<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8" ?><rss version="2.0" xml:base="https://www.lawfareblog.com/recent" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" xmlns:og="http://ogp.me/ns#" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:foaf="http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/" xmlns:rdfs="http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#" xmlns:sioc="http://rdfs.org/sioc/ns#" xmlns:sioct="http://rdfs.org/sioc/types#" xmlns:skos="http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#" xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#">
  <channel>
    <title>Lawfare - Hard National Security Choices</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/recent</link>
    <description></description>
    <language>en</language>
     <atom:link href="https://www.lawfareblog.com/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
      <item>
    <title>UN Special Rapporteur Releases Guantánamo Report
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/un-special-rapporteur-releases-guant%25C3%25A1namo-report</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On June 26, United Nations Special Rapporteur on Human Rights and Counter-Terrorism Fionnuala Ní Aoláin released her report following a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.ohchr.org/en/special-procedures/sr-terrorism/us-and-guantanamo-detention-facility&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;technical visit to the United States and U.S. Naval Station Guantánamo Bay&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; from Feb. 6 to May 6. She was the first UN investigator ever granted access to the detention center by the U.S. government.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Ní Aoláin‘s visit comprised three parts—the rights of victims of terrorism, the rights of detainees at Guantánamo Bay, and the rights of former detainees—and opened the “possibility to address the profound human rights violations that have occurred there and the irreparable harms to the lives and health of the 780 Muslim men who have been detained there, including 30 men who remain.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In her report, the special rapporteur found that detainees had been subjected to “cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment under international law.” She writes: &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It is evident that the horror and harms of extraordinary rendition, arbitrary detention, and systematic torture, cruel, inhuman, and degrading treatment or punishment inflicted overtime occurred in part because of an exceptional and international law deficient legal and policy regime; the permeation of arbitrariness across subsequent detention practices; and the lack of international law compliant domestic oversight and accountability.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;She also called the attacks on Sept. 11, 2001 a “crime against humanity,” and recognized that the victims “have equal right to remedy and reparation, encompassing a wide set of entitlements like access to justice and access to information.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Read the special rapporteur’s report &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23862470-2023-06-26-sr-terrorism-technical-visit-us-guantanamo-detention-facility?responsive=1&amp;amp;title=1&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;here&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; or below: &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;iframe height=&quot;905&quot; sandbox=&quot;allow-scripts allow-same-origin allow-popups allow-forms allow-popups-to-escape-sandbox&quot; src=&quot;https://embed.documentcloud.org/documents/23862470-2023-06-26-sr-terrorism-technical-visit-us-guantanamo-detention-facility/?embed=1&amp;amp;responsive=1&amp;amp;title=1&quot; style=&quot;border: 1px solid #aaa; width: 100%; height: 800px; height: calc(100vh - 100px);&quot; title=&quot;2023-06-26-SR-terrorism-technical-visit-US-guantanamo-detention-facility (Hosted by DocumentCloud)&quot; width=&quot;700&quot;&gt;&lt;/iframe&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Read the reply from the U.S. government &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23862471-2023-06-26-us-government-reply?responsive=1&amp;amp;title=1&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;here&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; or below: &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;iframe height=&quot;906&quot; sandbox=&quot;allow-scripts allow-same-origin allow-popups allow-forms allow-popups-to-escape-sandbox&quot; src=&quot;https://embed.documentcloud.org/documents/23862471-2023-06-26-us-government-reply/?embed=1&amp;amp;responsive=1&amp;amp;title=1&quot; style=&quot;border: 1px solid #aaa; width: 100%; height: 800px; height: calc(100vh - 100px);&quot; title=&quot;2023-06-26-US-government-reply (Hosted by DocumentCloud)&quot; width=&quot;700&quot;&gt;&lt;/iframe&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Tue, 27 Jun 2023 15:37:04 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Tyler McBrien</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24498</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>The Arraignment That Wasn’t
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/arraignment-wasnt</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It is a Tuesday morning in Miami, and once again, I find myself arriving at the federal courthouse at an ungodly hour. I should acknowledge an improvement; this time, I have at least arrived on the right day, rather than &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/what-actually-happened-trumps-arraignment&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;a full rotation of the Earth&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; before the hearing is scheduled to begin. That said, it is just after 5:00 a.m. ET on the right day. I am, once again, first in &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://twitter.com/AnnaBower/status/1673657690101370882&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;The Line&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Just under five hours later, I am seated on a wooden pew in courtroom 10-5  at the James Lawrence King federal office building. Along with the clutch of press seated in the rows behind me, I am here for the arraignment of Waltine Nauta, the “body man” turned co-defendant of Donald J. Trump. Nauta is set to be arraigned today on criminal charges related to false statements and conspiracy to obstruct justice. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;If, that is, he ever shows up. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As we await the magistrate judge who will preside over the hearing, a bearded man clad in a gray, slightly wrinkled suit makes his way up the aisle. This is Stanley Woodward, Nauta’s Washington, D.C.-based counsel. Yet, as the clock ticks toward the scheduled 9:45 a.m. ET starting time, Woodward’s client is nowhere in sight.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Woodward last appeared alongside his client at an initial hearing two weeks prior, when he told Magistrate Judge Jonathan Goodman that Nauta could not be arraigned because he had been unable to secure local counsel prior to the hearing. Under court rules, a defendant must be represented by local counsel admitted to practice in the Southern District of Florida—or at least be sponsored by one to appear &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;pro hac vice&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The court security officer, however, does not know that Woodward is the defendant’s attorney. As Woodward approaches the front of the gallery, she eyes him with suspicion. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;“Are you counsel of record?” she asks. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;“Well, it’s complex,” Woodward replies, a hint of frustration in his voice. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The court officer, who still appears dubious, nonetheless allows Woodward to take a seat at the table reserved for defense attorneys on the right side of the room. (Note to self: In the future, always say, “Well, it’s complicated” when challenged about whether I’m allowed to be where I am going.)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The prosecutors arrive. To my left, a pack of attorneys dressed in hues of gray and navy blue march toward their designated table. Leading the group are Jay Bratt and David Harbach of the special counsel’s office. They are trailed by their Justice Department colleagues, Karen Gilbert and Michael Thakur. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Before taking a seat, Harbach approaches the defense table, where Woodward has been quietly scrolling the docket on his computer for several minutes. After exchanging pleasantries and a brief handshake, the men tilt their faces away from the gallery. Woodward whispers animatedly into Harbach’s ear, punctuating his speech with shrugs and vigorous nods—explaining, presumably, why his client, who was scheduled to be arraigned today, is not yet in the room. Bratt, his interest piqued by the impromptu conference, floats over to listen in. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;When Woodward finally finishes his monologue, the looks on Harbach’s and Bratt’s faces suggest they are displeased. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Well, “let’s see” what the court says, Bratt tells Woodward. The prosecutors hurry back to the left side of the courtroom, where they whisper in a huddle with Gilbert and Thakur. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The whispering ends abruptly when Magistrate Judge Edwin Torres enters the room and the bailiff booms, “All rise!” Torres will preside over today’s hearing, though U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon has been assigned to the case. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;“I see that Mr. Nauta is not present,” Torres observes after the parties make their appearances for the record, eyeing the empty seat next to Woodward. He shifts his gaze to Woodward: Is there good cause for the defendant’s absence?&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Woodward jumps in to explain. Nauta was scheduled to fly to Miami from the airport in Newark, New Jersey, he says. But Nauta’s flight was among the 500 or so that were grounded as the result of weather delays. Woodward claims that Nauta spent eight hours at the airport and three hours stuck on the tarmac. Despite these “best efforts,” he “simply” could not get a flight to Miami in time for the arraignment. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Torres, in response, does not seem inclined to further interrogate the circumstances of Nauta’s absence. He finds that Nauta’s failure to appear in court today will be excused for “good cause.” But he wants to know if Woodward can “proceed with the arraignment” despite Nauta’s absence.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;“No,” Woodward replies, the arraignment cannot proceed—though the reason why has nothing to do with Nauta’s absence. Instead, Woodward  explains, Nauta has “not been able to retain local counsel” who could either represent Nauta during the arraignment or sponsor a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;pro hac vice&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; application for Woodward. As a result, Woodward asks the court to allow a brief continuance of the arraignment so that Nauta can finally find counsel admitted to the bar in the Southern District of Florida. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Torres, mulling the suggestion, turns to the Justice Department for its view on the continuance. Harbach, rising to his feet, says that the government would like to keep the delay “as brief as possible.” He notes that Judge Cannon has scheduled a pretrial conference for July 14. The prosecutors would like to avoid pushing that date back as a result of Nauta’s delayed arraignment. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Woodward, responding to the prosecution’s request, says that he has a trial in another case set for the week of July 14, which means that he will move to delay the pretrial conference anyway.  He hasn’t been able to do so yet, he says, because court rules prohibit him from filing any motions on the docket unless he has sponsorship from local counsel, which he does not. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;At this, Torres interjects to emphasize that the date of the July 14 conference is not his decision; that falls under the purview of Cannon, the presiding judge in the case. With that in mind, Torres asks about a date that could work for Woodward and Nauta. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Woodward suggests July 6. That should be enough time, he says, to retain local counsel and to get the necessary paperwork filed. In reply, Torres reminds Woodward that the court can appoint an attorney for Nauta if he cannot afford one. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Now, with the date of Nauta’s arraignment nailed down, Torres turns to location. Noting that the court has previously set arraignment proceedings in this case in Miami for “security reasons,” he suggests that the arraignment could be held in West Palm Beach if Woodward intends to request a waiver of Nauta’s appearance at that hearing. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Woodward indicates that he expects that he will file such a motion to waive Nauta’s appearance. And he expects that he will not be present for the July 6 hearing—instead, the local counsel that Nauta must inevitably hire will deal with that. “Sir, as much as I love your city, I really don’t want to be here on the sixth,” Woodward declares. Still, he continues, it would be preferable to schedule the hearing for the Miami courthouse. Miami is easier to get to in case he or his client need to show up in person, he says. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Torres, sounding stern for the first time all morning, cautions Woodward that July 6 is the “drop-dead deadline to get somebody on board.” Then he finally announces an order: “I’ll set the arraignment for next Thursday, the sixth.” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;And the hearing is over. The ratio of minutes standing in line to minutes of hearing time today clocked in at 30:1.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Tue, 27 Jun 2023 15:01:08 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Anna Bower</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24497</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>What Counterman Means for Prosecuting Trump Over Jan. 6
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/what-counterman-means-prosecuting-trump-over-jan-6</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Earlier today, the Supreme Court &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/22-138_43j7.pdf&quot;&gt;issued its opinion in &lt;em&gt;Counterman v. Colorado&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;​, holding that when a defendant is prosecuted for communicating a violent threat, the government must establish that the defendant understood, even if they did not specifically intend, that their communication would likely be perceived as threatening. &lt;em&gt;Counterman&lt;/em&gt; is an important First Amendment decision generally, but for our purposes here at &lt;em&gt;Lawfare&lt;/em&gt;, it is most interesting for what it signals about the viability and probability of a prosecution of former President Donald Trump for inciting the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In short, it just got meaningfully less likely. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Writing for the majority, Justice Kagan steered a middle ground on what the First Amendment requires for &quot;true-threats cases&quot; like the government&#039;s prosecution of Billy Counterman for repeated harassing and disturbing Facebook messages to a local musician. On the one hand, she rejected the government&#039;s position, which was supported by a dissent written by Justice Barrett and joined by Justice Thomas, that a true-threats prosecution need only establish that the defendant&#039;s communication was reasonably perceived by the recipient as threatening. On the other hand, Kagan also declined to take up the suggestion made by Justice Sotomayor in her concurrence (joined by Justice Gorsuch) that the government be required to establish that the defendant specifically intended to communicate a threat. Rather, Kagan held that it is enough that the defendant knew that the communication could be reasonably perceived as threatening—that is, that the defendant was reckless in making the threat.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;What all nine Justices did agree on, however, was that prosecutions for inciting violent or lawless action—a different crime than issuing threats—do require establishing specific intent, not just recklessness (see the majority opinion at page 13, Sotomayor&#039;s opinion at 16–18, and Barrett&#039;s opinion at 7). As Kagan explained, an intent requirement for incitement prosecutions is “a way to ensure that efforts to prosecute incitement would not bleed over, either directly or through a chilling effect, to dissenting political speech at the First Amendment’s core.” And while this part of the opinion is, technically, dicta—nonbinding because it is not strictly necessary to decide the legal question at issue (the requirements for true-threats prosecutions)—the explicitness with which the majority opinion not only addresses but announces the intent requirement, taken with the unanimous agreement it garnered on the Court, is a good indication that it should be taken as authoritative.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;em&gt;Counterman&lt;/em&gt;, therefore, will have an important effect on any future prosecution of Trump for inciting the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol. As Jed Shugerman and I have argued both &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/cassidy-hutchinsons-testimony-changed-our-minds-about-indicting-donald-trump&quot;&gt;in &lt;em&gt;Lawfare&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt; and &lt;a href=&quot;https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4256652&quot;&gt;at greater length elsewhere&lt;/a&gt; (soon to be updated to take into account the &lt;em&gt;Counterman&lt;/em&gt; decision), the combination of Trump&#039;s inflammatory &quot;Stop the Steal&quot; speech along with actions like ordering the removal of the magnetometers that kept the crowd from getting closer to him and, after the speech, commanding the Secret Service to take him to Capitol, provides a basis for prosecuting him for insurrection consistent with the First Amendment&#039;s limitation on incitement prosecutions.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;But until today it was unclear whether the government would have to establish that Trump specifically intended the violence that occurred or whether he was merely profoundly reckless as to the possibility of that violence. After &lt;em&gt;Counterman&lt;/em&gt;, no responsible prosecutor—certainly not special counsel Jack Smith—will bring an indictment against Trump unless they feel confident that they could prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that at least part of what motivated Trump to speak and act the way he did on Jan. 6 was a desire to see his supporters forcefully disrupt the certification of the electoral college vote.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;To be sure, this is not an insurmountable evidentiary burden. Trump did, after all, urge his supporters to “fight like hell,” and he did try to make it easier for an armed, angry crowd to get closer to his rabble-rousing speech. But specific intent is, by definition, harder to prove than recklessness. And, in the absence of smoking-gun evidence—for example, Trump being caught on tape telling someone that he was trying to start a riot—the prosecution would need to convince the jury that Trump’s action establish, beyond a reasonable doubt, his specific intent to cause violence rather than simply put pressure on his congressional allies or stroke his own ego.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It&#039;s easy to imagine this added burden as the determining factor in the decision of whether or not to bring a prosecution that would be even more high-stakes than Trump’s current Mar-a-Lago indictment.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Indeed, as I was reading &lt;em&gt;Counterman&lt;/em&gt;, the explicitness with which all three principal opinions underscored the intent requirement for incitement prosecutions felt almost like a cautionary signal to the Department of Justice. There is of course no indication that the Justices, either collectively or individually, are trying to backchannel. But the Justices follow the news just like the rest of us, and it’s not hard to imagine that, in the back of their minds, they’re taking advantage of an opportunity to discourage creative prosecutorial legal theories and clarify the high bar they expect an incitement prosecution to meet, whether of Trump or anyone else. Whatever their intentions, the implications of &lt;em&gt;Counterman&lt;/em&gt; will no doubt be apparent to the special counsel. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Tue, 27 Jun 2023 14:10:05 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Alan Z. Rozenshtein</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24496</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Our New Website Is Launching Tomorrow
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/our-new-website-launching-tomorrow</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;When you look at &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Lawfare&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; tomorrow, it will look different. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On Wednesday morning, we will be launching our new website, which has been more than a year in the making. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The new website reflects an enormous amount of work by a bunch of people, and it features a raft of new functionality we hope will be of value to readers and listeners and consumers of our videos and webinars. I will describe the new site and the thinking behind it in greater detail tomorrow. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;We are also changing the site’s URL. Our long-serving home, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;http://www.lawfareblog.com&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;http://www.lawfareblog.com&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, will redirect to the new site, which will be &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;http://www.lawfaremedia.org&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;http://www.lawfaremedia.org&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. This change reflects &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Lawfare&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;’s final break with its history as a blog and signals our vision moving forward: as a venue not just for our written content, but also for podcasts, webinars, and other media. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;All existing links should continue to work. But as with all changes to DNS records, it will take a number of hours for the change to propagate across the web. The result is that different readers will see the new site at different times. And there may be rough edges with some links for a little while, while we iron out the kinks.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;There may well be a few glitches in the transition and the new webpage over the next few days. It is also a work in progress and something we intend to keep refining and improving upon after launch. But we are very excited for this new chapter in &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Lawfare&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;’s history, and all the new functionality it will allow us to bring to our readers and listeners.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Tue, 27 Jun 2023 11:47:14 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Benjamin Wittes</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24495</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Senate Report Details FBI, DHS Failures Prior to Jan. 6
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/senate-report-details-fbi-dhs-failures-prior-jan-6</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On June 27, the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee issued a majority staff report entitled “Planned in Plain Sight: A Review of the Intelligence Failures in Advance of January 6th, 2021.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The report details the failures of federal law enforcement agencies—including the FBI and the Department of Homeland Security’s Office of Intelligence and Analysis—to collect and analyze intelligence on potential violence in the lead-up to the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;According to the report, “At a fundamental level, the agencies failed to fulfill their mission and connect the public and nonpublic information they received” and “multiple federal agencies failed to effectively coordinate in the lead up to January 6th, contributing to the failures that allowed the Capitol to be breached that day.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;You can read the report &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;http://v&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;here&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; or below:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;iframe height=&quot;905&quot; sandbox=&quot;allow-scripts allow-same-origin allow-popups allow-forms allow-popups-to-escape-sandbox&quot; src=&quot;https://embed.documentcloud.org/documents/23862107-hsgac-majority-report_jan-6-intel/?embed=1&amp;amp;responsive=1&amp;amp;title=1&quot; style=&quot;border: 1px solid #aaa; width: 100%; height: 800px; height: calc(100vh - 100px);&quot; title=&quot;hsgac-majority-report_jan-6-intel (Hosted by DocumentCloud)&quot; width=&quot;700&quot;&gt;&lt;/iframe&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Tue, 27 Jun 2023 11:43:50 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Katherine Pompilio</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24494</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>How Big Is the Cyber Insurance Market? Can It Keep Growing?
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/how-big-cyber-insurance-market-can-it-keep-growing</link>
    <description>&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The cyber insurance market may be small, new, and volatile, but it could also become an important form of economic security. In fact, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/National-Cybersecurity-Strategy-2023.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;the Biden administration appears to be counting on that&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. Cybersecurity strategy could be improved with a better understanding of the basic characteristics of the cyber insurance market, particularly its size, the size of the cyber reinsurance market on which it depends, where future risk capital could come from, and at what price. Publicly available data on the size and reach of the cyber insurance and reinsurance, or re/insurance, market is thin and often dated. Views on how much premium is written or coverage is outstanding often have to be cobbled together from disparate sources, with subsequent projections built on a shaky foundation. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;This piece seeks to provide a better starting point for such analysis. Using a mix of formal and informal research methods—hardly ideal but utterly practical—I’ve pulled together industry-wide estimates for cyber re/insurance premiums and coverage outstanding, as well as a view on historical growth. Further, given the strategic role that &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.schroders.com/en-bm/bm/professional/insights/what-are-insurance-linked-securities-and-how-do-they-work/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;the insurance-linked securities (ILS) market&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; could play in bringing breadth and depth to the cyber re/insurance market, I’ve included a few thoughts on the scope of cyber ILS so far, as well as how that market could continue its growth trajectory. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center; margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Sources and Methods&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It’s notoriously difficult to form a comprehensive and accurate view of the global cyber insurance market. At best, publicly available data reports tend to focus on the overall U.S. market, which may represent only 55 to 60 percent of the cyber insurance industry worldwide, according to both formal interviews and private discussions. While the data afforded by the likes of &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://bestsreview.ambest.com/edition/2022/August/index.html#page=50&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;A.M. Best&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://content.naic.org/sites/default/files/cmte-c-cyber-supplement-report-2022-for-data-year-2021.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;the National Association of Insurance Commissioners&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; tends to be the best available, it still leaves some nontrivial gaps. Company reports can range from pure propaganda to the high-quality research often produced by the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.swissre.com/institute/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Swiss Re Institute&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.munichre.com/en/solutions/for-industry-clients/natcatservice.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Munich Re NatCatSERVICE&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. Again, such reports are helpful but still offer only a partial view. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;While the following view of the cyber re/insurance market size and composition is hardly perfect, it aims to advance our collective understanding of the market as it stands today and where it could go tomorrow—while also offering something more than the “anecdata” currently shared by word of mouth. The methods used to compile the data below are mixed, beginning with a review of publicly available sources, as described above, to provide a foundation for the private sources of information gathered. This foundation was supported by interviews with seven cyber insurance executives, 10 cyber reinsurance executives, and 10 ILS managers on a wide range of cyber re/insurance market dynamics. The formal research and interviews focusing on market size and composition are supplemented by informal conversations with re/insurance and ILS market players. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The results below consist of both point estimates and ranges. In an inexact exercise, the latter can help frame the probable, and the included point estimates can be supported sufficiently based on the underlying conversations or publicly available sources. This piece is an attempt to document the side conversations that occur in any market environment and present them in a manner in which they can help with further analysis, cyber insurance market growth, and even improved cybersecurity, given &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://saisreview.sais.jhu.edu/insurance-instead-of-deterrence-a-pivot-in-cybersecurity-strategy/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;the role of insurance in economic security&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and the stated reliance on the private sector in &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/National-Cybersecurity-Strategy-2023.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;the latest U.S. National Cybersecurity Strategy&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center; margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Global Cyber Insurance Premiums and Limit Outstanding&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Global cyber market premiums tend to be easier to ascertain in retrospect, and time adds at least a bit of certainty. As a result, recent estimates are most likely to defy consensus, with those for 2023 being the most volatile by nature. The year is still in progress, and market conditions could influence the final result. Conversations with the market players and experts suggest that global cyber insurance premiums could end this year at up to $15 billion. Recent rapid rate increases, however, have slowed—which isn’t a surprise—meaning that a more modest outcome of around $13 billion is more realistic. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;For 2022, it’s also fairly difficult to estimate because it’s so recent, but global cyber insurance premiums range from &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.swissre.com/risk-knowledge/advancing-societal-benefits-digitalisation/sustainable-cyber-insurance-market.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Swiss Re’s $10 billion&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.munichre.com/topics-online/en/digitalisation/cyber/cyber-insurance-risks-and-trends-2023.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Munich Re’s $11.9 billion&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to as much as $14 billion. Several private sources put the 2022 estimate at around $10-12 billion. These numbers also square with independently calculated estimates of worldwide reinsurance premiums (more on this below). Even at the low end of the 2022 range, global cyber premiums clearly climbed sharply from the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://reports.swissre.com/2021/vision-and-strategy/market-trends/cyber&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;2021 Swiss Re estimate of $8 billion&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, itself up from only $5.5 billion in 2020.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The high rate of market concentration may contribute to some of the volatility of industry estimates. Despite the high rate of premium growth recently, the cyber insurance market remains highly concentrated. The five largest insurers account for as much as a third of the worldwide total, according to estimates gathered from formal interviews, in conjunction with the market size estimates above. Market share could vary from the range above, but the point nonetheless remains. Further, focus on cyber insurance premiums masks the fact that revenue growth does not mean an increase in protection for end insureds. In fact, premiums have grown far faster than the protection offered for cyber risks.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The amount of cyber insurance limit outstanding is even harder to estimate than premiums. Informal private conversations yield a 2022 range of around $360-500 billion. The estimates at the higher end come from sources who believe that the market shares of the largest players are relatively low, while the lower estimates reflect a belief that market concentration is quite high. A working estimate of $400-450 billion seems to be the right fit, as it would reflect an average rate on line (ROL)—or cost of insurance—ranging from around two and a half percent to a little more than three percent, which seems indicative of the recent rate increases that led to such significant premium growth. There’s still room for people to disagree reasonably, but the range of the potential 2022 premium suggests a limit outstanding of at least close to $400 billion and pretty far down from $500 billion. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center; margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Global Cyber Reinsurance Premiums and Limit Outstanding&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Historically, estimating the global reinsurance premium in the cyber market was as easy as halving the insurance estimate. A &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.researchgate.net/publication/365766378_Cyber_insurance_strengthening_resilience_for_the_digital_transformation&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Swiss Re report&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; put the rate at which insurers cede cyber to reinsurers at 45 to 50 percent, although some private sources say it could be as high as 55 percent. That would put the 2022 global reinsurance premium at $7 billion, 2021 at close to $5 billion, and 2020 at a bit under $3 billion. The year to come is more difficult to forecast, as some structural factors have changed the amount of reinsurance that insurers may consume. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Until this year, insurers have largely relied on quota share structures, through which reinsurers basically share proportionately in the business written by the insurers they cover. On the one hand, some non-proportional reinsurance covers made it into the market, but they represented a small slice of overall cyber reinsurance risk transfer. So-called event covers, which provide reinsurance protection for insurers when there is a single catastrophic cyber loss event, on the other hand, were few and far between. In 2023, however, event covers have begun to gain some traction. Because they consume less capital than quota shares, the move to more event cover may appear to cost the cyber reinsurance sector some growth. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The increased use of non-proportional reinsurance—including event covers—makes it difficult to estimate cyber reinsurance premiums by halving cyber insurance premiums, particularly because some larger cyber insurers have integrated more event covers into their risk transfer strategies. If we take 2022’s cyber insurance premium at $10-14 billion, then the worldwide cyber reinsurance premium would be something less than $5.5-7 billion, and probably closer to $5-5.5 billion. What’s interesting, though, is that nominally smaller cyber reinsurance growth could enable disproportionately faster cyber insurance market growth, since insurers would be able to keep more of their attritional business, hedge out the catastrophic exposure, and use their capital more efficiently. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Market concentration appears to have been alleviated to some extent by the entry of new reinsurers into the sector. The five largest reinsurers accounted for &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/federal-cyber-insurance-backstop-premature&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;more than 80 percent&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of worldwide premiums in 2021, and for 2022, that concentration fell to 50-60 percent. The sharp drop is implied by two underlying factors evident especially in the formal interviews. One is the entry of new participants, or reinsurers, into the market. Admittedly, this did little to alleviate the previously high rate of market concentration directly. The second factor is that smaller and mid-sized reinsurers not only saw rate increases from their quota share business but also saw those rate increases as a reason to lean further into the cyber reinsurance market, a move further encouraged by the post-ransomware lull (at least in terms of insured losses, if not actual attacks) beginning in the second half of 2021. However, even these expansionary forces have been dulled by access to additional capital. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Several reinsurers revealed in their formal interviews that they would need access to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.artemis.bm/glossary/retrocession/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;retrocession&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; (reinsurance for reinsurance companies) to support further growth. While some reinsurers already write retrocession—“retro,” as it’s known colloquially—they don’t offer much capacity. Further, many prospective buyers would like to see retro come from outside the reinsurance sector as a way to protect against systemic risk. Even with the changes over the past year, cyber reinsurance remains highly concentrated. A few changes in business strategy could cause a meaningful chunk of that risk capital to be diverted to other classes of business. That’s why reinsurers need access to a separate source of retro capital, and that points directly to the ILS market.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center; margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Nascent Cyber ILS Market&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;ILS refers to a segment of the global re/insurance industry that uses capacity from the capital markets. As insurers lay off risk to reinsurers, both insurers and reinsurers may package up risk into a variety of formats to secure protection from these outside sources of capital. Initially seen as an outlet for retro in the property-catastrophe space, the ILS market has evolved to take on additional risks, although natural catastrophe is still the bulk of what the sector covers. In fact, the role that the ILS market initially played in “peak peril” risk transfer—the most difficult systemic risks, such as a hurricane in Florida or a typhoon in Japan—is seen as a model for how it could operate in the cyber re/insurance market, where peak perils could be viewed as cloud outage and self-replicating malware. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The cyber re/insurance market has sought ILS involvement for years, even before my early efforts to help develop the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.artemis.bm/news/pcs-launches-global-cyber-index-service-for-risk-transfer-industry/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Property Claim Services (PCS) Global Cyber&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; industry loss index in 2017. In fact, the PCS team (which I led at the time) began working on the loss index to support the forms of &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.artemis.bm/library/what-are-industry-loss-warranties-ilws/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;alternative risk transfer&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that ILS managers would want to consume. It has taken time for protection buyers to understand some of the quirks of ILS risk transfer—from collateral management to minimum ROLs—with early trading consisting of small, bespoke transactions with little opportunity to scale. But that’s changing—quickly. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The cyber ILS market has achieved a limit outstanding of as much as $1 billion, roughly a 100 percent year-over-year increase. The fact that it is still a hair less than one percent of the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.artemis.bm/ils-fund-managers/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;$104.9 billion in ILS capital&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; currently under management suggests not just that cyber ILS is still small but also that it has plenty of room for growth. The fact that cyber is a diversifying risk for ILS managers focused heavily on natural catastrophes could make it an increasingly attractive class of business for some. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Further cyber re/insurance market maturation will be necessary to enable access to more ILS capital. Interviews suggest that further improvements to event definition will help, as well as the issuance of liquid instruments (with the recent &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://therecord.media/in-an-industry-first-insurance-firm-announces-cyber-bond-to-cover-claims-over-300-million&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;cyber catastrophe bond&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; being a good first step). Finally, cyber risk and event modeling, according to most interview participants, need to continue to advance in order to more fully meet the needs of ILS managers. The good news is that the market is generally headed in the right direction and simply needs to continue to refine what it already does.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center; margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;How to Raise the Stakes Responsibly&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Cyber re/insurance market growth is certainly important in its own right. It’s possible to claim dismissively—or even derisively—that an expanded cyber re/insurance market is simply a way to drive more profit into the insurance industry. Of course it is. And there’s nothing wrong with that. Successful businesses are good. Successful insurers continue to provide financial protection to society. That’s a worthy enough aim in itself. But the stakes are far higher than commercial success. Cyber re/insurance has emerged as a key pillar for cybersecurity, just as re/insurance has long been a largely unsung contributor to economic security. As the most recent &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/National-Cybersecurity-Strategy-2023.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;U.S. National Cybersecurity Strategy&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; reveals, cyber re/insurance plays a direct role in economic security and could play a larger one as time passes.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-bottom:11px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The quantification of the current state of the global cyber re/insurance market explored here—as well as the support offered by the ILS sector—provides a crucial reference point for further strategic planning, be it corporate or state security. Much of the analysis produced has had to rely on tenuous assumptions, optimistic projections, and, frankly, guesswork. It’s tough to operate under those circumstances. With at least a preliminary view of the size and composition of the global cyber re/insurance market, the analysts, scholars, and other stakeholders looking at the cyber re/insurance market hopefully will be able to apply their talent to greater effect.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Tue, 27 Jun 2023 11:01:07 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Tom Johansmeyer</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24493</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>The Lawfare Podcast: What the Hell Happened in Russia?
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-what-hell-happened-russia</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;It was a heck of a weekend in Russia. There was an insurrection, kind of? A coup, sort of? A column of troops led by Wagner chieftain Yevgeny Prigozhin marched toward Moscow from Rostov-on-Don, threatened the destabilization of the Putin regime, and then in a sudden back flip, everybody stood down and the whole thing was resolved in a weird deal between the Russian president and the renegade mercenary.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;To talk it all through, &lt;em&gt;Lawfare&lt;/em&gt; Editor-in-Chief Benjamin Wittes sat down with Alina Polyakova, President of the Center for European Policy Analysis; cybersecurity guru and &lt;em&gt;Lawfare &lt;/em&gt;Contributing Editor Matt Tait; and Dmitri Alperovitch of the Silverado Policy Accelerator. They talked about what happened over the weekend, what they know and what they think, what it might mean for Vladimir Putin&#039;s regime, and what it might mean for the war in Ukraine. &lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;
&lt;iframe frameborder=&quot;0&quot; height=&quot;110px&quot; src=&quot;https://embed.acast.com/60518a52f69aa815d2dba41c/649a59f801b7f100115fda14&quot; width=&quot;100%&quot;&gt;&lt;/iframe&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Tue, 27 Jun 2023 05:01:24 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Jen Patja Howell</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24492</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Yevgeny Prigozhin, We Knew Him When
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/yevgeny-prigozhin-we-knew-him-when</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;When Russian catering magnate-turned-warlord Yevgeny Prigozhin &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/06/24/world/europe/prigozhin-putin-russia.html?name=styln-russia-ukraine&amp;amp;region=TOP_BANNER&amp;amp;block=storyline_menu_recirc&amp;amp;action=click&amp;amp;pgtype=LegacyCollection&amp;amp;variant=undefined&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;announced his mutiny&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; against the country’s Ministry of Defense and began his soon-to-be aborted march toward Moscow this past Friday, most American news coverage—understandably—focused on Prigozhin’s role as leader of the paramilitary Wagner Group. After all, it was the Wagner mercenaries under Prigozhin, on whom the Russian military has relied heavily in prosecuting the invasion of Ukraine, who seemed to be gearing up for a possible coup against Russian President Vladimir Putin. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;But here at &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Lawfare, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;we were reminded of a different, earlier business venture of Prigozhin’s—one that had significantly less to do with mutiny, and significantly more to do with Facebook memes.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In between his gig as the owner of a hot dog stand in 1990s Russia, and his attempted uprising against the Putin government thirty years later, Prigozhin made news in the United States for his role in Russian election interference. According to Special Counsel Robert Mueller, Prigozhin established and funded the Internet Research Agency—the “troll farm” famous for posting divisive content on U.S. social media platforms in the runup to the 2016 election. Back in those days, the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Lawfare &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;team closely followed Prigozhin’s adventures. Now that Prigozhin has graduated from a U.S. indictment on charges of conspiracy to defraud the United States, to a brief criminal investigation in his home country for inciting an armed rebellion against the Russian government, to a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://edition.cnn.com/europe/live-news/russia-ukraine-war-news-06-26-23/h_6ce99c171c7c349ca0cdf9e985dc41a6&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;possible dismissal&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of that investigation now that he’s turned around and departed for Belarus, we’re proud to say we knew him way back when. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Prigozhin has seized headlines in the last 72 hours, and for good reason. After &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://apnews.com/article/putin-russia-ukraine-war-prigozhin-infighting-0e051f0a43522f57ef1810a8b03f6e62&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;months of harsh public criticism&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu over Russia’s lackluster performance in its war against Ukraine, Prigozhin ratcheted up his rhetoric and demanded Shoigu’s ouster on June 23. The next day, Wagner troops, under Prighozin’s command, took control of the Russian military’s southern headquarters in the city of Rostov-on-Don, which &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/2023/06/25/wagner-rebellion-rostov-scenes/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;led to surreal scenes&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of soldiers waiting in line for coffee and a seemingly unflappable city worker sweeping the street in between tanks and armored vehicles. Prigozhin then ordered his troops to march on Moscow. The Wagner columns came within 120 miles of Russia’s capital, until Prigozhin called off his dogs, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-wagner-prigozhin-9acbdf1eda849692ca0423a4116058d1&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;as a result of an apparent deal&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; struck between the Wagner commander and the Kremlin.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Americans not closely following the war in Ukraine could be forgiven for wondering: who exactly is this guy? Prigozhin got his start as a hot dog salesman in St. Petersburg, following his release from a Soviet prison on robbery charges. He went on to build a catering empire and became known as “Putin’s chef” for the many contracts he won with the Kremlin; many &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/26/business/dealbook/prigozhins-wagner-money.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;press photos&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of government functions show Prigozhin displaying plates of food to the Russian president. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;But Prigozhin’s activities quickly expanded beyond food service. In the mid-2010s, journalists and investigators began to trace links between the caterer and the Wagner Group, a paramilitary organization that &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.bbc.com/news/world-60947877&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;backed pro-Russian “separatists” in eastern Ukraine in 2014&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/15/world/europe/russia-syria-mercenaries.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;deployed to Syria&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to back Syrian President Bashar al-Assad against a rebellion. Wagner Group mercenaries are also &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.bbc.com/news/world-60947877&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;widely known to operate across several Afri&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;can countries&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, mostly on behalf of authoritarian regimes or warlords. They’ve supported General Khalifa Haftar’s forces in Libya,  guarded diamond mines in the Central African Republic (CAR), and propped up the CAR’s weak president, Faustin-Archange Touadéra. Another Prigozhin-linked company &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.brookings.edu/blog/order-from-chaos/2022/02/08/russias-wagner-group-in-africa-influence-commercial-concessions-rights-violations-and-counterinsurgency-failure/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;received diamond and gold mining licenses&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in CAR around the time that Wagner came to Touadéra’s aid.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Strong evidence suggests these forces have committed war crimes and other atrocities. A UN report &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/may/20/russian-mercenaries-behind-slaughter-in-mali-village-un-report-finds&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;linked Wagner soldiers to the slaughter of roughly 500 people&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in a Malian village in March 2022, along with the rape and torture of scores more. The group also &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.cbsnews.com/news/russia-wagner-group-central-african-republic-bambari-massacre-rape-mass-murder/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;stands accused of several massacres of civilians&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in CAR. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Throughout this period, Prigozhin was touchy about any reporting concerning his involvement with Wagner. In 2021, he &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/jan/24/uk-government-let-lawyers-bypass-sanctions-to-help-putin-ally-sue-journalist&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;brought a U.K. libel case against Eliot Higgins&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, the founder of the open-source investigative group Bellingcat, who had published evidence about Prigozhin’s involvement with the group. (After finally acknowledging his Wagner role in September of the following year, Prigozhin said about his previous denials that &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/24/yevgeny-prigozhin-the-hotdog-seller-who-rose-to-the-top-of-putin-war-machine-wagner-group&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;“in any issue there should be room for sport.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;) Higgins, for his trouble, was stuck with an estimated bill for £70,000 in legal fees, even though &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.ft.com/content/8c8b0568-cdd1-4529-a4fd-82e57983ddc5&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;the case sputtered out&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; when &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.bellingcat.com/app/uploads/2022/05/BEL.00548.PRESS_.2022.05.18.Press-Release-Struck-Out-vf.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Prigozhin’s British lawyers withdrew&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; following the invasion of Ukraine. Journalists in Russia have not been so lucky. In February 2022, a Moscow court &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://ipi.media/alerts/court-in-moscow-finds-journalist-venediktov-guilty-of-defamation-against-head-of-wagner-group/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;found Russian journalist Alexey Venediktov guilty of defamation&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; for calling Prigozhin the “overlord of PMC Wagner.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;But after the beginning of the war in Ukraine, Prigozhin’s coyness around his involvement with Wagner quickly vanished. In September 2022, he &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/sep/26/putin-ally-yevgeny-prigozhin-admits-founding-wagner-mercenary-group&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;proudly announced&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that he’d founded Wagner. As one of the bigger boosters of the invasion, he popped up recruiting Russians—&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/06/24/russia-wagner-prigozhin-insurrection-explained/?utm_campaign=wp_main&amp;amp;utm_medium=social&amp;amp;utm_source=twitter&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;including prisoners&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;—to join Wagner and travel to Ukraine to fight alongside the Russian military. Wagner mercenaries grew increasingly prominent in the war as the army struggled, and Prigozhin’s troops notched a few victories for Russia—committing atrocities in the process. The most notable of both occurred in the Ukrainian city of Bakhmut, where Wagner soldiers led the charge, racking up substantial casualties on both sides.  In one disturbing incident, Wagner troops &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wsj.com/articles/grim-life-and-brutal-death-of-a-wagner-recruit-40d9473a&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;executed a returned defector&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; with a sledgehammer. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As part of his sudden eagerness to associate himself with his own private military force, Prigozhin also publicly took credit for the first time for another of his businesses, the Internet Research Agency (IRA). The “troll farm,” as it’s come to be known, was centrally involved in Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election. Though Prigozhin had &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.reuters.com/world/us/russias-prigozhin-admits-interfering-us-elections-2022-11-07/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;previously admitted generally to interfering in U.S. elections&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, he &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/russias-prigozhin-admits-links-what-us-says-was-election-meddling-troll-farm-2023-02-14/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;specifically copped to his leading role&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in a social media post from February 2023. &quot;I was never just the financier of the Internet Research Agency,” he wrote. “I thought it up, I created it, I managed it for a long time.&quot; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The IRA’s existence was &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://medium.com/dfrlab/the-russians-who-exposed-russias-trolls-72db132e3cd1&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;first reported on by the Russian opposition outlet Novaya Gazeta&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in 2013. The paper chronicled how the organization would coordinate to spread pro-Kremlin propaganda or disruptive falsehoods using fake accounts on social media. Further reporting by the paper Moy Rayon unearthed links between Prigozhin and the IRA, tracing the agency’s corporate ownership to a holding company owned by Prigozhin. And the Mueller investigation would uncover further links, mapping out the links between Prigozhin’s companies and the financial support flowing to the IRA. According to a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.193579/gov.uscourts.dcd.193579.1.0_3.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;February 2018 indictment&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, just before Prigozhin’s birthday, the organization “arranged for a real U.S. person to stand in front of the White House in the District of Columbia under false pretenses to hold a sign that read ‘Happy 55th Birthday Dear Boss.’” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;That indictment, along with the Mueller report and separate reports released by the Senate Intelligence Committee, provides extensive detail about the IRA’s operations during the 2016 election cycle. As the Mueller report puts it:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The IRA later used social media accounts and interest groups to sow discord in the U.S. political system through what it termed &quot;information warfare.&quot; The campaign evolved from a generalized program designed in 2014 and 2015 to undermine the U.S. electoral system, to a targeted operation that by early 2016 favored candidate Trump and disparaged candidate Clinton. The IRA&#039;s operation also included the purchase of political advertisements on social media in the names of U.S. persons and entities, as well as the staging of political rallies inside the United States. To organize those rallies, IRA employees posed as U.S. grassroots entities and persons and made contact with Trump supporters and Trump Campaign officials in the United States. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It’s important to keep in mind, though, that the agency  was only one element in Russia’s interference campaign against the US during the 2016 election. While the IRA conducted social media influence efforts, Russian military intelligence (GRU) &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.justice.gov/archives/sco/file/1373816/download&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;focused on a ‘hack-and-dump’ operation&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; against the Clinton campaign. The GRU stole “hundreds of thousands of documents” and later leaked them “through online personas, “DCLeaks” and “Guccifer 2.0,” and later through the organization WikiLeaks.” According to the Mueller report, the leak “was designed and timed to interfere with the 2016 U.S. presidential election and undermine the Clinton Campaign.” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Russian “active measures”—which the Mueller report defines as “operations conducted by Russian security services aimed at influencing the course of international affairs”—began in 2014, when the IRA began building its network of accounts on platforms like Facebook, YouTube, and Twitter (and later Tumblr and Instagram). These accounts pretended to be personal accounts of US persons. By early 2015, the IRA evolved its tactics, and focused on creating social media pages or groups “that claimed (falsely) to be affiliated with U.S. political and grassroots organizations. In certain cases, the IRA created accounts that mimicked real U.S. organizations.” These accounts covered a range of issues across the political spectrum. As Alina Polyakova &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/what-mueller-report-tells-us-about-russian-influence-operations&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;explains&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, “It was only once the IRA established its audience base that it turned explicitly to the U.S. elections around February 2016, with the explicit goal of undermining the Clinton campaign.” The final step in this campaign was to actively promote Trump’s campaign, which it started doing around the spring of 2016.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Russian presence and reach on platforms like Facebook and Twitter was significant. The IRA spent around $100,000 on over 3,500 ads on Facebook. According to the report, “the IRA’s social media accounts reached tens of millions of U.S. persons. Individual IRA social media accounts attracted hundreds of thousands of followers.” In August 2018, Facebook deactivated several IRA-controlled accounts, which had “made over 80,000 posts” reaching “at least 29 million US persons. On Twitter, the strategy included the use of individual accounts pretending to be individuals, and the use of a bot network that amplified its existing content. In early 2018, Twitter identified 3,814 accounts associated with the IRA; 1.4 million people were believed to “have been in contact with an IRA-controlled account.” Some of the popular tweets were quoted by media outlets who “attributed them to the reactions of real U.S. persons” and several “high-profile US persons” —including several affiliated with the Trump campaign—promoted IRA tweets.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The IRA also attempted to target and recruit US persons who could amplify its content online, and they pursued these people across the political spectrum. The recruited would moderate social media groups or even “perform political acts”—some of them bizarre performances, like “walking around New York City dressed up as Santa Claus with a Trump mask.” But the IRA was particularly interested in engaging with people affiliated with the Trump campaign. In many cases, campaign affiliates promoted content produced by the IRA, seemingly without knowing its origin. In the few instances in which the IRA employees reached out to the campaign directly, they requested “signs and other materials to use at rallies” or “help coordinate logistics.” The investigation did not identify “evidence that any Trump Campaign official understood the requests were coming from foreign nationals,” and the extent of coordination seems to have been limited to volunteers setting aside some signs. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The IRA’s ambitions did not stop at viral memes. The report shows that the IRA hoped to extend its influence into “real life” by organizing dozens of rallies. Starting in 2015 with the “confederate rally,” it attempted to organize gatherings on “socially divisive issues in the United States.” Attendance at these rallies was not consistent, with some of them drawing “few (if any) participants, while others drew hundreds.” The organization of these rallies seems to have followed a similar playbook to social media activity. Only in June 2016 the rallies began to focus on the election “often promoting the Trump Campaign and opposing the Clinton Campaign.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Mueller’s February 2018 indictment named Prigozhin as a defendant along with the IRA, 13 other Russians, and two of Prigozhin’s companies, Concord Management and Consulting and Concord Catering. (In a strange twist, the indictment became public &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/24/world/middleeast/american-commandos-russian-mercenaries-syria.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;within weeks of a firefight&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in Syria between the U.S. military and Wagner Group mercenaries, which ended with multiple Wagner members and up to 300 pro-Assad Syrian fighters dead.) The two Concord entities fought the charges, arguing that the indictment should  be dismissed on the grounds that, among other things, Mueller had been &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/5001625-Motion-to-Dismiss-Case-Based-on-the-Special.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;appointed “unlawfully&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;” and the charges were “&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/5004929-Memorandum-in-Support-of-Motion-to-Dismiss-08-31.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;unconstitutionally vague&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;.”After a prolonged back-and-forth, in &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/document-concord-management-used-discovery-disinformation-campaign-mueller-says&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;January 2019&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, the Justice Department accused Concord of using the case to obtain &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/16/us/politics/concord-case-russian-interference.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;confidential information&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; from the government that it then “altered and disseminated as part of a disinformation campaign&quot; seeking to undermine the credibility of the Mueller investigation. In order to prevent Concord from obtaining any further information and publishing it online, including government sources and methods for an investigation, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-usa-trump-russia-concord-idUKKBN214068&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;prosecutors recommended&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; the charges be dropped in the interest of preserving national security. The judge tossed out the case.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;That wasn’t the end of the U.S. government’s efforts to counter the troll farm, though. In March 2018, the US Department of the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm0312&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;sanctioned the IRA LLC&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, Concord Management and Consulting, and Concord Catering along with Prigozhin and twelve other individuals for their interference with the 2016 election and malicious cyberattacks. In December that year, the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm577&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;OFAC issued new designations&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; related to the IRA. These designations linked the IRA to Project Lakhta, a Russian effort “which has sought to interfere in political and electoral systems worldwide.” The Concord enterprises are named as the controllers and funders of Lakhta.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Despite efforts to suspend and remove IRA activity online, the troll farm keeps plugging away. “Gentlemen, we have interfered, we do interfere and we will interfere,” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/07/us/politics/yevgeny-prigozhin-putin-ally-elections.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Prigozhin wrote in advance of the 2022 U.S. midterm elections&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. In March 2023, the National Intelligence Council made public the declassified version of an &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/ICA-declass-16MAR21.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;assessment on foreign threats to the 2020 elections&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;which found “short-lived troll farms that used unwitting third-country nationals in Ghana, Mexico, and Nigeria.” The social media research company Graphika has documented &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;IRA operations on Facebook&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in the Central African Republic and South Africa, which took place over the course of 2020. Thanks to the #WagnerLeaks—hacked documents on Prigozhin’s companies—we now have a better picture of how the troll-farms controlled by Prigozhin &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.businessinsider.com/yevgeny-prigozhin-wagnerleaks-wagner-putin-hack-mexico-trolls-facebook-instagram-2023-2&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;operated in&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; Mexico. And even after the IRA was designated in March, the Federal News Agency LLC—which was used by Project Lakhta to “obscure its activities”—announced “a new Russian-funded, English-language website called USA Really.” USA Really acted similarly to the IRA, posting content on divisive issues and attempting to hold rallies.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Treasury’s OFAC has continued to designate and take action against IRA-related individuals and entities. In September 2020, three actors that supported the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm1118&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;IRA’s cryptocurrency accounts&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; were sanctioned. The OFAC has continued to increase its pressure on Prigozhin, sanctioning him pursuant Executive Order 13848 on election interference, Executive Order 13693 for cyber activity, and Executive Order 13661 for activity in Ukraine. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm787&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;“Several” of his private jets&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and his &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm1058&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;mining interests&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm1133&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;in Sudan&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; have been targeted by the Treasury.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;What will happen to Prigozhin next is anyone’s guess. As of now, he’s &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/06/26/putin-prigozhin-russia-rebellion-wagner/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;said to have accepted a deal to travel to Belarus&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, although it’s not exactly clear where he is or what will happen to Wagner troops in Ukraine. From our perspective, though, it’s also worth asking what Prigozhin’s fall from grace might mean for future information operations coming out of the IRA. On the social media platform BlueSky, former Twitter Head of Trust and Safety Yoel Roth &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://staging.bsky.app/profile/yoyoel.com/post/3jyukxwobpd2x&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;has suggested&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that he’d “expect less—and less successful—activity” from the organization in the 2024 U.S. presidential election. (He also noted that the agency reportedly struggled with staffing reductions and low morale in 2020—perhaps just like any other tech startup.)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It can be tempting to exaggerate the IRA’s influence. In the U.S. context, there is scant evidence that the trolling operation made any significant difference in the 2016 election, much less that it won the election for Trump. There’s good reason to believe that the GRU hack-and-leak, which relied on the credulity of the mainstream press, was actually far more influential than the social media prong of the operation—though even there, the specific electoral impact is impossible to pin down. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;At the same time, it would also be a mistake to write off Prigozhin’s troll factory as a silly sideshow. As Jim Rutenberg &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/02/magazine/russiagate-paul-manafort-ukraine-war.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;has written in the New York Times&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, the war in Ukraine casts into sharp relief the connections between far-right, antidemocratic forces in the U.S. and Russia, with Ukraine caught in between. Some of the communications described by Mueller between a suspected GRU spy and Trump’s campaign manager Paul Manafort involve a Russia-backed “peace plan” for eastern Ukraine that would have involved massive concessions to Russia from the government in Kyiv—presaging the Russian invasion six years later. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;An outright invasion is, of course, a very different thing than an information operation.  But the Ukraine war shows that Prigozhin and Putin, whatever the current state of their relationship, have been collaborators in a series of efforts to undermine democratic self-governance around the world, by seeking to influence elections and now by directly attacking a burgeoning democracy in Ukraine. It’s likewise harder to write off Russia’s 2016 election interference as fair play by Putin now that the far-right regime in the Kremlin has launched a war to obliterate its democratic neighbor, with Prigozhin differing only on the question of how much support his private army should receive in service of that invasion. Unlike some of the bizarre memes that the Internet Research Agency posted on Facebook, that’s not funny at all.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Mon, 26 Jun 2023 18:48:20 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Quinta Jurecic, Gia Kokotakis, Eugenia Lostri, Tyler McBrien</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24491</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>703 Ways Trump’s Mar-a-Lago Conduct Bears No Resemblance to Hillary Clinton’s Emails
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/703-ways-trumps-mar-lago-conduct-bears-no-resemblance-hillary-clintons-emails</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;“When caught, Hillary [Clinton] then deleted and acid washed ... 33,000 emails in defiance of a congressional subpoena already launched,” ex-President Donald Trump&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.rev.com/blog/transcripts/trump-responds-to-charges-in-speech-following-arraignment-in-federal-court-transcript&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;lamented&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; on the evening after his federal arraignment on 37 counts of willful retention of national defense information, obstruction of justice, and false statements. “There’s never been obstruction as grave as that. . . . Hillary Clinton broke the law and she didn’t get indicted.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;“Is there a different standard for a Democratic secretary of state versus a former Republican president?”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://apnews.com/article/trump-indictment-clinton-classified-documents-republican-claims-7681bc9807ecd8bc37fd3f39b9756cc7&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;asked&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; Florida governor and Republican presidential hopeful Ron DeSantis shortly after news of Trump’s classified-documents&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/23841854/us_v_trump-nauta_23-80101-color-photos.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;indictment&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; broke. “I think there needs to be one standard of justice in this country.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Many Republicans who know in their guts that, as I will establish in this piece, Trump’s conduct is palpably different from Clinton’s are publicly encouraging the corrosive myth that a double standard has been applied in the indictment of one and the non-prosecution of the other. Here’s Sen. Lindsey Graham doing just that&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12183213/Hes-not-spy-Lindsey-Graham-slams-espionage-charges-against-Trump-ridiculous.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;on ABC’s &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;This Week&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; earlier this month: “Most Republicans believe we live in a country where Hillary Clinton did very similar things and nothing happened to her.” Note&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;that Graham didn’t say that &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;he&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; believed we live in that world. Yet he managed to leave the impression that he was sympathetic to that view and that Republicans who held it were justified in doing so.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Even Fox News chief political analyst Brit Hume, while voicing concerns about Trump’s conduct, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.mediaite.com/news/foxs-brit-hume-calls-trump-out-cold-the-one-thing-were-not-hearing-is-he-didnt-do-these-things/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;did a version&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of the “many-Republicans-believe” dodge recently:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;At the same time, of course, . . . we’re going to hear an awful lot about the unequal application of justice from [Trump’s] defenders and perhaps from his defense team in light of the way in particularly the Hillary Clinton case was handled, where she was, where James Comey, then FBI director, had conducted an investigation of her handling of material at her home in New York and outlined a case that he said could be brought but shouldn’t be. He didn’t dispute her guilt.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;For the record, Comey &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;did&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; dispute Clinton’s guilt.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.fbi.gov/news/press-releases/statement-by-fbi-director-james-b-comey-on-the-investigation-of-secretary-hillary-clinton2019s-use-of-a-personal-e-mail-system&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;His view&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; was that “no reasonable prosecutor would bring such a case” because her state of mind, which he described as “extremely careless,” didn’t make out a crime.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Importantly, the crux of Clinton’s case, unlike Trump’s, was about gradations of carelessness, recklessness, and gross negligence—states of mind that can constitute felonies only in rare situations, like manslaughter. This fact alone already makes Clinton’s case qualitatively different from Trump’s. None of the seven crimes that a Florida grand jury found Trump to have committed hinges on proving a defendant’s “extreme carelessness.” Trump is&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/23841854/us_v_trump-nauta_23-80101-color-photos.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;accused of&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; acting “with intent,” “knowingly,” “willfully,” and “corruptly,” and of doing so over a period of 18 months. The&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/23841854/us_v_trump-nauta_23-80101-color-photos.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;indictment&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; alleges that he told bald-faced lies to at least two of his own lawyers—Evan Corcoran and Christina Bobb in June 2022—in an effort to persist in, and cover-up, his 31 other intentional crimes. It alleges that he repeatedly urged one of those lawyers, Corcoran, to conceal or destroy documents on his behalf, in both May and June of 2022. It alleges that Trump enlisted multiple employees into his obstructive conduct, at least one of whom became an active co-conspirator. Though indictments never set forth all the evidence the government intends to use to prove them, this one does foreshadow the evidence that supports it; at a minimum, that includes the testimony of multiple eyewitnesses, text messages, photographs, video surveillance footage, and an audio recording.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In contrast, let’s review the evidence of Hillary Clinton’s conduct. While that evidence is by no means flattering, it is not just different from Trump’s, it is radically different. Different to the point that the insistence on their similarity is not a matter of reasonable interpretation. It is, rather, a kind of lie—a lie either to make Clinton’s conduct look worse than it was, to make Trump’s look more benign than it was, or both at the same time. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;From July 2015 to July 2016, a team of FBI investigators and federal prosecutors conducted a&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://vault.fbi.gov/hillary-r.-clinton/Hillary%20R.%20Clinton%20Part%2001/view&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;probe&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, code-named Midyear Exam, into Hillary Clinton’s use of a private email server during her years as secretary of state. The Midyear probe was later scrutinized by a maniacally meticulous meta-probe conducted by the Department of Justice’s Inspector General’s Office, which produced a 568-page&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/4515884/DOJ-OIG-2016-Election-Final-Report.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;report&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in June 2018.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Although the Midyear team looked at four federal criminal statutes, it quickly&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/4515884/DOJ-OIG-2016-Election-Final-Report.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;concluded&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that only one of them conceivably reached Clinton’s conduct. That was&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/793&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;18 U.S.C. §793(f)(1),&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; whose language purports to make it a felony for someone, “through gross negligence,” to permit national security information “to be removed from its proper place of custody.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;After reviewing past military and civilian prosecutions under § 793(f)(1), however; past declinations of prosecution under it; and the legislative history of that provision, which was originally enacted in 1917, the Midyear team&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/4515884/DOJ-OIG-2016-Election-Final-Report.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;concluded&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that the term “gross negligence,” as used in Section 793(f)(1), required conduct “so gross as to almost suggest deliberate intention,” criminally reckless, or “something that falls just a little short of being willful.” For reasons laid out below, the Midyear investigators found that Clinton’s “extreme carelessness” did not meet that standard. In fact, they concluded that an attempt to prosecute her might well lead to a court’s striking down that provision of law as unconstitutional.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Some readers will interject at this point: What about the 30,000 emails Trump says Clinton destroyed? What about the acid baths and the smashed computers? Why wasn’t that obstruction of justice?&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;We will look at that allegation, too. At this stage, suffice it to say that the true facts surrounding Clinton’s emails did not spur the investigators or lawyers at either the FBI or the Justice Department or the US Attorney’s office in the Eastern District of Virginia or the inspector general’s office to believe that any of the six obstruction or false statement charges now leveled against Trump—or any other obstruction charges anywhere on the books—were even remotely implicated.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In 2018, the inspector general&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/4515884/DOJ-OIG-2016-Election-Final-Report.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;concluded&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that the Midyear team’s decision not to prosecute Clinton was plausible, reasonable, and unremarkable. “We found no evidence that the conclusions by Department prosecutors were affected by bias or other improper considerations,” the report says. “[R]ather, we concluded that they were based on the prosecutors’ assessment of the facts, the law, and past Department practice.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Because the investigation of Hillary Clinton’s emails occurred seven to eight years ago, many readers may not remember what actually happened. In light of the ubiquitous claims of a “double standard” now being bandied about, let’s go through the actual facts found by the investigation. The exercise reveals that there are at least 703 powerful reasons that Trump’s case is both more worthy of prosecution and more prosecutable—i.e., provable—than Clinton’s.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Except where otherwise indicated, the factual account below is drawn from the findings of the June 2018&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/4515884/DOJ-OIG-2016-Election-Final-Report.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;inspector general’s report&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Hillary&#039;s Emails&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On Jan. 21, 2009, Hillary Clinton became secretary of state. When she did, she continued using a private email server that she and her husband, ex-President Bill Clinton, had been using since 2008. That server was located in their home in Chappaqua, New York. In January 2009, Hillary directed aides to create for her a “clintonemail.com” account on that server “as a matter of convenience,” she later told the FBI. Although some have retrospectively suggested that she set up the account to circumvent Freedom of Information Act inquiries, there has never been any evidence that she set up a private email server with an eye toward later mishandling classified information. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Clinton used the clintonemail.com domain for both personal and official emails. She also used a personal mobile device for official and personal emails “to avoid carrying multiple devices,” she later told the FBI.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Clinton and her husband upgraded server equipment shortly after she took office, in March 2009. About four years later, on Feb. 1, 2013, she stepped down as secretary of state. Soon thereafter, she and her husband upgraded the server again. That third server was maintained by a Colorado-based company called Platte River Networks, which kept the server at offices in New Jersey. The server was maintained by a Platte River employee named Paul Combetta.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In May 2014, more than a year after Clinton left office, the U.S. House Select Committee on Benghazi was formed to investigate the terrorist attack on the U.S. Temporary Mission Facility in Libya in September 2012. The committee requested certain documents from the State Department.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Sometime that summer, the department realized that it could not locate Clinton’s emails. It reached out to attorney Cheryl Mills, who had been Clinton’s chief of staff and counselor during her State Department years. Mills told the department about the “clintonemail.com” addresses. Department officials then instructed Mills to produce Clinton’s emails from those accounts. The officials also told her, Mills later told the FBI, that it was Clinton’s or Mill’s&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt; “obligation to filter out personal emails from what was provided to State.” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;(Emphasis added.)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Clinton then told Mills and Clinton’s personal attorney, David Kendall of Williams &amp;amp; Connolly, to oversee the process of providing Clinton’s work-related emails to the State Department.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;&lt;strong&gt;The Culling and the &#039;Oh Shit&#039; Moment&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In late summer 2014, Mills contacted Platte River Networks employee Combetta, who administered Clinton’s server. Mills instructed him to copy and transfer her emails onto laptops belonging to Mills and Heather Samuelson, a lawyer who had been Clinton’s White House liaison when she was Secretary of State, so that they could cull through them, as the State Department had instructed, winnowing out the personal from the work-related emails.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The three attorneys—Mills, Samuelson, and Kendall—did not personally search through the content of Clinton’s 60,000-plus emails. Instead, they did what litigation attorneys typically do during discovery; they devised an automated search protocol that looked for certain header or footer information and for certain keywords, and sorted through them that way. Samuelson did, however,&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://vault.fbi.gov/hillary-r.-clinton/Hillary%20R.%20Clinton%20Part%2001/view&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;personally inspect&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;to&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;from&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;subject&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; fields of each email, she told the FBI.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In December 2014, Clinton’s attorneys turned over 30,490 emails that were deemed work-related as a result of the culling. That left 31,830 emails that were deemed personal. Mills preserved the 30,490 work-related emails on thumb drives. Then she asked Combetta to “securely delete” all of Clinton’s emails from her and Samuelson’s laptops so that they could continue to use those computers for other matters. Combetta wiped Clinton’s emails from their laptops using an off-the-shelf software product called BleachBit. At that point, all of Clinton’s emails still remained on the Clinton server in Platte River Network’s custody.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Around that time, however—sometime between November 2014 and January 2015—Clinton told her lawyers that she wanted to change the “retention policy” on her personal emails to just 60 days. Her three attorneys appear to have seen nothing illegal about Clinton’s request to make that change at that particular time. Nor, for that matter, did the Midyear FBI investigators or prosecutors who later probed into Clinton’s and the lawyers’ conduct. Nor either did the inspector general meta-investigators who, in 2018, probed the work of the Midyear probers. Remember that at this time these personal emails were not under subpoena by either congressional investigators or criminal investigators. Despite the insistence of Trump and his defenders, these were not government documents; they were actually personal records. There has never been any evidence that the lawyers characterized government records as personal records by way of evading the obligation to return government records. And there is no evidence that Clinton herself participated in the sorting of the material.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Clinton’s lawyers then instructed Combetta, the Platte River Networks employee administering the server, to implement the new retention policy—in other words, to delete all of Clinton’s personal emails older than 60 days. Apparently because of an oversight, however, Combetta &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;failed to carry out the request when asked&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On March 2, 2015, the New York Times&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/03/us/politics/hillary-clintons-use-of-private-email-at-state-department-raises-flags.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;reported&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that Clinton had used a personal email account at the State Department, possibly breaking rules. The next day—about two to four months &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;after&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; Clinton instructed Combetta to delete emails under her new retention policy—the House Benghazi committee sent Clinton a preservation order requiring her to keep all emails on her clintonemail.com accounts. On March 4, the committee subpoenaed Clinton’s emails relating to the Benghazi incident. On March 9, Mills emailed Combetta to make sure he understood his obligation to preserve Clinton emails, pursuant to the preservation order.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On March 12, in light of the Times article, certain members of Congress asked the inspectors general for the State Department and the Intelligence Community to conduct a coordinated review of State Department employees’ email practices.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;At some point in March 2015, after receiving the preservation order, Combetta experienced what he would later describe to FBI agents as an “oh shit” moment. He realized that he had never deleted Clinton’s emails, as directed months earlier under Clinton’s new retention policy. So sometime between March 25 and March 31, Combetta wiped Clinton’s emails from her private server—including the 31,830 deemed “personal” from the culling—notwithstanding the preservation order. Again, he used the software product BleachBit. (Combetta admitted this to Midyear investigators on May 3, 2016, after being given “use immunity” by prosecutors. He took sole and full responsibility for deleting the emails, saying that neither Mills nor Samuelson knew of his deletions. The Midyear investigative team—later interviewed by the inspector general’s office—recounted to the inspector general’s office that they believed Combetta’s account, that it squared with forensic evidence, and that it was consistent with the testimony of others, including Mills and Samuelson. After interviewing Midyear team members and reviewing their contemporaneous emails, the inspector general found no reason to second-guess their judgment.)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;&lt;strong&gt;The Referral to the FBI&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;During the summer of 2015, the inspector general of the intelligence community, conducting its review of State Department email practices, came across four Clinton emails that, though not bearing any classification markings, were judged to contain classified information. In July, as required by law, the inspector general&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.dni.gov/index.php/newsroom/press-releases/press-releases-2015/item/1232-statement-from-the-inspectors-general-of-the-intelligence-community-and-the-department-of-state-regarding-the-review-of-former-secretary-clinton-s-emails&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;referred&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; the matter to the FBI. On July 10, the FBI commenced a criminal inquiry—Midyear Exam. The team included investigators from the FBI’s headquarters; investigators from the FBI’s Washington Field Office; attorneys from the Department of Justice’s National Security Division, and prosecutors for the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Virginia.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The probe ended a year later, with FBI director Comey delivering his famous&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.fbi.gov/news/press-releases/statement-by-fbi-director-james-b-comey-on-the-investigation-of-secretary-hillary-clinton2019s-use-of-a-personal-e-mail-system&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;press briefing&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; on its essential findings on July 5, 2016. That same month, the FBI also provided Congress with a “&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://vault.fbi.gov/hillary-r.-clinton&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;letterhead memorandum&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;” discussing the probe’s findings in greater detail.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;By then, the Midyear team had recovered more of Clinton’s emails. It had been able forensically to recover some—but not all—from the wiped server and laptops. It also searched Clinton’s other devices and then obtained more emails from government and third-party email services used by her colleagues. The team issued 56 grand jury subpoenas, obtained five court orders pursuant to 18 USC § 2703(d), and executed three search warrants. In all, the investigators recovered an additional 17,488 Clinton emails besides the 30,490 she had turned over.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;These additional emails were a mix of work-related and personal emails, according to the inspector general’s&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/4515884/DOJ-OIG-2016-Election-Final-Report.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Report&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. It was impossible to tell with certainty how many of them—if any—had been among the 31,830 that Clinton’s lawyers had deemed “personal” and that Combetta had deleted. In part, that was because it would be natural for Clinton not to have kept all her State Department emails until Dec. 2014, when the culling occurred. As Director Comey&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.fbi.gov/news/press-releases/statement-by-fbi-director-james-b-comey-on-the-investigation-of-secretary-hillary-clinton2019s-use-of-a-personal-e-mail-system&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;explained&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in July 2016:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;I should add here that we found no evidence that any of the additional work-related emails were intentionally deleted in an effort to conceal them. Our assessment is that, like many email users, Secretary Clinton periodically deleted emails or emails were purged from the system when devices were changed. Because she was not using a government account—or even a commercial account like Gmail—there was no archiving at all of her emails, so it is not surprising that we discovered emails that were not on Secretary Clinton’s system in 2014, when she produced the 30,000 e-mails to the State Department.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Nevertheless, Comey thought it likely that at least some of the 31,830 deleted emails were recovered through the investigation.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Upon examining the original 30,490 emails that Clinton provided in December 2014, the Midyear team&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/4515884/DOJ-OIG-2016-Election-Final-Report.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;found&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; 69 email chains that, in the view of the intelligence experts, contained classified information. When the team combed through the additional 17,488 emails recovered during the probe, they found an additional 12 chains containing classified information. That made 81 chains in all, composed of 193 individual emails.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Before breaking those numbers down further, however, let’s be clear about what we’re talking about. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;None of these emails contained headers or footers bearing classification markings indicating to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;readers&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt; that they contained classified information&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. In other words, these emails were &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;not&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; marked with the warnings required under Executive Order 13526 or its predecessor which set forth proper procedures for handling classified information. Accordingly&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;readers of these emails, like Clinton, were &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;not&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; necessarily on notice of the sensitivity of the information contained within them.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;And to be clear, we are also &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;not&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; talking about a situation in which Clinton or her staff were, for instance, attaching to their emails documents of the kind we’ve seen spilling out of Trump’s boxes, with garish warning sleeves unmistakably signposting to anyone within 15 feet that they contain classified information requiring special treatment.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;During the course of their investigation, the Midyear team interviewed 72 people. These included the rank-and-file State Department officials who introduced classified information into the unmarked emails that eventually reached Clinton; 13 higher-level officials who forwarded such information to Clinton; and Clinton herself. The originators of those emails, according to the inspector general’s report, told Midyear investigators that they:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;used unclassified emails because of “operational tempo,” that is, the need to get information quickly to senior State Department officials at times when the recipients lacked access to classified systems. To accomplish this, senders often refrained from using specific classified facts or terms in emails and worded emails carefully in an attempt to avoid transmitting classified information.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Of the 13 higher-level officials, three of them—Mills, deputy chief of staff Jake Sullivan, and deputy chief of staff and adviser Huma Abedin—accounted for 68 percent of the email traffic sent to Clinton. According to the inspector general’s&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/4515884/DOJ-OIG-2016-Election-Final-Report.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;report&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, these three aides told the FBI:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;they did not believe the information contained in their emails was classified; they tried to talk around classified information in situations where there was an urgent need to convey information and they did not have access to classified systems; some of the information they were discussing had already appeared in news reports; and they relied on the originators of the emails to properly mark them. These explanations were consistent with those provided to the FBI by both the originators of the emails containing classified information and Clinton. Based in part on these explanations, the prosecutors determined that no one “within the scope of the investigation,” including the three senior aides, “committed any criminal offenses.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As for Clinton herself, she told the FBI (according to the inspector general’s report) that “during her tenure she received classified information through secure briefings, secure calls, classified hard documents, and classified faxes, and she “did not recall receiving any emails she thought should not be on an unclassified system.” When confronted with each allegedly offending email, she told investigators (per the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/4515884/DOJ-OIG-2016-Election-Final-Report.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;report&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;):&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;that she did not believe the information contained in the email was classified or that she relied on the State Department employees who worked for her to use their judgment in determining whether information was classified and appropriate to send on unclassified systems. ... Clinton’s responses to these questions were consistent with the testimony of other witnesses on the email chains, including Clinton’s senior aides who forwarded classified information to her.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;One Midyear prosecutor later told the inspector general: “[T]he problem was the State Department was so screwed up in the way they treated classified information that if you wanted to prosecute Hillary Clinton, you would have had to prosecute 150 State Department people.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Now let’s discuss the breakdown of these &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;unmarked&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; email chains that were deemed to contain classified information. According to the FBI&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://vault.fbi.gov/hillary-r.-clinton/Hillary%20R.%20Clinton%20Part%2001/view&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;letterhead memorandum&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, eight of the 81 chains contained top secret information. Seven of those eight chains contained information so sensitive as to merit “Special Access Program” designation, and three of the eight contained information designated as Sensitive Compartmented Information. The other 73 chains included information found to be classified at either the Secret (37 chains) or Confidential level (36 chains).&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;At this point, I’ll turn to an important question that the Midyear team members asked themselves. Was the most sensitive information—the Top Secret, SAP, and SCI information—found among the 30,490 emails Clinton turned over in December 2014? Or was it, rather, found among the 17,488 additional emails that the FBI could only recover forensically or through investigative means? If Clinton and her lawyers intentionally destroyed emails to hide them from investigators, one would have expected them to be found in the latter group.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Yet all of those most sensitive email chains—&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;all of them&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;—were found among the “work-related” emails dutifully turned over by Mills in Dec. 2014. The twelve additional chains of classified information recovered during the investigation were all classified at lower levels: Secret or Confidential.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Finally, toward the end of the probe, investigators did come across three email chains that—while not properly marked classified in headers or footers—did contain certain interior paragraphs that began with the marking “(C).” This coding means “Confidential,” the lowest level of classification.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Clinton told FBI investigators, according to the inspector general’s report, that&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;she did not know what the “(C)” meant and “speculated it was a reference to paragraphs ranked in alphabetical order.” ... Clinton told the interviewers that she did not agree that the information contained in the email was classified, because it described information that was already in the press.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Though some investigators were highly skeptical of Clinton’s claim not to know what the marking meant, they also regarded her assertion as not disprovable. According to the&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/4515884/DOJ-OIG-2016-Election-Final-Report.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;report&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;[Comey] stated, “By her demeanor, she was credible and open and all that kind of stuff, but—so I can’t sit here and tell you I believed her. I can only tell you, in no particular could we prove that she was being untruthful to us.” ... The prosecutors stated that the “(C)” markings were somewhat ambiguous given their placement in the email chains and the fact that the classification marking “Confidential” was not spelled out anywhere in the email, let alone in a readily apparent manner. They further stated that Clinton’s statement regarding her knowledge of the “(C)” marking was not one that could be affirmatively disproved.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On top of that, the State Department never provided a determination to the Midyear investigators that the information contained in those three email chains &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;really was,&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;in fact&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;confidential at the time the emails were sent&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. Moreover, the department conceded that the information contained in two of the three chains was &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;not confidential&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; as of July 2016, when the Midyear Exam was concluding.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Comparing Clinton and Trump: Classified Markings&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;So let’s analyze the distinctions between the allegations against Clinton and the allegations against Trump that might fairly bear upon a prosecutorial decision about whether to bring charges. The obvious starting place is the specific reasons that the Midyear Exam team gave for declining prosecution of Clinton. According to the inspector general, the first was that, “None of the emails contained clear classification markings as required under Executive Order 13526 and its predecessor.” The team’s point was that it was going to be hard to prove that Clinton understood that her emails contained classified information.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;By contrast, according to the&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/23841854/us_v_trump-nauta_23-80101-color-photos.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;indictment&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, the 15 boxes that Trump returned to the U.S. National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) in January 2022 contained 197 documents bearing unambiguous classification markings. At least 30 of those were marked TOP SECRET, and some bore SCI and SAP markings indicating extraordinary sensitivity. Another 98 documents were marked SECRET.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Also according to the indictment, Trump had been personally involved in packing the boxes that were removed from the White House to Mar-a-Lago. That makes it likely that he was aware from the start that he had removed classified information and retained it in an unsecure location. And it is sharply different from Clinton’s case, where investigators developed no evidence that Clinton played any role in sorting or producing the material in question. That’s 197 significant reasons that his situation is materially different from Clinton’s.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Then, in June 2022, according to the indictment, Trump’s attorney, Evan Corcoran, returned another 38 clearly marked classified documents to the FBI in response to a grand jury subpoena issued on May 11. Should we give Trump some credit for returning these documents voluntarily? No. The indictment makes clear that their return was &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;not&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; voluntary. On the contrary, it alleges (a) that Trump hid boxes from his attorney, Corcoran, before Corcoran could search through them looking for responsive documents; and (b) that once Corcoran did find these 38 documents in his search, Trump urged Corcoran in multiple ways to destroy or conceal those rather than turn them over. There is, by contrast, no evidence that Clinton ever encouraged her lawyers or anyone else to hide material from investigators. Adding these 38 documents to the first 197 makes 235 material ways in which Trump’s situation materially differs from Clinton’s.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Then, on Aug. 8, 2022, the FBI searched Mar-a-Lago. It found still another 102 unambiguously marked classified documents. Among these were 17 at the TOP SECRET level and 54 at the SECRET level. That brings us to 337 reasons why Trump’s situation is both more worthy of prosecution—and more provable—than Clinton’s.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;
&lt;strong&gt;Were Documents Used for Official Purposes?&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The second factor favoring non-prosecution of Clinton, according to the Midyear team, was that her emails were always used for official purposes. According to the inspector general:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The emails in question were sent to other government officials in furtherance of the senders’ official duties. There was no evidence that the senders or former Secretary Clinton intended that classified information be sent to unauthorized recipients, or that they intentionally sought to store classified information on unauthorized systems.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The same cannot be said for the 337 documents with classification markings that Trump took to Mar-a-Lago. Every one of them was, by definition, removed for an unofficial, non-governmental purpose. Indeed, Trump has publicly emphasized this point, declaring in interviews that the documents were his personal property and that he had every right to take them. That makes 674 reasons to distinguish the two cases.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In addition, the indictment alleges at least two specific instances in which Trump brandished classified documents in nongovernmental settings. In July 2021, at his golf club in Bedminster, New Jersey, he allegedly waved around and “described” a military “plan of attack” at a recorded meeting with four other individuals, none of whom had security clearances.  Then, in August or September 2021, he showed a map he described as classified to a representative of his political PAC, who also lacked a security clearance. There is no alleged similar conduct by Clinton. These intentional exposures of alleged national security information to five unauthorized individuals count as five additional reasons to treat Trump’s case as far more grave—and provably so—than Clinton’s. That’s 679 reasons.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Proof of Knowledge That Information Was Classified&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;A third factor that the Midyear team weighed in deciding not to prosecute Clinton was the absence of direct proof that Clinton knew her emails contained classified information. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;There was no evidence that the senders or former Secretary Clinton believed or were aware at the time that the emails contained classified information. In the absence of clear classification markings, the prosecutors determined that it would be difficult to dispute the sincerity of these witnesses’ stated beliefs that the material was not classified.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Was there any direct evidence—beyond the circumstantial evidence of possessing 337 documents bearing classification markings—that Trump knew he possessed classified documents? Indeed, there was. As just noted, he allegedly admitted as much in the two meetings in 2021—one of which was recorded.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On top of that, Trump or his surrogates have repeatedly admitted publicly that he knew he possessed documents that were marked as classified. To be sure, they have offered excuses for his possessing them, but those excuses have been far-fetched, inconsistent with the facts, and inconsistent with each other. Former Trump Defense Department official Kash Patel, for instance, told&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2022/05/05/documents-mar-a-lago-marked-classified-were-already-declassified-kash-patel-says/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Breitbart&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in May 2022 that, shortly before leaving the White House, Trump declassified “whole sets of materials” marked classified in Patel’s presence because Trump “thought the American public should have the right to read [those documents] themselves.” Yet, after absconding with them, Trump never made any of those documents public.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In August 2022, another Trump surrogate&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://twitter.com/Acyn/status/1558261235883311106&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;floated the notion&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that Trump had issued a “standing order” to render documents declassified as soon as he carried them off the White House premises in January 2021. But 18 former Trump administration officials told&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.cnn.com/2022/08/18/politics/trump-claim-standing-order-declassify-nonsense-patently-false-former-officials/index.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;CNN&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that they never heard of any such order, with some characterizing the claim as “laughable” or “a complete fiction.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;At times, Trump&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.mediaite.com/news/trump-returns-to-fbi-planted-evidence-accusation-in-wild-rant-after-doj-appealed-special-master-ruling/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;has&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.mediaite.com/politics/twitters-theory-on-why-trumps-claiming-the-fbi-planted-evidence-at-mar-a-lago-hes-guilty-as-sin/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;suggested&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that the FBI &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;planted&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; classified documents at his premises. Finally, Trump has also &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/110550283506811833&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;claimed&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;—and is&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.rev.com/blog/transcripts/trump-responds-to-charges-in-speech-following-arraignment-in-federal-court-transcript&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;still claiming&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;—that the Presidential Records Act conferred upon him an unreviewable, unilateral power to declare documents containing sensitive national defense information to be “personal” and then to do with them as he pleased. “In other words,” he&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/presidential-records-act-clintons-socks-and-trumps-boxes&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;said&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; on the night of his arraignment, “whatever documents a president decides to take with him, he has the right to do so. It’s an absolute right. This is the law.” (For a refutation of Trump’s interpretation of the Presidential Records Act, see “&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/presidential-records-act-clintons-socks-and-trumps-boxes&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;The Presidential Records Act, Clinton’s Socks, and Trump’s Boxes.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;”)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Trump’s last theory raises profoundly disturbing questions. What if Trump is still hoarding and hiding nuclear or military secrets? Does he consider them his keepsakes and souvenirs under his outlandish interpretation of the Presidential Records Act? Can he frame and hang them on the walls of his golf clubs to serve as conversational ice-breakers? Can he sell them at auction? Can he swap them in business deals?&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The fact that Trump is still asserting—&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;right now&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;—that this preposterous theory justifies his conversion and misappropriation of documents containing national security secrets makes his case radically different from Clinton’s. She, after all, never insisted on her right to store classified material on her private server.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;I count each of Trump’s four categories of implausible and inconsistent exculpatory statements—all but admitting his willful retention of classified documents—as additional factors rendering Trump’s case incomparably more serious than Clinton’s. Similarly, Trump’s alleged direct admissions of wrongfully possessing classified documents at the two meetings in Bedminster in 2021, one of which was recorded, constitute two more factors making Trump’s guilt palpably more provable than Clinton’s. Those six factors bring us to 685.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Personal Warnings That Information Was Classified&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;A fourth consideration that the Midyear team said counseled in favor of non-prosecution was the following (per the inspector general): “There was no evidence that former Secretary Clinton had any contemporaneous concerns about the classified status of the information that was conveyed on her unclassified systems, nor any evidence that any individual ever contemporaneously conveyed such concerns to her.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Did anyone, in contrast, convey concerns to Trump that he might be unlawfully possessing classified information? Indeed, they did. Though I am almost certainly omitting scores of examples, suffice it to say that the federal grand jury’s May 11 subpoena demanding return of all documents with classification markings must count as one such expression of concern. A second would be the letter the FBI sent him on June 8, 2022, referenced in the&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/22267195/102-1.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;redacted search warrant&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; for the Mar-a-Lago premises that was unsealed on August 26, 2022:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As I previously indicated to you, Mar-a-Lago does not include a secure location authorized for the storage of classified information. As such, it appears that since the time classified documents [REDACTED] were removed from the secure facilities at the White House and moved to Mar-a-Lago on or around January 20, 2021, they have not been handled in an appropriate manner or stored in an appropriate location. ...&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Each of these warnings renders Trump’s crimes more serious and more provable than Clinton’s, raising the number of such factors to 687.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Was the Conduct Planned?&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;A fifth reason the Midyear team listed for not prosecuting Clinton was that “[t]here was no evidence that Clinton set up her servers or private email account with the intent of communicating or retaining classified information, or that she had knowledge that classified information would be communicated or retained on it.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In contrast, the indictment alleges that Trump engaged in an intentional and rococo 18-month scheme to remove and retain classified information from proper storage. This constitutes a 688th factor making Trump’s conduct materially more provable and more grave than Clinton’s.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Obstruction and False Statements&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As noted earlier, the Midyear team never had any occasion to suspect that Clinton had committed any of the four obstruction of justice or two false statement offenses with which a grand jury has now charged Trump. In contrast, the indictment alleges that Trump violated each of those statutes and, in several instances, did so in multiple ways.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;For instance, the indictment alleges that Trump conspired with his body man, Waltine Nauta, to obstruct justice, in violation of&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1512&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;18 U.S.C. § 1512(k)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, in at least six ways: (a) suggesting to attorney his Corcoran that he falsely tell the FBI and grand jury that Trump had no documents responsive to the May 11, 2022 grand jury; (b) moving boxes to conceal them from Corcoran, the FBI, and the grand jury; (c) suggesting that Corcoran hide and destroy documents responsive to the subpoena; (d) providing just a fraction of documents responsive to the subpoena while falsely claiming to comply fully; (e) causing a false certification to be submitted to the FBI and grand jury falsely claiming that all responsive documents had been furnished; and (f) making of false and misleading statements to the FBI in May 26, 2022. Though the last category of false statements were made by Nauta, they were allegedly made in furtherance of the conspiracy, so we should count them against Trump.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Similarly, the government alleges that some of the same acts just described also amount to violations of a second obstruction of justice statute,&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1512&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;18 USC 1512(b)(2)(A)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, in two ways; of a third obstruction statute,&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1512&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;18 USC 1512(c)(1),&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in one way; of a fourth obstruction statute,&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1519&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;18 USC 1519&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, in two ways; of the first clause of the false statement statute,&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1001&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;18 USC 1001(a)(1)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, in one way; and of its second clause,&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1001&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;18 USC 1001(a)(2)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in three ways.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;That final allegation actually comprises three false statements contained in the false certification that Trump had his attorney Christina Bobb sign for submission to the FBI and grand jury, claiming that:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;a. “A diligent search was conducted of the boxes that were moved from the White House to Florida”;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;b. “This search was conducted after receipt of the subpoena, in order to locate any and all documents that are responsive to the subpoena”; and&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;c. “Any and all responsive documents accompany this certification.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;According to the indictment, Bobb had never read the subpoena, had not been present for Corcoran’s search, did not know which documents Corcoran was returning, and appears to have had no knowledge that Trump and Nauta had hidden responsive documents from Corcoran.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In sum, the indictment charges that Trump committed these six obstruction or false statement felonies in 15 different ways. That’s 15 more reasons why Trump’s acts represent wrongdoing of a different order of magnitude than Clinton’s. And they bring us to a total of 703 ways in which Trump’s conduct was materially more grave, and provably so, than Clinton’s.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Of course, that still leaves us with one last hurdle. It’s Sen. Graham’s point. Regardless of what I’ve laid out, it’s quite true that “[m]any Republicans believe we live in a country where Hillary Clinton did very similar things and nothing happened to her.” Graham’s implication is that we have no choice but to bow to those inaccurate beliefs—indeed, to amplify them—because so many people sincerely hold them.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;But that’s wrong. People of character, decency, and backbone do have an alternative. They can politely explain to the “many Republicans” in question why they are mistaken.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The only real hurdle is finding people of character, decency, and backbone.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Mon, 26 Jun 2023 13:56:14 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Roger Parloff</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24490</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>The Unfortunate Irony of Meta’s EU Troubles and the Case of TikTok
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/unfortunate-irony-metas-eu-troubles-and-case-tiktok</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On Jan. 4, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/04/technology/meta-facebook-eu-gdpr.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Meta was fined 390 million euros&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; (approximately $414 million) for illegally forcing European Union users to accept personalized ads on Facebook and Instagram. The fine was issued by the Irish Data Protection Commission (DPC), which serves as Meta’s main regulator in Europe (the company’s European operations are headquartered out of Ireland for &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/dec/27/facebook-to-close-controversial-irish-holding-companies&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;tax purposes&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;). The commission gave Meta &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wsj.com/articles/meta-to-let-users-opt-out-of-some-targeted-ads-but-only-in-europe-44b20b6d&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;three months&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to comply with EU data privacy protection under the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/24/technology/europe-gdpr-privacy.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;General Data Protection Regulation&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; (GDPR) after finding that it could not use the law’s &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://gdpr-info.eu/art-6-gdpr/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;contractual necessity&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; clause as a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-64153383&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;workaround&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; for collecting and processing user digital activity for targeted advertising. Essentially, Meta couldn’t rely on its notoriously &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/06/12/opinion/facebook-google-privacy-policies.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;opaque&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.facebook.com/legal/terms?paipv=0&amp;amp;eav=AfZ-D_bZeW6HP0BTjZAKl_g18zSJgUTdvuG50wnxlcy1-BY6yaA53kRS0se5UsyGhPI&amp;amp;_rdr&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;terms of service&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; agreements to justify targeted ads for EU users. Rather, Facebook and Instagram had to provide users with a way to opt out of having their digital activity collected and used to tailor the advertisements they saw on the apps. This will likely have significant financial implications for the company: In 2022, Meta made $113.64 billion in advertising revenue, almost a quarter of which came from Europe. At the time the decision was issued, the New York Times&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;reported that it &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/04/technology/meta-facebook-eu-gdpr.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;jeopardized 5 to 7 percent&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of Meta’s overall advertising revenue. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On May 22, the DPC &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://edpb.europa.eu/news/news/2023/12-billion-euro-fine-facebook-result-edpb-binding-decision_en#:~:text=Brussels%2C%2022%20May%20%2D%20Following%20the,Protection%20Authority%20(IE%20DPA).&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;fined Meta again&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, this time for breaking &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://gdpr-info.eu/chapter-5/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;EU privacy laws&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; when transferring EU user data from Europe to the United States. In addition to the record $1.3 billion fine, the commission ordered Meta to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/05/22/meta-fined-eu-facebook-data-privacy/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;suspend all transfers of personal data&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; belonging to EU users and users within the European Economic Area to the United States. In this case, the DPC’s main concern was whether Facebook specifically provided enough “&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://gdpr-info.eu/art-46-gdpr/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;appropriate safeguards&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;” when transferring EU user data to the United States, which is a much more relaxed data privacy regulatory environment, particularly when it comes to U.S. foreign intelligence collection programs. The case &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/european-union-hits-facebook-parent-meta-with-record-1-3-billion-privacy-fine&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;stems from&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/16/business/eu-data-transfer-pact-rejected.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;2020 decision&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; issued by the European Court of Justice that struck down the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://commission.europa.eu/law/law-topic/data-protection/international-dimension-data-protection/eu-us-data-transfers_en&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Privacy Shield&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;—a 2016 U.S.-EU agreement that allowed businesses in both jurisdictions to more easily transfer data across the Atlantic—and is the latest development in a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/oct/17/eu-rules-data-us-edward-snowden&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;decade-old campaign&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to protect European citizens’ data from U.S. surveillance. Indeed, the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://edpb.europa.eu/system/files/2023-05/final_for_issue_ov_transfers_decision_12-05-23.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;commission explicitly noted&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that its decision “exposes a situation whereby any internet platforms falling within the definition of an electronic communications service provider subject to the U.S. Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act 702 PRISM program may equally fall foul” of GDPR safeguards for data transfers. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Fear of a foreign government gathering intelligence on citizens through a social media platform is surely familiar to the United States. Indeed, the concerns regarding foreign surveillance inherent in the commission’s May 22 decision against Meta seem to echo those of &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.cnbc.com/2023/03/26/us-house-speaker-mccarthy-says-lawmakers-to-move-forward-with-tiktok-bill.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;U.S. lawmakers’&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; vis-a-vis the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and TikTok. Despite causing some inconveniences for multinational companies handling data across international borders, Europe’s response to these concerns through instruments like the GDPR offers U.S. officials a more practical model than pervious &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.investopedia.com/terms/n/nonce.asp&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;nonce&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; bans for realistically and effectively addressing related fears involving U.S. citizens and national security.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Case of TikTok&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In calling to order the House of Representatives’s &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://energycommerce.house.gov/events/full-committee-hearing-tik-tok-how-congress-can-safeguard-american-data-privacy-and-protect-children-from-online-harms&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Energy and Commerce Committee hearing&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; on March 23, Rep. Cathy McMorris Rodgers (R-Wash.) told TikTok CEO Shou Chew that he had been invited to testify before the committee “because the American people need the truth about the threat TikTok poses to [their] national and personal security.” According to Congress, Chew was there because “TikTok surveils us all,” pointing to alleged “internal records reveal[ing] … a backdoor for China to access user data.” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In his &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://docs.house.gov/meetings/IF/IF00/20230323/115519/HHRG-118-IF00-Wstate-ChewS-20230323.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;written testimony&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, Chew claimed that ByteDance, TikTok’s parent company, “is not an agent of China” and that “there is no way for the Chinese government to access [U.S. user data] or compel access to it.” However, an &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.axios.com/2023/05/13/bytedance-executive-china-government-data&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;ex-ByteDance executive&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, who had filed a wrongful dismissal suit in February against the company, alleged that the CCP was able to access U.S. TikTok user data through a “backdoor channel in the code.” The concern regarding CCP access to U.S. user data stems from two Chinese national security laws. The first, the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.chinalawtranslate.com/en/anti-espionage/#:~:text=No%20individual%20or%20organization%20may%20suppress%20or%20take%20revenge%20against,accusations%20in%20accordance%20with%20law.&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;2014 Counter-Espionage Law&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, states that “when the state security organ investigates and understands the situation of espionage and collects relevant evidence, the relevant organizations and individuals shall provide it truthfully and may not refuse.” Under the second, the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/beijings-new-national-intelligence-law-defense-offense&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;2017 National Intelligence Law&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, “any organization or citizen shall support, assist and cooperate with the state intelligence work in accordance with the law.” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In response to concerns for  EU citizens’ privacy and the security of their information, which largely &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.iai.it/sites/default/files/tis_rossi.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;came to the fore&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; after Edward &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2018/05/25/today-a-new-eu-law-transforms-privacy-rights-for-everyone-without-edward-snowden-it-might-never-have-happened/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Snowden’s 2013 leaks&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, EU lawmakers drafted &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/oct/17/eu-rules-data-us-edward-snowden&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;comprehensive legislation&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that erected safeguards for Europeans’ data in the EU and beyond. Rather than seeking a similar path toward thorough privacy protections for Americans, the U.S. government has instead zeroed in on a designated “boogeyman” for all digital data collection and security concerns: a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.politico.com/news/2023/04/16/why-washington-wont-ban-tiktok-00091690#:~:text=Washington%20has%20tried%20this%20once,out%20that%20effort%20within%20months.&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;proposed national ban&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; on a single application used by &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://newsroom.tiktok.com/en-us/150-m-us-users&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;over 150 million Americans&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In December 2020, then-President Trump attempted to ban TikTok via executive order—he was &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.npr.org/2020/12/07/944039053/u-s-judge-halts-trumps-tiktok-ban-the-2nd-court-to-fully-block-the-action&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;unsuccessful&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. In May, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://news.mt.gov/Governors-Office/Governor_Gianforte_Bans_TikTok_in_Montana&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Montana banned TikTok&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; from operating in the state in the interest of protecting “Montanans’ personal, private, and sensitive data and information from intelligence gathering by the Chinese Communist Party.” It appears, however, that Montana’s ban may not work out as the state intended. Ironically, if TikTok attempts to comply with the ban, it would have to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/05/19/montana-tik-tok-ban-challenges/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;start collecting&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; precise user location data to determine in which state they are using the app. According to the Council on Foreign Relations’s &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/05/19/montana-tik-tok-ban-challenges/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Tarah Wheeler&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, doing so would create “a surveillance state that includes fine-grained location data and the ability to monitor and read people’s phones—the exact mirror of the Chinese surveillance state they’re afraid of to begin with.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;President Biden, for his part, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/10/07/fact-sheet-president-biden-signs-executive-order-to-implement-the-european-union-u-s-data-privacy-framework/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;issued his own executive order&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in October of last year concerning data privacy and protection: &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/10/14/2022-22531/enhancing-safeguards-for-united-states-signals-intelligence-activities#p-154&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Executive Order 14086&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. The order provides a new framework for safeguarding personal data … &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/10/14/2022-22531/enhancing-safeguards-for-united-states-signals-intelligence-activities#p-154&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;transferred from Europe&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to the United States. The order primarily addresses European concerns regarding improperly obtained data through U.S. signals intelligence activities (from which U.S. citizens are, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/19/us/politics/fbi-violated-surveillance-program-rules.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;at least in principle&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, supposed to already be &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.dni.gov/files/icotr/Section702-Basics-Infographic.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;protected&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;) rather than the commercial activities. Nevertheless, it lays out a clearer structure for review, requirements, and redress that could be recycled and tailored into legislation that could better secure the data privacy of American citizens than chasing after problem apps with bans.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Why a Ban Just Won’t Cut It&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;If protecting user data is indeed a critical matter of &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IN/IN12131&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;national security&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;,&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; then lawmakers should treat it as such. Rather than seeking legal justifications (and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wired.com/story/montana-tiktok-ban/#:~:text=Montana&#039;s%20TikTok%20ban%20will%20be,against%20the%20social%20media%20app.&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;technological conjurations&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;) to try to ban a single platform used by millions of Americans, U.S. policymakers could pursue comprehensive legislation that provides internet users explicit rights over the collection, processing, use, and movement of their data, as well as legal recourse for abuses. And they wouldn’t have to start from scratch: Multiple countries—be it Australia, Canada, South Africa, or the members of the EU—and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.forbes.com/sites/conormurray/2023/04/21/us-data-privacy-protection-laws-a-comprehensive-guide/?sh=191655935f92&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;even some U.S. states&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; offer convenient case studies for discerning which and what kind of provisions would be most desirable for protecting U.S. citizens’ data in the U.S. context across multiple platforms and applications. TikTok data is not and should not be Americans’ only security concern regarding social media: The very &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/business/2015/05/30/net-of-insecurity-part-1/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;nature of the internet&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, which is diffuse and open by design; the sheer &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.forbes.com/sites/bernardmarr/2018/05/21/how-much-data-do-we-create-every-day-the-mind-blowing-stats-everyone-should-read/?sh=56de9a1360ba&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;amount&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of information &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.forbes.com/sites/bernardmarr/2018/05/21/how-much-data-do-we-create-every-day-the-mind-blowing-stats-everyone-should-read/?sh=56de9a1360ba&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;generated and collected&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; across digital platforms; and the lack of comprehensive federal &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.cigionline.org/static/documents/documents/no.241%202_0.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;data regulation&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; put &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;all&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; U.S. digital data at risk. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;With or without a TikTok ban, Americans’ digital data is still &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.politico.com/news/2022/12/21/data-brokers-privacy-federal-government-00072600&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;up for sale&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. The &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.axios.com/2023/03/16/us-tells-tiktok-ban-sale-cfius&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Biden administration’s warning&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to TikTok earlier this year that it may face a national ban if ByteDance fails to sell its stake in the U.S. version of the app is reminiscent of the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States’s &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/04/03/why-is-us-is-forcing-chinese-company-sell-gay-dating-app-grindr/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;2019 decision&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to mandate the Chinese owners of Grindr, a dating app, to sell it back to a U.S. firm. As Justin Sherman argued in a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/open-data-market-and-risks-national-security&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;2022 &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Lawfare &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;piece&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, although the owners conceded and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.reuters.com/article/us-grindr-m-a-sanvicente-exclusive/exclusive-winning-bidder-for-grindr-has-ties-to-chinese-owner-idUSKBN2391AI&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;sold the application&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to San Vicente Acquisition, a low-profile investment group, doing so did nothing to prevent Grindr from legally selling its data to governments through data brokers or from sharing user data with third parties, including through a Chinese software development kit. Thus, even if TikTok acquiesces to the administration’s demands and sells its stake, such divestment wouldn’t necessarily prevent the Chinese or another foreign government from obtaining U.S. user data through the open market.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In addition to the data up for sale, there is the potluck of U.S. citizens’ information &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2021-12-07/hacking-cybersecurity-keeping-wrong-secrets&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;available for free&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. In April 2015, Facebook’s Mark Zuckerburg told Congress that the company &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/12/opinion/facebook-mailru-russia-privacy-surveillance.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;would end its policy&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of granting applications created on the platform unrestricted access to user data in May of that year. In 2018, however, Facebook (now Meta) revealed that it &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wired.com/story/facebook-gave-russian-internet-giant-special-data-extension/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;allowed apps developed by Mail.ru Group&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, a Russian technology conglomerate with &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.scribd.com/document/370313106/2018-01-29-Treasury-Caatsa-241-Final#from_embed&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;ties to the Kremlin&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, to operate under the more permissive pre-May 2015 rules for two weeks beyond the designated cut-off date. Doing so allowed the apps to collect data by delving deep into profiles and tracking activity unbeknownst to Facebook users, who were ultimately left exposed to and unprotected from such abuse due to the lack of U.S. privacy regulations. Facebook declined to comment on its determinations regarding what Mail.ru may have done with the data. Its reason? &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://money.cnn.com/2018/07/10/technology/mailru-facebook-russia/index.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Confidentiality&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and privacy concerns between the company and app developers. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Foreign adversaries are not the only ones accessing U.S. data: In 2017, engineers working for the athletic social networking app Strava created and published a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wired.com/story/strava-heat-map-military-bases-fitness-trackers-privacy/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;heat map&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of anonymized user training data. After reviewing the map, an Australian grad student &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://twitter.com/Nrg8000/status/957318498102865920&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;posted his revelations&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; about the data on Twitter in 2018: His data visualization revealed—and mapped—the locations of forward-deployed U.S. bases (as well as military forces of other countries) and an undisclosed CIA site in Djibouti. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In her &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.cigionline.org/static/documents/documents/no.241%202_0.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;comparative assessment&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of data risks in the United States, Canada, and Germany, Susan Ariel Aaronson, a senior fellow at the Centre for International Governance Innovation, examined the case of &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/07/17/faceapp-adds-decades-your-age-fun-popular-russian-owned-app-raises-privacy-concerns/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;FaceApp&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, which took the United States by storm after its release in 2017. At the time of the report’s writing (April 2020), about 80 million users had downloaded FaceApp, an image editing application &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-tech-russia-idUSKBN1Y62D4&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;developed by the Russian company&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; Wireless Lab that went viral for its &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.businessinsider.com/faceapp-old-age-face-filter-how-to-use-2019-7&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;“old” face filter&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. Upon downloading the app, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.faceapp.com/terms-2019-en.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;users granted FaceApp&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; “a fully paid, royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable, worldwide, non-exclusive, and fully sublicensable right and license to use, reproduce, perform, display, distribute, adapt, modify, re-format, create derivative works of, and otherwise commercially or non-commercially exploit in any manner, any and all Feedback, and to sublicense the foregoing rights, in connection with the operation and maintenance of the Services and/or FaceApp’s business.” In non-term-and-conditions legalese: They essentially signed away their rights to their data and allowed FaceApp to do whatever it wanted with it. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In 2019, the FBI &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.democrats.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/FBI%20Letter%20to%20Schumer%20re%20FaceApp11.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;reviewed the app&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; as part of a larger national security investigation into Russian-made software, concluding that the app was “a potential counterintelligence threat based on the data [it] collects, its privacy and terms of use [policies], and the legal mechanism available to the Government of Russia that permit access to data within Russia’s borders.” It remains unclear whether the app is indeed an arm of the Russian government; however, Aaronson points out that the company’s terms of service “give it great power to control the information it collects” and that it plans to continue selling it. She also points to U.S. companies such as &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/18/technology/clearview-privacy-facial-recognition.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Clearview AI&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that are “scraping the web and selling personal profiles to police authorities in both democratic and repressive states.” According to Aaronson, “America’s failure to enact clear personal data protection rules has enabled firms to obtain and monetize personal data for a wide range of current and future purposes.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Yes, the United States could try to force the sale of FaceApp or threaten to ban it. But waiting to take formidable action after a new app pops up in stores, becomes wildly popular across the country, collects and stores vast quantities of user data, and is assessed by the FBI to be a national security risk is not a national data security strategy: It is a Sisyphean game of whack-a-mole. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;If personal and national security concerns are not enough to cajole congressional support and action, it is also worth mentioning that a clearly articulated national framework of data regulation in the United States also has advantages for business interests by providing countries with a more consistent standard. As &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.brookings.edu/techstream/to-enhance-data-security-federal-privacy-legislation-is-just-a-start/#:~:text=Aside%20from%20the%20aforementioned%20virtues,U.S.%20states%20adopting%20different%20standards.&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Robert D. Williams&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of the Brookings Institution and Yale Law School notes, such a standard would reduce compliance costs and mitigate inefficiencies arising from the adoption of different regulatory schemes by individual U.S. states. It would also &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/25/opinion/congress-privacy-law.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;promote the harmonization&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of the U.S. operational data environment “with those of other major economies, easing trade concerns and promoting American technology in Europe and beyond.” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;A Reality Check&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;While the GDPR may fuel Meta’s ire, it should be the object of envy for the American social media consumer. Even &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.skadden.com/insights/publications/2021/11/chinas-new-data-security-and-personal-information-protection-laws&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;China&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; has its own version of the GDPR, the 2021 Personal Information Protection Law (PIPL), with data collection consent requirements and protections for data transfers similar to those at issue in the aforementioned cases involving Meta’s European operations. Of course, the differences in political realities in China versus those in the EU cannot and should not be ignored. Despite its similarities &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.jtl.columbia.edu/bulletin-blog/the-personal-information-protection-law-chinas-version-of-the-gdpr&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;on paper&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to the GDPR, the PIPL’s de facto execution will depend wholly on how the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.brookings.edu/articles/seven-major-changes-in-chinas-finalized-personal-information-protection-law/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;CCP elects to implement&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; its provisions in furtherance of the party’s interests, including its increasing desire to exert expanded &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.economist.com/china/2022/06/28/as-censorship-in-china-increases-vpns-are-becoming-more-important?utm_medium=cpc.adword.pd&amp;amp;utm_source=google&amp;amp;ppccampaignID=17210591673&amp;amp;ppcadID=&amp;amp;utm_campaign=a.22brand_pmax&amp;amp;utm_content=conversion.direct-response.anonymous&amp;amp;gclid=CjwKCAjwv8qkBhAnEiwAkY-ahrxLePnoCQ8FdwWJOFuivdnSwu-R_iT_9tcSdNi4klsIC9xI3vwuxRoCfLEQAvD_BwE&amp;amp;gclsrc=aw.ds&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;surveillance and control &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;over its populations’ digital activities. Still, the larger point remains that as comprehensive national data protection laws are &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://deliverypdf.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=814097103098092070022116031064066029017056072092062036000096090108096016030126029027043029022061045007055005104065081029119078029094032037017029121099071074072064089080087070126087104014092083001064099065096115105097094001096067088109012103098002&amp;amp;EXT=pdf&amp;amp;INDEX=TRUE&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;becoming the norm&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, the United States’ lack of an overarching, nationwide legal architecture for protecting U.S. internet user data that regulates private companies rather than banning problematic platforms retroactively—and only after a critical threat is detected—sticks out like a sore thumb. The United States’ lateness to the game, however, offers U.S. policymakers a vast repository of models from which they could pick and choose in crafting harmonizing legislation that protects U.S. netizens and reduces aforementioned private-sector costs of doing business in a fractured global data policy landscape. Many countries that have &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://deliverypdf.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=860065085009089110089096102007098073058016039023044067109085005111072010078004088025025031037030005038045121018003093101030009114023070069004112125115028067025125038087030106028087096002087118077074069102021088107075029105075124068088071016077081065&amp;amp;EXT=pdf&amp;amp;INDEX=TRUE&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;followed the way&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of the EU in enacting data privacy laws have &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.cnbc.com/2021/04/08/from-california-to-brazil-gdpr-has-created-recipe-for-the-world.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;borrowed from the GDPR&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, but there are serious concerns that ought to be deliberated and debated regarding challenges to its &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.ft.com/content/66668ba9-706a-483d-b24a-18cfbca142bf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;implementation&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and lacunae that &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wired.com/story/gdpr-2022/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;continue to threaten&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; user privacy despite the legal regime’s stringency. U.S. policymakers thus have the advantage of accessing the successes and failures of the GDPR and other countries’ policies. Importantly, however, that doesn’t mean that U.S. legislatures can simply continue to kick the can down the road, relying on ineffective and perforated bans while making zero progress on comprehensive legislation.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;To comply with the January ruling from the EU Commission, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wsj.com/articles/meta-to-let-users-opt-out-of-some-targeted-ads-but-only-in-europe-44b20b6d&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Meta changed its model&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to permit users to opt out of targeted ads—but only in Europe. European Instagram and Facebook users now have a mechanism, as cumbersome as it may be, to reclaim greater control over their digital information. As an American Facebook user, all I can say is that it must be nice. But at least now the CCP might not be able to get Montana Gov. Greg Gianforte’s data—at least not for free.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Mon, 26 Jun 2023 09:07:39 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Ania Zolyniak</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24489</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>The Lawfare Podcast: Bulelani Jili on Africa’s Demand for and Adoption of Chinese Surveillance Technologies
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-bulelani-jili-africas-demand-and-adoption-chinese-surveillance-technologies</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;Countries across Africa are procuring and employing surveillance tools from China. This trend is a product of China’s diplomatic strategy, its technological ambitions, and growing corporate power and reach, as well as African domestic demands. A &lt;a href=&quot;https://dfrlab.org/2023/05/15/africas-demand-for-and-adoption-of-chinese-surveillance-technology/&quot; target=&quot;_blank&quot;&gt;white paper&lt;/a&gt; from the Digital Forensic Research Lab (DFRLab) at the Atlantic Council argues that research on this topic disproportionately focuses on the motivations and ambitions of the supplier, and seeks instead to focus on the local features that drive the adoption of Chinese surveillance tools.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;Lawfare&lt;/i&gt;’s Fellow in Technology Policy and Law, Eugenia Lostri, sat down with Bulelani Jili, the author of the white paper. Bulelani is a fellow at the Atlantic Council’s Cyber Statecraft Initiative, and a Meta Research Ph.D. Fellow at Harvard University. They discussed the supply and demand drivers for surveillance technology in Africa, the risks to civil liberties that come from the deployment of these technologies without proper checks and balances, and how all this fits in the context of U.S.-China competition.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;
&lt;iframe frameborder=&quot;0&quot; height=&quot;110px&quot; src=&quot;https://embed.acast.com/60518a52f69aa815d2dba41c/6498963306ff360011853a0d&quot; width=&quot;100%&quot;&gt;&lt;/iframe&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Mon, 26 Jun 2023 05:01:20 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Jen Patja Howell</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24488</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Counterterrorism Jenga
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/counterterrorism-jenga</link>
    <description>&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:justify&quot;&gt;Editor’s Note: &lt;i&gt;As the United States focuses on China and Russia and moves away from the Middle East, its ability to strike at terrorist groups such as al-Qaeda and the Islamic State is in question. National Defense University’s Kim Cragin examines the Biden administration’s “over-the-horizon” approach and argues that its foundations are increasingly shaky.&lt;/i&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p align=&quot;right&quot; style=&quot;text-align:right&quot;&gt;&lt;i&gt;Daniel Byman&lt;/i&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p align=&quot;center&quot; style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;***&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:justify&quot;&gt;When the U.S. military pulled out of Afghanistan in &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/speeches-remarks/2021/07/08/remarks-by-president-biden-on-the-drawdown-of-u-s-forces-in-afghanistan/&quot;&gt;August 2021&lt;/a&gt;, lawmakers and experts alike &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.axios.com/2021/09/12/afghanistan-counterterrorism-over-horizon-biden&quot;&gt;expressed concern&lt;/a&gt; that this would hinder the United States’ ability to counter al-Qaeda, the Islamic State, and other foreign terrorist adversaries. But the Biden administration rejected the idea that the military could protect the U.S. homeland only from permanent, forward-deployed, bases in the Middle East and elsewhere. Instead, President Biden &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/speeches-remarks/2021/08/16/remarks-by-president-biden-on-afghanistan/&quot;&gt;stated&lt;/a&gt;, and the National Security Strategy &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/8-November-Combined-PDF-for-Upload.pdf&quot;&gt;reiterated&lt;/a&gt;, that the United States has&lt;i&gt; &lt;/i&gt;“developed counterterrorism over-the-horizon capability that will allow us to keep our eyes firmly fixed on any direct threats to the United States in the region and to act quickly and decisively if needed.”&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:justify&quot;&gt;This ambition—over-the-horizon counterterrorism—is not unreasonable. It has been tried in the past with varying degrees of success. President Reagan approved the U.S. military’s first over-the-horizon strikes against terrorist-linked facilities in Libya with &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.jstor.org/stable/44327159?addFooter=false&quot;&gt;Operation El Dorado Canyon&lt;/a&gt;. President Clinton applied a similar logic against al-Qaeda with cruise missile strikes in Afghanistan and Sudan as part of &lt;a href=&quot;https://govinfo.library.unt.edu/911/report/911Report_Ch4.htm&quot;&gt;Operation Infinite Reach&lt;/a&gt;. Yet even as the government goes all-in on this approach, it is removing many of the building blocks that make over-the-horizon counterterrorism feasible without compensating elsewhere for these changes. I refer to this as “counterterrorism Jenga.” The U.S. government &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/10/12/fact-sheet-the-biden-harris-administrations-national-security-strategy/&quot;&gt;has prioritized&lt;/a&gt; strategic competition with China and Russia. As a result, it is removing the “blocks” of U.S. counterterrorism, built over the past two decades. While some re-prioritization makes sense, al-Qaeda and the Islamic State have &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.centcom.mil/MEDIA/Transcripts/Article/3332606/senate-armed-services-committee-hearing-on-posture-of-uscentcom-and-usafricom-i/&quot;&gt;not disappeared&lt;/a&gt;. Policymakers need to be more deliberate about which blocks are being removed. The United States arguably can afford for the Jenga tower to become wobbly—but it shouldn’t be allowed to collapse.           &lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:justify&quot;&gt;The term “over the horizon” is derived from early warning, long distance, radar technology. The term simply implies that U.S. security forces or assets will continue to confront terrorist networks and groups, but they will do so from outside a conflict zone. That is, U.S. forces and assets will cross one or more international borders to execute a strike. Over-the-horizon operations can include &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/us-drone-strike-kills-senior-isis-leader-plotted-attacks-europe-rcna78065&quot;&gt;drone strikes&lt;/a&gt; on terrorist operatives, training camps, or other facilities, but they also can incorporate &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/islamic-state-group-confirms-death-leader-qurayshi-names-new-chief-rcna19646&quot;&gt;raids&lt;/a&gt;. The success of these strikes and raids depends less on specific capabilities than on a methodology developed over the past 22 years, referred to in shorthand as “&lt;a href=&quot;https://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/f3ead-opsintel-fusion-%E2%80%9Cfeeds%E2%80%9D-the-sof-targeting-process&quot;&gt;find, fix, finish&lt;/a&gt;.”&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:justify&quot;&gt;Several &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.centcom.mil/MEDIA/Transcripts/Article/3332606/senate-armed-services-committee-hearing-on-posture-of-uscentcom-and-usafricom-i/&quot;&gt;U.S. officials&lt;/a&gt; have outlined the find-fix-finish methodology in &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wilsoncenter.org/event/the-efficacy-and-ethics-us-counterterrorism-strategy&quot;&gt;generic terms&lt;/a&gt; or with reference to a specific &lt;a href=&quot;https://twitter.com/WashInstitute/status/1612880389709697039&quot;&gt;operation&lt;/a&gt;, most recently the &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.voanews.com/a/watching-al-qaida-chief-s-pattern-of-life-key-to-his-death/6683376.html&quot;&gt;strike&lt;/a&gt; against al-Qaeda leader Ayman al-Zawahiri on July 31, 2022, in Kabul, Afghanistan. In the first step, “&lt;a href=&quot;https://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/f3ead-opsintel-fusion-%E2%80%9Cfeeds%E2%80%9D-the-sof-targeting-process&quot;&gt;find&lt;/a&gt;,” intelligence analysts identify and nominate an individual who poses an urgent threat to the United States, its citizens, or installations. It is relatively easy to nominate a terrorist leader, such as Ayman al-Zawahiri or Osama bin Laden. But, however &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.npr.org/2011/05/03/135927693/is-it-wrong-to-celebrate-bin-ladens-death&quot;&gt;satisfying&lt;/a&gt;, decapitation strikes generally do not halt emerging plots. Instead, practitioners often focus on finding more elusive figures, such as &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wilsoncenter.org/event/the-efficacy-and-ethics-us-counterterrorism-strategy&quot;&gt;experienced commanders or skilled subordinates&lt;/a&gt;, who are in the midst of planning, orchestrating, or even executing high-profile attacks. This is more difficult. For the past 22 years, the United States has identified these terrorists chiefly from within a conflict zone and in partnership with local security forces, who have a better understanding of the people, culture, and terrain. But as the U.S. military reduces its forward presence in Afghanistan, Syria, Somalia, Yemen, and elsewhere, it is pulling blocks out of the Jenga tower. &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.politico.com/news/2023/04/25/taliban-bombing-afghanistan-00093765&quot;&gt;John Kirby&lt;/a&gt;, the National Security Council spokesman, recently stressed that the United States retains other, remote, intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance capabilities (ISR) that can be, and continue to be, applied to identifying terrorist threats. The tower remains standing, but without the close cooperation of forward-deployed U.S. forces and local partners, it’s somewhat more unstable.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:justify&quot;&gt;The second step, “&lt;a href=&quot;https://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/f3ead-opsintel-fusion-%E2%80%9Cfeeds%E2%80%9D-the-sof-targeting-process&quot;&gt;fix&lt;/a&gt;,” requires U.S. intelligence analysts and operatives to reliably predict where the previously identified terrorist will be and when. This step is what President Biden referred to when he stated that the United States could keep its eyes “firmly fixed on any direct threats.” Importantly, the terrorist also must be fairly isolated, so that the strike or raid will not cause civilian casualties. “Fixing” a target, in this sense, requires nuanced understanding of the environment and detailed intelligence on the terrorist to achieve an accurate strike or raid and avoid civilian casualties. &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wilsoncenter.org/event/the-efficacy-and-ethics-us-counterterrorism-strategy&quot;&gt;John Brennan&lt;/a&gt;, the former assistant to President Obama for counterterrorism, described the decision-making process as follows:&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:justify&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;background:white&quot;&gt;I can tell you today that there have indeed been occasions when we decided against conducting a strike in order to avoid the injury or death of innocent civilians. This reflects our commitment to doing everything in our power to avoid civilian casualties, even if it means having to come back another day to take out that terrorist, as we have done previously.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:justify&quot;&gt;For over-the-horizon counterterrorism, the key phrase in Brennan’s statement is “come back another day.” In his March 2023 &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.centcom.mil/MEDIA/Transcripts/Article/3332606/senate-armed-services-committee-hearing-on-posture-of-uscentcom-and-usafricom-i/&quot;&gt;testimony&lt;/a&gt; before the Senate Armed Services Committee, Gen. Michael Kurilla, commander of CENTCOM, stated that he spends 80 percent of the overhead surveillance time allocated to him simply transiting the distance between Qatar and Afghanistan. This significantly reduces the ability of U.S. intelligence analysts to “fix” a potential target in Afghanistan (and to a lesser extent in other locations). If civilians arrive in the area unexpectedly or the terrorist gets stuck in traffic, the strike is halted, but it can be more difficult to “come back another day” with an over-the-horizon posture due to the long transit times. The Jenga tower gets a little bit more unstable.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:justify&quot;&gt;The final step is “&lt;a href=&quot;https://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/f3ead-opsintel-fusion-%E2%80%9Cfeeds%E2%80%9D-the-sof-targeting-process&quot;&gt;finish&lt;/a&gt;.” It does &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.centcom.mil/MEDIA/Transcripts/Article/3332606/senate-armed-services-committee-hearing-on-posture-of-uscentcom-and-usafricom-i/&quot;&gt;not necessarily mean&lt;/a&gt; a U.S. military strike or raid. Sometimes local law enforcement arrest the individual. But, in the context of over-the-horizon counterterrorism, it typically refers to a military operation. Like with the other two steps, this can be accomplished from both within and outside a conflict zone, but it poses greater challenges from outside a conflict zone. For example, on Jan. 26, 2023, U.S. forces raided the Somali headquarters of Islamic State facilitator &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/26/us/politics/isis-leader-us-somalia-raid.html&quot;&gt;Bilal al-Sudani&lt;/a&gt;. Practitioners will state publicly that they &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wilsoncenter.org/event/the-efficacy-and-ethics-us-counterterrorism-strategy&quot;&gt;prefer&lt;/a&gt; raids, such as the Sudani operation, because it allows them to gather additional intelligence. But during the raid, Sudani and his associates &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-64423598&quot;&gt;fought back&lt;/a&gt;, causing U.S. forces to kill him and 10 others. No U.S. forces were injured, but operations like this nevertheless pose greater risks to U.S. forces. The longer distances involved reduce soldiers’ situational awareness and make it more difficult to prepare for raids or respond to contingencies. Uncrewed drones also can be shot down, and as drones travel long distances, they are exposed to greater risk. This risk is especially evident in contested environments, such as &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/21/us/politics/american-drone-yemen.html&quot;&gt;Yemen&lt;/a&gt; or &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.airforcetimes.com/flashpoints/2023/05/04/russian-missile-nearly-hit-us-mq-9-drone-in-syria-last-year-centcom/&quot;&gt;Syria&lt;/a&gt;. The Jenga tower gets even more unstable.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:justify&quot;&gt;The cumulative effect is that the methodology—find, fix, finish—slows down when applied from an over-the-horizon posture. That’s important. The find-fix-finish methodology used today was refined during the height of the counterinsurgency operations in Iraq and Afghanistan, which allowed for a much faster pace, higher volume, and greater consistency of operations. All of these are diminished with an over-the-horizon posture. Of course, the threat posed by al-Qaeda, the Islamic State, and other foreign terrorist adversaries to the U.S. homeland is much lower today than it was eight or even 22 years ago. But it still exists. A 2020 U.S. &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.dni.gov/index.php/newsroom/reports-publications/reports-publications-2022/item/2321-isis-core-rebuilding-poised-to-grow-globally-through-2021&quot;&gt;National Intelligence Estimate&lt;/a&gt; assessed that the Islamic State has even started to rebound.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:justify&quot;&gt;That’s why you increasingly see experts and practitioners—myself included—expressing their discomfort with the status of U.S. counterterrorism. It is not so much a rejection of over the horizon, per se, or at least not across all of us. It is that we are removing some blocks without bolstering others. The United States pulled out of Afghanistan but didn’t compensate by allocating CENTCOM additional ISR resources, investing in alternative strike capabilities, or expanding access to the surrounding countries. Experts are collectively wincing at the instability of the Jenga tower. We’ve gotten to the point at which my young daughter might say, “Mommy, why don’t &lt;i&gt;you &lt;/i&gt;pull out the next block? I don’t want to touch it!”&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Sun, 25 Jun 2023 09:01:21 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Kim Cragin</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24485</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>The Week That Was: All of Lawfare in One Post
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/week-was-all-lawfare-one-post-485</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/mtait&quot;&gt;Matt Tait&lt;/a&gt; offered a &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/there-no-norm-against-prosecuting-former-presidents&quot;&gt;counterargument&lt;/a&gt; to the claim that former President Donald Trump’s indictment violates norms against former presidents. Tait evaluated fundamental, emergent, and derived norms of the U.S. government and its history, and concluded that there is no basis prohibiting the prosecution of former presidents of the United States. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/ecolumbus&quot;&gt;Eric Columbus&lt;/a&gt; examined former President Donald Trump’s &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/presidential-records-act-clintons-socks-and-trumps-boxes&quot;&gt;claim that&lt;/a&gt; the Presidential Records Act and its application in former President Bill Clinton’s “Socks” case exonerate him from wrongdoing in relation to his unlawful retention of classified documents. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/tmcbrien&quot;&gt;Tyler McBrien&lt;/a&gt; shared a &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/justice-department-submits-protective-order-mar-lago-case&quot;&gt;motion&lt;/a&gt; submitted by Special Counsel Jack Smith for a protective order to limit the disclosure of discovery information in the case of &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;United States of America v. Donald J. Trump and Waltine Nauta&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://lawfareblog.com/contributors/kpompilio&quot;&gt;Katherine Pompilio&lt;/a&gt; shared a new page, “&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/docket-watch-trump-prosecuted-florida1&quot;&gt;Docket Watch: Trump Prosecuted in Florida&lt;/a&gt;.” The page tracks primary source documents or other materials related to the indictment of former President Donald Trump and subsequent proceedings in connection with the investigation into the improper removal of classified documents from the White House to Mar-a-Lago. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Lawfare Podcast&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/arozenshtein&quot;&gt;Alan Rozenshtein&lt;/a&gt; sat down with &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/spell&quot;&gt;Stephanie Pell&lt;/a&gt; and &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/bkalt&quot;&gt;Brian Kalt&lt;/a&gt; to discuss the many roles of former President &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-stephanie-pell-and-brian-kalt-how-trump-indictment-will-affect-trump-campaign-and&quot;&gt;Donald Trump&lt;/a&gt;: president, candidate, defendant, and more. They discussed how these roles interact on a logistical and legal level, the consequences they pose for his campaign, and their impact on his potential presidency, if he is reelected in 2024.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Chatter&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/bwittes&quot;&gt;Benjamin Wittes&lt;/a&gt; sat down with &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/rparloff&quot;&gt;Roger Parloff&lt;/a&gt; to discuss his &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/chatter-podcast-covering-january-6th-trials-roger-parloff&quot;&gt;experience covering&lt;/a&gt; the Jan. 6 trials. They explored what it was like to give play-by-play accounts of the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers trials, the Venue Transfer Motions filed by many Jan. 6 defendants, the other journalists who have been crucial in gathering information on the Jan. 6 cases, and more. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On Tuesday, all of season one of &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;The Aftermath &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;became available. Listen &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://pod.link/1472798169&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;here&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, or wherever you get your podcasts. To mark the release of the first season, Wittes and Pompilio sat down with &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/norpett&quot;&gt;Natalie Orpett&lt;/a&gt; and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Ian Enright&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;  to discuss the purpose of the series, episode production, and more. Watch a recording of the discussion &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-live-discussing-season-1-aftermath&quot;&gt;here&lt;/a&gt;.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/hhan&quot;&gt;Hyemin Han&lt;/a&gt; shared a &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/hunter-biden-enters-tax-plea-deal-likely-probation-gun-charges&quot;&gt;U.S. District Court of Delaware&lt;/a&gt; filing in which Hunter Biden pleaded guilty to two misdemeanor charges of willful failure to pay income taxes. The filing also indicates that he will likely enter a pretrial diversion agreement on a charge of unlawful gun possession. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Lawfare No Bull&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;,  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/hbaker&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Hadley Baker&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; shared edited audio of the House Judiciary Committee’s hearing on Special Counsel John Durham’s &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-no-bull-house-judiciary-committee-durham-report&quot;&gt;recently released report&lt;/a&gt;. The report examined the origins and conduct surrounding the FBI’s Crossfire Hurricane investigation into allegations of Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election. The hearing included testimony from Durham.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Lawfare Podcast&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, McBrien sat down with &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Joel Simon &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Katy Glenn Bass&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to discuss a &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-protests-police-and-press&quot;&gt;new report&lt;/a&gt; from the Knight First Amendment Institute that addresses the arrest and physical attack of journalists covering social justice protests. They discussed the long legacy of law enforcement attacks against journalists in protest settings, the legal definition of members of “the press,” and the steps necessary to better protect press freedom. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/mstern&quot;&gt;Michael Stern&lt;/a&gt; discussed the Supreme Court’s decision to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/upcoming-supreme-court-case-threatens-congressional-subpoena-power&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;hear a case&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; on whether the U.S. solicitor general has the ability to review whether members of Congress have the right to sue the executive branch for information. Stern argued that the case’s stakes extend beyond the federal statute, as a ruling in favor of the solicitor general could severely diminish Congress’s access to information and increase the president’s power. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/jgoldsmith&quot;&gt;Jack Goldsmith&lt;/a&gt; discussed how the Biden administration could &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/can-biden-sidestep-congress-iran-nuclear-deal&quot;&gt;avoid an obligation&lt;/a&gt; to present a potential nuclear anti-proliferation agreement with Iran for a congressional vote. He concluded that President Biden has the best chance of skirting the Iran Nuclear Agreement Review Act by making the agreement verbally rather than by invoking Article II of the U.S. Constitution.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/mwalzer&quot;&gt;Michael Walzer&lt;/a&gt; discussed the &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/confusing-judicial-reform-unleashing-extremism&quot;&gt;judicial reform&lt;/a&gt; debate in Israel through the lens of how it would unleash extremism both in Israel and abroad. He argued that support for protests against judicial reform is centered in the domestic, geopolitical, and moral-political implications of the agendas of ultrareligious political parties and ultranationalist members of government. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Lawfare Podcast&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Anderson sat down with &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Richard Gowan&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to discuss the Biden administration’s anticipated UN Security Council &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-richard-gowan-us-push-un-security-council-reform&quot;&gt;reform proposal&lt;/a&gt;. They discussed the connection between the Ukraine conflict and heightened interest in Security Council reform, what the reform might look like, and who will benefit most.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In this week’s installment of &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Lawfare’s Foreign Policy Essay&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; series, &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/cglenn&quot;&gt;Caileigh Glenn &lt;/a&gt;assessed &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/can-you-sanctions-proof-government&quot;&gt;four Russian strategies&lt;/a&gt; to limit the impacts of sanctions on its government’s function and decision-making. She argued that the protection of potential targets of sanctions, retaliation, and de-dollarization largely failed to “sanction-proof” the Russian government, while reliance on partnerships with non-sanctioning countries produced more effective results.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/mnevitt&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Mark Nevitt&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; discussed the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/can-law-adapt-meet-climate-crisis-0&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;legal crisis within the climate crisis&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. He examined how existing laws, statutes, and doctrines hide climate risk and incentivize risk-taking.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Rational Security&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-variant: normal; white-space: pre-wrap;&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style: normal;&quot;&gt;, Anderson, Rozenshtein, and &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/qjurecic&quot; style=&quot;font-weight: 400;&quot;&gt;Quinta Jurecic&lt;/a&gt; sat down with &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/pstephan&quot;&gt;Paul Stephan&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to discuss &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/rational-security-even-stephan-edition&quot;&gt;this week’s close-calls&lt;/a&gt; in national security news, including Secretary of State Antony Blinken’s meeting with President Xi Jinping in Beijing, what to do with $300 billion of frozen Russian-related assets, President Biden’s attendance at a summit of AI industry leaders, and more.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/bnimmo&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Ben Nimmo&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/ehutchins&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Eric Hutchins&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; discussed their&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/new-kill-chain-approach-disrupting-online-threats&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt; newly-developed kill chain&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; for online operations. They argued that in the face of a growing number of cross-platform attacks, the kill chain will help defenders disrupt threats, compare different operations, and share information.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/jgoldstein&quot;&gt;Josh A. Goldstein&lt;/a&gt; and &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/alohn&quot;&gt;Andrew Lohn&lt;/a&gt; assessed &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/finding-language-models-influence-operations&quot;&gt;five potential strategies&lt;/a&gt; to identify the use of artificial intelligence language models in disinformation campaigns: human detection, automated detection, infiltration of propagandist units, monitoring by AI providers, and state-backed hacking. They concluded that while each approach can contribute to conquering short-term problems, none of the strategies are long-term solutions for detecting AI disinformation.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Lawfare Podcast, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Rozenshtein sat down with &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Jane Bambauer&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Derek Bambauer&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Mihai Surdeanu&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to discuss the harm caused by &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-large-language-negligence&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;large language models&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. They covered what it means for an LLM to breach its duty of care and under what conditions Section 230 may shield the output of LLMs.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;And &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/achander&quot;&gt;Anupam Chander&lt;/a&gt; and &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/contributors/jjones&quot;&gt;Joe Jones&lt;/a&gt; discussed the Irish Data Protection Commissioner’s &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/what-if-it-were-illegal-transfer-personal-data-european-union-united-states&quot;&gt;recent order&lt;/a&gt; requiring Meta to stop transferring EU personal data to the United States. They analyzed the 10-year legal history leading to this decision, potential operational consequences for Meta, and next steps for policymakers. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;And that was the week that was. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 16:22:25 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Gia Kokotakis</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24487</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>A New Kill Chain Approach to Disrupting Online Threats
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/new-kill-chain-approach-disrupting-online-threats</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;If the internet is a battlefield between threat actors and the investigators who defend against them, that field has never been so crowded. The threats range from hacking to scams, election interference to harassment. The people behind them include intelligence services, troll farms, hate groups, and commercial companies of cyber mercenaries. The defenders include investigators at tech companies, universities, think tanks, government agencies, and media outlets. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;This is a seismic change from the 2016 U.S. presidential election cycle, when Russian attackers from GRU military intelligence and the Internet Research Agency exploited an environment that was not only largely undefended but also largely undefined. As we look ahead to 2024 and the many elections it brings, one great improvement is that there are now defenders who specialize in understanding and thwarting many different types of threats. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Increasingly, however, threat actors do not work in one threat area alone. An &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/Meta-Quarterly-Adversarial-Threat-Report_Q1-2022.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;online network from Azerbaijan&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that Meta took down in 2022 combined hacking with influence operations. A &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/Meta-Quarterly-Adversarial-Threat-Report-Q4-2022.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Bolivian network&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; combined influence operations and mass reporting, trying to get the social media accounts of news organizations and opposition members shut down for nonexistent violations. Threat actors routinely work across many different platforms, from the European &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://graphika.com/reports/viral-vendetta/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;anti-vaccine group&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that coordinated on Telegram to harass people across social media and in real life, to the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/Meta-Quarterly-Adversarial-Threat-Report_Q1-2022.pdf#page=6&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Iranian cyber espionage operation&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that created malicious applications disguised as a VPN app, a salary calculator, an audio book reader, and a chat app.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As long as the defenders remain siloed, without a common framework to understand and discuss threats, there is a risk that blended and cross-platform operations like these will be able to find a weak point and exploit it. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;A Kill Chain for Online Operations&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;To help break down those siloes between investigators in different fields, companies, and institutions, we have developed a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://carnegieendowment.org/2023/03/15/phase-based-tactical-analysis-of-online-operations-pub-89275&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;framework&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to analyze, map, and disrupt many different sorts of online threats: a kill chain for online operations. This is by no means the first time the “kill chain” concept—which identifies the sequence of activities attackers go through in their operations and looks for ways to disrupt them—has been applied to the study of internet threats. In fact, we have taken inspiration from pioneering works such as the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lockheedmartin.com/content/dam/lockheed-martin/rms/documents/cyber/LM-White-Paper-Intel-Driven-Defense.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Lockheed Martin Intrusion Kill Chain&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2019/08/influence_opera.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Influence Operations Kill Chain&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. But this is the first kill chain designed to cover all types of online operations in which the target is a human being rather than a computer, from espionage and social engineering through influence operations to coordinated harassment or gang recruitment. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;We conceived our framework by examining case studies conducted by our Meta threat-investigator colleagues. While the threat actors’ goals were very different—from selling merchandise to stealing someone’s login details—we repeatedly observed them using the same tricks. Whether using AI-generated profile pictures to disguise their accounts, or trying to steer people toward websites and smaller platforms where the defenses might be less robust, spammers, influence operators, hackers, and fraudsters used common techniques.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;We designed our kill chain to identify and sequence those common behaviors—mapping the steps that bad actors take along the path toward their goal. Our goal is to identify the points along that path where the defenders can trip up the attackers. Disrupting any one of those steps can interrupt the operation. Ultimately, however, the defender’s goal is to “complete the kill chain” and find ways to disrupt them all. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;At a series of round tables hosted by the Carnegie Endowment’s Partnership for Countering Influence Operations, we sought feedback on this framework from our peers at other platforms and in the research community. During this process, we realized that our collective field needs not only a map but also a dictionary: a shared body of terminology that describes the behaviors we see. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Even within individual disciplines, the vocabulary of threat analysis is ambiguous. One threat can have many names: Different researchers refer to the same threat as “misinformation,” “disinformation,” “malinformation,” or “influence operations.” Conversely, one name can be applied to multiple threats: the term “exploitation” has been applied to both executing unauthorized code on a target’s system and amplifying an influence campaign with bots, trolls, and “useful idiots.” In &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://carnegieendowment.org/2023/03/15/phase-based-tactical-analysis-of-online-operations-pub-89275&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;this paper&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, we have tried, wherever possible, to avoid terminology that has, or could have, a contested definition.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;h3 style=&quot;text-align:center; margin-top:21px; margin-bottom:5px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Disrupt, Compare, Share&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As we gathered feedback, some experts asked us, “Are you trying to get better at disrupting these operations, or sharing information about them?” In fact, we have designed the kill chain for three main purposes: to disrupt, compare, and share.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The first goal is to enable disruption of online operations by identifying weaknesses across their life cycle, but especially in the earliest phases.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Take a hypothetical example: Threat researchers discover an online operation that registers fake social media accounts by using email addresses from a niche domain. It disguises them by copying pictures of a particular influencer, then uses the disguised accounts to spam-post links to websites on social media and elsewhere online. If the researchers prioritize ways to detect more accounts with the same combination of email domain and influencer photos, they can potentially identify further waves of fake accounts before they can even start spamming.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The second goal is to enable investigators to compare different operations—whether these are two operations of the same type, two operations of different types, or even one operation at two moments in time.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Let’s extend the hypothetical example: The researchers could look for the same combination of the niche email domain and the photos of the same influencer turning up in other cases. If they find that the same combination also featured in a newly discovered fraud case and an older spam network, they can investigate whether these three apparently separate cases were, in fact, connected.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The third goal is to enable sharing across the community according to a commonly understood framework that helps reduce the information noise and quickly understand the case. While considering appropriate privacy protections, threat research sharing is intended to “complete the kill chain” by enabling different teams to take action against malicious activity at many more points along the threat actor’s path. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;To conclude our hypothetical example: The original researchers could share these specific  insights with peers across the industry and the open-source research community who can then find and disrupt this malicious activity on their respective platforms and on the open internet.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;h3 style=&quot;text-align:center; margin-top:21px; margin-bottom:5px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Principles of the Kill Chain &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;To make the kill chain useful to the wide range of defenders we envisage, we built it according to six principles: It is tactical, observation based, platform agnostic, optimized for human-on-human operations, applicable to one or many platforms, and modular. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;To make the kill chain tactical and observation based, it focuses on behaviors that can be directly observed or inferred with high probability. For example, if an operation tweets that it is inviting direct messages on Signal, it is legitimate to infer that the operation likely has a Signal account. The kill chain is not intended to map operations’ strategic intentions or authors: It maps the “how” of their behavior, not the “who” or the “why.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It is platform agnostic, meaning that it can be applied to operations on all kinds of platforms (for example, social media and email services, among many others) and is designed to analyze operations that spread across one or many platforms. This can also include offline activity, such as registering companies or renting office space for trolls.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The kill chain is optimized for operations in which the source and target are human—whether the operation is an espionage team using a fake persona to befriend an engineer in a strategically sensitive industry or an influence operation recruiting an unwitting journalist. The kill chain focuses on these types of operations because we see the highest degree of commonality between different types of operations whose shared goal is to engage or entrap someone. The kill chain can be applied to machine-on-machine attacks, but it is not designed primarily with them in mind. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Finally, the kill chain is modular. Its phases follow a sequence, but not every operation will make use of every phase.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;h3 style=&quot;text-align:center; margin-top:21px; margin-bottom:5px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Ten Links in the Chain&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The kill chain itself consists of 10 phases or links. This is longer than comparable frameworks, because most kill chains begin with the reconnaissance phase—traditionally the earliest phase that cyber defenders would be able to detect—while ours includes asset acquisition and disguise, both of which likely come before reconnaissance on social media. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Each phase describes a broad type of activity. To use the industry’s traditional framing, they are top-level tactics. Each tactic breaks down into a number of separate techniques, and each technique breaks down further into detailed procedures—explained in more depth in &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://carnegieendowment.org/2023/03/15/phase-based-tactical-analysis-of-online-operations-pub-89275&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;our paper&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. For example, we divide the tactic of acquiring assets into separate techniques, such as acquiring email addresses or phone numbers. The technique of acquiring email addresses is then broken down into procedures, such as acquiring encrypted or throwaway email addresses. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Acquiring Assets&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In our view, online operations begin when threat actors start setting up the assets they need. This can include acquiring IP and email addresses, phone numbers, and social media accounts, but also acquiring bank accounts, crypto wallets, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/March-2021-CIB-Report.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;computer hardware&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, and office space, as well as registering companies.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Disguising Assets&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Once an operation has acquired its assets, it will likely want to make those assets look convincing. At the most basic level, this is likely to involve adding a profile picture (stolen, non-human, or AI-generated) and a basic biography. In more sophisticated cases, it can include fake personas that are backstopped across many social media platforms (for example, a fake news editor with a Facebook profile, Twitter account, LinkedIn presence, and website) and even backstopped with fake family members, as &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://about.fb.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/April-2021-CIB-Report.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Meta reported of one influence operation&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; linked to Fatah—a political party in Palestine.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Gathering Information&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;This phase refers to any attempt—manual or automated—that an operation makes to gather information. It can range from scraping and accessing databases of stolen passwords to viewing potential victims’ social media profiles, as the Department of Justice reported in &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/singaporean-national-pleads-guilty-acting-united-states-illegal-agent-chinese-intelligence&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;an espionage case in 2020&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Coordinating and Planning&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;This phase refers to the many ways in which threat actors coordinate and plan. This can range from public posts to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://graphika.com/reports/viral-vendetta/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;recruitment channels on Telegram&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to automated and scripted posting. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Testing Defenses&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;An operation that experiments with different behaviors in order to see what it can get away with is considered to be testing the defenses. For example, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wired.com/2014/09/how-hackers-use-virustotal/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;hacking groups have reportedly uploaded their own malware&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to an antivirus data website like VirusTotal to see if it would be detected. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Evading Detection&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Any repetitive action an operation undertakes to stay hidden can be classed as evading detection. This can include camouflaging keywords with typos—such “vaxxine” instead of “vaccine”—or deploying technical fixes, such as &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.disinfo.eu/doppelganger/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;the Russian operation known as Doppelganger,&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; which geo-limited the websites it was running so that they could be viewed from only one country. Unlike asset disguise, which is mostly static, evading detection is an ongoing process. For example, evading detection is the equivalent of flying an airplane under the radar, and asset disguise would be the equivalent of painting it in camouflage colors. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Indiscriminate Engagement&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Operations that make no effort to land in front of a particular audience conduct indiscriminate engagement. The Chinese network known as &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://graphika.com/reports/spamouflage&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Spamouflage&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, for example, posted huge numbers of low-quality memes and videos on Facebook, YouTube, Twitter, and smaller websites but made no apparent effort to reach an interested audience. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Targeted Engagement&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;By contrast, operations that take steps to be seen only by particular audiences conduct targeted engagement. This includes, of course, advertising but also outreach by email and direct message, posting into particular social media groups, using target-specific hashtags, and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://blog.google/threat-analysis-group/new-campaign-targeting-security-researchers/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;the ruse deployed by one North Korean espionage group&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; who posed as security researchers to lure other researchers into sharing vulnerabilities and exploit code. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Compromising Assets&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;This phase consists of anything an operation does to take over assets—whether those are accounts, information, or money—from their original owners. This includes typical cyber exploits such as data exfiltration or account takeover, but it can also include &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://techcrunch.com/2017/03/15/twitter-counter-hacked/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;compromises of third-party apps&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.mandiant.com/resources/blog/ghostwriter-influence-campaign&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;accessing social media accounts by taking over the underlying email account&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, and even convincing real people to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/09/17/popular-facebook-page-vets-trump-seemed-be-place-former-military-months-macedonians-controlled-it/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;grant admin access&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to accounts they control. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Enabling Longevity&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Finally, an operation that takes steps to preempt or evade enforcement is engaged in attempts to enable longevity. For example, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://about.fb.com/news/2022/09/removing-coordinated-inauthentic-behavior-from-china-and-russia/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;a Russian operation that ran spoofed domains&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; posing as European news outlets tried to register new domains when the original ones were blocked.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;h3 style=&quot;text-align:center; margin-top:21px; margin-bottom:5px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Looking Ahead&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The defender community in 2023 is far larger and more experienced than it was in 2016, but we are all working in a highly adversarial space where the most predictable feature is that threat actors will try to be unpredictable. We should expect operations that combine old threats in new ways, as well as threats that involve completely new behaviors. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It is our hope that our kill chain will enable defenders in different parts of the community to share their analyses as old threats evolve and new ones emerge, giving us all the best chance to defend against them. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As with any framework, ours is an attempt to split complex operations into smaller elements as a way to impose a systematic view on malicious activities that, by design, seek to evade and evolve. As such, there will always be edge cases and a need for flexibility. In particular, we expect ongoing discussion around the question of when an operation evolves so much that it becomes a new entity—such as &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://edition.cnn.com/2020/03/12/world/russia-ghana-troll-farms-2020-ward/index.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;the Russian Internet Research Agency hiring people in Ghana&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to post about issues of race in the U.S. ahead of the 2020 presidential election. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;This kill chain remains a work in progress, and we look forward to new discoveries in the field of online operations that will allow us to evolve and refine it. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt; &lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Disclosure: Facebook provides support for &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Lawfare&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;’s Digital Social Contract paper series, for which Alan Rozenshtein is the editor. This article is not part of that series, and Facebook does not have any editorial role in &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Lawfare.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 13:52:32 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Ben Nimmo, Eric Hutchins</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24486</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Lawfare No Bull: The House Judiciary Committee on the Durham Report
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-no-bull-house-judiciary-committee-durham-report</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;b id=&quot;docs-internal-guid-9774cd48-7fff-30fd-d49c-822408398927&quot; style=&quot;font-weight:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-variant:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;vertical-align:baseline&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;Today on &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-variant:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;vertical-align:baseline&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;Lawfare No Bull: &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-variant:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;vertical-align:baseline&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;On June 21, the House Judiciary Committee held a hearing to discuss &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/notes-durham-report-reading-diary&quot;&gt;Special Counsel John Durham’s recently released report&lt;/a&gt; that examined the origins and conduct surrounding the FBI’s Crossfire Hurricane investigation into allegations of Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election. The committee heard testimony from Durham:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/b&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;iframe allow=&quot;autoplay&quot; frameborder=&quot;0&quot; height=&quot;110px&quot; src=&quot;https://embed.acast.com/$/613faeac0d07cc0012b28958/the-house-judiciary-committee-on-the-durham-report&quot; width=&quot;100%&quot;&gt;&lt;/iframe&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;You can subscribe to &lt;em&gt;Lawfare No Bull&lt;/em&gt; on&lt;a href=&quot;https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/lawfare-no-bull/id1585705233&quot;&gt; Apple Podcasts&lt;/a&gt; or wherever you get your podcasts. Ad-free versions of all of &lt;em&gt;Lawfare&lt;/em&gt;’s podcast offerings are available on&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.patreon.com/lawfare&quot;&gt; our Patreon page&lt;/a&gt;.&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 11:18:46 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Hadley Baker</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24484</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Can Law Adapt to Meet the Climate Crisis?
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/can-law-adapt-meet-climate-crisis-0</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Editor’s Note:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt; This piece has been adapted from a forthcoming article in the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4372312&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Stanford Law Review&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On the North Carolina Outer Banks, homes are &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/interactive/2023/obx-rodanthe-erosion-rising-sea-levels/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;collapsing&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; into the Atlantic. Along the Louisiana bayou, whole communities are being &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/difficult-conversations-how-rising-sea-levels-threaten-the-lives-of-louisianas-coastal-residents&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;swallowed&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; by the sea. Tragically, Americans are choosing to move to coastal barrier islands and the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1718850115&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;wildland-urban interface (WUI),&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; favoring climate-exposed locations over safer communities. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The underlying culprit is climate change. And the situation is exacerbated by existing laws, statutes, and doctrines that hide climate risk and incentivize risk-taking. These laws, statutes, and doctrines have failed to adapt and keep pace with our climate-destabilized future. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In sum, we have a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;legal &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;crisis lurking within the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;climate&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; crisis.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Climate Adaptation Tools Thwarted by Outdated Legal Doctrines&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As I discuss below, several statutes, legal doctrines, and policies may have worked for a stable “Earth 1.0.” But they are proving unworkable for our climate-destabilized “Earth 2.0.” This legal inertia thwarts innovative adaptation action. It may already be having a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.eenews.net/articles/how-a-1992-high-court-ruling-eroded-regulatory-might/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;chilling effect&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; on forward-looking adaptation efforts. Just as communities must take action to avert climate disaster, laws designed for a more stable time must adapt to meet the climate moment. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As climate change destabilizes the physical environment, governments have just four core adaptation strategies at their disposal: resistance, accommodation, deliberate disinvestment, and managed retreat. Each one quickly confronts legal and fiscal realities. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;First, choosing the resistance strategy—such as building sea walls or “armoring” the shoreline—may harm adjacent properties and create legal liability under existing tort or property law. After all, the floodwater must go &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;somewhere&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. And the government cannot force private property owners to upgrade their existing property without running afoul of the Fifth Amendment’s &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/amendment-5/takings-clause-overview&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Takings Clause&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. A government’s physical invasion of private property—however small—triggers the Takings Clause. This requires “just compensation” to be paid from the locality to the affected private property owner. A flurry of takings claims will quickly drain government coffers. We cannot resist our way out of the climate crisis. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Army Corps of Engineers has proposed plans to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.thecity.nyc/environment/2022/9/26/23373901/army-corps-details-ny-coastal-plan&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;armor&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; the entire island of Manhattan—at an extraordinary cost range of &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://bronx.news12.com/proposal-for-new-york-city-sea-walls-unveiled-by-the-army-corps-of-engineers&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;$52&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;-$&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/17/nyregion/the-119-billion-sea-wall-that-could-defend-new-york-or-not.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;119 billion&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. Beyond the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/06/15/opinion/nyc-flood-waterfront-plan.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;aesthetic&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; issues associated with such a massive project, the water could &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.thecity.nyc/environment/2022/9/26/23373901/army-corps-details-ny-coastal-plan&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;harm&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; adjacent shoreline communities and cause an &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4372312&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;indirect taking&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;—a concept first articulated more than 150 years ago. The U.S. government constructed a dam that flooded a citizen’s property&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, resulting in a Fifth Amendment violation. That $52 billion price tag for construction may be just the beginning as litigation is sure to follow. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Second, choosing the accommodation&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;strategy—such as passing sensible, climate-informed coastal regulations—may run afoul of the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://riskcenter.wharton.upenn.edu/climate-risk-solutions-2/legal-doctrine-must-also-adapt/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;regulatory takings&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; doctrine. This legal doctrine emerged 100 years ago during a far more stable physical environment. Today, s&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;ome localities require that properties along coastal barrier islands elevate their structures. Some are turning to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.oyez.org/cases/1991/91-453&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;no-build&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; provisions that would prohibit coastal construction on certain barrier islands along the coast. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;But the accommodation strategy could trigger a regulatory takings challenge. This could result in a city, state, or locality having to compensate the private property owner for “taking” the private property.  This will be no small sum:  Zillow &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.zillow.com/research/homes-at-risk-coastal-flooding-25040/#:~:text=Unchecked%20greenhouse%20gas%20emissions%20would,homes%20were%20built%20after%202009.&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;estimates&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that climate change will place 3.4 million homes worth $1.75&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt; trillion&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; at increased flood risk by the end of this century. Governments simply can’t afford to accommodate our way out of the climate crisis. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Third, several communities in low-lying parts of Florida and Louisiana are choosing the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.flseagrant.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/Castles-and-Roads-In-the-Sand_2018_48_ELR_10914.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;disinvestment&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; strategy, refusing to maintain roads and infrastructure in coastal communities. For example, a county in Florida refused to maintain a key coastal road, citing the expense associated with repairs to a road vulnerable to climate change. Wealthy homeowners sued the county, claiming that it refused to follow the requisite abandonment procedures. The court found that the county &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/fl-district-court-of-appeal/1568206.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;must provide&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; a “&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;reasonable level of maintenance&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;that affords meaningful access&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, unless or until the County formally abandons the road”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;(emphasis added)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The upshot: There is no free lunch in our climate choices. Deliberate disinvestment and inaction &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/fl-district-court-of-appeal/1568206.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;may impose&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; governmental liability, and any attempts to abandon coastal roads will be closely scrutinized. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;But being too proactive in taking adaptation measures has its own challenges, even beyond the initial fiscal investment. For example, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.miamigov.com/My-Government/ClimateChange/Climate-Change-Action&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Miami&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; is on track to spend $500 million on climate adaptation measures&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, an enormous investment that will be closely watched—particularly if these adaptation measures fail or go awry. As a general matter, governments are not liable for failure to provide essential services. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;But &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://casetext.com/case/litz-v-md-dept-of-the-envt-3&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;some courts&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; have found that the failure to maintain existing city services creates liability. And the Army Corps of Engineers was &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://casetext.com/case/st-bernard-parish-govt-v-united-states-1&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;sued&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; by plaintiffs in the lower Ninth Ward of New Orleans on an analogous theory. They argued that the government was liable for damage to the property because the Army failed to maintain a levee system protecting New Orleans. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;While this suit was ultimately unsuccessful, it showcases that climate change-driven extreme weather events will call into question the adequacy of existing adaptation measures. These decisions will be closely scrutinized. Somewhat paradoxically, Miami’s investment may result in taking on &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;greater&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; legal duties owed if something goes awry. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Governments at all levels must walk a legal tightrope between action and inaction.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Finally, choosing the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2590332219300806&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;managed retreat&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; strategy—systematically moving people out of harm’s way prior to disaster striking—may appear to be a wise choice for certain coastal communities. But this is enormously expensive and difficult to scale—witness the&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/30/climate/native-tribes-relocate-climate.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt; $25 million&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; price tag for ongoing efforts to move small Native American communities decimated by slow-onset sea level rise and other climate impacts. And truly involuntary retreat must wrestle with eminent domain prohibitions and the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2023/04/23/books/review/the-rediscovery-of-america-ned-blackhawk.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;dark history&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of forced migration in the United States and elsewhere.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;What’s left? &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4372312&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Unmanaged retreat&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;—the displacement of people following a natural disaster. Unmanaged retreat is ad hoc, reactive, disjointed, and deeply inequitable. In 2022, the U.S. Census &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/disasters-displaced-more-than-3-million-americans-in-2022/#:~:text=More%20than%203%20million%20adults,hurricanes%2C%20floods%20and%20other%20events.&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;estimated&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that more than 3 million adults were forced to evacuate their homes in the past year because of a natural disaster. That’s 1.4 percent of the U.S. adult population. While many of these displacements were short term, the impact is staggering. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Roughly 16 percent of the displaced adults &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/disasters-displaced-more-than-3-million-americans-in-2022/#:~:text=The%20Census%20Bureau%20estimate%20far,of%20the%20U.S.%20adult%20population.&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;never returned home&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, and 12 percent found themselves displaced for more than six months. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In the absence of a national climate adaptation plan, disaster strategy has emerged as our default national adaptation strategy. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Existing Laws Incentivize Climate Risk-Taking&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Beyond these adaptation strategies, existing laws obfuscate and even incentivize climate risk-taking. The taxpayer-funded National Flood Insurance Program, for example, underwrites construction in climate-exposed flood zones. Meanwhile, state and local real estate laws often hide flood risk. In 21 states, home sellers &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://kleinmanenergy.upenn.edu/research/publications/climate-adaptation-strategies-how-do-we-manage-managed-retreat/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;are not required&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to notify prospective buyers that the home is located in a flood zone. The federal &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://kleinmanenergy.upenn.edu/research/publications/climate-adaptation-strategies-how-do-we-manage-managed-retreat/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Privacy Act&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; protects prior flood claims as a protected “record.” Remarkably, prospective used car buyers have &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://kleinmanenergy.upenn.edu/research/publications/climate-adaptation-strategies-how-do-we-manage-managed-retreat/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;more access&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to critical flood information than prospective homebuyers—does this make any sense?&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In a natural disaster’s aftermath, the president &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://scholarlycommons.law.emory.edu/faculty-articles/7/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;declares&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; a “major disaster” or “emergency” under the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.fema.gov/disaster/stafford-act&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Stafford Act&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. This taps into Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) disaster funding, and there are few to no restrictions on using federal funds to rebuild homes in the same location, multiple times. This facilitates a senseless “destroy, rebuild, and repeat” cycle. Too often, this results in rebuilding in the same place where disaster struck. The number of repetitive loss properties—those properties that file repeat flood claims—&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nrdc.org/resources/losing-ground-severe-repetitive-flooding-united-states&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;is increasing&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. Case in point—a single home in Mississippi was &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2590332219300806#bbib70&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;rebuilt&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; 34 times in 32 years, costing taxpayers $663,000 for a home worth just $69,000. Even climate skeptics must admit that this is a terrible return on taxpayer investment. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;An Emerging Legal Destabilization?&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Thankfully, some nascent efforts underway at the local, state, and federal levels address this growing need for legal adaptation. Congress has taken steps to reform the Stafford Act through increased pre-disaster mitigation measures. Proposed FEMA &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.npr.org/2023/06/01/1179573166/fema-lawsuit-flood-insurance-rate-hikes&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;flood maps&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; now take into account future climate projections, but the increase in insurance rates has already sparked a flurry of lawsuits. New York’s legislature just &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nys/central-ny/ny-state-of-politics/2023/06/01/new-york-lawmakers-seek-to-tighten-flood-disclosure-law-for-homebuyers&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;passed&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; a law to mandate flood disclosure information prior to a new home purchase; that bill just landed on Gov. Kathy Hochul’s desk and is ready for signature.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;And a piece of federal legislation was recently proposed—the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/senate-bill/3531&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;National Climate Adaptation and Resilience Strategy Act&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. This requires the appointment of a chief resilience officer to direct national resilience and adaptation efforts across the United States.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;While the U.S. Constitution is nearly impossible to amend at this time, some enterprising plaintiffs have rediscovered existing environmental protections within state constitutions. Last week, a judge &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://time.com/6286358/held-v-montana-trial-starts/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;heard arguments&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in a lawsuit filed by 16 youth plaintiffs against the state of Montana for &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-michael-gerrard-held-v-montana&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;violating a constitutional provision&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; requiring a “healthful environment” for all Montana citizens. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Despite these attempts to update and transform laws, doctrines, and policies, climate change continues to outpace these efforts. The best-laid plans may well be thwarted by a legal architecture inadequate for the climate-driven physical destabilization. Whether law can adapt to meet the climate moment remains to be seen.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 08:01:12 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Mark Nevitt</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24482</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>The Lawfare Podcast: Large Language Negligence
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-large-language-negligence</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;As large language models like ChatGPT play an increasingly important role in our society, there will no doubt be examples of them causing harm. Lawsuits have already been filed in cases where LLMs have made false statements about individuals, but what about run-of-the-mill negligence cases? What happens when an LLM provides faulty medical advice or causes extreme emotional distress?&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;A forthcoming symposium in the Journal of Free Speech Law tackles these questions, and Alan Rozenshtein, Associate Professor of Law at the University of Minnesota and Senior Editor at &lt;i&gt;Lawfare, &lt;/i&gt;spoke with three of the symposium&#039;s contributors at the University of Arizona and the University of Florida: law professors Jane Bambauer and Derek Bambauer, and computer scientist Mihai Surdeanu. &lt;a href=&quot;https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4432822&quot;&gt;Jane&#039;s paper&lt;/a&gt; focuses on what it means for a LLM to breach its duty of care, and &lt;a href=&quot;https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4443714&quot;&gt;Derek and Mihai explore&lt;/a&gt; under what conditions the output of LLMs may be shielded from liability by that all-important Internet statute, Section 230.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;
&lt;iframe frameborder=&quot;0&quot; height=&quot;110px&quot; src=&quot;https://embed.acast.com/60518a52f69aa815d2dba41c/6494cdb0f937660011e1bbf7&quot; width=&quot;100%&quot;&gt;&lt;/iframe&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 05:01:15 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Jen Patja Howell</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24483</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>The Chatter Podcast: Covering the January 6th Trials with Roger Parloff
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/chatter-podcast-covering-january-6th-trials-roger-parloff</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;Since joining Lawfare in November 2021, Roger Parloff has been a constant presence at the January 6th trials. Now based in Washington, D.C, he had, earlier in his career, served as a staff writer for Fortune and American Lawyer Magazine, and has been published in The New York Times, Yahoo Finance, ProPublica, New York, &lt;a href=&quot;http://newyorker.com/&quot; rel=&quot;nofollow&quot; target=&quot;_blank&quot;&gt;NewYorker.com&lt;/a&gt;, and Air Mail News. As a senior editor at Lawfare, he&#039;s focused on January 6 related matters, including covering the more than 1,000 federal criminal cases that have been filed while also keeping up on the pending investigations of higher-ups.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;In his conversation with Benjamin Wittes, Lawfare’s editor in chief and this week’s Chatter guest host, Roger talks about giving live play-by-play of the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers trials, the Venue Transfer Motions filed by many Jan. 6th defendants, the other journalists and &quot;sedition hunters&quot; who have been crucial in gathering information and reporting on the Jan. 6th cases, and more.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;Parloff’s latest essay on &lt;em&gt;Lawfare &lt;/em&gt;on this subject is entitled: “&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/should-nine-oath-keepers-receive-terror-enhanced-sentences&quot; rel=&quot;nofollow&quot; target=&quot;_blank&quot;&gt;Should Nine Oath Keepers Receive Terror-Enhanced Sentences?&lt;/a&gt;”&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;iframe allow=&quot;autoplay&quot; frameborder=&quot;0&quot; height=&quot;110px&quot; src=&quot;https://embed.acast.com/$/6183f163bc7be70013fcaa56/covering-the-january-6th-trials-with-roger-parloff&quot; width=&quot;100%&quot;&gt;&lt;/iframe&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;Chatter is a production of Lawfare and Goat Rodeo. This episode was produced and edited by Cara Shillenn of Goat Rodeo. Podcast theme by David Priess, featuring music created using Groovepad.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;See &lt;a href=&quot;http://acast.com/privacy&quot;&gt;acast.com/privacy&lt;/a&gt; for privacy and opt-out information.&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Thu, 22 Jun 2023 15:01:53 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Roger Parloff, Benjamin Wittes</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24480</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>What If It Were Illegal to Transfer Personal Data From the European Union to the United States?
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/what-if-it-were-illegal-transfer-personal-data-european-union-united-states</link>
    <description>&lt;p style=&quot;margin-top:16px; margin-bottom:16px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On May 22, 2023, the Irish Data Protection Commissioner (DPC)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://edpb.europa.eu/our-work-tools/consistency-findings/register-decisions/2023/decision-data-protection-commission_en&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;ordered&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; Meta to stop transferring EU personal data to the United States. Such transfers underpin Meta’s EU business, which makes up approximately 10 percent of its global revenue. To boot, the DPC imposed a fine of 1.2 billion euros (about $1.3 billion) against Meta’s Irish subsidiary responsible for the transfer of EU data and ordered Meta to remedy the fact that EU personal data was already in the U.S. by bringing that data “into compliance” with the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-top:16px; margin-bottom:16px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;A billion-dollar-plus fine—a sum greater than the Irish defense budget and the EU’s largest ever for a privacy violation—alongside an order to stop practices that have become so commonplace, if not essential, to the internet’s promise of easy global communications is a wake-up call. It is a wake-up call not just for the internet but also for national surveillance, which faces the challenge of increasing distrust among nations, including among traditional allies.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-top:16px; margin-bottom:16px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As historic and consequential as this enforcement against one company is, it is important to understand what this record fine does &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;not&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; represent. This is not a fine for over-collection of data by a company often criticized for its ubiquitous data gathering, or for that company’s business model of offering free services at the price of advertising targeted based on personal data, or for misusing data in unexpected or harmful ways. On the whole, the enforcement stems not from what Meta did—other than engage in a practice of transferring personal data to a country, which thousands of other companies engage in—but from what U.S. surveillance authorities could do with that data and the rights and recourse that exist for non-U.S. persons when their data is used by U.S. surveillance authorities.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-top:16px; margin-bottom:16px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The decision has enormous implications, not just for Meta or other companies based in the United States but also for companies around the world that seek to provide services to the European market. The reality is that countless companies (and even nonprofit organizations), both American and European, likely commit the same data protection violation for which Meta faces a $1.3 billion penalty: After all, they also transfer data to the United States, using “electronic communications services” that are subject to U.S. government directives issued under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act’s Section 702. Of course, most of these organizations would not face fines nearly as severe because they are unlikely to transfer the volume of data or earn the revenue that Meta does. But the penalty would be painful nonetheless, and the prospect of having to stop data flows to the United States to avoid further pains would be devastating to many companies.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-top:16px; margin-bottom:16px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Many observers have worried that the World Wide Web could be carved up into national or regional zones. The historic fine issued by the Irish data protection authority against Meta in May suggests that such concerns have reached a crisis level, imperiling data transfers from the EU to the U.S., at least until stronger controls over U.S. surveillance law are in place and recognized as adequate by the EU.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot; style=&quot;margin-top:16px; margin-bottom:16px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Snowden and Schrems&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-top:16px; margin-bottom:16px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Meta’s travails began &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jun/06/nsa-phone-records-verizon-court-order&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;10 years ago this month&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; with Edward Snowden’s revelations of widespread electronics signals gathering by the U.S. National Security Agency. Disclosures related to hitherto unknown U.S. surveillance practices and programs, such as PRISM, and how they extended to data on non-U.S. persons, catalyzed action and activism in Europe. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-top:16px; margin-bottom:16px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Those revelations drove the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in 2015 to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.jsf?text=&amp;amp;docid=169195&amp;amp;pageIndex=0&amp;amp;doclang=EN&amp;amp;mode=lst&amp;amp;dir=&amp;amp;occ=first&amp;amp;part=1&amp;amp;cid=366760&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;invalidate&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://iapp.org/resources/article/us-eu-safe-harbor-guidance-and-resources/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;EU-U.S. Safe Harbor&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;—an agreement that facilitated data transfers from the EU to certified U.S. companies—on account of the lack of “essential equivalence” between U.S. and EU privacy protections. That case was the result of a complaint brought by the Austrian Max Schrems, who was then a law student. After the EU approved a new mechanism for data transfer to the United States, Schrems would challenge the lawfulness of using other GDPR-sanctioned mechanisms to transfer data to the United States and, in doing so, brought about the demise of the successor to the Safe Harbor—the EU-U.S. Privacy Shield—in July 2020. The CJEU in &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.jsf;jsessionid=C57AE008866D9BE7161894EA7697845D?text=&amp;amp;docid=228677&amp;amp;pageIndex=0&amp;amp;doclang=EN&amp;amp;mode=lst&amp;amp;dir=&amp;amp;occ=first&amp;amp;part=1&amp;amp;cid=366680&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Schrems II&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; found U.S. surveillance practices to lack some of the hallmarks of EU privacy protections: “necessary and proportionate” limits on the collection of personal data by U.S. surveillance authorities and the existence of effective redress functions for individuals.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Having eliminated two EU-U.S. adequacy agreements, Schrems turned his focus on Meta—one company amid &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R46917&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;the thousands that had relied on the “adequate” transatlantic pipeline&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. In the absence of an EU-sanctioned “adequate” U.S. framework for transfers, companies like Meta resorted to reliance on alternative organization-level mechanisms to legally effect such  transfers. By far the most prevalent is use of standard contractual clauses that  bind non-EU data importers to the privacy standards that bind EU data exporters. One &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://iapp.org/media/pdf/resource_center/IAPP_EY_Annual_Privacy_Governance_Report_2021.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;study&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; found that 94 percent of organizations turned to these standard contractual clauses to legally effect transfers of data from the EU to the U.S. following &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Schrems II&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. Mindful of the risk that those contractual commitments may not count for much if abrogated by overriding laws and practices in the country of the data importer, the European Data Protection Board—comprising each of the EU member state data privacy supervisory authorities—released guidance as to when EU data can be transferred internationally, under what conditions, and what “supplementary measures” could be utilized to legally effect the transfer.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Meta’s Choices&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Notwithstanding seemingly favorable commentary by the Irish DPC about Meta’s diligence around its privacy safeguards, no measures implemented by a private organization—not even those with the resources of Meta—could fill the purported gaps that exist in U.S. surveillance law and practice.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Such an order raises two prospects of operational consequence for Meta. The first is the option to cease transfers of EU data to the United States. The second is to somehow shield EU data in the U.S. from U.S. surveillance authorities. Neither is likely to be practical or desirable. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Meta’s Solution 1: Just Stop Transferring Data&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Meta has suggested that it needs to transfer personal data to the U.S. in order to offer services in the EU. In its &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://investor.fb.com/financials/sec-filings-details/default.aspx?FilingId=15526422&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;2021 Annual Report&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, Meta warned that it might be unable to operate its main services, including Facebook and Instagram, if it were unable to transfer data from Europe across the Atlantic: “If a new transatlantic data transfer framework is not adopted and we are unable to continue to rely on SCCs (standard contractual clauses) or rely upon other alternative means of data transfers from Europe to the United States, we will likely be unable to offer a number of our most significant products and services, including Facebook and Instagram, in Europe.” Similar warnings were sounded in subsequent investor disclosures and, incidentally, by dozens of other companies.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Some companies have gone the way of localizing data in-territory as a way of mitigating or altogether avoiding the risk and concerns of conflicts of law. Microsoft has its appropriately named EU Data Boundary available for some of its enterprise data. TikTok has its U.S.-based Project Texas, which is serving as inspiration for its move toward a European version titled Project Clover. The hope that localized data processing as a means of engendering regulatory certainty and customer trust is often premised on theories akin to the merits of stashing cash under the mattress. Localizing practices can &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://scholarlycommons.law.emory.edu/elj/vol64/iss3/2/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;introduce&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; new or heightened security vulnerabilities, threaten to fragment the functioning of the internet, and undermine the efficacy of law enforcement and national security practices, especially those with a cross-border component.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It appears unlikely that, despite its continued investment in EU data centers, Meta will want or be able to provide its EU services without some means of routing EU data to its headquarters in the U.S.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Meta’s Solution 2: End-to-End Encryption&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Assuming Meta proceeds with transferring EU data to the U.S., a nearly decisive way to avoid U.S. surveillance laws is to make that data nearly impossible to read, so that turning it over essentially reveals nothing. Encryption is a neat solution in theory. In practice, this would require end-to-end encryption at all parts of the data processing life cycle in order to be confident that surveillance authorities cannot obtain access to personal data. It would effectively require Meta itself to never be able to read the data. After all, if Meta holds the encryption key, the National Security Agency could possibly order it to turn over that data in an unencrypted form or to hand over the key. Such end-to-end encryption would undermine Meta’s business model, which, as we’ve said, relies on advertising that is targeted based on users’ personal information. It would also make it difficult for Meta to engage in routine content moderation and fraud detection, including the detection of what Meta calls “coordinated inauthentic behavior.” Finally, law enforcement agencies on both sides of the Atlantic would be displeased with having less access to information.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The root causes of the enforcement directed at Meta—European perceptions of U.S. surveillance overreach—are not matters that Meta can address. Lancing the boil is a measure that only governments with competence for law enforcement and national security matters can perform.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Next Steps for Policymakers&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Many eyes and clocks are fixed on the ongoing transatlantic work to finalize a third data adequacy framework. In the eleventh hour, there is work on both sides of the pond. Significant&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/10/07/fact-sheet-president-biden-signs-executive-order-to-implement-the-european-union-u-s-data-privacy-framework/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt; reforms&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to U.S. laws and practices, ushered in by Executive Order 14086 and accompanying Attorney General regulations, are undeniable improvements to the privacy safeguards that were assessed by the CJEU as wanting in &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Schrems I&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;II&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. Those enhancements are limited so as to be applicable only to the citizens of “qualifying states” that offer comparably reciprocal rights to U.S. persons when U.S. data is in that state. The U.S. is yet to designate the EU as a qualifying state, with such designation necessarily needing to account for important differences between the EU member states, each of which is competent for its own national security laws and practices. Across the pond, the European Commission has &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_22_7631&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;concluded preliminarily&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that the reformed U.S. rules and practices are “adequate” to protect European personal data. That assessment, which is snaking its way through the EU’s internal process for adoption, depends on the U.S. designating the EU a “qualifying state.” The prevailing expectation, supported by statements from high-level representatives on both sides, is that the new adequate EU-U.S. agreement—the Data Privacy Framework—will be online this summer.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;That such an arrangement is anticipated and in short order will put in place a data transfer framework that many have been calling for since the demise of the Privacy Shield. It would also relieve Meta from having to turn off the taps for its transatlantic transfers, something it would otherwise be required to do by October this year.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The long-awaited and forthcoming transatlantic triumph is only one piece, albeit an important piece, in an increasingly fragmented and unstable global puzzle for international data transfers. Indeed, that puzzle contains many puzzles within puzzles. For all their ease from the perspective of the organizations relying on them as a legal mechanism for transfer, adequacy decisions have proved cumbersome to scale up. The EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework would bring the EU’s list of “adequate” destinations to 15. That’s after over 25 years of reviewing countries to see if they have adequate protections. Even the UK, which left the EU in part to be more fleet of regulatory foot, has found the task of assessing countries to be labor intensive and has increasingly spread its bets across different initiatives. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Now extrapolate those challenges further afield. The &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://lawreview.uchicago.edu/print-archive/privacy-andor-trade&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;proliferation&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of GDPR-type laws around the world has resulted in over &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://iapp.org/resources/article/infographic-global-adequacy-capabilities/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;70 countries&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; with similar but independent powers to assess the “adequacy” of other countries’ law. The &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://iapp.org/resources/article/infographic-global-data-transfer-contracts/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;numbers are similar&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; for countries covered by different versions of standard contractual clauses. Then there are those countries with even more restrictive gateways to lawfully transfer data and countries that require the local storage of data as a condition of doing business in-territory. Mapping an organization’s data transfers is one challenge. Navigating the complex web of unilateral and bilateral mechanisms is of a different, more challenging order. That’s before the near impossible task of finding (if they exist) and assessing (if they’re accessible) the extent to which laws and practices pertaining to national security and law enforcement undercut privacy protections. Past and current criticisms laid at the door of the U.S. are not unique to the U.S. Indeed, many of the countries found adequate by the EU before the Schrems jurisprudence have their own vulnerabilities to legal challenge, to say nothing of the laws and practices that exist among EU member states.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Also, keep in mind that any hard-fought determination of adequacy would still leave out most of the world as inadequate to receive personal data from the European Union without elaborate and expensive safeguards.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It is against that backdrop that many rightly laud multilateral initiatives taking on both the complex web of different transfer mechanisms and the lack of trust and standardization when it comes to surveillance. On the former, initiatives such as the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.globalcbpr.org/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Global Cross-Border Privacy Rules Forum&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; stand out and appear to be gathering momentum with the commitments being made by some of the fastest growing and most established digital economies to the design of a more scalable multilateral data transfers certification mechanism. There is also momentum, albeit more limited than the Global CBPRs, behind the modernized &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.coe.int/en/web/data-protection/convention108/modernised&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Convention 108&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;—a legally binding instrument of the Council of Europe—which creates a data flows bloc for all signatories apart from EU member states. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;On surveillance, there is no greater accelerant toward establishing and promoting trust than the “landmark” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.oecd.org/newsroom/landmark-agreement-adopted-on-safeguarding-privacy-in-law-enforcement-and-national-security-data-access.htm&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;OECD (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development) agreement&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; on the principles for government access to data for the purposes of national security and law enforcement. That all OECD members could, on matters of profound sensitivity and national specificity, articulate principles that they agree are good and commonly held is no small feat. That those same countries were of one voice in how they “reject any approach … that, regardless of the context, is inconsistent with democratic values and the rule of law, and is unconstrained, unreasonable, arbitrary or disproportionate” suggests there might just be a paradigm shift in perspective to focus on bad actors.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Conclusion&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The concatenation of circumstances that followed the Snowden revelations, spearheaded in large part by Max Schrems and now his organization None of Your Business, has undoubtedly &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;prompted sharper scrutiny of and reforms to surveillance laws. The economics of modern digital trade have fused with national security equities, and the importance of trust has prevailed as both a journey and a destination to securing both. The importance of trust in data transfers, what that trust can enable, what its absence curtails, and the strategic dividends associated with coalescing around shared principles has risen to the top of the geopolitical in-box for presidents and prime ministers. Hopefully they can come together and avoid the sort of total breakdown that would further fragment the internet.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Thu, 22 Jun 2023 13:04:11 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Anupam Chander, Joe Jones</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24479</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Rational Security: The &amp;#039;Even Stephan&amp;#039; Edition
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/rational-security-even-stephan-edition</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;This week, Alan, Quinta, and Scott were joined by UVA Law Professor Paul Stephan to talk through the close-calls in this week&#039;s national security news, including:&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;ul&gt;
&lt;li&gt;“Xi’s All That.” Secretary of State Antony Blinken visited Beijing this past week, for a long delayed sit-down with President Xi Jinping to try and de-escalate the two superpowers’ tense relationship. Was this meeting a smart move or a giveaway? And what should we make of President Biden calling the Chinese leader a “dictator” shortly after Blinken’s return?&lt;/li&gt;
&lt;li&gt;“Adverse REPOssession.” The question of what to do with the $300 billion in Russia-related assets frozen by the United States and its allies has reemerged, with members of Congress recently introducing a new version of the REPO Act that would seize those assets and make them available as reparations for Ukraine, among other purposes. Is seizure the right way to handle these assets? What challenges and risks might such a dramatic step encounter?&lt;/li&gt;
&lt;li&gt;“Robo Joe.” President Biden joined a summit of leaders in the AI industry this week as part of his administration’s ongoing effort to seriously engage the policy challenges raised by AI technology. But what are the realistic prospects for regulation? And what form should it take?&lt;/li&gt;
&lt;/ul&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;
&lt;iframe frameborder=&quot;0&quot; height=&quot;110px&quot; src=&quot;https://embed.acast.com/60427f9d34b9a27f4b6e3a8d/6493a29883b55d0010db9cad&quot; width=&quot;100%&quot;&gt;&lt;/iframe&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;For object lessons, Alan recommended the new Apple comedy “&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.imdb.com/title/tt13366604/&quot; rel=&quot;noopener noreferrer&quot; target=&quot;_blank&quot;&gt;Platonic&lt;/a&gt;.” Quinta doubled-down on the TV recommendations with the stage play-turned-movie about leaks in the intelligence community, “&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/reality_2023&quot; rel=&quot;noopener noreferrer&quot; target=&quot;_blank&quot;&gt;Reality&lt;/a&gt;.” Scott urged listeners to check out Gil Scott-Heron’s classic 2010 final album “&lt;a href=&quot;https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/13893-im-new-here/&quot; rel=&quot;noopener noreferrer&quot; target=&quot;_blank&quot;&gt;I’m New Here&lt;/a&gt;,” and two phenomenal reimaginings: “&lt;a href=&quot;https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/15140-were-new-here/&quot; rel=&quot;noopener noreferrer&quot; target=&quot;_blank&quot;&gt;We’re New Here&lt;/a&gt;” by Jamiexx and “&lt;a href=&quot;https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/gil-scott-heron-makaya-mccraven-were-new-again-a-reimagining-by-makaya-mccraven/&quot; rel=&quot;noopener noreferrer&quot; target=&quot;_blank&quot;&gt;We’re New Again&lt;/a&gt;” by Makaya McCraven. And Paul recommended the new book “&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.amazon.com/Lock-Up-Novel-John-Banville/dp/1335449639&quot; rel=&quot;noopener noreferrer&quot; target=&quot;_blank&quot;&gt;The Lock-Up: A Novel&lt;/a&gt;” by John Banville.&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Thu, 22 Jun 2023 12:01:21 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Jen Patja Howell</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24478</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Confusing Judicial Reform With Unleashing Extremism
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/confusing-judicial-reform-unleashing-extremism</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Editor’s Note: &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;The following is adapted from an address given at Columbia Law School on May 4, 2023, at a conference on “The Battle over the Israeli Judiciary” put on by Columbia Law School and Academic Exchange.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The argument between advocates of judicial activism and advocates of judicial restraint is an important one—ongoing over many years and obviously unresolved—one that regularly invites our attention. I have had a small part in the argument, mostly on the restraint side. Many of you will remember the enthusiastic reception of John Rawls’s &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;A Theory of Justice&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in law schools back in the 1970s and 1980s. I remember law professors arguing that since Rawls obviously got it right, the courts should begin enforcing the “difference principle”—or, at least, using it as a guide in deciding difficult cases. I wrote a piece back then &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://people.brandeis.edu/~teuber/Walzer_Philosophy+Democracy.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;arguing for judicial restraint&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;When the parallel arguments began in Israel some years later, with Supreme Court President Aharon Barak leading an activist court and defending a doctrinal activism, his leading intellectual opponent was Ruth Gavison, a professor at Hebrew University’s law school and a good friend of mine—a friend with whom I partly agreed. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;But I don’t believe that those old arguments, important and legitimate as they are, are truly what lies behind the current Israeli debate over the government’s so-called judicial reform. They are not what Israelis are really arguing about when they push for these laws or take to the streets to oppose them. And they are not the proper focus when American analysts watch events in Israel from overseas. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The new Israeli government has a radical, ultranationalist, and ultrareligious agenda—an agenda aimed at both the West Bank and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://jstreet.org/the-green-line/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;green-line Israel&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. Its leaders chose to begin with legislation drastically weakening the Israeli Supreme Court because they believe that its judges will be an obstacle to the realization of their agenda. This isn’t a question of judicial philosophy; it is a political question. Actually, this Israeli Supreme Court does not have a great record defending justice in the West Bank; the judges have not done anywhere near enough, for example, to prevent the seizure of Palestinian land and the expansion of settlements, nor have they managed to overturn the effective legal impunity of settler thugs and would-be militias, whose daily acts of violence against Palestinians are recorded in the Israeli press, it seems, only in the pages of Ha’aretz. So it is really heartening to discover that this government’s leaders expect the court to stand in their way. I suppose, I hope, that they know more than I do. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Some of my friends on the left, here and in Israel, have criticized the men and women protesting against the judicial “reform” because the protesters don’t talk openly about the occupation and about what’s happening in the West Bank—and about what will happen if this government is able to enact and enforce its program. Indeed, the protesters talk only about democracy at home and not about what democracy would require in the occupied territories, not about the “geopolitical” issues Israel confronts. But the defense of democracy is a rejection of unchecked power; that has been a steady theme of the protests. Now, we can oppose unchecked power and defend limited government for all sorts of reasons, including reasons having to do with abstract principles of political theory. But, in fact, in Israel today, the reasons for opposing unchecked power have to do with the likely—the immediately likely—uses of that power.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Many protesters, I admit, fear the uses of unchecked power not abroad (the West Bank is abroad for these purposes) but at home, to advance the program of religious zealots, the current leaders of the ultraorthodox, Haredi, political parties. These parties, a crucial part of the governing coalition and a significant source of its radicalism, have a twofold agenda. First, they mean to consolidate and entrench the autonomy of their community. Specifically, they aim to defend their ability to refuse the conscription of their young men (and women) and their ability to ignore the national curriculum in their schools: not only math and reading but also history and civics. The Haredim don’t want to teach citizenship or the meaning of democracy to their children, and they don’t accept the central obligation of Israeli citizenship—and this is now to be made official, a central and permanent feature of Israeli society. They also hope to extend the authority of the rabbinic courts, chiefly at the expense of religious women. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;These are all domestic matters. But some of the leaders of the Haredi parties also want to enforce aspects of religious Jewishness. I mean here that they wish to enforce their understanding of religious Jewishness, which is not the only possible understanding of it. And they aim to do so across the larger society. Sabbath observance, gender separation, and immigration policy are the current examples, but there could be more to come. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;This would mean the further alienation of non-Jews from the state of Israel, another domestic matter. But it also means that in the Greater Israel that this government, or some of its leading members, mean to create, Palestinian Arabs could constitute a majority or near majority of the population and at the same time would be, at best, second-class citizens of a pervasively Jewish, an in-your-face Jewish country. And that is a geopolitical matter since it would affect the standing of Israel in global society and, possibly, its relations with currently friendly states—and its connection, if this matters to the government, to world Jewry. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Still, the Haredim have some built-in restraint, a certain old-fashioned sense of vulnerability derived from their history, and broader Jewish history; they are mostly not all that interested in Greater Israel.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;By contrast, the most significant geopolitical dangers the government poses come not from the Haredim but from the ultranationalist members of the government, who represent the settlers. They are also religious but come from a different strain of Judaism—and they are radically unrestrained. Before looking at their larger program, I want to say something about the proposal, agreed to by the prime minister in response to demands from the criminal turned police minister Itamar Ben Gvir to create a “national guard” alongside or between the Israeli Defense Forces and the police. The idea had been discussed before the previous election; it may be a good idea if it were based on the American model of an apolitical force used in emergencies. I am sure that the Israeli Supreme Court would not interfere in the creation of a force of that sort, on the assumption that it would be used in legal ways. But the current proposal would place this force in the hands of one of the most radical members of the government, who has in the past, and more recently, called for the violent repression of West Bank Palestinians and of protesters in Israel proper. I wonder if it is “reasonable”—a much disputed concept but certainly relevant here—to create a national guard to defend law and order and put at its head a man committed to violence and aggression. Might that be an issue for the court? I will have to leave that question to the lawyers. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The aim of the ultranationalists is, quite simply, the establishment of Greater Israel, one state from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea, ruled by Jews, preferably Jews like themselves. And these zealots are prepared—I want to be careful here, so I will choose a euphemism—to impose all the hardships on the Palestinians that would be necessary to ensure that this Greater Israel will be a Jewish state. We all know, if we are willing to know, what those hardships would involve.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Over the past decades, people like me have been arguing that the ongoing occupation and the steadily expanding settlements would turn Israel into a pariah state. We were wrong; we didn’t grasp the geopolitical realities. It turns out that Israel’s high-tech economy, its military strength, and its intelligence capacities override any interest among Arab countries or, more generally, around the world in the troubles of the Palestinians. Will that continue to be true if the program of the current government is realized? Perhaps our previous view was simply premature. I have no relevant knowledge here; I can only notice that the people responsible for Israel’s high-tech economy, its military strength, and its intelligence capacities all seem to believe that the realization of the government’s program would be disastrous.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;I am more interested today in what you might call the geopolitics of diaspora and, especially, American Jewry. For the past decade, I have been a member of a group of liberal and left &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;academics who fight against the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement on every campus where we have people and in the professional associations. We win some battles, and lose some, but we have proved, I think, that winning is possible and that the best way to win on the American campus today is to defend Israel from the left, which is to say critically. I would guess that the current Israeli uprising in defense of democracy will make winning easier (for the moment)—and that the defeat of the uprising would make winning virtually impossible. That is also a geopolitical problem, given the percentage of Jewish young people who go to college and the fact that American Jewry has been, in the past, a valuable geopolitical asset for Israel. Lose the young, and we lose the asset. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;But I don’t want to end with the geopolitical dangers that the government’s program will bring with it. There are also moral-political dangers. Religious coercion, radical inequality, and nationalist aggrandizement represent a version of politics that requires our moral condemnation. The protesters in Israel know that, or many of them do, and that is what drives their protest. And I believe that American Jews and liberal Americans more generally know it too, and that should lead us to support the protesters. Since the government of Israel, as I noted above, believes that the judges of the Supreme Court will obstruct their program of coercion, inequality, and aggrandizement, we should also, whatever our judicial philosophy, support the integrity of the court system.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Thu, 22 Jun 2023 08:59:38 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Michael Walzer</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24476</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>The Lawfare Podcast: Richard Gowan on the U.S. Push for UN Security Council Reform
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-richard-gowan-us-push-un-security-council-reform</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;At the United Nations, Russia&#039;s obstruction of efforts to respond to its invasion of Ukraine is finally sparking serious interest in an issue that has long simmered in the background of global politics: reform of the UN Security Council to make it a larger and more inclusive body. In contrast to prior U.S. administrations, the Biden administration is at the tip of the spear of this effort and may be preparing to release a reform proposal of its own in the coming weeks.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;To better understand this forthcoming proposal and the context that has led to it, &lt;i&gt;Lawfare&lt;/i&gt; Senior Editor Scott R. Anderson sat down with Richard Gowan, an experienced UN watcher and current UN Director at the International Crisis Group. They discussed why the Ukraine conflict has sparked an interest in Security Council reform, what reform is likely to look like, and who stands to benefit the most.&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;
&lt;iframe frameborder=&quot;0&quot; height=&quot;110px&quot; src=&quot;https://embed.acast.com/60518a52f69aa815d2dba41c/64937164ec5a6f0011b93ae8&quot; width=&quot;100%&quot;&gt;&lt;/iframe&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Thu, 22 Jun 2023 05:01:24 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Jen Patja Howell</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24477</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>Can Biden Sidestep Congress on an Iran Nuclear Deal?
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/can-biden-sidestep-congress-iran-nuclear-deal</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Biden administration might soon reach an agreement of sorts with Iran that would seek, among other things, to curb Iran’s nuclear weapons program. A major complication is that the&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; 2015 &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.congress.gov/114/bills/s615/BILLS-114s615is.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Iran Nuclear Agreement Review Act&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; (INARA) requires the president to “transmit” an “agreement” relating to the nuclear program of Iran to Congress, and then establishes a review period during which (a) the president may not exercise his sanctions-waiving authority and (b) Congress can vote on the agreement. News reports suggest that the Biden team is laying the groundwork to argue that &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/14/us/politics/biden-iran-nuclear-program.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;an informal deal with Iran does not constitute an “agreement”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and thus does not trigger any reporting duty under the INARA. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;This article assesses this argument and concludes that the Biden administration’s only plausible (but far from airtight) argument for avoiding its INARA duties is to make the agreement unwritten (that is, purely verbal).&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Original Iran Deal and the INARA&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;President Obama signed the INARA in 2015 to assuage Congress over the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://2009-2017.state.gov/documents/organization/245317.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; (JCPOA), the elaborate agreement that aimed to slow Iran’s nuclear weapons program. The Obama administration claimed that the Constitution did not require the president to submit the JCPOA for approval by the Senate or Congress because it was a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;nonbinding&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; agreement (that is, not governed by international law) entirely within the president’s constitutional authority to make and complete.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The INARA came about because Obama planned to implement the JCPOA by exercising various powers, conferred by Congress, to waive U.S. sanctions against Iran on a one-year basis. The INARA &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/2160e&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;requires&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; the president to “transmit to the appropriate congressional committees and leadership” an “agreement with Iran,” as defined, along with related certifications and reports. It then bars the president from exercising waiver authority for 30 days—a period the original law extended to 60 days for the JCPOA—during which Congress could review the agreement and have an opportunity to disapprove the agreement or narrow or eliminate the president’s sanctions-waiving authority, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;if&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; it could enact a joint resolution that overcame a presidential veto.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The INARA, in other words, did not require submission of the JCPOA for congressional approval. Rather, it required submission of the JCPOA for congressional consideration and potential nonapproval if Congress could muster supermajorities in each house. Congress was unable to muster the votes needed to kill or limit the JCPOA, however, and after 60 days Obama exercised his waiver authority and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/2016/01/16/executive-order-revocation-of-executive-orders-with-respect-to-Iran&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;implemented&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; the agreement.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The JCPOA operated for three years until President Trump &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/08/world/middleeast/trump-iran-nuclear-deal.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;announced&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in May 2018 that he was withdrawing from the agreement and reimposing domestic sanctions against Iran.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Biden Initiatives With Iran&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Biden administration last summer seemed &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2022/08/09/us/politics/iran-nuclear-deal-eu.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;on the verge&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of reaching a new agreement with Iran to slow its nuclear program in exchange for sanctions relief from the United States. The deal &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.axios.com/2022/10/31/iran-nuclear-deal-talks-biden&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;faltered&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; last fall, and Biden said it was “&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.axios.com/2022/12/20/biden-iran-nuclear-deal-dead-video&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;dead&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;” last November. But negotiations with Iran continued, and it now seems, according to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/14/us/politics/biden-iran-nuclear-program.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;many&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.wsj.com/articles/biden-administration-iran-deal-nuclear-weapons-international-atomic-energy-agency-7251bbe1&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;news&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.axios.com/2023/06/13/netanyahu-iran-us-indirect-talks-mini-agreement&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;reports&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, that an informal deal with Iran may be imminent. The deal &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/14/us/politics/biden-iran-nuclear-program.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;appears to involve&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; some combination of (a) the United States giving Iran sanctions relief under domestic law and in international institutions, and (b) Iran freeing American prisoners, agreeing not to enrich uranium beyond current purity levels, and agreeing to tamp down on proxy attacks on U.S. contractors in Iraq and Syria.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It is the sanctions-relief-for-nuclear-slowdown element of this agreement that potentially implicates the INARA. Yet the Biden administration appears to be signaling that any such deal would not be an “agreement” within the terms of the INARA. It has been reported that any agreement with Iran related to its nuclear program would be (as the New York Times &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/14/us/politics/biden-iran-nuclear-program.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;says&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;) “an informal, unwritten agreement” or (as &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.reuters.com/world/us-iran-talks-cool-tensions-with-mutual-understanding-2023-06-16/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Reuters&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.axios.com/2023/06/13/netanyahu-iran-us-indirect-talks-mini-agreement&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Axios &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.reuters.com/world/us-iran-talks-cool-tensions-with-mutual-understanding-2023-06-16/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;report&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;) an “understanding.” Some of these reports suggest that the Biden team is characterizing the agreement in these ways to circumvent its obligations under the INARA.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Last week, State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller, when asked about the “nuclear deal” with Iran, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.state.gov/briefings/department-press-briefing-june-14-2023/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;stated&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:justify&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;[R]umors about a nuclear deal, interim or otherwise, are false and misleading. ... We believe – our number one policy is ensuring that Iran never obtains a nuclear weapon, so of course we’ve been watching Iran’s enrichment activities. We believe diplomacy is the best path to help achieve that, but we’re preparing for all possible options and contingencies.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;When pressed on whether a nuclear deal was “on the agenda,” he further &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.state.gov/briefings/department-press-briefing-june-14-2023/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;obfuscated&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;I will say we have at all times believed that diplomacy is the best path forward. At the same time, we are not naive about Iran’s ambitions and Iran’s activities, but we have always believed at every step of the way that diplomacy is the best path forward for preventing Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon. But for the United States, all options are on the table.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Secretary of State Antony Blinken also &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2023/06/20/iran-us-nuclear-talks-prisoners/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;stated&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; last week that “some of the reports that we’ve seen about an agreement about nuclear matters and detainees are simply not accurate or not true.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;These careful denials about “rumors” or “some … reports” about a nuclear “deal” or “agreement” leave open the possibility of a less formal diplomatic understanding, perhaps unwritten, related to Iran’s nuclear program. As one Iranian official reportedly &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.reuters.com/world/us-iran-talks-cool-tensions-with-mutual-understanding-2023-06-16/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;said&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, “Call it whatever you want, whether a temporary deal, an interim deal or a mutual understanding—both sides want to prevent further escalation.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Why might the Biden administration want to avoid sending the new “agreement” to Congress under the INARA? After all, it seems unlikely that Congress could muster the supermajorities needed to overcome a presidential veto and defeat the implementation of the deal. But transmitting the agreement under the INARA would raise the political costs of the agreement, since the law triggers collateral duties and the administration would need to engage extensively with the Hill on the issue during the period the agreement was before it.  The administration might also want to spare some Democrats a perhaps-awkward vote, and to avoid the possible spectacle of having to implement the deal via a presidential veto in the face of majority opposition in Congress. Basically, the deal is much easier for the president to get done, politically and otherwise, if Congress is not involved. (Whether this is a good constitutional arrangement is another question.) &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Legal Issues&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As noted, the INARA &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/2160e&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;requires&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; the president to “transmit to the appropriate congressional committees and leadership” an “agreement with Iran,” as defined.  The law is still in force and is in the present tense, so the INARA obligation persists even though the INARA was written with the JCPOA present in mind.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The INARA defines the term “agreement” as follows: &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The term “agreement” means an agreement related to the nuclear program of Iran that includes the United States, commits the United States to take action, or pursuant to which the United States commits or otherwise agrees to take action, regardless of the form it takes, whether a political commitment or otherwise, and regardless of whether it is legally binding or not, including any joint comprehensive plan of action entered into or made between Iran and any other parties, and any additional materials related thereto, including annexes, appendices, codicils, side agreements, implementing materials, documents, and guidance, technical or other understandings, and any related agreements, whether entered into or implemented prior to the agreement or to be entered into or implemented in the future.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Note how broad this definition is. To be covered, the agreement need do only two things: (a) “relate[] to the nuclear program of Iran” and (b) “include[] the United States” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;or&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; “commit[] the United States to take action” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;or&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; be an agreement “pursuant to which the United States commits or otherwise agrees to take action.” And the definition emphasizes that the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;form the agreement takes&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;does not matter&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. If the definitional criteria are satisfied, the agreement is covered by the INARA, “regardless of the form it takes, whether a political commitment &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;or otherwise&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, and regardless of whether it is legally binding or not.” The INARA’s insistence that the form of the agreement does not matter takes place against the background of the State Department itself having emphasized that nonbinding instruments might assume various forms or titles, including “&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://2009-2017.state.gov/documents/organization/65728.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;non-binding agreements, gentlemen’s agreements, joint statements or declarations&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;.” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;House Foreign Affairs Committee chairman Michael T. McCaul sent Biden a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://foreignaffairs.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/6.15.23-MTM-letter-to-Potus-re-Iran-Final39.pdf?utm_source=ActiveCampaign&amp;amp;utm_medium=email&amp;amp;utm_content=Iran+Deal%3A+Back+on+the+Table%3F&amp;amp;utm_campaign=Iran+Deal%3A+Back+on+the+Table%3F&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;letter&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; last week that parsed the INARA definition above and concluded that it “requires that any agreement, arrangement, or understanding with Iran needs to be submitted to Congress pursuant to INARA.” McCaul presumably added “arrangement” and “understanding”—alternative phrasings for informal nonbinding agreements—to underscore that INARA applies if the definition is satisfied &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;regardless of the form of the agreement.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;But the definition is even broader than McCaul lets on because it does &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;not&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; (as he suggests) require an agreement &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;with &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Iran for the definition to apply. Rather, under the statutory definition, the agreement need only concern Iran’s nuclear program and involve the United States or commit the United States to action or lead it to take action. I do not know the reason for this phrasing. But one very important consequence of it is to include any agreement that meets the statutory criteria &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;even if the agreement is done through a third party&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. The United States has been negotiating with Iran indirectly &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.axios.com/2023/06/12/iran-us-indirect-talks-nuclear-program-biden-admin-oman&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;through&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/14/us/politics/biden-iran-nuclear-program.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Oman&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. One can imagine an arrangement with Iran through the auspices of Oman akin to the famous 1981 &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.parstimes.com/history/algiers_accords.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Algiers Accord&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that ended the hostage crisis between the United States and Iran, which involved independent commitments by Iran and the United States, coordinated and announced by Algiers. Such an agreement would still be covered by the INARA as long as it concerns Iran’s nuclear program and involves the United States or commits the United States to action or leads it to take action.   &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Biden administration nonetheless has a plausible argument for avoiding the INARA if the “agreement” is unwritten. The &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; “regardless of the form [the agreement] takes” language, considered alone, seems to include nonwritten agreements. But other statutory language might imply that the INARA duty is limited to written agreements. The president under the INARA must “transmit ... the agreement ... &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;in&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;cluding all related materials and annexes&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;” (emphasis added) to certain congressional committees. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It is conceivable that a nonwritten agreement has annexes (written or nonwritten), but the natural reading of “annex” is something appended to a document. Also, the INARA requires that the president certify that “the agreement includes the appropriate terms, conditions, and duration of the agreement’s requirements with respect to Iran’s nuclear activities.” Agreements of this complexity might be hard to accomplish through a nonwritten agreement, which might suggest that Congress had written agreements in mind. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;If the Biden administration makes a nonwritten agreement to avoid the INARA, a tricky question will arise about what constitutes the nonwritten agreement. Surely the elements of the (almost certainly complex) agreement would be written down, in some form, during negotiations, even if there is no final text to which the parties formally assent or which a third party promulgates. Can the Biden administration in effect write down the terms of an agreement with Iran but then proclaim and agree to the terms verbally, without assenting to a “text,” all in order to avoid its domestic law duties to Congress?  This would be an extreme elevation of form over substance that would not obviously be true to the statute.  Congress should press this issue hard if the Biden team goes the nonwritten agreement route to skirt the INARA.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;text-align:center&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:700; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Constitutional Issues&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;One can imagine the Biden administration deploying a constitutional avoidance argument to bolster a claim about the INARA’s inapplicability to nonwritten agreements. But such an argument would be weak.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Offices of Legal Counsel (OLCs) of &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.justice.gov/olc/file/2009-06-01-un-delegs/download&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Democratic&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.justice.gov/olc/file/1356291/download&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Republican&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; administrations have long asserted a broad exclusive presidential power under Article II over diplomacy. The executive branch has invoked this power in various ways to excuse executive branch compliance with federal statutes that &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.justice.gov/olc/file/1548931/download&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;prohibit the expenditure of funds&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; from the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) in the United States to further the PLO’s interests; that bar the PLO from &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.justice.gov/olc/file/1356291/download&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;maintaining a Washington, D.C., office&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and undertaking diplomatic activities the secretary of state aims to authorize; that &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/olc/opinions/2009/06/31/section7054.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;prohibit State Department officials&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; from attending certain international conferences; and that bar certain &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.justice.gov/file/18346/download&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;diplomacy-related activities&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; of the Office of Science and Technology Policy involving Chinese officials. (For more examples, and a critique of these opinions, see &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3659&amp;amp;context=faculty_scholarship&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;here&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;.)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Perhaps the most on-point (but not terribly on point) OLC opinion relying on the logic of an exclusive presidential power over diplomacy is a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.justice.gov/olc/file/1348136/download&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;2020 opinion&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that advised that the president could disregard a notice and waiting period requirement on the president withdrawing from the Open Skies Treaty. The opinion turned in part on the president’s exclusive power “to execute a treaty of the United States” but also in part on the president’s exclusive power “to conduct the Nation’s diplomacy,” torqued up by &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/576/13-628/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Zivotofsky II&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;OLC basically reasoned that a congressionally mandated waiting period on treaty withdrawal unduly burdened these powers considered together.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;These are broad assertions of executive power, but it would be a stretch to extend them to the new Iran deal. Congress in the INARA does not purport to stop the president from making the deal. The duty to transmit the agreements attaches within five days “&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;after&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;” the executive branch “reach[es] an agreement with Iran relating to the nuclear program of Iran.” Congress is, rather, regulating the president’s power to implement the agreement under domestic law waiver authorities that the president possesses only because Congress conferred them. Congress has a very strong claim to regulate that end of the deal—domestic implementation—regardless of what informal diplomatic arrangements the president makes on the international plane pursuant to Article II. And the president’s exclusive Article II claim to implement the agreement without congressional interference is weak to the extent that his implementation tool—waiver authority—derives entirely from Congress.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p class=&quot;rtecenter&quot;&gt;&lt;strong&gt;* * *&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;We should pause to note how remarkable it would be if the Biden administration made a deal of this significance a nonwritten one just to avoid the consequences of (weak) congressional review. President Obama made the JCPOA as a nonbinding agreement in order to avoid the constitutional need to secure affirmative congressional approval, but in doing so he had to bow to the INARA process. And now the Biden administration may reach a new nonbinding, nonwritten agreement with Iran that would (because nonbinding) require no affirmative congressional approval and also would (because unwritten) avoid the statutory requirement to transmit the deal under the INARA for congressional scrutiny.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;If this comes to pass, it would be consistent with a larger trend: Despite important &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.lawfareblog.com/congress-mandates-sweeping-transparency-reforms-international-agreements&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;recent Case Act reforms&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, which enhance the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;ex post &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;transparency of international agreements, presidents are becoming &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3589900&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;more&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4023641&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;more&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; creative at cutting Congress out of the process of making and implementing international agreements. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Wed, 21 Jun 2023 14:34:57 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Jack Goldsmith</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24472</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>The Cyberlaw Podcast: Yet Another Synthetic Moral Panic Over Privacy
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/cyberlaw-podcast-yet-another-synthetic-moral-panic-over-privacy</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Senator Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) is to moral panics over privacy what Andreessen Horowitz is to cryptocurrency startups. He’s constantly trying to blow life into them, hoping to justify new restrictions on government or private uses of data. His latest crusade is against the intelligence community’s purchase of behavioral data, which is generally available to everyone from Amazon to the GRU. He has launched his campaign several times, introducing legislation, holding up Avril Haines’s confirmation over the issue, and extracting a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/www.odni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/ODNI-Declassified-Report-on-CAI-January2022.pdf__;!!ApXA7kLm!2V3qMpdFJqZlsgtCbgn9_hpuHjpfO9q7bihvuU1QqfdaRy75x0vhWo-mdqjOwb7HxdBpqBOC6LLs69BkO-WdxdSNAU1v$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;DNI report&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; on the topic that has now been declassified. It was a sober and reasonable explanation of why commercial data is valuable for intelligence purposes, so naturally WIRED magazine’s headline summary was,&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; “&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/www.wired.com/story/odni-commercially-available-information-report/?utm_source=pocket_saves__;!!ApXA7kLm!2V3qMpdFJqZlsgtCbgn9_hpuHjpfO9q7bihvuU1QqfdaRy75x0vhWo-mdqjOwb7HxdBpqBOC6LLs69BkO-WdxTkmpO2U$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;The U.S. Is Openly Stockpiling Dirt on All Its Citizens&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;.” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://fedsoc.org/contributors/matthew-heiman&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Matthew Heiman &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;takes us through the story, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;sparking a debate that pulls in &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://law.ucla.edu/faculty/faculty-profiles/michael-karanicolas&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Michael Karanicolas&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/advancedcyberstrategies.com/about__;!!ApXA7kLm!zWL4sD1J_Lfio1GWCZzXIBXPKCy4VLcac7pObD0_2FhqG1nNBDToCTi24rLJOcH36lxC4GblPdZ7WsOoR-HockJc-g$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Cristin Flynn Goodwin&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Next, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Michael explains &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/www.nytimes.com/2023/06/14/science/ibm-quantum-computing.html?action=click&amp;amp;module=Well&amp;amp;pgtype=Homepage&amp;amp;section=Science&amp;amp;utm_source=pocket_saves__;!!ApXA7kLm!2V3qMpdFJqZlsgtCbgn9_hpuHjpfO9q7bihvuU1QqfdaRy75x0vhWo-mdqjOwb7HxdBpqBOC6LLs69BkO-WdxcXPdWM8$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;IBM’s announcement&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that it has made a big step forward in quantum computing. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Meanwhile, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Cristin tells us, the EU has taken another incremental step forward in &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/www.nytimes.com/2023/06/14/technology/europe-ai-regulation.html?action=click&amp;amp;module=Well&amp;amp;pgtype=Homepage&amp;amp;section=Technology&amp;amp;utm_source=pocket_saves__;!!ApXA7kLm!2V3qMpdFJqZlsgtCbgn9_hpuHjpfO9q7bihvuU1QqfdaRy75x0vhWo-mdqjOwb7HxdBpqBOC6LLs69BkO-Wdxbhk2QPT$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;producing its AI Act&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; – mainly by piling even more demands on artificial intelligence companies. We debate whether Europe can be a leader in AI regulation if it has no AI industry. (I think it makes the whole effort easier, pointing to a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/crfm.stanford.edu/2023/06/15/eu-ai-act.html?utm_source=pocket_saves__;!!ApXA7kLm!2V3qMpdFJqZlsgtCbgn9_hpuHjpfO9q7bihvuU1QqfdaRy75x0vhWo-mdqjOwb7HxdBpqBOC6LLs69BkO-WdxTx4qjpn$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Stanford study&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; suggesting that every AI model we’ve seen is already in violation of the AI Act’s requirements.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Michael and I discuss &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/medium.com/@bjax_/a-tale-of-unwanted-disruption-my-week-without-amazon-df1074e3818b__;!!ApXA7kLm!2V3qMpdFJqZlsgtCbgn9_hpuHjpfO9q7bihvuU1QqfdaRy75x0vhWo-mdqjOwb7HxdBpqBOC6LLs69BkO-WdxV61R6mN$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;a story&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; claiming persuasively that an Amazon driver’s allegation of racism led to an Amazon customer being booted out of his own “smart” home system for days. This leads us to the question of how Silicon Valley’s many “local” monopolies enable its unaccountable power to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/reason.com/volokh/2023/06/17/smart-home-system-home-system-that-amazon-can-mess-with-if-it-doesnt-like-what-you-say/__;!!ApXA7kLm!2x81hakMILjfPMZaYV8IJD0_em-6-aPDlsfSXZEl_VYxGVnkIsYtbOGdOCbMCT_pH2Tv4_HFWKV5i2YKv0dXFDAO$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;dish out punishment&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; to customers it doesn’t approve of.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Matthew recaps the administration’s effort to turn the debate over renewal of section 702 of FISA. This week, it rolled out some impressive claims about the cyber value of 702, including &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/therecord.media/colonial-pipeline-hack-section-702-surveillance-fbi?utm_source=pocket_saves__;!!ApXA7kLm!2V3qMpdFJqZlsgtCbgn9_hpuHjpfO9q7bihvuU1QqfdaRy75x0vhWo-mdqjOwb7HxdBpqBOC6LLs69BkO-WdxVKTjPwH$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;identifying the Colonial Pipeline attackers&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; (and getting back some of the ransom). It also introduced yet another set of FBI reforms designed to ensure that agents face career consequences for breaking the rules on accessing 702 data. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Cristin and I &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/www.wsj.com/articles/how-north-koreas-hacker-army-stole-3-billion-in-crypto-funding-nuclear-program-d6fe8782?mod=hp_lead_pos5&amp;amp;utm_source=pocket_saves__;!!ApXA7kLm!2V3qMpdFJqZlsgtCbgn9_hpuHjpfO9q7bihvuU1QqfdaRy75x0vhWo-mdqjOwb7HxdBpqBOC6LLs69BkO-WdxYKO98oe$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;award North Korea the “Most Improved Nation State Hacker”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; prize for the decade, as the country triples its cryptocurrency thefts and shows real talent for social engineering and supply chain exploits. Meanwhile, the Russians who are likely behind Anonymous Sudan decided to embarrass Microsoft with a &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/msrc.microsoft.com/blog/2023/06/microsoft-response-to-layer-7-distributed-denial-of-service-ddos-attacks/?utm_source=pocket_saves__;!!ApXA7kLm!2V3qMpdFJqZlsgtCbgn9_hpuHjpfO9q7bihvuU1QqfdaRy75x0vhWo-mdqjOwb7HxdBpqBOC6LLs69BkO-WdxWK1VqoU$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;DDOS attack on its application level&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. The real puzzle is what Russia gains from the stunt. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Finally, in updates and quick hits, we give deputy national cyber director Rob Knake a fond sendoff, as he &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/therecord.media/white-house-oncd-cyber-official-rob-knake-to-depart-national-cyber-strategy?utm_source=pocket_saves__;!!ApXA7kLm!2V3qMpdFJqZlsgtCbgn9_hpuHjpfO9q7bihvuU1QqfdaRy75x0vhWo-mdqjOwb7HxdBpqBOC6LLs69BkO-WdxRktyjHn$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;moves to the private sector&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, we anticipate an important competition decision in a couple of months as the FTC tries to stop &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/www.theverge.com/2023/6/13/23760192/microsoft-activision-blizzard-tro-granted-ftc-injunction__;!!ApXA7kLm!2V3qMpdFJqZlsgtCbgn9_hpuHjpfO9q7bihvuU1QqfdaRy75x0vhWo-mdqjOwb7HxdBpqBOC6LLs69BkO-WdxZDVKwNt$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;the Microsoft-Activision Blizzard merger in court,&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; and I speculate on what could be a Very Big Deal – the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://urldefense.com/v3/__https:/www.theverge.com/2023/6/14/23759094/european-commission-google-antitrust-advertising-market-antitrust__;!!ApXA7kLm!2V3qMpdFJqZlsgtCbgn9_hpuHjpfO9q7bihvuU1QqfdaRy75x0vhWo-mdqjOwb7HxdBpqBOC6LLs69BkO-WdxX8SAY7Z$&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;possible breakup of Google’s adtech business&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;iframe allowfullscreen=&quot;&quot; height=&quot;90&quot; mozallowfullscreen=&quot;&quot; msallowfullscreen=&quot;&quot; oallowfullscreen=&quot;&quot; scrolling=&quot;no&quot; src=&quot;//html5-player.libsyn.com/embed/episode/id/27225255/height/90/theme/custom/thumbnail/yes/direction/forward/render-playlist/no/custom-color/88AA3C/&quot; style=&quot;border: none&quot; title=&quot;Libsyn Player&quot; webkitallowfullscreen=&quot;&quot; width=&quot;100%&quot;&gt;&lt;/iframe&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.steptoe.com/podcasts/TheCyberlawPodcast-463.mp3&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Download 463rd Episode (mp3)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;You can subscribe to The Cyberlaw Podcast using &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/steptoe-cyberlaw-podcast/id830593115?mt=2&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;iTunes&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://play.google.com/music/listen#/ps/Ikx2d2ncjvw6zuoq3zh4qp2i7qu&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Google Play&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://open.spotify.com/show/3Co2wdTUaZr4Xqnlxs4soG&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Spotify&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;http://pcasts.in/steptoe&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Pocket Casts&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, or our &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;http://www.steptoe.com/feed-Cyberlaw.rss&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;RSS feed.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; As always, The Cyberlaw Podcast is open to feedback. Be sure to engage with &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://twitter.com/stewartbaker&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;@stewartbaker&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; on Twitter. Send your questions, comments, and suggestions for topics or interviewees to &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;mailto:CyberlawPodcast@gmail.com&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;CyberlawPodcast@gmail.com&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. Remember: If your suggested guest appears on the show, we will send you a highly coveted Cyberlaw Podcast mug! &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;The views expressed in this podcast are those of the speakers and do not reflect the opinions of their institutions, clients, friends, families, or pets.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Wed, 21 Jun 2023 11:21:25 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Stewart Baker</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24475</guid>
  </item>
  <item>
    <title>The Presidential Records Act, Clinton&amp;#039;s Socks, and Trump&amp;#039;s Boxes
</title>
    <link>https://www.lawfareblog.com/presidential-records-act-clintons-socks-and-trumps-boxes</link>
    <description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;“...EVERYONE UNDERSTANDS THAT THE PRESIDENTIAL RECORDS ACT, PLUS THE CLINTON SOCKS CASE, TOTALLY EXONERATED ME FROM THE CONTINUING WITCH HUNT BROUGHT ON BY CORRUPT JOE BIDEN, THE DOJ, DERANGED JACK SMITH, AND THEIR RADICAL LEFT, MARXIST THUGS…”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;—Donald Trump, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/110550283506811833&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;June 15, 2023&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The notion that presidents—and, for that matter, the rest of the federal government—must preserve their records is of recent vintage. Presidential records were traditionally considered the property of the president who created or received them. Many presidents bequeathed their papers to their heirs; some destroyed them. As former President William Howard Taft &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://scholarship.law.cornell.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=&amp;amp;httpsredir=1&amp;amp;article=2917&amp;amp;context=clr&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;explained&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in 1915:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Executive office of the President is not a recording office. The vast amount of correspondence that goes through it, signed either by the President or his secretaries, does not become the property or a record of the government, unless it goes on to the official files of the Department to which it may be addressed. The retiring President takes with him all of the correspondence, originals and copies, which he carried on during his administration.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In 1950, Congress passed the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2021-title44/pdf/USCODE-2021-title44-chap31.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Federal Records Act&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, which requires federal agencies—but not the president—to preserve their records. Five years later, Congress passed the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.archives.gov/presidential-libraries/laws/1955-act.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Presidential Libraries Act&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, which encouraged (but did not require) former presidents to donate their records to private, federally maintained libraries.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Then came Richard Nixon. Four months after Nixon resigned in disgrace, Congress—concerned that he would destroy key papers—enacted the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.archives.gov/presidential-libraries/laws/1974-act.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Presidential Recordings and Materials Preservation Act&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, which required that the archivist of the United States take into custody all of Nixon’s presidential records.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;(Nixon, being Nixon, fought back, filing suit the day after President Ford signed the legislation. After the Supreme Court &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ll/usrep/usrep433/usrep433425/usrep433425.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;upheld&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; the law’s constitutionality, Nixon filed a separate lawsuit in 1980 demanding compensation under the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment. In 1992, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://law.resource.org/pub/us/case/reporter/F2/978/978.F2d.1269.92-5021.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;agreed&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that he was entitled to compensation. Nixon died in 1994, and in 2000 his estate settled with the U.S. government for &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2000/06/13/us/government-agrees-to-pay-nixon-estate.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;$18 million&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;.)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Then in 1978, Congress enacted the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.archives.gov/presidential-libraries/laws/1978-act.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Presidential Records Act&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; (PRA), establishing for all time that presidential records belong to the nation the president serves. The act &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.archives.gov/about/laws/presidential-records.html#2202&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;provides&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that “[t]he &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;United States shall reserve and retain complete ownership, possession, and control of Presidential records.” While president, the president is responsible for maintaining his records. Upon leaving office, that responsibility &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.archives.gov/about/laws/presidential-records.html#2203&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;passes to the U.S. archivist&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, who “shall assume responsibility for the custody, control, and preservation of, and access to, the Presidential records of that President.”  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The PRA &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.archives.gov/about/laws/presidential-records.html#2201&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;defines&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; presidential records as materials “created or received by the President, the President’s immediate staff, or a unit or individual of the Executive Office of the President whose function is to advise or assist the President, in the course of conducting activities which relate to or have an effect upon the carrying out of the constitutional, statutory, or other official or ceremonial duties of the President.” The PRA excludes from this definition official agency records, which are covered by the Federal Records Act.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The PRA also excludes personal records, which it defines as materials “of a purely private or nonpublic character which do not relate to or have an effect upon the carrying out of the constitutional, statutory, or other official or ceremonial duties of the President.” &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Now let’s examine the famous CLINTON SOCKS CASE, which Trump insists exonerates him. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Key point: The case is not about Bill Clinton’s cat named &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socks_(cat)&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Socks&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, who generally avoided litigation and partisan controversy (with one &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://mashable.com/article/socks-the-cat-gop-investigation&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;exception&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;). Rather, it involves tape recordings of conversations between President Clinton and historian Taylor Branch intended to serve as a personal diary of sorts, and which eventually formed the basis of Branch’s 2009 book, “The Clinton Tapes&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; According to Branch, Clinton would store the tape recordings in his &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/history/2023/06/16/trump-bill-clinton-sock-drawer-records/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;sock drawer&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; for safekeeping and to ensure that staff didn’t find, and possibly leak, the tapes.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In 2010, the right-wing public interest group Judicial Watch sued the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA), demanding that it obtain custody of the tapes and deposit them in the Clinton Presidential Library. Judicial Watch argued that Clinton should have included the tapes among the records transferred to NARA at the end of his presidency, and that NARA had to take steps to obtain the records. Judge Amy Berman Jackson &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://ecf.dcd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/show_public_doc?2010cv1834-13&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;dismissed the case&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; because Judicial Watch did not identify anything that NARA could do to retrieve the tapes from Clinton. Jackson further noted that NARA was powerless to classify the records as presidential: “[T]he PRA does not confer any mandatory or even discretionary authority on the Archivist to classify records.” Finally, Jackson was “not so sure” whether the tapes should have been deemed presidential records, given that the PRA’s definition &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.archives.gov/about/laws/presidential-records.html#2201&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;excludes&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; “&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;personal notes serving as the functional equivalent of a diary or journal which are not prepared or utilized for, or circulated or communicated in the course of, transacting Government business.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;”  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Trump’s post-arraignment &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.rev.com/blog/transcripts/trump-responds-to-charges-in-speech-following-arraignment-in-federal-court-transcript&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;speech&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; was likely the first time a president quoted multiple sentences from a decade-old federal district court opinion. Trump latched onto the court’s conclusion that only the president could determine whether records were presidential or personal:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Not only was Bill Clinton never even considered for criminal prosecution based on the tapes he took, but when he was sued for them, he won the case. Judge Amy Berman Jackson’s decision states: “Under the statutory scheme established by the Presidential Records Act, the decision to segregate personal materials from Presidential records is made by the President during the President’s term, and in the President’s sole discretion.” You’re surprised to hear that aren’t you?&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Any normal administration, even an opposing one, would consider that to be the end, but not the corrupt Biden administration. The Socks decision, as it’s known, also states: “The National Archives and Records Administration, or NARA, does not have the authority to designate material as ‘Presidential records.’”  ...  “NARA does not have the tapes in question, and NARA lacks any right, duty, or means to seize control of them.” This is law. “[T]he President enjoys unconstrained authority to make decisions regarding the disposal of documents. ... “[N]either the Archivist nor Congress has the authority to veto the President’s decision.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Presidential Records Act “does not confer any mandatory or even discretionary authority on the Archivist to classify records. Under the statute, this responsibility is left solely to the President of the United States.” Think of that. That’s the decision. Think of that. Now, just think of that. In other words, whatever documents a president decides to take with him, he has the right to do so. It’s an absolute right. This is the law. And that is something that people have now seen and it couldn’t be more clear. They ought to drop this case immediately because they’re destroying a country.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As usual, Trump was nowhere near the target. The indictment does not allege any violation of the Presidential Records Act. Rather, it alleges that Trump violated (among other things) the Espionage Act. Yet Trump appears to believe &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;that he can be subject to only one requirement at a time. The ban on willful retention of national defense information purports to apply to everyone. The PRA, by contrast, applies only to presidents. Does the latter &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;exempt&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; a president from the former? &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Of course not. Consider a different example: The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.sec.gov/rules/final/33-8124.htm&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;requires&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; CEOs of publicly traded companies to certify the accuracy of information provided in their companies’ financial reports. No one would suggest that this requirement somehow exempts CEOs from the generally applicable requirement not to embezzle company funds. Presidents, like CEOs, are subject to some requirements by virtue of their position and to other requirements because they apply to all of us.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;As Andy McCarthy &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/frivolous-trump-argument-no-1-classified-intelligence-reports-compiled-by-government-agencies-are-personal-records-under-the-presidential-records-act/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;put it&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; in the National Review, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;If lawmakers intended the PRA to modify the Espionage Act such that presidents were immune from the latter, they would have said so. They did not. No surprise there: The provisions address vastly different matters and can easily be read in conjunction.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The PRA is a civil-law statute to provide guidance for the archiving of presidential records. The Espionage Act is a criminal statute prescribing severe penalties against people, including top government officials, who mishandle national-defense information. When statutes can sensibly be read harmoniously, they are not supposed to be construed as if they were antithetical. Here, the two provisions can easily be read harmoniously; indeed, it is Trump defenders who must strain mightily to claim there is any conflict. There is not a shred of a basis to believe that Congress, without mentioning it, was modifying the Espionage Act when, 60 years later, it passed the PRA—which is no doubt why, up until now, in the near half-century that the PRA has been on the books, no one has suggested such a thing.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;Furthermore, Trump is both trying to use the PRA as a shield and essentially claiming to have violated it.  Classified documents are obviously not “personal records.”  And indeed there is no evidence that, while president,  he actually categorized classified documents as personal records. Finally, the indictment strongly suggests that most—and possibly all—of the documents in question were actually &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;agency &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;records, prepared by agencies and at some point shown to the president, which are governed by the Federal Records Act, not the PRA.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It appears that Trump is attached to this bizarre reading of the PRA almost as much as he is to his &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/15/us/politics/trump-documents-boxes.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;beloved boxes&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;. CNN has &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.cnn.com/2022/08/25/politics/trump-maralago-documents-private-concerns-legal-tom-fitton/index.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;reported&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that the idea has been rattling in his head since February 2022, when the head of Judicial Watch, Tom Fitton, contacted Trump shortly after the Archives confirmed a Washington Post &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/02/07/trump-records-mar-a-lago/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;report&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that Trump had returned 15 boxes. Fitton reportedly told Trump about the Clinton case and suggested that he need not return anything because the Archives had no means of obtaining them over his objections.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It could have ended there. Fitton, as many have &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://finance.yahoo.com/news/trump-advisors-want-tom-fitton-030639181.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;noted&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, is not even a lawyer. But Trump &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.cnn.com/2022/08/25/politics/trump-maralago-documents-private-concerns-legal-tom-fitton/index.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;reportedly&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; arranged for Fitton to speak to his actual lawyers. Thereafter, the Clinton case made its way into Trump’s briefs as he tried to grind the Justice Department’s investigation to a halt before &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.618763/gov.uscourts.flsd.618763.84.0_4.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Judge Aileen Cannon&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.618763/gov.uscourts.flsd.618763.171.0_2.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;special master&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that she appointed, and the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca11.79817/gov.uscourts.ca11.79817.51.0.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; (which eventually &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://media.ca11.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/files/202213005.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;put an end to this escapade&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; by holding that Cannon had no jurisdiction to appoint a special master or to block the Justice Department from using the documents seized at Mar-a-Lago). Whereas Trump’s lawyers conspicuously declined to assert in court his &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/22/us/politics/trump-documents-declassification.html&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;dubious claim&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that he had declassified the documents in question, they appeared to have no such qualms about advancing his equally suspect PRA arguments.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Justice Department briefs in the special master litigation &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.618763/gov.uscourts.flsd.618763.182.1.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;explained&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, in tones of increasing exasperation, the folly of Trump’s argument:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;[F]or the reasons already explained by the government, the single district court decision relied upon by Plaintiff, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Judicial Watch v. National Archives and Records Administration&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, 845 F. Supp. 2d 288 (D.D.C. 2012), provides no support for Plaintiff’s upside-down reading of the PRA. ... The dispute in &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Judicial Watch&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; concerned whether a third party has a civil mechanism to enforce alleged violations of the PRA or whether—as the government maintained—that responsibility rests solely with NARA and the Attorney General. Nothing in the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:italic&quot;&gt;Judicial Watch&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; civil litigation presented the question of whether the PRA somehow exempts former Presidents from the obligation to comply with criminal laws, including laws prohibiting the unlawful retention of national defense information and obstruction of justice.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;/blockquote&gt;
&lt;p style=&quot;margin-right:48px&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;In reversing Cannon, the Eleventh Circuit did not address the PRA arguments, because it held that she had no jurisdiction to hear the case in any event.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;The Mar-a-Lago classified documents litigation is not Trump’s first tussle with the PRA. While in office, Trump reportedly had a penchant for &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/02/05/trump-ripping-documents/&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;tearing up documents&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that needed to be preserved in order to comply with the PRA. Aides would race to restore the leftover pieces and try to tape them together. The Archives &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.archives.gov/press/press-releases/2022/nr22-001#january-31-2022&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;confirmed&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that it received some taped-together records at the end of the Trump administration “along with a number of torn-up records that had not been reconstructed.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;And Trump has already lost one high-stakes court battle involving the PRA. The Jan. 6 committee requested from the Archives presidential records pertaining to the events of Jan. 6 under a provision in the PRA that &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.archives.gov/about/laws/presidential-records.html#2205&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;requires&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; disclosure of presidential records—even where not yet available to the public—to a congressional committee “if such records contain information that is needed for the conduct of its business and that is not otherwise available.” Trump &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.levin-center.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/2021-11-16-Trump-brief-supporting-preliminary-injunction-in-National-Archives-case.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;argued&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt; that, among other things, the information requested was not needed for the committee’s business and that the request should be denied because the materials were protected by executive privilege. (As a lawyer representing the Jan. 6 committee, I worked on the briefs in opposition to Trump.) Trump lost before the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://levin-center.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/2021-11-9-D.C.-District-court-opinion-denying-Trump-motion-for-injunctive-relief.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;district court&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, lost before the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.levin-center.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/2021-12-9-D.C.-Circuit-opinion-denying-Trump-preliminary-injunction.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;D.C. Circuit&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;, and lost before the &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https://www.levin-center.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/2022-1-19-Supreme-Court-order-denying-stay-pending-appeal-in-Trump-v-Thompson.pdf&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;-webkit-text-decoration-skip:none&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;text-decoration-skip-ink:none&quot;&gt;Supreme Court&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-weight:400; font-variant:normal; white-space:pre-wrap&quot;&gt;&lt;span style=&quot;font-style:normal&quot;&gt;It’s anybody’s guess whether Trump’s lawyers will repeat these absurd arguments about the PRA as the Mar-a-Lago case proceeds to trial. If they do, it won’t necessarily be because their client is confused about the law. It will be because Trump, for all his folly, knows that his literal get-out-of-jail-free card is winning the presidency. If he wins, he could order the Justice Department to drop the case, grant himself a self-pardon, and/or (if he is already imprisoned) file a petition for a writ of habeas corpus that would almost certainly result in his release. If Trump—who knows his supporters better than legal pundits do—concludes that making a fantastical argument about the PRA will help keep his supporters from jumping ship, then we are doomed to hear or and read much more of this nonsense as the case makes its way to trial.  &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;
</description>
     <pubDate>Wed, 21 Jun 2023 11:15:00 -0400</pubDate>
 <dc:creator>Eric Columbus</dc:creator>
 <guid isPermaLink="false">24474</guid>
  </item>
  </channel>
</rss>
