I think for the sake of my sanity I’m going to treat this book the way that I treated Once Upon a Witch’s Death, which also was licensed by Yen as a one-shot and then had future volumes roll out much later in Japan. CIW notably has not called this Volume 1, implying it’s complete in one book. The webnovel is very clearly complete, but this book stops just before the climactic battle and has a bunch of side stories instead. The author says in the afterword they were surprised this got a LN pickup at all. So, let’s put it this way: if this does have a second volume to wrap things up, then I definitely recommend it, as I found it a lot of fun, especially its heroine. If this is all that we get, I suspect it will just be frustrating. And if it turns out the book is actually complete and my digital copy is missing a chapter or two, please let me know.

Let’s also get a content warning out of the way: this book is filled with blood and gore, most of it caused by the heroine killing people. They’re all trying to kill her, to be clear, she’s not evil. Bellreuge is the 2nd princess of an empire, an illegitimate child, and has spent literally her entire life dodging assassination attempts and learning from her mother how to fight back. Her older sister was briefly sweet and loving to her, but when the Queen died big sis turned 100% evil. To avoid constant assassins every day, Bellreuge became her sister’s handmaiden, essentially working as a slave and being abused left and right. Now, finally, her sister is going to be married. Except… the margrave’s son, a man with a bloody reputation, proposes to Bellreuge instead!

That synopsis covers about the first 2 pages of this book. The rest involves Bellreuge being forced to escape constant walls of people trying to kill her and going to the margravate, which turns out to be a country of hotheads who love to fight, and her new fiance is merely the worst of them. Bellreuge herself is so emotionally beaten down by years of abuse and constant death threats that, while she’s perfectly capable of acting like a royal princess if she needs to, she also tends to go to “stiletto in the brain” as the “when all you have is a hammer” answer. She and Asturm, her fiance, are awkward around each other for about half the book as they simply haven’t communicated at all, and the scene where they turn an archery contest into a “yes, I think I could fall in love with you” is the best in the book. Unfortunately, much as Bellreuge wants to simply avoid anything to do with her situation, everyone else in the world knows she has to fight her sister and become Empress. They gather armies and prepare to do battle…

And then we get short stories from the POV of her maid/bodyguard, Asturm himself, and his little sister to round things off. The end! Highly recommended if there’s a 2nd volume eventually, mildly recommended if this is all we get.

MICHELLE: I am certainly intrigued by On Their Frontlines, but I do really love the works of Kazune Kawahara and it’s about time I read some of A Star Brighter Than the Sun, so I will go with that, this time.

ASH: Kazune Kawahara manga are always a great pick! But I’ll be joining Sean in choosing On Their Frontlines this week; I’ve heard incredibly good things about the series.

ANNA: Both of these sound like great options, but I’m also going to go with On Their Frontlines.

KATE: Billy Bat is great fun: it’s a valentine to the pulpy American comics of the 1930s and 1940s, but it’s also a swell mystery and a thoughtful meditation on creativity. It’s definitely worth adding to the pile! I also wanted to make a plug for Akino Kondoh’s Box Garden Beetle. If her name sounds familiar, that’s because she was featured in <a href="https://mangacritic.mangabookshelf.com/2010/05/21/ax-vol-1-a-collection-of-alternative-manga/"AX: Alternative Manga. Her work is weird, playful, and sometimes a little unsettling, but always worth a look.

I don’t think I’ve mentioned Ascendance of a Bookworm in these reviews yet, which is a bit of a surprise. We do have a reincarnated girl who is now in the nobility but knows little about it, trying to earn money for her family by inventing things she remembers from back in Japan. She has a posse of friends and classmates, she has adorable siblings, and she has a dad who’s kinda useless. (Sylvester is the dad I mean in this case.) And she’s even intriguing royalty. But if this is a Bookworm lookee likee, there’s one thing that it’s been missing to this point: where’s Ferdinand? Good news, as hitting this series like a bomb is court mage Primus Geitz. He’s the most powerful magic user in the country. He’s a bit of a jerk, but also immediately understands Patience in a way few have so far. And he’s already proposing, much to her horror. Now we’ll see how close it really gets to Bookworm.

We pick up where we left off, with Patience and company discovering amazing new things in the local ruins. As the book goes on, more and more people show up to verify and explore this, and unfortunately, Patience (and later Angela) is the only one who can activate the Open Sesame trap door that lets them into this. She’s also using her household magic to clean ancient moldy ruins and ancient hard to read texts into just as new. And she’s using echolocation to find where the electricity and wiring is in this ancient ruin, as that’s a lost art in this magic-only world. And she’s using teleportation to rescue her brother from … well, not certain death, but a scary dark place. And she’s also telling everyone how solar power works. Finally, it’s up to Geitz, rapidly becoming her least favorite person, to say what we all guessed: she’s not using Household Magic. It’s a lot bigger than what.

Again, Patience is going to have to deal with a fiance soon. Not only does this world not really believe in marrying for love, it also tends to engage em young to keep them tied down somewhere important. That’s especially true of Patience, who is rapidly becoming the most important 11-year-old in history. And this book doesn’t even have half of her fiance candidates. Probably because it adds Geitz. Unlike Ferdinand, though, Geitz has not yet revealed his softer side, and is happily ready to bribe and blackmail Patience’s brothers as he realizes that she’ll do anything they say. I suppose she can always try marrying royalty… but the job she actually is starting to want, a sort of wandering diplomat, is feeling farther away with this book, as she simply as too much magic and too many innovations.

And what’s worse, this arc still isn’t over. And there’s far too many plot strands still up in the air, including Patience’s father. Did I also mention she’s now a Baronetess? I didn’t even know that had a feminine version. For those who enjoy watching OP tweens suffer.

We’re now seventeen books into this series, short story collections aside, and Mia has gotten very good at actual princess things. Sure, she sometimes faces death from things like assassins (as in this book, where we get to see something rare in fictional works, armor actually doing its job in a realistic way), but for the most part, Mia is no longer in any danger of the world turning against her and getting guillotined. As such, Mia has to face an even more dangerous fate, and one that so far she has been very bad at stopping: people in the future thinking TOO highly of her. Mia wants to be a good Empress and avoid execution, she does not want to be worshiped as a God. And when the suggestion of a giant golden statue of her hits her ears, she naturally tries to do everything possible in this book to transfer praise and worthy deeds to others and avoid doing everything herself. Which… works somewhat, but it’s still a C+ overall.

We pick up where we left off last time, with Princess Orania accused of trying to assassinate her father, and then escaping. Now Mia is trying to do damage control, which involves talking with the King (doesn’t help much), getting an in with the merchants (works much better), and meeting with the nation’s Parliament, where she lays out a way that “stop treating your underclass like crap” can work for them (even better). Unfortunately, this does not stop the rest of the plot, which involves escaping, getting captured, cool sword battles, escaping again, getting captured again, and everything ending at a lighthouse, which Mia desperately wants to avoid as it’s where the future suggests her golden statue is put! Does Mia have enough allies and enough power of speechifying to save the day?

This can be a very idealistic series, but at its core is a very dark and bitter future, and even now that we’ve mostly escaped that future we still see where it came from. The actual conspirator behind everything turns out to be so indoctrinated by the serpents that talking to them isn’t going to work, and in the end, despite our getting the backstory behind Orania’s father, the “does not really care about his daughter” part is mostly present and correct – more to the point, he doesn’t care about anything except his past love. There’s no “I was doing tough love in order to save you”, which I was expecting. I do appreciate that Orania is able to get past this and use it to be stronger. Using Mia as a guide, as Mia again does very well here, narrator and gorging on sweets aside. (There’s some fat-shaming again, I fear I will never be entirely rid of that.) The idealism comes in Mia’s speech, where she rails against the pointlessness of revenge and inspires everyone to work harder for the future of their children. The narrator did not talk about people misinterpreting Mia at all in this volume – they interpret her just fine.

Presumably, then, the next volume will start a new arc. I’m not sure how long this series plans to run, but I’ll always happily read more.

The author speaks in the afterword about having grand plans for a lot of wacky fun in the second half of this arc, but as they began to actually write the book, it became apparent that wacky fun was going to have to take a backseat. This is a serious book, with lots of threats to our heroines and the city as a whole. Reirin herself is still battling her own chronic illness, and has come to terms with the fact that she’ll be dying very soon – something which absolutely terrifies Keigetsu. And then there’s the brothel they’re infiltrating, which is filled with sex workers who are trying their hardest to be the one who steps on rather than the one who gets stepped on. There’s a chilling drug that not only can give you lifelong addiction, but no one knows how it’s made! And then there’s the guys who they’ve left behind, who are ready to rush the place at the drop of a hat, and have taken their hats off and prepared to drop them just in case.

In order to help Nadir stop the drug trade and find evidence to convict his crooked aide, Reirin and Keigetsu (who remain swapped the entire book) have to infiltrate the brothel that is the most likely source of the drug. Seika is going as well, of course, because she’s come to the horrifying conclusion that her childhood friend may be there. Unfortunately, for Reirin’s plans and perhaps Keigetsu’s self-image, Reirin-in-Keigetsu is not considered pretty enough to be a sex worker, so she’s made a simple laborer while the other two infiltrate above stairs. Still, this lets her easily investigate… but she’s coming up empty. Meanwhile, things go from bad to worse for Keigetsu and Seika – not because they’re being bullied as newbies (they’ve seen far worse in the inner court, and are more appalled at how unsubtle it is), but because Kinyou, Seika’s friend, *is* there, is the one at the very top, and will do anything to throw Seika out of there fast.

For those of you not reading this as a yuri series (there are some, right? The author if no one else…), there’s a lot of good stuff here. We’ve seen subtext between Keigetsu and Reirin’s brother Keishou in previous books, but there’s even more of it here. Likewise, while they start off as enemies, fans of shoujo manga should realize that Seika and Prince Nadir’s back and forth is very familiar, and likely may also turn romantic. That said, the author also cannot stop writing the strongest relationships in this series between the women. Seika and Kinyou have what amounts to a DIY marriage ceremony before Seika departs for the inner court, and there is a lot of anguish and pain between the two of them that does not scream “besties!”. Speaking of anguish and pain, Keigetsu is still reeling from the reveal that Reirin is much closer to dying than anyone thought, and it’s not a surprise that the solution that pops into mind is “why don’t we just stay like this forever so she can have my healthy body?”. Reirin would never allow that of course… so Keigetsu has to start hiding things from her again, which I’m sure will go as well as it always has.

Reirin says she’s going to tell everyone else at court about her condition in the next book, and presumably stand down as a maiden. I’m 100% sure that won’t happen, but I’m unsure where this will go. In any case, this series remains terrific, though as always, if you suffer from chronic illness, it can be very hard to get through.

We’ve had a couple of “trapped in the world of a game” series with more than one person aware of it, but those tend to go a different way than this one is. Usually you get the main character figuring things out, trying to change their fate, etc. and we get the other character (often an evil heroine) simply waiting for their life to be the same as the game and getting upset when it is not. That’s not what we get here, as there are two people actively trying to push back against the game’s events… in a previous life, no less, so it’s a mashup of that as well… and occasionally struggling as they see things out of context. Lilka knows that Lofus is already quite different from before, and yet when she hears about him interacting with Fol, she immediately can’t help but thinking of Fol as being the same as the past world. It’s very hard to draw outside the lines of the coloring book in your head.

Lofus continues in this book to do what he does best: make everyone’s lives a much better place while being an absolute dick about it. He is, unfortunately, unable to find an easy fix for Iz’s wasting mana disease, but he does manage to forge new ties with a merchant who really likes Lofus… possibly a bit too much… and get his railroad started with the unwanted but grudgingly necessary help of Raymond, who is still trying to be the one to force Lofus back into the game plot. Meanwhile, Fol is doing her best to map the unmappable, and Lilka is continuing to be a sky pirate. Unfortunately, as love interests go, they both have one primary flaw, which is that they’re not near the hero every day. Yes, that’s right, remember how I was feeling bad for Yusurika, Lofus’ hapless bodyguard who seemed to be unable to stop him waltzing into trouble? Turns out she’s also a love interest, and moves to the front of the line in this book.

I will admit I am not entirely positive about the Yusurika subplot. Not necessarily because of the love interest thing, it’s that kind of book, I know he’ll just continue to stack up women like cordwood. And her tragic past as a cursed dark-haired girl, despite her amazing healing powers, is unoriginal but par for the course. I am merely grumpy about the old chestnut “wait, I met you years ago and became your reason for living but have totally forgotten it because for me it was Tuesday” plot, which even Lofus has to fudge and say “no, of course I remember you”. Speaking of other love interests… not, not Fran the Saint or Maylene the Mage, but Raymond the wannabe Demon Lord, who is our token BL option (sorry, fans of the merchant, but he’s clearly comedy relief). Lofus may try to avoid dealing with him and hate his personality, but there’s no denying that their hate chemistry would spawn a number of AO3 fanfics if this were in Shonen Jump.

There’s a semi-cliffhanger at the end, but I would not worry too much about Lilka. Especially as the 7th book came out in July. For fans of the “villain” genre.

MICHELLE: I didn’t get mine ’til grad school in the mid-’90s!

ASH: What’s the Internet?

ANNA: In retrospect, a huge mistake!

SEAN: Ablaze has the 6th volume of Gannibal.

Airship has the 2nd volume of Classroom of the Elite: Year 3 and the 20th and final (barring any short story collections) volume of How a Realist Hero Rebuilt the Kingdom in print.

In early digital they have Heroine? Saint? No, I’m an All-Works Maid (And Proud of It)! 7 and The Neverending Winter, the Land of Broken Dreams (the 4th in the The Tunnel to Summer, the Exit of Goodbyes collection).

And in only digital, there is Reborn as an Assassin’s Apprentice 2.

Two debuts from Cross Infinite World. Assassin Empress Bellreuge (Ansatsu Jotei Bellreuge ~Shiitagerareshi Koujo wa Ai o Ete Nariagaru~) is a one-shot about a girl who gets a proposal from a margrave with a nasty reputation. This makes her half-sister… the princess… simply furious. Fortunately, Bellreuge is good at avoiding assassins.

ASH: That is a good skill to have!

ANNA: Better than the alternative!

SEAN: From Corporate Drone to Mincemaster! One Order of Dragon Coming Right Up! (Makikomarete Shoukan Sareta Genkai OL, Guild Shozoku no [Mamono Kaitai Jou] toshite Funtouchuu ~Dragon desu ka? Mochiron Sabakemasu!~) is a story about a girl summoned to another world!… or rather, the girl next to her is. Out goes the useless girl they accidentally summoned onto the street. Fortunately, someone finds a use for her weird skill.

ASH: Another series for the monster menu subgenre!

SEAN: They also have a 5th volume of Onmyoji and Tengu Eyes.

Ghost Ship have Tamamori’s Fantasies Never Stop! 5.

Glacier Bay Books have Akari, a oneshot that ran in Flat Hero’s. After his wife dies, a man loses interest in anything. Then his granddaughter shows up.

And they have Baku-chan, a manga about a tapir coming to Japan and facing prejudice.

And they have Box Garden Beetle (Hakoniwa Mushi), which ran in AX (not the convention). This is a collection of stories by a famous alternative manga artist.

ASH: Releases from Glacier Bay Books are always worth checking out!

ANNA: Just cool to have more publishers in the mix!

SEAN: Hanashi Media gives us The Disfavored Prince is a Genius Alchemist 2 and Tsukimichi: Moonlit Fantasy 19.

A quiet week for J-Novel Club. On the light novel side, they have Invaders of the Rokujouma!? 48, Nia Liston: The Merciless Maiden 10, Revenge of the Soul Eater: Cast Out as a Weakling by My Sword Saint Father 6, and Royal Spirits Are a Royal Pain! Give Me a Regular Romance 4.

And for manga they have The Banished Former Hero Does As He Pleases 9 and Hell Mode 11.

Kana has Billy Bat 2.

MICHELLE: I still need to read the first one!

ASH: Same! I’ve got quite the backlog.

ANNA: Me too! I did buy it.

SEAN: Kodama have a giant Baki the Grappler box set, with the first 8 omnibuses. They also have Omnibuses 23 and 24 of Baki the Grappler as well.

ASH: The release schedule of this series is truly impressive.

SEAN: And there’s a 5th volume of Smile!.

ASH: I feel like I blinked and missed three volumes.

SEAN: Kodansha Manga has one print debut, How to Grill Our Love (Yaiteru Futari), a Weekly Morning series about a newlywed couple who love barbecue! We’ve had the digital of this for some time.

Also in print: Initial D Omnibus 11, MF Ghost 6, Nina the Starry Bride 17, Shugo Chara! 20th Anniversary Edition 3, Tune In to the Midnight Heart 9, and The World Is Dancing 4.

ANNA: Obligatory yay on my part for Nina the Starry Bride!

SEAN: Seven Seas, for danmei, has a 5th Dinghai Fusheng Records.

Seven Seas, for non-Airship Japanese novels, has a 6th The Twelve Kingdoms.

ASH: I still love this series so much.

SEAN: As for manga debuts, there are three. Cheeky Devil Cop! (Akuma de Fukei!) is a Weekly Young Magazine series about a cute demon who wants an evil minion, and the evil-looking human cop she meets seems perfect. But he wants to send her back to hell!

Luna Knight runs in Monthly Young Magazine. A girl runs a flower shop and waits for her missing sister to return. Then when the shop burns down, she regains lost memories.

Printernia Nippon: My Squishy Bio-Printed Pet runs in Matogrosso. In the future, you can 3D print your pets! But our lead guy screws up, and doesn’t get a dog, he gets… what is that anyway?

There’s also a deluxe hardcover version of Dai Dark coming out, covering the first three books.

ASH: It even glows in the dark!

SEAN: Also from Seven Seas: 10 Things I Want to Do Before I Turn 40 2, BASTARD 5, Dungeon Elf: What’s a Dungeon without Treasure Chests? 2, I Got Married to the Girl I Hate Most in Class 7, The Ideal Sponger Life 22, Miss Kobayashi’s Dragon Maid 17, Monster Guild: The Dark Lord’s (No-Good) Comeback! 11, Precarious Woman Executive Miss Black General 13 (the final volume), Seaside Stranger 7, The Strange House 6, The Tale of a Little Alchemist Blessed by the Spirits 2, The Weakest Tamer Began a Journey to Pick Up Trash 8, and The World’s Fastest Level Up 8.

MICHELLE: Oh, I had forgotten about Seaside Stranger!

SEAN: Square Enix Manga has Always a Catch! 8.

Steamship debuts The Obsessed Mage and His Beloved Statue Bride: She Cannot Resist His Seductive Voice (Yandere Mahoutsukai wa Sekizou no Otome shika Aisenai: Majo wa Manadeshi no Atsui Kuchizuke de Tokeru), the manga version of the light novel, already published by Seven Seas. Our heroine, to save the country, turns herself to stone for twenty years. Now her cute teenage assistant is an older, sexier man, and still totally in love with her.

ASH: Cue drama.

ANNA: Whoops!

SEAN: Takumigraphics (Fantagraphics’ new manga imprint) debut On Their Frontlines: The Lives of Japanese War Brides (Senba no Hito). This 350-page book details the lives of four people shortly after the war. I’ve heard REALLY good things about this, and it’s also a bit LGBTQ?

ASH: I have likewise heard very encouraging things about this release.

ANNA: Wow, sounds interesting for sure.

SEAN: Udon Entertainment has – take this with a grain of salt – three titles out next week. In the Manga Biographies series we get Amelia Earhart and Momofuku Ando (the guy who invented cup noodles). There’s also Blue Archive: Comic Anthology 3.

Viz have a debut. Shiba Inu Rooms (Shiba-tsuki Bukken) stars a young woman who gets an apartment dirt cheap… because it’s haunted by the ghost of a Shiba Inu! Think wacky comedy.

ASH: I’m not sure I can resist a Shiba Inu manga! Even without being a ghost, they can be delightfully extra.

ANNA: This sounds cute!

SEAN: Also from Viz: Hima-Ten! 2, I’m No Angel 2, Kaiju No. 8 16 (the final volume), Magical Girl Dandelion 3, Nana 25th Anniversary Edition 5, Nue’s Exorcist 8, RuriDragon 4, Spy x Family 16, A Star Brighter than the Sun 7, Super Psychic Policeman Chojo 5, and Ultimate Exorcist Kiyoshi 3.

MICHELLE: I really do need to read A Star Brighter than the Sun.

ASH: Reading Nana again is a great option, too!

SEAN: What are you reading in this perpetual September?

There’s a bit right at the end of this book where all the nobles ask Haruka why he’s not all that worried about the Empire invading, even though they clearly are saying they’re going to do so. And Haruka utters a stream of gobbledegook, as he always does. But when translated by Book Club President, it amounts to: they don’t want to invade, they want all their enemies to collapse from within and then waltz in as saviors. It makes a lot of sense, though Haruka is also well aware that there’s a time limit on this, and I suspect in the next book we may finally leave Omui to go somewhere else again. Because this is the third book in a row where the plot is basically Dungeon, Inn, Dungeon, Inn, over and over for nearly 500 pages. The dungeon stuff is mostly filled with Haruka’s monologues about how he’s trying to improve, why no one will let him do so, and the occasional sensible observation. As for the inn, well…

On the cover is Haruka’s new servitude victim, an archdemon that Haruka decides to name Morning Star Archdemon, after the weapon he gives her. That said, relax – not only does she look like an underage gothic lolita on the cover, but Haruka thinks she is as well. So she’s going in with the demon scythes and the chickenatrice, in that she’ll be seen fighting but will not be part of the ongoing bedroom adventures. Which is good, as those are taking up more and more of the book. The book is still somehow rated OT rather than Mature, probably as Seven Seas knows that this series is not exactly picking up any new readers. That said, I used to say that the sex was there but ignorable because Haruka’s narration mostly made it incoherent. That is mostly true, but we also now get narration from the girls, which is a lot less incoherent. Honestly, I’m impressed the author has almost made this all plot relevant – the Dungeon Masters clearly want the other girls to get with Haruka as well, but know that, as they are and as he is, he would simply break them. So there’s training instead. Which involves either a lot of “stamina training” and also consumption of some “miracle medicine”. Class Rep seems to be doing better than the others, mostly as she’s their sacrifice half the time. Anyway.

In non-sexy and dungeon-related stuff… there is a bit of it… we see Haruka trying to open a portal back to Japan so that he can send the girls back home. (He’s given up on the guys, who are either married now or avoiding getting married.) He’s thinking of their families back home, and also worries that if he lets it go too long they’ll be too inhuman to ever really return. I have news for Haruka, that’s long since already happened, even if it’s only been four months since the start of the series. The girls all know this too – they’ve explicitly told him they’ve come to terms with the isekai and are staying, but he is, of course, ignoring them, mostly as he still feels responsible for everything. The Dungeon Emperors don’t only do “sex training” with the girls, they also do dungeon training, and they’re the biggest hardasses out there. Mostly as they know the girls have the same issue they do – if Haruka gets strong enough that they can’t be at his side anymore, their hearts will completely shatter. Meanwhile, Haruka thinks the ideal solution is to not have anyone he cares about at his side. You can see why this isn’t getting anywhere.

So yeah, we read another 500 pages of wheel-spinning, as the author admits in the afterword. Will things happen in Book 16? We can but pray.

In my last review I mentioned that the hero’s party itself barely featured in the book. That changes with this second book, and we get to see what kind of hero’s party they are. And, frankly, it’s very much towards the idealistic end of the spectrum. No one is getting banished from the party with these guys – in fact, we literally see that near the end. The hero is the sort of girl you want to be the hero who saves the world, and she’s got strength and stamina out the wazoo. Sadly, no one really trained her, so she lacks any real experience – which is probably why Rhuys’ prophesies keep showing her dying horribly before she can complete her destiny. Technically Ariagnée, who is demi-human herself, should not really be training the hero on how to kill folks like her should the time come. But alas, the bad guys reckoned without one important fact that this book emphasizes as much as the last: Ariagnée is gay as hell, and will do anything for a cute girl.

Acting on a new vision that says that the hero is going to be ambushed by assassins, Rhuys and Ariagnée try to quickly get ahead of the party to take care of things… and end up running right into them, as noted above. Ariagnée helps Lina (the hero), who is quick to learn but also a bit of a meathead when it comes to combat. Rhuys has an awkward meetup with Agnes, the party’s cleric, who is the protoge of the woman who tried to have Rhuys killed in the first book. There’s also Sierra, a typical “not the hero but very similar” warrior, and a mage who is the only guy in the group. After ditching the party, and having a quick detour at a lake (more on that later), they end up being attacked by assassins… no, not the assassins who are ambushing the hero, another, slightly less good group of assassins. Because it turns out that the hero being chosen by magic fiat upsets folks who dreamed of THEIR hero being chosen.

That detour I mentioned is basically a maguffin that allows our two heroines to come to terms with their past. They meet a guy who is trying to find an artifact that lets you talk to the dead… which gets pretty dark when you hear why she died. But then Ariagnée uses it to talk with her mother, who is rather blasé about being dead, and encourages her. Rhuys has to rely on a DIFFERENT maguffin, but also gets a bit of closure that hopefully makes her a lot less death seeking than the first book, in that it turns out only half her family didn’t care about her at all. This may be an adventure series with yuri subtext, but the world they’re in is dark, and there’s a lot of corpses stacking up, particularly towards the end. Rhuys may keep seeing vision of the hero dying, but when merchant Utile (who, by the way, looks EXACTLY like Richeh from Witch Hat Atelier) asks Rhuys to make sure Ariagnée stays safe, we nod along. Please protect Ariagnée from the narrative.

There’s no third volume of this yet, but Drecom tends to wrap series up fast rather than cancelling them unfinished, so I’m sure one will pop up. If you like subverting the hero’s journey, or just a lot of gay women (there’s at least three, and I’m prepared to go up to seven if I have to) this is a good read.

These are chunky books, with each volume being around twice the size of your average light novel. As a result, I deeply appreciate that the book starts with a “story so far” catching me up on what happened in Book One, because after that the reader is not really given any more help. There are lots of characters in this, and you need to remember who they are and which faction they’re with. More characters are introduced. Some characters we thought would be major players in this book end up being taken off the board instead. Liliana has changed a lot about the way that the “plot” of this world is supposed to go, but it feels like fate wants to railroad her anyway. Things are definitely not helped by her attempts to distance herself from the love interests, which not only fails, but actually gets worse. Basically, she’s so good at everything that she may accidentally end up as dead as the narrative wants.

Liliana can actually speak now, though she hides that from most people. And she’s much calmer and better at powerful magic, meaning she has an alive handmaiden rather than the dead handmaiden she had in the narrative. Despite this, the world keeps moving on, and she keeps trying to figure out how to fix things so she escapes her fate. Maybe it can be by understanding the complicated politics of the various countries that deal with them – especially the Empire, who seem to be actively sabotaging them. Maybe she can save the entire country when a massive monster swarm attacks the royal capital on the Prince’s birthday party. Maybe she can make an ally, and indeed hire, the assassin who’s been trying to kill her and her allies. And maybe she can get Riley to choose someone else to be his fiancee, though honestly, that’s the hardest goal. After all, he’s mostly figured out what she’s hiding.

This book has a problem a lot of light novels taken from webnovels do, which is that the big climax of the book happens a little over halfway through it, and the ending is sort of a quiet “to be continued”. I suppose it’s better than a nasty cliffhanger, but after 389 pages it can feel anticlimactic. That said, we did have lots of climaxes in the pages beforehand. The addition of Obsidian to the cast is fantastic, as every heroine needs someone who will snark at her and also try to kill her just so she can prove she’s still better than him. I also liked the subplot around Austin, who ends up going out on the monster hunt even though he’s too inexperienced. He survives, but clearly needs therapy, and I appreciate this is recognized and forced onto him. As for Liliana, I think she may need to admit soon that she and Riley are in fact a perfect couple. Then again, she still isn’t even ten years old yet.

If you like your villainess stories to be more like black coffee than sweet tea, this is right yup your street.