<!DOCTYPE html><html id="phx-wrapper" lang="en"><head><title>Education - Pacific Standard</title><link rel="canonical" href="https://psmag.com/education"><link rel="publisher" href="https://plus.google.com/+Psmagplus"><meta name="keywords" content="Education"><meta name="pagetype" content="rich_term"><meta name="item-id" content="ci020b8c5f100126b7"><meta name="published" content="2017-05-24T22:30:09Z"><meta name="modified" content="2018-09-05T19:32:05Z"><meta name="dcterms.rightsHolder" content="Grist"><meta name="dcterms.dateCopyrighted" content="2023"><meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"><meta name="twitter:site" content="@PacificStand"><meta name="twitter:url" content="https://psmag.com/education"><meta name="twitter:domain" content="psmag.com"><meta property="og:type" content="website"><meta property="og:url" content="https://psmag.com/education"><meta property="og:title" content="Education"><meta property="og:site_name" content="Pacific Standard"><meta property="fb:pages" content="PacificStand"><meta name="pinterest-rich-pin" content="true"><meta name="apple-mobile-web-app-title" content="Pacific Standard"><meta name="parsely-title" content="Education - Pacific Standard"><meta name="parsely-link" content="https://psmag.com/education"><meta name="parsely-type" content="index"><meta name="parsely-post-id" content="ci020b8c5f100126b7"><meta name="parsely-pub-date" content="2017-05-24T22:30:09Z"><meta name="parsely-tags" content="Education"><meta name="sailthru.title" content="Education"><meta name="sailthru.date" content="2017-05-24T22:30:09Z"><meta name="sailthru.tags" content="Education"><meta name="phx:content-item-id" content="ci020b8c5f100126b7"><meta name="phx:content-object-type" content="ContentRichTerm"><meta name="phx:exclusive-content-type" content="free"><meta property="phx:site-keyword" content="psmag"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1"><link rel="shortcut icon" href="https://psmag.com/.image/MTQ2ODUzNDM4MzAxNDE0OTQ4/favicon-32x32.png"><style type="text/css">:root {
  --deprecated_color_tile_background: #ffffff;--color_highlighted_label: #ffffff;--color_label: #8c8c8c;--color_header_background: #fafafa;--color_sticky_nav_text_hover: #8c8c8c;--font_body_secondary_family: &quot;proxima-nova&quot;, sans-serif;--highlighted_text_line_height: 1.25;--color_ui_hover_overlay: #DF0A79;--color_footer_nav_text: #333333;--color_stamp_text: #ffffff;--color_stamp_background: #000000;--color_header_subnav_background: #ffffff;--blockquote_text_color: #8c8c8c;--color_text_primary_inverted: #ffffff;--color_text_primary: #333333;--font_ui_weight: 600;--font_ui_transform: uppercase;--font_ui_multiplier: 1;--font_ui_hmultiplier: 1;--button_border_style: 3px;--color_anchor_hover_text: #000000;--palette_primary: #000000;--deprecated_ui_primary: #8c8c8c;--color_button_border: #ffffff;--pullquote_font_size: L;--pullquote_text_link_color: #000000;--palette_accent: #000000;--deprecated_ui_primary_light: rgba(#8c8c8c, .5);--color_footer_nav_text_hover: #000000;--image_hero_overlay: none;--palette_tone_black: #000000;--font_headline_primary_family: &quot;proxima-nova&quot;, sans-serif;--font_body_primary_weight: 400;--font_body_primary_multiplier: .9;--font_body_primary_hmultiplier: 1;--color_header_nav_background: #000000;--pullquote_text_transform: none;--color_featured_header_nav_text_hover: #8c8c8c;--font_headline_primary_weight: 900;--font_headline_primary_transform: uppercase;--font_headline_primary_multiplier: .8;--font_headline_primary_hmultiplier: .9;--deprecated_color_inverted: #ffffff;--color_divider: #fafafa;--pullquote_background_color: rgba(0, 0, 0, 0);--color_header_subnav_text_hover: #fafafa;--font_meta_family: &quot;merriweather&quot;, serif;--blockquote_border_size: 2;--color_button_background: #ffffff;--color_headline_inverted: #ffffff;--pullquote_text_hover_color: $color_hover_body;--deprecated_color_secondary: #000000;--header_background_image_type: none;--site_alignment: left;--palette_tone_dark: #333333;--color_text_secondary_inverted: #ffffff;--color_header_subnav_border: #333333;--color_image_hero_text: #ffffff;--color_sticky_nav_text: #ffffff;--deprecated_color_body_text: #333333;--color_image_tile_text: #ffffff;--color_featured_header_nav_text: #ffffff;--font_meta_weight: 700;--font_meta_transform: uppercase;--font_meta_multiplier: .9;--font_meta_hmultiplier: 1;--header_background_position: top center;--color_headline: #000000;--color_button_text: #000000;--color_navbar_background: #FFFFFF;--image_tile_overlay: linearDark;--sticky_nav_background_opacity: 100;--color_button_background_inverted: #8c8c8c;--color_button_border_inverted: #000000;--color_header_nav_text_hover: #8c8c8c;--color_header_text: #8c8c8c;--background_color_hub: #ffffff;--font_body_secondary_weight: 400;--font_body_secondary_multiplier: 1.1;--font_body_secondary_hmultiplier: .9;--color_label_inverted: #ffffff;--color_sticky_nav_background: #000000;--blockquote_text_link_color: #000000;--header_background_size: auto auto;--color_button_text_inverted: #ffffff;--deprecated_color_accent: #ffffff;--background_color_tile: #ffffff;--featured_header_background_opacity: 100;--deprecated_color_ui_secondary: #fafafa;--deprecated_color_body_background: #ffffff;--blockquote_font_size: XS;--pullquote_text_color: #000000;--color_header_subnav_text: #333333;--color_divider_inverted: #ffffff;--deprecated_color_primary: #000000;--color_button_hover: opacity;--header_background_repeat: repeat;--font_body_primary_family: &quot;merriweather&quot;, serif;--color_anchor_text: #000000;--blockquote_background_color: rgba(0, 0, 0, 0);--color_highlight: #000000;--blockquote_text_hover_color: $color_hover_body;--table_of_contents_title: Related Stories;--color_header_nav_text: #ffffff;--font_headline_secondary_family: &quot;proxima-nova&quot;, sans-serif;--blockquote_text_transform: none;--color_text_secondary: #333333;--pullquote_font_family: body-secondary;--color_featured_header_background: #fafafa;--color_footer_text: #333333;--blockquote_font_family: headline-secondary;--font_headline_secondary_weight: 900;--font_headline_secondary_transform: uppercase;--font_headline_secondary_multiplier: 1;--font_headline_secondary_hmultiplier: 1;--table_of_contents_background_color: #fafafa;--blockquote_border_color: #8c8c8c;--font_ui_family: &quot;proxima-nova&quot;, sans-serif;--palette_tone_light: #fafafa;--palette_tone_mid: #8c8c8c;--palette_tone_white: #ffffff;--debug_fonts_v2: false;--site_component_spacing: 20px;--featured_media_background: #000000;--horizontal_rule_variant_one_color: #8c8c8c;--horizontal_rule_variant_one_height: 2;--horizontal_rule_variant_one_style: solid;--horizontal_rule_variant_one_width: 100;--horizontal_rule_variant_two_color: #8c8c8c;--horizontal_rule_variant_two_height: 6;--horizontal_rule_variant_two_style: double;--horizontal_rule_variant_two_width: 100;--horizontal_rule_variant_three_color: #8c8c8c;--horizontal_rule_variant_three_height: 2;--horizontal_rule_variant_three_style: dotted;--horizontal_rule_variant_three_width: 100;--horizontal_rule_variant_four_color: #8c8c8c;--horizontal_rule_variant_four_height: 2;--horizontal_rule_variant_four_style: dashed;--horizontal_rule_variant_four_width: 100;--drop_caps_variant1_color: #000000;--drop_caps_variant1_font_family: body-primary;--drop_caps_variant1_size: M;--drop_caps_variant2_color: #000000;--drop_caps_variant2_font_family: body-primary;--drop_caps_variant2_size: M;--component_with_background_padding: 20px;--font_headline_detail_weight: 900;--font_headline_detail_transform: uppercase;--font_headline_detail_multiplier: .8;--font_headline_detail_hmultiplier: .9;--font_headline_detail_family: &quot;proxima-nova&quot;, sans-serif;--color_off_canvas_background: rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.8);--color_off_canvas_link: #ffffff;--color_off_canvas_link_hover: #ffffff;--color_off_canvas_link_hover_background: rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.8);--in_content_ad_border_color: #ffffff;--in_content_ad_min_height: 250;--off_canvas_child_link_font_size: M;--section_header_title_font_size: S;--section_header_title_color: #000000;--section_header_title_text_decoration: none;--section_header_title_text_transform: none;--section_header_title_letter_spacing: normal;--color_header_subnav_text_hover_decoration: none
}</style><script>window.phxTheme = {"palette":{"primary":{"main":"#000000","contrastText":"#ffffff"},"secondary":{"main":"#000000","contrastText":"#ffffff"},"text":{"primary":"#333333","secondary":"#333333"}},"typography":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":16.2,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.65,"textTransform":"none","h1":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":38.400000000000006,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"h2":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":48,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"h3":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":36,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"h4":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":24,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.2,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"h5":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":16,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"h6":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":13,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"body1":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":16.2,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.65,"textTransform":"none"},"body2":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":17.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"none"},"headlinePrimary":{"XL":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":57.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"L":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":38.400000000000006,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"M":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":28.8,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":19.200000000000003,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":12.8,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XXS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":10.4,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XXXS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":8,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"}},"headlineSecondary":{"L":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":48,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"M":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":36,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":24,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.2,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":16,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XXS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":13,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"uppercase"}},"headlineDetail":{"XL":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":44.800000000000004,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"L":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":38.400000000000006,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"M":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":28.8,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":19.200000000000003,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.2,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":16,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XXS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":14.4,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XXXS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":12.8,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"900","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.2,"textTransform":"uppercase"}},"bodyPrimary":{"L":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":18.900000000000002,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.5,"textTransform":"none"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":16.2,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.65,"textTransform":"none"},"XS":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":12.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.5,"textTransform":"none"}},"bodySecondary":{"L":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":39.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.1,"textTransform":"none"},"M":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":22,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.25,"textTransform":"none"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":17.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.3,"textTransform":"none"},"XS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":14.3,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"400","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.4,"textTransform":"none"}},"ui":{"XL":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":20,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"600","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"L":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":16,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"600","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.4,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"M":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":14,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"600","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.5,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":12,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"600","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.4,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"XS":{"fontFamily":"\"proxima-nova\", sans-serif","fontSize":10,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"600","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.4,"textTransform":"uppercase"}},"meta":{"XL":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":21.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"700","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.2,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"L":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":14.4,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"700","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.4,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"M":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":12.6,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"700","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.5,"textTransform":"uppercase"},"S":{"fontFamily":"\"merriweather\", serif","fontSize":10.8,"fontStyle":"normal","fontWeight":"700","letterSpacing":"inherit","lineHeight":1.6,"textTransform":"uppercase"}}}}
</script><style type="text/css">[ng\:cloak], [ng-cloak], [data-ng-cloak], [x-ng-cloak], .ng-cloak, .x-ng-cloak {display: none !important;}</style><link rel="preload" href="https://c.amazon-adsystem.com/aax2/apstag.js" as="script"><link rel="preload" href="https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/tag/js/gpt.js" as="script"><link rel="preload" href="https://www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js" as="script"><link rel="preload" href="https://use.typekit.net/zam7fot.css" as="style"><link rel="preload" href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=IBM+Plex+Mono:wght@400;500&family=IBM+Plex+Sans:wght@400;500&display=swap" as="style"><link rel="preconnect" href="/.image/cs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good/MTQ2MTgzMzA3OTc1OTkyODY0/navbar.png"><link rel="preconnect" href="/.image/cs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.png"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://saymedia-com.videoplayerhub.com/videoloader.js"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://static.chartbeat.com/"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://carbon-cdn.ccgateway.net/script"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://cdn.petametrics.com/"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://secure.quantserve.com/"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://a9695278-4085-40b3-9f02-8d4c38a6ff01.edge.permutive.app/c97f7cbe-37c1-46b7-bef0-5c831be22e3e-web.js"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://ccpa.sp-prod.net"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://wrapper-api.sp-prod.net"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://sb.scorecardresearch.com/"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://fastlane.rubiconproject.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://hbopenbid.pubmatic.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://tlx.3lift.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://ib.adnxs.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://as-sec.casalemedia.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://c2shb.pubgw.yahoo.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://grid.bidswitch.net"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://ssc.33across.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://ap.lijit.com"><link rel="dns-prefetch" href="https://a.teads.tv">
<script>var mainResourceExecStartTime = window.performance.now() | 0;</script><script>var appCacheBuster = "v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483";</script><script>var genTs = 1692820378725;</script><script>window.Promise||document.write('<script src="/.bootscripts/polyfills/promise.min.js?' + appCacheBuster + '"></s'+'cript>');</script><script>window.fetch||document.write('<script src="/.bootscripts/polyfills/fetch.min.js?' + appCacheBuster + '"></s'+'cript>');</script><script>Object.assign||document.write('<script src="/.bootscripts/polyfills/assign.min.js?' + appCacheBuster + '"></s'+'cript>');</script><script>(typeof window.Element.prototype.closest === 'function')||document.write('<script src="/.bootscripts/polyfills/element-closest.min.js?' + appCacheBuster + '"></s'+'cript>');</script><script>(window.customElements&&window.customElements.define&&window.customElements.get&&window.customElements.whenDefined)||document.write('<script src="/.bootscripts/polyfills/webcomponents.min.js?' + appCacheBuster + '"></s'+'cript>');</script><script>(String.prototype.endsWith||String.prototype.startsWith)||document.write('<script src="/.bootscripts/polyfills/string.min.js?' + appCacheBuster + '"></s'+'cript>');</script><script>"use strict";if(typeof IntersectionObserver==="undefined"||"IntersectionObserver"in window&&"IntersectionObserverEntry"in window&&!("isIntersecting"in window.IntersectionObserverEntry.prototype)){document.write("<script src=\"/.bootscripts/polyfills/intersectionobserver.min.js?"+appCacheBuster+"\"></s"+"cript>")}</script><script>"use strict";(function(){if(typeof window.CustomEvent==="function")return false;function CustomEvent(event,params){params=params||{bubbles:false,cancelable:false,detail:undefined};var evt=document.createEvent("CustomEvent");evt.initCustomEvent(event,params.bubbles,params.cancelable,params.detail);return evt}CustomEvent.prototype=window.Event.prototype;window.CustomEvent=CustomEvent})();</script><script>"use strict";window.scriptErrorsPromiseResolved;window.scriptErrorsPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){window.scriptErrorsPromiseResolved=resolve});function petametricsErrorHandlerWrapper(msg,url,lineNo,columnNo,error){window.scriptErrorsPromise.then(function(){window.liftIgniterPromise.then(function(){window.$p("customErrorHandler",msg,url,lineNo,columnNo,error)})})}window.addEventListener("error",function(errorEvent){var _errorEvent$error;petametricsErrorHandlerWrapper((errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:errorEvent.message)||(errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:(_errorEvent$error=errorEvent.error)===null||_errorEvent$error===void 0?void 0:_errorEvent$error.message),errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:errorEvent.filename,errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:errorEvent.lineno,errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:errorEvent.colno,errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:errorEvent.error)});window.addEventListener("unhandledrejection",function(errorEvent){var _errorEvent$reason,_errorEvent$reason2;var msg=errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:(_errorEvent$reason=errorEvent.reason)===null||_errorEvent$reason===void 0?void 0:_errorEvent$reason.message;var stack=errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:(_errorEvent$reason2=errorEvent.reason)===null||_errorEvent$reason2===void 0?void 0:_errorEvent$reason2.stack;var filename,lineno,colno;if(typeof stack==="string"){var _stack$split,_stack$split$,_stack$split$$split;msg=stack.split("\n")[0];var fileInfo=(_stack$split=stack.split("\n"))===null||_stack$split===void 0?void 0:(_stack$split$=_stack$split[1])===null||_stack$split$===void 0?void 0:(_stack$split$$split=_stack$split$.split(" at "))===null||_stack$split$$split===void 0?void 0:_stack$split$$split[1];if(typeof fileInfo==="string"&&fileInfo.split(":").length>=4){var pieces=fileInfo.split(":");filename=pieces.slice(0,pieces.length-2).join(":");lineno=pieces[pieces.length-2];colno=pieces[pieces.length-1]}}petametricsErrorHandlerWrapper("unhandledrejection: "+msg,filename,lineno,colno,errorEvent===null||errorEvent===void 0?void 0:errorEvent.reason)});</script><script>"use strict";window.phxTrackedFeatures={};function addPhxTrackedNumericFeature(name,test_percent){phxTrackedFeatures[name]=Math.random()*100<test_percent}</script><script>"use strict";window.phxBooleans={};function addPhxBoolean(name,value){phxBooleans[name]=value}</script><script>addPhxBoolean('alt-demo-data', false);</script><script>addPhxBoolean('use-hummingbird', true);</script><script>"use strict";window.phxCommerce={};</script><script>window.phxCommerce['trackonomics'] = {};
for (const [key, value] of Object.entries({"siteId":"cs01c121f980009512","partner":"","section":"politics","pageType":"Rich Term Page","tempestContentId":"ci020b8c5f100126b7"})) {
    if (value) {
        window.phxCommerce['trackonomics'][key] = value;
    }
}</script><script>"use strict";function _createForOfIteratorHelper(o,allowArrayLike){var it=typeof Symbol!=="undefined"&&o[Symbol.iterator]||o["@@iterator"];if(!it){if(Array.isArray(o)||(it=_unsupportedIterableToArray(o))||allowArrayLike&&o&&typeof o.length==="number"){if(it)o=it;var i=0;var F=function F(){};return{s:F,n:function n(){if(i>=o.length)return{done:true};return{done:false,value:o[i++]}},e:function e(_e){throw _e},f:F}}throw new TypeError("Invalid attempt to iterate non-iterable instance.\nIn order to be iterable, non-array objects must have a [Symbol.iterator]() method.")}var normalCompletion=true,didErr=false,err;return{s:function s(){it=it.call(o)},n:function n(){var step=it.next();normalCompletion=step.done;return step},e:function e(_e2){didErr=true;err=_e2},f:function f(){try{if(!normalCompletion&&it["return"]!=null)it["return"]()}finally{if(didErr)throw err}}}}function _unsupportedIterableToArray(o,minLen){if(!o)return;if(typeof o==="string")return _arrayLikeToArray(o,minLen);var n=Object.prototype.toString.call(o).slice(8,-1);if(n==="Object"&&o.constructor)n=o.constructor.name;if(n==="Map"||n==="Set")return Array.from(o);if(n==="Arguments"||/^(?:Ui|I)nt(?:8|16|32)(?:Clamped)?Array$/.test(n))return _arrayLikeToArray(o,minLen)}function _arrayLikeToArray(arr,len){if(len==null||len>arr.length)len=arr.length;for(var i=0,arr2=new Array(len);i<len;i++){arr2[i]=arr[i]}return arr2}(function(){if(window.document.location.hash&&window.document.location.hash.indexOf("phxLighthouseDebug")!==-1&&PerformanceObserver&&PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes){var debugLog=function debugLog(timestamp,msg){console.log("[phxLighthouseDebug] "+(timestamp|0)+"ms "+msg)};var getParentNodeRecursive=function getParentNodeRecursive(nextNode,original,num){if(nextNode.nodeName==="HTML"){return{node:original,num:0}}if(nextNode.className||nextNode.id){return{node:nextNode,num:num}}return getParentNodeRecursive(nextNode.parentNode,original,num+1)};var nodeString=function nodeString(node){var str="unknown";var num=0;if(node){var newNode=getParentNodeRecursive(node,node,num);num=newNode.num;node=newNode.node;if(node.localName){str=node.localName}else if(node.nodeName){str=node.nodeName}if(node&&node.className){str+="."+node.className}if(node&&node.id){str+="#"+node.id}if(num>0){str="childof["+num+"]:"+str}}return str};if(PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes.includes("layout-shift")){var transformString=function transformString(previousRect,currentRect){var str="";if(!previousRect||!currentRect){if(!previousRect)str+="np";if(!currentRect)str+="nc";return str}if(!previousRect.width||!previousRect.height||!currentRect.width||!currentRect.height){if(!previousRect.width)str+="npw";if(!previousRect.height)str+="nph";if(!currentRect.width)str+="ncw";if(!currentRect.height)str+="nch";return str}if(previousRect.width!==currentRect.width){if(previousRect.width<currentRect.width){str+="he"}else{str+="hc"}if(previousRect.left===currentRect.left){str+="fl"}else if(previousRect.right===currentRect.right){str+="fr"}else if(previousRect.left+previousRect.right===currentRect.left+currentRect.right){str+="fc"}else if(previousRect.left<currentRect.left&&previousRect.right<currentRect.right){str+="sr"}else if(previousRect.left>currentRect.left&&previousRect.right>currentRect.right){str+="sl"}}else{if(previousRect.left<currentRect.left){str+="htsr"}else if(previousRect.left>currentRect.left){str+="htsl"}}if(previousRect.height!==currentRect.height){if(previousRect.height<currentRect.height){str+="ve"}else{str+="vc"}if(previousRect.top===currentRect.top){str+="ft"}else if(previousRect.bottom===currentRect.bottom){str+="fb"}else if(previousRect.top+previousRect.bottom===currentRect.top+currentRect.bottom){str+="fc"}else if(previousRect.top<currentRect.top&&previousRect.bottom<currentRect.bottom){str+="sd"}else if(previousRect.top>currentRect.top&&previousRect.bottom>currentRect.bottom){str+="su"}}else{if(previousRect.top<currentRect.top){str+="vtsd"}else if(previousRect.top>currentRect.top){str+="vtsu"}}return str};var fmtTransformString=function fmtTransformString(src){var unknownSrc={width:"unknown",height:"unknown",left:"unknown",right:"unknown",top:"unknown",bottom:"unknown"};var pr=src.previousRect||unknownSrc;var cr=src.currentRect||unknownSrc;return"width:".concat(pr.width,"->").concat(cr.width,",height:").concat(pr.height,"->").concat(cr.height,",left:").concat(pr.left,"->").concat(cr.left,",right:").concat(pr.right,"->").concat(cr.right,",top:").concat(pr.top,"->").concat(cr.top,",bottom:").concat(pr.bottom,"->").concat(cr.bottom)};var getNodeStringAndTransformString=function getNodeStringAndTransformString(nsList,sources,tsSummaryList){var str="";for(var i=0;i<nsList.length;i++){str+="["+tsSummaryList[i]+"] "+nsList[i]+" "+fmtTransformString(sources[i])+"\n  "}return str};new PerformanceObserver(function(list){list.getEntries().forEach(function(entry){if(entry.hadRecentInput)return;var nodeStrings=entry.sources.map(function(s){return nodeString(s.node)});var transformStringsSummary=entry.sources.map(function(s){return transformString(s.previousRect,s.currentRect)});debugLog(entry.startTime,"CLS "+entry.value+" from:\n  "+getNodeStringAndTransformString(nodeStrings,entry.sources,transformStringsSummary))})}).observe({type:"layout-shift",buffered:true})}else{debugLog(Date.now()-window.performance.timing.navigationStart,"layout-shift is not a supported entry type")}if(PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes.includes("largest-contentful-paint")){new PerformanceObserver(function(list){var perfEntries=list.getEntries();var entry=perfEntries[perfEntries.length-1];debugLog(entry.startTime,"LCP: "+nodeString(entry.element))}).observe({entryTypes:["largest-contentful-paint"]})}else{debugLog(Date.now()-window.performance.timing.navigationStart,"largest-contentful-paint is not a supported entry type")}if(PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes.includes("first-input")){new PerformanceObserver(function(list){list.getEntries().forEach(function(entry){var delay=entry.processingStart-entry.startTime;debugLog(entry.startTime,"FID: delay "+delay+" ms; name: "+entry.name+"; target: "+nodeString(entry.target))})}).observe({type:"first-input",buffered:true})}else{debugLog(Date.now()-window.performance.timing.navigationStart,"first-input is not a supported entry type")}if(PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes.includes("event")){var maxDuration=0;new PerformanceObserver(function(list){var _iterator=_createForOfIteratorHelper(list.getEntries()),_step;try{for(_iterator.s();!(_step=_iterator.n()).done;){var entry=_step.value;if(!entry.interactionId)continue;var msg=": duration "+entry.duration+"; name: "+entry.name+"; startTime: "+entry.startTime+"; processingStart: "+entry.processingStart+"; processingEnd: "+entry.processingEnd+"; target: "+nodeString(entry.target);if(entry.duration>maxDuration){maxDuration=entry.duration;debugLog(entry.startTime,"[INP LONGEST]"+msg)}else{debugLog(entry.startTime,"[INP ALL]"+msg)}}}catch(err){_iterator.e(err)}finally{_iterator.f()}}).observe({type:"event",durationThreshold:16,buffered:true})}else{debugLog(Date.now()-window.performance.timing.navigationStart,"event is not a supported entry type")}debugLog(Date.now()-window.performance.timing.navigationStart,"Enabled")}})();</script><script>"use strict";if(phxTrackedFeatures["experimental-lazy"]&&PerformanceObserver&&PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes&&PerformanceObserver.supportedEntryTypes.includes("largest-contentful-paint")){window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta={"creationTime":window.performance.now()|0};window.criticalElementsPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){var _navigator,_navigator$connection;var LCP_TIME_BUDGET=(((_navigator=navigator)===null||_navigator===void 0?void 0:(_navigator$connection=_navigator.connection)===null||_navigator$connection===void 0?void 0:_navigator$connection.effectiveType)||"4g")=="4g"?4000:10000;var MAX_TIME_AVAILABLE=LCP_TIME_BUDGET-window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta.creationTime;var MAX_POST_LCP_TIME=250;if(MAX_TIME_AVAILABLE<=0){window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta["case"]="MAX_TIME_AVAILABLE <= 0";window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta.resolutionTime=window.performance.now()|0;resolve(true)}else{var detectionTimeout=setTimeout(function(){window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta["case"]="detectionTimeout hit";window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta.resolutionTime=window.performance.now()|0;resolve(false)},MAX_TIME_AVAILABLE);var waitTimeout=null;var observer=new PerformanceObserver(function(list){if(!window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta.resolutionTime){clearTimeout(detectionTimeout);if(waitTimeout){clearTimeout(waitTimeout)}var POST_LCP_TIME=Math.min(MAX_POST_LCP_TIME,LCP_TIME_BUDGET-window.performance.now()|0);if(POST_LCP_TIME<=0){window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta["case"]="POST_LCP_TIME <= 0";window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta.resolutionTime=window.performance.now()|0;resolve(true)}else{waitTimeout=setTimeout(function(){window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta["case"]="POST_LCP_TIME end";window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta.resolutionTime=window.performance.now()|0;resolve(true)},POST_LCP_TIME)}}});observer.observe({entryTypes:["largest-contentful-paint"]})}})}else{window.criticalElementsPromiseMeta={"creationTime":window.performance.now()|0,"resolutionTime":window.performance.now()|0,"case":"skipped"};window.criticalElementsPromise=Promise.resolve()}</script><script>(function(siteProductionDomain, useCMP, mavenUidTarget) {"use strict";function _classCallCheck(instance,Constructor){if(!(instance instanceof Constructor)){throw new TypeError("Cannot call a class as a function")}}function _defineProperties(target,props){for(var i=0;i<props.length;i++){var descriptor=props[i];descriptor.enumerable=descriptor.enumerable||false;descriptor.configurable=true;if("value"in descriptor)descriptor.writable=true;Object.defineProperty(target,descriptor.key,descriptor)}}function _createClass(Constructor,protoProps,staticProps){if(protoProps)_defineProperties(Constructor.prototype,protoProps);if(staticProps)_defineProperties(Constructor,staticProps);Object.defineProperty(Constructor,"prototype",{writable:false});return Constructor}var VENDOR_IDS={indexexchange:10,quantcast:11,sovrn:13,oath:25,appnexus:32,rhythmone:36,taboola:42,rubicon:52,"33across":58,"33acrosshi":58,gumgum:61,amazonuam:68,openx:69,pubmatic:76,comscore:77,teads:132,outbrain:164,spotx:165,adobe:264,nielsen:373,dailymotion:573,cedato:672,google:755,arcspan:"6425d7744f9aee6206619515",bandcamp:"5f102879d9efe96bbebaf30b",blockthrough:"5efcaf4416696c0e08b30a4d",blueconic:"5eb32dea09c3f947e75e6f02",brightedge:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d7684",brightcove:"5ec796b4320b5a4efd764e0f",chartbeat:"5ea172e36ede87504f7b4590",chicory:"62d6e92851a820068650d77f",clicksco:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d7685",embedly:"5f102879d9efe96bbebaf30b",excoplayer:"62d137270550eb06a62f5855",facebook:"5e716fc09a0b5040d575080f",fubotv:"60cb5ddd1bfbb16ffb1ed67d",ihsmarkit:"5f45507146d0607f71d2d2b6",instagram:"5e717c8e69966540e4554f05",jeeng:"6104438de751ef061d94b7d5",jwplayer:"5f0f1187b8e05c109c2b8464",kargo:"5e542b3a4cd8884eb41b5a75",kickstarter:"5f3ee3dc8957bf8047ac94cc",krux:"5e542b3a4cd8884eb41b5a76",linkedin:"5e777e669cb08971eb078d71",lytics:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d7687",mantis:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d7688",maven:"5f4fdc68ccd23307f4a3fe5f",metabet:"61115122a5573307dc2c043c",narrativ:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d768d",nbcsports:"5f45507146d0607f71d2d2b6",openweb:"5e7ced57b8e05c4854221bd7",parsely:"5efb47c3a86ed40d775a6693",permutive:"5eff0d77969bfa03746427eb",pinterest:"5e839a38b8e05c4e491e738e",polldaddy:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c3057240f6f",pubexchange:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d768a",pulsepoint:"5f1b2fbdb8e05c30686fd6f3",qualtrics:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c3057240fa0",sailthru:"5f3bfd07a4724a6aaf5d768b",sendtonews:"5f4975d6c34a678c4f80dd99",skimlinks:"5efb47d829507407f91c4d4e",sortable:"5f2d22a6b8e05c02ba124dc2",soundcloud:"5e7179e49a0b5040d5750812",sportradar:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c306e139f88",spotify:"5e7f6927b8e05c111d01b40f",tiktok:"5e7f6927b8e05c4e491e7380",ted:"5f3ee41ef16f426d9f757c24",tealium:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c30686fd72a",theplatform:"5f3ee4d4ed1f54674a088416",threatmetrix:"636e6f897bd70406aa851625",trustx:"5ec7c9a9b8e05c4a1e720e76",twitter:"5e71760b69966540e4554f01",undertone:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c306e139f31",vidazoo:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c306c059802",viglink:"5f05be4cb8e05c109c2b83d2",vimeo:"5f1b2fbeb8e05c30686fd74c",vox:"60943f2c5a38c71211313c38",youtube:"5e7ac3fae30e7d1bc1ebf5e8"};var TCF2_PURPOSE_IDS={all:[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10],storage:[1],personalization:[3,4,5,6],advertising:[2,3,4,7],content:[5,6,8],measurement:[7,8,9,10],"advertising/basic":[2],"advertising/profile":[3],"advertising/personalized":[4],"content/profile":[5],"content/personalized":[6],"measurement/advertising":[7],"measurement/content":[8],"measurement/research":[9],"measurement/development":[10]};var UID_TIMEOUT=5000;var UID_LONG_TIMEOUT=10*1000;var BaseGdprStatus=function(){function BaseGdprStatus(){var _this=this;_classCallCheck(this,BaseGdprStatus);this._tcfVersion=2;this._useCMP=true;this.tcfPromise=new Promise(function(resolve){_this._tcfPromiseResolve=resolve});this.mavenContextPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){_this.resolveMavenContext=resolve;_this.rejectMavenContext=reject});if(this._isDebugging()){this.resolveMavenContext({uid:"WzmLYjUt7kNuYfzvKqsRmw",countryCode:"DE",inEEA:true,isDemonetized:false,version:3,build:"59"})}else if(this._disableGdpr()){this.resolveMavenContext({uid:"WzmLYjUt7kNuYfzvKqsRmw",countryCode:"US",regionCode:"PA",inEEA:false,isDemonetized:false,version:3,build:"59"})}else{this.fetchMavenContext()}}_createClass(BaseGdprStatus,[{key:"VENDOR_IDS",get:function get(){return VENDOR_IDS}},{key:"PURPOSE_IDS",get:function get(){return TCF2_PURPOSE_IDS}},{key:"newMavenContextPromise",value:function newMavenContextPromise(){var _this2=this;return new Promise(function(resolve,reject){var detectionTimeout=setTimeout(function(){reject(new Error("Timeout"))},_this2.mavenUidTimeout);_this2.resolveMavenContext=function(context){clearTimeout(detectionTimeout);resolve(context)};_this2.rejectMavenContext=function(err){clearTimeout(detectionTimeout);reject(err)}})}},{key:"mavenUidTimeout",get:function get(){var roll=Math.floor(Math.random()*100);var target=mavenUidTarget;if(window.sessionStorage){var stored=window.sessionStorage.getItem("use-longer-uid-timeout-sample");if(stored!==null){roll=parseInt(stored,10)}else{try{window.sessionStorage.setItem("use-longer-uid-timeout-sample",roll)}catch(e){roll=target+1}}}var success=target>0&&roll<target;window.mavenUidLongerTimeout=success;return success?UID_LONG_TIMEOUT:UID_TIMEOUT}},{key:"_applyClass",value:function _applyClass(){if(document.body){document.body.classList.add("is-gdpr-applicable","is-consent-applicable")}else{document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",this._applyClass.bind(this))}}},{key:"siteProductionDomain",set:function set(siteProductionDomain){this._siteProductionDomain=siteProductionDomain}},{key:"useCMP",set:function set(state){this._useCMP=state}},{key:"tcfReady",value:function tcfReady(){this._tcfPromiseResolve()}},{key:"_isDebugging",value:function _isDebugging(){return window.location.hash&&window.location.hash==="#assumeGdprApplicable"&&window.location.hostname!==this._siteProductionDomain}},{key:"_disableGdpr",value:function _disableGdpr(){return window.location.hash==="#disableGdpr"&&window.location.hostname!==this._siteProductionDomain}},{key:"isApplicable",value:function isApplicable(){if(this._isDebugging()){this._applyClass();return Promise.resolve(true)}return this.mavenContextPromise.then(function(payload){return!!payload.inEEA})}},{key:"isApplicableSafe",value:function isApplicableSafe(){return this.isApplicable()["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);return true})}},{key:"isDemonetized",value:function isDemonetized(){return this.mavenContextPromise.then(function(payload){return!!payload.isDemonetized})}},{key:"isDemonetizedSafe",value:function isDemonetizedSafe(){return this.isDemonetized()["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);return true})}},{key:"demonetizedReason",value:function demonetizedReason(){return this.mavenContextPromise.then(function(payload){if(payload.isDemonetized){return payload.demonetizedReason?payload.demonetizedReason:"Unknown"}})}},{key:"demonetizedReasonSafe",value:function demonetizedReasonSafe(){return this.demonetizedReason()["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);return"EndpointError="+err.message})}},{key:"countryCodeSafe",value:function countryCodeSafe(){return this.mavenContextPromise.then(function(payload){return payload.countryCode||""})["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);return""})}},{key:"regionCodeSafe",value:function regionCodeSafe(){return this.mavenContextPromise.then(function(payload){return payload.regionCode||""})["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);return""})}},{key:"getMavenUid",value:function getMavenUid(){return this.mavenContextPromise.then(function(payload){return payload.uid||null})}},{key:"fetchMavenContext",value:function fetchMavenContext(uid,didConsent){var _this3=this;this.mavenContextPromise=this.newMavenContextPromise();window.criticalElementsPromise.then(function(){var queryString=uid?"?uid=".concat(uid).concat(didConsent?"&didConsent=true":""):"";fetch("https://uid.mavencoalition.io/v3".concat(queryString),{credentials:"include"}).then(function(response){if(response.status===200){response.json().then(function(payload){return _this3.resolveMavenContext(payload)})}else{var status="";if(response.statusText){status=": "+response.statusText}throw new Error("[".concat(response.status,"] Invalid UID service response").concat(status))}})["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);_this3.rejectMavenContext(err)})})}},{key:"getMavenUidSafe",value:function getMavenUidSafe(){return this.getMavenUid()["catch"](function(err){console.error(err);return null})}},{key:"waitForConsentValue",value:function waitForConsentValue(){var _this4=this;if(!this._useCMP){return Promise.resolve()}if(!this._consentSetPromise){this._consentSetPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){_this4.isConsentSet().then(function(isSet){if(isSet){resolve(true);return}function setCallback(){if(window.phxConsentManagement){window.phxConsentManagement.setConsentUiCallback(function(){resolve(true)});return true}return false}if(!setCallback()){window.setTimeout(function(){if(!setCallback()){reject("phxConsentManagement was not resolved in time.")}},1000)}})})}return this._consentSetPromise}},{key:"isConsentSet",value:function isConsentSet(){}},{key:"isConsentGivenForPurposes",value:function isConsentGivenForPurposes(){}},{key:"isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes",value:function isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes(){}},{key:"getCookie",value:function getCookie(name){var value="; ".concat(document.cookie);var parts=value.split("; ".concat(name,"="));if(parts.length===2)return parts.pop().split(";").shift()}}]);return BaseGdprStatus}();if(typeof module!=="undefined"){module.exports=BaseGdprStatus}"use strict";function _typeof(obj){"@babel/helpers - typeof";return _typeof="function"==typeof Symbol&&"symbol"==typeof Symbol.iterator?function(obj){return typeof obj}:function(obj){return obj&&"function"==typeof Symbol&&obj.constructor===Symbol&&obj!==Symbol.prototype?"symbol":typeof obj},_typeof(obj)}function _classCallCheck(instance,Constructor){if(!(instance instanceof Constructor)){throw new TypeError("Cannot call a class as a function")}}function _defineProperties(target,props){for(var i=0;i<props.length;i++){var descriptor=props[i];descriptor.enumerable=descriptor.enumerable||false;descriptor.configurable=true;if("value"in descriptor)descriptor.writable=true;Object.defineProperty(target,descriptor.key,descriptor)}}function _createClass(Constructor,protoProps,staticProps){if(protoProps)_defineProperties(Constructor.prototype,protoProps);if(staticProps)_defineProperties(Constructor,staticProps);Object.defineProperty(Constructor,"prototype",{writable:false});return Constructor}function _inherits(subClass,superClass){if(typeof superClass!=="function"&&superClass!==null){throw new TypeError("Super expression must either be null or a function")}subClass.prototype=Object.create(superClass&&superClass.prototype,{constructor:{value:subClass,writable:true,configurable:true}});Object.defineProperty(subClass,"prototype",{writable:false});if(superClass)_setPrototypeOf(subClass,superClass)}function _setPrototypeOf(o,p){_setPrototypeOf=Object.setPrototypeOf?Object.setPrototypeOf.bind():function _setPrototypeOf(o,p){o.__proto__=p;return o};return _setPrototypeOf(o,p)}function _createSuper(Derived){var hasNativeReflectConstruct=_isNativeReflectConstruct();return function _createSuperInternal(){var Super=_getPrototypeOf(Derived),result;if(hasNativeReflectConstruct){var NewTarget=_getPrototypeOf(this).constructor;result=Reflect.construct(Super,arguments,NewTarget)}else{result=Super.apply(this,arguments)}return _possibleConstructorReturn(this,result)}}function _possibleConstructorReturn(self,call){if(call&&(_typeof(call)==="object"||typeof call==="function")){return call}else if(call!==void 0){throw new TypeError("Derived constructors may only return object or undefined")}return _assertThisInitialized(self)}function _assertThisInitialized(self){if(self===void 0){throw new ReferenceError("this hasn't been initialised - super() hasn't been called")}return self}function _isNativeReflectConstruct(){if(typeof Reflect==="undefined"||!Reflect.construct)return false;if(Reflect.construct.sham)return false;if(typeof Proxy==="function")return true;try{Boolean.prototype.valueOf.call(Reflect.construct(Boolean,[],function(){}));return true}catch(e){return false}}function _getPrototypeOf(o){_getPrototypeOf=Object.setPrototypeOf?Object.getPrototypeOf.bind():function _getPrototypeOf(o){return o.__proto__||Object.getPrototypeOf(o)};return _getPrototypeOf(o)}if(typeof BaseGdprStatus==="undefined"){var BaseGdprStatus=require("./gdprStatus")}var SP_PURPOSE_IDS={"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313eff6":1,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f012":2,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f02b":3,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f03f":4,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f053":5,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f061":6,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f06c":7,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f087":8,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f097":9,"5f31cdf48fe52a6a6313f0a9":10};var _spToIabMap=function _spToIabMap(m){var result={};for(var _i=0,_Object$keys=Object.keys(m);_i<_Object$keys.length;_i++){var k=_Object$keys[_i];result[SP_PURPOSE_IDS[k]||k]=m[k]}return result};var SourcepointGdprStatus=function(_BaseGdprStatus){_inherits(SourcepointGdprStatus,_BaseGdprStatus);var _super=_createSuper(SourcepointGdprStatus);function SourcepointGdprStatus(){_classCallCheck(this,SourcepointGdprStatus);return _super.apply(this,arguments)}_createClass(SourcepointGdprStatus,[{key:"isConsentSet",value:function isConsentSet(){if(this._disableGdpr()){return Promise.resolve(true)}if(!this._useCMP){return Promise.resolve(false)}if(this._consents){return Promise.resolve(true)}if(document.cookie.indexOf("euconsent-v2=")===-1){return Promise.resolve(false)}return this.getConsentValues().then(function(consents){return!!consents})}},{key:"getVendorConsentValues",value:function getVendorConsentValues(){return this.getConsentValues().then(function(consents){return consents&&consents.vendorConsents||{}})}},{key:"getPurposeConsentValues",value:function getPurposeConsentValues(){return this.getConsentValues().then(function(consents){return consents&&consents.purposeConsents||{}})}},{key:"setConsentValues",value:function setConsentValues(consents){this._consents=consents}},{key:"getConsentValues",value:function getConsentValues(forceUpdate){var _this=this;if(this._consents&&!forceUpdate){return Promise.resolve(this._consents)}return new Promise(function(resolve,reject){_this.tcfPromise.then(function(){window.__tcfapi("getTCData",2,function(data,success){if(success&&data.vendor&&data.purpose){window.__tcfapi("getCustomVendorConsents",2,function(customData,success){var consents={vendorConsents:data.vendor.consents,vendorPurposeConsents:{},purposeConsents:data.purpose.consents};if(success&&customData){var cv=customData.consentedVendors;if(cv){cv.forEach(function(v){var vg=customData.grants[v._id];if(vg){var pg=vg.purposeGrants;consents.vendorConsents[v._id]=Object.keys(pg).some(function(k){return pg[k]});consents.vendorPurposeConsents[v._id]=_spToIabMap(pg)}})}}_this._consents=consents;resolve(consents)})}})})})}},{key:"isConsentGivenForPurposes",value:function isConsentGivenForPurposes(purposes,purposeConsents){var _this2=this;if(this._disableGdpr()){return Promise.resolve(true)}if(!this._useCMP){return Promise.resolve(false)}return this.getConsentValues().then(function(consents){var pc=purposeConsents||consents.purposeConsents;var _everyConsentForPurposes=function _everyConsentForPurposes(purposes){return purposes.every(function(id){if(typeof id==="string"){id=_this2.PURPOSE_IDS[id]}if(Array.isArray(id)){return _everyConsentForPurposes(id)}else{return!!pc[id]}})};return consents&&(purposeConsents||consents.purposeConsents)&&_everyConsentForPurposes(purposes)})}},{key:"isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes",value:function isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes(vendorId,purposes){var _this3=this;if(this._disableGdpr()){return Promise.resolve(true)}if(!this._useCMP){return Promise.resolve(false)}if(this.VENDOR_IDS[vendorId]){vendorId=this.VENDOR_IDS[vendorId]}return this.getConsentValues().then(function(consents){if(consents&&consents.purposeConsents&&consents.vendorConsents&&!!consents.vendorConsents[vendorId]){if(!purposes){return true}var vpc=_this3._consents.vendorPurposeConsents;if(vpc){var pc=vpc[vendorId];if(pc){return _this3.isConsentGivenForPurposes(purposes,pc)}}return _this3.isConsentGivenForPurposes(purposes)}else{return false}})}}]);return SourcepointGdprStatus}(BaseGdprStatus);window.GdprStatus=new SourcepointGdprStatus;window.GdprStatus.siteProductionDomain = siteProductionDomain;
window.GdprStatus.useCMP = useCMP;
})('psmag.com', true, 0);</script><script id="subscription-common">"use strict";(function(){var IDs={};function getCookieValue(a){var b=document.cookie.match("(^|[^;]+)\\s*"+a+"\\s*=\\s*([^;]+)");return b?b.pop():""}function getRGISUserId(){if(IDs.rgis!==undefined){return IDs.rgis}var cookieVal=getCookieValue("RGIS");if(cookieVal){if(!cookieVal.startsWith("-")){cookieVal=cookieVal.replace(/"/g,"");var userid=cookieVal.split("|")[0];var validRegex=/(^\d+)/;if(validRegex.test(userid)){return IDs.rgis=userid.match(validRegex)[0]}}}return IDs.rgis=null}function getTempestPremiumUserId(){if(IDs.tempest!==undefined){return IDs.tempest}var cookieVal=getCookieValue("userToken");if(cookieVal){var userInfoParts=decodeURIComponent(cookieVal).split(":");if(userInfoParts.length===3){return IDs.tempest=userInfoParts[0]}}return IDs.tempest=null}function phxGetLoggedInStatus(){var rgis=getRGISUserId();if(rgis){return{"type":"rgis","id":rgis}}var tempestPrem=getTempestPremiumUserId();if(tempestPrem){return{"type":"tempestPremium","id":tempestPrem}}return null}window.phxGetLoggedInStatus=phxGetLoggedInStatus;window.phxIsLoggedIn=function(){return!!phxGetLoggedInStatus()}})();</script><script>window.TempestIdentityPromise = Promise.resolve();</script><script>(function(){
    window.GdprStatus.getMavenUidSafe().then(function(muid) {
        if(muid) {
            document.cookie = 'muid=' + encodeURIComponent(muid) + '; path=/; max-age=31536000';
        }
    });
})();</script><script>(function(){
    // Return a random integer; this will be used as an 
    // identifier for all auctions on the page.
    function generateCorrelator() {
        // Use the Math.random function since
        // we do not need a cryptographically secure
        // number here
        var rand = Math.random();
        
        return Math.floor(rand * 2 ** 63);
    }
    var correlator1 = generateCorrelator();
    var correlator2 = generateCorrelator();
    if (correlator1 === correlator2) {
        // Collision suggests that the browser is using a simulated
        // PRNG and thus is not a real user.
        window.mavenCorrelator = 0;
    } else {
        window.mavenCorrelator = correlator1;
    }
})();</script><script>"use strict";(function(){var pageLoadPromises=[];window.getTimedOutPageLoadPromise=function(timeoutMs){if(document.readyState==="complete"){return Promise.resolve(true)}else{var pageLoadPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){window.addEventListener("load",function(){resolve(true)});pageLoadPromises.push(setTimeout(function(){resolve(true)},timeoutMs||0))});return pageLoadPromise}};window.addEventListener("load",function(){for(var i in pageLoadPromises){window.clearTimeout(pageLoadPromises[i])}})})();</script><script>"use strict";function _typeof(obj){"@babel/helpers - typeof";return _typeof="function"==typeof Symbol&&"symbol"==typeof Symbol.iterator?function(obj){return typeof obj}:function(obj){return obj&&"function"==typeof Symbol&&obj.constructor===Symbol&&obj!==Symbol.prototype?"symbol":typeof obj},_typeof(obj)}function _slicedToArray(arr,i){return _arrayWithHoles(arr)||_iterableToArrayLimit(arr,i)||_unsupportedIterableToArray(arr,i)||_nonIterableRest()}function _nonIterableRest(){throw new TypeError("Invalid attempt to destructure non-iterable instance.\nIn order to be iterable, non-array objects must have a [Symbol.iterator]() method.")}function _unsupportedIterableToArray(o,minLen){if(!o)return;if(typeof o==="string")return _arrayLikeToArray(o,minLen);var n=Object.prototype.toString.call(o).slice(8,-1);if(n==="Object"&&o.constructor)n=o.constructor.name;if(n==="Map"||n==="Set")return Array.from(o);if(n==="Arguments"||/^(?:Ui|I)nt(?:8|16|32)(?:Clamped)?Array$/.test(n))return _arrayLikeToArray(o,minLen)}function _arrayLikeToArray(arr,len){if(len==null||len>arr.length)len=arr.length;for(var i=0,arr2=new Array(len);i<len;i++){arr2[i]=arr[i]}return arr2}function _iterableToArrayLimit(arr,i){var _i=arr==null?null:typeof Symbol!=="undefined"&&arr[Symbol.iterator]||arr["@@iterator"];if(_i==null)return;var _arr=[];var _n=true;var _d=false;var _s,_e;try{for(_i=_i.call(arr);!(_n=(_s=_i.next()).done);_n=true){_arr.push(_s.value);if(i&&_arr.length===i)break}}catch(err){_d=true;_e=err}finally{try{if(!_n&&_i["return"]!=null)_i["return"]()}finally{if(_d)throw _e}}return _arr}function _arrayWithHoles(arr){if(Array.isArray(arr))return arr}function _classCallCheck(instance,Constructor){if(!(instance instanceof Constructor)){throw new TypeError("Cannot call a class as a function")}}function _defineProperties(target,props){for(var i=0;i<props.length;i++){var descriptor=props[i];descriptor.enumerable=descriptor.enumerable||false;descriptor.configurable=true;if("value"in descriptor)descriptor.writable=true;Object.defineProperty(target,descriptor.key,descriptor)}}function _createClass(Constructor,protoProps,staticProps){if(protoProps)_defineProperties(Constructor.prototype,protoProps);if(staticProps)_defineProperties(Constructor,staticProps);Object.defineProperty(Constructor,"prototype",{writable:false});return Constructor}function _get(){if(typeof Reflect!=="undefined"&&Reflect.get){_get=Reflect.get.bind()}else{_get=function _get(target,property,receiver){var base=_superPropBase(target,property);if(!base)return;var desc=Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(base,property);if(desc.get){return desc.get.call(arguments.length<3?target:receiver)}return desc.value}}return _get.apply(this,arguments)}function _superPropBase(object,property){while(!Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(object,property)){object=_getPrototypeOf(object);if(object===null)break}return object}function _inherits(subClass,superClass){if(typeof superClass!=="function"&&superClass!==null){throw new TypeError("Super expression must either be null or a function")}subClass.prototype=Object.create(superClass&&superClass.prototype,{constructor:{value:subClass,writable:true,configurable:true}});Object.defineProperty(subClass,"prototype",{writable:false});if(superClass)_setPrototypeOf(subClass,superClass)}function _setPrototypeOf(o,p){_setPrototypeOf=Object.setPrototypeOf?Object.setPrototypeOf.bind():function _setPrototypeOf(o,p){o.__proto__=p;return o};return _setPrototypeOf(o,p)}function _createSuper(Derived){var hasNativeReflectConstruct=_isNativeReflectConstruct();return function _createSuperInternal(){var Super=_getPrototypeOf(Derived),result;if(hasNativeReflectConstruct){var NewTarget=_getPrototypeOf(this).constructor;result=Reflect.construct(Super,arguments,NewTarget)}else{result=Super.apply(this,arguments)}return _possibleConstructorReturn(this,result)}}function _possibleConstructorReturn(self,call){if(call&&(_typeof(call)==="object"||typeof call==="function")){return call}else if(call!==void 0){throw new TypeError("Derived constructors may only return object or undefined")}return _assertThisInitialized(self)}function _assertThisInitialized(self){if(self===void 0){throw new ReferenceError("this hasn't been initialised - super() hasn't been called")}return self}function _isNativeReflectConstruct(){if(typeof Reflect==="undefined"||!Reflect.construct)return false;if(Reflect.construct.sham)return false;if(typeof Proxy==="function")return true;try{Boolean.prototype.valueOf.call(Reflect.construct(Boolean,[],function(){}));return true}catch(e){return false}}function _getPrototypeOf(o){_getPrototypeOf=Object.setPrototypeOf?Object.getPrototypeOf.bind():function _getPrototypeOf(o){return o.__proto__||Object.getPrototypeOf(o)};return _getPrototypeOf(o)}(function(){var DELAY_TIMEOUT=30000;var POST_LOAD_DELAY=100;var pageTag="phoenix-page";window.customElements.whenDefined(pageTag).then(function(){return window.customElements.get(pageTag)}).then(function(pageClass){var PhoenixScript=function(_pageClass$PhoenixEle){_inherits(PhoenixScript,_pageClass$PhoenixEle);var _super=_createSuper(PhoenixScript);function PhoenixScript(){_classCallCheck(this,PhoenixScript);return _super.apply(this,arguments)}_createClass(PhoenixScript,[{key:"connectedCallback",value:function connectedCallback(){_get(_getPrototypeOf(PhoenixScript.prototype),"connectedCallback",this).call(this);this.delayLoad=this.hasAttribute("delay-load");this.afterCriticalElements=this.hasAttribute("load-after-critical-elements");this.templateId=this.getAttribute("script-id");this.scriptSrc=this.getAttribute("src");if(!this.templateId&&!this.scriptSrc){throw new Error("script-id or src is required")}if(this.templateId&&this.scriptSrc){throw new Error("script-id and src are mutually exclusive")}if(this.hasAttribute("script-attributes")){try{this.scriptAttributes=this.getAttr("script-attributes",{parseJson:true})}catch(e){console.error(e)}}this._handleWaitForPromises()}},{key:"_setScriptAttributes",value:function _setScriptAttributes(elem){if(!this.scriptAttributes){return}try{for(var _i=0,_Object$entries=Object.entries(this.scriptAttributes);_i<_Object$entries.length;_i++){var _Object$entries$_i=_slicedToArray(_Object$entries[_i],2),k=_Object$entries$_i[0],v=_Object$entries$_i[1];elem.setAttribute(k,v)}}catch(e){console.error(e)}}},{key:"_whenPageLoaded",value:function _whenPageLoaded(minimumDelayMs,timeoutMs){var _this=this;if(document.readyState==="complete"){return new Promise(function(resolve){setTimeout(resolve,minimumDelayMs)})}else{if(!this.delayLoadTimeouts){this.delayLoadTimeouts=[]}window.addEventListener("load",function(){for(var i in _this.delayLoadTimeouts){window.clearTimeout(_this.delayLoadTimeouts[i])}});return new Promise(function(resolve){window.addEventListener("load",function(){setTimeout(resolve,minimumDelayMs)});_this.delayLoadTimeouts.push(setTimeout(resolve,minimumDelayMs+timeoutMs||0))})}}},{key:"_handleWaitForPromises",value:function _handleWaitForPromises(){var _this2=this;var promises=[this.canRender()];if(this.delayLoad){var delay=parseInt(this.getAttribute("delay-load"),10)||POST_LOAD_DELAY;promises.push(this._whenPageLoaded(delay,DELAY_TIMEOUT))}if(this.afterCriticalElements){promises.push(window.criticalElementsPromise)}Promise.all(promises).then(function(results){if(results[0]){_this2._inject()}})}},{key:"_inject",value:function _inject(){var script=document.createElement("script");if(this.scriptSrc){script.src=this.scriptSrc}else if(this.templateId){var template=document.getElementById(this.templateId);if(!template){throw new Error("template not found for "+this.templateId)}script.innerHTML=template.innerHTML;template.parentElement.removeChild(template)}this._setScriptAttributes(script);var scriptDescription=this.scriptSrc?"scriptSrc ".concat(this.scriptSrc):"templateId ".concat(this.templateId);window.mostRecentScriptDescription=scriptDescription;try{this.appendChild(script)}catch(e){e.message="appendChild failed for script with ".concat(scriptDescription,"; ")+"original error ".concat(e.message);throw e}}}]);return PhoenixScript}(pageClass.PhoenixElement);window.customElements.define("phoenix-script",PhoenixScript)})})();</script><script id="typekit-loader">"use strict";window.fontLoadedPromise=new Promise(function(resolve){window.fontLoadedResolve=resolve});</script><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://use.typekit.net/zam7fot.css" onload="window.fontLoadedResolve()"><link rel="stylesheet" href="/site/styles/main.min.css?config=published&amp;cv=cdf3cea2f833ffb6c03daf9211693543&amp;v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"><script src="/.bootscripts/runtime.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=IBM+Plex+Mono:wght@400;500&amp;family=IBM+Plex+Sans:wght@400;500&amp;display=swap"><script src="/.bootscripts/vendors-react.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script>(function () {
    var givenQs = '&' + window.location.search.substr(1) + '&';
    var newQs = givenQs.replace(/&(bt_email|vero_id)=[^&]+&/, '&REDACTED=REDACTED&');
    if (newQs !== givenQs) {
        console.warn('We have redacted a personal information argument in the query string');
        var newUrl = window.location.pathname + '?' + newQs.substr(1, newQs.length - 2);
        window.history.replaceState({}, '', newUrl);
    }
})();
</script><script>var phxConfigQueue = window.phxConfigQueue || [];
</script><script async src="/.bootscripts/config.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script>phxConfigQueue.push(function () {
    this.features.init({"alt-demo-data":false,"use-hummingbird":true});
    this.membership.init({"exclusiveContent":{"subscribeUrl":"","loginCta":"","enabled":false,"meteredContentEnabled":false},"premiumExperience":{"joinTout":"Join","additionalMenuLinks":[],"enabled":false,"subscribePageLogin":false}});
    this.siteBasePath = '';
    this.siteKeyword = 'psmag';
    this.metabetSiteId = '';
    this.sportradarClientId = '';
    this.ssgClientId = '';
    this.statsApiHostname = 'sports-stats.si.com';
});</script><script>(function(consentConfig) {"use strict";function _classCallCheck(instance,Constructor){if(!(instance instanceof Constructor)){throw new TypeError("Cannot call a class as a function")}}function _defineProperties(target,props){for(var i=0;i<props.length;i++){var descriptor=props[i];descriptor.enumerable=descriptor.enumerable||false;descriptor.configurable=true;if("value"in descriptor)descriptor.writable=true;Object.defineProperty(target,descriptor.key,descriptor)}}function _createClass(Constructor,protoProps,staticProps){if(protoProps)_defineProperties(Constructor.prototype,protoProps);if(staticProps)_defineProperties(Constructor,staticProps);Object.defineProperty(Constructor,"prototype",{writable:false});return Constructor}function _classPrivateMethodInitSpec(obj,privateSet){_checkPrivateRedeclaration(obj,privateSet);privateSet.add(obj)}function _classPrivateFieldInitSpec(obj,privateMap,value){_checkPrivateRedeclaration(obj,privateMap);privateMap.set(obj,value)}function _checkPrivateRedeclaration(obj,privateCollection){if(privateCollection.has(obj)){throw new TypeError("Cannot initialize the same private elements twice on an object")}}function _classPrivateMethodGet(receiver,privateSet,fn){if(!privateSet.has(receiver)){throw new TypeError("attempted to get private field on non-instance")}return fn}function _classPrivateFieldGet(receiver,privateMap){var descriptor=_classExtractFieldDescriptor(receiver,privateMap,"get");return _classApplyDescriptorGet(receiver,descriptor)}function _classApplyDescriptorGet(receiver,descriptor){if(descriptor.get){return descriptor.get.call(receiver)}return descriptor.value}function _classPrivateFieldSet(receiver,privateMap,value){var descriptor=_classExtractFieldDescriptor(receiver,privateMap,"set");_classApplyDescriptorSet(receiver,descriptor,value);return value}function _classExtractFieldDescriptor(receiver,privateMap,action){if(!privateMap.has(receiver)){throw new TypeError("attempted to "+action+" private field on non-instance")}return privateMap.get(receiver)}function _classApplyDescriptorSet(receiver,descriptor,value){if(descriptor.set){descriptor.set.call(receiver,value)}else{if(!descriptor.writable){throw new TypeError("attempted to set read only private field")}descriptor.value=value}}function _typeof2(obj){"@babel/helpers - typeof";return _typeof2="function"==typeof Symbol&&"symbol"==typeof Symbol.iterator?function(obj){return typeof obj}:function(obj){return obj&&"function"==typeof Symbol&&obj.constructor===Symbol&&obj!==Symbol.prototype?"symbol":typeof obj},_typeof2(obj)}var SOURCEPOINT_MMS_DOMAIN="https://message.maven.io";var CCPA="CCPA";var CCPA_STATES=["CA","VA"];var GDPR="GDPR";var CCPA_SHIM=function CCPA_SHIM(){(function(){var e=false;var c=window;var t=document;function r(){if(!c.frames["__uspapiLocator"]){if(t.body){var a=t.body;var e=t.createElement("iframe");e.style.cssText="display:none";e.name="__uspapiLocator";a.appendChild(e)}else{setTimeout(r,5)}}}r();function p(){var a=arguments;__uspapi.a=__uspapi.a||[];if(!a.length){return __uspapi.a}else if(a[0]==="ping"){a[2]({gdprAppliesGlobally:e,cmpLoaded:false},true)}else{__uspapi.a.push([].slice.apply(a))}}function l(t){var r=typeof t.data==="string";try{var a=r?JSON.parse(t.data):t.data;if(a.__cmpCall){var n=a.__cmpCall;c.__uspapi(n.command,n.parameter,function(a,e){var c={__cmpReturn:{returnValue:a,success:e,callId:n.callId}};t.source.postMessage(r?JSON.stringify(c):c,"*")})}}catch(a){}}if(typeof __uspapi!=="function"){c.__uspapi=p;__uspapi.msgHandler=l;c.addEventListener("message",l,false)}})()};var GDPR_SHIM=function GDPR_SHIM(){function _typeof(t){return(_typeof=typeof Symbol=="function"&&_typeof2(Symbol.iterator)=="symbol"?function(t){return _typeof2(t)}:function(t){return t&&typeof Symbol=="function"&&t.constructor===Symbol&&t!==Symbol.prototype?"symbol":_typeof2(t)})(t)}!function(){for(var t,e,o=[],n=window,r=n;r;){try{if(r.frames.__tcfapiLocator){t=r;break}}catch(t){}if(r===n.top)break;r=n.parent}t||(function t(){var e=n.document,o=!!n.frames.__tcfapiLocator;if(!o)if(e.body){var r=e.createElement("iframe");r.style.cssText="display:none",r.name="__tcfapiLocator",e.body.appendChild(r)}else setTimeout(t,5);return!o}(),n.__tcfapi=function(){for(var t=arguments.length,n=new Array(t),r=0;r<t;r++){n[r]=arguments[r]}if(!n.length)return o;n[0]==="setGdprApplies"?n.length>3&&parseInt(n[1],10)===2&&typeof n[3]=="boolean"&&(e=n[3],typeof n[2]=="function"&&n[2]("set",!0)):n[0]==="ping"?typeof n[2]=="function"&&n[2]({gdprApplies:e,cmpLoaded:!1,cmpStatus:"stub"}):o.push(n)},n.addEventListener("message",function(t){var e=typeof t.data=="string",o={};if(e)try{o=JSON.parse(t.data)}catch(t){}else o=t.data;var n=_typeof(o)==="object"?o.__tcfapiCall:null;n&&window.__tcfapi(n.command,n.version,function(o,r){var a={__tcfapiReturn:{returnValue:o,success:r,callId:n.callId}};t&&t.source&&t.source.postMessage&&t.source.postMessage(e?JSON.stringify(a):a,"*")},n.parameter)},!1))}()};var _ccpaPrivacyManagerId=new WeakMap;var _gdprPrivacyManagerId=new WeakMap;var _customConsentUiCallback=new WeakMap;var _consentType=new WeakMap;var _consentString=new WeakMap;var _loadSourcepointPromise=new WeakMap;var _CCPAAcceptedPromise=new WeakMap;var _consentResolver=new WeakMap;var _consentPromise=new WeakMap;var _isCcpaState=new WeakSet;var SourcepointConsentManagement=function(){function SourcepointConsentManagement(){_classCallCheck(this,SourcepointConsentManagement);_classPrivateMethodInitSpec(this,_isCcpaState);_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_ccpaPrivacyManagerId,{writable:true,value:void 0});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_gdprPrivacyManagerId,{writable:true,value:void 0});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_customConsentUiCallback,{writable:true,value:void 0});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_consentType,{writable:true,value:null});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_consentString,{writable:true,value:null});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_loadSourcepointPromise,{writable:true,value:void 0});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_CCPAAcceptedPromise,{writable:true,value:void 0});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_consentResolver,{writable:true,value:void 0});_classPrivateFieldInitSpec(this,_consentPromise,{writable:true,value:void 0})}_createClass(SourcepointConsentManagement,[{key:"init",value:function init(config){var _this=this;_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_consentPromise,new Promise(function(resolve){_classPrivateFieldSet(_this,_consentResolver,resolve)}));var gdpr=window.GdprStatus;var cb=function cb(choiceID){gdpr.getConsentValues(true).then(function(consents){ga("_tempestTracker.send","event","CMP",_this._consentChoice(consents))});if(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this,_customConsentUiCallback)){_classPrivateFieldGet(_this,_customConsentUiCallback).call(_this,choiceID)}};return Promise.all([gdpr.isApplicable(),gdpr.countryCodeSafe(),gdpr.regionCodeSafe()]).then(function(values){var isApplicable=values[0];var countryCode=values[1];var regionCode=values[2];window._sp_queue=[];window._sp_={config:{mmsDomain:SOURCEPOINT_MMS_DOMAIN,accountId:config.accountId,baseEndpoint:"https://cdn.privacy-mgmt.com",events:{onMessageChoiceSelect:cb}}};if(!config.disableCCPA&&_classPrivateMethodGet(_this,_isCcpaState,_isCcpaState2).call(_this,countryCode,regionCode)){_this._addConsentApplicableClass();return _this._initCCPA(config)}else if(isApplicable){_this._addConsentApplicableClass();return _this._initGDPR(config,gdpr)}else{delete window._sp_;delete window._sp_queue;_classPrivateFieldSet(_this,_consentType,null);_classPrivateFieldGet(_this,_consentResolver).call(_this,_classPrivateFieldGet(_this,_consentString))}})}},{key:"_initCCPA",value:function _initCCPA(config){var _this2=this;_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_consentType,CCPA);_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_ccpaPrivacyManagerId,config.ccpaPrivacyManagerId);Object.assign(window._sp_.config,{targetingParams:{type:_classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentType)},ccpa:{alwaysDisplayDns:false}});CCPA_SHIM();return this.loadSourcepoint().then(function(){window.__uspapi("getUSPData",1,function(uspData,success){if(success){_this2.setConsentString(uspData.uspString)}})})}},{key:"_initGDPR",value:function _initGDPR(config,gdpr){var _this3=this;_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_consentType,GDPR);_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_gdprPrivacyManagerId,config.gdprPrivacyManagerId);Object.assign(window._sp_.config,{targetingParams:{type:_classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentType)},gdpr:{waitForConsent:true}});GDPR_SHIM();window.__tcfapi("addEventListener",2,function(tcData,success){if(success){if(tcData.eventStatus==="tcloaded"){if(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this3,_consentString)===null){_this3.setConsentString(tcData.tcString);gdpr.tcfReady()}gdpr.getConsentValues(true)}else if(tcData.eventStatus==="useractioncomplete"){if(tcData.tcString!==_classPrivateFieldGet(_this3,_consentString)){window.location.reload()}}}});return this.loadSourcepoint().then(function(){return gdpr.isConsentSet().then(function(isSet){if(!isSet){ga("_tempestTracker.send","event","CMP","initial_display")}})})}},{key:"getConsentString",value:function getConsentString(){return _classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentPromise)}},{key:"consentType",get:function get(){return _classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentType)}},{key:"setConsentString",value:function setConsentString(string){_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_consentString,string);_classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentResolver).call(this,_classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentString))}},{key:"displayUi",value:function displayUi(){var _this4=this;return this.loadSourcepoint().then(function(){if(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this4,_consentType)===CCPA){window._sp_.ccpa.loadPrivacyManagerModal(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this4,_ccpaPrivacyManagerId))}else if(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this4,_consentType)===GDPR){ga("_tempestTracker.send","event","CMP","subsequent_display");window._sp_.gdpr.loadPrivacyManagerModal(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this4,_gdprPrivacyManagerId))}})}},{key:"setConsentUiCallback",value:function setConsentUiCallback(cb){_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_customConsentUiCallback,cb)}},{key:"ccpaAccepted",value:function ccpaAccepted(){var _this5=this;if(!_classPrivateFieldGet(this,_CCPAAcceptedPromise)){return _classPrivateFieldGet(this,_consentPromise).then(function(){if(_classPrivateFieldGet(_this5,_consentType)===CCPA){_classPrivateFieldSet(_this5,_CCPAAcceptedPromise,new Promise(function(resolve,reject){var rejected=document.cookie.split(";").some(function(item){if(item.trim().startsWith("ccpaReject")){var cookieVal=item.split("=")[1];if(cookieVal==="true"){return true}}return false});resolve(!rejected)}))}else{_classPrivateFieldSet(_this5,_CCPAAcceptedPromise,Promise.resolve(true))}return _classPrivateFieldGet(_this5,_CCPAAcceptedPromise)})}return _classPrivateFieldGet(this,_CCPAAcceptedPromise)}},{key:"loadSourcepoint",value:function loadSourcepoint(){if(!_classPrivateFieldGet(this,_loadSourcepointPromise)){_classPrivateFieldSet(this,_loadSourcepointPromise,this._loadScript("https://cdn.privacy-mgmt.com/unified/wrapperMessagingWithoutDetection.js"))}return _classPrivateFieldGet(this,_loadSourcepointPromise)}},{key:"_loadScript",value:function _loadScript(s){return new Promise(function(resolve,reject){var e=document.createElement("script");e.src=s;e.onload=resolve;document.head.appendChild(e)})}},{key:"_addConsentApplicableClass",value:function _addConsentApplicableClass(){var _this6=this;if(document.body){document.body.classList.add("is-consent-applicable")}else{document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",function(){_this6._addConsentApplicableClass()})}}},{key:"_consentChoice",value:function _consentChoice(consents){var ACCEPTED_ALL=0,REJECTED_ALL=1,CUSTOM=2,CODES=["accept_all","reject_all","accept_custom"];var vc=consents.vendorConsents;var pc=consents.purposeConsents;var allVendorConsents=!Object.keys(vc).some(function(id){return!vc[id]}),allPurposeConsents=!Object.keys(pc).some(function(id){return!pc[id]});if(allVendorConsents&&allPurposeConsents){return CODES[ACCEPTED_ALL]}else if(Object.keys(vc).some(function(id){return vc[id]})||Object.keys(pc).some(function(id){return pc[id]})){return CODES[CUSTOM]}else{return CODES[REJECTED_ALL]}}}]);return SourcepointConsentManagement}();function _isCcpaState2(countryCode,regionCode){return countryCode==="US"&&(!regionCode||CCPA_STATES.indexOf(regionCode)!==-1)}window.phxConsentManagement=new SourcepointConsentManagement;window.phxConsentManagement.init(consentConfig);
})({"accountId":821,"appCacheBuster":"v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483","ccpaPrivacyManagerId":"5dfbacb056e32a4ed86363e7","disableCCPA":false,"gdprPrivacyManagerId":"335151","platform":"sourcepoint","siteId":"5812"});</script><script>(function(w,apiKey,waitForCarbonReady){"use strict";var promiseResolver;var handle=w.setTimeout(function(){if(promiseResolver!=undefined){promiseResolver()}promiseResolver=undefined},4000);var setCarbonDemographics=function setCarbonDemographics(){var pct={};var realTimeDataHandler=function realTimeDataHandler(){var ls=w.localStorage;var realtimeData=ls?ls.getItem("ccRealtimeData"):null;var contextualData=ls?ls.getItem("ccContextualData"):null;var profile,iabIds;try{if(realtimeData){profile=JSON.parse(realtimeData)}}catch(e){}try{if(contextualData){iabIds=JSON.parse(contextualData)}}catch(e){}if(profile){pct.realtime=profile;var aaq=w.phxAdAuctionQueue||(w.phxAdAuctionQueue=[]);aaq.push(function(){var _this=this;var _profile=profile,demographics=_profile.demographics,audiences=_profile.audiences;if(demographics){demographics.forEach(function(d){if(d.confidence){_this.setKeyValue("carbon_"+d.id,d.confidence)}})}})}if(iabIds){pct.contextual=iabIds}};if(waitForCarbonReady===true){window._ccApiReady=window._ccApiReady||[];window._ccApiReady.push(function(){if(window.carbon){window.carbon.realtimeReady(realTimeDataHandler)}})}else{realTimeDataHandler()}w.phoenixCarbonTargeting=pct;if(promiseResolver!=undefined){w.clearTimeout(handle);promiseResolver()}};if(waitForCarbonReady===true){w.carbonReadyPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){promiseResolver=resolve});w.carbonReady=w.carbonReady||[];w.carbonReady.push(setCarbonDemographics)}else{setCarbonDemographics()}})(window,'268a88b6647a',false);</script><script>"use strict";var scriptName="adScripts:alpha";var startMark="phxMark:prebidStart";var endMark="phxMark:prebidEnd";var pbjs=window.pbjs||(window.pbjs={});pbjs.que=pbjs.que||[];if(window.performance&&window.performance.mark){window.performance.mark(startMark);pbjs.que.push(function(){window.performance.mark(endMark);window.performance.measure(scriptName,startMark,endMark)})}</script><script async src="/runtime/alpha.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script>window.criticalElementsPromise.then(function(r) {
!function(a9,a,p,s,t,A,g){if(a[a9])return;function q(c,r){a[a9]._Q.push([c,r])}a[a9]={init:function(){q("i",arguments)},fetchBids:function(){q("f",arguments)},setDisplayBids:function(){},targetingKeys:function(){return[]},deleteId:function(){q("di",arguments)},renewId:function(){q("ri",arguments)},updateId:function(){q("ui",arguments)},_Q:[]};A=p.createElement(s);A.async=!0;A.src=t;g=p.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];g.parentNode.insertBefore(A,g)}("apstag",window,document,"script","https://c.amazon-adsystem.com/aax2/apstag.js");
var data={pubID:'5128',adServer:'googletag',videoServer:'DFP'};
var sid='26';if(sid){data.schain={complete:1,ver:'1.0',nodes:[{asi:'thearenagroup.net',sid:sid,hp:1}]}}
window.apstag.init(data);"use strict";var _window$localStorage,_window$localStorage$;var emailHashData=(_window$localStorage=window.localStorage)===null||_window$localStorage===void 0?void 0:(_window$localStorage$=_window$localStorage.getItem)===null||_window$localStorage$===void 0?void 0:_window$localStorage$.call(_window$localStorage,"emailHashes");if(emailHashData){var data;try{data=JSON.parse(emailHashData)}catch(e){}if(data&&data.length){var emailHash=data.find(function(el){return el.alg==="sha256"});if(emailHash){window.apstag.renewId({hashedRecords:[{type:"email",record:emailHash.digest}]})}}}});</script><script>var phxAdAuctionQueue = window.phxAdAuctionQueue || (window.phxAdAuctionQueue = []);
</script><script async src="/runtime/beta1.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script>(function(adAuctionConfig){"use strict";window.GdprStatus.isApplicable().then(function(isApplicable){adAuctionConfig.gdprIsApplicable=isApplicable;phxAdAuctionQueue.push(function(){this.startAuction(adAuctionConfig)})});})({"beacons":{"targetingParams":{"paramSeparators":{"ksg":":","terms":";"},"exclude":{"ag":true,"in":true,"pt":true,"et":true,"gd":true}}},"siteProductionDomain":"psmag.com","hummingbirdUrl":"https://hummingbird.mavencoalition.io/collect","slots":[{"config":{"sizes":[[320,50],[320,60],[300,50]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomA"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-eae660fbcaf54969a95a28792bca5054","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[768,66]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomB"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-078c74fc1474463f8bd9670cfd25173a","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[900,65],[970,90]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomC"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-0a451b5695604c78ade439fdbad638ab","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[900,65],[970,90]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomD"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-1d9ca2cd72594bce833bd6ba30146371","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-4196fa807ecf4a25a2c3fb6a72168125","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-d8c40617282d41da85c4d04fe46bc163","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-cc14dff601ce45adb7dcbcbc80a6b42d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-cc6add8a5b944bf09a8929508e50568d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-219c92ad79054ccdb03c895ff9c73587","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-a5aa41619e8f4e66b98e84224bc568ec","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-a96b2fe1fbe4495ba6b8ec1136051fb9","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-fd7fc70d0df547dcaa63430553337ac5","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-8dd3920542f541988e801159d6e1c495","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-0e660040f13a460c978a24cc26824c31","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-596a954310744f9e84f68386950d2c44","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-253f9f43e1c443ca82c261ab32d31f1e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[1,1]]},"model":{"zone":"adhesion","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"adhesion"}],"screenSizes":null,"slotModel":{"zone":"adhesion","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-adhesion-f78ea9310b864de891190811eb13d39e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"}],"units":{"A":[{"code":"ad-fixed_bottom-eae660fbcaf54969a95a28792bca5054","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#fixed_bottom-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#fixed_bottom-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390760,"zoneId":2180026}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_fixedbottom_320x50_HDX"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_mw","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_mw","siteId":"812712"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b5fbd6c0066","pos":"fixed_bottom"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349274,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019858"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[320,50]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-4196fa807ecf4a25a2c3fb6a72168125","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390760,"zoneId":2180026}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"156422","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_mobile"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_mw","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_0_mw","siteId":"812712"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b5fbd6c0066","pos":"in_content_0"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"300x250","cp":562127,"ct":736896}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019859"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-4196fa807ecf4a25a2c3fb6a72168125","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_mw","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-219c92ad79054ccdb03c895ff9c73587","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390760,"zoneId":2180026}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"156422","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_mobile"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_mw","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_1_mw","siteId":"812712"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b5fbd6c0066","pos":"in_content_1"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"300x250","cp":562127,"ct":736896}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019859"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-219c92ad79054ccdb03c895ff9c73587","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_mw","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-8dd3920542f541988e801159d6e1c495","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390760,"zoneId":2180026}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"156422","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_mobile"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_2_mw","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_2_mw","siteId":"812712"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b5fbd6c0066","pos":"in_content_2"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"300x250","cp":562127,"ct":736896}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019859"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-8dd3920542f541988e801159d6e1c495","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_2_mw","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-adhesion-f78ea9310b864de891190811eb13d39e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#adhesion-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#adhesion-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390760,"zoneId":2180026}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407980","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_adhesion"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_mw","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_mw","siteId":"812712"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b5fbd6c0066","pos":"adhesion"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349162,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019858"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[1,1]]}}}],"B":[{"code":"ad-fixed_bottom-078c74fc1474463f8bd9670cfd25173a","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#fixed_bottom-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#fixed_bottom-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_fixedbottom_leaderboard_HDX"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"fixed_bottom"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349274,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-d8c40617282d41da85c4d04fe46bc163","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_0"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-d8c40617282d41da85c4d04fe46bc163","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-a5aa41619e8f4e66b98e84224bc568ec","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_1"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-a5aa41619e8f4e66b98e84224bc568ec","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-0e660040f13a460c978a24cc26824c31","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_2"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-0e660040f13a460c978a24cc26824c31","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-adhesion-f78ea9310b864de891190811eb13d39e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#adhesion-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#adhesion-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407980","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_adhesion"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"adhesion"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349162,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[1,1]]}}}],"C":[{"code":"ad-fixed_bottom-0a451b5695604c78ade439fdbad638ab","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#fixed_bottom-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#fixed_bottom-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_fixedbottom_leaderboard_HDX"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"fixed_bottom"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349274,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-cc14dff601ce45adb7dcbcbc80a6b42d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_0"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-cc14dff601ce45adb7dcbcbc80a6b42d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-cc14dff601ce45adb7dcbcbc80a6b42d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_0"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}}],"mediaTypes":{"video":{"api":[1,2],"context":"outstream","mimes":["application/javascript","video/mp4","video/webm"],"minduration":0,"maxduration":15,"playerSize":[640,480],"protocols":[1,2,3,4,5,6]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-a96b2fe1fbe4495ba6b8ec1136051fb9","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_1"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-a96b2fe1fbe4495ba6b8ec1136051fb9","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-a96b2fe1fbe4495ba6b8ec1136051fb9","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_1"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}}],"mediaTypes":{"video":{"api":[1,2],"context":"outstream","mimes":["application/javascript","video/mp4","video/webm"],"minduration":0,"maxduration":15,"playerSize":[640,480],"protocols":[1,2,3,4,5,6]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-596a954310744f9e84f68386950d2c44","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_2"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-596a954310744f9e84f68386950d2c44","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-596a954310744f9e84f68386950d2c44","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_2"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}}],"mediaTypes":{"video":{"api":[1,2],"context":"outstream","mimes":["application/javascript","video/mp4","video/webm"],"minduration":0,"maxduration":15,"playerSize":[640,480],"protocols":[1,2,3,4,5,6]}}},{"code":"ad-adhesion-f78ea9310b864de891190811eb13d39e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#adhesion-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#adhesion-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407980","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_adhesion"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"adhesion"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349162,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[1,1]]}}}],"D":[{"code":"ad-fixed_bottom-1d9ca2cd72594bce833bd6ba30146371","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#fixed_bottom-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#fixed_bottom-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_fixedbottom_leaderboard_HDX"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"fixed_bottom"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349274,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"adzoneindex":"fixed_bottom_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_fixed_bottom_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-cc6add8a5b944bf09a8929508e50568d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_0"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-cc6add8a5b944bf09a8929508e50568d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-cc6add8a5b944bf09a8929508e50568d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_0"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}}],"mediaTypes":{"video":{"api":[1,2],"context":"outstream","mimes":["application/javascript","video/mp4","video/webm"],"minduration":0,"maxduration":15,"playerSize":[640,480],"protocols":[1,2,3,4,5,6]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-fd7fc70d0df547dcaa63430553337ac5","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_1"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-fd7fc70d0df547dcaa63430553337ac5","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-fd7fc70d0df547dcaa63430553337ac5","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-1"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_1_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_1"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}}],"mediaTypes":{"video":{"api":[1,2],"context":"outstream","mimes":["application/javascript","video/mp4","video/webm"],"minduration":0,"maxduration":15,"playerSize":[640,480],"protocols":[1,2,3,4,5,6]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-253f9f43e1c443ca82c261ab32d31f1e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"teads","params":{"placementId":"100612","pageId":"170914"}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407979","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_incontent_desktop"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_2"}},{"bidder":"pulsepoint","params":{"bidfloor":0.1,"cf":"728x90","cp":562127,"ct":736890}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[728,90]]}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-253f9f43e1c443ca82c261ab32d31f1e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}}],"mediaTypes":{"native":{"image":{"aspect_ratios":[{"min_height":400,"min_width":600,"ratio_height":2,"ratio_width":3}],"required":true,"sendId":true,"sizes":[600,400]},"title":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"clickUrl":{"required":true,"sendId":true},"sponsoredBy":{"len":80,"required":true,"sendId":true},"body":{"required":false,"sendId":true}}}},{"code":"ad-in_content-253f9f43e1c443ca82c261ab32d31f1e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#in_content-2"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","member":"8186","video":{"playback_method":"auto_play_sound_off","skippable":false},"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_in_content_2_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"in_content_2"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349159,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}}],"mediaTypes":{"video":{"api":[1,2],"context":"outstream","mimes":["application/javascript","video/mp4","video/webm"],"minduration":0,"maxduration":15,"playerSize":[640,480],"protocols":[1,2,3,4,5,6]}}},{"code":"ad-adhesion-f78ea9310b864de891190811eb13d39e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education","ortb2Imp":{"ext":{"gpid":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#adhesion-0","data":{"pbadslot":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education#adhesion-0"}}},"bids":[{"bidder":"rubicon","params":{"accountId":10348,"siteId":390758,"zoneId":2180000}},{"bidder":"pubmatic","params":{"adSlot":"4407980","pmzoneid":"psmag.com","publisherId":"156229"}},{"bidder":"triplelift","params":{"inventoryCode":"TheMaven_adhesion"}},{"bidder":"appnexus","params":{"allowSmallerSizes":true,"invCode":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_dt","member":"8186","keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"ix","params":{"id":"psmag.com_adhesion_0_dt","siteId":"812711"}},{"bidder":"yahoossp","params":{"dcn":"8a969d6501787859e95f5b60262d00bc","pos":"adhesion"}},{"bidder":"grid","params":{"uid":349162,"keywords":{"cm":"tempest","adzone":"adhesion","index":0,"adzoneindex":"adhesion_0","siteadzoneindex":"psmag.com_adhesion_0","path":"psmag.com/education","terms":["Education"],"pagetype":"richterm","cv":"politics"}}},{"bidder":"33across","params":{"siteId":"dDAkWSTCqr7iovrkHcnlxd","productId":"siab"}},{"bidder":"sovrn","params":{"tagid":"1019857"}}],"mediaTypes":{"banner":{"sizes":[[1,1]]}}}]},"unitVendorConfig":{},"timeout":1500,"sellerId":"26","isPermutiveEnabled":true,"pbjsConfig":{"contentItemId":"ci020b8c5f100126b7","productionDomain":"psmag.com","mavenChannel":"psmag.com","experimentString":null,"userSync":{"userIds":[{"name":"connectId","params":{"pixelId":58487},"storage":{"type":"html5","name":"connectid","expires":15}}]}},"videoTimeout":2100,"useGpt":true});</script><script>(function(workspaceApiKey, workspaceId, scriptSrc) {"use strict";Promise.all([window.GdprStatus.isApplicableSafe(),window.criticalElementsPromise]).then(function(values){var consentRequired=values[0];!function(e,o,n,i){if(!e){e=e||{},window.permutive=e,e.q=[];var t=function t(){return([1e7]+-1e3+-4e3+-8e3+-1e11).replace(/[018]/g,function(e){return(e^(window.crypto||window.msCrypto).getRandomValues(new Uint8Array(1))[0]&15>>e/4).toString(16)})};e.config=i||{},e.config.apiKey=o,e.config.workspaceId=n,e.config.environment=e.config.environment||"production",(window.crypto||window.msCrypto)&&(e.config.viewId=t());for(var g=["addon","identify","track","trigger","query","segment","segments","ready","on","once","user","consent"],r=0;r<g.length;r++){var w=g[r];e[w]=function(o){return function(){var n=Array.prototype.slice.call(arguments,0);e.q.push({functionName:o,arguments:n})}}(w)}}}(window.permutive,workspaceApiKey,workspaceId,{"consentRequired":consentRequired});window.googletag=window.googletag||{},window.googletag.cmd=window.googletag.cmd||[],window.googletag.cmd.push(function(){if(0===window.googletag.pubads().getTargeting("permutive").length){var _window$localStorage,_window$localStorage$,_window$localStorage2,_window$localStorage3;var e=(_window$localStorage=window.localStorage)===null||_window$localStorage===void 0?void 0:(_window$localStorage$=_window$localStorage.getItem)===null||_window$localStorage$===void 0?void 0:_window$localStorage$.call(_window$localStorage,"_pdfps");window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("permutive",e?JSON.parse(e):[]);var o=(_window$localStorage2=window.localStorage)===null||_window$localStorage2===void 0?void 0:(_window$localStorage3=_window$localStorage2.getItem)===null||_window$localStorage3===void 0?void 0:_window$localStorage3.call(_window$localStorage2,"permutive-id");o&&(window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("puid",o),window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("ptime",Date.now().toString())),window.permutive.config.viewId&&window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("prmtvvid",window.permutive.config.viewId),window.permutive.config.workspaceId&&window.googletag.pubads().setTargeting("prmtvwid",window.permutive.config.workspaceId)}});phxConfigQueue.push(function(){var _this=this;window.permutive.ready(function(){_this.identities.collectIdentities().then(function(identities){if(identities.length>0){window.permutive.identify(identities)}})["finally"](function(){window.permutive.addon("web",{page:{classifications_watson:{categories:"$alchemy_taxonomy",concepts:"$alchemy_concepts",emotion:"$alchemy_document_emotion",entities:"$alchemy_entities",keywords:"$alchemy_keywords",sentiment:"$alchemy_document_sentiment"}}})})},"initialised")});var e=document.createElement("script");e.async=true;e.src=scriptSrc;document.head.appendChild(e);if(consentRequired){window.GdprStatus.waitForConsentValue().then(function(){window.GdprStatus.isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes("permutive",["storage","advertising/basic"]).then(function(result){if(result){window.permutive.consent({opt_in:true,token:"CONSENT_GIVEN"})}else{window.permutive.consent({opt_in:false})}})})}});})("b71fc044-4cae-4225-b686-4012617b40c1","c97f7cbe-37c1-46b7-bef0-5c831be22e3e", "https://a9695278-4085-40b3-9f02-8d4c38a6ff01.edge.permutive.app/c97f7cbe-37c1-46b7-bef0-5c831be22e3e-web.js");</script><script>window.phxPageTarget = {config: {"global":{"config":{"networkCode":"88059007,2154169","adUnitPathTemplates":[{"type":"simple","key":"adSlotKey"},{"type":"simple","key":"basePath"},{"type":"simple","key":"section"}],"beacons":{"targetingParams":{"paramSeparators":{"ksg":":","terms":";"},"exclude":{"ag":true,"in":true,"pt":true,"et":true,"gd":true}}},"customTargetingTemplates":{"adindex":{"type":"simple","key":"index"},"adzone":{"type":"simple","key":"zone"},"adzoneindex":{"type":"simple","key":"zoneIndex"},"adzoneposition":{"type":"simple","key":"zonePosition"},"amznbid":{"type":"simple","key":"amznbid"},"amzniid":{"type":"simple","key":"amzniid"},"amznp":{"type":"simple","key":"amznp"},"amznsz":{"type":"simple","key":"amznsz"},"cm":{"type":"simple","key":"coalitionMember"},"hb_adid":{"type":"simple","key":"prebidAdId"},"hb_bidder":{"type":"simple","key":"prebidWinner"},"hb_pb":{"type":"simple","key":"prebidPriceBucket"},"hb_pbd":{"type":"simple","key":"prebidPriceBucketDollar"},"hb_size":{"type":"simple","key":"prebidAdSize"},"author_pageview":{"type":"simple","key":"authorPageview"},"position":{"type":"simple","key":"positionTarget"},"rid":{"type":"simple","key":"rid"},"siteadzoneindex":{"type":"simple","key":"siteZoneIndex"},"sponlineitemid":{"type":"simple","key":"sponsorLineItemId"},"sponsor":{"type":"simple","key":"sponsor"},"native_card_type":{"type":"simple","key":"nativeCardType"},"prebid_floor":{"type":"simple","key":"prebidFloor"}},"customTargetingPageTemplates":{"ag":{"type":"simple","key":"ag"},"author":{"type":"simple","key":"author"},"breakpoint":{"type":"simple","key":"breakpoint"},"channel":{"type":"simple","key":"channelCode"},"chars":{"type":"simple","key":"characterCount"},"correlator":{"type":"simple","key":"correlator"},"cv":{"type":"simple","key":"coreVertical"},"cs":{"type":"simple","key":"cs"},"direct":{"type":"simple","key":"directOnly"},"env":{"type":"simple","key":"env"},"et":{"type":"simple","key":"et"},"experiments":{"type":"simple","key":"experiments"},"feats":{"type":"simple","key":"trackedFeatures"},"gd":{"type":"simple","key":"gd"},"in":{"type":"simple","key":"in"},"ksg":{"type":"simple","key":"ksg"},"kuid":{"type":"simple","key":"kuid"},"lang":{"type":"simple","key":"languageCode"},"loggedin":{"type":"simple","key":"loggedIn"},"pagetype":{"type":"simple","key":"pageType"},"path":{"type":"simple","key":"path"},"pod":{"type":"simple","key":"pod"},"pt":{"type":"simple","key":"pt"},"referrer":{"type":"simple","key":"referrer"},"sv":{"type":"simple","key":"specialtyVerticals"},"terms":{"type":"simple","key":"terms"},"trending":{"type":"simple","key":"isTrendingContent"}},"expectedRefreshCount":6,"specialSizes":{"0":"fluid","1":"fluid","2":"fluid","3":"fluid","4":"fluid","320x50":"fixedBottomA","320x60":"fixedBottomA","300x50":"fixedBottomA","728x90":"fixedBottomD","768x66":"fixedBottomB","900x65":"fixedBottomD","970x90":"fixedBottomD","1x2":"siteSkin","1x1":"adhesion","940x529":"video","640x360":"outstream"},"lazyLoading":{"disabled":false,"thresholds":{"mobileScaling":3,"renderMarginPercent":150,"fetchMarginPercent":300}},"pageLoadTimeout":12000},"baseModel":{"coalitionMember":"tempest","hostname":"psmag.com","adSlotKey":"psmag.com","basePath":null,"path":"/education","channelCode":"web","languageCode":"en","directOnly":0,"author":null,"pageType":"section","section":["education"],"terms":[],"coreVertical":"politics","specialtyVerticals":[],"env":"prod","isTrendingContent":"0","experiments":null}},"sizedSlots":[{"config":{"sizes":[[320,50],[320,60],[300,50]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomA"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-eae660fbcaf54969a95a28792bca5054","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[768,66]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomB"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-078c74fc1474463f8bd9670cfd25173a","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[900,65],[970,90]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomC"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-0a451b5695604c78ade439fdbad638ab","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[900,65],[970,90]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomD"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-1d9ca2cd72594bce833bd6ba30146371","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-4196fa807ecf4a25a2c3fb6a72168125","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-d8c40617282d41da85c4d04fe46bc163","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-cc14dff601ce45adb7dcbcbc80a6b42d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-cc6add8a5b944bf09a8929508e50568d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-219c92ad79054ccdb03c895ff9c73587","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-a5aa41619e8f4e66b98e84224bc568ec","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-a96b2fe1fbe4495ba6b8ec1136051fb9","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-fd7fc70d0df547dcaa63430553337ac5","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-8dd3920542f541988e801159d6e1c495","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-0e660040f13a460c978a24cc26824c31","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-596a954310744f9e84f68386950d2c44","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-253f9f43e1c443ca82c261ab32d31f1e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},{"config":{"sizes":[[1,1]]},"model":{"zone":"adhesion","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"adhesion"}],"screenSizes":null,"slotModel":{"zone":"adhesion","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-adhesion-f78ea9310b864de891190811eb13d39e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"}],"outOfPageSlots":[],"dynamicSlots":[]}};</script><script>var phxAdvertisingQueue = window.phxAdvertisingQueue || [];
var phxAdServerQueue = window.phxAdServerQueue || [];
</script><script async src="/runtime/gamma.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script async src="/runtime/webads.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script>var googletag = googletag || {};googletag.cmd = googletag.cmd || [];</script><script async src="https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/tag/js/gpt.js"></script><script async src="/runtime/delta.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script>if (window.phxPageTarget) {
    phxAdvertisingQueue.push(function () {
        this.beginPage(window.phxPageTarget.config);
    });
}</script><script>(function() {
    window._comscore = window._comscore || [];
    var comscoreTag = {
        c1: '2',
        c2: '27019031',
    };
    var campaignId = '';
    var siteUrl = '';
    if (campaignId || siteUrl) {
        comscoreTag.c3 = campaignId;
        comscoreTag.c4 = siteUrl ? encodeURIComponent(siteUrl) : '';
    }
    var brand = '';
    if (brand) {
        comscoreTag.c6 = brand;
    }
    window._comscore.push(comscoreTag);
})();</script><script>(function() {
    var _load = function () {
        var s = document.createElement("script"), el = document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];
        s.src = "https://sb.scorecardresearch.com/beacon.js";
        el.parentNode.insertBefore(s, el);
    };
    var gdpr = window.GdprStatus;
    Promise.all([gdpr.isApplicable(), window.criticalElementsPromise]).then(function(values) {
        var isApplicable = values[0];
        if (isApplicable) {
            //- This causes the Comscore script to delay until consent state
            //- is known; the rest of the code above is benign in the event that
            //- consent has not been given.
            gdpr.waitForConsentValue().then(function () {
                gdpr.isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes(GdprStatus.VENDOR_IDS.comscore, GdprStatus.PURPOSE_IDS.measurement)
                .then(function(value) {
                    if (value) {
                        _load();
                    }
                });
            });
        } else {
            _load();
        }
    });
})();</script><base href="/"><meta charset="utf-8"><meta name="referrer" content="unsafe-url"><meta http-equiv="cleartype" content="on"><meta name="HandheldFriendly" content="True"><meta name="MobileOptimized" content="320"><meta name="apple-mobile-web-app-capable" content="no"><meta name="apple-mobile-web-app-status-bar-style" content="black"><link rel="apple-touch-icon" href="/site/images/apple-touch-icon.png?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="57x57" href="/site/images/apple-touch-icon-57x57-precomposed.png?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="72x72" href="/site/images/apple-touch-icon-72x72-precomposed.png?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="114x114" href="/site/images/apple-touch-icon-114x114-precomposed.png?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"><link rel="manifest" href="/site.webmanifest"><meta name="format-detection" content="telephone=no"><meta name="format-detection" content="address=no"><meta name="google-site-verification" content="ZgvHOWx_79PGGGpfWBMphtj46BEry3GMnUTgDsx7xIw"><meta name="msvalidate.01" content="565AA37CB662E60BF24DDCABEC686D8F"><meta name="generator" content="Tempest - maven.io"><link rel="schema.dcterms" href="http://purl.org/dc/terms/"><meta name="pinterest" content="nohover"></head><body class="mm-alt-demo-data-enabled mm-use-hummingbird-enabled has-legacy-nav is-sidebar-enabled is-balloon-header-active" phx-page-manager><script async src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=UA-1778701-17"></script><script>window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || [];
function gtag(){dataLayer.push(arguments);}
gtag('js', new Date());
</script><script>window.googleAnalyticsConfig = {"initialModel":{"title":"Education","pageType":"Rich Term Page","mavenPageType":"section","exclusiveContentType":"free","isTrendingContent":"0","path":"/education","contributorContent":0,"subscriptionStatus":"Unsubscribed","monetization":"1","channelName":"Web","coreVertical":"politics","primaryDomain":"psmag.com","mavenChannel":"psmag.com","contentItemId":"ci020b8c5f100126b7","siteType":null,"premiumDetail":0,"features":""},"trackers":[{"name":"_tempestTracker","id":"UA-1778701-17","cookieDomain":"psmag.com","sendEvents":true,"setFieldValues":true,"customDimensionMap":{"pageType":1,"parentSectionName":2,"authorName":3,"publicationQuarter":4,"originalPublishDate":7,"premiumDetail":9,"channelName":11,"subscriptionStatus":12,"sectionPath":13,"eeaStatus":14,"trackedRichTermNames":16,"trackedExtendedAttributes":17,"primaryDomain":21,"mavenChannel":22,"coreVertical":23,"specialtyVerticals":24,"hasMavenUid":29,"author":30,"demonetizedReason":32,"sanitizedTitle":33,"videoTitle":34,"videoAuthorName":35,"monetization":36,"memberId":37,"contentItemId":38,"gaUserId":39,"contributorContent":42,"features":43,"mavenPageType":44,"suid":46,"membershipOfferSlug":48,"membershipProductName":49,"membershipProductCode":50,"membershipPlanCodes":51,"exclusiveContentType":52,"siteType":53,"recommendationAlgorithm":54,"trwDialogueLink":55,"experiments":56,"breakpoint":57,"characterCount":58,"isTrendingContent":59,"correlator":60},"customEventDimensionMap":{"videoTitle":34,"videoAuthorName":35,"videoMonetizationState":47}},{"cookieDomain":"psmag.com","sendEvents":true,"setFieldValues":true,"contentItemIdPrefix":null,"customDimensionMap":{"subscriptionStatus":null,"mavenPageType":null,"trackedRichTermNames":1,"sectionPath":null,"publicationQuarter":null,"memberId":null,"recommendationAlgorithm":null,"authorName":2,"contentItemId":null,"pageType":null,"channelName":null,"parentSectionName":null,"gaUserId":null},"name":"_siteTracker0","id":"UA-3354517-5"}],"type":"gtag","usePublisherGtag":false,"ids":["UA-1778701-17","UA-3354517-5"]} || {trackers: []};
var googleAnalyticsConfigPromiseResolved;
var googleAnalyticsPromiseResolved;
window.googleAnalyticsConfigPromise = new Promise(function(resolve, reject) {
      googleAnalyticsConfigPromiseResolved = resolve;
});
 window.googleAnalyticsPromise = new Promise(function(resolve, reject) {
      googleAnalyticsPromiseResolved = resolve;
});
Promise.all([window.GdprStatus.isApplicableSafe(), window.GdprStatus.getMavenUidSafe(), window.GdprStatus.demonetizedReasonSafe(), window.TempestIdentityPromise, window.criticalElementsPromise]).then(function(results) {
   var isApplicable = results[0];
   var mavenUid = results[1];
   var demonetizedReason = results[2];
   var ti = results[3];
  (function (googleAnalyticsConfig, breakpoints, breakpointHeights, experimentString) {"use strict";function ownKeys(object,enumerableOnly){var keys=Object.keys(object);if(Object.getOwnPropertySymbols){var symbols=Object.getOwnPropertySymbols(object);enumerableOnly&&(symbols=symbols.filter(function(sym){return Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(object,sym).enumerable})),keys.push.apply(keys,symbols)}return keys}function _objectSpread(target){for(var i=1;i<arguments.length;i++){var source=null!=arguments[i]?arguments[i]:{};i%2?ownKeys(Object(source),!0).forEach(function(key){_defineProperty(target,key,source[key])}):Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptors?Object.defineProperties(target,Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptors(source)):ownKeys(Object(source)).forEach(function(key){Object.defineProperty(target,key,Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(source,key))})}return target}function _defineProperty(obj,key,value){if(key in obj){Object.defineProperty(obj,key,{value:value,enumerable:true,configurable:true,writable:true})}else{obj[key]=value}return obj}function getCurrentBreakpoint(){var breakpoint;var width=window.innerWidth;var height=window.innerHeight;for(var possibleBreakpoint in breakpoints){if(width>=breakpoints[possibleBreakpoint]){if(!breakpointHeights[possibleBreakpoint]||height>=breakpointHeights[possibleBreakpoint]){breakpoint=possibleBreakpoint}}}return breakpoint}var updateModel=function updateModel(model){var _model$characterCount,_window$localStorage;model.hasMavenUid=mavenUid?"1":"0";model.demonetizedReason=demonetizedReason||"0";model.correlator=mavenCorrelator;var moreFeatures=phxTrackedFeatures?Object.keys(phxTrackedFeatures).map(function(name){return"".concat(name,":").concat(phxTrackedFeatures[name]?"1":"0")}).join(";"):"";model.features=model.features?"".concat(model.features,";").concat(moreFeatures):moreFeatures;model.features=model.features.split(";").sort().join(";");model.breakpoint=getCurrentBreakpoint();model.experiments=experimentString;model.eeaStatus=isApplicable?"1":"0";model.characterCount=(_model$characterCount=model.characterCountByBreakpoint)===null||_model$characterCount===void 0?void 0:_model$characterCount[model.breakpoint];var userStatus=window.phxGetLoggedInStatus();if((userStatus===null||userStatus===void 0?void 0:userStatus["type"])==="rgis"){model.memberId=userStatus["id"];model.memberIdSource="1"}else if((_window$localStorage=window.localStorage)!==null&&_window$localStorage!==void 0&&_window$localStorage.getItem("possibleMemberId")){var _window$localStorage2;model.memberId=(_window$localStorage2=window.localStorage)===null||_window$localStorage2===void 0?void 0:_window$localStorage2.getItem("possibleMemberId");model.memberIdSource="0"}if(window.URLSearchParams){var queryParams=new URLSearchParams(window.location.search);if(queryParams.has("suid")){model.suid=queryParams.get("suid")}if(queryParams.has("trw")){model.trwDialogueLink=queryParams.get("trw")}}return model};googleAnalyticsConfig.sendPageView=function(_model,_analyticType){var model=updateModel(_model);var analyticsData=[];for(var i=0;i<googleAnalyticsConfig.trackers.length;i++){var tracker=googleAnalyticsConfig.trackers[i];var config={};var customMap={};var setters={};var prefix="";if(tracker.name){config.name=tracker.name;prefix=tracker.name+"."}if(tracker.cookieDomain){config.cookieDomain=tracker.cookieDomain}if(tracker.sampleRate){config.sampleRate=tracker.sampleRate}if(isApplicable){config.storage="none";config.storeGac=false;setters.displayFeaturesTask=null}if(tracker.name==="_tempestTracker"&&mavenUid){setters.userId=mavenUid}setters.page=model.path;setters.title=model.title;setters.anonymizeIp=true;var cd=tracker.customDimensionMap;for(var k in cd){if(!cd[k]||!cd.hasOwnProperty(k)){continue}var val=model[k];if(k==="contentItemId"&&tracker.contentItemIdPrefix){val=tracker.contentItemIdPrefix+"-"+val}else if(k==="features"&&typeof val==="string"){if(!window.mavenUidLongerTimeout){val=val.replace("use-longer-uid-timeout:1","use-longer-uid-timeout:0")}}if(val!==undefined&&val!==null&&val!==""){customMap["dimension".concat(cd[k])]=val}}if(!tracker.initialCustomMap){tracker.initialCustomMap=customMap}analyticsData.push({config:config,id:tracker.id,prefix:prefix,setters:setters,customMap:customMap,initialCustomMap:tracker.initialCustomMap})}var analyticsType=_analyticType||googleAnalyticsConfig.type;var GTAG_EVENT_HANDLER=function GTAG_EVENT_HANDLER(data,type){var config=data.config,setters=data.setters,id=data.id,customMap=data.customMap,initialCustomMap=data.initialCustomMap;var extendedCustomMap=_objectSpread(_objectSpread({},initialCustomMap),{},{page_path:setters.page,page_location:window.location.href,page_title:setters.title});if(!googleAnalyticsConfig.initialsetup[type][id]){gtag("config",id,_objectSpread(_objectSpread(_objectSpread(_objectSpread(_objectSpread({},config),setters),customMap),extendedCustomMap),{},{anonymize_ip:setters.anonymizeIp,user_id:setters.userId}));googleAnalyticsConfig.initialsetup[type][id]=true}else{gtag("event","page_view",_objectSpread(_objectSpread({},extendedCustomMap),{},{send_to:id}))}gtag("get",id,"client_id",function(clientId){model.gaUserId=clientId})};if(["ga4","ga-ga4","ga4-gtag"].includes(analyticsType)){for(var _i=0;_i<analyticsData.length;_i++){var _analyticsData$_i=analyticsData[_i],_config=_analyticsData$_i.config,id=_analyticsData$_i.id;if(id==="G-CY0JQWZCM6"||_config.name==="_publisherPersonalGA4Tracker"){GTAG_EVENT_HANDLER(analyticsData[_i],"ga4")}}}if(["gtag","ga-gtag","ga4-gtag"].includes(analyticsType)){for(var _i2=0;_i2<analyticsData.length;_i2++){var _id=analyticsData[_i2].id;if(_id==="G-CY0JQWZCM6"){continue}GTAG_EVENT_HANDLER(analyticsData[_i2],"gtag")}}if(["ga","ga-gtag","ga-ga4"].includes(analyticsType)){ga(function(){for(var _i3=0;_i3<analyticsData.length;_i3++){var _analyticsData$_i2=analyticsData[_i3],_config2=_analyticsData$_i2.config,_prefix=_analyticsData$_i2.prefix,_setters=_analyticsData$_i2.setters,_id2=_analyticsData$_i2.id,_customMap=_analyticsData$_i2.customMap;if(_id2==="G-CY0JQWZCM6"||_config2.name==="_publisherPersonalGA4Tracker"){continue}var props=_objectSpread(_objectSpread({},_setters),_customMap);if(!googleAnalyticsConfig.initialsetup.ga[_id2]){ga("create",_id2,_config2);googleAnalyticsConfig.initialsetup.ga[_id2]=true}model.gaUserId=ga.getAll()[0].get("clientId");for(var key in props){ga("".concat(_prefix,"set"),key,props[key])}ga("".concat(_prefix,"send"),"pageview",model.path)}})}};googleAnalyticsConfig.initialModel.positionInSession="initial";googleAnalyticsConfig.initialsetup={gtag:{},ga:{},ga4:{}};googleAnalyticsConfig.sendPageView(googleAnalyticsConfig.initialModel);googleAnalyticsConfigPromiseResolved();  })(window.googleAnalyticsConfig, {"A":0,"B":675,"C":1240,"D":1680}, {"D":1050}, null);
});</script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/PhoenixGoogleAnalytics.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><script>window.phoenixTrackClickEvent = function(el) {
    window.phoenixTrackClickEvent._q = window.phoenixTrackClickEvent._q || [];
    window.phoenixTrackClickEvent._q.push(el);
    return true;
}
</script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/analytics.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><script>(function() {
    var _load = function () {
        !function(a,b,c,d,e,f){a.ddjskey=e;a.ddoptions=f||null;var m=b.createElement(c),n=b.getElementsByTagName(c)[0];m.async=1,m.src=d,n.parentNode.insertBefore(m,n)}(window,document,"script","https://js.datadome.co/tags.js", "2AC20A4365547ED96AE26618B66966", { ajaxListenerPath: true });
    };
    Promise.all([window.criticalElementsPromise]).then(function() {
        _load();
    });
})();</script><a class="is-skip-link" href="#main-content">Skip to main content</a><phoenix-page><phoenix-style href="/site/styles/print.min.css?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483" media="print" delay-load load-after-critical></phoenix-style><div id="lyra-wrapper"><phoenix-overlay class="m-off-canvas m-overlay is-left-drawer" overlay-name="offcanvas" role="navigation" style="visibility: hidden;" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true"><phoenix-notifier event-name="phoenix:overlay" events="click mousewheel scroll touchmove DOMMouseScroll"><div class="m-overlay-mask"></div></phoenix-notifier><div class="m-off-canvas--menu m-overlay--content"><div class="m-vertical-nav m-off-canvas--scroller-no-footer"><div class="m-off-canvas--header has-search"><div class="m-off-canvas--header-flagship"></div><div class="m-off-canvas--header-auth"></div><div class="m-off-canvas--header-close"><phoenix-notifier event-name="phoenix:overlay"><button class="m-overlay--close mm-overlay--close-static m-icon-button m-off-canvas--menu-close-btn" aria-label="Close Menu" type="button"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon mm-icon-button--static" icon="ico_close"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_close"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_close"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></phoenix-icon-fallback></button></phoenix-notifier></div><div class="m-off-canvas--header-search"><form class="m-off-canvas--search" role="form" action="/search" method="GET"><input class="m-off-canvas--search-input" aria-label="Search" placeholder="Search" name="query"><button class="m-off-canvas--search-button m-icon-button" aria-label="Submit Search" type="submit"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon mm-icon-button--size-reset" icon="ico_search"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_search"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_search"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></phoenix-icon-fallback></button></form></div></div><div class="m-off-canvas--scroll-wrapper"><nav role="navigation"><phoenix-accordion class="m-accordion mn-accordion--off-canvas" id="offcanvas0-accordion"><ul><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-0" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/news" title="News in Brief">News in Brief</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-1" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/economics" title="Economics">Economics</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-2" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/education" title="Education">Education</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-3" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/environment" title="Environment">Environment</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-4" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/social-justice" title="Social Justice">Social Justice</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-5" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/tag/features-investigations" title="Features &amp; Investigations">Features &amp; Investigations</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-6" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/ideas" title="Ideas">Ideas</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li><li><phoenix-accordion-item class="m-accordion--item" id="offcanvas0-7" accordion-id="offcanvas0-accordion"><div class="m-accordion--item-heading"><a class="m-accordion--item-heading-link" href="/audio-podcasts" title="Audio">Audio</a></div></phoenix-accordion-item></li></ul></phoenix-accordion><ul class="m-off-canvas--social-links"><li><a class="m-icon-button m-off-canvas--social-link" aria-label="facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/PacificStand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_facebook"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_facebook"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li><li><a class="m-icon-button m-off-canvas--social-link" aria-label="linkedin" href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/pacific-standard-magazine" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_linkedin"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_linkedin"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li><li><a class="m-icon-button m-off-canvas--social-link" aria-label="instagram" href="https://www.instagram.com/pacificstand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_instagram"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_instagram"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li><li><a class="m-icon-button m-off-canvas--social-link" aria-label="twitter" href="https://twitter.com/pacificstand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_twitter"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_twitter"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li></ul><div class="m-off-canvas--maven-logo-wrapper"><a rel="noopener" target="_blank"></a></div><ul class="m-off-canvas--nav-secondary m-vertical-nav--menu m-vertical-nav-secondary" phx-track-id="Nav List"><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/about" title="About" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>About</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/audience-influence" title="Impact" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Impact</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/contact-us" title="Contact" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Contact</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/write-us" title="Pitching" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Pitching</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/fellowship-program" title="Careers" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Careers</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/advertise" title="Partnerships" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Partnerships</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="/page/privacy-statement" title="Terms of Use" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Terms of Use</em></a></li><li phx-track-id="Item"><a href="https://www.saymedia.com/privacy" target="_blank" rel="noopener" title="Platform Privacy" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Name"><em>Platform Privacy</em></a></li></ul></nav></div></div></div></phoenix-overlay><phoenix-overlay class="m-overlay is-right-drawer" overlay-name="right-drawer" style="visibility: hidden;" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true"><phoenix-notifier event-name="phoenix:overlay" events="click mousewheel scroll touchmove DOMMouseScroll"><div class="m-overlay-mask"></div></phoenix-notifier><div class="m-overlay--content m-nav-widget"><phoenix-notifier event-name="phoenix:overlay"><button class="m-overlay--close m-icon-button" aria-label="Close Menu" type="button"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_close"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_close"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_close"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></phoenix-icon-fallback></button></phoenix-notifier><div class="m-nav-widget--header"><div class="m-nav-widget--header-title"><strong></strong><span class="m-nav-widget--header-caption"></span></div><div class="m-nav-widget--header-subtitle">August 23, 2023</div></div><div class="m-nav-widget--content"></div></div></phoenix-overlay><div class="m-page-wrapper is-below-header-ad"><div class="m-ad-adhesion" id="ad-adhesion-f78ea9310b864de891190811eb13d39e"></div><phoenix-sticky-nav class="m-site-nav l-sticky-navbar mm-site-nav--sticky-nav" nav-target=".m-header--navbar" style="visibility: hidden;" tabindex="-1" aria-hidden="true"><phoenix-notifier class="m-site-nav--icon-button m-site-nav--menu" event-name="phoenix:overlay" event-value="offcanvas"><button class="m-off-canvas--toggle m-icon-button" aria-label="Menu" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="offcanvas" tabindex="0"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon m-site-nav--menu-icon" icon="ico_hamburger_flipped"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_hamburger_flipped"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></button></phoenix-notifier><div class="m-site-nav--menu-items"><a class="m-site-nav--logo" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="logo" href="/"><img src="https://psmag.com/.image/cs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good/MTQ2MTgzMzA3OTc1OTkyODY0/navbar.png" alt="Pacific Standard home"></a><div class="m-navbar m-site-nav--links-container"><ul class="m-navbar--links"><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/news" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">News in Brief</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/economics" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Economics</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/education" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Education</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/environment" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Environment</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/social-justice" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Social Justice</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/tag/features-investigations" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Features &amp; Investigations</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/ideas" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Ideas</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/audio-podcasts" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Audio</span></a></li></ul></div></div><div class="m-site-nav--search-group"><div class="m-site-nav--search m-site-nav--icon"><a class="m-icon-button has-underline-on-hover" aria-label="Search" href="/search" title="Search" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="search"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_search"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_search"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div></div></phoenix-sticky-nav><div class="m-header-components"><phoenix-intersection-notifier in-view="phoenix:header:in" out-of-view="phoenix:header:out" threshold="0.1"><header class="m-header mm-header-large mm-header--left mm-header--content-detail" phx-track-id="header"><section class="m-header--container"><ul class="m-header--social-nav"><li class="m-header--link m-header--social-facebook" phx-track-id="social"><a aria-label="facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/PacificStand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="facebook-follow"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_facebook"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_facebook"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li><li class="m-header--link m-header--social-linkedin" phx-track-id="social"><a aria-label="linkedin" href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/pacific-standard-magazine" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="linkedin-follow"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_linkedin"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_linkedin"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li><li class="m-header--link m-header--social-instagram" phx-track-id="social"><a aria-label="instagram" href="https://www.instagram.com/pacificstand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="instagram-follow"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_instagram"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_instagram"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li><li class="m-header--link m-header--social-twitter" phx-track-id="social"><a aria-label="twitter" href="https://twitter.com/pacificstand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="twitter-follow"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_twitter"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_twitter"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></li></ul><div class="m-header--main"><a class="m-header--logo" href="/" aria-label="Pacific Standard" phx-track-id="logo" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-picture class="m-background mm-background--site-logo not-size-a"><picture class="m-header--logo-picture-block is-waiting-to-load" aria-hidden="true"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_400/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.webp 400w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_700/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.webp 700w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_800/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.webp 800w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_1400/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.webp 1400w"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_400/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.png 400w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_700/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.png 700w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_800/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.png 800w, https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_1400/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.png 1400w"><img class="m-background--image" decoding="async" nopin="true" src="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_700/MTQ2NzYyMDc3MDk5MjcxOTc5/large.png" srcset="" alt="Pacific Standard home"></picture></phoenix-picture></a><phoenix-import class="m-header--coverlines-container" src="/.api/coverlines" phx-track-id="coverline"></phoenix-import></div></section><div class="m-site-nav m-header--navbar mm-site-nav--protected mm-site-nav--condensed" nav-target=".m-header--navbar"><phoenix-notifier class="m-site-nav--icon-button m-site-nav--menu" event-name="phoenix:overlay" event-value="offcanvas"><button class="m-off-canvas--toggle m-icon-button" aria-label="Menu" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="offcanvas" tabindex="0"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon m-site-nav--menu-icon" icon="ico_hamburger_flipped"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_hamburger_flipped"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></button></phoenix-notifier><div class="m-site-nav--menu-items"><a class="m-site-nav--logo" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="logo" href="/"><img src="https://psmag.com/.image/cs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good/MTQ2MTgzMzA3OTc1OTkyODY0/navbar.png" alt="Pacific Standard home" style="max-height:122px;"></a><div class="m-navbar m-site-nav--links-container"><ul class="m-navbar--links"><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/news" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">News in Brief</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/economics" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Economics</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/education" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Education</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/environment" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Environment</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/social-justice" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Social Justice</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/tag/features-investigations" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Features &amp; Investigations</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/ideas" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Ideas</span></a></li><li class="m-navbar--link" phx-track-id="section"><a class="m-navbar--link-item" href="/audio-podcasts" target="" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><span class="m-navbar--link-text">Audio</span></a></li></ul></div></div><div class="m-site-nav--search-group"><div class="m-site-nav--search m-site-nav--icon"><a class="m-icon-button has-underline-on-hover" aria-label="Search" href="/search" title="Search" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="search"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg" icon="ico_search"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_search"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div></div></div></header></phoenix-intersection-notifier></div><section class="m-page-container trackable click"></section><div class="m-page" ng-class="pageClasses" id="main-content"><script type="application/json" id="pageItemData">{"id":"ci020b8c5f100126b7","isDetailPage":false,"objectType":"ContentRichTerm","originalPublicationTimestamp":"2017-05-24T22:30:09Z","path":"/education","publicationTimestamp":"2017-05-24T22:30:09Z","title":"Education","viewProperties":{"viewMeta":{"showLimitedSiteFooter":false,"suppressDisplayAds":false,"disableSiteFooter":false,"suppressContentRecommendations":false,"promoTwitter":{"teaser":null,"title":null,"imageId":null},"disableSiteHeader":false,"promoFacebook":{"teaser":null,"title":null,"imageId":null}},"rss":{"collection":{"filter":{"term":"ci020b8c5f100126b7","type":"ContentArticle"}}},"analyticsModel":{"title":"Education","pageType":"Rich Term Page","mavenPageType":"section","exclusiveContentType":"free"}},"commentsEnabled":true,"disqusId":"8abe6483-40d0-11e7-bae9-066758d48690","isCanvas":true,"metaDescription":"","promoTitle":"Education","slug":"education","teaser":"","hasGallery":false,"associatedRichTerms":[]}</script><section class="m-sub-navigation m-component-stack mm-component-stack--is-stacked"><div class="m-sub-navigation--container"><phoenix-breadcrumbs class="m-sub-navigation--items m-breadcrumbs" id="subnav"><phoenix-notifier event-name="phoenix:breadcrumbs:toggle" event-value="subnav" events="click"><button class="m-breadcrumbs--expand-button m-icon-button mm-icon-button--small-icon is-hidden" aria-label="{{isCollapsed ? 'Expand Breadcrumbs' : 'Collapse Breadcrumbs'}}"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_angle_double_right"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_angle_double_right"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></button></phoenix-notifier><phoenix-breadcrumbs-container class="m-breadcrumbs--container"><ul class="m-breadcrumbs--items" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/BreadcrumbList"><li class="m-breadcrumbs--item" phoenix-breadcrumbs-item itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem"><a class="m-breadcrumbs--link m-sub-navigation--link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" href="https://psmag.com" itemid="https://psmag.com" itemprop="item" content="https://psmag.com" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/WebPage"><span itemprop="name">Home</span></a><meta itemprop="position" content="1"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-breadcrumbs--divider" icon="ico_angle_right" aria-hidden="true"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_angle_right"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></li><li class="m-breadcrumbs--item" phoenix-breadcrumbs-item itemprop="itemListElement" itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/ListItem"><span class="m-breadcrumbs--link is-inactive" itemprop="name">Education</span><meta itemprop="position" content="2"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-breadcrumbs--divider" icon="ico_angle_right" aria-hidden="true"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_angle_right"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></li></ul></phoenix-breadcrumbs-container></phoenix-breadcrumbs></div></section><section class="m-component-stack mm-component-stack--is-stacked"><div class="m-hub-header mm-hub-header--extra-small"><div class="m-hub-header--item m-hub-header--title"><h1 class="m-hub-header--title-heading" role="heading"><span>Education</span></h1></div><div class="m-hub-header--item m-hub-header--body"><div class="m-hub-header--body-content"></div></div></div></section><section class="m-list-hub m-component-stack mm-component-stack--is-stacked mm-component-stack--has-footer"><phoenix-hub class="m-card-group--container" data-group-size="6" data-first-group-size="6"><section class="m-card-group mm-card-group--has-heroes"><phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking class="m-card-group--content l-grid lm-grid--density-single-column lm-grid--standard-cards" config="{&quot;siteBasePath&quot;:null,&quot;size&quot;:6,&quot;widgetName&quot;:&quot;tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1&quot;}"><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/remembering-the-legislation-that-kept-northern-schools-segregated" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/remembering-the-legislation-that-kept-northern-schools-segregated','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="0"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/remembering-the-legislation-that-kept-northern-schools-segregated" title="Remembering the Legislation That Kept Northern Schools Segregated" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY1NzExMDg5NDgzNTI0MDE5/gettyimages-164236039.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY1NzExMDg5NDgzNTI0MDE5/gettyimages-164236039.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY1NzExMDg5NDgzNTI0MDE5/gettyimages-164236039.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY1NzExMDg5NDgzNTI0MDE5/gettyimages-164236039.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY1NzExMDg5NDgzNTI0MDE5/gettyimages-164236039.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY1NzExMDg5NDgzNTI0MDE5/gettyimages-164236039.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTY1NzExMDg5NDgzNTI0MDE5/gettyimages-164236039.jpg" srcset="" alt="Jean De Lafayette Elementary School in Chicago, Illinois."></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/remembering-the-legislation-that-kept-northern-schools-segregated"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Remembering the Legislation That Kept Northern Schools Segregated</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">The Milliken v. Bradley ruling sanctioned a form of segregation that has allowed suburbs to escape being included in court-ordered desegregation and busing plans with nearby cities.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/jon-hale" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Jon Hale</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/as-schools-try-to-become-more-culturally-inclusive-some-teachers-arent-buying-in" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/as-schools-try-to-become-more-culturally-inclusive-some-teachers-arent-buying-in','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="1"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/as-schools-try-to-become-more-culturally-inclusive-some-teachers-arent-buying-in" title="As Schools Try to Become More Culturally Inclusive, Some Teachers Aren't Buying in" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY1NjkwNjc2NTc3NTc2NzQx/jeffrey-hamilton-jrre6er0py0-unsplash.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY1NjkwNjc2NTc3NTc2NzQx/jeffrey-hamilton-jrre6er0py0-unsplash.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY1NjkwNjc2NTc3NTc2NzQx/jeffrey-hamilton-jrre6er0py0-unsplash.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY1NjkwNjc2NTc3NTc2NzQx/jeffrey-hamilton-jrre6er0py0-unsplash.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY1NjkwNjc2NTc3NTc2NzQx/jeffrey-hamilton-jrre6er0py0-unsplash.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY1NjkwNjc2NTc3NTc2NzQx/jeffrey-hamilton-jrre6er0py0-unsplash.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTY1NjkwNjc2NTc3NTc2NzQx/jeffrey-hamilton-jrre6er0py0-unsplash.jpg" srcset="" alt="Classroom"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/as-schools-try-to-become-more-culturally-inclusive-some-teachers-arent-buying-in"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">As Schools Try to Become More Culturally Inclusive, Some Teachers Aren't Buying in</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">A Delaware high school led trainings on the impact of race on learning to try to better serve their student population, resulting in controversy.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/kelly-field" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Kelly Field</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/how-should-teachers-deal-with-distracting-technology-in-the-classroom" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/how-should-teachers-deal-with-distracting-technology-in-the-classroom','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="2"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/how-should-teachers-deal-with-distracting-technology-in-the-classroom" title="How Should Teachers Deal With Distracting Technology in the Classroom?" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY1MjQ3NDQ0Mjc0MTI4MTg0/miguel-henriques--8atmwer8bi-unsplash.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY1MjQ3NDQ0Mjc0MTI4MTg0/miguel-henriques--8atmwer8bi-unsplash.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY1MjQ3NDQ0Mjc0MTI4MTg0/miguel-henriques--8atmwer8bi-unsplash.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY1MjQ3NDQ0Mjc0MTI4MTg0/miguel-henriques--8atmwer8bi-unsplash.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY1MjQ3NDQ0Mjc0MTI4MTg0/miguel-henriques--8atmwer8bi-unsplash.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY1MjQ3NDQ0Mjc0MTI4MTg0/miguel-henriques--8atmwer8bi-unsplash.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTY1MjQ3NDQ0Mjc0MTI4MTg0/miguel-henriques--8atmwer8bi-unsplash.jpg" srcset="" alt="College lecture"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/how-should-teachers-deal-with-distracting-technology-in-the-classroom"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">How Should Teachers Deal With Distracting Technology in the Classroom?</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">A new study finds students believe it is a teacher's responsibility to get them to not use technology for purposes unrelated to class.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/james-mcwilliams" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By James McWilliams</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/taking-a-music-course-could-help-students-boost-grades-in-other-subjects" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/taking-a-music-course-could-help-students-boost-grades-in-other-subjects','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="3"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/taking-a-music-course-could-help-students-boost-grades-in-other-subjects" title="A Major New Study Confirms the Academic Benefits of Music Education" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY1MDM1NjMzNjY2OTU5MzU3/dayne-topkin-cb10k2ugb-4-unsplash.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY1MDM1NjMzNjY2OTU5MzU3/dayne-topkin-cb10k2ugb-4-unsplash.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY1MDM1NjMzNjY2OTU5MzU3/dayne-topkin-cb10k2ugb-4-unsplash.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY1MDM1NjMzNjY2OTU5MzU3/dayne-topkin-cb10k2ugb-4-unsplash.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY1MDM1NjMzNjY2OTU5MzU3/dayne-topkin-cb10k2ugb-4-unsplash.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY1MDM1NjMzNjY2OTU5MzU3/dayne-topkin-cb10k2ugb-4-unsplash.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTY1MDM1NjMzNjY2OTU5MzU3/dayne-topkin-cb10k2ugb-4-unsplash.jpg" srcset="" alt="music education"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/taking-a-music-course-could-help-students-boost-grades-in-other-subjects"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Taking a Music Course Could Help Students Boost Grades in Other Subjects</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Research on 112,000 Canadian students finds that high schoolers who took more music courses did better in math, science, and English.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/tomjacobs" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Tom Jacobs</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/thousands-of-transborder-students-commute-to-american-colleges-from-mexico-every-day" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/thousands-of-transborder-students-commute-to-american-colleges-from-mexico-every-day','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="4"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/thousands-of-transborder-students-commute-to-american-colleges-from-mexico-every-day" title="Thousands of 'Transborder' Students Commute to American Colleges From Mexico Every Day" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY0ODc3NTI3ODY3NzI4OTkx/gettyimages-1053652372.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY0ODc3NTI3ODY3NzI4OTkx/gettyimages-1053652372.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY0ODc3NTI3ODY3NzI4OTkx/gettyimages-1053652372.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY0ODc3NTI3ODY3NzI4OTkx/gettyimages-1053652372.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY0ODc3NTI3ODY3NzI4OTkx/gettyimages-1053652372.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY0ODc3NTI3ODY3NzI4OTkx/gettyimages-1053652372.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTY0ODc3NTI3ODY3NzI4OTkx/gettyimages-1053652372.jpg" srcset="" alt="People wait to board a bus for Mexico beside the border wall at the U.S.–Mexico border checkpoint in Calexico, California, on October 25th, 2018."></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/thousands-of-transborder-students-commute-to-american-colleges-from-mexico-every-day"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Thousands of 'Transborder' Students Commute to American Colleges From Mexico Every Day</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Many transborder students are U.S. citizens who live in Mexico because it's cheaper or because their parents were deported.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/charlotte-west" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Charlotte West</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/a-california-bill-would-let-college-athletes-sign-endorsement-deals-in-spite-of-the-ncaa" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/a-california-bill-would-let-college-athletes-sign-endorsement-deals-in-spite-of-the-ncaa','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-1',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="5"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/a-california-bill-would-let-college-athletes-sign-endorsement-deals-in-spite-of-the-ncaa" title="A California Bill Would Let College Athletes Sign Endorsement Deals, in Spite of the NCAA" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY0NzYzNDEwMDQ5ODA0MjQ0/athletes.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY0NzYzNDEwMDQ5ODA0MjQ0/athletes.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY0NzYzNDEwMDQ5ODA0MjQ0/athletes.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY0NzYzNDEwMDQ5ODA0MjQ0/athletes.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY0NzYzNDEwMDQ5ODA0MjQ0/athletes.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY0NzYzNDEwMDQ5ODA0MjQ0/athletes.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTY0NzYzNDEwMDQ5ODA0MjQ0/athletes.jpg" srcset="" alt="From left to right: OJ Mayo, Reggie Bush, Kayla Pedersen, JJ Hones &amp; Ed O'Bannon."></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/a-california-bill-would-let-college-athletes-sign-endorsement-deals-in-spite-of-the-ncaa"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">A California Bill Would Let College Athletes Sign Endorsement Deals, in Spite of the NCAA</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Female athletes stand to gain especially from the prospective passage of the legislation.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/james-mcwilliams" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By James McWilliams</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div></phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking></section><section class="m-brand-engagement m-component-stack mm-component-stack--is-stacked mm-component-stack--has-header mm-component-stack--has-background mm-brand-engagement--premium" style="background-color:#000000;"><div class="m-brand-engagement--container"><div class="m-component-header m-component-stack--header mm-component-header--inverted" style="background-color:rgba(0, 0, 0, 0);"><div class="m-component-header--container mm-component-header--size-extra-small"><h2 class="m-component-header--image" role="heading" aria-level="2"><img src="https://psmag.com/.image/cs_srgb%2Cq_auto:good/MTUzMDcwOTAxNjc4NTgxMzY4/section_header_art_xtrasmall_subscribe.svg" alt="Subscribe to our Newsletter"></h2></div></div><div class="m-brand-engagement--container"><div class="m-brand-engagement--buttons"><div class="m-brand-engagement--form-wrapper"><phoenix-brand-engagement-form class="m-brand-engagement--form" error-message="Error!" success-message="Thanks!" action="/.api/add-email-to-mailing-list"><form><input class="m-brand-engagement--form-input" name="email" placeholder="Email Address" aria-label="Email Address" type="email"><button class="m-brand-engagement--form-submit" type="submit">Subscribe</button></form></phoenix-brand-engagement-form></div><div class="m-brand-engagement--social-buttons"><div class="m-brand-engagement--social-button m-social--facebook"><a class="m-icon-button m-brand-engagement--social-link m-button mm-button--fixed-dimensions m-social--button mm-icon-button--small-icon" aria-label="facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/PacificStand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_facebook"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_facebook"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div><div class="m-brand-engagement--social-button m-social--linkedin"><a class="m-icon-button m-brand-engagement--social-link m-button mm-button--fixed-dimensions m-social--button mm-icon-button--small-icon" aria-label="linkedin" href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/pacific-standard-magazine" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_linkedin"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_linkedin"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div><div class="m-brand-engagement--social-button m-social--instagram"><a class="m-icon-button m-brand-engagement--social-link m-button mm-button--fixed-dimensions m-social--button mm-icon-button--small-icon" aria-label="instagram" href="https://www.instagram.com/pacificstand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_instagram"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_instagram"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div><div class="m-brand-engagement--social-button m-social--twitter"><a class="m-icon-button m-brand-engagement--social-link m-button mm-button--fixed-dimensions m-social--button mm-icon-button--small-icon" aria-label="twitter" href="https://twitter.com/pacificstand" target="_blank" rel="noopener" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-icon-button--icon" icon="ico_twitter"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_twitter"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div></div></div></div></div></section><section class="m-adaptive-ad-component m-component-stack"><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-4196fa807ecf4a25a2c3fb6a72168125","visClasses":["not-size-b","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-0","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-4196fa807ecf4a25a2c3fb6a72168125","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"sizes":["970x90"],"classes":["is-970x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-d8c40617282d41da85c4d04fe46bc163","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-0","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-d8c40617282d41da85c4d04fe46bc163","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},"blockthroughTag":"5ae8a9beef-168"}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;970x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-970x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-cc14dff601ce45adb7dcbcbc80a6b42d","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-0","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-cc14dff601ce45adb7dcbcbc80a6b42d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},"blockthroughTag":"5ae8a9beef-168"}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c" data-ad-group="in_content-0"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-cc6add8a5b944bf09a8929508e50568d","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-c"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-0","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"0","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"authorPageview":null,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-cc6add8a5b944bf09a8929508e50568d","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},"showBlockthrough":true,"blockthroughTag":"5ae8a9beef-168"}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside></section><section class="m-card-group mm-card-group--has-heroes"><phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking class="m-card-group--content l-grid lm-grid--density-single-column lm-grid--standard-cards" config="{&quot;siteBasePath&quot;:null,&quot;size&quot;:6,&quot;widgetName&quot;:&quot;tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2&quot;}"><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/computers-in-the-classroom-may-do-more-harm-than-good" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/computers-in-the-classroom-may-do-more-harm-than-good','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="0"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/computers-in-the-classroom-may-do-more-harm-than-good" title="Computers in the Classroom May Do More Harm Than Good—If They're Overused" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYxNTM4MDY3NTgzMjE1MjI5/john-schnobrich-520023-unsplash.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYxNTM4MDY3NTgzMjE1MjI5/john-schnobrich-520023-unsplash.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYxNTM4MDY3NTgzMjE1MjI5/john-schnobrich-520023-unsplash.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYxNTM4MDY3NTgzMjE1MjI5/john-schnobrich-520023-unsplash.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYxNTM4MDY3NTgzMjE1MjI5/john-schnobrich-520023-unsplash.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYxNTM4MDY3NTgzMjE1MjI5/john-schnobrich-520023-unsplash.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYxNTM4MDY3NTgzMjE1MjI5/john-schnobrich-520023-unsplash.jpg" srcset="" alt="people with laptop computer cafe"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/computers-in-the-classroom-may-do-more-harm-than-good"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Computers in the Classroom May Do More Harm Than Good—If They're Overused</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">New research finds that computers are most effective as teaching tools when used sparingly, and to teach kids at certain ages specific subjects.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/tomjacobs" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Tom Jacobs</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/colleges-are-attracting-more-latinx-students-but-arent-doing-enough-to-help-them-succeed" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/colleges-are-attracting-more-latinx-students-but-arent-doing-enough-to-help-them-succeed','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="1"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/colleges-are-attracting-more-latinx-students-but-arent-doing-enough-to-help-them-succeed" title="Colleges Are Attracting More Latinx Students, but Aren't Doing Enough to Help Them Succeed" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY0NTI4MjE2NTY3MTI5NDQx/priscilla-du-preez-293218-unsplash.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY0NTI4MjE2NTY3MTI5NDQx/priscilla-du-preez-293218-unsplash.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY0NTI4MjE2NTY3MTI5NDQx/priscilla-du-preez-293218-unsplash.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY0NTI4MjE2NTY3MTI5NDQx/priscilla-du-preez-293218-unsplash.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY0NTI4MjE2NTY3MTI5NDQx/priscilla-du-preez-293218-unsplash.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY0NTI4MjE2NTY3MTI5NDQx/priscilla-du-preez-293218-unsplash.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTY0NTI4MjE2NTY3MTI5NDQx/priscilla-du-preez-293218-unsplash.jpg" srcset="" alt="Library shelves"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/colleges-are-attracting-more-latinx-students-but-arent-doing-enough-to-help-them-succeed"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Colleges Are Attracting More Latinx Students, but Aren't Doing Enough to Help Them Succeed</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Like many U.S. colleges, Indiana University–Northwest is seeing a sharp rise in Latinx students—but support for them is lagging.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/aaron-cantú" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Aaron Cantú</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/why-californias-school-accountability-laws-no-longer-work" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/why-californias-school-accountability-laws-no-longer-work','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="2"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/why-californias-school-accountability-laws-no-longer-work" title="Why California's School Accountability Laws No Longer Work" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY0MjcwMjk0MTE3MTMyMjM1/gettyimages-691607160.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY0MjcwMjk0MTE3MTMyMjM1/gettyimages-691607160.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY0MjcwMjk0MTE3MTMyMjM1/gettyimages-691607160.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY0MjcwMjk0MTE3MTMyMjM1/gettyimages-691607160.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY0MjcwMjk0MTE3MTMyMjM1/gettyimages-691607160.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY0MjcwMjk0MTE3MTMyMjM1/gettyimages-691607160.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTY0MjcwMjk0MTE3MTMyMjM1/gettyimages-691607160.jpg" srcset="" alt="Students work on a project identifying countries in North, Central, and South America during a history class."></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/why-californias-school-accountability-laws-no-longer-work"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Why California's School Accountability Laws No Longer Work</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Changes to the state's evaluation system for schools has thrown the state's school accountability system into flux.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/will-huntsberry" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Will Huntsberry</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/the-battle-of-the-thermostat-women-perform-better-on-tests-when-rooms-are-warmer" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/the-battle-of-the-thermostat-women-perform-better-on-tests-when-rooms-are-warmer','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="3"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/the-battle-of-the-thermostat-women-perform-better-on-tests-when-rooms-are-warmer" title="Women Perform Better on Tests When Rooms Are Warmer" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY0MjIzNTY2MjE1MTI4MTkz/ben-mullins-785450-unsplash.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY0MjIzNTY2MjE1MTI4MTkz/ben-mullins-785450-unsplash.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY0MjIzNTY2MjE1MTI4MTkz/ben-mullins-785450-unsplash.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY0MjIzNTY2MjE1MTI4MTkz/ben-mullins-785450-unsplash.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY0MjIzNTY2MjE1MTI4MTkz/ben-mullins-785450-unsplash.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY0MjIzNTY2MjE1MTI4MTkz/ben-mullins-785450-unsplash.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTY0MjIzNTY2MjE1MTI4MTkz/ben-mullins-785450-unsplash.jpg" srcset="" alt="Woman girl taking standardized test school classroom"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/the-battle-of-the-thermostat-women-perform-better-on-tests-when-rooms-are-warmer"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Women Perform Better on Tests When Rooms Are Warmer</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">For female students, higher room temperatures mean higher scores.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/tomjacobs" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Tom Jacobs</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/how-to-combat-gender-bias-in-teacher-evaluations" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/how-to-combat-gender-bias-in-teacher-evaluations','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="4"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/how-to-combat-gender-bias-in-teacher-evaluations" title="How to Combat Gender Bias in Teacher Evaluations" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY0MDg0MTAyNzIxNDQ3MDEy/edwin-andrade-153753-unsplash.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY0MDg0MTAyNzIxNDQ3MDEy/edwin-andrade-153753-unsplash.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY0MDg0MTAyNzIxNDQ3MDEy/edwin-andrade-153753-unsplash.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTY0MDg0MTAyNzIxNDQ3MDEy/edwin-andrade-153753-unsplash.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTY0MDg0MTAyNzIxNDQ3MDEy/edwin-andrade-153753-unsplash.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTY0MDg0MTAyNzIxNDQ3MDEy/edwin-andrade-153753-unsplash.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTY0MDg0MTAyNzIxNDQ3MDEy/edwin-andrade-153753-unsplash.jpg" srcset="" alt="classroom students professor university college"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/how-to-combat-gender-bias-in-teacher-evaluations"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">How to Combat Gender Bias in Teacher Evaluations</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">New research suggests that simply reminding students about the reality of implicit bias can help them avoid it.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/tomjacobs" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Tom Jacobs</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/guns-in-schools-make-minority-students-feel-less-safe" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/guns-in-schools-make-minority-students-feel-less-safe','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-2',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="5"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/guns-in-schools-make-minority-students-feel-less-safe" title="Minority Students in Texas Raise Concerns Over a Program Arming Teachers" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYxODg3OTk0NDA2NTEyMjUz/gettyimages-158759533.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYxODg3OTk0NDA2NTEyMjUz/gettyimages-158759533.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYxODg3OTk0NDA2NTEyMjUz/gettyimages-158759533.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYxODg3OTk0NDA2NTEyMjUz/gettyimages-158759533.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYxODg3OTk0NDA2NTEyMjUz/gettyimages-158759533.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYxODg3OTk0NDA2NTEyMjUz/gettyimages-158759533.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYxODg3OTk0NDA2NTEyMjUz/gettyimages-158759533.jpg" srcset="" alt="Firearm instructor Clark Aposhian holds a handgun up as he teaches a concealed-weapons training class to 200 Utah teachers in December of 2012. After the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooting in Parkland, Florida, 14 state legislatures introduced bills calling to arm school staffs."></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/guns-in-schools-make-minority-students-feel-less-safe"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Minority Students in Texas Raise Concerns Over a Program Arming Teachers</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">The state is looking to expand its school marshal program, which allows teachers to carry firearms in case of an active shooter, causing some students to worry about their safety.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/alex-samuels" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Alex Samuels</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div></phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking></section><section class="m-adaptive-ad-component m-component-stack"><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-219c92ad79054ccdb03c895ff9c73587","visClasses":["not-size-b","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-1","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-219c92ad79054ccdb03c895ff9c73587","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"sizes":["970x90"],"classes":["is-970x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-a5aa41619e8f4e66b98e84224bc568ec","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-1","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-a5aa41619e8f4e66b98e84224bc568ec","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},"blockthroughTag":"5ae8a9c908-168"}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;970x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-970x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-a96b2fe1fbe4495ba6b8ec1136051fb9","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-1","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-a96b2fe1fbe4495ba6b8ec1136051fb9","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},"blockthroughTag":"5ae8a9c908-168"}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c" data-ad-group="in_content-1"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-fd7fc70d0df547dcaa63430553337ac5","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-c"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-1","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"1","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-fd7fc70d0df547dcaa63430553337ac5","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},"showBlockthrough":true,"blockthroughTag":"5ae8a9c908-168"}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside></section><section class="m-card-group mm-card-group--has-heroes"><phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking class="m-card-group--content l-grid lm-grid--density-single-column lm-grid--standard-cards" config="{&quot;siteBasePath&quot;:null,&quot;size&quot;:6,&quot;widgetName&quot;:&quot;tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-3&quot;}"><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/what-do-teacher-salaries-do-to-teacher-performance" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/what-do-teacher-salaries-do-to-teacher-performance','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-3',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="0"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/what-do-teacher-salaries-do-to-teacher-performance" title="Does Raising Teacher Salaries Improve Performance?" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYxNDQ1MzYzMTMwMDUwNDcy/gettyimages-1082814956.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYxNDQ1MzYzMTMwMDUwNDcy/gettyimages-1082814956.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYxNDQ1MzYzMTMwMDUwNDcy/gettyimages-1082814956.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYxNDQ1MzYzMTMwMDUwNDcy/gettyimages-1082814956.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYxNDQ1MzYzMTMwMDUwNDcy/gettyimages-1082814956.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYxNDQ1MzYzMTMwMDUwNDcy/gettyimages-1082814956.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYxNDQ1MzYzMTMwMDUwNDcy/gettyimages-1082814956.jpg" srcset="" alt="Yevgeniya Pokhilko was one of thousands of teachers who marched in the rain through Los Angeles, California, on January 14th, 2019."></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/what-do-teacher-salaries-do-to-teacher-performance"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Does Raising Teacher Salaries Improve Performance?</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">It may seem obvious, but other countries' experiences illustrate a more complicated story in improving education outcomes for students.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/david-evans" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By David Evans</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/a-huge-shift-how-california-is-making-up-for-20-years-of-english-only-education" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/a-huge-shift-how-california-is-making-up-for-20-years-of-english-only-education','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-3',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="1"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/a-huge-shift-how-california-is-making-up-for-20-years-of-english-only-education" title="'A Huge Shift': How California Is Making Up for 20 Years of English-Only Education" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNjQyMTU2NDkyMjY4OTcx/44983277815_8183f5b841_o.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNjQyMTU2NDkyMjY4OTcx/44983277815_8183f5b841_o.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNjQyMTU2NDkyMjY4OTcx/44983277815_8183f5b841_o.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNjQyMTU2NDkyMjY4OTcx/44983277815_8183f5b841_o.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNjQyMTU2NDkyMjY4OTcx/44983277815_8183f5b841_o.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNjQyMTU2NDkyMjY4OTcx/44983277815_8183f5b841_o.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYzNjQyMTU2NDkyMjY4OTcx/44983277815_8183f5b841_o.jpg" srcset="" alt="An elementary classroom in the two-way bilingual immersion program at Ann Leavenworth School in Fresno, California. The program starts in preschool and continues through sixth grade, aiming to develop high-level bilingual proficiency and biliteracy in English and Spanish."></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/a-huge-shift-how-california-is-making-up-for-20-years-of-english-only-education"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">How California Is Making Up for 20 Years of English-Only Education</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Half of California's children come from immigrant families, and educating them well is crucial to the state's future. New programs in Fresno offer reasons for hope.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/sarah-jackson" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Sarah Jackson</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/real-men-dont-learn-other-languages" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/real-men-dont-learn-other-languages','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-3',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="2"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/real-men-dont-learn-other-languages" title="Real Men Don't Learn Other Languages" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNzYwODU4MzgyNDc3MDI1/gettyimages-55854359.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNzYwODU4MzgyNDc3MDI1/gettyimages-55854359.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNzYwODU4MzgyNDc3MDI1/gettyimages-55854359.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNzYwODU4MzgyNDc3MDI1/gettyimages-55854359.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNzYwODU4MzgyNDc3MDI1/gettyimages-55854359.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNzYwODU4MzgyNDc3MDI1/gettyimages-55854359.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYzNzYwODU4MzgyNDc3MDI1/gettyimages-55854359.jpg" srcset="" alt="College graduates"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/real-men-dont-learn-other-languages"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Real Men Don't Learn Other Languages</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">New research finds many men view learning a second language as a feminine pursuit.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/tomjacobs" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Tom Jacobs</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/free-college-has-critics-on-the-right-and-left-is-it-viable" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/free-college-has-critics-on-the-right-and-left-is-it-viable','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-3',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="3"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/free-college-has-critics-on-the-right-and-left-is-it-viable" title="Free College Has Critics on the Right and Left. Is It Viable?" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNzYwNjI5NDA3MDMzMDU3/gettyimages-963067608.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNzYwNjI5NDA3MDMzMDU3/gettyimages-963067608.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNzYwNjI5NDA3MDMzMDU3/gettyimages-963067608.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNzYwNjI5NDA3MDMzMDU3/gettyimages-963067608.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNzYwNjI5NDA3MDMzMDU3/gettyimages-963067608.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNzYwNjI5NDA3MDMzMDU3/gettyimages-963067608.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYzNzYwNjI5NDA3MDMzMDU3/gettyimages-963067608.jpg" srcset="" alt="Graduation"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/free-college-has-critics-on-the-right-and-left-is-it-viable"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Free College Has Critics on the Right and Left. Is It Viable?</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Tuition costs have ballooned since the 1970s, but some argue making college free is a regressive solution.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/james-mcwilliams" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By James McWilliams</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/are-american-families-being-priced-out-of-child-care" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/are-american-families-being-priced-out-of-child-care','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-3',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="4"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/are-american-families-being-priced-out-of-child-care" title="Are American Families Going to Be Priced Out of Child Care?" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNjQ3NTk1Nzk5OTEzODk5/ben-white-197668-unsplash.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNjQ3NTk1Nzk5OTEzODk5/ben-white-197668-unsplash.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNjQ3NTk1Nzk5OTEzODk5/ben-white-197668-unsplash.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNjQ3NTk1Nzk5OTEzODk5/ben-white-197668-unsplash.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNjQ3NTk1Nzk5OTEzODk5/ben-white-197668-unsplash.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNjQ3NTk1Nzk5OTEzODk5/ben-white-197668-unsplash.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYzNjQ3NTk1Nzk5OTEzODk5/ben-white-197668-unsplash.jpg" srcset="" alt="ben-white-197668-unsplash"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/are-american-families-being-priced-out-of-child-care"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Are American Families Going to Be Priced Out of Child Care?</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">In many parts of the country, child care costs more than a mortgage.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/elise-franchino" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Elise Franchino</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/participation-in-arts-raises-kids-self-esteem" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/participation-in-arts-raises-kids-self-esteem','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-3',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="5"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/participation-in-arts-raises-kids-self-esteem" title="Participation in the Arts Raises Kids' Self-Esteem" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNTc0MzA0NTk4OTI2NTA3/clark-young-143623-unsplash.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNTc0MzA0NTk4OTI2NTA3/clark-young-143623-unsplash.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNTc0MzA0NTk4OTI2NTA3/clark-young-143623-unsplash.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNTc0MzA0NTk4OTI2NTA3/clark-young-143623-unsplash.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNTc0MzA0NTk4OTI2NTA3/clark-young-143623-unsplash.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNTc0MzA0NTk4OTI2NTA3/clark-young-143623-unsplash.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYzNTc0MzA0NTk4OTI2NTA3/clark-young-143623-unsplash.jpg" srcset="" alt="Child playing piano music arts education"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/participation-in-arts-raises-kids-self-esteem"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Participation in the Arts Raises Kids' Self-Esteem</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">New research finds particularly positive results when parents and kids work on a creative project together.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/tomjacobs" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Tom Jacobs</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div></phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking></section><section class="m-adaptive-ad-component m-component-stack"><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-2"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-2"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-8dd3920542f541988e801159d6e1c495","visClasses":["not-size-b","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-2","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[300,250],[320,50],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":300,"height":250},{"width":320,"height":50},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-8dd3920542f541988e801159d6e1c495","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-2"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-2"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"sizes":["970x90"],"classes":["is-970x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-0e660040f13a460c978a24cc26824c31","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-2","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[970,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"width":970,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-0e660040f13a460c978a24cc26824c31","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;970x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-970x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-2"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d" data-ad-group="in_content-2"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-596a954310744f9e84f68386950d2c44","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-d"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-2","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-596a954310744f9e84f68386950d2c44","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside><aside class="m-in-content-ad-row l-inline mm-in-content-ad-row--in-content not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c" data-ad-group="in_content-2"><div class="m-in-content-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c" data-ad-group="in_content-2"><phoenix-ad class="m-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c m-in-content-ad--slot" config='{"adHtml":"","adReloaderDelay":0,"maxAdReloads":5,"adCloseButton":false,"classRules":[{"sizes":["728x90"],"classes":["is-728x90"]},{"dimensions":["0x0"],"classes":["m-advertisement--fluid-card","m-advertisement--fluid-list-card"]}],"overrideOutstreamScript":false,"moduleClass":"m-in-content-ad","slotId":"ad-in_content-253f9f43e1c443ca82c261ab32d31f1e","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-c"],"extraClasses":null,"zone":"in_content","adGroup":"in_content-2","slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],"fluid"]},"model":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"sizes":[{"width":728,"height":90},{"name":"fluid"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"in_content","index":"2","isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false,"nativeCardType":"list"},"id":"ad-in_content-253f9f43e1c443ca82c261ab32d31f1e","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"},"showBlockthrough":true}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;sizes&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;is-728x90&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;0x0&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-card&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fluid-list-card&quot;]}]" skip-dynamic-call></phoenix-ad></div></aside></section><section class="m-card-group mm-card-group--has-heroes"><phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking class="m-card-group--content l-grid lm-grid--density-single-column lm-grid--standard-cards" config="{&quot;siteBasePath&quot;:null,&quot;size&quot;:6,&quot;widgetName&quot;:&quot;tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-4&quot;}"><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/as-graduate-school-costs-skyrocket-the-student-debt-problem-is-getting-worse" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/as-graduate-school-costs-skyrocket-the-student-debt-problem-is-getting-worse','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-4',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="0"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/as-graduate-school-costs-skyrocket-the-student-debt-problem-is-getting-worse" title="As Graduate School Costs Skyrocket, the Student-Debt Problem Is Getting Worse" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNTU2Njc1NjM3MjI0ODAy/gettyimages-51875784.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNTU2Njc1NjM3MjI0ODAy/gettyimages-51875784.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNTU2Njc1NjM3MjI0ODAy/gettyimages-51875784.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNTU2Njc1NjM3MjI0ODAy/gettyimages-51875784.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNTU2Njc1NjM3MjI0ODAy/gettyimages-51875784.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNTU2Njc1NjM3MjI0ODAy/gettyimages-51875784.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYzNTU2Njc1NjM3MjI0ODAy/gettyimages-51875784.jpg" srcset="" alt="GettyImages-51875784"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/as-graduate-school-costs-skyrocket-the-student-debt-problem-is-getting-worse"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">As Graduate School Costs Skyrocket, the Student-Debt Problem Is Getting Worse</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Universities are increasingly turning to graduate programs to balance their books. Students are shouldering the costs.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/jon-marcus" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Jon Marcus</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/heres-why-california-wants-to-ban-teach-for-america-during-a-teacher-shortage" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/heres-why-california-wants-to-ban-teach-for-america-during-a-teacher-shortage','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-4',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="1"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/heres-why-california-wants-to-ban-teach-for-america-during-a-teacher-shortage" title="Here's Why California Wants to Ban Teach for America During a Teacher Shortage" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNDYxNTM1NjY5MTY3NDU4/element5-digital-352043-unsplash.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNDYxNTM1NjY5MTY3NDU4/element5-digital-352043-unsplash.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNDYxNTM1NjY5MTY3NDU4/element5-digital-352043-unsplash.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNDYxNTM1NjY5MTY3NDU4/element5-digital-352043-unsplash.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNDYxNTM1NjY5MTY3NDU4/element5-digital-352043-unsplash.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNDYxNTM1NjY5MTY3NDU4/element5-digital-352043-unsplash.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYzNDYxNTM1NjY5MTY3NDU4/element5-digital-352043-unsplash.jpg" srcset="" alt="School"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/heres-why-california-wants-to-ban-teach-for-america-during-a-teacher-shortage"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Here's Why California Wants to Ban Teach for America During a Teacher Shortage</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">A bill in the California assembly would effectively prevent the program from operating in the state, if passed.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/brianna-provenzano" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Brianna Provenzano</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/we-want-a-kid-you-dont-have-any-idea-what-to-do-with" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/we-want-a-kid-you-dont-have-any-idea-what-to-do-with','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-4',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="2"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/we-want-a-kid-you-dont-have-any-idea-what-to-do-with" title="'We Want a Kid You Don't Have Any Idea What to Do With'" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNDYzMjg0Nzk0NTk4NzU0/kaplansava5.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNDYzMjg0Nzk0NTk4NzU0/kaplansava5.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNDYzMjg0Nzk0NTk4NzU0/kaplansava5.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNDYzMjg0Nzk0NTk4NzU0/kaplansava5.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNDYzMjg0Nzk0NTk4NzU0/kaplansava5.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNDYzMjg0Nzk0NTk4NzU0/kaplansava5.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYzNDYzMjg0Nzk0NTk4NzU0/kaplansava5.jpg" srcset="" alt="Jason Wasserman, a teacher, plays chess with an advisee. &quot;It's all the underdogs,&quot; he says of students at SAVA."></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/we-want-a-kid-you-dont-have-any-idea-what-to-do-with"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">'We Want a Kid You Don't Have Any Idea What to Do With'</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Sacramento Academic and Vocational Academy helps very vulnerable students succeed in high school—and beyond.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/emily-kaplan" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Emily Kaplan</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/what-an-pilot-shortage-reveals-about-higher-education" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/what-an-pilot-shortage-reveals-about-higher-education','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-4',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="3"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/what-an-pilot-shortage-reveals-about-higher-education" title="What Does America's Pilot Shortage Reveal About Higher Education?" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNDM1MjE0NDk4OTY0NjUx/gettyimages-73560767.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNDM1MjE0NDk4OTY0NjUx/gettyimages-73560767.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNDM1MjE0NDk4OTY0NjUx/gettyimages-73560767.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzNDM1MjE0NDk4OTY0NjUx/gettyimages-73560767.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzNDM1MjE0NDk4OTY0NjUx/gettyimages-73560767.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzNDM1MjE0NDk4OTY0NjUx/gettyimages-73560767.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYzNDM1MjE0NDk4OTY0NjUx/gettyimages-73560767.jpg" srcset="" alt="A commercial airliner flies across the sky."></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/what-an-pilot-shortage-reveals-about-higher-education"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">What Does America's Pilot Shortage Reveal About Higher Education?</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">The United States is the only country in the world with major airlines that require four-year degrees in order to be a pilot.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/julie-brosnan" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Julie Brosnan</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/restoring-prisoners-access-to-education-reduces-recidivism" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/restoring-prisoners-access-to-education-reduces-recidivism','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-4',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="4"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/restoring-prisoners-access-to-education-reduces-recidivism" title="Restoring Prisoners' Access to Education Reduces Recidivism" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTUzMDk2Mzg1MzMwMTYwNjQ3/faustin-tuyambaze-135473.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTUzMDk2Mzg1MzMwMTYwNjQ3/faustin-tuyambaze-135473.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTUzMDk2Mzg1MzMwMTYwNjQ3/faustin-tuyambaze-135473.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTUzMDk2Mzg1MzMwMTYwNjQ3/faustin-tuyambaze-135473.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTUzMDk2Mzg1MzMwMTYwNjQ3/faustin-tuyambaze-135473.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTUzMDk2Mzg1MzMwMTYwNjQ3/faustin-tuyambaze-135473.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTUzMDk2Mzg1MzMwMTYwNjQ3/faustin-tuyambaze-135473.jpg" srcset="" alt="Graduation"></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/restoring-prisoners-access-to-education-reduces-recidivism"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">Restoring Prisoners' Access to Education Reduces Recidivism</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Bipartisan legislation in the Senate and House of Representatives would make prisoners eligible for Pell Grants, reversing a clause in the 1994 crime bill that stripped such eligibility.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/james-mcwilliams" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By James McWilliams</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div><div class="l-grid--item"><div class="m-standard-hero--container"><!-- ! when modifying attributes of this phoenix-super-link, make sure you also set attributes in superLink in card/main.js--><phoenix-super-link href="/education/the-female-scientist-who-first-discovered-a-comet" onclick="return window.phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent &amp;&amp; phoenixTrackRecommendationClickEvent('cardclick','/education/the-female-scientist-who-first-discovered-a-comet','tempestn_hero-hub_psmag_category-page_title-not-found-1-4',false, 'Image')"><phoenix-card class="m-card mm-card--landscape-image mm-card--type-standard mm-card--density-single-column" role="article" index="5"><div class="m-card--media"><a class="m-card--image-link" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Image" rel="" href="/education/the-female-scientist-who-first-discovered-a-comet" title="How an Autodidact Astronomer Became the First American to Discover a Comet" tabindex="-1"><phoenix-picture><picture class="is-waiting-to-load"><source type="image/webp" data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzMjczNjgyNjU4MDEwNTEx/maria-mitchell-2.webp 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzMjczNjgyNjU4MDEwNTEx/maria-mitchell-2.webp 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzMjczNjgyNjU4MDEwNTEx/maria-mitchell-2.webp 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><source data-srcset="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_320/MTYzMjczNjgyNjU4MDEwNTEx/maria-mitchell-2.jpg 320w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_640/MTYzMjczNjgyNjU4MDEwNTEx/maria-mitchell-2.jpg 640w, https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_960/MTYzMjczNjgyNjU4MDEwNTEx/maria-mitchell-2.jpg 960w" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)"><img class="m-card--image-element" decoding="async" nopin="true" sizes="(min-width: 674px) 620px,calc(100vw - 40px)" src="https://psmag.com/.image/ar_16:9%2Cc_fill%2Ccs_srgb%2Cfl_progressive%2Cg_faces:center%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_620/MTYzMjczNjgyNjU4MDEwNTEx/maria-mitchell-2.jpg" srcset="" alt="Maria Mitchell."></picture><div class="m-card--image-aspect-ratio-pusher"></div></phoenix-picture></a></div><div class="m-card--content"><div class="m-card--label-container"><div class="m-card--label"><a href="/education" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event)" phx-track-id="Label">Education</a></div></div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--header"><a onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="Title" rel="" href="/education/the-female-scientist-who-first-discovered-a-comet"><h2 class="m-ellipsis--text m-card--header-text" role="heading" aria-level="2">How an Autodidact Astronomer Became the First American to Discover a Comet</h2></a></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis m-card--body-container"><p class="m-card--body m-ellipsis--text">Maria Mitchell was the only widely recognized and respected female astronomer of her time—something she fought to change.</p></phoenix-ellipsis><div class="m-card--metadata"><div class="m-card--metadata-a"><span class="m-card--metadata-slot"><a class="m-card--metadata-b-link" href="https://psmag.com/author/laetitia-meyrueix" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event, 'click', 'phx-track-id', false) &amp;&amp; window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" oncontextmenu="return window.phoenixStopEventPropagation &amp;&amp; phoenixStopEventPropagation(event);" phx-track-id="SectionKey">By Laetitia Meyrueix</a></span></div></div></div></phoenix-card></phoenix-super-link></div></div></phoenix-non-personalized-recommendations-tracking></section><phoenix-footer-loader class="m-component-footer--container m-component-stack--footer" more-results-token="MjQ6MjQ6MjUzMDg0ZmI0YmE4NjY2MTU0ZWJmOWVhNzYzYTFjNDE=" initial-slots="eyJBIjp7ImkiOjN9LCJCIjp7ImkiOjN9LCJDIjp7ImkiOjN9LCJEIjp7ImkiOjN9fQ==" site-base-path=""><div class="m-footer-loader"><button class="m-footer-loader--button m-component-footer--loader m-button" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="load more"><div class="m-footer-loader--button-text m-component-footer--text m-component-footer--loading">Loading…</div><div class="m-footer-loader--button-text m-component-footer--text m-component-footer--button-text">See More</div></button></div></phoenix-footer-loader></phoenix-hub></section><div class="m-detail--blockthrough-ads"><span class="bt-uid-tg" uid="5ae8a9c908-168" style="display: none !important"></span></div><footer class="m-footer mm-footer--has-publisher-logo"><div class="m-footer--container"><div class="m-footer--publisher-logo-cell"><a href="https://psmag.com" aria-label="Grist"><img src="https://psmag.com/.image/c_fit%2Ccs_srgb%2Ch_60%2Cq_auto:good%2Cw_600/MTcyODQ5NTk0MzcwMTA3MTgz/grist-logo-60tall.png" alt="Grist" height="30"></a></div><div class="m-footer--links-cell"><ul class="m-footer--links"><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/about" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">About</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/audience-influence" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Impact</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/contact-us" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Contact</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/write-us" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Pitching</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/fellowship-program" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Careers</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/advertise" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Partnerships</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="/page/privacy-statement" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Terms of Use</a></li><li aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="https://www.saymedia.com/privacy" rel="noopener" target="_blank" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Platform Privacy</a></li><li class="is-consent-applicable-only" aria-hidden="false" phx-track-id="Footer Links"><a href="javascript:window.phxConsentManagement.displayUi()" onclick="return phoenixTrackClickEvent(this, event);" phx-track-id="Link">Privacy Settings</a></li></ul><div class="m-footer--copyright">&copy; 2023 Grist</div></div><div class="m-footer--maven-logo-cell"><a rel="noopener" target="_blank" href="https://thearenagroup.net/" aria-label="A channel by The Arena Group"><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-footer--maven-logo" icon="arena_footer_logo"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#arena_footer_logo"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></a></div></div></footer></div><div id="do-not-sell-button"></div><div class="m-fixedbottom-ad--container"><phoenix-ad class="m-fixedbottom-ad not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d" auto-reload config='{"adReloaderDelay":30,"maxAdReloads":25,"moduleClass":"m-fixedbottom-ad","slotId":"ad-fixed_bottom-eae660fbcaf54969a95a28792bca5054","visClasses":["not-size-b","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[320,50],[320,60],[300,50]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomA"}],"screenSizes":["A"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-eae660fbcaf54969a95a28792bca5054","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;300x50&quot;,&quot;301x50&quot;,&quot;320x50&quot;,&quot;321x50&quot;,&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-contained&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-close-button&quot;]}]" fixed-visible skip-dynamic-call container-height="50" container-width="300"><div class="m-fixedbottom-ad--slot is-placeholder not-size-b not-size-c not-size-d"><div id="ad-fixed_bottom-eae660fbcaf54969a95a28792bca5054"></div><div class="m-advertisement--close-button is-hidden"><div class="m-advertisement--close-button-label">CLOSE</div></div></div></phoenix-ad><phoenix-ad class="m-fixedbottom-ad not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d" auto-reload close-button config='{"adReloaderDelay":30,"maxAdReloads":25,"moduleClass":"m-fixedbottom-ad","slotId":"ad-fixed_bottom-078c74fc1474463f8bd9670cfd25173a","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-c","not-size-d"],"slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[768,66]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomB"}],"screenSizes":["B"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-078c74fc1474463f8bd9670cfd25173a","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;300x50&quot;,&quot;301x50&quot;,&quot;320x50&quot;,&quot;321x50&quot;,&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-contained&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-close-button&quot;]}]" fixed-visible skip-dynamic-call container-height="90" container-width="728"><div class="m-fixedbottom-ad--slot is-placeholder not-size-a not-size-c not-size-d"><div id="ad-fixed_bottom-078c74fc1474463f8bd9670cfd25173a"></div><div class="m-advertisement--close-button is-hidden"><div class="m-advertisement--close-button-label">CLOSE</div></div></div></phoenix-ad><phoenix-ad class="m-fixedbottom-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d" auto-reload close-button config='{"adReloaderDelay":30,"maxAdReloads":25,"moduleClass":"m-fixedbottom-ad","slotId":"ad-fixed_bottom-0a451b5695604c78ade439fdbad638ab","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-d"],"slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[900,65],[970,90]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomC"}],"screenSizes":["C"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-0a451b5695604c78ade439fdbad638ab","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;300x50&quot;,&quot;301x50&quot;,&quot;320x50&quot;,&quot;321x50&quot;,&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-contained&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-close-button&quot;]}]" fixed-visible skip-dynamic-call container-height="90" container-width="728"><div class="m-fixedbottom-ad--slot is-placeholder not-size-a not-size-b not-size-d"><div id="ad-fixed_bottom-0a451b5695604c78ade439fdbad638ab"></div><div class="m-advertisement--close-button is-hidden"><div class="m-advertisement--close-button-label">CLOSE</div></div></div></phoenix-ad><phoenix-ad class="m-fixedbottom-ad not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c" auto-reload close-button config='{"adReloaderDelay":30,"maxAdReloads":25,"moduleClass":"m-fixedbottom-ad","slotId":"ad-fixed_bottom-1d9ca2cd72594bce833bd6ba30146371","visClasses":["not-size-a","not-size-b","not-size-c"],"slotConfig":{"config":{"sizes":[[728,90],[900,65],[970,90]]},"model":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"sizes":[{"name":"fixedBottomD"}],"screenSizes":["D"],"slotModel":{"zone":"fixed_bottom","index":0,"isOutstream":false,"deferLoad":false},"id":"ad-fixed_bottom-1d9ca2cd72594bce833bd6ba30146371","adUnitPath":"/88059007,2154169/psmag.com/education"}}' data-class-rules="[{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;300x50&quot;,&quot;301x50&quot;,&quot;320x50&quot;,&quot;321x50&quot;,&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom&quot;,&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-contained&quot;]},{&quot;dimensions&quot;:[&quot;728x90&quot;,&quot;729x90&quot;,&quot;970x90&quot;,&quot;971x90&quot;,&quot;1x1&quot;],&quot;classes&quot;:[&quot;m-advertisement--fixedbottom-close-button&quot;]}]" fixed-visible skip-dynamic-call container-height="90" container-width="728"><div class="m-fixedbottom-ad--slot is-placeholder not-size-a not-size-b not-size-c"><div id="ad-fixed_bottom-1d9ca2cd72594bce833bd6ba30146371"></div><div class="m-advertisement--close-button is-hidden"><div class="m-advertisement--close-button-label">CLOSE</div></div></div></phoenix-ad></div></div></div><script id="phx-webcomponent-page" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/page.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-accountMenu" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/accountMenu.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-knownUser" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/knownUser.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-dropDown" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/dropDown.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-ad" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/ad.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-picture" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/picture.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-notifier" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/notifier.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-import" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/import.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-card" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/card.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-superLink" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/superLink.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-ellipsis" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/ellipsis.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-style" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/style.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-overlay" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/overlay.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-intersectionNotifier" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/intersectionNotifier.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><script id="phx-webcomponent-balloonHeader" async src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/balloonHeader.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/tabs.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/sodoRunner.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/timeago.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/simpleForm.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/brandEngagementForm.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/accordion.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/breadcrumbs.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/hub.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/nonPersonalizedRecommendationsTracking.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/footerLoader.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/stickyNav.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script delay-load load-after-critical-elements src="/.bootscripts/webcomponents/iconFallback.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><phoenix-script src="https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/tempest-promotions/optinmonster.js" block-on-gdpr-applicable delay-load></phoenix-script><phoenix-script src="https://ericzassenhaus.com/js/hide_premium.js" block-on-gdpr-applicable delay-load></phoenix-script><script>"use strict";function _toConsumableArray(arr){return _arrayWithoutHoles(arr)||_iterableToArray(arr)||_unsupportedIterableToArray(arr)||_nonIterableSpread()}function _nonIterableSpread(){throw new TypeError("Invalid attempt to spread non-iterable instance.\nIn order to be iterable, non-array objects must have a [Symbol.iterator]() method.")}function _unsupportedIterableToArray(o,minLen){if(!o)return;if(typeof o==="string")return _arrayLikeToArray(o,minLen);var n=Object.prototype.toString.call(o).slice(8,-1);if(n==="Object"&&o.constructor)n=o.constructor.name;if(n==="Map"||n==="Set")return Array.from(o);if(n==="Arguments"||/^(?:Ui|I)nt(?:8|16|32)(?:Clamped)?Array$/.test(n))return _arrayLikeToArray(o,minLen)}function _iterableToArray(iter){if(typeof Symbol!=="undefined"&&iter[Symbol.iterator]!=null||iter["@@iterator"]!=null)return Array.from(iter)}function _arrayWithoutHoles(arr){if(Array.isArray(arr))return _arrayLikeToArray(arr)}function _arrayLikeToArray(arr,len){if(len==null||len>arr.length)len=arr.length;for(var i=0,arr2=new Array(len);i<len;i++){arr2[i]=arr[i]}return arr2}phxConfigQueue.push(function(){var _document$querySelect;var newClasses=[this.device.get()];var info=this.browser.get();if(info.found){newClasses=newClasses.concat([info.type,info.type+info.version]);if(info.iOS){newClasses=newClasses.concat(["ios","ios"+info.iOS])}if(info.samsung){newClasses=newClasses.concat("samsung")}}newClasses=newClasses.map(function(s){return s.toLowerCase()});(_document$querySelect=document.querySelector("html").classList).add.apply(_document$querySelect,_toConsumableArray(newClasses))});</script><phoenix-script delay-load src="/.bootscripts/hubRebalancer.min.js?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483"></phoenix-script><script type="text/template" id="videoplayer-tag">(function(src){"use strict";var e=document.createElement("script");e.src=src;e.onload=function(){if(window.BT){BT.clearThrough()}};document.body.appendChild(e);})('https://saymedia-com.videoplayerhub.com/videoloader.js')</script><phoenix-script block-premium block-on-ccpa-reject block-on-gdpr-vendor-consent="blockthrough" block-on-gdpr-purpose-consent="advertising" delay-load script-id="videoplayer-tag"></phoenix-script><script>'use strict';
window._sf_startpt = (new Date()).getTime();
window._sf_async_config = {"uid":57536,"disableFeaturedMedia":false,"domain":"psmag.com","useCanonical":true,"sections":"N/A","authors":"N/A","flickerControl":false};
</script><script type="text/template" id="chartbeat-init-57536">"use strict";window._sf_endpt=new Date().getTime();</script><phoenix-script script-id="chartbeat-init-57536" block-on-gdpr-vendor-consent="chartbeat" block-on-gdpr-purpose-consent="storage,measurement/advertising,measurement/content,measurement/development" block-premium delay-load></phoenix-script><phoenix-script src="https://static.chartbeat.com/js/chartbeat_video.js" block-on-gdpr-vendor-consent="chartbeat" block-on-gdpr- purpose-consent="storage,measurement/advertising,measurement/content,measurement/development" block-on-ccpa-reject block-premium delay-load></phoenix-script><phoenix-script src="https://static.chartbeat.com/js/chartbeat_mab.js" block-on-gdpr-vendor-consent="chartbeat" block-on-gdpr-purpose-consent="storage,measurement/advertising,measurement/content,measurement/development" block-on-ccpa-reject block-premium delay-load></phoenix-script><script type="application/json" id="liftigniter-metadata">{"noShow":"true"}</script><script>"use strict";window.liftIgniterPromiseResolved;window.liftIgniterPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){window.liftIgniterPromiseResolved=resolve});window.scriptErrorsPromiseResolved();window.liftIgniterLoadPromiseResolved;window.liftIgniterLoadPromise=new Promise(function(resolve,reject){window.liftIgniterLoadPromiseResolved=resolve;window.liftIgniterLoadPromiseRejected=reject});</script><script type="text/template" id="liftigniter-init">(function(jsKey, vendorId, purposes, cookieName) {"use strict";if(typeof $igniter_var==="undefined"){!function n(t,c,r,o,a,i,s,e,f,l,u){l=null!=t[r]&&"function"==typeof t[r].now?t[r].now():null,t.$igniter_var=i,t[i]=t[i]||function(){(t[i].q=t[i].q||[]).push(arguments)},e=c.getElementsByTagName(o)[0],(f=c.createElement(o)).async=1,"https://cdn"==a?(t[i].s=l,f.onerror=function(e){t[i].e=e,n(t,c,r,o,a+"-fallback",i,s)}):t[i].r=l,(u=!t.Promise||!t.MutationObserver||!Object.assign)||(t[i].v="nbc"+(0<=a.indexOf("-fallback")?"f":"")),f.src=a+".petametrics.com/"+s+(u?"":"-nbc")+".js?ts="+(+new Date/216e5|0),e.parentNode.insertBefore(f,e)}(window,document,"performance","script","https://cdn","$p",jsKey);Promise.all([window.GdprStatus.getMavenUidSafe(),window.GdprStatus.isApplicableSafe(),window.GdprStatus.isDemonetizedSafe()]).then(function(values){var mavenUid=values[0],inEEA=values[1],isDemonetized=values[2];var adblocker=null;var POLL_INTERVAL=3*1000;var START_TIME=window.performance.now();var adBlockTick=function adBlockTick(){if(typeof window.adblockDetector==="undefined"){adblocker=true;if(!config.globalCtx.adblocker){$p("updateConfig",{globalCtx:{adblocker:adblocker}})}if(window.performance.now()<START_TIME+10*1000){intervalId=setTimeout(adBlockTick,POLL_INTERVAL)}}else{try{window.adblockDetector.init({found:function found(){adblocker=true;if(!config.globalCtx.adblocker){$p("updateConfig",{globalCtx:{adblocker:adblocker}})}stopPoll()},notFound:function notFound(){adblocker=false;$p("updateConfig",{globalCtx:{adblocker:adblocker}});stopPoll()},debug:false})}catch(e){console.error("adblockDetector init failed",e.message);intervalId=setTimeout(adBlockTick,POLL_INTERVAL)}}};var intervalId=setTimeout(adBlockTick,0);var stopPoll=function stopPoll(){return clearTimeout(intervalId)};var config={globalCtx:{isDemonetized:isDemonetized,adblocker:adblocker}};function initAndSendPageview(userId){$p("init",jsKey,{config:config});if(userId){$p("setUserId",userId,"replaceIfEmpty")}$p("send","pageview");window.liftIgniterPromiseResolved();$p("onload",function(){return window.liftIgniterLoadPromiseResolved()})}function fetchAndSend(consented){var rgis=window.GdprStatus.getCookie("RGIS");var c3id=rgis&&typeof rgis==="string"&&rgis.length>=1&&rgis[0]==="\""&&rgis.indexOf("|")!==-1?rgis.slice(1,rgis.indexOf("|")):undefined;var igCookie=consented&&window.GdprStatus.getCookie(cookieName);var uid=c3id||igCookie;if(uid&&igCookie!=="donottrack"&&uid!==mavenUid&&(c3id||!/^\d+$/.test(mavenUid))){window.GdprStatus.fetchMavenContext(uid,consented);window.GdprStatus.getMavenUidSafe().then(function(userId){return initAndSendPageview(userId)})}else{initAndSendPageview(mavenUid)}}if(inEEA){window.GdprStatus.waitForConsentValue().then(function(){window.GdprStatus.isConsentGivenForVendorPurposes(vendorId,purposes).then(function(isConsentGiven){fetchAndSend(isConsentGiven)})})}else{fetchAndSend(true)}})}})('999gba4qphtjrmpe', 'maven', ["storage","content","measurement"], '_ig');</script><phoenix-script script-id="liftigniter-init" block-on-ccpa-reject block-premium></phoenix-script><!-- Template for the recommended content widget--><script id="li-recommendation-template" type="application/mustache">{{#items}}<div class="m-liftigniter--recommended-item"><a class="m-liftigniter--link" href="{{url}}">{{#thumbnail}}<div class="m-liftigniter--thumbnail-container"><img class="m-liftigniter--thumbnail" src="{{thumbnail}}" width="80" height="80"></div>{{/thumbnail}}<div class="m-liftigniter--metadata"><div class="m-liftigniter--related-story">RELATED STORY</div><phoenix-ellipsis class="m-ellipsis"><div class="m-liftigniter--title m-ellipsis--text">{{title}}</div></phoenix-ellipsis><phoenix-icon-fallback class="m-svg m-liftigniter--right-arrow" icon="ico_angle_right" aria-hidden="true"><svg><use xlink:href="/assets-global/icons/svg-sprite.svg?v=2023-08-23-165559-06792ee-034483#ico_angle_right"></use></svg></phoenix-icon-fallback></div><button class="m-liftigniter--button" type="submit">READ</button></a></div>{{/items}}</script><script type="text/template" id="quantcast-init">window._qevents = window._qevents || [];
(function () {"use strict";var element=document.createElement("script");element.src="https://secure.quantserve.com/quant.js";document.head.appendChild(element);})();
window._qevents.push([{"qacct":"p-d6cmgEH1kmz7P"}])</script><phoenix-script block-premium block-on-gdpr-vendor-consent="quantcast" block-on-gdpr-purpose-consent="all" block-on-ccpa-reject delay-load script-id="quantcast-init"></phoenix-script><script type="text/template" id="carbon-analytics">(function(scriptUrl, tagId, userSyncUrl) {"use strict";var _window$localStorage,_window$localStorage$;window.CustomerConnectAnalytics="cca";window.cca=window.cca||function(){(window.cca.q=window.cca.q||[]).push(arguments)};var script=document.createElement("script");script.src=scriptUrl+"?id="+window.location.hostname+"&parentId="+tagId;document.head.appendChild(script);var sync=function sync(params){var userSync=userSyncUrl+"?puid="+params.uid+(params.gdprConsent?"&gdprcs="+encodeURIComponent(params.gdprConsent):"")+(params.uspConsent?"&ccpacs="+encodeURIComponent(params.uspConsent):"");var img=document.createElement("img");img.height="1";img.width="1";img.src=userSync;img.alt="";document.body.appendChild(img)};Promise.all([window.GdprStatus.getMavenUidSafe(),window.phxConsentManagement.getConsentString(),window.criticalElementsPromise]).then(function(values){var consentType=window.phxConsentManagement.consentType;sync({uid:values[0],gdprConsent:consentType==="GDPR"&&values[1],uspConsent:consentType==="CCPA"&&values[1]})});var emailHashData=(_window$localStorage=window.localStorage)===null||_window$localStorage===void 0?void 0:(_window$localStorage$=_window$localStorage.getItem)===null||_window$localStorage$===void 0?void 0:_window$localStorage$.call(_window$localStorage,"emailHashes");if(emailHashData){var data;try{data=JSON.parse(emailHashData)}catch(e){1}if(data&&data.length){window.carbonReady=window.carbonReady||[];window.carbonReady.push(function(){["sha256","md5"].forEach(function(alg){var emailHash=data.find(function(el){return el.alg===alg});if(emailHash){ccao.api.storeHashedEmail(emailHash.alg,emailHash.digest)}})})}}})('https://carbon-cdn.ccgateway.net/script', 'b4b3d228', 'https://eus-api.ccgateway.net/v1/s/mavenid');</script><phoenix-script script-id="carbon-analytics" block-on-gdpr-vendor-consent="clicksco" block-on-gdpr-purpose-consent="measurement" block-on-ccpa-reject block-premium delay-load></phoenix-script><script>var mainResourceExecEndTime = window.performance.now() | 0;</script></phoenix-page><script>(function(appScripts) {"use strict";function dropExtScript(src){return new Promise(function(resolve,reject){var e=document.createElement("script");e.async=false;e.src=src;e.addEventListener("load",function(){resolve()},false);e.addEventListener("error",function(){console.error("failed to load "+src);resolve()},false);document.body.appendChild(e)})}function dropExtScripts(scripts){var promises=[];scripts.forEach(function(s){promises.push(dropExtScript(s))});return Promise.all(promises)}function loadAndStartApp(){dropExtScripts(appScripts).then(function(){var e=document.createElement("script");e.text="require(['main']);";document.body.appendChild(e)})}if(appScripts.length>0){window.getTimedOutPageLoadPromise(30000).then(loadAndStartApp)}})([]);</script></body></html>