0,1,2.56,14.37V80.59l-64-73.87H410.16v.65l18.78,22v38c-.13,33.29-5.93,51.82-18.78,53.09v.64h62.63v-.64c-10-1-29.85-12.47-38.43-34.94a40.17,40.17,0,0,1-2.57-14.4V32.63l75.69,88.44h15.74V86.28h0V58.43c.36-32,6.18-49.82,18.77-51.06V6.72Z" data-reactid="153"></path><path d="M652.53,6.72v.65c8.19,1.12,11.88,3.69,15.25,11.24l50,106.48h.8L736,86.94h0l13.58-29.55,29.2,67.7h.64l19.16-42.57,21.51-46.79c9.75-18.1,19.84-27.68,27.75-28.36V6.72ZM708.09,22c-4.65-10.92-4.65-14.29,7.07-14.29,9.8,0,14.62,3.37,17.83,10.92l15.12,35.13L734.54,83.27ZM811,48.57l-15.18,33L773.14,22C769,11.06,767.68,7.69,779.4,7.69c11.16,0,24.15,6.29,30.52,16.83A25.76,25.76,0,0,1,811,48.57Z" data-reactid="154"></path><path d="M668.74,69.36c-12.2,29.55-53.31,50.91-74.84,50.91V63h57.65v-.57h0v-1.6h0v-.67H593.9V7.53c21.53,0,51.88,21.36,63.76,50.91h.65L650.44,6.72H544.12v.65c11.24,2.57,14.45,10.43,14.45,32.12V88.31c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64H650.44l19.11-51.71Z" data-reactid="155"></path><path d="M1186.11,120.45v.64h-67.45v-.64c11.24-2.57,14.45-10.44,14.45-32.12V39.51c0-21.68-3.21-29.55-14.45-32.12V6.75h57.65c34.21,0,60.39,3.69,60.39,32.28,0,30.35-36.3,34.69-66.81,32.28v-.65c22-.8,30.51-11.72,30.51-31.47,0-20.24-8.83-31.48-32-31.64V88.33C1168.44,110,1169.41,117.88,1186.11,120.45Z" data-reactid="156"></path><path d="M1533.4,120.29c21.52,0,46.25-20.72,60.22-75h1.13l-3.54,75.8h-107.6v-.64c11.24-2.57,14.46-10.44,14.46-32.12V39.51c0-21.68-3.22-29.55-14.46-32.12V6.75h64.24v.64c-11.24,2.57-14.45,10.44-14.45,32.12Z" data-reactid="157"></path><path d="M1662.37,7.39c-11.24,2.57-14.45,10.44-14.45,32.12V88.33c0,21.68,3.21,29.55,14.45,32.12v.64h-64.24v-.64c11.25-2.57,14.46-10.44,14.46-32.12V39.51c0-21.68-3.21-29.55-14.46-32.12V6.75h64.24Z" data-reactid="158"></path><path d="M1727.74,3.85c17.34,0,29.06,9,35.65,9,7.07,0,8-5.78,8.51-12.85h.8l12.53,60.23h-.8C1775.11,34.69,1757,5,1727.74,5c-17.83,0-28.59,26.18-28.59,58.62s10.76,58.46,28.59,58.46c29.23,0,47.37-29.71,56.69-55.25h.8L1772.7,127h-.8c-.48-7.07-1.44-12.85-8.51-12.85-6.59,0-18.31,9-35.65,9-38.55,0-68.26-23.13-68.26-59.58S1689.19,3.85,1727.74,3.85Z" data-reactid="159"></path><path d="M1124.19,69.38c-12.21,29.55-53.32,50.91-74.84,50.91V63.09H1107v-.62h0v-1.6h0v-.62h-57.64V7.55c21.52,0,51.87,21.36,63.75,50.91h.65l-7.87-51.71H999.56v.64C1010.8,10,1014,17.83,1014,39.51V88.33c0,18.74-2.4,27.16-10.31,30.76a3.82,3.82,0,0,1-3,0c-3.88-1.58-6.7-4.26-10.75-10.22l-30.68-45c-4.66,2.89-13.81,4-19.59,4-9.64,0-18.31-2.24-26.18-8.51v-.16c55.73,4.5,69.06-9.47,69.06-27.3,0-20.08-21.68-25.21-52.52-25.21H859.68v.64c11.24,2.57,14.45,10.44,14.45,32.12V88.33c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64h64.24v-.64c-11.24-2.57-14.46-10.44-14.46-32.12V7.87h11.89c18.15,0,24.73,11.4,24.73,25.05s-6.58,25.86-24.73,25.54l-9.8-.16,42.56,62.79h151.77L1125,69.38Z" data-reactid="160"></path><path d="M1440.45,60.87v-.32c26.34-3,41.91-13.17,41.91-28.59,0-14.13-12.84-25.21-48.34-25.21H1305.11v.64c11,.87,26.69,12.12,35.62,28.15a63.21,63.21,0,0,1,5.44,25.65v6.9c0,15.25-3.24,27.7-9.36,36-5.81,7.88-14.25,12-24.39,12h-2.32a23.62,23.62,0,0,1-16.38-6.56c-7-7.28-10.77-19.51-10.77-35.69V22.81c0-12,4.33-13.82,13.33-15.42V6.75H1232v.64c9.47,1.6,13.17,3.37,14.13,11.08a234.43,234.43,0,0,1,1.45,26.5V75.8c0,24.09,10.43,47.7,51.23,47.7,17.77,0,30-5.61,37.93-14.89C1344.67,99.92,1349,86,1349,68.09v-6.9c0-.79,0-1.58,0-2.36.25-25.72,5.35-47.2,16.38-50.91a7.16,7.16,0,0,1,2.05-.34h.57a7.79,7.79,0,0,1,2.35.36c9.64,3.05,12.47,11.23,12.47,31.58V88.33c0,21.68-3.21,29.55-14.45,32.12v.64H1440c30.67,0,49.78-10.6,49.78-31.15C1489.75,65.69,1463.41,61.19,1440.45,60.87Zm-22.33-53H1425c14.46,0,21.36,9,21.36,26.34s-6.9,27-21.36,27h-6.91Zm6.75,112.1h-6.75V62.31h6.75c15.74,0,27.94,7.71,27.94,29.07S1440.61,120,1424.87,120Z" data-reactid="161"></path></svg></a><h1 class="--visuallyHidden" data-reactid="162">The New Republic</h1></nav></div></div><main id="main" data-reactid="163"><h1 data-reactid="164">404 Error</h1><div class="NotFound__oops" data-reactid="165">Oops.</div><div class="NotFound__brokenLink" data-reactid="166">This link is broken, but the democratic experiment endures.</div><div class="NotFound__cta" data-reactid="167"><!-- react-text: 168 -->Find more ennobling content back at <!-- /react-text --><a href="https://tnr.com" data-reactid="169">tnr.com</a></div></main><footer class="footer undefinedFooter fade-in" id="footer" data-reactid="170"><div class="footer__topRow" data-reactid="171"><ul class="footer__verticalsNav" data-reactid="172"><li data-reactid="173"><a href="/the-soapbox" data-reactid="174">THE SOAPBOX</a><!-- react-text: 175 --> <!-- /react-text --><svg class="footerSlash" width="7.52" height="20.67" data-reactid="176"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="177"></line></svg></li><li data-reactid="178"><a href="/apocalypse-soon" data-reactid="179">APOCALYPSE SOON</a><!-- react-text: 180 --> <!-- /react-text --><svg class="footerSlash" width="7.52" height="20.67" data-reactid="181"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="182"></line></svg></li><li data-reactid="183"><a href="/sold-short" data-reactid="184">SOLD SHORT</a><!-- react-text: 185 --> <!-- /react-text --><svg class="footerSlash" width="7.52" height="20.67" data-reactid="186"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="187"></line></svg></li><li data-reactid="188"><a href="/critical-mass" data-reactid="189">CRITICAL MASS</a><!-- react-text: 190 --> <!-- /react-text --><svg class="footerSlash" width="7.52" height="20.67" data-reactid="191"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="192"></line></svg></li><li data-reactid="193"><a href="/magazine" data-reactid="194">MAGAZINE</a><!-- react-text: 195 --> <!-- /react-text --><svg class="footerSlash" width="7.52" height="20.67" data-reactid="196"><line x1="10%" y1="100%" x2="90%" y2="0" data-reactid="197"></line></svg></li><li data-reactid="198"><a href="/podcasts" data-reactid="199">PODCASTS</a></li></ul><ul class="footer__aboutNav" data-reactid="200"><li data-reactid="201"><a href="https://w1.buysub.com/servlet/OrdersGateway?cds_mag_code=NRD&amp;cds_page_id=242949&amp;cds_response_key=I0FNRFTR" data-reactid="202">Donate</a></li><li data-reactid="203"><a href="https://advertise.newrepublic.com/" data-reactid="204">Advertise</a></li><li data-reactid="205"><a href="/pages/subscriber-services" data-reactid="206">Subscriber Services</a></li><li data-reactid="207"><a href="/tags/press-release" data-reactid="208">Press</a></li><li data-reactid="209"><a href="/pages/about#jobs" data-reactid="210">Jobs</a></li><li data-reactid="211"><a href="/pages/contact" data-reactid="212">Contact</a></li><li class="footer__socialMedia--mobile" data-reactid="213"><a href="https://www.facebook.com/newrepublic/" data-reactid="214"><svg class="footer__facebookIcon" aria-label="the new republic on Facebook" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" data-reactid="215"><path d="M22.675 0h-21.35c-.732 0-1.325.593-1.325 1.325v21.351c0 .731.593 1.324 1.325 1.324h11.495v-9.294h-3.128v-3.622h3.128v-2.671c0-3.1 1.893-4.788 4.659-4.788 1.325 0 2.463.099 2.795.143v3.24l-1.918.001c-1.504 0-1.795.715-1.795 1.763v2.313h3.587l-.467 3.622h-3.12v9.293h6.116c.73 0 1.323-.593 1.323-1.325v-21.35c0-.732-.593-1.325-1.325-1.325z" data-reactid="216"></path></svg></a><a href="https://www.twitter.com/newrepublic/" data-reactid="217"><svg class="footer__twitterIcon" aria-label="the new republic on Twitter" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" data-reactid="218"><path d="M24 4.557c-.883.392-1.832.656-2.828.775 1.017-.609 1.798-1.574 2.165-2.724-.951.564-2.005.974-3.127 1.195-.897-.957-2.178-1.555-3.594-1.555-3.179 0-5.515 2.966-4.797 6.045-4.091-.205-7.719-2.165-10.148-5.144-1.29 2.213-.669 5.108 1.523 6.574-.806-.026-1.566-.247-2.229-.616-.054 2.281 1.581 4.415 3.949 4.89-.693.188-1.452.232-2.224.084.626 1.956 2.444 3.379 4.6 3.419-2.07 1.623-4.678 2.348-7.29 2.04 2.179 1.397 4.768 2.212 7.548 2.212 9.142 0 14.307-7.721 13.995-14.646.962-.695 1.797-1.562 2.457-2.549z" data-reactid="219"></path></svg></a><a href="https://www.instagram.com/newrepublic/" data-reactid="220"><svg class="footer__instagramIcon" aria-label="the new republic on Instagram" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" data-reactid="221"><path d="M12 2.163c3.204 0 3.584.012 4.85.07 3.252.148 4.771 1.691 4.919 4.919.058 1.265.069 1.645.069 4.849 0 3.205-.012 3.584-.069 4.849-.149 3.225-1.664 4.771-4.919 4.919-1.266.058-1.644.07-4.85.07-3.204 0-3.584-.012-4.849-.07-3.26-.149-4.771-1.699-4.919-4.92-.058-1.265-.07-1.644-.07-4.849 0-3.204.013-3.583.07-4.849.149-3.227 1.664-4.771 4.919-4.919 1.266-.057 1.645-.069 4.849-.069zm0-2.163c-3.259 0-3.667.014-4.947.072-4.358.2-6.78 2.618-6.98 6.98-.059 1.281-.073 1.689-.073 4.948 0 3.259.014 3.668.072 4.948.2 4.358 2.618 6.78 6.98 6.98 1.281.058 1.689.072 4.948.072 3.259 0 3.668-.014 4.948-.072 4.354-.2 6.782-2.618 6.979-6.98.059-1.28.073-1.689.073-4.948 0-3.259-.014-3.667-.072-4.947-.196-4.354-2.617-6.78-6.979-6.98-1.281-.059-1.69-.073-4.949-.073zm0 5.838c-3.403 0-6.162 2.759-6.162 6.162s2.759 6.163 6.162 6.163 6.162-2.759 6.162-6.163c0-3.403-2.759-6.162-6.162-6.162zm0 10.162c-2.209 0-4-1.79-4-4 0-2.209 1.791-4 4-4s4 1.791 4 4c0 2.21-1.791 4-4 4zm6.406-11.845c-.796 0-1.441.645-1.441 1.44s.645 1.44 1.441 1.44c.795 0 1.439-.645 1.439-1.44s-.644-1.44-1.439-1.44z" data-reactid="222"></path></svg></a></li></ul></div><div class="footer__bottomRow" data-reactid="223"><ul class="footer__ctaList" data-reactid="224"><li class="footer__ctaListItem" data-reactid="225"><a href="#" data-reactid="226"><span data-reactid="227"><!-- react-text: 228 -->Subscribe to <!-- /react-text --><i data-reactid="229">The New Republic</i></span></a></li><li class="footer__ctaListItem" data-reactid="230"><a href="https://mailchi.mp/61665a30a33b/tnrdaily" data-reactid="231">Sign Up for Our Newsletters</a></li></ul><ul class="footer__miscList" data-reactid="232"><li class="footer__socialMedia" data-reactid="233"><a href="https://www.facebook.com/newrepublic/" data-reactid="234"><svg class="footer__facebookIcon" aria-label="the new republic on Facebook" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" data-reactid="235"><path d="M22.675 0h-21.35c-.732 0-1.325.593-1.325 1.325v21.351c0 .731.593 1.324 1.325 1.324h11.495v-9.294h-3.128v-3.622h3.128v-2.671c0-3.1 1.893-4.788 4.659-4.788 1.325 0 2.463.099 2.795.143v3.24l-1.918.001c-1.504 0-1.795.715-1.795 1.763v2.313h3.587l-.467 3.622h-3.12v9.293h6.116c.73 0 1.323-.593 1.323-1.325v-21.35c0-.732-.593-1.325-1.325-1.325z" data-reactid="236"></path></svg></a><a href="https://www.twitter.com/newrepublic/" data-reactid="237"><svg class="footer__twitterIcon" aria-label="the new republic on Twitter" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" data-reactid="238"><path d="M24 4.557c-.883.392-1.832.656-2.828.775 1.017-.609 1.798-1.574 2.165-2.724-.951.564-2.005.974-3.127 1.195-.897-.957-2.178-1.555-3.594-1.555-3.179 0-5.515 2.966-4.797 6.045-4.091-.205-7.719-2.165-10.148-5.144-1.29 2.213-.669 5.108 1.523 6.574-.806-.026-1.566-.247-2.229-.616-.054 2.281 1.581 4.415 3.949 4.89-.693.188-1.452.232-2.224.084.626 1.956 2.444 3.379 4.6 3.419-2.07 1.623-4.678 2.348-7.29 2.04 2.179 1.397 4.768 2.212 7.548 2.212 9.142 0 14.307-7.721 13.995-14.646.962-.695 1.797-1.562 2.457-2.549z" data-reactid="239"></path></svg></a><a href="https://www.instagram.com/newrepublic/" data-reactid="240"><svg class="footer__instagramIcon" aria-label="the new republic on Instagram" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" data-reactid="241"><path d="M12 2.163c3.204 0 3.584.012 4.85.07 3.252.148 4.771 1.691 4.919 4.919.058 1.265.069 1.645.069 4.849 0 3.205-.012 3.584-.069 4.849-.149 3.225-1.664 4.771-4.919 4.919-1.266.058-1.644.07-4.85.07-3.204 0-3.584-.012-4.849-.07-3.26-.149-4.771-1.699-4.919-4.92-.058-1.265-.07-1.644-.07-4.849 0-3.204.013-3.583.07-4.849.149-3.227 1.664-4.771 4.919-4.919 1.266-.057 1.645-.069 4.849-.069zm0-2.163c-3.259 0-3.667.014-4.947.072-4.358.2-6.78 2.618-6.98 6.98-.059 1.281-.073 1.689-.073 4.948 0 3.259.014 3.668.072 4.948.2 4.358 2.618 6.78 6.98 6.98 1.281.058 1.689.072 4.948.072 3.259 0 3.668-.014 4.948-.072 4.354-.2 6.782-2.618 6.979-6.98.059-1.28.073-1.689.073-4.948 0-3.259-.014-3.667-.072-4.947-.196-4.354-2.617-6.78-6.979-6.98-1.281-.059-1.69-.073-4.949-.073zm0 5.838c-3.403 0-6.162 2.759-6.162 6.162s2.759 6.163 6.162 6.163 6.162-2.759 6.162-6.163c0-3.403-2.759-6.162-6.162-6.162zm0 10.162c-2.209 0-4-1.79-4-4 0-2.209 1.791-4 4-4s4 1.791 4 4c0 2.21-1.791 4-4 4zm6.406-11.845c-.796 0-1.441.645-1.441 1.44s.645 1.44 1.441 1.44c.795 0 1.439-.645 1.439-1.44s-.644-1.44-1.439-1.44z" data-reactid="242"></path></svg></a></li><li data-reactid="243"><a href="/pages/terms-and-conditions" data-reactid="244"> Terms and Conditions</a></li><li data-reactid="245"><a href="/pages/privacy" data-reactid="246">Privacy Policy</a></li><li data-reactid="247"><a href="/pages/do-not-sell-my-personal-information" data-reactid="248">Do Not Sell</a></li></ul></div></footer></span></div>
    <script>window.__REDESIGN_PUBLIC_LAUNCH__=true</script>
    <script>window.__APOLLO_STATE__={}</script>
    <script src="//assets.newrepublic.com/assets/newmain-847ae25fb6880e43cff4.js"></script>
    
<!-- Facebook -->
  <div id="fb-root"></div>
  <script>
  window.fbAsyncInit = function() {
    FB.init({
      appId      : "1675346479369918",
      xfbml      : true,
      version    : 'v2.5'
    })
  };

  (function(d, s, id){
     var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
     if (d.getElementById(id)) {return;}
     js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id;
     js.src = "//connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js";
     fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
   }(document, 'script', 'facebook-jssdk'));
  </script>
<!-- /Facebook -->
<script type="text/javascript">window._sf_endpt = (new Date()).getTime()</script>
  </body>
</html>