How Would You Move Mount Fuji?
I read the book How Would You Move Mount Fuji? and I thought it was pretty interesting. It mainly focuses on how Microsoft interviews and why they ask the questions they do. It also gives you reasoning and logic behind some of the questions with right answers (or more correct answers).
I am always a fan of books about interviewing because they are usually so wrong. As I have never been interviewed (or interviewed for) Microsoft, I can’t tell you whether this book is good preparation for a Microsoft interview, I can tell you that it attempts to make a case for puzzle based questions.
Obviously puzzle based questions don’t work for everyone. Some positions do not require out of the box thinking. But for those in the company that do require that out of the box thinking, I could see it being useful (at least at a company the size of Microsoft). As the book points out though, this interview technique can leave people on the outside who can perform the job up to standards or even better than the person hired. And while leaving people on the table that could be hired might work for some positions at Microsoft, it might not work everywhere. As labor shortages increase, I wonder if this will change that technique some?
Bill Gates is going to be testifying in front of a Congressional committee this week on the need for more visas for highly skilled workers. One might wonder if the labor shortage could be averted by a simple change in interviewing technique?
Comments
3 Responses to “How Would You Move Mount Fuji?”
Leave a Reply
-
About
Your HR Guy is a Human Resources Generalist practicing in the field. But don't let that fool you, this isn't a boring blog. I seek relevance and humor in a place we will spend much of our lives. Everything from workplace issues, job seeking and terrible bosses. Read more...
![View Lance Haun [lancehaun@gmail.com]'s profile on LinkedIn](http://www.linkedin.com/img/webpromo/btn_viewmy_160x33.gif)
Featured on:
HRM Today- A Right to Vote?HR Wench, Jenn Barnes posted on EFCA and whether or not it actually takes the legal right to a vote away from employees. Her assessment was that while there is usually a vote, employees involved in an election to determine union representation in a bargaining unit is not required. Technically, this is correct. There is [...]HumanRaceHorses
- Ask the question!Three times in the past three weeks, I spent time with people who are very good at their jobs as individuals, but who didn’t operate well as a team. In each case, the issue was that no one asked any questions. Instead, team members would say things like: “Let me try to explain this to you…” “Oh, [...]JasonSeiden
- Blogs are great. Now get off my back!Just a little rant today, please bear with it. I’m getting just a little tired of justifying my enjoyment of blogs. I know it’s not “real” journalism, and that some people are just jerks on ego trips. I’m not looking for journalism and I don’t follow jerks. The blogosphere is a self-correcting marketplace; if you suck, [...]HR Minion
- Unions and Your RightsThere is a lot of talk lately about the proposed Employee Free Choice Act (EFCA), also known as BOOGAH BOOGAH BOOGAH THE UNIONS ARE COMING FOR YOUR CHILDREN! I haven’t decided if I’m for or against the proposed EFCA. What I have decided is that I’m tired of anti-EFCA folks saying the proposed EFCA will “take away [...]HR Wench
- Q: How do I delegate better?A: The answer to this question is not what you think. I know, I know… there are only about four gazillion books out there on delegating. Throw in all the stuff written about productivity, management, and accountability, and the number zooms up to about nine gazillion. Or 10, I lost count. And if any of it [...]JasonSeiden
- Employees, current and future, want to be in the ‘know’In a world of instant communication and news, the smut magazine’s tagline says it all, “Inquiring minds want to know”. Whether you are an internal employee or a job seeker qualifying your future employers, people want to know as much as they can about the company. If you are already in the organization, you want to [...]Kristin Gissaro
- HR MattersPrior to being in Human Resources, I worked in Production Control. Every day I could see the fruits of my labor. I received constant feedback. Some wise guru said that feedback was an instant motivator. It certainly was for me. Then, I transferred into the Human Resources Department. Things changed drastically. In HR, we do our [...]rulrici
- Companies Tap Pension Plans To Fund Executive BenefitsI wrote about Brett Favre’s sense of entitlement, this weekend, but no one has a bigger sense of entitlement than Joe CEO – the guy who failed as a leader but leaves your organization with a little coin in his pocket. Companies Tap Pension Plans To Fund Executive Benefits - WSJ.com At a time when scores [...]Laurie Ruettimann
- Is it More Difficult to Blog Openly About HR?As you may have heard, HR Wench is out of the anonymous closet. She’s a fellow Portlander so I’ve been encouraging her to reveal herself but for slightly selfish reasons. But for every anonymous HR person revealing their true identity, there are probably three more starting blogs under the shroud of secrecy. Why does this [...]Lance Haun
- Recruitment Spotlight: 8 Musts for Conducting a Job InterviewMy new book, Success for Hire (ASTD Press) features employee recruitment and retention practices that a lot of people think they know but in reality, don’t put into practice. One of those practices is effective in-person interviewing, which can ensure that you hire the right candidate the first time around. The next time [...]Alexandra Levit
- A Right to Vote?
HR Guy….
I guess me and a lot of others would be left on the “outside” because
my response would be…”Why would I need to?”
I’ve been in IT for 25 years and I think I’m too old and jaded to work for
anybody that insists on using twee interview questions.
Maybe they should ask questions like “Do you understand the impact of you
leaving a mistake in your code and client companies missing their deadline
for printing payroll checks?”
Perhaps Old Bill needs to start tossing some cash around in the U.S. to get
colleges and trade schools up to snuff on turning out skilled technical workers.
But then again, he’s probably pretty sure they won’t offshore his job or
screw up his paycheck.
[...] that same note, I had a comment in my book review about Microsoft’s hiring process from an older person who just doesn’t get the idea of those types of interview questions. I [...]
Companies everywhere complain that so few candidates bother coming prepared to job interviews. I’ve spoken to job candidates about preparation, and they wonder why should they bother. Many applicants would really like the interview to concentrate on the job–can they do it, will they do it, and how. Instead they’re faced with either behavioral interview questions where they speak about what they did for somebody else, or they’re presented with puzzles that make preparation irrelevant.
Employers need to concentrate on the job. One sad reality, however, is many an employer can’t accurately describe what it really takes to do the work. So they fall for this fads.