This is not exactly a series that moves at the speed of light. As Yoshin says in this book, they haven’t even gotten to their first anniversary yet. Thee reason that it feels like it’s been forever is that by now Yoshin and Nanami are essentially married in all but legal name, and the only reason that they haven’t gone further than kissing is Yoshin’s iron will… well, no, because the two of them are massive cowards, that becomes apparent near the end here. But we are actually headed into final exams, which means senior year will soon be upon them. This is not an issue for Nanami, who has terrific grades and a career she’s striving for. Yoshin, though, has only just woken up to the fact that he now has a girlfriend, as well as actual other friends (something he literally has to be told here). Not a surprise his future is hazy.

The last few volumes have consistently hit holidays, and this one does as well, Valentine’s Day is coming up. For Yoshin this has always been just another day, one he can safely ignore. Nanami is somewhat horrified to hear that he hasn’t even gotten obligation chocolate from classmates, but is also kind of delighted as she gets another of his firsts. Meanwhile, his friend Hitoshi, who we saw on the class trip getting along with a Hawaiian girl, went back there with his parents and they got on even better. To the point where she’s coming there for a trip. And since she’s American, they researched American Valentine’s, meaning Yoshin now also has to come up with a Valentine gift. And they also want the day off to be romantic. Which means, before that, ALL THE WORK HOURS. Fortunately, Nanami is now working at the same restaurant as Yoshin does, because this series is comfy as hell.

Yoshin’s self-reflective monologue about how he’s not remotely the protagonist of a story, with Nanami trying hard to convince him this isn’t the case, is probably not as cute as the author thinks it is, but it does give a nice view into the mind of Yoshin, who may have had a hot loving girlfriend for almost a year, but still tends to get into the “woe is me, why do I suck so much?” mindset at the drop of a hat. This is probably the main reason why he and Nanami still aren’t going further, despite the fact that even her grandparents are kind of hinting that the two of them should bonk, and their parents leaving several convenient times when no one is in the house. But no, nothing happens beyond a few really heavy french kisses. This despite Nanami really trying hard, with senpai/kohai roleplay, maid cosplay, more maid cosplay, still MORE maid cosplay, and “won’t you lick the chocolate off my body?” play. Which, as I said, goes nowhere, alas.

The next volume came out in Japan about a week and a half ago, and no doubt deals with White Day. We will be waiting. A bit frustrated, but waiting.

This series has always been pretty light on the harem aspect. There are several girls, they kind of like our lead, he’s been told to find a wife. But honestly, right now no one is “main girl” and nothing is happening at all. This book in particular is uninterested in the question. possibly as the “main girl” of this book, if there is one, is Mewi, who definitely fills the “daughter” role more than a romantic interest. But, as the cover art indicates, the real star of this volume is Bel himself. He still is very bad at self-confidence, at seeing himself as anything but just some average guy with a sword. Which is unfortunate, as sometimes when you continue to improve, to get to the next level, you need to know that you can take on the best of the best and still triumph. And Bel has leveled up.

While cooking with Mewi, Bel cuts himself with a kitchen knife. He regards this as something that could happen to everyone, but those around him are startled. Then, at the training hall, he spars with Vesper, the guy who was nearly but not entirely killed a number of volumes ago, and is now well enough to start light training again. While fighting him, Bel notices that his eyes can see the future of what Vesper is about to do… and Bel is so flummoxed by this he loses. This *really* startles everyone. Now Bel has to worry: is this all a part of his getting old and starting to lose his edge? Or has he genuinely unlocked some instinctual skill? He’d better figure things out quickly, unfortunately; Mewi went out with friends one day and never came home.

I admit when I got to that plotline I was wondering if the answer would be “whoops, Mewi was doing something entirely innocent and it’s all a misunderstanding”. But no, Mewi is essentially going through the exact same thing Bel is, only he has decades more experience than she does and knows his own limitations (in fact, one might argue he exaggerates his own limitations). Mewi, on the other hand, is learning fast and getting stronger, to the point where she thinks she can take out some random kidnappers with the help of her friends… only to find they’re not just random thugs after all, and she really is still a kid who is learning. I am… grumpy about Bel slapping Mewi after she’s rescued, but I’ll gloss over it. As for Bel’s future vision, I’m pleased to see it has very definite limits, but it does also allow him to stay ahead of his young students for now… which means, of course, he will still think of them as students. Which ties back to the start. No wife for you.

The anime’s second season is going on, and it does a pretty good job. For those who want to read about a far too modest guy and his amazing sword skills, this is top tier.

In/Spectre, Vol. 21 | By Kyo Shirodaira and Chashiba Katase | Kodansha Manga – Sometimes the best, most likely solution to a mystery is not the one that anyone involved wants to hear. This is especially true when it’s Kotoko doing the sleuthing. Here she proposes a decent enough solution that will allow them to try to get the matriarch of the family to remove her veil… then comes up with a more likely answer that will force the family to lift lids off cans of worms they don’t want to. But on the bright side, it will get that veil off. And there is the (supposedly) final appearance of Mecha-Kotoko, which is designed to take Kotoko herself down a peg and is thus very welcome. This one has a lot less of Kotoko being terrible, so it’s not as good as previous volumes, but I’m still enjoying it a great deal. – Sean Gaffney

Medalist, Vol. 14 | By Tsurumaikada | Kodansha Manga – If the last volume was about Inori having her worst day ever as a figure skater, this volume is about her comeback, and the back half is here to show off her awesomeness. That said, the manga tries not to ignore the other skaters that are also competing, and everyone gets a chance to show off some fantastic moves, technique, speed, et cetera, and the author gets to show off amazing drawing skills. We also get someone who is clearly being set up to be the next major antagonist in the series: Dahlia, the other Japanese competitor in this event. She thinks Inori is “a bit TOO innocent.” Unfortunately, we’re not able to see what Dahlia does until volume fifteen, so we must wait. This remains one of the best manga out there, always spellbinding. – Sean Gaffney

The Mortifying Ordeal of Being Seen, Vol. 1 | By mmk | Viz Media – This is a fairly standard high school romcom with a good gimmick: the guy is handsome but is also a “typical guy,” i.e. he hasn’t remembered the name of the girl who’s sat next to him the whole year, just that she has large breasts. But when he tries another crass remark that he insists is a compliment, she talks about the fact that she can almost see his nipples… and he freaks. Yup, he can dish it out but can’t take it. The rest of the volume has variations on that theme, with the two of them also gradually getting to know each other and developing actual feelings beyond “you are sexually attractive to me.” She’s a little weird. He’s a little annoying. They’re perfect for each other, really. This is cute, but full of sexual leering—on purpose. – Sean Gaffney

The 100 Girlfriends Who Really, Really, Really, Really, REALLY Love You, Vol. 18 | By Rikito Nakamura and Yukiko Nozawa | Ghost Ship – New volume, new girlfriend. Saiki is a brilliant idol singer, but she longs to be an eccentric brilliant idol singer, emphasis on the eccentric, so keeps trying to do weird things. Naturally, she rejects Rentaro’s confession as too normal for her… until she finds out about his other girlfriends. The other major plotline sees the return of the Rentaro Family idol group… only because he’s got so many new girlfriends, the new girls are the ones who take it on. And, naturally, some girls are really good at idoling, and some… are not. Needless to say, this series remains very heartwarming and (in this volume) only slightly horny. No worries, the horny will return. – Sean Gaffney

Our Dining Table: Seconds, Please!, Vol. 2 | By Mita Ori | Seven Seas – I continue to enjoy this gentle, slice-of-life story, largely because it’s not just about Minoru and Yutaka as a couple, but is equally about Minoru’s relationship with his little brother, Tane. Early in the volume, Minoru and Yutaka put off moving in together because Tane’s just not ready to be without his big brother yet. However, as time goes on, Minoru graduates college and is set to embark on a training course at the same time as Tane is about to begin elementary school. By then, Tane has grown up enough to be more worried about Minoru being all alone than about himself. It’s really sweet, and more than once Tane made me think of Yotsuba. Have I made it clear how much Tane is the true star of this series? Because he totally is (though I do like Minoru and Yutaka, too, of course). – Michelle Smith

Stella Must Die, Vol. 1 | By Yasunori Mitsunaga | Kodansha Manga – Well, this was really, really weird. Take a standard “otome heroine is in danger” situation, and cross it with… Parasyte… and you have this. A king has died and now there’s a throne war. The older siblings need the young princess dead. They try poison. They try assassins. They try summoning demons. But the “shit worm” living inside her intestines, who is a reincarnated Japanese guy, keeps protecting her. The first volume is a combination of setup that I’m sure will pay off later and some truly grotesque situations, though fortunately by the end of the book Stella is aware of what’s going on, rather than just an unconscious prisoner in her own body. I’m not sure I’ll keep going, but this is definitely unique. – Sean Gaffney

KATE: Make mine Chiisakobee, too. Something about that cover really speaks to me!

ASH: That cover really is great. So count me in for Chiisakobee, too! (Although I’ll also probably be taking a closer look at Ask Iwata when I have a chance.)

MICHELLE: Sure. I don’t have any better ideas, really.

ANNA: I guess I’m gonna go with the consensus this week!!

I was talking online about how comfy and relaxing I found this series, and someone pointed out some quotes I made while reading the first book that talked about how tired and cliched it was. And of course both things are correct. There’s nothing here that’s going to make you say “wow, that’s something I’ve never seen before” or “didn’t expect them to react like that!”. But it’s like a nice meat and potato stew in the middle of winter. There’s meat. There’s potatoes. There’s carrots. And that’s about it. You don’t really want much else. We’ve got lots of Arata and Reina being married in all but name but still too shy to do anything about it. They’re raising their adopted daughter, adopted niece, and girl who’s still a bit too loli to get into the harem sweepstakes but she’s working on it. And, of course, we have today’s cover star, the blonde vampire who is hundreds of years old. She’s exactly what you think as well. Thank goodness.

It is pointed out to Arata that while he visited the dragonfolk village, he hasn’t yet visited the ogrefolk village, so he and the rest of his family decide to do just that. There they find that it’s essentially a Japanese hot springs town, and the ogre vibe is so “Japan” that Arata is somewhat overwhelmed by the whole thing. He meets Sakuya, the sister of the ogre he met in previous books, and thankfully she’s not falling for him – though she does help accidentally facilitate the big fanservice scene of the book. A problem comes up, though, when Luna, who is hitting puberty but still can’t remember her ancestor (the trigger for it in this series), winds up possessed, then dying, then back to normal but occasionally possessed again. And then there’s Mina, who’s spent three volumes tormenting our main couple but it’s been hiding her true desires – and Arata wants to give them to her.

There’s some nice backstory for Mina here, which doesn’t tell us anything we hadn’t guessed but does help to set up the big problem. Arata’s wish is to have everyone on the island gather together in peace for a big banquet. Mina is a vampire who wants a really, really really good fight, so that she can finally die. These two are fundamentally incompatible, but this is basically a shonen series, so the outcome of their fight should not surprise you. Honestly, as blonde vampires go, Mina is on the nicer side all round, though Arata and Reina may disagree after she tries to seduce Arata in Reina’s body… and we’re told that she does the same for Reina in Arata’s body. I like to think of that as Mina being a stand in for the reader, who wants to knock their heads together and say “You two need to fuck”. As for the rest of the book, it’s cute. It’s relaxing. It’s uneventful, mostly.

That said, a large number of additional cast may hit in the next volume. We’ll see if that stirs the pot any. Till then, I’ve come to like this quite a bit.

I’m still enjoying this series a lot more than I expected to, and it’s for much the same reasons as the first. I’m not as wild about the “cringe” part of the title, though thankfully there’s less of him regretting his chuuni past and feeling embarrassed here. There’s more of the serious bits here as well, though, and I’m definitely enjoying those. This series has a backstory that it is content to give to you in bits and bobs, rather than as a giant wall of flashback, and I appreciate that. It also wants to remind you about what being absent for nearly two hundred years would do to people who are, shall we say, a bit codependent on you. Likewise, Shio not telling everyone he’s from another world turns out to be for a very good reason, especially given the aforementioned codependency. All this makes me forgive the fact that there’s a tournament arc in this book.

The first volume introduced us to four of Shio’s posse of supernatural badasses, here we meet another. Hræsvelgr, though, is having a much harder time getting over the vanishing of the most important person in her life. Sure, she’s kept herself busy helping out a schmuck of a guy who doesn’t even know how to use her power properly, but really what she is is suicidal. Meanwhile, our protagonist needs, of course, weapons. Which means he needs money. Fortunately, he’s headed to the fantasy equivalent of Las Vegas, where he can enter a fighting tournament to get some cash, as well as meeting the ruler of the city, Kaguya, who is very interested in him. Unfortunately, that fake Helheim is still making a bad name for itself, and it doesn’t help that there are a lot of demons around trying to bring back the Demon Lord Shio killed last time. Only… did Shio really kill him?

Things aren’t all serious, of course. We meet another demon, Furcas, who is basically the terrifying demon equivalent of “dumb meathead girl”, so I was naturally disposed to liking her. (There’s a human equivalent too. TWO meathead girls in one volume, my cup runneth over!). I was amused as well at the creeping horror that Shio has when he realizes that Aleu, the schmuck Hræsvelgr is helping, is not doing a bit but really is that much of a schmuck, and his flirting with Kaguya was first-rate. That said, the best scenes were the serious ones, particularly the ones with Hræsvelgr. Her meltdown after discovering that the gang has gotten back together without her is painful to read. And of course then there’s Shio finally telling Hræsvelgr what he’s been avoiding – that merely by his followers being around the man they love, he is slowly being killed. Oh yes, and Shio also finds that most of what’s been happening is thanks to the complete dick who summoned his middle school class in the first place. He’s not happy.

There’s a third volume of this series out in Japan, but it hasn’t started serializing on JNC, so we may have to wait a bit. This continues to be better than I expected, and not very much like The Eminence in Shadow at all.

MICHELLE: I’m waiting on the outcome of hurricane season before I can make any declarations.

ASH: That seems fair.

SEAN: Yen On has one debut, which is My Yandere Girlfriend Hiding in the Dungeon Kills Me Over and Over Again (Dungeon ni Hisomu Yandere na Kanojo ni Ore wa Nando mo Korosareru). Do you want Re: Zero but with more yanderes? Good news!

Also from Yen On: The Angel Next Door Spoils Me Rotten 10, Banished from the Hero’s Party, I Decided to Live a Quiet Life in the Countryside 15 (the final volume), The Detective Is Already Dead 12, If the Villainess and Villain Met and Fell in Love 5, Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon? 20, The Kept Man of the Princess Knight 6, Kunon the Sorcerer Can See 6, Rascal Does Not Dream of a Beach Queen + (the 16th book in the 15-book series), Sasaki & Peeps 10, To the Monster I Love 2, Wandering Witch 17, Wolf & Parchment: New Theory Spice & Wolf 12, and You Are My Regret 4.

ASH: Wait… 16th out 15?

SEAN: Viz’s debut is Ask Iwata, a self-help guide for gamers written by the CEO of Nintendo.

ASH: It’s outside of my usual reading, but I’ve heard good things about this one.

SEAN: Also from Viz: Akane-banashi 17, Dandadan 20, Girl Crush 8, Kill Blue 8, Mao 25, Marriagetoxin 14, Rai Rai Rai 5, Rainbows After Storms 11, and Tsumiki Ogami’s Not-So-Ordinary Life 7.

MICHELLE: Wow, Mao is already up to volume 25.

SEAN: I missed a Tokyopop release last week: the 4th light novel of My Beautiful Man, namely My Uncontrollable Man.

This week they have My Noons and Midnights Are for You 2.

Titan Manga debut High Elf with a Long Life (Tensei Shite High Elf ni Narimashita ga, Slow Life wa 120-nen de Akimashita), the manga version of a light novel released by J-Novel Club under a slightly different title. A reincarnated as an elf guy wants a normal isekai, not sitting in the elf village doing nothing! This runs in Comic Earth Star.

ASH: You know, I could use some sitting around doing nothing.

ANNA: Me too!

SEAN: SuBLime has A Man Who Defies the World of BL 5 and Scattering His Virgin Bloom: Love Frenzy 3.

From Square Enix Manga we see Daemons of the Shadow Realm 11, My Clueless First Friend 9, and My Isekai Life 26.

Seven Seas, on the danmei side, has the 8th and final volume of Ballad of Sword and Wine: Qiang Jin Jiu. This comes with an exclusive extra chapter, and a special edition with stickers, postcards, etc.

ASH: Ooh, fancy!

ANNA: For the fans!!!

SEAN: There’s also Legend of Exorcism: Tianbao Fuyao Lu 6.

Seven Seas debuts a manga anime watchers have already started: Draw This, Then Die! (Kore Kaite Shine). This shonen series from Gessan, and stars a girl who lives on a remote island who LOVES manga – but can she draw her own manga?

ASH: Signs point to yes, maybe?

ANNA: Hoping for the best for her!

SEAN: Hotel Inhumans is a Sunday Web Every series, and also inspired an anime. A hotel has to provide for its customer needs… but the customers are all hitmen!

ASH: I’m sure that won’t cause any problems whatsoever!

ANNA: Sounds a little John Wicky!

SEAN: PUNKS TRIANGLE stitch is a sequel to PUNKS TRIANGLE, and runs in Bloom. BL fashion designer x model.

Also from Seven Seas: Arifureta: From Commonplace to World’s Strongest 16, Diary of a Female Lead: Shujinkou Nikki 7, Hate Me, but Let Me Stay 7, Karate Survivor in Another World 10, Koharu and Minato: Happy Life with My Girlfriend 2, My Girlfriend is 8 Meters Tall 4, My Kitten is a Picky Eater 9, Pet Shop of Horrors: Collector’s Edition 7 (the final volume), Romelia War Chronicle: The Count’s Daughter Rallies an Army in the Wake of Mankind’s Victory 3, and Succubus and Hitman 11.

One Peace Books has the 4th and final volume of The Revenge of My Youth: My Re Life With an Angelic Girl.

Last Gasp has a 3rd volume of Ultra Heaven.

ASH: Which is a good r minder for me to read the first two…

SEAN: Kodansha Manga debuts You Might As Well Be the One (Isso Anata ga Todome wo Sashite), a shoujo manga from Dessert. A flashy girl meets a kind boy. But he has… a secret!

MICHELLE: Hm. Intentional Billy Joel reference, or no, one wonders.

SEAN: Kodansha also has The Fragrant Flower Blooms With Dignity 14, Issak Omnibus 7, Love at First Memory 3, Pass the Monster Meat, Milady! 10, Perfectly Fine on My Own, So My Fiancé Can Twist in the Wind 3, and Tank Chair 9.

Digitally we have Cat-Life Balance 2, Giant Killing 57, Issak 14, and TenPuru -No One Can Live on Loneliness- 15.

MICHELLE: Obligatory Giant Killing squee.

ASH: It is a good one.

SEAN: Kana debuts Chiisakobee, a seinen manga based on a novel. It runs in Big Comic Spirits. A man who lost his parents and his parents’ family business in a fire resolves to rebuild, with the help of others.

J-Novel Club has print manga! Ascendance of a Bookworm Part 4 Vol. 5, Isekai Tensei: Recruited to Another World 7, and My Quiet Blacksmith Life in Another World 4.

J-Novel Club has print light novels! In Another World With My Smartphone 33, My Quiet Blacksmith Life in Another World 9, and The Unwanted Undead Adventurer 14.

J-Novel Club has digital manga! The 100th Time’s the Charm: She Was Executed 99 Times, So How Did She Unlock “Super Love” Mode?! 6, Duchess in the Attic 7, Even Exiled, She’s Still the Beloved Saint! St. Evelyn’s Weird and Wonderful Friends 4, I’m a Noble on the Brink of Ruin, So I Might as Well Try Mastering Magic 8, The Oblivious Saint Can’t Contain Her Power: Disgraced No Longer, I’m Finding Happiness with the Prince! 7, The Otome Heroine’s Fight for Survival 7, and Scooped Up by an S-Rank Adventurer! This White Mage Is One Heck of a Healer 5.

J-Novel Club has digital light novels! Campfire Cooking in Another World with My Absurd Skill 17, DUNGEON DIVE: Aim for the Deepest Level 13, The Fearsome Witch Teaches in Another World 4, Fired? But I Maintain All the Software! 2, From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman: My Hotshot Disciples Are All Grown Up Now, and They Won’t Leave Me Alone 10, An Introvert’s Hookup Hiccups: This Gyaru Is Head Over Heels for Me! 13, Proud to Be the Villainess 2, Unsung Epics of the Hero’s Journey 2, and The Villainess Speaks Not 2.

ASH: I remember back in the day when J-Novel Club was just starting out; they grow up so fast!

SEAN: Ghost Ship gives us Betrayed by the Hero, I Formed a MILF Party With His Mom! 5 and Girls Zombie Party 2.

Two weeks after Alphapolis debuted the paperback Vol. 1s of A Gatherer’s Adventure in Isekai, May I Ask for One Final Thing?, and Possibly the Greatest Alchemist of All Time, we get the Vol. 2s.

ASH: That was fast.

SEAN: Airship has print volumes for The Devil Princess 4 and The Tale of a Little Alchemist Blessed by the Spirits 3.

For early digital we get Chronicles of an Aristocrat Reborn in Another World 3 and Venus Mission: I Was an Assassin-for-Hire Who Died, Now I’m Hunting Heroes in Another World 2.

Can manga make things cooler? Or drier? Try it out!

Usually, when you’re writing a romance, there are various tricks you can use to make sure that it doesn’t resolve itself too soon. The usual method is to have the protagonist be dense as a brick, and there’s a bit of that here, as Misha does not seem to realize just how utterly infatuated with her Vil has become. Another way, best suited for longer-running series, is to plant seeds of doubt in the protagonist’s mind, doubt that this is really love. Could they be lying? Could this be betrayal? Are they just being used? The author tries to do this with Misha and Vil as well, but it comes off a bit less well, mostly as she simply cannot fall for the obvious bait. She can’t picture Vil as anything but a swell guy. Which is good news for those who like sweet romance, but does mean that any conflict is gonna be delayed till Book 3. Which isn’t out in Japan yet.

Misha continues to do her best at school, even though her weak snow magic makes her struggle a lot of the time. She’s a little wary around Vil now that she knows his real identity. Unfortunately for her, he’s not about to give up on the one person who treats him like a normal human being. As such, she’s made Vil’s personal assistant, which naturally means she has to treat him the same and be around him all the time. She also volunteers to be staff at the next school dance, mostly as she doesn’t want to buy a new gown. Unfortunately, at the dance, a large number of students start collapsing with sickness, and they have to figure out what’s happened. As for her weak snow magic, well, you’ve read series like this before. It turns out it may, in fact, be strong, powerful magic, it’s just she’s been learning how to magic the wrong way this entire time. In other words, her school life is filled with protagonist-like events, as expected.

This was, once again, pleasant without really knocking me out. I am amused by Misha’s familiar Gem, who not only can seemingly do anything, and not only is hiding their true power from Misha, but is also a filthy little shipper, and manages to get Misha and Vil together despite her best non-efforts. I also liked the drama of the food poisoning at the dance, though I rolled my eyes a bit at the fact that everyone ended up getting a reward. If this is supposed to be a school set up around noble rules, there’s no way those first-years who came up with the food that made everyone ill would not be getting in at least a little trouble. As for the ongoing plot, it’s clear that someone really wants Vil dead, and since poison didn’t work, we’ll turn to vicious rumor. I’m not sure if the prince is in on it, but it wouldn’t surprise me. As for the romance, I did like the cute beta couple, thought once again, I can’t see this being an option if this is written in class war-ese rather than romance novel-ese.

So good, but not great, stuff. Now we wait for a third book.

I will admit, this is the first volume in the series that I wasn’t that wild about. It’s still great whenever Cecil is being Cecil or Bertia is being Bertia, but I get the sense the author thought of this as a two-book arc, and was determined to keep it that way despite the fact that the second book doesn’t have nearly the interest that the first one does. The first book in the arc had a “you’ll never marry my daughter!” dad and a shut-in mom, a deadly and attractive combination. This second book has a family of mostly airheads, and also has a girl who irrationally hates Kuro. Yes, the irrational hatred is the actual plot, and it does turn out to have a reason, but it makes her annoying and easy to dislike. I admit that I was counting pages towards the end there. Fortunately, the book is still narrated by Cecil, which automatically raises it up.

Last time we met Kuro’s family, this time we meet Zeno’s. His mother is a ditz… as are his four sisters, who don’t believe he actually has a girl who likes him, so kidnap him immediately and try to get him to marry the girl they approve of – the niece of the King of Light, Light Sparrow. She’s been sickly, especially lately. She also seems to really like Zeno when she meets him… but she takes an immediate, visceral dislike of Kuro, saying that she can sense she’s evil. This goes badly. Bertia tries to handle this by showing off how cute Kuro really is, which does not work at all. Cecil tries to figure out what is making Light Sparrow sick and why she relapsed, and this goes better. Finally, they return home to a big surprise.

There were a few things I did really enjoy. The revelation of what’s wrong with Light Sparrow ties back into much earlier in the series, and while it’s a bit of a handwave solution, I appreciated how it was handled on the human end, with Cecil, despite wanting to simply ignore it, giving in to Bertia’s kindness. Speaking of things typing back to plotlines I had actually completely forgotten about, one of the minor issues in and earlier book (Bertia’s maid has a “weak presence”, which causes people to ignore her) is also given a solution stemming from the spirit world, and I did appreciate the maid’s resolute “nope” to the solution being offered. Good for her. And then there’s the ending, which is pretty telegraphed, and not entirely unexpected. I did appreciate Cecil, on hearing the news, realizing he now has TWO people to love unconditionally. Cecil is, at best, lacking empathy, so it’s nice to see he’s not going the route of, say, the lead couple in I Swear I Won’t Bother You Again!.

If you want to skip this book and start with the next one: Bertia wants to do Halloween, and Cecil will be making it more of a harvest festival with costumes. Also, she’s pregnant. This was OK.

MICHELLE: I am absolutely interested in Crescent Moon Marching, but for this one week of each year, it’s just gotta be Kaze Hikaru, for me.

ANNA: I will not pass up the chance to celebrate a new volume of Kaze Hikaru!

ASH: Marching band manga??? Marching band manga?!! As soon as I learned about it, I wanted to read Crescent Moon Marching; I’m very excited that its time has come. I loved being in marching band in high school and college (usually playing mellophone) and I still enjoy watching performances immensely, so I suspect I’ll appreciate this series, too.

SEAN: I mean, yes, it’s Kaze Hikaru, the Excel Saga of the 2020s, but if I make my pick what I’m most interested in, it’s definitely Girl Meets Rock!.