<!DOCTYPE html><html id="phx-wrapper" lang="en"><head><title>Business &amp; Economics - Pacific Standard</title><link rel="canonical" href="https://psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"><link rel="publisher" href="https://plus.google.com/+Psmagplus"><meta name="keywords" content="Business &amp; Economics"><meta name="pagetype" content="rich_term"><meta name="item-id" content="ci020b8c5f200526b7"><meta name="published" content="2017-06-30T20:18:28Z"><meta name="modified" content="2017-11-01T18:08:08Z"><meta name="dcterms.rightsHolder" content="Grist"><meta name="dcterms.dateCopyrighted" content="2023"><meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"><meta name="twitter:site" content="@PacificStand"><meta name="twitter:url" content="https://psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"><meta name="twitter:image" content="https://psmag.com/.image/t_share/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.jpg"><meta name="twitter:domain" content="psmag.com"><meta property="og:type" content="website"><meta property="og:url" content="https://psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"><meta property="og:title" content="Business &amp; Economics"><meta property="og:image" content="https://psmag.com/.image/t_share/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.jpg"><meta property="og:site_name" content="Pacific Standard"><meta property="fb:pages" content="PacificStand"><meta name="pinterest-rich-pin" content="true"><meta name="apple-mobile-web-app-title" content="Pacific Standard"><meta name="parsely-title" content="Business &amp; Economics - Pacific Standard"><meta name="parsely-link" content="https://psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"><meta name="parsely-type" content="index"><meta name="parsely-image-url" content="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Ch_400%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.jpg"><meta name="parsely-post-id" content="ci020b8c5f200526b7"><meta name="parsely-pub-date" content="2017-06-30T20:18:28Z"><meta name="parsely-tags" content="Business &amp; Economics"><meta name="sailthru.title" content="Business &amp; Economics"><meta name="sailthru.image.full" content="https://psmag.com/.image/t_share/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.jpg"><meta name="sailthru.date" content="2017-06-30T20:18:28Z"><meta name="sailthru.tags" content="Business &amp; Economics"><meta name="phx:content-item-id" content="ci020b8c5f200526b7"><meta name="phx:content-object-type" content="ContentRichTerm"><meta name="phx:exclusive-content-type" content="free"><meta property="phx:site-keyword" content="psmag"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1"><link rel="shortcut icon" href="https://psmag.com/.image/MTQ2ODUzNDM4MzAxNDE0OTQ4/favicon-32x32.png"><style type="text/css">:root {
  --deprecated_color_tile_background: #ffffff;--color_highlighted_label: #ffffff;--color_label: #8c8c8c;--color_header_background: #fafafa;--color_sticky_nav_text_hover: #8c8c8c;--font_body_secondary_family: &quot;proxima-nova&quot;, sans-serif;--highlighted_text_line_height: 1.25;--color_ui_hover_overlay: #DF0A79;--color_footer_nav_text: #333333;--color_stamp_text: #ffffff;--color_stamp_background: #000000;--color_header_subnav_background: #ffffff;--blockquote_text_color: #8c8c8c;--color_text_primary_inverted: #ffffff;--color_text_primary: #333333;--font_ui_weight: 600;--font_ui_transform: uppercase;--font_ui_multiplier: 1;--font_ui_hmultiplier: 1;--button_border_style: 3px;--color_anchor_hover_text: #000000;--palette_primary: #000000;--deprecated_ui_primary: #8c8c8c;--color_button_border: #ffffff;--pullquote_font_size: L;--pullquote_text_link_color: #000000;--palette_accent: #000000;--deprecated_ui_primary_light: rgba(#8c8c8c, .5);--color_footer_nav_text_hover: #000000;--image_hero_overlay: none;--palette_tone_black: #000000;--font_headline_primary_family: &quot;proxima-nova&quot;, sans-serif;--font_body_primary_weight: 400;--font_body_primary_multiplier: .9;--font_body_primary_hmultiplier: 1;--color_header_nav_background: #000000;--pullquote_text_transform: none;--color_featured_header_nav_text_hover: #8c8c8c;--font_headline_primary_weight: 900;--font_headline_primary_transform: uppercase;--font_headline_primary_multiplier: .8;--font_headline_primary_hmultiplier: .9;--deprecated_color_inverted: #ffffff;--color_divider: #fafafa;--pullquote_background_color: rgba(0, 0, 0, 0);--color_header_subnav_text_hover: #fafafa;--font_meta_family: &quot;merriweather&quot;, serif;--blockquote_border_size: 2;--color_button_background: #ffffff;--color_headline_inverted: #ffffff;--pullquote_text_hover_color: $color_hover_body;--deprecated_color_secondary: #000000;--header_background_image_type: none;--site_alignment: left;--palette_tone_dark: #333333;--color_text_secondary_inverted: #ffffff;--color_header_subnav_border: #333333;--color_image_hero_text: #ffffff;--color_sticky_nav_text: #ffffff;--deprecated_color_body_text: #333333;--color_image_tile_text: #ffffff;--color_featured_header_nav_text: #ffffff;--font_meta_weight: 700;--font_meta_transform: uppercase;--font_meta_multiplier: .9;--font_meta_hmultiplier: 1;--header_background_position: top center;--color_headline: #000000;--color_button_text: #000000;--color_navbar_background: #FFFFFF;--image_tile_overlay: linearDark;--sticky_nav_background_opacity: 100;--color_button_background_inverted: #8c8c8c;--color_button_border_inverted: #000000;--color_header_nav_text_hover: #8c8c8c;--color_header_text: #8c8c8c;--background_color_hub: #ffffff;--font_body_secondary_weight: 400;--font_body_secondary_multiplier: 1.1;--font_body_secondary_hmultiplier: .9;--color_label_inverted: #ffffff;--color_sticky_nav_background: #000000;--blockquote_text_link_color: #000000;--header_background_size: auto auto;--color_button_text_inverted: #ffffff;--deprecated_color_accent: #ffffff;--background_color_tile: #ffffff;--featured_header_background_opacity: 100;--deprecated_color_ui_secondary: #fafafa;--deprecated_color_body_background: #ffffff;--blockquote_font_size: XS;--pullquote_text_color: #000000;--color_header_subnav_text: #333333;--color_divider_inverted: #ffffff;--deprecated_color_primary: #000000;--color_button_hover: opacity;--header_background_repeat: repeat;--font_body_primary_family: &quot;merriweather&quot;, serif;--color_anchor_text: #000000;--blockquote_background_color: rgba(0, 0, 0, 0);--color_highlight: #000000;--blockquote_text_hover_color: $color_hover_body;--table_of_contents_title: Related Stories;--color_header_nav_text: #ffffff;--font_headline_secondary_family: &quot;proxima-nova&quot;, sans-serif;--blockquote_text_transform: none;--color_text_secondary: #333333;--pullquote_font_family: body-secondary;--color_featured_header_background: #fafafa;--color_footer_text: #333333;--blockquote_font_family: headline-secondary;--font_headline_secondary_weight: 900;--font_headline_secondary_transform: uppercase;--font_headline_secondary_multiplier: 1;--font_headline_secondary_hmultiplier: 1;--table_of_contents_background_color: #fafafa;--blockquote_border_color: #8c8c8c;--font_ui_family: &quot;proxima-nova&quot;, sans-serif;--palette_tone_light: #fafafa;--palette_tone_mid: #8c8c8c;--palette_tone_white: #ffffff;--debug_fonts_v2: false;--site_component_spacing: 20px;--featured_media_background: #000000;--horizontal_rule_variant_one_color: #8c8c8c;--horizontal_rule_variant_one_height: 2;--horizontal_rule_variant_one_style: solid;--horizontal_rule_variant_one_width: 100;--horizontal_rule_variant_two_color: #8c8c8c;--horizontal_rule_variant_two_height: 6;--horizontal_rule_variant_two_style: double;--horizontal_rule_variant_two_width: 100;--horizontal_rule_variant_three_color: #8c8c8c;--horizontal_rule_variant_three_height: 2;--horizontal_rule_variant_three_style: dotted;--horizontal_rule_variant_three_width: 100;--horizontal_rule_variant_four_color: #8c8c8c;--horizontal_rule_variant_four_height: 2;--horizontal_rule_variant_four_style: dashed;--horizontal_rule_variant_four_width: 100;--drop_caps_variant1_color: #000000;--drop_caps_variant1_font_family: body-primary;--drop_caps_variant1_size: M;--drop_caps_variant2_color: #000000;--drop_caps_variant2_font_family: body-primary;--drop_caps_variant2_size: M;--component_with_background_padding: 20px;--font_headline_detail_weight: 900;--font_headline_detail_transform: uppercase;--font_headline_detail_multiplier: .8;--font_headline_detail_hmultiplier: .9;--font_headline_detail_family: &quot;proxima-nova&quot;, sans-serif;--color_off_canvas_background: rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.8);--color_off_canvas_link: #ffffff;--color_off_canvas_link_hover: #ffffff;--color_off_canvas_link_hover_background: rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.8);--in_content_ad_border_color: #ffffff;--in_content_ad_min_height: 250;--off_canvas_child_link_font_size: M;--section_header_title_font_size: S;--section_header_title_color: #000000;--section_header_title_text_decoration: none;--section_header_title_text_transform: none;--section_header_title_letter_spacing: normal;--color_header_subnav_text_hover_decoration: none
}</style><script>window.phxTheme = {"palette":{"primary":{"main":"#000000","contrastText":"#ffffff"},"secondary":{"main":"#000000","contrastText":"#ffffff"},"text":{"primary":"#333333","secondary":"#333333"}},"typography":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":16.2,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.65,"textTransform":"none","h1":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":38.400000000000006,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"h2":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":48,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"h3":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":36,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"h4":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":24,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.2,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"h5":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":16,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"h6":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":13,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"body1":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":16.2,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.65,"textTransform":"none"},"body2":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":17.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"none"},"headlinePrimary":{"XL":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":57.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"L":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":38.400000000000006,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"M":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":28.8,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":19.200000000000003,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":12.8,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XXS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":10.4,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XXXS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":8,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"}},"headlineSecondary":{"L":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":48,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"M":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":36,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":24,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.2,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":16,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XXS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":13,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"uppercase"}},"headlineDetail":{"XL":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":44.800000000000004,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"L":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":38.400000000000006,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"M":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":28.8,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":19.200000000000003,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.2,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":16,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XXS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":14.4,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XXXS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":12.8,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.2,"textTransform":"uppercase"}},"bodyPrimary":{"L":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":18.900000000000002,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.5,"textTransform":"none"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":16.2,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.65,"textTransform":"none"},"XS":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":12.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.5,"textTransform":"none"}},"bodySecondary":{"L":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":39.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.1,"textTransform":"none"},"M":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":22,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.25,"textTransform":"none"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":17.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"none"},"XS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":14.3,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.4,"textTransform":"none"}},"ui":{"XL":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":20,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"600","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"L":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":16,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"600","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.4,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"M":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":14,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"600","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.5,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":12,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"600","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.4,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":10,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"600","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.4,"textTransform":"uppercase"}},"meta":{"XL":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":21.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"700","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.2,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"L":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":14.4,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"700","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.4,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"M":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":12.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"700","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.5,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":10.8,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"700","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.6,"textTransform":"uppercase"}}}}
</script><style type="text/css">[ng\:cloak], [ng-cloak], [data-ng-cloak], [x-ng-cloak], .ng-cloak, .x-ng-cloak {display: none !important;}</style><link rel="preload" href="https://c.amazon-adsystem.com/aax2/apstag.js" as="script"><link rel="preload" href="https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/tag/js/gpt.js" as="script"><link rel="preload" href="https://www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js" as="script"><link rel="preload" href="https://use.typekit.net/zam7fot.css" as="style"><link rel="preload" href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=IBM+Plex+Mono:wght@400;500&family=IBM+Plex+Sans:wght@400;500&display=swap" as="style"><link rel="preconnect" href="/.image/cs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good/MTQ2MTgzMzA3OTc1OTkyODY0/navbar.png"><link rel="preconnect" href="/.image/cs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.png"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://saymedia-com.videoplayerhub.com/videoloader.js"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://static.chartbeat.com/"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://carbon-cdn.ccgateway.net/script"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://cdn.petametrics.com/"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://secure.quantserve.com/"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://a9695278-4085-40b3-9f02-8d4c38a6ff01.edge.permutive.app/c97f7cbe-37c1-46b7-bef0-5c831be22e3e-web.js"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://ccpa.sp-prod.net"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://wrapper-api.sp-prod.net"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://sb.scorecardresearch.com/"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://fastlane.rubiconproject.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://hbopenbid.pubmatic.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://tlx.3lift.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://ib.adnxs.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://as-sec.casalemedia.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://c2shb.pubgw.yahoo.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://grid.bidswitch.net"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://ssc.33across.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://ap.lijit.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://a.teads.tv">
<script>var mainResourceExecStartTime = window.performance.now() | 0;</script><script>var appCacheBuster = "v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483";</script><script>var genTs = 1692821496569;</script><script>window.Promise||document.write('<script src="/.bootscripts/polyfills/promise.min.js?' + appCacheBuster + '"></s'+'cript>');</script><script>window.fetch||document.write('<script src="/.bootscripts/polyfills/fetch.min.js?' + appCacheBuster + '"></s'+'cript>');</script><script>Object.assign||document.write('<script src="/.bootscripts/polyfills/assign.min.js?' + appCacheBuster + '"></s'+'cript>');</script><script>(typeof window.Element.prototype.closest === 'function')||document.write('<script src="/.bootscripts/polyfills/element-closest.min.js?' + appCacheBuster + '"></s'+'cript>');</script><script>(window.customElements&&window.customElements.define&&window.customElements.get&&window.customElements.whenDefined)||document.write('<script src="/.bootscripts/polyfills/webcomponents.min.js?' + appCacheBuster + '"></s'+'cript>');</script><script>(String.prototype.endsWith||String.prototype.startsWith)||document.write('<script src="/.bootscripts/polyfills/string.min.js?' + appCacheBuster + '"></s'+'cript>');</script><script>"use strict";if(typeof IntersectionObserver==="undefined"||"IntersectionObserver"in window&&"IntersectionObserverEntry"in window&&!("isIntersecting"in window.IntersectionObserverEntry.prototype)){document.write("<script src=\"/.bootscripts/polyfills/intersectionobserver.min.js?"+appCacheBuster+"\"></s"+"cript>")}</script><script>"use strict";(function(){if(typeof window.CustomEvent==="function")return false;function CustomEvent(event,params){params=params||{bubbles:false,cancelable:false,detail:undefined};var evt=document.createEvent("CustomEvent");evt.initCustomEvent(event,params.bubbles,params.cancelable,params.detail);return evt}CustomEvent.prototype=window.Event.prototype;window.CustomEvent=CustomEvent})();</script><script>"use strict";window.scriptErrorsPromiseResolved;window.scriptErrorsPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){window.scriptErrorsPromiseResolved=resolve});function petametricsErrorHandlerWrapper(msg,url,lineNo,columnNo,error){window.scriptErrorsPromise.then(function(){window.liftIgniterPromise.then(function(){window.$p("customErrorHandler",msg,url,lineNo,columnNo,error)})})}window.addEventListener("error",function(errorEvent){var _errorEvent$error;petametricsErrorHandlerWrapper((errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:errorEvent.message)||(errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:(_errorEvent$error=errorEvent.error)===null||_errorEvent$error===void 0?void 0:_errorEvent$error.message),errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:errorEvent.filename,errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:errorEvent.lineno,errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:errorEvent.colno,errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:errorEvent.error)});window.addEventListener("unhandledrejection",function(errorEvent){var _errorEvent$reason,_errorEvent$reason2;var msg=errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:(_errorEvent$reason=errorEvent.reason)===null||_errorEvent$reason===void 0?void 0:_errorEvent$reason.message;var stack=errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:(_errorEvent$reason2=errorEvent.reason)===null||_errorEvent$reason2===void 0?void 0:_errorEvent$reason2.stack;var filename,lineno,colno;if(typeof stack==="string"){var _stack$split,_stack$split$,_stack$split$$split;msg=stack.split("\n")[0];var fileInfo=(_stack$split=stack.split("\n"))===null||_stack$split===void 0?void 0:(_stack$split$=_stack$split[1])===null||_stack$split$===void 0?void 0:(_stack$split$$split=_stack$split$.split(" at "))===null||_stack$split$$split===void 0?void 0:_stack$split$$split[1];if(typeof fileInfo==="string"&&fileInfo.split(":").length>=4){var pieces=fileInfo.split(":");filename=pieces.slice(0,pieces.length-2).join(":");lineno=pieces[pieces.length-2];colno=pieces[pieces.length-1]}}petametricsErrorHandlerWrapper("unhandledrejection: "+msg,filename,lineno,colno,errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:errorEvent.reason)});</script><script>"use strict";window.phxTrackedFeatures={};function addPhxTrackedNumericFeature(name,test_percent){phxTrackedFeatures[name]=Math.random()*100<test_percent}</script><script>"use strict";window.phxBooleans={};function addPhxBoolean(name,value){phxBooleans[name]=value}</script><script>addPhxBoolean('alt-demo-data', false);</script><script>addPhxBoolean('use-hummingbird', true);</script><script>"use strict";window.phxCommerce={};</script><script>window.phxCommerce['trackonomics'] = {};
for (const [key, value] of Object.entries({"siteId":"cs01c121f980009512","partner":"","section":"politics","pageType":"Rich Term Page","tempestContentId":"ci020b8c5f200526b7"})) {
    if (value) {
        window.phxCommerce['trackonomics'][key] = value;
    }
}</script><script>"use strict";function _createForOfIteratorHelper(o,allowArrayLike){var it=typeof Symbol!=="undefined"&&o[Symbol.iterator]||o["@@iterator"];if(!it){if(Array.isArray(o)||(it=_unsupportedIterableToArray(o))||allowArrayLike&&o&&typeof o.length==="number"){if(it)o=it;var i=0;var F=function F(){};return{s:F,n:function n(){if(i>=o.length)return{done:true};return{done:false,value:o[i++]}},e:function e(_e){throw _e},f:F}}throw new TypeError("Invalid attempt to iterate non-iterable instance.\nIn order to be iterable, non-array objects must have a [Symbol.iterator]() method.")}var normalCompletion=true,didErr=false,err;return{s:function s(){it=it.call(o)},n:function n(){var step=it.next();normalCompletion=step.done;return step},e:function e(_e2){didErr=true;err=_e2},f:function f(){try{if(!normalCompletion&&it["return"]!=null)it["return"]()}finally{if(didErr)throw err}}}}function _unsupportedIterableToArray(o,minLen){if(!o)return;if(typeof o==="string")return _arrayLikeToArray(o,minLen);var n=Object.prototype.toString.call(o).slice(8,-1);if(n==="Object"&&o.constructor)n=o.constructor.name;if(n==="Map"||n==="Set")return Array.from(o);if(n==="Arguments"||/^(?:Ui|I)nt(?:8|16|32)(?:Clamped)?Array$/.test(n))return _arrayLikeToArray(o,minLen)}function _arrayLikeToArray(arr,len){if(len==null||len>arr.length)len=arr.length;for(var i=0,arr2=new Array(len);i<len;i++){arr2[i]=arr[i]}return arr2}(function(){if(window.document.location.hash&&window.document.location.hash.indexOf("phxLighthouseDebug")!==-1&&PerformanceObserver&&PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes){var debugLog=function debugLog(timestamp,msg){console.log("[phxLighthouseDebug] "+(timestamp|0)+"ms "+msg)};var getParentNodeRecursive=function getParentNodeRecursive(nextNode,original,num){if(nextNode.nodeName==="HTML"){return{node:original,num:0}}if(nextNode.className||nextNode.id){return{node:nextNode,num:num}}return getParentNodeRecursive(nextNode.parentNode,original,num+1)};var nodeString=function nodeString(node){var str="unknown";var num=0;if(node){var newNode=getParentNodeRecursive(node,node,num);num=newNode.num;node=newNode.node;if(node.localName){str=node.localName}else if(node.nodeName){str=node.nodeName}if(node&&node.className){str+="."+node.className}if(node&&node.id){str+="#"+node.id}if(num>0){str="childof["+num+"]:"+str}}return str};if(PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes.includes("layout-shift")){var transformString=function transformString(previousRect,currentRect){var str="";if(!previousRect||!currentRect){if(!previousRect)str+="np";if(!currentRect)str+="nc";return str}if(!previousRect.width||!previousRect.height||!currentRect.width||!currentRect.height){if(!previousRect.width)str+="npw";if(!previousRect.height)str+="nph";if(!currentRect.width)str+="ncw";if(!currentRect.height)str+="nch";return str}if(previousRect.width!==currentRect.width){if(previousRect.width<currentRect.width){str+="he"}else{str+="hc"}if(previousRect.left===currentRect.left){str+="fl"}else if(previousRect.right===currentRect.right){str+="fr"}else if(previousRect.left+previousRect.right===currentRect.left+currentRect.right){str+="fc"}else if(previousRect.left<currentRect.left&&previousRect.right<currentRect.right){str+="sr"}else if(previousRect.left>currentRect.left&&previousRect.right>currentRect.right){str+="sl"}}else{if(previousRect.left<currentRect.left){str+="htsr"}else if(previousRect.left>currentRect.left){str+="htsl"}}if(previousRect.height!==currentRect.height){if(previousRect.height<currentRect.height){str+="ve"}else{str+="vc"}if(previousRect.top===currentRect.top){str+="ft"}else if(previousRect.bottom===currentRect.bottom){str+="fb"}else if(previousRect.top+previousRect.bottom===currentRect.top+currentRect.bottom){str+="fc"}else if(previousRect.top<currentRect.top&&previousRect.bottom<currentRect.bottom){str+="sd"}else if(previousRect.top>currentRect.top&&previousRect.bottom>currentRect.bottom){str+="su"}}else{if(previousRect.top<currentRect.top){str+="vtsd"}else if(previousRect.top>currentRect.top){str+="vtsu"}}return str};var fmtTransformString=function fmtTransformString(src){var unknownSrc={width:"unknown",height:"unknown",left:"unknown",right:"unknown",top:"unknown",bottom:"unknown"};var pr=src.previousRect||unknownSrc;var cr=src.currentRect||unknownSrc;return"width:".concat(pr.width,"->").concat(cr.width,",height:").concat(pr.height,"->").concat(cr.height,",left:").concat(pr.left,"->").concat(cr.left,",right:").concat(pr.right,"->").concat(cr.right,",top:").concat(pr.top,"->").concat(cr.top,",bottom:").concat(pr.bottom,"->").concat(cr.bottom)};var getNodeStringAndTransformString=function getNodeStringAndTransformString(nsList,sources,tsSummaryList){var str="";for(var i=0;i<nsList.length;i++){str+="["+tsSummaryList[i]+"] "+nsList[i]+" "+fmtTransformString(sources[i])+"\n  "}return str};new PerformanceObserver(function(list){list.getEntries().forEach(function(entry){if(entry.hadRecentInput)return;var nodeStrings=entry.sources.map(function(s){return nodeString(s.node)});var transformStringsSummary=entry.sources.map(function(s){return transformString(s.previousRect,s.currentRect)});debugLog(entry.startTime,"CLS "+entry.value+" from:\n  "+getNodeStringAndTransformString(nodeStrings,entry.sources,transformStringsSummary))})}).observe({type:"layout-shift",buffered:true})}else{debugLog(Date.now()-window.performance.timing.navigationStart,"layout-shift is not a supported entry type")}if(PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes.includes("largest-contentful-paint")){new PerformanceObserver(function(list){var perfEntries=list.getEntries();var entry=perfEntries[perfEntries.length-1];debugLog(entry.startTime,"LCP: "+nodeString(entry.element))}).observe({entryTypes:["largest-contentful-paint"]})}else{debugLog(Date.now()-window.performance.timing.navigationStart,"largest-contentful-paint is not a supported entry type")}if(PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes.includes("first-input")){new PerformanceObserver(function(list){list.getEntries().forEach(function(entry){var delay=entry.processingStart-entry.startTime;debugLog(entry.startTime,"FID: delay "+delay+" ms; name: "+entry.name+"; target: "+nodeString(entry.target))})}).observe({type:"first-input",buffered:true})}else{debugLog(Date.now()-window.performance.timing.navigationStart,"first-input is not a supported entry type")}if(PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes.includes("event")){var maxDuration=0;new PerformanceObserver(function(list){var _iterator=_createForOfIteratorHelper(list.getEntries()),_step;try{for(_iterator.s();!(_step=_iterator.n()).done;){var entry=_step.value;if(!entry.interactionId)continue;var msg=": duration "+entry.duration+"; name: "+entry.name+"; startTime: "+entry.startTime+"; processingStart: "+entry.processingStart+"; processingEnd: "+entry.processingEnd+"; target: "+nodeString(entry.target);if(entry.duration>maxDuration){maxDuration=entry.duration;debugLog(entry.startTime,"[INP LONGEST]"+msg)}else{debugLog(entry.startTime,"[INP ALL]"+msg)}}}catch(err){_iterator.e(err)}finally{_iterator.f()}}).observe({type:"event",durationThreshold:16,buffered:true})}else{debugLog(Date.now()-window.performance.timing.navigationStart,"event is not a supported entry type")}debugLog(Date.now()-window.performance.timing.navigationStart,"Enabled")}})();</script><script>"use strict";if(phxTrackedFeatures["experimental-lazy"]&&PerformanceObserver&&PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes&&PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes.includes("largest-contentful-paint")){window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta={"creationTime":window.performance.now()|0};window.criticalElementsPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){var _navigator,_navigator$connection;var LCP_TIME_BUDGET=(((_navigator=navigator)===null||_navigator===void 0?void 0:(_navigator$connection=_navigator.connection)===null||_navigator$connection===void 0?void 0:_navigator$connection.effectiveType)||"4g")=="4g"?4000:10000;var MAX_TIME_AVAILABLE=LCP_TIME_BUDGET-window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta.creationTime;var MAX_POST_LCP_TIME=250;if(MAX_TIME_AVAILABLE<=0){window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta["case"]="MAX_TIME_AVAILABLE <= 0";window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta.resolutionTime=window.performance.now()|0;resolve(true)}else{var detectionTimeout=setTimeout(function(){window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta["case"]="detectionTimeout hit";window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta.resolutionTime=window.performance.now()|0;resolve(false)},MAX_TIME_AVAILABLE);var waitTimeout=null;var observer=new PerformanceObserver(function(list){if(!window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta.resolutionTime){clearTimeout(detectionTimeout);if(waitTimeout){clearTimeout(waitTimeout)}var POST_LCP_TIME=Math.min(MAX_POST_LCP_TIME,LCP_TIME_BUDGET-window.performance.now()|0);if(POST_LCP_TIME<=0){window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta["case"]="POST_LCP_TIME <= 0";window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta.resolutionTime=window.performance.now()|0;resolve(true)}else{waitTimeout=setTimeout(function(){window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta["case"]="POST_LCP_TIME end";window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta.resolutionTime=window.performance.now()|0;resolve(true)},POST_LCP_TIME)}}});observer.observe({entryTypes:["largest-contentful-paint"]})}})}else{window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta={"creationTime":window.performance.now()|0,"resolutionTime":window.performance.now()|0,"case":"skipped"};window.criticalElementsPromise=Promise.resolve()}</script><script>(function(siteProductionDomain, useCMP, mavenUidTarget) {"use strict";function _classCallCheck(instance,Constructor){if(!(instance instanceof Constructor)){throw new TypeError("Cannot call a class as a function")}}function _defineProperties(target,props){for(var i=0;i<props.length;i++){var descriptor=props[i];descriptor.enumerable=descriptor.enumerable||false;descriptor.configurable=true;if("value"in descriptor)descriptor.writable=true;Object.defineProperty(target,descriptor.key,descriptor)}}function _createClass(Constructor,protoProps,staticProps){if(protoProps)_defineProperties(Constructor.prototype,protoProps);if(staticProps)_defineProperties(Constructor,staticProps);Object.defineProperty(Constructor,"prototype",{writable:false});return Constructor}var VENDOR_IDS={indexexchange:10,quantcast:11,sovrn:13,oath:25,appnexus:32,rhythmone:36,taboola:42,rubicon:52,"33across":58,"33acrosshi":58,gumgum:61,amazonuam:68,openx:69,pubmatic:76,comscore:77,teads:132,outbrain:164,spotx:165,adobe:264,nielsen:373,dailymotion:573,cedato:672,google:755,arcspan:"6425d7744f9aee6206619515",bandcamp:"5f102879d9efe96bbebaf30b",blockthrough:"5efcaf4416696c0e08b30a4d",blueconic:"5eb32dea09c3f947e75e6f02",brightedge:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d7684",brightcove:"5ec796b4320b5a4efd764e0f",chartbeat:"5ea172e36ede87504f7b4590",chicory:"62d6e92851a820068650d77f",clicksco:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d7685",embedly:"5f102879d9efe96bbebaf30b",excoplayer:"62d137270550eb06a62f5855",facebook:"5e716fc09a0b5040d575080f",fubotv:"60cb5ddd1bfbb16ffb1ed67d",ihsmarkit:"5f45507146d0607f71d2d2b6",instagram:"5e717c8e69966540e4554f05",jeeng:"6104438de751ef061d94b7d5",jwplayer:"5f0f1187b8e05c109c2b8464",kargo:"5e542b3a4cd8884eb41b5a75",kickstarter:"5f3ee3dc8957bf8047ac94cc",krux:"5e542b3a4cd8884eb41b5a76",linkedin:"5e777e669cb08971eb078d71",lytics:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d7687",mantis:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d7688",maven:"5f4fdc68ccd23307f4a3fe5f",metabet:"61115122a5573307dc2c043c",narrativ:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d768d",nbcsports:"5f45507146d0607f71d2d2b6",openweb:"5e7ced57b8e05c4854221bd7",parsely:"5efb47c3a86ed40d775a6693",permutive:"5eff0d77969bfa03746427eb",pinterest:"5e839a38b8e05c4e491e738e",polldaddy:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c3057240f6f",pubexchange:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d768a",pulsepoint:"5f1b2fbdb8e05c30686fd6f3",qualtrics:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c3057240fa0",sailthru:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d768b",sendtonews:"5f4975d6c34a678c4f80dd99",skimlinks:"5efb47d829507407f91c4d4e",sortable:"5f2d22a6b8e05c02ba124dc2",soundcloud:"5e7179e49a0b5040d5750812",sportradar:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c306e139f88",spotify:"5e7f6927b8e05c111d01b40f",tiktok:"5e7f6927b8e05c4e491e7380",ted:"5f3ee41ef16f426d9f757c24",tealium:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c30686fd72a",theplatform:"5f3ee4d4ed1f54674a088416",threatmetrix:"636e6f897bd70406aa851625",trustx:"5ec7c9a9b8e05c4a1e720e76",twitter:"5e71760b69966540e4554f01",undertone:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c306e139f31",vidazoo:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c306c059802",viglink:"5f05be4cb8e05c109c2b83d2",vimeo:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c30686fd74c",vox:"60943f2c5a38c71211313c38",youtube:"5e7ac3fae30e7d1bc1ebf5e8"};var TCF2_PURPOSE_IDS={all:[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10],storage:[1],personalization:[3,4,5,6],advertising:[2,3,4,7],content:[5,6,8],measurement:[7,8,9,10],"advertising/basic":[2],"advertising/profile":[3],"advertising/personalized":[4],"content/profile":[5],"content/personalized":[6],"measurement/advertising":[7],"measurement/content":[8],"measurement/research":[9],"measurement/development":[10]};var UID_TIMEOUT=5000;var UID_LONG_TIMEOUT=10*1000;var BaseGdprStatus=function(){function BaseGdprStatus(){var _this=this;_classCallCheck(this,BaseGdprStatus);this._tcfVersion=2;this._useCMP=true;this.tcfPromise=new Promise(function(resolve){_this._tcfPromiseResolve=resolve});this.mavenContextPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){_this.resolveMavenContext=resolve;_this.rejectMavenContext=reject});if(this._isDebugging()){this.resolveMavenContext({uid:"WzmLYjUt7kNuYfzvKqsRmw",countryCode:"DE",inEEA:true,isDemonetized:false,version:3,build:"59"})}else if(this._disableGdpr()){this.resolveMavenContext({uid:"WzmLYjUt7kNuYfzvKqsRmw",countryCode:"US",regionCode:"PA",inEEA:false,isDemonetized:false,version:3,build:"59"})}else{this.fetchMavenContext()}}_createClass(BaseGdprStatus,[{key:"VENDOR_IDS",get:function get(){return VENDOR_IDS}},{key:"PURPOSE_IDS",get:function get(){return TCF2_PURPOSE_IDS}},{key:"newMavenContextPromise",value:function newMavenContextPromise(){var _this2=this;return new Promise(function(resolve,reject){var detectionTimeout=setTimeout(function(){reject(new Error("Timeout"))},_this2.mavenUidTimeout);_this2.resolveMavenContext=function(context){clearTimeout(detectionTimeout);resolve(context)};_this2.rejectMavenContext=function(err){clearTimeout(detectionTimeout);reject(err)}})}},{key:"mavenUidTimeout",get:function get(){var roll=Math.floor(Math.random()*100);var target=mavenUidTarget;if(window.sessionStorage){var stored=window.sessionStorage.getItem("use-longer-uid-timeout-sample");if(stored!==null){roll=parseInt(stored,10)}else{try{window.sessionStorage.setItem("use-longer-uid-timeout-sample",roll)}catch(e){roll=target+1}}}var success=target>0&&roll<target;window.mavenUidLongerTimeout=success;return success?UID_LONG_TIMEOUT:UID_TIMEOUT}},{key:"_applyClass",value:function _applyClass(){if(document.body){document.body.classList.add("is-gdpr-applicable","is-consent-applicable")}else{document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",this._applyClass.bind(this))}}},{key:"siteProductionDomain",set:function set(siteProductionDomain){this._siteProductionDomain=siteProductionDomain}},{key:"useCMP",set:function set(state){this._useCMP=state}},{key:"tcfReady",value:function tcfReady(){this._tcfPromiseResolve()}},{key:"_isDebugging",value:function _isDebugging(){return window.location.hash&&window.location.hash==="#assumeGdprApplicable"&&window.location.hostname!==this._siteProductionDomain}},{key:"_disableGdpr",value:function _disableGdpr(){return window.location.hash==="#disableGdpr"&&window.location.hostname!==this._siteProductionDomain}},{key:"isApplicable",value:function isApplicable(){if(this._isDebugging()){this._applyClass();return Promise.resolve(true)}return this.mavenContextPromise.then(function(payload){return!!payload.inEEA})}},{key:"isApplicableSafe",value:function isApplicableSafe(){return this.isApplicable()["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);return true})}},{key:"isDemonetized",value:function isDemonetized(){return this.mavenContextPromise.then(function(payload){return!!payload.isDemonetized})}},{key:"isDemonetizedSafe",value:function isDemonetizedSafe(){return this.isDemonetized()["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);return true})}},{key:"demonetizedReason",value:function demonetizedReason(){return this.mavenContextPromise.then(function(payload){if(payload.isDemonetized){return payload.demonetizedReason?payload.demonetizedReason:"Unknown"}})}},{key:"demonetizedReasonSafe",value:function demonetizedReasonSafe(){return this.demonetizedReason()["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);return"EndpointError="+err.message})}},{key:"countryCodeSafe",value:function countryCodeSafe(){return this.mavenContextPromise.then(function(payload){return payload.countryCode||""})["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);return""})}},{key:"regionCodeSafe",value:function regionCodeSafe(){return this.mavenContextPromise.then(function(payload){return payload.regionCode||""})["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);return""})}},{key:"getMavenUid",value:function getMavenUid(){return this.mavenContextPromise.then(function(payload){return payload.uid||null})}},{key:"fetchMavenContext",value:function fetchMavenContext(uid,didConsent){var _this3=this;this.mavenContextPromise=this.newMavenContextPromise();window.criticalElementsPromise.then(function(){var queryString=uid?"?uid=".concat(uid).concat(didConsent?"&didConsent=true":""):"";fetch("https://uid.mavencoalition.io/v3".concat(queryString),{credentials:"include"}).then(function(response){if(response.status===200){response.json().then(function(payload){return _this3.resolveMavenContext(payload)})}else{var status="";if(response.statusText){status=": "+response.statusText}throw new Error("[".concat(response.status,"] Invalid UID service response").concat(status))}})["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);_this3.rejectMavenContext(err)})})}},{key:"getMavenUidSafe",value:function getMavenUidSafe(){return this.getMavenUid()["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);return null})}},{key:"waitForConsentValue",value:function waitForConsentValue(){var _this4=this;if(!this._useCMP){return Promise.resolve()}if(!this._consentSetPromise){this._consentSetPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){_this4.isConsentSet().then(function(isSet){if(isSet){resolve(true);return}function setCallback(){if(window.phxConsentManagement){window.phxConsentManagement.setConsentUiCallback(function(){resolve(true)});return true}return false}if(!setCallback()){window.setTimeout(function(){if(!setCallback()){reject("phxConsentManagement was not resolved in time.")}},1000)}})})}return this._consentSetPromise}},{key:"isConsentSet",value:function isConsentSet(){}},{key:"isConsentGivenForPurposes",value:function isConsentGivenForPurposes(){}},{key:"isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes",value:function isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes(){}},{key:"getCookie",value:function getCookie(name){var value="; ".concat(document.cookie);var parts=value.split("; ".concat(name,"="));if(parts.length===2)return parts.pop().split(";").shift()}}]);return BaseGdprStatus}();if(typeof module!=="undefined"){module.exports=BaseGdprStatus}"use strict";function _typeof(obj){"@babel/helpers - typeof";return _typeof="function"==typeof Symbol&&"symbol"==typeof Symbol.iterator?function(obj){return typeof obj}:function(obj){return obj&&"function"==typeof Symbol&&obj.constructor===Symbol&&obj!==Symbol.prototype?"symbol":typeof obj},_typeof(obj)}function _classCallCheck(instance,Constructor){if(!(instance instanceof Constructor)){throw new TypeError("Cannot call a class as a function")}}function _defineProperties(target,props){for(var i=0;i<props.length;i++){var descriptor=props[i];descriptor.enumerable=descriptor.enumerable||false;descriptor.configurable=true;if("value"in descriptor)descriptor.writable=true;Object.defineProperty(target,descriptor.key,descriptor)}}function _createClass(Constructor,protoProps,staticProps){if(protoProps)_defineProperties(Constructor.prototype,protoProps);if(staticProps)_defineProperties(Constructor,staticProps);Object.defineProperty(Constructor,"prototype",{writable:false});return Constructor}function _inherits(subClass,superClass){if(typeof superClass!=="function"&&superClass!==null){throw new TypeError("Super expression must either be null or a function")}subClass.prototype=Object.create(superClass&&superClass.prototype,{constructor:{value:subClass,writable:true,configurable:true}});Object.defineProperty(subClass,"prototype",{writable:false});if(superClass)_setPrototypeOf(subClass,superClass)}function _setPrototypeOf(o,p){_setPrototypeOf=Object.setPrototypeOf?Object.setPrototypeOf.bind():function _setPrototypeOf(o,p){o.__proto__=p;return o};return _setPrototypeOf(o,p)}function _createSuper(Derived){var hasNativeReflectConstruct=_isNativeReflectConstruct();return function _createSuperInternal(){var Super=_getPrototypeOf(Derived),result;if(hasNativeReflectConstruct){var NewTarget=_getPrototypeOf(this).constructor;result=Reflect.construct(Super,arguments,NewTarget)}else{result=Super.apply(this,arguments)}return _possibleConstructorReturn(this,result)}}function _possibleConstructorReturn(self,call){if(call&&(_typeof(call)==="object"||typeof call==="function")){return call}else if(call!==void 0){throw new TypeError("Derived constructors may only return object or undefined")}return _assertThisInitialized(self)}function _assertThisInitialized(self){if(self===void 0){throw new ReferenceError("this hasn't been initialised - super() hasn't been called")}return self}function _isNativeReflectConstruct(){if(typeof Reflect==="undefined"||!Reflect.construct)return false;if(Reflect.construct.sham)return false;if(typeof Proxy==="function")return true;try{Boolean.prototype.valueOf.call(Reflect.construct(Boolean,[],function(){}));return true}catch(e){return false}}function _getPrototypeOf(o){_getPrototypeOf=Object.setPrototypeOf?Object.getPrototypeOf.bind():function _getPrototypeOf(o){return o.__proto__||Object.getPrototypeOf(o)};return _getPrototypeOf(o)}if(typeof BaseGdprStatus==="undefined"){var BaseGdprStatus=require("./gdprStatus")}var SP_PURPOSE_IDS={"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313eff6":1,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f012":2,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f02b":3,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f03f":4,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f053":5,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f061":6,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f06c":7,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f087":8,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f097":9,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f0a9":10};var _spToIabMap=function _spToIabMap(m){var result={};for(var _i=0,_Object$keys=Object.keys(m);_i<_Object$keys.length;_i++){var k=_Object$keys[_i];result[SP_PURPOSE_IDS[k]||k]=m[k]}return result};var SourcepointGdprStatus=function(_BaseGdprStatus){_inherits(SourcepointGdprStatus,_BaseGdprStatus);var _super=_createSuper(SourcepointGdprStatus);function SourcepointGdprStatus(){_classCallCheck(this,SourcepointGdprStatus);return _super.apply(this,arguments)}_createClass(SourcepointGdprStatus,[{key:"isConsentSet",value:function isConsentSet(){if(this._disableGdpr()){return Promise.resolve(true)}if(!this._useCMP){return Promise.resolve(false)}if(this._consents){return Promise.resolve(true)}if(document.cookie.indexOf("euconsent-v2=")===-1){return Promise.resolve(false)}return this.getConsentValues().then(function(consents){return!!consents})}},{key:"getVendorConsentValues",value:function getVendorConsentValues(){return this.getConsentValues().then(function(consents){return consents&&consents.vendorConsents||{}})}},{key:"getPurposeConsentValues",value:function getPurposeConsentValues(){return this.getConsentValues().then(function(consents){return consents&&consents.purposeConsents||{}})}},{key:"setConsentValues",value:function setConsentValues(consents){this._consents=consents}},{key:"getConsentValues",value:function getConsentValues(forceUpdate){var _this=this;if(this._consents&&!forceUpdate){return Promise.resolve(this._consents)}return new Promise(function(resolve,reject){_this.tcfPromise.then(function(){window.__tcfapi("getTCData",2,function(data,success){if(success&&data.vendor&&data.purpose){window.__tcfapi("getCustomVendorConsents",2,function(customData,success){var consents={vendorConsents:data.vendor.consents,vendorPurposeConsents:{},purposeConsents:data.purpose.consents};if(success&&customData){var cv=customData.consentedVendors;if(cv){cv.forEach(function(v){var vg=customData.grants[v._id];if(vg){var pg=vg.purposeGrants;consents.vendorConsents[v._id]=Object.keys(pg).some(function(k){return pg[k]});consents.vendorPurposeConsents[v._id]=_spToIabMap(pg)}})}}_this._consents=consents;resolve(consents)})}})})})}},{key:"isConsentGivenForPurposes",value:function isConsentGivenForPurposes(purposes,purposeConsents){var _this2=this;if(this._disableGdpr()){return Promise.resolve(true)}if(!this._useCMP){return Promise.resolve(false)}return this.getConsentValues().then(function(consents){var pc=purposeConsents||consents.purposeConsents;var _everyConsentForPurposes=function _everyConsentForPurposes(purposes){return purposes.every(function(id){if(typeof id==="string"){id=_this2.PURPOSE_IDS[id]}if(Array.isArray(id)){return _everyConsentForPurposes(id)}else{return!!pc[id]}})};return consents&&(purposeConsents||consents.purposeConsents)&&_everyConsentForPurposes(purposes)})}},{key:"isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes",value:function isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes(vendorId,purposes){var _this3=this;if(this._disableGdpr()){return Promise.resolve(true)}if(!this._useCMP){return Promise.resolve(false)}if(this.VENDOR_IDS[vendorId]){vendorId=this.VENDOR_IDS[vendorId]}return this.getConsentValues().then(function(consents){if(consents&&consents.purposeConsents&&consents.vendorConsents&&!!consents.vendorConsents[vendorId]){if(!purposes){return true}var vpc=_this3._consents.vendorPurposeConsents;if(vpc){var pc=vpc[vendorId];if(pc){return _this3.isConsentGivenForPurposes(purposes,pc)}}return _this3.isConsentGivenForPurposes(purposes)}else{return false}})}}]);return SourcepointGdprStatus}(BaseGdprStatus);window.GdprStatus=new SourcepointGdprStatus;window.GdprStatus.siteProductionDomain = siteProductionDomain;
window.GdprStatus.useCMP = useCMP;
})('psmag.com', true, 0);</script><script id="subscription-common">"use strict";(function(){var IDs={};function getCookieValue(a){var b=document.cookie.match("(^|[^;]+)\\s*"+a+"\\s*=\\s*([^;]+)");return b?b.pop():""}function getRGISUserId(){if(IDs.rgis!==undefined){return IDs.rgis}var cookieVal=getCookieValue("RGIS");if(cookieVal){if(!cookieVal.startsWith("-")){cookieVal=cookieVal.replace(/"/g,"");var userid=cookieVal.split("|")[0];var validRegex=/(^\d+)/;if(validRegex.test(userid)){return IDs.rgis=userid.match(validRegex)[0]}}}return IDs.rgis=null}function getTempestPremiumUserId(){if(IDs.tempest!==undefined){return IDs.tempest}var cookieVal=getCookieValue("userToken");if(cookieVal){var userInfoParts=decodeURIComponent(cookieVal).split(":");if(userInfoParts.length===3){return IDs.tempest=userInfoParts[0]}}return IDs.tempest=null}function phxGetLoggedInStatus(){var rgis=getRGISUserId();if(rgis){return{"type":"rgis","id":rgis}}var tempestPrem=getTempestPremiumUserId();if(tempestPrem){return{"type":"tempestPremium","id":tempestPrem}}return null}window.phxGetLoggedInStatus=phxGetLoggedInStatus;window.phxIsLoggedIn=function(){return!!phxGetLoggedInStatus()}})();</script><script>window.TempestIdentityPromise = Promise.resolve();</script><script>(function(){
    window.GdprStatus.getMavenUidSafe().then(function(muid) {
        if(muid) {
            document.cookie = 'muid=' + encodeURIComponent(muid) + '; path=/; max-age=31536000';
        }
    });
})();</script><script>(function(){
    // Return a random integer; this will be used as an 
    // identifier for all auctions on the page.
    function generateCorrelator() {
        // Use the Math.random function since
        // we do not need a cryptographically secure
        // number here
        var rand = Math.random();
        
        return Math.floor(rand * 2 ** 63);
    }
    var correlator1 = generateCorrelator();
    var correlator2 = generateCorrelator();
    if (correlator1 === correlator2) {
        // Collision suggests that the browser is using a simulated
        // PRNG and thus is not a real user.
        window.mavenCorrelator = 0;
    } else {
        window.mavenCorrelator = correlator1;
    }
})();</script><script>"use strict";(function(){var pageLoadPromises=[];window.getTimedOutPageLoadPromise=function(timeoutMs){if(document.readyState==="complete"){return Promise.resolve(true)}else{var pageLoadPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){window.addEventListener("load",function(){resolve(true)});pageLoadPromises.push(setTimeout(function(){resolve(true)},timeoutMs||0))});return pageLoadPromise}};window.addEventListener("load",function(){for(var i in pageLoadPromises){window.clearTimeout(pageLoadPromises[i])}})})();</script><script>"use strict";function _typeof(obj){"@babel/helpers - typeof";return _typeof="function"==typeof Symbol&&"symbol"==typeof Symbol.iterator?function(obj){return typeof obj}:function(obj){return obj&&"function"==typeof Symbol&&obj.constructor===Symbol&&obj!==Symbol.prototype?"symbol":typeof obj},_typeof(obj)}function _slicedToArray(arr,i){return _arrayWithHoles(arr)||_iterableToArrayLimit(arr,i)||_unsupportedIterableToArray(arr,i)||_nonIterableRest()}function _nonIterableRest(){throw new TypeError("Invalid attempt to destructure non-iterable instance.\nIn order to be iterable, non-array objects must have a [Symbol.iterator]() method.")}function _unsupportedIterableToArray(o,minLen){if(!o)return;if(typeof o==="string")return _arrayLikeToArray(o,minLen);var n=Object.prototype.toString.call(o).slice(8,-1);if(n==="Object"&&o.constructor)n=o.constructor.name;if(n==="Map"||n==="Set")return Array.from(o);if(n==="Arguments"||/^(?:Ui|I)nt(?:8|16|32)(?:Clamped)?Array$/.test(n))return _arrayLikeToArray(o,minLen)}function _arrayLikeToArray(arr,len){if(len==null||len>arr.length)len=arr.length;for(var i=0,arr2=new Array(len);i<len;i++){arr2[i]=arr[i]}return arr2}function _iterableToArrayLimit(arr,i){var _i=arr==null?null:typeof Symbol!=="undefined"&&arr[Symbol.iterator]||arr["@@iterator"];if(_i==null)return;var _arr=[];var _n=true;var _d=false;var _s,_e;try{for(_i=_i.call(arr);!(_n=(_s=_i.next()).done);_n=true){_arr.push(_s.value);if(i&&_arr.length===i)break}}catch(err){_d=true;_e=err}finally{try{if(!_n&&_i["return"]!=null)_i["return"]()}finally{if(_d)throw _e}}return _arr}function _arrayWithHoles(arr){if(Array.isArray(arr))return arr}function _classCallCheck(instance,Constructor){if(!(instance instanceof Constructor)){throw new TypeError("Cannot call a class as a function")}}function _defineProperties(target,props){for(var i=0;i<props.length;i++){var descriptor=props[i];descriptor.enumerable=descriptor.enumerable||false;descriptor.configurable=true;if("value"in descriptor)descriptor.writable=true;Object.defineProperty(target,descriptor.key,descriptor)}}function _createClass(Constructor,protoProps,staticProps){if(protoProps)_defineProperties(Constructor.prototype,protoProps);if(staticProps)_defineProperties(Constructor,staticProps);Object.defineProperty(Constructor,"prototype",{writable:false});return Constructor}function _get(){if(typeof Reflect!=="undefined"&&Reflect.get){_get=Reflect.get.bind()}else{_get=function _get(target,property,receiver){var base=_superPropBase(target,property);if(!base)return;var desc=Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(base,property);if(desc.get){return desc.get.call(arguments.length<3?target:receiver)}return desc.value}}return _get.apply(this,arguments)}function _superPropBase(object,property){while(!Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(object,property)){object=_getPrototypeOf(object);if(object===null)break}return object}function _inherits(subClass,superClass){if(typeof superClass!=="function"&&superClass!==null){throw new TypeError("Super expression must either be null or a function")}subClass.prototype=Object.create(superClass&&superClass.prototype,{constructor:{value:subClass,writable:true,configurable:true}});Object.defineProperty(subClass,"prototype",{writable:false});if(superClass)_setPrototypeOf(subClass,superClass)}function _setPrototypeOf(o,p){_setPrototypeOf=Object.setPrototypeOf?Object.setPrototypeOf.bind():function _setPrototypeOf(o,p){o.__proto__=p;return o};return _setPrototypeOf(o,p)}function _createSuper(Derived){var hasNativeReflectConstruct=_isNativeReflectConstruct();return function _createSuperInternal(){var Super=_getPrototypeOf(Derived),result;if(hasNativeReflectConstruct){var NewTarget=_getPrototypeOf(this).constructor;result=Reflect.construct(Super,arguments,NewTarget)}else{result=Super.apply(this,arguments)}return _possibleConstructorReturn(this,result)}}function _possibleConstructorReturn(self,call){if(call&&(_typeof(call)==="object"||typeof call==="function")){return call}else if(call!==void 0){throw new TypeError("Derived constructors may only return object or undefined")}return _assertThisInitialized(self)}function _assertThisInitialized(self){if(self===void 0){throw new ReferenceError("this hasn't been initialised - super() hasn't been called")}return self}function _isNativeReflectConstruct(){if(typeof Reflect==="undefined"||!Reflect.construct)return false;if(Reflect.construct.sham)return false;if(typeof Proxy==="function")return true;try{Boolean.prototype.valueOf.call(Reflect.construct(Boolean,[],function(){}));return true}catch(e){return false}}function _getPrototypeOf(o){_getPrototypeOf=Object.setPrototypeOf?Object.getPrototypeOf.bind():function _getPrototypeOf(o){return o.__proto__||Object.getPrototypeOf(o)};return _getPrototypeOf(o)}(function(){var DELAY_TIMEOUT=30000;var POST_LOAD_DELAY=100;var pageTag="phoenix-page";window.customElements.whenDefined(pageTag).then(function(){return window.customElements.get(pageTag)}).then(function(pageClass){var PhoenixScript=function(_pageClass$PhoenixEle){_inherits(PhoenixScript,_pageClass$PhoenixEle);var _super=_createSuper(PhoenixScript);function PhoenixScript(){_classCallCheck(this,PhoenixScript);return _super.apply(this,arguments)}_createClass(PhoenixScript,[{key:"connectedCallback",value:function connectedCallback(){_get(_getPrototypeOf(PhoenixScript.prototype),"connectedCallback",this).call(this);this.delayLoad=this.hasAttribute("delay-load");this.afterCriticalElements=this.hasAttribute("load-after-critical-elements");this.templateId=this.getAttribute("script-id");this.scriptSrc=this.getAttribute("src");if(!this.templateId&&!this.scriptSrc){throw new Error("script-id or src is required")}if(this.templateId&&this.scriptSrc){throw new Error("script-id and src are mutually exclusive")}if(this.hasAttribute("script-attributes")){try{this.scriptAttributes=this.getAttr("script-attributes",{parseJson:true})}catch(e){console.error(e)}}this._handleWaitForPromises()}},{key:"_setScriptAttributes",value:function _setScriptAttributes(elem){if(!this.scriptAttributes){return}try{for(var _i=0,_Object$entries=Object.entries(this.scriptAttributes);_i<_Object$entries.length;_i++){var _Object$entries$_i=_slicedToArray(_Object$entries[_i],2),k=_Object$entries$_i[0],v=_Object$entries$_i[1];elem.setAttribute(k,v)}}catch(e){console.error(e)}}},{key:"_whenPageLoaded",value:function _whenPageLoaded(minimumDelayMs,timeoutMs){var _this=this;if(document.readyState==="complete"){return new Promise(function(resolve){setTimeout(resolve,minimumDelayMs)})}else{if(!this.delayLoadTimeouts){this.delayLoadTimeouts=[]}window.addEventListener("load",function(){for(var i in _this.delayLoadTimeouts){window.clearTimeout(_this.delayLoadTimeouts[i])}});return new Promise(function(resolve){window.addEventListener("load",function(){setTimeout(resolve,minimumDelayMs)});_this.delayLoadTimeouts.push(setTimeout(resolve,minimumDelayMs+timeoutMs||0))})}}},{key:"_handleWaitForPromises",value:function _handleWaitForPromises(){var _this2=this;var promises=[this.canRender()];if(this.delayLoad){var delay=parseInt(this.getAttribute("delay-load"),10)||POST_LOAD_DELAY;promises.push(this._whenPageLoaded(delay,DELAY_TIMEOUT))}if(this.afterCriticalElements){promises.push(window.criticalElementsPromise)}Promise.all(promises).then(function(results){if(results[0]){_this2._inject()}})}},{key:"_inject",value:function _inject(){var script=document.createElement("script");if(this.scriptSrc){script.src=this.scriptSrc}else if(this.templateId){var template=document.getElementById(this.templateId);if(!template){throw new Error("template not found for "+this.templateId)}script.innerHTML=template.innerHTML;template.parentElement.removeChild(template)}this._setScriptAttributes(script);var scriptDescription=this.scriptSrc?"scriptSrc ".concat(this.scriptSrc):"templateId ".concat(this.templateId);window.mostRecentScriptDescription=scriptDescription;try{this.appendChild(script)}catch(e){e.message="appendChild failed for script with ".concat(scriptDescription,"; ")+"original error ".concat(e.message);throw e}}}]);return PhoenixScript}(pageClass.PhoenixElement);window.customElements.define("phoenix-script",PhoenixScript)})})();</script><script id="typekit-loader">"use strict";window.fontLoadedPromise=new Promise(function(resolve){window.fontLoadedResolve=resolve});</script><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://use.typekit.net/zam7fot.css" onload="window.fontLoadedResolve()"><link rel="stylesheet" href="/site/styles/main.min.css?config=published&amp;cv=cdf3cea2f833ffb6c03daf9211693543&amp;v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"><script src="/.bootscripts/runtime.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=IBM+Plex+Mono:wght@400;500&amp;family=IBM+Plex+Sans:wght@400;500&amp;display=swap"><script src="/.bootscripts/vendors-react.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script>(function () {
    var givenQs = '&' + window.location.search.substr(1) + '&';
    var newQs = givenQs.replace(/&(bt_email|vero_id)=[^&]+&/, '&REDACTED=REDACTED&');
    if (newQs !== givenQs) {
        console.warn('We have redacted a personal information argument in the query string');
        var newUrl = window.location.pathname + '?' + newQs.substr(1, newQs.length - 2);
        window.history.replaceState({}, '', newUrl);
    }
})();
</script><script>var phxConfigQueue = window.phxConfigQueue || [];
</script><script async src="/.bootscripts/config.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script>phxConfigQueue.push(function () {
    this.features.init({"alt-demo-data":false,"use-hummingbird":true});
    this.membership.init({"exclusiveContent":{"subscribeUrl":"","loginCta":"","enabled":false,"meteredContentEnabled":false},"premiumExperience":{"joinTout":"Join","additionalMenuLinks":[],"enabled":false,"subscribePageLogin":false}});
    this.siteBasePath = '';
    this.siteKeyword = 'psmag';
    this.metabetSiteId = '';
    this.sportradarClientId = '';
    this.ssgClientId = '';
    this.statsApiHostname = 'sports-stats.si.com';
});</script><script>(function(consentConfig) {"use strict";function _classCallCheck(instance,Constructor){if(!(instance instanceof Constructor)){throw new TypeError("Cannot call a class as a function")}}function _defineProperties(target,props){for(var i=0;i<props.length;i++){var descriptor=props[i];descriptor.enumerable=descriptor.enumerable||false;descriptor.configurable=true;if("value"in descriptor)descriptor.writable=true;Object.defineProperty(target,descriptor.key,descriptor)}}function _createClass(Constructor,protoProps,staticProps){if(protoProps)_defineProperties(Constructor.prototype,protoProps);if(staticProps)_defineProperties(Constructor,staticProps);Object.defineProperty(Constructor,"prototype",{writable:false});return Constructor}function _classPrivateMethodInitSpec(obj,privateSet){_checkPrivateRedeclaration(obj,privateSet);privateSet.add(obj)}function _classPrivateFieldInitSpec(obj,privateMap,value){_checkPrivateRedeclaration(obj,privateMap);privateMap.set(obj,value)}function _checkPrivateRedeclaration(obj,privateCollection){if(privateCollection.has(obj)){throw new TypeError("Cannot initialize the same private elements twice on an object")}}function _classPrivateMethodGet(receiver,privateSet,fn){if(!privateSet.has(receiver)){throw new TypeError("attempted to get private field on non-instance")}return fn}function _classPrivateFieldGet(receiver,privateMap){var descriptor=_classExtractFieldDescriptor(receiver,privateMap,"get");return _classApplyDescriptorGet(receiver,descriptor)}function _classApplyDescriptorGet(receiver,descriptor){if(descriptor.get){return descriptor.get.call(receiver)}return descriptor.value}function _classPrivateFieldSet(receiver,privateMap,value){var descriptor=_classExtractFieldDescriptor(receiver,privateMap,"set");_classApplyDescriptorSet(receiver,descriptor,value);return value}function _classExtractFieldDescriptor(receiver,privateMap,action){if(!privateMap.has(receiver)){throw new TypeError("attempted to "+action+" private field on non-instance")}return privateMap.get(receiver)}function _classApplyDescriptorSet(receiver,descriptor,value){if(descriptor.set){descriptor.set.call(receiver,value)}else{if(!descriptor.writable){throw new TypeError("attempted to set read only private field")}descriptor.value=value}}function _typeof2(obj){"@babel/helpers - typeof";return _typeof2="function"==typeof Symbol&&"symbol"==typeof Symbol.iterator?function(obj){return typeof obj}:function(obj){return obj&&"function"==typeof Symbol&&obj.constructor===Symbol&&obj!==Symbol.prototype?"symbol":typeof obj},_typeof2(obj)}var SOURCEPOINT_MMS_DOMAIN="https://message.maven.io";var CCPA="CCPA";var CCPA_STATES=["CA","VA"];var GDPR="GDPR";var CCPA_SHIM=function CCPA_SHIM(){(function(){var e=false;var c=window;var t=document;function r(){if(!c.frames["__uspapiLocator"]){if(t.body){var a=t.body;var e=t.createElement("iframe");e.style.cssText="display:none";e.name="__uspapiLocator";a.appendChild(e)}else{setTimeout(r,5)}}}r();function p(){var a=arguments;__uspapi.a=__uspapi.a||[];if(!a.length){return __uspapi.a}else if(a[0]==="ping"){a[2]({gdprAppliesGlobally:e,cmpLoaded:false},true)}else{__uspapi.a.push([].slice.apply(a))}}function l(t){var r=typeof t.data==="string";try{var a=r?JSON.parse(t.data):t.data;if(a.__cmpCall){var n=a.__cmpCall;c.__uspapi(n.command,n.parameter,function(a,e){var c={__cmpReturn:{returnValue:a,success:e,callId:n.callId}};t.source.postMessage(r?JSON.stringify(c):c,"*")})}}catch(a){}}if(typeof __uspapi!=="function"){c.__uspapi=p;__uspapi.msgHandler=l;c.addEventListener("message",l,false)}})()};var GDPR_SHIM=function GDPR_SHIM(){function _typeof(t){return(_typeof=typeof Symbol=="function"&&_typeof2(Symbol.iterator)=="symbol"?function(t){return _typeof2(t)}:function(t){return t&&typeof Symbol=="function"&&t.constructor===Symbol&&t!==Symbol.prototype?"symbol":_typeof2(t)})(t)}!function(){for(var t,e,o=[],n=window,r=n;r;){try{if(r.frames.__tcfapiLocator){t=r;break}}catch(t){}if(r===n.top)break;r=n.parent}t||(function t(){var e=n.document,o=!!n.frames.__tcfapiLocator;if(!o)if(e.body){var r=e.createElement("iframe");r.style.cssText="display:none",r.name="__tcfapiLocator",e.body.appendChild(r)}else setTimeout(t,5);return!o}(),n.__tcfapi=function(){for(var t=arguments.length,n=new Array(t),r=0;r<t;r++){n[r]=arguments[r]}if(!n.length)return o;n[0]==="setGdprApplies"?n.length>3&&parseInt(n[1],10)===2&&typeof n[3]=="boolean"&&(e=n[3],typeof n[2]=="function"&&n[2]("set",!0)):n[0]==="ping"?typeof n[2]=="function"&&n[2]({gdprApplies:e,cmpLoaded:!1,cmpStatus:"stub"}):o.push(n)},n.addEventListener("message",function(t){var e=typeof t.data=="string",o={};if(e)try{o=JSON.parse(t.data)}catch(t){}else o=t.data;var n=_typeof(o)==="object"?o.__tcfapiCall:null;n&&window.__tcfapi(n.command,n.version,function(o,r){var a={__tcfapiReturn:{returnValue:o,success:r,callId:n.callId}};t&&t.source&&t.source.postMessage&&t.source.postMessage(e?JSON.stringify(a):a,"*")},n.parameter)},!1))}()};var _ccpaPrivacyManagerId=new WeakMap;var _gdprPrivacyManagerId=new WeakMap;var _customConsentUiCallback=new WeakMap;var _consentType=new WeakMap;var _consentString=new WeakMap;var _loadSourcepointPromise=new WeakMap;var _CCPAAcceptedPromise=new WeakMap;var _consentResolver=new WeakMap;var _consentPromise=new WeakMap;var _isCcpaState=new WeakSet;var SourcepointConsentManagement=function(){function SourcepointConsentManagement(){_classCallCheck(this,SourcepointConsentManagement);_classPrivateMethodInitSpec(this,_isCcpaState);_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_ccpaPrivacyManagerId,{writable:true,value:void 0});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_gdprPrivacyManagerId,{writable:true,value:void 0});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_customConsentUiCallback,{writable:true,value:void 0});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_consentType,{writable:true,value:null});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_consentString,{writable:true,value:null});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_loadSourcepointPromise,{writable:true,value:void 0});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_CCPAAcceptedPromise,{writable:true,value:void 0});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_consentResolver,{writable:true,value:void 0});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_consentPromise,{writable:true,value:void 0})}_createClass(SourcepointConsentManagement,[{key:"init",value:function init(config){var _this=this;_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_consentPromise,new Promise(function(resolve){_classPrivateFieldSet(_this,_consentResolver,resolve)}));var gdpr=window.GdprStatus;var cb=function cb(choiceID){gdpr.getConsentValues(true).then(function(consents){ga("_tempestTracker.send","event","CMP",_this._consentChoice(consents))});if(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this,_customConsentUiCallback)){_classPrivateFieldGet(_this,_customConsentUiCallback).call(_this,choiceID)}};return Promise.all([gdpr.isApplicable(),gdpr.countryCodeSafe(),gdpr.regionCodeSafe()]).then(function(values){var isApplicable=values[0];var countryCode=values[1];var regionCode=values[2];window._sp_queue=[];window._sp_={config:{mmsDomain:SOURCEPOINT_MMS_DOMAIN,accountId:config.accountId,baseEndpoint:"https://cdn.privacy-mgmt.com",events:{onMessageChoiceSelect:cb}}};if(!config.disableCCPA&&_classPrivateMethodGet(_this,_isCcpaState,_isCcpaState2).call(_this,countryCode,regionCode)){_this._addConsentApplicableClass();return _this._initCCPA(config)}else if(isApplicable){_this._addConsentApplicableClass();return _this._initGDPR(config,gdpr)}else{delete window._sp_;delete window._sp_queue;_classPrivateFieldSet(_this,_consentType,null);_classPrivateFieldGet(_this,_consentResolver).call(_this,_classPrivateFieldGet(_this,_consentString))}})}},{key:"_initCCPA",value:function _initCCPA(config){var _this2=this;_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_consentType,CCPA);_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_ccpaPrivacyManagerId,config.ccpaPrivacyManagerId);Object.assign(window._sp_.config,{targetingParams:{type:_classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentType)},ccpa:{alwaysDisplayDns:false}});CCPA_SHIM();return this.loadSourcepoint().then(function(){window.__uspapi("getUSPData",1,function(uspData,success){if(success){_this2.setConsentString(uspData.uspString)}})})}},{key:"_initGDPR",value:function _initGDPR(config,gdpr){var _this3=this;_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_consentType,GDPR);_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_gdprPrivacyManagerId,config.gdprPrivacyManagerId);Object.assign(window._sp_.config,{targetingParams:{type:_classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentType)},gdpr:{waitForConsent:true}});GDPR_SHIM();window.__tcfapi("addEventListener",2,function(tcData,success){if(success){if(tcData.eventStatus==="tcloaded"){if(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this3,_consentString)===null){_this3.setConsentString(tcData.tcString);gdpr.tcfReady()}gdpr.getConsentValues(true)}else if(tcData.eventStatus==="useractioncomplete"){if(tcData.tcString!==_classPrivateFieldGet(_this3,_consentString)){window.location.reload()}}}});return this.loadSourcepoint().then(function(){return gdpr.isConsentSet().then(function(isSet){if(!isSet){ga("_tempestTracker.send","event","CMP","initial_display")}})})}},{key:"getConsentString",value:function getConsentString(){return _classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentPromise)}},{key:"consentType",get:function get(){return _classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentType)}},{key:"setConsentString",value:function setConsentString(string){_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_consentString,string);_classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentResolver).call(this,_classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentString))}},{key:"displayUi",value:function displayUi(){var _this4=this;return this.loadSourcepoint().then(function(){if(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this4,_consentType)===CCPA){window._sp_.ccpa.loadPrivacyManagerModal(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this4,_ccpaPrivacyManagerId))}else if(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this4,_consentType)===GDPR){ga("_tempestTracker.send","event","CMP","subsequent_display");window._sp_.gdpr.loadPrivacyManagerModal(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this4,_gdprPrivacyManagerId))}})}},{key:"setConsentUiCallback",value:function setConsentUiCallback(cb){_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_customConsentUiCallback,cb)}},{key:"ccpaAccepted",value:function ccpaAccepted(){var _this5=this;if(!_classPrivateFieldGet(this,_CCPAAcceptedPromise)){return _classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentPromise).then(function(){if(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this5,_consentType)===CCPA){_classPrivateFieldSet(_this5,_CCPAAcceptedPromise,new Promise(function(resolve,reject){var rejected=document.cookie.split(";").some(function(item){if(item.trim().startsWith("ccpaReject")){var cookieVal=item.split("=")[1];if(cookieVal==="true"){return true}}return false});resolve(!rejected)}))}else{_classPrivateFieldSet(_this5,_CCPAAcceptedPromise,Promise.resolve(true))}return _classPrivateFieldGet(_this5,_CCPAAcceptedPromise)})}return _classPrivateFieldGet(this,_CCPAAcceptedPromise)}},{key:"loadSourcepoint",value:function loadSourcepoint(){if(!_classPrivateFieldGet(this,_loadSourcepointPromise)){_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_loadSourcepointPromise,this._loadScript("https://cdn.privacy-mgmt.com/unified/wrapperMessagingWithoutDetection.js"))}return _classPrivateFieldGet(this,_loadSourcepointPromise)}},{key:"_loadScript",value:function _loadScript(s){return new Promise(function(resolve,reject){var e=document.createElement("script");e.src=s;e.onload=resolve;document.head.appendChild(e)})}},{key:"_addConsentApplicableClass",value:function _addConsentApplicableClass(){var _this6=this;if(document.body){document.body.classList.add("is-consent-applicable")}else{document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",function(){_this6._addConsentApplicableClass()})}}},{key:"_consentChoice",value:function _consentChoice(consents){var ACCEPTED_ALL=0,REJECTED_ALL=1,CUSTOM=2,CODES=["accept_all","reject_all","accept_custom"];var vc=consents.vendorConsents;var pc=consents.purposeConsents;var allVendorConsents=!Object.keys(vc).some(function(id){return!vc[id]}),allPurposeConsents=!Object.keys(pc).some(function(id){return!pc[id]});if(allVendorConsents&&allPurposeConsents){return CODES[ACCEPTED_ALL]}else if(Object.keys(vc).some(function(id){return vc[id]})||Object.keys(pc).some(function(id){return pc[id]})){return CODES[CUSTOM]}else{return CODES[REJECTED_ALL]}}}]);return SourcepointConsentManagement}();function _isCcpaState2(countryCode,regionCode){return countryCode==="US"&&(!regionCode||CCPA_STATES.indexOf(regionCode)!==-1)}window.phxConsentManagement=new SourcepointConsentManagement;window.phxConsentManagement.init(consentConfig);
})({"accountId":821,"appCacheBuster":"v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483","ccpaPrivacyManagerId":"5dfbacb056e32a4ed86363e7","disableCCPA":false,"gdprPrivacyManagerId":"335151","platform":"sourcepoint","siteId":"5812"});</script><script>(function(w,apiKey,waitForCarbonReady){"use strict";var promiseResolver;var handle=w.setTimeout(function(){if(promiseResolver!=undefined){promiseResolver()}promiseResolver=undefined},4000);var setCarbonDemographics=function setCarbonDemographics(){var pct={};var realTimeDataHandler=function realTimeDataHandler(){var ls=w.localStorage;var realtimeData=ls?ls.getItem("ccRealtimeData"):null;var contextualData=ls?ls.getItem("ccContextualData"):null;var profile,iabIds;try{if(realtimeData){profile=JSON.parse(realtimeData)}}catch(e){}try{if(contextualData){iabIds=JSON.parse(contextualData)}}catch(e){}if(profile){pct.realtime=profile;var aaq=w.phxAdAuctionQueue||(w.phxAdAuctionQueue=[]);aaq.push(function(){var _this=this;var _profile=profile,demographics=_profile.demographics,audiences=_profile.audiences;if(demographics){demographics.forEach(function(d){if(d.confidence){_this.setKeyValue("carbon_"+d.id,d.confidence)}})}})}if(iabIds){pct.contextual=iabIds}};if(waitForCarbonReady===true){window._ccApiReady=window._ccApiReady||[];window._ccApiReady.push(function(){if(window.carbon){window.carbon.realtimeReady(realTimeDataHandler)}})}else{realTimeDataHandler()}w.phoenixCarbonTargeting=pct;if(promiseResolver!=undefined){w.clearTimeout(handle);promiseResolver()}};if(waitForCarbonReady===true){w.carbonReadyPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){promiseResolver=resolve});w.carbonReady=w.carbonReady||[];w.carbonReady.push(setCarbonDemographics)}else{setCarbonDemographics()}})(window,'268a88b6647a',false);</script><script>"use strict";var scriptName="adScripts:alpha";var startMark="phxMark:prebidStart";var endMark="phxMark:prebidEnd";var pbjs=window.pbjs||(window.pbjs={});pbjs.que=pbjs.que||[];if(window.performance&&window.performance.mark){window.performance.mark(startMark);pbjs.que.push(function(){window.performance.mark(endMark);window.performance.measure(scriptName,startMark,endMark)})}</script><script async src="/runtime/alpha.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script>window.criticalElementsPromise.then(function(r) {
!function(a9,a,p,s,t,A,g){if(a[a9])return;function q(c,r){a[a9]._Q.push([c,r])}a[a9]={init:function(){q("i",arguments)},fetchBids:function(){q("f",arguments)},setDisplayBids:function(){},targetingKeys:function(){return[]},deleteId:function(){q("di",arguments)},renewId:function(){q("ri",arguments)},updateId:function(){q("ui",arguments)},_Q:[]};A=p.createElement(s);A.async=!0;A.src=t;g=p.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];g.parentNode.insertBefore(A,g)}("apstag",window,document,"script","https://c.amazon-adsystem.com/aax2/apstag.js");
var data={pubID:'5128',adServer:'googletag',videoServer:'DFP'};
var sid='26';if(sid){data.schain={complete:1,ver:'1.0',nodes:[{asi:'thearenagroup.net',sid:sid,hp:1}]}}
window.apstag.init(data);"use strict";var _window$localStorage,_window$localStorage$;var emailHashData=(_window$localStorage=window.localStorage)===null||_window$localStorage===void 0?void 0:(_window$localStorage$=_window$localStorage.getItem)===null||_window$localStorage$===void 0?void 0:_window$localStorage$.call(_window$localStorage,"emailHashes");if(emailHashData){var data;try{data=JSON.parse(emailHashData)}catch(e){}if(data&&data.length){var emailHash=data.find(function(el){return el.alg==="sha256"});if(emailHash){window.apstag.renewId({hashedRecords:[{type:"email",record:emailHash.digest}]})}}}});</script><script>var phxAdAuctionQueue = window.phxAdAuctionQueue || (window.phxAdAuctionQueue = []);
</script><script async src="/runtime/beta1.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script>(function(adAuctionConfig){"use strict";window.GdprStatus.isApplicable().then(function(isApplicable){adAuctionConfig.gdprIsApplicable=isApplicable;phxAdAuctionQueue.push(function(){this.startAuction(adAuctionConfig)})});})({"beacons":{"targetingParams":{"paramSeparators":{"ksg":":","terms":";"},"exclude":{"ag":true,"in":true,"pt":true,"et":true,"gd":true}}},"siteProductionDomain":"psmag.com","hummingbirdUrl":"https://hummingbird.mavencoalition.io/collect","slots":[{"config":{"sizes":[[320,50],[320,60],[300,50]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomA"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-311b969ac85943b5b486551c75530722","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[768,66]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomB"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-ad8543a813384bbba469db41128b3240","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[900,65],[970,90]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomC"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-1b89a1efb71d4840b17a943b9632c891","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[900,65],[970,90]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomD"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-d7c63167b4fe42d081ee5f48477c8e70","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-f4d291c5fa724521a0543295c9475062","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-3a493f5649284bd39f2299df85b65674","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-5174334bf75c43f98c913ceaa756adf7","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-60355ed344084823b33d0f0431a47033","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-d86d956ef7f6494180a551521c18780d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-66685d57fd1c43e7a2f723d6acc86aab","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-08ab681ae2904c83b8a9372d791ad91e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-15a2d81e702d40059e81bcec3829e324","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[1,1]]},"model":{"zone":"adhesion","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"adhesion"}],"screenSizes":null,"slotModel":{"zone":"adhesion","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-adhesion-abd53d3997c444d8888cfca630c491a2","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"}],"units":{"A":[{"code":"ad-fixed_bottom-311b969ac85943b5b486551c75530722","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#fixed_bottom-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#fixed_bottom-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390760,"zoneId":2180026}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_fixedbottom_320x50_HDX"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_mw","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_mw","siteId":"812712"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b5fbd6c0066","pos":"fixed_bottom"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349274,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019858"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[320,50]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-f4d291c5fa724521a0543295c9475062","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390760,"zoneId":2180026}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"156422","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_mobile"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_mw","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_0_mw","siteId":"812712"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b5fbd6c0066","pos":"in_content_0"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"300x250","cp":562127,"ct":736896}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019859"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-f4d291c5fa724521a0543295c9475062","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_mw","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-d86d956ef7f6494180a551521c18780d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390760,"zoneId":2180026}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"156422","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_mobile"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_mw","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_1_mw","siteId":"812712"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b5fbd6c0066","pos":"in_content_1"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"300x250","cp":562127,"ct":736896}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019859"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-d86d956ef7f6494180a551521c18780d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_mw","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-adhesion-abd53d3997c444d8888cfca630c491a2","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#adhesion-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#adhesion-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390760,"zoneId":2180026}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407980","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_adhesion"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_mw","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_mw","siteId":"812712"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b5fbd6c0066","pos":"adhesion"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349162,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019858"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[1,1]]}}}],"B":[{"code":"ad-fixed_bottom-ad8543a813384bbba469db41128b3240","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#fixed_bottom-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#fixed_bottom-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_fixedbottom_leaderboard_HDX"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"fixed_bottom"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349274,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-3a493f5649284bd39f2299df85b65674","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_0"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-3a493f5649284bd39f2299df85b65674","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-66685d57fd1c43e7a2f723d6acc86aab","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_1"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-66685d57fd1c43e7a2f723d6acc86aab","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-adhesion-abd53d3997c444d8888cfca630c491a2","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#adhesion-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#adhesion-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407980","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_adhesion"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"adhesion"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349162,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[1,1]]}}}],"C":[{"code":"ad-fixed_bottom-1b89a1efb71d4840b17a943b9632c891","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#fixed_bottom-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#fixed_bottom-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_fixedbottom_leaderboard_HDX"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"fixed_bottom"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349274,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-5174334bf75c43f98c913ceaa756adf7","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_0"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-5174334bf75c43f98c913ceaa756adf7","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-5174334bf75c43f98c913ceaa756adf7","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_0"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}}],"mediaTypes":{"video":{"api":[1,2],"context":"outstream","mimes":["application/javascript","video/mp4","video/webm"],"minduration":0,"maxduration":15,"playerSize":[640,480],"protocols":[1,2,3,4,5,6]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-08ab681ae2904c83b8a9372d791ad91e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_1"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-08ab681ae2904c83b8a9372d791ad91e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-08ab681ae2904c83b8a9372d791ad91e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_1"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}}],"mediaTypes":{"video":{"api":[1,2],"context":"outstream","mimes":["application/javascript","video/mp4","video/webm"],"minduration":0,"maxduration":15,"playerSize":[640,480],"protocols":[1,2,3,4,5,6]}}},{"code":"ad-adhesion-abd53d3997c444d8888cfca630c491a2","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#adhesion-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#adhesion-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407980","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_adhesion"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"adhesion"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349162,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[1,1]]}}}],"D":[{"code":"ad-fixed_bottom-d7c63167b4fe42d081ee5f48477c8e70","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#fixed_bottom-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#fixed_bottom-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_fixedbottom_leaderboard_HDX"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"fixed_bottom"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349274,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-60355ed344084823b33d0f0431a47033","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_0"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-60355ed344084823b33d0f0431a47033","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-60355ed344084823b33d0f0431a47033","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_0"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}}],"mediaTypes":{"video":{"api":[1,2],"context":"outstream","mimes":["application/javascript","video/mp4","video/webm"],"minduration":0,"maxduration":15,"playerSize":[640,480],"protocols":[1,2,3,4,5,6]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-15a2d81e702d40059e81bcec3829e324","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_1"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-15a2d81e702d40059e81bcec3829e324","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-15a2d81e702d40059e81bcec3829e324","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_1"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}}],"mediaTypes":{"video":{"api":[1,2],"context":"outstream","mimes":["application/javascript","video/mp4","video/webm"],"minduration":0,"maxduration":15,"playerSize":[640,480],"protocols":[1,2,3,4,5,6]}}},{"code":"ad-adhesion-abd53d3997c444d8888cfca630c491a2","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#adhesion-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics#adhesion-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407980","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_adhesion"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"adhesion"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349162,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics","terms":["Business & Economics"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[1,1]]}}}]},"unitVendorConfig":{},"timeout":1500,"sellerId":"26","isPermutiveEnabled":true,"pbjsConfig":{"contentItemId":"ci020b8c5f200526b7","productionDomain":"psmag.com","mavenChannel":"psmag.com","experimentString":null,"userSync":{"userIds":[{"name":"connectId","params":{"pixelId":58487},"storage":{"type":"html5","name":"connectid","expires":15}}]}},"videoTimeout":2100,"useGpt":true});</script><script>(function(workspaceApiKey, workspaceId, scriptSrc) {"use strict";Promise.all([window.GdprStatus.isApplicableSafe(),window.criticalElementsPromise]).then(function(values){var consentRequired=values[0];!function(e,o,n,i){if(!e){e=e||{},window.permutive=e,e.q=[];var t=function t(){return([1e7]+-1e3+-4e3+-8e3+-1e11).replace(/[018]/g,function(e){return(e^(window.crypto||window.msCrypto).getRandomValues(new Uint8Array(1))[0]&15>>e/4).toString(16)})};e.config=i||{},e.config.apiKey=o,e.config.workspaceId=n,e.config.environment=e.config.environment||"production",(window.crypto||window.msCrypto)&&(e.config.viewId=t());for(var g=["addon","identify","track","trigger","query","segment","segments","ready","on","once","user","consent"],r=0;r<g.length;r++){var w=g[r];e[w]=function(o){return function(){var n=Array.prototype.slice.call(arguments,0);e.q.push({functionName:o,arguments:n})}}(w)}}}(window.permutive,workspaceApiKey,workspaceId,{"consentRequired":consentRequired});window.googletag=window.googletag||{},window.googletag.cmd=window.googletag.cmd||[],window.googletag.cmd.push(function(){if(0===window.googletag.pubads().getTargeting("permutive").length){var _window$localStorage,_window$localStorage$,_window$localStorage2,_window$localStorage3;var e=(_window$localStorage=window.localStorage)===null||_window$localStorage===void 0?void 0:(_window$localStorage$=_window$localStorage.getItem)===null||_window$localStorage$===void 0?void 0:_window$localStorage$.call(_window$localStorage,"_pdfps");window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("permutive",e?JSON.parse(e):[]);var o=(_window$localStorage2=window.localStorage)===null||_window$localStorage2===void 0?void 0:(_window$localStorage3=_window$localStorage2.getItem)===null||_window$localStorage3===void 0?void 0:_window$localStorage3.call(_window$localStorage2,"permutive-id");o&&(window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("puid",o),window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("ptime",Date.now().toString())),window.permutive.config.viewId&&window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("prmtvvid",window.permutive.config.viewId),window.permutive.config.workspaceId&&window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("prmtvwid",window.permutive.config.workspaceId)}});phxConfigQueue.push(function(){var _this=this;window.permutive.ready(function(){_this.identities.collectIdentities().then(function(identities){if(identities.length>0){window.permutive.identify(identities)}})["finally"](function(){window.permutive.addon("web",{page:{classifications_watson:{categories:"$alchemy_taxonomy",concepts:"$alchemy_concepts",emotion:"$alchemy_document_emotion",entities:"$alchemy_entities",keywords:"$alchemy_keywords",sentiment:"$alchemy_document_sentiment"}}})})},"initialised")});var e=document.createElement("script");e.async=true;e.src=scriptSrc;document.head.appendChild(e);if(consentRequired){window.GdprStatus.waitForConsentValue().then(function(){window.GdprStatus.isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes("permutive",["storage","advertising/basic"]).then(function(result){if(result){window.permutive.consent({opt_in:true,token:"CONSENT_GIVEN"})}else{window.permutive.consent({opt_in:false})}})})}});})("b71fc044-4cae-4225-b686-4012617b40c1","c97f7cbe-37c1-46b7-bef0-5c831be22e3e", "https://a9695278-4085-40b3-9f02-8d4c38a6ff01.edge.permutive.app/c97f7cbe-37c1-46b7-bef0-5c831be22e3e-web.js");</script><script>window.phxPageTarget = {config: {"global":{"config":{"networkCode":"88059007,2154169","adUnitPathTemplates":[{"type":"simple","key":"adSlotKey"},{"type":"simple","key":"basePath"},{"type":"simple","key":"section"}],"beacons":{"targetingParams":{"paramSeparators":{"ksg":":","terms":";"},"exclude":{"ag":true,"in":true,"pt":true,"et":true,"gd":true}}},"customTargetingTemplates":{"adindex":{"type":"simple","key":"index"},"adzone":{"type":"simple","key":"zone"},"adzoneindex":{"type":"simple","key":"zoneIndex"},"adzoneposition":{"type":"simple","key":"zonePosition"},"amznbid":{"type":"simple","key":"amznbid"},"amzniid":{"type":"simple","key":"amzniid"},"amznp":{"type":"simple","key":"amznp"},"amznsz":{"type":"simple","key":"amznsz"},"cm":{"type":"simple","key":"coalitionMember"},"hb_adid":{"type":"simple","key":"prebidAdId"},"hb_bidder":{"type":"simple","key":"prebidWinner"},"hb_pb":{"type":"simple","key":"prebidPriceBucket"},"hb_pbd":{"type":"simple","key":"prebidPriceBucketDollar"},"hb_size":{"type":"simple","key":"prebidAdSize"},"author_pageview":{"type":"simple","key":"authorPageview"},"position":{"type":"simple","key":"positionTarget"},"rid":{"type":"simple","key":"rid"},"siteadzoneindex":{"type":"simple","key":"siteZoneIndex"},"sponlineitemid":{"type":"simple","key":"sponsorLineItemId"},"sponsor":{"type":"simple","key":"sponsor"},"native_card_type":{"type":"simple","key":"nativeCardType"},"prebid_floor":{"type":"simple","key":"prebidFloor"}},"customTargetingPageTemplates":{"ag":{"type":"simple","key":"ag"},"author":{"type":"simple","key":"author"},"breakpoint":{"type":"simple","key":"breakpoint"},"channel":{"type":"simple","key":"channelCode"},"chars":{"type":"simple","key":"characterCount"},"correlator":{"type":"simple","key":"correlator"},"cv":{"type":"simple","key":"coreVertical"},"cs":{"type":"simple","key":"cs"},"direct":{"type":"simple","key":"directOnly"},"env":{"type":"simple","key":"env"},"et":{"type":"simple","key":"et"},"experiments":{"type":"simple","key":"experiments"},"feats":{"type":"simple","key":"trackedFeatures"},"gd":{"type":"simple","key":"gd"},"in":{"type":"simple","key":"in"},"ksg":{"type":"simple","key":"ksg"},"kuid":{"type":"simple","key":"kuid"},"lang":{"type":"simple","key":"languageCode"},"loggedin":{"type":"simple","key":"loggedIn"},"pagetype":{"type":"simple","key":"pageType"},"path":{"type":"simple","key":"path"},"pod":{"type":"simple","key":"pod"},"pt":{"type":"simple","key":"pt"},"referrer":{"type":"simple","key":"referrer"},"sv":{"type":"simple","key":"specialtyVerticals"},"terms":{"type":"simple","key":"terms"},"trending":{"type":"simple","key":"isTrendingContent"}},"expectedRefreshCount":6,"specialSizes":{"0":"fluid","1":"fluid","2":"fluid","3":"fluid","4":"fluid","320x50":"fixedBottomA","320x60":"fixedBottomA","300x50":"fixedBottomA","728x90":"fixedBottomD","768x66":"fixedBottomB","900x65":"fixedBottomD","970x90":"fixedBottomD","1x2":"siteSkin","1x1":"adhesion","940x529":"video","640x360":"outstream"},"lazyLoading":{"disabled":false,"thresholds":{"mobileScaling":3,"renderMarginPercent":150,"fetchMarginPercent":300}},"pageLoadTimeout":12000},"baseModel":{"coalitionMember":"tempest","hostname":"psmag.com","adSlotKey":"psmag.com","basePath":null,"path":"/previous-site-sections/business-economics","channelCode":"web","languageCode":"en","directOnly":0,"author":null,"pageType":"section","section":["previous-site-sections","business-economics"],"terms":[],"coreVertical":"politics","specialtyVerticals":[],"env":"prod","isTrendingContent":"0","experiments":null}},"sizedSlots":[{"config":{"sizes":[[320,50],[320,60],[300,50]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomA"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-311b969ac85943b5b486551c75530722","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[768,66]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomB"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-ad8543a813384bbba469db41128b3240","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[900,65],[970,90]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomC"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-1b89a1efb71d4840b17a943b9632c891","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[900,65],[970,90]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomD"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-d7c63167b4fe42d081ee5f48477c8e70","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-f4d291c5fa724521a0543295c9475062","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-3a493f5649284bd39f2299df85b65674","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-5174334bf75c43f98c913ceaa756adf7","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-60355ed344084823b33d0f0431a47033","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-d86d956ef7f6494180a551521c18780d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-66685d57fd1c43e7a2f723d6acc86aab","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-08ab681ae2904c83b8a9372d791ad91e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-15a2d81e702d40059e81bcec3829e324","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},{"config":{"sizes":[[1,1]]},"model":{"zone":"adhesion","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"adhesion"}],"screenSizes":null,"slotModel":{"zone":"adhesion","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-adhesion-abd53d3997c444d8888cfca630c491a2","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"}],"outOfPageSlots":[],"dynamicSlots":[]}};</script><script>var phxAdvertisingQueue = window.phxAdvertisingQueue || [];
var phxAdServerQueue = window.phxAdServerQueue || [];
</script><script async src="/runtime/gamma.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script async src="/runtime/webads.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script>var googletag = googletag || {};googletag.cmd = googletag.cmd || [];</script><script async src="https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/tag/js/gpt.js"></script><script async src="/runtime/delta.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script>if (window.phxPageTarget) {
    phxAdvertisingQueue.push(function () {
        this.beginPage(window.phxPageTarget.config);
    });
}</script><script>(function() {
    window._comscore = window._comscore || [];
    var comscoreTag = {
        c1: '2',
        c2: '27019031',
    };
    var campaignId = '';
    var siteUrl = '';
    if (campaignId || siteUrl) {
        comscoreTag.c3 = campaignId;
        comscoreTag.c4 = siteUrl ? encodeURIComponent(siteUrl) : '';
    }
    var brand = '';
    if (brand) {
        comscoreTag.c6 = brand;
    }
    window._comscore.push(comscoreTag);
})();</script><script>(function() {
    var _load = function () {
        var s = document.createElement("script"), el = document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];
        s.src = "https://sb.scorecardresearch.com/beacon.js";
        el.parentNode.insertBefore(s, el);
    };
    var gdpr = window.GdprStatus;
    Promise.all([gdpr.isApplicable(), window.criticalElementsPromise]).then(function(values) {
        var isApplicable = values[0];
        if (isApplicable) {
            //- This causes the Comscore script to delay until consent state
            //- is known; the rest of the code above is benign in the event that
            //- consent has not been given.
            gdpr.waitForConsentValue().then(function () {
                gdpr.isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes(GdprStatus.VENDOR_IDS.comscore, GdprStatus.PURPOSE_IDS.measurement)
                .then(function(value) {
                    if (value) {
                        _load();
                    }
                });
            });
        } else {
            _load();
        }
    });
})();</script><base href="/"><meta charset="utf-8"><meta name="referrer" content="unsafe-url"><meta http-equiv="cleartype" content="on"><meta name="HandheldFriendly" content="True"><meta name="MobileOptimized" content="320"><meta name="apple-mobile-web-app-capable" content="no"><meta name="apple-mobile-web-app-status-bar-style" content="black"><link rel="apple-touch-icon" href="/site/images/apple-touch-icon.png?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="57x57" href="/site/images/apple-touch-icon-57x57-precomposed.png?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="72x72" href="/site/images/apple-touch-icon-72x72-precomposed.png?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="114x114" href="/site/images/apple-touch-icon-114x114-precomposed.png?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"><link rel="manifest" href="/site.webmanifest"><meta name="format-detection" content="telephone=no"><meta name="format-detection" content="address=no"><meta name="google-site-verification" content="ZgvHOWx_79PGGGpfWBMphtj46BEry3GMnUTgDsx7xIw"><meta name="msvalidate.01" content="565AA37CB662E60BF24DDCABEC686D8F"><meta name="generator" content="Tempest - maven.io"><link rel="schema.dcterms" href="http://purl.org/dc/terms/"><meta name="pinterest" content="nohover"></head><body class="mm-alt-demo-data-enabled mm-use-hummingbird-enabled has-legacy-nav is-sidebar-enabled is-balloon-header-active" phx-page-manager><script async src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=UA-1778701-17"></script><script>window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || [];
function gtag(){dataLayer.push(arguments);}
gtag('js', new Date());
</script><script>window.googleAnalyticsConfig = {"initialModel":{"title":"Business & Economics","pageType":"Rich Term Page","mavenPageType":"section","exclusiveContentType":"free","isTrendingContent":"0","path":"/previous-site-sections/business-economics","contributorContent":0,"subscriptionStatus":"Unsubscribed","monetization":"1","channelName":"Web","coreVertical":"politics","primaryDomain":"psmag.com","mavenChannel":"psmag.com","contentItemId":"ci020b8c5f200526b7","siteType":null,"premiumDetail":0,"features":""},"trackers":[{"name":"_tempestTracker","id":"UA-1778701-17","cookieDomain":"psmag.com","sendEvents":true,"setFieldValues":true,"customDimensionMap":{"pageType":1,"parentSectionName":2,"authorName":3,"publicationQuarter":4,"originalPublishDate":7,"premiumDetail":9,"channelName":11,"subscriptionStatus":12,"sectionPath":13,"eeaStatus":14,"trackedRichTermNames":16,"trackedExtendedAttributes":17,"primaryDomain":21,"mavenChannel":22,"coreVertical":23,"specialtyVerticals":24,"hasMavenUid":29,"author":30,"demonetizedReason":32,"sanitizedTitle":33,"videoTitle":34,"videoAuthorName":35,"monetization":36,"memberId":37,"contentItemId":38,"gaUserId":39,"contributorContent":42,"features":43,"mavenPageType":44,"suid":46,"membershipOfferSlug":48,"membershipProductName":49,"membershipProductCode":50,"membershipPlanCodes":51,"exclusiveContentType":52,"siteType":53,"recommendationAlgorithm":54,"trwDialogueLink":55,"experiments":56,"breakpoint":57,"characterCount":58,"isTrendingContent":59,"correlator":60},"customEventDimensionMap":{"videoTitle":34,"videoAuthorName":35,"videoMonetizationState":47}},{"cookieDomain":"psmag.com","sendEvents":true,"setFieldValues":true,"contentItemIdPrefix":null,"customDimensionMap":{"subscriptionStatus":null,"mavenPageType":null,"trackedRichTermNames":1,"sectionPath":null,"publicationQuarter":null,"memberId":null,"recommendationAlgorithm":null,"authorName":2,"contentItemId":null,"pageType":null,"channelName":null,"parentSectionName":null,"gaUserId":null},"name":"_siteTracker0","id":"UA-3354517-5"}],"type":"gtag","usePublisherGtag":false,"ids":["UA-1778701-17","UA-3354517-5"]} || {trackers: []};
var googleAnalyticsConfigPromiseResolved;
var googleAnalyticsPromiseResolved;
window.googleAnalyticsConfigPromise = new Promise(function(resolve, reject) {
      googleAnalyticsConfigPromiseResolved = resolve;
});
 window.googleAnalyticsPromise = new Promise(function(resolve, reject) {
      googleAnalyticsPromiseResolved = resolve;
});
Promise.all([window.GdprStatus.isApplicableSafe(), window.GdprStatus.getMavenUidSafe(), window.GdprStatus.demonetizedReasonSafe(), window.TempestIdentityPromise, window.criticalElementsPromise]).then(function(results) {
   var isApplicable = results[0];
   var mavenUid = results[1];
   var demonetizedReason = results[2];
   var ti = results[3];
  (function (googleAnalyticsConfig, breakpoints, breakpointHeights, experimentString) {"use strict";function ownKeys(object,enumerableOnly){var keys=Object.keys(object);if(Object.getOwnPropertySymbols){var symbols=Object.getOwnPropertySymbols(object);enumerableOnly&&(symbols=symbols.filter(function(sym){return Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(object,sym).enumerable})),keys.push.apply(keys,symbols)}return keys}function _objectSpread(target){for(var i=1;i<arguments.length;i++){var source=null!=arguments[i]?arguments[i]:{};i%2?ownKeys(Object(source),!0).forEach(function(key){_defineProperty(target,key,source[key])}):Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptors?Object.defineProperties(target,Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptors(source)):ownKeys(Object(source)).forEach(function(key){Object.defineProperty(target,key,Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(source,key))})}return target}function _defineProperty(obj,key,value){if(key in obj){Object.defineProperty(obj,key,{value:value,enumerable:true,configurable:true,writable:true})}else{obj[key]=value}return obj}function getCurrentBreakpoint(){var breakpoint;var width=window.innerWidth;var height=window.innerHeight;for(var possibleBreakpoint in breakpoints){if(width>=breakpoints[possibleBreakpoint]){if(!breakpointHeights[possibleBreakpoint]||height>=breakpointHeights[possibleBreakpoint]){breakpoint=possibleBreakpoint}}}return breakpoint}var updateModel=function updateModel(model){var _model$characterCount,_window$localStorage;model.hasMavenUid=mavenUid?"1":"0";model.demonetizedReason=demonetizedReason||"0";model.correlator=mavenCorrelator;var moreFeatures=phxTrackedFeatures?Object.keys(phxTrackedFeatures).map(function(name){return"".concat(name,":").concat(phxTrackedFeatures[name]?"1":"0")}).join(";"):"";model.features=model.features?"".concat(model.features,";").concat(moreFeatures):moreFeatures;model.features=model.features.split(";").sort().join(";");model.breakpoint=getCurrentBreakpoint();model.experiments=experimentString;model.eeaStatus=isApplicable?"1":"0";model.characterCount=(_model$characterCount=model.characterCountByBreakpoint)===null||_model$characterCount===void 0?void 0:_model$characterCount[model.breakpoint];var userStatus=window.phxGetLoggedInStatus();if((userStatus===null||userStatus===void 0?void 0:userStatus["type"])==="rgis"){model.memberId=userStatus["id"];model.memberIdSource="1"}else if((_window$localStorage=window.localStorage)!==null&&_window$localStorage!==void 0&&_window$localStorage.getItem("possibleMemberId")){var _window$localStorage2;model.memberId=(_window$localStorage2=window.localStorage)===null||_window$localStorage2===void 0?void 0:_window$localStorage2.getItem("possibleMemberId");model.memberIdSource="0"}if(window.URLSearchParams){var queryParams=new URLSearchParams(window.location.search);if(queryParams.has("suid")){model.suid=queryParams.get("suid")}if(queryParams.has("trw")){model.trwDialogueLink=queryParams.get("trw")}}return model};googleAnalyticsConfig.sendPageView=function(_model,_analyticType){var model=updateModel(_model);var analyticsData=[];for(var i=0;i<googleAnalyticsConfig.trackers.length;i++){var tracker=googleAnalyticsConfig.trackers[i];var config={};var customMap={};var setters={};var prefix="";if(tracker.name){config.name=tracker.name;prefix=tracker.name+"."}if(tracker.cookieDomain){config.cookieDomain=tracker.cookieDomain}if(tracker.sampleRate){config.sampleRate=tracker.sampleRate}if(isApplicable){config.storage="none";config.storeGac=false;setters.displayFeaturesTask=null}if(tracker.name==="_tempestTracker"&&mavenUid){setters.userId=mavenUid}setters.page=model.path;setters.title=model.title;setters.anonymizeIp=true;var cd=tracker.customDimensionMap;for(var k in cd){if(!cd[k]||!cd.hasOwnProperty(k)){continue}var val=model[k];if(k==="contentItemId"&&tracker.contentItemIdPrefix){val=tracker.contentItemIdPrefix+"-"+val}else if(k==="features"&&typeof val==="string"){if(!window.mavenUidLongerTimeout){val=val.replace("use-longer-uid-timeout:1","use-longer-uid-timeout:0")}}if(val!==undefined&&val!==null&&val!==""){customMap["dimension".concat(cd[k])]=val}}if(!tracker.initialCustomMap){tracker.initialCustomMap=customMap}analyticsData.push({config:config,id:tracker.id,prefix:prefix,setters:setters,customMap:customMap,initialCustomMap:tracker.initialCustomMap})}var analyticsType=_analyticType||googleAnalyticsConfig.type;var GTAG_EVENT_HANDLER=function GTAG_EVENT_HANDLER(data,type){var config=data.config,setters=data.setters,id=data.id,customMap=data.customMap,initialCustomMap=data.initialCustomMap;var extendedCustomMap=_objectSpread(_objectSpread({},initialCustomMap),{},{page_path:setters.page,page_location:window.location.href,page_title:setters.title});if(!googleAnalyticsConfig.initialsetup[type][id]){gtag("config",id,_objectSpread(_objectSpread(_objectSpread(_objectSpread(_objectSpread({},config),setters),customMap),extendedCustomMap),{},{anonymize_ip:setters.anonymizeIp,user_id:setters.userId}));googleAnalyticsConfig.initialsetup[type][id]=true}else{gtag("event","page_view",_objectSpread(_objectSpread({},extendedCustomMap),{},{send_to:id}))}gtag("get",id,"client_id",function(clientId){model.gaUserId=clientId})};if(["ga4","ga-ga4","ga4-gtag"].includes(analyticsType)){for(var _i=0;_i<analyticsData.length;_i++){var _analyticsData$_i=analyticsData[_i],_config=_analyticsData$_i.config,id=_analyticsData$_i.id;if(id==="G-CY0JQWZCM6"||_config.name==="_publisherPersonalGA4Tracker"){GTAG_EVENT_HANDLER(analyticsData[_i],"ga4")}}}if(["gtag","ga-gtag","ga4-gtag"].includes(analyticsType)){for(var _i2=0;_i2<analyticsData.length;_i2++){var _id=analyticsData[_i2].id;if(_id==="G-CY0JQWZCM6"){continue}GTAG_EVENT_HANDLER(analyticsData[_i2],"gtag")}}if(["ga","ga-gtag","ga-ga4"].includes(analyticsType)){ga(function(){for(var _i3=0;_i3<analyticsData.length;_i3++){var _analyticsData$_i2=analyticsData[_i3],_config2=_analyticsData$_i2.config,_prefix=_analyticsData$_i2.prefix,_setters=_analyticsData$_i2.setters,_id2=_analyticsData$_i2.id,_customMap=_analyticsData$_i2.customMap;if(_id2==="G-CY0JQWZCM6"||_config2.name==="_publisherPersonalGA4Tracker"){continue}var props=_objectSpread(_objectSpread({},_setters),_customMap);if(!googleAnalyticsConfig.initialsetup.ga[_id2]){ga("create",_id2,_config2);googleAnalyticsConfig.initialsetup.ga[_id2]=true}model.gaUserId=ga.getAll()[0].get("clientId");for(var key in props){ga("".concat(_prefix,"set"),key,props[key])}ga("".concat(_prefix,"send"),"pageview",model.path)}})}};googleAnalyticsConfig.initialModel.positionInSession="initial";googleAnalyticsConfig.initialsetup={gtag:{},ga:{},ga4:{}};googleAnalyticsConfig.sendPageView(googleAnalyticsConfig.initialModel);googleAnalyticsConfigPromiseResolved();  })(window.googleAnalyticsConfig, {"A":0,"B":675,"C":1240,"D":1680}, {"D":1050}, null);
});</script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/PhoenixGoogleAnalytics.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><script>window.phoenixTrackClickEvent = function(el) {
    window.phoenixTrackClickEvent._q = window.phoenixTrackClickEvent._q || [];
    window.phoenixTrackClickEvent._q.push(el);
    return true;
}
</script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/analytics.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><script>(function() {
    var _load = function () {
        !function(a,b,c,d,e,f){a.ddjskey=e;a.ddoptions=f||null;var m=b.createElement(c),n=b.getElementsByTagName(c)[0];m.async=1,m.src=d,n.parentNode.insertBefore(m,n)}(window,document,"script","https://js.datadome.co/tags.js", "2AC20A4365547ED96AE26618B66966", { ajaxListenerPath: true });
    };
    Promise.all([window.criticalElementsPromise]).then(function() {
        _load();
    });
})();</script><a class="is-skip-link" href="#main-content">Skip to main content</a><phoenix-page><phoenix-style href="/site/styles/print.min.css?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483" media="print" delay-load load-after-critical></phoenix-style><div id="lyra-wrapper"><phoenix-overlay class="m-off-canvas m-overlay is-left-drawer" overlay-name="offcanvas" role="navigation" style="visibility: hidden;" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true"><phoenix-notifier event-name="phoenix:overlay" events="click mousewheel scroll touchmove DOMMouseScroll"><div class="m-overlay-mask"></div></phoenix-notifier><div class="m-off-canvas--menu m-overlay--content"><div class="m-vertical-nav m-off-canvas--scroller-no-footer"><div class="m-off-canvas--header has-search"><div class="m-off-canvas--header-flagship"></div><div class="m-off-canvas--header-auth"></div><div class="m-off-canvas--header-close"><phoenix-notifier event-name="phoenix:overlay"><button class="m-overlay--close mm-overlay--close-static m-icon-button m-off-canvas--menu-close-btn" aria-label="Close Menu" type="button"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon mm-icon-button--static" icon="ico_close"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_close"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_close"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></phoenix-icon-fallback></button></phoenix-notifier></div><div class="m-off-canvas--header-search"><form class="m-off-canvas--search" role="form" action="/search" method="GET"><input class="m-off-canvas--search-input" aria-label="Search" placeholder="Search" name="query"><button class="m-off-canvas--search-button m-icon-button" aria-label="Submit Search" type="submit"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon mm-icon-button--size-reset" icon="ico_search"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_search"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_search"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></phoenix-icon-fallback></button></form></div></div><div class="m-off-canvas--scroll-wrapper"><nav role="navigation"><phoenix-accordion class="m-accordion mn-accordion--off-canvas" id="offcanvas0-accordion"><ul><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-0" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/news" title="News in Brief">News in Brief</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-1" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/economics" title="Economics">Economics</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-2" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/education" title="Education">Education</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-3" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/environment" title="Environment">Environment</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-4" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/social-justice" title="Social Justice">Social Justice</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-5" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/tag/features-investigations" title="Features &amp; Investigations">Features &amp; Investigations</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-6" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/ideas" title="Ideas">Ideas</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-7" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/audio-podcasts" title="Audio">Audio</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li></ul></phoenix-accordion><ul class="m-off-canvas--social-links"><li><a class="m-icon-button m-off-canvas--social-link" aria-label="facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/PacificStand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_facebook"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_facebook"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li><li><a class="m-icon-button m-off-canvas--social-link" aria-label="linkedin" href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/pacific-standard-magazine" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_linkedin"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_linkedin"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li><li><a class="m-icon-button m-off-canvas--social-link" aria-label="instagram" href="https://www.instagram.com/pacificstand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_instagram"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_instagram"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li><li><a class="m-icon-button m-off-canvas--social-link" aria-label="twitter" href="https://twitter.com/pacificstand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_twitter"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_twitter"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li></ul><div class="m-off-canvas--maven-logo-wrapper"><a rel="noopener" target="_blank"></a></div><ul class="m-off-canvas--nav-secondary m-vertical-nav--menu m-vertical-nav-secondary" phx-track-id="Nav List"><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/about" title="About" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>About</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/audience-influence" title="Impact" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Impact</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/contact-us" title="Contact" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Contact</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/write-us" title="Pitching" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Pitching</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/fellowship-program" title="Careers" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Careers</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/advertise" title="Partnerships" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Partnerships</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/privacy-statement" title="Terms of Use" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Terms of Use</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="https://www.saymedia.com/privacy" target="_blank" rel="noopener" title="Platform Privacy" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Platform Privacy</em></a></li></ul></nav></div></div></div></phoenix-overlay><phoenix-overlay class="m-overlay is-right-drawer" overlay-name="right-drawer" style="visibility: hidden;" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true"><phoenix-notifier event-name="phoenix:overlay" events="click mousewheel scroll touchmove DOMMouseScroll"><div class="m-overlay-mask"></div></phoenix-notifier><div class="m-overlay--content m-nav-widget"><phoenix-notifier event-name="phoenix:overlay"><button class="m-overlay--close m-icon-button" aria-label="Close Menu" type="button"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_close"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_close"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_close"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></phoenix-icon-fallback></button></phoenix-notifier><div class="m-nav-widget--header"><div class="m-nav-widget--header-title"><strong></strong><span class="m-nav-widget--header-caption"></span></div><div class="m-nav-widget--header-subtitle">August 23, 2023</div></div><div class="m-nav-widget--content"></div></div></phoenix-overlay><div class="m-page-wrapper is-below-header-ad"><div class="m-ad-adhesion" id="ad-adhesion-abd53d3997c444d8888cfca630c491a2"></div><phoenix-sticky-nav class="m-site-nav l-sticky-navbar mm-site-nav--sticky-nav" nav-target=".m-header--navbar" style="visibility: hidden;" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true"><phoenix-notifier class="m-site-nav--icon-button m-site-nav--menu" event-name="phoenix:overlay" event-value="offcanvas"><button class="m-off-canvas--toggle m-icon-button" aria-label="Menu" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="offcanvas" tabindex="0"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon m-site-nav--menu-icon" icon="ico_hamburger_flipped"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_hamburger_flipped"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></button></phoenix-notifier><div class="m-site-nav--menu-items"><a class="m-site-nav--logo" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="logo" href="/"><img src="https://psmag.com/.image/cs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good/MTQ2MTgzMzA3OTc1OTkyODY0/navbar.png" alt="Pacific Standard home"></a><div class="m-navbar m-site-nav--links-container"><ul class="m-navbar--links"><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/news" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">News in Brief</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/economics" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Economics</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/education" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Education</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/environment" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Environment</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/social-justice" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Social Justice</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/tag/features-investigations" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Features &amp; Investigations</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/ideas" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Ideas</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/audio-podcasts" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Audio</span></a></li></ul></div></div><div class="m-site-nav--search-group"><div class="m-site-nav--search m-site-nav--icon"><a class="m-icon-button has-underline-on-hover" aria-label="Search" href="/search" title="Search" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="search"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_search"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_search"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div></div></phoenix-sticky-nav><div class="m-header-components"><phoenix-intersection-notifier in-view="phoenix:header:in" out-of-view="phoenix:header:out" threshold="0.1"><header class="m-header mm-header-large mm-header--left mm-header--content-detail" phx-track-id="header"><section class="m-header--container"><ul class="m-header--social-nav"><li class="m-header--link m-header--social-facebook" phx-track-id="social"><a aria-label="facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/PacificStand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="facebook-follow"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_facebook"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_facebook"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li><li class="m-header--link m-header--social-linkedin" phx-track-id="social"><a aria-label="linkedin" href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/pacific-standard-magazine" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="linkedin-follow"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_linkedin"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_linkedin"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li><li class="m-header--link m-header--social-instagram" phx-track-id="social"><a aria-label="instagram" href="https://www.instagram.com/pacificstand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="instagram-follow"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_instagram"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_instagram"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li><li class="m-header--link m-header--social-twitter" phx-track-id="social"><a aria-label="twitter" href="https://twitter.com/pacificstand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="twitter-follow"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_twitter"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_twitter"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li></ul><div class="m-header--main"><a class="m-header--logo" href="/" aria-label="Pacific Standard" phx-track-id="logo" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-picture class="m-background mm-background--site-logo not-size-a"><picture class="m-header--logo-picture-block is-waiting-to-load" aria-hidden="true"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_400/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.webp 400w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_700/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.webp 700w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_800/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.webp 800w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_1400/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.webp 1400w"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_400/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.png 400w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_700/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.png 700w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_800/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.png 800w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_1400/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.png 1400w"><img class="m-background--image" decoding="async" nopin="true" src="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_700/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.png" srcset="" alt="Pacific Standard home"></picture></phoenix-picture></a><phoenix-import class="m-header--coverlines-container" src="/.api/coverlines" phx-track-id="coverline"></phoenix-import></div></section><div class="m-site-nav m-header--navbar mm-site-nav--protected mm-site-nav--condensed" nav-target=".m-header--navbar"><phoenix-notifier class="m-site-nav--icon-button m-site-nav--menu" event-name="phoenix:overlay" event-value="offcanvas"><button class="m-off-canvas--toggle m-icon-button" aria-label="Menu" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="offcanvas" tabindex="0"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon m-site-nav--menu-icon" icon="ico_hamburger_flipped"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_hamburger_flipped"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></button></phoenix-notifier><div class="m-site-nav--menu-items"><a class="m-site-nav--logo" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="logo" href="/"><img src="https://psmag.com/.image/cs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good/MTQ2MTgzMzA3OTc1OTkyODY0/navbar.png" alt="Pacific Standard home" style="max-height:122px;"></a><div class="m-navbar m-site-nav--links-container"><ul class="m-navbar--links"><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/news" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">News in Brief</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/economics" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Economics</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/education" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Education</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/environment" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Environment</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/social-justice" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Social Justice</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/tag/features-investigations" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Features &amp; Investigations</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/ideas" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Ideas</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/audio-podcasts" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Audio</span></a></li></ul></div></div><div class="m-site-nav--search-group"><div class="m-site-nav--search m-site-nav--icon"><a class="m-icon-button has-underline-on-hover" aria-label="Search" href="/search" title="Search" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="search"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_search"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_search"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div></div></div></header></phoenix-intersection-notifier></div><section class="m-page-container trackable click"></section><div class="m-page" ng-class="pageClasses" id="main-content"><script type="application/json" id="pageItemData">{"id":"ci020b8c5f200526b7","isDetailPage":false,"objectType":"ContentRichTerm","originalPublicationTimestamp":"2017-06-30T20:18:28Z","path":"/previous-site-sections/business-economics","publicationTimestamp":"2017-06-30T20:18:28Z","title":"Business & Economics","viewProperties":{"viewMeta":{"showLimitedSiteFooter":false,"suppressDisplayAds":false,"disableSiteFooter":false,"suppressContentRecommendations":false,"promoTwitter":{"teaser":null,"title":null,"imageId":null},"disableSiteHeader":false,"promoFacebook":{"teaser":null,"title":null,"imageId":null}},"rss":{"collection":{"filter":{"term":"ci020b8c5f200526b7","type":"ContentArticle"}}},"analyticsModel":{"title":"Business & Economics","pageType":"Rich Term Page","mavenPageType":"section","exclusiveContentType":"free"}},"commentsEnabled":true,"disqusId":"8bc958df-40d0-11e7-bae9-066758d48690","isCanvas":true,"metaDescription":"","primaryImage":{"isReadonlyContent":false,"title":"Business & Economics Section Heading","format":"jpg","bytes":83410,"primaryPhotoId":"ci01dbd3cce0012a83","createdTimestamp":"2015-10-23T18:45:34Z","primaryContentSiteId":"cs01c121f980009512","height":700,"cloudinaryVersionId":1445625932,"publicId":"assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1","objectType":"ContentPhoto","width":1200,"hasFaces":true,"migrationId":"d18c1640f5c390c6a921856c971a77846eebe936","createdPrincipalId":"up016bb0b8226d860f","id":"ci01dbd3cce0012a83","primarySiteId":"cs01c121f980009512"},"primaryImageId":"ci01dbd3cce0012a83","slug":"business-economics","hasGallery":false,"associatedRichTerms":[]}</script><section class="m-sub-navigation m-component-stack mm-component-stack--is-stacked"><div class="m-sub-navigation--container"><phoenix-breadcrumbs class="m-sub-navigation--items m-breadcrumbs" id="subnav"><phoenix-notifier event-name="phoenix:breadcrumbs:toggle" event-value="subnav" events="click"><button class="m-breadcrumbs--expand-button m-icon-button mm-icon-button--small-icon is-hidden" aria-label="{{isCollapsed ? 'Expand Breadcrumbs' : 'Collapse Breadcrumbs'}}"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_angle_double_right"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_angle_double_right"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></button></phoenix-notifier><phoenix-breadcrumbs-container class="m-breadcrumbs--container"><ul class="m-breadcrumbs--items" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/BreadcrumbList"><li class="m-breadcrumbs--item" phoenix-breadcrumbs-item itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem"><a class="m-breadcrumbs--link m-sub-navigation--link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" href="https://psmag.com" itemid="https://psmag.com" itemprop="item" content="https://psmag.com" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/WebPage"><span itemprop="name">Home</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="1"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-breadcrumbs--divider" icon="ico_angle_right" aria-hidden="true"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_angle_right"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></li><li class="m-breadcrumbs--item" phoenix-breadcrumbs-item itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem"><a class="m-breadcrumbs--link m-sub-navigation--link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" href="/previous-site-sections" itemid="https://psmag.com/previous-site-sections" itemprop="item" content="https://psmag.com/previous-site-sections" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/WebPage" title="Previous Site Sections"><span itemprop="name">Previous Site Sections</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="2"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-breadcrumbs--divider" icon="ico_angle_right" aria-hidden="true"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_angle_right"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></li><li class="m-breadcrumbs--item" phoenix-breadcrumbs-item itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem"><span class="m-breadcrumbs--link is-inactive" itemprop="name">Business &amp; Economics</span><meta itemprop="position" content="3"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-breadcrumbs--divider" icon="ico_angle_right" aria-hidden="true"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_angle_right"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></li></ul></phoenix-breadcrumbs-container></phoenix-breadcrumbs></div></section><section class="m-component-stack mm-component-stack--is-stacked"><div class="m-hub-header mm-hub-header--extra-small mm-hub-header--has-background mm-hub-header--has-title-image"><div class="m-hub-header--item m-hub-header--title"><phoenix-picture class="m-background"><picture class="m-background--picture-block is-waiting-to-load" aria-hidden="true"><source type="image/webp" sizes="(min-width:2520px) 2520px, (min-width:1880px) 1880px, (min-width:1240px) 1240px, (min-width: 675px) 675px, 100vw" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.webp 960w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_1280/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.webp 1280w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_1920/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.webp 1920w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_2560/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.webp 2560w"><source sizes="(min-width:2520px) 2520px, (min-width:1880px) 1880px, (min-width:1240px) 1240px, (min-width: 675px) 675px, 100vw" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.jpg 960w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_1280/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.jpg 1280w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_1920/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.jpg 1920w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_2560/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.jpg 2560w"><img class="m-background--image" decoding="async" nopin="true" src="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_1280/assets/MTMzOTMzNDkwMjg1NTg3MDc1/business--economics-section-heading.jpg" srcset=""></picture></phoenix-picture><h1 class="m-hub-header--title-heading" role="heading"><img class="m-hub-header--title-image" src="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_1290/assets/MTMzOTMzNDg5NzQ4NzU2NDkw/business--economics-section-overlay.svg" alt="Business &amp; Economics"></h1></div><div class="m-hub-header--item m-hub-header--body"><div class="m-hub-header--body-content"></div></div></div></section><section class="m-list-hub m-component-stack mm-component-stack--is-stacked mm-component-stack--has-footer"><phoenix-hub class="m-card-group--container" data-group-size="6" data-first-group-size="6"><section class="m-card-group mm-card-group--has-heroes"><phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking class="m-card-group--content l-grid lm-grid--density-single-column lm-grid--standard-cards" config="{&quot;siteBasePath&quot;:null,&quot;size&quot;:6,&quot;widgetName&quot;:&quot;tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1&quot;}"><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/from-prison-to-public-service" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/from-prison-to-public-service','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="0"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/from-prison-to-public-service" title="From Prison to Public Service" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTMwOTA1OTc4NTc2MDgzNDIy/shutterstock_211835152jpg.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTMwOTA1OTc4NTc2MDgzNDIy/shutterstock_211835152jpg.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTMwOTA1OTc4NTc2MDgzNDIy/shutterstock_211835152jpg.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTMwOTA1OTc4NTc2MDgzNDIy/shutterstock_211835152jpg.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTMwOTA1OTc4NTc2MDgzNDIy/shutterstock_211835152jpg.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTMwOTA1OTc4NTc2MDgzNDIy/shutterstock_211835152jpg.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTMwOTA1OTc4NTc2MDgzNDIy/shutterstock_211835152jpg.jpg" srcset="" alt="shutterstock_211835152.jpg"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/from-prison-to-public-service"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">From Prison to Public Service</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Ban the Box initiatives are one step toward breaking the cycle of incarceration.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/charmaine-davis" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Charmaine Davis</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/recession-money-tax-unseen-toll-wages-millions-seized-pay-past-debts-90833" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/recession-money-tax-unseen-toll-wages-millions-seized-pay-past-debts-90833','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="1"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/recession-money-tax-unseen-toll-wages-millions-seized-pay-past-debts-90833" title="The Wages of Millions Are Being Seized to Pay Past Debts" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTI3NTgyNTEyNDgxNjA0ODgy/debt-under-water.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTI3NTgyNTEyNDgxNjA0ODgy/debt-under-water.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTI3NTgyNTEyNDgxNjA0ODgy/debt-under-water.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTI3NTgyNTEyNDgxNjA0ODgy/debt-under-water.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTI3NTgyNTEyNDgxNjA0ODgy/debt-under-water.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTI3NTgyNTEyNDgxNjA0ODgy/debt-under-water.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTI3NTgyNTEyNDgxNjA0ODgy/debt-under-water.jpg" srcset="" alt="debt-under-water"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/recession-money-tax-unseen-toll-wages-millions-seized-pay-past-debts-90833"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">The Wages of Millions Are Being Seized to Pay Past Debts</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">A new study provides the first-ever tally of how many employees lose up to a quarter of their paychecks over debts like unpaid credit card or medical bills and student loans.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/paul-kiel-chris-arnold" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Paul Kiel &amp;amp; Chris Arnold</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/across-cultures-music-therapy-promotes-sleep-54975" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/across-cultures-music-therapy-promotes-sleep-54975','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="2"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/across-cultures-music-therapy-promotes-sleep-54975" title="Across Cultures, Music Therapy Promotes Sounder Sleep" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTI3NTgxNjI3NzE4NDIwNDkw/counting-sheep.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTI3NTgxNjI3NzE4NDIwNDkw/counting-sheep.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTI3NTgxNjI3NzE4NDIwNDkw/counting-sheep.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTI3NTgxNjI3NzE4NDIwNDkw/counting-sheep.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTI3NTgxNjI3NzE4NDIwNDkw/counting-sheep.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTI3NTgxNjI3NzE4NDIwNDkw/counting-sheep.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTI3NTgxNjI3NzE4NDIwNDkw/counting-sheep.jpg" srcset="" alt="counting-sheep"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/across-cultures-music-therapy-promotes-sleep-54975"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Across Cultures, Music Therapy Promotes Sounder Sleep</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Find yourself nodding off during a five-hour Wagner opera? Here’s your excuse.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/tomjacobs" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Tom Jacobs</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/us-postal-service-saturday-delivery-postal-banking-52778" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/us-postal-service-saturday-delivery-postal-banking-52778','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="3"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/us-postal-service-saturday-delivery-postal-banking-52778" title="Signed, Sealed, Deposited" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTI3NTgxNjE0NTY0ODc0NzE4/usps.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTI3NTgxNjE0NTY0ODc0NzE4/usps.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTI3NTgxNjE0NTY0ODc0NzE4/usps.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTI3NTgxNjE0NTY0ODc0NzE4/usps.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTI3NTgxNjE0NTY0ODc0NzE4/usps.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTI3NTgxNjE0NTY0ODc0NzE4/usps.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTI3NTgxNjE0NTY0ODc0NzE4/usps.jpg" srcset="" alt="usps"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/us-postal-service-saturday-delivery-postal-banking-52778"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Bring Back Postal Banking</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">How to save the Postal Service—and protect ordinary Americans from financial predators—in one easy step: bring back postal banking!</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/david-dayen" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By David Dayen</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/threat-of-climate-change-may-decrease-support-for-war-49467" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/threat-of-climate-change-may-decrease-support-for-war-49467','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="4"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/threat-of-climate-change-may-decrease-support-for-war-49467" title="Accepting a Warming Planet Could Cool Urge To Go To War" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTI3NTgxNDc5MjczNTM1OTY2/drought.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTI3NTgxNDc5MjczNTM1OTY2/drought.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTI3NTgxNDc5MjczNTM1OTY2/drought.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTI3NTgxNDc5MjczNTM1OTY2/drought.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTI3NTgxNDc5MjczNTM1OTY2/drought.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTI3NTgxNDc5MjczNTM1OTY2/drought.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTI3NTgxNDc5MjczNTM1OTY2/drought.jpg" srcset="" alt="drought"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/threat-of-climate-change-may-decrease-support-for-war-49467"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Accepting a Warming Planet Could Cool Urge To Go To War</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">New psychological research suggests the shared threats posed by a changing climate may bring people together in a common cause.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/tomjacobs" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Tom Jacobs</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/bad-economy-more-domestic-violence-but-less-crime-42200" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/bad-economy-more-domestic-violence-but-less-crime-42200','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--text-only mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="5"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/bad-economy-more-domestic-violence-but-less-crime-42200" title="Bad Economy = More Domestic Violence ... But Less Crime?" tabindex="-1"><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/bad-economy-more-domestic-violence-but-less-crime-42200"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Bad Economy = More Domestic Violence ... But Less Crime?</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/vbeiser" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Vince Beiser</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div></phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking></section><section class="m-brand-engagement m-component-stack mm-component-stack--is-stacked mm-component-stack--has-header mm-component-stack--has-background mm-brand-engagement--premium" style="background-color:#000000;"><div class="m-brand-engagement--container"><div class="m-component-header m-component-stack--header mm-component-header--inverted" style="background-color:rgba(0, 0, 0, 0);"><div class="m-component-header--container mm-component-header--size-extra-small"><h2 class="m-component-header--image" role="heading" aria-level="2"><img src="https://psmag.com/.image/cs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good/MTUzMDcwOTAxNjc4NTgxMzY4/section_header_art_xtrasmall_subscribe.svg" alt="Subscribe to our Newsletter"></h2></div></div><div class="m-brand-engagement--container"><div class="m-brand-engagement--buttons"><div class="m-brand-engagement--form-wrapper"><phoenix-brand-engagement-form class="m-brand-engagement--form" error-message="Error!" success-message="Thanks!" action="/.api/add-email-to-mailing-list"><form><input class="m-brand-engagement--form-input" name="email" placeholder="Email Address" aria-label="Email Address" type="email"><button class="m-brand-engagement--form-submit" type="submit">Subscribe</button></form></phoenix-brand-engagement-form></div><div class="m-brand-engagement--social-buttons"><div class="m-brand-engagement--social-button m-social--facebook"><a class="m-icon-button m-brand-engagement--social-link m-button mm-button--fixed-dimensions m-social--button mm-icon-button--small-icon" aria-label="facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/PacificStand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_facebook"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_facebook"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div><div class="m-brand-engagement--social-button m-social--linkedin"><a class="m-icon-button m-brand-engagement--social-link m-button mm-button--fixed-dimensions m-social--button mm-icon-button--small-icon" aria-label="linkedin" href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/pacific-standard-magazine" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_linkedin"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_linkedin"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div><div class="m-brand-engagement--social-button m-social--instagram"><a class="m-icon-button m-brand-engagement--social-link m-button mm-button--fixed-dimensions m-social--button mm-icon-button--small-icon" aria-label="instagram" href="https://www.instagram.com/pacificstand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_instagram"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_instagram"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div><div class="m-brand-engagement--social-button m-social--twitter"><a class="m-icon-button m-brand-engagement--social-link m-button mm-button--fixed-dimensions m-social--button mm-icon-button--small-icon" aria-label="twitter" href="https://twitter.com/pacificstand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_twitter"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_twitter"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div></div></div></div></div></section><section class="m-adaptive-ad-component m-component-stack"><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-f4d291c5fa724521a0543295c9475062","visClasses":["not-size-b","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-0","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-f4d291c5fa724521a0543295c9475062","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"sizes":["970x90"],"classes":["is-970x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-3a493f5649284bd39f2299df85b65674","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-0","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-3a493f5649284bd39f2299df85b65674","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},"blockthroughTag":"5ae8a9beef-168"}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;970x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-970x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-5174334bf75c43f98c913ceaa756adf7","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-0","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-5174334bf75c43f98c913ceaa756adf7","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},"blockthroughTag":"5ae8a9beef-168"}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-60355ed344084823b33d0f0431a47033","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-c"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-0","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-60355ed344084823b33d0f0431a47033","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},"showBlockthrough":true,"blockthroughTag":"5ae8a9beef-168"}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside></section><section class="m-card-group mm-card-group--has-heroes"><phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking class="m-card-group--content l-grid lm-grid--density-single-column lm-grid--standard-cards" config="{&quot;siteBasePath&quot;:null,&quot;size&quot;:6,&quot;widgetName&quot;:&quot;tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2&quot;}"><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/the-cash-benefits-of-a-catholic-education-29729" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/the-cash-benefits-of-a-catholic-education-29729','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--text-only mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="0"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/the-cash-benefits-of-a-catholic-education-29729" title="The Cash Benefits of a Catholic Education" tabindex="-1"><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/the-cash-benefits-of-a-catholic-education-29729"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">The Cash Benefits of a Catholic Education</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Better teachers in Catholic high schools and more semesters of math and language boost student earnings later in life, a study shows.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/mburns" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Melinda Burns</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/history-and-health-cooperatives-9007" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/history-and-health-cooperatives-9007','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--text-only mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="1"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/history-and-health-cooperatives-9007" title="History and Health Cooperatives" tabindex="-1"><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/history-and-health-cooperatives-9007"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">A Look at History of Health Cooperatives in the U.S.</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Depression-era health solution may find new favor in the modern American struggle for health care change.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/joanmelcher" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Joan Melcher</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/the-smoldering-trash-revolt-7306" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/the-smoldering-trash-revolt-7306','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--text-only mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="2"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/the-smoldering-trash-revolt-7306" title="The Smoldering Trash Revolt" tabindex="-1"><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/the-smoldering-trash-revolt-7306"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Product Stewardship Bills Shift Recycling Cost To Manufacturers</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Recycling is leveling off, trash is piling up and cities are broke. In a throwaway society, who should pay for waste disposal?</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/mburns" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Melinda Burns</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/a-whiff-of-desire-testosterone-levels-sensitive-to-scent-7044" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/a-whiff-of-desire-testosterone-levels-sensitive-to-scent-7044','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--text-only mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="3"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/a-whiff-of-desire-testosterone-levels-sensitive-to-scent-7044" title="A Whiff of Desire: Testosterone Levels Sensitive to Scent" tabindex="-1"><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/a-whiff-of-desire-testosterone-levels-sensitive-to-scent-7044"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Woman's Own Scent Raises Men's Testosterone</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">The scent of an ovulating woman is linked to higher testosterone levels in men.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/tomjacobs" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Tom Jacobs</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/what-would-horatio-alger-do-3883" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/what-would-horatio-alger-do-3883','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--text-only mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="4"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/what-would-horatio-alger-do-3883" title="What Would Horatio Alger Do?" tabindex="-1"><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/what-would-horatio-alger-do-3883"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">What Would Horatio Alger Do?</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Thousands of Americans are defying eviction notices and exercising civil disobedience.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/drosenfeld" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By David Rosenfeld</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/small-p-philanthropy-the-sentimentality-of-crowds-4027" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/small-p-philanthropy-the-sentimentality-of-crowds-4027','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--text-only mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="5"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/small-p-philanthropy-the-sentimentality-of-crowds-4027" title="'Small P' Philanthropy: The Sentimentality of Crowds" tabindex="-1"><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/small-p-philanthropy-the-sentimentality-of-crowds-4027"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">'Small P' Philanthropy: The Sentimentality of Crowds</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Charities wonder if giving donors control over their donations makes for wise policy.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/lindseymccormack" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Lindsey McCormack</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div></phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking></section><section class="m-adaptive-ad-component m-component-stack"><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-d86d956ef7f6494180a551521c18780d","visClasses":["not-size-b","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-1","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-d86d956ef7f6494180a551521c18780d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"sizes":["970x90"],"classes":["is-970x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-66685d57fd1c43e7a2f723d6acc86aab","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-1","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-66685d57fd1c43e7a2f723d6acc86aab","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},"blockthroughTag":"5ae8a9c908-168"}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;970x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-970x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-08ab681ae2904c83b8a9372d791ad91e","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-1","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-08ab681ae2904c83b8a9372d791ad91e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},"blockthroughTag":"5ae8a9c908-168"}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-15a2d81e702d40059e81bcec3829e324","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-c"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-1","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-15a2d81e702d40059e81bcec3829e324","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"},"showBlockthrough":true,"blockthroughTag":"5ae8a9c908-168"}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside></section><section class="m-card-group mm-card-group--has-heroes"><phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking class="m-card-group--content l-grid lm-grid--density-single-column lm-grid--standard-cards" config="{&quot;siteBasePath&quot;:null,&quot;size&quot;:3,&quot;widgetName&quot;:&quot;tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-3&quot;}"><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/dc-center-monument-to-congress-and-pork-4088" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/dc-center-monument-to-congress-and-pork-4088','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-3',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--text-only mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="0"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/dc-center-monument-to-congress-and-pork-4088" title="D.C. Center Monument to Congress — and Pork" tabindex="-1"><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/dc-center-monument-to-congress-and-pork-4088"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">D.C. Center Monument to Congress — and Pork</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">The U.S. Capitol's new visitors' center, which opened today, came in almost nine times over its original cost estimate.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/meghan-gordon" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Meghan Gordon</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/forecasting-the-unknowable-future-of-business-4349" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/forecasting-the-unknowable-future-of-business-4349','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-3',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--text-only mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="1"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/forecasting-the-unknowable-future-of-business-4349" title="Forecasting the Unknowable Future of Business" tabindex="-1"><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/forecasting-the-unknowable-future-of-business-4349"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Forecasting the Unknowable Future of Business</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Corruption and terrorism pockmark the road ahead for international business, according to a respected global survey.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/barbara-hesselgrave" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Barbara Hesselgrave</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/business-economics/whistleblower-details-ohio-voting-red-flags-4382" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/business-economics/whistleblower-details-ohio-voting-red-flags-4382','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-3',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--text-only mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="2"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/business-economics/whistleblower-details-ohio-voting-red-flags-4382" title="Whistleblower Details Ohio Voting Red Flags" tabindex="-1"><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/previous-site-sections/business-economics" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Business &amp; Economics</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/business-economics/whistleblower-details-ohio-voting-red-flags-4382"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Whistleblower Details Ohio Voting Red Flags</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/drosenfeld" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By David Rosenfeld</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div></phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking></section></phoenix-hub></section><div class="m-detail--blockthrough-ads"><span class="bt-uid-tg" uid="5ae8a9c908-168" style="display: none !important"></span></div><footer class="m-footer mm-footer--has-publisher-logo"><div class="m-footer--container"><div class="m-footer--publisher-logo-cell"><a href="https://psmag.com" aria-label="Grist"><img src="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Ch_60%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_600/MTcyODQ5NTk0MzcwMTA3MTgz/grist-logo-60tall.png" alt="Grist" height="30"></a></div><div class="m-footer--links-cell"><ul class="m-footer--links"><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/about" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">About</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/audience-influence" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Impact</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/contact-us" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Contact</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/write-us" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Pitching</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/fellowship-program" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Careers</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/advertise" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Partnerships</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/privacy-statement" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Terms of Use</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="https://www.saymedia.com/privacy" rel="noopener" target="_blank" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Platform Privacy</a></li><li class="is-consent-applicable-only" aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="javascript:window.phxConsentManagement.displayUi()" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Privacy Settings</a></li></ul><div class="m-footer--copyright">&copy; 2023 Grist</div></div><div class="m-footer--maven-logo-cell"><a rel="noopener" target="_blank" href="https://thearenagroup.net/" aria-label="A channel by The Arena Group"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-footer--maven-logo" icon="arena_footer_logo"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#arena_footer_logo"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div></div></footer></div><div id="do-not-sell-button"></div><div class="m-fixedbottom-ad--container"><phoenix-ad class="m-fixedbottom-ad not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d" auto-reload config='{"adReloaderDelay":30,"maxAdReloads":25,"moduleClass":"m-fixedbottom-ad","slotId":"ad-fixed_bottom-311b969ac85943b5b486551c75530722","visClasses":["not-size-b","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[320,50],[320,60],[300,50]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomA"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-311b969ac85943b5b486551c75530722","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;300x50&quot;,&quot;301x50&quot;,&quot;320x50&quot;,&quot;321x50&quot;,&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-contained&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-close-button&quot;]}]" fixed-visible skip-dynamic-call container-height="50" container-width="300"><div class="m-fixedbottom-ad--slot is-placeholder not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d"><div id="ad-fixed_bottom-311b969ac85943b5b486551c75530722"></div><div class="m-advertisement--close-button is-hidden"><div class="m-advertisement--close-button-label">CLOSE</div></div></div></phoenix-ad><phoenix-ad class="m-fixedbottom-ad not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d" auto-reload close-button config='{"adReloaderDelay":30,"maxAdReloads":25,"moduleClass":"m-fixedbottom-ad","slotId":"ad-fixed_bottom-ad8543a813384bbba469db41128b3240","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[768,66]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomB"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-ad8543a813384bbba469db41128b3240","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;300x50&quot;,&quot;301x50&quot;,&quot;320x50&quot;,&quot;321x50&quot;,&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-contained&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-close-button&quot;]}]" fixed-visible skip-dynamic-call container-height="90" container-width="728"><div class="m-fixedbottom-ad--slot is-placeholder not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d"><div id="ad-fixed_bottom-ad8543a813384bbba469db41128b3240"></div><div class="m-advertisement--close-button is-hidden"><div class="m-advertisement--close-button-label">CLOSE</div></div></div></phoenix-ad><phoenix-ad class="m-fixedbottom-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d" auto-reload close-button config='{"adReloaderDelay":30,"maxAdReloads":25,"moduleClass":"m-fixedbottom-ad","slotId":"ad-fixed_bottom-1b89a1efb71d4840b17a943b9632c891","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-d"],"slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[900,65],[970,90]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomC"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-1b89a1efb71d4840b17a943b9632c891","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;300x50&quot;,&quot;301x50&quot;,&quot;320x50&quot;,&quot;321x50&quot;,&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-contained&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-close-button&quot;]}]" fixed-visible skip-dynamic-call container-height="90" container-width="728"><div class="m-fixedbottom-ad--slot is-placeholder not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d"><div id="ad-fixed_bottom-1b89a1efb71d4840b17a943b9632c891"></div><div class="m-advertisement--close-button is-hidden"><div class="m-advertisement--close-button-label">CLOSE</div></div></div></phoenix-ad><phoenix-ad class="m-fixedbottom-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c" auto-reload close-button config='{"adReloaderDelay":30,"maxAdReloads":25,"moduleClass":"m-fixedbottom-ad","slotId":"ad-fixed_bottom-d7c63167b4fe42d081ee5f48477c8e70","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-c"],"slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[900,65],[970,90]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomD"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-d7c63167b4fe42d081ee5f48477c8e70","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/previous-site-sections/business-economics"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;300x50&quot;,&quot;301x50&quot;,&quot;320x50&quot;,&quot;321x50&quot;,&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-contained&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-close-button&quot;]}]" fixed-visible skip-dynamic-call container-height="90" container-width="728"><div class="m-fixedbottom-ad--slot is-placeholder not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c"><div id="ad-fixed_bottom-d7c63167b4fe42d081ee5f48477c8e70"></div><div class="m-advertisement--close-button is-hidden"><div class="m-advertisement--close-button-label">CLOSE</div></div></div></phoenix-ad></div></div></div><script id="phx-webcomponent-page" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/page.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-accountMenu" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/accountMenu.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-knownUser" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/knownUser.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-dropDown" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/dropDown.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-ad" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/ad.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-picture" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/picture.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-notifier" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/notifier.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-import" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/import.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-card" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/card.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-superLink" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/superLink.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-ellipsis" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/ellipsis.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-style" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/style.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-overlay" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/overlay.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-intersectionNotifier" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/intersectionNotifier.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-balloonHeader" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/balloonHeader.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/tabs.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/sodoRunner.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/timeago.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/simpleForm.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/brandEngagementForm.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/accordion.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/breadcrumbs.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/hub.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/nonPersonalizedRecommendationsTracking.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/footerLoader.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/stickyNav.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/iconFallback.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script src="https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/tempest-promotions/optinmonster.js" block-on-gdpr-applicable delay-load></phoenix-script><phoenix-script src="https://ericzassenhaus.com/js/hide_premium.js" block-on-gdpr-applicable delay-load></phoenix-script><script>"use strict";function _toConsumableArray(arr){return _arrayWithoutHoles(arr)||_iterableToArray(arr)||_unsupportedIterableToArray(arr)||_nonIterableSpread()}function _nonIterableSpread(){throw new TypeError("Invalid attempt to spread non-iterable instance.\nIn order to be iterable, non-array objects must have a [Symbol.iterator]() method.")}function _unsupportedIterableToArray(o,minLen){if(!o)return;if(typeof o==="string")return _arrayLikeToArray(o,minLen);var n=Object.prototype.toString.call(o).slice(8,-1);if(n==="Object"&&o.constructor)n=o.constructor.name;if(n==="Map"||n==="Set")return Array.from(o);if(n==="Arguments"||/^(?:Ui|I)nt(?:8|16|32)(?:Clamped)?Array$/.test(n))return _arrayLikeToArray(o,minLen)}function _iterableToArray(iter){if(typeof Symbol!=="undefined"&&iter[Symbol.iterator]!=null||iter["@@iterator"]!=null)return Array.from(iter)}function _arrayWithoutHoles(arr){if(Array.isArray(arr))return _arrayLikeToArray(arr)}function _arrayLikeToArray(arr,len){if(len==null||len>arr.length)len=arr.length;for(var i=0,arr2=new Array(len);i<len;i++){arr2[i]=arr[i]}return arr2}phxConfigQueue.push(function(){var _document$querySelect;var newClasses=[this.device.get()];var info=this.browser.get();if(info.found){newClasses=newClasses.concat([info.type,info.type+info.version]);if(info.iOS){newClasses=newClasses.concat(["ios","ios"+info.iOS])}if(info.samsung){newClasses=newClasses.concat("samsung")}}newClasses=newClasses.map(function(s){return s.toLowerCase()});(_document$querySelect=document.querySelector("html").classList).add.apply(_document$querySelect,_toConsumableArray(newClasses))});</script><phoenix-script delay-load src="/.bootscripts/hubRebalancer.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><script type="text/template" id="videoplayer-tag">(function(src){"use strict";var e=document.createElement("script");e.src=src;e.onload=function(){if(window.BT){BT.clearThrough()}};document.body.appendChild(e);})('https://saymedia-com.videoplayerhub.com/videoloader.js')</script><phoenix-script block-premium block-on-ccpa-reject block-on-gdpr-vendor-consent="blockthrough" block-on-gdpr-purpose-consent="advertising" delay-load script-id="videoplayer-tag"></phoenix-script><script>'use strict';
window._sf_startpt = (new Date()).getTime();
window._sf_async_config = {"uid":57536,"disableFeaturedMedia":false,"domain":"psmag.com","useCanonical":true,"sections":"N/A","authors":"N/A","flickerControl":false};
</script><script type="text/template" id="chartbeat-init-57536">"use strict";window._sf_endpt=new Date().getTime();</script><phoenix-script script-id="chartbeat-init-57536" block-on-gdpr-vendor-consent="chartbeat" block-on-gdpr-purpose-consent="storage,measurement/advertising,measurement/content,measurement/development" block-premium delay-load></phoenix-script><phoenix-script src="https://static.chartbeat.com/js/chartbeat_video.js" block-on-gdpr-vendor-consent="chartbeat" block-on-gdpr- purpose-consent="storage,measurement/advertising,measurement/content,measurement/development" block-on-ccpa-reject block-premium delay-load></phoenix-script><phoenix-script src="https://static.chartbeat.com/js/chartbeat_mab.js" block-on-gdpr-vendor-consent="chartbeat" block-on-gdpr-purpose-consent="storage,measurement/advertising,measurement/content,measurement/development" block-on-ccpa-reject block-premium delay-load></phoenix-script><script type="application/json" id="liftigniter-metadata">{"noShow":"true"}</script><script>"use strict";window.liftIgniterPromiseResolved;window.liftIgniterPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){window.liftIgniterPromiseResolved=resolve});window.scriptErrorsPromiseResolved();window.liftIgniterLoadPromiseResolved;window.liftIgniterLoadPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){window.liftIgniterLoadPromiseResolved=resolve;window.liftIgniterLoadPromiseRejected=reject});</script><script type="text/template" id="liftigniter-init">(function(jsKey, vendorId, purposes, cookieName) {"use strict";if(typeof $igniter_var==="undefined"){!function n(t,c,r,o,a,i,s,e,f,l,u){l=null!=t[r]&&"function"==typeof t[r].now?t[r].now():null,t.$igniter_var=i,t[i]=t[i]||function(){(t[i].q=t[i].q||[]).push(arguments)},e=c.getElementsByTagName(o)[0],(f=c.createElement(o)).async=1,"https://cdn"==a?(t[i].s=l,f.onerror=function(e){t[i].e=e,n(t,c,r,o,a+"-fallback",i,s)}):t[i].r=l,(u=!t.Promise||!t.MutationObserver||!Object.assign)||(t[i].v="nbc"+(0<=a.indexOf("-fallback")?"f":"")),f.src=a+".petametrics.com/"+s+(u?"":"-nbc")+".js?ts="+(+new Date/216e5|0),e.parentNode.insertBefore(f,e)}(window,document,"performance","script","https://cdn","$p",jsKey);Promise.all([window.GdprStatus.getMavenUidSafe(),window.GdprStatus.isApplicableSafe(),window.GdprStatus.isDemonetizedSafe()]).then(function(values){var mavenUid=values[0],inEEA=values[1],isDemonetized=values[2];var adblocker=null;var POLL_INTERVAL=3*1000;var START_TIME=window.performance.now();var adBlockTick=function adBlockTick(){if(typeof window.adblockDetector==="undefined"){adblocker=true;if(!config.globalCtx.adblocker){$p("updateConfig",{globalCtx:{adblocker:adblocker}})}if(window.performance.now()<START_TIME+10*1000){intervalId=setTimeout(adBlockTick,POLL_INTERVAL)}}else{try{window.adblockDetector.init({found:function found(){adblocker=true;if(!config.globalCtx.adblocker){$p("updateConfig",{globalCtx:{adblocker:adblocker}})}stopPoll()},notFound:function notFound(){adblocker=false;$p("updateConfig",{globalCtx:{adblocker:adblocker}});stopPoll()},debug:false})}catch(e){console.error("adblockDetector init failed",e.message);intervalId=setTimeout(adBlockTick,POLL_INTERVAL)}}};var intervalId=setTimeout(adBlockTick,0);var stopPoll=function stopPoll(){return clearTimeout(intervalId)};var config={globalCtx:{isDemonetized:isDemonetized,adblocker:adblocker}};function initAndSendPageview(userId){$p("init",jsKey,{config:config});if(userId){$p("setUserId",userId,"replaceIfEmpty")}$p("send","pageview");window.liftIgniterPromiseResolved();$p("onload",function(){return window.liftIgniterLoadPromiseResolved()})}function fetchAndSend(consented){var rgis=window.GdprStatus.getCookie("RGIS");var c3id=rgis&&typeof rgis==="string"&&rgis.length>=1&&rgis[0]==="\""&&rgis.indexOf("|")!==-1?rgis.slice(1,rgis.indexOf("|")):undefined;var igCookie=consented&&window.GdprStatus.getCookie(cookieName);var uid=c3id||igCookie;if(uid&&igCookie!=="donottrack"&&uid!==mavenUid&&(c3id||!/^\d+$/.test(mavenUid))){window.GdprStatus.fetchMavenContext(uid,consented);window.GdprStatus.getMavenUidSafe().then(function(userId){return initAndSendPageview(userId)})}else{initAndSendPageview(mavenUid)}}if(inEEA){window.GdprStatus.waitForConsentValue().then(function(){window.GdprStatus.isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes(vendorId,purposes).then(function(isConsentGiven){fetchAndSend(isConsentGiven)})})}else{fetchAndSend(true)}})}})('999gba4qphtjrmpe', 'maven', ["storage","content","measurement"], '_ig');</script><phoenix-script script-id="liftigniter-init" block-on-ccpa-reject block-premium></phoenix-script><!-- Template for the recommended content widget--><script id="li-recommendation-template" type="application/mustache">{{#items}}<div class="m-liftigniter--recommended-item"><a class="m-liftigniter--link" href="{{url}}">{{#thumbnail}}<div class="m-liftigniter--thumbnail-container"><img class="m-liftigniter--thumbnail" src="{{thumbnail}}" width="80" height="80"></div>{{/thumbnail}}<div class="m-liftigniter--metadata"><div class="m-liftigniter--related-story">RELATED STORY</div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis"><div class="m-liftigniter--title m-ellipsis--text">{{title}}</div></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-liftigniter--right-arrow" icon="ico_angle_right" aria-hidden="true"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_angle_right"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></div><button class="m-liftigniter--button" type="submit">READ</button></a></div>{{/items}}</script><script type="text/template" id="quantcast-init">window._qevents = window._qevents || [];
(function () {"use strict";var element=document.createElement("script");element.src="https://secure.quantserve.com/quant.js";document.head.appendChild(element);})();
window._qevents.push([{"qacct":"p-d6cmgEH1kmz7P"}])</script><phoenix-script block-premium block-on-gdpr-vendor-consent="quantcast" block-on-gdpr-purpose-consent="all" block-on-ccpa-reject delay-load script-id="quantcast-init"></phoenix-script><script type="text/template" id="carbon-analytics">(function(scriptUrl, tagId, userSyncUrl) {"use strict";var _window$localStorage,_window$localStorage$;window.CustomerConnectAnalytics="cca";window.cca=window.cca||function(){(window.cca.q=window.cca.q||[]).push(arguments)};var script=document.createElement("script");script.src=scriptUrl+"?id="+window.location.hostname+"&parentId="+tagId;document.head.appendChild(script);var sync=function sync(params){var userSync=userSyncUrl+"?puid="+params.uid+(params.gdprConsent?"&gdprcs="+encodeURIComponent(params.gdprConsent):"")+(params.uspConsent?"&ccpacs="+encodeURIComponent(params.uspConsent):"");var img=document.createElement("img");img.height="1";img.width="1";img.src=userSync;img.alt="";document.body.appendChild(img)};Promise.all([window.GdprStatus.getMavenUidSafe(),window.phxConsentManagement.getConsentString(),window.criticalElementsPromise]).then(function(values){var consentType=window.phxConsentManagement.consentType;sync({uid:values[0],gdprConsent:consentType==="GDPR"&&values[1],uspConsent:consentType==="CCPA"&&values[1]})});var emailHashData=(_window$localStorage=window.localStorage)===null||_window$localStorage===void 0?void 0:(_window$localStorage$=_window$localStorage.getItem)===null||_window$localStorage$===void 0?void 0:_window$localStorage$.call(_window$localStorage,"emailHashes");if(emailHashData){var data;try{data=JSON.parse(emailHashData)}catch(e){1}if(data&&data.length){window.carbonReady=window.carbonReady||[];window.carbonReady.push(function(){["sha256","md5"].forEach(function(alg){var emailHash=data.find(function(el){return el.alg===alg});if(emailHash){ccao.api.storeHashedEmail(emailHash.alg,emailHash.digest)}})})}}})('https://carbon-cdn.ccgateway.net/script', 'b4b3d228', 'https://eus-api.ccgateway.net/v1/s/mavenid');</script><phoenix-script script-id="carbon-analytics" block-on-gdpr-vendor-consent="clicksco" block-on-gdpr-purpose-consent="measurement" block-on-ccpa-reject block-premium delay-load></phoenix-script><script>var mainResourceExecEndTime = window.performance.now() | 0;</script></phoenix-page><script>(function(appScripts) {"use strict";function dropExtScript(src){return new Promise(function(resolve,reject){var e=document.createElement("script");e.async=false;e.src=src;e.addEventListener("load",function(){resolve()},false);e.addEventListener("error",function(){console.error("failed to load "+src);resolve()},false);document.body.appendChild(e)})}function dropExtScripts(scripts){var promises=[];scripts.forEach(function(s){promises.push(dropExtScript(s))});return Promise.all(promises)}function loadAndStartApp(){dropExtScripts(appScripts).then(function(){var e=document.createElement("script");e.text="require(['main']);";document.body.appendChild(e)})}if(appScripts.length>0){window.getTimedOutPageLoadPromise(30000).then(loadAndStartApp)}})([]);</script></body></html>