The Ninth Circuit reversed. The issue, it said, was not whether phone numbers were sequentially dialed, but whether the equipment used could hypothetically sequentially dial telephone numbers. It also held that there was a disputed issue of fact whether King’s publisher, Simon & Schuster, counted as an “affiliate.”

Faced with the prospect of going to trial and the risk of $500 to $1500 damages assessed for each call (i.e., $30 to $90 million in damages) defendants have settled. There is a settlement fund of $10 million established, plaintiffs can submit claims that will pay $175 (or a pro rata amount if the fund is exhausted) and plaintiffs’ attorneys will ask for $2.725 million from that fund.

This is superficially all well and good, but if the claim response is the all-too-typical 1%, the attorneys may well collect 27 times as much as the class will get. Indeed, assuming that $1 million for notice and administration disappears from the fund, the full $10 million won’t be paid out unless over half the class signs up. There is also a mysterious $250,000 “cy pres” award whose destination is not specified in the notice or in the settlement.

If you’re a class member who received the text message in 2006, congratulations, you can get free money: fill out a claim form before September 20 (and kudos to the parties for allowing claimants to do it online); if you’re a class member who has concerns about the settlement, contact me.

Related posts

• The Bluetooth Headset Class Action settlement: Consumers $0, Lawyers $850,000 (28)
• Grand Theft Auto: Class Action Settlement – $26,505 for the unrepresented class, $1 million fee request (12)
• Grand Theft Auto: Class Action – The Frank Brief (16)
• Bluetooth Headset Settlement Update (6)
• Bluetooth class action update; new blog (2)

• Are you a member of Tyson chicken or H&R Block Express IRA class action settlements?
• Jim Copland on Harry Reid and the trial bar. [NRO]
• Jim Copland on the Ground Zero settlement, which may pay lawyers $200 million—but the judge plans fee scrutiny. [NY Post; NY Daily News]
• Kevin LaCroix interviews the Circle of Greed authors. [D&O Diary]
• Judgeships: Rhode Island lead paint trial lawyer in despite mediocre rating, but Sri Srinivasan out because of his clients—not Al Qaeda, but, heaven forfend, eeeevil corporations like Hertz.
• There’s no evidence that workers on automotive brakes (which sometimes contain asbestos) get mesothelioma at a greater rate than the rest of the population, but auto companies still get sued over it. Ford fought one in Madison County, rather than settle, and won. [Madison County Record]
• Overview of defensive medicine at work. [AP]
• Pantsless Rielle Hunter on John Edwards: “He’s very honest and truthful.” [GQ]

Related posts

• Archived politics items, pre-July 2003 (0)
• Update: “Victims and Families United” (0)
• Supported by a Reid (0)
• September 3 roundup (2)
• Publicity roundup (0)

Related posts

• Toyota show trials, cont’d (2)
• Toyota acceleration: why I’m skeptical (40)
• Sudden acceleration: litigation springs eternal (0)
• Staged footage in ABC News Toyota “test” (4)
• On 770 KTTH-Seattle at 4:10 PM Pacific today, talking Toyota (0)

Related posts

• Update: Sudden acceleration: litigation springs eternal (10)
• $18 million “sudden acceleration” verdict in South Carolina (8)
• SUV suits follow-up (7)
• Sudden acceleration: litigation springs eternal (0)
• Driver falls asleep: jury blames Ford to tune of $61M (14)

Related posts

• Toyota acceleration: why I’m skeptical (40)
• Sudden acceleration: litigation springs eternal (0)
• “Lawyers Ask Court To Stop Toyota From Fixing Cars” (5)
• “I am not afraid of my Toyota Prius” (16)
• Update: Sudden acceleration: litigation springs eternal (10)

Related posts

• U.K.: Footballer sues over “negligent” tackle (3)
• U.K.: defending assumption of risk (0)
• U.K.: compensation-culture roundup (1)
• The horn is now silent (0)
• September 24 roundup (2)

And if you’re on Facebook, do become a fan of the Center for Class Action Fairness so you can keep up with us and others can learn about it.

Related posts

• The return of Grand Theft Auto: Class Action (6)
• Update: Grand Theft Auto suits (1)
• More on the Grand Theft Auto lawsuit (0)
• Latest issue of Class Action Watch (2)
• Grand Theft Auto: Class Action Settlement – $26,505 for the unrepresented class, $1 million fee request (12)

Related posts

• Waxman, Stupak demand info from health insurers (8)
• Voting on bills without reading them (7)
• Toyota show trials, cont’d (2)
• Toyota acceleration: why I’m skeptical (40)
• Thomas Geoghegan runs for Congress (1)

Related posts

• Unintended results of bicycle helmet laws (4)
• U.K.: “Health and safety snoops to enter family homes” (0)
• January 20 roundup (8)
• “The greatest risk is living swaddled in bubble wrap” (2)
• What it means for a product to be “safe” (0)