On CNET: CNN's 'hologram' was horrendous
BNET Business Network:
BNET
TechRepublic
ZDNet

June 11th, 2007

Google calls Microsoft on antitrust

Posted by Garett Rogers @ 11:50 am

Categories: Google, Microsoft

Tags: Google Inc., Antitrust, Microsoft Windows Vista, Microsoft Corp., Garett Rogers

The antitrust complaint from Google with regards to Desktop Search on Windows Vista is “heating up” as Barry Schwartz puts it. According to Google, Microsoft has an unfair advantage over the competition when it comes to their Google Desktop product.

Google complained to federal and state prosecutors that consumers who try to use its search tool for computer hard drives on Vista were frustrated because Vista has a competing desktop search program that cannot be turned off. When the Google and Vista search programs are run simultaneously on a computer, their indexing programs slow the operating system considerably, Google contended. As a result, Google said that Vista violated Microsoft’s 2002 antitrust settlement, which prohibits Microsoft from designing operating systems that limit the choices of consumers.

According to the New York Times, the state department is backing Microsoft in this one even though the arguments, in my opinion, have a certain level of substance.

State officials told the newspaper that a memo by Thomas Barnett, an assistant attorney general, rejected the Google complaint, repeating legal arguments made by Microsoft.

Garett Rogers is employed as a programmer for iQmetrix, which specializes in retail management software for the wireless industry. See his full profile and disclosure of his industry affiliations.

  • Talkback
  • Most Recent of 32 Talkback(s)
It's not about being better, it's about choice
The user should have the choice to use any desktop search that they want. It's called "fair use."

Although I agree that if indexing can be turned off allowing Google Desktop to function uninhibited, then this is a non-issue.... (Read the rest)
Posted by: T1Oracle Posted on: 06/17/07 You are currently: Logged In | Log out
That's good Ratatosk   | 06/11/07
They should also have the option of un-installing IE. DonnieBoy   | 06/11/07
Um, Safari on Windows? Someguy2   | 06/11/07
Where have you been? You can now download the beta for Safari on Windows. DonnieBoy   | 06/11/07
Oh, and here is the link to download Safari for Windows DonnieBoy   | 06/11/07
Yes, it does. Carl Rogers   | 06/11/07
Running Internet Explorer 6 (IE-6) on Linux. joe.smetona@...   | 06/13/07
They should have the option of un-installing IE zulubuck   | 06/13/07
Internet explorer cannot be removed from Windows. joe.smetona@...   | 06/13/07
Really, who wants two search products on the same computer??? DonnieBoy   | 06/11/07
Of course you have a choice mdemuth   | 06/12/07
No more State or Federal anti-trust lawsuits for MS. davidr555   | 06/11/07
Right, Google might be on their own here, at least until 2008. DonnieBoy   | 06/11/07
MS Live search interface connected THEE WOLF   | 06/11/07
No one forced... pietasterkid   | 06/11/07
In case you did not hear, MS was found to have a monopoly and to have DonnieBoy   | 06/11/07
About Google Privacy. joe.smetona@...   | 06/13/07
About Google Privacy II joe.smetona@...   | 06/13/07
GAWD... BFD   | 06/11/07
Google Search does the same thing. joe.smetona@...   | 06/13/07
It's not about being better, it's about choice T1Oracle   | 06/17/07
Since when is a desktop search not part of the OS? SniperCT   | 06/11/07
When it's in Linux tracy anne   | 06/12/07
It doesn't surprise me. joe.smetona@...   | 06/12/07
Message has been deleted. evildictaitor   | 06/13/07
You are incorrect. joe.smetona@...   | 06/13/07
Disable Windows File Protection Instructions. joe.smetona@...   | 06/13/07
Try Agent Ransack (free) joe.smetona@...   | 06/12/07
Google's calendar can't be 'turned off', either! mikeszdnet   | 06/12/07
Google Calendar is not resident on PC> joe.smetona@...   | 06/13/07
Get Vista then you can turn it off evildictaitor   | 06/13/07
It doesn't surprise me either ! WhiteSand   | 06/13/07

What do you think?

5 Trackbacks

The URI to TrackBack this entry is:
http://blogs.zdnet.com/Google/wp-trackback.php?p=605

  • Emails from the Edge; Mr. October or Zuba Tuba.
    Hello Mo;. Here we are poised on the precipice of the 21st century advance from traditional to new thinking in computers and BOTH Apple and Microsoft are sitting there almost about able to do what they've been working on since 2001 (at ...

    Trackback by VCSY, A Laughing Place, Part 3 — June 12, 2007 @ 12:40 am

  • Leopard looks like Vista - A response
    This was posted earlier on ZDNet.com, and whilst I usually have the utmost respect for these paid bloggers, I'd have to say that this was one of the most mis-informed posts I've ever had the misfortune of reading. ...

    Trackback by Apple Aficionado — June 12, 2007 @ 7:04 pm

  • 10 Ways Leopard Copied Vista
    WARNING: I do like Leopard. I just though that this was good retalliation against all the constant “Windows copied us” stuff from Apple. It’s good that the OSes copy stuff from each other– that way, they both get better. ...

    Trackback by Jason Herron .com — June 12, 2007 @ 10:14 pm

  • ZDNet writer proclaims Apple Leopard a ripoff of Vista
    I cannot let this go: Mary Jo Foley of ZDNet has established herself as ... “Instant Search” in Vista (the subsystem that Google is trying to...

    Trackback by Anonymous — June 15, 2007 @ 3:11 am

  • ZDNet writer proclaims Apple Leopard a ripoff of Vista
    There will always be the Dvoraks and general naysayers spouting flamebait and ignorant nothings regarding Macs and their beautiful operating systems; if there weren’t, well, Microsoft would be SOL. However, as someone who respects ...

    Trackback by Untitled — June 17, 2007 @ 7:40 pm

advertisement

Recent Entries

advertisement

Archives

Favorite Links

ZDNet Blogs

Fusion

advertisement
Click Here