We Know What You Did On Fear Street

Thirty Second Episode: The Thrill Club

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Fri, 12 Jun 2020 23:34:00 -0700

Our 32nd Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

We Know What You Did on Fear Street · Episode 32 - Thrill Club

You know what they need more of on Fear Street?? Scary stories!!! Talia and co. fill this void by meeting once a week and telling stories about one of them getting murdered. AND SHOCKER!!! The stories start coming true!! Will someone please tell Talia to stop plagiarizing because everyone knows plagarism = death in Shadyside!

Featured Book: The Thrill Club (Fear Street #24) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

The Thrill Club Stats

Characters: Talia Blanton, Seth Varner, Rudy Phillips, Maura Drake, Nessa Troy, Shandel Carter

Locations: Shadyside High School, Canyon Road, Alma's Coffee Shop, Shadyside Park, St. Elizabeth's (Arkham), Old Mill Road, Old Mill Road Cemetery

Fear Street Connection: Seth & Maura's houses

Romances: Talia/Seth/Maura/Rudy & Nessa

Fashions: White overall w/ a pink bodysuit, tight blue tank dress (velvet?) w/ black high-heeled sandals

Sweaters: 1

Kills: 2 murders, 2 weirdo soul-leaving-body deaths

Recurring Character Sightings: Jade & Deena from The Wrong Number!

Most Dated Reference: "I didn't know you'd have a cow!"

Theories:

Mia: Is there a judicial branch of the Fear Street Division?? That's the reason why Talia got off.

Michelle:

Cassi:

Cassi's PSA: Don't stop in a cemetery to tie your shoes!

Ratings:

Mia-- 2/5 Permanent Astral Projections

Michelle-- 3.5/5 Bob Classics

Cassi-- 2.5/5 Tribal Chants

Currently's

Mia

Reading: Sawkill Girls by Claire Legrand & Teeth in the Mist by Dawn Kurtagich
Watching: Lincoln Rhyme: Hunt for the Bone Collector (NBC) So Weird (Disney+)

Michelle

Reading: A Good Girl's Guide to Murder by Holly Jackson
Watching: The Stranger (Netflix)

Cassi

Reading: A Good Girl's Guide to Murder by Holly Jackson
Watching: Next in Fashion (Netflix)

Fear Street Madness

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Wed, 4 Mar 2020 07:37:00 -0800

It’s that time of year where Hero vs Villain, Final Girl vs Serial Killer, & Fear vs Goode are pitted together to see who comes out alive. It’s March Madness and we’ve finally read enough books to participate!

Over the next month, 16 competitors will face off in head-to-head match-ups until one is crowned THE SCARIEST ON FEAR STREET.

For your viewing pleasure I give you a completely random bracket of books covered in the podcast:

Click Here for a fillable bracket

Prom Queen vs Sleepwalker

The New Girl vs Runaway

Overnight vs Second Evil

First Evil vs Thrill Club

Sunburn vs Ski Weekend

The Dead Lifeguard vs Silent Night

The Secret vs Halloween Party

The Burning vs The Second Horror

How it works

There will be 3 rounds of voting. Voting will be posted on Twitter (@fearstpodcast) every Friday through March. You will have until Wednesday of the next week to vote. Except for the last poll. The final poll will be posted March 27th and voting will close March 31st. The Champion will be posted April 1st.

"What about [insert Fear Street Book here]?"

I’m sure your favorite Fear Street book did not make this bracket, neither did mine. This year we only considered books that have been covered on We Know What You Did on Fear Street. That gave us 30 books to choose from (including Thrill Club, due up this weekend!) and that is not enough for a 32 book bracket so 16 it was. Out of those 30 we chose 4 categories, assigned books to each category and used a random number generator to choose which made it onto the bracket. Scientific, No. Easy to track, Definitely.

Voting Starts on Friday!

Let us know in the comments who you think will win!

Twenty-Sixth Episode: Fear Park, The First Scream

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Sun, 29 Sep 2019 23:14:00 -0700

Our 26th Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

When the townspeople of Shadyside decide they NEED an amusement park-- there's only one location in mind: the Fear Woods. I mean, who wouldn't feel safe riding death trap rides in cursed woods?? One person not cool with their exciting plans: Nicholas Fear (who also is the son of Nora & Daniel). Will his son Robin be able to diffuse the situation, or will his dad convince everyone to get off his lawn??

Featured Book: Fear Park (Fear Park #1) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

Fear Park Stats

Characters: Meghan Fairwood, Richard Bradley, Robin Fear, Nicholas Fear, Jack Bradley, Dierdre Bradley, Paul Malone

Locations: Shadyside High School, Division Street, Roger's (Malt Shoppe), Park Drive, Fear Woods

Fear Street Connection: Robin's house, woods
Romances: Richard/Meghan/Robin, Rob/Dierdre/Paul

Fashions: Green jumper over pale lemon-colored blouse, overalls & work boots
Sweaters: 3, but LOTS of blouses

Kills: 5 confirmed-- probably everyone who was at the work site

Recurring Character Sightings: None

Most Dated Reference: Palooka?

Theories:

Mia: Questions, so many questions

Michelle: International network of Fears who pull straws to figure out who's turn it is to inhabit Shadyside

Cassi: There's a Fear family bible

Cassi's PSA: None, but put your own seatbelt on when riding a rollercoaster

Ratings:

Michelle-- 3.5/5 Purple Haze Clouds

Mia-- 3.5/5 Noooooo's

Cassi-- 3.5/5 Historical Inaccuracies

Currently's:

Michelle

Reading: We Sold Our Souls by Grady Hendrix
Watching: Dead to Me (Netflix), Chambers (Netflix)

Mia

Reading: Two Can Keep a Secret by Karen M. McManus
Watching: Possessed (Netflix)

Cassi

Reading: Aurora Rising (The Aurora Cycle #1) by Jay Kristoff & Amie Kaufman
Watching: Looking for things to watch??

Twenty-Fifth Episode: Runaway

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Mon, 20 May 2019 20:10:00 -0700

Our 25th Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Felicia Fletcher makes the stupid mistake of running TO Fear Street instead of away from it. Now, she's hiding out (aka squatting) on the infamous street, going to high school (why??), and trying to avoid the jealous girlfriend of a guy she's been kissing. Can all of this keep her distracted from what happened before she ran away?

Featured Book: Runaway (Fear Street #41) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

Runaway Stats

Characters: Felicia Fletcher/Smith, Nick, Zan (Alexandria), Doug Gaynor (RIP), Barry, Debbie Wilson, a dude named "Homicide"
Locations: Ridgely College, The Burger Basket, The Donut Hole, Shadyside High School

Fear Street Connection: 627 Fear Street
Romances: Felicia/Nick/Zan

Fashions: Wet clothes chic
Sweaters: 0

Kills: 2

Recurring Character Sightings: None

Most Dated Reference: Payphone

Theories:

Mia: Shadyside is a parallel dimension: and leaving it brings you to places all around to country.

Cassi's PSA: Peer Pressure is bad... it's a slippery slope between weed & telekinetic murder

Ratings:

Michelle-- 4/5 Soul Asylum Songs

Mia-- 4.5/5 Telekinetic Murders

Cassi-- 4/5 Fringe Jackets

Currently's:

Michelle

Reading: Now You See Her by Lisa Leighton & Laura Stropki
Watching: Project Runway (Bravo)

Mia

Reading: She's been moving
Watching: Demon Street (web-series)

Cassi

Reading: Everlasting Rose (The Belles #2) by Dhonielle Clayton
Watching: Schitt's Creek (Netflix)

Twenty-Fourth Episode: Sleepwalker

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Mon, 1 Apr 2019 23:15:00 -0700

Our 24th Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Mayra Barnes has a new summer job... on Fear Street. That was her first mistake, her second was dating a guy who does stage magic, and her third was not doing what the cat says. When she starts sleepwalking, she can't help but think it's her "old lady w/ a young face" boss casting a spell... but also a dude with a giant neck is stalking her, so what's that about???

Featured Book: The Sleepwalker (Fear Street #6) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

Sleepwalker Stats

Characters: Mayra Barnes, Mrs. Cottler, Walker, Link, Donna Cash, Stephanie (Link's sister), Mr. Kleeg (aka Mr. Clean), Dr. Sterne, Cal
Locations: Ray's Pizza Place, The Division Street Mall, Clothes Call, Lake Monolac

Fear Street Connection: Mrs. Cottler's House, Fear Lake, & Cal's House
Romances: Mayra/Walker/Suki

Fashions: Day-Glo green shorts & matching midriff top
Sweaters: 1

Kills: 1

Recurring Character Sightings: Suki Thomas, Pete Goodwin, Dr. Sterne

Most Dated Reference: Garfield the cat PJ's

Theories:

SO MANY.

Cassi's PSA: Don't date anyone who is into stage magic.

Ratings:

Michelle-- 4.5/5 Billy Joel songs (In the middle of the night, I go walking in my sleep)

Mia-- 3.5/5 Cat Familiars

Cassi-- 2.5/5 Teleporting Cats

Currently's:

Michelle

Reading: Slayer (#1) by Kiersten White, Beastie Boys Book
Watching: The Dirt (YES, WATCH IT!!!!) (Netflix), Binging 90's-2000's movies, Light as a Feather (Hulu)

Mia

Reading: Pet Sematary by Stephen King
Watching: The Witch Files (Netflix), Re:Mind (Netflix)

Cassi

Reading: Slayer (#1) by Kiersten White, Courting Darkness (Duology #1) by Robin LaFevers
Watching: The Umbrella Academy (Netflix)

Twenty-Third Episode: Double Date

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Wed, 27 Feb 2019 18:22:00 -0800

Our 23rd Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Bobby Newkirk sucks!!! After working his way through the cheerleading squad, Bobby "full of himself" Newkirk decides to bet himself that he can date a set of twins at the same time. The problem with that (besides the fact that it's gross)?? The Wade twins live on Fear Street-- and one of them might be crazy.... murderously crazy. Muahahahahhaa.

Featured Book: Double Date (Fear Street #23) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

Double Date Stats

Characters: Bobby Newkirk, Bree & Samantha Wade, Arnie, Paul, Melanie Harris, Kimmy Bass
Locations: The Mill (old abandoned), Division Street Mall, River Ridge, The Corner, The Gold Barn, Pete's Pizza

Fear Street Connection: Wade House (the "last" house on Fear Street)
Romances: Sam/Bobby/Bree

Fashions: Another disgusting vest-- this one is SILKY
Sweaters: NONE!

Kills: NONE! (not cool)

Recurring Character Sightings: Ronnie Mitchell, Kimmy Bass, Suki Thomas, David Metcalf, Cory Brooks, Arnie

Most Dated Reference: The one strap backpack

Possible Band Names:

The Dry Heaves
The Hot Bods
The Emotional Ones
Thrills and Chills
The Chicken Livered Wimps
Plastic Monkey Heads
Cannibal Ants

Songs Bobby wrote during the duration of DOUBLE DATE:

"Was she trying to make me feel bad?"
"Bree doesn't know (don't tell Bree)"
"Who's the man (you the man)"
"Am I a bet?"
"I wish I was double-jointed"
"Too bad she can't dance"
"Melanie (is having a cow)"
"It's so easy to control girls"
"She's even weird about pizza"
"I got zapped"
"Honey"

Theories:

We had nothing to say besides BOBBY NEWKIRK sucks. And the driving theory was clearly upheld (teens MUST drive like aholes in Shadyside).

Cassi's PSA: Only Date 1 person at a time. Also, don't date Bobby Newkirk.

Ratings:

Michelle-- 4/5 I want to ride and ride and ride

Mia-- 3/5 Temporary Tattoos

Cassi-- 3/5 Terrible Bandnames

Currently's:

Michelle

Reading: My Best Friend's Exorcism by Grady Hendrix
Watching: Carmen Sandiego (Netflix), Conversations with a Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes (Netflix)

Mia

Reading: Burnt Offerings by Robert Marasco
Watching: Carmen Sandiego (Netflix), The Punisher: Season 2 (Netflix)
Playing: The Sims

Cassi

Reading: King of Scars (Nikolai Duology #1) by Leigh Bardugo
Watching: Fyre (Netflix), Kim's Convenience (Netflix)

Article about Dan Mallory that we talked about

Fear Street Friday-- We Will Go Down With These Ships

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Fri, 15 Feb 2019 05:34:00 -0800

Happy Valentine's Day(ish) Fear Street fans!!

We're not the most romance-centric bunch that you'd ever meet, but in honor of the holiday we decided to share with you our ultimate ships (romantic relationships we like) and OTPs (One True Pairs). We broke it down into Fear Street (which was super hard because these Shadyside High relationships are NOT good) AND our other favorite ships from TV/Movies/Books.

(PS- Click on the book covers for more info about them)

AND if your Valentine's Day didn't rock-- we've got you covered with THESE break-up songs to rock-out to!!

Fear Street Ships

Dawn/Leather Jacket - Prom Queen

Dawn and that Leather Jacket have been through a lot together. She saved it from a life of the unfashionable and it saved her from a knife. Plus, in true Fear Street mode, she stole if from her "friend".

Angelica/Simon - The Burning

Dark powers, evil schemes and more money than they know what to do with. Angelica and Simon were meant to be together. They're two peas in a homicidal pod, except Angelica's better with magic. They should have stayed in New Orleans and continued to force their will on the rest of the high society fodder.

Other Ships

Joey/Pacey - Dawson's Creek

The OTP to beat all OTPs. Pacey is still the perfect guy and around him Joey becomes much more bearable. I've been a Pacey/Joey 'shipper since that episode in season 1 where they have to do the horny frog science project together. So romantic.

Faith/Wesley - Angel the Series

This 'ship comes with caveats. I only 'ship Faith/Wesley season 3 of Angel and beyond; after Faith and Wesley have both hit rock bottom and are starting to figure out how to make up for the shit they've pulled. They're both angsty and contrite and perfect for each other.

Chuck/Blair - Gossip Girl

This one is simple. They're both too smart and too classy for everyone else in NYC. The only good parts of Gossip Girl were Chuck and Blair scheming together. I love scheming Chuck and Blair!

Fear Street Ships

Della & Pete- The Overnight OTP

These 2 are totally endgame-- I mean it's the least dysfunctional relationship in Shadyside that we've seen so far!

Cory- The New Girl & Lea- The Secret Bedroom

I'm shipping these 2 because they're both stalkers and probably belong together? Lea may not have been as straight up stupid as Corey, but she sure was as dense. Girl was always showing up places thinking she was going to get with Don-- NEWS FLASH, he's just not that into you!! With that kind of commitment to a non-real romance, I think she's perfect for Corey.

Other Ships

Joey and Pacey- Dawson's Creek OTP

Is there a fictional character better than Pacey Witter?? When there is a love triangle, I'm usually on the wrong side of it-- so when this actually happened?!?!?!? Well, let's just say the series finale is one of my most watched episodes of any show ever (that and, of course, the K-Mart lock-in episode).

Movie Katniss & Peeta- The Hunger Games

Book Katniss and Peeta did not do it for me. In the book, Katniss is SO understandably messed-up and emotionally closed off. In the movie, Katniss fucking LOVES Peeta and it is NOT an act for the capitol. I felt that love.

Dylan & Brenda- Beverly Hills 90210

Brenda and Dylan forever. If you shipped Dylan & Kelly or Dylan & whoever else on this show, you were wrong and I will fight you over it :)

Cinder & Thorne- The Lunar Chronicles series by Marissa Meyer

If you read the Lunar Chronicles series, you know that Cinder is meant to be with Kai and Thorne is meant to be with Cress. And to that I say: NO!! Cress is SO annoying and definitely not socially ready to be in a relationship. And Cinder had so much more chemistry with Thorne than she did with Kai. I knew it wasn't going to happen, but in my head it did!!

Fear Street Ship

Corky and Ricky- The New Year's Party

I know you both hate me for this but I seriously do ship them, not even joking. One thing you will notice in a lot of my ships is that I like when they play with the trope and the girl is the heroic one and I feel like these two fall into that. Plus I like the idea that they met in a Fear Street support group where they were like "BITCH, I GOT FUCKED UP IN TWO BOOKS!"

Other Ships

Veronica and Logan in Veronica Mars

This is another example of the female being the hero. But also, their love story is epic spanning years and continents, ruined lives and bloodshed, because they don't write songs about the ones that are easy.

Leslie Knope & Ben Wyatt- Parks and Recreation

I identify hardcore with these two, like I am a weird combination of Leslie and Ben. So them getting together felt like validation. Plus they are just so damn cute.

Kaz & Inej- Six of Crows by Leigh Bardugo

In terms of most romances, I like a slowburn. And this relationship is quite the slowburn. These two had me wanting them to get together for so long that even them holding hands felt like the sweetest and most romantic thing.

Katniss and Peeta- The Hunger Games

I'm adding this one to the list because because there was so much discussion of Team Peeta or Team Gale and this was a time where it was so rare for me to ship a couple that is actually endgame. I've blocked out all my ships that never sailed but this one I remember.

Ronan & Adam- The Raven Cycle by Maggie Steifvater

This one is fresh in my mind because the title and cover for the new Ronan book was just released. But I was not initially a shipper of these two but then when I saw the subtle clues of their feelings I was in it hardcore. So much so that I even fell down a fan art rabbit hole.

Talk to us!! What are your OTPs?? Do you have any non-canon ships?? Are you a Pacey/Joey, Dylan/Brenda person?? (Hahahah, what am I saying, of course you are!!).

Twenty Second Episode: Ski Weekend

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Mon, 4 Feb 2019 08:00:00 -0800

Our 22nd Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Ariel, Doug, and Shannon may not be in Shadyside anymore, but that doesn't mean they're safe. Traveling in a snowstorm with a stranger AND a girl who lives on Fear Street AND a dude who drives in the snow like an asshat probably aren't the best choices... but taking the "country road" over the highway & going to a rando house in the woods w/ more strangers just might get them killed...

Featured Book: Ski Weekend (Fear Street #10) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

Ski Weekend Stats

Characters: Doug, Ariel, Shannon, Red, Eva, Lou Hitchcock
Locations: Pineview Lodge & the mouse house

Fear Street Connection: Ariel's House (maybe Shannon)
Romances: Ariel/Red, Shannon/Doug

Fashions: Green corduroy "slacks"
Sweaters: 5

Kills: 2

Recurring Character Sightings: None-- not even a Gary Bandt mention?!?!?

Most Dated Reference: "I got the tape"

Theories:

Mia's Theories: Lou was putting them on edge by acting like a loose cannon-- it was all calculated.
Living on Fear Street gives you psychic powers: Ariel.

Michelle's Theory: Driving theory (that all teens must drive like a-holes) upheld.

Cassi's PSA: Stranger Danger

Ratings:

Michelle-- 4.5/5 Last Icefall (hopefully) aka "I hate these meeces to pieces"

Mia-- 5/5 Future Medical Examiners

Cassi-- 4/5 Frozen Snowballs

Currently's:

Michelle

Reading: Two Can Keep a Secret by Karen M. McManus
Watching: You (Netflix)

Mia

Reading: NOS4A2 by Joe Hill
Watching: Birdbox (Netflix), Black Mirror: Bandersnatch (Netflix)

Cassi

Reading: Runaways: Vol 2 by Rainbow Rowell (is it really reading, if it's comics??? hahahaha.), Giant Days series by John Allison
Watching: Outlander (Starz), Parks & Rec (Netflix)

Twenty-First Episode: Silent Night 2

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Wed, 2 Jan 2019 20:31:00 -0800

Our 21st Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Reva Dalby is back!! Did you really think that her vow of niceness would last?? SPOILER: It didn't. Now, while Reva is busy thinking (and saying) terrible things about people, a group of completely inept wannabe criminals are plotting to kidnap her for ransom. Do they not know if you kidnap Reva Dalby, you also kidnap her mouth??

Featured Book: Silent Night 2 (Fear Street Super Chiller #5) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Covers mentioned:

Silent Night 2 Stats

Characters: Reva Dalby, Pam Dalby, Paul Nichols AKA Pres, Diane Morris, Robert Dalby, Danny (the unstable, angry stock character), Victor Dias
Locations: Dalby's Department Store, Waynesbridge, Freddy's, River Ridge (makeout spot), Conononka River, Division Street Mall

Fear Street Connection: Pam's House
Romances: Diane/Pres, Reva/Victor/Pam, Reva/Herself

Fashions: Brown leather bomber jacket, the floppy navy blue hat (a Blossom hat???), Pam's Christmas outfit: red tights, green skirt, red stretch top (whatever that is), red & green ribbons in hair
Sweaters: 6

Kills: 1

Recurring Character Sightings: None

Most Dated Reference: Wall-to-wall carpet, number revealer (call-ID, Bob).

Theories:

Mia's Theories: Danny is dying of a brain tumor, Mr. Dalby never told anyone about Pam's kidnapping.

Michelle's Theory: Dr. Jekyll, Mr. Hyde retelling

Ratings:

Michelle-- 3/5 Snarky Thoughts

Mia-- 2/5 OSHA Violations

Cassi-- 1/3 Stupid Criminals

Twentieth Episode: The Secret Bedroom

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Mon, 19 Nov 2018 23:56:00 -0800

Our 20th Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Welcome to Shadyside Lea Carson!! There's another new girl on Fear Street and her new house has a secret. There's a boarded-up room in the attic and Lea can't stay away from it. What is in there?? Will we ever know-- or did nothing ever happen and this book should have not existed?

Featured Book: The Secret Bedroom (Fear Street #13) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

The Secret Bedroom Stats

Characters: Lea Carson, Marci Hendryx, Don Jacobs, Catherine (the ghost)

Locations: Division Street Mall, Pete's Pizza

Fear Street Connection: Lea's House
Romances: Lea/Don/Marci

Fashions: Short green suade skirt over black tights and a silky green top
Sweaters: 5

Kills: 1

Recurring Character Sightings: Deena Martinson, Jade Smith, Ricky Schorr, Cory Brooks, Gary Brandt

Most Dated Reference: Sassy Magazine

Theories:

Mia's Theories: The parents on Fear Street are never home because they're smarter than that. Catherine isn't really gone-- she set up the whole skeleton incident so that Lea will think she left.

Cassi's PSA: That's not how fever dreams work.

Ratings:

Michelle-- 2/5 Super Stalker Girls

Mia-- 2.5/5 House Flips

Cassi-- 2.5/5 Shabby Railings

Nineteenth Episode: The Wrong Number

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Thu, 25 Oct 2018 21:36:00 -0700

Our 19th Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Welcome to the 90est of all 90's books-- a book that could never be updated. It may lack in smart characters, but it makes up in NOSTALGIA and a reverse Scooby-Doo plot.

Featured Book: The Wrong Number (Fear Street #2) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

The Wrong Number Stats

Characters: Deena Martinson, Jade Smith, Chuck Martinson, Rob Morell, Stanley Farberson

Locations: North Hills, Division Street, Old Mill Road, Canyon Drive, Park Drive, The Alberga Three, Old Village, Division Street Mall, Pete's Pizza

Fear Street Connection: 884 Fear Street-- The Farberson residence
Romances: Jade/Chuck

Fashions: Pink and white checked jumpsuit w/ shortsleeves, Denim jumpsuit w/ patches, Navy jumper w/ a pink wool jacket
Sweaters: 1

Kills: 1

Recurring Character Sightings: Cory Brooks, Lisa Blume, Della O'Connor

Most Dated Reference: Everything-- phones, phone books, tape player, VHS tape, Kim Basinger, Dire Straits

Mia's Theories: Fear Street division has future-telling forensics, Fog covers Fear Street and it messes with your memory, The clay they found on Fear Street is either the chared bodies of the people/ghosts the died in the fire OR Angelica brought it from New Orleans to use in her special witchy rituals.

Michelle's Theory:

Cassi's Theories: Jade is Claudia.

Ratings:

Michelle-- 2.5/5 Awesome Jumpsuits

Mia-- 2/5 Dumpster Dives

Cassi-- 3/6 Wrongful Arrests

Eighteenth Episode: Cheerleaders-- The 2nd Evil

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Thu, 25 Oct 2018 21:14:00 -0700

Our 18th Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Summer O'Saga is over :( But don't worry-- this one transitions us really well!! The Ancient Evil is back... and so is Sarah Fear(?). If you want Razzmatazz and Possession, we've got you covered.

Featured Book: The Second Evil (Cheerleaders #2) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

The Second Evil Stats

Characters: Kimmy Bass, Debra Kern, Ronnie Mitchell, Corky Corcoran, Chip Chasner, Sarah Beth Plummer, Miss Green, Jon Daly (Jennifer's Brother), Ben Fear, Heather Diehl, Megan Carman, Sean Corcoran

Locations: North Hills, Division Street, Old Mill Road, Alma's, Fear Lake, Simon Fear's Mansion, Fear Street Cemetary

Fear Street Connection: Corcoran House, Fear Street Cemetary, Fear Mansion
Romances: Chip/Corky

Fashions: Awesome 90's outfit- tights, denim cutoffs, & oversized t-shirts
Sweaters: 6

Kills: 2

Recurring Character Sightings: Suki Thomas!! Gary Brandt, Myrna Barnes

Most Dated Reference: Crimped Hair

Mia's Theories:

Michelle's Theory:

Ratings:

Michelle-- 3.5/5 Fake Sarah Fears

Mia-- 3.5/5 Pleasure Boats (AKA Gang Bangs)

Cassi-- 3.5/5 Razzamatazz

Seventeenth Episode: Summer of Saga-- The Burning

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Thu, 25 Oct 2018 20:39:00 -0700

Our 17th Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

This summer we're going back... back to the beginning of it all!! Follow along with us as we read all 3 Saga books and find out the origins of the Fear family. Use #SummerofSaga on Twitter to talk with us about it (& tell us if you're #TeamFier or #TeamGoode)!!

Featured Book: The Burning (The Fear Street Saga #1) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

The Burning Stats

Characters: Simon Fear, Angelica Pierce, James Daumier, Hamilton Scott, Julia (17), Hannah (16), Robert (14), Brandon (11), Joseph (5), Mrs. Mackenzie, Lucy Goode, Daniel Fear, Nora Goode

Locations: New Orleans 1845, Shadyside Village 1865-1900

Fear Street Connection: The infamous Fear Mansion

Romances: Nora/Daniel, Simon/Angelica/James&Hamilton

Fashions: Capes!!! Ruffled shirts, 3 tiered hooped skirts, ribbon tied around a neck (does her head fall off?)

Kills: 10-- and one murdered dog

Recurring Character Sightings: None (the Ancient Evil)

Most Dated Reference: Everything!!

Mia's Theories: The Fears left New Orleans because they were the Delphine LaLaurie's of their time or Marie Laveau told them to scram. The maid in Shadyside is old Aggie from the last book. Nora is the first patient of Arkham.

Cassi's Theory: The curse continues in modern day because all the redheads in town are descendants of Fears & Goodes.

Ratings:

Michelle-- 3/5 Goblets of Blood

Mia-- 3.5/5 Birthday Corpses

Cassi-- 3/5 Secret Rooms

Sixteenth Episode: Summer of Saga-- The Secret

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Tue, 9 Oct 2018 18:56:00 -0700

Our 16th Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Featured Book: The Secret (The Fear Street Saga #1) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

The Secret Stats

Characters: Jonathan Fier, Ezra Fier, Jane Fier, Abigail Fier, Rachel Fier, Delilah Wilson, Elizabeth Fier, Simon Fier, Samuel Fier, Kate Fier, Katherine Fier, Franklin Goode, Old Aggie

Locations: Wickham Village, Western Massachusetts

Fear Street Connection: None (yet.)
Romances: Nora/Daniel, Susannah/Edward, Jeremy/Mary

Fashions: Cloaks!!!

Kills: 7

Recurring Character Sightings: None (the Ancient Evil)

Most Dated Reference: Everything!!

Mia's Theories:

Michelle's Theory: The Amulet is a honing device (sort of like the book from Hocus Pocus)

Cassi's Theory: Redheads in Shadyside are all decendents of Fears.

Ratings:

Michelle-- 5/5

Mia-- 4/5

Cassi-- 4/5

Fifteenth Episode: SUMMER OF SAGA-- The Betrayal

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Tue, 4 Sep 2018 04:29:00 -0700

Our 15th Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Featured Book: The Betrayal (The Fear Street Saga #1) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

The Betrayal Stats

Characters: Susannah Goode, Martha Goode, George Goode, William Goode, Benjamin Fier, Matthew Fier, Edward Fier, Mary Fier, Constance Fier, Rebecca Fier, Ezra Fier, Jeremy Thorne

Locations: Wickham Village, Wild Western PA

Fear Street Connection: None (yet.)
Romances: Nora/Daniel, Susannah/Edward, Jeremy/Mary

Fashions: Cloaks!!!

Kills: 6

Recurring Character Sightings: None (the Ancient Evil)

Most Dated Reference: Everything!!

Mia's Theories:

Michelle's Theory:

Cassi's Theory: Redheads in Shadyside are all decendents of Fears.

Ratings:

Michelle-- 5/5 Fires that Won't Go Out

Mia-- 4/5 Popping Heads

Cassi-- 4/5 Unsurprising Plot-Twist Nominees

Fourteenth Episode: Bad Moonlight

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Wed, 16 May 2018 08:00:00 -0700

Our 14th Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Featured Book: Bad Moonlight (Super Chiller #8) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

Bad Moonlight Stats

Characters: Danielle Verona, Caroline, Billy Dark, Joey, Kit Kragen, Dee Waters, Mary Beth, Dr. Moore, Aunt Margaret, Cliff (the brother), Shawna Davidson

Locations: North Hills, Division Street, Park Drive, Mill Road, Midland Hotel, the Rocket Club, the Roadhouse, Red Heat

Fear Street Connection: Danielle's House
Romances: Danielle/Kit

Fashions: the Alaia

Kills: 5

Recurring Character Sightings: None

Most Dated Reference: Super Soaker

Mia's Theories: Post Bad Moonlight they are a werewolf band (with a new name) that becomes the most popular band in Shadyside (take that The Razors!!) and play at the proms & at Red Heat.

Michelle's Theory: Dee is a werewolf slayer and that's why she was killed. Also, the "teens from Shadyside must drive like assholes" theory is upheld.

Cassi's PSA: Don't drink out of puddles.

Ratings:

Michelle-- 1.5/5 Coyote Ugly Knock-Offs

Mia-- 3.5/5 Werewolf Slayers

Cassi-- 3.5/5 Hallucinations

Thirteenth Episode: The New Boy-- & Our 1 Year Anniversary!!

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Mon, 9 Apr 2018 06:58:00 -0700

Our 13th Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Featured Book: The New Boy (Fear Street #20) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

The New Boy Stats

Characters: Janie Simpson, Faith, Eve Miller, Paul Gordon (Faith's BF), Ian Smith (Eve's BF), Ross Gabriel aka Robert Kingston, Jordan Bly

Locations: North Hills, Canyon Drive, Old Village, Old Mill Road, Pete's Pizza, White Castle, the Mall, Doughnut Hole, Shadyside Park, Congnonka River, Park Drive

Fear Street Connection: Ross's House
Romances: Janie/Ross/Eve/Ian, Faith/Paul

Fashions: Blue blazer & sexy red denims, Cover art-- turtleneck & cable-knit sweater UNDER a jean jacket

Kills: 2

Recurring Character Sightings: Corky Corcoran, Kimmy Bass, Deena Martinson, Gary Brandt, Pam Dalby, Ricky Schorr

Most Dated Reference: Cordless phone w/ antenna (& Speed Dial)

Mia's Theories: Bloodstain Theory (Bloodstain = The Cheese Touch), Parents in Shadyside are part of a cult that sacrifices their children to the evil of Fear Street
Cassi's Theory: The water in Shadyside is poisoned with something that makes people bad at jokes
Michelle's Theory: Ross is dead or he's Sam Beckett in Quantum Leap.

Cassi's PSA: Don't cheat on your boyfriend (especially if he's a raging psycho).

Ratings:

Michelle-- 2/5 Ross is not cools

Mia-- 2/5 Blue Scarves

Cassi-- 2.5/5 Problematic Male Characters

Twelfth Episode: Missing

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Tue, 20 Mar 2018 06:00:00 -0700

Our 12th Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Featured Book: Missing (Fear Street #4) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

Missing Stats

Characters: Mark Burroughs, Cara Burroughs, Gena Rowlings, Captain Farraday, Mr. Marcus, Roger

Locations: Division Street, Cranford Industries, Mill Road, Hawthorne Drive, Alma's

Fear Street Connection: The Burroughs house
Romances: Mark/Gena

Fashions: Cover fashion-- possible Endless Summer t-shirt??

Kills: 2 (the dog is fine)

Recurring Character Sightings: Cory Brooks, Dave Metcalf, Lisa Blume, Arnie Torbin, Gary Brandt

Most Dated Reference: Swatch Watch

Mia's Theories: Fear Woods = Drug Dens, Animals succumb to the evil that permeates the woods. Shadyside pays people to live on Fear Street.
Cassi's Theory: The Government is doing top-secret experiments on Fear Street.

Cassi's PSA: Don't get into cars with people who say they're police in unmarked cars.

Ratings:

Michelle-- 4.5/5 Struck Poses

Mia-- 4.5/5 Monkey Skulls

Cassi-- 4.5/5 Subversive Groups

Eleventh Episode: Broken Hearts

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Fri, 16 Feb 2018 05:30:00 -0800

Our Eleventh Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!

Featured Book: Broken Hearts (Superchiller #4) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

Broken Hearts Stats

Characters: Erica, Josie, & Rachel McClain, Melissa Davis, Jerry Jenkman (Josie's original boyfriend), Luke Hoskins (Rachel's boyfriend), Dave Kinley (Melissa's boyfriend-- Josie's ex-boyfriend), Steve Barron (Josie's new boyfriend)

Locations: Shadyside Riding Club, The Corner, Shadyside Indoor Rink, Fear Lake, Greetings

Romances: Jerry/Josie/Steve, Rachel/Luke/Melissa/Dave

Fashions: The muffler worn by Luke & 4 sweaters

Kills: 3 and a dog :(

Recurring Character Sightings: Cory Brooks, Dave (Donald) Metcalf, Lisa Blume

Most Dated Reference: Cassette Tape

Mia's Theories: Melissa can only date McClain ex's. Supernatural Shadyside Security should be a thing.

Thought to Ponder: By living on Fear Street, does it make you more susceptible to being a victim or a psycho.

Cassi's PSA: Wear a helmet. Don't be an asshole.

Ratings:

Michelle-- 5/5 Ominous Locker Messages

Mia-- 3/5 Red Wigs

Cassi-- 3/5 Bad Poems

Broken Hearts Playlist

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Fri, 9 Feb 2018 05:07:00 -0800

Happy Fear Street Friday!! The 3 of us may not be the most **swoon** romantic types of gals, but that doesn't mean we're like Josie McClain-- heart of stone anyone?? We've had our share of heartbreak, and what do you do when your heart is broken? Listen to epic break-up music of course!!
Here is a playlist we put together to celebrate our book for February: Broken Hearts (Superchiller #4). Maybe Luke and Jerry Jenkman should have had a mixed tape of these songs and they would've been more chill...

Fear Street Playlist-- Broken Hearts
ULTIMATE 90's PLAYLIST

Fear Street Final Girls

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Fri, 2 Feb 2018 05:20:00 -0800

In honor of Women in Horror Month, us girls at WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET are going to be doing some womenly horror posts-- starting with our favorite FINAL GIRLS on Fear Street (so far).

Not everyone makes it off Fear Street alive. For those that do they find themselves in the most exclusive club. These women are wiser, stronger and more traumatized than any of us, but which ones are the best? Which do we look up to as true Final Girls?

1. Nikki Meyer from The Halloween Party

Nikki was the only one to keep calm during Justine’s terrifying remake of the car crash her parents died in, mostly because she couldn't actually hear any of the terrible noises. Still, it’s Nikki who first suspects something weird is going on, Nikki who investigates and begins to put together the clues, and Nikki who gets them the majority of the guests out of the murder party alive. She’s smart, cool in a crisis, and has some sort of magic eyesight that let’s her lip-read through walls. She’s definitely on my “survive a night in Fear Mansion” team.

2. Reva Dalby from Silent Night

Reva’s terrible. She’s mean and bitchy and selfish, but she’s also not a pushover. She’s smart and honestly, I’d rather have her with me than against me. Don’t mess with a mean girl. She will end you.

3. Cara Burroughs from Missing

When Cara’s parents go missing she doesn’t lose her cool. She teams up with her brother to find them and save the day. Cara must have read a lot of Nancy Drew growing up and it paid off. She is determined to solve the mystery, save the day and reign in her brother all without breaking a sweat. Oh, and she doesn’t take any of your gaslighting BS. You’re lying and she knows it.

1. Corky Corcoran from Cheerleaders: The First Evil

Obviously, I had to go with Corky. She is probably the most final girl of all the characters in this series that I have met. Not only is making sure she’s trying solve the mystery but she also has to deal with the loss of her sister. And she kicks some serious Ancient Evil ass in the first of what I assume is many dirt tornados.

2. Dawn Rodgers from The Prom Queen and Bad Dreams

We joke about Dawn being in all the clubs and not really having any boyfriends but she’s freaking resilient. Not only did she survive one attempted murder, but multiple attempts.She survived being pushed down the stairs in Bad Dreams and in The Prom Queen they tried to kill her like five times. Plus for one of them, she only survived because she stole a leather jacket. Much respect for that.

3. Lisa Blume from The New Girl and like all the books

Lisa was like the only character I liked in The New Girl. She was the only one who had her head on straight. Plus she totally got the brunt of the shit in that book. There were dead cats in her locker and she got pushed down the stairs. But she came out of it (relatively) unscathed and was even elected student council president at one point. Her only issue is that she’s still dating Cory. I hope he becomes a villain in a later book and she has to cut him loose.

1. Lizzie McVay- The Prom Queen

She didn't fall for Justin Stiles crap, and remember when that creepy guy Lucas tried to mess with her?? She rolled the window up on his fingers and kicked his ass out of her car. She also gave a hell of a fight at the end of Prom Queen, and held the murderer down until the cops arrived.

2. Della O’Connor- The Overnight

When dude tried to attack her, she pushed him down a ravine. Sure, she made some bad decisions after that, but in the end she did NOT need Gary or Pete to save her, she saved herself... oh and she'll shoot you in the face with a ZAP gun with zero fucks given.

3. Kimmy Bass-- Cheerleaders Trilogy

I don’t like her, okay?? But she survives a lot of ancient evil shizzzzzz. Including…. Well, I don’t want to spoil books 2 & 3 for Cassi, but she fucking GETS it in those books.

Who are your fave Final Girls in Shadyside??

Tenth Episode: The New Year's Party

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Mon, 22 Jan 2018 09:05:00 -0800

Our Tenth Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is now available!!!

Featured Book: The New Year's Party (Superchiller #9) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

New Year's Party Stats

Characters: Reenie Baker, Greta Sorenson, Artie Hodges, Ty Lanford, Sean, Sandi Burke, Marc Bentley, Liz/Beth, PJ/Jeremy

Locations: Red Heat, Two Cute, Burger Basket, Old Mill Road

Romances: Artie/Greta/PJ, Reenie/Sean

Fashions: Plaid shirt w/ ripped jeans, Sweater OVER a turtleneck, Short black dress w/ a sparkly vest & sheer black stockings

Kills: 5 (or 3)

Recurring Character Sightings: Deena Martinson, Corky Corcoran, Ricky Schorr, Pete Goodwin, Lisa Blume, Justin Stiles

Most Dated Reference: Snail Mail (although there were 1960's references galore)

Mia's Theories: This is a glitch in the Matrix, You can't come back as a ghost unless you A. die on Fear Street and B. are a teenager

Cassi's Theories: All the books are happening during the same school year.

Michelle's Theory: The ancient evil possesses all cars driven by teenagers.

Cassi's PSA: Don't walk on frozen water.

Ratings:

Michelle-- 3/5 Halloween Reboots

Mia-- 2/5

Cassi-- 4/5 Abandoned Mansions

Ninth Episode: Silent Night

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Tue, 9 Jan 2018 03:37:00 -0800

Our Eighth Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is available!!!

Featured Book: Silent Night (Superchiller #2) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

Other Covers in the series:

Silent Night Stats

Characters: Reva Dalby, Michael Dalby (6), Pam Dalby, Hank Davis, Mickey Waley, Lissa Dewey, Mitch Castelona, Foxy, Clay Parker, Robb Spring

Locations: Dalby's (on Division Street), 7-11 on Mission Street

Romances: Pshhhht, you know Reva loves only Reva

Fashions: Chinos!!! Sweaters (8)!!!

Kills: 3

Recurring Character Sightings: None

Most Dated Reference: Shoulder Pads baby!!!

Mia's Theories: Fear Street is leaking, Fear Street Mutant Powers??, 99% of the police budget is the Fear Street Division

Cassi's Theories: Mr. Dalby = Ocean's 11

Cassi's PSA: Don't be a boyfriend stealer & don't open packages leaking blood.

Ratings:

Michelle-- 3.5/5 Boyfriend Stealers

Mia-- 3.5/5 Deparment Store Mannequins

Cassi-- 4/5 Superfluous Car Chases

Mini Review - Midsummer Night's Scream

noreply@blogger.com (Mia) — Fri, 8 Dec 2017 13:02:00 -0800

This week on #FearStreetFriday we take a shallow dive into the pages of R.L. Stine's mash-up of Shakespeare and Slasher movies, A Midsummer Night's Scream.

Were there masks in this book?

60 years ago three teens died in horrifying accidents while filming Mayhem Manor. Now Claire and her friends have been cast in the remake being produced by Claire’s father’s studio (talk about nepotism).

It’s not long before the teens find themselves having the same accidents as the cast from 60 years ago! And because that’s not strange enough, there’s a creepy troll named Benny in a mysterious trailer filled with magic potions.

This book was bonkers! Part Fear Street in LA and part that one episode of Are You Afraid of the Dark with the leprechaun and the troll, but all ridiculous fun.

Full disclosure, I have this weird eye strain thing right now so I listened to the audio book version and fell asleep for like 40 minutes during the climax, BUT that did not stop my enjoyment of this romp through Stine’s weird brain.

First of all, I love how Claire and her friends are kind of shallow and terribly spoiled, but none of them are complete wastes of space. They’re just teenagers and they’re a lot of fun even when they do or say something that deserves a slap (which is often). Just don’t expect anyone to mature or learn a lesson in this book. These kids give Reva Dalby a run for her money in the lack of self-awareness department.

Then there’s the way Stine doesn’t mess around with his kills. Don’t expect a fake out cliffhanger on every chapter. Even though he had the perfect stage for pranks and fake outs, every broken neck and melted face counts. No take-backs in this book.

And my favorite part of this book is how Stine seems to be completely unaware that some genres shouldn’t mix. Are we having a fun romp full of magic potion mix-ups and teenaged pining or is this a slasher movie that knocks off it’s cast (pun intended) one by one until it’s just the final girl against the killer? Stine doesn’t think he needs to choose. He gives us the “best” of both worlds.

And if anyone wants to tell me what Bad Guy McBaderson's motivations were, I would be much obliged. I slept through that part.

I give this one 3/5 aging potions.

-Mia

Eighth Episode: Bad Dreams

noreply@blogger.com (Michelle) — Wed, 29 Nov 2017 02:54:00 -0800

Our Eighth Episode of WE KNOW WHAT YOU DID ON FEAR STREET is available!!!

Featured Book: Bad Dreams (Fear Street #22) by R.L. Stine

Music Cred: Creepy Loop by LisaCole

Follow us on Twitter: @fearstpodcast

Email us: fearstreetpodcast@gmail.com

Cover:

Bad Dreams Stats

Characters-- Maggie & Andrea Travers, Justin Stiles, Tiffany Hollings, Dawn Rodgers

Locations-- The Corner, Shadyside High School

Romances-- Maggie/Justin
Fashions-- White T-shirt w/ a green checked vest

Kills-- None :(

Recurring Character sightings-- Justin, Dawn, Deena Martinson, Jade Smith

Most Dated Reference-- Map (like a REAL paper map), Trapper Keeper (the star of the show)

Mia's Theories-- Maggie is an unreliable narrator and this whole story is BS.
Michelle's Theory-- Shadyside is a part of the Men in Black universe and memories are routinely erased so that Fear Street phenomenon is not reported in the media
Cassi's Theory-- The Ancient Evil did it

Cassi's PSA-- Be nice to your sister!!

Ratings

Michelle - 2/5 Nytol Tablets that went unused

Cassi - 2/5 Ancient Evils

Mia - 1.5/5 White Lacey Nightgowns